paper_id
uint32
0
3.7k
title
stringlengths
14
154
paper_url
stringlengths
42
42
authors
listlengths
1
21
type
stringclasses
3 values
abstract
stringlengths
413
2.52k
keywords
stringlengths
4
397
TL;DR
stringlengths
5
250
submission_number
int64
2
14.3k
arxiv_id
stringlengths
10
10
embedding
listlengths
768
768
3,500
Learning from End User Data with Shuffled Differential Privacy over Kernel Densities
https://openreview.net/forum?id=QjSOgxJ0hp
[ "Tal Wagner" ]
Spotlight
We study a setting of collecting and learning from private data distributed across end users. In the shuffled model of differential privacy, the end users partially protect their data locally before sharing it, and their data is also anonymized during its collection to enhance privacy. This model has recently become a prominent alternative to central DP, which requires full trust in a central data curator, and local DP, where fully local data protection takes a steep toll on downstream accuracy. Our main technical result is a shuffled DP protocol for privately estimating the kernel density function of a distributed dataset, with accuracy essentially matching central DP. We use it to privately learn a classifier from the end user data, by learning a private density function per class. Moreover, we show that the density function itself can recover the semantic content of its class, despite having been learned in the absence of any unprotected data. Our experiments show the favorable downstream performance of our approach, and highlight key downstream considerations and trade-offs in a practical ML deployment of shuffled DP.
differential privacy, shuffled differential privacy, kernel density estimation, kde
We present a method for collecting and learning a classifier from private data distributed across end users, via kernel density estimates in the shuffled DP model.
7,378
2502.14087
[ -0.0009579691104590893, -0.017849983647465706, -0.002253204118460417, 0.09551852196455002, 0.0447981096804142, 0.014830972999334335, 0.013237533159554005, -0.04492524638772011, -0.0034500453621149063, -0.025477243587374687, -0.004956153687089682, -0.027599047869443893, -0.06484424322843552, 0.002416857285425067, 0.015086525119841099, 0.037682484835386276, 0.03587518632411957, -0.033670417964458466, -0.0030697432812303305, 0.03649279102683067, 0.005600478500127792, -0.032865010201931, -0.015162901021540165, -0.0013563253451138735, 0.0009533169795759022, -0.008364963345229626, 0.013269426301121712, 0.0074963998049497604, -0.002617065329104662, 0.018175648525357246, 0.05783659964799881, -0.006643525790423155, 0.010810294188559055, -0.027213674038648605, 0.014528312720358372, 0.0377148874104023, -0.00790233351290226, 0.008106565102934837, 0.0032152205239981413, 0.046726275235414505, -0.03954310342669487, 0.001297520357184112, 0.011748873628675938, 0.005212628748267889, -0.08207649737596512, -0.0045240819454193115, -0.07449613511562347, 0.03503579646348953, 0.012117435224354267, -0.005145454313606024, -0.09588449448347092, 0.009644880890846252, 0.012193321250379086, -0.0013813619734719396, 0.0080158282071352, 0.05070566013455391, 0.05187090113759041, -0.08494318276643753, 0.005566659849137068, -0.05786548927426338, -0.02552531287074089, 0.011999594047665596, 0.03509026765823364, 0.004384634084999561, -0.0054100872948765755, -0.017855731770396233, 0.01870635896921158, 0.04471384361386299, -0.02854202501475811, -0.04507967084646225, -0.00860146339982748, -0.0037944107316434383, -0.0033017925452440977, -0.03343456983566284, 0.0016463490901514888, -0.029298780485987663, 0.029615959152579308, 0.01002812385559082, 0.04749995470046997, -0.010298136621713638, -0.016390807926654816, 0.01529589481651783, -0.003921227995306253, 0.044747792184352875, 0.013784332200884819, -0.01990562677383423, -0.09011615812778473, -0.019254159182310104, -0.05962280556559563, 0.05137006193399429, -0.03582410141825676, -0.04340340197086334, 0.03255081921815872, -0.0018575177527964115, 0.013205008581280708, -0.002673543058335781, 0.037587132304906845, 0.01644464023411274, 0.00495672645047307, -0.008481878787279129, -0.016520807519555092, -0.0009539685561321676, 0.025460436940193176, -0.027969371527433395, -0.10403477400541306, -0.01621435396373272, -0.02857404388487339, -0.026942849159240723, -0.012713806703686714, 0.012669935822486877, -0.015518351458013058, 0.003985651768743992, 0.0181247740983963, 0.022536026313900948, -0.07769637554883957, 0.02439221739768982, 0.0008645667694509029, 0.010376306250691414, 0.010078899562358856, -0.019169770181179047, 0.0868828147649765, 0.06983766704797745, -0.0016970295691862702, 0.05106730759143829, 0.024312518537044525, -0.011279509402811527, 0.031370989978313446, 0.024457989260554314, -0.0029480443336069584, -0.04942456632852554, 0.02964344061911106, 0.0498848557472229, 0.03342844173312187, 0.027253346517682076, -0.01012010034173727, -0.019204149022698402, -0.012877743691205978, 0.04776277020573616, 0.045716509222984314, -0.028482571244239807, 0.031162695959210396, -0.030636098235845566, 0.01745872013270855, -0.01893283985555172, 0.07495011389255524, -0.036795832216739655, -0.0013239033287391067, -0.03123733215034008, -0.032108455896377563, -0.011294620111584663, 0.01041205320507288, 0.030306467786431313, 0.038781262934207916, -0.09826274961233139, 0.009221140295267105, 0.036490220576524734, 0.01783186011016369, 0.020870059728622437, 0.011120461858808994, 0.0050188228487968445, -0.005218238569796085, -0.013196081854403019, -0.04588313028216362, 0.014584231190383434, -0.016599899157881737, -0.0938081219792366, 0.06704225391149521, 0.05278396233916283, -0.026196276769042015, 0.0007940609939396381, -0.030726728960871696, -0.023876259103417397, 0.064510278403759, 0.017770299687981606, 0.008787620812654495, 0.01601749286055565, 0.04954591393470764, -0.010840443894267082, 0.03425820916891098, 0.03329038992524147, -0.08348691463470459, 0.01926693692803383, 0.006152607034891844, 0.0033612975385040045, -0.030766237527132034, 0.0177110955119133, 0.04142901673913002, 0.0006248491117730737, 0.0208300594240427, 0.015032337047159672, -0.06964746862649918, 0.00023062436957843602, 0.004179909825325012, 0.004244418814778328, 0.06256560981273651, 0.02488609030842781, 0.03593394532799721, 0.02080073393881321, 0.00811723992228508, 0.02292529307305813, 0.013951029628515244, -0.026570118963718414, 0.00981752760708332, -0.016523955389857292, -0.053959786891937256, -0.002559683285653591, 0.014313493855297565, -0.0216950885951519, -0.01708974316716194, -0.0219497699290514, -0.028773488476872444, -0.014480061829090118, -0.013992865569889545, -0.01718568243086338, 0.029148295521736145, 0.0012397425016388297, -0.04452291503548622, 0.012970761395990849, 0.027771104127168655, -0.028666118159890175, 0.042132601141929626, 0.019746411591768265, -0.008324114605784416, 0.024539576843380928, 0.003720866981893778, 0.1260945349931717, 0.07365748286247253, -0.008167354390025139, 0.03713062033057213, 0.044215623289346695, 0.01875149831175804, -0.03131258860230446, 0.017288081347942352, -0.01410374790430069, 0.029963737353682518, 0.02053011953830719, 0.010931432247161865, -0.061137180775403976, 0.07656130939722061, -0.03429045155644417, 0.0022780755534768105, 0.062329474836587906, -0.001626467565074563, 0.048779018223285675, 0.01356371957808733, -0.0024060572031885386, 0.01876586489379406, -0.0113991042599082, 0.0013580535305663943, -0.013646367006003857, -0.03456201031804085, 0.0051605538465082645, -0.0006934006232768297, -0.026695139706134796, 0.03316733241081238, -0.051955632865428925, 0.02786441147327423, 0.040922511368989944, 0.05428135022521019, 0.04016329348087311, 0.017696216702461243, 0.03241463378071785, -0.019848395138978958, -0.039783574640750885, -0.023992402479052544, -0.10461592674255371, -0.04472708702087402, -0.001156137092038989, 0.0558907687664032, 0.008823671378195286, 0.03813731297850609, -0.026567475870251656, -0.013897786848247051, 0.0075379968620836735, -0.007517991121858358, -0.006060481537133455, 0.025487417355179787, 0.003897843649610877, -0.04442455992102623, -0.028895102441310883, -0.009747321717441082, 0.06348290294408798, 0.005841144360601902, -0.006353323347866535, -0.026621123775839806, -0.054270271211862564, 0.003284141421318054, -0.030231691896915436, -0.03187820687890053, 0.002466849284246564, 0.04923040047287941, 0.0020835092291235924, -0.0057255844585597515, 0.024569690227508545, 0.05061202868819237, 0.05336560681462288, 0.024406660348176956, -0.009096525609493256, 0.012808128260076046, 0.0315990149974823, -0.036680158227682114, 0.014782028272747993, -0.016704201698303223, -0.005242305342108011, -0.033851075917482376, -0.03371638059616089, 0.013873199932277203, 0.020941102877259254, -0.2398177832365036, 0.0019814269617199898, 0.029830321669578552, 0.0031010531820356846, 0.017705906182527542, -0.003887956729158759, 0.03298809751868248, -0.015618780627846718, -0.009851953946053982, -0.0017180185532197356, 0.01778644323348999, 0.019672783091664314, 0.006627591792494059, 0.044078320264816284, 0.04804401844739914, 0.0376652367413044, -0.022493697702884674, -0.03260647505521774, 0.036121658980846405, -0.02149125747382641, -0.017901495099067688, -0.060789842158555984, -0.018736789003014565, 0.04154461249709129, -0.006941225379705429, 0.007146751973778009, -0.03576163202524185, 0.013233976438641548, -0.051702454686164856, 0.0019858931191265583, -0.06522376090288162, -0.009107613936066628, -0.046274587512016296, 0.05070233717560768, -0.007965085096657276, 0.015873625874519348, 0.04724886268377304, 0.012934111058712006, -0.012222024612128735, 0.04336852580308914, 0.024575278162956238, -0.000018874516172218136, -0.017398744821548462, 0.005118414293974638, 0.07760344445705414, 0.030091892927885056, -0.062321294099092484, -0.015620335005223751, -0.013322417624294758, 0.006265114992856979, -0.005271016154438257, -0.05844129994511604, -0.03378206863999367, -0.02123454585671425, -0.024053135886788368, -0.0320938341319561, -0.04664936289191246, 0.0055986810475587845, 0.004723085090517998, 0.01949808932840824, 0.04711006581783295, -0.045771073549985886, -0.00017077714437618852, -0.022640062496066093, 0.01957980915904045, -0.044662147760391235, -0.07310023158788681, -0.08391059935092926, 0.0774674043059349, 0.04014850780367851, -0.014296681620180607, 0.005279936362057924, -0.021580686792731285, -0.09769243746995926, 0.006453274749219418, 0.00038231592043302953, 0.007151604164391756, -0.026245679706335068, 0.056838374584913254, 0.06855589151382446, -0.019988253712654114, -0.01874491386115551, 0.01897721365094185, 0.0077430447563529015, 0.005800242535769939, -0.03330611065030098, -0.00035710251540876925, -0.016989942640066147, -0.01978701539337635, -0.05436744540929794, 0.026182761415839195, 0.017749518156051636, 0.044148221611976624, -0.005104169249534607, 0.05143188685178757, 0.047451168298721313, -0.012411560863256454, 0.05811108648777008, 0.009004699997603893, 0.02273966558277607, 0.010625861585140228, -0.050662800669670105, -0.035495858639478683, -0.05487263947725296, -0.007261299062520266, 0.024879418313503265, -0.037830058485269547, -0.0015530699165537953, 0.006206427235156298, -0.008727937005460262, -0.04694430157542229, -0.026935169473290443, 0.0044034565798938274, -0.0028642809484153986, 0.006215208675712347, -0.01861797831952572, -0.0025280704721808434, 0.036101751029491425, 0.03617417812347412, -0.043610602617263794, -0.015835976228117943, 0.03118969313800335, -0.01473743561655283, -0.006431227084249258, -0.019139517098665237, -0.013298941776156425, -0.0036683864891529083, -0.006811222527176142, 0.014442169107496738, -0.03222116082906723, 0.04134976491332054, 0.02029348537325859, 0.025918466970324516, -0.005543929059058428, 0.05627823621034622, 0.02942548133432865, -0.00544046750292182, -0.015910916030406952, 0.02005232870578766, 0.0063665579073131084, 0.05860920622944832, -0.007730068638920784, 0.04567008838057518, 0.04609638452529907, 0.040543872863054276, -0.0003319231909699738, 0.027717294171452522, -0.0015755067579448223, -0.02074863202869892, -0.044679105281829834, 0.0007376557332463562, -0.04731551185250282, 0.028149163350462914, -0.029001066461205482, 0.015439102426171303, -0.014626337215304375, 0.0550849623978138, 0.013477529399096966, -0.008624736219644547, -0.06614425778388977, 0.021805647760629654, 0.0024484775494784117, -0.019505798816680908, -0.009694053791463375, 0.03012232668697834, 0.05579021945595741, -0.06351276487112045, -0.014815595000982285, 0.034589413553476334, 0.0025299207773059607, 0.016058698296546936, 0.0004142204998061061, -0.017196888104081154, 0.0012423954904079437, -0.0024799671955406666, -0.007077825255692005, 0.012642043642699718, -0.007001886144280434, -0.0423751100897789, -0.00004101585363969207, 0.005331245716661215, -0.01125892624258995, -0.044994521886110306, 0.015749584883451462, 0.1059812530875206, 0.048530254513025284, -0.014507359825074673, -0.029268871992826462, -0.03664758428931236, 0.0657925084233284, -0.031285788863897324, 0.020810566842556, -0.03577541187405586, -0.01685919612646103, -0.00864018127322197, -0.05083047226071358, 0.0010197269730269909, 0.026324113830924034, -0.04710151255130768, -0.005033107940107584, 0.0032635354436933994, -0.007502046879380941, -0.016272101551294327, -0.0030963956378400326, 0.021102385595440865, -0.048062436282634735, 0.038836512714624405, 0.04019004479050636, -0.025261834263801575, 0.03921473026275635, -0.061364106833934784, -0.02143014222383499, -0.018141943961381912, -0.03183138370513916, 0.019516894593834877, 0.009199464693665504, -0.03937852755188942, -0.009362476877868176, -0.017892200499773026, 0.012769434601068497, 0.02855793945491314, 0.00989404134452343, -0.004561353474855423, -0.016617383807897568, -0.006705278996378183, 0.0426020585000515, -0.04885546490550041, -0.006615677382797003, 0.0022509219124913216, -0.006020017433911562, -0.009765648283064365, -0.03863966837525368, -0.0009100899915210903, 0.016380690038204193, -0.052604883909225464, -0.0041033378802239895, -0.055541809648275375, 0.02140883356332779, -0.05863894522190094, 0.019508667290210724, -0.018420329317450523, -0.026232970878481865, -0.038472361862659454, -0.042925529181957245, 0.009849912486970425, 0.029205450788140297, -0.0328715480864048, 0.018972741439938545, 0.04351726919412613, 0.014215243048965931, 0.009116481989622116, 0.007607562467455864, -0.06939060240983963, 0.00905346404761076, 0.06542722880840302, 0.009538335725665092, -0.010185209102928638, -0.07697723060846329, 0.01323836762458086, 0.016482092440128326, -0.04081067442893982, 0.030551277101039886, 0.0020083975978195667, -0.009344854392111301, 0.015815453603863716, 0.04246019944548607, 0.0058881668373942375, -0.008589230477809906, 0.03434818983078003, -0.045095447450876236, -0.011024870909750462, -0.0476803258061409, 0.00914840679615736, 0.025977766141295433, -0.04900963604450226, 0.04087444394826889, 0.028198374435305595, -0.06150875240564346, 0.026372432708740234, -0.04155430570244789, -0.06934447586536407, 0.011159500107169151, -0.01229834370315075, -0.013570396229624748, -0.02722097933292389, -0.05360495299100876, -0.03218984231352806, -0.0009683401440270245, -0.04034147039055824, -0.0029945680871605873, 0.01543932780623436, 0.02464965358376503, 0.02139883302152157, 0.020763682201504707, -0.0035941144451498985, -0.0021361021790653467, 0.0010431777918711305, 0.03422342240810394, 0.0043905326165258884, 0.03173109516501427, -0.022577011957764626, 0.05352137237787247, 0.004773202817887068, -0.00667999591678381, 0.04266950860619545, 0.03586861491203308, -0.0007338675204664469, -0.056946761906147, 0.05358561500906944, -0.036251697689294815, -0.03507528454065323, -0.07907566428184509, 0.053258266299963, 0.027313102036714554, -0.0378764308989048, -0.07364679872989655, 0.05326394736766815, -0.03811497241258621, 0.0017042096005752683, -0.013726850040256977, -0.0008051257464103401, 0.004555400926619768, 0.06912237405776978, 0.032920241355895996, 0.019887736067175865, 0.0601799413561821, 0.037765927612781525, 0.0013062173966318369, 0.036755651235580444, 0.06195096671581268, 0.09764646738767624, 0.02623772993683815, -0.026047591120004654, 0.07267565280199051, -0.0077397082932293415, -0.028462447226047516, -0.01155446283519268, -0.013487598858773708, -0.03717321902513504, -0.04070066288113594, 0.028136130422353745, 0.0520419105887413, 0.02036861702799797, 0.059162288904190063, -0.05712196230888367, 0.020229533314704895, 0.0626857727766037, 0.000009813784345169552, 0.01187566015869379, 0.057181812822818756, -0.00786512903869152, 0.011769698932766914, -0.05690319091081619, -0.04871787503361702, 0.009269953705370426, 0.002203780459240079, 0.011214771308004856, 0.005825181026011705, -0.033521924167871475, -0.013865471817553043, 0.026721389964222908, 0.003775199642404914, 0.08276918530464172, -0.03883085772395134, -0.06393180787563324, 0.0011386353289708495, 0.019384948536753654, 0.017792927101254463, 0.049330178648233414, 0.03056558035314083, -0.011427256278693676, 0.00488098431378603, -0.04526088386774063, 0.01635931432247162, 0.019949307665228844, -0.02428961545228958, 0.01043678168207407, -0.02167579159140587, -0.03904850035905838, 0.007635942194610834, -0.010821620933711529, -0.03690694645047188, -0.06620179861783981, -0.01291937567293644, -0.022699648514389992, -0.05969659984111786, -0.11289822310209274, 0.0405096597969532, 0.02966160885989666, -0.03953457623720169, 0.03250378370285034, -0.04092118889093399, 0.01689021661877632, 0.012085667811334133, -0.06561563163995743, 0.004711694084107876, 0.014542672783136368, 0.005379964131861925, 0.0354437418282032, -0.008075297810137272, 0.04043585807085037, 0.0041740876622498035, -0.03675473481416702, 0.015319595113396645, -0.03987140953540802, 0.008813676424324512, -0.015217699110507965, -0.02373410388827324, -0.11427154392004013, 0.029102101922035217, 0.02860633283853531, -0.0615285225212574, -0.08009656518697739, 0.027473170310258865, -0.016370104625821114, 0.04342491179704666, 0.06320220232009888, 0.019858257845044136, -0.01994481310248375, -0.009672684594988823, -0.03090530075132847, 0.017831947654485703, -0.0042571756057441235, 0.04663943499326706, -0.011337535455822945, 0.08126813173294067, 0.06422452628612518, -0.04596136510372162, -0.02686278522014618, 0.041322894394397736, -0.03121616318821907, 0.0026372678112238646, -0.05071283504366875, -0.020998243242502213, 0.02163105085492134, -0.0779816210269928, -0.0287589430809021, 0.050358690321445465, -0.013876239769160748, -0.034007031470537186, -0.012617470696568489, 0.016279201954603195, 0.01609848439693451, -0.03334913030266762, -0.04854872077703476, -0.002385832369327545, -0.04860964044928551, -0.003308618441224098, -0.08606421947479248, 0.028998859226703644, -0.026626935228705406, -0.018158890306949615, -0.0005523007712326944, -0.0680411159992218, -0.031443025916814804, -0.011656897142529488, 0.058208927512168884, 0.02076144516468048, -0.011886212974786758, 0.016985224559903145 ]
3,501
Biologically Constrained Barrel Cortex Model Integrates Whisker Inputs and Replicates Key Brain Network Dynamics
https://openreview.net/forum?id=UvfI4grcM7
[ "Tianfang Zhu", "Dongli Hu", "Jiandong Zhou", "Kai Du", "Anan LI" ]
Spotlight
The brain's ability to transform sensory inputs into motor functions is central to neuroscience and crucial for the development of embodied intelligence. Sensory-motor integration involves complex neural circuits, diverse neuronal types, and intricate intercellular connections. Bridging the gap between biological realism and behavioral functionality presents a formidable challenge. In this study, we focus on the columnar structure of the superficial layers of mouse barrel cortex as a model system. We constructed a model comprising 4,218 neurons across 13 neuronal subtypes, with neural distribution and connection strengths constrained by anatomical experimental findings. A key innovation of our work is the development of an effective construction and training pipeline tailored for this biologically constrained model. Additionally, we converted an existing simulated whisker sweep dataset into a spiking-based format, enabling our network to be trained and tested on neural signals that more closely mimic those observed in biological systems. The results of object discrimination utilizing whisker signals demonstrate that our barrel cortex model, grounded in biological constraints, achieves a classification accuracy exceeds classical convolutional neural networks (CNNs), recurrent neural networks (RNNs), and long short-term memory networks (LSTMs), by an average of 8.6%, and is on par with recent spiking neural networks (SNNs) in performance. Interestingly, a whisker deprivation experiment, designed in accordance with neuroscience practices, further validates the perceptual capabilities of our model in behavioral tasks. Critically, it offers significant biological interpretability: post-training analysis reveals that neurons within our model exhibit firing characteristics and distribution patterns similar to those observed in the actual neuronal systems of the barrel cortex. This study advances our understanding of neural processing in the barrel cortex and exemplifies how integrating detailed biological structures into neural network models can enhance both scientific inquiry and artificial intelligence applications. The code is available at https://github.com/fun0515/RSNN_bfd.
Barrel cortex, biophysical modeling, sensory-motor integration, recurrent spiking neural networks
Training a biologically constrained barrel cortex model and exploring its biological interpretability.
7,299
null
[ -0.04083713889122009, 0.004604260437190533, -0.015806732699275017, 0.009148098528385162, 0.039598628878593445, 0.021747076883912086, 0.03578319028019905, 0.006845396943390369, -0.042446818202733994, -0.0395967997610569, -0.0017375575844198465, -0.02381283976137638, -0.05217267572879791, 0.0012639024062082171, -0.027659470215439796, 0.04708559811115265, 0.06083054095506668, -0.0286624226719141, 0.014228381216526031, 0.0038658161647617817, 0.022358819842338562, -0.03552407771348953, 0.03204694762825966, 0.0320434533059597, 0.03703431785106659, -0.03380551561713219, 0.018505461513996124, -0.00031831470550969243, -0.010740254074335098, 0.007300304248929024, 0.022344745695590973, -0.010889495722949505, -0.011622395366430283, -0.051195304840803146, 0.03653203696012497, 0.03211008757352829, -0.03215933218598366, -0.013859310187399387, -0.012544660829007626, -0.02543538808822632, -0.045939985662698746, 0.01615212671458721, -0.011761303059756756, 0.03232716768980026, -0.04438618943095207, 0.027457034215331078, -0.09526124596595764, 0.027875816449522972, 0.014562851749360561, -0.0038744083140045404, -0.10644984245300293, 0.020194966346025467, 0.013974067755043507, -0.02958652935922146, 0.0012503585312515497, 0.021323613822460175, 0.020343942567706108, -0.0429534874856472, -0.009366439655423164, -0.07003016024827957, 0.0019750052597373724, 0.0067659099586308, -0.004097743425518274, 0.004329166375100613, -0.03011280670762062, 0.008515660651028156, 0.03126579523086548, 0.028059080243110657, -0.053444650024175644, 0.016542576253414154, -0.012963222339749336, -0.027493350207805634, -0.007686686236411333, 0.011449921876192093, 0.006796620320528746, -0.061458393931388855, -0.004270717967301607, 0.019527843222022057, 0.09210323542356491, 0.01979174092411995, 0.04111441969871521, 0.026938075199723244, 0.011168407276272774, 0.022716695442795753, 0.014503736048936844, 0.023491518571972847, -0.03484058752655983, -0.04898928105831146, -0.10546215623617172, 0.03283315524458885, -0.05239646136760712, -0.017390290275216103, 0.025163959711790085, 0.04722040146589279, 0.032749008387327194, 0.019559144973754883, 0.020464329048991203, -0.006556104402989149, 0.003325809957459569, -0.00044939492363482714, -0.00804972741752863, 0.0038343723863363266, 0.00832513440400362, 0.011357376351952553, -0.08466985821723938, -0.030820677056908607, 0.005108776967972517, -0.03702237829566002, -0.001160059473477304, -0.00411728722974658, -0.03963356465101242, -0.012993504293262959, 0.026987524703145027, 0.010333879850804806, -0.08924860507249832, 0.0606812983751297, 0.026911122724413872, 0.03389153257012367, -0.016237309202551842, -0.018260076642036438, 0.03713993355631828, 0.045911528170108795, -0.015202498994767666, 0.046622999012470245, 0.0001287814084207639, -0.005198243074119091, 0.007816050201654434, 0.01600978709757328, 0.007272443734109402, -0.04616164788603783, -0.000562136119697243, 0.040641847997903824, 0.0006694372859783471, 0.0010948345297947526, -0.0014441069215536118, 0.0012809212785214186, 0.0396825335919857, -0.0037460513412952423, 0.02545250579714775, 0.05997272580862045, -0.004663282539695501, -0.042113907635211945, 0.042131755501031876, -0.05203954130411148, 0.07892319560050964, -0.029662685468792915, -0.03224693238735199, -0.00008894129132386297, -0.03736983239650726, -0.008534595370292664, -0.003069758415222168, 0.015599427744746208, -0.00385673507116735, -0.08667541295289993, 0.018595552071928978, 0.07069274038076401, 0.010382800363004208, 0.009024782106280327, -0.0012790507171303034, -0.0010476461611688137, 0.024660907685756683, -0.039612043648958206, -0.0208680909126997, 0.002705699997022748, -0.008654242381453514, -0.028581587597727776, 0.041974566876888275, 0.013504001311957836, -0.04351715371012688, 0.012433457188308239, -0.03367563709616661, -0.03739326819777489, 0.04848916456103325, -0.0011730098631232977, -0.009026817046105862, -0.034686196595430374, 0.04747878387570381, -0.018098467960953712, 0.016090907156467438, 0.04000105708837509, -0.07721889764070511, 0.07073238492012024, -0.0030020561534911394, 0.0013863317435607314, -0.003987602889537811, -0.03434252738952637, 0.08961816132068634, -0.048442739993333817, -0.029126960784196854, 0.03048097901046276, -0.045679833739995956, -0.03035697527229786, 0.021598482504487038, -0.0232541561126709, 0.07859135419130325, -0.01288407389074564, -0.024455921724438667, 0.026446929201483727, 0.01003151573240757, 0.06401659548282623, 0.03835218772292137, -0.043093569576740265, 0.03622525557875633, -0.013003265485167503, -0.030539292842149734, -0.035786695778369904, 0.0466085821390152, -0.05195149406790733, 0.03377806022763252, -0.011615348979830742, -0.016207445412874222, 0.00133768399246037, 0.00885901041328907, -0.02465452067553997, 0.056554969400167465, -0.01548613142222166, -0.011138825677335262, 0.027391718700528145, -0.017145154997706413, -0.04965377599000931, -0.006840330082923174, 0.013768347911536694, -0.023425301536917686, 0.016966616734862328, -0.021137209609150887, 0.11178312450647354, 0.06389082968235016, -0.037503499537706375, -0.025205694139003754, 0.013199716806411743, 0.02564235031604767, 0.01008833572268486, -0.004781743045896292, 0.022684916853904724, 0.010193387977778912, -0.005735127255320549, 0.0038825939409434795, -0.031114736571907997, 0.062074292451143265, -0.06396540999412537, -0.02091449871659279, 0.10188446938991547, -0.01884407363831997, 0.04038883373141289, -0.02435716614127159, 0.0038683428429067135, 0.07630894333124161, -0.025719260796904564, -0.011016950942575932, -0.016763893887400627, -0.025205204263329506, 0.021307725459337234, -0.011435480788350105, -0.012776503339409828, 0.024376893416047096, -0.06170075759291649, -0.04866490140557289, -0.031726986169815063, 0.06684388220310211, 0.04302816838026047, 0.028357332572340965, 0.027417056262493134, 0.0009760234970599413, 0.005757972132414579, -0.051023803651332855, -0.11847707629203796, -0.01705644652247429, -0.017716078087687492, 0.05206279456615448, -0.015472925268113613, 0.031119391322135925, 0.008612453937530518, 0.029159056022763252, -0.03213797137141228, -0.006338729057461023, 0.03047829121351242, 0.0012242826633155346, -0.03917043283581734, -0.01582794263958931, -0.04123431071639061, 0.003845038590952754, 0.06799444556236267, 0.013417383655905724, -0.012376588769257069, 0.02030797116458416, -0.08029510080814362, -0.022926131263375282, 0.0065092043951153755, 0.027950135990977287, -0.019828718155622482, -0.02253897860646248, 0.014371203258633614, -0.02105891704559326, 0.014678958803415298, -0.000533198588527739, 0.08347424119710922, 0.04691771790385246, 0.018041539937257767, 0.00588338915258646, 0.022274743765592575, -0.021572083234786987, 0.014885633252561092, -0.026096729561686516, 0.003856606548652053, -0.018800143152475357, 0.03757714107632637, 0.023016193881630898, -0.01926896907389164, -0.26832228899002075, -0.015421677380800247, -0.004081538412719965, -0.03782316669821739, 0.03226255625486374, -0.009842777624726295, 0.05020389333367348, -0.035337597131729126, -0.022172851487994194, 0.016573047265410423, 0.018908649682998657, 0.039510250091552734, 0.005929234903305769, 0.06665972620248795, 0.04265977814793587, -0.014685583300888538, -0.0033317499328404665, -0.058400921523571014, -0.007198748178780079, 0.003548026317730546, -0.017338939011096954, -0.06564638763666153, -0.03934057429432869, 0.04948355257511139, -0.001542252372018993, 0.041462261229753494, -0.07031918317079544, -0.0011452586622908711, -0.03359617665410042, -0.0005918075912632048, -0.02861141785979271, -0.03422475978732109, -0.009592336602509022, 0.03411759063601494, 0.017906468361616135, 0.00486834067851305, 0.0319075807929039, -0.005080241244286299, 0.044210292398929596, 0.0020380609203130007, 0.00974588468670845, -0.03012847527861595, -0.0019174267072230577, -0.0004409144457895309, 0.07182876765727997, 0.012569192796945572, -0.04487866908311844, -0.005047209095209837, -0.0010687230387702584, 0.03502514585852623, -0.027018455788493156, -0.020388174802064896, -0.022524990141391754, 0.015373891219496727, 0.020628521218895912, -0.023190809413790703, 0.021962333470582962, 0.0028915416914969683, 0.003630040679126978, -0.023968735709786415, -0.021999837830662727, -0.028025005012750626, -0.033524468541145325, -0.03896921128034592, 0.004778393544256687, -0.033284250646829605, -0.06282977014780045, -0.06734742969274521, 0.04914621263742447, 0.026428120210766792, 0.021669447422027588, -0.01328020729124546, -0.0500270240008831, -0.10522846132516861, 0.042031824588775635, -0.0006164590013213456, -0.03184501454234123, -0.027870796620845795, 0.01556331105530262, 0.016195915639400482, -0.004909730050712824, -0.037847407162189484, -0.012135269120335579, 0.03935467451810837, 0.004325632005929947, -0.007929433137178421, 0.017139317467808723, -0.017849981784820557, -0.0279806200414896, -0.019757652655243874, 0.03422445058822632, -0.0038698152638971806, 0.011843663640320301, -0.04407823085784912, 0.011970718391239643, 0.007491552736610174, 0.02486247383058071, 0.05158311873674393, 0.03274483233690262, -0.0032686374615877867, 0.06298261880874634, -0.05998529493808746, -0.06459435075521469, -0.04055342078208923, -0.04012523591518402, 0.008617143146693707, -0.05539810657501221, -0.03264584392309189, 0.07046815752983093, 0.021470090374350548, -0.01489095576107502, -0.02831421233713627, -0.0034215173218399286, -0.05015041306614876, -0.011420778930187225, -0.0276485588401556, -0.014743800275027752, 0.04299390688538551, 0.015120168216526508, -0.034182872623205185, -0.027516068890690804, 0.017540721222758293, -0.03880232572555542, 0.015648245811462402, 0.015539278276264668, 0.00743506383150816, -0.017167700454592705, -0.010187583044171333, -0.022643866017460823, -0.0029277747962623835, 0.051148299127817154, 0.01569007895886898, -0.00693603465333581, 0.04607006907463074, 0.04524005204439163, 0.040790654718875885, -0.002078596968203783, 0.01635145954787731, 0.013267372734844685, -0.017852015793323517, 0.020819449797272682, -0.008317099884152412, 0.03785056993365288, 0.029625719413161278, -0.010584029369056225, 0.032680612057447433, 0.011591033078730106, 0.0065190973691642284, -0.02133042924106121, 0.03015011176466942, 0.031310923397541046, -0.04131900891661644, -0.03743007406592369, -0.02848254330456257, -0.023376788944005966, -0.042144183069467545, 0.024533575400710106, 0.02908196672797203, 0.02614276297390461, -0.07275395840406418, 0.02119258977472782, 0.009195560589432716, -0.007096120622009039, 0.005063922610133886, -0.0005559656419791281, 0.06265345960855484, -0.018294071778655052, 0.0025061063934117556, 0.014564364217221737, -0.009875153191387653, 0.015974674373865128, -0.018199218437075615, -0.00899240281432867, -0.00862949714064598, -0.04373307153582573, -0.006585295777767897, 0.012127045542001724, -0.029698289930820465, -0.009158422239124775, 0.029881462454795837, 0.021301576867699623, -0.035859715193510056, 0.021173397079110146, -0.0025821032468229532, 0.06820595264434814, 0.0008074407815001905, 0.024584272876381874, -0.02495478093624115, -0.012649132870137691, 0.012090373784303665, -0.010545835830271244, 0.02097270078957081, -0.02583739534020424, -0.021698007360100746, -0.04294406995177269, -0.02303915284574032, -0.016258519142866135, 0.055747829377651215, -0.0235865768045187, -0.04831670969724655, 0.011509542353451252, 0.013197743333876133, -0.03035990335047245, 0.027844276279211044, 0.07002966105937958, -0.07680727541446686, 0.0043501053005456924, 0.03157723322510719, -0.001712055061943829, 0.028321288526058197, -0.0050260392017662525, 0.005884924903512001, -0.03589271381497383, -0.012486571446061134, 0.017967771738767624, 0.004088848363608122, 0.002826401498168707, -0.03469912335276604, -0.00857953354716301, 0.020456572994589806, -0.004946662113070488, 0.008407610468566418, -0.010710721835494041, -0.03888962045311928, -0.01742863655090332, 0.012174626812338829, -0.0029800748452544212, 0.021900197491049767, 0.027639664709568024, -0.02708015777170658, 0.022491401061415672, -0.048295583575963974, -0.018674608319997787, 0.051188431680202484, -0.0003873721288982779, -0.027474481612443924, -0.05788644403219223, 0.032808125019073486, 0.016430258750915527, 0.009305178187787533, 0.003721006214618683, 0.020948264747858047, -0.06598704308271408, 0.031134184449911118, -0.0013839737512171268, 0.04453379288315773, 0.0067787268199026585, 0.02070656605064869, 0.013602831400930882, 0.00023674101976212114, 0.023297013714909554, -0.012538731098175049, 0.003393936902284622, 0.01487780548632145, 0.04934319108724594, -0.00946555845439434, -0.016051067039370537, -0.054896194487810135, -0.037446290254592896, -0.012431671842932701, -0.01828181929886341, 0.03972749784588814, -0.06124855950474739, 0.07289901375770569, 0.032888397574424744, 0.009977443143725395, -0.04276182875037193, -0.031802136451005936, 0.026665931567549706, -0.06137306988239288, 0.023979537189006805, -0.007815450429916382, -0.05438018590211868, 0.04705972969532013, -0.05004534125328064, -0.014107510447502136, 0.02120084874331951, -0.021079326048493385, 0.06109706684947014, -0.0432104654610157, -0.04490688815712929, 0.03188006579875946, -0.049949806183576584, -0.024023666977882385, 0.015321721322834492, -0.05133191496133804, 0.0073259565979242325, -0.07070975750684738, -0.025632306933403015, -0.010759314522147179, 0.01933307759463787, 0.05400218814611435, -0.016343342140316963, 0.017003703862428665, 0.004057424608618021, -0.008809120394289494, 0.03714687377214432, 0.06401541829109192, 0.017064861953258514, 0.022747499868273735, -0.038707185536623, 0.06613460183143616, 0.030184442177414894, 0.03004969097673893, 0.01254995446652174, 0.014934134669601917, 0.01998802274465561, -0.04096313193440437, -0.0009453066159039736, -0.002519059693440795, 0.00563074229285121, -0.059158436954021454, 0.05713924393057823, -0.005118757952004671, -0.0350567102432251, 0.007096582092344761, 0.03506502881646156, -0.03777715191245079, -0.000016348240023944527, 0.01615825481712818, 0.0017813234589993954, -0.006864542607218027, 0.061515454202890396, 0.020713655278086662, 0.04731898009777069, 0.07579567283391953, 0.02265063114464283, 0.007949842140078545, -0.0048174927942454815, 0.08698195964097977, 0.0816875696182251, 0.02014787681400776, 0.041227102279663086, 0.0986502394080162, -0.03132631257176399, -0.04322116822004318, 0.026834804564714432, 0.03614469990134239, -0.002044441644102335, -0.02136869914829731, 0.05117245763540268, 0.09476850181818008, -0.013676781207323074, 0.06862452626228333, -0.0239983182400465, -0.005791685078293085, 0.04283931851387024, -0.006189238745719194, 0.00541875371709466, 0.02954051084816456, 0.05057726800441742, -0.0077250683680176735, -0.005390834528952837, -0.0050362166948616505, -0.005078267306089401, -0.06659829616546631, 0.02445285953581333, 0.02345319092273712, -0.01631636917591095, 0.02404068596661091, -0.027974694967269897, 0.04145436733961105, 0.10121389478445053, -0.012566585093736649, 0.010226544924080372, -0.004222105722874403, -0.0003936999128200114, 0.025319168344140053, 0.0406431183218956, 0.025973383337259293, 0.008923778310418129, -0.04435104876756668, -0.03846539556980133, 0.01760116033256054, 0.0026621625293046236, 0.03655707463622093, 0.015118195675313473, -0.05460543558001518, -0.004002759233117104, -0.014178071171045303, -0.008921623229980469, -0.043702322989702225, -0.060692742466926575, -0.02105005830526352, -0.019493047147989273, -0.036362458020448685, -0.0426105335354805, 0.03813882917165756, -0.019325638189911842, -0.06331107765436172, -0.007886504754424095, 0.03169269487261772, -0.007509852759540081, 0.007170744705945253, -0.044746872037649155, -0.014878838323056698, 0.03368775546550751, -0.014769216068089008, -0.0013945630053058267, 0.06435788422822952, 0.037003450095653534, -0.003886467544361949, -0.037965744733810425, 0.045767586678266525, -0.015724340453743935, 0.03234178572893143, -0.009521912783384323, -0.030768271535634995, -0.08623607456684113, -0.0068572587333619595, 0.008781641721725464, -0.02250017784535885, -0.08855581283569336, 0.01649218052625656, -0.026880167424678802, 0.03738747537136078, 0.052467577159404755, -0.045355021953582764, -0.004824410658329725, -0.05582256242632866, -0.03536617010831833, -0.01458789873868227, -0.008030814118683338, 0.055868156254291534, -0.011774775572121143, 0.06384864449501038, 0.06794711202383041, -0.007976134307682514, -0.016198884695768356, 0.015257527120411396, -0.010422427207231522, -0.018746813759207726, -0.026126617565751076, -0.025816285982728004, 0.010086488910019398, -0.11126698553562164, -0.017989540472626686, 0.03290150687098503, 0.008870412595570087, -0.05001042038202286, 0.005577895324677229, -0.030085450038313866, 0.047349102795124054, -0.029603328555822372, -0.011167798191308975, -0.03785659372806549, -0.0165969617664814, -0.04764460772275925, -0.06357955932617188, 0.005296868737787008, -0.013776346109807491, 0.022884756326675415, -0.02943224087357521, -0.019554195925593376, -0.006468542851507664, 0.0036761597730219364, 0.01913655549287796, 0.027735689654946327, -0.0029095918871462345, 0.02009214088320732 ]
3,502
FairMT-Bench: Benchmarking Fairness for Multi-turn Dialogue in Conversational LLMs
https://openreview.net/forum?id=RSGoXnS9GH
[ "Zhiting Fan", "Ruizhe Chen", "Tianxiang Hu", "Zuozhu Liu" ]
Spotlight
The increasing deployment of large language model (LLM)-based chatbots has raised concerns regarding fairness. Fairness issues in LLMs may result in serious consequences, such as bias amplification, discrimination, and harm to minority groups. Many efforts are dedicated to evaluating and mitigating biases in LLMs. However, existing fairness benchmarks mainly focus on single-turn dialogues, while multi-turn scenarios, which better reflect real-world conversations, pose greater challenges due to conversational complexity and risk for bias accumulation. In this paper, we introduce a comprehensive benchmark for fairness of LLMs in multi-turn scenarios, **FairMT-Bench**. Specifically, We propose a task taxonomy to evaluate fairness of LLMs cross three stages: context understanding, interaction fairness, and fairness trade-offs, each comprising two tasks. To ensure coverage of diverse bias types and attributes, our multi-turn dialogue dataset FairMT-10K is constructed by integrating data from established fairness benchmarks. For evaluation, we employ GPT-4 along with bias classifiers like Llama-Guard-3, and human annotators to ensure robustness. Our experiments and analysis on FairMT-10K reveal that in multi-turn dialogue scenarios, LLMs are more prone to generating biased responses, showing significant variation in performance across different tasks and models. Based on these findings, we develop a more challenging dataset, FairMT-1K, and test 15 current state-of-the-art (SOTA) LLMs on this dataset. The results highlight the current state of fairness in LLMs and demonstrate the value of this benchmark for evaluating fairness of LLMs in more realistic multi-turn dialogue contexts. This underscores the need for future works to enhance LLM fairness and incorporate FairMT-1K in such efforts. Our code and dataset are available at https://github.com/FanZT6/FairMT-bench.
Fairness, Benchmark, Large language model
null
7,273
null
[ -0.004314528778195381, -0.03524422645568848, -0.027765028178691864, 0.02434215322136879, -0.0060233986005187035, 0.03870534524321556, 0.027729112654924393, 0.047175318002700806, -0.03058198094367981, -0.003748059505596757, -0.00862754788249731, 0.05392978712916374, -0.07813172042369843, -0.032187022268772125, 0.010647045448422432, 0.0446450337767601, 0.015013998374342918, -0.03791731595993042, 0.013103802688419819, -0.009888587519526482, 0.021082036197185516, 0.006540846545249224, 0.043580107390880585, -0.014608982019126415, 0.048675503581762314, 0.026464879512786865, 0.028463806957006454, 0.0056808339431881905, -0.05121150612831116, 0.02087598294019699, 0.03321099653840065, -0.016354406252503395, 0.017601560801267624, 0.010141955688595772, 0.009522205218672752, 0.0008406308479607105, -0.053772855550050735, 0.05265248939394951, 0.02645786665380001, 0.017633195966482162, -0.019238194450736046, 0.02388892136514187, -0.009271099232137203, 0.02184402383863926, -0.054313406348228455, 0.02025730349123478, -0.1030195876955986, 0.024677129462361336, 0.004087470937520266, 0.004415194038301706, -0.10569789260625839, 0.01764553412795067, -0.03191453963518143, 0.029025642201304436, -0.002030160976573825, 0.04834588244557381, -0.0030363977421075106, -0.1391790807247162, -0.02198503166437149, 0.00033235008595511317, -0.03229827806353569, 0.005952329840511084, 0.02900419570505619, -0.006723439786583185, 0.03993309289216995, 0.0006357901729643345, 0.013680546544492245, -0.006747618317604065, -0.0682072639465332, -0.026358915492892265, -0.02734500542283058, 0.009847160428762436, -0.0007199905812740326, -0.01202322542667389, 0.02188652753829956, -0.0780804380774498, -0.009495626203715801, 0.05584871768951416, 0.05792941898107529, 0.007711998652666807, -0.030198585242033005, -0.005636656656861305, 0.029467469081282616, 0.05839332193136215, 0.026525462046265602, 0.0011815791949629784, -0.0016113168094307184, -0.013506222516298294, -0.07400655001401901, 0.012566398829221725, 0.021779974922537804, -0.07668883353471756, 0.007139267399907112, 0.005929649341851473, 0.03537578508257866, -0.026501262560486794, 0.0427420437335968, 0.01979944482445717, 0.0025495050940662622, 0.020866939797997475, -0.022385133430361748, -0.042677950114011765, 0.029673896729946136, 0.014640631154179573, -0.14242759346961975, -0.00835507269948721, -0.015800155699253082, -0.011401978321373463, 0.004168346524238586, 0.035384949296712875, -0.03399672359228134, -0.002938753692433238, 0.04253801330924034, -0.004336733371019363, -0.07843250036239624, 0.03036886267364025, 0.0054906816221773624, -0.01320003904402256, 0.0063276272267103195, 0.026655549183487892, 0.06923909485340118, 0.04808676242828369, 0.02868783287703991, 0.08034978061914444, -0.0007421038462780416, 0.023625914007425308, 0.039227187633514404, 0.04427103325724602, -0.014038095250725746, -0.029015816748142242, 0.031271256506443024, 0.04516417533159256, -0.0068556698970496655, 0.00969747081398964, -0.002641693688929081, -0.006603355053812265, 0.04017490893602371, 0.005461595486849546, 0.06471656262874603, 0.013912439346313477, 0.017910901457071304, -0.012325615622103214, 0.05396100506186485, 0.003618411021307111, 0.0384175181388855, -0.021135415881872177, -0.055816736072301865, -0.02380651794373989, -0.02359239012002945, 0.025270937010645866, 0.002462489763274789, 0.006671329960227013, 0.008097238838672638, -0.06536561250686646, 0.037285447120666504, 0.04593511298298836, 0.003561505349352956, -0.03990936651825905, -0.007597330026328564, 0.009833663702011108, -0.02374093048274517, 0.019476961344480515, -0.06284727901220322, -0.024418000131845474, 0.022374330088496208, -0.011754326522350311, 0.02334275282919407, -0.02370639517903328, -0.04054146260023117, 0.0349314846098423, -0.030653828755021095, -0.006101144943386316, 0.052220165729522705, -0.033912234008312225, -0.05368447303771973, 0.007576823700219393, 0.03906465321779251, 0.036750677973032, 0.030709486454725266, 0.011130825616419315, -0.05368039757013321, -0.004951723851263523, 0.012495535425841808, 0.003989625722169876, 0.06682197749614716, 0.005535847507417202, 0.06585085391998291, -0.044099316000938416, -0.02010422758758068, 0.03341291472315788, -0.06696418672800064, 0.015856461599469185, 0.029207123443484306, 0.02289964072406292, 0.07411710917949677, -0.03496088832616806, 0.03702812269330025, 0.04398432746529579, 0.012600469402968884, 0.04720228537917137, 0.06123530864715576, -0.013428883627057076, 0.031154166907072067, -0.020057344809174538, -0.05604279413819313, -0.011904950253665447, 0.031610243022441864, -0.042513929307460785, -0.05125715956091881, 0.029514184221625328, -0.04801981896162033, 0.03144768998026848, 0.028979694470763206, 0.02144319750368595, -0.01317567564547062, -0.03022409975528717, -0.003988234791904688, -0.016767611727118492, 0.007135745137929916, -0.012069125659763813, 0.039492636919021606, 0.045009952038526535, 0.020699327811598778, -0.010190259665250778, -0.02099752612411976, 0.08289548009634018, 0.04946814477443695, 0.0032223195303231478, -0.014529219828546047, 0.0392913892865181, 0.00726504297927022, 0.006983435712754726, -0.0227353572845459, -0.013560011051595211, 0.008970909751951694, -0.041628170758485794, 0.005569532047957182, -0.013794359751045704, 0.07046230137348175, -0.009198700077831745, 0.005822535138577223, 0.0470796637237072, -0.008343963883817196, 0.04798969253897667, -0.0034564975649118423, 0.01925191842019558, -0.019419508054852486, -0.019754912704229355, -0.019998714327812195, -0.03590007126331329, -0.00885428860783577, -0.009552336297929287, 0.014837563037872314, -0.031024673953652382, -0.005714721512049437, -0.02317165583372116, 0.003267318941652775, -0.0029836478643119335, 0.025001253932714462, 0.04138144105672836, 0.02516615390777588, 0.030016513541340828, 0.02054731361567974, -0.044864948838949203, 0.0013962326338514686, -0.10878614336252213, -0.06104448437690735, -0.009537390433251858, 0.02512127347290516, -0.02010900154709816, 0.054065607488155365, -0.01980411261320114, 0.00549312261864543, -0.03498610109090805, -0.01401827484369278, 0.008722677826881409, 0.0017240585293620825, -0.03123684786260128, -0.04191449284553528, -0.028134837746620178, -0.029328899458050728, 0.026148905977606773, -0.021606488153338432, -0.03278304636478424, -0.016107194125652313, -0.02525412105023861, -0.000922803592402488, -0.08270137012004852, 0.0186044629663229, 0.00806618295609951, -0.019029738381505013, -0.011402934789657593, 0.01260102167725563, -0.02138788439333439, 0.026691220700740814, 0.020246803760528564, 0.03259720653295517, -0.0041274502873420715, -0.02881099097430706, 0.04018498957157135, -0.0077046058140695095, 0.005927655380219221, 0.003554542316123843, 0.02525811642408371, -0.018088368698954582, -0.0231457632035017, 0.008313539437949657, -0.011277311481535435, -0.26199591159820557, -0.01399972289800644, 0.004477738402783871, 0.004952713847160339, 0.03695741295814514, -0.046132128685712814, 0.08024442195892334, -0.004410133231431246, -0.007906724698841572, -0.00035282489261589944, -0.002059241756796837, 0.030489481985569, -0.028934059664607048, 0.03907644748687744, 0.02454598806798458, 0.04977015033364296, -0.03851212188601494, -0.04700867459177971, 0.03196388855576515, 0.031221656128764153, -0.01885562390089035, -0.06859040260314941, -0.039830904453992844, 0.06295160204172134, 0.006256927736103535, 0.038099728524684906, -0.039657317101955414, -0.04062044620513916, -0.04491736367344856, -0.008675524033606052, 0.006166503299027681, -0.001998486230149865, -0.025893615558743477, -0.0014896667562425137, 0.01921840012073517, 0.006692133843898773, 0.06442410498857498, 0.02830852009356022, 0.03762112930417061, 0.04075511544942856, 0.03829042613506317, -0.03314503654837608, -0.0336439348757267, 0.024608222767710686, 0.0684935599565506, 0.017926795408129692, -0.030393211171030998, -0.03184737637639046, -0.03119937889277935, 0.032324694097042084, -0.004735041409730911, -0.04938475415110588, -0.02811948023736477, 0.03931257873773575, 0.011532341130077839, -0.015119931660592556, -0.031229155138134956, -0.03230928257107735, -0.0010183993726968765, -0.00956887099891901, -0.04375426471233368, -0.03301507607102394, -0.05751148238778114, -0.010262362658977509, -0.04047903046011925, -0.07474426180124283, -0.07564353942871094, -0.051981665194034576, 0.03603358194231987, 0.04751022905111313, -0.019249120727181435, -0.003512586699798703, 0.013346610590815544, -0.08193430304527283, -0.0017673977417871356, -0.005644962657243013, -0.04207899421453476, -0.02839343249797821, -0.030122384428977966, 0.054346535354852676, -0.018404707312583923, -0.04601799696683884, 0.02071133442223072, -0.03982555866241455, 0.01781349442899227, -0.0007295405957847834, 0.0015317429788410664, -0.03148479014635086, -0.01583312265574932, -0.012169494293630123, 0.0440029501914978, 0.0056376950815320015, -0.020216504111886024, 0.015209829434752464, 0.04782998189330101, -0.016264718025922775, -0.0028195541817694902, 0.03438457474112511, 0.02501961588859558, 0.030392302200198174, 0.040389396250247955, -0.07366640120744705, -0.0008927312446758151, -0.03414737805724144, -0.03056393750011921, 0.022008733823895454, -0.07481120526790619, -0.022528665140271187, 0.008838020265102386, -0.000849367817863822, -0.01926841214299202, -0.0026707006618380547, -0.006463401485234499, 0.010480981320142746, -0.014335582964122295, -0.01692681945860386, 0.016974451020359993, 0.02423834428191185, 0.03457662835717201, -0.01618266850709915, -0.003474092809483409, 0.029698599129915237, -0.024899853393435478, 0.008522349409759045, -0.02674349583685398, 0.0012111869873479009, -0.02711666002869606, -0.0005274701397866011, -0.03423560410737991, 0.031323548406362534, 0.000005582091034739278, 0.005051710642874241, -0.0032125862780958414, -0.0047109308652579784, 0.04137811064720154, -0.011284074746072292, 0.007278009783476591, -0.005597903858870268, 0.0066080414690077305, 0.0018344658892601728, 0.05214019864797592, -0.03590518236160278, 0.014917171560227871, 0.025872690603137016, 0.074271060526371, 0.010966979898512363, 0.03688817471265793, -0.0325976200401783, -0.025817908346652985, 0.027555039152503014, 0.04712904989719391, -0.06500591337680817, 0.002213245490565896, -0.027027970179915428, 0.050073035061359406, 0.020654061809182167, -0.01927700825035572, 0.0176302008330822, -0.0029300448950380087, -0.0840081050992012, 0.020665675401687622, 0.020924312993884087, 0.005912318825721741, -0.0011080960975959897, 0.03635257109999657, 0.020185891538858414, -0.004141739569604397, 0.01732584834098816, 0.02837495319545269, 0.012838955037295818, -0.012871723622083664, -0.049046073108911514, -0.010464604012668133, 0.01578863337635994, -0.016926661133766174, -0.010767355561256409, 0.025286322459578514, -0.00982852652668953, -0.008450969122350216, 0.027568001300096512, -0.026867151260375977, -0.026150310412049294, 0.007843819446861744, -0.000006192962246132083, 0.07472996413707733, 0.006331792101264, 0.007515566889196634, 0.03229936212301254, 0.004652426578104496, 0.0111772445961833, -0.011416291818022728, 0.008457600139081478, -0.006725644692778587, -0.042483147233724594, -0.05079975351691246, -0.05763302370905876, 0.027910126373171806, -0.02371901087462902, 0.011167480610311031, -0.03890063986182213, -0.03891267627477646, 0.0132994269952178, -0.03556027263402939, -0.006881525740027428, 0.0325322225689888, -0.10316342860460281, -0.0027190649416297674, 0.00036803967668674886, -0.03734841197729111, 0.03838485851883888, -0.020816616714000702, -0.035937193781137466, -0.029956597834825516, -0.033527448773384094, 0.007197657134383917, -0.0602886900305748, -0.024927090853452682, -0.024895913898944855, -0.028133271262049675, -0.01649039052426815, -0.013996708206832409, -0.05998753011226654, 0.019582292065024376, 0.004221538081765175, -0.011367375031113625, 0.025729307904839516, -0.05187329649925232, 0.0016677802195772529, 0.005086034536361694, -0.02580118551850319, 0.00950092263519764, -0.052341435104608536, 0.05640309676527977, 0.04572072625160217, -0.011231417767703533, -0.00037242224789224565, -0.06189906597137451, 0.017780210822820663, 0.007200074382126331, -0.00110004679299891, -0.006841796450316906, -0.009574364870786667, -0.03702252730727196, -0.008543095551431179, 0.005569619592279196, 0.03841527923941612, 0.012902948074042797, -0.012486787512898445, -0.027209417894482613, -0.0007537365891039371, -0.008466329425573349, 0.016229145228862762, -0.03312324360013008, 0.01614517904818058, 0.022987214848399162, -0.06289303302764893, -0.0004999891389161348, -0.07491282373666763, -0.06625368446111679, -0.003846687264740467, -0.027527328580617905, 0.030195968225598335, -0.06421232223510742, 0.03687170520424843, 0.0027578368317335844, 0.008195021189749241, 0.05326522886753082, -0.05052405223250389, 0.026133164763450623, -0.02398751676082611, -0.00829010084271431, -0.04340573772788048, -0.019727958366274834, 0.03721022605895996, -0.018229059875011444, -0.007257538847625256, -0.025873938575387, -0.017187222838401794, 0.03779162839055061, -0.01992575079202652, -0.012306241318583488, -0.01633278653025627, -0.023491084575653076, -0.002715128706768155, 0.09023549407720566, -0.039341289550065994, 0.007053101900964975, 0.004250121768563986, -0.023122217506170273, -0.009281735867261887, 0.002784309908747673, 0.06366703659296036, -0.0182989202439785, 0.044154565781354904, -0.04808903485536575, -0.00047990219900384545, 0.017431208863854408, 0.03755565360188484, 0.002148413797840476, 0.029730897396802902, -0.0020568999461829662, 0.04633133113384247, 0.04613159969449043, -0.0026304868515580893, 0.05731409415602684, 0.016458844766020775, -0.022031515836715698, -0.05265406519174576, 0.06187540665268898, 0.04372761398553848, -0.0253482423722744, -0.05267646536231041, 0.08497131615877151, 0.01795763336122036, -0.040241822600364685, 0.0027344871778041124, 0.01039515808224678, -0.05045377090573311, 0.027019429951906204, 0.016272980719804764, -0.005155608523637056, -0.003588254563510418, 0.07774753868579865, 0.002883904380723834, 0.06940396130084991, 0.08553507924079895, -0.002755257999524474, -0.023942342028021812, 0.03994085639715195, 0.07864212989807129, 0.06586037576198578, 0.05553533509373665, -0.026708731427788734, 0.05801135301589966, -0.03087119199335575, -0.06285388022661209, 0.016718072816729546, 0.05625506117939949, -0.017857320606708527, -0.027007177472114563, 0.009536541067063808, 0.08902205526828766, -0.02928410843014717, 0.06551174819469452, -0.013779429718852043, 0.007299170363694429, 0.03546702116727829, 0.022537726908922195, 0.029994968324899673, 0.093780018389225, 0.015532618388533592, 0.024425284937024117, -0.02274283953011036, -0.02228844165802002, 0.029659127816557884, -0.018335288390517235, 0.0007209412869997323, 0.019494565203785896, -0.020373372361063957, 0.031831543892621994, -0.004687190987169743, 0.04256165400147438, 0.10054104030132294, -0.01367622334510088, -0.05426197126507759, 0.043867915868759155, 0.027395198121666908, 0.030312616378068924, 0.027451293542981148, 0.028019892051815987, -0.01941847801208496, 0.013146425597369671, -0.039679042994976044, -0.0039062085561454296, -0.0161752812564373, -0.014046297408640385, 0.04616072028875351, -0.047459494322538376, -0.0005118815461173654, 0.038083869963884354, 0.04478178173303604, -0.04867129400372505, -0.06485521793365479, -0.03634519875049591, -0.06937909126281738, -0.013265241868793964, -0.03637184575200081, 0.02057662606239319, 0.02021024189889431, -0.04401121661067009, -0.0010989635484293103, -0.039118919521570206, 0.012288075871765614, -0.0016240732511505485, -0.07161711901426315, -0.008280141279101372, 0.041821349412202835, 0.01117822714149952, -0.03359351307153702, 0.03958592936396599, 0.04461774602532387, 0.01669647917151451, 0.02304788865149021, 0.012626750394701958, 0.04348783567547798, 0.02460482344031334, -0.03917081281542778, -0.03072577528655529, -0.056662023067474365, 0.014345003291964531, 0.018944118171930313, 0.0022492879070341587, -0.08023729920387268, 0.01889614574611187, 0.0045969984494149685, 0.045919910073280334, 0.04187360033392906, 0.040915556252002716, 0.02210365980863571, 0.023475535213947296, -0.01281667035073042, -0.019434256479144096, 0.009319732896983624, 0.027544135227799416, -0.009569141082465649, 0.042733076959848404, 0.006242965813726187, -0.056414633989334106, -0.05477006360888481, 0.022939424961805344, 0.0037796625401824713, -0.05626611411571503, -0.02276507578790188, -0.026491371914744377, -0.025326794013381004, -0.03971584513783455, -0.014299748465418816, 0.00771969323977828, -0.010936671867966652, -0.022600237280130386, 0.026426251977682114, 0.0007805454661138356, -0.04449634253978729, -0.014443570747971535, -0.013586334884166718, -0.03410306200385094, -0.016823533922433853, -0.025196237489581108, -0.057397592812776566, 0.0020133580546826124, -0.041503436863422394, -0.008894502185285091, -0.027608104050159454, -0.029079977422952652, 0.01582273654639721, 0.008214166387915611, 0.04450463876128197, -0.0017366723623126745, 0.01557159423828125, -0.018125958740711212 ]
3,503
OmniCorpus: A Unified Multimodal Corpus of 10 Billion-Level Images Interleaved with Text
https://openreview.net/forum?id=kwqhn2VuG4
[ "Qingyun Li", "Zhe Chen", "Weiyun Wang", "Wenhai Wang", "Shenglong Ye", "Zhenjiang Jin", "Guanzhou Chen", "Yinan He", "Zhangwei Gao", "Erfei Cui", "Jiashuo Yu", "Hao Tian", "Jiasheng Zhou", "Chao Xu", "Bin Wang", "Xingjian Wei", "Wei Li", "Wenjian Zhang", "Bo Zhang", "Pinlong Cai", "et al. (18 additional authors not shown)" ]
Spotlight
Image-text interleaved data, consisting of multiple images and texts arranged in a natural document format, aligns with the presentation paradigm of internet data and closely resembles human reading habits. Recent studies have shown that such data aids multimodal in-context learning and maintains the capabilities of large language models during multimodal fine-tuning. However, the limited scale and diversity of current image-text interleaved data restrict the development of multimodal large language models. In this paper, we introduce OmniCorpus, a 10 billion-scale image-text interleaved dataset. Using an efficient data engine, we filter and extract large-scale high-quality documents, which contain 8.6 billion images and 1,696 billion text tokens. Compared to counterparts (e.g., MMC4, OBELICS), our dataset 1) has 15 times larger scales while maintaining good data quality; 2) features more diverse sources, including both English and non-English websites as well as video-centric websites; 3) is more flexible, easily degradable from an image-text interleaved format to pure text corpus and image-text pairs. Through comprehensive analysis and experiments, we validate the quality, usability, and effectiveness of the proposed dataset. We hope this could provide a solid data foundation for future multimodal model research.
Image-text interleaved dataset
We introduce OmniCorpus, the first 10 billion-level image-text interleaved dataset with diverse sources, providing a robust foundation for future multimodal model research.
7,129
2406.08418
[ 0.0019576495978981256, -0.051175087690353394, 0.00391171220690012, 0.04577716812491417, 0.02554595284163952, 0.006723019760102034, 0.006978233810514212, 0.025498339906334877, -0.046606890857219696, -0.03753525763750076, -0.044041577726602554, -0.0014547330792993307, -0.07733503729104996, -0.03305971249938011, 0.009196845814585686, 0.017250772565603256, 0.017889132723212242, -0.0006140554905869067, 0.0038305039051920176, 0.02042531967163086, -0.014507001265883446, -0.02055693231523037, 0.005031580105423927, -0.003670064266771078, 0.004090329632163048, 0.014717470854520798, 0.020585395395755768, 0.02076593227684498, -0.07305041700601578, 0.011054436676204205, 0.011949550360441208, -0.00034349554334767163, -0.0066164112649858, -0.007666392717510462, 0.03809572011232376, -0.014534167014062405, -0.035633429884910583, -0.017833253368735313, 0.023723408579826355, -0.005553523078560829, -0.0490240640938282, 0.03199448436498642, -0.005196704529225826, -0.019618671387434006, -0.05400721728801727, 0.0025821032468229532, -0.08127477765083313, 0.047869130969047546, -0.017321638762950897, -0.004299019929021597, -0.07927951961755753, 0.037737470120191574, -0.012961109168827534, -0.00005673397026839666, -0.015375739894807339, 0.043645668774843216, 0.024027304723858833, -0.10105567425489426, 0.023623663932085037, -0.025755660608410835, -0.011478733271360397, 0.018376357853412628, 0.011991163715720177, -0.025404121726751328, -0.021078430116176605, -0.031313974410295486, -0.017349084839224815, 0.034348227083683014, -0.06024384871125221, -0.04133973643183708, -0.006695756688714027, -0.003416555467993021, -0.0393834263086319, 0.01145840622484684, 0.01695377752184868, -0.05212957412004471, 0.0030645672231912613, 0.0053527941927313805, 0.07302410155534744, 0.004193901550024748, 0.02082875557243824, 0.021561043336987495, 0.04739653319120407, 0.04942334070801735, -0.0051571279764175415, 0.004893403500318527, -0.03448132053017616, -0.024482371285557747, -0.0861736610531807, 0.03581230342388153, -0.005903377663344145, -0.04616926610469818, 0.01734056882560253, 0.042158015072345734, 0.047036781907081604, 0.015066960826516151, -0.001837797462940216, 0.0046671414747834206, -0.0007666146266274154, 0.010870731435716152, -0.053133171051740646, 0.004248665180057287, 0.037073567509651184, 0.023776648566126823, -0.09632348269224167, -0.00794351939111948, -0.023759115487337112, 0.005464174319058657, 0.027907365933060646, 0.003034216584637761, -0.025024324655532837, -0.030847102403640747, 0.01980808936059475, -0.018288996070623398, -0.05357560142874718, 0.043919630348682404, 0.01711943931877613, 0.0019048056565225124, 0.0034130397252738476, 0.02427217736840248, 0.06605987995862961, 0.07230350375175476, 0.0012864639284089208, 0.05561533570289612, -0.02037857100367546, -0.01567050628364086, -0.020732775330543518, 0.03551594913005829, -0.04871796444058418, -0.018209991976618767, -0.01894327811896801, 0.0517137385904789, 0.005353670101612806, 0.017544656991958618, 0.001082437695004046, 0.003914843313395977, 0.0008543617441318929, 0.0018943867180496454, 0.08116434514522552, -0.03254192695021629, 0.0394025519490242, -0.04212510585784912, -0.006244189105927944, -0.02179907262325287, 0.09596427530050278, -0.012729190289974213, -0.003989012446254492, -0.03587297350168228, -0.05042174458503723, -0.009863439947366714, 0.0019007977098226547, -0.043078940361738205, 0.029603250324726105, -0.0785566121339798, 0.08067935705184937, 0.056017231196165085, 0.032130222767591476, 0.007346614729613066, 0.017045656219124794, 0.0030478115659207106, 0.0032825665548443794, 0.008881792426109314, -0.054605141282081604, 0.03205079212784767, -0.035216186195611954, -0.08718520402908325, 0.025425171479582787, 0.019956640899181366, -0.03150395303964615, 0.021493790671229362, -0.06052646413445473, -0.056970544159412384, 0.042332325130701065, -0.01442395243793726, -0.0031982932705432177, 0.010878271423280239, 0.05039836838841438, 0.020195402204990387, 0.040872786194086075, 0.011253394186496735, -0.09483464062213898, 0.04391041398048401, 0.000549621123354882, -0.006684769410640001, 0.01775912009179592, -0.019121963530778885, 0.09958752989768982, -0.02522701397538185, -0.008142507635056973, -0.01003691554069519, -0.06204398348927498, -0.04673832282423973, 0.02303667739033699, -0.008480599150061607, 0.04755992814898491, 0.0139409638941288, -0.006111951544880867, 0.03367072343826294, 0.04011048004031181, 0.05168205127120018, 0.01516515389084816, -0.004563651978969574, 0.07407204806804657, -0.026177171617746353, -0.007408597506582737, -0.0023135498631745577, 0.019195491448044777, -0.03452417999505997, -0.01007912214845419, -0.019555654376745224, -0.00648580864071846, -0.007068408653140068, 0.035132069140672684, 0.004455225542187691, -0.0034573846496641636, 0.018913939595222473, 0.006052450276911259, 0.016387315467000008, -0.007222207263112068, -0.061362408101558685, 0.029722608625888824, 0.001767526613548398, -0.020619401708245277, -0.033566299825906754, -0.049497902393341064, 0.10342472046613693, 0.05991313233971596, -0.044338297098875046, 0.003936347085982561, 0.0031318231485784054, -0.042733483016490936, 0.013140811584889889, 0.0157850943505764, 6.165647050693224e-7, -0.0014663169858977199, -0.02087658829987049, 0.01098973024636507, -0.012171516194939613, 0.07580286264419556, -0.04310523346066475, -0.06415960192680359, 0.06151783466339111, -0.012200631201267242, 0.04943457990884781, 0.030088169500231743, 0.004626684356480837, 0.025135289877653122, -0.027407189831137657, -0.020020952448248863, -0.03494389355182648, 0.008229423314332962, -0.004803022835403681, -0.031042858958244324, -0.04284163936972618, 0.02615753561258316, -0.04529532417654991, 0.008204816840589046, -0.005647348240017891, 0.06331474334001541, 0.015920555219054222, 0.02897517755627632, 0.033192988485097885, -0.0017107157036662102, -0.023033374920487404, 0.005625767167657614, -0.09525584429502487, 0.0005483103450387716, -0.03391209989786148, 0.04439437761902809, 0.018592974171042442, 0.06989200413227081, 0.006461744662374258, -0.0075503443367779255, -0.005739642307162285, 0.03663822263479233, -0.03429235517978668, 0.02609596773982048, -0.0033471696078777313, -0.022903522476553917, -0.03601772338151932, -0.018079062923789024, 0.04752509295940399, 0.002502436749637127, -0.029875151813030243, -0.022547481581568718, -0.0565604493021965, 0.011203656904399395, -0.04907584562897682, -0.0015093648107722402, 0.0009393515065312386, 0.0298713818192482, 0.033003147691488266, 0.004723634570837021, -0.011298906989395618, 0.03304625675082207, 0.0584476962685585, 0.027557583525776863, -0.007557360455393791, -0.035278428345918655, 0.04502503201365471, -0.022359613329172134, -0.01797725446522236, 0.01734272576868534, 0.012170271947979927, 0.008419644087553024, -0.010113473981618881, -0.015317492187023163, 0.0052408985793590546, -0.2739671468734741, -0.019780533388257027, 0.01278019417077303, -0.02071690559387207, 0.022899653762578964, -0.05009899660944939, 0.04082745686173439, -0.025263674557209015, -0.030776960775256157, -0.0058415732346475124, 0.0035250200890004635, 0.05414050817489624, 0.018890686333179474, 0.05118769779801369, 0.061788443475961685, 0.042097948491573334, 0.019377196207642555, -0.005047883838415146, 0.009489589370787144, 0.07155876606702805, -0.02079971693456173, -0.05608348548412323, -0.0036665613297373056, 0.042033713310956955, -0.020723707973957062, 0.04077905789017677, -0.069355309009552, -0.010814589448273182, -0.013446480967104435, -0.020880432799458504, 0.026516146957874298, -0.05321943387389183, 0.009003585204482079, 0.029475178569555283, -0.0017902371473610401, 0.021120581775903702, 0.07149753719568253, 0.03457142785191536, 0.03159300610423088, 0.0010599225061014295, -0.006305815652012825, -0.03839816898107529, -0.04664861783385277, -0.043999023735523224, 0.04865054413676262, 0.01780037209391594, -0.06316663324832916, -0.01055493950843811, -0.035501159727573395, 0.04077126085758209, -0.009715401567518711, -0.05284151807427406, -0.02438133955001831, -0.0009475320111960173, 0.0017368553671985865, -0.027466515079140663, 0.015502547845244408, -0.005060083698481321, -0.03683650493621826, -0.02411765791475773, -0.0026598318945616484, -0.012396905571222305, -0.06778858602046967, -0.0336608849465847, -0.0099252974614501, -0.04386088252067566, -0.04798825457692146, -0.03277099132537842, 0.06047743186354637, 0.05680752173066139, -0.04388808459043503, 0.02185642719268799, -0.029147688299417496, -0.08701897412538528, -0.011113946326076984, -0.004181954078376293, -0.01816018857061863, -0.0020665540359914303, -0.021041885018348694, 0.04363250732421875, -0.029821334406733513, -0.013109550811350346, 0.015731921419501305, 0.002788958605378866, 0.03326401114463806, -0.030912136659026146, 0.015339281409978867, -0.022320864722132683, 0.003450425574555993, -0.04689366742968559, 0.04973343759775162, -0.02624775841832161, -0.03121563047170639, 0.024982677772641182, 0.040526047348976135, 0.014971991069614887, 0.018490392714738846, 0.06437136977910995, 0.012052418664097786, 0.024570118635892868, 0.01875884085893631, -0.0672679990530014, -0.03697285056114197, -0.040527213364839554, -0.021546095609664917, 0.02510484866797924, -0.05520985275506973, -0.02315998263657093, 0.041254717856645584, -0.002815808402374387, -0.027604272589087486, -0.01511326339095831, 0.0234653539955616, -0.033069442957639694, -0.008069870062172413, -0.004327236674726009, 0.020190007984638214, 0.0021129760425537825, 0.041152335703372955, -0.008147367276251316, -0.0005320187192410231, 0.010749798268079758, -0.031418584287166595, 0.012731135822832584, -0.0009534950950182974, -0.029446255415678024, 0.012523573823273182, -0.02034333534538746, -0.01554744690656662, 0.0021380800753831863, 0.03401314467191696, 0.011739945970475674, -0.004396265838295221, 0.03939925879240036, 0.03975624591112137, -0.003174567362293601, -0.023515846580266953, 0.0063076326623559, 0.01134232897311449, 0.001957498025149107, 0.018122157081961632, -0.03352712094783783, 0.020018715411424637, 0.05896401405334473, 0.046570319682359695, -0.003385845571756363, -0.0026680685114115477, 0.0321306549012661, -0.016454556956887245, 0.012650326825678349, 0.028582897037267685, -0.02757996693253517, -0.055070213973522186, -0.016227327287197113, -0.0030511333607137203, -0.005912210792303085, 0.018516752868890762, 0.004463558550924063, 0.044841136783361435, -0.07902881503105164, 0.04359155893325806, -0.00618391577154398, 0.017810694873332977, -0.0017832417506724596, 0.01767401397228241, 0.03321387246251106, 0.02220628410577774, -0.007615941110998392, 0.037103455513715744, -0.004156729206442833, 0.03453271463513374, -0.019286159425973892, 0.00021900376304984093, -0.03201679140329361, -0.014609044417738914, 0.0030272495932877064, -0.009104623459279537, -0.00005146815237822011, -0.01589937135577202, 0.08770506083965302, 0.018218277022242546, -0.015086431987583637, 0.02288680151104927, 0.00013267743634060025, 0.10468561202287674, 0.02579396404325962, 0.006390047259628773, -0.011492432095110416, -0.016529714688658714, 0.012831464409828186, -0.008710446767508984, 0.035511571913957596, -0.03852755203843117, -0.02076326310634613, -0.03158605843782425, -0.054068222641944885, 0.013583634048700333, -0.0037097667809575796, -0.010109594091773033, -0.006862352602183819, -0.02866331860423088, 0.028718559071421623, -0.05663736164569855, -0.03281811997294426, -0.0003519078018143773, -0.0745183452963829, 0.00359270884655416, -0.017655350267887115, -0.009933940134942532, 0.040020544081926346, -0.009622743353247643, -0.03606894612312317, -0.044930148869752884, -0.0326116718351841, 0.0170940849930048, 0.005656865891069174, -0.006117973476648331, -0.0478326790034771, -0.007722137961536646, -0.058467090129852295, -0.0061086686328053474, 0.013602223247289658, -0.030359920114278793, 0.017671681940555573, 0.018786855041980743, 0.02877543866634369, 0.0015655516181141138, -0.012667376548051834, 0.005249293986707926, -0.05477002635598183, 0.03695913404226303, -0.03668217733502388, 0.026252267882227898, 0.04792563244700432, 0.02537025511264801, -0.005259143188595772, -0.008079737424850464, 0.030124152079224586, 0.04435887932777405, 0.018564220517873764, -0.007064987439662218, -0.006887255236506462, -0.017386773601174355, 0.023048918694257736, 0.009504118002951145, 0.05995219573378563, -0.0037239764351397753, 0.010026589967310429, 0.01954999566078186, 0.019532272592186928, 0.007622332777827978, -0.013456032611429691, -0.05977879464626312, -0.02054242417216301, 0.0198573786765337, -0.026824653148651123, -0.0018855556845664978, -0.06516756862401962, -0.048673734068870544, 0.04137866199016571, -0.026863284409046173, 0.012570422142744064, -0.018584858626127243, 0.056762222200632095, 0.025194009765982628, 0.0597010962665081, 0.0180378220975399, -0.01217318419367075, 0.031972914934158325, -0.051271211355924606, 0.025003351271152496, -0.08135705441236496, -0.04090192914009094, 0.07053487747907639, -0.031897276639938354, 0.01373603381216526, 0.009569660760462284, -0.033476509153842926, 0.025785047560930252, -0.030747972428798676, -0.035966210067272186, 0.005906124133616686, -0.01863088831305504, -0.00756421871483326, -0.0020786637905985117, -0.029645485803484917, 0.00020956377557013184, -0.039995692670345306, -0.04311949387192726, -0.014135610312223434, -0.020244156941771507, 0.05648709461092949, -0.03356345742940903, 0.0033492017537355423, -0.025407597422599792, -0.0016340321162715554, 0.00834259670227766, 0.0432591512799263, 0.012459895573556423, 0.017195213586091995, -0.0361579954624176, 0.06053701415657997, 0.026840759441256523, -0.01648041233420372, 0.020838342607021332, 0.008192922919988632, -0.027770530432462692, -0.0567830465734005, 0.0488395094871521, 0.004397921729832888, -0.014140625484287739, -0.07803802937269211, 0.08385832607746124, 0.03173314779996872, -0.03430284932255745, -0.0376921072602272, 0.017625898122787476, -0.0365230031311512, 0.037683259695768356, -0.03145194053649902, 0.03001996874809265, 0.016472306102514267, 0.07676240801811218, -0.004290163516998291, 0.02333182841539383, 0.06976364552974701, -0.011950822547078133, 0.0019801470916718245, 0.0158823411911726, 0.03593127802014351, 0.05004694685339928, 0.06446298211812973, -0.01377666275948286, 0.06813345104455948, -0.023224610835313797, -0.06801076233386993, 0.024170365184545517, 0.06278814375400543, -0.0116707943379879, 0.006006019189953804, -0.011087761260569096, 0.0710027813911438, 0.010619310662150383, 0.04174119234085083, -0.05715138465166092, -0.03221149742603302, 0.042740024626255035, -0.008942785672843456, -0.00806429423391819, 0.03186151385307312, 0.03922756388783455, 0.012983666732907295, -0.021308433264493942, -0.015930160880088806, 0.01146706473082304, -0.02142786979675293, 0.03774860128760338, -0.004486719612032175, 0.014381250366568565, 0.014118959195911884, -0.0399254634976387, 0.0953231155872345, 0.09949726611375809, -0.0035834030713886023, -0.0404808446764946, 0.018022695556282997, 0.018930204212665558, 0.06088094785809517, 0.053334709256887436, -0.014771630056202412, -0.009370493702590466, 0.020692268386483192, -0.03065117821097374, 0.009904011152684689, -0.015467789955437183, 0.003198456484824419, 0.028558943420648575, -0.036637965589761734, -0.053346261382102966, 0.02149639092385769, -0.031799644231796265, -0.011822277680039406, 0.002779199741780758, -0.032549791038036346, -0.012288548983633518, -0.048042893409729004, -0.015153268352150917, 0.03488251939415932, 0.031796932220458984, -0.034060508012771606, -0.015120281837880611, -0.03855970501899719, 0.027152301743626595, 0.0512407161295414, -0.06915255635976791, 0.0054628886282444, 0.03547695279121399, -0.005246013402938843, -0.02885856293141842, 0.05641886964440346, 0.04480314254760742, -0.027758415788412094, -0.024031581357121468, 0.03208823874592781, 0.044580359011888504, 0.01843646913766861, -0.005269304849207401, -0.036354199051856995, -0.11129383742809296, -0.004237258806824684, -0.009572379291057587, -0.032580748200416565, -0.07765506207942963, 0.009195506572723389, -0.009230870753526688, 0.050369903445243835, 0.047320716083049774, -0.009957375936210155, 0.02193361334502697, -0.03397247567772865, -0.012945134192705154, -0.02985764481127262, 0.013644875027239323, 0.05544527247548103, -0.05273115634918213, 0.06371154636144638, 0.044997841119766235, 0.004803863354027271, -0.01451351772993803, 0.018203800544142723, -0.009826610796153545, 0.028014525771141052, -0.03541165217757225, -0.007628046441823244, -0.05669315904378891, -0.07632041722536087, -0.02365141548216343, 0.05912747234106064, -0.011344308033585548, -0.029044801369309425, 0.003223086940124631, 0.004901561886072159, -0.039769139140844345, -0.01682746224105358, -0.004360889084637165, -0.02808772586286068, -0.027523452416062355, -0.03362104296684265, -0.07145993411540985, 0.011356361210346222, 0.005276837851852179, -0.005558780860155821, -0.0080031119287014, -0.009233381599187851, 0.005714947823435068, 0.02925904653966427, 0.028518404811620712, 0.01681256853044033, 0.047359976917505264, -0.014686805196106434 ]
3,504
MAGNet: Motif-Agnostic Generation of Molecules from Scaffolds
https://openreview.net/forum?id=5FXKgOxmb2
[ "Leon Hetzel", "Johanna Sommer", "Bastian Rieck", "Fabian J Theis", "Stephan Günnemann" ]
Spotlight
Recent advances in machine learning for molecules exhibit great potential for facilitating drug discovery from in silico predictions. Most models for molecule generation rely on the decomposition of molecules into frequently occurring substructures (motifs), from which they generate novel compounds. While motif representations greatly aid in learning molecular distributions, such methods fail to represent substructures beyond their known motif set, posing a fundamental limitation for discovering novel compounds. To address this limitation and enhance structural expressivity, we propose to separate structure from features by abstracting motifs to scaffolds and, subsequently, allocating atom and bond types. To this end, we introduce a novel factorisation of the molecules' data distribution that considers the entire molecular context and facilitates learning adequate assignments of atoms and bonds to scaffolds. Complementary to this, we propose MAGNet, the first model to freely learn motifs. Importantly, we demonstrate that MAGNet's improved expressivity leads to molecules with more structural diversity and, at the same time, diverse atom and bond assignments.
graph generative models, 2d molecules
null
7,094
null
[ -0.0064230263233184814, 0.0014902056427672505, -0.0013228431344032288, 0.02931995689868927, 0.03698234632611275, -0.04727274179458618, 0.011495938524603844, -0.009610314853489399, 0.020683210343122482, -0.035708948969841, -0.004443557001650333, 0.005383582320064306, -0.09521100670099258, 0.030804689973592758, 0.028214355930685997, 0.0674719363451004, 0.02657194249331951, 0.03118191659450531, -0.006454961374402046, 0.014225983060896397, -0.020004551857709885, -0.00047641346463933587, 0.021080315113067627, 0.017290085554122925, 0.060282543301582336, 0.010849668644368649, 0.024737093597650528, -0.014461999759078026, -0.03022126480937004, -0.002804025076329708, 0.026796404272317886, -0.0014380094362422824, 0.010739131830632687, -0.04786054044961929, 0.002580739092081785, 0.019182441756129265, -0.06370016932487488, 0.014035629108548164, 0.0011077162344008684, -0.026576541364192963, -0.057057589292526245, 0.01847926899790764, 0.00999347772449255, 0.029812170192599297, -0.04192935302853584, 0.02911396697163582, -0.11332255601882935, 0.06760165840387344, 0.012022435665130615, -0.04487268999218941, -0.08263535797595978, 0.06243448704481125, 0.0487263947725296, -0.033340536057949066, 0.0030136220157146454, 0.03751176968216896, 0.01759495586156845, -0.038544878363609314, 0.009739505127072334, -0.03925758972764015, -0.04720231518149376, 0.04426756873726845, 0.029735907912254333, 0.01658172905445099, 0.004090529400855303, -0.01633174531161785, 0.006717366632074118, 0.04182654619216919, -0.06278096139431, -0.012103715911507607, -0.013704530894756317, -0.025011612102389336, -0.012736784294247627, -0.033129606395959854, 0.05229664593935013, -0.04998383671045303, 0.01445926632732153, 0.011293632909655571, 0.06265699118375778, 0.04391036182641983, -0.012017481960356236, 0.05502352491021156, -0.007561697158962488, 0.02510242722928524, -0.008291380479931831, 0.0007739558932371438, -0.07976289093494415, 0.03067297302186489, -0.07833544164896011, 0.0510113425552845, -0.000742339005228132, -0.04070040211081505, 0.007590846158564091, 0.028680365532636642, 0.051087893545627594, -0.03470233827829361, 0.0264655202627182, 0.003426722250878811, 0.006018579471856356, 0.006404936779290438, -0.0007127904100343585, -0.04661472141742706, -0.02499105967581272, -0.03397868946194649, -0.09000035375356674, -0.013220064342021942, -0.05846292898058891, -0.036305081099271774, -0.02312478981912136, -0.02063470520079136, -0.012425616383552551, -0.02079976350069046, -0.022527167573571205, 0.016184797510504723, -0.051475830376148224, 0.039135534316301346, 0.028534363955259323, 0.028371291235089302, -0.021422376856207848, -0.005530567839741707, 0.04167632758617401, 0.0658898875117302, -0.004862391855567694, 0.07186957448720932, -0.014694808050990105, 0.0063984692096710205, 0.0051835705526173115, 0.013710616156458855, -0.06056957319378853, -0.03565071523189545, 0.027765914797782898, 0.04506378620862961, -0.03961286321282387, -0.021670864894986153, -0.023414064198732376, -0.024027086794376373, -0.011697760783135891, -0.0011968115577474236, 0.04192335903644562, -0.00028393647517077625, 0.0071051171980798244, -0.018514497205615044, 0.041742317378520966, -0.023688599467277527, 0.07046666741371155, -0.032843369990587234, -0.010757599025964737, -0.02174847014248371, -0.01981584168970585, 0.015634002164006233, 0.03227093443274498, 0.005867531523108482, -0.015031091868877411, -0.017471453174948692, 0.038171250373125076, 0.07772502303123474, 0.0279103834182024, 0.023855799809098244, 0.01598847284913063, -0.023854168131947517, 0.0035027251578867435, -0.009906630963087082, -0.02410462498664856, 0.009502229280769825, 0.013244429603219032, -0.030646739527583122, 0.02592749521136284, 0.07063467800617218, -0.037571318447589874, -0.009991148486733437, -0.030626799911260605, -0.05019186809659004, 0.05050646886229515, -0.03182247281074524, 0.010887488722801208, 0.011762815527617931, 0.03210308030247688, 0.005960843991488218, 0.04110080748796463, 0.012201786041259766, -0.08297055959701538, 0.013168047182261944, 0.013505993410944939, -0.030999070033431053, 0.008296508342027664, 0.002363246399909258, 0.09647350758314133, 0.0124922264367342, -0.005516895093023777, 0.04665336757898331, -0.08225972205400467, -0.03199848532676697, 0.036350641399621964, 0.0013292747316882014, 0.07040304690599442, -0.002701233606785536, -0.0031521606724709272, 0.04877849668264389, -0.01600528694689274, 0.03270590677857399, 0.003827370936051011, 0.014867296442389488, 0.05212774872779846, -0.039272911846637726, -0.03061961941421032, -0.021263230592012405, 0.033513303846120834, -0.08420325070619583, -0.0561845488846302, -0.0005607907078228891, 0.022152002900838852, -0.010915459133684635, 0.02891603484749794, -0.04095663130283356, 0.04012627899646759, -0.005905920173972845, 0.007345897611230612, 0.009777509607374668, -0.038638483732938766, -0.011128113605082035, -0.020835725590586662, -0.02435319870710373, -0.037286803126335144, 0.000972628069575876, -0.020688632503151894, 0.11711771786212921, 0.07601945847272873, -0.04170740768313408, 0.008878553286194801, 0.027113759890198708, 0.015860665589571, -0.0011084709549322724, 0.02079077437520027, -0.0292799212038517, -0.007856941781938076, -0.022387521341443062, 0.02376221865415573, 0.009805628098547459, 0.035550881177186966, -0.0747026577591896, 0.0069619095884263515, 0.05226108804345131, -0.052736103534698486, 0.058176346123218536, 0.03273333981633186, 0.020987791940569878, 0.0456133708357811, -0.027233973145484924, -0.05310564860701561, -0.029315894469618797, -0.05294924974441528, -0.008746448904275894, -0.018033618107438087, 0.01381890382617712, 0.023282330483198166, -0.0695042684674263, -0.014317141845822334, 0.0019683390855789185, 0.06842396408319473, 0.06566191464662552, 0.0025025568902492523, 0.0020624944008886814, 0.016752922907471657, -0.009395908564329147, -0.030410828068852425, -0.10306306928396225, -0.018134351819753647, -0.02436276338994503, 0.059528738260269165, 0.02698589861392975, 0.04822065308690071, -0.007397702429443598, 0.0004467208927962929, 0.0012966495705768466, -0.042746614664793015, 0.003944988362491131, -0.003932993393391371, -0.0034196919295936823, -0.054450247436761856, -0.026870323345065117, 0.018969904631376266, 0.07771775126457214, -0.0029048973228782415, -0.0427694097161293, -0.03175178915262222, -0.054235976189374924, -0.042403701692819595, -0.03456538915634155, -0.01120828464627266, 0.01882249116897583, 0.004298953805118799, 0.025530051440000534, -0.036785583943128586, -0.006707586348056793, 0.01819814182817936, 0.03961283341050148, 0.011560962535440922, 0.04007824510335922, -0.0054978979751467705, -0.018001321703195572, -0.0043182531371712685, 0.018512608483433723, -0.04136884585022926, -0.011164059862494469, 0.03364267945289612, 0.0026085451245307922, 0.028902629390358925, -0.007147171534597874, -0.2463017851114273, -0.023566585034132004, -0.00023967451124917716, -0.006689015310257673, 0.05564512312412262, 0.0005975163076072931, 0.015408325009047985, -0.03266965225338936, -0.009566829539835453, -0.014961747452616692, -0.01339061837643385, 0.03162543475627899, 0.023064136505126953, 0.037915728986263275, 0.05646068602800369, 0.0391690656542778, 0.007395797409117222, -0.029148969799280167, 0.019991450011730194, 0.0004827478260267526, 0.006222701631486416, -0.041689030826091766, -0.02264580689370632, 0.010595664381980896, -0.037335317581892014, 0.017062479630112648, -0.06565432995557785, -0.03272002935409546, -0.03410189971327782, -0.002911483636125922, -0.03763747587800026, -0.02821400947868824, -0.013886138796806335, 0.02022659406065941, 0.02988302707672119, 0.016732824966311455, 0.02891572192311287, -0.027747949585318565, 0.008506285957992077, 0.007919269613921642, -0.008852466940879822, -0.006293818820267916, -0.022344961762428284, -0.018991593271493912, 0.07781735062599182, 0.009589508175849915, -0.0041969288140535355, -0.013250480405986309, -0.05125277861952782, 0.037087708711624146, -0.022790392860770226, -0.01799907349050045, -0.003940867260098457, 0.006407869514077902, 0.01713690161705017, -0.0001392859994666651, -0.0057864380069077015, 0.008175736293196678, -0.034462861716747284, 0.010807367973029613, 0.014096276834607124, -0.04565601795911789, -0.00809413380920887, -0.01939423382282257, -0.03581901267170906, -0.02959349751472473, -0.04124045372009277, -0.08083577454090118, 0.029720982536673546, 0.05161162093281746, -0.004292116034775972, 0.041539136320352554, 0.004910717252641916, -0.08532965183258057, 0.018337873741984367, 0.002670705085620284, -0.00026230193907395005, -0.021745964884757996, -0.0005781775689683855, 0.03000815026462078, -0.01866651140153408, -0.012896496802568436, -0.010839099064469337, 0.04991484433412552, 0.019939567893743515, -0.01242312416434288, -0.013147816061973572, -0.014545656740665436, -0.025738714262843132, -0.007713172119110823, 0.021080300211906433, 0.011903578415513039, 0.04871010035276413, -0.008557640947401524, 0.010490522719919682, 0.006223208736628294, 0.005336639937013388, 0.029513007029891014, 0.03768086060881615, 0.022623909637331963, 0.055724095553159714, -0.07160356640815735, 0.007226194720715284, -0.035446640104055405, -0.028544725850224495, -0.02825324423611164, -0.06042137369513512, -0.04229250177741051, 0.06606191396713257, 0.013974754139780998, -0.03952624648809433, -0.003961589187383652, 0.010890165343880653, -0.004038583021610975, -0.003468479961156845, -0.0439666211605072, 0.04096219688653946, 0.03552331402897835, 0.02868514508008957, -0.019636832177639008, -0.0427342988550663, 0.06628263741731644, 0.004945068620145321, 0.00862159300595522, -0.04174027219414711, -0.012749630957841873, 0.003175909398123622, -0.010105869732797146, 0.014378996565937996, 0.00446924427524209, 0.02725796401500702, 0.035920485854148865, -0.032100800424814224, 0.014968615025281906, 0.04352543130517006, 0.05522951856255531, -0.03952135145664215, -0.030499404296278954, -0.0006475700647570193, -0.04772527515888214, 0.021508464589715004, -0.021606668829917908, 0.04456797614693642, 0.016615133732557297, 0.06546562910079956, 0.03632050380110741, 0.04129306972026825, 0.07239875197410583, 0.00846826285123825, -0.0062321689911186695, -0.01834937371313572, -0.011546103283762932, 0.011592736467719078, -0.017793050035834312, 0.021025406196713448, -0.01740921288728714, 0.024186011403799057, -0.00215530046261847, 0.030265145003795624, -0.08305478096008301, 0.033114563673734665, 0.0031258156523108482, -0.017951922491192818, -0.0055324723944067955, -0.004151128698140383, 0.049079615622758865, -0.05139010399580002, 0.029161280021071434, -0.0022973576560616493, 0.01871301420032978, 0.03208789601922035, -0.028288206085562706, -0.041333120316267014, -0.0033844129648059607, -0.0749354362487793, -0.0019053840078413486, -0.016766849905252457, -0.016154063865542412, -0.03488475829362869, 0.026001177728176117, 0.007213307544589043, -0.042057108134031296, -0.0009755994542501867, 0.0026359010953456163, 0.07934878766536713, -0.01907086931169033, -0.013096475973725319, -0.028495611622929573, -0.043931618332862854, 0.040623120963573456, 0.015340692363679409, -0.001412639976479113, -0.02150377444922924, -0.05172228813171387, -0.01998854987323284, -0.06185522675514221, 0.0005526599707081914, 0.03440570831298828, 0.005146078299731016, 0.014134733937680721, 0.009082368575036526, 0.006134675350040197, -0.06481041014194489, 0.035491399466991425, 0.04038652405142784, -0.07676000893115997, -0.008259093388915062, 0.051371924579143524, 0.026074238121509552, 0.01803264580667019, -0.011572392657399178, -0.039586715400218964, -0.06232595816254616, -0.010138030163943768, 0.012721309438347816, 0.012411491945385933, 0.03882629796862602, -0.011612625792622566, 0.0010289782658219337, 0.0018645053496584296, 0.023441320285201073, 0.004316354636102915, 0.007491796277463436, -0.050099581480026245, 0.018093302845954895, 0.05377279594540596, -0.02031048573553562, 0.008275319822132587, -0.010160415433347225, -0.017715174704790115, 0.03645995259284973, -0.045254483819007874, 0.012154421769082546, 0.03226081654429436, -0.00244765542447567, -0.00030603105551563203, -0.01982356235384941, 0.0314929336309433, 0.0010946060065180063, 0.006860144902020693, 0.003731024218723178, -0.032086797058582306, -0.018913952633738518, -0.0036352728493511677, -0.00581749714910984, 0.031611256301403046, 0.011778004467487335, 0.005943452939391136, -0.02032087743282318, 0.03710491582751274, 0.008839280344545841, -0.0065021030604839325, -0.016689369454979897, -0.041052550077438354, 0.049584388732910156, 0.005944956559687853, -0.04148456081748009, -0.039155736565589905, -0.008602973073720932, 0.008480818010866642, -0.00804020743817091, 0.03263738751411438, -0.04063542187213898, 0.06374037265777588, 0.01651955209672451, 0.025561997666954994, -0.017258021980524063, -0.07518056780099869, 0.0676933079957962, -0.03340599685907364, -0.018656490370631218, -0.030452031642198563, 0.0006162848439998925, 0.08159791678190231, -0.030349768698215485, 0.018566766753792763, -0.0006483046454377472, -0.029816146939992905, -0.007534945849329233, -0.03175405412912369, -0.071379154920578, 0.02758605219423771, 0.0015676586190238595, 0.04000267758965492, 0.030024034902453423, -0.049239207059144974, -0.030817953869700432, -0.01932394504547119, -0.04642000421881676, -0.03206337243318558, 0.030150912702083588, 0.058537762612104416, -0.06570925563573837, -0.020947013050317764, -0.013547155074775219, 0.0642639622092247, 0.003854468697682023, 0.06958480924367905, 0.007766478229314089, 0.019497020170092583, -0.02539007179439068, 0.0751420110464096, 0.06614069640636444, 0.00008656492718728259, 0.004446887411177158, 0.014921619556844234, -0.006665060296654701, -0.010518754832446575, 0.02607874572277069, -0.00939035415649414, -0.031098026782274246, -0.07323102653026581, 0.0781811773777008, 0.019739612936973572, -0.0850505456328392, -0.007435158360749483, 0.02803228609263897, -0.030919494107365608, 0.017496811226010323, 0.025096582248806953, -0.00611420813947916, 0.00981000903993845, 0.05247475951910019, -0.010072940960526466, 0.0436771884560585, 0.07849227637052536, 0.04446660727262497, 0.00729543250054121, -0.04553999751806259, 0.06362422555685043, 0.051420196890830994, 0.015809891745448112, 0.015065182000398636, 0.06043772026896477, -0.023463672026991844, -0.04194145277142525, -0.013339180499315262, -0.00166266446467489, -0.02078179270029068, 0.001601118827238679, 0.0523090697824955, 0.06128910183906555, -0.0028910383116453886, 0.05022689700126648, -0.016005611047148705, -0.011226542294025421, 0.03820373862981796, 0.008068541996181011, 0.009660474956035614, 0.022249871864914894, 0.02795557864010334, 0.04063495248556137, -0.05812554806470871, -0.007801427971571684, -0.035100504755973816, -0.007863068021833897, 0.03298567607998848, 0.012130387127399445, -0.026094337925314903, 0.016541756689548492, -0.02410665713250637, 0.04731323942542076, 0.09579024463891983, 0.01311674527823925, -0.02582412399351597, 0.020567690953612328, 0.03677738457918167, -0.0004460649215616286, 0.0449325256049633, -0.015790266916155815, 0.015273215249180794, -0.0162009559571743, -0.041766609996557236, 0.018514318391680717, -0.0015934885013848543, 0.019810931757092476, 0.011224319227039814, -0.026200294494628906, -0.03148697689175606, -0.013339160941541195, -0.0023004307877272367, -0.037085454910993576, -0.05686114728450775, -0.002198571339249611, -0.03110305778682232, -0.06722903996706009, -0.05190981552004814, 0.009551613591611385, -0.029023539274930954, -0.04083704575896263, 0.02286284975707531, -0.0034492029808461666, 0.02604804001748562, 0.026091821491718292, -0.04023157060146332, -0.020374156534671783, 0.0708329901099205, 0.0289078988134861, 0.0012908843345940113, 0.022121844813227654, 0.014648745767772198, 0.000434490735642612, -0.042836450040340424, 0.06717545539140701, -0.0008892678306438029, 0.03282279521226883, -0.007928874343633652, -0.007262041326612234, -0.10687954723834991, 0.012571449391543865, 0.018349306657910347, -0.05489351227879524, -0.07575561106204987, 0.0022933257278054953, -0.016518499702215195, 0.02397824451327324, 0.04144434258341789, 0.011865333653986454, -0.033141836524009705, -0.04524071514606476, 0.03169265761971474, 0.036590926349163055, -0.0005093168583698571, 0.057438936084508896, -0.05900070071220398, 0.05184250324964523, 0.013847824186086655, -0.014287090860307217, -0.022592810913920403, 0.02064153552055359, 0.032007765024900436, 0.00466239545494318, -0.032948948442935944, -0.022612184286117554, -0.03677402809262276, -0.09419549256563187, -0.04409366846084595, 0.027808591723442078, -0.0381997674703598, -0.04284007102251053, -0.0017650293884798884, 0.021350305527448654, 0.02652042545378208, -0.016497371718287468, -0.0163981132209301, -0.012685098685324192, -0.025421038269996643, -0.052315834909677505, -0.07856667041778564, -0.028077511116862297, -0.0012361651752144098, -0.005665923934429884, -0.027844201773405075, -0.029905587434768677, 0.017117740586400032, -0.028807785362005234, 0.009248646907508373, 0.004912964999675751, 0.00944539625197649, 0.03082423098385334 ]
3,505
Broaden your SCOPE! Efficient Multi-turn Conversation Planning for LLMs with Semantic Space
https://openreview.net/forum?id=3cgMU3TyyE
[ "Zhiliang Chen", "Xinyuan Niu", "Chuan-Sheng Foo", "Bryan Kian Hsiang Low" ]
Spotlight
Large language models (LLMs) are used in chatbots or AI assistants to hold conversations with a human user. In such applications, the quality (e.g., user engagement, safety) of a conversation is important and can only be exactly known at the end of the conversation. To maximize its expected quality, conversation planning reasons about the stochastic transitions within a conversation to select the optimal LLM response at each turn. Existing simulation-based conversation planning algorithms typically select the optimal response by simulating future conversations with a large number of LLM queries at every turn. However, this process is extremely time-consuming and hence impractical for real-time conversations. This paper presents a novel approach called Semantic space COnversation Planning with improved Efficiency (SCOPE) that exploits the dense semantic representation of conversations to perform conversation planning efficiently. In particular, SCOPE models the stochastic transitions in conversation semantics and their associated rewards to plan entirely within the semantic space. This allows us to select the optimal LLM response at every conversation turn without needing additional LLM queries for simulation. As a result, SCOPE can perform conversation planning 70 times faster than conventional simulation-based planning algorithms when applied to a wide variety of conversation starters and two reward functions seen in the real world, yet achieving a higher reward within a practical planning budget. Our code can be found at: https://github.com/chenzhiliang94/convo-plan-SCOPE.
Multi-turn Conversation Planning, Multi-turn LLM Optimization, MCTS, Semantic Space
Conversation planning typically uses many LLM queries for look-ahead simulation to select responses that maximize long-term rewards. By learning transition and reward models in text semantic space, we conversation plan without needing LLM queries.
7,084
null
[ -0.002800035523250699, -0.03238873556256294, -0.01658579893410206, 0.004203443881124258, 0.05602867901325226, 0.012892275117337704, 0.01658562198281288, 0.016008177772164345, 0.0018463425803929567, -0.018440626561641693, -0.03407597914338112, 0.03791499137878418, -0.06841623783111572, -0.0024376283399760723, 0.024846889078617096, 0.06285642087459564, 0.025102868676185608, -0.014636932872235775, 0.02387997694313526, 0.004327643197029829, -0.003117320826277137, 0.030572321265935898, 0.04927671328186989, -0.0028240690007805824, 0.0705299824476242, 0.026369014754891396, -0.008143777959048748, 0.028289759531617165, -0.018097059801220894, 0.0019633895717561245, 0.032412752509117126, -0.01422365102916956, 0.026231415569782257, -0.01993963122367859, -0.01751660741865635, -0.025083737447857857, -0.03697669878602028, 0.01862630993127823, 0.009160628542304039, 0.0012965858913958073, -0.04479079693555832, 0.02695329301059246, -0.01729770377278328, -0.02980290725827217, -0.04434327408671379, -0.005082151852548122, -0.0750502198934555, 0.014244381338357925, 0.023438280448317528, -0.023292725905776024, -0.11179094016551971, 0.003995216451585293, -0.021157747134566307, 0.006081125698983669, 0.0011299694888293743, 0.029945606365799904, 0.053803473711013794, -0.12647557258605957, 0.0005113387596793473, -0.028283901512622833, -0.03793087229132652, 0.014256841503083706, 0.005916357971727848, 0.020840922370553017, 0.018569113686680794, -0.012729699723422527, -0.012682623229920864, 0.021830420941114426, -0.0409952737390995, -0.04358777776360512, -0.036509133875370026, 0.035035695880651474, -0.024323441088199615, 0.011834663338959217, -0.0001671275676926598, -0.030355609953403473, 0.00785827450454235, 0.054982155561447144, 0.04522324725985527, 0.005164477042853832, -0.017906852066516876, 0.008786131627857685, 0.017251592129468918, 0.03051849454641342, 0.021169515326619148, 0.004085074178874493, -0.01691778004169464, -0.016696881502866745, -0.07231150567531586, 0.027503281831741333, 0.014925270341336727, -0.07549472898244858, 0.016922637820243835, 0.02425581030547619, 0.014335943385958672, 0.006475181318819523, 0.01185685396194458, 0.01918468438088894, -0.027651347219944, 0.00579262338578701, -0.02457725629210472, -0.034220121800899506, 0.0014698206214234233, -0.019052058458328247, -0.10899462550878525, -0.006820419803261757, -0.025831114500761032, -0.026535024866461754, -0.01706782542169094, 0.011817043647170067, -0.05844353511929512, -0.03027723729610443, 0.043853867799043655, 0.017539042979478836, -0.07400312274694443, 0.029625331982970238, 0.03910670056939125, 0.02600315771996975, 0.01514642033725977, 0.03492015600204468, 0.03412024676799774, 0.02664731815457344, 0.012395507656037807, 0.0651218518614769, -0.04099201038479805, -0.005052500870078802, -0.0029267712961882353, 0.03276432305574417, -0.014437960460782051, -0.05785983428359032, 0.033589813858270645, 0.03214877471327782, -0.017069684341549873, -0.003011861816048622, -0.005901578348129988, 0.009555074386298656, 0.018179811537265778, 0.020222634077072144, 0.04967730864882469, -0.010843624360859394, -0.0028975915629416704, -0.014100487343966961, 0.07927963137626648, -0.028189240023493767, 0.07544978708028793, 0.018696727231144905, -0.03707055747509003, -0.022878481075167656, -0.0518164299428463, -0.011007598601281643, 0.010150240734219551, 0.010557939298450947, 0.015397724695503712, -0.04309350997209549, 0.04732191935181618, 0.052698198705911636, 0.0005584615864790976, -0.015466013923287392, 0.025456244125962257, 0.017314178869128227, 0.014840804971754551, 0.0020987731404602528, -0.07798675447702408, 0.017012573778629303, 0.0006671182927675545, -0.03616311028599739, 0.03670872747898102, 0.01296712551265955, -0.026645798236131668, 0.014906280674040318, -0.02774236723780632, 0.006909193936735392, 0.05332336947321892, -0.03538782522082329, -0.04130475968122482, 0.01001698523759842, 0.05956217274069786, 0.01647540181875229, 0.03992743045091629, 0.016408171504735947, -0.05645878612995148, 0.00790388509631157, 0.02393515780568123, 0.0044881729409098625, 0.019095873460173607, -0.0010827045189216733, 0.09721129387617111, 0.005041844677180052, -0.045961491763591766, 0.012381250038743019, -0.0597425177693367, -0.007363187149167061, 0.005954282358288765, 0.04696405678987503, 0.07282976061105728, -0.026394501328468323, 0.008343370631337166, 0.08481472730636597, 0.030789267271757126, 0.07213610410690308, 0.0531008206307888, 0.018338777124881744, 0.04018724337220192, 0.0015511630335822701, -0.009787052869796753, -0.02554013952612877, 0.031775470823049545, -0.04226008802652359, -0.04066282510757446, 0.05095935985445976, -0.0298790093511343, 0.006615328602492809, 0.03683290258049965, 0.0029978363309055567, 0.011274704709649086, -0.014534256421029568, -0.009529519826173782, -0.03207984194159508, 0.001968401949852705, -0.040566787123680115, 0.059059400111436844, 0.017285356298089027, -0.0038366252556443214, -0.009634649381041527, -0.026785751804709435, 0.09018342941999435, 0.0650181770324707, 0.0005906795850023627, -0.04315249249339104, -0.004601754248142242, 0.005469396710395813, 0.010557388886809349, 0.005185994319617748, -0.012872359715402126, 0.02596384845674038, -0.03357973322272301, -0.0009274653857573867, -0.028774980455636978, 0.03548571839928627, -0.02540130913257599, -0.04598259925842285, 0.06284932047128677, 0.003418973181396723, 0.0652046799659729, -0.010343672707676888, 0.04074489325284958, 0.012935702688992023, -0.007457169704139233, 0.015055248513817787, -0.013149550184607506, -0.012122280895709991, 0.0026245771441608667, 0.010187345556914806, -0.011189449578523636, -0.0038020312786102295, -0.03256027027964592, -0.010873665101826191, -0.0043907067738473415, 0.0523197315633297, 0.05884844437241554, 0.011450426653027534, 0.039005301892757416, 0.033531755208969116, -0.024043748155236244, -0.02432456612586975, -0.10114634037017822, -0.01758638024330139, -0.033612463623285294, 0.007225732784718275, 0.0014505881117656827, 0.029381560161709785, -0.014757107943296432, 0.030934931710362434, -0.013257394544780254, 0.009131243452429771, 0.005371308419853449, 0.01460063736885786, -0.009743120521306992, -0.012709395959973335, -0.0145166777074337, -0.027027081698179245, 0.02615845575928688, -0.029924791306257248, -0.006956517230719328, -0.02970263361930847, -0.02592366188764572, 0.0011276742443442345, -0.07430906593799591, 0.009864934720098972, 0.0018551552202552557, 0.0029151947237551212, -0.00444048922508955, -0.007749792188405991, 0.0062398179434239864, 0.043905045837163925, 0.007198689971119165, 0.03430350124835968, -0.013109284453094006, -0.029967857524752617, 0.02103266678750515, -0.05421534553170204, 0.011449718847870827, 0.02126101590692997, 0.02127753011882305, -0.004530139267444611, -0.03009699285030365, 0.02824447862803936, 0.005829467438161373, -0.276780903339386, -0.0140268849208951, -0.0012880261056125164, -0.017834998667240143, 0.03806736692786217, 0.0016264859586954117, 0.03438173234462738, -0.05342838168144226, -0.03401236608624458, 0.012441213242709637, -0.002641947939991951, 0.00776290288195014, -0.007232645060867071, 0.054650526493787766, 0.06766041368246078, 0.04114464670419693, -0.010806688107550144, -0.03703521937131882, 0.00029397994512692094, 0.018777338787913322, -0.008066490292549133, -0.0664607509970665, -0.02665340155363083, 0.06886672973632812, -0.0021179586183279753, 0.052552223205566406, -0.05441979691386223, -0.004161334130913019, -0.008322498761117458, -0.0010882928036153316, -0.007195230107754469, -0.022191651165485382, -0.014217072166502476, 0.019011465832591057, -0.01970513164997101, -0.0050686863251030445, 0.07616651058197021, 0.0013163371477276087, 0.05517488718032837, 0.017093311995267868, 0.037574946880340576, -0.023368079215288162, -0.04200506955385208, 0.02229447476565838, 0.06036592274904251, -0.014536749571561813, -0.08057219535112381, -0.021915128454566002, 0.0005346862017177045, 0.035528481006622314, 0.013647247105836868, -0.0507502555847168, -0.01123282965272665, 0.003640676150098443, 0.044973332434892654, -0.015379323624074459, 0.00024392816703766584, -0.01038198173046112, -0.015312743373215199, -0.0007764034671708941, -0.003781173611059785, -0.03116084448993206, -0.05893478915095329, -0.039312634617090225, -0.016512086614966393, -0.060872577130794525, -0.0458686463534832, -0.03273830562829971, 0.023328440263867378, 0.037251509726047516, -0.01825995370745659, 0.012811373919248581, 0.006561583839356899, -0.10234197974205017, -0.017202574759721756, 0.0028137946501374245, -0.011683575809001923, -0.031093234196305275, 0.012819516472518444, 0.04711821675300598, -0.06378913670778275, -0.031435780227184296, -0.02262360043823719, 0.033633965998888016, 0.023275889456272125, -0.0249018594622612, 0.006378911901265383, -0.058431677520275116, -0.051140256226062775, -0.03991749882698059, 0.038887981325387955, 0.015850456431508064, -0.0178956538438797, 0.03324979916214943, 0.05122581869363785, 0.021680260077118874, -0.000477523630252108, 0.06065467745065689, 0.010582878254354, 0.013376057147979736, 0.04006028547883034, -0.06579047441482544, -0.008055140264332294, -0.03917747363448143, -0.031832803040742874, 0.0003420257125981152, -0.07090185582637787, -0.0195634588599205, 0.009628350846469402, 0.011415595188736916, -0.026128701865673065, 0.016055181622505188, -0.0006042564637027681, 0.021881982684135437, -0.032784923911094666, -0.0014552200445905328, -0.004247724544256926, 0.04120694473385811, 0.0332304984331131, -0.012621880508959293, -0.07160266488790512, 0.024111125618219376, -0.028394445776939392, -0.00019314666860736907, 0.006654718425124884, -0.021596521139144897, -0.027753684669733047, -0.018407244235277176, -0.028633348643779755, 0.012628705240786076, -0.008181841112673283, 0.02757749892771244, -0.005312785040587187, -0.022977111861109734, 0.043482955545186996, -0.025685958564281464, -0.004441175609827042, -0.005488893017172813, 0.02791016921401024, 0.00637676240876317, -0.008866829797625542, -0.010054671205580235, 0.03624863922595978, 0.055843621492385864, 0.00912670698016882, 0.010815632529556751, 0.004973719362169504, 0.006952648516744375, 0.03786561265587807, 0.011155675165355206, 0.015596226789057255, -0.09717106074094772, -0.009493757970631123, -0.03767004981637001, 0.061889130622148514, -0.02335321344435215, 0.005694304592907429, -0.01791546121239662, 0.024850931018590927, -0.06411952525377274, 0.028697744011878967, -0.0005146077601239085, -0.010298755951225758, -0.000870021409355104, 0.03634200245141983, 0.03697014972567558, -0.060313060879707336, 0.039119645953178406, 0.04536296799778938, 0.009579339995980263, 0.007262744475156069, -0.07661301642656326, -0.04751357063651085, 0.007153684739023447, 0.004032208118587732, 0.014194711111485958, 0.033620916306972504, -0.029364127665758133, -0.03709442541003227, 0.0514274500310421, 0.020853981375694275, -0.03584105521440506, -0.016190651804208755, 0.004258370492607355, 0.08779753744602203, -0.008998865261673927, 0.010640139691531658, 0.017729805782437325, -0.02404971234500408, 0.01112445816397667, -0.03416135534644127, 0.01940988004207611, -0.018539242446422577, -0.031112313270568848, -0.041816454380750656, -0.06017911806702614, 0.047546837478876114, 0.007674065418541431, 0.005043742712587118, 0.005342582706362009, 0.010812834836542606, -0.007471126038581133, -0.037324994802474976, -0.03425411134958267, 0.0393218956887722, -0.0812993049621582, 0.02165018767118454, 0.025770284235477448, 0.01512559037655592, 0.03926166519522667, -0.05219484120607376, -0.04432446509599686, -0.04235977306962013, -0.035516541451215744, -0.00019037193851545453, 0.000362467224476859, -0.03160828351974487, -0.009487466886639595, -0.012578141875565052, -0.016535822302103043, 0.02060745842754841, -0.058284442871809006, 0.011762029491364956, -0.019375935196876526, -0.021106936037540436, 0.04109644889831543, -0.05192973092198372, -0.04247496649622917, 0.005086726509034634, -0.05370677262544632, 0.02761414833366871, -0.052540164440870285, 0.02542785182595253, 0.01966213248670101, -0.006612907629460096, 0.01218887884169817, -0.053217142820358276, 0.02835259772837162, 0.03019016422331333, -0.0030555289704352617, -0.01781078241765499, -0.020240651443600655, -0.011324325576424599, -0.005876239854842424, -0.0010484271915629506, 0.05647563189268112, 0.008130555972456932, 0.00175586121622473, -0.014019785448908806, 0.013734744861721992, -0.0017432939494028687, 0.016376378014683723, -0.02635456994175911, -0.0016668759053573012, 0.04911511391401291, -0.02699870988726616, -0.036490362137556076, -0.05681254342198372, -0.0770607739686966, 0.033032674342393875, -0.01030015479773283, 0.003465699963271618, -0.07359527051448822, 0.0570443719625473, 0.011884569190442562, 0.05373413488268852, 0.015161917544901371, -0.022517135366797447, 0.050212789326906204, -0.030951110646128654, 0.03596426546573639, -0.07598615437746048, -0.020040957257151604, 0.03615032881498337, -0.03439868241548538, -0.030252305790781975, 0.003938938491046429, -0.0467461422085762, 0.044551897794008255, 0.01648382656276226, -0.03147134184837341, 0.024062680080533028, -0.009478331543505192, -0.02692561410367489, 0.0828588604927063, -0.03426133841276169, -0.04210998862981796, 0.003420093562453985, -0.029629578813910484, 0.01095925085246563, 0.012088960967957973, 0.05827785283327103, -0.034286849200725555, 0.03249749541282654, -0.04219775274395943, 0.008214214816689491, 0.02123095467686653, 0.04494170472025871, 0.01851184107363224, 0.0363740436732769, -0.012368478812277317, 0.04467419162392616, 0.037587970495224, 0.02447373792529106, 0.003491634037345648, -0.00037763844011351466, -0.018346425145864487, -0.05086177960038185, 0.045173000544309616, 0.018110860139131546, 0.02065368928015232, -0.0316225104033947, 0.07654794305562973, 0.03595197573304176, -0.05658101290464401, 0.009921734221279621, 0.004268147051334381, -0.047613296657800674, -0.00025678862584754825, -0.026156475767493248, 0.004629033152014017, 0.010143180377781391, 0.0788058415055275, 0.010728736408054829, 0.05084596946835518, 0.0866147056221962, 0.01319925021380186, -0.029451381415128708, -0.006868291646242142, 0.07459670305252075, 0.0487118735909462, 0.0882435068488121, 0.0015634531155228615, 0.08818746358156204, -0.041072022169828415, -0.058237284421920776, -0.008732925169169903, -0.0006834929808974266, -0.01459792722016573, -0.05045308172702789, 0.03588828444480896, 0.06631555408239365, -0.0065701426938176155, 0.07565886527299881, -0.0529358945786953, -0.022098636254668236, 0.04424233362078667, 0.025174139067530632, 0.012383118271827698, 0.04861053451895714, 0.03374732658267021, 0.028522629290819168, -0.018442032858729362, -0.03079109638929367, 0.026841802522540092, -0.02369236946105957, -0.024337874725461006, 0.014615388587117195, 0.0038322838954627514, -0.002514243358746171, -0.01145025622099638, 0.0545075424015522, 0.10628626495599747, -0.04218171536922455, -0.032445624470710754, 0.012552953325212002, -0.016620131209492683, 0.003893982619047165, 0.05618302896618843, 0.02868136577308178, -0.01594618149101734, 0.022658025845885277, -0.044782575219869614, -0.03126993402838707, 0.010993561707437038, -0.024819390848279, 0.021448804065585136, -0.026297224685549736, -0.002817566739395261, 0.010339031927287579, 0.023452159017324448, -0.05783841758966446, -0.0470096580684185, -0.037837542593479156, -0.048228561878204346, -0.021242516115307808, -0.04659522697329521, 0.04017799720168114, 0.019299006089568138, -0.017903489992022514, 0.031708765774965286, -0.02509498782455921, -0.012312590144574642, 0.0010689498158171773, -0.06223934516310692, 0.01755095086991787, 0.06751051545143127, -0.00804750807583332, 0.008434463292360306, 0.04340733587741852, 0.025945674628019333, -0.003852987429127097, 0.02105376124382019, 0.0010849746176972985, 0.026629874482750893, 0.011021461337804794, -0.010726905427873135, -0.022630084306001663, -0.09497785568237305, -0.01312065776437521, 0.011378936469554901, -0.005896967835724354, -0.0693678930401802, -0.005472940392792225, -0.011284587904810905, 0.05802713334560394, 0.06353013962507248, 0.03821868449449539, 0.00671114306896925, 0.0037311878986656666, -0.008971580304205418, 0.01646147482097149, 0.02397768758237362, 0.00219176197424531, -0.0201878622174263, 0.03532949090003967, 0.024210115894675255, -0.026113776490092278, -0.01628926955163479, 0.024502074345946312, -0.008689972572028637, -0.036025989800691605, -0.009867338463664055, -0.03505779057741165, -0.018264545127749443, -0.07089845836162567, -0.02473391778767109, 0.0505455806851387, 0.014449751935899258, -0.014782262034714222, 0.005725722759962082, -0.0018610397819429636, -0.04450284317135811, -0.007226306013762951, -0.036488186568021774, -0.0075646196492016315, 0.0038782041519880295, -0.02768729068338871, -0.055650509893894196, 0.016979387030005455, -0.04394052177667618, -0.051017068326473236, -0.03003387153148651, -0.04384453222155571, -0.006592059042304754, 0.014927965588867664, 0.048121802508831024, -0.01718449965119362, 0.007354838773608208, -0.030007341876626015 ]
3,506
SPA-BENCH: A COMPREHENSIVE BENCHMARK FOR SMARTPHONE AGENT EVALUATION
https://openreview.net/forum?id=OZbFRNhpwr
[ "Jingxuan Chen", "Derek Yuen", "Bin Xie", "Yuhao Yang", "Gongwei Chen", "Zhihao Wu", "Li Yixing", "Xurui Zhou", "Weiwen Liu", "Shuai Wang", "Kaiwen Zhou", "Rui Shao", "Liqiang Nie", "Yasheng Wang", "Jianye HAO", "Jun Wang", "Kun Shao" ]
Spotlight
Smartphone agents are increasingly important for helping users control devices efficiently, with (Multimodal) Large Language Model (MLLM)-based approaches emerging as key contenders. Fairly comparing these agents is essential but challenging, requiring a varied task scope, the integration of agents with different implementations, and a generalisable evaluation pipeline to assess their strengths and weaknesses. In this paper, we present SPA-Bench, a comprehensive SmartPhone Agent Benchmark designed to evaluate (M)LLM-based agents in an interactive environment that simulates real-world conditions. SPA-Bench offers three key contributions: (1) A diverse set of tasks covering system and third-party apps in both English and Chinese, focusing on features commonly used in daily routines; (2) A plug-and-play framework enabling real-time agent interaction with Android devices, integrating over ten agents with the flexibility to add more; (3) A novel evaluation pipeline that automatically assesses agent performance across multiple dimensions, encompassing seven metrics related to task completion and resource consumption. Our extensive experiments across tasks and agents reveal challenges like interpreting mobile user interfaces, action grounding, memory retention, and execution costs. We propose future research directions to ease these difficulties, moving closer to real-world smartphone agent applications.
AI Agent, LLM, MLLM, Benchmark, Smartphone Control
A comprehensive benchmark for smartphone agents, evaluating multiple agents across smartphone control tasks in various scenarios.
6,945
null
[ -0.016683025285601616, -0.0181292537599802, 0.002968626096844673, 0.02732185460627079, 0.042475998401641846, 0.0023816735483705997, 0.04933876544237137, 0.008052433840930462, -0.022484097629785538, -0.021858179941773415, 0.006816063076257706, 0.017842372879385948, -0.05176384001970291, -0.047439247369766235, -0.01565379835665226, 0.052645664662122726, 0.03992355987429619, -0.004164228215813637, 0.03431147709488869, -0.0166991725564003, -0.037974994629621506, 0.005109267309308052, 0.04702507331967354, 0.03896116092801094, 0.013967350125312805, 0.03295338526368141, 0.03651341050863266, 0.013288646005094051, -0.03556571900844574, 0.016374940052628517, 0.04996105656027794, -0.02268366329371929, -0.004631708841770887, -0.028250427916646004, -0.0001616182562429458, 0.01266448013484478, -0.03302760422229767, 0.03575544059276581, -0.03008282743394375, -0.00467949453741312, -0.04855111613869667, 0.03544135019183159, -0.011686624959111214, 0.009869063273072243, -0.021071352064609528, 0.001568429870530963, -0.09052033722400665, 0.03104131482541561, 0.014730109833180904, -0.005719898734241724, -0.11218924075365067, 0.02042721025645733, -0.014003799296915531, 0.0016005848301574588, 0.0035138805396854877, 0.0112284692004323, 0.011165311560034752, -0.11776577681303024, 0.011391863226890564, -0.048765260726213455, -0.02525969035923481, 0.013830892741680145, 0.0332445427775383, -0.010614490136504173, -0.003592575201764703, -0.0016834457637742162, 0.031055964529514313, 0.022358939051628113, -0.03298986330628395, 0.011193899437785149, -0.01470141764730215, -0.028611982241272926, -0.015111517161130905, -0.014942898415029049, -0.01019221730530262, -0.04015224799513817, 0.05381089076399803, 0.06295572966337204, 0.05541215464472771, -0.00044052404700778425, -0.023499229922890663, 0.0007071171421557665, 0.008439543657004833, 0.041124098002910614, 0.00011742342030629516, 0.009014075621962547, 0.024731971323490143, -0.028615683317184448, -0.05556970462203026, 0.0178226251155138, 0.05790194123983383, -0.036019355058670044, 0.031460631638765335, 0.03269996494054794, 0.033929936587810516, 0.01844949461519718, 0.0041373781859874725, 0.011368428356945515, -0.01001488696783781, 0.008418362587690353, -0.019052106887102127, -0.00831848755478859, 0.001661795424297452, 0.013034606352448463, -0.07660073041915894, -0.026509134098887444, -0.013807404786348343, -0.006232159212231636, -0.01185868214815855, -0.0022144177928566933, 0.0058972956612706184, -0.0004972358583472669, 0.03411097824573517, -0.007871787063777447, -0.09078825265169144, 0.02366485632956028, 0.00045944060548208654, 0.03129646182060242, -0.012713897973299026, 0.035326119512319565, 0.07494136691093445, 0.09019626677036285, -0.009747461415827274, 0.04693473130464554, -0.02746928483247757, -0.012869990430772305, 0.037599410861730576, -0.010619798675179482, 0.03595997020602226, -0.0237568486481905, 0.041081175208091736, 0.029345449060201645, 0.02578800544142723, -0.01398341916501522, -0.014963604509830475, 0.019703751429915428, 0.026233835145831108, 0.009189984761178493, 0.07992173731327057, -0.02092045173048973, 0.01013163011521101, -0.02083888091146946, 0.07581060379743576, -0.010502777993679047, 0.0667303279042244, -0.031772710382938385, 0.013427114114165306, -0.019579162821173668, -0.044779885560274124, -0.001971831312403083, -0.003413551254197955, 0.00832739844918251, 0.0006482201279141009, -0.041388705372810364, 0.03324025496840477, 0.0444103479385376, 0.03170447051525116, -0.016828684136271477, 0.008756429888308048, -0.012500425800681114, -0.006830478087067604, -0.005616576876491308, -0.06801893562078476, -0.0037568837869912386, 0.01466478779911995, -0.043675415217876434, 0.023715466260910034, 0.027560105547308922, 0.0072254398837685585, -0.0010024512885138392, -0.03814183548092842, -0.0476209931075573, 0.02779858559370041, -0.023584337905049324, -0.026339391246438026, 0.01128483284264803, 0.030433518812060356, 0.011842010542750359, 0.004809678066521883, 0.032458383589982986, -0.06137802451848984, 0.032516419887542725, 0.010659136809408665, 0.013059502467513084, 0.024568943306803703, 0.03469235822558403, 0.07574300467967987, -0.013375336304306984, -0.04901881888508797, -0.0017258108127862215, -0.0840923935174942, -0.01869504526257515, 0.04570556432008743, 0.0275361817330122, 0.04375823587179184, -0.020338496193289757, -0.012886355631053448, 0.03035622090101242, 0.036991678178310394, 0.022777913138270378, 0.029721271246671677, -0.009086993522942066, 0.03238333389163017, 0.013355134986341, -0.0395379364490509, -0.04201848804950714, 0.0375714972615242, -0.05013963580131531, -0.05474722757935524, 0.027702340856194496, -0.016218578442931175, -0.0029014344327151775, 0.00798893254250288, -0.011514843441545963, -0.001499987207353115, 0.005116376094520092, -0.01659884862601757, 0.00920137669891119, -0.006403421517461538, -0.05600076913833618, 0.029306894168257713, 0.012331079691648483, -0.032877255231142044, 0.014466245658695698, -0.03846878558397293, 0.08368438482284546, 0.03966016322374344, -0.04902411624789238, -0.0024342851247638464, 0.006412762217223644, 0.003149476833641529, -0.001973263220861554, -0.0002843944530468434, -0.07532060891389847, -0.012495243921875954, -0.034354571253061295, 0.021606197580695152, -0.029452065005898476, 0.024351460859179497, -0.044418565928936005, -0.02816237509250641, 0.046654172241687775, -0.016998115926980972, 0.059935469180345535, 0.02435416541993618, 0.012154304422438145, -0.005621712189167738, -0.03854013979434967, 0.0044807386584579945, -0.03179444000124931, 0.00037974072620272636, -0.011819631792604923, -0.005827686749398708, -0.010260846465826035, 0.036836616694927216, -0.07350613176822662, -0.009653456509113312, -0.003332490334287286, 0.06919742375612259, 0.03665809705853462, 0.04224732518196106, 0.04421921446919441, -0.010762310586869717, -0.028576990589499474, 0.00009157333261100575, -0.12024585157632828, -0.024511441588401794, -0.03183324262499809, 0.020652959123253822, 0.04527290537953377, 0.04814881831407547, -0.05436346307396889, -0.003907645586878061, -0.008608618751168251, 0.012618115171790123, 0.006841479334980249, 0.005910323932766914, -0.008449099957942963, 0.0021709289867430925, -0.023869629949331284, 0.03183875232934952, 0.06371520459651947, 0.02709445357322693, -0.028907733038067818, 0.000904979940969497, -0.05078896880149841, 0.007613493595272303, -0.030034957453608513, -0.022252533584833145, 0.0021558874286711216, 0.035825684666633606, -0.007704695221036673, -0.004543478600680828, -0.0003092315455432981, 0.010386627167463303, 0.04783801734447479, 0.02092689275741577, 0.027651015669107437, -0.03624482825398445, 0.0290926955640316, -0.014257571659982204, -0.02123197540640831, -0.0317794568836689, -0.005514555610716343, 0.005591560620814562, -0.030005725100636482, 0.003625058103352785, -0.017902351915836334, -0.2581425905227661, -0.03596438467502594, 0.020834816619753838, -0.005839810706675053, 0.015224975533783436, -0.01067820843309164, 0.06127810478210449, -0.019611436873674393, -0.013765254057943821, 0.0265165064483881, 0.034604281187057495, 0.04015370085835457, 0.04001849517226219, 0.018344789743423462, 0.04860759526491165, 0.033562928438186646, -0.018566548824310303, -0.03444817289710045, 0.013311365619301796, 0.01460838783532381, -0.03398671746253967, -0.08734792470932007, 0.02333252504467964, 0.0033184385392814875, 0.036427661776542664, 0.07162309437990189, -0.03748026862740517, -0.013303719460964203, -0.01167089119553566, -0.03439292311668396, -0.010540620423853397, -0.026499144732952118, -0.01714019477367401, 0.02900012955069542, 0.020591065287590027, 0.00005344000965123996, 0.07132190465927124, 0.015547879040241241, 0.024110611528158188, -0.01739027164876461, 0.02464378997683525, 0.007169249001890421, -0.06943315267562866, 0.016229096800088882, 0.07309836894273758, 0.025713477283716202, -0.041253719478845596, -0.011849014088511467, -0.03419975936412811, 0.026989609003067017, 0.002241174690425396, -0.01513818372040987, -0.053963299840688705, 0.011468888260424137, 0.005421604495495558, -0.028694499284029007, -0.01590886525809765, -0.014401883818209171, -0.018021348863840103, 0.0025699546094983816, 0.00912510696798563, -0.013491684570908546, -0.06314978748559952, 0.005212133284658194, -0.013632147572934628, -0.04517088830471039, -0.061751481145620346, -0.06547952443361282, 0.04073970392346382, 0.017374038696289062, -0.00745242927223444, -0.05517829954624176, 0.009691963903605938, -0.10939860343933105, 0.001831637229770422, 0.0017688926309347153, -0.01855158992111683, -0.009432592429220676, 0.01882786490023136, 0.060123514384031296, -0.05390210077166557, -0.038501299917697906, 0.0034307350870221853, -0.013697572983801365, 0.023210737854242325, -0.01884147711098194, -0.029567521065473557, -0.033206865191459656, 0.0014701869804412127, -0.029010308906435966, 0.06837595254182816, -0.009730725549161434, -0.00007643312710570171, 0.013690701685845852, 0.04856513440608978, 0.043952953070402145, 0.025023022666573524, 0.04471262916922569, 0.0026805324014276266, 0.009134635329246521, 0.025646833702921867, -0.057538848370313644, 0.01776379719376564, 0.0019183604745194316, 0.015549489296972752, 0.035682376474142075, -0.04420469328761101, -0.021231165155768394, 0.0355081707239151, 0.010440543293952942, 0.0032099129166454077, -0.0525951161980629, -0.00018154745339415967, -0.003954445477575064, -0.013308661058545113, 0.004234408028423786, 0.0076840720139443874, 0.052344463765621185, 0.014054127968847752, -0.023267606273293495, -0.048359714448451996, 0.021705318242311478, -0.0020878633949905634, 0.01705350913107395, -0.01901962235569954, -0.0022943883668631315, -0.0245587769895792, 0.02876666560769081, 0.0020666089840233326, -0.01792345941066742, 0.008727682754397392, 0.020013360306620598, -0.04333113878965378, 0.004993604961782694, 0.020068902522325516, -0.0003286889987066388, -0.008585890755057335, -0.02791438065469265, 0.0353751964867115, -0.02025686949491501, 0.03709730505943298, -0.050830066204071045, 0.041791003197431564, 0.04603740945458412, 0.026445606723427773, -0.01833009533584118, 0.03445551171898842, -0.022664964199066162, 0.007985676638782024, 0.0033462676219642162, 0.01322669256478548, -0.07522640377283096, -0.02864501066505909, -0.035016074776649475, 0.02336925081908703, -0.06928884983062744, 0.004182881209999323, -0.024955734610557556, 0.0008510455954819918, -0.037113677710294724, 0.015215704217553139, -0.022455336526036263, -0.047306813299655914, -0.0167839415371418, -0.002331643598154187, 0.044607359915971756, -0.029523028060793877, -0.019863059744238853, 0.00840421300381422, -0.017802434042096138, -0.011182115413248539, -0.06209675967693329, -0.012681884691119194, -0.012233251705765724, -0.0464143380522728, 0.020111829042434692, 0.028305673971772194, -0.012610492296516895, -0.041892848908901215, 0.037894658744335175, -0.01994333043694496, -0.04079333320260048, 0.0009520670864731073, -0.008592119440436363, 0.0938020795583725, 0.009499852545559406, 0.015386940911412239, 0.007158460561186075, -0.010281108319759369, 0.01156549621373415, 0.006213124375790358, 0.04863188788294792, -0.021578971296548843, -0.057622279971838, -0.039456453174352646, -0.058222487568855286, 0.021539555862545967, 0.006573823746293783, -0.022262006998062134, -0.005567984189838171, -0.0028489280957728624, -0.0077727558091282845, -0.035758405923843384, -0.014689226634800434, 0.01365930587053299, -0.08498060703277588, 0.00988795142620802, 0.04353534057736397, -0.0006393743096850812, 0.02776934579014778, -0.051024384796619415, -0.03446721285581589, -0.031030962243676186, -0.01657770201563835, -0.007682402618229389, -0.0103711923584342, -0.017427418380975723, -0.04705597460269928, -0.01580832153558731, -0.02481848932802677, -0.0037060061004012823, -0.006878439337015152, -0.05967356264591217, -0.035970233380794525, -0.002240670146420598, 0.03060751035809517, -0.018056685104966164, -0.020987343043088913, -0.022564195096492767, -0.019961901009082794, 0.030101610347628593, -0.04062914475798607, 0.03532383218407631, 0.039284177124500275, 0.002517028246074915, 0.021607521921396255, -0.04682282730937004, 0.005431625060737133, 0.017903069034218788, -0.004668361973017454, -0.04242447391152382, 0.008955003693699837, -0.04433324933052063, -0.0055128284730017185, 0.00914807803928852, 0.029627682641148567, 0.03075842373073101, 0.009229992516338825, -0.022454189136624336, 0.007555242162197828, 0.031275663524866104, 0.022931642830371857, -0.008349369280040264, 0.02899152599275112, 0.0652049109339714, -0.03649788349866867, -0.01011541299521923, -0.039109084755182266, -0.05169399827718735, 0.014750126749277115, -0.02161865495145321, 0.02962162159383297, -0.011900145560503006, 0.03085014782845974, 0.01755504496395588, 0.0102400416508317, 0.03899705410003662, -0.06215041130781174, 0.06374409049749374, -0.06254246830940247, 0.04413026571273804, -0.07934726774692535, 0.0013131920713931322, 0.06768827885389328, -0.03938905522227287, -0.015471786260604858, 0.03981482610106468, -0.016161831095814705, 0.032095324248075485, -0.04321283474564552, -0.041399117559194565, 0.019228043034672737, -0.04311451315879822, -0.03440173342823982, 0.030744928866624832, -0.06821706891059875, -0.0036604914348572493, -0.058359209448099136, -0.02834298089146614, 0.03267001360654831, -0.004240219946950674, 0.037689123302698135, -0.02745937742292881, 0.042171724140644073, -0.043411485850811005, 0.03738513961434364, 0.018706064671278, 0.022791663184762, -0.010852472856640816, 0.026161963120102882, -0.025610273703932762, 0.07432591170072556, 0.059144508093595505, 0.008027931675314903, 0.017947010695934296, 0.0068220049142837524, -0.02070537582039833, -0.0377013273537159, 0.05450819060206413, 0.010668529197573662, -0.024709835648536682, -0.08232354372739792, 0.07048197835683823, 0.03671862185001373, -0.039058029651641846, -0.0005438774242065847, 0.049652181565761566, -0.06056275963783264, -0.02210109308362007, 0.02104327455163002, 0.005763556808233261, 0.012306817807257175, 0.04744132235646248, 0.01825207844376564, 0.06797041743993759, 0.08667179197072983, 0.03880926966667175, -0.030147865414619446, 0.012761400081217289, 0.08158734440803528, 0.06439179927110672, 0.041270021349191666, -0.011042875237762928, 0.08009825646877289, 0.004281524568796158, -0.05199972540140152, 0.04045645520091057, 0.05334757640957832, -0.04354705289006233, -0.02233622968196869, 0.03206042945384979, 0.09705626964569092, -0.0024594778660684824, 0.05202605202794075, -0.04187944531440735, -0.02228919044137001, 0.055897220969200134, 0.0181877464056015, 0.016209445893764496, 0.02836625650525093, 0.04460606724023819, 0.06776225566864014, -0.040010251104831696, -0.004039722494781017, 0.005599008873105049, -0.05729774758219719, -0.023163707926869392, 0.03373805060982704, -0.00697214063256979, 0.008345340378582478, -0.005109845194965601, 0.046703875064849854, 0.1024990826845169, -0.012976186349987984, -0.0023293832782655954, 0.025527220219373703, -0.014271266758441925, 0.013854117132723331, 0.04296457767486572, 0.02448227070271969, 0.005687038879841566, 0.017073119059205055, -0.015161504037678242, 0.011039799079298973, 0.023034268990159035, -0.027278566733002663, 0.061223745346069336, -0.057416219264268875, -0.016773955896496773, 0.005897941999137402, -0.0011147278128191829, -0.06590811908245087, -0.018737537786364555, -0.03079179674386978, -0.045775167644023895, -0.031157180666923523, -0.04468439519405365, 0.04231366887688637, 0.018501991406083107, -0.09440363198518753, -0.0019747742917388678, -0.01869244873523712, 0.019986020401120186, 0.00930215697735548, -0.04181910306215286, 0.0056437356397509575, 0.045156605541706085, 0.0025063178036361933, -0.013701147399842739, 0.006781715899705887, 0.03605051338672638, -0.01915852166712284, 0.005493273958563805, 0.0027613507118076086, -0.011486569419503212, 0.038259342312812805, -0.010447674430906773, -0.0034874784760177135, -0.08770684897899628, -0.03714456036686897, 0.012877034023404121, -0.027775611728429794, -0.08269333094358444, 0.0004727244086097926, -0.0579010434448719, 0.06254490464925766, 0.06959384679794312, 0.0013163498369976878, 0.04506348446011543, -0.007460843771696091, 0.027690088376402855, 0.04787374660372734, 0.000025271949198213406, 0.03191158175468445, -0.02655823342502117, 0.06661518663167953, 0.03943869099020958, -0.03622825816273689, -0.06972618401050568, 0.06707079708576202, -0.006749555002897978, -0.016375279054045677, -0.03890698030591011, -0.018854228779673576, -0.02583744004368782, -0.08584221452474594, -0.008780248463153839, 0.0373457707464695, -0.001824094564653933, -0.04883304238319397, 0.0005025567952543497, 0.001640851842239499, -0.031982988119125366, -0.005210913717746735, -0.011678703129291534, 0.01100109238177538, -0.0240760650485754, 0.00875074416399002, -0.07571779936552048, -0.01270010881125927, -0.035455331206321716, -0.006114345975220203, -0.02678634785115719, -0.026603475213050842, 0.027276476845145226, 0.025159675627946854, 0.041029706597328186, 0.0008429419249296188, 0.022623686119914055, -0.021540844812989235 ]
3,507
DeepRTL: Bridging Verilog Understanding and Generation with a Unified Representation Model
https://openreview.net/forum?id=2hcfoCHKoB
[ "Yi Liu", "Changran XU", "Yunhao Zhou", "Zeju Li", "Qiang Xu" ]
Spotlight
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have shown significant potential for automating hardware description language (HDL) code generation from high-level natural language instructions. While fine-tuning has improved LLMs' performance in hardware design tasks, prior efforts have largely focused on Verilog generation, overlooking the equally critical task of Verilog understanding. Furthermore, existing models suffer from weak alignment between natural language descriptions and Verilog code, hindering the generation of high-quality, synthesizable designs. To address these issues, we present DeepRTL, a unified representation model that excels in both Verilog understanding and generation. Based on CodeT5+, DeepRTL is fine-tuned on a comprehensive dataset that aligns Verilog code with rich, multi-level natural language descriptions. We also introduce the first benchmark for Verilog understanding and take the initiative to apply embedding similarity and GPT Score to evaluate the models' understanding capabilities. These metrics capture semantic similarity more accurately than traditional methods like BLEU and ROUGE, which are limited to surface-level n-gram overlaps. By adapting curriculum learning to train DeepRTL, we enable it to significantly outperform GPT-4 in Verilog understanding tasks, while achieving performance on par with OpenAI's o1-preview model in Verilog generation tasks.
Large Language Model, Program Representation Learning, Verilog Understanding and Generation
null
6,938
2502.15832
[ 0.006330535747110844, -0.018866119906306267, -0.03760300204157829, 0.0562874898314476, 0.05040509253740311, 0.016984743997454643, 0.01583465375006199, 0.011264467611908913, 0.02216436341404915, 0.0002918910176958889, 0.004443319048732519, 0.01788538694381714, -0.06386486440896988, 0.020583821460604668, 0.008508909493684769, 0.05340207740664482, 0.04282721132040024, -0.022813573479652405, 0.01445695385336876, 0.02341441996395588, 0.021885128691792488, -0.02556789107620716, 0.023599890992045403, 0.02668401598930359, 0.017570802941918373, -0.0016901788767427206, 0.020821314305067062, -0.0074464199133217335, -0.029873641207814217, 0.03433448076248169, 0.03937731683254242, -0.032258935272693634, 0.03838780149817467, -0.02054462768137455, -0.007002080790698528, -0.016552934423089027, -0.07607125490903854, -0.00958302989602089, 0.003476987360045314, 0.01736048236489296, -0.03623732924461365, -0.0011984651209786534, -0.01362189743667841, -0.0015548552619293332, -0.03044435754418373, 0.045416198670864105, -0.1089734360575676, 0.034091077744960785, 0.03703470528125763, -0.014349841512739658, -0.08700218796730042, 0.002505027921870351, -0.011377697810530663, -0.01239063497632742, 0.011772827245295048, 0.008528572507202625, 0.04365915060043335, -0.07171054929494858, -0.012192986905574799, -0.0716049000620842, -0.01688489504158497, -0.00912783294916153, 0.01941065303981304, 0.01864917390048504, 0.01371693890541792, -0.015051326714456081, -0.009664335288107395, 0.014583243057131767, -0.0722334012389183, -0.03970564901828766, -0.04002747684717178, 0.0011038719676434994, -0.012716279365122318, -0.002925006439909339, 0.02704397402703762, -0.04052773863077164, -0.0033074072562158108, 0.03370782360434532, 0.0713493674993515, 0.012039070948958397, 0.01821804977953434, 0.03222593292593956, 0.03511112183332443, 0.03745283931493759, 0.018530601635575294, 0.009247473441064358, -0.050257131457328796, -0.05345284193754196, -0.05148443579673767, 0.047456223517656326, -0.04515102133154869, -0.017271820455789566, 0.02332504279911518, 0.04043828323483467, -0.005576758179813623, 0.011566882021725178, 0.004198392387479544, 0.013687320053577423, -0.016230210661888123, 0.010723632760345936, -0.024666642770171165, -0.02899468131363392, 0.03800230845808983, -0.009122063405811787, -0.07986532896757126, -0.01774396002292633, -0.033838894218206406, -0.025508349761366844, 0.01057138480246067, -0.006190593354403973, -0.002993293572217226, -0.0006615809979848564, 0.017031999304890633, -0.015890466049313545, -0.07527078688144684, 0.05925280973315239, 0.025786971673369408, 0.013514342717826366, 0.0038118467200547457, -0.016431039199233055, 0.03976741433143616, 0.05956696718931198, -0.010731718502938747, 0.06539972871541977, 0.02323908917605877, 0.01094213780015707, 0.01444976031780243, 0.014870146289467812, -0.036056749522686005, -0.03238486871123314, -0.01756373792886734, 0.054467059671878815, -0.006438807584345341, 0.0037897443398833275, -0.006725425366312265, 0.01430052611976862, -0.002087607979774475, -0.0037252292968332767, 0.04844963550567627, 0.00890851579606533, -0.011480453424155712, -0.027327585965394974, 0.10989424586296082, -0.05984235554933548, 0.05221056938171387, 0.02893982268869877, -0.019891496747732162, -0.009120861999690533, -0.03029017522931099, 0.017623012885451317, -0.01630527339875698, 0.030915945768356323, -0.030853264033794403, -0.0650310218334198, 0.047411978244781494, 0.057310618460178375, 0.019317425787448883, 0.03953781723976135, 0.007675247732549906, 0.03617825359106064, -0.02511032484471798, -0.01811748370528221, -0.028340376913547516, 0.008588467724621296, -0.016990995034575462, -0.03280830755829811, 0.05890297889709473, 0.02732164040207863, -0.008908743970096111, -0.026746712625026703, -0.02280333824455738, -0.018079105764627457, 0.02556164748966694, 0.01728213205933571, -0.023571902886033058, 0.0015113784465938807, 0.05336261913180351, -0.031281400471925735, 0.007118524517863989, 0.02006610855460167, -0.08462288975715637, 0.011412703432142735, 0.017339348793029785, -0.0027437179815024137, -0.011028842069208622, -0.030206412076950073, 0.08411230146884918, -0.04943963512778282, -0.03133699297904968, -0.0018452820368111134, -0.08108416199684143, -0.011542199179530144, 0.0011044411221519113, -0.03530469909310341, 0.06709275394678116, 0.00884805154055357, -0.0009156599990092218, 0.03290814533829689, 0.012322723865509033, 0.057395342737436295, 0.05165214464068413, -0.020283913239836693, 0.007567557971924543, -0.005465738940984011, -0.04384676739573479, -0.005794846918433905, 0.04460359364748001, -0.026974666863679886, -0.046880971640348434, -0.03339545056223869, -0.0013985957484692335, -0.008830500766634941, 0.049337103962898254, -0.03303081914782524, 0.02676662616431713, -0.01536609698086977, 0.01197697315365076, -0.0038751931861042976, 0.030974559485912323, -0.05745958164334297, 0.05730767175555229, 0.03377183899283409, -0.003787058172747493, 0.015870077535510063, -0.05472800135612488, 0.1009417250752449, 0.07274703681468964, -0.04199707508087158, -0.01960565708577633, 0.046058736741542816, -0.006070259027183056, -0.012756532058119774, 0.004865535534918308, -0.03200242668390274, -0.005956368055194616, -0.024933047592639923, -0.03247024491429329, -0.017705800011754036, 0.041417744010686874, -0.04289201274514198, -0.02462635189294815, 0.07949163019657135, -0.018556464463472366, 0.05474521964788437, -0.0020695228595286608, 0.021584687754511833, 0.03342149034142494, -0.04665639251470566, -0.006031356286257505, -0.01798669435083866, -0.006652488838881254, -0.012384642846882343, 0.04323214665055275, 0.005562833044677973, -0.023527080193161964, -0.06357085704803467, -0.012639729306101799, 0.003284695092588663, 0.04848552867770195, 0.04618234559893608, 0.02541988715529442, 0.018554355949163437, 0.010919056832790375, -0.04735499992966652, -0.006314506288617849, -0.10236874222755432, -0.03700043261051178, -0.0028843823820352554, 0.04837719723582268, 0.0072650727815926075, -0.0035707529168576, 0.01983596198260784, -0.0064698136411607265, -0.03596505895256996, -0.04783250018954277, -0.014519874006509781, 0.027364928275346756, -0.007291285786777735, -0.016822749748826027, -0.0254327654838562, 0.007756126578897238, 0.0609540119767189, -0.039575885981321335, -0.01776939071714878, -0.035370614379644394, -0.019924290478229523, 0.004881779197603464, -0.049191731959581375, 0.027320142835378647, -0.004894215147942305, 0.01918523944914341, 0.03146132826805115, -0.045958906412124634, 0.03447575122117996, 0.06524567306041718, 0.06064942479133606, 0.060280691832304, -0.0027587220538407564, -0.02223517745733261, 0.024356095120310783, -0.010807218961417675, 0.015426849015057087, -0.042763739824295044, 0.026125634089112282, -0.012888460420072079, 0.01978367567062378, 0.03327799588441849, 0.006115726660937071, -0.25807780027389526, -0.053697340190410614, -0.009690328501164913, -0.039747972041368484, 0.05631379038095474, 0.017993507906794548, 0.018868887796998024, -0.01592220924794674, 0.009256820194423199, 0.03836243599653244, 0.029786407947540283, -0.011846186593174934, 0.013661804609000683, 0.02817430905997753, 0.0743478313088417, 0.051005251705646515, -0.02617153897881508, -0.03955259174108505, 0.0252881720662117, 0.05074349790811539, -0.007624462712556124, -0.07876361906528473, -0.027848197147250175, 0.014398012310266495, 0.0008497503586113453, 0.017554383724927902, -0.115976482629776, -0.011624584905803204, -0.026275670155882835, -0.024133222177624702, -0.01887674070894718, -0.014711723662912846, -0.019977470859885216, 0.01709880121052265, -0.00766402343288064, -0.017356183379888535, 0.04023416340351105, 0.014495020732283592, 0.03400912880897522, 0.030737049877643585, 0.016625959426164627, -0.020548978820443153, -0.016358068212866783, 0.009553587064146996, 0.08116482198238373, 0.0068299840204417706, -0.08456343412399292, -0.019619720056653023, -0.025551272556185722, 0.042429979890584946, -0.0227954238653183, 0.004059905186295509, 0.026855051517486572, 0.01795092225074768, -0.017545541748404503, -0.0196621585637331, 0.003941030707210302, 0.013230661861598492, -0.009096257388591766, 0.025301041081547737, -0.03691650927066803, -0.047868262976408005, -0.02101851813495159, -0.02738550491631031, -0.038018301129341125, -0.010713331401348114, -0.034021224826574326, -0.049729637801647186, -0.002641380298882723, 0.042899928987026215, -0.05572614073753357, 0.02347899042069912, -0.03903137519955635, -0.09572743624448776, -0.0010688025504350662, 0.0012048041680827737, -0.02145855687558651, -0.027116568759083748, 0.015683406963944435, 0.027338365092873573, -0.005986804608255625, -0.08161896467208862, -0.009998074732720852, 0.007918075658380985, 0.0313018299639225, 0.0025218494702130556, -0.020812055096030235, -0.07867581397294998, -0.013544033281505108, -0.0328972265124321, 0.0518452413380146, -0.006960040424019098, 0.006211607251316309, -0.02798827551305294, 0.062365736812353134, 0.0196949765086174, 0.04878513514995575, 0.03653028607368469, 0.012640664353966713, 0.014838917180895805, -0.007321566808968782, -0.06905581057071686, -0.012973637320101261, -0.02991405874490738, -0.015117370523512363, 0.04020925983786583, -0.03722206875681877, -0.04496551305055618, 0.06085234507918358, 0.03205471485853195, -0.029048040509223938, -0.041904643177986145, 0.025981355458498, -0.007838085293769836, 0.009074128232896328, -0.006290847435593605, 0.026216380298137665, 0.02865726500749588, 0.03943515941500664, -0.022055795416235924, -0.05095479637384415, 0.012851396575570107, -0.018177347257733345, 0.01846664771437645, 0.010266384109854698, -0.022927284240722656, 0.003079988295212388, -0.009057712741196156, -0.004250688944011927, -0.018690764904022217, 0.0375523641705513, 0.04348111152648926, -0.0002014996571233496, 0.00829595047980547, 0.019745634868741035, 0.018296273425221443, -0.032105159014463425, 0.003219116711989045, 0.009061588905751705, 0.003199502360075712, -0.003174365032464266, -0.02767515927553177, 0.034257370978593826, 0.0016577612841501832, 0.03274252265691757, 0.006780022289603949, 0.034555256366729736, 0.003655551001429558, 0.0013575569028034806, -0.006762310862541199, 0.008336364291608334, -0.04659632220864296, 0.03515882417559624, -0.03902462497353554, 0.019652215763926506, -0.03992046043276787, 0.04749661311507225, 0.0019053425639867783, -0.018588243052363396, -0.05738905817270279, 0.046625230461359024, 0.02110232226550579, -0.011199657805263996, 0.015182411298155785, 0.04594476893544197, 0.04360064119100571, -0.018993614241480827, -0.015289733186364174, 0.03027328848838806, 0.008376692421734333, -0.018816927447915077, -0.02330746315419674, -0.015714064240455627, -0.012660209089517593, -0.03898471221327782, 0.024539764970541, 0.01166311465203762, -0.04323923587799072, 0.002121449913829565, 0.009629940614104271, 0.0034890747629106045, -0.021193373948335648, -0.006350233219563961, 0.016343282535672188, 0.07650456577539444, -0.005833874922245741, 0.03772713616490364, 0.006017428357154131, -0.023020988330245018, 0.029029302299022675, 0.0037957122549414635, 0.005245517008006573, -0.044912710785865784, 0.006740906275808811, -0.06834406405687332, -0.0474817156791687, 0.003512936644256115, 0.018161246553063393, 0.014154830947518349, -0.040760528296232224, 0.010938059538602829, -0.003803006839007139, -0.04125267267227173, -0.03653305396437645, 0.04361698403954506, -0.04741895943880081, 0.026109028607606888, 0.05221409350633621, -0.007414777297526598, 0.01665092259645462, -0.022847909480333328, -0.032654136419296265, -0.023277873173356056, -0.012602519243955612, -0.017796358093619347, -0.018504707142710686, -0.008605800569057465, -0.012498036958277225, -0.047304343432188034, -0.02758495882153511, 0.03888722136616707, -0.0018296976340934634, 0.03226981684565544, -0.017247408628463745, -0.035974469035863876, 0.013310392387211323, -0.03343740478157997, 0.004107750486582518, -0.0008072270429693162, -0.027588527649641037, 0.027955709025263786, -0.043983593583106995, 0.031461793929338455, 0.039732225239276886, -0.0052692219614982605, -0.02571660652756691, -0.08103287220001221, 0.03333277255296707, -0.01359811145812273, -0.004779978655278683, 0.005380862392485142, -0.03552636131644249, -0.03705856576561928, 0.022121954709291458, -0.00956859439611435, 0.011174080893397331, -0.0139467753469944, 0.007332510314881802, 0.018054159358143806, 0.008391916751861572, 0.013778339140117168, 0.0074513680301606655, -0.031868528574705124, -0.0021169213578104973, 0.0698670893907547, -0.06219509616494179, -0.007610410917550325, -0.05818673223257065, -0.05183282122015953, 0.0020165597088634968, -0.05221205949783325, 0.001810600166209042, -0.0462273508310318, 0.06811488419771194, 0.019836392253637314, 0.07077609747648239, 0.025861285626888275, -0.05940601974725723, 0.045878395438194275, -0.028984971344470978, 0.01656726561486721, -0.071066714823246, 0.006636484991759062, 0.07482486963272095, -0.040334589779376984, -0.012346383184194565, -0.014912347309291363, -0.02828231081366539, 0.01560361310839653, -0.01876864582300186, -0.05070611834526062, 0.01720251888036728, 0.01640622690320015, 0.0003847531334031373, 0.022471914067864418, -0.025307856500148773, -0.03014637716114521, -0.022947441786527634, -0.027827654033899307, 0.018020102754235268, 0.014049726538360119, 0.018200790509581566, -0.024106033146381378, 0.009269329719245434, -0.03184663876891136, -0.025908323004841805, 0.01605864427983761, 0.042333461344242096, 0.028933363035321236, 0.058824989944696426, -0.013824084773659706, 0.0729931890964508, 0.03882365673780441, 0.03065970540046692, 0.012953332625329494, 0.021006980910897255, -0.007177373394370079, -0.018236331641674042, 0.03352794051170349, 0.008127239532768726, -0.02836301550269127, -0.03694513812661171, 0.05634411796927452, 0.03552529588341713, -0.05268818885087967, 0.00250869058072567, 0.02309572510421276, -0.06728767603635788, -0.014161900617182255, -0.02689640410244465, 0.012099185958504677, -0.009525276720523834, 0.0888473242521286, 0.011735391803085804, 0.01973596215248108, 0.07292565703392029, 0.020761646330356598, -0.08502978086471558, 0.014814458787441254, 0.1014895960688591, 0.07062222808599472, 0.03759858012199402, -0.044479645788669586, 0.07903368026018143, -0.03107542172074318, -0.05308534577488899, 0.028654100373387337, 0.015382635407149792, 0.01319775078445673, -0.01361058559268713, 0.035398636013269424, 0.08136530965566635, 0.006380235310643911, 0.07511057704687119, -0.03107617050409317, 0.015639403834939003, 0.06521783769130707, 0.0041009350679814816, 0.004866735078394413, 0.07474075257778168, 0.001761630759574473, -0.009611131623387337, -0.00021172755805309862, -0.009841486811637878, -0.0233926884829998, 0.0015267862472683191, 0.012284179218113422, 0.002958898199722171, 0.03132304921746254, 0.004249853082001209, -0.013852269388735294, 0.02587229758501053, 0.10579919815063477, -0.02707292139530182, -0.026408130303025246, -0.020621897652745247, 0.01023358665406704, -0.002396028023213148, -0.004786488600075245, -0.04400273784995079, -0.019519992172718048, -0.00857891608029604, -0.059142570942640305, -0.002165258163586259, 0.0008971311617642641, 0.010019542649388313, 0.03447748348116875, -0.011899737641215324, -0.045217812061309814, 0.015360891819000244, 0.014367848634719849, -0.02700289897620678, -0.03913526237010956, -0.07116237282752991, -0.03637651726603508, -0.040106892585754395, -0.02320053055882454, 0.003132843878120184, 0.006569339893758297, -0.04997313767671585, -0.024696476757526398, -0.020252399146556854, 0.018715741112828255, 0.03386420011520386, -0.048909250646829605, 0.006772032007575035, 0.011882925406098366, -0.0028961391653865576, -0.009763098321855068, 0.06610235571861267, 0.021769097074866295, -0.0010483718942850828, -0.03246227651834488, 0.02954193204641342, 0.013577026315033436, -0.003261386416852474, 0.006064639892429113, -0.026622824370861053, -0.09781109541654587, 0.004712542984634638, 0.036541882902383804, -0.004693473689258099, -0.07982684671878815, -0.006224689073860645, -0.02739964798092842, 0.03984111547470093, 0.07858272641897202, -0.007981165312230587, 0.042586371302604675, 0.024743126705288887, -0.007320240139961243, 0.009132813662290573, 0.03327032923698425, 0.034342654049396515, -0.042452123016119, 0.07455970346927643, 0.045749712735414505, -0.01838979870080948, 0.0034530642442405224, 0.027698641642928123, 0.010209561325609684, -0.04658341780304909, -0.01840188167989254, -0.012206907384097576, -0.029355287551879883, -0.08878976851701736, -0.004050263669341803, -0.012453213334083557, 0.007290901616215706, -0.0323445089161396, 0.023145396262407303, -0.010580726899206638, -0.013588651083409786, 0.019273702055215836, -0.042445842176675797, -0.019432472065091133, -0.03843885660171509, -0.039567042142152786, -0.027155674993991852, 0.03191018104553223, -0.0428292416036129, 0.023903340101242065, -0.009655465371906757, -0.024833055213093758, -0.008647149428725243, 0.018902281299233437, 0.08288845419883728, 0.01446626428514719, 0.026985473930835724, -0.00713415676727891 ]
3,508
Robust Function-Calling for On-Device Language Model via Function Masking
https://openreview.net/forum?id=yVQcr4qjD6
[ "Qiqiang Lin", "Muning Wen", "Qiuying Peng", "Guanyu Nie", "Junwei Liao", "Jun Wang", "Xiaoyun Mo", "Jiamu Zhou", "Cheng Cheng", "Yin Zhao", "Jun Wang", "Weinan Zhang" ]
Spotlight
Large language models have demonstrated impressive value in performing as autonomous agents when equipped with external tools and API calls. Nonetheless, effectively harnessing their potential for executing complex tasks crucially relies on enhancements in their function-calling capabilities. This paper identifies a critical gap in existing function-calling models, where performance varies significantly across benchmarks, often due to over-fitting to specific naming conventions. To address such an issue, we introduce Hammer, a novel family of foundation models specifically engineered for on-device function calling. Hammer employs an augmented dataset that enhances models’ sensitivity to irrelevant functions and incorporates function masking techniques to minimize over-fitting. Our empirical evaluations reveal that Hammer not only outperforms larger models but also demonstrates robust generalization across diverse benchmarks, achieving state-of-the-art results. Our open-source contributions include a specialized dataset for irrelevance detection, a tuning framework for enhanced generalization, and the Hammer models, establishing a new standard for function-calling performance.
language models, function-calling, mobile assistant, tool-using
null
6,867
2410.04587
[ -0.028504159301519394, 0.016612600535154343, -0.012106827460229397, 0.006697517354041338, 0.031681474298238754, 0.05139219015836716, 0.05529770627617836, -0.023438777774572372, -0.026026511564850807, -0.02770007774233818, 0.025833480060100555, 0.02621457912027836, -0.06466647982597351, -0.022033529356122017, 0.008451023139059544, 0.043070971965789795, 0.050609443336725235, -0.0004557416832540184, 0.020368311554193497, 0.0002569206408225, 0.01074750442057848, 0.016528544947504997, 0.053578201681375504, 0.021573536098003387, 0.01392342895269394, -0.0011051826877519488, 0.013349802233278751, 0.008362186141312122, -0.02947620302438736, 0.02080487832427025, 0.04766131937503815, 0.012556953355669975, 0.01783519797027111, -0.06120482459664345, 0.004648914560675621, 0.005816104356199503, -0.023203039541840553, 0.00946310255676508, 0.023917552083730698, 0.0370803102850914, -0.04290114343166351, 0.0004031560383737087, -0.014421054162085056, 0.017387935891747475, -0.06818860024213791, 0.034482963383197784, -0.12050771713256836, 0.011163326911628246, -0.017228486016392708, -0.009111941792070866, -0.09365415573120117, 0.02485552243888378, -0.026522992178797722, -0.04508575424551964, 0.018195807933807373, 0.014967958442866802, 0.03888153284788132, -0.10890313982963562, -0.0318119078874588, -0.04043584689497948, -0.0351526141166687, 0.008678904734551907, 0.011508672498166561, 0.00022825376072432846, 0.02037622034549713, 0.014670949429273605, 0.008537265472114086, 0.010563451796770096, -0.06414240598678589, -0.03960157930850983, -0.029477639123797417, 0.0017472446197643876, -0.030502263456583023, -0.03196536749601364, -0.0028657999355345964, -0.05427182465791702, 0.02150091528892517, 0.037984125316143036, 0.06695284694433212, 0.008693196810781956, 0.015122960321605206, 0.03061404824256897, 0.02751825749874115, 0.052589043974876404, 0.026503900066018105, -0.0018816423835232854, -0.018692519515752792, -0.02788887359201908, -0.05461184307932854, 0.03047884628176689, 0.026381606236100197, -0.06867540627717972, 0.010232584550976753, 0.018309837207198143, 0.0197137501090765, 0.03796173259615898, 0.0058546545915305614, 0.003419913351535797, 0.012941598892211914, 0.024856390431523323, -0.011238359846174717, -0.024899879470467567, 0.009931325912475586, -0.005112410522997379, -0.10331486910581589, -0.019615432247519493, -0.001585290185175836, -0.01403594110161066, -0.021351192146539688, -0.0017054846975952387, 0.007890202105045319, 0.016301147639751434, 0.019461898133158684, -0.005562984384596348, -0.0844787061214447, 0.028592491522431374, 0.002305457601323724, -0.0003998463216703385, 0.000876550329849124, -0.03150571510195732, 0.07710780948400497, 0.06943085044622421, -0.0065706041641533375, 0.06368648260831833, 0.015699027106165886, -0.007311904337257147, 0.013823507353663445, 0.04055868461728096, 0.007735373452305794, -0.0051444279961287975, -0.019966352730989456, 0.04378283768892288, 0.02653280273079872, 0.019974851980805397, -0.026843927800655365, 0.01563393883407116, -0.012328430078923702, 0.01882893219590187, 0.04293768107891083, -0.010362655855715275, 0.006227280478924513, 0.004824327304959297, 0.049555182456970215, -0.05658293142914772, 0.07319910824298859, -0.022521106526255608, -0.025591693818569183, -0.030593469738960266, -0.00208549783565104, 0.01563100703060627, -0.009550722315907478, 0.0221635140478611, -0.02127671241760254, -0.08381597697734833, 0.05460427701473236, 0.05058065429329872, 0.034737177193164825, 0.00854363851249218, -0.00489034503698349, -0.007819227874279022, -0.013966094702482224, -0.02264753170311451, -0.03985012322664261, 0.024140311405062675, 0.01592704840004444, -0.02091507613658905, 0.049492307007312775, 0.025864116847515106, 0.011511377990245819, -0.024004433304071426, -0.021590285003185272, -0.023861641064286232, 0.05028283968567848, 0.006651905830949545, -0.03407913073897362, -0.039229441434144974, 0.06069296970963478, -0.02669859491288662, 0.006552235223352909, 0.05587426945567131, -0.07698563486337662, 0.020686643198132515, 0.05120017006993294, 0.015350119210779667, -0.013407611288130283, -0.023170674219727516, 0.07998272031545639, -0.05463649332523346, -0.03956848010420799, -0.028564730659127235, -0.07028471678495407, -0.02997972071170807, 0.03706128150224686, 0.004155150149017572, 0.06826598197221756, -0.009474145248532295, -0.028108278289437294, 0.03618708997964859, 0.02317165955901146, 0.044297635555267334, 0.03454902768135071, -0.0269447211176157, 0.0316571407020092, 0.007402230519801378, -0.034845173358917236, -0.003907660022377968, 0.04831395298242569, -0.061201032251119614, -0.025373108685016632, 0.02878512069582939, -0.014572488144040108, -0.003090119222179055, 0.04613907262682915, -0.016009368002414703, 0.02114575169980526, -0.02543838508427143, -0.01330616045743227, -0.007386046927422285, 0.005654510110616684, -0.06821924448013306, 0.02362578921020031, 0.026266777887940407, -0.026978272944688797, 0.03020014427602291, -0.0417294055223465, 0.09558416903018951, 0.05545420199632645, -0.0449196957051754, -0.008212336339056492, -0.0056730094365775585, 0.00980463344603777, 0.004087530076503754, -0.0009602638892829418, -0.050681985914707184, -0.006186061073094606, -0.028038818389177322, 0.009073898196220398, -0.010377953760325909, 0.013827075250446796, -0.034526675939559937, -0.005975942127406597, 0.0656600371003151, -0.022249847650527954, 0.05255476012825966, -0.013115293346345425, 0.027459047734737396, 0.03857274726033211, -0.042959753423929214, 0.02304515242576599, -0.056299787014722824, -0.00978386402130127, -0.007989116944372654, 0.013678433373570442, -0.02015218883752823, 0.05528832972049713, -0.04157303273677826, 0.00006100184691604227, -0.00865341629832983, 0.060857903212308884, 0.05656018853187561, 0.018237270414829254, 0.023468950763344765, -0.014017559587955475, -0.04119594395160675, -0.02026946470141411, -0.1310855895280838, 0.008777450770139694, 0.008875459432601929, 0.0375872477889061, 0.010621851310133934, 0.030331408604979515, 0.011288177222013474, 0.0010186537401750684, -0.022027242928743362, -0.009981406852602959, -0.01246923953294754, -0.028157120570540428, -0.001779395854100585, -0.046473462134599686, -0.016197627410292625, 0.010068771429359913, 0.0632132887840271, -0.008441251702606678, -0.0290273055434227, -0.03327391296625137, -0.04171689599752426, 0.004719735123217106, -0.0694499984383583, -0.008172562345862389, 0.011674878187477589, 0.043353356420993805, 0.0029033124446868896, -0.023356156423687935, 0.02682863548398018, 0.020706837996840477, 0.07014930248260498, 0.04616231843829155, 0.029785610735416412, -0.05501791462302208, 0.027704697102308273, -0.015244166366755962, 0.005914620589464903, -0.019987810403108597, 0.025586502626538277, -0.022300001233816147, -0.0026388932019472122, -0.022290850058197975, -0.008740098215639591, -0.261421799659729, -0.006570638623088598, 0.014093700796365738, -0.01615804247558117, -0.0031335267703980207, -0.011782298795878887, 0.009332297369837761, -0.01812843233346939, -0.014418375678360462, 0.01619710959494114, 0.019989948719739914, 0.046057652682065964, 0.007682956755161285, 0.014170498587191105, 0.05467019975185394, 0.014619330875575542, -0.001984294271096587, -0.0035208456683903933, 0.0072997561655938625, 0.041225966066122055, -0.009518261067569256, -0.07629935443401337, 0.023815667256712914, 0.007604713551700115, -0.035043660551309586, 0.020397130399942398, -0.08219850063323975, -0.02148779109120369, -0.030176134780049324, -0.00022979191271588206, -0.04703699052333832, -0.016097083687782288, -0.01661391369998455, 0.0177193284034729, 0.011411137878894806, 0.026789063587784767, 0.05268457904458046, 0.007096732966601849, 0.034554556012153625, 0.0345437116920948, 0.03559044003486633, -0.020246760919690132, -0.01375260204076767, 0.018324684351682663, 0.07712367177009583, 0.0022036407608538866, -0.04936319589614868, -0.01058261375874281, -0.029498564079403877, 0.032573506236076355, -0.013080812990665436, -0.04235510155558586, -0.03536246716976166, 0.024447020143270493, 0.02372187003493309, -0.03529549390077591, -0.012460247613489628, -0.017644628882408142, 0.004722170531749725, 0.017287779599428177, -0.009812869131565094, -0.02416784130036831, -0.04446764662861824, -0.004572562873363495, -0.021697187796235085, -0.02900799736380577, -0.06432713568210602, -0.044899120926856995, 0.049149032682180405, 0.036846309900283813, -0.007863050326704979, -0.009879945777356625, 0.016246801242232323, -0.09638276696205139, -0.02505803480744362, -0.013411586172878742, -0.03487087041139603, -0.027406305074691772, 0.0010240470292046666, 0.044713109731674194, -0.06206804886460304, -0.04388806223869324, -0.007530760020017624, -0.02120228111743927, 0.022512439638376236, -0.023980746045708656, -0.04427976533770561, -0.02807188406586647, 0.004146742634475231, -0.02205245941877365, 0.04040306806564331, -0.012230735272169113, 0.009360534138977528, 0.01842949539422989, 0.05339024215936661, 0.02404951862990856, 0.04578031599521637, 0.054961033165454865, 0.02448871172964573, 0.04310782998800278, -0.01570030301809311, -0.07742521911859512, -0.0263893473893404, -0.048940509557724, 0.005717020016163588, 0.06124289333820343, -0.05495188757777214, -0.02622115984559059, 0.05380336567759514, -0.008594009093940258, -0.005968091078102589, -0.02070731110870838, 0.012893829494714737, -0.012195095419883728, 0.003831282025203109, -0.008867758326232433, 0.005870856810361147, 0.009913378395140171, 0.052335210144519806, -0.038378819823265076, -0.05623062700033188, 0.017597941681742668, -0.039821963757276535, -0.00028079072944819927, 0.004020671360194683, -0.020182831212878227, -0.022085770964622498, 0.010168022476136684, 0.00369163672439754, -0.021372882649302483, 0.029361257329583168, 0.020295774564146996, -0.042565569281578064, 0.021977877244353294, 0.03979983553290367, 0.02845107950270176, -0.00041194999357685447, 0.0027699738275259733, 0.001089839031919837, -0.02590751089155674, 0.030514154583215714, -0.03623756393790245, 0.048589516431093216, 0.032672714442014694, 0.024279121309518814, -0.0202330332249403, -0.016898753121495247, 0.007794544100761414, 0.0012362467823550105, 0.021827448159456253, 0.0116051584482193, -0.06370251625776291, 0.001483540516346693, -0.04991290345788002, 0.03257835656404495, -0.021061748266220093, 0.034938666969537735, -0.01637057401239872, -0.016889294609427452, -0.047800760716199875, 0.03477467969059944, 0.028715163469314575, -0.02627314068377018, -0.026385782286524773, 0.014957725070416927, 0.021215595304965973, -0.05263329669833183, -0.012128296308219433, 0.0284538883715868, 0.005453272257000208, -0.018028240650892258, -0.015126350335776806, -0.00961994007229805, -0.010262379422783852, -0.005044138990342617, 0.010938882827758789, -0.018878325819969177, 0.011754021048545837, -0.02091372199356556, 0.030255818739533424, 0.021260136738419533, -0.01338021457195282, 0.00980117917060852, 0.01949765346944332, 0.10840653628110886, -0.0180123932659626, 0.018427707254886627, -0.00031638043583370745, -0.025891341269016266, 0.033652450889348984, -0.026507951319217682, 0.01836298778653145, -0.02131308615207672, -0.040412597358226776, -0.039386846125125885, -0.06149988994002342, 0.00020289482199586928, 0.04483233019709587, 0.00038101166137494147, -0.05121893435716629, -0.0014207962667569518, -0.0026680463925004005, -0.04512426257133484, -0.01002854947000742, 0.03821076452732086, -0.07780087739229202, 0.025520045310258865, 0.04194444417953491, 0.0010795957641676068, 0.0343109592795372, -0.024325372651219368, -0.023263171315193176, -0.04195502772927284, -0.026953158900141716, 0.001299154362641275, 0.0004921468207612634, -0.03261774778366089, -0.014620210975408554, -0.019096415489912033, -0.00905507244169712, -0.0045696282759308815, -0.007028110790997744, -0.014607000164687634, -0.026542233303189278, 0.028481699526309967, 0.030070247128605843, -0.04313390702009201, 0.01189771294593811, 0.01201087050139904, -0.043267928063869476, 0.04601972550153732, -0.056378234177827835, 0.05463343486189842, 0.060887131839990616, 0.009874063543975353, 0.016007939353585243, -0.08668619394302368, 0.010101932100951672, -0.05911822244524956, 0.010577267035841942, -0.003943096846342087, -0.017722588032484055, -0.007877030409872532, 0.02540489286184311, -0.02592342719435692, 0.03742720186710358, 0.007298393175005913, -0.0010733883827924728, -0.036731619387865067, 0.03631620109081268, 0.009968695230782032, 0.06896428763866425, -0.03158401697874069, 0.03524041548371315, 0.050178442150354385, -0.04785919561982155, -0.020311901345849037, -0.05979190394282341, -0.0471426323056221, -0.006351499818265438, -0.018470920622348785, 0.021540163084864616, -0.0356295183300972, 0.038405124098062515, 0.02049737423658371, 0.03206825256347656, 0.010291804559528828, -0.03562524914741516, 0.05336669459939003, -0.045027364045381546, 0.005533425137400627, -0.06288579106330872, -0.017956621944904327, 0.05672808736562729, -0.022243326529860497, -0.003728316631168127, 0.022085856646299362, 0.001997377723455429, 0.007940398529171944, -0.007718522567301989, -0.040008895099163055, 0.0062830946408212185, -0.005322844255715609, -0.02383963018655777, 0.013254452496767044, -0.05488504469394684, -0.0052979737520217896, -0.0294501855969429, -0.03004623018205166, -0.005624300800263882, 0.036205705255270004, 0.059741634875535965, -0.012444387190043926, 0.03046276420354843, -0.021761983633041382, 0.0007318119751289487, 0.028275607153773308, 0.05392716825008392, 0.026501363143324852, 0.051108989864587784, -0.009380056522786617, 0.06738587468862534, 0.03581854701042175, 0.009335151873528957, 0.01473481860011816, 0.024263370782136917, -0.008325491100549698, -0.07000238448381424, 0.03455592691898346, -0.019630560651421547, -0.03539140895009041, -0.04654036834836006, 0.07879835367202759, 0.026633594185113907, -0.028845157474279404, -0.007057908456772566, 0.02693559043109417, -0.05646128207445145, 0.025289488956332207, -0.0007541680242866278, -0.01635228656232357, -0.01676934026181698, 0.0737578347325325, 0.006363365333527327, 0.02860243059694767, 0.0717390924692154, 0.0177061315625906, -0.022765258327126503, -0.029508162289857864, 0.06637796014547348, 0.07263839989900589, 0.0490947850048542, 0.0020114078652113676, 0.023999739438295364, -0.016934623941779137, -0.0579802542924881, -0.0014066954609006643, 0.023714987561106682, -0.023729357868433, -0.02820044755935669, 0.04585818201303482, 0.11721289902925491, -0.0170952919870615, 0.07491128146648407, -0.03564878925681114, -0.024172497913241386, 0.025275200605392456, 0.0013421945041045547, 0.0066155637614429, 0.08354825526475906, 0.04319968447089195, 0.02142011560499668, -0.020992135629057884, 0.0068138232454657555, -0.003027429338544607, -0.06171969324350357, -0.004305610898882151, 0.021879184991121292, -0.0011175699764862657, 0.0038416755851358175, -0.01608167588710785, 0.04862472787499428, 0.09931154549121857, -0.0046705580316483974, -0.019284451380372047, 0.0179462768137455, 0.06694576889276505, 0.053377795964479446, 0.01859661377966404, -0.019083987921476364, 0.00398362847045064, 0.003291427157819271, -0.006950258743017912, 0.015549979172647, 0.010471729561686516, 0.0002648260269779712, 0.050911180675029755, -0.04420433193445206, -0.06268905848264694, -0.026435350999236107, 0.0019832286052405834, -0.02836683578789234, -0.04428551718592644, -0.054446373134851456, -0.0399007573723793, -0.056019701063632965, -0.06527817249298096, 0.0027762269601225853, -0.02130219154059887, -0.04435225948691368, -0.005795366130769253, -0.032021041959524155, -0.009186689741909504, -0.0018141883192583919, -0.05610974505543709, 0.004436355549842119, 0.036438193172216415, 0.013286363333463669, -0.013287235982716084, 0.03258164972066879, 0.03890387341380119, 0.007809564471244812, -0.020117145031690598, 0.037662092596292496, 0.005706785712391138, 0.03631741553544998, 0.014532329514622688, 0.021005813032388687, -0.09176278114318848, 0.01853274181485176, 0.033024296164512634, -0.0030044433660805225, -0.09429669380187988, -0.00018387600721325725, -0.032054487615823746, 0.024113906547427177, 0.08322026580572128, 0.007931762374937534, 0.028218215331435204, -0.04308249428868294, 0.010010001249611378, 0.04034280776977539, 0.010400145314633846, 0.04952378198504448, -0.04015004262328148, 0.07701870054006577, 0.022695841267704964, -0.0027396446093916893, -0.003908969461917877, 0.03533734008669853, -0.02642117068171501, 0.000027562835384742357, -0.03658318892121315, -0.0354250930249691, 0.007516993675380945, -0.06134381517767906, -0.01647258922457695, 0.009151781909167767, 0.005594245623797178, -0.0307180043309927, 0.012289239093661308, -0.005585785955190659, -0.014553776010870934, -0.018471598625183105, -0.04454575851559639, 0.006814976688474417, -0.031664058566093445, -0.02785615250468254, -0.04274887964129448, 0.01195261999964714, -0.017992312088608742, 0.026736939325928688, -0.028229190036654472, -0.02890324778854847, -0.0001641691051190719, -0.008154293522238731, 0.05436453968286514, 0.006470935419201851, -0.010629480704665184, -0.0029055280610919 ]
3,509
IGL-Bench: Establishing the Comprehensive Benchmark for Imbalanced Graph Learning
https://openreview.net/forum?id=uTqnyF0JNR
[ "Jiawen Qin", "Haonan Yuan", "Qingyun Sun", "Lyujin Xu", "Jiaqi Yuan", "Pengfeng Huang", "Zhaonan Wang", "Xingcheng Fu", "Hao Peng", "Jianxin Li", "Philip S. Yu" ]
Spotlight
Deep graph learning has gained grand popularity over the past years due to its versatility and success in representing graph data across a wide range of domains. However, the pervasive issue of imbalanced graph data distributions, where certain parts exhibit disproportionally abundant data while others remain sparse, undermines the efficacy of conventional graph learning algorithms, leading to biased outcomes. To address this challenge, Imbalanced Graph Learning (IGL) has garnered substantial attention, enabling more balanced data distributions and better task performance. Despite the proliferation of IGL algorithms, the absence of consistent experimental protocols and fair performance comparisons pose a significant barrier to comprehending advancements in this field. To bridge this gap, we introduce **IGL-Bench**, a foundational comprehensive benchmark for imbalanced graph learning, embarking on **17** diverse graph datasets and **24** distinct IGL algorithms with uniform data processing and splitting strategies. Specifically, IGL-Bench systematically investigates state-of-the-art IGL algorithms in terms of **effectiveness**, **robustness**, and **efficiency** on node-level and graph-level tasks, with the scope of class-imbalance and topology-imbalance. Extensive experiments demonstrate the potential benefits of IGL algorithms on various imbalanced conditions, offering insights and opportunities in the IGL field. Further, we have developed an open-sourced and unified package to facilitate reproducible evaluation and inspire further innovative research, available at: https://github.com/RingBDStack/IGL-Bench.
imbalanced graph learning, graph class-imbalance, graph topology-imbalance, comprehensive benchmark
We establish the IGL-Bench, a foundational comprehensive benchmark for imbalanced graph learning, embarking on 17 diverse graph datasets and 24 distinct IGL algorithms with uniform data processing and splitting strategies.
6,858
null
[ -0.0003160882624797523, -0.023860270157456398, 0.03833141177892685, 0.027980225160717964, 0.001040391973219812, 0.0000030808391784376, 0.033967286348342896, 0.008760896511375904, 0.0009916092967614532, -0.04968191310763359, 0.037895169109106064, -0.044704046100378036, -0.08407440781593323, -0.006520895287394524, 0.009464635513722897, 0.04160797595977783, 0.0324089489877224, -0.0038264580070972443, -0.00026725014322437346, 0.01950663886964321, 0.017596593126654625, -0.03732733801007271, -0.004396660253405571, 0.013070137239992619, 0.024983739480376244, 0.004049640614539385, 0.028220126405358315, 0.02513987198472023, -0.019955554977059364, 0.013104278594255447, 0.0324767604470253, -0.019133709371089935, 0.013165575452148914, -0.03765321522951126, 0.0338258370757103, 0.012455068528652191, -0.04437825083732605, 0.01893739029765129, 0.007527232635766268, 0.00982598029077053, -0.027402907609939575, 0.04183567315340042, -0.018820861354470253, 0.03635299578309059, -0.05288257077336311, 0.04846273735165596, -0.12022587656974792, 0.0501495897769928, 0.022364098578691483, -0.0434468649327755, -0.10937130451202393, 0.023496977984905243, 0.036094654351472855, 0.0017742002382874489, -0.018508320674300194, 0.028810955584049225, 0.04873891547322273, -0.06333290040493011, 0.005318537820130587, -0.05968615412712097, -0.02045140415430069, 0.025221649557352066, 0.030886517837643623, 0.023362044245004654, 0.003886140650138259, -0.024667223915457726, -0.022303549572825432, 0.016901487484574318, -0.060866840183734894, -0.01829899661242962, -0.0013138530775904655, 0.002637165132910013, -0.013313708826899529, 0.027685584500432014, 0.0068455589935183525, -0.02929120883345604, -0.030986657366156578, 0.011602671816945076, 0.09198370575904846, -0.01146023441106081, -0.0007669563638046384, 0.02648361772298813, 0.00642298674210906, 0.028891660273075104, 0.00044084052206017077, 0.007488810922950506, -0.06448974460363388, -0.04746219888329506, -0.08777104318141937, 0.04070989415049553, -0.037991978228092194, -0.03923024237155914, 0.046062301844358444, 0.00978507474064827, 0.008423077873885632, -0.01610431633889675, 0.03280610591173172, 0.0026546986773610115, 0.04689241945743561, -0.016015710309147835, -0.009734501130878925, -0.0575740672647953, 0.013773593120276928, 0.033181313425302505, -0.11514919251203537, -0.030854979529976845, -0.03225916996598244, -0.01182340458035469, -0.021762676537036896, -0.014767573215067387, -0.0423961877822876, 0.019598137587308884, 0.01364186406135559, -0.011902955360710621, -0.06629244238138199, 0.036515023559331894, 0.01949729211628437, -0.0054471432231366634, -0.0022809759248048067, 0.012019953690469265, 0.029786763712763786, 0.07721809297800064, 0.01920611411333084, 0.07807090133428574, -0.007247282657772303, 0.0326942503452301, 0.005899239797145128, 0.00321094854734838, -0.03428460657596588, -0.01009997446089983, 0.01292540691792965, 0.04875889793038368, 0.0018628273392096162, -0.009903836995363235, 0.005033950787037611, -0.039485447108745575, 0.005470389500260353, 0.0003989085671491921, 0.028611604124307632, -0.030669428408145905, -0.0023660059086978436, -0.02387135662138462, 0.039515458047389984, -0.03365619108080864, 0.08346860855817795, -0.023562442511320114, -0.010025651194155216, -0.0167512446641922, -0.006835476495325565, -0.011368104256689548, 0.012242354452610016, 0.013570478186011314, -0.03800993412733078, -0.031858302652835846, 0.026591205969452858, 0.05892376974225044, 0.005713546648621559, 0.01845019869506359, 0.011254780925810337, 0.02072686143219471, 0.017928829416632652, 0.010148748755455017, -0.03502441942691803, -0.00930768996477127, -0.020762713626027107, -0.0589149110019207, 0.03893100842833519, 0.03292137384414673, -0.05971679836511612, 0.0060380627401173115, -0.02405637316405773, -0.06359466910362244, 0.05229804664850235, -0.020199647173285484, -0.02327614650130272, 0.007934021763503551, 0.055288851261138916, 0.004021559841930866, 0.012886141426861286, 0.03324529528617859, -0.08851898461580276, 0.024063056334853172, 0.023522915318608284, 0.013404586352407932, -0.03448052331805229, 0.023551620543003082, 0.07096317410469055, -0.023636318743228912, 0.02130792662501335, 0.024197040125727654, -0.09252005815505981, 0.006229167804121971, 0.04730284959077835, 0.008971587754786015, 0.07224006205797195, 0.008686104789376259, -0.0019720986019819975, -0.01939828135073185, 0.006471490487456322, 0.04731186479330063, 0.0353773832321167, -0.02582089975476265, 0.04482410103082657, -0.01544640026986599, -0.054285600781440735, 0.001849177642725408, 0.022909868508577347, -0.03490947186946869, -0.07048831880092621, -0.008349337615072727, 0.0029615224339067936, -0.026051921769976616, 0.007531335577368736, 0.009305198676884174, -0.0023874572943896055, 0.0014720583567395806, -0.015586849302053452, 0.013342968188226223, 0.023282017558813095, -0.0052153728902339935, 0.05162837356328964, 0.02986997365951538, -0.0179921742528677, -0.00944680068641901, -0.022811805829405785, 0.07186783105134964, 0.025006461888551712, -0.022271275520324707, 0.009054029360413551, 0.03310088440775871, 0.02162173204123974, 0.02521440200507641, 0.00942570623010397, -0.04155953601002693, -0.03647284954786301, -0.01765238121151924, 0.006421271245926619, -0.03597830608487129, 0.07415894418954849, -0.038513731211423874, -0.0036046800669282675, 0.030774880200624466, -0.023298436775803566, 0.06669367104768753, 0.018447265028953552, -0.0014262389158830047, 0.018247492611408234, -0.008106691762804985, -0.02540995180606842, -0.04166443273425102, 0.009201491251587868, 0.017813483253121376, -0.012177538126707077, -0.010043737478554249, 0.011401509866118431, -0.05610746517777443, 0.04203617945313454, -0.0042858123779296875, 0.05758070573210716, 0.07650058716535568, 0.031126871705055237, 0.01329421903938055, -0.01360984519124031, -0.0427556112408638, -0.022518334910273552, -0.12658508121967316, -0.04519730806350708, -0.010114310309290886, 0.05631734058260918, -0.004839164670556784, 0.06673864275217056, -0.006370938383042812, 0.009122478775680065, -0.008227929472923279, -0.023385634645819664, -0.0006169581320136786, 0.014675418846309185, -0.0038724923506379128, -0.056145988404750824, -0.020761093124747276, 0.007232910953462124, 0.05291462689638138, 0.000031192055757855996, 0.00887370016425848, -0.05196814984083176, -0.04080743342638016, 0.009038086049258709, -0.029041100293397903, -0.020669467747211456, 0.016892993822693825, 0.05902000516653061, 0.06283006072044373, -0.013540045358240604, -0.02169918641448021, 0.03919088840484619, 0.07959900051355362, 0.043535783886909485, -0.01845722645521164, -0.03162093833088875, 0.036053527146577835, 0.02329185977578163, 0.025138823315501213, -0.013442453928291798, 0.009874546900391579, -0.013588814996182919, 0.0010467120446264744, 0.03697819635272026, -0.003114077728241682, -0.2661711871623993, -0.016788629814982414, 0.01477646641433239, -0.015898579731583595, 0.010110977105796337, -0.04464923217892647, 0.03848159685730934, 0.004064108710736036, -0.03497181832790375, -0.0028842396568506956, -0.0008955967496149242, 0.01614382117986679, 0.0034404455218464136, 0.010809150524437428, 0.042223427444696426, 0.056739430874586105, 0.021461941301822662, -0.036324456334114075, 0.009945709258317947, 0.03556098788976669, -0.022654308006167412, -0.0972859337925911, -0.030658796429634094, 0.03095947578549385, -0.032278966158628464, 0.02638290636241436, -0.07829629629850388, -0.02045121230185032, -0.03481096029281616, -0.001961205620318651, 0.02144092135131359, -0.0011193945538252592, -0.01558729074895382, 0.01961699314415455, 0.01990068517625332, -0.0069261109456419945, 0.02962571009993553, -0.009694608859717846, 0.015789806842803955, 0.0402100645005703, 0.0011879021767526865, 0.0027000021655112505, -0.04016359522938728, 0.015219390392303467, 0.09307289868593216, 0.025782661512494087, -0.05745798349380493, -0.02979140542447567, -0.020321914926171303, 0.032716553658246994, -0.0003713931073434651, -0.015742653980851173, -0.017537809908390045, 0.002181318122893572, -0.030633535236120224, -0.031331293284893036, -0.012502970173954964, 0.012669513933360577, -0.030409762635827065, -0.005813309922814369, 0.0016497911419719458, -0.024709826335310936, -0.0036490801721811295, -0.008069376461207867, -0.021142829209566116, -0.05464783310890198, -0.06828498840332031, -0.06514205783605576, -0.0096164895221591, 0.03151959925889969, 0.021940074861049652, 0.03939541429281235, -0.016806958243250847, -0.08457545936107635, 0.019466673955321312, -0.006719251163303852, -0.003172503085806966, -0.005352826789021492, 0.014241637662053108, 0.04683511704206467, -0.02167474292218685, -0.04380403459072113, -0.0030963397584855556, 0.022785134613513947, 0.01952548697590828, -0.016674064099788666, 0.000004342864940554136, -0.01466944720596075, 0.008230019360780716, -0.008478822186589241, 0.02727051079273224, -0.001579795847646892, 0.04326033964753151, 0.017412368208169937, 0.017347170040011406, 0.03832481801509857, 0.031962212175130844, 0.04731263592839241, 0.040642738342285156, 0.048727478832006454, 0.0491136871278286, -0.08372008800506592, -0.024477973580360413, -0.02784508652985096, -0.044592682272195816, 0.02404099330306053, -0.05359506234526634, 0.0006388681358657777, 0.06720182299613953, -0.023364555090665817, -0.03431588038802147, -0.05902814865112305, 0.04507121071219444, -0.027276504784822464, -0.0006918022409081459, -0.026154380291700363, 0.0000517779917572625, 0.027810504660010338, 0.017956232652068138, -0.009508883580565453, -0.02730255387723446, 0.03827644884586334, -0.006356359925121069, 0.0072411601431667805, -0.02689509652554989, -0.01673843525350094, 0.009442023932933807, 0.008819954469799995, 0.0016469631809741259, 0.015462195500731468, 0.025571085512638092, 0.07040838897228241, 0.004667220637202263, -0.0018372646300122142, 0.023119613528251648, 0.014832617715001106, -0.0136989401653409, -0.03020654059946537, 0.04676893353462219, -0.013632425107061863, 0.04597768932580948, 0.008089213632047176, 0.039636608213186264, 0.011864948086440563, 0.0435422845184803, 0.04388635605573654, 0.021469471976161003, 0.010540492832660675, -0.004972771275788546, 0.02802443318068981, 0.007552985101938248, -0.03672603890299797, -0.022105593234300613, -0.04388132691383362, 0.04348861426115036, 0.028319435194134712, 0.02387252077460289, 0.004531922750174999, -0.004599912092089653, -0.07210852950811386, 0.055371321737766266, -0.013541425578296185, -0.00962618738412857, -0.018054112792015076, 0.005406868644058704, 0.03831743821501732, 0.01680934615433216, -0.01594061218202114, 0.0031959826592355967, -0.010808167979121208, -0.007236584555357695, -0.0006673386669717729, -0.03633483126759529, -0.014119267463684082, -0.022586753591895103, 0.022050751373171806, -0.00882161408662796, 0.005224555730819702, 0.00999006163328886, 0.04418284446001053, -0.030577801167964935, -0.02138875052332878, 0.0003763825516216457, -0.011883878149092197, 0.09012021869421005, 0.01593947596848011, -0.006369082257151604, -0.002467772923409939, -0.012290715239942074, 0.058073680847883224, 0.027404285967350006, 0.005469087511301041, -0.011626382358372211, -0.03063369356095791, -0.01174878515303135, -0.04718482866883278, 0.021774543449282646, 0.0026682631578296423, -0.049912966787815094, -0.07903686910867691, -0.02429783344268799, 0.021282942965626717, -0.039593663066625595, -0.006081434898078442, 0.04063054919242859, -0.079695925116539, -0.023243118077516556, 0.03757992014288902, -0.030595971271395683, 0.05784023925662041, -0.025894559919834137, -0.04789397493004799, -0.04450446739792824, -0.025780269876122475, 0.03099403902888298, 0.004525022581219673, 0.00594544131308794, -0.014724873006343842, -0.02603979967534542, -0.0012425996828824282, -0.017207525670528412, 0.009499176405370235, 0.010365210473537445, -0.0211061742156744, 0.006752105429768562, 0.05519561097025871, -0.01280636340379715, -0.020870141685009003, -0.01716088317334652, -0.008537501096725464, 0.01143058855086565, -0.02266460843384266, 0.04213741794228554, 0.0517486147582531, -0.018268821761012077, 0.0435585118830204, -0.04983145743608475, 0.03348242864012718, 0.0340808629989624, -0.031052492558956146, -0.008580449968576431, -0.012313970364630222, -0.03583088144659996, 0.00393044063821435, 0.012458479031920433, -0.01731039583683014, 0.026782136410474777, 0.013926401734352112, 0.0066963802091777325, -0.019810182973742485, 0.03256935253739357, -0.012859167531132698, -0.02915162406861782, -0.025009339675307274, 0.06387263536453247, -0.060007527470588684, -0.01763082668185234, -0.08012846112251282, -0.026883667334914207, -0.0074839405715465546, -0.054215800017118454, -0.0024957568384706974, 0.018608108162879944, 0.04860527440905571, 0.0294394101947546, 0.03232791647315025, 0.00030008135945536196, -0.04687374830245972, 0.020113864913582802, -0.03198466822504997, 0.025022292509675026, -0.05468923971056938, -0.026554321870207787, 0.021891213953495026, -0.03107023984193802, 0.0006458290154114366, 0.015894891694188118, -0.01229764986783266, 0.01341727189719677, -0.03458789363503456, -0.06449936330318451, -0.0029450207948684692, -0.015284317545592785, 0.009913155809044838, 0.025643352419137955, -0.009686053730547428, -0.032484475523233414, -0.00811732653528452, -0.03689606860280037, -0.026633938774466515, -0.01220976933836937, 0.040132179856300354, -0.04624118655920029, 0.0255646463483572, -0.03105081245303154, 0.0009773961501196027, 0.0421738475561142, 0.03795592114329338, 0.010653257369995117, 0.034539297223091125, -0.02889104373753071, 0.06239291653037071, 0.04025169089436531, -0.022328225895762444, 0.014515225775539875, 0.04320336505770683, -0.013705595396459103, -0.038776740431785583, 0.06630270928144455, -0.008721272461116314, -0.0290767140686512, -0.06767185032367706, 0.059641268104314804, 0.0009477263665758073, -0.05665203183889389, -0.026743575930595398, 0.027515284717082977, -0.02374309115111828, 0.025803467258810997, 0.01208847388625145, 0.015486963093280792, -0.005760231055319309, 0.07448941469192505, 0.009769274853169918, 0.04990823566913605, 0.050280045717954636, 0.0382852666079998, -0.0022201475221663713, -0.019631069153547287, 0.08427833020687103, 0.0665297582745552, 0.023914676159620285, -0.012827706523239613, 0.09786916524171829, -0.0311764907091856, -0.03789987042546272, 0.010379464365541935, 0.019309213384985924, -0.02043095976114273, -0.035045769065618515, -0.0029920206870883703, 0.08904003351926804, -0.01224745437502861, 0.06588079780340195, -0.06221171095967293, -0.009328394196927547, 0.042635634541511536, 0.013996526598930359, 0.015394898131489754, 0.0895380899310112, 0.0038573103956878185, 0.034309424459934235, -0.020695040002465248, -0.0062932949513196945, -0.014023571275174618, -0.017750533297657967, 0.037886641919612885, 0.018191635608673096, -0.02584897167980671, -0.009058325551450253, 0.014610644429922104, 0.004558474291115999, 0.09284918010234833, -0.025152849033474922, -0.061384208500385284, -0.0006716888165101409, 0.014102029614150524, 0.024079298600554466, 0.03179685026407242, 0.011804979294538498, -0.0661291554570198, -0.0217280276119709, -0.05833131819963455, -0.008503476157784462, -0.018791187554597855, -0.005060939583927393, 0.020922034978866577, -0.041765205562114716, -0.0016139728249982, 0.04697020724415779, 0.004288504831492901, -0.002650768728926778, -0.06388895958662033, -0.01825232245028019, -0.04133645445108414, -0.04911365360021591, -0.05529869720339775, 0.0022417569998651743, 0.012339954264461994, -0.0063258749432861805, -0.010983322747051716, -0.004579091444611549, -0.005014543887227774, 0.03149460628628731, -0.05998337268829346, -0.01655753329396248, 0.02064625360071659, -0.0003275586059316993, -0.006399077363312244, 0.03649298846721649, 0.012768168933689594, -0.04709801450371742, -0.002339521422982216, 0.04909146577119827, 0.026146752759814262, 0.024906763806939125, -0.01712278462946415, -0.022642361000180244, -0.11417977511882782, -0.02381303906440735, 0.0035498742945492268, -0.051609110087156296, -0.09302522242069244, 0.0201529823243618, 0.0020236726850271225, 0.03269477188587189, 0.05619638040661812, 0.008014892227947712, -0.0220189206302166, -0.022254137322306633, 0.00865908619016409, -0.007995144464075565, -0.040101293474435806, 0.03705517575144768, -0.02991294488310814, 0.08280712366104126, 0.019427001476287842, -0.030004050582647324, -0.016575291752815247, 0.016493666917085648, -0.000052024010074092075, -0.03770000860095024, -0.0365031398832798, -0.00028887350345030427, 0.00022473932767752558, -0.08981376141309738, 0.016815317794680595, -0.01922597922384739, -0.0007609286694787443, -0.026494553312659264, -0.017990341410040855, -0.025614634156227112, -0.029921317473053932, 0.004849373362958431, -0.01590433344244957, 0.00785866193473339, -0.004000321961939335, -0.016116606071591377, -0.08118697255849838, 0.01462322287261486, -0.039119839668273926, 0.047172099351882935, -0.01788194477558136, -0.046655237674713135, 0.015623904764652252, -0.007837306708097458, 0.04000996798276901, 0.017197834327816963, 0.02658211439847946, 0.006607492920011282 ]
3,510
Learning Equivariant Non-Local Electron Density Functionals
https://openreview.net/forum?id=FhBT596F1X
[ "Nicholas Gao", "Eike Eberhard", "Stephan Günnemann" ]
Spotlight
The accuracy of density functional theory hinges on the approximation of non-local contributions to the exchange-correlation (XC) functional. To date, machine-learned and human-designed approximations suffer from insufficient accuracy, limited scalability, or dependence on costly reference data. To address these issues, we introduce Equivariant Graph Exchange Correlation (EG-XC), a novel non-local XC functional based on equivariant graph neural networks (GNNs). Where previous works relied on semi-local functionals or fixed-size descriptors of the density, we compress the electron density into an SO(3)-equivariant nuclei-centered point cloud for efficient non-local atomic-range interactions. By applying an equivariant GNN on this point cloud, we capture molecular-range interactions in a scalable and accurate manner. To train EG-XC, we differentiate through a self-consistent field solver requiring only energy targets. In our empirical evaluation, we find EG-XC to accurately reconstruct `gold-standard' CCSD(T) energies on MD17. On out-of-distribution conformations of 3BPA, EG-XC reduces the relative MAE by 35% to 50%. Remarkably, EG-XC excels in data efficiency and molecular size extrapolation on QM9, matching force fields trained on 5 times more and larger molecules. On identical training sets, EG-XC yields on average 51% lower MAEs.
Density Functional Theory, DFT, Functional, Exchange Correlation, XC, Equivariance, Graph Neural Network, Electron Density, Kohn-Sham DFT
We propose an equivariant graph neural network-driven exchange correlation functional for Kohn-Sham DFT.
6,847
2410.07972
[ 0.006219087168574333, 0.008564496412873268, -0.006904757581651211, 0.06905481219291687, 0.04027178883552551, 0.0005590669461525977, -0.010030251927673817, 0.011115454137325287, 0.012869325466454029, -0.04707085341215134, 0.027642954140901566, 0.005436575040221214, -0.06146378070116043, -0.00028048353851772845, 0.044606175273656845, 0.05102720111608505, 0.04575539752840996, 0.03743937984108925, -0.00124140246771276, 0.01207214966416359, -0.004214089829474688, 0.00417490815743804, 0.04568300023674965, 0.02672022208571434, 0.037606969475746155, 0.002333762589842081, 0.02532927878201008, -0.022083070129156113, -0.00791402067989111, -0.006776162423193455, 0.019569389522075653, 0.035288624465465546, -0.0020983011927455664, -0.031181776896119118, 0.0031837797723710537, 0.018768874928355217, -0.06536652147769928, -0.00628071092069149, 0.020289840176701546, 0.029155777767300606, -0.056333284825086594, 0.002312652301043272, 0.010677180252969265, 0.038248416036367416, -0.04456518962979317, 0.03677178546786308, -0.09389230608940125, 0.04466037452220917, -0.0071103512309491634, -0.050327118486166, -0.06962945312261581, 0.0314183309674263, 0.019417816773056984, -0.02417500875890255, -0.004177096765488386, 0.042173080146312714, 0.009977229870855808, -0.03910207003355026, -0.02851182594895363, -0.03825603798031807, -0.038150276988744736, 0.03914666175842285, 0.0010957375634461641, 0.032911788672208786, 0.01626548357307911, -0.0010098525090143085, 0.03402728959918022, 0.032037314027547836, -0.0767384022474289, -0.037064749747514725, -0.013724805787205696, 0.0013526505790650845, 0.0027693139854818583, -0.016970491036772728, -0.0024687719997018576, -0.0016977253835648298, 0.011777272447943687, -0.018178647384047508, 0.06526640802621841, 0.049491461366415024, 0.02483902871608734, 0.03671117126941681, -0.00033357046777382493, 0.0354023240506649, -0.016665644943714142, 0.004221050534397364, -0.06923040747642517, -0.005220375489443541, -0.09316673874855042, 0.05767951160669327, -0.014551613479852676, -0.04204413667321205, 0.02431456558406353, 0.042003076523542404, 0.03560810536146164, -0.027341283857822418, 0.04731205478310585, -0.00451025040820241, 0.04531152546405792, -0.030007703229784966, -0.03166664391756058, -0.027219269424676895, -0.01799737848341465, -0.024488680064678192, -0.08438850939273834, -0.026953022927045822, -0.062448300421237946, -0.03830799460411072, -0.031011326238512993, -0.01628279499709606, -0.048273246735334396, 0.00818868912756443, 0.010362817905843258, -0.009600427933037281, -0.07238977402448654, 0.008151140995323658, 0.01859225146472454, 0.02150285243988037, -0.000288176815956831, 0.026025250554084778, 0.036092694848775864, 0.09945512562990189, 0.009280419908463955, 0.07434118539094925, 0.03533017262816429, 0.04071402549743652, -0.006123961415141821, 0.014544199220836163, -0.0360136516392231, -0.019801082089543343, 0.025676503777503967, 0.029476840049028397, 0.0033872011117637157, 0.004548419266939163, 0.0047848764806985855, -0.03625157102942467, -0.020513014867901802, 0.008669956587255001, 0.0530036985874176, -0.017512770369648933, -0.0020348711404949427, -0.05642094835639, 0.05651385709643364, -0.003915238659828901, 0.07302375137805939, -0.013554884120821953, -0.026837311685085297, -0.04334907978773117, 0.008255809545516968, 0.036432161927223206, 0.033017124980688095, -0.01147009152919054, -0.007952007465064526, -0.0308541152626276, 0.016249803826212883, 0.03809312731027603, 0.007586274296045303, 0.024085575714707375, 0.0013346030609682202, -0.022033514454960823, 0.007519375067204237, 0.002889215247705579, -0.008042069151997566, 0.03926651179790497, 0.0013520534848794341, -0.025514710694551468, 0.00825144536793232, 0.04911705479025841, -0.054170411080121994, -0.004078634548932314, -0.008875151164829731, -0.07261615246534348, 0.061625972390174866, -0.030561525374650955, -0.01304772961884737, 0.011857942678034306, 0.02814408764243126, -0.008209015242755413, -0.0015350135508924723, 0.01663517951965332, -0.08278830349445343, 0.019114570692181587, 0.0493333674967289, -0.04682474583387375, -0.016300786286592484, 0.013890468515455723, 0.06436299532651901, 0.00674783531576395, 0.007066728081554174, 0.01554052159190178, -0.06610585004091263, -0.002180451061576605, 0.044716063886880875, -0.025582946836948395, 0.08200863748788834, -0.038067471235990524, -0.006191782653331757, 0.0010546030243858695, 0.003012420842424035, 0.004898416809737682, 0.0032753474079072475, -0.013010603375732899, 0.03579144552350044, 0.005277091637253761, -0.04687414690852165, -0.018693478778004646, 0.05234882980585098, -0.03299407660961151, -0.03589656576514244, 0.014226839877665043, -0.0031503483187407255, -0.007087917998433113, 0.010688968002796173, -0.013670243322849274, -0.0284856166690588, 0.0032282609026879072, -0.021257897838950157, 0.002969942754134536, -0.018574833869934082, 0.007920798845589161, 0.03990889713168144, 0.016733067110180855, -0.021218644455075264, -0.017082033678889275, -0.014597735367715359, 0.11884555220603943, 0.08001355081796646, -0.056380745023489, -0.0036718430928885937, 0.04111099988222122, 0.014145712368190289, -0.015907207503914833, 0.024670803919434547, -0.03206796199083328, 0.025573302060365677, -0.05360513925552368, 0.012445233762264252, 0.0217540692538023, 0.042998578399419785, -0.04529270902276039, -0.005863745231181383, 0.06582388281822205, -0.03547990694642067, 0.04252522066235542, -0.016879623755812645, -0.009661693125963211, 0.06603690981864929, -0.03569547459483147, -0.0550532303750515, -0.026532268151640892, -0.036377739161252975, 0.000983647769317031, -0.012380325235426426, 0.009869655594229698, 0.053244177252054214, -0.06977057456970215, -0.011752252466976643, 0.00641275430098176, 0.06678452342748642, 0.041718803346157074, 0.02647543139755726, -0.00843772292137146, 0.010727890767157078, 0.007029789034277201, -0.019999485462903976, -0.12254998832941055, -0.06655397266149521, 0.003784238826483488, 0.04601483792066574, 0.011947336606681347, 0.04246843606233597, 0.01058496255427599, 0.005025345832109451, -0.021426398307085037, -0.036321528255939484, 0.0003444167086854577, -0.015565375797450542, 0.017206786200404167, -0.040322959423065186, -0.017913512885570526, 0.017342403531074524, 0.0739930123090744, -0.00665459968149662, -0.030039221048355103, -0.034458596259355545, -0.035451021045446396, 0.0015502473106607795, -0.043258074671030045, -0.018349459394812584, -0.0006174604059197009, 0.04822409152984619, -0.006224832031875849, -0.025073541328310966, 0.03841690346598625, 0.04918700456619263, 0.031303130090236664, 0.04128023609519005, 0.030905483290553093, -0.00378711917437613, 0.03451043739914894, 0.010961426421999931, 0.027431556954979897, -0.03991461172699928, 0.008099581114947796, 0.004187974613159895, -0.01972571574151516, -0.0054222107864916325, 0.012515491805970669, -0.2550731897354126, -0.007452420424669981, 0.002967617241665721, 0.027652336284518242, 0.034622859209775925, -0.022855129092931747, 0.02227514050900936, -0.03817584365606308, -0.021960947662591934, -0.004432735964655876, -0.01033612061291933, 0.051924388855695724, -0.006984188687056303, 0.026379048824310303, 0.042666755616664886, 0.03023185022175312, 0.03308624029159546, -0.03329091891646385, 0.01231435313820839, 0.021656343713402748, -0.022402210161089897, -0.042568713426589966, -0.0323408804833889, 0.001749620190821588, -0.004225181415677071, 0.01695135235786438, -0.08498869091272354, 0.0002979713899549097, -0.04289117828011513, 0.007346795406192541, -0.05043645575642586, 0.006961350794881582, 0.007955755107104778, 0.011233494617044926, 0.03766237944364548, 0.03261270374059677, -0.008098338730633259, -0.06202634051442146, -0.02435033768415451, 0.0018144354689866304, -0.024326514452695847, 0.01870656944811344, -0.028991451486945152, 0.045332394540309906, 0.0635693147778511, 0.015046547167003155, 0.0071091256104409695, 0.01231309026479721, -0.0017944747814908624, 0.04769948497414589, -0.03688612952828407, -0.04378649592399597, 0.03026026114821434, -0.009162801317870617, -0.013201041147112846, -0.006207363214343786, -0.04820040240883827, 0.03418700397014618, -0.01151715125888586, 0.00366319646127522, 0.03402118757367134, -0.032323747873306274, -0.00623789057135582, -0.013648595660924911, -0.044338516891002655, -0.057953525334596634, -0.07756359130144119, -0.08875775337219238, 0.058680735528469086, 0.058551426976919174, -0.030794726684689522, 0.004667998291552067, -0.053221043199300766, -0.07529278844594955, 0.029185190796852112, -0.007871265523135662, -0.020338501781225204, -0.03007790632545948, 0.027506954967975616, 0.026191353797912598, -0.03834008052945137, -0.0004316149861551821, 0.014292134903371334, 0.04224244877696037, 0.013219956308603287, -0.012817186303436756, -0.009303816594183445, -0.015438060276210308, -0.04647720977663994, 0.007836082018911839, 0.05060487613081932, -0.016180917620658875, 0.045374397188425064, -0.009803413413465023, 0.033119454979896545, 0.012399363331496716, 0.008706890977919102, 0.0057344138622283936, 0.03845156356692314, 0.03410226106643677, 0.04223327711224556, -0.05093253776431084, -0.003977387212216854, -0.050811827182769775, -0.049693137407302856, 0.0032950027380138636, -0.04770030826330185, -0.031985994428396225, 0.03130466863512993, 0.023970168083906174, -0.022245533764362335, -0.009631015360355377, 0.008090339601039886, 0.0287827979773283, -0.02554878406226635, -0.02175908535718918, 0.005874961148947477, 0.010259810835123062, 0.03342817351222038, -0.03898419067263603, 0.00005131875514052808, 0.03139520809054375, -0.02837345190346241, -0.007469561416655779, -0.04081564396619797, -0.007585389539599419, -0.004047902766615152, -0.004108665511012077, -0.013485045172274113, 0.02355005405843258, -0.0007794522098265588, 0.05477326363325119, -0.007192668970674276, 0.025076141580939293, 0.05784191936254501, 0.004097648896276951, -0.0089170066639781, -0.014913554303348064, 0.02317943051457405, -0.04997681453824043, 0.033235687762498856, -0.008692926727235317, 0.02233908325433731, 0.027006538584828377, 0.06226544827222824, 0.029178988188505173, 0.029053349047899246, 0.03725667670369148, -0.012410014867782593, 0.004438138101249933, 0.04039734601974487, -0.028456805273890495, -0.00000980727327259956, 0.0033065727911889553, -0.023614414036273956, -0.010015375912189484, 0.03584195300936699, -0.025153977796435356, 0.03601239621639252, -0.05774778872728348, 0.06150493770837784, -0.018622074276208878, -0.01466826070100069, -0.010133284144103527, 0.016451602801680565, 0.04977964982390404, -0.006055756006389856, 0.0359472818672657, -0.022700242698192596, 0.00540749728679657, -0.0011144252493977547, -0.016093997284770012, -0.024328688159585, -0.014235986396670341, -0.03755376115441322, 0.0421195849776268, -0.016994258388876915, -0.005249010398983955, 0.0077248807065188885, -0.010904553346335888, 0.023121649399399757, -0.003917694091796875, 0.008338003419339657, 0.011358608491718769, 0.06563723087310791, -0.046565067023038864, -0.03014477528631687, -0.011102331802248955, -0.012447800487279892, 0.019961021840572357, 0.03294933959841728, 0.0031141957733780146, -0.054181698709726334, -0.017048686742782593, -0.009772973135113716, -0.03364924341440201, -0.019919801503419876, 0.01425011083483696, -0.03970622271299362, 0.029225610196590424, 0.018473559990525246, 0.030014559626579285, -0.07227568328380585, 0.008269619196653366, 0.04214463755488396, -0.04643983021378517, 0.009264037944376469, 0.029336053878068924, 0.02348155714571476, -0.008805247023701668, -0.03417154401540756, -0.07440333068370819, -0.08203696459531784, -0.000524153292644769, 0.025226859375834465, 0.013601796701550484, 0.024464691057801247, -0.011605242267251015, -0.03083978407084942, -0.020796913653612137, -0.016056524589657784, 0.034286875277757645, 0.009533360600471497, -0.04276849702000618, 0.021398773416876793, 0.06646578013896942, 0.01247953251004219, 0.03391437605023384, 0.019872229546308517, -0.03204438090324402, -0.018734972923994064, -0.038087960332632065, 0.022632448002696037, 0.043829772621393204, 0.017446700483560562, 0.017805643379688263, -0.05973805859684944, 0.03506633639335632, 0.006673476658761501, -0.027425341308116913, -0.007595169823616743, -0.019371461123228073, -0.04357589781284332, 0.004624284338206053, -0.019628699868917465, 0.006684665102511644, 0.03978492319583893, 0.023645246401429176, -0.021459946408867836, 0.00774180656298995, 0.010714596137404442, -0.03680851683020592, -0.03691104054450989, -0.009288939647376537, 0.051862932741642, -0.0006701703532598913, -0.055164895951747894, -0.05217447131872177, 0.010401309467852116, 0.00033288219128735363, -0.01773010939359665, 0.01565292291343212, -0.05473095923662186, 0.051896754652261734, 0.014961041510105133, 0.021102096885442734, -0.002019550884142518, -0.07483597099781036, 0.045988719910383224, -0.046138253062963486, -0.014074104838073254, -0.04606424644589424, -0.022410649806261063, 0.04803226515650749, -0.012554208748042583, -0.026781832799315453, -0.026792215183377266, -0.05100320652127266, 0.00887676514685154, -0.013312037102878094, -0.06723455339670181, 0.01715506799519062, 0.021909836679697037, -0.0005670922691933811, 0.058351460844278336, -0.03598159924149513, -0.06141669303178787, -0.03425895795226097, -0.06105006858706474, -0.022272836416959763, 0.017704322934150696, 0.04057682678103447, -0.0077492790296673775, -0.011814545840024948, -0.015408062376081944, 0.039064858108758926, 0.021443478763103485, 0.0577545091509819, 0.0014653027756139636, 0.027870357036590576, -0.029747776687145233, 0.0838179886341095, 0.05460586026310921, -0.023231321945786476, 0.020114149898290634, 0.01139381155371666, -0.001430713920854032, -0.032934367656707764, 0.0397697389125824, -0.0033666924573481083, -0.010060413740575314, -0.06655050069093704, 0.03989686816930771, 0.022535888478159904, -0.06862803548574448, -0.0052879201248288155, 0.03510773926973343, -0.031107187271118164, -0.00836305320262909, -0.008576816879212856, 0.004231608472764492, 0.0010173408081755042, 0.06358573585748672, -0.0226986575871706, 0.058015380054712296, 0.067919060587883, 0.036487970501184464, 0.014733865857124329, -0.05420193076133728, 0.09119809418916702, 0.07392697036266327, 0.014485308900475502, 0.02024742029607296, 0.05796302855014801, -0.023146608844399452, -0.033476416021585464, -0.018869929015636444, 0.031622692942619324, -0.03530304878950119, -0.024510610848665237, 0.00026860166690312326, 0.10686412453651428, 0.02894056774675846, 0.06884055584669113, -0.028994739055633545, -0.04334541782736778, 0.0025287189055234194, 0.0017111727502197027, 0.014693657867610455, 0.018690217286348343, -0.004105743952095509, 0.02784213423728943, -0.04502219706773758, -0.018285313621163368, -0.03815925866365433, -0.006396710406988859, 0.02958204224705696, -0.011871065944433212, -0.01811295747756958, 0.022524654865264893, -0.012020094320178032, 0.02176058664917946, 0.09279962629079819, -0.00685863895341754, -0.0323157012462616, 0.013933845795691013, 0.005558214616030455, -0.007848450914025307, 0.030450891703367233, 0.0015235786559060216, 0.010790330357849598, 0.0019507904071360826, -0.029826492071151733, 0.01702112704515457, -0.002173502929508686, -0.027372973039746284, 0.0021280383225530386, -0.008473812602460384, -0.02507951855659485, 0.006238201633095741, 0.013289649970829487, -0.054875001311302185, -0.08372440189123154, -0.015694525092840195, -0.02509845234453678, -0.06066476181149483, -0.07750055193901062, 0.03775976225733757, -0.022440094500780106, -0.02559630572795868, 0.039364952594041824, -0.03197777271270752, 0.014921223744750023, 0.020232010632753372, -0.060102805495262146, -0.027430947870016098, 0.06156187132000923, 0.007953964173793793, -0.012455279007554054, 0.015521792694926262, 0.020058216527104378, -0.04429524764418602, -0.024599147960543633, 0.07104477286338806, 0.010303054004907608, 0.046367473900318146, -0.00012020445865346119, 0.016448229551315308, -0.0962429791688919, 0.04369892179965973, 0.038698483258485794, -0.0620979368686676, -0.08935075253248215, 0.02639930136501789, -0.00754183903336525, 0.016920344904065132, 0.044086288660764694, 0.026504134759306908, -0.006219291593879461, -0.020743750035762787, 0.010840002447366714, 0.03385071083903313, -0.0032464778050780296, 0.06168188899755478, -0.040779806673526764, 0.08592984825372696, -0.0003912770771421492, -0.0022301599383354187, -0.029116319492459297, 0.005643355194479227, 0.014310778118669987, -0.008972146548330784, -0.04190286993980408, -0.009710847400128841, -0.039363961666822433, -0.08485201746225357, -0.010365665890276432, -0.010724253952503204, -0.024265078827738762, -0.02160302735865116, -0.04261886700987816, 0.04374482110142708, -0.007321805227547884, 0.000885463145095855, -0.020093824714422226, -0.02351929061114788, -0.029805833473801613, -0.04010417312383652, -0.030154284089803696, -0.002131712855771184, 0.001942856702953577, -0.0076038893312215805, -0.04160649701952934, -0.035065095871686935, -0.007916431874036789, -0.05582400783896446, 0.02641431801021099, 0.020517118275165558, 0.04651191085577011, 0.014449821785092354 ]
3,511
PaRa: Personalizing Text-to-Image Diffusion via Parameter Rank Reduction
https://openreview.net/forum?id=KZgo2YQbhc
[ "Shangyu Chen", "Zizheng Pan", "Jianfei Cai", "Dinh Phung" ]
Spotlight
Personalizing a large-scale pretrained Text-to-Image (T2I) diffusion model is chal- lenging as it typically struggles to make an appropriate trade-off between its training data distribution and the target distribution, i.e., learning a novel concept with only a few target images to achieve personalization (aligning with the personalized target) while preserving text editability (aligning with diverse text prompts). In this paper, we propose PaRa, an effective and efficient Parameter Rank Reduction approach for T2I model personalization by explicitly controlling the rank of the diffusion model parameters to restrict its initial diverse generation space into a small and well-balanced target space. Our design is motivated by the fact that taming a T2I model toward a novel concept such as a specific art style implies a small generation space. To this end, by reducing the rank of model parameters during finetuning, we can effectively constrain the space of the denoising sampling trajectories towards the target. With comprehensive experiments, we show that PaRa achieves great advantages over existing finetuning approaches on single/multi-subject generation as well as single-image editing. Notably, compared to the prevailing fine-tuning technique LoRA, PaRa achieves better parameter efficiency (2× fewer learnable parameters) and much better target image alignment.
Text-to-Image diffusion model, Diffusion model fine-tuning
Achieve lightweight and reliable personalized models through the subspace of the pre-trained Stable Diffusion model.
6,805
2406.05641
[ 0.012302037328481674, -0.0183965265750885, 0.009871063753962517, 0.037775669246912, 0.04546966776251793, 0.05084260180592537, 0.024406274780631065, -0.041698381304740906, -0.011775866150856018, -0.053759120404720306, -0.002835287246853113, -0.014679541811347008, -0.03004695288836956, 0.0027899539563804865, 0.0020663796458393335, 0.06679309904575348, 0.031174276024103165, 0.007083309814333916, -0.023336652666330338, 0.0009740129462443292, -0.013908015564084053, -0.007590882945805788, 0.03894157335162163, -0.021236535161733627, -0.008174672722816467, -0.0015679310308769345, 0.03504331037402153, 0.00735398568212986, -0.021164702251553535, 0.003962624818086624, 0.034524545073509216, -0.009222508408129215, -0.036860670894384384, -0.013775982894003391, 0.002308000111952424, -0.04308048263192177, -0.024700608104467392, -0.002222268143668771, 0.010843301191926003, 0.008870664052665234, -0.047339968383312225, 0.006620295811444521, -0.0031992485746741295, 0.034370966255664825, -0.03978423401713371, -0.031590722501277924, -0.1255658119916916, 0.019935371354222298, -0.0028914993163198233, -0.017586268484592438, -0.09491357952356339, 0.05088002607226372, -0.017422953620553017, -0.008510149084031582, 0.011701919138431549, 0.04603460058569908, 0.03471744805574417, -0.04873017221689224, -0.002234801184386015, -0.02911965921521187, -0.013600452803075314, 0.026123523712158203, -0.0029421986546367407, 0.023790908977389336, -0.006185713689774275, -0.02733791060745716, -0.02925259806215763, 0.030208645388484, -0.04857689142227173, -0.042136214673519135, -0.006266738288104534, -0.011258725076913834, 0.03392479196190834, -0.0038079891819506884, -0.0298254806548357, -0.0404520183801651, 0.014998583123087883, 0.039848823100328445, 0.05516757443547249, -0.00800721999257803, 0.046930041164159775, 0.010032274760305882, -0.011792037636041641, 0.034237541258335114, -0.02124142087996006, -0.018481379374861717, -0.0400935560464859, -0.040513407438993454, -0.03538332134485245, 0.020636938512325287, -0.012932551093399525, -0.07101540267467499, 0.007969350554049015, 0.02878732793033123, 0.018764398992061615, 0.012772933579981327, 0.021275971084833145, -0.01625777781009674, -0.013324187137186527, 0.031202688813209534, -0.01226530596613884, -0.03496183082461357, 0.03499386087059975, -0.013113686814904213, -0.10288210213184357, -0.02575574442744255, -0.029440907761454582, -0.0012454852694645524, 0.003262410406023264, 0.0059007639065384865, -0.03277142345905304, -0.02374085783958435, -0.004298217594623566, -0.019451310858130455, -0.09843607991933823, 0.011070125736296177, -0.009840250015258789, 0.049374859780073166, -0.0017251807730644941, -0.010572417639195919, 0.049619998782873154, 0.06197141110897064, 0.025441966950893402, 0.06816982477903366, -0.025068677961826324, 0.01748599112033844, 0.05934929847717285, 0.0007639285759069026, -0.07013535499572754, -0.018615728244185448, 0.0034678534138947725, 0.039942435920238495, 0.033260248601436615, -0.01957681216299534, 0.006595642771571875, -0.06868627667427063, 0.0031227697618305683, 0.016397371888160706, 0.0579424723982811, -0.03868008404970169, 0.010257814079523087, -0.024082783609628677, 0.02613256126642227, -0.043716687709093094, 0.054737966507673264, -0.028117766603827477, 0.03573952242732048, -0.015153903514146805, -0.027234122157096863, -0.006434913724660873, 0.025458281859755516, -0.014906658791005611, 0.05845499783754349, -0.0484880693256855, -0.00741383945569396, 0.07614874839782715, 0.046530283987522125, 0.011426358483731747, 0.00711595406755805, -0.005267196800559759, 0.03438377380371094, 0.006904350593686104, -0.041347187012434006, 0.010754184797406197, 0.013830863870680332, -0.015328424982726574, -0.003958107437938452, 0.0331108532845974, 0.0015619180630892515, -0.04897308722138405, -0.031003769487142563, -0.005822934675961733, 0.039820343255996704, 0.015748759731650352, -0.004509531892836094, 0.033250585198402405, 0.02675330825150013, 0.023310424759984016, 0.04860194772481918, 0.007968991063535213, -0.09408386796712875, 0.052908845245838165, 0.005659640301018953, 0.012526114471256733, -0.0060997470282018185, -0.016348358243703842, 0.1038472056388855, -0.0022935369051992893, 0.014249851927161217, 0.03856221213936806, -0.07984381914138794, -0.014294750988483429, 0.04355127736926079, -0.04124199599027634, 0.0682811290025711, 0.032942034304142, -0.019960623234510422, 0.06447871029376984, 0.0623219795525074, 0.03377337008714676, 0.02671624720096588, -0.056315746158361435, 0.05449671670794487, -0.0212183129042387, -0.0309509988874197, -0.019648119807243347, 0.018102480098605156, -0.027163304388523102, -0.014938433654606342, 0.0277737844735384, -0.011210163123905659, 0.012819682247936726, -0.006709611508995295, 0.028393670916557312, 0.0023145826999098063, 0.014657272957265377, -0.0323503278195858, 0.00520542124286294, 0.0008078361861407757, -0.06135525554418564, 0.021854285150766373, 0.005743675399571657, -0.021339762955904007, 0.013480499386787415, -0.03977276012301445, 0.08783996850252151, 0.033834099769592285, -0.05503355339169502, 0.018596723675727844, 0.03555865213274956, -0.008208905346691608, 0.024819543585181236, 0.05777357891201973, -0.011514345183968544, -0.011191780678927898, -0.03125443309545517, -0.0011522980639711022, -0.035864733159542084, 0.06179184839129448, -0.04516620934009552, -0.002204107353463769, 0.05251175910234451, 0.0007409911486320198, 0.08201859891414642, -0.017432047054171562, 0.02464883029460907, 0.012738403864204884, 0.00023975595831871033, -0.037842217832803726, -0.016346316784620285, 0.026967160403728485, 0.020186513662338257, -0.011485474184155464, -0.03859947621822357, 0.026022113859653473, -0.05967053025960922, 0.0042968993075191975, 0.018149517476558685, 0.04292067512869835, 0.028848474845290184, -0.02128921076655388, 0.01075031328946352, -0.024102045223116875, -0.014109413139522076, -0.003281928366050124, -0.09350670874118805, -0.005261652637273073, -0.03444009646773338, 0.013724598102271557, -0.01963634230196476, 0.06456178426742554, -0.01950245536863804, -0.017204497009515762, -0.05662902817130089, -0.025778140872716904, -0.011853434145450592, 0.009370858781039715, 0.0010579786030575633, -0.037596240639686584, -0.029238831251859665, -0.006860792171210051, 0.08367353677749634, -0.02116609551012516, -0.020388809964060783, -0.03315459564328194, -0.03136943653225899, -0.03096025064587593, -0.027297845110297203, -0.02415686659514904, 0.010395810008049011, 0.0263320691883564, 0.02517740987241268, -0.0037960659246891737, 0.019708897918462753, 0.03166143223643303, 0.038688451051712036, 0.023754408583045006, -0.0022290272172540426, -0.022967027500271797, 0.025217484682798386, 0.01422711368650198, 0.03236532583832741, 0.02956957183778286, 0.025923684239387512, -0.0006229962455108762, -0.00742644676938653, 0.013752304948866367, 0.007911375723779202, -0.2803303599357605, 0.014185292646288872, 0.0356682725250721, -0.010688938200473785, 0.021868417039513588, -0.0030661779455840588, 0.03197199106216431, -0.02718883380293846, -0.007755485363304615, 0.009843053296208382, 0.0009223007364198565, 0.06561301648616791, -0.009973262436687946, 0.05383730307221413, 0.02075926773250103, 0.04055395349860191, -0.01674002967774868, -0.005499495193362236, -0.0009562742197886109, 0.03945058584213257, -0.007067698519676924, -0.03615257516503334, 0.007306224200874567, 0.036451566964387894, -0.03207983076572418, 0.045658983290195465, -0.06559981405735016, 0.021215150132775307, 0.00008087536843959242, -0.010557110421359539, 0.05042539909482002, -0.06761907041072845, 0.001221208251081407, 0.03528425469994545, 0.011870519258081913, -0.031204789876937866, 0.037448666989803314, 0.009693028405308723, 0.013020328246057034, 0.00954566989094019, -0.00005514476652024314, 0.013752025552093983, -0.005855774972587824, -0.006461229175329208, 0.04586443677544594, -0.019689122214913368, -0.03882857412099838, 0.0029259936418384314, -0.009993065148591995, 0.04782886430621147, 0.0004179868847131729, -0.054129038006067276, -0.013896816410124302, 0.014477686956524849, -0.0004265314491931349, -0.025208186358213425, 0.010922436602413654, -0.002983632031828165, 0.01884474605321884, 0.011603076942265034, -0.008243217132985592, -0.052311912178993225, -0.041795045137405396, -0.02307276241481304, -0.023120492696762085, -0.030601881444454193, -0.07432013750076294, -0.03909541293978691, 0.03068348951637745, 0.03632808476686478, -0.024204334244132042, 0.005152363330125809, -0.0027799729723483324, -0.08653569221496582, 0.0006468890933319926, -0.02040286548435688, -0.0019280052511021495, 0.01578940637409687, -0.027175018563866615, 0.033529892563819885, -0.025786839425563812, -0.04927479103207588, 0.004351584706455469, 0.019034015014767647, 0.018820488825440407, -0.025445664301514626, 0.028752224519848824, -0.040333155542612076, 0.00008906613948056474, -0.06513546407222748, 0.04982932284474373, -0.010356497019529343, -0.011462045833468437, 0.028118064627051353, 0.04405611380934715, 0.002823308575898409, 0.051416538655757904, 0.07164734601974487, 0.022042350843548775, -0.0280221626162529, 0.038049232214689255, -0.07301830500364304, -0.032860368490219116, -0.02742701768875122, -0.02250085398554802, -0.0059012118726968765, -0.06374693661928177, -0.02715541049838066, 0.011136786080896854, -0.05276241526007652, -0.04957245662808418, -0.030935611575841904, -0.019735122099518776, -0.021248867735266685, -0.00491554569453001, -0.014233226887881756, 0.005530295893549919, 0.03505691885948181, 0.03194102272391319, -0.01372118666768074, -0.016362279653549194, 0.053985465317964554, -0.052268169820308685, 0.002585887210443616, -0.0048701879568398, 0.0047964537516236305, -0.01854870468378067, -0.029816754162311554, 0.019281309098005295, -0.03518562391400337, 0.026552513241767883, -0.00013732060324400663, 0.005965883377939463, 0.021488003432750702, 0.03282652050256729, -0.03992869332432747, 0.012528513558208942, -0.009356125257909298, 0.045348577201366425, -0.029331902042031288, -0.0013947951374575496, 0.02566429227590561, 0.018332015722990036, 0.02004939503967762, 0.01878429763019085, 0.006248909048736095, 0.013325732201337814, 0.015472630970180035, -0.002729549305513501, -0.029928134754300117, 0.011137577705085278, -0.043110281229019165, -0.05931756645441055, -0.025858765468001366, 0.016642307862639427, -0.010191697627305984, 0.010925567708909512, -0.03428606688976288, -0.006863970775157213, -0.0449971929192543, 0.031569529324769974, -0.0014306864468380809, -0.04060821980237961, 0.014463257044553757, -0.0032497202046215534, 0.03016609139740467, -0.007565225008875132, -0.008181635290384293, -0.00040344815352000296, -0.028055841103196144, 0.02126852236688137, -0.007387220859527588, -0.011055692099034786, -0.052996568381786346, -0.013506487011909485, -0.000668894499540329, -0.005056580062955618, 0.01422349363565445, -0.039703067392110825, 0.0858592838048935, 0.04306621849536896, -0.017819438129663467, -0.001481946324929595, 0.01486856397241354, 0.07952924817800522, 0.01594197377562523, 0.021022971719503403, -0.005869602784514427, -0.0581696443259716, 0.045850109308958054, -0.06174350157380104, 0.022471198812127113, -0.05746934935450554, -0.045576028525829315, -0.01373058371245861, -0.0381719246506691, -0.008911652490496635, 0.02312636375427246, 0.010124514810740948, 0.005988244898617268, -0.03415008261799812, -0.0003807063912972808, -0.04296151548624039, -0.01908395066857338, 0.018090417608618736, -0.09835872799158096, 0.03235635906457901, 0.025023145601153374, -0.05189197510480881, 0.025382865220308304, -0.009014236740767956, -0.0408916100859642, -0.05382179468870163, -0.05008018761873245, -0.003748727962374687, -0.03632131591439247, -0.04204091429710388, -0.044585034251213074, 0.0218614861369133, -0.026476861909031868, 0.03140241280198097, 0.008412138558924198, 0.01948494464159012, -0.03270237147808075, 0.012134833261370659, 0.0544513501226902, -0.0037736992817372084, -0.029020383954048157, -0.01621379144489765, -0.010255835019052029, 0.029393022879958153, -0.05827324837446213, -0.00856922660022974, 0.06161358952522278, -0.00671326695010066, 0.010783283039927483, -0.06535392254590988, 0.00006962668703636155, 0.007529509253799915, -0.014353590086102486, 0.002694902243092656, -0.022673817351460457, -0.025136057287454605, -0.00045261537889018655, -0.020746180787682533, 0.060038141906261444, -0.011844467371702194, 0.010558039881289005, -0.019547387957572937, 0.028657138347625732, 0.02277122065424919, 0.013923296704888344, -0.04977956414222717, -0.006100944709032774, 0.05641366168856621, -0.013136018998920918, -0.016441749408841133, -0.05576235055923462, -0.03849407285451889, 0.014529942534863949, 0.018699152395129204, 0.05196291208267212, -0.007103384006768465, 0.017411766573786736, 0.043812137097120285, 0.011961746960878372, 0.019564421847462654, -0.0015072360401973128, 0.02922734245657921, -0.019130557775497437, 0.0068510752171278, -0.06954030692577362, -0.00023988851171452552, 0.03784783184528351, -0.028349729254841805, 0.00947070587426424, -0.009436212480068207, -0.016344338655471802, 0.03096824698150158, -0.03262504190206528, -0.05588686093688011, -0.012511699460446835, -0.03148853778839111, -0.00763360969722271, 0.011043751612305641, -0.05345693975687027, 0.012232319451868534, -0.02863147296011448, -0.06291882693767548, 0.012864772230386734, 0.03953583166003227, 0.040284715592861176, 0.005805092863738537, -0.0006252583698369563, -0.02289547026157379, -0.0036616898141801357, 0.029614880681037903, 0.07227249443531036, -0.0156842153519392, 0.044566452503204346, -0.0015651303110644221, 0.06290549039840698, 0.03045806661248207, 0.02331431955099106, 0.006840500980615616, 0.007631668355315924, -0.022906748577952385, -0.05300046131014824, 0.03203568980097771, 0.02605755627155304, -0.026151856407523155, -0.07467972487211227, 0.06410223990678787, 0.03220196068286896, -0.06175488978624344, -0.0574689544737339, 0.07003261148929596, -0.003980978392064571, 0.04595420882105827, -0.046300943940877914, 0.024307893589138985, 0.03707455098628998, 0.05979366600513458, 0.01298040896654129, 0.008670712821185589, 0.08246366679668427, -0.0262728463858366, 0.021689865738153458, -0.02262750267982483, 0.03741800785064697, 0.0737842321395874, 0.08696037530899048, -0.023339267820119858, 0.06943292915821075, -0.028598448261618614, -0.05154264345765114, 0.03371349722146988, 0.04330168291926384, -0.029705513268709183, -0.03087788261473179, 0.005298767704516649, 0.11135202646255493, -0.00005729811891796999, 0.04437946900725365, -0.03767211735248566, -0.02902146615087986, -0.005765218753367662, 0.01523282565176487, -0.010321559384465218, -0.0140181053429842, 0.022401271387934685, 0.04567556828260422, -0.05782480165362358, 0.011191259138286114, 0.01275087520480156, -0.033518847078084946, 0.024933835491538048, 0.018142925575375557, -0.04336657002568245, -0.009492745622992516, 0.013051345013082027, 0.028526363894343376, 0.09146708995103836, -0.034117553383111954, -0.06384280323982239, 0.014365868642926216, 0.043974775820970535, 0.015073753893375397, 0.04663129523396492, 0.018212558701634407, -0.01412042323499918, 0.009308895096182823, -0.026975343003869057, 0.025266559794545174, 0.025258610025048256, -0.024470584467053413, 0.03168482333421707, -0.048703063279390335, 0.008098137564957142, 0.047332264482975006, 0.005443020723760128, -0.05882875248789787, -0.04018504172563553, -0.0414024256169796, -0.023778434842824936, -0.04447471722960472, -0.01654854789376259, 0.035631533712148666, -0.005038091912865639, -0.012788696214556694, -0.021250387653708458, -0.04242398217320442, -0.0024487816262990236, 0.056890346109867096, -0.08167019486427307, -0.0046208519488573074, 0.013803012669086456, 0.013567376881837845, -0.01843515783548355, 0.03385339304804802, 0.021482866257429123, -0.00741827767342329, 0.010481569916009903, 0.03820498660206795, 0.021865729242563248, 0.03403065353631973, -0.008519569411873817, -0.02063557878136635, -0.09033335000276566, -0.014344577677547932, 0.028480861335992813, -0.0204154122620821, -0.063080333173275, 0.04361066222190857, 0.008128327317535877, 0.038135137408971786, 0.04756859689950943, 0.036966681480407715, -0.013736902736127377, -0.03498188406229019, 0.003487891983240843, -0.02060847170650959, 0.018352774903178215, 0.0807361975312233, -0.03367001563310623, 0.09623025357723236, 0.03807930648326874, -0.005038863979279995, -0.014332590624690056, 0.04773436114192009, -0.015692755579948425, 0.04386289790272713, -0.04027298092842102, -0.006984044797718525, -0.0212389025837183, -0.09181760996580124, -0.016752341762185097, 0.05049808323383331, -0.004816061817109585, -0.030254065990447998, 0.03371750935912132, -0.0032832862343639135, 0.008743750862777233, -0.00016456622688565403, -0.01237290445715189, -0.004139262717217207, -0.03170030936598778, -0.020407820120453835, -0.08087735623121262, -0.0043924530036747456, -0.009136088192462921, 0.011075682006776333, 0.01219975296407938, -0.02684999629855156, -0.005476886406540871, -0.0015194406732916832, 0.06491067260503769, 0.023618442937731743, 0.03946767747402191, 0.01968476176261902 ]
3,512
Near-Optimal Online Learning for Multi-Agent Submodular Coordination: Tight Approximation and Communication Efficiency
https://openreview.net/forum?id=i8dYPGdB1C
[ "Qixin Zhang", "Zongqi Wan", "Yu Yang", "Li Shen", "Dacheng Tao" ]
Spotlight
Coordinating multiple agents to collaboratively maximize submodular functions in unpredictable environments is a critical task with numerous applications in machine learning, robot planning and control. The existing approaches, such as the OSG algorithm, are often hindered by their poor approximation guarantees and the rigid requirement for a fully connected communication graph. To address these challenges, we firstly present a $\textbf{MA-OSMA}$ algorithm, which employs the multi-linear extension to transfer the discrete submodular maximization problem into a continuous optimization, thereby allowing us to reduce the strict dependence on a complete graph through consensus techniques. Moreover, $\textbf{MA-OSMA}$ leverages a novel surrogate gradient to avoid sub-optimal stationary points. To eliminate the computationally intensive projection operations in $\textbf{MA-OSMA}$, we also introduce a projection-free $\textbf{MA-OSEA}$ algorithm, which effectively utilizes the KL divergence by mixing a uniform distribution. Theoretically, we confirm that both algorithms achieve a regret bound of $\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{\frac{C_{T}T}{1-\beta}})$ against a  $(\frac{1-e^{-c}}{c})$-approximation to the best comparator in hindsight, where $C_{T}$ is the deviation of maximizer sequence, $\beta$ is the spectral gap of the network and $c$ is the joint curvature of submodular objectives. This result significantly improves the $(\frac{1}{1+c})$-approximation provided by the state-of-the-art OSG algorithm. Finally, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed algorithms through simulation-based multi-target tracking.
Online Learning, Submodular Maximization, Surrogate Gradient, Multi-Agent
null
6,794
2502.05028
[ -0.02862183377146721, -0.01127853337675333, 0.038543395698070526, 0.030588332563638687, 0.048932623118162155, 0.0236989576369524, 0.017160989344120026, -0.0031094695441424847, -0.012605288997292519, -0.0449683740735054, -0.008334471844136715, 0.0011221764143556356, -0.08278747648000717, -0.008181345649063587, 0.02655215933918953, 0.06513351947069168, 0.034484896808862686, 0.01543513871729374, -0.02452157437801361, 0.0069563924334943295, 0.015574654564261436, -0.002959238598123193, 0.03552832826972008, -0.0015940541634336114, 0.045914385467767715, 0.0369073860347271, 0.01718786545097828, 0.01994072087109089, -0.007860830053687096, -0.014953655190765858, -0.001917074783705175, -0.019146231934428215, 0.01826728694140911, -0.021565496921539307, 0.011627130210399628, 0.019318977370858192, -0.016336092725396156, 0.008599791675806046, -0.004790990147739649, 0.020351910963654518, -0.027033990249037743, 0.029898110777139664, -0.021849142387509346, 0.0287302415817976, -0.02933088317513466, 0.01611432433128357, -0.0771254375576973, 0.03544013574719429, 0.036880843341350555, -0.06151687353849411, -0.0995149090886116, 0.03359861299395561, 0.031884245574474335, -0.01460299827158451, -0.025759251788258553, 0.045504383742809296, 0.013130441308021545, -0.06457312405109406, -0.012891741469502449, -0.05075426027178764, -0.038565997034311295, 0.01002510916441679, 0.034218840301036835, -0.014319213107228279, -0.027539005503058434, 0.028774045407772064, 0.019522907212376595, 0.05249765142798424, -0.025559760630130768, 0.006835591979324818, -0.02892070822417736, -0.014280390925705433, -0.007208779454231262, 0.012453252449631691, 0.018465949222445488, -0.040998972952365875, 0.03626880794763565, -0.0031242920085787773, 0.0478457547724247, 0.018089281395077705, -0.0020195862744003534, 0.02431357279419899, -0.008077903650701046, 0.013964008539915085, 0.0028948583640158176, -0.007607860025018454, -0.020038630813360214, -0.03308314457535744, -0.08845359086990356, 0.06095346435904503, -0.06267862021923065, -0.08058334141969681, 0.004966115579009056, 0.04886718839406967, 0.024564281105995178, 0.006592839490622282, 0.021815437823534012, 0.05994353070855141, 0.0250606220215559, -0.018608244135975838, -0.011360309086740017, -0.021438727155327797, -0.013737926259636879, -0.014412186108529568, -0.1015162393450737, -0.026297876611351967, -0.006317261140793562, -0.015219753608107567, -0.0035366909578442574, 0.011747945100069046, -0.06076228246092796, 0.012390663847327232, 0.005678533110767603, -0.040106482803821564, -0.05611860379576683, 0.04122032970190048, -0.001476393430493772, 0.010077380575239658, -0.010380517691373825, -0.013964993879199028, 0.06699618697166443, 0.0646185502409935, -0.030478160828351974, 0.07569266855716705, -0.008910004049539566, 0.013299135491251945, 0.032746847718954086, 0.03128714859485626, -0.04955393821001053, -0.012870347127318382, 0.05258733779191971, 0.03448512405157089, 0.008936060592532158, 0.0004376703582238406, -0.0028030099347233772, -0.0013685858575627208, -0.003553238930180669, 0.0313071683049202, 0.020900996401906013, 0.003646478522568941, -0.007512012962251902, -0.000317270343657583, 0.06782756000757217, 0.002801197115331888, 0.05008547008037567, -0.028537031263113022, 0.007625042460858822, -0.05421888455748558, -0.059292037039995193, -0.023119689896702766, -0.015924932435154915, -0.04617541655898094, -0.021099582314491272, -0.052883896976709366, 0.0187250766903162, 0.05813796818256378, 0.049844399094581604, -0.009723913855850697, 0.011482149362564087, 0.01673618145287037, 0.01850510574877262, 0.035469863563776016, -0.03885730355978012, 0.021925784647464752, -0.02614557556807995, -0.08606979250907898, 0.056918688118457794, 0.06281358003616333, -0.016615185886621475, -0.021854648366570473, -0.029473718255758286, -0.03373676910996437, 0.03911104053258896, 0.012058787047863007, -0.0009118820307776332, -0.019246965646743774, 0.0610542930662632, -0.02026803232729435, 0.04124077036976814, 0.03097234107553959, -0.08599904924631119, 0.01023777760565281, 0.024887926876544952, -0.012898700311779976, 0.002874984173104167, -0.04548419639468193, 0.06946456432342529, -0.04700620844960213, -0.0004941019578836858, -0.02305462397634983, -0.04463097080588341, -0.0028946755919605494, 0.05866701900959015, -0.022772332653403282, 0.0624704509973526, 0.006771978456526995, -0.026642821729183197, 0.008109420537948608, 0.016593344509601593, 0.02322193793952465, 0.0447256863117218, -0.00027333988691680133, 0.051595136523246765, -0.004794620908796787, -0.040605802088975906, 0.009273314848542213, 0.0490325428545475, -0.06363201141357422, -0.036722030490636826, 0.025300566107034683, -0.007941339164972305, -0.026062380522489548, 0.011285722255706787, 0.0002354974130867049, 0.04671405255794525, -0.014991693198680878, 0.003599846735596657, -0.010295921936631203, 0.03424210473895073, -0.02448190189898014, 0.020883509889245033, 0.005176539067178965, -0.036463238298892975, 0.036204829812049866, -0.0067504714243113995, 0.08858063817024231, 0.08315237611532211, -0.02231396920979023, -0.014507215470075607, 0.01928025670349598, 0.01068110391497612, 0.004633400123566389, 0.0338822677731514, -0.0053951977752149105, 0.022885851562023163, -0.03543192520737648, -0.01766757108271122, -0.055443767458200455, 0.05860375985503197, -0.04887816309928894, -0.029394835233688354, 0.06137462332844734, -0.0015335348434746265, 0.05729614943265915, 0.018348947167396545, 0.008368546143174171, 0.04903050512075424, 0.00890339445322752, -0.004138167481869459, 0.0213477686047554, -0.03213494271039963, -0.02288758009672165, 0.021898694336414337, -0.029689015820622444, -0.0077163102105259895, -0.06310764700174332, 0.016127824783325195, -0.01007404550909996, 0.08592641353607178, 0.0363100990653038, 0.036386698484420776, 0.04522107541561127, 0.006418753881007433, -0.02908327430486679, -0.033154089003801346, -0.1069331020116806, -0.07729528099298477, 0.004758853930979967, 0.025534844025969505, 0.042481400072574615, 0.054476216435432434, -0.029677193611860275, 0.057176150381565094, -0.02962561883032322, -0.0325147770345211, 0.011358225718140602, 0.014278564602136612, 0.00037006178172305226, -0.05591905862092972, -0.03439878299832344, 0.02482384815812111, 0.07424677908420563, 0.010185323655605316, -0.01855490542948246, -0.0512344129383564, -0.04176349937915802, -0.002604081528261304, -0.03701421618461609, 0.008176716975867748, 0.005214609671384096, -0.012063681147992611, 0.011911265552043915, -0.04156056419014931, 0.012701130472123623, 0.010499202646315098, 0.04153577238321304, 0.032167959958314896, 0.024530377238988876, -0.004060477018356323, 0.0025152198504656553, -0.0008979253470897675, 0.014758901670575142, -0.014514969661831856, -0.02721376344561577, -0.048700034618377686, -0.03168623521924019, 0.02790864184498787, 0.016991570591926575, -0.26114925742149353, -0.016677463427186012, -0.000969723507296294, 0.011783231049776077, 0.03808491304516792, -0.03750528022646904, 0.042668409645557404, -0.05528729781508446, -0.027086474001407623, -0.009598745964467525, 0.017921973019838333, 0.024623282253742218, 0.025869041681289673, 0.04364897310733795, 0.03340680152177811, -0.013945951126515865, -0.03753548115491867, -0.015137563459575176, 0.03196277469396591, 0.024049485102295876, -0.02296626754105091, -0.059824053198099136, -0.010606872849166393, 0.012363456189632416, -0.012194909155368805, 0.06937043368816376, -0.08309570699930191, -0.03917723894119263, -0.02123054303228855, 0.013592670671641827, -0.03888186439871788, -0.028524285182356834, -0.014183178544044495, 0.01360362395644188, 0.030106889083981514, 0.012435307726264, 0.05064849182963371, -0.0033735441975295544, 0.04419611394405365, 0.011762385256588459, -0.004690397530794144, -0.009909026324748993, -0.04475519433617592, -0.01730811782181263, 0.03638412058353424, 0.049817394465208054, -0.017196733504533768, -0.0007533149910159409, -0.011180802248418331, 0.040541473776102066, 0.02713567577302456, -0.04056534916162491, 0.018593449145555496, -0.02115098014473915, 0.022453581914305687, -0.07032395899295807, -0.024841217324137688, -0.040986452251672745, -0.0006299508968368173, 0.028853440657258034, -0.012851303443312645, -0.04884406551718712, 0.0019297287799417973, -0.02499348670244217, 0.000816288695205003, -0.025671692565083504, -0.06593717634677887, -0.05686771869659424, 0.014577070251107216, 0.017795922234654427, 0.01119527593255043, 0.002728446386754513, -0.05605591461062431, -0.08563598990440369, -0.010493051260709763, 0.020215943455696106, 0.0029790953267365694, -0.035735711455345154, 0.015872567892074585, 0.060821693390607834, -0.04502690210938454, -0.03625950589776039, -0.0068003893829882145, 0.020412828773260117, 0.03101678378880024, -0.01927066408097744, 0.022015882655978203, -0.019557753577828407, -0.03304888308048248, -0.022893693298101425, 0.031205428764224052, -0.00001716929727990646, 0.04150814935564995, -0.0072717443108558655, 0.06213224679231644, 0.03614242747426033, 0.013928801752626896, 0.013997087255120277, 0.029967067763209343, 0.0009918425930663943, 0.0242299921810627, -0.06836947053670883, -0.02943912148475647, -0.03582145646214485, -0.027944868430495262, 0.032427072525024414, -0.06573507934808731, -0.021835649386048317, 0.03453321009874344, -0.019038468599319458, -0.014038095250725746, -0.027179142460227013, 0.027533002197742462, -0.021291466429829597, 0.012140379287302494, -0.02173069678246975, -0.002029028022661805, 0.0327901728451252, 0.026908472180366516, 0.010465512052178383, -0.051515426486730576, 0.03192603960633278, -0.009938923642039299, 0.027053946629166603, -0.006530021317303181, 0.0058680567890405655, 0.004734561778604984, -0.030121661722660065, -0.010296313092112541, -0.008351447992026806, 0.028607884421944618, 0.06824737787246704, 0.047305576503276825, 0.002847429132089019, 0.03962632268667221, 0.0033830676693469286, -0.0483800433576107, -0.009245438501238823, 0.05879107490181923, -0.02811211161315441, 0.026829412207007408, 0.00705264788120985, 0.02304529957473278, 0.004386644344776869, -0.003930962644517422, 0.0064617362804710865, -0.010712644085288048, 0.030201423913240433, 0.012718482874333858, 0.006258443463593721, 0.008556321263313293, -0.03522226959466934, 0.038533277809619904, -0.026609377935528755, 0.03795751556754112, -0.01891147717833519, 0.024865323677659035, -0.015646759420633316, 0.028872625902295113, -0.058605991303920746, 0.009767189621925354, 0.0005285871447995305, -0.021830933168530464, -0.01611051894724369, 0.024629222229123116, 0.055505603551864624, -0.03101498819887638, 0.0004726804909296334, -0.017299262806773186, 0.0048440066166222095, 0.05239284783601761, -0.04447246715426445, -0.04590320959687233, -0.03436160087585449, -0.0146248210221529, -0.005592741072177887, 0.010392994619905949, -0.030664971098303795, -0.026057517156004906, 0.00782807171344757, 0.012930363416671753, -0.010738145560026169, -0.03608831763267517, 0.028649674728512764, 0.05233298987150192, -0.017800580710172653, -0.020110459998250008, -0.035466618835926056, 0.0065459152683615685, 0.029044335708022118, 0.022731531411409378, 0.05040799826383591, -0.046212248504161835, -0.03478064388036728, 0.0022105148527771235, -0.029870806261897087, 0.00918442290276289, 0.031426649540662766, -0.04716187343001366, 0.017295436933636665, -0.004485918674618006, 0.031521886587142944, -0.07545647025108337, -0.0190267376601696, 0.03541821613907814, -0.053891148418188095, 0.015277042984962463, 0.03288545832037926, -0.02525526098906994, 0.014356904663145542, -0.07725483924150467, -0.029775403439998627, -0.03828509524464607, 0.03715648874640465, 0.036495521664619446, -0.02730686217546463, -0.029568878933787346, 0.02615492232143879, -0.009804032742977142, -0.014134814031422138, -0.005680585280060768, 0.0014782038051635027, -0.009471900761127472, -0.028601149097085, -0.019928360357880592, 0.07169783860445023, -0.0051089017651975155, 0.002092717681080103, 0.01975519396364689, -0.0025411786045879126, 0.01707007735967636, -0.051487427204847336, 0.013930313289165497, 0.04097675532102585, 0.019835403189063072, 0.03947962075471878, -0.042296379804611206, 0.036737218499183655, -0.04440869390964508, -0.03971375897526741, -0.003632771782577038, 0.011545362882316113, -0.031616926193237305, -0.011940198950469494, -0.032384417951107025, 0.013542404398322105, 0.005273695103824139, -0.011569080874323845, 0.019995158538222313, 0.019015152007341385, 0.014343959279358387, 0.0049178218469023705, -0.04889454320073128, -0.00215775053948164, 0.036867935210466385, -0.002959656994789839, -0.027194082736968994, -0.0434512160718441, -0.006686331704258919, 0.02773379534482956, -0.06946013122797012, 0.02786393091082573, -0.06473907083272934, 0.0034363330341875553, 0.03711477294564247, 0.04636954888701439, 0.017888769507408142, -0.024419398978352547, 0.039453260600566864, -0.07118508964776993, 0.01783997006714344, -0.07126862555742264, 0.014120527543127537, 0.04482042416930199, -0.023259205743670464, 0.020372068509459496, 0.046741560101509094, -0.01191931962966919, 0.034952111542224884, -0.035162974148988724, -0.04303685948252678, 0.03889741003513336, -0.02841753326356411, -0.04668265953660011, 0.057323750108480453, -0.057067204266786575, -0.033290132880210876, -0.003386954078450799, -0.06744563579559326, 0.0342370830476284, -0.0005343610537238419, 0.02493993751704693, 0.0003157127066515386, -0.0039628115482628345, -0.030491868034005165, 0.03556334972381592, 0.067197784781456, 0.04835310950875282, 0.04550519585609436, 0.029610207304358482, -0.051847074180841446, 0.06652845442295074, 0.05648847669363022, 0.024228869006037712, -0.0077755264937877655, 0.03667960688471794, -0.028396492823958397, -0.03725753724575043, 0.04931366443634033, -0.014168603345751762, -0.01691659726202488, -0.05942141264677048, 0.031363971531391144, 0.02083740197122097, -0.05492318421602249, -0.029336748644709587, 0.013028525747358799, -0.04953353852033615, 0.017666978761553764, -0.017745548859238625, 0.02735026739537716, 0.055408645421266556, 0.08467359095811844, 0.009598814882338047, 0.021729176864027977, 0.05982201546430588, 0.009755479171872139, -0.01410260796546936, -0.015483676455914974, 0.06559985876083374, 0.0532800629734993, 0.02918688952922821, -0.021756809204816818, 0.07440907508134842, -0.03885843604803085, -0.05614893138408661, 0.018744001165032387, 0.006962048355489969, -0.02947850711643696, -0.00040400453144684434, -0.010103022679686546, 0.02960282750427723, -0.004261475056409836, 0.06703715771436691, -0.04904978722333908, -0.014936565421521664, 0.05376755818724632, -0.011543366126716137, 0.013251193799078465, 0.02715536579489708, 0.05175577104091644, 0.029855672270059586, -0.021489545702934265, -0.016911480575799942, -0.012994636781513691, 0.00864311121404171, 0.027760233730077744, 0.003199969884008169, -0.011546057648956776, 0.03895996883511543, 0.01443545799702406, -0.015666749328374863, 0.06848233938217163, -0.048192404210567474, -0.0423397533595562, -0.021164458245038986, 0.02695387601852417, -0.031191300600767136, 0.004063107073307037, 0.028827354311943054, -0.026277437806129456, 0.03810412436723709, -0.030488841235637665, 0.023573381826281548, 0.018993191421031952, 0.02099701762199402, 0.032945845276117325, -0.01140389684587717, 0.010500773787498474, 0.011289617046713829, 0.003911038860678673, -0.01809595339000225, -0.03255855664610863, -0.0210710521787405, -0.08949515223503113, -0.04741116613149643, -0.040579888969659805, 0.01819656230509281, 0.021435225382447243, -0.04641943424940109, 0.024553805589675903, -0.04031335562467575, 0.00656582647934556, -0.008102606050670147, -0.08144410699605942, -0.010722563602030277, 0.03741831332445145, 0.01692190207540989, 0.027459068223834038, 0.0183478482067585, 0.039723943918943405, -0.010211172513663769, -0.004485716577619314, 0.014917843043804169, 0.02326706051826477, 0.01918841153383255, -0.029954174533486366, -0.0062334355898201466, -0.08781585097312927, 0.0036419827956706285, 0.008076636120676994, -0.05649641901254654, -0.0740995779633522, 0.019425205886363983, -0.013456442393362522, 0.029389021918177605, 0.061985909938812256, -0.014451715163886547, 0.0035408767871558666, -0.050019439309835434, 0.027796229347586632, -0.01750006340444088, 0.0047372146509587765, 0.03554295375943184, -0.02779977209866047, 0.029963765293359756, 0.044965509325265884, -0.020114734768867493, -0.04043787717819214, 0.06249017268419266, 0.013950979337096214, -0.000792207894846797, 0.005058949813246727, -0.03464920073747635, -0.04179151728749275, -0.1042773649096489, -0.035994987934827805, 0.06904271990060806, 0.02370622381567955, -0.05768747627735138, -0.0037286092992872, -0.0019816800486296415, -0.0016996015328913927, 0.015265634283423424, -0.0020486258435994387, -0.04095458984375, -0.034851979464292526, -0.020563052967190742, -0.06865551322698593, 0.011305682361125946, -0.02483081817626953, -0.012144873850047588, -0.03541896119713783, -0.037023380398750305, -0.049703389406204224, 0.03250759094953537, 0.03384944051504135, -0.010391050018370152, 0.023702571168541908, 0.02658965438604355 ]
3,513
PETRA: Parallel End-to-end Training with Reversible Architectures
https://openreview.net/forum?id=0fhzSFsGUT
[ "Stephane Rivaud", "Louis Fournier", "Thomas Pumir", "Eugene Belilovsky", "Michael Eickenberg", "Edouard Oyallon" ]
Spotlight
Reversible architectures have been shown to be capable of performing on par with their non-reversible architectures, being applied in deep learning for memory savings and generative modeling. In this work, we show how reversible architectures can solve challenges in parallelizing deep model training. We introduce PETRA, a novel alternative to backpropagation for parallelizing gradient computations. PETRA facilitates effective model parallelism by enabling stages (i.e., a set of layers) to compute independently on different devices, while only needing to communicate activations and gradients between each other. By decoupling the forward and backward passes and keeping a single updated version of the parameters, the need for weight stashing is also removed. We develop a custom autograd-like training framework for PETRA, and we demonstrate its effectiveness on standard computer vision benchmarks, achieving competitive accuracies comparable to backpropagation using ResNet-18, ResNet-34, and ResNet-50 models.
Model parallelism, Delayed gradient, Reversible architectures
We show how combining reversible architectures with delayed gradient approaches for model parallelism allows to achieve computational speedups with drastic memory reduction.
6,763
2406.02052
[ -0.013622588478028774, -0.030909039080142975, -0.010446484200656414, 0.0453675240278244, 0.04171394929289818, 0.03101116605103016, 0.036060404032468796, 0.019899634644389153, -0.011951540596783161, -0.045294180512428284, 0.00924687273800373, -0.0034736725501716137, -0.029928766191005707, -0.0006504306220449507, 0.00020411828882060945, 0.027573132887482643, 0.062317486852407455, -0.030972225591540337, 0.034455738961696625, 0.03035847470164299, 0.007565453182905912, -0.04363957792520523, 0.0022050729021430016, 0.020069677382707596, 0.003762532025575638, -0.018057238310575485, 0.043055370450019836, 0.0037938326131552458, -0.05551643669605255, 0.0006030143122188747, 0.029011089354753494, 0.0023163051810115576, 0.010466452687978745, -0.01502431184053421, 0.04566861316561699, 0.008203708566725254, -0.0562400184571743, 0.018056217581033707, 0.011972826905548573, 0.0066689359955489635, -0.017692511901259422, -0.0051656123250722885, -0.010111226700246334, -0.010228456929326057, -0.03799600526690483, 0.07054854929447174, -0.09289998561143875, 0.017030084505677223, -0.03298057243227959, -0.028948409482836723, -0.1024763286113739, 0.017268097028136253, 0.004967157728970051, -0.024838807061314583, 0.017453813925385475, -0.005338442511856556, 0.013716176152229309, -0.06606414914131165, -0.015165159478783607, -0.0522136390209198, -0.002081089885905385, 0.01726038195192814, 0.023280439898371696, 0.026099884882569313, 0.02859555184841156, -0.03141153231263161, 0.03576141595840454, 0.01705700345337391, -0.05723382160067558, -0.06130571290850639, -0.034686341881752014, -0.005118788219988346, -0.009549403563141823, 0.010476949624717236, 0.01810949295759201, -0.04386254772543907, 0.0024107058998197317, 0.01774337887763977, 0.09744993597269058, -0.005799528211355209, 0.036105044186115265, 0.011718845926225185, 0.01440960168838501, 0.06820453703403473, 0.001828567823395133, 0.01477227546274662, -0.025263052433729172, -0.03430546075105667, -0.0726945623755455, 0.04641575738787651, -0.03578830510377884, -0.040829386562108994, 0.006622356362640858, 0.0432204008102417, 0.032541386783123016, 0.013847376219928265, -0.0006525030476041138, 0.0030574628617614508, 0.03161735460162163, 0.005949055310338736, -0.026695584878325462, -0.03830030560493469, -0.022821303457021713, -0.017731165513396263, -0.08706916868686676, -0.018356624990701675, -0.027435170486569405, -0.01622621715068817, 0.026971105486154556, 0.0031740996055305004, -0.01582711562514305, -0.0038052573800086975, 0.011334102600812912, -0.030096817761659622, -0.09274376183748245, 0.01451473031193018, -0.008478790521621704, -0.004901175387203693, -0.041721589863300323, -0.030023643746972084, 0.07974451035261154, 0.08597469329833984, 0.02230824902653694, 0.0771167203783989, 0.01506984792649746, 0.006187680643051863, 0.02617010660469532, 0.038770560175180435, -0.032424259930849075, -0.036502379924058914, -0.02055993303656578, 0.04127856343984604, 0.014729704707860947, 0.02663545310497284, 0.010324530303478241, -0.04313318803906441, -0.017565226182341576, 0.01500062644481659, 0.06400406360626221, 0.0066963364370167255, 0.011311881244182587, -0.012503285892307758, 0.07709594815969467, -0.054260049015283585, 0.07034281641244888, -0.022866014391183853, 0.006533394567668438, -0.007698941044509411, -0.030059367418289185, 0.0200341884046793, -0.022346656769514084, 0.02479175105690956, -0.008412609808146954, -0.10056284070014954, 0.02617204748094082, 0.053214721381664276, 0.03697185218334198, 0.047435954213142395, -0.011645413935184479, 0.00988744106143713, 0.005658090580254793, -0.008352787233889103, -0.006719029508531094, 0.0035082141403108835, -0.0042606620118021965, -0.041166871786117554, 0.04006051644682884, 0.026128705590963364, -0.0030747223645448685, 0.012510966509580612, -0.046424560248851776, -0.01895860768854618, 0.0371156707406044, 0.007173073943704367, -0.036131251603364944, 0.0015365283470600843, 0.07707591354846954, -0.005245324224233627, 0.0004780337621923536, 0.005249285604804754, -0.0949372872710228, 0.04890494793653488, 0.017183659598231316, 0.011900686658918858, 0.009779066778719425, -0.02470392920076847, 0.10104038566350937, -0.044631484895944595, -0.010538585484027863, 0.02365422435104847, -0.08702656626701355, -0.009058029390871525, 0.008435536175966263, -0.0032656509429216385, 0.055648431181907654, 0.00998569093644619, -0.014814813621342182, 0.005883826874196529, 0.03695483133196831, 0.056150104850530624, 0.04738759249448776, -0.0505087785422802, 0.038814276456832886, -0.011021559126675129, -0.02264903485774994, -0.0017183424206450582, 0.04126106575131416, -0.054366983473300934, -0.031093895435333252, -0.0015997318550944328, 0.020920516923069954, 0.011092470958828926, -0.007890178821980953, 0.007295812945812941, 0.0018128779483959079, -0.0012157211313024163, -0.03164299577474594, -0.0006340194377116859, 0.04046382009983063, -0.04918111488223076, 0.041034381836652756, 0.004056911449879408, 0.007953076623380184, 0.02392609603703022, -0.03455762937664986, 0.10908110439777374, 0.03689265996217728, -0.0445646271109581, -0.002771819941699505, 0.011553608812391758, 0.008965176530182362, 0.010050086304545403, -0.02900242991745472, 0.0009095171117223799, 0.002275047590956092, -0.009977532550692558, -0.012820719741284847, -0.03970758989453316, 0.06335372477769852, -0.053766075521707535, -0.046363744884729385, 0.033246006816625595, -0.020138677209615707, 0.05889977887272835, 0.03402180224657059, 0.005952869541943073, 0.05638866126537323, -0.03981778770685196, -0.005640367045998573, -0.04992896690964699, -0.03313044086098671, -0.00967385433614254, 0.010300795547664165, -0.011328257620334625, 0.016920305788517, -0.042802125215530396, -0.013160480186343193, -0.006436237134039402, 0.050806477665901184, 0.0545692965388298, 0.01709570549428463, 0.053962621837854385, -0.0054938411340117455, -0.017648177221417427, -0.016489850357174873, -0.13229350745677948, -0.019109198823571205, -0.002881632186472416, 0.09128771722316742, -0.007728685159236193, 0.05166579410433769, -0.01463403645902872, 0.009494580328464508, -0.02757764607667923, -0.03673514351248741, -0.00048733476432971656, 0.014529294334352016, 0.021396052092313766, -0.0474160872399807, -0.04644059017300606, 0.017049862071871758, 0.05898994579911232, 0.005335806868970394, 0.016812480986118317, -0.01686546579003334, -0.0437173992395401, -0.016942206770181656, -0.05861571803689003, 0.019396517425775528, 0.007172747980803251, 0.04826707765460014, 0.03020152449607849, -0.024967387318611145, -0.0004656536621041596, 0.027746934443712234, 0.08338018506765366, 0.04753442481160164, -0.023440634831786156, -0.03142482787370682, 0.031405992805957794, -0.01694808341562748, 0.0498121976852417, 0.0034905557986348867, 0.03794519975781441, -0.021503429859876633, 0.0008202094468288124, 0.023611003533005714, -0.011851966381072998, -0.23497986793518066, -0.008545521646738052, 0.012488195672631264, -0.021509623154997826, 0.05067446827888489, -0.017260046675801277, 0.022103823721408844, -0.014381478540599346, 0.002435246016830206, -0.019609779119491577, 0.002818974433466792, 0.00406653992831707, 0.01868889108300209, 0.04136448726058006, 0.04592038318514824, 0.013760067522525787, -0.013780161738395691, -0.004496087785810232, 0.04340672120451927, 0.04726574569940567, -0.01833580620586872, -0.0749349296092987, -0.0037019834853708744, 0.026481004431843758, -0.016237718984484673, -0.004611558746546507, -0.1099965050816536, 0.013284958899021149, -0.03485805168747902, -0.02205747365951538, -0.015757940709590912, -0.0051637617871165276, 0.00013142354146111757, 0.04370766878128052, 0.01111479103565216, -0.016619987785816193, 0.028081189841032028, 0.0017871540039777756, 0.03544202819466591, -0.0001805456995498389, 0.02283521741628647, -0.04417097941040993, -0.006178483832627535, 0.049762062728405, 0.08717462420463562, 0.03525237366557121, -0.0423249676823616, -0.018556492403149605, -0.03692950680851936, 0.013795476406812668, 0.004586433991789818, -0.041341181844472885, -0.021802378818392754, 0.019181201234459877, -0.025022203102707863, -0.0053840819746255875, -0.0220783818513155, 0.010059217922389507, -0.002499838126823306, 0.032788582146167755, -0.00336214667186141, -0.05864153802394867, 0.0025547463446855545, -0.03631243109703064, -0.007471970748156309, -0.03579976037144661, -0.06877023726701736, -0.05121400207281113, 0.03209501877427101, 0.032748252153396606, -0.021035782992839813, 0.007835643365979195, -0.04667007178068161, -0.09505821764469147, 0.021936753764748573, -0.015058252029120922, -0.013386969454586506, -0.024257570505142212, -0.01580127887427807, 0.049410078674554825, -0.02029787003993988, -0.0545809306204319, 0.015317490324378014, -0.016628660261631012, 0.028704609721899033, -0.006636854261159897, -0.011942354962229729, -0.04719968140125275, 0.00690244697034359, -0.036641329526901245, 0.05184468999505043, 0.014192547649145126, 0.010515579953789711, -0.04451151192188263, 0.04542595148086548, 0.04821506515145302, 0.03232971951365471, 0.06639782339334488, 0.04576200619339943, 0.02138000912964344, 0.003267205785959959, -0.08876858651638031, -0.009024267084896564, -0.03092346340417862, -0.01661675237119198, 0.011463365517556667, -0.05148438736796379, -0.015415915288031101, 0.046559277921915054, 0.026088297367095947, -0.03888992220163345, -0.04245973005890846, 0.03249877691268921, -0.036260027438402176, -0.03800056129693985, 0.008969311602413654, 0.012837587855756283, 0.04658161476254463, 0.034447528421878815, -0.04126276820898056, -0.03927668184041977, 0.05135088413953781, -0.024632900953292847, 0.007151931989938021, 0.027032965794205666, -0.011349627748131752, 0.015101540833711624, 0.0032823728397488594, -0.027489041909575462, -0.024989543482661247, 0.0219874270260334, 0.02421426959335804, 0.011734696105122566, 0.0328793004155159, 0.05043976381421089, 0.0008852724567987025, -0.007259550038725138, 0.004511859733611345, 0.04391542449593544, 0.017024440690875053, 0.03808838501572609, -0.013116713613271713, 0.04260341078042984, 0.017523691058158875, 0.03715910762548447, 0.048787180334329605, 0.03003525361418724, 0.005301991011947393, -0.007762075401842594, -0.0379609577357769, 0.016685139387845993, -0.06542113423347473, -0.02790391445159912, -0.04308125376701355, 0.02925499528646469, -0.01088504958897829, 0.012059426866471767, -0.0018049090867862105, -0.01848253421485424, -0.04424692317843437, 0.04227795451879501, 0.039313752204179764, -0.009970922954380512, -0.0098489448428154, 0.0013668413739651442, 0.03959064558148384, 0.006545656826347113, -0.04041792452335358, 0.008233979344367981, 0.008753841742873192, -0.016949042677879333, -0.04057620093226433, -0.022420311346650124, -0.0035429333802312613, -0.011120899580419064, 0.04587411507964134, -0.0029245621990412474, -0.007671625353395939, -0.030899159610271454, 0.018724799156188965, -0.0000875089390319772, 0.01427844725549221, -0.00797626655548811, 0.0019734275992959738, 0.08747265487909317, 0.00577612454071641, -0.007109778001904488, 0.007123978808522224, -0.04003722593188286, 0.046667929738759995, -0.007484624162316322, 0.017597919330000877, -0.02434007078409195, -0.027355343103408813, -0.0226144976913929, -0.03759010136127472, 0.012066025286912918, 0.022974153980612755, -0.011965252459049225, -0.02677922509610653, -0.018162673339247704, 0.041789595037698746, -0.028269769623875618, -0.012333313934504986, 0.0013540495419874787, -0.0825938880443573, 0.008378423750400543, 0.0394994281232357, -0.011907431297004223, 0.013037112541496754, -0.00022032600827515125, -0.0029318516608327627, -0.027322737500071526, -0.007513024844229221, -0.009803283028304577, 0.004943748936057091, -0.030097318813204765, 0.0040031541138887405, -0.018798362463712692, -0.026168445125222206, 0.040882084518671036, -0.004619194194674492, -0.013047754764556885, -0.018454544246196747, -0.005527785513550043, 0.03107614256441593, -0.014285757206380367, 0.038245491683483124, -0.026868121698498726, -0.016165727749466896, 0.04571026936173439, -0.037264227867126465, 0.00362108345143497, 0.033272504806518555, -0.007108846679329872, -0.012998426333069801, -0.016422074288129807, 0.006189705803990364, -0.028196198865771294, 0.011976395733654499, -0.00935647264122963, -0.03963394835591316, -0.07694148272275925, 0.007544522173702717, -0.0175955630838871, 0.0032061233650892973, 0.005154106300324202, -0.00248453626409173, -0.0053564757108688354, 0.004562320187687874, 0.01960590109229088, 0.02656632661819458, -0.050851009786129, 0.002886128844693303, 0.0502859465777874, -0.027855509892106056, -0.0006872740923427045, -0.08025233447551727, -0.05991809815168381, -0.011978305876255035, -0.020071890205144882, 0.014459380879998207, -0.04580900818109512, 0.03852197527885437, 0.013582405634224415, 0.03864708170294762, 0.015575048513710499, -0.05829625576734543, 0.020811527967453003, -0.027300866320729256, 0.004242541268467903, -0.04780031368136406, -0.031364213675260544, 0.06827444583177567, -0.023792749270796776, 0.012195244431495667, 0.00658295676112175, -0.06524521112442017, 0.0341406986117363, -0.045281462371349335, -0.05313819274306297, 0.03297337144613266, -0.0287808608263731, 0.005414314568042755, 0.006620156578719616, -0.0369863361120224, 0.003951807040721178, -0.031326234340667725, -0.04551506042480469, 0.006065675988793373, 0.015762165188789368, 0.03276815265417099, 0.006775601301342249, 0.021511709317564964, -0.01708965189754963, -0.003274989314377308, 0.030234286561608315, 0.03914060816168785, 0.018893258646130562, 0.025548337027430534, -0.035253431648015976, 0.06326909363269806, 0.04172421619296074, 0.025207003578543663, 0.03217555955052376, 0.02255409210920334, -0.01131921075284481, -0.05033691227436066, 0.015543964691460133, 0.019640788435935974, -0.048316892236471176, -0.043037403374910355, 0.04504856839776039, 0.008117064833641052, -0.020831486210227013, -0.034691277891397476, 0.028310148045420647, -0.05347975343465805, -0.01734747923910618, -0.014708874747157097, 0.006044209469109774, 0.005392253864556551, 0.04646076634526253, 0.008430542424321175, 0.03293373063206673, 0.06735342741012573, 0.03875555843114853, -0.027111634612083435, -0.0009667865815572441, 0.07659821957349777, 0.044731367379426956, 0.024021709337830544, -0.02955746091902256, 0.06527727097272873, -0.028993304818868637, -0.03921831399202347, 0.013042903505265713, 0.04358692467212677, -0.03932567313313484, -0.06129370257258415, 0.05831532180309296, 0.09145703166723251, 0.006530468817800283, 0.061195582151412964, -0.05251539126038551, 0.0034283928107470274, 0.03713638707995415, 0.012369188480079174, -0.00006277874490479007, 0.045836444944143295, 0.008368934504687786, 0.0147627554833889, -0.024524366483092308, -0.027422377839684486, -0.004745648242533207, -0.027805035933852196, 0.019825568422675133, 0.03328816220164299, -0.02686230093240738, 0.02126697450876236, -0.015085509046912193, 0.019952526316046715, 0.08981404453516006, -0.025967570021748543, -0.041905876249074936, 0.002397014293819666, 0.017844131216406822, -0.004141281358897686, 0.008519032970070839, 0.0019319741986691952, -0.04102584347128868, 0.03263818100094795, -0.037365105003118515, 0.02802586928009987, 0.02172311395406723, -0.002862005727365613, 0.01702939160168171, -0.026056677103042603, -0.02657504566013813, 0.02407904341816902, 0.018073847517371178, -0.055835574865341187, -0.036934781819581985, -0.046882666647434235, -0.05398377776145935, -0.06126007065176964, -0.04113537445664406, 0.027755694463849068, -0.01965305767953396, -0.05611906573176384, -0.01840195804834366, -0.014085240662097931, 0.009175267070531845, 0.04133683070540428, -0.06815094500780106, 0.00441325269639492, 0.043014656752347946, -0.027352619916200638, -0.014772028662264347, 0.05497518554329872, 0.04114504158496857, -0.007503969129174948, -0.020925626158714294, 0.03519175946712494, 0.01799248345196247, -0.002426177728921175, -0.0015440188581123948, -0.02258390747010708, -0.1029425635933876, 0.023758364841341972, 0.01904796063899994, -0.0704876184463501, -0.07421042025089264, 0.04405367746949196, -0.05078482627868652, 0.04042705148458481, 0.07185417413711548, -0.010243917815387249, 0.010630196891725063, -0.02418842352926731, -0.02987046353518963, -0.017165647819638252, -0.009912517853081226, 0.06539075821638107, -0.0024477439001202583, 0.0741804838180542, 0.05124529451131821, -0.012243803590536118, -0.0061914799734950066, 0.025194991379976273, -0.036150168627500534, -0.0036846091970801353, -0.0408945307135582, -0.011532922275364399, -0.014982352964580059, -0.10656040906906128, -0.01147034764289856, 0.030575618147850037, -0.009496030397713184, -0.05211899057030678, 0.013278274796903133, -0.02062746323645115, 0.024616094306111336, -0.04856390133500099, -0.020471777766942978, -0.027060892432928085, -0.03193442523479462, -0.024203896522521973, -0.015302064828574657, 0.01457416731864214, -0.009558762423694134, 0.0631789043545723, -0.012389685027301311, -0.05112367495894432, 0.0011678999289870262, 0.006496142596006393, 0.045615240931510925, 0.00004335197081672959, 0.032956741750240326, -0.011785589158535004 ]
3,514
BirdSet: A Large-Scale Dataset for Audio Classification in Avian Bioacoustics
https://openreview.net/forum?id=dRXxFEY8ZE
[ "Lukas Rauch", "Raphael Schwinger", "Moritz Wirth", "René Heinrich", "Denis Huseljic", "Marek Herde", "Jonas Lange", "Stefan Kahl", "Bernhard Sick", "Sven Tomforde", "Christoph Scholz" ]
Spotlight
Deep learning (DL) has greatly advanced audio classification, yet the field is limited by the scarcity of large-scale benchmark datasets that have propelled progress in other domains. While AudioSet is a pivotal step to bridge this gap as a universal-domain dataset, its restricted accessibility and limited range of evaluation use cases challenge its role as the sole resource. Therefore, we introduce BirdSet, a large-scale benchmark data set for audio classification focusing on avian bioacoustics. BirdSet surpasses AudioSet with over 6,800 recording hours ($\uparrow17\%$) from nearly 10,000 classes ($\uparrow18\times$) for training and more than 400 hours ($\uparrow7\times$) across eight strongly labeled evaluation datasets. It serves as a versatile resource for use cases such as multi-label classification, covariate shift or self-supervised learning. We benchmark six well-known DL models in multi-label classification across three distinct training scenarios and outline further evaluation use cases in audio classification. We host our dataset on Hugging Face for easy accessibility and offer an extensive codebase to reproduce our results.
audio classification, multi-label, dataset collection, bioacoustics
We introduce BirdSet, a multipurpose and large-scale dataset collection for audio classification.
6,728
2403.10380
[ 0.0007239140686579049, -0.03132535144686699, -0.04265379533171654, 0.04311041161417961, 0.037358615547418594, 0.04373495653271675, 0.0527355894446373, -0.009682517498731613, -0.009309758432209492, -0.04547717049717903, -0.007356294896453619, -0.0012555754510685802, -0.08377376943826675, -0.016721416264772415, -0.03124173916876316, 0.049255747348070145, 0.013811546377837658, -0.019209124147892, 0.03078698180615902, 0.010227274149656296, -0.024305813014507294, -0.035295337438583374, -0.006508874706923962, 0.04888075217604637, 0.027966471388936043, -0.015481136739253998, -0.007225808687508106, 0.027695897966623306, -0.015084391459822655, 0.02960452251136303, 0.035114750266075134, -0.004818806424736977, 0.005884913261979818, -0.04176424816250801, 0.018744610249996185, 0.02580571547150612, -0.03291764855384827, -0.00471120560541749, 0.011140712536871433, -0.0016548044513911009, -0.035628385841846466, -0.017205115407705307, -0.014495429582893848, 0.021067321300506592, -0.05775248259305954, 0.05165059491991997, -0.10397893190383911, 0.041833821684122086, 0.0009186862735077739, -0.008820539340376854, -0.07752345502376556, 0.0017102238489314914, -0.005228142719715834, -0.04238859564065933, 0.012889780104160309, 0.03361485153436661, 0.003499432699754834, -0.08419077843427658, -0.01782783307135105, -0.059736281633377075, -0.013131901621818542, 0.011685502715408802, 0.013374296016991138, -0.0381549634039402, 0.002272054087370634, -0.008540147915482521, 0.007824190892279148, 0.034872740507125854, -0.04337906092405319, -0.01897467114031315, -0.0037552767898887396, 0.027072181925177574, -0.01865704171359539, -0.00298874219879508, -0.009637473151087761, -0.050873033702373505, 0.014626520685851574, 0.013146094046533108, 0.10846395045518875, -0.0011393603635951877, 0.028852174058556557, 0.050107192248106, 0.025733504444360733, 0.03809799998998642, -0.03126378357410431, -0.013537194579839706, -0.03228044882416725, -0.013724020682275295, -0.09366662800312042, 0.05052945017814636, -0.003661563154309988, -0.06660889089107513, 0.03135259822010994, 0.0698312446475029, 0.009196961298584938, 0.03096839413046837, 0.011173166334629059, -0.013668131083250046, 0.03944002836942673, 0.01734972558915615, -0.03607405349612236, -0.023943787440657616, 0.04365377128124237, 0.03206322714686394, -0.10303359478712082, 0.0010853925487026572, -0.03759466111660004, -0.020539721474051476, -0.01573399268090725, 0.024028798565268517, -0.012532467022538185, -0.040895976126194, 0.011711983010172844, -0.003632022300735116, -0.07073774188756943, 0.04267500340938568, 0.012838847003877163, -0.005763818509876728, 0.026592550799250603, -0.01280670240521431, 0.0398106686770916, 0.06887304037809372, -0.015524697490036488, 0.04380721226334572, -0.004437657538801432, -0.019652321934700012, 0.028740987181663513, 0.005304757505655289, -0.009480413049459457, -0.03449440374970436, 0.000013292467883729842, 0.023706307634711266, 0.010200592689216137, 0.022383006289601326, 0.018356582149863243, -0.0029202918522059917, 0.010565544478595257, -0.008782400749623775, 0.05248907580971718, 0.04493533447384834, 0.006320612970739603, -0.023237669840455055, 0.01215443667024374, -0.019995996728539467, 0.09064426273107529, -0.007359025534242392, -0.016406601294875145, -0.01794050820171833, -0.02213205024600029, 0.0005732404533773661, 0.0058818599209189415, 0.017437782138586044, -0.034426137804985046, -0.05855632945895195, 0.013608237728476524, 0.015285736881196499, 0.011194831691682339, 0.02884884551167488, 0.008034654892981052, 0.0140707828104496, 0.031513433903455734, 0.005600794684141874, -0.03386283665895462, -0.010547389276325703, 0.0008577706757932901, -0.05324005335569382, 0.004461160395294428, 0.028928330168128014, -0.05711110681295395, 0.005629862193018198, -0.06328713148832321, -0.04875273257493973, 0.06660253554582596, 0.02015715278685093, -0.011736283078789711, -0.03730124980211258, 0.044526152312755585, 0.008034499362111092, 0.015115930698812008, 0.06257757544517517, -0.09141060709953308, 0.04358461871743202, 0.025800498202443123, -0.007242805324494839, 0.028042834252119064, -0.008868838660418987, 0.09138067066669464, -0.027378948405385017, 0.024330120533704758, 0.0021221700590103865, -0.06836596876382828, -0.04075729101896286, 0.01918364316225052, 0.006258857902139425, 0.04836971312761307, 0.0060090492479503155, 0.005256934091448784, 0.05069218948483467, 0.03020901046693325, 0.0654497891664505, 0.05204343423247337, -0.02539597637951374, 0.03905634582042694, -0.05089229345321655, -0.03542661294341087, 0.0163369569927454, 0.023227741941809654, -0.07351986318826675, -0.017010223120450974, -0.030668694525957108, 0.010467728599905968, 0.023301035165786743, 0.019019948318600655, 0.012914074584841728, 0.020550547167658806, 0.027103282511234283, 0.026730608195066452, 0.03293566033244133, -0.007568471133708954, -0.07507845759391785, 0.032441288232803345, 0.027108538895845413, -0.004230741877108812, -0.007329478394240141, -0.033046092838048935, 0.07977820187807083, 0.06730196624994278, -0.03870648145675659, -0.013347972184419632, 0.004488092847168446, 0.003625879529863596, 0.01261512003839016, -0.014660044573247433, 0.008777015842497349, 0.001893009408377111, 0.0028124689124524593, -0.002434446243569255, -0.031902920454740524, 0.05602727085351944, -0.03656826540827751, 0.013956749811768532, 0.03936682641506195, -0.0048125428147614, 0.06351003795862198, 0.02769976481795311, 0.01974550075829029, 0.04311908036470413, -0.036973122507333755, -0.027981337159872055, -0.048684898763895035, 0.016901355236768723, 0.007881210185587406, -0.014069125056266785, -0.010000737383961678, -0.015387707389891148, -0.06529099494218826, -0.03561563789844513, -0.02118770405650139, 0.059769775718450546, 0.03957216069102287, -0.0033753172028809786, 0.05820848420262337, -0.0030848642345517874, -0.020025724545121193, -0.0031959007028490305, -0.14461767673492432, -0.02244909666478634, -0.025805974379181862, 0.08442356437444687, -0.043109145015478134, 0.06189863011240959, 0.022750264033675194, 0.014522385783493519, -0.01335842628031969, -0.03734137490391731, 0.03551509231328964, 0.0409320704638958, -0.030598554760217667, -0.02490961365401745, -0.013716872781515121, 0.01293240673840046, 0.07863803952932358, -0.03442898020148277, -0.03853119909763336, 0.0012888122582808137, -0.040869299322366714, -0.015596545301377773, -0.05689045041799545, 0.01740672066807747, 0.002520659239962697, 0.026987407356500626, 0.022475751116871834, 0.002605572110041976, 0.029209282249212265, 0.03037209063768387, 0.024589113891124725, 0.03759633004665375, -0.01050063781440258, -0.015375238843262196, 0.006702960468828678, -0.01425238698720932, 0.02681032381951809, -0.020242052152752876, 0.026735898107290268, -0.016631117090582848, -0.0019012328702956438, 0.027003232389688492, -0.0025163099635392427, -0.26873910427093506, -0.008291230536997318, 0.03840668499469757, 0.0048584965988993645, 0.04951976239681244, -0.04718410223722458, 0.05242651328444481, -0.052628859877586365, -0.01879836618900299, -0.006991380825638771, -0.0291011780500412, 0.04748891294002533, 0.022137342020869255, 0.04844090715050697, 0.03406864032149315, 0.010596835985779762, -0.023081734776496887, -0.02427852898836136, 0.008570630103349686, 0.0589783750474453, 0.013808093033730984, -0.04484427347779274, -0.00007090409053489566, 0.03875664621591568, -0.0175965316593647, 0.03918380290269852, -0.049233488738536835, -0.018763700500130653, -0.0332423597574234, -0.03201260045170784, 0.03286520391702652, -0.03656620532274246, 0.016350818797945976, 0.03690999001264572, -0.008943534456193447, 0.016230914741754532, 0.04751961678266525, 0.005945134907960892, 0.014118808321654797, 0.012921077199280262, -0.018704351037740707, -0.05106954276561737, -0.006909281946718693, 0.01764894649386406, 0.06681771576404572, 0.03145375847816467, -0.030684715136885643, -0.034475330263376236, -0.008844216354191303, 0.04165327548980713, -0.013962535187602043, -0.017476553097367287, -0.02369825169444084, -0.025546878576278687, 0.006949021015316248, -0.027739671990275383, 0.015701841562986374, 0.0024741636589169502, 0.023933738470077515, 0.024228299036622047, 0.0345463827252388, -0.03788074851036072, -0.03275192156434059, -0.03707490116357803, 0.006829512305557728, -0.042808447033166885, -0.07478644698858261, -0.046261534094810486, 0.03745541349053383, 0.033978257328271866, 0.005791079718619585, 0.03158385679125786, -0.043574314564466476, -0.11499534547328949, 0.02374347671866417, -0.031756095588207245, -0.027665840461850166, -0.027017388492822647, 0.01472519151866436, 0.07022204995155334, -0.016444068402051926, -0.06924641132354736, -0.004997791722416878, 0.009991294704377651, 0.01108144037425518, -0.03535820543766022, 0.003714909078553319, 0.005120308604091406, -0.021246299147605896, -0.01859547197818756, 0.017574621364474297, -0.03731526806950569, -0.020261725410819054, -0.0066584148444235325, 0.041893355548381805, 0.05499434098601341, 0.027336539700627327, 0.0662241205573082, 0.04700874909758568, 0.03201725333929062, 0.024284906685352325, -0.04801848158240318, -0.02409646101295948, -0.06944092363119125, 0.002875039353966713, -0.012808636762201786, -0.024244990199804306, -0.029038965702056885, 0.07570524513721466, 0.029251480475068092, -0.008657650090754032, -0.05259953811764717, 0.02808167040348053, -0.04520457610487938, 0.005584831349551678, -0.032895833253860474, 0.01948375627398491, 0.011425706557929516, 0.05225678160786629, -0.004276783671230078, 0.01647220365703106, 0.03333038091659546, -0.005547652952373028, 0.017951976507902145, -0.005946966353803873, -0.02570115588605404, 0.03410591185092926, -0.028136497363448143, -0.06450620293617249, -0.04954583942890167, 0.037941500544548035, -0.004971246235072613, -0.020458167418837547, 0.008738948032259941, 0.05137617513537407, 0.008075552992522717, -0.02480645291507244, 0.00047333742259070277, 0.03248418867588043, -0.012790738604962826, 0.014818894676864147, -0.028120385482907295, 0.050332408398389816, 0.037909217178821564, -0.0006110993563197553, 0.04185578599572182, -0.0043362160213291645, -0.011028135195374489, -0.009279236197471619, -0.036658041179180145, 0.025680232793092728, -0.03563434258103371, -0.028425822034478188, -0.01857670210301876, 0.029058679938316345, -0.021402522921562195, 0.0313386432826519, 0.006205328274518251, 0.014333877712488174, -0.0755123645067215, 0.03683961555361748, -0.03081323392689228, -0.004035853780806065, -0.03475995734333992, 0.02512567862868309, 0.055740587413311005, 0.010959052480757236, -0.022123871371150017, 0.024005945771932602, -0.02140880934894085, 0.02014455944299698, -0.033378250896930695, -0.016117596998810768, 0.007212772965431213, -0.014662245288491249, -0.010511785745620728, 0.017313603311777115, -0.01694280095398426, -0.04134271666407585, 0.05777431279420853, 0.018222389742732048, -0.01703265681862831, 0.018804345279932022, 0.006571620237082243, 0.078304223716259, 0.04761883243918419, 0.005807927809655666, 0.02413415163755417, -0.010891460813581944, 0.015027527697384357, -0.03263110667467117, 0.0005044165882281959, -0.03487374633550644, -0.01755635254085064, -0.026533449068665504, -0.03613440319895744, 0.019237587228417397, 0.004896753467619419, -0.02972794696688652, -0.054635293781757355, -0.005033836234360933, 0.0010750108631327748, -0.009435909800231457, 0.002948582638055086, 0.012966967187821865, -0.08495680242776871, 0.017360616475343704, 0.019715864211320877, -0.04499135538935661, 0.01452349592000246, -0.011242400854825974, -0.04849524423480034, -0.05748172476887703, -0.0009417735273018479, 0.016474522650241852, -0.019554030150175095, -0.014926125295460224, -0.02129913680255413, -0.010196465067565441, -0.019683068618178368, -0.0026953050401061773, -0.03218436986207962, 0.005452165380120277, -0.009266603738069534, -0.03461451083421707, 0.047221578657627106, -0.023132292553782463, 0.019232330843806267, -0.018380066379904747, -0.02530021220445633, 0.011788963340222836, -0.017156409099698067, 0.013541522435843945, 0.04123526066541672, -0.022603275254368782, -0.009297601878643036, -0.036813363432884216, 0.014295341446995735, 0.047395944595336914, 0.02730843424797058, -0.007583133410662413, 0.02956317737698555, -0.032106779515743256, 0.017979487776756287, -0.02005704864859581, -0.0006561559857800603, 0.0022258798126131296, 0.041113823652267456, 0.010783662088215351, -0.0026414580643177032, 0.006706252694129944, 0.03579038754105568, -0.03861172869801521, 0.004321218468248844, 0.04571555182337761, -0.0239605400711298, -0.01059993077069521, -0.052355557680130005, -0.03842593729496002, 0.036858931183815, -0.00861651822924614, 0.029422743245959282, -0.035199929028749466, 0.06809501349925995, 0.03588298708200455, -0.007031386252492666, -0.01078270934522152, -0.034113578498363495, 0.031286031007766724, -0.03085828199982643, 0.03213087096810341, -0.06168530136346817, -0.07475417107343674, 0.06227631866931915, -0.015915952622890472, 0.00026121080736629665, 0.0075502581894397736, -0.028922343626618385, 0.05004151165485382, -0.006188089959323406, -0.04459760710597038, 0.02936738170683384, -0.050541382282972336, 0.0012907878262922168, -0.01790945790708065, -0.015865059569478035, 0.00046793994260951877, -0.01894764043390751, -0.003509080270305276, -0.03589002788066864, 0.030508557334542274, 0.040835555642843246, -0.02539089135825634, 0.027023745700716972, -0.0031565590761601925, 0.0002154285612050444, 0.005525234621018171, 0.030730053782463074, 0.04838515445590019, -0.009459419175982475, -0.04227122664451599, 0.05924040824174881, 0.04668720066547394, -0.014288980513811111, -0.004702480509877205, -0.0032301393803209066, 0.00015848012117203325, -0.06921090930700302, 0.00968635268509388, -0.011043135076761246, -0.018571805208921432, -0.042493656277656555, 0.049714285880327225, 0.0338430292904377, -0.04207884892821312, 0.029985632747411728, 0.018158961087465286, -0.05632573366165161, 0.039118532091379166, 0.014958830550312996, -0.007648108992725611, -0.044388629496097565, 0.04504216089844704, 0.06153567135334015, 0.04017460346221924, 0.05968291684985161, -0.009934165515005589, -0.011702929623425007, 0.02563915029168129, 0.04742731153964996, 0.03440528362989426, 0.04413187503814697, -0.010041150264441967, 0.052828963845968246, -0.03659285232424736, -0.06251316517591476, 0.03989865258336067, 0.05094289407134056, -0.01263071782886982, -0.025310778990387917, 0.03537338599562645, 0.06257059425115585, 0.034405164420604706, 0.053465548902750015, -0.04766072705388069, 0.005178049672394991, 0.009895686991512775, -0.0011598514392971992, 0.001664317212998867, 0.0563170351088047, -0.011454696767032146, 0.036656495183706284, -0.013304689899086952, -0.030098257586359978, 0.0020608357153832912, -0.017686335369944572, 0.02161194570362568, 0.03180178254842758, -0.01440567895770073, 0.02994929440319538, -0.003131281351670623, 0.07128212600946426, 0.06659284979104996, -0.025526301935315132, -0.04346649348735809, 0.0029622383881360292, 0.02103746496140957, 0.023848719894886017, 0.03618546947836876, -0.0045608882792294025, -0.03379293158650398, -0.0009058388532139361, -0.05794687196612358, -0.008723139762878418, 0.00678534060716629, 0.007637998089194298, -0.005096195265650749, -0.05526965111494064, -0.06942979991436005, 0.04738575965166092, -0.007662834599614143, -0.050275713205337524, -0.044818200170993805, -0.03195416182279587, 0.01532378513365984, -0.04448636248707771, -0.06573338806629181, 0.023768523707985878, -0.010570836253464222, -0.02761841006577015, -0.022117434069514275, -0.02256418764591217, 0.0201449915766716, 0.033963724970817566, -0.05258207395672798, -0.042796798050403595, 0.05172760784626007, -0.004902145359665155, -0.007993784733116627, 0.02565230056643486, 0.05296799913048744, -0.000684433791320771, -0.05048792064189911, 0.03632549196481705, 0.012591606006026268, 0.009095549583435059, -0.028573516756296158, 0.009836024604737759, -0.07913651317358017, 0.04468664526939392, 0.01932995207607746, -0.008625080808997154, -0.0777609646320343, 0.020547352731227875, 0.00655475165694952, 0.042874425649642944, 0.04627698287367821, 0.014988836832344532, -0.0029903575778007507, -0.01609080843627453, -0.013362218625843525, -0.011371063068509102, -0.002145141828805208, 0.033561840653419495, -0.005449321120977402, 0.045971352607011795, 0.029780849814414978, -0.016935190185904503, -0.03746689110994339, 0.043824825435876846, -0.027865365147590637, 0.021556708961725235, -0.03913262113928795, -0.0524529367685318, -0.03337506204843521, -0.10455958545207977, -0.007856767624616623, 0.024677759036421776, -0.0293992068618536, -0.02700158581137657, 0.02342722751200199, -0.00980547908693552, -0.00080202950630337, 0.0022900027688592672, -0.03360357880592346, -0.02442110702395439, -0.007069240789860487, -0.05213107168674469, -0.0863526239991188, -0.001534359180368483, -0.0176484826952219, 0.013213707134127617, -0.018983906134963036, -0.030690576881170273, -0.022887932136654854, -0.018380330875515938, 0.04846017807722092, 0.05234247073531151, -0.0020430884324014187, -0.03982635959982872 ]
3,515
SePer: Measure Retrieval Utility Through The Lens Of Semantic Perplexity Reduction
https://openreview.net/forum?id=ixMBnOhFGd
[ "Lu Dai", "Yijie Xu", "Jinhui Ye", "Hao Liu", "Hui Xiong" ]
Spotlight
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated improved generation performance by incorporating externally retrieved knowledge, a process known as retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Despite the potential of this approach, existing studies evaluate RAG effectiveness by 1) assessing retrieval and generation components jointly, which obscures retrieval's distinct contribution, or 2) examining retrievers using traditional metrics such as NDCG, which creates a gap in understanding retrieval's true utility in the overall generation process. To address the above limitations, in this work, we introduce an automatic evaluation method that measures retrieval quality through the lens of information gain within the RAG framework. Specifically, we propose Semantic Perplexity (SePer), a metric that captures the LLM's internal belief about the correctness of the retrieved information. We quantify the utility of retrieval by the extent to which it reduces semantic perplexity post-retrieval. Extensive experiments demonstrate that SePer not only aligns closely with human preferences but also offers a more precise and efficient evaluation of retrieval utility across diverse RAG scenarios.
information retrieval, metric
null
6,677
2503.01478
[ -0.02788654714822769, -0.02281368523836136, -0.01997201330959797, 0.054766204208135605, 0.02541869878768921, -0.02343308925628662, 0.010976755991578102, -0.010926556773483753, -0.026936929672956467, -0.004183666314929724, -0.04398529231548309, 0.03475812077522278, -0.0504976361989975, -0.0028794528916478157, 0.01717645302414894, 0.05608846992254257, 0.014107751660048962, -0.011363557539880276, 0.01893913932144642, 0.002017082879319787, -0.01244149450212717, -0.02110152505338192, -0.0014936499064788222, -0.007240829057991505, 0.06214915215969086, 0.03533557429909706, 0.012682273052632809, -0.01286430936306715, -0.04101310670375824, 0.0030813240446150303, 0.021359674632549286, -0.02295999974012375, 0.004075885750353336, 0.0032344446517527103, -0.02014179900288582, -0.04072553291916847, -0.07176859676837921, 0.03538547083735466, 0.011728954501450062, -0.015644017606973648, -0.03929487615823746, 0.017389189451932907, 0.00917442049831152, 0.008231474086642265, -0.06583840399980545, 0.01123406644910574, -0.09283902496099472, 0.023416409268975258, -0.00834190845489502, 0.001638484071008861, -0.1113419234752655, 0.03250359371304512, 0.008847544901072979, -0.01167899090796709, 0.005986405070871115, 0.02612786740064621, 0.058876946568489075, -0.09198103100061417, 0.017827162519097328, -0.0044671292416751385, -0.040884338319301605, 0.004668652545660734, 0.030444344505667686, 0.0058708032593131065, 0.014398599974811077, -0.03490482270717621, -0.0030450932681560516, 0.016838645562529564, -0.05266178771853447, -0.030419547110795975, -0.01862066239118576, 0.0231343824416399, -0.018233375623822212, 0.013942964375019073, -0.0018122554756700993, -0.028617672622203827, 0.04238886386156082, 0.04855237156152725, 0.038334932178258896, 0.0015313811600208282, -0.017446056008338928, 0.02408984862267971, 0.008419680409133434, 0.04874316602945328, 0.04500826448202133, 0.008408170193433762, -0.05767136439681053, -0.010959603823721409, -0.04166282340884209, 0.043599244207143784, 0.002513682236894965, -0.043909139931201935, 0.038695164024829865, 0.03305169194936752, 0.003731912700459361, 0.019894365221261978, 0.04211653023958206, 0.022620294243097305, -0.005457680206745863, 0.004072853364050388, -0.01579401269555092, -0.02401905320584774, 0.03745061904191971, -0.021568121388554573, -0.12540538609027863, 0.012604664079844952, -0.03310311958193779, -0.030262630432844162, 0.027782488614320755, -0.012521554715931416, -0.012495297007262707, 0.004213734995573759, 0.030209511518478394, 0.035317279398441315, -0.04787396639585495, 0.015750950202345848, 0.018128126859664917, -0.002653292613103986, -0.009533551521599293, 0.014338534325361252, 0.048996519297361374, 0.025139985606074333, 0.02000272087752819, 0.07946252077817917, -0.021412786096334457, -0.004145908169448376, 0.01737588830292225, 0.0356857031583786, -0.06470195949077606, -0.03805555775761604, -0.0057117389515042305, 0.031402722001075745, -0.011842717416584492, 0.02278684452176094, -0.031512051820755005, 0.026579005643725395, 0.03797781094908714, 0.007522838655859232, 0.06814191490411758, -0.012256424874067307, -0.01836872100830078, -0.04008309543132782, -0.0012970813550055027, -0.021682359278202057, 0.07517676055431366, -0.005413401871919632, -0.019609568640589714, 0.001548891537822783, -0.0010296726832166314, 0.003268952015787363, 0.025625670328736305, -0.0001481779181631282, 0.0017711217515170574, -0.04520418867468834, 0.03315891698002815, 0.07498695701360703, 0.0016100286738947034, 0.008526255376636982, 0.01823517680168152, 0.006149881985038519, -0.031241558492183685, -0.007918654009699821, -0.05226557329297066, 0.03060789220035076, -0.012292273342609406, -0.04909800365567207, -0.006934825796633959, 0.027421539649367332, -0.03196609765291214, -0.013572119176387787, -0.03727375343441963, -0.0374886691570282, 0.052127618342638016, -0.05305617302656174, -0.04963071271777153, 0.004107143264263868, 0.05489419773221016, 0.04079463332891464, 0.0439971387386322, 0.020332640036940575, -0.07720346748828888, 0.0367513932287693, -0.01184618379920721, -0.01267821155488491, 0.019908994436264038, 0.0009175526793114841, 0.09399720281362534, 0.0010930257849395275, 0.01766943745315075, 0.017452703788876534, -0.08544448763132095, -0.030402453616261482, 0.010720462538301945, 0.0007833410636521876, 0.03555499017238617, 0.013762068934738636, 0.03924095258116722, 0.08545324206352234, 0.014826307073235512, 0.03679396212100983, 0.05823417007923126, -0.012072642333805561, 0.04259343072772026, -0.024275584146380424, -0.021715404465794563, -0.020102819427847862, 0.007039761170744896, -0.04537377879023552, -0.053978025913238525, 0.015128067694604397, -0.009189765900373459, 0.023474829271435738, -0.004996344912797213, -0.009132239036262035, -0.03200453892350197, 0.010823856107890606, 0.016308100894093513, -0.012689411640167236, -0.012670347467064857, -0.0464106984436512, 0.052791282534599304, 0.0019054278964176774, 0.028193889185786247, 0.008207599632441998, -0.03531960770487785, 0.10477681457996368, 0.05303335189819336, -0.014241423457860947, 0.02486020140349865, 0.062815822660923, 0.016083478927612305, 0.0035239316057413816, 0.005639767739921808, -0.02789025567471981, -0.02823708765208721, 0.005396917928010225, -0.023337846621870995, -0.0197138674557209, 0.0665154755115509, -0.021363839507102966, -0.0381956472992897, 0.04489222913980484, -0.043567027896642685, 0.057385921478271484, 0.026082677766680717, 0.01527857780456543, 0.02923336997628212, -0.0076292031444609165, -0.01899406500160694, -0.04668614640831947, -0.01576559618115425, -0.0038350692484527826, -0.020068395882844925, -0.03429717943072319, 0.01683640293776989, -0.03605895861983299, 0.014250433072447777, -0.010694997385144234, 0.01905439794063568, 0.058423738926649094, 0.00434185191988945, 0.040326137095689774, 0.015658285468816757, -0.06978178024291992, 0.01596047542989254, -0.08119604736566544, -0.011602078564465046, -0.03542971611022949, -0.005034150555729866, 0.0032616734970360994, 0.04624057561159134, -0.0020235248375684023, 0.031738318502902985, -0.003278252435848117, -0.036035072058439255, 0.009278964251279831, 0.04433321952819824, 0.007355296518653631, -0.0647394210100174, -0.022272715345025063, -0.020459681749343872, 0.01707962341606617, -0.023222478106617928, -0.02830425463616848, -0.02825312130153179, -0.04335653781890869, 0.027737366035580635, -0.036644890904426575, -0.007755608297884464, 0.013318640179932117, 0.0005984791787341237, -0.004054427612572908, 0.0006582686328329146, 0.00042787945130839944, 0.08017382025718689, 0.032944515347480774, 0.05038674548268318, 0.03171651065349579, 0.003263915190473199, 0.037193674594163895, -0.03445101156830788, -0.001009801751933992, 0.028818372637033463, 0.040186308324337006, 0.00405542179942131, -0.029268832877278328, -0.005234257783740759, -0.002529654186218977, -0.28370192646980286, -0.026276029646396637, 0.003436111379414797, -0.02892102301120758, 0.024044370278716087, -0.0027076557744294405, 0.02176905982196331, -0.04672587662935257, -0.009297573007643223, 0.0011219264706596732, 0.01575399376451969, 0.014856765978038311, 0.0171714648604393, 0.06218317523598671, 0.05788097530603409, 0.042519185692071915, 0.02014906518161297, -0.007770235650241375, -0.0027339919470250607, 0.03466714918613434, 0.0011124463053420186, -0.04978227987885475, -0.0581621378660202, 0.03856759890913963, -0.005181274376809597, 0.025772608816623688, -0.06372196227312088, -0.0064790258184075356, -0.052108511328697205, -0.018388479948043823, 0.020299997180700302, 0.0008015907951630652, 0.007234053686261177, 0.044387053698301315, -0.01705343648791313, -0.009555348195135593, 0.05173899233341217, 0.00819281954318285, 0.03132779523730278, 0.02136049047112465, 0.029405536130070686, -0.025813478976488113, -0.006092185154557228, -0.004028927534818649, 0.04936116561293602, -0.02806914784014225, -0.05381316319108009, -0.018951360136270523, -0.003214403986930847, 0.05578097328543663, -0.022861002013087273, -0.024788064882159233, -0.03512108698487282, 0.02861972153186798, 0.007778162136673927, -0.05522855371236801, 0.018837355077266693, -0.030686844140291214, -0.04122323915362358, -0.021798348054289818, 0.01466484647244215, -0.048968974500894547, -0.004402541555464268, -0.013106492348015308, -0.04215500131249428, -0.01774768903851509, -0.06601976603269577, -0.05129526928067207, 0.03281313553452492, 0.055784884840250015, -0.03559726104140282, 0.04478469863533974, 0.012191110290586948, -0.07654229551553726, -0.0020612378139048815, 0.004310798365622759, -0.01890772394835949, -0.00932620745152235, -0.017135966569185257, 0.03560003265738487, -0.053107019513845444, -0.03904902935028076, -0.005624281708151102, 0.04432336241006851, 0.0023489489685744047, -0.030310317873954773, 0.0018576958682388067, -0.038952987641096115, -0.03718516230583191, -0.025684963911771774, 0.039803192019462585, -0.00026353306020610034, -0.019876139238476753, 0.02842787653207779, 0.04403390735387802, 0.029191330075263977, 0.006272258702665567, 0.0745348408818245, 0.05066487938165665, 0.0241131279617548, 0.027408985421061516, -0.06826645880937576, 0.011713709682226181, -0.010642471723258495, -0.013162879273295403, 0.03466208651661873, -0.06084079295396805, -0.030785365030169487, 0.03291651979088783, -0.02618105709552765, -0.045824773609638214, -0.009687593206763268, -0.014952774159610271, 0.02422001212835312, -0.012205378152430058, -0.0008492115302942693, 0.0054704854264855385, 0.043526068329811096, 0.004841125104576349, -0.016328463330864906, -0.03627393767237663, 0.0013841134496033192, -0.01264371071010828, -0.012863018549978733, -0.01568865217268467, -0.04378197342157364, -0.011514266952872276, -0.032946281135082245, 0.015104477293789387, -0.002370512578636408, 0.033706214278936386, -0.0058737825602293015, 0.0071822162717580795, -0.00384504534304142, 0.05256251245737076, -0.01993049681186676, 0.010795263573527336, 0.0058017694391310215, 0.006068800576031208, -0.008048650808632374, -0.010590577498078346, -0.03387722373008728, 0.03111479990184307, 0.04607664421200752, 0.005332876928150654, 0.0007951063453219831, 0.014264602214097977, 0.005606599152088165, -0.017407959327101707, 0.0024447417818009853, 0.03098856471478939, -0.04147902876138687, -0.015973364934325218, -0.043034628033638, 0.0033622512128204107, -0.009684099815785885, 0.04397986829280853, -0.0015363411512225866, 0.022045519202947617, -0.07672026008367538, 0.04663189873099327, -0.0162341445684433, 0.02060518227517605, -0.010501762852072716, 0.022756485268473625, 0.01566307246685028, -0.017059899866580963, 0.024712800979614258, 0.035786841064691544, 0.03656424582004547, 0.004955742042511702, -0.02945251576602459, 0.00056117819622159, 0.006304447073489428, -0.016042524948716164, 0.002561332192271948, 0.015467454679310322, 0.009753279387950897, -0.01887906901538372, 0.05204163119196892, 0.02883612923324108, 0.0027489708736538887, 0.00009716141357785091, 0.025960225611925125, 0.08448415249586105, 0.02719227410852909, 0.029758842661976814, 0.006346250884234905, -0.05085420981049538, 0.012939107604324818, -0.017447130754590034, 0.009777371771633625, -0.016128376126289368, -0.034511249512434006, -0.038671620190143585, -0.07688155770301819, 0.027102269232273102, 0.017424440011382103, -0.018989095464348793, -0.01572137326002121, 0.007197380065917969, -0.00856930110603571, -0.0441301129758358, -0.03492975980043411, 0.020032787695527077, -0.06480780988931656, -0.009238380007445812, -0.01094738207757473, -0.024165790528059006, 0.020838499069213867, -0.03486356884241104, -0.058430228382349014, -0.06741443276405334, 0.0023402362130582333, 0.04862368479371071, -0.004460812080651522, -0.04003836214542389, -0.020335303619503975, 0.00354915508069098, 0.004223069176077843, 0.0229115579277277, -0.03969767317175865, 0.011879287660121918, -0.0031236486975103617, 0.03217724338173866, 0.05765102431178093, -0.03214626759290695, -0.050825703889131546, -0.03170672431588173, -0.05542973056435585, 0.017201893031597137, -0.06337811797857285, 0.04510747641324997, 0.059318285435438156, -0.005041218362748623, -0.008748870342969894, -0.037614721804857254, 0.034065090119838715, -0.0016855660360306501, -0.0029845901299268007, 0.00019507970137055963, -0.03662559390068054, -0.02140984497964382, 0.017562568187713623, -0.0015500858426094055, 0.02983882464468479, 0.0004559062363114208, -0.014147138223052025, -0.021100526675581932, 0.0332922637462616, 0.009775812737643719, 0.015057393349707127, -0.06613274663686752, -0.019067050889134407, 0.07566506415605545, -0.015543879941105843, -0.036264367401599884, -0.1009059026837349, -0.05257108062505722, 0.019844472408294678, 0.005247334949672222, 0.028945192694664, -0.040852081030607224, 0.04893248900771141, 0.003495502285659313, 0.04594644904136658, -0.00034706518636085093, -0.0043741450645029545, 0.02468888647854328, -0.043649397790431976, -0.015629958361387253, -0.04198729991912842, -0.009292686358094215, 0.10124210268259048, -0.036861319094896317, -0.019826073199510574, -0.023634111508727074, -0.0428909994661808, 0.02880948595702648, -0.007666615303605795, -0.058324459940195084, -0.00033933421946130693, -0.0057134185917675495, 0.018493354320526123, 0.03964262083172798, -0.027084195986390114, -0.02561251074075699, -0.0009061305318027735, -0.0372149832546711, -0.021243492141366005, -0.011245721951127052, 0.06382429599761963, -0.04570166394114494, 0.017987394705414772, -0.01807912066578865, 0.003768505062907934, 0.03251146897673607, 0.09023892134428024, -0.00018625147640705109, 0.02822427824139595, -0.048408377915620804, 0.04132795333862305, 0.0456082746386528, -0.030941322445869446, 0.0421716570854187, -0.003098297631368041, -0.016881266608834267, -0.048751890659332275, 0.04221123084425926, -0.015356569550931454, -0.013990843668580055, -0.05118091031908989, 0.07699187099933624, 0.04304177314043045, -0.04415846988558769, -0.046526890248060226, 0.042959269136190414, -0.0236395001411438, 0.016593044623732567, -0.018396181985735893, -0.002286977134644985, -0.021864859387278557, 0.07172609865665436, 0.04068600386381149, 0.04980537295341492, 0.08295091241598129, -0.019306208938360214, -0.021829377859830856, 0.018062202259898186, 0.06394397467374802, 0.06495147198438644, 0.055314455181360245, -0.0009141515474766493, 0.0710156038403511, -0.004411222413182259, -0.037042245268821716, -0.00009283508552471176, 0.03418388217687607, -0.0048089297488331795, -0.04759879782795906, -0.015752164646983147, 0.03835052251815796, 0.0074678342789411545, 0.08018013089895248, -0.03363930433988571, -0.015453804284334183, 0.03688349202275276, 0.017000317573547363, 0.006529683247208595, 0.028028691187500954, 0.027653835713863373, 0.004593060351908207, -0.02252989076077938, -0.02946661412715912, 0.02082323469221592, -0.01609092578291893, 0.019846182316541672, -0.01005799975246191, -0.012009470723569393, 0.00992558989673853, -0.03696124255657196, 0.048514705151319504, 0.13138069212436676, -0.019283274188637733, -0.04401750862598419, 0.014895225875079632, 0.011096861213445663, 0.022020163014531136, 0.04273733124136925, 0.04065084084868431, 0.0005246926448307931, -0.028602786362171173, -0.04062936455011368, -0.017007838934659958, 0.0380043126642704, -0.009812437929213047, 0.03114527091383934, -0.008223790675401688, -0.01954381726682186, 0.017777219414711, 0.021766768768429756, -0.04053189978003502, -0.041035860776901245, -0.029286935925483704, -0.02386733703315258, -0.04842672497034073, -0.02519182674586773, 0.04632648453116417, 0.038543593138456345, -0.035151369869709015, 0.02387131378054619, -0.03624122217297554, 0.01171763427555561, 0.0279241893440485, -0.07453208416700363, 0.02220531739294529, 0.006270251702517271, 0.012595194391906261, -0.0014028612058609724, 0.041554491966962814, 0.034695446491241455, -0.032264042645692825, 0.000003907283826265484, 0.03628069534897804, -0.0013283772859722376, 0.02888723835349083, 0.007000217214226723, -0.03269069269299507, -0.10468391329050064, 0.010302056558430195, 0.014772872440516949, -0.04298755154013634, -0.08418983966112137, 0.012812012806534767, -0.01890924945473671, 0.01047539059072733, 0.056301940232515335, 0.03026796504855156, 0.03968043997883797, -0.019528843462467194, 0.013049493543803692, 0.03307962790131569, 0.024473601952195168, 0.04875660315155983, -0.02574673667550087, 0.04509437829256058, 0.018409373238682747, 0.030587179586291313, -0.07595520466566086, 0.03357403725385666, -0.009052705951035023, -0.022951357066631317, -0.04854416847229004, -0.015539382584393024, -0.048925526440143585, -0.10070887953042984, -0.05303493142127991, 0.010769917629659176, -0.043655093759298325, -0.020238647237420082, 0.010711472481489182, -0.007955269888043404, -0.026289965957403183, -0.04071244224905968, -0.009123221971094608, -0.01853676699101925, 0.00105121114756912, 0.005110630765557289, -0.051507025957107544, -0.003148491494357586, -0.023589232936501503, -0.007583999074995518, -0.014495919458568096, -0.028316518291831017, 0.009861210361123085, -0.0029593969229608774, 0.029220979660749435, -0.012197284027934074, 0.05388684943318367, -0.02320382557809353 ]
3,516
Physics-aligned field reconstruction with diffusion bridge
https://openreview.net/forum?id=D042vFwJAM
[ "Zeyu Li", "Hongkun Dou", "Shen Fang", "Wang Han", "Yue Deng", "Lijun Yang" ]
Spotlight
The reconstruction of physical fields from sparse measurements is pivotal in both scientific research and engineering applications. Traditional methods are increasingly supplemented by deep learning models due to their efficacy in extracting features from data. However, except for the low accuracy on complex physical systems, these models often fail to comply with essential physical constraints, such as governing equations and boundary conditions. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a novel data-driven field reconstruction framework, termed the Physics-aligned Schr\"{o}dinger Bridge (PalSB). This framework leverages a diffusion bridge mechanism that is specifically tailored to align with physical constraints. The PalSB approach incorporates a dual-stage training process designed to address both local reconstruction mapping and global physical principles. Additionally, a boundary-aware sampling technique is implemented to ensure adherence to physical boundary conditions. We demonstrate the effectiveness of PalSB through its application to three complex nonlinear systems: cylinder flow from Particle Image Velocimetry experiments, two-dimensional turbulence, and a reaction-diffusion system. The results reveal that PalSB not only achieves higher accuracy but also exhibits enhanced compliance with physical constraints compared to existing methods. This highlights PalSB's capability to generate high-quality representations of intricate physical interactions, showcasing its potential for advancing field reconstruction techniques. The source code can be found at https://github.com/lzy12301/PalSB.
Fluid dynamics, diffusion models, super-resolution
We propose a diffusion-based framework for the reconstruction of physical field with enhanced compliance with physical laws.
6,648
null
[ -0.04739268124103546, -0.016850929707288742, -0.003584030782803893, 0.029725119471549988, 0.03561990335583687, 0.00931713730096817, -0.004540201276540756, 0.00022363767493516207, -0.04912154749035835, -0.06479865312576294, 0.0366707518696785, -0.03077477589249611, -0.02351963333785534, 0.002129045082256198, 0.01984710432589054, 0.0561477392911911, 0.028041329234838486, -0.020287562161684036, 0.011100457049906254, 0.026391196995973587, -0.022242939099669456, -0.03694962337613106, 0.020845094695687294, 0.03490269184112549, 0.026674222201108932, -0.016840528696775436, 0.03179125487804413, 0.0020773529540747404, 0.010966219007968903, 0.037916067987680435, 0.027666939422488213, 0.019810710102319717, -0.028235912322998047, -0.06303867697715759, -0.009928406216204166, -0.002553818980231881, -0.05062209814786911, 0.011926228180527687, -0.024425311014056206, -0.006285977549850941, -0.03279760852456093, 0.01887360028922558, -0.014711289666593075, -0.039685990661382675, -0.03208630532026291, 0.01687851920723915, -0.07653190940618515, 0.044429581612348557, -0.020586714148521423, -0.03188994526863098, -0.08119089901447296, 0.012170474976301193, -0.005044387187808752, 0.04236160218715668, -0.02832978405058384, 0.016309889033436775, -0.0009599950863048434, -0.023892151191830635, -0.036796506494283676, -0.045126114040613174, 0.004650740418583155, 0.004658992867916822, -0.007797901518642902, -0.010746811516582966, 0.015197710134088993, -0.0386672280728817, -0.028501242399215698, 0.030157659202814102, -0.028498107567429543, -0.046414293348789215, 0.014835684560239315, -0.009448271244764328, 0.03416743874549866, -0.019925003871321678, 0.0436733141541481, -0.05834845080971718, 0.004573856480419636, 0.030409371480345726, 0.0640389621257782, 0.006392150651663542, 0.07148728519678116, 0.0016959202475845814, -0.00464569590985775, 0.019140781834721565, 0.027775267139077187, -0.005879469681531191, -0.0564507320523262, -0.004281098488718271, -0.04689675569534302, 0.03955051302909851, -0.018727218732237816, -0.043133631348609924, -0.005357692949473858, 0.054520342499017715, 0.07134025543928146, -0.005970308091491461, 0.017988242208957672, 0.006745833903551102, -0.0020781841594725847, -0.019795136526226997, -0.03794488310813904, -0.025967203080654144, 0.03347599878907204, 0.03715106099843979, -0.057304270565509796, -0.054631929844617844, -0.041283994913101196, -0.050250791013240814, -0.051461055874824524, 0.0013978721108287573, -0.01403870340436697, -0.014724118635058403, -0.007507116533815861, -0.024661321192979813, -0.108231320977211, 0.03323375806212425, 0.04456000775098801, 0.0015741889365017414, 0.05406715348362923, 0.00969719234853983, 0.0240988377481699, 0.03238542750477791, 0.005652104038745165, 0.056813377887010574, -0.004012634977698326, 0.031064338982105255, 0.016115989536046982, 0.0647985190153122, -0.0697394460439682, -0.0012179147452116013, -0.005079311318695545, 0.057786617428064346, -0.0064645735546946526, -0.0392010360956192, 0.031883977353572845, -0.008343959227204323, 0.02780395746231079, 0.03532041609287262, -0.00044209291809238493, -0.00551007641479373, 0.0044119455851614475, -0.02200295962393284, 0.06667894124984741, -0.015199452638626099, 0.05133899673819542, 0.0034435417037457228, 0.01113305613398552, -0.04199966415762901, -0.04364239424467087, 0.020575877279043198, -0.022042669355869293, 0.018798772245645523, 0.04910887032747269, -0.035527925938367844, -0.004734304267913103, 0.04979833960533142, 0.016611844301223755, 0.02405918389558792, -0.008601554669439793, -0.012726339511573315, 0.019699836149811745, -0.0545186921954155, 0.020747119560837746, 0.035357676446437836, -0.018084978684782982, -0.011681742034852505, 0.06565562635660172, 0.0012175451265648007, -0.023723626509308815, -0.010442190803587437, -0.026803936809301376, -0.021760232746601105, 0.03530802205204964, 0.009992605075240135, -0.0029554252978414297, -0.02054278925061226, 0.05073002725839615, 0.002488242695108056, 0.01667073927819729, -0.0034857422579079866, -0.07685031741857529, 0.02078673429787159, 0.006427818909287453, -0.011260881088674068, 0.024988563731312752, -0.003117035375908017, 0.07965153455734253, -0.012852037325501442, -0.02328512817621231, 0.03444693237543106, -0.06654346734285355, -0.000060452755860751495, 0.007810572162270546, -0.016654765233397484, 0.08101685345172882, -0.0026084145065397024, -0.013817721046507359, 0.02560250088572502, 0.0365624837577343, 0.034131478518247604, 0.003127937437966466, -0.031781069934368134, 0.0014460294041782618, -0.024320349097251892, -0.03847714513540268, -0.034177739173173904, 0.056034285575151443, -0.03950661048293114, -0.035305097699165344, -0.000009018386663228739, -0.025174321606755257, -0.011981946416199207, -0.006290598772466183, -0.04351237788796425, 0.040693704038858414, -0.02841082587838173, -0.04746311157941818, 0.010932141914963722, -0.0028885602951049805, -0.03617766126990318, 0.051403436809778214, 0.01782284304499626, -0.02557540498673916, 0.023341061547398567, -0.022223930805921555, 0.08919088542461395, 0.09543051570653915, -0.0371222123503685, -0.013194608502089977, 0.01610454171895981, 0.03796098008751869, 0.014001969248056412, 0.010199190117418766, -0.017897553741931915, 0.027639107778668404, -0.05394615978002548, 0.009978875517845154, -0.02066895179450512, 0.0803145095705986, -0.036033399403095245, -0.014084093272686005, 0.062429849058389664, -0.0033255608286708593, 0.07211516797542572, 0.014808695763349533, 0.028022190555930138, 0.06645426899194717, -0.04747428745031357, -0.03384954482316971, -0.03188161551952362, -0.012170840986073017, 0.02666112221777439, -0.021272148936986923, -0.038265030831098557, 0.0475824736058712, -0.07144814729690552, -0.037852559238672256, -0.0002899814280681312, 0.06912508606910706, 0.027284089475870132, 0.01847626455128193, -0.01053555402904749, -0.01851847767829895, -0.022831017151474953, -0.06173704192042351, -0.0986073687672615, -0.0024135049898177385, 0.011534051969647408, 0.022171519696712494, -0.01018949318677187, 0.008979850448668003, 0.009122734889388084, 0.026413898915052414, -0.03450672701001167, 0.010702216997742653, 0.016522156074643135, 0.039077743887901306, -0.008284606970846653, 0.0036962167359888554, -0.031945813447237015, 0.03820236399769783, 0.07302030175924301, -0.017894171178340912, -0.03915402665734291, 0.020064035430550575, -0.025974590331315994, 0.0015751754399389029, 0.0035535208880901337, -0.012107187882065773, 0.01780962198972702, 0.014250646345317364, -0.03470432013273239, -0.025676334276795387, 0.029859628528356552, 0.02786749228835106, 0.06347212940454483, 0.046855684369802475, -0.007582802791148424, -0.009932456538081169, 0.010697818361222744, -0.01978413388133049, 0.028035808354616165, -0.016840338706970215, -0.002971301320940256, -0.018220925703644753, -0.014281529001891613, 0.015407407656311989, -0.02107895165681839, -0.2757556736469269, 0.005518282763659954, -0.00802287831902504, -0.04186151921749115, 0.018249448388814926, 0.02207300253212452, 0.03823952376842499, -0.03218556195497513, -0.057478539645671844, -0.0156254842877388, -0.006508276332169771, 0.024771448224782944, 0.005899953190237284, 0.06385022401809692, 0.06470327824354172, 0.04276809096336365, 0.02659105882048607, -0.05388498306274414, 0.026942241936922073, 0.024181269109249115, -0.02789386175572872, -0.05376041680574417, -0.033812012523412704, 0.01184452697634697, -0.0024953654501587152, 0.004031070042401552, -0.05018727853894234, 0.008744068443775177, -0.03196591138839722, 0.006976936012506485, -0.01734732650220394, -0.03433847427368164, -0.021174918860197067, 0.043978363275527954, 0.016038833186030388, -0.014386803843080997, 0.025106649845838547, 0.021802445873618126, 0.03221108019351959, -0.013295996934175491, -0.011409148573875427, -0.0061810556799173355, -0.018748607486486435, 0.021154487505555153, 0.043741267174482346, 0.005229392554610968, -0.013795587234199047, 0.005267512984573841, 0.003975581377744675, 0.03622640296816826, 0.004825136158615351, -0.0030404755380004644, -0.0020385654643177986, -0.024217745289206505, 0.0018685613758862019, 0.003774762386456132, 0.02963671274483204, 0.03598488122224808, -0.010865261778235435, 0.014407929964363575, -0.0313197560608387, -0.03757135570049286, -0.04091113433241844, -0.01174698956310749, 0.03548377379775047, -0.05177099257707596, -0.07060275226831436, -0.0837968960404396, 0.04013040289282799, 0.02111968956887722, -0.0035828212276101112, -0.03358757123351097, -0.02150449901819229, -0.12181930243968964, 0.020986298099160194, 0.005445170681923628, 0.007879376411437988, -0.03357939049601555, -0.026692340150475502, 0.010098280385136604, -0.026829125359654427, -0.050635773688554764, 0.01331090647727251, 0.02204771153628826, 0.001990758115425706, -0.01280367374420166, 0.017577845603227615, -0.06673665344715118, -0.02053813636302948, -0.04605446010828018, 0.026365719735622406, -0.027072414755821228, 0.07602109760046005, -0.004514477215707302, 0.03986073285341263, 0.044604361057281494, 0.0008253762498497963, 0.06481654196977615, 0.038964394479990005, -0.018192995339632034, 0.03670298308134079, -0.06325000524520874, -0.02954958751797676, -0.02821987494826317, -0.007192953955382109, 0.02219288796186447, -0.03974669799208641, -0.0036877221427857876, 0.04723726212978363, 0.016890520229935646, -0.016520481556653976, -0.021888650953769684, 0.04351601377129555, -0.006263028830289841, -0.0029948800802230835, -0.003252247115597129, 0.010077440179884434, 0.041620057076215744, 0.025617340579628944, -0.015995508059859276, -0.004985903389751911, 0.02775578573346138, 0.021376539021730423, -0.006861377507448196, 0.00015904039901215583, 0.0018435933161526918, -0.035519327968358994, -0.00311342254281044, -0.004931654315441847, -0.017926080152392387, 0.04533212631940842, 0.05192721262574196, 0.0007131891907192767, 0.04578521102666855, 0.04780225828289986, 0.008277282118797302, 0.0015560623724013567, -0.026026273146271706, 0.043249115347862244, -0.03265289217233658, 0.02333385869860649, -0.014335096813738346, 0.026750588789582253, 0.01730569452047348, 0.039829473942518234, 0.026502227410674095, -0.002171905245631933, 0.03711370378732681, 0.015296915546059608, 0.016046712175011635, 0.018673978745937347, -0.04195886850357056, -0.07271333783864975, -0.0216359905898571, -0.030395526438951492, 0.002783186035230756, 0.013662515208125114, -0.033483147621154785, 0.057167645543813705, -0.0723191499710083, 0.05955464765429497, 0.05279199779033661, -0.05193736031651497, -0.005751864518970251, -0.029055360704660416, 0.05425771325826645, 0.004383530467748642, 0.0012035098625347018, 0.02293732762336731, -0.033678293228149414, 0.013720977120101452, -0.030294403433799744, -0.0468272790312767, -0.04241941124200821, -0.03331971913576126, 0.044806379824876785, 0.0018631175626069307, -0.03633108735084534, -0.021493496373295784, 0.04302991181612015, 0.00460666511207819, -0.04119038209319115, 0.024675307795405388, 0.004850585944950581, 0.05472579970955849, -0.009545981884002686, 0.0037631585728377104, -0.02674841322004795, -0.004472722765058279, 0.04051372781395912, 0.020217321813106537, 0.01224637683480978, -0.04831283539533615, -0.018542960286140442, -0.027894679456949234, -0.05776601657271385, 0.013829835690557957, 0.015047851018607616, -0.04010697826743126, -0.005710309371352196, -0.027631476521492004, -0.00797655526548624, -0.011893019080162048, 0.03785785287618637, 0.00007097450725268573, -0.06200341880321503, 0.013780043460428715, 0.04360725358128548, 0.005914334207773209, 0.02455899491906166, 0.007928823120892048, -0.013255272060632706, -0.07967328280210495, 0.026726936921477318, -0.0022518883924931288, 0.02275870181620121, -0.017188560217618942, -0.024888508021831512, -0.007350015453994274, 0.03402360528707504, 0.03600604087114334, 0.00670597655698657, -0.017230169847607613, -0.03009667992591858, 0.009693742729723454, -0.004504016600549221, -0.021853940561413765, 0.00866733305156231, -0.022613834589719772, -0.01452711969614029, 0.0250457301735878, -0.0725247785449028, -0.014837842434644699, 0.03226738050580025, 0.020870404317975044, 0.032476138323545456, -0.09427326917648315, 0.01985420472919941, -0.041860152035951614, 0.01946266181766987, 0.03465014323592186, -0.02880438044667244, 0.007849159650504589, 0.00021926085173618048, 0.0012981916079297662, -0.004692176356911659, 0.015659822151064873, -0.010576307773590088, -0.03563517704606056, 0.02265063486993313, -0.01572597771883011, -0.03310472518205643, -0.041456740349531174, 0.018753299489617348, 0.05972738191485405, -0.023933768272399902, -0.048513200134038925, -0.07922723144292831, -0.052090827375650406, 0.006328979041427374, 0.027259957045316696, -0.0062761264853179455, -0.05139508098363876, 0.008377423509955406, 0.013779650442302227, 0.02041643112897873, -0.004122995771467686, -0.034959811717271805, 0.04538953676819801, -0.043754298239946365, -0.005921781063079834, -0.039369672536849976, 0.02743440866470337, 0.019058246165513992, -0.030910467728972435, 0.03719329461455345, 0.015462696552276611, 0.0009240609360858798, 0.03550339490175247, -0.05834637209773064, -0.07929835468530655, 0.02577686309814453, 0.02675025537610054, 0.01968223974108696, 0.022326789796352386, -0.024988126009702682, 0.005300666205585003, -0.009516075253486633, -0.04174615442752838, 0.016045335680246353, 0.02001340128481388, 0.037867333739995956, -0.04781965911388397, 0.008009355515241623, -0.005769072100520134, -0.028800280764698982, -0.006293545477092266, 0.048875097185373306, -0.014904077164828777, 0.025104807689785957, -0.026730062440037727, 0.06522942334413528, 0.04802771657705307, -0.011850645765662193, 0.04667171090841293, -0.009878668934106827, 0.006237089168280363, -0.031025968492031097, 0.05042401701211929, 0.022537022829055786, 0.009914662688970566, -0.05759154260158539, 0.018712418153882027, 0.05090092867612839, -0.054478634148836136, -0.015708385035395622, 0.05241073668003082, 0.006987845525145531, -0.003379350993782282, 0.01002474408596754, 0.007810455281287432, 0.023647906258702278, 0.033209409564733505, -0.00690981512889266, 0.04238619655370712, 0.05852150171995163, 0.017938654869794846, -0.00007090274448273703, -0.02109328843653202, 0.06464588642120361, 0.07669078558683395, 0.021971317008137703, 0.02558806538581848, 0.07473360747098923, -0.02075241133570671, -0.06007345765829086, 0.013712259940803051, 0.041589319705963135, -0.0128017608076334, -0.04235382005572319, -0.014470103196799755, 0.1195337101817131, 0.017966117709875107, 0.049789946526288986, -0.018804946914315224, 0.02212228812277317, 0.029892656952142715, 0.06068284809589386, 0.010393578559160233, -0.013466530479490757, -0.008929505944252014, -0.020720405504107475, -0.034330304712057114, -0.023874150589108467, -0.02824568934738636, -0.028870444744825363, 0.0322527140378952, 0.02140011079609394, -0.001469892100431025, 0.03398362919688225, -0.009839251637458801, 0.02904352732002735, 0.07885567098855972, -0.02570151723921299, -0.022092698141932487, -0.040950242429971695, 0.000007810765964677557, 0.01616135612130165, 0.011992027051746845, 0.024353429675102234, 0.008300220593810081, -0.0037623089738190174, -0.065363310277462, 0.03246397525072098, 0.035582952201366425, -0.018173346295952797, 0.02585178054869175, -0.053399790078401566, -0.0014980569249019027, 0.033406294882297516, 0.012482255697250366, -0.03743721917271614, -0.06329181045293808, -0.029280317947268486, -0.025260958820581436, -0.06585278362035751, -0.011197103187441826, 0.040463369339704514, -0.03294629603624344, -0.040578778833150864, 0.020531341433525085, -0.04919268935918808, 0.00035098270745947957, 0.039383918046951294, -0.06264019012451172, -0.039640117436647415, 0.047326624393463135, -0.05424312502145767, 0.021895479410886765, 0.037722449749708176, 0.04887039214372635, -0.023609912022948265, 0.006408169399946928, 0.03498664125800133, -0.031417299062013626, 0.018326204270124435, -0.0327124148607254, 0.011797876097261906, -0.10622162371873856, 0.015336373820900917, 0.017363445833325386, -0.016621926799416542, -0.08349018543958664, 0.045570243149995804, -0.021259896457195282, -0.010154436342418194, 0.03837531432509422, -0.022866996005177498, -0.0024600352626293898, -0.02828894555568695, -0.03268015757203102, -0.03660457581281662, 0.0016702174907550216, 0.07280796021223068, -0.028105920180678368, 0.09710419178009033, 0.04606691375374794, -0.016787247732281685, 0.004571030382066965, 0.020277438685297966, 0.019203871488571167, -0.0042208521626889706, -0.04625058174133301, -0.012386167421936989, -0.0411289781332016, -0.08071684837341309, -0.023838484659790993, 0.034757815301418304, -0.009201058186590672, -0.03783975914120674, 0.002135921735316515, 0.027313360944390297, 0.05117744579911232, -0.044975049793720245, 0.02848801761865616, -0.017275871708989143, -0.022969990968704224, -0.01611935719847679, -0.06833222508430481, 0.0364505797624588, 0.047184981405735016, 0.02032366767525673, -0.011445979587733746, -0.058069922029972076, 0.025270942598581314, -0.01793033815920353, 0.02676827274262905, -0.0022071683779358864, 0.003776176366955042, -0.011808967217803001 ]
3,517
RegMix: Data Mixture as Regression for Language Model Pre-training
https://openreview.net/forum?id=5BjQOUXq7i
[ "Qian Liu", "Xiaosen Zheng", "Niklas Muennighoff", "Guangtao Zeng", "Longxu Dou", "Tianyu Pang", "Jing Jiang", "Min Lin" ]
Spotlight
The data mixture for large language model pre-training significantly impacts performance, yet how to determine an effective mixture remains unclear. We propose RegMix to automatically identify a high-performing data mixture by formulating it as a regression task. RegMix trains many small models on diverse data mixtures, uses regression to predict performance of unseen mixtures, and applies the best predicted mixture to train a large-scale model with orders of magnitude more compute. To empirically validate RegMix, we train 512 models with 1M parameters for 1B tokens to fit the regression model and predict the best data mixture. Using this mixture we train a 1B parameter model for 25B tokens (i.e. 1000× larger and 25× longer) which we find performs best among 64 candidate 1B parameter models with other mixtures. Furthermore, RegMix consistently outperforms human selection in experiments involving models up to 7B models trained on 100B tokens, while matching or exceeding DoReMi using just 10% of the computational resources. Our experiments also show that (1) Data mixtures significantly impact performance; (2) Web corpora rather than data perceived as high-quality like Wikipedia have the strongest positive correlation with downstream performance; (3) Domains interact in complex ways often contradicting common sense, thus automatic approaches like RegMix are needed; (4) Data mixture effects transcend scaling laws. Our code is available at https://github.com/sail-sg/regmix.
language model pre-training, data mixture, regression
We introduce RegMix, an automated data mixture method that formulates data mixture as a regression problem. RegMix achieves a 6.3% improvement over human selection on the HellaSwag benchmark, with only a 2% extra training FLOPs.
6,642
2407.01492
[ -0.013234799727797508, -0.04772622883319855, -0.025519300252199173, 0.04851136356592178, 0.019699804484844208, 0.041519660502672195, 0.03180278465151787, 0.014378096908330917, -0.04296675696969032, -0.011993867345154285, -0.05096365138888359, 0.038941096514463425, -0.045994244515895844, -0.005389649420976639, -0.005819079931825399, 0.0433596633374691, 0.019378360360860825, -0.009813965298235416, 0.05521272122859955, 0.022578831762075424, -0.012928209267556667, -0.04721540957689285, 0.015056589618325233, 0.0001897615729831159, 0.022965842857956886, 0.0059506818652153015, 0.010792946442961693, 0.012556602247059345, -0.06109278276562691, 0.0299009308218956, 0.04088718816637993, 0.029311610385775566, 0.028877945616841316, 0.002537512220442295, 0.027889065444469452, 0.01855216920375824, -0.05009566619992256, 0.01957821659743786, 0.0035364842042326927, 0.028113866224884987, -0.054660364985466, 0.021512603387236595, -0.016327740624547005, -0.00032827534596435726, -0.050938449800014496, 0.0060312761925160885, -0.12348919361829758, 0.014408941380679607, 0.006109657697379589, -0.025836702436208725, -0.10861019790172577, 0.05805888772010803, 0.004439967684447765, -0.014807390049099922, 0.0055692377500236034, 0.022442130371928215, 0.04877781122922897, -0.07510128617286682, -0.0033540339209139347, -0.026077229529619217, -0.029235556721687317, 0.03757506236433983, -0.007206871174275875, 0.001201415667310357, 0.004088615998625755, -0.007555931806564331, 0.0026231701485812664, 0.026183923706412315, -0.06503696739673615, -0.04728882387280464, 0.022191952913999557, 0.019441580399870872, -0.021194180473685265, 0.031407155096530914, 0.012028676457703114, -0.049729473888874054, 0.0064678918570280075, 0.03648735210299492, 0.04850471764802933, 0.009175914339721203, -0.0003506410284899175, 0.0038093484472483397, 0.018883217126131058, 0.0382448211312294, 0.012084495276212692, 0.011576239950954914, -0.05716381594538689, -0.038058795034885406, -0.054867442697286606, 0.014607442542910576, 0.011155764572322369, -0.04599672555923462, 0.02032899297773838, 0.014567305333912373, -0.01980718784034252, 0.024079127237200737, 0.023008286952972412, -0.0008101161220110953, -0.029211346060037613, 0.028698747977614403, -0.04932045191526413, -0.009520595893263817, 0.06392880529165268, 0.017414294183254242, -0.10305061936378479, -0.014985593967139721, -0.0027292442973703146, 0.013571402058005333, 0.03731773793697357, -0.002507628407329321, 0.020876435562968254, -0.013770918361842632, 0.011678265407681465, -0.010427426546812057, -0.06301640719175339, 0.05762031674385071, -0.013856209814548492, 0.020171955227851868, 0.013041346333920956, 0.002108374610543251, 0.04319315776228905, 0.04447362571954727, 0.018281783908605576, 0.059096887707710266, -0.030193161219358444, 0.04187615215778351, 0.04337088391184807, 0.03876715525984764, -0.04509323090314865, -0.02635611779987812, -0.02386096864938736, 0.049240149557590485, -0.001398407039232552, 0.016582148149609566, 0.00788949429988861, -0.005892428569495678, 0.02417527697980404, 0.0387335903942585, 0.08842520415782928, -0.0058751641772687435, 0.02318446710705757, 0.010330642573535442, 0.030194047838449478, -0.03515580669045448, 0.04975321143865585, 0.013254656456410885, -0.022695446386933327, -0.02021864801645279, -0.05473167449235916, 0.003931932616978884, 0.03102801740169525, -0.009663003496825695, 0.027574611827731133, -0.060585230588912964, 0.01883547380566597, 0.08819589763879776, -0.002121079945936799, 0.021879145875573158, -0.00660225423052907, 0.028670141473412514, -0.00013920842320658267, 0.010228753089904785, -0.053623784333467484, 0.0033519924618303776, -0.014626355841755867, -0.0443120039999485, 0.012880471535027027, 0.03534989431500435, -0.05953279510140419, 0.01056876964867115, -0.05319414287805557, -0.043751735240221024, 0.09001069515943527, -0.0320233590900898, -0.013355410657823086, -0.03292793035507202, 0.061683837324380875, 0.00855906493961811, 0.04623326659202576, 0.01776152476668358, -0.08367948979139328, 0.04195927828550339, -0.00001558271105750464, 0.01989324763417244, 0.041221022605895996, -0.024085747078061104, 0.10479847341775894, -0.04434843733906746, 0.017137667164206505, 0.039394017308950424, -0.06219054013490677, -0.06450612097978592, 0.02590293623507023, -0.014819562435150146, 0.038741011172533035, 0.008177059702575207, 0.008009213954210281, 0.0382029265165329, 0.03730790689587593, 0.04108510538935661, 0.0430232398211956, -0.04130061715841293, 0.0716458335518837, 0.0008059169631451368, -0.026706194505095482, -0.007654104381799698, 0.00675031915307045, -0.050331227481365204, -0.041816361248493195, -0.006877956446260214, -0.022049305960536003, 0.00308199692517519, 0.01689988560974598, -0.027464954182505608, 0.015752099454402924, 0.023585733026266098, 0.01789933815598488, 0.008419624529778957, -0.009195082820951939, -0.049832481890916824, 0.05629219114780426, 0.016408085823059082, -0.04921552538871765, 0.001755805336870253, -0.05077790096402168, 0.07528528571128845, 0.0750846192240715, 0.00487606693059206, -0.005053152330219746, 0.02237280085682869, 0.010100445710122585, -0.008993959054350853, 0.040271610021591187, -0.016868719831109047, 0.01531870849430561, -0.006562709342688322, -0.008126293309032917, -0.018333541229367256, 0.02973794750869274, -0.039173271507024765, -0.008879592642188072, 0.051604676991701126, -0.0324166864156723, 0.04523792862892151, -0.014291051775217056, 0.014443587511777878, 0.024627119302749634, -0.009182672016322613, -0.017485495656728745, -0.06060199812054634, 0.012507189065217972, 0.0176293533295393, -0.0022218232043087482, -0.028373224660754204, -0.013911757618188858, -0.036316171288490295, -0.02955446019768715, -0.03939009830355644, 0.06128311529755592, 0.05173078179359436, -0.004222170449793339, 0.018621038645505905, 0.0070409770123660564, -0.032530784606933594, 0.018385006114840508, -0.08513987809419632, -0.04305709898471832, -0.030717164278030396, 0.0020441855303943157, -0.001901331590488553, 0.030810704454779625, 0.007144947070628405, 0.009321329183876514, -0.013216727413237095, 0.0028536049649119377, 0.023234795778989792, 0.05895557254552841, -0.01885894127190113, -0.05693799629807472, -0.02777104265987873, -0.03591381385922432, 0.05932723358273506, -0.022616615518927574, -0.012995634227991104, -0.05294505134224892, -0.04754101112484932, -0.014733970165252686, -0.046878524124622345, -0.004153579939156771, 0.014404053799808025, 0.012533016502857208, 0.01849418319761753, -0.02125055529177189, 0.009646217338740826, 0.04261808097362518, 0.05088924616575241, 0.0455615296959877, 0.011740879155695438, -0.02088823728263378, 0.04131025820970535, -0.015090384520590305, 0.039647314697504044, 0.014629589393734932, 0.023348405957221985, -0.00494279945269227, -0.017270619049668312, -0.014179089106619358, -0.014133058488368988, -0.26090162992477417, -0.013892123475670815, -0.013400943949818611, -0.03183029964566231, 0.044617101550102234, -0.042906273156404495, 0.05126392841339111, -0.044831499457359314, -0.016026293858885765, -0.007161105517297983, 0.024286216124892235, 0.027909422293305397, 0.02482711151242256, 0.05356205254793167, 0.04447915032505989, 0.055978428572416306, 0.01369484607130289, -0.021915191784501076, -0.0011920861434191465, 0.048065971583127975, 0.002513465704396367, -0.04716483876109123, -0.013130633160471916, 0.07343535870313644, -0.00481394911184907, 0.03238833323121071, -0.07443924993276596, -0.004920838866382837, -0.043620966374874115, 0.006211988627910614, 0.02256554551422596, -0.013668663799762726, -0.01568659394979477, 0.02351699024438858, -0.007888386957347393, 0.01746896468102932, 0.06358852982521057, 0.020272566005587578, 0.055747970938682556, 0.005237166304141283, -0.007469785865396261, -0.02119622379541397, -0.027333829551935196, -0.04013296961784363, 0.05057717114686966, 0.01679731160402298, -0.05576536804437637, -0.014344860799610615, -0.014835257083177567, 0.03661401569843292, -0.024708257988095284, -0.019452009350061417, -0.014183314517140388, 0.025726230815052986, 0.03261283412575722, -0.019948333501815796, 0.02247847057878971, -0.007045322097837925, -0.018885279074311256, -0.011054016649723053, 0.020940184593200684, -0.03257019445300102, -0.03815235197544098, -0.054122477769851685, -0.010169870220124722, -0.05935944244265556, -0.06833650916814804, -0.07126069068908691, 0.06098967418074608, 0.03732552379369736, -0.061260100454092026, 0.023341737687587738, 0.03218170627951622, -0.09279761463403702, -0.0063170758076012135, -0.0026068356819450855, -0.0014969707699492574, 0.00803289469331503, -0.009226307272911072, 0.037632931023836136, -0.05889013782143593, -0.04130737483501434, 0.0038469438441097736, -0.014812381006777287, 0.037292420864105225, -0.03797561302781105, 0.00048167858039960265, -0.029149869456887245, -0.004365643486380577, -0.036871396005153656, 0.04216204583644867, -0.043022625148296356, -0.009567140601575375, 0.036882296204566956, 0.052017271518707275, 0.03430256247520447, 0.012567076832056046, 0.06095142289996147, 0.055930398404598236, -0.004836799576878548, 0.022258350625634193, -0.09082211554050446, -0.0001720262662274763, -0.05355225130915642, -0.004788944497704506, 0.01598260924220085, -0.06772314012050629, -0.02651294693350792, 0.05103606358170509, -0.021128235384821892, -0.02358524315059185, -0.021862629801034927, -0.025958482176065445, -0.01845884509384632, -0.020477334037423134, -0.01544413436204195, -0.010468116030097008, 0.013619853183627129, 0.037746597081422806, -0.0306699238717556, 0.0018423468573018909, 0.023068349808454514, -0.018176164478063583, -3.263250647478344e-8, -0.005380644928663969, -0.04661491885781288, 0.027610233053565025, -0.030584610998630524, -0.00858160387724638, 0.005254436284303665, 0.00033662759233266115, 0.030589668080210686, 0.009271446615457535, -0.011913727968931198, 0.0458570197224617, -0.006529127713292837, 0.008344186469912529, -0.0007111407467164099, 0.03261248767375946, -0.015770837664604187, 0.007455770391970873, -0.021285628899931908, 0.02873861975967884, 0.048595085740089417, 0.04051409661769867, 0.021330825984477997, 0.00391733692958951, -0.008512287400662899, -0.0017016230849549174, -0.010308414697647095, 0.020019620656967163, -0.031768232583999634, -0.006794235669076443, -0.04086058959364891, 0.015299580991268158, -0.013733401894569397, 0.05531623214483261, -0.00009035929542733356, 0.004902008455246687, -0.05298126861453056, 0.06356067955493927, 0.002772498643025756, 0.00012580312613863498, 0.02182062529027462, 0.03452134504914284, 0.01627069152891636, -0.019831746816635132, 0.02934960275888443, 0.010526399128139019, 0.03714756667613983, 0.012833544053137302, -0.008581039495766163, -0.02095974050462246, -0.008642134256660938, 0.0006965279462747276, 0.017250671982765198, 0.0137849235907197, 0.023806758224964142, -0.02119884081184864, 0.04245322197675705, 0.02112310193479061, -0.012214520014822483, -0.013829189352691174, 0.024865902960300446, 0.08728475868701935, 0.05558767169713974, 0.007994280196726322, -0.007016731891781092, -0.036356501281261444, 0.01696159690618515, -0.04278264939785004, 0.013463284820318222, -0.006682736333459616, -0.04108039662241936, -0.03364042192697525, -0.04442500323057175, 0.009747051633894444, 0.016278034076094627, -0.029334889724850655, -0.00860106572508812, -0.0011129899648949504, -0.017538899555802345, -0.037035729736089706, -0.009461316280066967, 0.00810872670263052, -0.08294989168643951, -0.025988787412643433, -0.02069929987192154, -0.030586039647459984, 0.0020757317543029785, -0.01152802724391222, -0.041466597467660904, -0.061622753739356995, -0.00784191396087408, 0.00898138340562582, -0.03698933497071266, -0.02959645539522171, -0.00432064151391387, 0.03799411281943321, -0.018564876168966293, 0.00795801356434822, 0.002904791384935379, -0.010608265176415443, -0.017433857545256615, -0.014690575189888477, 0.048665549606084824, -0.042870376259088516, 0.004569597542285919, -0.018430547788739204, -0.032347895205020905, 0.03809065744280815, -0.025146054103970528, 0.02879902347922325, 0.06253597885370255, 0.005296812858432531, -0.009339551441371441, -0.053900569677352905, 0.025115519762039185, 0.028320597484707832, -0.0267656147480011, 0.00911521352827549, -0.020850764587521553, -0.036576200276613235, 0.018832998350262642, 0.003704838687554002, 0.03398600593209267, -0.01700555719435215, 0.014446916058659554, -0.01192470546811819, -0.009296350181102753, 0.024782560765743256, 0.05360948294401169, -0.07073506712913513, -0.010967094451189041, 0.05626830831170082, -0.018737895414233208, -0.03927159681916237, -0.08034822344779968, -0.062188584357500076, 0.01858261600136757, -0.010342451743781567, 0.05532320588827133, -0.02054581046104431, 0.045999228954315186, 0.019359393045306206, 0.06703587621450424, 0.000043228450522292405, -0.028640586882829666, 0.027396058663725853, -0.063276007771492, -0.012847899459302425, -0.060761164873838425, -0.01900390349328518, 0.11644192039966583, -0.0003794280637521297, -0.009104560129344463, -0.018585581332445145, -0.05404999479651451, 0.02443152479827404, -0.011155623942613602, -0.0570664145052433, -0.00861283764243126, -0.016231752932071686, -0.000566151924431324, 0.009080260992050171, -0.029972882941365242, -0.006678321398794651, 0.016113590449094772, -0.043200936168432236, -0.023021314293146133, 0.003626967314630747, 0.05937118083238602, -0.05650537461042404, 0.02753268927335739, -0.028998225927352905, -0.02367585524916649, 0.02043720707297325, 0.037984274327754974, 0.012827904894948006, 0.030414113774895668, -0.01823265850543976, 0.04501167684793472, 0.02460809424519539, -0.013715401291847229, -0.007295530755072832, -0.01082693412899971, -0.017113683745265007, -0.060761358588933945, 0.0414312481880188, 0.00842455867677927, -0.010983244515955448, -0.034314293414354324, 0.08384629338979721, 0.040717098861932755, -0.05227252468466759, -0.05280148983001709, 0.014350717887282372, -0.031570423394441605, 0.02217482402920723, -0.006886790972203016, 0.019207365810871124, -0.031269364058971405, 0.0738091766834259, 0.040275219827890396, 0.04721101000905037, 0.058984655886888504, -0.0012655028840526938, -0.027434110641479492, 0.005429027136415243, 0.06832220405340195, 0.05405396223068237, 0.054474834352731705, 0.028489070013165474, 0.049952469766139984, -0.052804578095674515, -0.04913010820746422, 0.05508263036608696, 0.04124150425195694, -0.020023759454488754, -0.02854161709547043, -0.0007691794307902455, 0.08837036043405533, 0.007060695439577103, 0.05821415036916733, -0.03819289058446884, 0.008435091935098171, -0.005454019643366337, 0.0031658306252211332, -0.0012446880573406816, 0.04208880662918091, 0.003736176062375307, 0.02869596891105175, -0.020032642409205437, -0.01740051992237568, 0.004070925060659647, -0.02010234445333481, -0.0045544966123998165, 0.015531025826931, -0.01597338728606701, 0.0021784708369523287, -0.034173283725976944, 0.04529011994600296, 0.10145361721515656, -0.03278445452451706, -0.02110045589506626, 0.006107442080974579, 0.03873549401760101, -0.0009683173266239464, 0.05676371604204178, 0.004844099283218384, -0.0548165962100029, -0.0026625939644873142, -0.06129205971956253, 0.00497010862454772, 0.0012559848837554455, -0.03684209659695625, 0.008595260791480541, -0.031898099929094315, -0.0354304201900959, -0.004704935941845179, -0.01595420576632023, -0.03553324192762375, -0.05087372288107872, -0.03540392965078354, -0.03440571203827858, -0.07575999200344086, -0.042132940143346786, 0.00530978525057435, 0.007017103955149651, -0.01812216080725193, 0.012073185294866562, -0.04143618792295456, 0.007789320312440395, 0.02732859179377556, -0.06551223993301392, 0.01832767017185688, 0.027274729683995247, -0.028967706486582756, -0.0018931840313598514, 0.04470279812812805, 0.015529715456068516, -0.012180916965007782, -0.02565929852426052, 0.03146960586309433, 0.03616975620388985, 0.022669672966003418, 0.009233202785253525, -0.022854331880807877, -0.08480039238929749, 0.01887367106974125, 0.011067352257668972, -0.03760620951652527, -0.07171275466680527, 0.010767393745481968, -0.0034661588724702597, 0.04335171729326248, 0.0455842949450016, -0.009377213194966316, 0.010847007855772972, -0.023067934438586235, -0.031052984297275543, 0.005731440149247646, 0.014836517162621021, 0.03602142259478569, -0.001765179680660367, 0.05227271094918251, 0.03884466737508774, 0.009128972887992859, -0.04782005399465561, 0.013016769662499428, -0.01832088828086853, -0.00437403516843915, -0.012101938016712666, 0.005147548392415047, -0.032725702971220016, -0.07827948778867722, -0.02716948837041855, 0.03643258288502693, -0.031573351472616196, -0.016558263450860977, -0.008144248276948929, -0.002106538275256753, -0.023539816960692406, -0.01676938682794571, -0.012436113320291042, -0.005636227782815695, -0.01694350317120552, -0.009394807741045952, -0.07992909848690033, -0.0011244533816352487, -0.017199669033288956, 0.0022299718111753464, -0.051994968205690384, -0.03426439315080643, 0.01772516593337059, 0.004044164903461933, 0.058833714574575424, -0.0022560306824743748, 0.04370633885264397, 0.0018170512048527598 ]
3,518
When Attention Sink Emerges in Language Models: An Empirical View
https://openreview.net/forum?id=78Nn4QJTEN
[ "Xiangming Gu", "Tianyu Pang", "Chao Du", "Qian Liu", "Fengzhuo Zhang", "Cunxiao Du", "Ye Wang", "Min Lin" ]
Spotlight
Auto-regressive language Models (LMs) assign significant attention to the first token, even if it is not semantically important, which is known as **attention sink**. This phenomenon has been widely adopted in applications such as streaming/long context generation, KV cache optimization, inference acceleration, model quantization, and others. Despite its widespread use, a deep understanding of attention sink in LMs is still lacking. In this work, we first demonstrate that attention sinks exist universally in auto-regressive LMs with various inputs, even in small models. Furthermore, attention sink is observed to emerge during the LM pre-training, motivating us to investigate how *optimization*, *data distribution*, *loss function*, and *model architecture* in LM pre-training influence its emergence. We highlight that attention sink emerges after effective optimization on sufficient training data. The sink position is highly correlated with the loss function and data distribution. Most importantly, we find that attention sink acts more like key biases, *storing extra attention scores*, which could be non-informative and not contribute to the value computation. We also observe that this phenomenon (at least partially) stems from tokens' inner dependence on attention scores as a result of softmax normalization. After relaxing such dependence by replacing softmax attention with other attention operations, such as sigmoid attention without normalization, attention sinks do not emerge in LMs up to 1B parameters. The code is available at https://github.com/sail-sg/Attention-Sink.
Attention Sink, Language Models, Empirical Study
We conduct extensive experiments to empirically understand when attention sink emerges in language models.
6,630
2410.10781
[ -0.024321118369698524, -0.036720506846904755, 0.003514859126880765, 0.03623340651392937, 0.03453262895345688, 0.043689895421266556, 0.04807824641466141, 0.03097141534090042, -0.011620021425187588, -0.00039691434358246624, -0.018534936010837555, 0.003352995263412595, -0.03611823171377182, 0.005717099644243717, -0.0010364253539592028, 0.0504840612411499, 0.06498529762029648, -0.02062995731830597, 0.036092132329940796, 0.01757798157632351, -0.001976650906726718, 0.00007100197399267927, 0.049583710730075836, 0.023468714207410812, 0.045227520167827606, -0.017316769808530807, 0.005444076843559742, 0.00041591539047658443, -0.012635034509003162, -0.0023072708863765, 0.012501860968768597, 0.0039238170720636845, 0.011986620724201202, 0.007934775203466415, 0.010060879401862621, 0.0018189289839938283, -0.05244923755526543, 0.009292082861065865, 0.020941806957125664, 0.04109743610024452, -0.06789201498031616, 0.008640424348413944, -0.021379783749580383, -0.0005570524954237044, -0.06526494771242142, 0.0021154109854251146, -0.13719841837882996, 0.011116044595837593, 0.026440158486366272, -0.02542099915444851, -0.13125616312026978, 0.03205946087837219, 0.029388796538114548, -0.03998398780822754, 0.014676952734589577, 0.013405079022049904, 0.059852465987205505, -0.10299768298864365, -0.0012061602901667356, -0.05307457968592644, -0.018023498356342316, 0.024274544790387154, 0.02702934481203556, 0.003899231320247054, 0.009286242537200451, -0.043316736817359924, 0.011468800716102123, 0.024849560111761093, -0.06552593410015106, -0.05407228693366051, -0.016321513801813126, 0.03714810311794281, -0.02078835479915142, 0.02685495838522911, -0.021348048001527786, -0.04716189578175545, 0.028536666184663773, 0.04226790368556976, 0.07306287437677383, -0.004859122913330793, -0.024024363607168198, 0.02713405154645443, 0.02086368389427662, 0.044254008680582047, 0.006694731302559376, -0.0013099287170916796, -0.002966610947623849, -0.04154292494058609, -0.05548099800944328, 0.025579722598195076, -0.01753060519695282, -0.06552786380052567, 0.006590588483959436, 0.014963866211473942, 0.0023741363547742367, 0.029601532965898514, 0.040835537016391754, 0.0029194841627031565, -0.005711425561457872, 0.010671915486454964, -0.018408626317977905, -0.03643067181110382, 0.02625446207821369, 0.05136966332793236, -0.09187658131122589, -0.03930782899260521, -0.010289848782122135, -0.009250367060303688, 0.0009923645993694663, -0.008128372952342033, -0.015448800288140774, -0.009206999093294144, 0.022053606808185577, -0.0035480516962707043, -0.0802183747291565, -0.0014758299803361297, -0.0005394124891608953, 0.028812872245907784, -0.005741282366216183, 0.02052142284810543, 0.034639451652765274, 0.026976583525538445, 0.010754615999758244, 0.07200019806623459, -0.037987906485795975, 0.019849145784974098, 0.006996168289333582, 0.022953441366553307, -0.021397124975919724, -0.027263430878520012, 0.005369332153350115, 0.02111709676682949, 0.012938376516103745, 0.008028177544474602, -0.005337935872375965, 0.0254542026668787, 0.04396303743124008, 0.04056767001748085, 0.08633455634117126, 0.019983267411589622, -0.002873379271477461, -0.004469465930014849, 0.0544775016605854, -0.03655708208680153, 0.05895565077662468, 0.0005421589594334364, -0.022239482030272484, -0.004081948194652796, -0.052679937332868576, 0.020438475534319878, 0.015119696035981178, -0.004912304691970348, -0.005263905972242355, -0.04377118870615959, 0.041055548936128616, 0.05536623299121857, 0.0013534451136365533, 0.0055310288444161415, 0.033527109771966934, 0.04299870505928993, 0.026766637340188026, 0.03424319997429848, -0.06035661697387695, 0.019476979970932007, -0.009476011618971825, -0.05020561441779137, 0.02952463924884796, 0.004037982784211636, -0.038961004465818405, 0.02343524619936943, -0.017178654670715332, -0.034154657274484634, 0.061657778918743134, -0.029101351276040077, -0.013020804151892662, -0.0007975556654855609, 0.05407620593905449, 0.01915431022644043, 0.030520163476467133, 0.05081090331077576, -0.07251466065645218, 0.02088346518576145, -0.0025718631222844124, 0.02988385409116745, 0.017933854833245277, -0.02837120182812214, 0.06202297285199165, -0.014504033140838146, 0.010956581681966782, 0.011740759946405888, -0.06462830305099487, -0.0033442811109125614, 0.00014793805894441903, -0.0006808422622270882, 0.07319971174001694, -0.022507034242153168, 0.0032419587951153517, 0.04966583102941513, 0.03756887838244438, 0.07058025151491165, 0.0532585047185421, -0.014611097052693367, 0.018537765368819237, -0.008063712157309055, -0.04485447332262993, 0.003846948267892003, 0.019214291125535965, -0.06023069843649864, -0.07449467480182648, 0.02463303692638874, -0.039289578795433044, 0.0004185632278677076, -0.000504357973113656, 0.009916889481246471, 0.004403317347168922, -0.01636483706533909, -0.008192133158445358, -0.005854124203324318, -0.011957167647778988, -0.05367265269160271, 0.0528278611600399, 0.0034223373513668776, 0.012529117055237293, 0.00564301572740078, -0.030764788389205933, 0.09307185560464859, 0.07059211283922195, -0.027698887512087822, 0.022415263578295708, 0.01839485950767994, 0.017207441851496696, -0.008852747268974781, 0.009673411957919598, -0.015197141095995903, 0.003106549149379134, -0.033778116106987, -0.01265670359134674, -0.04249991849064827, 0.03504083678126335, -0.03952484577894211, 0.013536017388105392, 0.0674489438533783, -0.037586092948913574, 0.05045811086893082, -0.017921503633260727, 0.00574485631659627, 0.054534755647182465, -0.03542843088507652, -0.03608760982751846, -0.024990253150463104, -0.030023057013750076, 0.004923862870782614, 0.00425786292180419, -0.04801839217543602, 0.0061247884295880795, -0.023677093908190727, -0.03539973869919777, -0.011229469440877438, 0.056063152849674225, 0.0582556277513504, 0.009953616186976433, 0.0300673209130764, -0.005082760006189346, -0.035688433796167374, -0.007101304363459349, -0.11325143277645111, -0.0256436076015234, -0.024018172174692154, 0.030903678387403488, -0.013082211837172508, 0.00631807092577219, -0.020612845197319984, 0.02214394323527813, -0.03575951233506203, -0.01217162050306797, -0.006440875586122274, 0.03702535480260849, -0.033733513206243515, -0.03623497858643532, -0.00014023321273270994, -0.023075582459568977, 0.042716432362794876, -0.028518633916974068, -0.01227541547268629, -0.029531532898545265, -0.04722413048148155, -0.014909038320183754, -0.022317634895443916, 0.006730715278536081, 0.012454268522560596, 0.018681004643440247, -0.0030946116894483566, -0.01697874255478382, 0.024284357205033302, 0.044833313673734665, 0.05727691203355789, 0.04502785950899124, -0.0005104342708364129, -0.013602557592093945, 0.022323377430438995, -0.00866397563368082, 0.029236197471618652, 0.007346917409449816, 0.053907860070466995, 0.007022629026323557, -0.013341053389012814, 0.01220697071403265, -0.007035035640001297, -0.27334341406822205, -0.009957070462405682, 0.03407343477010727, -0.008256720378994942, 0.04471185803413391, -0.022871213033795357, 0.036734987050294876, -0.010199652053415775, -0.023764600977301598, 0.020088454708456993, -0.013810299336910248, 0.011346316896378994, 0.02512264810502529, 0.055065639317035675, 0.02057662233710289, 0.011395364999771118, 0.0042592124082148075, -0.025651564821600914, -0.0004746701451949775, 0.03914890065789223, -0.014307166449725628, -0.07420646399259567, -0.03286071866750717, 0.06275821477174759, 0.022447505965828896, 0.062469661235809326, -0.08710146695375443, 0.0060827769339084625, -0.017529575154185295, 0.011759883724153042, -0.036596838384866714, -0.03772779181599617, 0.021965648978948593, 0.04212266951799393, -0.01878366619348526, 0.008841989561915398, 0.031600408256053925, 0.01393668819218874, 0.031129566952586174, 0.014289547689259052, 0.012970277108252048, -0.01900714635848999, -0.007567897439002991, 0.006115303840488195, 0.06067308411002159, 0.010630490258336067, -0.06038250774145126, -0.025592152029275894, -0.015650182962417603, 0.010294228792190552, -0.025640344247221947, -0.04055269435048103, -0.021167265251278877, 0.007777488324791193, 0.015366612002253532, -0.007658007089048624, 0.0004244721494615078, -0.028065379709005356, -0.005013543181121349, -0.00009946370118996128, 0.004203343763947487, -0.023113137111067772, -0.009702282026410103, -0.04811876267194748, -0.026082923635840416, -0.04954905807971954, -0.06674613803625107, -0.01213394571095705, 0.0459798201918602, 0.04703959450125694, -0.012676714919507504, 0.018049055710434914, 0.004167985171079636, -0.09428207576274872, -0.017015306279063225, -0.018669595941901207, -0.02271299622952938, 0.006077290046960115, 0.0060036154463887215, 0.06849735975265503, -0.035586483776569366, -0.0500955656170845, 0.0013055801391601562, 0.009557387791574001, 0.00823206827044487, -0.03215114027261734, -0.00726665835827589, -0.026945939287543297, -0.04082578048110008, -0.027402417734265327, 0.039200082421302795, -0.00021397386444732547, 0.024018188938498497, 0.000991206499747932, 0.02844400890171528, 0.04199209809303284, 0.026714077219367027, 0.0593252032995224, 0.037942707538604736, 0.0014741654740646482, 0.04837535321712494, -0.04435289278626442, -0.014823525212705135, -0.012957306578755379, -0.009540697559714317, 0.02298065461218357, -0.05217099189758301, -0.024132953956723213, 0.033207569271326065, 0.01667357049882412, -0.04983321949839592, -0.044764913618564606, -0.02027786709368229, 0.0014787764521315694, -0.030959250405430794, -0.0064926790073513985, -0.00430932454764843, 0.024091357365250587, 0.011442132294178009, -0.043617770075798035, -0.019482411444187164, 0.050461579114198685, -0.03419365733861923, 0.000012599611181940418, 0.017269305884838104, -0.013607115484774113, -0.0218909103423357, -0.019636187702417374, -0.0072717247530817986, 0.030357850715517998, 0.04269628971815109, 0.03366836905479431, -0.012402945198118687, -0.017801880836486816, 0.05541083961725235, -0.03111913613975048, 0.020386559888720512, -0.012101192027330399, 0.03855619579553604, 0.004439695738255978, 0.00003849191125482321, -0.024373304098844528, 0.02837253175675869, 0.032695189118385315, 0.029245158657431602, 0.016571274027228355, 0.019537106156349182, -0.006648162379860878, 0.006842238362878561, -0.02352409064769745, 0.0551239475607872, -0.07270145416259766, -0.03658175840973854, -0.053229402750730515, 0.012967247515916824, -0.0170751865953207, 0.01716873049736023, -0.02898603305220604, -0.023428406566381454, -0.03883946314454079, 0.06016065925359726, -0.03227286413311958, -0.012924602255225182, 0.007023764308542013, 0.007495834492146969, 0.007201852276921272, -0.0321117602288723, 0.006489621475338936, 0.06852918863296509, 0.004493419546633959, -0.004742951598018408, -0.014663945883512497, -0.03864744305610657, -0.010515703819692135, 0.002172968117520213, 0.009443231858313084, 0.02935332991182804, -0.016036465764045715, -0.007762016728520393, 0.03303713724017143, 0.008094988763332367, 0.0004522195958998054, 0.006747879087924957, 0.04493871331214905, 0.10454728454351425, -0.0009890773799270391, 0.011964219622313976, 0.010890036821365356, -0.057732898741960526, 0.029734287410974503, -0.02578321285545826, -0.031629934906959534, -0.01336002442985773, -0.04591241478919983, -0.0344577394425869, -0.010617446154356003, -0.007985780946910381, 0.023361030966043472, 0.00419925432652235, 0.0022068656980991364, -0.030169876292347908, 0.02606508694589138, -0.024180036038160324, -0.012539523653686047, 0.030786482617259026, -0.08399320393800735, 0.02427143044769764, 0.0251444261521101, -0.03314662724733353, 0.008385123685002327, -0.015129867941141129, -0.02503436803817749, -0.09293615072965622, -0.03311249613761902, 0.03331414610147476, -0.024456379935145378, -0.04506911709904671, -0.04697934538125992, 0.016590112820267677, 0.010529440827667713, 0.004036746919155121, 0.0008300828048959374, 0.00242063426412642, -0.018913136795163155, 0.02018168196082115, 0.025758842006325722, -0.025436552241444588, 0.0076404837891459465, -0.01178589928895235, -0.03512321785092354, 0.02866826020181179, -0.01949950121343136, 0.052229251712560654, 0.05636988952755928, -0.013963770121335983, -0.020230792462825775, -0.021286893635988235, 0.015958981588482857, -0.0029798797331750393, 0.013557879254221916, 0.01993209309875965, -0.009939136914908886, -0.03634946793317795, 0.02413073554635048, -0.0011496201623231173, 0.04890753701329231, 0.009106015786528587, 0.014461998827755451, -0.008065767586231232, 0.013650534674525261, 0.02353757619857788, 0.041328009217977524, -0.04759631305932999, 0.011149056255817413, 0.060568541288375854, -0.042857520282268524, -0.04736798629164696, -0.09352128952741623, -0.04631597176194191, 0.00015619429177604616, -0.013646871782839298, 0.021478192880749702, -0.0394018180668354, 0.07212280482053757, 0.019359983503818512, 0.041206084191799164, 0.012062878347933292, -0.007739265915006399, 0.05089402571320534, -0.02897654101252556, -0.012162911705672741, -0.07518020272254944, -0.058587584644556046, 0.06950484216213226, -0.007452128455042839, 0.011639009229838848, -0.012704364955425262, -0.050874173641204834, 0.024976730346679688, -0.015533261001110077, -0.03062860481441021, 0.022108422592282295, -0.01508109737187624, 0.010417900048196316, 0.02553567849099636, -0.07439208775758743, -0.04189448803663254, -0.034351181238889694, -0.03217126056551933, -0.016860928386449814, 0.01743001863360405, 0.03554077818989754, -0.013092907145619392, 0.0276991818100214, -0.007247903849929571, 0.004679863806813955, 0.01089461613446474, 0.05877915397286415, 0.023735934868454933, 0.031170735135674477, -0.03813420981168747, 0.06183229759335518, 0.04026147723197937, 0.01878734678030014, 0.010018689557909966, 0.011828013695776463, -0.030621299520134926, -0.06553279608488083, 0.040041375905275345, -0.00044308495125733316, 0.007938669994473457, -0.044329933822155, 0.06872048228979111, 0.04280976951122284, -0.051604412496089935, -0.03353060781955719, 0.025771424174308777, -0.043998826295137405, -0.04528602585196495, -0.005375192500650883, -0.005422654561698437, -0.04838339611887932, 0.06713971495628357, 0.043120138347148895, 0.046525921672582626, 0.05826691538095474, 0.007010872941464186, -0.02536199800670147, 0.025155935436487198, 0.09531772136688232, 0.06431630998849869, 0.06276681274175644, 0.0018802861450240016, 0.07150194048881531, -0.04370176047086716, -0.035390693694353104, 0.02542593702673912, 0.02045474573969841, -0.01238673273473978, -0.04863949120044708, 0.008569941855967045, 0.08989071846008301, 0.0014015407068654895, 0.06606543064117432, -0.040371403098106384, -0.026234911754727364, 0.0427052266895771, 0.010219239629805088, -0.002008160576224327, 0.03707212954759598, 0.02344495989382267, 0.007509550079703331, -0.02152724377810955, -0.031637899577617645, -0.021746313199400902, -0.012291413731873035, -0.014729276299476624, -0.002160879084840417, 0.0037215095944702625, -0.010096088983118534, -0.024927886202931404, 0.03730039298534393, 0.10489138960838318, -0.014323778450489044, -0.011339196935296059, -0.013998253270983696, -0.01798085868358612, 0.011532306671142578, 0.05393919721245766, -0.03638321906328201, -0.03098403662443161, 0.0034527878742665052, -0.03444650396704674, 0.00220843986608088, 0.010015103034675121, -0.009616203606128693, 0.008221818134188652, -0.006180927623063326, -0.015528618358075619, -0.014881722629070282, 0.01442686840891838, -0.039331335574388504, -0.06145747750997543, -0.03606511279940605, -0.05749204382300377, -0.0522175207734108, -0.036949578672647476, 0.041976090520620346, 0.018491458147764206, 0.004325268790125847, -0.007275552488863468, -0.04714730754494667, -0.018855338916182518, -0.005571852438151836, -0.05128619447350502, -0.00981996487826109, 0.01482702698558569, -0.017615746706724167, -0.03323061019182205, 0.02825501561164856, 0.015317595563828945, -0.019003458321094513, -0.012697814032435417, 0.0345926359295845, 0.040713753551244736, 0.018528223037719727, 0.010816900990903378, -0.02642945386469364, -0.10598672926425934, 0.02145177312195301, 0.0034290014300495386, -0.04774034395813942, -0.07703417539596558, 0.054482076317071915, -0.0009005992906168103, 0.019465571269392967, 0.08260077983140945, 0.0031982765067368746, 0.016251089051365852, -0.03238384425640106, -0.009553121402859688, 0.02422507107257843, 0.02271476574242115, 0.05140459164977074, 0.02380969375371933, 0.06240002065896988, 0.029879024252295494, 0.0021889195777475834, -0.031006066128611565, -0.0011058638337999582, -0.05224629491567612, -0.012326427735388279, 0.0015170045662671328, -0.02024907059967518, -0.009196302853524685, -0.09270824491977692, -0.011734179221093655, 0.033393021672964096, -0.009577379561960697, -0.02505836822092533, 0.009024842642247677, -0.05367092415690422, 0.009595734067261219, -0.010486632585525513, -0.009497986175119877, -0.018114283680915833, -0.011918339878320694, -0.028254328295588493, -0.06563272327184677, -0.011451688595116138, -0.01673681102693081, -0.00027320082881487906, -0.0437450110912323, -0.035730913281440735, 0.007704705931246281, -0.014280439354479313, 0.06871269643306732, -0.0032281652092933655, -0.00826875027269125, -0.025249451398849487 ]
3,519
PianoMotion10M: Dataset and Benchmark for Hand Motion Generation in Piano Performance
https://openreview.net/forum?id=rxVvRBgqmS
[ "Qijun Gan", "Song Wang", "Shengtao Wu", "Jianke Zhu" ]
Spotlight
Recently, artificial intelligence techniques for education have been received increasing attentions, while it still remains an open problem to design the effective music instrument instructing systems. Although key presses can be directly derived from sheet music, the transitional movements among key presses require more extensive guidance in piano performance. In this work, we construct a piano-hand motion generation benchmark to guide hand movements and fingerings for piano playing. To this end, we collect an annotated dataset, PianoMotion10M, consisting of 116 hours of piano playing videos from a bird's-eye view with 10 million annotated hand poses. We also introduce a powerful baseline model that generates hand motions from piano audios through a position predictor and a position-guided gesture generator. Furthermore, a series of evaluation metrics are designed to assess the performance of the baseline model, including motion similarity, smoothness, positional accuracy of left and right hands, and overall fidelity of movement distribution. Despite that piano key presses with respect to music scores or audios are already accessible, PianoMotion10M aims to provide guidance on piano fingering for instruction purposes. The source code and dataset can be accessed at https://github.com/agnJason/PianoMotion10M.
Hand pose estimation, piano music, motion generation
We construct the first large-scale piano-motion dataset, PianoMotion10M for hand motion generation.
6,629
2406.09326
[ -0.016637254506349564, -0.009443789720535278, -0.014498301781713963, 0.021612774580717087, 0.0522298589348793, 0.026445239782333374, 0.050440963357686996, 0.002747890306636691, -0.03336067497730255, -0.048068005591630936, -0.030566388741135597, -0.012408860959112644, -0.048275984823703766, -0.02084478922188282, -0.03999096900224686, 0.05473097041249275, 0.009054468013346195, -0.033242322504520416, 0.017750810831785202, -0.011057241819798946, -0.029047878459095955, -0.01733792945742607, 0.036041803658008575, 0.031798556447029114, 0.0290096253156662, 0.00037763637374155223, 0.00781831331551075, 0.019803369417786598, -0.052450116723775864, -0.0043405806645751, 0.014137581922113895, -0.005547878798097372, 0.033224452286958694, -0.0469609797000885, 0.026865262538194656, 0.0032433264423161745, -0.02190171368420124, 0.030037518590688705, 0.012454588897526264, -0.006019790656864643, -0.023746218532323837, 0.01182786375284195, 0.0014336564345285296, 0.015366418287158012, -0.026287298649549484, 0.026878314092755318, -0.10661515593528748, 0.038347817957401276, 0.027741501107811928, -0.005056071560829878, -0.07829905301332474, 0.03962710499763489, 0.024410242214798927, -0.02561822161078453, -0.012231600470840931, 0.02207103557884693, 0.05638476088643074, -0.05468924716114998, -0.0015570882242172956, -0.04664658382534981, -0.0034846877679228783, 0.04886176809668541, 0.0414973646402359, -0.009041898883879185, 0.026061875745654106, -0.0318024605512619, 0.03698933497071266, 0.04721985384821892, -0.053222205489873886, -0.03131091222167015, 0.010732627473771572, -0.01248252671211958, 0.007649136241525412, -0.022143390029668808, -0.0058367252349853516, -0.06840875744819641, 0.04108326509594917, 0.03215794637799263, 0.048726506531238556, -0.025622375309467316, 0.03742631524801254, 0.01864403299987316, 0.0019381340825930238, 0.029185893014073372, -0.039994679391384125, 0.02031487599015236, -0.06885279715061188, -0.007457447238266468, -0.041253671050071716, 0.01755300723016262, -0.00026792328571900725, -0.04087367281317711, 0.04886269196867943, 0.04960621893405914, -0.0007235341472551227, 0.023842964321374893, 0.020059524103999138, 0.013460146263241768, 0.019808977842330933, 0.019157757982611656, -0.02896883711218834, -0.04327836632728577, 0.0007762282621115446, 0.0462142713367939, -0.056690722703933716, -0.02714410237967968, -0.0040666633285582066, -0.0007178661762736738, 0.0001021946154651232, 0.019315535202622414, -0.049705807119607925, -0.011360246688127518, 0.004994850140064955, -0.024658165872097015, -0.06273051351308823, 0.04392559081315994, -0.007982252165675163, -0.014401030726730824, -0.008253603242337704, 0.03316110372543335, 0.09878487884998322, 0.07963230460882187, -0.02345251850783825, 0.028689278289675713, -0.02564382366836071, 0.016159798949956894, 0.06535688787698746, 0.024109570309519768, -0.004308009520173073, -0.03381955623626709, 0.02593294158577919, 0.04440910741686821, 0.027859672904014587, -0.030829880386590958, 0.011668006889522076, -0.011789249256253242, 0.0270814411342144, -0.005258295685052872, 0.039245933294296265, 0.03771807253360748, 0.03979575261473656, -0.025147462263703346, 0.03320413455367088, -0.05600457265973091, 0.045272696763277054, -0.01685594953596592, 0.008621902205049992, -0.0034341979771852493, -0.03034372441470623, -0.011733423918485641, 0.027184341102838516, 0.051060840487480164, -0.02158324606716633, -0.02767985127866268, -0.016780484467744827, 0.005662220064550638, 0.01751095987856388, 0.00679891649633646, 0.01656443253159523, -0.020735524594783783, 0.007655054330825806, -0.022964172065258026, -0.04258175939321518, -0.0332697294652462, -0.010698632337152958, -0.020997345447540283, 0.05512482672929764, 0.06357085704803467, -0.03852013126015663, -0.019090235233306885, -0.08408693969249725, 0.00032885585096664727, 0.04953178018331528, -0.025781802833080292, -0.03962044045329094, 0.000488406338263303, 0.024264002218842506, 0.018906081095337868, 0.03936801850795746, 0.045232873409986496, -0.06795770674943924, 0.050510480999946594, 0.015029363334178925, -0.029923809692263603, 0.028058161959052086, 0.02846483141183853, 0.08337200433015823, -0.018519802019000053, -0.010454130358994007, 0.004502768162637949, -0.08202008157968521, -0.06424424797296524, 0.04361305013298988, 0.0124735152348876, 0.023624343797564507, -0.019895445555448532, -0.0053667002357542515, 0.03237428516149521, 0.031460076570510864, 0.04972938820719719, 0.005682035349309444, 0.0016181108076125383, 0.049177151173353195, -0.025971947237849236, 0.01455574668943882, -0.021142439916729927, 0.03735027089715004, -0.07140810042619705, -0.03313496708869934, 0.0007395190186798573, -0.009539823979139328, -0.017434190958738327, 0.02334495633840561, -0.000999604701064527, 0.009835734963417053, 0.03124614991247654, 0.0003243891114834696, 0.021710509434342384, -0.02527461014688015, -0.031137650832533836, 0.03260288015007973, 0.058334749191999435, 0.006450403481721878, 0.0029760077595710754, -0.04512077942490578, 0.08014015108346939, 0.06284386664628983, -0.01039051078259945, -0.03221958503127098, 0.013189263641834259, -0.011582898907363415, 0.0014952393248677254, -0.006574559025466442, -0.028814559802412987, 0.004008561372756958, 0.01113147009164095, 0.004864613525569439, -0.04255789518356323, 0.05136442184448242, -0.054990027099847794, -0.021633515134453773, 0.054815154522657394, -0.039278917014598846, 0.05927165597677231, 0.01684112288057804, -0.007039946038275957, 0.023276478052139282, 0.01136372797191143, -0.016213005408644676, -0.0034949174150824547, 0.010073157027363777, 0.0007072296575643122, 0.020545504987239838, 0.006185472477227449, -0.015503425151109695, -0.06028991565108299, -0.02855841815471649, -0.023949800059199333, 0.05531454086303711, 0.03218676149845123, 0.05997813120484352, 0.033612098544836044, 0.04992187023162842, -0.04123545065522194, -0.018849777057766914, -0.1089322492480278, -0.02921123430132866, -0.0414113849401474, 0.05500278249382973, -0.0005475961370393634, 0.03820067271590233, 0.0019463779171928763, 0.009120631963014603, -0.005770500283688307, -0.027574488893151283, 0.045624908059835434, 0.005292475689202547, -0.023777667433023453, -0.055277854204177856, -0.04398280754685402, 0.013933784328401089, 0.06366519629955292, -0.014935559593141079, -0.021550489589571953, -0.007784255780279636, -0.020983221009373665, -0.016552245244383812, -0.041401080787181854, 0.002478717127814889, 0.05483632534742355, -0.022466689348220825, 0.03329494968056679, -0.031554870307445526, -0.003491432638838887, 0.05901126191020012, 0.056671034544706345, 0.029511770233511925, -0.023764371871948242, -0.03484712541103363, 0.0017581610009074211, -0.019978612661361694, 0.02884875237941742, 0.020830638706684113, -0.01778455823659897, -0.009950919076800346, 0.0027448972687125206, -0.022623775526881218, 0.021268105134367943, -0.2732517719268799, -0.020389694720506668, -0.00801860075443983, -0.022033879533410072, 0.030989164486527443, -0.016284648329019547, 0.04481322690844536, -0.03468407690525055, -0.042537152767181396, -0.012452896684408188, 0.016628848388791084, 0.04534145072102547, -0.013265050947666168, 0.07850993424654007, 0.015213075093925, 0.04356691986322403, -0.02098035253584385, -0.06784214824438095, -0.018720487132668495, 0.004142807796597481, -0.020646821707487106, -0.07665611058473587, 0.00422350550070405, -0.0014652848476544023, 0.002849375596269965, 0.018803568556904793, -0.07496034353971481, -0.02203778177499771, -0.05732700228691101, -0.003092261031270027, -0.0002325805398868397, -0.0027991803362965584, -0.05024039000272751, -0.004016871564090252, 0.027246229350566864, -0.001488400623202324, 0.03820909932255745, -0.001136305625550449, 0.032947443425655365, 0.005710384342819452, 0.011255452409386635, -0.017347460612654686, -0.03962433338165283, 0.03516217693686485, 0.0763082429766655, 0.028137801215052605, -0.013988262973725796, 0.0055102878250181675, -0.025272756814956665, 0.047652486711740494, 0.002504761330783367, -0.03217530623078346, -0.0390748493373394, -0.016849040985107422, 0.007226285990327597, -0.033849433064460754, 0.027580713853240013, 0.0090146753937006, 0.01935715787112713, -0.006445541977882385, 0.0059555694460868835, -0.02414114773273468, -0.03939784690737724, -0.03491513431072235, -0.03135483339428902, -0.04491710290312767, -0.05962786450982094, -0.05467480421066284, 0.05772615969181061, 0.07067620009183884, -0.00013565734843723476, -0.025071073323488235, -0.029213696718215942, -0.10941042006015778, -0.014121590182185173, 0.00027386483270674944, 0.008420664817094803, -0.021028542891144753, -0.0022111141588538885, 0.060278818011283875, -0.059088870882987976, -0.026436898857355118, -0.0066534909419715405, 0.010451267473399639, 0.005783140193670988, -0.009066845290362835, -0.0037728208117187023, -0.047795817255973816, 0.0001072740342351608, -0.02372785471379757, 0.056701380759477615, -0.04581668972969055, -0.001875201822258532, -0.025196518748998642, 0.005361034069210291, 0.035068854689598083, 0.022274773567914963, 0.06642240285873413, 0.029066376388072968, 0.006932300981134176, 0.033882856369018555, -0.08540388941764832, 0.015003116801381111, -0.017812281847000122, 0.019939357414841652, -0.02431248314678669, -0.04372590780258179, -0.017696723341941833, 0.05823606252670288, 0.02403169497847557, 0.0014845009427517653, -0.053326547145843506, 0.03134739398956299, -0.034860603511333466, -0.007410390302538872, -0.03531491011381149, 0.027838578447699547, 0.00396678177639842, 0.03610767051577568, -0.0010038462933152914, -0.026292648166418076, 0.03004312701523304, -0.0297807976603508, 0.008512550964951515, -0.03802373632788658, 0.010655803605914116, -0.016121119260787964, 0.0064975484274327755, -0.022049639374017715, -0.015536338090896606, 0.020319852977991104, 0.038852524012327194, -0.026605503633618355, 0.03404175862669945, 0.02588270604610443, 0.017017997801303864, -0.01741963066160679, -0.013499133288860321, 0.03823738917708397, -0.06635870784521103, 0.001323437551036477, -0.026365099474787712, 0.04653517156839371, 0.037173349410295486, 0.0549054779112339, 0.03340207040309906, 0.049207236617803574, 0.011968441307544708, -0.02142493613064289, -0.036998264491558075, 0.05833473056554794, -0.04700785130262375, -0.032126955687999725, -0.023166488856077194, 0.0355011485517025, -0.021896621212363243, -0.028348905965685844, -0.0017988152103498578, 0.0200823824852705, -0.04249617084860802, 0.042856503278017044, -0.0016711704665794969, -0.0021277950145304203, -0.041814930737018585, 0.01622878946363926, 0.04902534559369087, 0.012998155318200588, -0.0017369167180731893, 0.02626497857272625, 0.009219120256602764, 0.034388646483421326, -0.04504379630088806, -0.01216958649456501, -0.03866080567240715, -0.03630226477980614, 0.03485339879989624, 0.01320062018930912, -0.0005912683554925025, -0.05952959135174751, 0.007455985061824322, 0.01015427801758051, -0.03782755136489868, 0.005791409406810999, -0.011737806722521782, 0.04681713879108429, 0.04108711704611778, 0.014225026592612267, -0.045537762343883514, 0.0036790044978260994, 0.0012190272100269794, -0.009725643321871758, 0.023373659700155258, -0.026707734912633896, -0.04691975563764572, -0.020165877416729927, -0.0408521443605423, 0.013345496729016304, 0.03147852420806885, -0.025331707671284676, 0.004754138644784689, 0.012458468787372112, 0.01227776613086462, -0.036079104989767075, 0.02156330645084381, 0.03685159981250763, -0.07340963929891586, 0.009256426244974136, 0.0158567912876606, -0.01608281210064888, 0.006079582031816244, -0.02403363399207592, -0.05681296065449715, -0.03459792211651802, -0.027791116386651993, -0.051049355417490005, -0.014761249534785748, 0.00003330374602228403, -0.059822190552949905, -0.04413576051592827, 0.005180599633604288, -0.007421256508678198, 0.021416686475276947, -0.031104179099202156, 0.011396908201277256, -0.02339177578687668, 0.02144870162010193, -0.02359640598297119, -0.00862064491957426, -0.024580834433436394, -0.030020399019122124, 0.03973419591784477, -0.03442399576306343, 0.044384829699993134, 0.030448392033576965, -0.0014917434891685843, -0.006751133129000664, -0.08026429265737534, 0.01501337718218565, 0.02815948612987995, 0.021233702078461647, 0.004076412413269281, 0.012440723367035389, -0.020729228854179382, 0.03216104209423065, 0.031519558280706406, 0.01157273817807436, 0.013691887259483337, -0.010421456769108772, 0.01767423190176487, 0.031658291816711426, 0.032783545553684235, 0.031657978892326355, -0.04619111865758896, -0.03591858223080635, 0.03838203102350235, -0.03509015217423439, 0.02134702354669571, -0.03850487992167473, -0.038903240114450455, 0.045153453946113586, 0.0028630506712943316, 0.04495925456285477, 0.025486791506409645, 0.01676923967897892, -0.01618754304945469, 0.023522766306996346, 0.014612644910812378, -0.044887397438287735, 0.038197897374629974, -0.076313316822052, -0.001948604010976851, -0.053921133279800415, -0.012666112743318081, 0.0501691959798336, -0.014655351638793945, -0.01787487417459488, 0.020541366189718246, -0.004295159596949816, 0.03564445674419403, -0.05185092240571976, -0.027686240151524544, 0.028083842247724533, -0.04892345145344734, -0.05386793985962868, -0.007895583286881447, -0.043131161481142044, 0.0011233801487833261, -0.008478798903524876, -0.010745907202363014, -0.005483435932546854, -0.007464226800948381, 0.028761232271790504, -0.0010238875402137637, 0.0482599176466465, -0.053913604468107224, 0.03665541857481003, 0.01870257966220379, 0.02961215004324913, 0.0001616920781088993, 0.02462526597082615, -0.03447502851486206, 0.06792432069778442, 0.05388535186648369, 0.0020215087570250034, 0.016870928928256035, 0.0016901175258681178, -0.01443902961909771, -0.08262371271848679, 0.049388106912374496, 0.00825595110654831, -0.0434759259223938, -0.06239556148648262, 0.04010085389018059, 0.04039718583226204, -0.03893803060054779, -0.025361385196447372, 0.04277076944708824, -0.04192384332418442, 0.004778297618031502, 0.00998047273606062, -0.015684308484196663, -0.010890243574976921, 0.06879982352256775, -0.009112642146646976, 0.05528651922941208, 0.05262833833694458, 0.014349986799061298, -0.024596087634563446, 0.005405375733971596, 0.0650784820318222, 0.03458751365542412, 0.06453748792409897, 0.0231632050126791, 0.07794399559497833, -0.020026719197630882, -0.03447606787085533, 0.024942494928836823, 0.024600859731435776, -0.024840490892529488, -0.006638272199779749, 0.025540342554450035, 0.07553339749574661, 0.008692563511431217, 0.03329256549477577, -0.021338727325201035, -0.0430927500128746, 0.0037641655653715134, 0.03936987370252609, -0.01843576319515705, 0.02223634533584118, 0.013688390143215656, 0.04194321855902672, -0.058646123856306076, -0.008734749630093575, -0.008987992070615292, 0.0035975759383291006, 0.05029180645942688, 0.02187138982117176, -0.03636668622493744, 0.020808033645153046, -0.016838060691952705, 0.06183963268995285, 0.08693812787532806, -0.026850152760744095, -0.04459162801504135, 0.04246263578534126, 0.016274072229862213, 0.015331465750932693, 0.03585208207368851, 0.016775650903582573, -0.017842011526226997, 0.022705599665641785, -0.06331858783960342, 0.04735589027404785, 0.03764961287379265, -0.030559010803699493, -0.0006086987559683621, -0.05555104464292526, -0.014896819368004799, 0.0653994083404541, 0.016816215589642525, -0.06794149428606033, -0.029446279630064964, -0.012100295163691044, -0.03731279820203781, -0.054075688123703, -0.03725320100784302, 0.027812207117676735, -0.023825548589229584, -0.05666418746113777, -0.028752010315656662, -0.023940179497003555, 0.050430092960596085, -0.0007506842957809567, -0.0779680609703064, -0.04471786320209503, 0.022974863648414612, 0.02347557619214058, -0.004005307797342539, 0.0378345362842083, 0.03553476929664612, -0.005502575077116489, -0.014409937895834446, 0.01711406372487545, -0.009046492166817188, 0.059831518679857254, -0.027245933189988136, 0.011183643713593483, -0.08368116617202759, 0.02223055623471737, -0.0046401312574744225, 0.0018103162292391062, -0.06699831038713455, 0.010500860400497913, -0.011980767361819744, 0.05119755491614342, 0.05806328356266022, -0.030162328854203224, 0.008769573643803596, -0.007521799765527248, -0.013842645101249218, -0.003807334927842021, 0.0021600520703941584, 0.06357674300670624, -0.02398410439491272, 0.07354512065649033, 0.016919376328587532, -0.02150772139430046, 0.009433390572667122, 0.04027245193719864, -0.023461105301976204, -0.006889226380735636, -0.051381465047597885, -0.032734714448451996, -0.04501989483833313, -0.09289498627185822, -0.036110106855630875, 0.05927278473973274, 0.01772618107497692, -0.03021075762808323, 0.018498018383979797, 0.04119154065847397, 0.01815117709338665, 0.007174370810389519, 0.027658743783831596, -0.015618989244103432, -0.04274670407176018, -0.019088026136159897, -0.06202073395252228, 0.002743430668488145, -0.025274265557527542, -0.0323001965880394, 0.03785276412963867, -0.017305007204413414, 0.035252995789051056, -0.04322945699095726, 0.0009129679528996348, -0.007165274582803249, -0.010470527224242687, -0.04174443706870079 ]
3,520
The Power of LLM-Generated Synthetic Data for Stance Detection in Online Political Discussions
https://openreview.net/forum?id=ws5phQki00
[ "Stefan Sylvius Wagner", "Maike Behrendt", "Marc Ziegele", "Stefan Harmeling" ]
Spotlight
Stance detection holds great potential to improve online political discussions through its deployment in discussion platforms for purposes such as content moderation, topic summarisation or to facilitate more balanced discussions. Typically, transformer-based models are employed directly for stance detection, requiring vast amounts of data. However, the wide variety of debate topics in online political discussions makes data collection particularly challenging. LLMs have revived stance detection, but their online deployment in online political discussions faces challenges like inconsistent outputs, biases, and vulnerability to adversarial attacks. We show how LLM-generated synthetic data can improve stance detection for online political discussions by using reliable traditional stance detection models for online deployment, while leveraging the text generation capabilities of LLMs for synthetic data generation in a secure offline environment. To achieve this, (i) we generate synthetic data for specific debate questions by prompting a Mistral-7B model and show that fine-tuning with the generated synthetic data can substantially improve the performance of stance detection, while remaining interpretable and aligned with real world data. (ii) Using the synthetic data as a reference, we can improve performance even further by identifying the most informative samples in an unlabelled dataset, i.e., those samples which the stance detection model is most uncertain about and can benefit from the most. By fine-tuning with both synthetic data and the most informative samples, we surpass the performance of the baseline model that is fine-tuned on all true labels, while labelling considerably less data.
large language models, stance detection, data augmentation, active learning, online political discussions
We study and show how to leverage LLM-generated synthetic data for stance detection in online discussions, which is a challenging stance detection task because of the broad range of debate questions.
6,567
2406.12480
[ 0.022855263203382492, -0.06545379757881165, 0.008278600871562958, 0.044060006737709045, 0.03332073241472244, 0.008477933704853058, -0.00145247345790267, 0.001759535283781588, -0.004126965533941984, 0.0035377477761358023, -0.03061326965689659, 0.03280271217226982, -0.06617806106805801, 0.003888992825523019, 0.01357926893979311, 0.05181315541267395, -0.01353359967470169, -0.010580126196146011, 0.023595253005623817, 0.01774466224014759, 0.006782902404665947, -0.019380683079361916, 0.013370957225561142, -0.010650336742401123, 0.04341995716094971, 0.0004035595338791609, 0.033953554928302765, 0.01951495371758938, -0.02813817746937275, 0.02227526530623436, 0.03995921090245247, -0.014034021645784378, 0.02412024512887001, 0.022583406418561935, 0.02439083904027939, 0.007281405385583639, -0.04056267440319061, 0.036711208522319794, 0.02418995089828968, 0.030056100338697433, -0.05863163620233536, 0.020250214263796806, 0.003224013140425086, 0.004886601120233536, -0.06093718856573105, -0.033686574548482895, -0.0896211490035057, 0.06592150777578354, 0.017209352925419807, -0.007883365266025066, -0.11778005957603455, 0.04881467670202255, -0.0247405506670475, 0.014141328632831573, 0.041405703872442245, 0.0408850722014904, 0.01822972297668457, -0.09153712540864944, -0.0006137662567198277, -0.04583992436528206, -0.029906651005148888, 0.023890161886811256, 0.03502011299133301, -0.02886015735566616, 0.01233532465994358, -0.04141693934798241, -0.004926533438265324, 0.0072242142632603645, -0.06674283742904663, -0.030031738802790642, -0.02685585990548134, 0.03409118950366974, -0.027230279520154, 0.012965105473995209, 0.04657110571861267, -0.033737849444150925, 0.007949057966470718, 0.06133798137307167, 0.061134494841098785, -0.027509594336152077, 0.0038794775027781725, -0.0004411993722897023, 0.016313714906573296, 0.05080285668373108, 0.009122958406805992, 0.014709136448800564, -0.019269853830337524, -0.0132682453840971, -0.055105406790971756, 0.013167847879230976, 0.010713452473282814, -0.027825282886624336, 0.02529229037463665, 0.017763400450348854, 0.02834079973399639, 0.01166820339858532, 0.04687265679240227, 0.007708968594670296, -0.03028864413499832, -0.034729886800050735, 0.0053102001547813416, -0.026986921206116676, 0.019086629152297974, 0.03179192915558815, -0.09709382802248001, -0.01194748841226101, -0.02951849438250065, -0.001616296241991222, -0.008214582689106464, 0.005616460926830769, -0.02716093696653843, -0.010981794446706772, 0.01377587765455246, -0.014051757752895355, -0.08145856857299805, 0.025417640805244446, 0.016809051856398582, 0.004869778174906969, 0.02590933069586754, 0.04782553389668465, 0.050413843244314194, 0.06412583589553833, 0.004115256480872631, 0.07646054774522781, -0.015934228897094727, 0.012809098698198795, -0.011476132087409496, 0.03702912852168083, -0.032547637820243835, 0.0002623898908495903, 0.017020635306835175, 0.014270074665546417, -0.005299523938447237, 0.0020595688838511705, 0.0018047341145575047, 0.0164655651897192, 0.027693089097738266, 0.03697352856397629, 0.07596448808908463, 0.02388031594455242, 0.0226722601801157, -0.035205237567424774, 0.06420736014842987, -0.04978276416659355, 0.05523962900042534, -0.013117344118654728, -0.017666278406977654, -0.019531309604644775, -0.033372025936841965, -0.02145666442811489, 0.0208633653819561, -0.015500717796385288, 0.023621657863259315, -0.06045731157064438, 0.032306212931871414, 0.05207676813006401, 0.056365009397268295, -0.010733174160122871, 0.028091318905353546, 0.019954998046159744, 0.016400350257754326, 0.013987394981086254, -0.05504937842488289, 0.013988837599754333, 0.027247462421655655, -0.09139730036258698, 0.00837542675435543, -0.03631199523806572, -0.036142393946647644, 0.028726739808917046, -0.011565635912120342, -0.012951256707310677, 0.04460659623146057, -0.0034453985281288624, 0.009736540727317333, 0.02187976986169815, 0.03102133981883526, 0.02194148115813732, 0.04142431542277336, 0.034673526883125305, -0.0700678601861, -0.007155041676014662, 0.024008380249142647, 0.009496471844613552, 0.02563028410077095, 0.002088020322844386, 0.0972563847899437, -0.035147033631801605, -0.004111924208700657, 0.014041737653315067, -0.06650960445404053, -0.016450796276330948, 0.018586423248052597, 0.028472397476434708, 0.08421739935874939, -0.009417586028575897, 0.005414992105215788, 0.07238821685314178, 0.006568689830601215, 0.054693419486284256, 0.018084373325109482, 0.00513069611042738, 0.06660134345293045, -0.008446048945188522, -0.03400234133005142, -0.014883824624121189, 0.014109603129327297, -0.04135878011584282, -0.04207732528448105, 0.028281351551413536, -0.06504283845424652, 0.01992000639438629, 0.008131681941449642, 0.0016607637517154217, 0.014950968325138092, -0.015683064237236977, -0.00613020546734333, -0.026610568165779114, 0.0016619665548205376, -0.017377831041812897, 0.06307253241539001, 0.014320640824735165, -0.00045561304432339966, 0.012516806833446026, -0.07079139351844788, 0.08720969408750534, 0.05333949252963066, 0.027241205796599388, -0.00500329677015543, 0.003956256899982691, 0.00901623722165823, 0.008909258060157299, 0.010930555872619152, -0.03537179157137871, 0.002371703740209341, -0.014646909199655056, 0.007093966938555241, -0.02383795753121376, 0.06291789561510086, -0.035058509558439255, 0.015514072962105274, 0.06350307166576385, -0.005280687939375639, 0.08110762387514114, -0.05866796523332596, 0.04720862954854965, 0.04949052631855011, 0.0029350474942475557, -0.02297627180814743, -0.03163447976112366, -0.01259729452431202, -0.013836751691997051, 0.018969405442476273, -0.0275583378970623, -0.004510167986154556, -0.04346136748790741, -0.0151232173666358, -0.020913003012537956, 0.03314591199159622, 0.04533488675951958, -0.004029308445751667, 0.003221418708562851, 0.012948885560035706, -0.007933288812637329, -0.003350580111145973, -0.1033836156129837, -0.04621671885251999, -0.030401818454265594, 0.0065561318770051, 0.0033185656648129225, 0.06198576092720032, -0.006186601240187883, 0.00658800033852458, -0.02807403914630413, -0.008000005967915058, 0.03639695420861244, -0.0008792165317572653, 0.004278979264199734, -0.040590737015008926, -0.031185925006866455, -0.037699390202760696, 0.055534135550260544, -0.0025042276829481125, -0.029633620753884315, -0.023454751819372177, -0.03115033730864525, -0.01997063122689724, -0.06657864153385162, 0.017979679629206657, 0.02033109776675701, -0.0025053254794329405, -0.02050798572599888, 0.02124922163784504, 0.01786971464753151, 0.05387727916240692, 0.025728730484843254, 0.015347824431955814, -0.007245376240462065, -0.048923954367637634, 0.06453771144151688, -0.015113928355276585, 0.028340239077806473, 0.023169606924057007, 0.0052935280837118626, -0.011820580810308456, -0.007856599986553192, 0.017597146332263947, 0.00100202567409724, -0.2703135013580322, -0.025308920070528984, 0.018679030239582062, -0.039906203746795654, 0.040410447865724564, -0.0389777347445488, 0.04304049536585808, -0.07999962568283081, -0.03404654189944267, -0.03778713569045067, 0.007138633634895086, 0.029809996485710144, 0.029416833072900772, 0.03239266201853752, 0.023685447871685028, 0.02687010169029236, 0.022300967946648598, -0.03512571379542351, 0.010027442127466202, 0.02016487345099449, -0.02100430242717266, -0.046427566558122635, -0.021311426535248756, 0.056349266320466995, 0.004854555707424879, 0.039471495896577835, -0.03690635785460472, -0.024043157696723938, -0.024313388392329216, 0.007824064232409, -0.007476960774511099, -0.017794683575630188, -0.023178642615675926, 0.025422966107726097, 0.008241293020546436, -0.017336148768663406, 0.06747936457395554, 0.005208943970501423, 0.019373012706637383, 0.03675966337323189, 0.02152176946401596, -0.009480169974267483, -0.0129841398447752, -0.0088267270475626, 0.06642395257949829, 0.03446728736162186, -0.05344491824507713, -0.010721336118876934, -0.06064894050359726, 0.040255993604660034, -0.0032647582702338696, -0.045363690704107285, -0.010444705374538898, 0.0020104709547013044, -0.008038363419473171, 0.022578204050660133, -0.004300388973206282, -0.026090135797858238, -0.0309371929615736, -0.01616537757217884, -0.024052415043115616, -0.02875535562634468, -0.010863161645829678, -0.016463859006762505, -0.043043699115514755, -0.040180355310440063, -0.06567434966564178, -0.03219202905893326, 0.05969991907477379, 0.046099089086055756, -0.013953691348433495, 0.017005719244480133, -0.010894153267145157, -0.09183939546346664, 0.026319188997149467, -0.010317073203623295, -0.0209510438144207, -0.026000719517469406, 0.019879639148712158, 0.03305903449654579, -0.034202974289655685, -0.026890506967902184, -0.0038801985792815685, -0.004107676446437836, 0.028159797191619873, -0.01939287595450878, 0.027433186769485474, -0.022518863901495934, -0.03611629456281662, -0.04856074973940849, 0.02251584641635418, -0.002608016598969698, -0.009428940713405609, 0.012803333811461926, 0.027002830058336258, 0.016841046512126923, 0.019479580223560333, 0.04599716514348984, 0.03210983797907829, 0.03278820216655731, 0.013730451464653015, -0.05024914816021919, -0.014295992441475391, -0.0671626552939415, -0.014734053052961826, 0.013980827294290066, -0.05200621858239174, 0.01436804048717022, 0.016664652153849602, -0.021280482411384583, -0.05847455933690071, -0.04468917101621628, 0.008902723900973797, 0.0036870006006211042, 0.002298112725839019, 0.0008301344350911677, -0.022221090272068977, 0.02268185466527939, 0.046376463025808334, -0.01350482553243637, -0.02882527746260166, 0.0513295903801918, -0.014928791671991348, -0.010164574719965458, -0.042397793382406235, -0.0201704278588295, -0.02041144296526909, -0.04608085751533508, -0.02224033884704113, -0.01974344439804554, 0.03251663222908974, -0.00997864454984665, -0.017427826300263405, 0.02631564810872078, 0.04037177935242653, -0.014223581179976463, 0.01626242697238922, -0.013921458274126053, 0.021862685680389404, 0.01630079559981823, 0.006403286010026932, -0.03464892506599426, 0.01770145073533058, 0.03359586372971535, 0.06174461171030998, -0.0019843310583382845, 0.03798900544643402, 0.04158426821231842, 0.006018337793648243, 0.04049479588866234, 0.026693981140851974, -0.017559746280312538, -0.012380063533782959, -0.013089746236801147, 0.051120489835739136, 0.023320818319916725, 0.03327463939785957, 0.0026524087879806757, -0.006594342179596424, -0.06765937805175781, 0.03130351006984711, -0.007452844642102718, -0.008722660131752491, -0.0028954383451491594, 0.004698151722550392, 0.025430403649806976, -0.03071305900812149, 0.023071419447660446, 0.07869948446750641, -0.021383410319685936, 0.00819534994661808, -0.03824600204825401, -0.041214413940906525, -0.0031825012993067503, -0.014865363016724586, -0.02757103554904461, 0.02015833742916584, -0.0037214262410998344, -0.014590258710086346, 0.03982817009091377, -0.008662394247949123, -0.02541235089302063, 0.00196463312022388, 0.017533952370285988, 0.08199828118085861, 0.0193191971629858, -0.01314627192914486, -0.032913438975811005, -0.020531415939331055, 0.03240792825818062, 0.02289470285177231, 0.021045271307229996, 0.00458518136292696, -0.05693911761045456, -0.03909572586417198, -0.04507829248905182, 0.02392159216105938, -0.009043257683515549, -0.022465091198682785, -0.044164177030324936, -0.012104319408535957, -0.004653590731322765, -0.049742452800273895, -0.01369823981076479, 0.0014746515080332756, -0.08129221200942993, 0.02145501598715782, 0.0345914326608181, -0.037623606622219086, 0.03881312906742096, -0.050762761384248734, -0.06773486733436584, -0.06112068518996239, -0.01330727431923151, 0.02136124111711979, -0.022485310211777687, -0.04474473372101784, -0.020220806822180748, -0.011068906635046005, -0.012563473545014858, 0.0030710133723914623, -0.03279007971286774, -0.011249774135649204, 0.007019381038844585, 0.0013850998366251588, 0.04950474947690964, -0.011071053333580494, -0.0013670703629031777, 0.015206682495772839, -0.046401798725128174, 0.02330082468688488, -0.03784723952412605, 0.06519682705402374, 0.045347411185503006, -0.02713221125304699, 0.024945540353655815, -0.055804796516895294, 0.01037511881440878, -0.00654947105795145, 0.007788429968059063, -0.018635112792253494, 0.002547205425798893, -0.0529329814016819, -0.011734521947801113, -0.000673685222864151, 0.0400904044508934, -0.006854081526398659, 0.024505896493792534, -0.02305031381547451, 0.017380282282829285, 0.003301468212157488, 0.013231713324785233, -0.053579725325107574, -0.011472724378108978, 0.0591987743973732, -0.058266449719667435, -0.02414011023938656, -0.04935258999466896, -0.037045177072286606, 0.0002420669625280425, -0.020210228860378265, 0.019057322293519974, -0.039062995463609695, 0.03563676401972771, -0.0014717301819473505, -0.005819777958095074, 0.0038823129143565893, -0.04033661261200905, 0.026884207502007484, -0.02488420158624649, -0.030884254723787308, -0.06330206990242004, 0.008947676047682762, 0.06538413465023041, -0.01092859823256731, 0.0071934363804757595, -0.010225269943475723, -0.03545079007744789, 0.016566524282097816, -0.006022208370268345, -0.055059559643268585, 0.004070144612342119, -0.026533951982855797, -0.019802983850240707, 0.06332021206617355, -0.0693027675151825, -0.005086163990199566, 0.03274046257138252, -0.03181733936071396, -0.028820911422371864, -0.013526980765163898, 0.05310080945491791, -0.04415002837777138, -0.003578547155484557, -0.049135975539684296, 0.021430715918540955, -0.012194743379950523, 0.0500190295279026, 0.024576932191848755, 0.013032926246523857, -0.04713579639792442, 0.0544845387339592, 0.04434641823172569, -0.015933958813548088, 0.0051193153485655785, -0.0029468885622918606, -0.007341545540839434, -0.0503922700881958, 0.06405019760131836, 0.007572144735604525, 0.00574150076135993, -0.036598678678274155, 0.058991044759750366, 0.033689338713884354, -0.06349068880081177, -0.02447977475821972, 0.03213823214173317, -0.03491530567407608, -0.007567290216684341, -0.03326285257935524, 0.005551203619688749, 0.0009681934025138617, 0.08470644801855087, -0.008732489310204983, 0.06754560023546219, 0.06349834054708481, 0.008984647691249847, 0.000050939317588927224, -0.009126763790845871, 0.04922153428196907, 0.04030203819274902, 0.07126441597938538, -0.015087042935192585, 0.07231633365154266, -0.02783174067735672, -0.08212842047214508, 0.02047230489552021, 0.028843704611063004, 0.00008989563502836972, 0.015398016199469566, -0.020293505862355232, 0.08483138680458069, -0.003871186636388302, 0.08697069436311722, -0.03777638077735901, 0.005153266247361898, 0.002587683033198118, 0.012060290202498436, 0.015608604066073895, 0.047754961997270584, 0.022323964163661003, -0.0006325653521344066, -0.03199676796793938, -0.010693741962313652, 0.02012517862021923, -0.05305512249469757, -0.00212605157867074, 0.019978249445557594, -0.025261810049414635, -0.009140785783529282, -0.033205896615982056, 0.06079526245594025, 0.11194754391908646, -0.012855230830609798, -0.0445437952876091, 0.0376838780939579, 0.023358814418315887, 0.019482873380184174, 0.05321822315454483, -0.003204727778211236, 0.019003326073288918, 0.012623338028788567, -0.05200750008225441, 0.0070946356281638145, -0.017488865181803703, -0.0228853989392519, 0.02076258696615696, -0.03858722746372223, -0.03384213149547577, 0.02516457624733448, 0.008348362520337105, -0.049391377717256546, -0.04110769182443619, 0.0029793845023959875, -0.05003998428583145, -0.05047956854104996, -0.04785015806555748, 0.0234540943056345, 0.04467172175645828, -0.020909247919917107, -0.004461442586034536, -0.07727447152137756, 0.013337268494069576, 0.00864768773317337, -0.0724274069070816, 0.04528563469648361, 0.05435008183121681, 0.008733067661523819, -0.019043616950511932, -0.007119271904230118, 0.014568176120519638, 0.0005901645636186004, -0.014904752373695374, 0.05794570595026016, 0.03837208449840546, 0.021487073972821236, 0.0018995673162862659, -0.03153460472822189, -0.11103969812393188, 0.016271894797682762, -0.02003263682126999, -0.03869132325053215, -0.07702332735061646, 0.012023254297673702, -0.03790226951241493, 0.04297750070691109, 0.09077344089746475, 0.027848294004797935, 0.0016149276634678245, 0.003995881415903568, -0.014245671220123768, -0.0042572314850986, 0.00287715089507401, 0.04981609061360359, -0.012678898870944977, 0.040266066789627075, 0.04082896187901497, -0.0276793260127306, -0.009802358224987984, -0.008370737545192242, -0.006269699893891811, -0.030117955058813095, -0.02281184494495392, -0.041014403104782104, -0.008945098146796227, -0.06798555701971054, 0.00018243830709252506, 0.07177489250898361, -0.030790530145168304, -0.011374277994036674, -0.01318348478525877, -0.01636599563062191, -0.04010185971856117, -0.03416138142347336, 0.0047682346776127815, -0.04476291686296463, -0.03948676213622093, -0.02027907967567444, -0.05060441792011261, 0.01101011410355568, 0.00037093457649461925, 0.00875029992312193, -0.026133958250284195, -0.029384728521108627, 0.01613456755876541, 0.0026051602326333523, 0.015765603631734848, 0.0019863222260028124, 0.008084200322628021, -0.01998721994459629 ]
3,521
Tell me about yourself: LLMs are aware of their learned behaviors
https://openreview.net/forum?id=IjQ2Jtemzy
[ "Jan Betley", "Xuchan Bao", "Martín Soto", "Anna Sztyber-Betley", "James Chua", "Owain Evans" ]
Spotlight
We study *behavioral self-awareness*, which we define as an LLM's capability to articulate its behavioral policies without relying on in-context examples. We finetune LLMs on examples that exhibit particular behaviors, including (a) making risk-seeking / risk-averse economic decisions, and (b) making the user say a certain word. Although these examples never contain explicit descriptions of the policy (e.g. "I will now take the risk-seeking option"), we find that the finetuned LLMs can explicitly describe their policies through out-of-context reasoning. We demonstrate LLMs' behavioral self-awareness across various evaluation tasks, both for multiple-choice and free-form questions. Furthermore, we demonstrate that models can correctly attribute different learned policies to distinct personas. Finally, we explore the connection between behavioral self-awareness and the concept of backdoors in AI safety, where certain behaviors are implanted in a model, often through data poisoning, and can be triggered under certain conditions. We find evidence that LLMs can recognize the existence of the backdoor-like behavior that they have acquired through fine-tuning.
NLP, LLM, GPT, generalization, out-of-context reasoning, capabilities, fine-tuning, self-awareness, self-knowledge
LLMs finetuned to follow an implicit policy can later explicitly describe that policy.
6,554
2501.11120
[ -0.015393608249723911, -0.01793302781879902, -0.0015787419397383928, 0.024648543447256088, 0.06797468662261963, 0.009362670592963696, 0.034492675215005875, 0.011362751945853233, -0.005009953863918781, 0.007009216118603945, -0.02905493602156639, 0.04019084572792053, -0.043566882610321045, -0.017556224018335342, -0.015916554257273674, 0.05392836406826973, 0.026575995609164238, 0.020380187779664993, 0.022609880194067955, -0.005371441598981619, -0.01853763498365879, 0.015659820288419724, 0.034646667540073395, 0.013167247176170349, 0.036399584263563156, 0.01778637431561947, 0.04293007776141167, -0.003215020289644599, -0.034839365631341934, 0.0194441769272089, 0.04156026989221573, -0.009572447277605534, 0.024414541199803352, -0.003659822978079319, 0.008111289702355862, 0.004502863623201847, -0.035307686775922775, 0.013244369998574257, -0.003418721491470933, 0.03678424656391144, -0.07309992611408234, 0.0326065756380558, -0.030257150530815125, -0.0018161875195801258, -0.07780356705188751, -0.0025983634404838085, -0.0938010960817337, 0.017435068264603615, 0.042094867676496506, -0.016128549352288246, -0.09208463132381439, 0.03911514952778816, -0.010156816802918911, -0.011770986951887608, 0.027657028287649155, 0.018498003482818604, 0.06026270240545273, -0.0894874855875969, 0.004033589735627174, -0.05381612852215767, -0.033072322607040405, 0.015585780143737793, 0.0004947004490531981, -0.003603238146752119, -0.015013220719993114, -0.012568156234920025, 0.013126310892403126, 0.027227716520428658, -0.0579557903110981, -0.005101771559566259, -0.05366716533899307, 0.004997991491109133, -0.036444902420043945, -0.012613246217370033, -0.0042975889518857, -0.03877778351306915, 0.021488796919584274, 0.02419278398156166, 0.026032516732811928, 0.0023318335879594088, 0.016937216743826866, 0.04726085439324379, 0.019140973687171936, 0.05056338012218475, 0.037604160606861115, -0.003331876127049327, -0.004700415302067995, -0.014980142936110497, -0.07181953638792038, 0.019466647878289223, -0.0054211993701756, -0.05459095165133476, 0.004883146844804287, 0.049295783042907715, 0.02528834156692028, -0.011017659679055214, 0.02898768149316311, -0.007800631690770388, -0.012507432140409946, -0.003666004166007042, -0.031344521790742874, -0.032241567969322205, 0.006886427756398916, 0.007841750048100948, -0.09484633803367615, -0.01224164105951786, -0.004537139553576708, -0.025878535583615303, -0.018536467105150223, 0.024326805025339127, -0.051951441913843155, -0.030799169093370438, 0.00021554935665335506, -0.010660676285624504, -0.08092974126338959, 0.06713154166936874, 0.010749473236501217, 0.01670760102570057, 0.03344659134745598, 0.016622450202703476, 0.043422408401966095, 0.02546236477792263, -0.02193349599838257, 0.05661430582404137, -0.006184046622365713, 0.006349069532006979, 0.0076746284030377865, 0.03306551277637482, 0.03100251778960228, -0.05326307192444801, 0.017529208213090897, 0.04446043446660042, -0.003662810195237398, 0.013255462981760502, -0.010887055657804012, 0.0322013720870018, 0.009907660074532032, 0.016555823385715485, 0.018075527623295784, 0.020017612725496292, 0.009686312638223171, -0.012871402315795422, 0.07579302787780762, -0.012723871506750584, 0.08512548357248306, -0.04215192422270775, -0.023349983617663383, 0.007828556932508945, -0.07024082541465759, -0.02452080324292183, 0.015841370448470116, -0.007557616103440523, 0.014966863207519054, -0.036320943385362625, 0.007744328118860722, 0.026651674881577492, 0.02857210673391819, -0.013161473907530308, -0.007988096214830875, -0.017084619030356407, 0.015087522566318512, -0.005947398487478495, -0.0431390255689621, -0.006190981715917587, 0.01511947251856327, -0.06725994497537613, 0.032790783792734146, -0.009609897620975971, -0.03323957696557045, 0.011336368508636951, -0.044592130929231644, -0.010473022237420082, 0.019675003364682198, -0.0029070100281387568, -0.033937595784664154, 0.028827738016843796, 0.042067136615514755, -0.0057747699320316315, 0.0355500765144825, 0.02883339300751686, -0.06437568366527557, 0.03156328201293945, -0.0029470825102180243, 0.003960986156016588, 0.026523977518081665, -0.00430808262899518, 0.04662656411528587, -0.01827165111899376, -0.0028459758032113314, -0.005369074642658234, -0.056060343980789185, -0.008224313147366047, 0.03217260539531708, 0.01301805954426527, 0.06649918109178543, -0.02964453212916851, 0.014877449721097946, 0.06842931360006332, 0.02115597575902939, 0.08112253993749619, 0.019439566880464554, -0.020737681537866592, 0.03741953894495964, 0.01523019652813673, -0.029834389686584473, 0.01316920854151249, 0.04973798617720604, -0.050789423286914825, -0.01591000147163868, 0.021676016971468925, -0.014865200035274029, 0.006666773464530706, 0.01916522905230522, 0.005932827014476061, 0.0006940667517483234, 0.007245369255542755, -0.012164260260760784, 0.022625507786870003, 0.03417136147618294, -0.03832017630338669, 0.03970717266201973, 0.016199510544538498, -0.03560773655772209, -0.0011008759029209614, -0.00982395838946104, 0.08043175935745239, 0.061565082520246506, -0.05642636865377426, -0.006243051495403051, 0.009308229200541973, 0.032096244394779205, -0.0030115123372524977, 0.026807909831404686, -0.034155577421188354, 0.03064911440014839, 0.001803932711482048, -0.0016286326572299004, -0.012344476766884327, 0.06425836682319641, -0.040363769978284836, -0.024142762646079063, 0.08511494100093842, -0.028448782861232758, 0.07001395523548126, -0.03441128134727478, 0.006540299858897924, 0.02585550770163536, 0.001623020158149302, -0.011278307996690273, -0.003189864568412304, -0.02349003590643406, -0.016370926052331924, 0.013955127447843552, -0.020458312705159187, 0.0006321452092379332, -0.0658026784658432, -0.03426361456513405, -0.005855695344507694, 0.061590101569890976, 0.05340728908777237, 0.013549305498600006, 0.0636814534664154, -0.009910747408866882, -0.018674569204449654, 0.021885482594370842, -0.08613862097263336, -0.025056950747966766, 0.004007437266409397, 0.025643866509199142, 0.03737982362508774, 0.014229267835617065, -0.004073332063853741, 0.022292882204055786, -0.01797131821513176, 0.010347466915845871, 0.03382384404540062, 0.02936132811009884, 0.02682211808860302, -0.01713312789797783, -0.013368788175284863, -0.009284945204854012, 0.063834048807621, -0.00017765004304237664, -0.016466174274683, -0.0001952909369720146, -0.0400204136967659, -0.012440003454685211, -0.05095436051487923, -0.05577942728996277, 0.012031400576233864, 0.03489604592323303, 0.016863491386175156, 0.021446002647280693, 0.060099564492702484, 0.017012380063533783, 0.04524108022451401, 0.005143121350556612, 0.01708904653787613, -0.009778376668691635, 0.04925726354122162, 0.012246047146618366, 0.006818298250436783, 0.01083159539848566, 0.002840374130755663, 0.03359043970704079, -0.001081328489817679, 0.02598368003964424, 0.009197213687002659, -0.3179072141647339, -0.019447697326540947, 0.058544404804706573, -0.030389372259378433, 0.010969340801239014, -0.014601178467273712, 0.07319606840610504, -0.020620962604880333, -0.026343710720539093, 0.0121320690959692, 0.025578387081623077, 0.010961228981614113, 0.01098074670881033, 0.033641133457422256, 0.026613445952534676, 0.039018020033836365, -0.003507165005430579, -0.024901175871491432, -0.006555022671818733, 0.03595937415957451, -0.007555685471743345, -0.06426925957202911, -0.044974759221076965, 0.03820817172527313, -0.017155567184090614, 0.07165611535310745, -0.07208259403705597, -0.008405609987676144, -0.02095010131597519, 0.004360583145171404, -0.001476083300076425, 0.01051278319209814, -0.03214894235134125, 0.015089297667145729, 0.008877389132976532, -0.014209016226232052, 0.06041083112359047, -0.01775510050356388, 0.019423704594373703, 0.016912439838051796, 0.015216458588838577, -0.03076704777777195, -0.029370898380875587, 0.03519962728023529, 0.06945797801017761, 0.005262373480945826, -0.06220094487071037, -0.032029565423727036, -0.00905695278197527, 0.00917408149689436, -0.0038935309275984764, -0.012285624630749226, -0.03714003413915634, 0.0175055880099535, -0.0016975466860458255, 0.0046808416955173016, -0.011319062672555447, -0.0375828742980957, -0.02941550686955452, 0.0053530544973909855, 0.009144481271505356, -0.01037674956023693, -0.030428603291511536, -0.03971536457538605, -0.023118240758776665, -0.04503890499472618, -0.04309773072600365, -0.04746183380484581, 0.05844584479928017, 0.030964596197009087, 0.003317061113193631, 0.013251025229692459, -0.013804332353174686, -0.09488565474748611, 0.007927879691123962, -0.012081295251846313, -0.023662930354475975, -0.028873693197965622, 0.02709777094423771, 0.023394688963890076, -0.03402405604720116, -0.015797991305589676, 0.0018683797679841518, -0.006760088726878166, 0.038762692362070084, -0.0015042194863781333, 0.021174736320972443, -0.019514257088303566, -0.043654944747686386, -0.04820282757282257, 0.02376638539135456, 0.0264105387032032, -0.009590599685907364, -0.011404329910874367, 0.06324206292629242, 0.05523751303553581, 0.03007504902780056, 0.025177588686347008, 0.025024263188242912, 0.014727718196809292, 0.020851483568549156, -0.0617239773273468, -0.012462174519896507, -0.01825636252760887, -0.018582353368401527, 0.011752251535654068, -0.03214554488658905, -0.01598690263926983, 0.03770316019654274, -0.00985533557832241, -0.02093125879764557, -0.004567534662783146, 0.0019746841862797737, -0.003739168867468834, 0.0012885238975286484, -0.03482421860098839, -0.009948637336492538, 0.012159109115600586, 0.06028195843100548, -0.013219798915088177, -0.06298013031482697, 0.041272733360528946, -0.01800486445426941, 0.01820341683924198, -0.04401634633541107, -0.02758338488638401, -0.019803127273917198, -0.016787543892860413, 0.010702226310968399, 0.00820124614983797, 0.018959984183311462, 0.020347952842712402, 0.0019110175780951977, 0.004241962917149067, 0.07314617931842804, -0.031096700578927994, 0.0021232813596725464, 0.0032512659672647715, -0.016095906496047974, -0.035891592502593994, 0.007655852008610964, -0.018799027428030968, 0.05482534319162369, 0.04158506542444229, 0.02753727324306965, -0.009439055807888508, 0.003650840139016509, -0.003756947349756956, -0.005413756240159273, 0.005055702291429043, 0.04463348910212517, -0.06051870435476303, 0.0154134351760149, -0.044530238956213, 0.038818735629320145, -0.020694056525826454, 0.014864771626889706, 0.0043431613594293594, 0.013486115261912346, -0.048236772418022156, 0.031290262937545776, -0.00892659928649664, -0.006195415277034044, -0.02340094931423664, 0.03132191300392151, 0.07066836953163147, -0.05668536201119423, -0.016234716400504112, 0.030229860916733742, 0.030372925102710724, 0.008222620002925396, -0.030449533835053444, -0.01346773374825716, -0.020262494683265686, -0.043514594435691833, -0.004203863441944122, 0.0018075047992169857, -0.08212388306856155, -0.07149064540863037, 0.019856128841638565, -0.00020915908680763096, -0.03389725089073181, 0.003615966299548745, -0.011727430857717991, 0.07605413347482681, 0.014176462776958942, 0.02496718429028988, 0.0005506151937879622, -0.04038882628083229, -0.003152420511469245, -0.02200966700911522, 0.0033519731368869543, -0.04063144326210022, -0.05556730553507805, -0.04574761912226677, -0.06197411194443703, 0.006976116914302111, -0.028443699702620506, -0.0037072603590786457, -0.015170736238360405, -0.016434049233794212, -0.004024700727313757, -0.03781013935804367, -0.01800565794110298, 0.017109360545873642, -0.07091980427503586, 0.01596955768764019, 0.02335045300424099, -0.0074096485041081905, 0.0357242077589035, -0.079222172498703, -0.040920406579971313, -0.03306465595960617, -0.045071884989738464, 0.010016929358243942, -0.053046390414237976, -0.05607004836201668, -0.040550727397203445, -0.037650834769010544, 0.03704068437218666, 0.0064797899685800076, -0.026575669646263123, -0.007136275991797447, -0.020381061360239983, -0.014228506945073605, 0.013894268311560154, -0.0367668978869915, -0.02323172055184841, 0.032772164791822433, -0.028765851631760597, 0.01421338226646185, -0.030471675097942352, 0.026284897699952126, 0.02404094859957695, -0.048238594084978104, -0.0019114341121166945, -0.07310950011014938, 0.03574524447321892, -0.0018603119533509016, -0.01860628090798855, -0.02388189360499382, 0.01499989628791809, -0.031020311638712883, -0.036667000502347946, 0.037669587880373, 0.02234361320734024, 0.008063716813921928, -0.005662583280354738, 0.0058611417189240456, 0.015339314006268978, 0.00877689104527235, 0.014610819518566132, -0.01595156453549862, 0.004205386620014906, 0.06448854506015778, -0.019827766343951225, -0.005720606539398432, -0.040705569088459015, -0.04655894264578819, 0.024170253425836563, -0.015949945896863937, 0.0049590906128287315, -0.051353681832551956, 0.03013819269835949, 0.012476123869419098, 0.028130657970905304, 0.00221541547216475, 0.0035088693257421255, 0.053197991102933884, -0.06429771333932877, 0.01453620009124279, -0.068936787545681, 0.007545812055468559, 0.04790106043219566, -0.04407889023423195, 0.002946051536127925, 0.012218514457345009, -0.028167223557829857, 0.04739038273692131, -0.03004223294556141, -0.04348462447524071, 0.030097557231783867, -0.012722419574856758, -0.02707008644938469, 0.05665764585137367, -0.04684855416417122, -0.01665577106177807, -0.025283031165599823, -0.055065084248781204, -0.0024502682499587536, -0.03722577169537544, 0.05560719221830368, -0.02480924315750599, 0.02417028695344925, -0.01793154701590538, 0.028818177059292793, 0.013176297768950462, 0.048988621681928635, 0.02974419668316841, 0.03615053370594978, -0.0015851090429350734, 0.06002867594361305, 0.03931901603937149, 0.057297151535749435, 0.019364282488822937, 0.007128218654543161, -0.025238119065761566, -0.058057092130184174, 0.04365061968564987, -0.010708297602832317, -0.027454132214188576, -0.04453367739915848, 0.04997136816382408, 0.03937290236353874, -0.054388634860515594, -0.016531039029359818, 0.022161701694130898, -0.062441136687994, -0.030173396691679955, -0.005965956021100283, 0.013998804613947868, 0.02851765602827072, 0.06945615261793137, 0.02080288901925087, 0.0798698291182518, 0.05565699189901352, 0.0366499125957489, -0.01800614967942238, 0.007454413454979658, 0.06370140612125397, 0.05624447017908096, 0.05773333087563515, 0.03145144507288933, 0.08322373032569885, -0.054672498255968094, -0.04910793900489807, 0.006082538980990648, 0.02097346819937229, -0.005672102328389883, -0.018078964203596115, 0.02502388507127762, 0.04787667095661163, -0.00995426345616579, 0.035208579152822495, -0.05644364282488823, -0.005642428994178772, 0.06687428057193756, 0.057990897446870804, 0.00621902197599411, 0.042373184114694595, 0.02145647443830967, 0.005464150104671717, -0.03569178283214569, -0.03176800161600113, 0.02214437536895275, -0.05310304835438728, 0.0038291842211037874, 0.010108038783073425, -0.02237030863761902, 0.01689593680202961, -0.01579669862985611, 0.06445155292749405, 0.13783426582813263, -0.039043400436639786, -0.01018370408564806, 0.006812362466007471, 0.005051648709923029, 0.017073119059205055, 0.07158670574426651, -0.006126714870333672, 0.00371223664842546, 0.01820187270641327, -0.0376640222966671, -0.009298831224441528, 0.024607736617326736, -0.015092238783836365, 0.028961293399333954, -0.04979107901453972, -0.03214690461754799, 0.015732616186141968, 0.012465192005038261, -0.04396938905119896, -0.03772665187716484, -0.03861068934202194, -0.02067513018846512, -0.03252260014414787, -0.05463085696101189, 0.021029701456427574, 0.005570845678448677, -0.07221881300210953, 0.018513448536396027, -0.0051026782020926476, 0.037139035761356354, 0.008861299604177475, -0.05880817398428917, 0.00181617122143507, 0.0328429639339447, 0.012075157836079597, 0.00905642844736576, -0.003450320567935705, 0.029960278421640396, -0.013032745569944382, -0.005016375333070755, -0.021617980673909187, -0.009454665705561638, 0.026368020102381706, -0.033256303519010544, -0.009251167997717857, -0.08058997988700867, -0.026457076892256737, 0.03934764117002487, -0.049308113753795624, -0.08189848810434341, 0.020166907459497452, -0.03818199038505554, 0.03231899067759514, 0.10044848173856735, 0.018993405625224113, 0.005659978371113539, -0.0076004257425665855, -0.010962572880089283, 0.022551901638507843, 0.02140449918806553, 0.027587829157710075, -0.010132667608559132, 0.06560828536748886, 0.027902847155928612, -0.0467151403427124, -0.02809665910899639, 0.029953207820653915, 0.02383173070847988, -0.04839525744318962, -0.00903251115232706, -0.04085687920451164, 0.0009061297751031816, -0.08813229948282242, 0.005406344309449196, 0.06297332793474197, -0.000912180810701102, -0.029257191345095634, 0.003889043815433979, -0.03129302337765694, -0.01068743597716093, -0.008109343238174915, -0.06344052404165268, 0.018732158467173576, -0.021580185741186142, -0.03233275189995766, -0.04296794533729553, 0.011980204842984676, -0.018997618928551674, -0.011820721440017223, -0.03843366727232933, -0.04102187603712082, -0.004589070100337267, -0.02959667332470417, 0.006576934829354286, 0.009930354543030262, -0.007021761033684015, -0.02733444981276989 ]
3,522
COPER: Correlation-based Permutations for Multi-View Clustering
https://openreview.net/forum?id=5ZEbpBYGwH
[ "Ran Eisenberg", "Jonathan Svirsky", "Ofir Lindenbaum" ]
Spotlight
Combining data from different sources can improve data analysis tasks such as clustering. However, most of the current multi-view clustering methods are limited to specific domains or rely on a suboptimal and computationally intensive two-stage process of representation learning and clustering. We propose an end-to-end deep learning-based multi-view clustering framework for general data types (such as images and tables). Our approach involves generating meaningful fused representations using a novel permutation-based canonical correlation objective. We provide a theoretical analysis showing how the learned embeddings approximate those obtained by supervised linear discriminant analysis (LDA). Cluster assignments are learned by identifying consistent pseudo-labels across multiple views. Additionally, we establish a theoretical bound on the error caused by incorrect pseudo-labels in the unsupervised representations compared to LDA. Extensive experiments on ten multi-view clustering benchmark datasets provide empirical evidence for the effectiveness of the proposed model.
clustering, canonical correlation analysis, self supervision, multiview
null
6,526
null
[ 0.03076421655714512, 0.015145288780331612, -0.01569274254143238, 0.0337030328810215, 0.030455630272626877, 0.022220633924007416, -0.005305101163685322, -0.006423617247492075, 0.002543785609304905, -0.03515438735485077, -0.02331853285431862, -0.0010319874854758382, -0.07764886319637299, 0.01967981457710266, -0.026561446487903595, 0.03881101310253143, 0.027947615832090378, 0.016772720962762833, 0.005469667725265026, 0.02860013023018837, -0.016183212399482727, -0.043805256485939026, 0.011715611442923546, -0.013678491115570068, 0.04381838068366051, -0.0011390771251171827, 0.0364706888794899, 0.03617480769753456, -0.013610652647912502, 0.028124351054430008, 0.0156764704734087, 0.04248978570103645, 0.018358126282691956, -0.01545780524611473, 0.03158819302916527, -0.028059108182787895, -0.04416315257549286, 0.02972673624753952, 0.020375682041049004, -0.010918551124632359, -0.05210459604859352, -0.01224450208246708, -0.013758663088083267, 0.013630121015012264, -0.02825738862156868, -0.00824401993304491, -0.10500983893871307, 0.015228315256536007, -0.002901623956859112, -0.022185100242495537, -0.06698856502771378, 0.01904868148267269, 0.04074357450008392, -0.010656998492777348, -0.006763097830116749, 0.04144905135035515, 0.05833391845226288, -0.06485498696565628, -0.014435715042054653, -0.04626164957880974, -0.03776765987277031, 0.026747124269604683, 0.025328610092401505, 0.013236260041594505, -0.010624910704791546, 0.01674669235944748, -0.00642671762034297, 0.0393453910946846, -0.0401955284178257, -0.03283387050032616, 0.008308680728077888, -0.010422282852232456, 0.0024403424467891455, 0.04051811248064041, 0.010240815579891205, -0.012607420794665813, 0.0400136262178421, 0.0029072400648146868, 0.04460733383893967, -0.047989629209041595, 0.0034705025609582663, 0.019537288695573807, -0.018395405262708664, 0.0455995611846447, 0.0217446219176054, -0.024885516613721848, -0.06862188130617142, -0.03895808756351471, -0.05653565376996994, 0.04182600602507591, -0.012822974473237991, -0.020822174847126007, 0.031961165368556976, 0.036707185208797455, 0.022916151210665703, 0.0017226522322744131, 0.02918296493589878, 0.01119862962514162, 0.010656430386006832, -0.001903436379507184, 0.013463410548865795, -0.0036317917983978987, 0.00743435975164175, -0.007257433608174324, -0.07821467518806458, -0.020880792289972305, -0.019005583599209785, 0.007711698301136494, -0.029511410742998123, 0.003925810568034649, -0.07038962841033936, -0.01964736171066761, 0.0386933907866478, 0.0264914408326149, -0.0652964636683464, 0.022427739575505257, 0.008725781925022602, -0.008691038005053997, -0.021572072058916092, -0.023558922111988068, 0.05370187759399414, 0.058108799159526825, -0.004231382627040148, 0.06626731902360916, -0.02033698558807373, 0.01174674741923809, 0.007195300422608852, 0.037257105112075806, -0.05906127020716667, -0.04295438900589943, 0.0021902029402554035, 0.01930592767894268, 0.01603850908577442, -0.021033575758337975, -0.006400903221219778, -0.053727615624666214, -0.013210168108344078, 0.005981508642435074, 0.027709458023309708, 0.010164624080061913, 0.01427446585148573, -0.04374481737613678, 0.038680773228406906, -0.004243682604283094, 0.07605517655611038, -0.006430008448660374, -0.01596188172698021, -0.019426049664616585, -0.0025618202053010464, -0.023158228024840355, -0.013875627890229225, -0.014829856343567371, -0.007094631437212229, -0.07865811139345169, 0.008399457670748234, 0.04540771618485451, -0.00118922907859087, 0.03334803879261017, 0.027582980692386627, -0.0012851840583607554, 0.020289206877350807, -0.0373694971203804, -0.08109819144010544, 0.016685111448168755, -0.014390029013156891, -0.09155712276697159, 0.019653193652629852, 0.010605656541883945, -0.027945781126618385, 0.022988103330135345, -0.020786728709936142, -0.0430888794362545, 0.04594435542821884, -0.028757911175489426, 0.004864044021815062, -0.021467648446559906, 0.06554483622312546, 0.026989081874489784, 0.006261489354074001, 0.01698187179863453, -0.07859379053115845, 0.025944512337446213, -0.014815190806984901, -0.043930672109127045, 0.015732234343886375, 0.012360980734229088, 0.08640773594379425, -0.01983741484582424, 0.010762098245322704, 0.014139329083263874, -0.04816709831357002, -0.02950378879904747, 0.005747017450630665, 0.011424416676163673, 0.048375096172094345, 0.012154299765825272, -0.02401857078075409, 0.04497215524315834, 0.007017173804342747, 0.018921591341495514, 0.0004846772353630513, -0.005074274726212025, 0.056210052222013474, 0.00019196412176825106, -0.04202532023191452, -0.02290128916501999, 0.044858239591121674, -0.029681865125894547, -0.03239257261157036, -0.0029491411987692118, 0.013997010886669159, -0.028233302757143974, -0.006159825250506401, -0.000047848152462393045, 0.04793741554021835, 0.03404273837804794, -0.0011844070395454764, 0.018718605861067772, 0.012078413739800453, -0.043247293680906296, 0.042443811893463135, 0.004194964654743671, -0.04005035012960434, 0.04096201807260513, -0.016091668978333473, 0.12179694324731827, 0.07288380712270737, -0.003479013219475746, 0.03717879578471184, 0.0049947104416787624, 0.027479631826281548, 0.03744356706738472, 0.053743090480566025, -0.02661130391061306, 0.005055837333202362, -0.01795455627143383, 0.002544885501265526, -0.03727468475699425, 0.07823950797319412, -0.055508844554424286, -0.014740227721631527, 0.05903124436736107, -0.016871457919478416, 0.038271963596343994, 0.02276904322206974, 0.003060066606849432, 0.03223218396306038, -0.017752755433321, -0.023850351572036743, -0.029542939737439156, 0.004828979726880789, -0.0006289976881816983, -0.041872307658195496, -0.033547405153512955, 0.04374842718243599, -0.048674535006284714, 0.018811458721756935, -0.039936382323503494, 0.08285855501890182, 0.05601049214601517, 0.035143766552209854, 0.04181550070643425, -0.01197904348373413, -0.031678225845098495, -0.01585385762155056, -0.10826655477285385, -0.06286879628896713, -0.013747370801866055, 0.043098606169223785, 0.004858572967350483, 0.06343990564346313, 0.0013664885191246867, -0.0016720873536542058, -0.031027967110276222, -0.011142750270664692, 0.011478232219815254, 0.025445934385061264, -0.015603483654558659, -0.014956841245293617, -0.006599079351872206, -0.011326337233185768, 0.04305487871170044, 0.009264524094760418, -0.004512851592153311, -0.0053888908587396145, -0.034510232508182526, 0.010950478725135326, -0.02308776043355465, -0.020445315167307854, 0.014811891131103039, 0.036871958523988724, 0.04071519523859024, -0.016814744099974632, -0.01964602805674076, 0.05110738426446915, 0.059052009135484695, 0.05602654814720154, -0.016710825264453888, -0.03786788880825043, 0.02512938715517521, -0.026693211868405342, 0.03859693184494972, 0.033636629581451416, -0.03225402906537056, -0.011030316352844238, -0.013176764361560345, 0.0017014930490404367, -0.01786642335355282, -0.28437909483909607, -0.03688167780637741, 0.01070257369428873, -0.008538983762264252, 0.04054659232497215, -0.03281812369823456, 0.04937426745891571, -0.06301805377006531, 0.01787448301911354, -0.0314130000770092, -0.00872754119336605, 0.029497260227799416, -0.009098540060222149, 0.07642850279808044, 0.037601832300424576, 0.05486825481057167, 0.024731401354074478, 0.00007965117401909083, 0.031068339943885803, 0.015218551270663738, -0.03936769440770149, -0.05487523972988129, -0.05873788893222809, 0.05237732455134392, -0.03146107494831085, 0.029343903064727783, -0.06229951232671738, 0.029088182374835014, -0.026362787932157516, -0.011375859379768372, -0.016818109899759293, 0.0076690129935741425, -0.029837079346179962, 0.04033616557717323, 0.031173452734947205, -0.0021074621472507715, 0.07030683010816574, -0.02245262637734413, -0.018509745597839355, -0.011297443881630898, 0.014695601537823677, -0.0028071575798094273, -0.01648605614900589, 0.01697949320077896, 0.07298419624567032, -0.014406912960112095, -0.032953839749097824, -0.006778911221772432, -0.04119780659675598, 0.023648586124181747, 0.009498098865151405, -0.038945265114307404, -0.01619500108063221, 0.004683251027017832, -0.014392608776688576, -0.021726058796048164, -0.010832879692316055, 0.016415202990174294, -0.005675006657838821, 0.006691422779113054, -0.012233714573085308, -0.06305725127458572, 0.006381251383572817, -0.059251200407743454, -0.01829494722187519, -0.045981381088495255, -0.08444913476705551, -0.06426224857568741, 0.050926946103572845, 0.017260683700442314, -0.01303868554532528, 0.04533028602600098, -0.04966539889574051, -0.0950939729809761, 0.035694997757673264, 0.02423737570643425, -0.011242489330470562, -0.018628697842359543, -0.0010224825236946344, 0.06509938836097717, -0.019933028146624565, -0.04150313511490822, 0.028065890073776245, 0.018048619851469994, -0.010197247378528118, -0.050182703882455826, -0.0043650115840137005, -0.005608434788882732, -0.020210372284054756, -0.038330063223838806, 0.025582462549209595, -0.009657791815698147, 0.023072944954037666, 0.002931264927610755, 0.025649361312389374, 0.07299846410751343, 0.02001279965043068, 0.04543938860297203, 0.0437033511698246, -0.0022695523221045732, 0.02763190306723118, -0.07912171632051468, 0.002836233004927635, -0.020097047090530396, -0.018732735887169838, 0.017602523788809776, -0.032859962433576584, 0.011538675054907799, 0.0641283243894577, 0.010684317909181118, -0.023168878629803658, -0.035889673978090286, 0.003809497458860278, -0.0006201548967510462, 0.03554267808794975, -0.029440229758620262, -0.008778531104326248, 0.040599431842565536, 0.03221014887094498, 0.021392181515693665, -0.08315986394882202, 0.023182565346360207, -0.032974645495414734, 0.007756177801638842, -0.027376532554626465, -0.028049854561686516, -0.007098186761140823, -0.055924192070961, 0.004766632337123156, 0.02091246284544468, 0.011530065909028053, 0.02558530867099762, -0.0021567014046013355, 0.008589709177613258, 0.08538902550935745, -0.048085976392030716, -0.00017757245223037899, -0.008159326389431953, 0.016092833131551743, -0.029810981824994087, 0.04125720635056496, -0.006634423043578863, 0.05850892513990402, 0.025202138349413872, 0.014665507711470127, 0.031063195317983627, -0.0017131505301222205, 0.011773978359997272, -0.021033065393567085, -0.0005052084452472627, -0.025721518322825432, -0.03342941030859947, -0.02370149828493595, 0.006771530490368605, -0.009772239252924919, 0.009913640096783638, 0.015872851014137268, -0.0038147764280438423, -0.013454223051667213, -0.04185638576745987, 0.03162138909101486, 0.019426245242357254, -0.006133840885013342, -0.026744553819298744, 0.0052038440480828285, 0.05437040328979492, -0.003254804527387023, 0.005587154068052769, 0.014973212033510208, 0.016881363466382027, 0.02491782419383526, -0.012996655888855457, -0.027258384972810745, -0.005397035274654627, -0.010585092939436436, 0.014424744993448257, -0.006149863824248314, 0.00004294980317354202, -0.032433852553367615, 0.02733272686600685, -0.02384721301496029, -0.0008375917095690966, -0.011591160669922829, 0.008273299783468246, 0.05999064818024635, 0.031239617615938187, -0.0021249388810247183, -0.013137690722942352, -0.01724277436733246, 0.07232695817947388, 0.0082315132021904, 0.03319931402802467, -0.041160114109516144, -0.03164655342698097, -0.016928836703300476, -0.04365173727273941, -0.007868032902479172, 0.03540420159697533, -0.0332997664809227, -0.020302776247262955, -0.03210620954632759, 0.0012535594869405031, -0.029034296050667763, -0.02345704659819603, 0.04574735462665558, -0.05837137997150421, 0.03665042668581009, 0.011201683431863785, -0.045288410037755966, 0.019307730719447136, -0.027315238490700722, -0.06888844817876816, -0.0395069345831871, -0.0624125637114048, -0.011414555832743645, 0.004182445351034403, -0.015797797590494156, -0.012056484818458557, 0.0006157573661766946, -0.02384285442531109, 0.03851894661784172, -0.003860816825181246, -0.0018404546426609159, -0.02366119623184204, 0.02011767029762268, 0.06295725703239441, -0.01975500024855137, -0.006234358064830303, -0.044518496841192245, -0.017845138907432556, 0.027101388201117516, -0.04939224198460579, 0.0005456415819935501, 0.05748991295695305, -0.0027312124148011208, -0.020802432671189308, -0.05734064429998398, 0.020206129178404808, 0.0020953905768692493, 0.011670437641441822, 0.016391396522521973, -0.01796572282910347, -0.013355141505599022, -0.011762664653360844, 0.021598998457193375, 0.041985269635915756, -0.0022407961077988148, 0.02429056167602539, 0.007497506681829691, -0.004721902310848236, 0.002847772091627121, -0.01146057341247797, -0.06765276938676834, -0.013238181360065937, 0.05858778581023216, -0.0012802360579371452, -0.03572947904467583, -0.05334743484854698, -0.00525283720344305, -0.00043489510426297784, -0.008060348220169544, 0.020591162145137787, -0.000999446026980877, 0.044493719935417175, 0.03474253788590431, 0.03207957744598389, -0.02240355685353279, -0.015293478034436703, 0.04028644785284996, -0.0493696965277195, 0.030342526733875275, -0.05617399141192436, -0.015953198075294495, 0.08328762650489807, -0.031760074198246, 0.019135694950819016, -0.004226061049848795, -0.032534707337617874, 0.024321407079696655, -0.03707551956176758, -0.07239688187837601, -0.04201542213559151, -0.02703201398253441, 0.031421318650245667, 0.0012719527585431933, -0.035702578723430634, 0.015223363414406776, -0.015097319148480892, -0.051267120987176895, -0.02464984357357025, -0.001573472749441862, 0.03484651446342468, -0.04438391327857971, 0.017830416560173035, 0.014201250858604908, -0.0024220163468271494, 0.043109647929668427, 0.06967559456825256, -0.017522349953651428, 0.04807833209633827, -0.059055108577013016, 0.07404236495494843, 0.045664068311452866, -0.011039710603654385, -0.004683698993176222, 0.030110502615571022, -0.007716204505413771, -0.020759904757142067, 0.03395264968276024, 0.02774289809167385, -0.0037217119242995977, -0.09237051010131836, 0.0621817447245121, 0.028858931735157967, -0.04317940026521683, -0.022341955453157425, 0.028656959533691406, -0.03379269316792488, 0.03135316073894501, 0.0005205530906096101, 0.01680360548198223, -0.01615312695503235, 0.03774881362915039, 0.0020208454225212336, 0.04224975407123566, 0.06234297901391983, 0.030523160472512245, 0.008375904522836208, -0.028087472543120384, 0.07687248289585114, 0.07213900983333588, 0.01750093325972557, -0.01015540026128292, 0.06909643113613129, -0.027843773365020752, -0.05171792954206467, 0.037008389830589294, -0.013968442566692829, 0.0320625901222229, -0.03782114386558533, -0.0055938297882676125, 0.08396042883396149, 0.035221606492996216, 0.04998462647199631, -0.027402987703680992, 0.01267080008983612, 0.022091543301939964, -0.02614378184080124, 0.004448758438229561, 0.00023229776707012206, 0.041489336639642715, 0.03320068120956421, -0.036010727286338806, -0.01610320247709751, -0.028859209269285202, -0.0025752107612788677, 0.015978990122675896, -0.002448473358526826, -0.040528953075408936, 0.012059458531439304, -0.00954661425203085, 0.03841017931699753, 0.08003459870815277, 0.0008698501042090356, -0.057398032397031784, 0.0069085052236914635, 0.025206902995705605, 0.014837509021162987, 0.05984560027718544, 0.043819695711135864, -0.0028936138842254877, -0.013570975512266159, -0.0338548943400383, 0.004551245830953121, 0.030056051909923553, 0.00917332898825407, 0.0041359844617545605, -0.03685922548174858, -0.03324529901146889, 0.0007774158730171621, 0.02249649353325367, -0.063087597489357, -0.03989744558930397, -0.014499709941446781, -0.04913714900612831, -0.051800962537527084, -0.057208769023418427, 0.03486913442611694, 0.03009214997291565, -0.022478634491562843, -0.03393196687102318, -0.0207987017929554, 0.012579618953168392, 0.02167729288339615, -0.05631439387798309, 0.029530830681324005, 0.04850776493549347, 0.027437729761004448, 0.00970435794442892, 0.042208630591630936, 0.03282025828957558, -0.022642144933342934, -0.03618050366640091, 0.047786395996809006, 0.04177789017558098, 0.023810137063264847, 0.0008053288329392672, 0.013774278573691845, -0.08164883404970169, -0.008143587037920952, 0.008583526127040386, -0.04907507076859474, -0.08379235118627548, 0.054157618433237076, -0.015516480430960655, 0.024630466476082802, 0.05123303458094597, -0.0017236097482964396, 0.01351596787571907, -0.008703120984137058, 0.0169601421803236, -0.011360402218997478, -0.01115464884787798, 0.042522039264440536, -0.04583173245191574, 0.06126507371664047, 0.037352051585912704, 0.004564919508993626, -0.037077780812978745, 0.04368551820516586, -0.03696516528725624, 0.008401326835155487, -0.037217721343040466, -0.05138742923736572, -0.04837323725223541, -0.08239506930112839, -0.05675073713064194, 0.029547950252890587, -0.00696366373449564, -0.034237977117300034, -0.006346265785396099, -0.009478762745857239, -0.03499370440840721, -0.031624265015125275, 0.018231816589832306, 0.004459468647837639, -0.03791993111371994, -0.010674828663468361, -0.07566076517105103, 0.008590182289481163, -0.030253665521740913, -0.003667288925498724, -0.04492355138063431, -0.04061390459537506, -0.03732097148895264, -0.04333117604255676, 0.04033306986093521, 0.018601801246404648, 0.05672476813197136, -0.003780854633077979 ]
3,523
Improving Convergence Guarantees of Random Subspace Second-order Algorithm for Nonconvex Optimization
https://openreview.net/forum?id=tuu4de7HL1
[ "Rei Higuchi", "Pierre-Louis Poirion", "Akiko Takeda" ]
Spotlight
In recent years, random subspace methods have been actively studied for large-dimensional nonconvex problems. Recent subspace methods have improved theoretical guarantees such as iteration complexity and local convergence rate while reducing computational costs by deriving descent directions in randomly selected low-dimensional subspaces. This paper proposes the Random Subspace Homogenized Trust Region (RSHTR) method with the best theoretical guarantees among random subspace algorithms for nonconvex optimization. RSHTR achieves an $\varepsilon$-approximate first-order stationary point in $O(\varepsilon^{-3/2})$ iterations, converging locally at a linear rate. Furthermore, under rank-deficient conditions, RSHTR satisfies $\varepsilon$-approximate second-order necessary conditions in $O(\varepsilon^{-3/2})$ iterations and exhibits a local quadratic convergence. Experiments on real-world datasets verify the benefits of RSHTR.
random projection, trust region method, non-convex optimization, second-order stationary point, local convergence
This paper proposes the Random Subspace Homogenized Trust Region (RSHTR) method with the best theoretical guarantees among random subspace algorithms for non-convex optimization.
6,508
2406.14337
[ -0.01751408539712429, -0.025309963151812553, 0.024619413539767265, 0.07302604615688324, -0.0021250119898468256, 0.02490968070924282, 0.043405111879110336, -0.01301697175949812, -0.004883754067122936, -0.046502433717250824, -0.012087052688002586, -0.01951439678668976, -0.057918451726436615, -0.0010918574407696724, -0.00724318390712142, 0.061933714896440506, 0.05500693991780281, -0.019933529198169708, -0.002137294039130211, 0.04034768044948578, -0.016597939655184746, -0.00024970987578853965, 0.03669559583067894, 0.020996350795030594, 0.05197068303823471, -0.001378677668981254, 0.004919941071420908, 0.0049187419936060905, -0.016770675778388977, 0.0019894433207809925, 0.03367524966597557, 0.01144492719322443, -0.0192062146961689, -0.040679462254047394, 0.02573058009147644, 0.0675559863448143, -0.035255979746580124, 0.02921479567885399, -0.0010945947142317891, 0.019493822008371353, -0.016615698114037514, -0.00720271235331893, -0.01658920757472515, 0.04011660814285278, -0.01959020271897316, -0.00567248510196805, -0.0995430052280426, 0.020212329924106598, 0.004721960052847862, -0.01210593432188034, -0.06001928076148033, 0.0358068123459816, 0.031731292605400085, -0.027597632259130478, 0.007364809047430754, 0.057329483330249786, 0.008815016597509384, -0.03672334551811218, 0.011130385100841522, -0.04312014952301979, -0.03463190048933029, -0.0068496223539114, 0.015568221919238567, 0.008156264200806618, -0.022585177794098854, 0.003328582039102912, 0.013162375427782536, 0.04467947781085968, -0.03425804525613785, -0.03131754696369171, -0.02255248837172985, -0.012668158859014511, 0.02008303627371788, 0.006980936508625746, -0.012756896205246449, -0.04933324083685875, 0.020057102665305138, 0.033043574541807175, 0.04546181857585907, 0.043928056955337524, 0.041909489780664444, 0.006191684398800135, 0.019878970459103584, 0.02448873780667782, -0.015947751700878143, -0.014989807270467281, -0.0473838709294796, -0.03426263853907585, -0.059519026428461075, 0.06051366403698921, -0.037719450891017914, -0.03252282738685608, 0.031902726739645004, 0.01178719848394394, 0.021238353103399277, -0.018854476511478424, 0.04277142882347107, 0.008134913630783558, 0.029112165793776512, -0.004536138381808996, -0.015850255265831947, -0.028309382498264313, 0.006215833127498627, -0.0350235290825367, -0.07163805514574051, -0.0030799168162047863, -0.06106407195329666, -0.02570570819079876, -0.0281708762049675, -0.0037777104880660772, -0.03053777851164341, 0.041163332760334015, 0.03110426850616932, -0.013838403858244419, -0.08105689287185669, 0.03323294222354889, -0.008802074007689953, 0.014277475886046886, 0.0061691077426075935, 0.016899367794394493, 0.057630930095911026, 0.0634320005774498, -0.007958564907312393, 0.07668183743953705, 0.007824395783245564, 0.03125355765223503, 0.014147546142339706, 0.025383325293660164, -0.0463179349899292, -0.04108043387532234, 0.016834314912557602, 0.030089128762483597, 0.04054868966341019, -0.005549012217670679, -0.02089797891676426, -0.024654071778059006, -0.023759743198752403, 0.01001127902418375, 0.03851050138473511, -0.0019426835933700204, -0.015459178946912289, -0.015568593516945839, 0.07154864817857742, -0.013684587553143501, 0.04431925341486931, -0.06114131584763527, 0.0587746798992157, -0.043487340211868286, -0.0546402782201767, 0.010685878805816174, 0.0335996113717556, 0.007971675135195255, 0.002292065182700753, -0.07637828588485718, -0.004807516932487488, 0.018097063526511192, 0.02688819169998169, 0.03891626000404358, 0.007403773721307516, 0.0013445495860651135, 0.04716284200549126, -0.007520037237554789, -0.02042257785797119, 0.0033708568662405014, -0.010466915555298328, -0.05350179970264435, 0.08558005839586258, 0.06344206631183624, -0.034287530928850174, 0.0061164493672549725, -0.05018385872244835, -0.05022798106074333, 0.0505434051156044, -0.009720541536808014, 0.027765430510044098, -0.01205098070204258, 0.05990510806441307, -0.024499215185642242, 0.029395168647170067, 0.027611851692199707, -0.08037790656089783, 0.04844875633716583, 0.026562251150608063, -0.013363923877477646, 0.011819371022284031, -0.015472416765987873, 0.09442337602376938, -0.02498563751578331, 0.027033070102334023, 0.042252399027347565, -0.08493126928806305, -0.01977015659213066, -0.005905254278331995, -0.019496038556098938, 0.08416688442230225, 0.023581374436616898, -0.001976895146071911, 0.0019152554450556636, 0.024803677573800087, 0.027316195890307426, 0.05056241154670715, -0.06447518616914749, 0.037160951644182205, -0.009651144035160542, -0.06162049621343613, -0.009852197021245956, 0.04309886321425438, -0.05592238903045654, -0.047864317893981934, 0.01282407809048891, -0.001723600085824728, 0.032740622758865356, -0.03003433160483837, 0.01606367714703083, 0.016151299700140953, -0.011555047705769539, 0.02204521745443344, 0.02202385663986206, 0.028297608718276024, -0.05050712451338768, 0.07042653858661652, 0.017491761595010757, -0.01707616075873375, 0.05689903721213341, 0.0008018459193408489, 0.09122200310230255, 0.06737741082906723, -0.03482396900653839, 0.009260118007659912, 0.016066446900367737, -0.02357710711658001, -0.0036958821583539248, 0.03274598345160484, -0.010292510502040386, -0.0017873644828796387, 0.018886748701334, 0.017097532749176025, -0.021499715745449066, 0.09761420637369156, -0.03762789070606232, -0.03860786557197571, 0.05369771271944046, -0.02049839310348034, 0.03622281178832054, 0.005379901267588139, -0.028242453932762146, 0.02660570666193962, 0.025517361238598824, -0.01727585680782795, -0.02014775015413761, -0.013396795839071274, 0.00578024098649621, 0.005368194542825222, -0.017214138060808182, 0.036913495510816574, -0.04901977628469467, 0.025083964690566063, -0.007851770147681236, 0.053927429020404816, 0.05930698290467262, 0.014539718627929688, -0.013951811008155346, 0.0030560223385691643, -0.05295920372009277, -0.045622192323207855, -0.12094523012638092, -0.05972906947135925, -0.027561727911233902, 0.050839465111494064, 0.00966655369848013, 0.0628402978181839, -0.03255811333656311, 0.009701334871351719, 0.0011610311921685934, -0.02248508669435978, 0.002088832436129451, 0.02292809821665287, 0.023338692262768745, -0.03697003051638603, -0.0018165975343436003, 0.028792396187782288, 0.07361888885498047, -0.007539183832705021, 0.015993624925613403, -0.038627300411462784, -0.022788982838392258, -0.006413876544684172, -0.05394824221730232, -0.02294621616601944, -0.015362129546701908, -0.02026054635643959, 0.01576366275548935, -0.0011223364854231477, 0.0296473391354084, 0.008862370625138283, 0.037250980734825134, 0.03840353712439537, 0.0418480709195137, 0.01682867854833603, -0.007822453044354916, 0.010207870975136757, 0.015598427504301071, -0.042060840874910355, -0.018421703949570656, -0.023256907239556313, -0.0011533426586538553, -0.001409863238222897, -0.036229778081178665, -0.2587665617465973, 0.008311547338962555, -0.029877236112952232, 0.006955136079341173, 0.05000710114836693, -0.0011320128105580807, 0.031210768967866898, -0.014779595658183098, -0.03240807354450226, 0.03826279938220978, -0.017132196575403214, 0.02449006401002407, 0.001516925636678934, 0.056672800332307816, 0.03477422520518303, 0.00811952818185091, 0.014178845100104809, -0.015182106755673885, 0.027294164523482323, 0.015581068582832813, -0.015477066859602928, -0.07127001136541367, 0.013240331783890724, 0.011515186168253422, -0.004162766505032778, 0.011653508991003036, -0.041460104286670685, 0.008122740313410759, -0.050070103257894516, -0.007562622893601656, -0.038562897592782974, -0.02233670838177204, -0.01750938594341278, 0.04292842745780945, 0.0018205019878223538, 0.004761870484799147, 0.00047378617455251515, -0.022264879196882248, 0.016783930361270905, 0.022340821102261543, -0.00827576220035553, 0.015363272279500961, 0.008534668013453484, 0.018028533086180687, 0.03923686593770981, 0.029979858547449112, 0.0007079579518176615, -0.009607636369764805, -0.003566412953659892, 0.04341866448521614, -0.016343971714377403, -0.024444108828902245, 0.005755184683948755, 0.011385888792574406, -0.016447003930807114, -0.04390481859445572, -0.005607176572084427, -0.011763665825128555, 0.011395377106964588, 0.03428494185209274, -0.014026866294443607, -0.056643057614564896, -0.017546331509947777, -0.042207006365060806, -0.01833793707191944, -0.050754234194755554, -0.08779510855674744, -0.06964679807424545, 0.02697109989821911, 0.025129981338977814, -0.0033848604653030634, 0.03670826554298401, -0.04338778927922249, -0.07900389283895493, 0.016021134331822395, -0.013965711928904057, 0.019457785412669182, -0.0037512402050197124, 0.010274568572640419, 0.0662434995174408, -0.04084784537553787, -0.05006807669997215, -0.006075497251003981, 0.03275609388947487, -0.02100418135523796, 0.0009614356094971299, 0.04977438226342201, -0.013472638092935085, -0.035610392689704895, -0.0576387383043766, 0.05940378084778786, -0.010692400857806206, 0.044816914945840836, -0.022705702111124992, 0.07998784631490707, 0.046719104051589966, -0.005443935748189688, 0.013921988196671009, 0.035338133573532104, -0.0034245161805301905, 0.027372369542717934, -0.08292587846517563, 0.022146429866552353, -0.025391189381480217, 0.007412511855363846, 0.007909903302788734, -0.049282580614089966, -0.034543171525001526, 0.019111692905426025, 0.013602608814835548, -0.019941940903663635, -0.025490570813417435, -0.007689258549362421, -0.011025931686162949, -0.0012217615731060505, -0.03598380088806152, 0.002108055865392089, 0.029885657131671906, 0.024342872202396393, 0.003672641236335039, -0.02060605026781559, 0.03547476604580879, -0.020976483821868896, -0.012411133386194706, -0.0019150245934724808, 0.02832828275859356, 0.003141118446364999, -0.019080666825175285, -0.012708866037428379, -0.03510945662856102, 0.02915200963616371, 0.06611934304237366, 0.03619031235575676, 0.012610013596713543, 0.07566805183887482, 0.021480567753314972, -0.011017750017344952, -0.03050084039568901, 0.03563256934285164, 0.02303217351436615, 0.03332468867301941, 0.019511809572577477, 0.006924614310264587, 0.013646390289068222, 0.03552602604031563, 0.017719924449920654, 0.004543558694422245, -0.0006738808006048203, -0.00727299926802516, -0.006328511983156204, 0.004301215521991253, -0.051305804401636124, 0.010709087364375591, -0.015618941746652126, 0.02136477269232273, -0.017424296587705612, 0.03660840913653374, -0.008931401185691357, 0.015947287902235985, -0.08007349818944931, 0.06291553378105164, 0.008036148734390736, -0.04368511959910393, 0.0069165313616395, 0.01944497972726822, 0.08382934331893921, -0.005503918509930372, -0.009635775350034237, -0.022878658026456833, -0.01548023335635662, 0.036810774356126785, -0.0004442090867087245, -0.04699324071407318, -0.04845380410552025, -0.03252974897623062, 0.006445529870688915, 0.009710474871098995, -0.015227070078253746, -0.03603743761777878, -0.007775524165481329, -0.006595438811928034, -0.019218046218156815, -0.04086365923285484, 0.05967320501804352, 0.07730890065431595, -0.0031876584980636835, -0.007607018109411001, -0.028447486460208893, -0.03871214762330055, 0.04294182360172272, 0.0066544245928525925, 0.011282221414148808, -0.03543657809495926, -0.04275209456682205, -0.0021378055680543184, -0.05305025726556778, 0.012439356185495853, 0.013764203526079655, -0.020605914294719696, 0.007983384653925896, -0.006787532474845648, 0.008098923601210117, -0.02726869285106659, 0.006832486484199762, 0.039612676948308945, -0.07494305819272995, 0.02650466375052929, 0.008741987869143486, -0.02511991374194622, 0.0113087622448802, -0.016787869855761528, -0.029680514708161354, -0.031237604096531868, -0.024554269388318062, -0.010481457225978374, -0.02611667290329933, -0.07113119214773178, 0.015628810971975327, 0.025704089552164078, 0.000877950806170702, -0.004252244718372822, -0.013361766003072262, 0.011272133328020573, -0.015650711953639984, -0.04157084971666336, 0.05118074640631676, -0.03954518586397171, -0.0499662421643734, -0.011651451699435711, -0.03315121307969093, -0.0006950396345928311, -0.062175724655389786, 0.014364669099450111, 0.04905474931001663, -0.012498586438596249, 0.013496005907654762, -0.06751232594251633, 0.01024602260440588, -0.047609563916921616, -0.018314015120267868, -0.03022637404501438, 0.00838509202003479, -0.03700639680027962, -0.02726353518664837, -0.016448352485895157, 0.048712123185396194, 0.015049226582050323, 0.0018882194999605417, 0.03434620797634125, 0.037448085844516754, 0.03866276144981384, 0.01628934033215046, -0.05885494872927666, 0.007957996800541878, 0.06264083087444305, -0.018382569774985313, -0.01841725967824459, -0.09712693840265274, 0.020988963544368744, 0.041953667998313904, -0.04584014415740967, 0.02086641453206539, -0.022899672389030457, 0.05489668622612953, 0.021342812106013298, 0.05339157208800316, 0.001712377998046577, -0.035635724663734436, 0.022253602743148804, -0.044412821531295776, -0.034027356654405594, -0.06851252168416977, -0.007294948678463697, 0.011822480708360672, -0.034117620438337326, 0.021989842876791954, 0.028386633843183517, -0.043924108147621155, 0.023342713713645935, -0.03431256487965584, -0.057815421372652054, -0.011959949508309364, -0.0490928553044796, -0.023226354271173477, 0.002848973497748375, -0.03551838546991348, -0.02380065619945526, 0.0024282457306981087, -0.05336780846118927, -0.010819428600370884, 0.007271727547049522, 0.026958363130688667, 0.00913308747112751, -0.02442450262606144, -0.06162150204181671, 0.027087382972240448, 0.04683724045753479, 0.04410931095480919, -0.025829214602708817, -0.0021051333751529455, -0.0666726678609848, 0.05216113477945328, 0.05738895758986473, 0.00710870698094368, 0.018544888123869896, 0.02174793742597103, -0.007861870341002941, -0.04121818393468857, 0.06872477382421494, -0.019323179498314857, -0.02962523140013218, -0.05246656388044357, 0.050085268914699554, 0.038679614663124084, -0.04348103702068329, -0.022701477631926537, 0.0371362529695034, -0.043491706252098083, 0.015140592120587826, -0.013400307856500149, 0.006749859545379877, 0.026214223355054855, 0.07318824529647827, -0.006384007167071104, 0.02865949459373951, 0.04584040865302086, -0.016886578872799873, -0.009508459828794003, -0.027315422892570496, 0.06670074909925461, 0.0823468416929245, 0.019043810665607452, -0.04535875841975212, 0.0671469196677208, -0.02156977169215679, -0.05261163413524628, -0.00031780495191924274, -0.003993334248661995, -0.03236245736479759, -0.050429560244083405, -0.030948210507631302, 0.06443306803703308, 0.02617129124701023, 0.08220096677541733, -0.06318839639425278, 0.0068479678593575954, 0.03839370235800743, -0.004560643807053566, -0.009806673973798752, 0.029940294101834297, 0.040261536836624146, 0.014689398929476738, -0.0009670890285633504, -0.01948857121169567, -0.019380411133170128, 0.043686483055353165, 0.046995047479867935, -0.017597006633877754, -0.01808742620050907, 0.022773271426558495, 0.026360327377915382, -0.02229510247707367, 0.060419294983148575, -0.056667961180210114, -0.03520040586590767, 0.017962325364351273, 0.00856403261423111, -0.015522096306085587, 0.03410431370139122, 0.0514996238052845, -0.0359455868601799, 0.043070320039987564, -0.038671817630529404, 0.0442952960729599, 0.02026021108031273, 0.005773620214313269, 0.020746737718582153, -0.0072622536681592464, 0.002118933480232954, 0.014761756174266338, 0.016099806874990463, -0.03806556016206741, -0.05412661284208298, -0.029301904141902924, -0.08234451711177826, -0.052971001714468, -0.02858906425535679, -0.00827837735414505, -0.017698103561997414, -0.043683700263500214, 0.0009884138125926256, -0.013396300375461578, 0.006788614671677351, 0.04167396202683449, -0.021178873255848885, -0.016275009140372276, 0.03957195207476616, -0.00469668535515666, 0.03077266737818718, 0.031164146959781647, 0.03734039142727852, 0.014733756892383099, -0.021337049081921577, 0.03330419957637787, -0.0006394752999767661, 0.0176288653165102, -0.007551174610853195, 0.003476614598184824, -0.07660459727048874, 0.006696609780192375, 0.010184047743678093, 0.004453741014003754, -0.05924510583281517, 0.015836991369724274, -0.062260255217552185, -0.019406214356422424, 0.03690874204039574, -0.006331923417747021, 0.03301400691270828, -0.05499642342329025, -0.041102662682533264, -0.013837105594575405, 0.005168684292584658, 0.042576756328344345, -0.013043302111327648, 0.03535734862089157, 0.01804729923605919, -0.01550146471709013, -0.04162466153502464, 0.07346849888563156, -0.028252828866243362, 0.03112819232046604, -0.0327722392976284, -0.007138916756957769, -0.0400707945227623, -0.09731993824243546, -0.013839961029589176, 0.005161659326404333, -0.007557910401374102, -0.02463516592979431, -0.007778477855026722, 0.0030538239516317844, -0.0261093657463789, 0.020551815629005432, 0.00006301690882537514, -0.006386026740074158, -0.0502745658159256, -0.02204900048673153, -0.0678199976682663, 0.03990836814045906, -0.004138447344303131, -0.010670209303498268, 0.0031288694590330124, -0.06076759845018387, -0.04301045089960098, -0.017734350636601448, 0.0317046232521534, 0.030785763636231422, 0.03932257369160652, -0.0007099452777765691 ]
3,524
Revisiting text-to-image evaluation with Gecko: on metrics, prompts, and human rating
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Im2neAMlre
[ "Olivia Wiles", "Chuhan Zhang", "Isabela Albuquerque", "Ivana Kajic", "Su Wang", "Emanuele Bugliarello", "Yasumasa Onoe", "Pinelopi Papalampidi", "Ira Ktena", "Christopher Knutsen", "Cyrus Rashtchian", "Anant Nawalgaria", "Jordi Pont-Tuset", "Aida Nematzadeh" ]
Spotlight
While text-to-image (T2I) generative models have become ubiquitous, they do not necessarily generate images that align with a given prompt. While many metrics and benchmarks have been proposed to evaluate T2I models and alignment metrics, the impact of the evaluation components (prompt sets, human annotations, evaluation task) has not been systematically measured. We find that looking at only *one slice of data*, i.e. one set of capabilities or human annotations, is not enough to obtain stable conclusions that generalise to new conditions or slices when evaluating T2I models or alignment metrics. We address this by introducing an evaluation suite of $>$100K annotations across four human annotation templates that comprehensively evaluates models' capabilities across a range of methods for gathering human annotations and comparing models. In particular, we propose (1) a carefully curated set of prompts -- *Gecko2K*; (2) a statistically grounded method of comparing T2I models; and (3) how to systematically evaluate metrics under three *evaluation tasks* -- *model ordering, pair-wise instance scoring, point-wise instance scoring*. Using this evaluation suite, we evaluate a wide range of metrics and find that a metric may do better in one setting but worse in another. As a result, we introduce a new, interpretable auto-eval metric that is consistently better correlated with human ratings than such existing metrics on our evaluation suite--across different human templates and evaluation settings--and on TIFA160.
text-to-image evaluation; text-to-image alignment; human evaluation;
We create a large benchmark for T2I alignment to evaluate models and metrics across skills, evaluation tasks, and human annotation templates.
6,464
2404.16820
[ 0.004076960496604443, -0.04625651612877846, -0.036022353917360306, 0.04764493927359581, 0.01301920972764492, 0.02244160696864128, 0.028470171615481377, 0.02636324241757393, 0.01958756521344185, -0.028552602976560593, -0.030455956235527992, 0.029649298638105392, -0.06802067905664444, -0.006916727405041456, -0.017386920750141144, 0.0405622199177742, 0.02357548661530018, 0.008479684591293335, 0.01802966184914112, 0.00892558041960001, -0.01847737282514572, -0.04421847313642502, 0.016323596239089966, -0.006989851128309965, 0.033395420759916306, -0.000027633293939288706, 0.03421922028064728, -0.0031744828447699547, -0.06419821828603745, 0.016043148934841156, 0.04328293725848198, 0.0018981911707669497, -0.009765510447323322, -0.023020396009087563, 0.0018961946479976177, -0.012078437954187393, -0.041666802018880844, -0.00225849449634552, 0.01810423843562603, 0.010603058151900768, -0.012936045415699482, -0.011936118826270103, -0.03567042946815491, 0.009672722779214382, -0.07892467081546783, 0.007783693727105856, -0.10642895102500916, 0.04449266567826271, -0.0007733373204246163, -0.007820350117981434, -0.08432983607053757, 0.047479357570409775, 0.007196314632892609, -0.010924269445240498, 0.010544201359152794, 0.03599495440721512, 0.0398792140185833, -0.10611245781183243, -0.009455413557589054, -0.04689855873584747, 0.001956278458237648, 0.025794638320803642, 0.015172493644058704, 0.04044251888990402, 0.00024840625701472163, -0.0161456111818552, 0.009722313843667507, 0.040507931262254715, -0.0622672401368618, -0.025403834879398346, -0.01178487204015255, 0.01353805884718895, -0.00915424432605505, 0.028377873823046684, 0.006860850378870964, -0.031593624502420425, -0.002788184443488717, 0.0283585786819458, 0.06593479961156845, -0.00047341868048533797, 0.022937092930078506, 0.02047147788107395, 0.015300976112484932, 0.02181948721408844, -0.0037600919604301453, 0.01637887954711914, -0.02438979223370552, -0.03618194907903671, -0.07445871829986572, 0.014590714126825333, -0.01585899107158184, -0.06416966766119003, 0.014127366244792938, 0.03323255479335785, 0.03108849562704563, 0.008508224040269852, 0.008477221243083477, 0.028052769601345062, -0.037216104567050934, -0.01719980686903, 0.0034401353914290667, -0.011805715970695019, 0.01788783073425293, 0.013888080604374409, -0.12344572693109512, -0.022959958761930466, -0.02779720351099968, -0.010256941430270672, 0.024974768981337547, -0.011619092896580696, -0.009395387955009937, -0.02919347770512104, -0.014205261133611202, -0.017001090571284294, -0.08486108481884003, 0.049047473818063736, -0.0021274101454764605, 0.002919059479609132, -0.04089084640145302, 0.022262198850512505, 0.06015295162796974, 0.05037709325551987, 0.025449885055422783, 0.0867718830704689, -0.010689634829759598, 0.02071664109826088, 0.0554155558347702, 0.01670517586171627, -0.0439118966460228, -0.0208380576223135, -0.016523275524377823, 0.043306197971105576, -0.021743329241871834, 0.013723321259021759, 0.007211583200842142, -0.011445717886090279, 0.015166636556386948, -0.028129784390330315, 0.0588650219142437, -0.002004705835133791, 0.022065486758947372, -0.009618855081498623, 0.02218976430594921, -0.021504700183868408, 0.06514964252710342, -0.03317207470536232, -0.0072057778015732765, -0.03557255119085312, -0.03893342986702919, 0.014935068786144257, -0.0003805585438385606, -0.016490695998072624, 0.025737259536981583, -0.06880318373441696, 0.02061307430267334, 0.07305745035409927, 0.03382071107625961, 0.00606560567393899, -0.004537275992333889, 0.03196200728416443, 0.014697954058647156, 0.0012031726073473692, -0.04802747443318367, 0.015447196550667286, -0.008886349387466908, -0.057130116969347, 0.013726962730288506, 0.0005413749604485929, -0.047433365136384964, -0.0005243816412985325, -0.037101928144693375, -0.04695119708776474, 0.040961913764476776, 0.012390844523906708, -0.012023347429931164, 0.027396149933338165, 0.048691872507333755, 0.013523656874895096, 0.04450544714927673, 0.021993590518832207, -0.08961480110883713, 0.03835614398121834, 0.014120829291641712, 0.004244334064424038, 0.04338103532791138, -0.020123682916164398, 0.0730138048529625, -0.022804908454418182, -0.02049189619719982, 0.027230985462665558, -0.09534542262554169, -0.04138980433344841, 0.04580816626548767, -0.020988576114177704, 0.05573270097374916, -0.003185868728905916, 0.0110241724178195, 0.05382426083087921, 0.018867770209908485, 0.032211627811193466, 0.04909079149365425, -0.04773147404193878, 0.06404086947441101, -0.02723725698888302, -0.03306673839688301, -0.0064950985834002495, 0.02554905042052269, -0.050223976373672485, -0.059775304049253464, 0.019080061465501785, -0.029718931764364243, 0.030971834436058998, 0.004264732822775841, 0.043962348252534866, 0.012407022528350353, 0.02134222351014614, 0.011573624797165394, 0.01431957259774208, 0.006935973651707172, -0.07108291983604431, 0.028918318450450897, 0.018215816468000412, 0.01211145892739296, -0.0037923119962215424, -0.03133060038089752, 0.10145137459039688, 0.07202158868312836, -0.02481750212609768, -0.00023099369718693197, 0.030092041939496994, -0.01709764078259468, 0.013978016562759876, 0.008276310749351978, -0.021749082952737808, -0.02098739705979824, 0.003131534205749631, 0.017485663294792175, -0.025360621511936188, 0.06474723666906357, -0.028943447396159172, 0.014698242768645287, 0.04878765717148781, -0.026327867060899734, 0.05759192630648613, 0.010001110844314098, 0.0068195657804608345, 0.027165092527866364, -0.0037008754443377256, -0.044553741812705994, -0.017771096900105476, -0.006011907942593098, 0.014089616015553474, -0.02393849566578865, -0.041876260191202164, 0.0019007113296538591, -0.031189898028969765, -0.0056727793999016285, -0.020280148833990097, 0.03468075767159462, 0.03542535379528999, 0.028234325349330902, -0.0036953536327928305, -0.02498302236199379, -0.01725063845515251, 0.018203847110271454, -0.09648287296295166, -0.04644346237182617, -0.02521906979382038, 0.010419693775475025, 0.008076155558228493, 0.05712262541055679, 0.019521242007613182, -0.010267149657011032, -0.03821425884962082, -0.028831085190176964, 0.031027941033244133, 0.018056485801935196, 0.0026809992268681526, -0.04374224692583084, -0.020078858360648155, 0.0021732300519943237, 0.059296637773513794, -0.022826222702860832, -0.03369789570569992, 0.0018918041605502367, -0.03779827430844307, -0.0024562666658312082, -0.05111459642648697, 0.005801469087600708, 0.008843852207064629, 0.004830545280128717, 0.035177186131477356, -0.008294127881526947, 0.0025825819466263056, 0.03849766403436661, 0.03550660237669945, 0.03372647613286972, -0.01660146564245224, -0.023212987929582596, 0.023616226390004158, -0.0018903374439105392, 0.017509765923023224, 0.02810845710337162, 0.009895073249936104, -0.023731881752610207, -0.01363864354789257, 0.00782458670437336, -0.02391808107495308, -0.29703980684280396, 0.004567647818475962, 0.018702467903494835, -0.013914702460169792, 0.016444426029920578, -0.03283501788973808, 0.03842223435640335, -0.043839532881975174, -0.012727076187729836, 0.026061881333589554, 0.01046279538422823, 0.05854482203722, 0.030790962278842926, 0.06562958657741547, 0.04370644688606262, 0.03764789178967476, -0.006872325669974089, -0.02510262094438076, 0.01744861900806427, 0.05308728292584419, -0.03643820434808731, -0.06251717358827591, -0.00751652242615819, 0.054610107094049454, 0.010356818325817585, 0.04856032505631447, -0.07578597217798233, -0.02619333565235138, -0.008569798432290554, -0.024108117446303368, 0.03288493677973747, -0.033653516322374344, -0.022938089445233345, 0.05403302609920502, 0.008276240900158882, 0.013791772536933422, 0.051248520612716675, -0.013538365252315998, -0.020903516560792923, -0.005800195503979921, 0.00831191148608923, -0.0222057793289423, -0.02718283236026764, -0.029708607122302055, 0.06951908022165298, -0.00918986089527607, -0.019607705995440483, -0.016660289838910103, 0.014403438195586205, 0.04908983036875725, -0.021667618304491043, -0.009402010589838028, -0.014685867354273796, 0.04227501153945923, -0.00090551539324224, -0.023825371637940407, 0.024398569017648697, 0.009052147157490253, -0.028803659602999687, -0.016827888786792755, -0.014387713745236397, -0.04830697551369667, -0.02248576655983925, -0.03272794187068939, -0.03825387358665466, -0.029567701742053032, -0.04472336545586586, -0.045378006994724274, 0.03249429911375046, 0.025901691988110542, -0.024109801277518272, 0.0019514525774866343, -0.012204312719404697, -0.09224911034107208, 0.009848838672041893, -0.00909822341054678, -0.012110602110624313, 0.014703326858580112, -0.025062575936317444, 0.03360244259238243, -0.035640548914670944, -0.07505928725004196, -0.0014538841787725687, 0.019488679245114326, 0.01846710406243801, -0.03788384795188904, -0.005596829578280449, -0.041470419615507126, 0.0028363107703626156, -0.038701191544532776, 0.06136500462889671, -0.0054802196100354195, -0.0015390216140076518, -0.0008991867653094232, 0.040710922330617905, 0.031175239011645317, 0.07073704153299332, 0.05488353222608566, 0.03583066165447235, 0.022283317521214485, 0.031428057700395584, -0.08590960502624512, 0.006805028300732374, -0.01623459905385971, -0.029692217707633972, 0.008761752396821976, -0.038306523114442825, -0.01395387388765812, 0.028911547735333443, -0.007405913434922695, -0.045271389186382294, -0.050803057849407196, -0.002199676353484392, -0.01093311607837677, -0.02640128880739212, -0.006298273801803589, 0.010537918657064438, 0.020223742350935936, 0.035813748836517334, -0.02194838412106037, -0.012845920398831367, 0.008591304533183575, -0.03588113561272621, -0.013029958121478558, -0.02488677017390728, 0.00033759954385459423, -0.0029615368694067, -0.03359043225646019, 0.010097404941916466, -0.00513225793838501, 0.03406450152397156, 0.02683101035654545, -0.0014055122155696154, 0.03599654510617256, 0.036067668348550797, -0.009680029936134815, -0.0010178700322285295, -0.029583053663372993, 0.0227592121809721, -0.03098207339644432, 0.02403407171368599, -0.03343655541539192, -0.011404220946133137, 0.01782386004924774, 0.04159795492887497, -0.022463183850049973, 0.01515366043895483, -0.012765524908900261, -0.025182468816637993, 0.0133106280118227, 0.035366714000701904, -0.04930587485432625, -0.025120021775364876, -0.02631331793963909, 0.02091517299413681, -0.006237981375306845, -0.0018103335751220584, -0.006130269728600979, 0.01615181565284729, -0.04954266548156738, 0.04684654250741005, 0.015641912817955017, -0.011484086513519287, -0.014116065576672554, 0.031270042061805725, 0.01778983511030674, 0.007519569247961044, 0.0016150408191606402, 0.005357090849429369, 0.012726966291666031, 0.016239523887634277, -0.011680048890411854, -0.030517425388097763, -0.014026620425283909, -0.03578365221619606, -0.006118030287325382, 0.006856683176010847, 0.03125863894820213, -0.045332420617341995, 0.0591324120759964, 0.014921368099749088, -0.024995330721139908, 0.024915385991334915, 0.010427900590002537, 0.09953601658344269, 0.031455978751182556, 0.008236713707447052, 0.007299304008483887, -0.04997889697551727, 0.031730055809020996, -0.007337868679314852, 0.01393140759319067, -0.014355666004121304, -0.02608371153473854, -0.026316454634070396, -0.050082627683877945, 0.0037885468918830156, 0.002284187125042081, 0.01670241169631481, -0.0060768043622374535, -0.0430825874209404, 0.019630515947937965, -0.05576099827885628, -0.010410493239760399, 0.017436442896723747, -0.08121052384376526, 0.009929973632097244, 0.0065925391390919685, -0.014325277879834175, -0.003956679720431566, -0.0046056401915848255, -0.056426070630550385, -0.06500223278999329, -0.03537789359688759, 0.019121190533041954, -0.02272091619670391, -0.018029874190688133, -0.05836138501763344, 0.007523334585130215, -0.031388428062200546, 0.0020996294915676117, 0.008629207499325275, -0.01798848994076252, -0.019766496494412422, 0.007032649591565132, 0.035927485674619675, -0.007047548890113831, -0.002204861957579851, -0.025357279926538467, -0.045786961913108826, 0.03243240714073181, -0.02864999696612358, 0.013022876344621181, 0.06483590602874756, -0.006889530457556248, 0.0044401404447853565, -0.0448867529630661, 0.028196975588798523, 0.021975545212626457, 0.0021438400726765394, 0.02572491019964218, 0.013404452241957188, -0.03618139028549194, 0.018936093896627426, -0.0013668760657310486, 0.02926729805767536, 0.003464122535660863, 0.01227528601884842, -0.0017002345994114876, 0.04495915398001671, 0.015689196065068245, 0.047201965004205704, -0.0420309416949749, 0.0016604420961812139, 0.05310758575797081, -0.0550394132733345, -0.032292719930410385, -0.05752481147646904, -0.05120715871453285, 0.0392666831612587, 0.010619165375828743, 0.043854471296072006, -0.0185613501816988, 0.04161766916513443, 0.013378066942095757, 0.025321369990706444, 0.019752420485019684, -0.006578644271939993, 0.03243756666779518, -0.055501069873571396, -0.0032052663154900074, -0.06337925791740417, -0.02614140324294567, 0.04858502000570297, -0.04034261032938957, -0.025252560153603554, -0.0045584943145513535, -0.029080362990498543, 0.023488255217671394, -0.02990982122719288, -0.03686950355768204, 0.006113249808549881, -0.022421149536967278, -0.0008902279660105705, 0.0058206492103636265, -0.049879852682352066, 0.04768434911966324, -0.03458096832036972, -0.04938477650284767, 0.0005574079696089029, 0.02033274807035923, 0.03444681689143181, -0.012084257788956165, 0.006196839269250631, -0.031094495207071304, 0.00021216949971858412, 0.04451098293066025, 0.0504583865404129, -0.022007349878549576, 0.020498692989349365, -0.030820736661553383, 0.0903361514210701, 0.024485278874635696, 0.010995281860232353, 0.015881238505244255, 0.025587916374206543, -0.038844458758831024, -0.053343936800956726, 0.057287171483039856, 0.013653992675244808, -0.00884205475449562, -0.06740216165781021, 0.07891826331615448, 0.042100973427295685, -0.059985432773828506, -0.032461944967508316, 0.04389702156186104, -0.04629525542259216, 0.015100499615073204, -0.029246792197227478, -0.0014810727443546057, -0.028524667024612427, 0.06706070154905319, 0.019690407440066338, 0.036609161645174026, 0.06646843254566193, -0.02256590686738491, -0.0016386592760682106, 0.00419769948348403, 0.07012719660997391, 0.07754343748092651, 0.0716259628534317, -0.011513061821460724, 0.0559561550617218, -0.028740109875798225, -0.050022393465042114, 0.017789259552955627, 0.044229939579963684, 0.008746865205466747, -0.028903912752866745, 0.028597388416528702, 0.05994391068816185, 0.019584722816944122, 0.08422736823558807, -0.06360194087028503, -0.007093902211636305, 0.005795253906399012, -0.004064131993800402, -0.02428324893116951, 0.020963670685887337, 0.026028702035546303, 0.0281071774661541, -0.036870554089546204, -0.01873784326016903, 0.017578070983290672, -0.04352442920207977, 0.0025704759173095226, 0.00886242464184761, -0.03407663479447365, 0.005255952011793852, -0.019892742857336998, 0.03437124192714691, 0.10336924344301224, -0.021840430796146393, -0.03985075652599335, 0.05933492258191109, 0.020165307447314262, 0.020526856184005737, 0.05512290820479393, 0.01693200133740902, 0.005556380841881037, 0.0027084974572062492, -0.02520682103931904, 0.020504040643572807, 0.04847697913646698, -0.017664184793829918, 0.012084468267858028, -0.022208133712410927, 0.00495142862200737, 0.0289161279797554, 0.00637800944969058, -0.04387013241648674, -0.03331244736909866, -0.014441680163145065, -0.05332459881901741, -0.03796504810452461, -0.02986985817551613, 0.038974255323410034, 0.011842943727970123, -0.05915377661585808, -0.01594335399568081, -0.02831277810037136, 0.03208807855844498, 0.025832178071141243, -0.07733692228794098, 0.0021249731071293354, 0.03517969325184822, 0.008733286522328854, -0.020569296553730965, 0.037950027734041214, 0.034344632178545, -0.02342349849641323, -0.02351391315460205, 0.04151395335793495, 0.04758934676647186, 0.027635173872113228, -0.015628090128302574, -0.029427722096443176, -0.0883527547121048, -0.020374763756990433, 0.03154827281832695, -0.03586302325129509, -0.07357039302587509, 0.029285978525877, -0.01733381114900112, 0.027812059968709946, 0.07489307224750519, 0.03812434524297714, 0.03463589400053024, -0.06267386674880981, -0.0013370770029723644, -0.00783875398337841, 0.03484884276986122, 0.03193614259362221, -0.025727905333042145, 0.07326983660459518, 0.0380820706486702, -0.0028633447363972664, -0.019705362617969513, -0.004132043570280075, -0.018390418961644173, 0.028608351945877075, -0.013641619123518467, -0.02325637824833393, -0.06449209898710251, -0.0995272696018219, -0.011395614594221115, 0.0376860648393631, 0.007127569057047367, -0.021392822265625, -0.002051478484645486, -0.0026527990121394396, 0.007784561719745398, 0.008555691689252853, -0.005899081472307444, -0.029752347618341446, -0.027288107201457024, -0.03274180367588997, -0.07535000145435333, -0.010404212400317192, -0.04046647250652313, 0.016848180443048477, -0.004223430063575506, -0.0370253287255764, -0.030086688697338104, 0.015854137018322945, 0.04816538840532303, 0.001021840376779437, 0.04732771962881088, 0.012526963837444782 ]
3,525
Diffusion Bridge AutoEncoders for Unsupervised Representation Learning
https://openreview.net/forum?id=hBGavkf61a
[ "Yeongmin Kim", "Kwanghyeon Lee", "Minsang Park", "Byeonghu Na", "Il-chul Moon" ]
Spotlight
Diffusion-based representation learning has achieved substantial attention due to its promising capabilities in latent representation and sample generation. Recent studies have employed an auxiliary encoder to identify a corresponding representation from data and to adjust the dimensionality of a latent variable $\mathbf{z}$. Meanwhile, this auxiliary structure invokes an *information split problem*; the information of each data instance $\mathbf{x}_0$ is divided into diffusion endpoint $\mathbf{x}_T$ and encoded $\mathbf{z}$ because there exist two inference paths starting from the data. The latent variable modeled by diffusion endpoint $\mathbf{x}_T$ has some disadvantages. The diffusion endpoint $\mathbf{x}_T$ is computationally expensive to obtain and inflexible in dimensionality. To address this problem, we introduce Diffusion Bridge AuteEncoders (DBAE), which enables $\mathbf{z}$-dependent endpoint $\mathbf{x}_T$ inference through a feed-forward architecture. This structure creates an information bottleneck at $\mathbf{z}$, so $\mathbf{x}_T$ becomes dependent on $\mathbf{z}$ in its generation. This results in $\mathbf{z}$ holding the full information of data. We propose an objective function for DBAE to enable both reconstruction and generative modeling, with their theoretical justification. Empirical evidence supports the effectiveness of the intended design in DBAE, which notably enhances downstream inference quality, reconstruction, and disentanglement. Additionally, DBAE generates high-fidelity samples in the unconditional generation. Our code is available at https://github.com/aailab-kaist/DBAE.
Diffusion Model, Represenation Learning, Autoencoders
This paper introduces Diffusion Bridge Autoencoders (DBAE) to design encoder dependent endpoint inference.
6,348
2405.17111
[ -0.007263891864567995, -0.03429165482521057, -0.025634508579969406, 0.04321776703000069, 0.04752996563911438, 0.038238368928432465, 0.017282135784626007, -0.012349632568657398, 0.0007006447413004935, -0.0610477440059185, 0.02196643501520157, -0.020854979753494263, -0.039843425154685974, 0.02934546209871769, -0.017615854740142822, 0.058337412774562836, 0.0378519631922245, -0.008030157536268234, 0.0012268510181456804, 0.04207487776875496, -0.008171698078513145, -0.050039228051900864, 0.015199096873402596, 0.0011835744371637702, 0.02359398826956749, 0.002737049711868167, 0.0050111194141209126, -0.019228946417570114, 0.00572551041841507, -0.005367797799408436, 0.023978527635335922, 0.0168258436024189, 0.0009252227027900517, -0.022980866953730583, -0.0024086427874863148, -0.02250927872955799, -0.05594208091497421, -0.002256448147818446, 0.012925676070153713, 0.012947911396622658, -0.0633481815457344, 0.018589338287711143, -0.013724975287914276, 0.03219205513596535, -0.05114128813147545, -0.036428239196538925, -0.14068010449409485, 0.016988473013043404, -0.006590902339667082, -0.02426336519420147, -0.09875693917274475, 0.00978892482817173, -0.014841685071587563, 0.0046865325421094894, 0.010074636898934841, 0.013012067414820194, 0.04737221822142601, -0.05781692638993263, -0.015848832204937935, -0.061090949922800064, -0.027735870331525803, 0.01789136789739132, 0.01565517857670784, -0.012765245512127876, -0.0019185278797522187, -0.02631295844912529, -0.003352694446220994, 0.058634642511606216, -0.04664605110883713, -0.06374739855527878, -0.026227856054902077, 0.005707358941435814, 0.005999292712658644, -0.022444767877459526, 0.007978888228535652, -0.01842048577964306, 0.02467312105000019, 0.001424824120476842, 0.10891938954591751, -0.016177577897906303, 0.027910923585295677, 0.046330612152814865, 0.0021004744339734316, 0.042209405452013016, -0.017875168472528458, 0.005997262895107269, -0.03672735393047333, 0.003771608229726553, -0.059011589735746384, 0.03247794508934021, -0.06421694159507751, -0.03803500160574913, 0.019228097051382065, 0.023866547271609306, 0.05450034514069557, -0.014346512965857983, 0.027759011834859848, 0.027067748829722404, 0.03224778175354004, -0.019771065562963486, -0.024588026106357574, -0.023593638092279434, 0.01915585994720459, -0.018651384860277176, -0.06452727317810059, -0.010197206400334835, -0.06703819334506989, -0.03110499680042267, -0.02881729230284691, 0.010609712451696396, -0.024078460410237312, -0.011727886274456978, 0.0012082125758752227, -0.024035021662712097, -0.07445766776800156, 0.013662554323673248, 0.026893658563494682, -0.003666907548904419, 0.006623648107051849, -0.0026006270200014114, 0.04386196285486221, 0.0565529391169548, -0.0059740482829511166, 0.06434972584247589, 0.004384733270853758, 0.04499620571732521, 0.005563735496252775, 0.03507918864488602, -0.046796251088380814, 0.0054265889339149, 0.015667235478758812, 0.03615740314126015, -0.00828807707875967, -0.0023533639032393694, 0.02464773878455162, -0.02495693415403366, 0.01449051033705473, 0.033272549510002136, 0.032449446618556976, -0.00965032260864973, 0.013180739246308804, -0.011885108426213264, 0.03511118143796921, 0.008615082129836082, 0.05478435382246971, -0.015631873160600662, -0.020841652527451515, -0.012035655789077282, -0.03744163736701012, 0.02812032774090767, 0.016054857522249222, 0.00015297826030291617, 0.02042984403669834, -0.0481717623770237, 0.01965884491801262, 0.02105274796485901, 0.010757855139672756, 0.019482970237731934, 0.006049492862075567, 0.024363182485103607, 0.04814966022968292, -0.04271591454744339, -0.0034739135298877954, -0.00227358634583652, -0.005612011067569256, -0.04822833091020584, 0.05094961076974869, 0.025121385231614113, -0.041363175958395004, -0.0418115109205246, 0.0015918167773634195, -0.04361056908965111, 0.03988344594836235, 0.004661456681787968, -0.01577235572040081, -0.007364422082901001, 0.030784890055656433, 0.033025044947862625, 0.025939220562577248, 0.02670963667333126, -0.09180159866809845, 0.03071272186934948, 0.017630120739340782, 0.0035946678835898638, 0.03314867243170738, -0.03838931396603584, 0.0887383222579956, -0.01858176849782467, -0.014304793439805508, 0.034904785454273224, -0.05299432948231697, -0.01694055087864399, 0.004665442742407322, -0.02915371023118496, 0.06866641342639923, 0.015730716288089752, -0.030244847759604454, 0.03382866829633713, 0.053884465247392654, 0.034976083785295486, 0.027927028015255928, -0.0340975821018219, 0.04204420745372772, -0.02789035625755787, -0.009621678851544857, 0.005572059191763401, 0.07861381024122238, -0.07332129031419754, -0.04925678297877312, -0.017692016437649727, 0.005861392244696617, -0.010100631974637508, -0.030435219407081604, -0.02875252068042755, 0.025084419175982475, -0.0070101008750498295, -0.008986531756818295, 0.01724942959845066, 0.01743461564183235, -0.03825243189930916, 0.05249921977519989, 0.03128322213888168, -0.03587368503212929, 0.02752162702381611, -0.02649826742708683, 0.10018198937177658, 0.07305217534303665, -0.03160526603460312, -0.013584636151790619, 0.034239113330841064, 0.004059755243360996, 0.005517213139683008, 0.040277037769556046, -0.04431845620274544, 0.026374300941824913, -0.026759009808301926, 0.016884423792362213, -0.031445495784282684, 0.07258736342191696, -0.04984930157661438, -0.013733581639826298, 0.06851594150066376, -0.02475377917289734, 0.04373922199010849, -0.01190921850502491, 0.05341101437807083, 0.06731081008911133, -0.05801565572619438, -0.021164411678910255, -0.0314168781042099, -0.0033247508108615875, 0.014672518707811832, -0.004198872018605471, -0.01768193393945694, 0.032924894243478775, -0.050689779222011566, -0.0066291047260165215, -0.017668604850769043, 0.04865305498242378, 0.04381350800395012, 0.01598217338323593, 0.01247330754995346, -0.0033582239411771297, -0.026539888232946396, -0.01087541040033102, -0.10253047198057175, -0.04745476692914963, -0.020020250231027603, 0.03733465448021889, -0.008879623375833035, 0.041110165417194366, -0.008729933761060238, 0.009086045436561108, -0.014895838685333729, -0.022009003907442093, 0.013498321175575256, 0.018948150798678398, -0.004821762442588806, -0.02345501258969307, -0.006638322491198778, 0.027347886934876442, 0.059604864567518234, -0.01861543208360672, 0.003629542887210846, -0.016414470970630646, -0.06858331710100174, -0.025613373145461082, 0.007916742004454136, -0.014668134041130543, 0.006162276957184076, 0.043854620307683945, 0.0185565073043108, -0.01191740669310093, 0.019652243703603745, 0.041435882449150085, 0.06476610153913498, 0.06617937982082367, 0.003431540448218584, -0.012978645041584969, 0.0017282759072259068, -0.0032926832791417837, 0.029175857082009315, -0.004675380419939756, 0.006623662076890469, -0.025206439197063446, -0.005294300615787506, 0.020476525649428368, -0.02537732757627964, -0.25769343972206116, 0.011457939632236958, -0.006430670619010925, -0.009936298243701458, 0.0246773362159729, -0.0491328239440918, 0.029792599380016327, -0.044007040560245514, -0.016479264944791794, 0.0075185224413871765, -0.0080693569034338, 0.017981108278036118, -0.006566554307937622, 0.046162791550159454, 0.043021056801080704, 0.010260533541440964, 0.00034475623397156596, -0.02905532531440258, 0.01996237225830555, 0.04242992401123047, -0.02665875479578972, -0.0643182322382927, -0.012170292437076569, 0.023646969348192215, -0.011836407706141472, 0.013151898980140686, -0.07853450626134872, 0.013123882003128529, -0.022410189732909203, 0.009072725661098957, -0.050394874066114426, -0.03365621715784073, 0.009053785353899002, 0.055298447608947754, 0.0034997055772691965, 0.014935240149497986, 0.024130767211318016, 0.01881708949804306, 0.0051074861548841, -0.007054674439132214, -0.008085531182587147, -0.01560784038156271, 0.0032298967707902193, 0.020900879055261612, 0.044765278697013855, 0.005758692976087332, -0.0442618727684021, 0.00410465570166707, -0.007301982492208481, 0.02017732337117195, -0.0008506613085046411, 0.010129467584192753, -0.019690169021487236, -0.028366466984152794, -0.0011461449321359396, -0.021509747952222824, -0.012272900901734829, -0.004235206637531519, -0.009087353013455868, 0.027006445452570915, 0.008874011225998402, -0.044483672827482224, -0.01106301136314869, -0.04220966994762421, -0.01674359105527401, -0.026896676048636436, -0.05836545303463936, -0.04639797285199165, 0.0403607003390789, 0.022551817819476128, -0.015938758850097656, 0.021064547821879387, -0.006301217712461948, -0.09465450048446655, 0.060601770877838135, 0.020830804482102394, -0.00017370327259413898, -0.027415841817855835, -0.018603218719363213, 0.0178797896951437, -0.03820107877254486, -0.041315436363220215, -0.012305045500397682, 0.010625121183693409, -0.00877817627042532, -0.00943677593022585, 0.01018051989376545, -0.02196059189736843, -0.037669587880373, -0.029177846387028694, 0.01797950081527233, 0.011555093340575695, 0.05360468477010727, -0.0032366327941417694, 0.03641580417752266, 0.08565077930688858, 0.057814229279756546, 0.06342579424381256, 0.01472985465079546, -0.010564333759248257, 0.04751588776707649, -0.06906735152006149, -0.04885122552514076, -0.036944013088941574, -0.017768895253539085, 0.037843696773052216, -0.044956307858228683, -0.010014870204031467, 0.027028020471334457, 0.012192465364933014, -0.06779241561889648, -0.032175011932849884, -0.0022798683494329453, 0.0052609993144869804, 0.005301021505147219, -0.04941191524267197, -0.007052640896290541, 0.04704251512885094, 0.02673875354230404, -0.0398315005004406, -0.011786405928432941, 0.05568930134177208, 0.008899836800992489, 0.012587129138410091, 0.017276370897889137, -0.012191766873002052, -0.05430864542722702, -0.012600685469806194, 0.017919734120368958, -0.01377593632787466, 0.08070217072963715, 0.06479942053556442, -0.007902508601546288, 0.03634260967373848, 0.06998918205499649, -0.014681476168334484, -0.01829618215560913, -0.010992034338414669, 0.020000047981739044, -0.03043191507458687, 0.04137488454580307, -0.026725854724645615, 0.04495111480355263, 0.008538367226719856, 0.03972110524773598, 0.021046727895736694, -0.0074945115484297276, 0.036115698516368866, -0.030200496315956116, -0.036756642162799835, 0.03123461827635765, -0.06697579473257065, -0.06875286996364594, -0.008772305212914944, 0.0036593014374375343, -0.03154536336660385, 0.04020872712135315, -0.019362673163414, 0.022031337022781372, -0.08267923444509506, 0.062331248074769974, -0.0006852166261523962, -0.01872275024652481, -0.00768863782286644, -0.0013514736201614141, 0.037863340228796005, -0.006769753061234951, 0.008468326181173325, 0.036485787481069565, -0.0055811055935919285, 0.018773166462779045, 0.00910304393619299, -0.046802155673503876, -0.021077899262309074, -0.0059074596501886845, 0.00009223788947565481, -0.036011725664138794, -0.023620055988430977, -0.059630755335092545, 0.05103035643696785, 0.029614165425300598, -0.04624214768409729, 0.008075390942394733, 0.018347257748246193, 0.07052428275346756, 0.02901679463684559, 0.02682359702885151, -0.01453246921300888, -0.07399873435497284, 0.0432821623980999, -0.010931970551609993, -0.005495878867805004, -0.06932632625102997, -0.03047061897814274, -0.03315882012248039, -0.04858103394508362, 0.009003606624901295, 0.0530712828040123, -0.02696547843515873, 0.007719310000538826, -0.007771674077957869, 0.007294824346899986, -0.03165657818317413, -0.003497340250760317, 0.04199626296758652, -0.053159527480602264, 0.014431597664952278, 0.044380947947502136, -0.03986743465065956, 0.022884491831064224, 0.023747731000185013, -0.022782405838370323, -0.0751190334558487, -0.02477460540831089, -0.009296798147261143, 0.000921882048714906, -0.019687552005052567, -0.0256594717502594, 0.0169675275683403, 0.016384610906243324, 0.03413804620504379, -0.003377936314791441, -0.032311368733644485, -0.00844745896756649, 0.008540572598576546, 0.019681399688124657, -0.0384882390499115, -0.0161436777561903, -0.01708642579615116, -0.003748699091374874, 0.00915610697120428, -0.06110888347029686, 0.031719159334897995, 0.06989270448684692, -0.009271604008972645, -0.009129844605922699, -0.06466837972402573, 0.03403714299201965, -0.020115014165639877, 0.009284050203859806, 0.003452866105362773, -0.0007269573980011046, -0.057752758264541626, 0.019957009702920914, 0.014740720391273499, 0.03454885631799698, -0.015288924798369408, 0.01614697091281414, 0.009994571097195148, 0.034453894942998886, 0.040238283574581146, 0.002037708880379796, -0.04743223637342453, -0.009394685737788677, 0.05886003375053406, -0.03472383692860603, -0.026402056217193604, -0.061346858739852905, -0.05165323615074158, 0.004821109119802713, 0.012230693362653255, 0.002688415814191103, -0.018797986209392548, 0.04888954386115074, 0.028697703033685684, 0.002842221176251769, -0.00525358971208334, 0.0028616650961339474, 0.02826901152729988, -0.04014049470424652, 0.016476528719067574, -0.045312557369470596, -0.028247477486729622, 0.05874112993478775, -0.037474870681762695, 0.007868797518312931, 0.0010846854420378804, -0.017949024215340614, 0.03180920332670212, -0.036896299570798874, -0.06348332017660141, 0.027011526748538017, -0.014462643302977085, 0.005622493103146553, 0.02200283296406269, -0.04771722853183746, 0.009434834122657776, -0.002840212546288967, -0.05273361876606941, -0.00020548496104311198, 0.013217529281973839, 0.0341213159263134, -0.017073078081011772, 0.017619600519537926, 0.004948980174958706, -0.0019854193087667227, 0.018720563501119614, 0.0867665559053421, 0.010514458641409874, 0.05042772740125656, -0.035372257232666016, 0.0659034326672554, 0.04828886315226555, 0.010065816342830658, 0.036470551043748856, 0.005457576829940081, -0.007737686857581139, -0.04851164668798447, 0.02010529674589634, 0.01595141366124153, -0.010474598035216331, -0.06626462936401367, 0.036212656646966934, 0.03902459517121315, -0.06288697570562363, -0.033747609704732895, 0.04536643996834755, -0.02072472870349884, -0.0014679235173389316, -0.003960866015404463, 0.011111952364444733, -0.0016113212332129478, 0.05578646436333656, -0.0066383895464241505, 0.04561730474233627, 0.056982383131980896, 0.04255295172333717, -0.02146012894809246, -0.01726561412215233, 0.07481704652309418, 0.07087858021259308, 0.018161602318286896, 0.0193024929612875, 0.06121845915913582, -0.010361932218074799, -0.056969672441482544, 0.023606769740581512, 0.017907122150063515, -0.003316194750368595, -0.08045993745326996, 0.012365518137812614, 0.10573935508728027, -0.006392381154000759, 0.04748333618044853, -0.05102478712797165, -0.00929384957998991, 0.036724671721458435, 0.03788081929087639, -0.0042490484192967415, 0.008442206308245659, 0.03641651198267937, -0.004408140201121569, -0.015436266548931599, 0.00933441985398531, -0.028677038848400116, -0.005383029580116272, 0.03289683908224106, 0.02984663099050522, 0.014790601097047329, 0.03739180415868759, 0.011821549385786057, 0.0457666777074337, 0.09292025119066238, -0.04290810227394104, -0.049818918108940125, -0.017061902210116386, 0.005788181908428669, 0.0011146413162350655, 0.013782619498670101, 0.0002544792369008064, -0.019326897338032722, -0.01489267311990261, -0.05960242077708244, 0.02804216556251049, 0.014298593625426292, -0.004205762408673763, 0.017732534557580948, -0.03749919682741165, -0.009704045951366425, 0.009592746384441853, 0.023061245679855347, -0.0557578019797802, -0.0525226816534996, -0.01531690638512373, -0.027410823851823807, -0.08404377102851868, -0.04265473037958145, 0.03309624642133713, 0.0023415128234773874, -0.04940841719508171, -0.029399380087852478, -0.04192012920975685, 0.012257554568350315, 0.03166956827044487, -0.06198707967996597, -0.024627700448036194, 0.05924312770366669, 0.00524462154135108, -0.026843590661883354, 0.011501498520374298, 0.005072978790849447, -0.0021475034300237894, -0.02108103781938553, 0.03389422222971916, -0.0018655714811757207, -0.002111275913193822, -0.032784946262836456, 0.020747553557157516, -0.08711837232112885, 0.04630373418331146, 0.014990195631980896, -0.02831369824707508, -0.09189258515834808, 0.04809032380580902, -0.02995707467198372, 0.04042242467403412, 0.0460079088807106, 0.009695981629192829, -0.015203160233795643, -0.041089121252298355, -0.00841032899916172, 0.0033656286541372538, -0.027246398851275444, 0.05970826745033264, -0.005926050245761871, 0.09536724537611008, 0.07179050147533417, -0.0036544636823236942, -0.003045350546017289, 0.011192808859050274, 0.005537893623113632, -0.005975125357508659, -0.0016898238100111485, -0.03467293828725815, -0.03946094587445259, -0.08418412506580353, -0.027076324447989464, 0.01782533898949623, -0.023826243355870247, -0.028451532125473022, 0.0003293049812782556, 0.0011850142618641257, 0.005347235593944788, -0.0058403280563652515, -0.011178895831108093, -0.017920318990945816, 0.0024334238842129707, -0.046329665929079056, -0.04752304032444954, 0.021156417205929756, -0.014897288754582405, 0.01080790814012289, -0.044840965420007706, -0.04523554444313049, -0.038730937987565994, -0.024710731580853462, 0.036803457885980606, 0.007771829608827829, 0.03110150247812271, -0.002033847849816084 ]
3,526
Bundle Neural Network for message diffusion on graphs
https://openreview.net/forum?id=scI9307PLG
[ "Jacob Bamberger", "Federico Barbero", "Xiaowen Dong", "Michael M. Bronstein" ]
Spotlight
The dominant paradigm for learning on graphs is message passing. Despite being a strong inductive bias, the local message passing mechanism faces challenges such as over-smoothing, over-squashing, and limited expressivity. To address these issues, we introduce Bundle Neural Networks (BuNNs), a novel graph neural network architecture that operates via *message diffusion* on *flat vector bundles* — geometrically inspired structures that assign to each node a vector space and an orthogonal map. A BuNN layer evolves node features through a diffusion-type partial differential equation, where its discrete form acts as a special case of the recently introduced Sheaf Neural Network (SNN), effectively alleviating over-smoothing. The continuous nature of message diffusion enables BuNNs to operate at larger scales, reducing over-squashing. We establish the universality of BuNNs in approximating feature transformations on infinite families of graphs with injective positional encodings, marking the first positive expressivity result of its kind. We support our claims with formal analysis and synthetic experiments. Empirically, BuNNs perform strongly on heterophilic and long-range tasks, which demonstrates their robustness on a diverse range of challenging real-world tasks.
graph neural network, sheaf neural network, geometric deep learning, algebraic topology, vector bundles, expressivity
We propose Bundle Neural Networks, a new type of Graph Neural Network that operates via message diffusion, a continuous version of message-passing that allows to mitigate over-smoothing, over-squashing, and is provably expressive.
6,260
2405.15540
[ 0.008706534281373024, -0.038905467838048935, 0.021223952993750572, 0.050901204347610474, 0.010964366607367992, 0.03733913600444794, 0.02208077162504196, 0.0001158461527666077, -0.030496226623654366, -0.07231540977954865, 0.022096548229455948, -0.036839790642261505, -0.05395317077636719, 0.020853258669376373, 0.029575802385807037, 0.027040597051382065, 0.03340642899274826, 0.0029927678406238556, -0.037839096039533615, 0.0019042941275984049, -0.0015391787746921182, -0.014784342609345913, 0.02146769128739834, -0.00918508693575859, 0.03128141537308693, 0.0015193434664979577, 0.03929396718740463, 0.015727557241916656, 0.004427362233400345, 0.028929581865668297, 0.04120500385761261, 0.002991632092744112, 0.01171936746686697, -0.04352857917547226, -0.007281289901584387, 0.005678314249962568, -0.01661367528140545, -0.014719333499670029, 0.0023614345118403435, -0.0008760330965742469, -0.05481838062405586, 0.03490561619400978, 0.0012231410946696997, 0.01817842200398445, -0.030336545780301094, 0.005023191217333078, -0.11325390636920929, 0.01575384847819805, 0.011009878478944302, -0.020300550386309624, -0.11154617369174957, 0.04534556344151497, 0.024040445685386658, 0.009523647837340832, 0.011825338937342167, 0.04409225657582283, -0.005504532251507044, -0.03559925779700279, -0.0026493777986615896, -0.05892278999090195, -0.032303497195243835, 0.02878454513847828, 0.004633885342627764, 0.004170326981693506, -0.004203010816127062, 0.0027585728093981743, -0.024872759357094765, 0.06878392398357391, -0.041917331516742706, -0.045885179191827774, -0.013165613636374474, -0.026307180523872375, -0.018698465079069138, 0.012928348034620285, 0.03734447807073593, -0.043778009712696075, 0.0154180359095335, 0.009974411688745022, 0.08125738054513931, -0.03177909180521965, -0.02276039496064186, 0.08315180242061615, -0.00702812010422349, 0.040195025503635406, 0.014924544841051102, 0.010721123777329922, -0.030415698885917664, -0.008686641231179237, -0.08804595470428467, 0.0650462731719017, -0.018003905192017555, -0.04637819528579712, 0.01406229380518198, 0.025161663070321083, 0.006706598214805126, -0.012089674361050129, 0.04420184716582298, 0.017052054405212402, 0.036830395460128784, -0.007284099236130714, -0.0411045104265213, -0.021012097597122192, 0.008812963031232357, -0.0053746639750897884, -0.09627345204353333, -0.01780039817094803, -0.01271732710301876, -0.019838036969304085, 0.0019114295719191432, -0.031098701059818268, -0.025097249075770378, 0.010653716512024403, 0.03007490746676922, 0.005395144689828157, -0.07033214718103409, 0.013262844644486904, 0.01711920090019703, -0.007935893721878529, -0.014448490925133228, -0.013783073984086514, 0.05026638135313988, 0.03460558503866196, -0.003541818354278803, 0.06817661970853806, -0.008549685589969158, -0.009015546180307865, -0.0032596972305327654, 0.015075446106493473, -0.015639230608940125, -0.020878436043858528, -0.0048258258029818535, 0.053609609603881836, 0.03315943852066994, 0.034331295639276505, 0.023914119228720665, -0.036302294582128525, 0.0073440829291939735, 0.011938891373574734, 0.02794824354350567, -0.02371435984969139, 0.012845507822930813, -0.015759523957967758, 0.03756731003522873, -0.026405032724142075, 0.07847245782613754, -0.022775012999773026, -0.012702951207756996, -0.017351631075143814, -0.024663591757416725, -0.001703294226899743, 0.010329358279705048, -0.028223656117916107, 0.004005260765552521, -0.05364358425140381, -0.009821292944252491, 0.04991428926587105, 0.039595115929841995, 0.05182478204369545, 0.0038569909520447254, -0.007111616898328066, 0.02575751394033432, -0.008574644103646278, -0.016142871230840683, 0.011203203350305557, -0.01582277938723564, -0.07063374668359756, 0.027167007327079773, 0.05426017940044403, -0.04222402349114418, -0.01747513748705387, 0.005073246546089649, -0.0480620414018631, 0.023787105455994606, 0.01847473345696926, -0.027397559955716133, -0.013187884353101254, 0.04312559589743614, 0.0013974218163639307, 0.00884842686355114, 0.014068066142499447, -0.09644514322280884, 0.04205988347530365, 0.034267641603946686, 0.008742444217205048, -0.02943950705230236, -0.048985082656145096, 0.06508148461580276, -0.0013768275966867805, 0.00028998416382819414, 0.027371834963560104, -0.07998952269554138, -0.012677472084760666, -0.00036654126597568393, -0.02220800146460533, 0.07472105324268341, 0.022156856954097748, -0.01626509614288807, 0.02166352979838848, 0.030804427340626717, 0.01607280969619751, 0.047947030514478683, -0.0034871548414230347, 0.05940032750368118, -0.01837162859737873, -0.049605485051870346, 0.024911625310778618, 0.048375360667705536, -0.05945565924048424, -0.047935254871845245, 0.001386798219755292, -0.009109631180763245, -0.021814806386828423, 0.025250041857361794, -0.023456841707229614, 0.02467399835586548, -0.00829606968909502, -0.00903872400522232, 0.0131142633035779, 0.04098409786820412, -0.06538165360689163, 0.010902831330895424, 0.011788119561970234, -0.041641443967819214, 0.017271989956498146, -0.04430825263261795, 0.10373006016016006, 0.07372762262821198, -0.0130429957062006, 0.003606459591537714, 0.0028731455095112324, 0.035523269325494766, 0.02556462585926056, 0.026691706851124763, -0.018746472895145416, -0.00430186977609992, 0.005090442486107349, -0.00015954527771100402, -0.04073803871870041, 0.05429079756140709, -0.04289834946393967, 0.021671097725629807, 0.08594541996717453, -0.02338513545691967, 0.0547495000064373, 0.00030464454903267324, 0.03940659761428833, 0.034824393689632416, -0.06348521262407303, 0.0019793249666690826, -0.0046237679198384285, -0.015310530550777912, 0.0075891222804784775, 0.0033051883801817894, -0.06693869084119797, 0.03779640793800354, -0.03526364639401436, 0.014539132826030254, -0.000090924630057998, 0.0858258605003357, 0.057050593197345734, 0.03522520884871483, -0.011564311571419239, -0.03392717242240906, -0.014099403284490108, -0.04802457615733147, -0.12748496234416962, -0.03806401416659355, 0.002031561452895403, 0.0429096482694149, 0.0041503082029521465, 0.05654320493340492, -0.04029738903045654, 0.034809213131666183, -0.03688593953847885, -0.01639781892299652, -0.03763265907764435, 0.023788398131728172, 0.0015442457515746355, -0.0479268915951252, -0.041648801416158676, 0.00892364326864481, 0.061525311321020126, 0.005055064335465431, -0.01134007703512907, -0.032278671860694885, -0.03603680059313774, 0.013790598139166832, 0.007565677165985107, 0.002719217212870717, 0.011254701763391495, 0.04009911045432091, 0.03890120983123779, 0.022367123514413834, 0.035745617002248764, 0.035547591745853424, 0.06166059896349907, 0.055332694202661514, 0.004882346373051405, -0.03321937471628189, -0.009840757586061954, -0.015369245782494545, 0.01559257972985506, -0.027367981150746346, 0.01428244262933731, -0.023905493319034576, 0.0146808922290802, 0.028513211756944656, -0.011679115705192089, -0.2605673670768738, 0.003546510124579072, 0.017461592331528664, -0.03178250044584274, 0.01685129664838314, -0.010456226766109467, 0.022337637841701508, -0.04080472141504288, -0.040427446365356445, 0.009646879509091377, -0.0036164449993520975, 0.03487993776798248, -0.00880948081612587, 0.0011424323311075568, 0.05352863669395447, -0.0055732280015945435, -0.018774034455418587, -0.01843990758061409, 0.007613118272274733, 0.029664451256394386, -0.033683665096759796, -0.07996031641960144, -0.015210885554552078, 0.017167361453175545, -0.027166958898305893, 0.04006592929363251, -0.08415280282497406, -0.024667350575327873, -0.016400977969169617, 0.012218308635056019, -0.01132490299642086, -0.0361134372651577, 0.027454687282443047, 0.0769670307636261, -0.020194141194224358, -0.02266472950577736, -0.002923706080764532, -0.03257550299167633, 0.005573372356593609, 0.053204458206892014, 0.02731737308204174, 0.011522680521011353, -0.02653377130627632, 0.006482929922640324, 0.05394141748547554, -0.015864938497543335, -0.06653054058551788, -0.003704627975821495, -0.04321802780032158, 0.04622392728924751, -0.010199415497481823, -0.04161517322063446, -0.01992853730916977, -0.03149721398949623, 0.019478019326925278, -0.022907007485628128, -0.00720520643517375, 0.010564841330051422, -0.02092571184039116, 0.011913357302546501, 0.0021206624805927277, -0.030649662017822266, 0.012684387154877186, -0.02683919109404087, -0.011798928491771221, -0.02223956026136875, -0.09255634993314743, -0.03768915310502052, 0.031700942665338516, -0.006645325105637312, 0.0059072887524962425, 0.04865303635597229, -0.0288092028349638, -0.09359832853078842, 0.00005168173447600566, 0.0147854033857584, -0.02871926873922348, 0.01335124671459198, 0.029468810185790062, 0.05058624595403671, -0.0138356052339077, -0.025710459798574448, -0.02603636309504509, 0.020618582144379616, 0.04493254795670509, -0.008336750790476799, 0.01392826996743679, -0.02716352418065071, -0.02274632453918457, -0.045222360640764236, 0.057432543486356735, -0.019182171672582626, 0.04988834634423256, 0.040518514811992645, 0.06691637635231018, 0.048654329031705856, 0.010714009404182434, 0.00603011529892683, 0.0219712033867836, 0.007615517824888229, 0.04286878556013107, -0.05367303267121315, -0.04157477244734764, -0.018413402140140533, -0.03703983873128891, 0.04054535925388336, -0.05049280822277069, 0.0030277888290584087, 0.015827752649784088, 0.018730316311120987, -0.027887973934412003, -0.061888404190540314, 0.022142041474580765, -0.009525734931230545, -0.034681592136621475, -0.011325357481837273, -0.02358524315059185, 0.03007415682077408, 0.02707429975271225, -0.03052796609699726, -0.013570415787398815, 0.04122220352292061, -0.021622564643621445, 0.04630107060074806, 0.0036166394129395485, 0.018150614574551582, -0.008624780923128128, -0.06267094612121582, 0.019218996167182922, 0.009472359903156757, 0.016460934653878212, 0.04491107538342476, 0.01830105297267437, 0.015261626802384853, 0.04913412407040596, 0.0021139481104910374, -0.05020521208643913, -0.01436341181397438, 0.014014815911650658, 0.0006728165317326784, 0.02621961198747158, 0.03029303438961506, 0.05570913106203079, 0.014218912459909916, 0.04705154150724411, 0.0053712851367890835, 0.003419839544221759, -0.007403284776955843, -0.0027774807531386614, -0.02390926145017147, 0.011876719072461128, -0.05090740695595741, -0.0258908960968256, -0.030390460044145584, -0.008223047479987144, -0.0034239422529935837, 0.06548454612493515, -0.002912756521254778, 0.010458176024258137, -0.06112369894981384, 0.04095258563756943, 0.014272641390562057, -0.02922188490629196, 0.006843774113804102, 0.016568554565310478, 0.045980602502822876, -0.032474856823682785, 0.01636103354394436, 0.0036947133485227823, -0.038688190281391144, -0.00818945188075304, -0.013081052340567112, -0.03200699761509895, -0.012169898487627506, -0.042575903236866, 0.015744885429739952, -0.014123307541012764, -0.025932155549526215, -0.005887492094188929, 0.04360945522785187, 0.010434374213218689, -0.021799536421895027, 0.004644889384508133, 0.0375802256166935, 0.08810050785541534, 0.020945599302649498, -0.016105998307466507, 0.028183110058307648, -0.054187286645174026, 0.08491545170545578, 0.009306134656071663, 0.031061634421348572, -0.04816405475139618, -0.044061191380023956, -0.023196231573820114, -0.03998241201043129, 0.016104843467473984, 0.02209784835577011, -0.022205865010619164, -0.03371449559926987, -0.009865336120128632, 0.02481643483042717, -0.04005486145615578, 0.030041851103305817, 0.027788719162344933, -0.07512439787387848, 0.03329739347100258, 0.06664378196001053, 0.0006180033087730408, 0.009568783454596996, -0.03447965905070305, 0.005906667094677687, -0.057145509868860245, -0.017792608588933945, 0.05784114450216293, 0.020166924223303795, -0.0034445696510374546, -0.04900267347693443, -0.01322508417069912, -0.02040746994316578, -0.0030215170700103045, 0.006304450798779726, -0.016078531742095947, -0.025325274094939232, 0.01602153666317463, 0.08179274201393127, -0.007624453864991665, -0.02816622704267502, -0.028240755200386047, -0.025546936318278313, 0.0029505810234695673, -0.01212875172495842, 0.005499839782714844, 0.03902242332696915, -0.01647510752081871, 0.007756182458251715, -0.047835469245910645, 0.0361776240170002, 0.008422087877988815, -0.03299162909388542, -0.018173886463046074, 0.000117489107651636, -0.05645998194813728, 0.0177623238414526, -0.003478710073977709, 0.03735004737973213, 0.011242126114666462, 0.019150394946336746, 0.00021559963352046907, 0.017362847924232483, 0.010301321744918823, 0.011602749116718769, -0.07264120876789093, -0.026292305439710617, 0.03543208912014961, -0.012797633185982704, -0.05346778780221939, -0.05231337621808052, 0.005200937855988741, 0.0006128327804617584, -0.05193162336945534, 0.012247893959283829, -0.02244245633482933, 0.02866988070309162, 0.0024273227900266647, 0.021098872646689415, 0.01524188183248043, -0.026254748925566673, 0.033735454082489014, -0.02870134450495243, 0.00709192082285881, -0.03905423730611801, -0.015957146883010864, 0.039110854268074036, -0.04142925515770912, 0.045940812677145004, 0.015592471696436405, 0.006980579346418381, -0.011813965626060963, -0.015655459836125374, -0.06042126938700676, -0.023207591846585274, -0.01225447840988636, 0.03528476506471634, 0.042632993310689926, -0.06579000502824783, -0.016740674152970314, -0.010495715774595737, -0.05794474482536316, -0.016507279127836227, -0.005204125307500362, 0.019394760951399803, -0.011594705283641815, 0.005539723671972752, 0.007470153272151947, 0.0026699500158429146, 0.009915907867252827, 0.05673603713512421, 0.02910788729786873, 0.04545179009437561, -0.05513862147927284, 0.03814086690545082, 0.06040611490607262, 0.0003991031844634563, 0.010964633896946907, 0.03361110761761665, -0.026324180886149406, -0.06173030287027359, 0.02477061189711094, -0.0002570553042460233, -0.016339344903826714, -0.05048898234963417, 0.04455504193902016, -0.00443855719640851, -0.06850565969944, -0.04088117182254791, 0.016294030472636223, -0.04746473208069801, 0.017132651060819626, -0.010294985957443714, -0.0050861225463449955, 0.04082827642560005, 0.08094394207000732, 0.0019313102820888162, 0.010229685343801975, 0.08030176162719727, 0.0019400327000766993, 0.008950918912887573, -0.041184525936841965, 0.07091864943504333, 0.05427718907594681, 0.03914312273263931, -0.028031092137098312, 0.0683654397726059, -0.023421933874487877, -0.08016269654035568, -0.008203479461371899, 0.014360906556248665, -0.01091571431607008, -0.019811568781733513, -0.0011399813229218125, 0.08089854568243027, -0.021979443728923798, 0.07666485756635666, -0.056013550609350204, 0.003021177602931857, 0.020669830963015556, 0.010722886770963669, -0.0077208043076097965, 0.03143440932035446, 0.03838593140244484, 0.03153542801737785, -0.015288095921278, -0.0036468387115746737, -0.014305385760962963, -0.02667407877743244, 0.01334324385970831, 0.05239657312631607, 0.0023056494537740946, 0.015761857852339745, 0.026748280972242355, 0.029067516326904297, 0.09646686166524887, -0.04066450893878937, -0.027685068547725677, -0.020449288189411163, 0.009412435814738274, 0.008162825368344784, 0.03522491827607155, 0.01002687681466341, -0.011259058490395546, -0.015982158482074738, -0.02119860053062439, -0.001268249237909913, 0.006909321062266827, -0.005742979701608419, 0.028270026668906212, -0.01636924035847187, -0.03508593514561653, -0.007176702376455069, -0.0026845973916351795, -0.016732079908251762, -0.055051691830158234, -0.020182659849524498, -0.054509878158569336, -0.06541130691766739, -0.0677138939499855, 0.010119699873030186, 0.010384337976574898, -0.038859590888023376, -0.009407401084899902, -0.00858247373253107, 0.020327579230070114, 0.02994399145245552, -0.057092759758234024, 0.015416610054671764, 0.029485108330845833, 0.0236881822347641, -0.015694625675678253, 0.02243759110569954, 0.025443416088819504, -0.05050687491893768, -0.005410201381891966, 0.04237569123506546, 0.015131357125937939, 0.005422856193035841, 0.03424334526062012, 0.022491196170449257, -0.08754154294729233, 0.021081186830997467, 0.011096488684415817, -0.0701913982629776, -0.0840630978345871, 0.02982429601252079, -0.006818132475018501, 0.005930077284574509, 0.055709876120090485, 0.036555834114551544, -0.016388893127441406, -0.045409996062517166, 0.04664405807852745, -0.02060656063258648, 0.015489768236875534, 0.055202558636665344, -0.01609274558722973, 0.07672103494405746, 0.042897410690784454, -0.035801295191049576, -0.03255821391940117, 0.020998792722821236, 0.0074221608228981495, 0.018806226551532745, -0.024031227454543114, -0.04050963744521141, -0.015605063177645206, -0.09408637881278992, -0.03499286249279976, 0.03945201635360718, -0.01672893762588501, -0.026741117238998413, 0.014570888131856918, -0.007891181856393814, 0.015802182257175446, -0.020086634904146194, -0.03815353661775589, -0.018951397389173508, 0.011827699840068817, -0.02066589519381523, -0.062366120517253876, 0.011309542693197727, -0.027499843388795853, 0.005507018882781267, -0.037104152143001556, -0.04872339591383934, -0.009778240695595741, 0.026813041418790817, 0.028247704729437828, -0.006353908218443394, 0.01469095703214407, 0.019953271374106407 ]
3,527
SynFlowNet: Design of Diverse and Novel Molecules with Synthesis Constraints
https://openreview.net/forum?id=uvHmnahyp1
[ "Miruna Cretu", "Charles Harris", "Ilia Igashov", "Arne Schneuing", "Marwin Segler", "Bruno Correia", "Julien Roy", "Emmanuel Bengio", "Pietro Lio" ]
Spotlight
Generative models see increasing use in computer-aided drug design. However, while performing well at capturing distributions of molecular motifs, they often produce synthetically inaccessible molecules. To address this, we introduce SynFlowNet, a GFlowNet model whose action space uses chemical reactions and buyable reactants to sequentially build new molecules. By incorporating forward synthesis as an explicit constraint of the generative mechanism, we aim at bridging the gap between in silico molecular generation and real world synthesis capabilities. We evaluate our approach using synthetic accessibility scores and an independent retrosynthesis tool to assess the synthesizability of our compounds, and motivate the choice of GFlowNets through considerable improvement in sample diversity compared to baselines. Additionally, we identify challenges with reaction encodings that can complicate traversal of the MDP in the backward direction. To address this, we introduce various strategies for learning the GFlowNet backward policy and thus demonstrate how additional constraints can be integrated into the GFlowNet MDP framework. This approach enables our model to successfully identify synthesis pathways for previously unseen molecules.
GFlowNets, de novo molecular generation, synthesizable molecular design
A GFlowNet with an action space of chemical reactions and a trained backward policy.
6,178
2405.01155
[ -0.014300627633929253, -0.00905484240502119, -0.012197118252515793, 0.03648008033633232, 0.05298997834324837, -0.025697844102978706, 0.014336477033793926, -0.010413254611194134, 0.015211377292871475, -0.0416388139128685, 0.02471466362476349, -0.0031955959275364876, -0.06524248421192169, 0.02069890685379505, 0.0161362923681736, 0.06304798275232315, 0.026192642748355865, 0.016593828797340393, 0.045228585600852966, 0.0011731286067515612, -0.018586425110697746, 0.010244861245155334, 0.00502203730866313, 0.02415667474269867, 0.05607420206069946, 0.0004360890598036349, 0.003027315018698573, -0.006330739241093397, -0.01582348346710205, -0.0022775731049478054, 0.04158993437886238, 0.00398252671584487, 0.02471707947552204, -0.04390518367290497, 0.01603647693991661, 0.011013396084308624, -0.07171909511089325, 0.011470330879092216, -0.008165722712874413, -0.012568631209433079, -0.06730704009532928, 0.018741361796855927, -0.046942029148340225, 0.02787790633738041, -0.022539902478456497, 0.04489954188466072, -0.07936227321624756, 0.0724225640296936, 0.003748163115233183, -0.011293315328657627, -0.08551494777202606, 0.02152106910943985, 0.03554675728082657, -0.0468117818236351, 0.02181200496852398, 0.009137806482613087, 0.032331932336091995, -0.038933850824832916, -0.005104409996420145, -0.043658528476953506, -0.021690798923373222, -0.0022691679187119007, 0.03122359700500965, 0.014299465343356133, 0.0011027507716789842, -0.02620110660791397, 0.02759738638997078, 0.0322699137032032, -0.053322162479162216, 0.0016848237719386816, -0.04132024198770523, -0.009848960675299168, 0.016403963789343834, -0.030911119654774666, 0.00470025883987546, -0.04396120458841324, 0.006739475764334202, 0.018185600638389587, 0.07223961502313614, 0.0674193724989891, 0.028233353048563004, 0.038128141313791275, -0.015723800286650658, 0.028919074684381485, -0.021452412009239197, 0.012647956609725952, -0.03368525207042694, 0.0350307896733284, -0.05467391386628151, 0.04172149673104286, -0.006231491453945637, -0.04686211049556732, 0.00009072767716133967, 0.01212164107710123, 0.03846273198723793, -0.031107742339372635, 0.014703786000609398, -0.007995852269232273, -0.00040316200465895236, 0.022104430943727493, -0.02033182978630066, -0.03903212025761604, -0.03414589911699295, -0.015315557830035686, -0.07941439002752304, -0.0010993311880156398, -0.041422128677368164, -0.04364636540412903, 0.006679977290332317, 0.0005095872329548001, 0.0007767839124426246, 0.008714396506547928, 0.00772841414436698, -0.00622774800285697, -0.07169227302074432, 0.05424843728542328, 0.023299427703022957, 0.015573074109852314, -0.013136166147887707, -0.01429244689643383, 0.04668714851140976, 0.06468302011489868, -0.035638872534036636, 0.08615196496248245, 0.014324872754514217, -0.003811048809438944, 0.015511051751673222, -0.00520223006606102, -0.034827832132577896, -0.008273139595985413, 0.02140793576836586, 0.03606632724404335, -0.030904091894626617, -0.020844142884016037, -0.020500782877206802, -0.02401730976998806, 0.017601260915398598, 0.034945450723171234, 0.04047590494155884, -0.010047858580946922, 0.00774068757891655, 0.004037876613438129, 0.05099432170391083, -0.035884469747543335, 0.07171091437339783, -0.0066040451638400555, 0.027890535071492195, -0.05364961922168732, -0.024321602657437325, 0.01956988498568535, -0.005634531378746033, 0.02549278363585472, 0.00521091278642416, -0.028937166556715965, 0.04046829044818878, 0.05202027037739754, 0.03438669815659523, 0.04356251657009125, 0.001926857396028936, -0.021109744906425476, -0.013059400022029877, -0.004756735172122717, -0.007609168067574501, -0.020714526996016502, 0.0018156241858378053, -0.014690703712403774, 0.03367169573903084, 0.07826899737119675, -0.040498558431863785, -0.035411152988672256, -0.03234221786260605, -0.06926778703927994, 0.04580274969339371, -0.02914024516940117, 0.00898072961717844, 0.006293300073593855, 0.0505269356071949, -0.0013912387657910585, 0.02785106748342514, 0.007061299867928028, -0.07772968709468842, 0.0004939842619933188, 0.01809866726398468, -0.028542863205075264, 0.001256876508705318, -0.0012750803725793958, 0.09867218881845474, 0.0027964862529188395, -0.009100959636271, 0.028503989800810814, -0.07234320044517517, -0.03794192150235176, 0.024318931624293327, -0.005429378245025873, 0.047568242996931076, -0.020834924653172493, -0.009819873608648777, 0.040173228830099106, -0.007245798595249653, 0.04680091515183449, 0.022690778598189354, 0.03189004957675934, 0.04241465404629707, -0.05867908149957657, -0.040349241346120834, -0.028169581666588783, 0.03275004401803017, -0.07716874033212662, -0.04061051830649376, 0.015591896139085293, 0.021508188918232918, -0.020290523767471313, 0.02079915627837181, -0.043665189296007156, 0.03956976160407066, -0.011572448536753654, -0.005482333712279797, 0.009402408264577389, -0.035219836980104446, 0.001260697259567678, 0.012234526686370373, -0.0032425171229988337, -0.009755212813615799, 0.03375726565718651, -0.02279203198850155, 0.09666214138269424, 0.056782159954309464, -0.03054734691977501, -0.018643055111169815, 0.048961251974105835, 0.009308364242315292, -0.012900948524475098, 0.005778906401246786, -0.02367332950234413, -0.003294044639915228, -0.020731547847390175, 0.006676110439002514, 0.0017435952322557569, 0.03852440416812897, -0.0735502615571022, 0.005784503649920225, 0.04483618959784508, -0.03913959488272667, 0.04068121686577797, 0.010094000026583672, 0.013577550649642944, 0.041746485978364944, -0.03196108341217041, -0.045804012566804886, -0.028235875070095062, -0.03602485731244087, 0.005331001710146666, 0.007493528071790934, 0.012601377442479134, 0.007625567261129618, -0.05970694124698639, -0.02585359290242195, 0.01223372295498848, 0.07234493643045425, 0.06362920999526978, 0.006788074038922787, 0.0008982923463918269, 0.022906644269824028, -0.014147852547466755, -0.03135894984006882, -0.12496868520975113, -0.0330633781850338, -0.019592957571148872, 0.04436786472797394, 0.018404114991426468, 0.04668882489204407, -0.009920244105160236, -0.021337319165468216, -0.034627072513103485, -0.04232392460107803, 0.015362725593149662, -0.001143683330155909, -0.004415912088006735, -0.032127317041158676, -0.022409232333302498, 0.02019837126135826, 0.07006075233221054, -0.018954284489154816, -0.01819351315498352, -0.038415346294641495, -0.029625890776515007, -0.0351518951356411, -0.01191758457571268, 0.006792732980102301, 0.04486185312271118, 0.0016139498911798, 0.00232889736071229, -0.07089391350746155, 0.0021225232630968094, 0.04809299111366272, 0.02123086526989937, 0.004330131225287914, 0.03162428364157677, -0.031072014942765236, 0.029234178364276886, 0.015783758834004402, 0.027285883203148842, -0.033466748893260956, 0.015948597341775894, -0.0017726183868944645, -0.0062392898835241795, 0.03660668060183525, 0.004520971793681383, -0.25174298882484436, -0.026641709730029106, -0.008095760829746723, 0.017169656231999397, 0.04322804510593414, 0.0011758455075323582, 0.044586531817913055, -0.02301979251205921, -0.027366414666175842, -0.019312500953674316, -0.0036860478576272726, 0.01944653131067753, 0.005930162966251373, 0.04889761656522751, 0.031747642904520035, 0.04233359172940254, -0.020780114457011223, -0.03179780766367912, 0.03599771112203598, 0.0036447288002818823, -0.014281750656664371, -0.05346928536891937, -0.027550356462597847, 0.01521949004381895, -0.010454487055540085, -0.001826953375712037, -0.07864225655794144, -0.02511117421090603, -0.03155039623379707, 0.02191539853811264, -0.04948212578892708, -0.016459401696920395, -0.010155363008379936, 0.011970202438533306, 0.036004532128572464, 0.0072676814161241055, 0.05557553470134735, -0.020344210788607597, 0.03338230401277542, -0.02308129332959652, -0.007766625843942165, -0.01109434012323618, -0.030315352603793144, -0.00328564434312284, 0.055714067071676254, 0.014631128869950771, 0.015827514231204987, -0.005980400368571281, -0.037394069135189056, 0.05555731803178787, -0.025252453982830048, -0.04368145018815994, -0.006855911575257778, 0.02532828040421009, 0.021187081933021545, -0.016946639865636826, 0.021838827058672905, -0.015433146618306637, -0.002085302723571658, 0.03297486528754234, 0.018392087891697884, -0.019365482032299042, -0.006693877745419741, 0.010693675838410854, -0.018988553434610367, -0.015207053162157536, -0.04874710738658905, -0.07430588454008102, 0.023210516199469566, 0.053550105541944504, 0.0016075267922133207, 0.036976203322410583, -0.008967765606939793, -0.08953786641359329, 0.03072785586118698, -0.012132866308093071, -0.013439852744340897, -0.02435709536075592, 0.007701626047492027, 0.02984614670276642, -0.023307228460907936, -0.02557786926627159, -0.02201780118048191, 0.03229564428329468, 0.04986054450273514, -0.02123904414474964, 0.00025988195557147264, -0.021467464044690132, -0.059127528220415115, 0.008347392082214355, 0.028488509356975555, -0.009323479607701302, 0.05924787372350693, -0.04081243649125099, 0.028610985726118088, 0.00025426835054531693, 0.03090769611299038, 0.05474751070141792, 0.03802186995744705, 0.022544734179973602, 0.055795490741729736, -0.06398649513721466, -0.025510940700769424, -0.029792003333568573, -0.0210128091275692, 0.005280450452119112, -0.052494123578071594, -0.021040556952357292, 0.069141685962677, 0.009171321988105774, -0.02900870144367218, -0.014899113215506077, 0.015654221177101135, -0.024209998548030853, 0.016816668212413788, -0.024611329659819603, 0.03731787949800491, 0.055980559438467026, 0.05401945486664772, -0.014371627010405064, -0.050908371806144714, 0.08096341043710709, -0.03193950280547142, 0.016015764325857162, 0.003350823651999235, 0.011018847115337849, -0.020079370588064194, -0.00015975396672729403, 0.01916857436299324, -0.00047905166866257787, 0.0257867481559515, 0.0370112769305706, -0.02541731670498848, -0.011592608876526356, 0.027477102354168892, 0.00961271207779646, -0.054328497499227524, -0.00931654591113329, -0.0025207523722201586, -0.03368844464421272, 0.006561430171132088, -0.03078261762857437, 0.014756552875041962, 0.005194466095417738, 0.059785254299640656, 0.029593925923109055, 0.03414764627814293, 0.06442482769489288, 0.010155376978218555, 0.00759899104014039, 0.019673077389597893, -0.03208259493112564, 0.00891476683318615, -0.03598659113049507, 0.03660224378108978, -0.03422147408127785, 0.011159216985106468, -0.011880897916853428, 0.03452552482485771, -0.06791722774505615, 0.05016109719872475, -0.0022919189650565386, -0.017893021926283836, -0.02060645818710327, 0.004408377222716808, 0.06018797308206558, -0.023342780768871307, -0.005545042455196381, -0.018776321783661842, -0.0011221379972994328, 0.016032235696911812, -0.0263789352029562, -0.029596269130706787, -0.008219493553042412, -0.032897766679525375, 0.030518751591444016, -0.01779160089790821, -0.02280925028026104, -0.04598157852888107, 0.031175794079899788, -0.005537425633519888, -0.0526106096804142, 0.016453338786959648, 0.02087458409368992, 0.08498549461364746, -0.027347544208168983, -0.019582323729991913, -0.008005578070878983, -0.021180689334869385, 0.0376356840133667, 0.006087797228246927, 0.018389299511909485, -0.053410355001688004, -0.07339158654212952, -0.024050408974289894, -0.048943061381578445, -0.007905389182269573, 0.04476221650838852, -0.0024372688494622707, -0.020915264263749123, 0.04119132459163666, 0.025623494759202003, -0.04357654228806496, -0.0015034304233267903, 0.04843483865261078, -0.07362161576747894, -0.0029833796434104443, 0.05036795884370804, 0.02728218026459217, 0.017358841374516487, -0.025296131148934364, -0.020106442272663116, -0.05048369988799095, -0.01750273071229458, -0.006146440748125315, 0.021576864644885063, -0.009142565540969372, -0.01851528137922287, -0.0030082352459430695, 0.006624944973737001, 0.023343143984675407, 0.015979403629899025, 0.018243607133626938, -0.05221426114439964, -0.006220458075404167, 0.047757264226675034, -0.025434505194425583, -0.0037993979640305042, 0.009903611615300179, -0.012136846780776978, 0.028182378038764, -0.06478076428174973, 0.010424279607832432, 0.015390025451779366, 0.0023653951939195395, -0.017644761130213737, -0.016783619299530983, 0.03211689367890358, 0.0006595852901227772, 0.0033781761303544044, -0.010565175674855709, -0.013418820686638355, -0.05176259204745293, 0.02348545379936695, -0.0025938800536096096, 0.012305198237299919, 0.02501455321907997, 0.009733951650559902, -0.002162251388654113, 0.013054465875029564, 0.012737746350467205, 0.0007661146228201687, -0.034750014543533325, -0.029958369210362434, 0.06661932915449142, -0.01903531327843666, -0.026560764759778976, -0.039507728070020676, -0.03466220200061798, -0.0018289033323526382, -0.004974087234586477, 0.049784064292907715, -0.08820744603872299, 0.04541928693652153, 0.03569599613547325, -0.0007287058397196233, -0.004725050181150436, -0.08005110919475555, 0.03059636428952217, -0.0425168052315712, -0.009486842900514603, -0.04934757947921753, -0.025561630725860596, 0.07570794224739075, -0.01370929554104805, -0.015456458553671837, 0.011203600093722343, -0.0382927730679512, 0.02598663978278637, -0.04167221114039421, -0.0731067806482315, 0.03728992119431496, -0.01632966846227646, 0.029246937483549118, 0.03956238925457001, -0.04932361841201782, -0.04078752174973488, -0.02473624236881733, -0.05254941061139107, -0.024807099252939224, 0.03418494760990143, 0.05135161057114601, -0.03900662064552307, 0.006712993141263723, -0.01728564314544201, 0.03677268698811531, 0.04186380282044411, 0.04161446541547775, -0.0033809528686106205, 0.043451763689517975, -0.0023252128157764673, 0.05269486829638481, 0.07736720889806747, 0.020512837916612625, -0.001780640915967524, 0.03736511245369911, 0.004767369478940964, -0.041914645582437515, 0.027218496426939964, 0.017709815874695778, -0.021365435793995857, -0.07834045588970184, 0.08614950627088547, -0.0014779748162254691, -0.08108493685722351, -0.01269705779850483, 0.03392048552632332, -0.04468277841806412, 0.01136245857924223, 0.010577057488262653, 0.015011829324066639, 0.010202846489846706, 0.05621381849050522, -0.016302740201354027, 0.053974006325006485, 0.07029935717582703, 0.025116531178355217, 0.014582481235265732, -0.04190618917346001, 0.09115146100521088, 0.06455446779727936, 0.016500739380717278, 0.0008689654059708118, 0.06615812331438065, -0.018803685903549194, -0.03780466690659523, -0.024644123390316963, 0.008709586225450039, -0.03569973260164261, -0.018788699060678482, 0.03685472905635834, 0.060743317008018494, 0.014968747273087502, 0.06412524729967117, -0.025203844532370567, -0.008384905755519867, 0.025994891300797462, 0.025059478357434273, 0.026417303830385208, 0.018001316115260124, 0.029566830024123192, 0.01662946492433548, -0.022821201011538506, -0.020998071879148483, -0.049612972885370255, -0.01979069598019123, 0.014720155857503414, 0.00544131500646472, -0.014745374210178852, -0.0036907827015966177, -0.024027254432439804, 0.008087568916380405, 0.08070439845323563, -0.01266472414135933, -0.022963283583521843, 0.0033684379886835814, 0.02622676081955433, -0.010727958753705025, 0.028470557183027267, 0.011158418841660023, 0.003370287362486124, -0.0246973168104887, -0.05028554052114487, 0.0012855790555477142, 0.005852283909916878, 0.032377246767282486, -0.007498526014387608, -0.021944034844636917, -0.002302387962117791, -0.020860794931650162, 0.010938876308500767, -0.04286174848675728, -0.07425040006637573, -0.005874290596693754, -0.062051162123680115, -0.051650289446115494, -0.032329414039850235, 0.004516561049968004, -0.03876535966992378, -0.04417499899864197, 0.0014378642663359642, -0.01785067655146122, 0.007506486028432846, 0.04307148605585098, -0.051339711993932724, -0.017590466886758804, 0.07738618552684784, 0.005001589190214872, -0.027984270825982094, 0.024396613240242004, 0.01132370624691248, -0.016165850684046745, -0.046836141496896744, 0.05386403948068619, 0.02153705060482025, 0.03073776327073574, -0.015918467193841934, 0.015567714348435402, -0.11454828083515167, 0.027123210951685905, 0.02425585500895977, -0.048622120171785355, -0.08973909169435501, 0.024419985711574554, -0.03575262054800987, 0.019210120663046837, 0.06467488408088684, 0.030554812401533127, 0.0034214870538562536, -0.06442075222730637, 0.03927011415362358, 0.05678071826696396, -0.019144728779792786, 0.06962309032678604, -0.07108067721128464, 0.05027048662304878, 0.03247273713350296, -0.009336385875940323, -0.0317561961710453, 0.027810385450720787, 0.037554867565631866, -0.00009182596113532782, -0.02499973773956299, -0.027126189321279526, -0.05376676470041275, -0.11320082098245621, -0.002510473830625415, 0.020699385553598404, -0.03756284713745117, -0.03998856991529465, 0.001052900101058185, 0.011108595877885818, 0.002738809445872903, -0.021471666172146797, -0.03032742440700531, -0.03828287124633789, -0.008926788344979286, -0.04214189201593399, -0.07534723728895187, -0.01222926378250122, 0.002341262297704816, 0.01965540647506714, -0.03954091668128967, -0.029990307986736298, 0.016997244209051132, -0.00430896645411849, 0.04077344387769699, -0.008550459519028664, 0.020450828596949577, 0.01943627931177616 ]
3,528
u-μP: The Unit-Scaled Maximal Update Parametrization
https://openreview.net/forum?id=P7KRIiLM8T
[ "Charlie Blake", "Constantin Eichenberg", "Josef Dean", "Lukas Balles", "Luke Yuri Prince", "Björn Deiseroth", "Andres Felipe Cruz-Salinas", "Carlo Luschi", "Samuel Weinbach", "Douglas Orr" ]
Spotlight
The Maximal Update Parametrization ($\mu$P) aims to make the optimal hyperparameters (HPs) of a model independent of its size, allowing them to be swept using a cheap proxy model rather than the full-size target model. We present a new scheme, u-$\mu$P, which improves upon $\mu$P by combining it with Unit Scaling, a method for designing models that makes them easy to train in low-precision. The two techniques have a natural affinity: $\mu$P ensures that the scale of activations is independent of model size, and Unit Scaling ensures that activations, weights and gradients begin training with a scale of one. This synthesis opens the door to a simpler scheme, whose default values are near-optimal. This in turn facilitates a more efficient sweeping strategy, with u-$\mu$P models reaching a lower loss than comparable $\mu$P models and working out-of-the-box in FP8.
maximal update parametrization, learning dynamics, hyperparameter transfer, efficiency, training, stability, scaling, numerics, fp8, low precision
We improve µP by combining it with Unit Scaling, leading to a simpler scheme with better default hyperparameters, lower loss, more efficient sweeping and simple FP8 training.
6,104
null
[ -0.0306707676500082, -0.0329408124089241, 0.002919320249930024, 0.02710016258060932, 0.018165674060583115, 0.057599764317274094, 0.0103855449706316, -0.03404879570007324, -0.01591266319155693, -0.05626292899250984, -0.00469153793528676, -0.0223750751465559, -0.07565106451511383, 0.005828483961522579, 0.000032774023566162214, 0.0802583247423172, 0.011248314753174782, 0.012251547537744045, 0.0004843929782509804, 0.025250140577554703, 0.013414386659860611, -0.010426593013107777, 0.049672652035951614, 0.002594397636130452, 0.012806729413568974, 0.01120112556964159, 0.041974931955337524, -0.02708452194929123, -0.0272345170378685, -0.02058233506977558, 0.01131510827690363, 0.0073229167610406876, 0.02245846576988697, -0.0212313961237669, 0.03953291475772858, 0.012322193011641502, -0.023268530145287514, 0.024736158549785614, 0.02239140123128891, -0.006940754596143961, -0.029966577887535095, 0.011371337808668613, -0.018518995493650436, 0.020397188141942024, -0.07225211709737778, -0.012432821094989777, -0.10904014110565186, 0.03368352726101875, -0.010637414641678333, -0.0659748837351799, -0.07242536544799805, 0.0340718999505043, -0.014603758230805397, -0.020759791135787964, -0.01873469352722168, 0.061448417603969574, 0.0314270555973053, -0.08447214215993881, 0.005764600355178118, -0.061297956854104996, -0.05066722631454468, 0.01269797794520855, 0.030934156849980354, 0.023959262296557426, -0.019820284098386765, 0.02098134160041809, -0.006259467452764511, 0.028427494689822197, -0.06454230844974518, -0.021113840863108635, -0.019170159474015236, -0.028933053836226463, 0.0013223575660958886, -0.01047686580568552, -0.004614085890352726, -0.027549859136343002, 0.03935987129807472, 0.01494408305734396, 0.04269004240632057, 0.018851257860660553, 0.016246424987912178, 0.004057212267071009, 0.03658560663461685, 0.02688506618142128, -0.018280204385519028, -0.005265241023153067, -0.04104677960276604, -0.03092123381793499, -0.10278183221817017, 0.05458326265215874, 0.010627686977386475, -0.051622722297906876, 0.023197807371616364, 0.019551478326320648, -0.004954098258167505, 0.0023678243160247803, -0.0066483234986662865, 0.01611887477338314, 0.034198325127363205, -0.0012199493357911706, -0.029551861807703972, -0.029408128932118416, 0.027432965114712715, -0.024778295308351517, -0.12490316480398178, -0.042497944086790085, -0.03730697184801102, -0.004293921869248152, -0.02051714062690735, -0.00427278783172369, -0.06762610375881195, 0.0005538175464607775, -0.015815550461411476, -0.026910610496997833, -0.0777096375823021, 0.037348423153162, -0.013979417271912098, 0.015824591740965843, -0.005830368027091026, -0.006761305034160614, 0.0419924259185791, 0.038830921053886414, 0.022464290261268616, 0.06853790581226349, 0.0002389606088399887, 0.017424216493964195, 0.03843443840742111, 0.029769165441393852, -0.027051113545894623, -0.00767580047249794, 0.007291780784726143, 0.0294167660176754, 0.019675197079777718, -0.002202032832428813, 0.019509688019752502, -0.04872462525963783, 0.004662466701120138, 0.026863688603043556, 0.03862282261252403, -0.01926739700138569, 0.015844717621803284, -0.008680552244186401, 0.06371563673019409, 0.00009779463289305568, 0.05989037826657295, -0.018537817522883415, 0.001649973331950605, -0.03977525979280472, -0.044547952711582184, -0.019472304731607437, 0.01721690408885479, -0.0020630278158932924, 0.005846319254487753, -0.011629478074610233, 0.03582078963518143, 0.05212612822651863, 0.035939522087574005, 0.022796349599957466, 0.02341873198747635, -0.025654932484030724, 0.00806269608438015, 0.0038523192051798105, -0.04905812069773674, -0.014634051360189915, -0.007276919670403004, -0.023204272612929344, 0.04287148267030716, 0.048878587782382965, -0.01938786916434765, -0.01764819584786892, -0.021046916022896767, -0.06816446781158447, 0.0823526605963707, 0.022947199642658234, -0.033328793942928314, 0.010722272098064423, 0.1043500155210495, 0.008234324865043163, 0.043517064303159714, 0.04045715928077698, -0.10423535853624344, 0.02469792030751705, 0.04756171256303787, -0.010714085772633553, 0.01280407514423132, -0.03132842853665352, 0.08266889303922653, -0.03860240802168846, -0.010138440877199173, 0.013364728540182114, -0.036116473376750946, -0.01082959771156311, 0.028647730126976967, -0.03403068333864212, 0.06357066333293915, 0.023875808343291283, -0.030252208933234215, 0.04574909061193466, 0.026242868974804878, 0.06423958390951157, 0.02999250404536724, 0.00043858253047801554, 0.0540444478392601, 0.004840690176934004, -0.03938286378979683, -0.03507157415151596, 0.04910573363304138, -0.08449039608240128, -0.05223481357097626, 0.028898822143673897, -0.025440745055675507, -0.018747985363006592, 0.0018146296497434378, -0.014862525276839733, 0.0042687952518463135, 0.02500476874411106, -0.000988402171060443, -0.016778111457824707, 0.029528947547078133, -0.04402286559343338, 0.04136323928833008, 0.03261571004986763, -0.052065081894397736, -0.002759272698312998, -0.015283976681530476, 0.06548717617988586, 0.07608291506767273, -0.041601959615945816, -0.031702011823654175, -0.0010811069514602423, 0.02762477658689022, -0.02000870183110237, 0.005632190033793449, -0.007767703849822283, 0.024465838447213173, -0.025944851338863373, 0.03669358044862747, -0.03210758417844772, 0.07487040758132935, -0.06173180416226387, -0.004954010248184204, 0.05905606225132942, 0.03146624192595482, 0.06080838292837143, 0.008493322879076004, -0.000221319030970335, 0.039710018783807755, -0.006013594102114439, -0.04745355620980263, -0.0011270302347838879, 0.00237416778691113, 0.00014084512076806277, 0.026615817099809647, -0.018010351806879044, 0.0028334243688732386, -0.07047629356384277, 0.00209085363894701, -0.0031980276107788086, 0.060067128390073776, 0.07146149128675461, 0.021947532892227173, 0.009815076366066933, -0.0036337277851998806, -0.03555327281355858, -0.03571033477783203, -0.11248937249183655, -0.041425421833992004, -0.007382667623460293, 0.05243087559938431, 0.048029590398073196, 0.025224357843399048, 0.016980472952127457, -0.020252352580428123, -0.026725098490715027, -0.0031039882451295853, 0.006323445588350296, 0.03353475406765938, -0.006291370373219252, -0.054418984800577164, 0.002168431878089905, 0.022265557199716568, 0.056568365544080734, -0.01891239546239376, -0.034202609211206436, -0.03007628209888935, -0.04923860356211662, -0.025970952585339546, -0.05528203397989273, 0.005652475170791149, 0.0037789202760905027, 0.0022952640429139137, 0.0093251783400774, -0.033085666596889496, 0.02795611135661602, 0.03769306838512421, 0.04434613138437271, 0.043569762259721756, 0.009880024939775467, -0.02458013780415058, 0.021320249885320663, -0.013004607520997524, 0.004218248650431633, 0.003332266816869378, -0.011528380215168, -0.00809503998607397, -0.009715324267745018, 0.007571479771286249, 0.019804228097200394, -0.28061404824256897, -0.026843713596463203, 0.02103336527943611, 0.0002516977838240564, 0.022633174434304237, -0.012775721028447151, 0.005624798126518726, -0.016306985169649124, -0.06357838213443756, -0.009131512604653835, 0.027793217450380325, 0.009544525295495987, 0.005375798791646957, 0.04110913723707199, 0.03965437039732933, 0.01856781542301178, -0.004815393593162298, 0.01708565466105938, 0.008761527016758919, 0.03879131004214287, 0.012988561764359474, -0.07843516767024994, 0.005227033048868179, 0.026459865272045135, -0.023170150816440582, 0.026306424289941788, -0.07814575731754303, -0.008640074171125889, -0.0691336989402771, -0.019861867651343346, -0.0036216576118022203, -0.017549578100442886, 0.019291453063488007, 0.015069074928760529, 0.01182627398520708, 0.012963973917067051, 0.02834593504667282, -0.002751080086454749, 0.023387059569358826, 0.005368141457438469, -0.014387387782335281, -0.0009600744815543294, -0.020322337746620178, 0.000006718285476381425, 0.08300803601741791, 0.030730171129107475, -0.02236936055123806, -0.023868322372436523, -0.010949287563562393, 0.029502978548407555, 0.019431594759225845, -0.01869269460439682, -0.011406556703150272, 0.00045019714161753654, 0.039317537099123, -0.000002441979859213461, 0.012913020327687263, 0.007141909562051296, 0.0028246536385267973, 0.003675977699458599, -0.0007818898884579539, -0.07759886234998703, -0.002502627205103636, -0.013373184949159622, -0.03436916694045067, -0.028928132727742195, -0.07194492220878601, -0.07227151095867157, 0.034289948642253876, 0.027106838300824165, 0.011583131738007069, 0.005289026536047459, -0.027807829901576042, -0.0943269431591034, 0.00817019771784544, -0.01219465397298336, -0.012021567672491074, -0.01413718331605196, -0.0203266479074955, 0.047012776136398315, -0.06214738264679909, -0.05008389428257942, 0.011350155808031559, 0.02358871139585972, 0.044830866158008575, -0.050783950835466385, 0.019526086747646332, -0.05620287358760834, -0.0036394617054611444, -0.037115760147571564, 0.0074218823574483395, -0.03164295107126236, 0.04905084893107414, -0.016362536698579788, 0.01689506322145462, 0.0042910706251859665, 0.039863958954811096, 0.06502100080251694, 0.02235323376953602, -0.01382604893296957, -0.0029367851093411446, -0.06748368591070175, 0.004526157863438129, -0.03166860714554787, -0.03425009176135063, 0.027801264077425003, -0.052275411784648895, -0.03906828537583351, 0.04113129526376724, 0.002181911375373602, -0.033171460032463074, -0.06050786003470421, 0.006368877831846476, -0.01633310317993164, -0.008591633290052414, 0.006539236754179001, -0.01315999124199152, 0.03243021294474602, 0.01891436241567135, 0.020988892763853073, -0.06577318161725998, 0.042074818164110184, -0.030291114002466202, 0.019178740680217743, -0.005002689082175493, -0.032960180193185806, 0.04459957033395767, -0.017307301983237267, -0.013989344239234924, -0.03331891447305679, 0.0357937254011631, 0.052550483494997025, 0.004670953843742609, 0.017356012016534805, 0.06622493267059326, 0.03584197163581848, -0.014354722574353218, -0.005810230504721403, 0.0560598224401474, -0.028943728655576706, 0.004136551171541214, 0.025471962988376617, 0.031148593872785568, 0.015503003261983395, -0.00248257745988667, 0.014896468259394169, 0.032855596393346786, -0.00933683943003416, 0.01894562505185604, -0.015011217445135117, 0.03434786945581436, -0.06546764075756073, 0.003046401310712099, -0.05158374458551407, 0.00883331336081028, 0.009518124163150787, 0.026451481506228447, -0.019994191825389862, 0.03307612985372543, -0.07148092240095139, 0.022999372333288193, 0.009863642044365406, -0.03490537405014038, -0.03315531834959984, 0.03157215937972069, 0.06874983757734299, -0.011363469995558262, -0.029464619234204292, -0.01936127059161663, -0.007597418501973152, 0.013470607809722424, -0.02097943238914013, -0.03876452520489693, -0.020295802503824234, -0.03532037138938904, 0.006699742749333382, 0.02370297908782959, 0.025530921295285225, -0.04884687811136246, 0.03103896789252758, 0.025826338678598404, -0.025538330897688866, -0.022978361696004868, -0.006467717699706554, 0.04013795033097267, -0.00211419933475554, -0.013133094646036625, 0.003924616612493992, -0.01258816011250019, 0.04390299692749977, 0.027795616537332535, 0.029570043087005615, -0.030075833201408386, -0.0314551442861557, -0.03246374800801277, -0.028518177568912506, -0.0010759555734694004, 0.046699926257133484, 0.0042887222953140736, -0.0005469063180498779, 0.0044586858712136745, 0.04002825915813446, -0.03899636119604111, -0.007620539050549269, 0.07576356083154678, -0.06063471734523773, -0.003641268704086542, 0.041823066771030426, -0.03290601074695587, 0.0007924797828309238, -0.05556521564722061, -0.0035976036451756954, -0.024213554337620735, 0.008263439871370792, -0.0006619857740588486, -0.007339976727962494, 0.011551079340279102, -0.004647023044526577, -0.00694602495059371, -0.056220702826976776, 0.03672981634736061, 0.0033651962876319885, 0.026569008827209473, -0.016918882727622986, 0.008257606998085976, 0.048967693001031876, -0.0007837244193069637, -0.02313816361129284, -0.010070346295833588, -0.03501858934760094, 0.05297189950942993, -0.04257209599018097, 0.01840512827038765, 0.0637446865439415, -0.011023914441466331, 0.002874781610444188, -0.04282801225781441, 0.03794793784618378, -0.03518502041697502, -0.028630582615733147, 0.005248962435871363, 0.012220562435686588, -0.009638703428208828, 0.026329027488827705, 0.002637274097651243, 0.02112491801381111, 0.025676129385828972, 0.008731893263757229, 0.004107493907213211, 0.021408144384622574, -0.025502050295472145, 0.01991359330713749, -0.08203323930501938, 0.0030616021249443293, 0.07836917042732239, -0.01035388931632042, -0.014784819446504116, -0.04319222271442413, -0.007076175883412361, -0.007188586518168449, -0.01314952690154314, 0.021829649806022644, -0.042429156601428986, 0.03874240815639496, 0.0372476652264595, 0.019530247896909714, 0.006997727323323488, -0.026152336969971657, 0.016720470041036606, -0.08120329678058624, -0.002344755455851555, -0.0518704317510128, -0.03461237996816635, 0.03081747516989708, -0.03746439889073372, 0.015888625755906105, 0.018929431214928627, -0.03500198572874069, 0.02573152631521225, -0.04379100352525711, -0.053670734167099, 0.03025447018444538, 0.001534368027932942, 0.0007868248503655195, 0.0355495922267437, -0.044730667024850845, -0.00665273005142808, -0.008033628575503826, -0.047869786620140076, 0.02574155479669571, 0.01427652407437563, 0.03738372400403023, -0.0031444975174963474, 0.019698092713952065, -0.015046076849102974, 0.024194715544581413, 0.034912168979644775, 0.07876121252775192, 0.011508254334330559, 0.028361806645989418, -0.007945324294269085, 0.05679609626531601, 0.020969772711396217, 0.005476715043187141, -0.006997016724199057, 0.009318722411990166, 0.005144895054399967, -0.05962809547781944, 0.03640762344002724, 0.017461786046624184, -0.022682413458824158, -0.048061542212963104, 0.052462123334407806, 0.009282786399126053, -0.044394005089998245, -0.025502093136310577, 0.04097394272685051, -0.04987027868628502, 0.007808056194335222, -0.016291124746203423, -0.0007174460333772004, 0.0183291956782341, 0.07187972962856293, 0.003782958257943392, 0.005821507889777422, 0.0458240881562233, -0.006664342246949673, -0.024863839149475098, -0.01622263342142105, 0.08144226670265198, 0.07934240996837616, 0.0509524829685688, -0.013282014057040215, 0.06089312955737114, -0.024705613031983376, -0.05726778879761696, 0.03818805515766144, 0.0255897156894207, -0.007545714266598225, -0.02935219742357731, 0.02095981314778328, 0.10231804847717285, 0.013177360408008099, 0.07240188866853714, -0.03219746798276901, 0.008996935561299324, -0.004258269444108009, -0.017745520919561386, 0.03167639672756195, 0.022660449147224426, 0.03258582204580307, 0.024454040452837944, -0.04463578760623932, -0.0185161754488945, -0.012154906988143921, 0.008558621630072594, 0.003744807094335556, -0.0065260534174740314, -0.01121497992426157, 0.01280665397644043, 0.005231059156358242, 0.02052466943860054, 0.08670058101415634, -0.040776222944259644, -0.023043787106871605, 0.02476576715707779, 0.011105960234999657, 0.00783666130155325, 0.016339894384145737, 0.019254449754953384, -0.007787289563566446, 0.04955599829554558, -0.03167077526450157, 0.04925067722797394, 0.058458369225263596, -0.016711926087737083, -0.006499522365629673, -0.00574611546471715, -0.047176141291856766, 0.025603611022233963, 0.03581999987363815, -0.01874205656349659, -0.035243645310401917, -0.046260375529527664, -0.028559356927871704, -0.0367995947599411, -0.03932494670152664, 0.010755319148302078, -0.0131017891690135, -0.023389888927340508, -0.004739466588944197, -0.04318927973508835, -0.02681453339755535, 0.03101065568625927, -0.05115123838186264, -0.015615744516253471, 0.027267543599009514, -0.00907195545732975, 0.012265892699360847, 0.01989072374999523, 0.03017606772482395, -0.016652777791023254, -0.011064520105719566, 0.0402599573135376, -0.004431604407727718, 0.028671687468886375, -0.0047190506011247635, -0.01708476059138775, -0.10015598684549332, 0.02084703929722309, 0.04317571595311165, -0.026274848729372025, -0.07800370454788208, 0.010056854225695133, -0.0454820841550827, -0.004815861117094755, 0.05067127197980881, 0.0001685601018834859, 0.010325576178729534, -0.03341652452945709, -0.021178938448429108, -0.03458124026656151, 0.012588594108819962, 0.056574441492557526, -0.012634442187845707, 0.039499085396528244, 0.0167090967297554, -0.01707087643444538, -0.010770753026008606, 0.020212167873978615, 0.010927348397672176, 0.016848502680659294, -0.04037132114171982, -0.006575420033186674, -0.002146454993635416, -0.08859913796186447, -0.022921016439795494, 0.0575491227209568, -0.01228247582912445, -0.04163217544555664, 0.02254931442439556, -0.019436202943325043, -0.014007320627570152, -0.020590579137206078, -0.01886678859591484, -0.008037657476961613, -0.04930485039949417, -0.01563069596886635, -0.08967231959104538, 0.014855494722723961, -0.03210485354065895, 0.03538908436894417, -0.045424945652484894, -0.025195691734552383, -0.012308182194828987, 0.015008848160505295, 0.04512607678771019, 0.02483360841870308, 0.02131681516766548, 0.025499070063233376 ]
3,529
Improved Convergence Rate for Diffusion Probabilistic Models
https://openreview.net/forum?id=SOd07Qxkw4
[ "Gen Li", "Yuchen Jiao" ]
Spotlight
Score-based diffusion models have achieved remarkable empirical performance in the field of machine learning and artificial intelligence for their ability to generate high-quality new data instances from complex distributions. Improving our understanding of diffusion models, including mainly convergence analysis for such models, has attracted a lot of interests. Despite a lot of theoretical attempts, there still exists significant gap between theory and practice. Towards to close this gap, we establish an iteration complexity at the order of $d^{1/3}\varepsilon^{-2/3}$, which is better than $d^{5/12}\varepsilon^{-1}$, the best known complexity achieved before our work. This convergence analysis is based on a randomized midpoint method, which is first proposed for log-concave sampling (Shen & Lee, 2019), and then extended to diffusion models by Gupta et al. (2024). Our theory accommodates $\varepsilon$-accurate score estimates, and does not require log-concavity on the target distribution. Moreover, the algorithm can also be parallelized to run in only $O(\log^2(d/\varepsilon))$ parallel rounds in a similar way to prior works.
score-based generative model, diffusion model, probability flow ODE, randomized learning rate
null
6,073
2410.13738
[ -0.016870366409420967, -0.026348209008574486, 0.0073574623093008995, 0.038003355264663696, 0.06981705874204636, 0.038460783660411835, 0.021793868392705917, -0.011749660596251488, -0.003553090849891305, -0.057804446667432785, 0.03374864161014557, -0.04333300143480301, -0.046777501702308655, 0.010242896154522896, 0.019619528204202652, 0.07991127669811249, 0.04765176400542259, -0.008381819352507591, -0.0026444848626852036, 0.01619541086256504, -0.01507443469017744, 0.003710585180670023, 0.0453629344701767, 0.020346127450466156, 0.02478746883571148, -0.0092548169195652, 0.03002469427883625, -0.007655242457985878, -0.0115353399887681, -0.021319996565580368, 0.02269948273897171, 0.015246843919157982, 0.005593268666416407, -0.008628949522972107, 0.008389124646782875, 0.016758734360337257, -0.035765230655670166, -0.0016874134307727218, 0.006381703540682793, 0.0048226951621472836, -0.029816970229148865, 0.01963319070637226, -0.021804921329021454, 0.05155574902892113, -0.05142134800553322, 0.0019397359574213624, -0.08270371705293655, 0.009684797376394272, 0.017645083367824554, -0.023591458797454834, -0.07649212330579758, 0.029687119647860527, 0.00980765838176012, -0.022327737882733345, -0.005957540590316057, 0.049665652215480804, 0.04293913021683693, -0.04037260264158249, -0.00025142193771898746, -0.03941875696182251, -0.03346281126141548, -0.006837243214249611, -0.019759979099035263, -0.008317398838698864, -0.028452755883336067, -0.03892245143651962, 0.0011342545039951801, 0.04221382364630699, -0.027918752282857895, -0.04196665436029434, -0.04679844155907631, -0.0033654160797595978, 0.0024821714032441378, -0.023752212524414062, -0.02022397145628929, -0.050203319638967514, 0.03372039645910263, 0.04146623983979225, 0.07699176669120789, -0.0032276285346597433, 0.014524754136800766, -0.00597804831340909, 0.013075322844088078, 0.03051040507853031, -0.008438261225819588, -0.0015582343330606818, -0.01201382651925087, -0.04168663173913956, -0.07017763704061508, 0.07309349626302719, -0.04082649201154709, -0.05858655273914337, 0.00265787192620337, 0.030207816511392593, 0.048408377915620804, -0.013114294968545437, 0.03353925421833992, 0.02209657058119774, 0.027579957619309425, -0.03203374519944191, -0.04955178126692772, -0.05203498899936676, -0.0012082905741408467, 0.0191696435213089, -0.07545533031225204, -0.012849726714193821, -0.028179729357361794, 0.008535109460353851, -0.008339807391166687, 0.014348969794809818, -0.0329289473593235, 0.025567585602402687, -0.0037912698462605476, 0.006541721522808075, -0.11402866244316101, 0.03244377672672272, -0.003619743976742029, -0.015043327584862709, 0.017729736864566803, -0.01552934106439352, 0.03045932948589325, 0.07828911393880844, -0.011727253906428814, 0.06681423634290695, -0.02262258343398571, 0.05387432500720024, 0.03543298691511154, 0.03796645998954773, -0.0382525771856308, -0.019792072474956512, 0.025259122252464294, 0.048670221120119095, 0.008634861558675766, 0.02241947129368782, -0.011025924235582352, -0.04786389321088791, -0.011063892394304276, 0.017135802656412125, 0.04607292264699936, -0.0016220689285546541, 0.010308610275387764, -0.017913371324539185, 0.04028688743710518, 0.0035507110878825188, 0.02399074099957943, -0.017681758850812912, 0.0011747692478820682, -0.03893329203128815, -0.04749273881316185, -0.03739033639431, 0.007944794371724129, 0.03138113394379616, 0.007853785529732704, -0.0456121489405632, -0.0018948550568893552, 0.025842005386948586, -0.008097508922219276, 0.009872276335954666, -0.0007741485605947673, -0.0011284042848274112, 0.03838551789522171, -0.017005980014801025, 0.005559777375310659, -0.02098212204873562, 0.009204420261085033, -0.05306800827383995, 0.05591512843966484, 0.041686516255140305, -0.015192368999123573, -0.010251387022435665, -0.02035299316048622, 0.006165400613099337, 0.05227178335189819, 0.008682402782142162, 0.012709765695035458, 0.006568161770701408, 0.04637189209461212, 0.037531595677137375, 0.057026490569114685, 0.021149590611457825, -0.084254689514637, 0.029495609924197197, 0.010762203484773636, 0.029116597026586533, -0.006554879248142242, -0.019589001312851906, 0.08343783766031265, -0.0070280395448207855, 0.007666204124689102, 0.028564728796482086, -0.07755138725042343, -0.013525583781301975, 0.04387320950627327, -0.011461488902568817, 0.06676187366247177, 0.01593717187643051, 0.004587642382830381, 0.010947724804282188, 0.05508887767791748, 0.021887293085455894, 0.03999647498130798, -0.05403450131416321, 0.04221559688448906, -0.021027108654379845, -0.04152132198214531, -0.0006725494167767465, 0.05598217993974686, -0.06960166990756989, -0.04241803288459778, 0.023290425539016724, -0.026615696027874947, 0.005278117023408413, 0.01119748130440712, -0.004995319992303848, 0.032680362462997437, 0.0012863115407526493, 0.023946944624185562, -0.013644310645759106, 0.017321370542049408, -0.044283539056777954, 0.020821962505578995, 0.0069379121996462345, -0.018661990761756897, 0.03872952610254288, 0.02333734557032585, 0.07294110208749771, 0.09743763506412506, -0.024763198569417, -0.003566813189536333, 0.01983780227601528, 0.006736988667398691, -0.011931671760976315, 0.03303787112236023, -0.017514076083898544, 0.0499008372426033, 0.002201913623139262, -0.04003763198852539, -0.03166614845395088, 0.0628708153963089, -0.050190962851047516, -0.014752944000065327, 0.04984967038035393, -0.0029488836880773306, 0.09205790609121323, 0.007819321006536484, 0.00951852835714817, 0.018664073199033737, -0.020854508504271507, -0.01572427526116371, -0.009341930039227009, -0.051277901977300644, 0.0013771458761766553, 0.01497083343565464, -0.03128434345126152, 0.03467684984207153, -0.050514329224824905, 0.02056063339114189, 0.005411667283624411, 0.06642729789018631, 0.02131696417927742, 0.046433474868535995, 0.01738686114549637, -0.004512560088187456, -0.04232638329267502, -0.013403959572315216, -0.12438923865556717, -0.0609854981303215, -0.006118468940258026, 0.04877986013889313, 0.005500848405063152, 0.05930246785283089, -0.030920391902327538, 0.01004323735833168, -0.02903810702264309, -0.0186631977558136, -0.00442908052355051, 0.020561542361974716, 0.013994111679494381, -0.05702987313270569, 0.00958304200321436, 0.023465435951948166, 0.07246258854866028, -0.022067012265324593, -0.02931588888168335, -0.017613722011446953, -0.0498669408261776, -0.017573157325387, -0.012832149863243103, 0.004184155259281397, 0.023160090669989586, -0.009253595024347305, 0.037039708346128464, -0.0014816629700362682, -0.006844017654657364, 0.02351810224354267, 0.021057121455669403, 0.029029181227087975, -0.004072368610650301, 0.001209542970173061, 0.007611017674207687, 0.007831619121134281, -0.013739394024014473, 0.008696123957633972, 0.020466066896915436, -0.01842423714697361, -0.026147933676838875, 0.031143775209784508, 0.012086406350135803, -0.26313841342926025, 0.025475066155195236, 0.010012481361627579, -0.003105190582573414, 0.00892464630305767, -0.020168516784906387, 0.0441158153116703, -0.03313126415014267, -0.014095532707870007, 0.04114781692624092, -0.001982747344300151, 0.05495704337954521, -0.02275637723505497, 0.07578428089618683, 0.021125422790646553, 0.0305929034948349, -0.0009273496107198298, -0.017235569655895233, -0.015721548348665237, 0.026013150811195374, 0.010862946510314941, -0.07842789590358734, -0.013804344460368156, -0.0027659910265356302, 0.013205044902861118, 0.037118371576070786, -0.06865064799785614, 0.0006917066057212651, -0.04743421450257301, 0.01262383721768856, -0.01599118299782276, -0.055926211178302765, 0.003659527050331235, 0.04470306634902954, 0.019993886351585388, 0.0016438520979136229, 0.01310424879193306, 0.0334169864654541, -0.012216366827487946, 0.04258741810917854, -0.01404343917965889, 0.00981090310961008, -0.02024242654442787, 0.02210395224392414, 0.04574143886566162, 0.012054311111569405, -0.01860010251402855, 0.011407489888370037, -0.01054145023226738, 0.04643268883228302, -0.0025279815308749676, -0.02442091517150402, -0.04193689301609993, -0.007264887448400259, -0.021473005414009094, -0.03950393199920654, -0.011542357504367828, -0.03793381527066231, -0.014084366150200367, 0.03679768741130829, -0.011632608249783516, -0.041063521057367325, -0.0024428553879261017, -0.03055441565811634, -0.04712453484535217, -0.023268504068255424, -0.08099070936441422, -0.007760373409837484, 0.045579694211483, -0.0036809155717492104, -0.01213328167796135, -0.005545631051063538, 0.0024610755499452353, -0.08572570234537125, 0.0033381818793714046, -0.009338841773569584, 0.015405258163809776, 0.017110440880060196, -0.021969905123114586, 0.06100575625896454, -0.0280662439763546, -0.028331652283668518, -0.01164525281637907, 0.0005402993992902339, 0.014216973446309566, -0.00037961016641929746, 0.007418010383844376, -0.02521001733839512, -0.03160910680890083, -0.06523474305868149, 0.03708629310131073, 0.01569414883852005, 0.0451635979115963, -0.010616783052682877, 0.04263385757803917, 0.04100026935338974, 0.011275515891611576, 0.0762048065662384, 0.01176545675843954, 0.00014886738790664822, 0.040917593985795975, -0.08515790104866028, -0.03972947224974632, -0.05566741153597832, -0.013739383779466152, 0.02269386686384678, -0.061211489140987396, -0.015221554785966873, 0.03087405115365982, -0.024029552936553955, -0.004337354097515345, -0.023082587867975235, -0.008444706909358501, -0.011087716557085514, 0.01027968991547823, -0.044515181332826614, -0.024684660136699677, 0.06375578045845032, 0.020546147599816322, 0.006538051646202803, -0.022161787375807762, 0.04064550623297691, -0.034673839807510376, -0.016040094196796417, 0.006955585442483425, 0.0323333777487278, -0.03067040629684925, -0.033088743686676025, 0.018888503313064575, -0.024579590186476707, 0.04465261101722717, 0.043578702956438065, 0.024819957092404366, 0.015054038725793362, 0.04553687572479248, -0.008115243166685104, -0.012096242979168892, -0.016095692291855812, 0.022933881729841232, -0.04704802855849266, 0.0306876040995121, 0.005349845625460148, 0.03108404576778412, 0.003931188955903053, 0.024190081283450127, 0.001993125304579735, 0.01850517839193344, 0.004698121454566717, 0.016800876706838608, -0.011506815440952778, 0.02804589457809925, -0.043935809284448624, 0.007313418202102184, -0.029776863753795624, -0.015123373828828335, -0.008407115936279297, 0.009457223117351532, -0.0167892687022686, 0.003077119356021285, -0.07831460982561111, 0.0605132170021534, 0.015989260748028755, -0.04476907104253769, -0.012933908961713314, 0.02685043402016163, 0.03517313301563263, -0.03552911430597305, 0.044171176850795746, -0.004234508145600557, 0.0002393777685938403, 0.05068301409482956, -0.010176843032240868, -0.025627152994275093, -0.023666607216000557, -0.027004335075616837, -0.002369347959756851, 0.03381556272506714, 0.00599939888343215, -0.046324074268341064, 0.03482590615749359, -0.01744493469595909, -0.07477296143770218, -0.04684247076511383, 0.033464010804891586, 0.07472442835569382, 0.024958085268735886, 0.019266188144683838, -0.010491996072232723, -0.06160741299390793, 0.035366300493478775, -0.05361403897404671, -0.011116785928606987, -0.004525734577327967, -0.04686995968222618, -0.0077240681275725365, -0.05091957747936249, 0.007979224435985088, 0.029124392196536064, -0.04015270620584488, 0.015296143479645252, -0.021231114864349365, -0.01316231582313776, -0.03731042146682739, -0.004787327256053686, 0.047648776322603226, -0.06139044463634491, 0.008501310832798481, 0.013974843546748161, -0.007475293707102537, 0.01353356521576643, 0.006313093937933445, -0.04432440921664238, -0.07012637704610825, -0.0022700633853673935, -0.0041267601773142815, -0.029476454481482506, -0.03685480356216431, -0.0234784334897995, 0.019326137378811836, 0.022325482219457626, 0.00841200165450573, 0.0012094235280528665, 0.0009602244244888425, -0.030254434794187546, -0.015430943109095097, 0.05633179098367691, -0.02808244340121746, -0.029835250228643417, -0.03887639567255974, -0.013841203413903713, 0.021740471944212914, -0.08452404290437698, -0.033117860555648804, 0.04813530296087265, 0.020002203062176704, 0.009992646984755993, -0.048610620200634, 0.036805134266614914, -0.007554588373750448, 0.01172574795782566, -0.024829111993312836, 0.017104972153902054, -0.019339656457304955, -0.0007611580076627433, -0.019451545551419258, 0.03206951916217804, 0.015966007485985756, 0.0034125312231481075, 0.005218962207436562, 0.0653453916311264, 0.023946499451994896, 0.022384827956557274, -0.061865612864494324, 0.008592340163886547, 0.06785382330417633, -0.025488141924142838, -0.02785477228462696, -0.07953458279371262, -0.04961834102869034, 0.04490156099200249, -0.027665408328175545, 0.01526087149977684, -0.01605866849422455, 0.022251198068261147, 0.01823556423187256, 0.033707041293382645, 0.03275290131568909, 0.018957877531647682, 0.0011886176653206348, -0.05456436425447464, -0.001311915460973978, -0.06071150302886963, 0.010767735540866852, 0.05282371863722801, -0.052876148372888565, 0.03475657477974892, 0.03117072395980358, -0.0030294170137494802, 0.053028881549835205, -0.04815986752510071, -0.05710804834961891, 0.004472402390092611, -0.020829981192946434, -0.02210218831896782, 0.023917950689792633, -0.060006026178598404, -0.028041884303092957, -0.02548225224018097, -0.05273546651005745, 0.009278617799282074, 0.041154444217681885, 0.035907477140426636, -0.007889490574598312, 0.01615981012582779, -0.02621881105005741, 0.023380687460303307, 0.03212963417172432, 0.05129347741603851, -0.015813589096069336, 0.028809674084186554, -0.019289709627628326, 0.06339173763990402, 0.0505019873380661, 0.03450826182961464, -0.0052047837525606155, 0.015676965937018394, -0.015798617154359818, -0.041322484612464905, 0.04130494222044945, -0.019565725699067116, 0.005640439223498106, -0.060208968818187714, 0.049353402107954025, 0.029826849699020386, -0.05400976166129112, -0.05837555229663849, 0.024336054921150208, -0.052431099116802216, 0.02682610973715782, -0.010635621845722198, -0.0050040739588439465, 0.03682096675038338, 0.07602695375680923, 0.016791552305221558, 0.05503980442881584, 0.056891877204179764, -0.013555502519011497, 0.005031570326536894, -0.011673935689032078, 0.0766107439994812, 0.07948188483715057, 0.048578180372714996, -0.01760493963956833, 0.053424060344696045, -0.024984344840049744, -0.061045967042446136, -0.03373393416404724, -0.0264071524143219, -0.0163887906819582, -0.03865530341863632, 0.02930750697851181, 0.08541596680879593, -0.009548933245241642, 0.05902855470776558, -0.050293441861867905, 0.020167022943496704, 0.021293066442012787, 0.004401463083922863, -0.027650516480207443, -0.0026077283546328545, 0.02014346234500408, -0.010603057220578194, -0.0408901572227478, 0.019193248823285103, 0.008476519025862217, -0.0023788725957274437, 0.030442269518971443, 0.024765871465206146, -0.012860934250056744, 0.03574276715517044, 0.030913149937987328, 0.015102646313607693, 0.0762014389038086, -0.07619284093379974, -0.013576574623584747, -0.0310637466609478, -0.006723339203745127, 0.01761416718363762, 0.03310029208660126, 0.04441458359360695, -0.009172960184514523, -0.005599549971520901, -0.008127590641379356, 0.018303487449884415, 0.05240991339087486, -0.0016976502956822515, 0.010592353530228138, -0.01599680446088314, 0.028872264549136162, 0.02520805224776268, -0.026216663420200348, -0.0645107701420784, -0.057682402431964874, -0.0037602377124130726, -0.04426576942205429, -0.06728051602840424, -0.02950676530599594, 0.05706211179494858, 0.007453639060258865, -0.0362740159034729, 0.025505058467388153, -0.020289309322834015, 0.0007157416548579931, 0.022279100492596626, -0.07557172328233719, -0.03209010884165764, 0.03523378446698189, -0.00818792637437582, -0.004334807395935059, 0.012453880161046982, 0.04790760576725006, -0.031270865350961685, -0.02449151501059532, 0.04180975630879402, 0.007618568371981382, 0.025588510558009148, -0.03575696051120758, 0.023760098963975906, -0.06396638602018356, -0.0016511757858097553, 0.03257289528846741, -0.01958262175321579, -0.08580446988344193, 0.02402799390256405, -0.03573031350970268, -0.0006480716401711106, 0.04617955908179283, 0.0015321647515520453, -0.012493516318500042, -0.07596305757761002, -0.02109493315219879, 0.004046586342155933, 0.009998234920203686, 0.035678185522556305, -0.0035582962445914745, 0.07917126268148422, 0.0394127257168293, -0.05107958987355232, -0.05858532711863518, 0.05862206220626831, -0.023282986134290695, 0.008161953650414944, -0.0222939383238554, -0.008801484480500221, -0.03362450376152992, -0.1151304692029953, 0.010358883999288082, 0.023196060210466385, -0.006187682971358299, -0.03426448255777359, 0.007365947589278221, -0.037527717649936676, -0.003879937343299389, 0.01219917368143797, -0.0372898243367672, -0.022965585812926292, -0.0201223473995924, -0.037204496562480927, -0.05943761020898819, 0.0002744739758782089, -0.006181526463478804, -0.0004940847284160554, 0.011364144273102283, -0.05892448499798775, -0.01555397268384695, -0.00859066005796194, 0.033014439046382904, 0.019659416750073433, 0.01028994657099247, -0.027992157265543938 ]
3,530
MagicPIG: LSH Sampling for Efficient LLM Generation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=ALzTQUgW8a
[ "Zhuoming Chen", "Ranajoy Sadhukhan", "Zihao Ye", "Yang Zhou", "Jianyu Zhang", "Niklas Nolte", "Yuandong Tian", "Matthijs Douze", "Leon Bottou", "Zhihao Jia", "Beidi Chen" ]
Spotlight
Large language models (LLMs) with long context windows have gained significant attention. However, the KV cache, stored to avoid re-computation, becomes a bottleneck. Various dynamic sparse or TopK-based attention approximation methods have been proposed to leverage the common insight that attention is sparse. In this paper, we first show that TopK attention itself suffers from quality degradation in certain downstream tasks because attention is not always as sparse as expected. Rather than selecting the keys and values with the highest attention scores, sampling with theoretical guarantees can provide a better estimation for attention output. To make the sampling-based approximation practical in LLM generation, we propose MagicPIG, a heterogeneous system based on Locality Sensitive Hashing (LSH). MagicPIG significantly reduces the workload of attention computation while preserving high accuracy for diverse tasks. MagicPIG stores the LSH hash tables and runs the attention computation on the CPU, which allows it to serve longer contexts and larger batch sizes with high approximation accuracy. MagicPIG can improve decoding throughput by up to $5\times$ across various GPU hardware and achieve 54ms decoding latency on a single RTX 4090 for Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct model with a context of 96k tokens.
locality sensitive hashing, randomized algorithms, llm inference, kv cache
We leverage Locality Sensitive Hashing (LSH) sampling to accelerate LLM decoding.
6,043
2410.16179
[ -0.022458363324403763, -0.013316775672137737, -0.012591308914124966, 0.0359233096241951, 0.03223022446036339, 0.020105861127376556, 0.035824552178382874, 0.04740360379219055, -0.025938740000128746, -0.00636299978941679, -0.016469277441501617, -0.006104661151766777, -0.06197567284107208, 0.010672623291611671, -0.01616809517145157, 0.04544973000884056, 0.04797854647040367, -0.030988365411758423, 0.027377501130104065, 0.027538558468222618, 0.032894790172576904, -0.0195921640843153, 0.01408468559384346, 0.01831045374274254, 0.017813384532928467, 0.02267317660152912, -0.004437007009983063, 0.013281548395752907, -0.04675290733575821, 0.008598394691944122, 0.015614365227520466, -0.01404942199587822, 0.00663600442931056, 0.0023116623051464558, 0.015485468320548534, -0.015303442254662514, -0.03449666127562523, 0.009839039295911789, 0.012850133702158928, 0.049854177981615067, -0.019322283565998077, 0.00431387173011899, -0.005165856331586838, 0.014085998758673668, -0.07785885035991669, -0.014687607996165752, -0.11966519802808762, 0.03653378412127495, 0.007334973197430372, -0.017285559326410294, -0.10450679808855057, 0.0448334775865078, 0.02462286315858364, -0.006328095681965351, 0.007817447185516357, 0.025913335382938385, 0.019455093890428543, -0.09367652237415314, 0.0030890258494764566, -0.02153095416724682, -0.03956663981080055, -0.013928793370723724, 0.0075024208053946495, 0.03835389018058777, -0.0140317277982831, -0.03725617378950119, 0.00991903804242611, 0.02654007449746132, -0.07009504735469818, -0.0697014257311821, 0.011047248728573322, 0.025124145671725273, -0.031337812542915344, 0.006644903682172298, 0.015475521795451641, -0.05352328345179558, -0.001966914627701044, 0.05969700589776039, 0.05665047839283943, 0.014564060606062412, -0.0031291416380554438, 0.018838470801711082, 0.024877581745386124, 0.05077870935201645, 0.012801717035472393, -0.005209724418818951, -0.01886264979839325, -0.026570631191134453, -0.08099103718996048, 0.048213403671979904, -0.009764455258846283, -0.05553658679127693, 0.021709660068154335, 0.030839011073112488, 0.0055446443147957325, -0.004415484145283699, 0.015389217995107174, -0.005207892972975969, -0.004539693705737591, 0.016444925218820572, -0.03418940305709839, -0.02625162899494171, 0.024006182327866554, 0.010415351949632168, -0.1003328263759613, -0.012926735915243626, -0.02658982202410698, -0.021059725433588028, -0.024303482845425606, -0.014856136403977871, -0.012297878973186016, -0.02346448414027691, 0.02944199927151203, -0.006497277412563562, -0.059143222868442535, 0.04223395511507988, 0.0017421887023374438, 0.00041104500996880233, -0.023005079478025436, 0.006350066978484392, 0.07246226817369461, 0.08413216471672058, -0.0071877953596413136, 0.0743386521935463, 0.006207142025232315, 0.010703089646995068, 0.029617326334118843, 0.03506723791360855, -0.005087023600935936, -0.04804030433297157, 0.01381334662437439, 0.04936859384179115, 0.003611808642745018, 0.0037128624971956015, 0.00414521899074316, 0.008734622970223427, -0.0005276790470816195, 0.012528163380920887, 0.06925227493047714, -0.024756107479333878, 0.001805494655855, -0.005689172074198723, 0.04187869280576706, -0.020514093339443207, 0.06229434907436371, 0.010713163763284683, -0.01899249479174614, -0.024700220674276352, -0.03628557175397873, 0.016872407868504524, -0.009525472298264503, 0.023511862382292747, -0.03012978471815586, -0.048663437366485596, 0.03433830663561821, 0.049845192581415176, 0.016768278554081917, -0.003004004480317235, -0.001109391450881958, 0.001686597941443324, -0.0024668413680046797, 0.00890914537012577, -0.06912025809288025, 0.01957848109304905, -0.018300067633390427, -0.039028555154800415, 0.035208821296691895, 0.04115908220410347, -0.05475499853491783, 0.017448265105485916, -0.021173276007175446, -0.008431839756667614, 0.04772220924496651, -0.013424179516732693, -0.04091636836528778, 0.012077923864126205, 0.05697353929281235, -0.015570337884128094, 0.050532374531030655, 0.04720987379550934, -0.07742686569690704, 0.003488308284431696, 0.014234444126486778, 0.009752381592988968, -0.017776941880583763, -0.01721165142953396, 0.10602696985006332, -0.04335837438702583, -0.0045503173023462296, -0.011621590703725815, -0.08042103052139282, -0.008052370510995388, 0.021657684817910194, 0.006916747894138098, 0.09584654122591019, -0.00020528101595118642, 0.031140005216002464, 0.02647707611322403, 0.05533947795629501, 0.044700928032398224, 0.05177605152130127, -0.017116811126470566, 0.04259790480136871, -0.020622674375772476, -0.0349888913333416, -0.02444305457174778, 0.019427411258220673, -0.04061361774802208, -0.051545582711696625, -0.009494084864854813, -0.008729776367545128, 0.010786655358970165, 0.020926116034388542, -0.005956761073321104, -0.009130277670919895, -0.018867963925004005, 0.011328035034239292, -0.002624964341521263, -0.011243979446589947, -0.04498625174164772, 0.049257539212703705, 0.010747957974672318, -0.019138919189572334, -0.00384590239264071, -0.030855320394039154, 0.10837341845035553, 0.06786470115184784, -0.05944204330444336, 0.002524453215301037, 0.00012842299474868923, -0.008298766799271107, -0.032014988362789154, -0.012301914393901825, -0.016658542677760124, -0.041554685682058334, -0.010460581630468369, -0.003581048222258687, -0.016237543895840645, 0.06346866488456726, -0.052053362131118774, -0.03131578862667084, 0.06844185292720795, -0.01407681219279766, 0.04652057960629463, -0.015324053354561329, 0.01281647477298975, 0.013642343692481518, -0.04034879058599472, -0.02414071373641491, -0.039458125829696655, -0.003978278953582048, 0.005282959435135126, 0.024475211277604103, -0.012269707396626472, -0.002034272998571396, -0.056874845176935196, -0.04580026492476463, 0.000946246727835387, 0.07139971107244492, 0.053383082151412964, -0.011083452962338924, 0.03060084581375122, 0.02925935946404934, -0.04282569885253906, -0.0016672974452376366, -0.10225684195756912, -0.029289472848176956, -0.03450887277722359, 0.024097755551338196, -0.031399015337228775, 0.038365449756383896, 0.0029255785048007965, 0.007007203530520201, -0.045656416565179825, -0.0006707602296955884, -0.02237756922841072, 0.02832457423210144, -0.03476831689476967, -0.010814808309078217, -0.024895574897527695, 0.000015920206351438537, 0.08193635940551758, -0.026584215462207794, 0.00611230218783021, -0.050843045115470886, -0.03971840813755989, -0.023292606696486473, -0.06275353580713272, -0.0021679052151739597, -0.012459325604140759, 0.013436459004878998, 0.009067573584616184, -0.04462523013353348, 0.011666316539049149, 0.019578127190470695, 0.0658414214849472, 0.060444191098213196, 0.0024250992573797703, -0.03603310137987137, 0.033029068261384964, 0.012920080684125423, 0.022398071363568306, -0.01968013495206833, 0.029691018164157867, -0.033901363611221313, -0.013034772127866745, 0.008606121875345707, -0.024817761033773422, -0.2738128900527954, -0.016032833606004715, -0.011021792888641357, -0.0247702207416296, 0.03186235949397087, -0.0010662251152098179, 0.020932894200086594, -0.014305593445897102, -0.0055298269726336, -0.0005571523797698319, -0.0032825374510139227, 0.024103736504912376, -0.010668979957699776, 0.035477425903081894, 0.07503309100866318, 0.02696741186082363, -0.005864795297384262, -0.025154143571853638, 0.03423381969332695, 0.04048888757824898, 0.02781982719898224, -0.07102983444929123, 0.003987904172390699, 0.050791796296834946, 0.006922017317265272, 0.031078075990080833, -0.08298231661319733, 0.006595905404537916, -0.03999805077910423, -0.01024434994906187, -0.027484958991408348, -0.030113911256194115, -0.007990696467459202, 0.050430089235305786, -0.0009131314582191408, -0.0011297377059236169, 0.07415076345205307, -0.0025606779381632805, 0.04432673752307892, -0.005630283150821924, 0.027044925838708878, -0.03521046042442322, -0.010668377391994, -0.0217579398304224, 0.07088570296764374, -0.008261832408607006, -0.08716712146997452, -0.030694913119077682, -0.03950388729572296, 0.020548846572637558, -0.03700663149356842, -0.039988819509744644, -0.03393951803445816, 0.02041693404316902, 0.02279324270784855, -0.002290131291374564, -0.014362619258463383, 0.011868207715451717, -0.017507463693618774, 0.012709486298263073, -0.025821860879659653, -0.04821694269776344, -0.030236873775720596, -0.01221733633428812, -0.027498522773385048, -0.04173547402024269, -0.06776387989521027, -0.0336911641061306, 0.032536838203668594, 0.032345980405807495, 0.0017814189195632935, 0.005687580909579992, -0.006024447735399008, -0.07929849624633789, 0.016112638637423515, 0.013060980476439, -0.03128639981150627, 0.015848251059651375, 0.016210801899433136, 0.039077289402484894, -0.0374438650906086, -0.05239911004900932, 0.003699281020089984, 0.00487900385633111, 0.009954303503036499, -0.04509253799915314, -0.01375619601458311, -0.03658803552389145, -0.029929757118225098, -0.026740003377199173, 0.04973682016134262, 0.011247714050114155, 0.016153335571289062, 0.0010960189392790198, 0.038750920444726944, 0.025297770276665688, 0.06086787208914757, 0.06021295115351677, 0.007154056802392006, 0.0053228591568768024, 0.036211587488651276, -0.05559074506163597, -0.026850180700421333, -0.0481596402823925, -0.01274123415350914, 0.03526019677519798, -0.048735328018665314, -0.012830845080316067, 0.057966094464063644, 0.0016210778849199414, -0.05586603283882141, -0.02759459987282753, 0.023338964208960533, -0.006271513178944588, -0.0006988091627135873, 0.0005304920487105846, 0.042261045426130295, 0.036622364073991776, 0.02272980660200119, -0.030429085716605186, -0.03253142908215523, 0.024305691942572594, -0.039937686175107956, 0.010186794213950634, 0.009842789731919765, -0.01833375170826912, -0.020887471735477448, 0.021446196362376213, -0.025766536593437195, -0.012270950712263584, 0.018357785418629646, 0.049331989139318466, 0.0032620930578559637, 0.0031141042709350586, 0.05452226102352142, 0.002964089158922434, 0.004343661479651928, -0.0029251468367874622, 0.04067401587963104, -0.0034633830655366182, 0.01722070388495922, -0.02026817947626114, 0.042892009019851685, 0.05522221699357033, 0.026030441746115685, 0.01243379432708025, 0.02150878868997097, -0.007026675157248974, -0.0068575660698115826, 0.020445948466658592, 0.04515813663601875, -0.04890623688697815, 0.0011150868376716971, -0.02077002264559269, 0.00924754235893488, -0.02076476439833641, 0.02103848196566105, 0.016963446512818336, 0.015036873519420624, -0.06439612805843353, 0.02682071551680565, 0.007592258974909782, -0.004164316225796938, -0.001196645898744464, 0.024654928594827652, 0.03416311740875244, 0.009121772833168507, 0.00890112854540348, 0.05267360806465149, 0.027114547789096832, 0.017731448635458946, -0.012778262607753277, -0.03674828261137009, -0.005878826603293419, -0.0014154536183923483, 0.012784707359969616, 0.013005894608795643, 0.020132949575781822, -0.027395905926823616, 0.050555430352687836, 0.014217051677405834, -0.008943114429712296, 0.013614087365567684, 0.022475235164165497, 0.10190035402774811, -0.007609284482896328, 0.010508079081773758, 0.004191100597381592, -0.03562898561358452, 0.015593251213431358, -0.01134948618710041, -0.012398253194987774, -0.00512302340939641, -0.016141235828399658, -0.048416655510663986, -0.050188176333904266, 0.019873254001140594, 0.014628213830292225, -0.01577221415936947, -0.06532492488622665, 0.00042248243698850274, 0.0014903817791491747, -0.034524403512477875, -0.029963016510009766, 0.04406154900789261, -0.07259499281644821, 0.003337336238473654, 0.00467680674046278, -0.015452034771442413, 0.03948391228914261, -0.010115713812410831, -0.010663197375833988, -0.03513611853122711, -0.011192064732313156, 0.007918145507574081, -0.03290475904941559, -0.012138706631958485, -0.021288683637976646, -0.015090815722942352, -0.026798009872436523, 0.010807480663061142, -0.008227406069636345, 0.027637075632810593, -0.028694292530417442, -0.0015387838939204812, 0.014752807095646858, -0.03940381854772568, -0.006002984009683132, 0.008065955713391304, -0.03648069500923157, 0.04703586921095848, -0.04168920964002609, 0.03377166762948036, 0.05066874623298645, -0.02130725048482418, 0.012509404681622982, -0.04052278771996498, 0.03599505126476288, 0.020805412903428078, 0.03404504805803299, 0.025185318663716316, -0.010848859325051308, -0.04179158806800842, 0.02759738638997078, 0.010728217661380768, 0.03948793187737465, 0.004705470986664295, 0.008941070176661015, -0.015485350042581558, 0.019982632249593735, -0.0051362840458750725, 0.019471991807222366, -0.009607861749827862, -0.010434010066092014, 0.043605122715234756, -0.043313197791576385, -0.05009209364652634, -0.0738418698310852, -0.059575002640485764, -0.004157789517194033, -0.003358997870236635, 0.03559209406375885, -0.037804897874593735, 0.0504334382712841, 0.03550850972533226, 0.05239785462617874, -0.0027391884941607714, -0.061500485986471176, 0.04277205839753151, -0.03536795452237129, 0.007909365929663181, -0.061163291335105896, -0.037472255527973175, 0.05415857210755348, -0.03792541101574898, -0.004679099656641483, 0.02367311343550682, -0.05069396272301674, 0.04301296919584274, -0.007776802405714989, -0.028104372322559357, 0.03045552223920822, -0.022395411506295204, 0.013561158441007137, 0.03785546496510506, -0.04258105531334877, -0.0013674832880496979, -0.01670331135392189, -0.01256104651838541, -0.00981574784964323, 0.013732592575252056, 0.04834377393126488, -0.01573817804455757, 0.01278671808540821, -0.05511616915464401, -0.02459520474076271, 0.00440010242164135, 0.04150180146098137, -0.010313192382454872, 0.021578215062618256, -0.02389610931277275, 0.06690223515033722, 0.039935510605573654, 0.0064483569003641605, 0.012722582556307316, -0.0064630345441401005, -0.030344733968377113, -0.048821184784173965, 0.026603899896144867, -0.03365928679704666, -0.012000800110399723, -0.06332877278327942, 0.07502949982881546, 0.04218572378158569, -0.03436610847711563, -0.0465642549097538, 0.03512829542160034, -0.026451045647263527, 0.007161748595535755, -0.03095436654984951, 0.0004944232641719282, -0.010685045272111893, 0.0751848816871643, 0.014539957977831364, 0.043713100254535675, 0.09708892554044724, -0.01064793486148119, 0.006190330255776644, 0.00906476378440857, 0.06334687024354935, 0.06279820948839188, 0.050649821758270264, 0.007613535039126873, 0.07335134595632553, -0.04144664481282234, -0.040977198630571365, 0.007878565229475498, 0.025807851925492287, -0.01105335634201765, -0.02096090093255043, 0.03306517004966736, 0.05872111767530441, -0.007848802953958511, 0.08310499042272568, -0.059839989989995956, -0.020954273641109467, 0.050579436123371124, 0.017733560875058174, 0.023116745054721832, 0.07571472972631454, 0.025755098089575768, 0.014566979371011257, -0.04997001588344574, -0.02286534756422043, 0.011049062013626099, -0.01938639022409916, -0.01335443276911974, -0.012710513547062874, -0.000806078314781189, 0.022680537775158882, 0.006791382096707821, 0.04090168699622154, 0.08541732281446457, -0.009145962074398994, -0.04590250551700592, 0.017448147758841515, 0.004975452553480864, 0.02033430151641369, 0.05201113969087601, -0.015488517470657825, 0.0008590829093009233, 0.010237982496619225, -0.043953318148851395, 0.011890512891113758, 0.012916265986859798, -0.006486193742603064, 0.06533694267272949, -0.013326691463589668, -0.04168345779180527, 0.0018085477640852332, 0.015706004574894905, -0.07557643204927444, -0.04479951038956642, -0.06407295912504196, -0.032574255019426346, -0.0434318482875824, -0.0056694066151976585, 0.010325558483600616, 0.0026956216897815466, -0.043737996369600296, -0.01516650803387165, -0.04559184983372688, 0.001687152311205864, 0.010351124219596386, -0.04605220630764961, -0.039678361266851425, 0.020073171705007553, -0.01340933796018362, -0.025865254923701286, 0.056106045842170715, 0.024979690089821815, -0.054212555289268494, -0.019760044291615486, 0.027398182079195976, 0.0014270821120589972, 0.014840569347143173, 0.004904802422970533, -0.02757718227803707, -0.11053455621004105, 0.01608329452574253, 0.009765432216227055, 0.004695051349699497, -0.0664072185754776, 0.00729962857440114, -0.03954029083251953, 0.029955172911286354, 0.06495987623929977, 0.004680207930505276, 0.036596689373254776, -0.038645174354314804, -0.026018919423222542, 0.0009446502663195133, 0.03217059001326561, 0.059601012617349625, 0.0029846590477973223, 0.07278789579868317, 0.04680899530649185, -0.007898208685219288, -0.028027113527059555, 0.011558781377971172, -0.010013192892074585, 0.004222582560032606, -0.018038589507341385, -0.002515743486583233, -0.04057753086090088, -0.0679222047328949, -0.015844348818063736, 0.022518744692206383, 0.010417760349810123, -0.027402890846133232, 0.015995236113667488, -0.04549726843833923, -0.0328955203294754, 0.0020161049906164408, -0.02636682242155075, -0.023224366828799248, -0.003770573530346155, -0.02647513337433338, -0.07321519404649734, 0.0012289707083255053, -0.03493249788880348, -0.0028638034127652645, -0.017263498157262802, -0.03037082403898239, 0.006275926250964403, 0.040304604917764664, 0.07055394351482391, 0.016426870599389076, -0.00033672404242679477, -0.023145336657762527 ]
3,531
Streamlining Redundant Layers to Compress Large Language Models
https://openreview.net/forum?id=IC5RJvRoMp
[ "Xiaodong Chen", "Yuxuan Hu", "Jing Zhang", "Yanling Wang", "Cuiping Li", "Hong Chen" ]
Spotlight
This paper introduces LLM-Streamline, a pioneer work on layer pruning for large language models (LLMs). It is based on the observation that different layers have varying impacts on hidden states, enabling the identification of less important layers to be pruned. LLM-Streamline comprises two parts: layer pruning, which removes consecutive layers with the lowest importance based on target sparsity, and layer replacement, a novel module that trains a lightweight network to replace the pruned layers to mitigate performance loss. Additionally, a new metric called stability is proposed to address the limitations of the widely used accuracy metric in evaluating model compression. Experiments show that LLM-Streamline outperforms both previous and concurrent state-of-the-art pruning methods in terms of both performance and training efficiency. Our code is available at \href{https://github.com/RUCKBReasoning/LLM-Streamline}{this repository}.
large language models, model compression, structured pruning
null
6,009
2403.19135
[ -0.026917504146695137, -0.04945980757474899, -0.014075838960707188, 0.023541467264294624, 0.0498308390378952, 0.04404773935675621, 0.0015576793812215328, -0.007908432744443417, -0.028259731829166412, -0.008551563136279583, -0.04118712618947029, 0.012903416529297829, -0.04370122030377388, -0.019895272329449654, 0.004927225410938263, 0.058228444308042526, 0.03144661337137222, -0.01588655635714531, 0.039675574749708176, 0.018462559208273888, -0.00180594262201339, -0.01874718628823757, 0.01149542536586523, 0.011714405380189419, 0.04516616091132164, -0.0026208930648863316, 0.0020733261480927467, 0.0182992834597826, -0.0422113873064518, 0.023316485807299614, 0.03799792379140854, -0.007495901547372341, 0.027480820193886757, -0.008084431290626526, 0.032811105251312256, -0.019230104982852936, -0.058752529323101044, 0.020015498623251915, -0.006197816226631403, 0.007222918793559074, -0.03369290009140968, 0.03214215487241745, -0.0012323888950049877, 0.02740289457142353, -0.037790585309267044, 0.01529639307409525, -0.10920041054487228, -0.010707218199968338, 0.0003215345786884427, -0.048858292400836945, -0.12357485294342041, 0.006807954050600529, -0.027203895151615143, -0.015279984101653099, 0.002134908689185977, 0.0064028725028038025, 0.04063921049237251, -0.11139937490224838, -0.0018505159532651305, -0.007968366146087646, -0.06411948800086975, -0.016386721283197403, 0.021663326770067215, 0.027431976050138474, -0.01818688213825226, -0.04735086113214493, -0.000505193427670747, 0.039956413209438324, -0.08902063220739365, -0.05976104736328125, 0.0035963139962404966, 0.048119544982910156, -0.025226958096027374, 0.022332923486828804, 0.015178476460278034, -0.03848476707935333, 0.004093910101801157, 0.03542488440871239, 0.05326710641384125, 0.019506005570292473, 0.01033241581171751, 0.0009056531707756221, 0.017988000065088272, 0.054210297763347626, 0.03925672918558121, 0.032020241022109985, -0.04107797518372536, -0.02200050838291645, -0.07404579222202301, 0.014624579809606075, -0.01151430793106556, -0.050970565527677536, 0.023097649216651917, 0.023348262533545494, 0.008548520505428314, 0.01606234535574913, 0.01167925726622343, 0.03627781197428703, 0.0097900265827775, 0.005532230716198683, -0.0075211599469184875, -0.029054874554276466, 0.03945061191916466, 0.03057881072163582, -0.11369624733924866, -0.024156320840120316, -0.019773203879594803, 0.018207289278507233, 0.011687024496495724, -0.026782667264342308, 0.0024913970846682787, -0.0093027763068676, -0.01005216222256422, 0.0017255517886951566, -0.0933307558298111, 0.014574206434190273, 0.0012363780988380313, -0.0172579362988472, 0.0063550639897584915, 0.0062574902549386024, 0.06536529958248138, 0.03750903904438019, 0.025800250470638275, 0.08477010577917099, 0.0070603713393211365, 0.034768957644701004, 0.006205027922987938, 0.05408121272921562, -0.033474743366241455, -0.034750256687402725, 0.002765927230939269, 0.06757822632789612, 0.02340789884328842, 0.00011916700896108523, 0.005711415316909552, -0.01086581964045763, 0.01764206402003765, 0.03046504780650139, 0.05421001464128494, -0.01891370676457882, -0.018511256203055382, 0.004366382025182247, 0.047633372247219086, -0.03350445255637169, 0.04194830358028412, 0.004841121379286051, -0.057800792157649994, -0.033072579652071, -0.0409841425716877, -0.016354255378246307, 0.027665358036756516, 0.04180257022380829, 0.0013620539102703333, -0.06309040635824203, -0.0021904734894633293, 0.04841224476695061, -0.012486577033996582, -0.0298419501632452, -0.008800500072538853, 0.027289044111967087, 0.008592074736952782, 0.002877339255064726, -0.0818813294172287, 0.01731681264936924, 0.0025706784799695015, -0.07394953817129135, 0.04132944345474243, -0.004191773012280464, -0.01800445467233658, 0.013167562894523144, -0.03452557325363159, -0.02451217733323574, 0.07647906243801117, -0.011237196624279022, -0.04235756769776344, -0.013318769633769989, 0.07696165889501572, 0.031630419194698334, 0.06346620619297028, 0.029507141560316086, -0.06817227602005005, 0.015138872899115086, 0.003906304948031902, -0.012785244733095169, 0.0033526718616485596, -0.0321536622941494, 0.10929735749959946, -0.05088275298476219, 0.007039933931082487, 0.008966709487140179, -0.08725667744874954, 0.0031203872058540583, 0.012363772839307785, -0.008049516007304192, 0.06816092878580093, -0.008862561546266079, 0.0005546285538002849, 0.049441300332546234, 0.0023632035590708256, 0.051019661128520966, 0.06398751586675644, -0.010255592875182629, 0.04224296286702156, -0.016373654827475548, -0.03975405916571617, 0.0171097032725811, 0.0017506713047623634, -0.06524192541837692, -0.036201804876327515, 0.015045013278722763, -0.00022800570877734572, -0.004327437840402126, 0.03225332498550415, -0.009590952657163143, 0.0126009751111269, -0.030973946675658226, -0.018758753314614296, -0.0026156308595091105, 0.059858281165361404, -0.038636863231658936, 0.0636797696352005, 0.03130847215652466, -0.019734453409910202, 0.0092288414016366, -0.033097051084041595, 0.07530134916305542, 0.05752180889248848, -0.009230573661625385, -0.00942940078675747, 0.010510890744626522, -0.00088166119530797, -0.010556329041719437, -0.007834604941308498, -0.04555298015475273, 0.009732591919600964, -0.02720155194401741, 0.004400794394314289, -0.054555680602788925, 0.04191175848245621, -0.033539172261953354, -0.012123695574700832, 0.05268063396215439, -0.000300930580124259, 0.06792200356721878, -0.009096316993236542, 0.01259450614452362, 0.013718264177441597, -0.006340246647596359, -0.007405438460409641, -0.01698223501443863, 0.0017729437677189708, 0.0060387481935322285, 0.0013520258944481611, -0.042090240865945816, -0.011636007577180862, -0.027470624074339867, -0.03679093345999718, 0.003974560182541609, 0.05041029304265976, 0.04758106544613838, 0.017341909930109978, 0.011157570406794548, 0.014189153909683228, -0.03885761648416519, 0.0014795712195336819, -0.07930465787649155, -0.022435525432229042, -0.04962357506155968, 0.055957991629838943, -0.012011912651360035, 0.04512781277298927, 0.014556700363755226, 0.004832410719245672, -0.030299706384539604, 0.0004950790898874402, 0.012267895974218845, 0.02465156465768814, 0.009260243736207485, -0.06099177524447441, -0.018705204129219055, -0.0009199391934089363, 0.04421347752213478, 0.0014735673321411014, -0.022193636745214462, -0.057568714022636414, -0.03783508017659187, 0.028672482818365097, -0.048515740782022476, -0.001542834215797484, -0.005315893329679966, 0.014937720261514187, 0.00027012370992451906, -0.03293786197900772, 0.005527133122086525, 0.05016413331031799, 0.05482649430632591, 0.04331143572926521, -0.017034536227583885, -0.002730396343395114, 0.037588492035865784, -0.03469116985797882, -0.00219027791172266, 0.00269974279217422, 0.02816401608288288, -0.03947434946894646, -0.0039007356390357018, 0.0055552017875015736, -0.002687691478058696, -0.2682357728481293, -0.004497527610510588, 0.01279469020664692, -0.04542503133416176, 0.05187338963150978, -0.0038633805233985186, 0.027475470677018166, -0.02312919683754444, -0.012361103668808937, 0.0024219851475208998, 0.0007016947492957115, 0.04217827320098877, 0.0028357321862131357, 0.029965078458189964, 0.06018592789769173, 0.032326437532901764, -0.026100941002368927, -0.005656285677105188, 0.019152142107486725, 0.04190593957901001, -0.0039732493460178375, -0.04877102002501488, -0.003926033619791269, 0.05227228254079819, 0.00910487025976181, 0.051524799317121506, -0.06850828975439072, 0.002195122418925166, -0.03000763989984989, -0.00847667083144188, 0.003921576775610447, -0.043519023805856705, 0.003642454044893384, 0.029981782659888268, -0.04027407988905907, 0.006267432123422623, 0.04344789311289787, 0.03409765288233757, 0.05898122116923332, 0.030981820076704025, 0.03251221030950546, -0.011919309385120869, -0.018319066613912582, -0.016720393672585487, 0.05629127845168114, 0.022428004071116447, -0.05842030420899391, -0.009252462536096573, 0.01010502502322197, 0.035822030156850815, 0.01718560792505741, -0.04516971856355667, -0.007604796439409256, 0.01853172853589058, 0.015301760286092758, -0.019813021644949913, -0.01612880825996399, -0.02945641428232193, -0.015042934566736221, 0.0070472536608576775, -0.00011864249972859398, -0.05463230609893799, -0.019648481160402298, -0.04807153716683388, -0.013846143148839474, -0.02613035775721073, -0.06359260529279709, -0.035384006798267365, 0.03663228079676628, 0.035033538937568665, -0.030415354296565056, 0.019114740192890167, 0.0057916357181966305, -0.07955600321292877, 0.007901348173618317, 0.0007203517598100007, -0.0411459319293499, -0.011455929838120937, -0.0040915352292358875, 0.036495935171842575, -0.06511261314153671, -0.056734826415777206, 0.010932664386928082, 0.011419187299907207, 0.020291082561016083, -0.02948778122663498, 0.018933389335870743, -0.03512119874358177, -0.027040373533964157, -0.043166954070329666, 0.033618319779634476, -0.011254621669650078, -0.021137574687600136, 0.03053153306245804, 0.042766839265823364, 0.0077143218368291855, 0.0025674470234662294, 0.07164330780506134, 0.020137876272201538, 0.018159545958042145, 0.020703911781311035, -0.05361749604344368, -0.010166419669985771, -0.045339059084653854, -0.020070573315024376, 0.04788340628147125, -0.0448787696659565, -0.03061015158891678, 0.030320975929498672, 0.0017873760079964995, -0.0418558195233345, -0.04444606974720955, 0.00944402627646923, -0.01694181002676487, -0.023210618644952774, 0.0038875143509358168, -0.010936462320387363, 0.027273787185549736, 0.008417043834924698, -0.022048622369766235, -0.02770085632801056, 0.03393959999084473, -0.005010252818465233, 0.002424712758511305, 0.005136219784617424, 0.0027337661013007164, 0.00324196252040565, -0.03223886713385582, -0.0006957290461286902, 0.008434150367975235, 0.019968651235103607, 0.03700539097189903, 0.013755463995039463, -0.02256501279771328, 0.04581514373421669, -0.0031737738754600286, 0.01830236241221428, -0.004430417437106371, 0.01722044311463833, -0.0001556143834022805, -0.007787002716213465, 0.013053176924586296, 0.04055675119161606, 0.02602049522101879, 0.02487107366323471, 0.03018839657306671, 0.01111766416579485, -0.016354959458112717, -0.0026108184829354286, 0.015344370156526566, 0.03627139329910278, -0.02657226100564003, 0.026339231058955193, -0.03230865299701691, 0.04076233133673668, -0.019710740074515343, 0.02628927119076252, -0.01089959591627121, 0.018971500918269157, -0.06283603608608246, 0.040210701525211334, 0.009407673962414265, -0.01622612215578556, 0.01832072250545025, 0.020813627168536186, 0.026026424020528793, 0.0009506213827989995, 0.006196528673171997, 0.03347700089216232, 0.0027442791033536196, 0.0031736940145492554, -0.01898893713951111, -0.018249455839395523, -0.0038554745260626078, 0.001186102512292564, 0.02239311672747135, 0.013008138164877892, 0.02723526582121849, -0.03865634649991989, 0.06083568558096886, 0.0019376487471163273, -0.025547286495566368, -0.005383084993809462, 0.018415244296193123, 0.08499553799629211, -0.0010064501548185945, 0.016993394121527672, 0.03793850541114807, -0.05016098916530609, 0.03367812931537628, 0.020928192883729935, 0.01187193114310503, -0.017310764640569687, -0.03028031252324581, -0.046244293451309204, -0.04565297067165375, 0.019664229825139046, 0.0567842572927475, 0.005851551424711943, 0.0025188992731273174, -0.03135809302330017, -0.03663629665970802, -0.04450909420847893, -0.03653866425156593, 0.022663401439785957, -0.07584322243928909, -0.007466825656592846, 0.01793522946536541, -0.01160324178636074, 0.004469284322112799, -0.019541766494512558, -0.024431295692920685, -0.0683639645576477, -0.028127679601311684, 0.02517920359969139, -0.022315360605716705, -0.026435786858201027, -0.0011088763130828738, 0.04650450125336647, -0.03118945099413395, 0.005293513182550669, -0.019264299422502518, 0.0030417279340326786, 0.008747260086238384, 0.004678140394389629, 0.049434635788202286, -0.0414559468626976, 0.008153252303600311, -0.012203737162053585, -0.027571676298975945, 0.040602751076221466, -0.07257779687643051, 0.0546991191804409, 0.07952471077442169, 0.014106545597314835, 0.03103138692677021, -0.059137407690286636, 0.03342967852950096, -0.013979985378682613, -0.0065429252572357655, 0.0317278616130352, 0.01356179267168045, -0.023410961031913757, 0.011567967012524605, -0.008264752104878426, 0.027639150619506836, 0.00916314497590065, -0.015664534643292427, -0.02045000158250332, 0.014950181357562542, 0.03869785740971565, 0.04438050091266632, -0.06955206394195557, -0.03466680645942688, 0.0644780620932579, -0.03465411439538002, -0.0304148830473423, -0.09156813472509384, -0.030374649912118912, 0.0006036580889485776, -0.017678510397672653, 0.015925778076052666, -0.029585599899291992, 0.04256628826260567, 0.042977966368198395, 0.03482664376497269, 0.0019204230047762394, -0.01476067490875721, 0.01679065451025963, -0.057154085487127304, -0.010969450697302818, -0.04770037904381752, -0.042646341025829315, 0.07749873399734497, -0.05382133647799492, 0.02451866678893566, -0.014421848580241203, -0.045338865369558334, 0.02398819476366043, -0.009521435014903545, -0.051959771662950516, -0.015387763269245625, -0.004867237526923418, -0.00224485294893384, 0.04770203307271004, -0.037230901420116425, 0.012493185698986053, 0.016700012609362602, -0.03535795211791992, 0.016663797199726105, -0.029088828712701797, 0.04401771351695061, -0.03259122744202614, -0.00015431296196766198, -0.03999777138233185, -0.017371229827404022, 0.019713349640369415, 0.04478316754102707, 0.03550015762448311, 0.00838292483240366, -0.009990096092224121, 0.044835515320301056, 0.033006709069013596, 0.010650931857526302, -0.01751674711704254, -0.004099785815924406, -0.014527861960232258, -0.07923059165477753, 0.0715334340929985, 0.025489483028650284, 0.01611710898578167, -0.02557862177491188, 0.06607181578874588, 0.05691144987940788, -0.045319147408008575, -0.012383522465825081, 0.03750152885913849, -0.06571414321660995, 0.011249639093875885, -0.018160175532102585, 0.0243917778134346, -0.025379834696650505, 0.07540691643953323, 0.02450861595571041, 0.01811559498310089, 0.07442282885313034, -0.021594664081931114, -0.04419670253992081, -0.01913730800151825, 0.06887918710708618, 0.05467328056693077, 0.04475107043981552, -0.02257292903959751, 0.05993114784359932, -0.048399291932582855, -0.04120253771543503, 0.04946349188685417, 0.03424918279051781, -0.009454597719013691, -0.05691572278738022, 0.03165408968925476, 0.08130622655153275, -0.0124265868216753, 0.06834595650434494, -0.03263648971915245, 0.009058528579771519, 0.01408054493367672, 0.005930456332862377, -0.00891068298369646, 0.052846670150756836, 0.027315599843859673, 0.0039868769235908985, -0.027830300852656364, -0.02999398671090603, 0.02376924455165863, -0.01674831472337246, 0.019093645736575127, 0.031859319657087326, -0.015861809253692627, -0.008904576301574707, -0.026448911055922508, 0.054172154515981674, 0.11071725189685822, -0.06068863347172737, -0.04302302002906799, -0.011802298948168755, 0.003496421966701746, 0.014090989716351032, 0.03539108857512474, 0.004976966883987188, -0.04924780875444412, -0.0008227777434512973, -0.049159590154886246, -0.040925074368715286, -0.005419874098151922, -0.009870041161775589, 0.0067073265090584755, 0.0021270313300192356, -0.023609643802046776, -0.0022434175480157137, 0.04472300410270691, -0.057059936225414276, -0.04591996595263481, -0.05191744118928909, -0.048364851623773575, -0.041274502873420715, -0.07168493419885635, 0.01087766233831644, 0.028964783996343613, -0.02000073716044426, -0.004776959773153067, -0.06816644221544266, -0.010849589481949806, 0.04457256197929382, -0.07321003079414368, 0.01310648862272501, 0.012218869291245937, -0.009921787306666374, -0.018437130376696587, 0.04493844509124756, 0.052554771304130554, -0.016283094882965088, -0.026075027883052826, 0.03055589273571968, 0.044033605605363846, 0.0166879091411829, -0.003508842084556818, 0.0025186233688145876, -0.07474653422832489, 0.01799607463181019, 0.00592611962929368, -0.02067696861922741, -0.07254796475172043, 0.016404613852500916, -0.0075155203230679035, 0.0354367196559906, 0.06080445647239685, -0.010762433521449566, 0.014175149612128735, -0.038863275200128555, -0.020796777680516243, -0.003970367833971977, -0.0048617227002978325, 0.04559082165360451, -0.0031555965542793274, 0.04217228293418884, 0.06587257236242294, 0.012614931911230087, -0.04019613936543465, 0.009679396636784077, -0.00201273406855762, -0.01719166897237301, -0.03146683797240257, -0.017138618975877762, -0.017436252906918526, -0.05245748534798622, -0.006855588871985674, 0.02429305762052536, 0.0002082361315842718, -0.0393594428896904, 0.015086214058101177, -0.024316921830177307, -0.026364415884017944, -0.031742826104164124, -0.010990443639457226, -0.020561756566166878, -0.03556380420923233, -0.024682478979229927, -0.060524605214595795, 0.03352183476090431, 0.003832185408100486, 0.008900928311049938, -0.021000394597649574, -0.022466102614998817, 0.02777707949280739, 0.04818742349743843, 0.029464030638337135, -0.007909356616437435, 0.00485489284619689, -0.03232194483280182 ]
3,532
Rethinking and Improving Autoformalization: Towards a Faithful Metric and a Dependency Retrieval-based Approach
https://openreview.net/forum?id=hUb2At2DsQ
[ "Qi Liu", "Xinhao Zheng", "Xudong Lu", "Qinxiang Cao", "Junchi Yan" ]
Spotlight
As a central component in formal verification, statement autoformalization has been widely studied including the recent efforts from machine learning community, but still remains a widely-recognized difficult and open problem. In this paper, we delve into two critical yet under-explored gaps: 1) absence of faithful and universal automated evaluation for autoformalization results; 2) agnosia of contextual information, inducing severe hallucination of formal definitions and theorems. To address the first issue, we propose **BEq** (_**B**idirectional **E**xtended Definitional E**q**uivalence_), an automated neuro-symbolic method to determine the equivalence between two formal statements, which is formal-grounded and well-aligned with human intuition. For the second, we propose **RAutoformalizer** (_**R**etrieval-augmented **Autoformalizer**_), augmenting statement autoformalization by _Dependency Retrieval_, retrieving potentially dependent objects from formal libraries. We parse the dependencies of libraries and propose to _structurally informalise_ formal objects by the topological order of dependencies. To evaluate OOD generalization and research-level capabilities, we build a novel benchmark, _Con-NF_, consisting of 961 informal-formal statement pairs from frontier mathematical researches. Experiments validate the effectiveness of our approaches: BEq is evaluated on 200 diverse formal statement pairs with expert-annotated equivalence label, exhibiting significantly improved accuracy ($82.50\\% \mapsto 90.50\\%$) and precision ($70.59\\% \mapsto 100.0\\%$). For dependency retrieval, a strong baseline is devised. Our RAutoformalizer substantially outperforms SOTA baselines in both in-distribution ProofNet benchmark ($12.83\\% \mapsto 18.18\\%$, BEq@8) and OOD Con-NF scenario ($4.58\\%\mapsto 16.86\\%$, BEq@8).
Large Language Model, Formal Verification, Autoformalization
For statement autoformalization, we propose a faithful neural-symbolic evaluation method, a new task "dependency retrieval", a new data synthesis method, a research-level benchmark and a new paradigm that is augmented by dependency retrieval.
5,989
null
[ 0.010185765102505684, -0.024848418310284615, -0.007478103041648865, 0.026661431416869164, 0.04473090171813965, 0.028440972790122032, 0.018149856477975845, -0.01662384532392025, -0.01290495228022337, -0.019487353041768074, -0.03917859122157097, 0.020141972228884697, -0.051610901951789856, -0.014480036683380604, 0.011384344659745693, 0.05019766092300415, 0.03117402270436287, -0.00423856358975172, 0.02296510525047779, 0.019616087898612022, -0.02149554155766964, 0.01261089462786913, 0.016337549313902855, -0.008835752494633198, 0.04988417401909828, 0.03745979070663452, 0.0044965497218072414, -0.025833429768681526, -0.059837982058525085, 0.009504815563559532, 0.06420040875673294, -0.0108548728749156, -0.0015298111829906702, -0.022618742659687996, 0.013246816582977772, -0.01031105499714613, -0.027080843225121498, 0.03398040309548378, -0.012556657195091248, -0.025778084993362427, -0.02441003918647766, 0.007490466348826885, 0.03415077552199364, 0.022158879786729813, -0.05967874452471733, 0.003593872068449855, -0.11967884749174118, 0.03339336812496185, -0.04780757799744606, -0.029257025569677353, -0.08452462404966354, 0.0508744940161705, -0.04048978537321091, -0.010934367775917053, 0.005364108830690384, 0.05552162602543831, 0.03592347726225853, -0.09598103165626526, -0.006897762883454561, -0.022025519981980324, -0.019837751984596252, 0.030794082209467888, 0.025809770449995995, 0.033222127705812454, -0.013643233105540276, -0.0010987063869833946, -0.016680948436260223, 0.010150842368602753, -0.0858859121799469, -0.0034866302739828825, -0.014823580160737038, 0.010450081899762154, -0.012643249705433846, 0.002079309429973364, 0.002307769376784563, -0.018195919692516327, -0.002864049281924963, 0.06065525487065315, 0.04808875918388367, 0.008594942279160023, 0.0008881659596227109, 0.039941295981407166, 0.023742415010929108, 0.010725614614784718, 0.02545700967311859, 0.013898500241339207, -0.03711114451289177, -0.021423809230327606, -0.04303765669465065, 0.02578846924006939, 0.00747882854193449, -0.028500616550445557, 0.02018226496875286, 0.027323221787810326, 0.011419238522648811, 0.005154049023985863, 0.022729013115167618, 0.047125376760959625, 0.015520364977419376, 0.01888522133231163, -0.020169604569673538, -0.014018414542078972, 0.04251193627715111, 0.027372442185878754, -0.09097909182310104, -0.02736380696296692, -0.070750892162323, 0.000515879481099546, 0.0662088543176651, -0.015569736249744892, -0.015701139345765114, -0.004385318141430616, 0.010534956119954586, 0.0036993587855249643, -0.09181526303291321, 0.04988119378685951, -0.01095536071807146, 0.036783598363399506, -0.019823115319013596, 0.019983632490038872, 0.06105358153581619, 0.04628685861825943, 0.03651097044348717, 0.07805133610963821, -0.019306564703583717, 0.057466138154268265, -0.016347242519259453, 0.028834767639636993, -0.02470160834491253, -0.047832585871219635, -0.019658558070659637, 0.021342772990465164, -0.01099888700991869, 0.012252586893737316, 0.008888847194612026, -0.005061658564954996, -0.0018780168611556292, -0.003287713509052992, 0.06665477901697159, -0.01774267666041851, -0.0015448041958734393, -0.024503430351614952, 0.005854744464159012, -0.03223377838730812, 0.05290975794196129, 0.02454294264316559, -0.03849000111222267, -0.020782683044672012, -0.023057136684656143, 0.019616693258285522, 0.028471753001213074, 0.0015262862434610724, -0.008744212798774242, -0.06588417291641235, 0.020684579387307167, 0.08061154931783676, -0.008755958639085293, 0.008668805472552776, 0.007563639897853136, -0.016762476414442062, 0.008029434829950333, 0.030728958547115326, -0.04663725569844246, 0.02879790961742401, -0.001581019489094615, -0.019271088764071465, 0.008314619772136211, 0.01810533180832863, -0.02360285259783268, 0.0070037562400102615, -0.0325024276971817, -0.057815954089164734, 0.05318626016378403, -0.03251434117555618, -0.028388576582074165, 0.003125751158222556, 0.05799230560660362, 0.0012738709338009357, 0.05493967980146408, 0.059873610734939575, -0.07859999686479568, 0.03877180814743042, -0.008880633860826492, -0.02593045122921467, 0.017843296751379967, 0.013068038038909435, 0.08912941813468933, -0.04969565570354462, 0.007261478342115879, 0.03251255676150322, -0.049684762954711914, -0.06298888474702835, 0.05400514230132103, -0.02200481854379177, 0.029628103598952293, 0.009246866218745708, -0.011295758187770844, 0.07650499045848846, -0.024484967812895775, 0.037145450711250305, 0.02765141986310482, 0.003584058489650488, 0.0614297091960907, -0.01639082096517086, -0.0035814722068607807, 0.00043736002407968044, 0.02995639480650425, -0.06581421196460724, -0.04705311357975006, -0.0045548975467681885, -0.014152404852211475, 0.015274133533239365, 0.018481221050024033, -0.004678660072386265, -0.004991678521037102, 0.03560627996921539, -0.025201210752129555, 0.004109666217118502, 0.019111620262265205, -0.06434449553489685, 0.04189511016011238, 0.01525291707366705, 0.005275442264974117, 0.012619097717106342, -0.049478694796562195, 0.09200552850961685, 0.06568989902734756, -0.033383335918188095, -0.035314932465553284, 0.03559879586100578, -0.020869264379143715, -0.008678886108100414, 0.01680576428771019, -0.031598202884197235, -0.015073638409376144, -0.028640223667025566, 0.007786816917359829, -0.001921887043863535, 0.04698286950588226, -0.014684800058603287, -0.0020558794494718313, 0.043200209736824036, -0.013240046799182892, 0.07107121497392654, 0.015640731900930405, 0.006755847949534655, 0.022646348923444748, -0.00027383584529161453, -0.03699406236410141, 0.019932756200432777, -0.013502613641321659, -0.01555237639695406, -0.01181663479655981, -0.045221805572509766, -0.010515551082789898, -0.0280989408493042, -0.01184167806059122, 0.00315665639936924, 0.03345724567770958, 0.06402713805437088, 0.02876056358218193, -0.01048588752746582, -0.018088404089212418, -0.019054580479860306, 0.020175056532025337, -0.08314238488674164, -0.03591196611523628, 0.0076411692425608635, 0.025256322696805, 0.0007742294110357761, 0.03503810241818428, 0.01719854213297367, 0.02894960157573223, -0.008460007607936859, -0.030323194339871407, 0.030549056828022003, 0.012401595711708069, 0.007979628629982471, -0.05549359694123268, -0.0027448884211480618, -0.028684543445706367, 0.041906289756298065, -0.020658405497670174, -0.030041908845305443, -0.05020814388990402, -0.0341997854411602, 0.0033764424733817577, -0.07525431364774704, -0.02111266739666462, 0.010652191005647182, 0.014147287234663963, 0.029575761407613754, -0.06781180202960968, 0.003941869363188744, 0.07512368261814117, 0.01693730615079403, 0.02299094945192337, 0.006602996960282326, -0.01404933724552393, 0.007096932269632816, -0.009496651589870453, 0.04626599699258804, 0.003973918966948986, 0.022239023819565773, 0.018439961597323418, 0.0055011906661093235, -0.00009924626647261903, -0.003980549518018961, -0.28787755966186523, 0.01023878250271082, -0.0018730043666437268, -0.028833061456680298, 0.032171886414289474, -0.005977493245154619, 0.03494887426495552, -0.05513232201337814, -0.03526932746171951, 0.0225030817091465, 0.015209498815238476, 0.03401545435190201, 0.038377728313207626, 0.06437550485134125, 0.0185878723859787, 0.04393189027905464, 0.006366933695971966, -0.028163451701402664, 0.009610915556550026, 0.0676996111869812, -0.02709178626537323, -0.05780307576060295, -0.007242752704769373, 0.03752843290567398, -0.013266116380691528, 0.028563346713781357, -0.09949424862861633, 0.020337853580713272, -0.059701889753341675, -0.0393105149269104, 0.02295345440506935, -0.015849173069000244, -0.009989626705646515, 0.024521833285689354, -0.015204264782369137, 0.012038216926157475, 0.01604503020644188, 0.039727963507175446, 0.022813705727458, 0.016113784164190292, 0.035468004643917084, -0.02117641642689705, -0.0308251790702343, 0.028126684948801994, 0.0655001625418663, -0.004696421325206757, -0.03668428957462311, -0.03131994977593422, -0.007600044831633568, 0.036186981946229935, -0.03360776603221893, -0.024839282035827637, -0.02085382491350174, -0.0036639971658587456, -0.008280889131128788, -0.031450945883989334, 0.01243075542151928, -0.010360943153500557, -0.039180923253297806, 0.009773313999176025, -0.0028824813198298216, -0.06976450234651566, -0.008708351291716099, -0.03333484008908272, -0.04163876920938492, -0.03551473841071129, -0.046908900141716, -0.027047669515013695, 0.036284320056438446, 0.055217545479536057, -0.033477362245321274, 0.043094784021377563, -0.03284315764904022, -0.09238564223051071, 0.004846733063459396, -0.013721775263547897, -0.009756123647093773, -0.01973276399075985, 0.01135321706533432, 0.035455990582704544, -0.05547080934047699, -0.05453551933169365, -0.007193537428975105, 0.045898545533418655, 0.012918089516460896, -0.0035549565218389034, 0.022471550852060318, -0.018023163080215454, -0.021530823782086372, -0.024984518066048622, 0.04431488737463951, -0.022632921114563942, -0.025880523025989532, 0.0016503145452588797, 0.03627778962254524, 0.00880385935306549, 0.04596723988652229, 0.03418426960706711, 0.03145727142691612, 0.0010883316863328218, -0.026453590020537376, -0.08736837655305862, 0.03527705743908882, -0.03419092297554016, -0.02710898406803608, 0.0014354669256135821, -0.05712532624602318, -0.03632465749979019, 0.025700727477669716, 0.020341474562883377, -0.08558294922113419, -0.012135353870689869, 0.008702659979462624, -0.013329356908798218, -0.0014642892638221383, -0.015581547282636166, -0.014900155365467072, 0.01832621917128563, -0.00040187695412896574, -0.036528393626213074, -0.030812062323093414, 0.02542242221534252, -0.0012533910339698195, -0.011422182433307171, -0.027491511777043343, -0.04327362775802612, -0.000801132817286998, -0.0035730518866330385, 0.02380162477493286, 0.019917719066143036, 0.000008864647497830447, 0.026900410652160645, -0.017771117389202118, -0.001492917537689209, 0.03849387541413307, 0.04394437000155449, -0.008862822316586971, -0.0024475171230733395, -0.003270486369729042, -0.02069307491183281, 0.03856489807367325, -0.020612364634871483, 0.04621643200516701, 0.03473127260804176, 0.03612906113266945, -0.012948013842105865, 0.036754850298166275, 0.006451152265071869, 0.014211690053343773, 0.0017967765452340245, 0.04206349328160286, -0.058428939431905746, 0.010758742690086365, -0.025064636021852493, 0.005306832958012819, -0.018933212384581566, 0.04485723003745079, -0.006759054027497768, 0.012051867321133614, -0.05303773283958435, 0.023452142253518105, -0.001626783050596714, -0.01136683113873005, -0.01922396756708622, 0.022108150646090508, 0.05566197633743286, -0.03976539149880409, 0.01588892564177513, 0.008074266836047173, 0.01585129275918007, -0.011857722885906696, -0.007364352699369192, -0.028363117948174477, 0.016077373176813126, 0.001189987757243216, 0.009362053126096725, 0.02193242684006691, 0.01223045028746128, 0.006522386334836483, 0.023703308776021004, 0.014550872147083282, -0.0192253477871418, -0.009255172684788704, 0.0007561834645457566, 0.06022721901535988, -0.00017568946350365877, 0.021474231034517288, 0.00665636733174324, -0.0403427854180336, 0.01859225705265999, -0.01805827207863331, -0.006331026088446379, -0.01570959948003292, -0.02885565720498562, -0.03522971644997597, -0.06603074818849564, 0.02950512059032917, 0.03848782181739807, -0.012513813562691212, 0.01861681416630745, -0.002924799919128418, 0.008575856685638428, -0.06618376821279526, -0.04196157678961754, 0.03546667844057083, -0.07471548765897751, -0.0006497972062788904, 0.007562712766230106, 0.009506681002676487, -0.00030613684793934226, -0.012573868036270142, -0.05696617439389229, -0.07790215313434601, -0.02235560491681099, 0.010304460301995277, -0.0012064524926245213, 0.002589498646557331, 0.00010652431956259534, 0.0044732834212481976, -0.05568474903702736, 0.016044894233345985, 0.01204656157642603, -0.005966822151094675, 0.006180913187563419, 0.03978235274553299, 0.0634603425860405, -0.03405378758907318, -0.0008429292356595397, -0.011479226872324944, -0.03261632099747658, 0.037444327026605606, -0.04959753528237343, 0.03301464393734932, 0.04434225708246231, -0.006394984666258097, -0.023580415174365044, -0.050020214170217514, 0.053001392632722855, 0.010373914614319801, -0.0225553996860981, 0.005780112463980913, -0.0165018942207098, -0.0064088390208780766, 0.010377285070717335, -0.01340326014906168, 0.02409513108432293, 0.037551768124103546, -0.0012301235692575574, -0.0011689611710608006, 0.037172943353652954, 0.008265347220003605, 0.03469236567616463, -0.058125607669353485, -0.026233624666929245, 0.051595188677310944, -0.0666065588593483, -0.04656944051384926, -0.09605824202299118, -0.034817423671483994, 0.012636631727218628, 0.0009038231219165027, 0.02515125647187233, -0.009407970122992992, 0.013810886070132256, 0.01271346490830183, 0.028127135708928108, -0.006246892735362053, 0.008783185854554176, 0.03770686313509941, -0.07174850255250931, 0.00750336516648531, -0.036527831107378006, -0.0042669461108744144, 0.08031747490167618, -0.04807852581143379, -0.04552260786294937, -0.02742590382695198, -0.05315816029906273, 0.030766932293772697, 0.021261215209960938, -0.030910145491361618, 0.026483848690986633, 0.012329366989433765, 0.014490583911538124, 0.030064109712839127, -0.03439426049590111, -0.002210411010310054, 0.002689533168449998, -0.06335172057151794, -0.008578742854297161, -0.007517944555729628, 0.05686892941594124, -0.006766586564481258, 0.01157547626644373, -0.03903547674417496, 0.02865353412926197, 0.04141484200954437, 0.0794038251042366, 0.016334041953086853, 0.03511837124824524, -0.031284697353839874, 0.0838506743311882, 0.057840507477521896, -0.0004831364203710109, -0.008534211665391922, 0.014487305656075478, -0.03335339576005936, -0.07338982075452805, 0.05210759863257408, 0.021839868277311325, -0.011468672193586826, -0.05383358895778656, 0.06888120621442795, 0.028967784717679024, -0.033537548035383224, -0.0267292819917202, -0.006514351349323988, -0.06417663395404816, -0.025279464200139046, -0.028473971411585808, -0.0021827397868037224, -0.042508915066719055, 0.06443282961845398, 0.010582362301647663, 0.03222091495990753, 0.07787048816680908, 0.03405163064599037, -0.019641131162643433, -0.03883088380098343, 0.03969018533825874, 0.05792894959449768, 0.03213007003068924, -0.007615654729306698, 0.04606401175260544, -0.019437111914157867, -0.047620467841625214, 0.023932427167892456, 0.025803858414292336, 0.008284101262688637, -0.03701981157064438, 0.03348258510231972, 0.08141244202852249, 0.014276610687375069, 0.09400010108947754, -0.011786551214754581, -0.020156491547822952, 0.025135086849331856, -0.005454838275909424, 0.027431586757302284, 0.042501963675022125, -0.01371193490922451, 0.009193883277475834, -0.028994768857955933, -0.019522732123732567, 0.002761306008324027, -0.021881578490138054, 0.0015490754740312696, -0.007366417441517115, -0.005722414702177048, 0.022727813571691513, -0.04238947108387947, 0.08351022750139236, 0.10705982893705368, -0.03737938776612282, -0.03553485497832298, 0.03546599671244621, 0.034294940531253815, 0.031145036220550537, 0.02521965280175209, -0.0190084520727396, -0.039550554007291794, 0.0054296087473630905, -0.05926905572414398, 0.036647167056798935, 0.017388969659805298, -0.011295134201645851, 0.02135954611003399, -0.0002928928006440401, -0.021875837817788124, 0.0002007386356126517, 0.01610897295176983, -0.039870183914899826, -0.0598955899477005, -0.023339224979281425, -0.04811347275972366, -0.03832954168319702, -0.031451571732759476, -0.006859400775283575, -0.0075316461734473705, -0.034200459718704224, -0.0020704015623778105, -0.042556144297122955, 0.008686704561114311, 0.0032637170515954494, -0.08429735153913498, 0.027416085824370384, 0.037668175995349884, 0.00010446165106259286, -0.011227707378566265, 0.021994220092892647, 0.0055759986862540245, -0.012522213160991669, -0.010385695844888687, 0.03401234373450279, 0.03145357593894005, 0.019788116216659546, 0.018121782690286636, -0.004485818557441235, -0.08456269651651382, 0.011707589030265808, -0.020655760541558266, -0.04913974553346634, -0.07015449553728104, 0.01931554451584816, -0.0397171825170517, -0.012259417213499546, 0.057442717254161835, 0.03159189969301224, 0.007199788000434637, -0.01592220552265644, 0.010436893440783024, 0.045689135789871216, 0.0309298075735569, 0.04188845306634903, -0.034810591489076614, 0.05564478412270546, 0.012120559811592102, -0.021876340731978416, -0.03187576308846474, 0.038945846259593964, -0.03166858106851578, -0.022508228197693825, -0.019125210121273994, -0.036262813955545425, -0.04012732207775116, -0.08548261970281601, -0.006631895899772644, 0.025497088208794594, -0.03337514027953148, -0.026880059391260147, -0.009725198149681091, 0.018479371443390846, -0.04027846083045006, 0.028300028294324875, 0.010121379047632217, 0.023509986698627472, -0.030881477519869804, -0.013241429813206196, -0.0339844711124897, -0.024149781093001366, 0.008342398330569267, 0.06952521204948425, -0.04326525703072548, -0.04508953168988228, -0.0025389038491994143, 0.0026755849830806255, 0.0488051176071167, 0.0023960163816809654, 0.028798915445804596, -0.002162369666621089 ]
3,533
Identifiable Exchangeable Mechanisms for Causal Structure and Representation Learning
https://openreview.net/forum?id=k03mB41vyM
[ "Patrik Reizinger", "Siyuan Guo", "Ferenc Huszár", "Bernhard Schölkopf", "Wieland Brendel" ]
Spotlight
Identifying latent representations or causal structures is important for good generalization and downstream task performance. However, both fields developed rather independently. We observe that several structure and representation identifiability methods, particularly those that require multiple environments, rely on exchangeable non--i.i.d. (independent and identically distributed) data. To formalize this connection, we propose the Identifiable Exchangeable Mechanisms (IEM) framework to unify key representation and causal structure learning methods. IEM provides a unified probabilistic graphical model encompassing causal discovery, Independent Component Analysis, and Causal Representation Learning. With the help of the IEM model, we generalize the Causal de Finetti theorem of Guo et al., 2022 by relaxing the necessary conditions for causal structure identification in exchangeable data. We term these conditions cause and mechanism variability, and show how they imply a duality condition in identifiable representation learning, leading to new identifiability results.
causality, ICA, identifiability, causal representation learning
A unfiying frameworkt for identifiable causal structure and representation learning method under the lens of exchangeability
5,985
2406.14302
[ -0.0002943217696156353, 0.00440038600936532, -0.028028566390275955, 0.019017493352293968, 0.029759567230939865, 0.013996331952512264, 0.030727995559573174, 0.0028706705197691917, -0.007750419434159994, -0.040021758526563644, 0.019844690337777138, 0.01891152374446392, -0.04017641767859459, 0.004963579587638378, -0.007900746539235115, 0.05178738385438919, 0.05490779131650925, -0.03982149064540863, -0.012039689347147942, 0.05911373719573021, -0.013801445253193378, -0.01451819483190775, 0.04642025753855705, 0.011229793541133404, 0.018818484619259834, 0.015985872596502304, 0.05254809558391571, -0.013310753740370274, -0.025917528197169304, -0.0003080127644352615, 0.051857274025678635, 0.031636983156204224, 0.004178887233138084, -0.02693815343081951, 0.013341805897653103, 0.030326634645462036, -0.04697299003601074, 0.01609296165406704, 0.0022107185795903206, 0.019570117816329002, -0.048214904963970184, -0.029922589659690857, -0.024642452597618103, 0.0178805124014616, -0.04643288254737854, -0.01349905226379633, -0.11555229127407074, 0.027513818815350533, 0.03493550792336464, -0.04018933326005936, -0.07105410099029541, 0.014611529186367989, 0.010335815139114857, 0.02347266487777233, 0.012006493285298347, 0.05124792829155922, 0.034360501915216446, -0.06298425793647766, 0.009028837084770203, -0.04930686578154564, -0.05637112632393837, 0.011899220757186413, 0.01882055774331093, -0.0014402443775907159, -0.01988126151263714, -0.02857290580868721, -0.0037986214738339186, 0.04761555418372154, -0.05031096562743187, -0.019993102177977562, -0.031464822590351105, -0.025059398263692856, 0.001311964588239789, 0.0037377586122602224, 0.03568520024418831, -0.027750961482524872, 0.02516513504087925, -0.00948631763458252, 0.044587891548871994, -0.017306024208664894, 0.02279062569141388, 0.04342598840594292, 0.0027621607296168804, 0.002750338288024068, 0.030324742197990417, -0.027544377371668816, -0.038634613156318665, -0.03006981685757637, -0.09757231920957565, 0.03858746960759163, -0.04157998412847519, -0.04607217758893967, 0.015255427919328213, 0.04892512783408165, 0.011509458534419537, -0.04744064062833786, 0.04969078302383423, 0.016467636451125145, 0.008234584704041481, -0.012905667535960674, -0.022290470078587532, -0.017290964722633362, -0.003663009498268366, 0.019375471398234367, -0.09416281431913376, -0.01250714436173439, 0.0016497811302542686, -0.04934624210000038, -0.031187841668725014, -0.00958496518433094, -0.030400676652789116, 0.009652308188378811, 0.009873297065496445, -0.021843476220965385, -0.08229099214076996, 0.031343281269073486, -0.002620228100568056, 0.05332716181874275, 0.006549755111336708, 0.00383352255448699, 0.037268586456775665, 0.04097890108823776, -0.0020034397020936012, 0.050873808562755585, -0.022627387195825577, 0.0125602837651968, 0.007009081542491913, 0.03690318763256073, -0.02823794074356556, -0.050175558775663376, 0.027562648057937622, 0.015131507068872452, 0.020004350692033768, -0.030242176726460457, 0.002193235093727708, -0.003303498262539506, 0.004656059667468071, 0.031203897669911385, 0.0177902951836586, 0.0075972662307322025, 0.007639472372829914, -0.05575248599052429, 0.008153057657182217, -0.026382599025964737, 0.06416361033916473, -0.024156339466571808, -0.027428140863776207, 0.00423786323517561, -0.01789011061191559, 0.0037992268335074186, 0.020163578912615776, 0.01790620945394039, 0.017329568043351173, -0.0679507777094841, 0.002543688751757145, 0.0411088801920414, -0.008894570171833038, 0.025606468319892883, 0.008191502653062344, -0.008422688581049442, 0.03748491778969765, -0.014948087744414806, -0.0021142608020454645, 0.020054956898093224, 0.012163626030087471, -0.044311605393886566, 0.050730012357234955, 0.029575131833553314, -0.03938993439078331, -0.039516083896160126, -0.02358894981443882, -0.028355518355965614, 0.06558851897716522, -0.0038841653149574995, 0.00864340178668499, -0.01576191559433937, 0.05654892325401306, -0.0011149044148623943, 0.015403312630951405, 0.016339650377631187, -0.08968262374401093, 0.028547104448080063, -0.00630161864683032, -0.02595078945159912, 0.02741245925426483, -0.02343764901161194, 0.07845047861337662, -0.03994611278176308, 0.0019895080476999283, 0.006738661788403988, -0.05369345843791962, -0.020234711468219757, 0.0384821817278862, -0.007123883347958326, 0.06288845837116241, 0.019960887730121613, -0.031106293201446533, 0.045990630984306335, 0.04081449657678604, 0.01935489848256111, 0.023493224754929543, -0.042883940041065216, 0.019285347312688828, -0.0044168694876134396, -0.03723296523094177, 0.00038264706381596625, 0.06581684201955795, -0.04257788136601448, -0.04682770371437073, 0.019429005682468414, -0.013039210811257362, -0.014377651736140251, -0.014136772602796555, -0.019322611391544342, 0.027250561863183975, 0.008980767801404, -0.003652792889624834, 0.040466345846652985, 0.0018955307314172387, -0.03258166089653969, 0.044500138610601425, 0.04034704715013504, -0.020940253511071205, 0.020032979547977448, -0.0036639596801251173, 0.0971064642071724, 0.05377432703971863, 0.010271374136209488, 0.013081223703920841, 0.054395806044340134, 0.05759061127901077, 0.0017252522520720959, 0.022252079099416733, -0.0377669557929039, 0.04163553565740585, -0.0036611929535865784, -0.01568889431655407, -0.020111145451664925, 0.06453140825033188, -0.05561790615320206, -0.0015923123573884368, 0.06600020080804825, -0.03360224887728691, 0.04625551775097847, -0.02298257313668728, 0.02381013333797455, 0.02617514133453369, -0.01571526564657688, -0.03579987213015556, -0.02402929589152336, -0.056568946689367294, -0.0017450080486014485, -0.006894411984831095, -0.05465070530772209, 0.035708408802747726, -0.05476014316082001, 0.013062693178653717, 0.010690669529139996, 0.0565665140748024, 0.044822875410318375, 0.021031709387898445, 0.03772693872451782, -0.0022002332843840122, -0.00763667980208993, -0.010058426298201084, -0.10475750267505646, -0.03970512002706528, 0.026711128652095795, 0.07005113363265991, -0.005326383747160435, 0.07238025963306427, -0.027478424832224846, 0.007276052609086037, 0.01015278697013855, -0.019643500447273254, 0.025692101567983627, 0.016724202781915665, -0.005777264479547739, -0.047182198613882065, -0.008961155079305172, 0.01881094090640545, 0.04366361349821091, 0.013049685396254063, -0.009034845046699047, -0.044708698987960815, -0.036466218531131744, -0.06124912574887276, -0.04070126637816429, -0.02510792203247547, 0.014478137716650963, 0.04235488548874855, 0.025738460943102837, 0.0036676630843430758, 0.005552144721150398, 0.015025584027171135, 0.05098613724112511, 0.019140198826789856, 0.024960311129689217, 0.012571638450026512, 0.007434778846800327, -0.005694740451872349, 0.028682103380560875, 0.0173404011875391, 0.006001659203320742, -0.003148317337036133, -0.0232431311160326, 0.006661617662757635, 0.010768679901957512, -0.2806316018104553, -0.015182532370090485, 0.01003862265497446, 0.014432953670620918, 0.025718504562973976, -0.037161219865083694, 0.07867801934480667, -0.03480908274650574, -0.01567990705370903, -0.0008842382812872529, 0.04142254218459129, 0.04212091490626335, 0.007895808666944504, 0.0251413956284523, 0.029094787314534187, 0.007293736562132835, -0.016216972842812538, -0.03233596682548523, 0.04121202975511551, 0.04091157391667366, -0.015168940648436546, -0.06241632252931595, -0.06261350959539413, 0.03478458523750305, -0.023976819589734077, -0.01103317178785801, -0.07157015800476074, 0.015752900391817093, -0.041141994297504425, -0.01564304530620575, -0.03603780269622803, -0.03995285555720329, -0.02705121971666813, 0.03312988206744194, 0.02635839954018593, 0.006594229023903608, 0.030414070934057236, -0.0061137257143855095, -0.003188282949849963, 0.010279517620801926, -0.016054213047027588, -0.024924341589212418, 0.019181666895747185, 0.00005969837729935534, 0.0467849038541317, 0.009217213839292526, 0.009975767694413662, -0.020751720294356346, -0.0023266670759767294, 0.03722178936004639, -0.008765434846282005, -0.013352838344871998, -0.009484197944402695, -0.0020063775591552258, -0.011697683483362198, -0.028669828549027443, -0.014092828147113323, -0.024412568658590317, 0.0006146289524622262, 0.028825322166085243, 0.023081321269273758, -0.03755691275000572, 0.004489639308303595, -0.06909890472888947, -0.010098849423229694, -0.037610601633787155, -0.07052000612020493, -0.07032888382673264, 0.047371551394462585, 0.020928682759404182, 0.00023092592891771346, 0.008973455056548119, -0.005938486196100712, -0.10022898763418198, 0.033825237303972244, 0.00325973192229867, 0.005405522417277098, 0.010487046092748642, 0.01177159883081913, 0.044595442712306976, 0.009161490015685558, -0.009485028684139252, -0.006945762317627668, 0.018923785537481308, 0.018773240968585014, 0.02202042192220688, 0.025641076266765594, -0.003632928943261504, -0.05593571811914444, -0.030269835144281387, -0.011341645382344723, 0.045744888484478, 0.05209110304713249, 0.017332931980490685, 0.05025598034262657, 0.04053819552063942, 0.02904682792723179, 0.03057800978422165, 0.07043125480413437, -0.009620088152587414, 0.021316509693861008, -0.08562710136175156, -0.03851708397269249, -0.018446268513798714, -0.04500375688076019, 0.025241142138838768, -0.07017242908477783, -0.016516070812940598, 0.0593489408493042, -0.044956739991903305, -0.03581260144710541, -0.04855196550488472, -0.02310827188193798, -0.024777285754680634, 0.008882814086973667, -0.015783676877617836, 0.001950604491867125, 0.02740350551903248, 0.05520808696746826, -0.027084553614258766, -0.013198553584516048, 0.034977491945028305, -0.024363655596971512, 0.031807541847229004, -0.011262084357440472, -0.004022363107651472, -0.013443618081510067, -0.028984980657696724, -0.0038153487257659435, -0.009198815561830997, 0.045660436153411865, 0.012655720114707947, 0.03447026386857033, 0.025493018329143524, 0.07041598856449127, -0.002642814302816987, -0.015042567625641823, 0.007851827889680862, 0.014452549628913403, -0.053699467331171036, 0.03846210986375809, 0.007007477339357138, 0.018840372562408447, -0.008536898531019688, 0.06805885583162308, 0.006201472133398056, -0.01949017494916916, -0.016625359654426575, -0.028810949996113777, -0.04113663360476494, 0.0467938669025898, -0.040758758783340454, -0.023711754009127617, -0.005145244300365448, -0.0037886740174144506, -0.00460620503872633, 0.03263694792985916, -0.009918011724948883, 0.024812255054712296, -0.060778047889471054, 0.047002632170915604, 0.005175826605409384, -0.0032460179645568132, 0.006111443042755127, 0.006869156379252672, 0.07042407989501953, -0.04057636111974716, 0.005228164605796337, 0.02857893332839012, 0.0052572633139789104, -0.0037339390255510807, -0.026712868362665176, -0.018392687663435936, -0.015257828868925571, -0.038826923817396164, 0.004612679127603769, -0.02519320882856846, -0.033824510872364044, -0.04266118258237839, 0.017963217571377754, 0.013845875859260559, -0.044814176857471466, -0.03130636364221573, -0.002387937856838107, 0.0775299146771431, -0.006071743555366993, 0.04582085460424423, -0.024814601987600327, -0.03198421746492386, 0.027517903596162796, -0.004557216074317694, 0.021188577637076378, -0.04957642778754234, -0.019232533872127533, -0.0171821266412735, -0.04154867306351662, -0.007374799344688654, -0.01623516157269478, -0.028083549812436104, -0.020193085074424744, -0.004055703524500132, 0.022053252905607224, -0.04559480398893356, -0.009473188780248165, 0.027073467150330544, -0.07268717139959335, -0.010364700108766556, 0.04203537479043007, -0.036552779376506805, 0.02621344104409218, -0.039567962288856506, -0.04965100437402725, -0.0520128533244133, 0.01111576147377491, 0.03502701222896576, -0.023623868823051453, 0.0194911677390337, -0.020985761657357216, -0.02736937440931797, -0.0005574249662458897, 0.050001200288534164, 0.022465195506811142, -0.0015589018585160375, 0.00401682686060667, 0.012176062911748886, 0.02969747968018055, -0.024713842198252678, -0.023515909910202026, 0.0049667092971503735, -0.047653015702962875, 0.004122035577893257, -0.03565605729818344, 0.006442942190915346, 0.051635563373565674, -0.022080373018980026, -0.03369208052754402, -0.022103024646639824, 0.05740603059530258, 0.01104715932160616, -0.006089255213737488, -0.0060228523798286915, -0.017406638711690903, -0.010635343380272388, -0.022387685254216194, 0.020060332491993904, 0.03366249054670334, 0.013567591086030006, 0.009332248009741306, 0.057787489145994186, 0.015381045639514923, 0.007789360824972391, 0.029603034257888794, -0.06838219612836838, -0.00999177061021328, 0.05102869123220444, -0.04586273059248924, -0.01380586251616478, -0.06752731651067734, 0.01505623571574688, -0.011127335950732231, -0.008057767525315285, 0.028556445613503456, 0.0037817363627254963, 0.04360097274184227, 0.008816677145659924, 0.04855223745107651, 0.008150064386427402, -0.019239727407693863, 0.03163956105709076, -0.06718610972166061, -0.0005809289868921041, -0.0632590651512146, -0.00013805327762383968, 0.029136747121810913, -0.045716654509305954, -0.016373036429286003, 0.0013396528083831072, 0.0002774326130747795, 0.03365880995988846, -0.035363659262657166, -0.061907701194286346, -0.006131982896476984, -0.02480575256049633, 0.003098138375207782, 0.0339297316968441, -0.03991388902068138, -0.036795902997255325, -0.022161277011036873, -0.042259231209754944, -0.0188282560557127, 0.004822915885597467, 0.04575919359922409, -0.006912211421877146, 0.010302639566361904, -0.0032023738604038954, 0.032660093158483505, 0.027034303173422813, 0.08029592782258987, 0.01622743345797062, 0.039459340274333954, -0.02563752420246601, 0.052836328744888306, 0.016787739470601082, 0.0007629900937899947, 0.02781403250992298, 0.0019240431720390916, -0.002696957439184189, -0.04861197620630264, 0.04433364421129227, 0.003926172852516174, -0.007296954281628132, -0.0776660367846489, 0.06062878668308258, 0.016793014481663704, -0.04635925590991974, -0.029781794175505638, 0.01409299485385418, -0.0390264131128788, 0.033037200570106506, 0.013609052635729313, -0.002855014754459262, 0.003914251923561096, 0.07646189630031586, -0.007473452016711235, 0.06294354051351547, 0.06011581048369408, 0.0675899013876915, -0.0027204768266528845, -0.012178350239992142, 0.08232083916664124, 0.07386483252048492, 0.04304150864481926, 0.02291841432452202, 0.08397748321294785, -0.02504977583885193, -0.0323488675057888, 0.00394813809543848, -0.005691529251635075, -0.01313920971006155, -0.017702829092741013, 0.01735605113208294, 0.09042949229478836, 0.009336436167359352, 0.07530870288610458, -0.04099066182971001, 0.001408413052558899, 0.0658378005027771, -0.0003241185622755438, 0.02825268544256687, 0.035823192447423935, 0.021300997585058212, 0.03813839703798294, -0.006583457347005606, -0.015533705241978168, -0.03963450714945793, -0.00403721584007144, 0.03842634707689285, 0.028298398479819298, -0.029969263821840286, 0.03049515001475811, 0.018135763704776764, 0.02190418541431427, 0.08774460852146149, -0.03445378690958023, -0.014735658653080463, -0.001892697298899293, 0.030320171266794205, 0.021413173526525497, 0.05251934379339218, -0.0181364044547081, -0.011522376909852028, -0.009958956390619278, -0.07660334557294846, 0.04336802288889885, 0.024269595742225647, 0.00024423436843790114, -0.0022338079288601875, -0.05218609422445297, -0.024719107896089554, 0.011478247120976448, 0.03302803635597229, -0.03353472054004669, -0.05768430978059769, -0.03005209192633629, -0.06390385329723358, -0.07566627115011215, -0.05078285187482834, 0.06204844266176224, -0.008002538233995438, -0.04632878676056862, 0.00980424415320158, -0.03983083367347717, 0.044720035046339035, 0.011270811781287193, -0.06877514719963074, -0.025136863812804222, 0.05522739514708519, 0.01703464984893799, 0.01827043667435646, 0.01956881396472454, -0.0012476576957851648, -0.00815799180418253, -0.03631666302680969, 0.0013853200944140553, 0.016159787774086, 0.02049846760928631, -0.04225335642695427, -0.03575750067830086, -0.08736778795719147, 0.003616244764998555, 0.008307985961437225, -0.044709838926792145, -0.08344147354364395, 0.030593303963541985, 0.005495420191437006, 0.01066855899989605, 0.030496690422296524, -0.020653240382671356, -0.004410699475556612, -0.010573731735348701, 0.00001266514209419256, 0.008209221065044403, 0.00722581846639514, 0.03304411098361015, -0.03923942521214485, 0.06517137587070465, 0.031246637925505638, -0.03461300581693649, -0.02564614824950695, 0.04223882034420967, -0.024434473365545273, -0.04178677126765251, -0.05713130533695221, -0.04891303926706314, -0.03550983965396881, -0.11090369522571564, -0.005083858501166105, 0.007326326798647642, -0.005814438220113516, -0.009954599663615227, -0.008834087289869785, -0.012309173122048378, -0.016614988446235657, -0.014363576658070087, -0.03553786873817444, -0.007109318394213915, -0.03138604387640953, -0.0259906854480505, -0.05937965586781502, 0.017003487795591354, -0.009216480888426304, -0.004849801771342754, -0.052099745720624924, -0.04879852384328842, -0.002303055953234434, -0.030282901600003242, 0.026911495253443718, 0.04126668721437454, 0.04670167341828346, -0.017400158569216728 ]
3,534
Learning Spatiotemporal Dynamical Systems from Point Process Observations
https://openreview.net/forum?id=37EXtKCOkn
[ "Valerii Iakovlev", "Harri Lähdesmäki" ]
Spotlight
Spatiotemporal dynamics models are fundamental for various domains, from heat propagation in materials to oceanic and atmospheric flows. However, currently available neural network-based spatiotemporal modeling approaches fall short when faced with data that is collected randomly over time and space, as is often the case with sensor networks in real-world applications like crowdsourced earthquake detection or pollution monitoring. In response, we developed a new method that can effectively learn spatiotemporal dynamics from such point process observations. Our model integrates techniques from neural differential equations, neural point processes, implicit neural representations and amortized variational inference to model both the dynamics of the system and the probabilistic locations and timings of observations. It outperforms existing methods on challenging spatiotemporal datasets by offering substantial improvements in predictive accuracy and computational efficiency, making it a useful tool for modeling and understanding complex dynamical systems observed under realistic, unconstrained conditions.
dynamics, spatiotemporal, neural, PDE, ODE
null
5,963
2406.00368
[ -0.005513699259608984, -0.02243887446820736, 0.0023540970869362354, 0.034782856702804565, 0.0316130667924881, 0.03825245425105095, 0.013336730189621449, 0.014901156537234783, -0.042943764477968216, -0.04442557319998741, 0.01482830848544836, -0.023024214431643486, -0.02966684103012085, 0.015958372503519058, 0.01875184290111065, 0.04887845739722252, 0.032829295843839645, -0.016867591068148613, 0.035023484379053116, 0.033518243581056595, 0.005369245540350676, -0.026079006493091583, 0.03862476721405983, 0.014947419986128807, 0.012326826341450214, -0.02013184316456318, 0.02467268705368042, 0.002948611509054899, -0.008779465220868587, 0.0002749549748841673, 0.005088228732347488, 0.024216916412115097, -0.024266278371214867, -0.027469757944345474, -0.008587929420173168, 0.014511099085211754, -0.04127863049507141, 0.004543582908809185, -0.014251481741666794, 0.008777813985943794, -0.050491996109485626, 0.023864153772592545, -0.005085846409201622, 0.0020906170830130577, 0.0003918232105206698, 0.046075981110334396, -0.08882907032966614, 0.051762621849775314, 0.02642975002527237, -0.018389254808425903, -0.11416210234165192, 0.04409899562597275, 0.016705475747585297, -0.01865486055612564, -0.02757604792714119, 0.03780604526400566, 0.03847406059503555, -0.061850517988204956, -0.003926620353013277, -0.06682480126619339, -0.0031724669970571995, 0.014789929613471031, 0.011609426699578762, -0.02213992364704609, 0.02315744198858738, 0.000768618774600327, 0.03955313190817833, 0.04991181194782257, -0.010859551839530468, -0.03143647313117981, -0.012612080201506615, 0.011592873372137547, -0.013711671344935894, 0.025774268433451653, -0.011875034309923649, -0.05830799415707588, 0.016364600509405136, 0.017660342156887054, 0.028163857758045197, 0.013913947157561779, 0.01585281826555729, -0.004361393395811319, 0.013225575909018517, 0.03460818529129028, -0.002298214239999652, 0.014128345996141434, -0.05533350259065628, -0.02280326932668686, -0.0792548879981041, 0.05093236267566681, -0.03656213358044624, -0.03913797438144684, 0.015603541396558285, 0.05349414050579071, 0.023109255358576775, -0.010015244595706463, 0.012901273556053638, 0.011929776519536972, 0.011743677780032158, -0.004764842800796032, -0.025119518861174583, -0.024663124233484268, 0.020013820379972458, 0.00651869922876358, -0.07841000705957413, -0.08475689589977264, -0.008711233735084534, -0.033031199127435684, -0.008500969037413597, -0.00215671444311738, -0.04393766075372696, 0.0017288781236857176, 0.030494537204504013, -0.025022942572832108, -0.06773312389850616, 0.01440335251390934, 0.031790852546691895, 0.035812027752399445, 0.0013643044512718916, -0.010486588813364506, 0.05245647579431534, 0.031304795295000076, -0.019267613068223, 0.05470182001590729, -0.026060989126563072, 0.032271161675453186, 0.005868016742169857, -0.014073592610657215, -0.024426663294434547, -0.03051874041557312, -0.00914834626019001, 0.01898573711514473, -0.008628006093204021, -0.0020743526984006166, 0.025614844635128975, -0.028033530339598656, -0.010757746174931526, 0.04529504477977753, 0.01682787947356701, 0.018988868221640587, 0.024698331952095032, -0.00958830863237381, 0.06896315515041351, -0.028814390301704407, 0.0631299689412117, -0.01298954151570797, 0.00017209077486768365, -0.06286723166704178, -0.014191827736794949, -0.0025204767007380724, 0.004764189478009939, 0.012178979814052582, -0.009424030780792236, -0.06688117235898972, 0.03053869679570198, 0.05397222191095352, 0.025777693837881088, 0.02480071783065796, -0.006689704954624176, 0.0007574033224955201, 0.028014205396175385, 0.010031375102698803, 0.01892414689064026, 0.034901171922683716, -0.018600642681121826, -0.07962440699338913, 0.054030608385801315, 0.005804584827274084, -0.019010029733181, 0.0001708583440631628, -0.04169424623250961, -0.02434246428310871, 0.04014163464307785, -0.007882784120738506, 0.019488129764795303, -0.016480354592204094, 0.05665948987007141, 0.0013689303305000067, 0.007726586423814297, 0.0069242557510733604, -0.08595026284456253, 0.0131134744733572, -0.004909297451376915, -0.0010370956733822823, 0.02497459203004837, -0.03599095344543457, 0.09818828850984573, -0.045380111783742905, 0.013415813446044922, -0.01112800557166338, -0.0457632802426815, -0.021981649100780487, -0.019085578620433807, -0.025615425780415535, 0.05220194160938263, -0.014270792715251446, -0.01026227232068777, 0.0047744750045239925, 0.02432134747505188, 0.07251176238059998, 0.041513122618198395, -0.03016243688762188, 0.05293460190296173, -0.005991500336676836, -0.027079755440354347, -0.04661989212036133, 0.06476640701293945, -0.0742873027920723, -0.0020634469110518694, 0.00944312009960413, -0.024969439953565598, -0.017338013276457787, 0.010912206023931503, -0.01866093836724758, 0.013557561673223972, -0.00041119218803942204, 0.0018323834519833326, 0.03822704404592514, 0.005514914635568857, -0.04190836101770401, 0.023347487673163414, 0.01370555441826582, -0.014386903494596481, 0.004698044620454311, -0.019536009058356285, 0.10619373619556427, 0.09101070463657379, -0.01914879120886326, 0.021396644413471222, -0.004695078823715448, 0.05609780550003052, 0.021676834672689438, -0.0013990108855068684, 0.005447051487863064, 0.021606070920825005, 0.034054677933454514, 0.026114311069250107, -0.028136422857642174, 0.008369453251361847, -0.05597791075706482, 0.008269757963716984, 0.0689142718911171, -0.027342386543750763, 0.08322761207818985, -0.031717099249362946, 0.008801240473985672, 0.062190450727939606, 0.005372981540858746, -0.033452026546001434, -0.0315542072057724, -0.017365531995892525, 0.0028835656121373177, 0.020579922944307327, 0.006226769648492336, -0.015285160392522812, -0.06309232860803604, -0.04069329798221588, 0.013224955648183823, 0.1028820350766182, 0.035226963460445404, 0.036074258387088776, 0.006823007948696613, 0.013169266283512115, -0.0185089111328125, -0.015788141638040543, -0.13992160558700562, -0.051269806921482086, -0.007540035992860794, 0.01056187879294157, 0.03650451451539993, 0.03801262751221657, -0.01599377766251564, 0.058279383927583694, -0.020650096237659454, -0.04700559377670288, -0.006632887292653322, 0.032640404999256134, -0.0128937978297472, -0.0329839289188385, -0.02540031634271145, 0.008342604152858257, 0.06174654886126518, -0.021010175347328186, -0.05786167085170746, 0.014883958734571934, -0.06159961223602295, -0.008537719957530499, -0.0018052675295621157, -0.005908467341214418, 0.006203339900821447, -0.0045243436470627785, -0.036573994904756546, -0.02164907194674015, 0.024580998346209526, 0.03338518738746643, 0.08454515039920807, 0.0327061265707016, -0.0232772808521986, -0.020044228062033653, -0.00730889942497015, -0.025485433638095856, 0.0039399415254592896, -0.013881773687899113, 0.006890523247420788, -0.036010727286338806, 0.016340984031558037, 0.016109565272927284, -0.0035558147355914116, -0.26379093527793884, -0.011164850555360317, 0.03774556890130043, -0.016796667128801346, 0.034760817885398865, 0.023207183927297592, 0.07684871554374695, -0.03070877678692341, -0.03555072098970413, 0.005097145214676857, -0.00012004961899947375, 0.019286667928099632, -0.01740715093910694, 0.05963200330734253, 0.033222079277038574, -0.034299954771995544, 0.007479005493223667, -0.03087475337088108, 0.0031031277030706406, 0.0209897980093956, -0.0376795269548893, -0.056031160056591034, -0.029750438407063484, 0.03687696531414986, -0.002367307897657156, 0.04873577132821083, -0.05141598358750343, 0.008718463592231274, -0.04352521896362305, 0.006370364222675562, -0.007349567487835884, -0.049112413078546524, -0.0052276006899774075, 0.04577713832259178, 0.02575724758207798, -0.002337896963581443, -0.0008242636104114354, 0.007341368123888969, 0.009056787006556988, 0.00023737797164358199, -0.012098429724574089, -0.0013734824024140835, -0.03609961271286011, 0.0015142201445996761, 0.07171233743429184, 0.021350247785449028, -0.009822050109505653, 0.01771553047001362, -0.00967966578900814, 0.017011117190122604, 0.023933587595820427, -0.049739040434360504, 0.029696013778448105, -0.030992241576313972, -0.025680433958768845, -0.04023584723472595, 0.015108970925211906, -0.0074425567872822285, 0.0020606277976185083, 0.0094076469540596, 0.0003661935334093869, -0.053396690636873245, 0.002944403328001499, -0.0300186425447464, 0.014457101933658123, -0.02344675362110138, -0.09215713292360306, -0.05089002847671509, 0.04823717102408409, 0.011954517103731632, -0.012204642407596111, -0.026880083605647087, -0.04528960958123207, -0.10887590050697327, 0.04513908177614212, 0.004046863876283169, 0.008973350748419762, -0.05262928828597069, 0.0328318290412426, 0.02429654449224472, -0.04085224121809006, -0.02822217345237732, 0.005340760573744774, 0.03855473920702934, 0.024417078122496605, 0.0056494795717298985, 0.008883865550160408, -0.04822163283824921, -0.040883634239435196, -0.03923510015010834, 0.013013506308197975, -0.008756645023822784, 0.06476563960313797, -0.00729766208678484, 0.036347270011901855, 0.060427650809288025, 0.002750087296590209, 0.032043639570474625, 0.05540269613265991, -0.04353092983365059, 0.025357170030474663, -0.04351096227765083, 0.00908068846911192, -0.060003671795129776, 0.0087136784568429, 0.021503277122974396, -0.03154141083359718, 0.01086643896996975, 0.029832368716597557, -0.00020805379608646035, -0.000825878232717514, -0.002207996789366007, -0.003749459283426404, -0.016034206375479698, -0.014896564185619354, -0.0006470952648669481, -0.025572948157787323, 0.027480503544211388, 0.08583273738622665, -0.014778497628867626, -0.047576043754816055, 0.02445954829454422, -0.03130505234003067, 0.032361216843128204, 0.008715478703379631, -0.0281817726790905, -0.019925307482481003, -0.03367239236831665, -0.010795290581882, -0.015483448281884193, 0.03868308663368225, 0.06404604762792587, 0.023632610216736794, 0.061744965612888336, 0.04773779585957527, 0.016627483069896698, -0.006068031769245863, -0.025972705334424973, 0.03288019821047783, -0.014438137412071228, 0.017063479870557785, 0.019185379147529602, 0.021437836810946465, 0.02229153923690319, 0.022401956841349602, 0.03409538045525551, -0.006208748556673527, 0.015035378746688366, 0.015234533697366714, -0.032965075224637985, 0.037397049367427826, -0.05895773321390152, -0.06078353896737099, -0.02111843042075634, -0.022575315088033676, -0.016363536939024925, 0.05860389024019241, -0.02502751164138317, 0.014557307586073875, -0.03137331083416939, 0.03949159011244774, 0.013299573212862015, -0.044450849294662476, 0.0007971762679517269, -0.025123653933405876, 0.05270292982459068, -0.03349514678120613, 0.021915771067142487, 0.02175602689385414, -0.014770140871405602, 0.027037478983402252, -0.03181443363428116, -0.03825424239039421, -0.018642351031303406, -0.017412349581718445, 0.001416373997926712, -0.0007261041318997741, -0.023658059537410736, -0.06300021708011627, 0.0023048738949000835, 0.03426065668463707, -0.01592462696135044, -0.025395696982741356, 0.02763948030769825, 0.07027174532413483, -0.0016211584443226457, -0.01768137514591217, -0.016878215596079826, -0.04344440624117851, 0.0364217609167099, 0.014509282074868679, 0.030627945438027382, -0.030062904581427574, -0.03809824958443642, -0.005220607854425907, -0.034243080765008926, 0.0030754990875720978, 0.0390981063246727, -0.01742367260158062, -0.016111131757497787, -0.012594952248036861, 0.014385645277798176, -0.031321391463279724, 0.017674975097179413, 0.029462993144989014, -0.05173124745488167, 0.01346781849861145, 0.05791901797056198, -0.03066316619515419, 0.00003865444887196645, -0.05110543966293335, -0.002304160501807928, -0.04267057403922081, 0.012378771789371967, 0.0037088191602379084, 0.04128267243504524, -0.00477592134848237, -0.036052532494068146, -0.0084194615483284, 0.013109588995575905, 0.02669071964919567, 0.0271897129714489, -0.0003895389090757817, -0.060108549892902374, 0.011488664895296097, 0.06119376793503761, -0.008288327604532242, -0.002775618340820074, 0.00023388053523376584, -0.013025514781475067, 0.0069641852751374245, -0.05162476748228073, -0.011769323609769344, 0.03674920275807381, -0.0085249999538064, -0.03907521814107895, -0.03907543048262596, 0.02610086463391781, 0.0027320284862071276, 0.012957514263689518, -0.03410743176937103, -0.005676649510860443, -0.03480947017669678, -0.0064184702932834625, 0.015754958614706993, 0.035219863057136536, 0.002432476030662656, 0.028965814039111137, 0.02240944653749466, 0.015085205435752869, 0.02905871346592903, -0.002158763352781534, -0.07958080619573593, 0.0042939139530062675, 0.03408440202474594, -0.00984891690313816, -0.03920428082346916, -0.0873725488781929, -0.00040853049722500145, -0.0057985614985227585, -0.02094455622136593, -0.01233726181089878, -0.022737137973308563, 0.03713883459568024, 0.00981592945754528, 0.041452791541814804, 0.02609051764011383, -0.03502833470702171, 0.021790215745568275, -0.0658319965004921, -0.004961454309523106, -0.058345526456832886, -0.03436654433608055, 0.03877393528819084, 0.004110273905098438, 0.023994114249944687, 0.021460149437189102, -0.022862568497657776, 0.06983128935098648, -0.03803824260830879, -0.055772703140974045, 0.036711230874061584, -0.032325346022844315, -0.012547544203698635, 0.030818048864603043, -0.05912189930677414, -0.010117344558238983, -0.012565197423100471, -0.06213539466261864, 0.013752921484410763, 0.024547837674617767, 0.010640786960721016, -0.018564481288194656, 0.02331218682229519, -0.01059378869831562, 0.05147208645939827, 0.0018219208577647805, 0.0437174029648304, -0.029248889535665512, 0.03625766932964325, -0.05374406278133392, 0.07894329726696014, 0.018644703552126884, -0.0018122736364603043, -0.009960147552192211, 0.008944759145379066, 0.01806977577507496, -0.057042960077524185, 0.03204065561294556, 0.020696915686130524, -0.016840707510709763, -0.06076788529753685, 0.049038298428058624, 0.03133502975106239, -0.04051484167575836, -0.001404567970894277, 0.02218574844300747, -0.04060198739171028, 0.0024277549237012863, 0.007568603381514549, -0.006819416303187609, -0.0016379400622099638, 0.07507741451263428, 0.016309233382344246, 0.07428028434515, 0.05055486783385277, 0.014877400361001492, 0.0054594362154603004, -0.009987856261432171, 0.06665725260972977, 0.05280698835849762, 0.028580356389284134, -0.007521315012127161, 0.060434866696596146, -0.05072217434644699, -0.012666282244026661, 0.030811382457613945, 0.004031321499496698, -0.030969344079494476, -0.04122159630060196, 0.030129434540867805, 0.09909867495298386, 0.038489244878292084, 0.06195715069770813, -0.04639822617173195, -0.025667009875178337, 0.029337791725993156, 0.03676658868789673, 0.003109070472419262, -0.021644672378897667, 0.018997030332684517, 0.014210942201316357, -0.008810432627797127, -0.05818430706858635, -0.020063402131199837, -0.035674165934324265, 0.01413770578801632, 0.037767719477415085, 0.02355230785906315, 0.019757777452468872, 0.015184720978140831, 0.02670927904546261, 0.08313009887933731, -0.029357237741351128, -0.05213741585612297, 0.009116214700043201, 0.012758537195622921, 0.000578699167817831, 0.03430736064910889, 0.008668798953294754, 0.012113665230572224, 0.030441652983427048, -0.020587649196386337, 0.05375537648797035, 0.018608927726745605, -0.030559195205569267, -0.00866901408880949, -0.04532206431031227, -0.018602702766656876, -0.006820742506533861, 0.008965209126472473, -0.03826206922531128, -0.06198130548000336, -0.03572075441479683, -0.03827505186200142, -0.05093063414096832, -0.040153346955776215, 0.07445545494556427, -0.02255820482969284, -0.003281164914369583, 0.014619858004152775, -0.025125905871391296, 0.020907308906316757, 0.02138427086174488, -0.06109429895877838, -0.0017820592038333416, 0.03158365935087204, -0.0059165358543396, 0.03726625815033913, 0.04677998647093773, 0.02291972190141678, -0.027498500421643257, -0.016448529437184334, 0.05283912643790245, -0.03855712339282036, 0.05311024934053421, -0.0020638247951865196, -0.007111500483006239, -0.09619098156690598, 0.02480742149055004, 0.02123267576098442, -0.02364077977836132, -0.07941565662622452, 0.02201767824590206, -0.04191456735134125, 0.038215018808841705, 0.06320793181657791, -0.022413447499275208, 0.007718857377767563, -0.08861611038446426, -0.018542014062404633, -0.031781744211912155, -0.0004878282197751105, 0.06125001981854439, -0.0344836451113224, 0.05081261694431305, 0.05053768306970596, -0.040928129106760025, 0.0015564949717372656, 0.009549330919981003, -0.009606841951608658, -0.011168144643306732, -0.04825097694993019, -0.014025856740772724, -0.01512871216982603, -0.1102466955780983, -0.036319006234407425, 0.03655187040567398, -0.0022627708967775106, -0.02368912287056446, 0.007258693687617779, 0.002429164247587323, 0.0014989598421379924, -0.032458044588565826, -0.010481911711394787, 0.006390080321580172, -0.032521605491638184, -0.05283483490347862, -0.07276009768247604, 0.014706488698720932, -0.027331514284014702, -0.006699923891574144, -0.05075400322675705, -0.01311053242534399, -0.02027135156095028, -0.006722231395542622, 0.022197194397449493, -0.0073738135397434235, 0.0158951748162508, 0.015209384262561798 ]
3,535
Probabilistic Neural Pruning via Sparsity Evolutionary Fokker-Planck-Kolmogorov Equation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=hJ1BaJ5ELp
[ "Zhanfeng Mo", "Haosen Shi", "Sinno Jialin Pan" ]
Spotlight
Neural pruning aims to compress and accelerate deep neural networks by identifying the optimal subnetwork within a specified sparsity budget. In this work, we study how to gradually sparsify the unpruned dense model to the target sparsity level with minimal performance drop. Specifically, we analyze the evolution of the population of optimal subnetworks under continuous sparsity increments from a thermodynamic perspective. We first reformulate neural pruning as an expected loss minimization problem over the mask distributions. Then, we establish an effective approximation for the sparsity evolution of the optimal mask distribution, termed the **S**parsity Evolutionary **F**okker-**P**lanck-**K**olmogorov Equation (**SFPK**), which provides closed-form, mathematically tractable guidance on distributional transitions for minimizing the expected loss under an infinitesimal sparsity increment. On top of that, we propose SFPK-pruner, a particle simulation-based probabilistic pruning method, to sample performant masks with desired sparsity from the destination distribution of SFPK. In theory, we establish the convergence guarantee for the proposed SFPK-pruner. Our SFPK-pruner exhibits competitive performance in various pruning scenarios. The code is available on https://github.com/mzf666/SFPK-main.
Optimization for Deep Network, Probabilistic Method, Machine learning, Model compression
We propose a principled probabilistic pruning framework, coined Sparsity Evolutionary FPK Equation that enables us to generate performant masks with desired sparsity via particle simulation of the dynamic of optimal mask distribution.
5,759
null
[ -0.030767161399126053, -0.022105615586042404, 0.01164030097424984, 0.028773892670869827, 0.03270089253783226, 0.05045923590660095, -0.0017381362849846482, 0.007264141924679279, -0.041270554065704346, -0.06612811237573624, 0.01090268511325121, -0.0186066385358572, -0.04697716608643532, -0.009975280612707138, 0.008699551224708557, 0.06217702850699425, 0.03509276360273361, 0.0014855002518743277, -0.01318424753844738, 0.036143239587545395, -0.013450609520077705, -0.035564132034778595, 0.023259812965989113, 0.008430800400674343, 0.04430977627635002, -0.007650149520486593, -0.007680544629693031, 0.021825594827532768, -0.0015164220239967108, 0.029442794620990753, 0.032547477632761, -0.0019825221970677376, -0.008861093781888485, -0.04443081468343735, -0.01753321662545204, 0.01419200748205185, -0.04171352460980415, 0.008415447548031807, -0.01948746293783188, 0.0320507287979126, -0.039403628557920456, 0.010505039244890213, -0.020199375227093697, 0.011803360655903816, -0.03383854776620865, -0.005755361635237932, -0.07097811251878738, 0.02402278035879135, 0.016230372712016106, -0.023634571582078934, -0.09770151227712631, 0.017385100945830345, 0.022614989429712296, -0.00940870214253664, 0.008171732537448406, 0.028581291437149048, 0.029996639117598534, -0.04782826825976372, -0.0019321716390550137, -0.02712712623178959, -0.06480827927589417, -0.0053332592360675335, 0.023494431748986244, 0.02307424135506153, -0.0503619983792305, -0.02871290035545826, 0.02088632807135582, 0.08275730162858963, -0.03290250152349472, -0.03437448665499687, 0.00048725309898145497, -0.005135097075253725, -0.013954976573586464, 0.01118757575750351, 0.009142127819359303, -0.04180518537759781, 0.03283688426017761, 0.03147827461361885, 0.06079741194844246, 0.02016492187976837, 0.036195866763591766, 0.0019001717446371913, 0.025308694690465927, 0.04129550978541374, 0.023934949189424515, 0.007344398181885481, -0.06475889682769775, -0.0304853655397892, -0.07979351282119751, 0.04233778268098831, -0.015956345945596695, -0.03733115270733833, 0.02213256061077118, 0.017821237444877625, 0.01819576881825924, 0.01476025115698576, 0.016911964863538742, 0.021351628005504608, 0.020267009735107422, 0.015983277931809425, -0.0077556162141263485, -0.0399518720805645, 0.017082279548048973, -0.017854278907179832, -0.07747861742973328, -0.020956499502062798, -0.030843259766697884, -0.01724325679242611, 0.020214926451444626, -0.01982516050338745, -0.025414280593395233, 0.012906546704471111, 0.027362056076526642, -0.005147865973412991, -0.10791165381669998, 0.025497078895568848, -0.010040431283414364, -0.008065182715654373, 0.0037467132788151503, -0.029442597180604935, 0.07161135226488113, 0.053613580763339996, -0.016173889860510826, 0.07240835577249527, -0.02729671820998192, 0.0005163374589756131, 0.05593608319759369, 0.06348232179880142, -0.02137770503759384, -0.06066696718335152, -0.01790158450603485, 0.015935417264699936, 0.050170838832855225, -0.0023586570750921965, 0.001670890604145825, -0.020795978605747223, -0.010979713872075081, 0.016857199370861053, 0.008627197705209255, -0.024302653968334198, -0.002805735683068633, -0.019646450877189636, 0.03569788858294487, -0.017168696969747543, 0.06484545767307281, -0.01834091730415821, 0.032220449298620224, -0.031663913279771805, -0.032456833869218826, -0.03560444340109825, -0.012865155935287476, 0.008874647319316864, 0.004869604017585516, -0.06366290152072906, -0.01444974448531866, 0.053324636071920395, 0.0006200146162882447, 0.007907253690063953, 0.007756748236715794, -0.0002461724216118455, 0.025979744270443916, -0.015037303790450096, -0.02226976864039898, 0.016470307484269142, -0.025902196764945984, -0.06217961758375168, 0.07582497596740723, 0.048594631254673004, -0.02915571630001068, 0.00392121821641922, -0.04091666638851166, -0.014868457801640034, 0.05752610042691231, 0.00830955058336258, -0.014836613088846207, -0.023416457697749138, 0.055328045040369034, 0.008522705174982548, 0.03249616175889969, 0.022001303732395172, -0.0834524929523468, 0.039873238652944565, -0.013687367551028728, 0.0018152773845940828, -0.02354922704398632, -0.05599653348326683, 0.0811363086104393, -0.006759704556316137, 0.03067249059677124, 0.0037164618261158466, -0.09021822363138199, -0.012312725186347961, -0.006969818379729986, -0.015336310490965843, 0.07746469229459763, 0.021027464419603348, -0.019903317093849182, -0.017836397513747215, 0.03281480446457863, 0.050479352474212646, 0.06241787225008011, -0.06581827253103256, 0.040166012942790985, -0.01665138453245163, -0.06399241834878922, 0.005673123523592949, 0.017837295308709145, -0.052366629242897034, -0.028871752321720123, 0.027414368465542793, -0.0002691346453502774, -0.03702618554234505, 0.01700775697827339, -0.015762154012918472, 0.05978519469499588, -0.01219894364476204, -0.01972620189189911, -0.007095324341207743, 0.02122589573264122, -0.05092157423496246, 0.04009753093123436, 0.0027228340040892363, -0.021208491176366806, -0.007239965256303549, -0.004428205545991659, 0.10304874926805496, 0.09452717751264572, -0.025104165077209473, -0.003927869256585836, -0.002973326947540045, 0.04057791829109192, -0.01503226812928915, 0.016914188861846924, -0.014476570300757885, 0.03327172249555588, -0.02212974801659584, 0.004184831865131855, -0.041282057762145996, 0.07953594624996185, -0.04419836401939392, -0.01169030461460352, 0.06705334037542343, -0.019169436767697334, 0.05620059743523598, 0.0002638063160702586, -0.006448759231716394, 0.024387625977396965, -0.016572533175349236, 0.0004876983002759516, -0.0029894064646214247, -0.012777022086083889, 0.021254394203424454, -0.00018162741616833955, -0.03208782896399498, 0.01140767801553011, -0.05849609896540642, -0.020941706374287605, -0.01981292851269245, 0.1026236042380333, 0.03509778156876564, 0.018850991502404213, -0.01764242723584175, 0.014525498263537884, -0.036818720400333405, -0.05324539169669151, -0.13202904164791107, -0.033221181482076645, -0.02322721853852272, 0.05907966569066048, 0.01696178875863552, 0.011371886357665062, -0.027933580800890923, 0.017226366326212883, -0.01281669456511736, -0.01488469447940588, -0.014830694533884525, 0.023573262616991997, -0.012029340490698814, -0.045894134789705276, -0.023630404844880104, 0.027743862941861153, 0.06958027184009552, -0.0083643589168787, -0.028697606176137924, -0.01629864051938057, -0.0506056509912014, 0.01594032719731331, 0.025800447911024094, -0.010920626111328602, 0.007825563661754131, -0.012845223769545555, 0.03133260831236839, -0.04363977164030075, -0.005085385404527187, 0.02875429391860962, 0.06741715222597122, 0.05293482169508934, 0.01589648239314556, -0.016200099140405655, -0.007723455782979727, -0.028406597673892975, 0.004422781523317099, -0.03145868331193924, 0.004113608505576849, -0.02910025604069233, 0.002089651534333825, 0.03729351982474327, -0.005340061150491238, -0.25783562660217285, 0.012463412247598171, -0.01197411585599184, -0.015435543842613697, 0.010942481458187103, 0.0012508827494457364, 0.02383190579712391, -0.01985827460885048, -0.003904888639226556, 0.0061241257935762405, 0.003993203863501549, 0.01147432066500187, 0.003191722556948662, 0.07845611870288849, 0.008964368142187595, 0.004538018722087145, -0.016489867120981216, -0.010817578062415123, 0.0066407169215381145, 0.001468586502596736, -0.004271342419087887, -0.06229512393474579, 0.012822991237044334, 0.020220205187797546, 0.011295304633677006, 0.04681728407740593, -0.052150972187519073, -0.00021931024093646556, -0.03159686177968979, 0.0033617995213717222, -0.03393907845020294, -0.0668884813785553, 0.007402469869703054, 0.027582954615354538, 0.01348805520683527, 0.014206292107701302, 0.030407477170228958, -0.010726328939199448, 0.000858641171362251, 0.06572031229734421, 0.022582707926630974, -0.0008062717388384044, -0.03950231522321701, 0.010767225176095963, 0.07501643151044846, 0.014685439877212048, -0.036041345447301865, -0.0033358358778059483, 0.014455145224928856, 0.024441279470920563, -0.0027908256743103266, -0.04122433066368103, 0.004135717172175646, -0.007271047215908766, 0.018868498504161835, -0.00150963943451643, 0.017054887488484383, -0.03143513575196266, -0.014283611439168453, 0.014692513272166252, 0.008719310164451599, -0.05586305260658264, 0.004333490040153265, -0.03747306019067764, -0.0038186463061720133, -0.026332033798098564, -0.07934249937534332, -0.06814131885766983, 0.06585466116666794, -0.010221758857369423, -0.005524239037185907, -0.004657058976590633, -0.015439176000654697, -0.07957509160041809, 0.04026874899864197, -0.010053032077848911, -0.02733151987195015, 0.010771225206553936, -0.005958227906376123, 0.04908674582839012, 0.003776772180572152, -0.041428517550230026, -0.013944112695753574, 0.03226075693964958, 0.022516854107379913, -0.009770509786903858, 0.017836935818195343, -0.017196329310536385, -0.032889485359191895, -0.04195496439933777, 0.01912604086101055, 0.03234005346894264, 0.054066743701696396, -0.008567452430725098, 0.04369264096021652, 0.05298604816198349, 0.01778787188231945, 0.059928048402071, 0.01801983080804348, 0.012900191359221935, 0.04973224923014641, -0.07004700601100922, -0.0500899963080883, -0.04322824254631996, -0.0546160452067852, 0.04574286565184593, -0.02919256128370762, -0.009828733280301094, 0.03643301874399185, -0.016791902482509613, -0.0040098936296999454, -0.05606773495674133, -0.013948985375463963, -0.01600201427936554, -0.0036751299630850554, -0.003672282909974456, -0.013051697984337807, 0.009605873376131058, 0.004220906645059586, 0.0020397240296006203, -0.014011395163834095, 0.03507642820477486, -0.04769895598292351, 0.008245499804615974, 0.00039568572537973523, -0.005554846953600645, -0.020155932754278183, -0.027887091040611267, 0.0021801430266350508, -0.01873364858329296, 0.04327093064785004, 0.043924540281295776, -0.008503420278429985, 0.03559022769331932, 0.05334964394569397, 0.020317191258072853, -0.01602359302341938, -0.016948726028203964, 0.046735990792512894, -0.015834815800189972, 0.01353191863745451, 0.03950336202979088, 0.04706822335720062, 0.010402459651231766, -0.01563876122236252, 0.034399501979351044, 0.022336959838867188, -0.00521415751427412, 0.005510525777935982, -0.013882734812796116, 0.01941285841166973, -0.04785694181919098, 0.016153857111930847, -0.04704073816537857, -0.014046764932572842, -0.005913413595408201, 0.04772776737809181, -0.014088951982557774, 0.013118753209710121, -0.04814380407333374, 0.06141422316431999, 0.029655838385224342, -0.04818234592676163, -0.021660132333636284, 0.009476780891418457, 0.03763563930988312, -0.03007359616458416, 0.02764633297920227, 0.033583927899599075, 0.006867234595119953, 0.027135029435157776, -0.00858208816498518, -0.04586770758032799, -0.018766198307275772, 0.0010894190054386854, -0.007813491858541965, 0.013488818891346455, -0.0010900148190557957, -0.0728691890835762, 0.0295530054718256, 0.004612191114574671, -0.007804880850017071, -0.01831388846039772, 0.025529686361551285, 0.08696907758712769, 0.003891056403517723, -0.004235106986016035, 0.001642112503759563, -0.02856987528502941, 0.05498838052153587, -0.01155280601233244, 0.03219011425971985, -0.022293075919151306, -0.04831928387284279, -0.01632027141749859, -0.03562416881322861, -0.02988944575190544, 0.05403625965118408, -0.04662300646305084, 0.0013045715168118477, 0.018363280221819878, 0.0006105836946517229, -0.039332032203674316, -0.023841354995965958, 0.0037953101564198732, -0.06373859196901321, 0.043528445065021515, 0.04097364470362663, -0.025317270308732986, 0.013798518106341362, -0.004035662859678268, -0.004580674692988396, -0.042338769882917404, -0.01565316505730152, 0.014642552472651005, -0.012586908414959908, -0.0007669208571314812, 0.015577233396470547, 0.018995970487594604, 0.018808314576745033, 0.014036210253834724, -0.018020806834101677, 0.029853006824851036, 0.004741319455206394, -0.0024210878182202578, 0.07185417413711548, -0.027720557525753975, 0.003388460725545883, -0.03409238159656525, -0.015893906354904175, 0.003534765215590596, -0.06522565335035324, -0.0009256738121621311, 0.05244455859065056, 0.0021992032416164875, 0.021502560004591942, -0.0535445436835289, 0.04045291990041733, -0.029013194143772125, -0.010106147266924381, 0.02296365611255169, 0.012849804013967514, -0.049394793808460236, -0.02294217050075531, -0.009343139827251434, 0.03604191541671753, 0.02364206500351429, 0.004445589613169432, 0.03451305255293846, 0.01266961358487606, 0.016707560047507286, 0.01967903971672058, -0.10875944048166275, 0.020587420091032982, 0.05916636064648628, -0.0061472635716199875, -0.05849211663007736, -0.09625095129013062, -0.015253644436597824, 0.014647560194134712, -0.01911192759871483, 0.01288201566785574, -0.03733687847852707, 0.038613565266132355, 0.019651087000966072, 0.029259271919727325, -0.009928086772561073, -0.04273761063814163, 0.02679702267050743, -0.054798707365989685, -0.009090234525501728, -0.04584483429789543, -0.012892249971628189, 0.059991881251335144, -0.026352286338806152, 0.059710826724767685, 0.016523214057087898, -0.008873254992067814, 0.021273070946335793, -0.05287640169262886, -0.03011745773255825, 0.01074162870645523, -0.03239593654870987, 0.0005686156218871474, 0.012832493521273136, -0.052888087928295135, -0.005844591185450554, -0.03816646710038185, -0.06609082967042923, 0.026958178728818893, 0.006133873015642166, 0.03635554388165474, -0.022601354867219925, -0.02308248169720173, -0.02261452190577984, 0.005148889031261206, 0.03286450728774071, 0.0771588534116745, -0.015603833831846714, 0.023857679218053818, -0.05019453540444374, 0.056088533252477646, 0.03886021301150322, 0.01655830815434456, -0.0033949054777622223, 0.0057068211026489735, -0.007607948035001755, -0.052779704332351685, 0.046740442514419556, -0.004245612304657698, -0.006541373673826456, -0.07711271196603775, 0.047623954713344574, 0.02100420743227005, -0.05921553820371628, 0.0007104697288013995, 0.05176249146461487, -0.054593563079833984, 0.014298979192972183, 0.00020486724679358304, 0.0028669736348092556, 0.009880109690129757, 0.08041644096374512, 0.00018136922153644264, 0.002258421154692769, 0.05848216265439987, -0.001560733886435628, -0.005024146754294634, -0.01572171039879322, 0.05598292872309685, 0.09687105566263199, 0.04411095753312111, -0.00804186426103115, 0.056652069091796875, -0.013016861863434315, -0.04405444860458374, 0.004994875285774469, 0.009971771389245987, -0.015016118064522743, -0.02999649941921234, 0.03161605820059776, 0.08540292084217072, -0.003766373498365283, 0.07153568416833878, -0.0385233499109745, 0.015701444819569588, 0.021433508023619652, 0.012280832976102829, 0.015587575733661652, 0.028848087415099144, 0.039321888238191605, -0.014856915920972824, -0.02065645158290863, -0.025085052475333214, 0.018770731985569, 0.032902058213949203, 0.02514030784368515, -0.007324266247451305, 0.00016889545076992363, 0.0025544448290020227, 0.028658011928200722, 0.03050898388028145, 0.07504187524318695, -0.024864478036761284, -0.058088503777980804, -0.00069183181039989, 0.01257796585559845, 0.00867424812167883, 0.03708017244935036, 0.008717472665011883, -0.003808325622230768, 0.004189022816717625, -0.02798123098909855, 0.0007918353076092899, -0.006898499093949795, 0.048548851162195206, 0.0013211563928052783, -0.024188287556171417, -0.013397779315710068, 0.000605146458838135, 0.0009331877809017897, -0.05035250633955002, -0.03774162381887436, -0.036705221980810165, -0.01606673002243042, -0.06599008291959763, -0.059553228318691254, -0.019122445955872536, -0.023868292570114136, -0.01830410771071911, 0.006712598260492086, -0.06664340943098068, 0.024416323751211166, 0.04526061192154884, -0.05881740152835846, -0.007535005919635296, 0.027862224727869034, -0.016740724444389343, -0.002168715465813875, 0.020707493647933006, 0.057303231209516525, -0.008194440975785255, -0.0006607246468774974, 0.056752730160951614, 0.005301713477820158, 0.01134203840047121, -0.020653368905186653, 0.012061084620654583, -0.07541169971227646, 0.03825189918279648, 0.025435686111450195, -0.042520251125097275, -0.08219767361879349, 0.04032405465841293, -0.03838017210364342, 0.027944384142756462, 0.05491063371300697, -0.007956763729453087, 0.015278249979019165, -0.06826111674308777, -0.027611011639237404, -0.013956683687865734, -0.0017127423780038953, 0.05397520586848259, -0.0032203514128923416, 0.044612374156713486, 0.04810159653425217, -0.009055662900209427, -0.03132426738739014, 0.0321187824010849, -0.04052652791142464, 0.05399354174733162, -0.0350634902715683, -0.025384647771716118, -0.051898613572120667, -0.07136421650648117, -0.01191463228315115, 0.04030124470591545, -0.02046165056526661, -0.05867677181959152, 0.01817944087088108, -0.04404134675860405, 0.02452460117638111, -0.024356020614504814, 0.011180352419614792, -0.01771220937371254, -0.04997631534934044, -0.0326501727104187, -0.08812572062015533, 0.038786403834819794, 0.00023996391973923892, -0.0021526634227484465, -0.01438075490295887, -0.0418575257062912, -0.029360203072428703, 0.007343736011534929, 0.031045088544487953, 0.04615636169910431, 0.011394722387194633, -0.016366269439458847 ]
3,536
Diffusion Attribution Score: Evaluating Training Data Influence in Diffusion Models
https://openreview.net/forum?id=kuutidLf6R
[ "Jinxu Lin", "Linwei Tao", "Minjing Dong", "Chang Xu" ]
Spotlight
As diffusion models become increasingly popular, the misuse of copyrighted and private images has emerged as a major concern. One promising solution to mitigate this issue is identifying the contribution of specific training samples in generative models, a process known as data attribution. Existing data attribution methods for diffusion models typically quantify the contribution of a training sample by evaluating the change in diffusion loss when the sample is included or excluded from the training process. However, we argue that the direct usage of diffusion loss cannot represent such a contribution accurately due to the calculation of diffusion loss. Specifically, these approaches measure the divergence between predicted and ground truth distributions, which leads to an indirect comparison between the predicted distributions and cannot represent the variances between model behaviors. To address these issues, we aim to measure the direct comparison between predicted distributions with an attribution score to analyse the training sample importance, which is achieved by Diffusion Attribution Score (\textit{DAS}). Underpinned by rigorous theoretical analysis, we elucidate the effectiveness of DAS. Additionally, we explore strategies to accelerate DAS calculations, facilitating its application to large-scale diffusion models. Our extensive experiments across various datasets and diffusion models demonstrate that DAS significantly surpasses previous benchmarks in terms of the linear data-modelling score, establishing new state-of-the-art performance.
Diffusion Model; Data Attribution; Training Data Influence
We propose Diffusion Attribution Score in diffusion model which can be used to evaluate the influence of training sample in the generation. Our proposed method reached the State Of The Art performance compared with baseline method.
5,713
2410.18639
[ 0.0026329178363084793, -0.023763809353113174, -0.016720430925488472, 0.06082412973046303, 0.05142134428024292, 0.01403428427875042, 0.018748415634036064, -0.021748410537838936, 0.001118387095630169, -0.07081907987594604, -0.01719820313155651, -0.022503813728690147, -0.039153702557086945, 0.00021594671125058085, -0.0012834249064326286, 0.0471317321062088, 0.03171319141983986, 0.004705571569502354, 0.0018946334021165967, 0.031981777399778366, -0.021706240251660347, -0.03627721965312958, 0.015363655053079128, 0.011642669327557087, 0.00829458050429821, -0.021855734288692474, 0.059258706867694855, -0.003666461678221822, -0.04246823489665985, 0.01346452347934246, 0.04133884981274605, -0.010584020055830479, 0.02902965247631073, 0.003483028616756201, 0.022401204332709312, 0.006310225464403629, -0.02916383370757103, -0.00715467007830739, 0.018708044663071632, 0.01970878429710865, -0.037024471908807755, 0.014418304897844791, -0.017764486372470856, 0.007939179427921772, -0.05919588357210159, -0.021119792014360428, -0.09866610169410706, 0.026284249499440193, 0.02577478624880314, -0.0011993383523076773, -0.07902760803699493, 0.030822888016700745, -0.0029269058723002672, 0.0013290344504639506, 0.004499683156609535, 0.03024671971797943, 0.027310991659760475, -0.0590854212641716, -0.015970958396792412, -0.06564062833786011, -0.007258006837219, 0.022371061146259308, 0.009921382181346416, 0.003091869642958045, 0.021419474855065346, -0.028549224138259888, 0.020235799252986908, 0.03585338220000267, -0.04308393597602844, -0.03411528095602989, -0.00030518899438902736, -0.014721836894750595, -0.006713514681905508, -0.023024825379252434, -0.04835484176874161, -0.035318855196237564, 0.02404063753783703, 0.025140808895230293, 0.06443379819393158, -0.027304917573928833, 0.011108830571174622, 0.023805830627679825, -0.013648086227476597, 0.024501947686076164, -0.009540670551359653, -0.018625371158123016, -0.024818716570734978, -0.034972790628671646, -0.06173691153526306, 0.034879013895988464, -0.03420111909508705, -0.037688836455345154, 0.03199750557541847, 0.033327892422676086, 0.04035025089979172, -0.03303632512688637, 0.02974908985197544, 0.011189732700586319, 0.0009409202612005174, -0.026178661733865738, -0.02704194374382496, -0.016710039228200912, -0.014830216765403748, 0.037503406405448914, -0.0911833867430687, -0.020030170679092407, -0.01869112066924572, -0.007449719589203596, -0.03658869490027428, 0.0028207325376570225, 0.0037293999921530485, 0.022276287898421288, -0.019615478813648224, -0.01942957192659378, -0.0810086578130722, 0.025208184495568275, 0.004435266833752394, -0.01858017034828663, 0.015758903697133064, 0.010933457873761654, 0.05420621111989021, 0.06538911163806915, -0.016689691692590714, 0.059794094413518906, -0.008873050101101398, 0.027778035029768944, 0.05140668898820877, 0.024005424231290817, -0.048120249062776566, -0.0012978259474039078, 0.017266202718019485, 0.025575697422027588, 0.008708806708455086, -0.008612842299044132, 0.015486163087189198, -0.051717352122068405, 0.036053311079740524, 0.01683047227561474, 0.06017091125249863, -0.023636236786842346, 0.017205677926540375, -0.0009170406847260892, 0.037937331944704056, -0.024243706837296486, 0.04734499752521515, -0.033244844526052475, 0.015399989672005177, -0.02132088504731655, -0.04906114563345909, 0.0036996910348534584, 0.02855643443763256, 0.020219847559928894, 0.02300790138542652, -0.059011586010456085, 0.00953366607427597, 0.035229895263910294, 0.017825273796916008, 0.003860142547637224, -0.012069722637534142, 0.00198545609600842, 0.021858932450413704, -0.031637731939554214, -0.0015794706996530294, -0.000019698592950589955, 0.004937892779707909, -0.04850732162594795, 0.03671411797404289, 0.041154343634843826, -0.0327121801674366, -0.018306970596313477, -0.031136469915509224, -0.04620801657438278, 0.047038484364748, 0.021148042753338814, 0.004155358299612999, 0.039643630385398865, 0.03363043814897537, 0.04800510033965111, 0.03647738695144653, 0.02615634724497795, -0.08922559022903442, 0.034854706376791, 0.011367714032530785, -0.007650593761354685, 0.003620473202317953, -0.015168530866503716, 0.07957752794027328, -0.006696077063679695, 0.0017717385198920965, 0.055241040885448456, -0.10586783289909363, -0.032426781952381134, 0.046283505856990814, -0.02187851071357727, 0.03502117097377777, 0.00040901105967350304, 0.008088067173957825, 0.025408081710338593, 0.038064491003751755, 0.012884761206805706, 0.03991364315152168, -0.03067573718726635, 0.0375819131731987, -0.042776674032211304, -0.027334654703736305, -0.0008757235482335091, 0.04022956266999245, -0.05340685322880745, -0.061681464314460754, 0.017703356221318245, -0.026331938803195953, -0.004146086052060127, -0.011999035254120827, 0.03112231008708477, 0.004899985156953335, -0.0031884415075182915, -0.007484364788979292, 0.03093324415385723, 0.011885997839272022, -0.035626113414764404, 0.056104131042957306, 0.04475364834070206, -0.02234417386353016, 0.0194082111120224, -0.019808445125818253, 0.08886772394180298, 0.0739457979798317, -0.012956992723047733, 0.005296772345900536, 0.027604367583990097, -0.01608808897435665, 0.00653086556121707, 0.03334943205118179, -0.0032114372588694096, 0.029521780088543892, -0.019759954884648323, -0.003553336951881647, -0.02799147553741932, 0.08845216780900955, -0.04787818714976311, 0.01168676558881998, 0.04258326068520546, -0.010326651856303215, 0.07490967214107513, -0.010223668068647385, 0.037885114550590515, 0.037543367594480515, -0.03633347153663635, -0.025974206626415253, -0.028264068067073822, -0.013798550702631474, 0.009631838649511337, 0.007200196851044893, -0.04808717221021652, 0.032048434019088745, -0.04898083582520485, -0.007099456153810024, -0.0020571912173181772, 0.03978665918111801, 0.033082589507102966, 0.038430068641901016, 0.017074542120099068, -0.028699876740574837, -0.020148253068327904, -0.009028160944581032, -0.09567683935165405, -0.030526725575327873, -0.00794761162251234, 0.04671777784824371, 0.010133876465260983, 0.08103670179843903, -0.0054143196903169155, 0.002467870945110917, -0.038824137300252914, -0.02344788797199726, 0.015426001511514187, 0.002686204854398966, 0.011455487459897995, -0.04551639407873154, 0.002161181066185236, -0.013108673505485058, 0.0915994718670845, -0.023635797202587128, -0.0062037804163992405, -0.005338518880307674, -0.04144829884171486, -0.0068846773356199265, 0.017527293413877487, 0.00569369038566947, 0.02467859908938408, 0.01863127388060093, 0.027976956218481064, 0.013778387568891048, 0.02440127544105053, 0.02635611779987812, 0.05281896889209747, 0.027895931154489517, -0.004433136899024248, -0.004213211592286825, 0.018246769905090332, -0.0024115375708788633, 0.00662511819973588, 0.015326034277677536, 0.010275457985699177, -0.029019111767411232, -0.03975651413202286, 0.006557461805641651, 0.010819156654179096, -0.29091981053352356, 0.02493540197610855, 0.016796965152025223, 0.033020615577697754, 0.01926780305802822, -0.05003355070948601, 0.04895582050085068, -0.027565373107790947, -0.03440241888165474, -0.0013888028915971518, -0.0016956329345703125, 0.023234380409121513, 0.009752554818987846, 0.05310966819524765, 0.020723354071378708, 0.03893626481294632, 0.008177528157830238, -0.04064345732331276, -0.004766072146594524, 0.01855853758752346, -0.03245219215750694, -0.06226605176925659, -0.017823588103055954, 0.02005368284881115, -0.0052315425127744675, 0.035637255758047104, -0.08324496448040009, -0.0127076655626297, -0.02738696150481701, 0.0011130139464512467, 0.02115345560014248, -0.043242815881967545, -0.02634352259337902, 0.04954449459910393, 0.016652226448059082, -0.029634812846779823, 0.032473836094141006, 0.006770002190023661, -0.027223987504839897, -0.0019538928754627705, 0.019984837621450424, 0.01510859839618206, -0.017347728833556175, 0.021631300449371338, 0.05222378298640251, 0.007002442143857479, -0.03747807443141937, -0.012706260196864605, -0.006676520686596632, 0.029124317690730095, -0.002079636324197054, -0.003938706591725349, -0.04533136636018753, 0.0021419513504952192, -0.05825440213084221, -0.017912985756993294, -0.01983672007918358, -0.013066815212368965, -0.016941774636507034, 0.025247270241379738, -0.0036628914531320333, -0.029047489166259766, -0.004834003746509552, -0.03139541298151016, -0.025681423023343086, -0.028004765510559082, -0.08072977513074875, -0.06059122830629349, 0.03373994678258896, 0.014998375438153744, -0.020951557904481888, 0.02281476929783821, -0.006317206658422947, -0.10562663525342941, 0.011288588866591454, -0.007959501817822456, 0.013384953141212463, -0.014278821647167206, -0.018117733299732208, 0.052158426493406296, -0.0019626396242529154, -0.036375924944877625, 0.005729146767407656, -0.010694047436118126, -0.019508469849824905, 0.0026321785990148783, 0.02238970249891281, -0.01148733589798212, 0.005741323344409466, -0.04204923287034035, 0.06474237143993378, 0.02897007204592228, 0.025386685505509377, 0.01225252915173769, 0.025098226964473724, 0.05312070995569229, 0.04113065078854561, 0.08045980334281921, 0.024326572194695473, 0.02552216127514839, 0.027788646519184113, -0.08772210031747818, -0.027318084612488747, -0.0697917565703392, -0.026360560208559036, 0.020845480263233185, -0.06581151485443115, -0.007860909216105938, 0.013031351380050182, -0.04533948376774788, -0.030095690861344337, -0.015354166738688946, -0.0206456258893013, -0.021626928821206093, -0.00002850449709512759, -0.029903216287493706, -0.005242068786174059, 0.013519537635147572, 0.035655587911605835, -0.033398620784282684, -0.0005587805644609034, 0.027916595339775085, -0.02851204201579094, -0.017678460106253624, 0.004358324687927961, 0.024110691621899605, -0.01010886486619711, -0.00031562757794745266, -0.018259713426232338, -0.0196856502443552, 0.02867644466459751, 0.03983965888619423, -0.005126278847455978, 0.026871180161833763, 0.0509868860244751, -0.002852840581908822, -0.016070226207375526, -0.009879344142973423, 0.018650049343705177, -0.06039922684431076, 0.026573535054922104, -0.005749046336859465, 0.05117105320096016, 0.03509828448295593, 0.07721211761236191, -0.013499020598828793, 0.02229776605963707, 0.023835621774196625, 0.005373519379645586, -0.04834583029150963, 0.0408908873796463, -0.05559861660003662, -0.031183205544948578, -0.02267644554376602, 0.005709871184080839, -0.008378894068300724, -0.0018532450776547194, -0.036135122179985046, 0.004903851542621851, -0.0565335750579834, 0.05026131868362427, 0.013461758382618427, -0.03143421187996864, -0.01875203661620617, -0.01744125783443451, 0.04918034002184868, 0.0015342117985710502, -0.015610863454639912, 0.017038924619555473, -0.009504608809947968, 0.026204107329249382, -0.023020973429083824, -0.026493065059185028, -0.028269199654459953, -0.023937633261084557, 0.016828380525112152, 0.025516385212540627, 0.014708168804645538, -0.016162114217877388, 0.03522242233157158, -0.013430836610496044, -0.038343485444784164, -0.012349977158010006, 0.010307914577424526, 0.07151107490062714, 0.03321226313710213, 0.0014902240363880992, 0.001959890127182007, -0.059862006455659866, 0.047019846737384796, -0.020750485360622406, -0.0012358992826193571, -0.016279952600598335, -0.05228221416473389, -0.03713037446141243, -0.04190732166171074, 0.012880835682153702, 0.02267329767346382, -0.015725480392575264, 0.005253832787275314, -0.020406387746334076, 0.013612207025289536, -0.01755852997303009, 0.016332047060132027, 0.017898008227348328, -0.07559794187545776, 0.02466074377298355, 0.055547550320625305, -0.050791870802640915, 0.033777572214603424, -0.0067191580310463905, -0.056446727365255356, -0.10432460904121399, -0.021504973992705345, 0.012822020798921585, -0.04125049710273743, -0.019329816102981567, -0.04718712717294693, 0.028191059827804565, 0.0068213678896427155, 0.020839866250753403, 0.009736285544931889, -0.008467982523143291, 0.017192821949720383, 0.004141135141253471, 0.023360103368759155, -0.03399413451552391, 0.0036249025724828243, -0.035517267882823944, -0.03995607793331146, 0.01140049658715725, -0.03332570567727089, 0.0015593619318678975, 0.041826024651527405, 0.008927748538553715, -0.007861877791583538, -0.0460733026266098, 0.036888543516397476, -0.002381663303822279, -0.011316251009702682, -0.024107862263917923, 0.008308813907206059, -0.030973583459854126, -0.00804917886853218, 0.022884318605065346, 0.006697377655655146, -0.024984534829854965, 0.010482456535100937, 0.017607776448130608, 0.03795560449361801, 0.04168025404214859, 0.02532254531979561, -0.050588566809892654, 0.007787282112985849, 0.07196319103240967, -0.049815140664577484, -0.0076789455488324165, -0.07354659587144852, -0.04437500238418579, 0.022026414051651955, 0.002251190133392811, 0.03608577698469162, 0.01979045942425728, 0.013068493455648422, 0.02166094444692135, 0.017792977392673492, 0.013390548527240753, -0.0006111824768595397, 0.010700118727982044, -0.050900571048259735, 0.003338176291435957, -0.051483459770679474, -0.005809835158288479, 0.06010667607188225, -0.06475352495908737, 0.03782229125499725, 0.014072843827307224, -0.03101518377661705, 0.04771748557686806, -0.07312117516994476, -0.07654941827058792, -0.0030062024015933275, -0.019614767283201218, -0.011188267730176449, 0.006146253552287817, -0.04613308981060982, 0.0004756272828672081, -0.0035425289534032345, -0.046299487352371216, -0.0011286757653579116, 0.024325869977474213, 0.03355136886239052, -0.0048721651546657085, 0.018346097320318222, -0.020709222182631493, -0.004587569274008274, 0.032277267426252365, 0.05111713334918022, 0.000144910576636903, 0.01697482354938984, -0.01650019735097885, 0.05438219755887985, 0.025505470111966133, 0.00024138808657880872, 0.029544861987233162, 0.016834944486618042, -0.02700556255877018, -0.05330989882349968, 0.05550302565097809, -0.0016740496503189206, -0.020884037017822266, -0.07071246206760406, 0.05304780602455139, 0.02516237273812294, -0.0653856098651886, -0.035180289298295975, 0.056979820132255554, -0.01720847375690937, 0.027108317241072655, 0.006792058236896992, 0.002072142204269767, -0.002156706526875496, 0.05387140437960625, 0.019358325749635696, 0.06483137607574463, 0.03813178464770317, 0.006276350934058428, 0.008096326142549515, 0.009330885484814644, 0.07711837440729141, 0.07386183738708496, 0.06633302569389343, 0.015551669523119926, 0.07554807513952255, -0.021800469607114792, -0.0557442344725132, 0.007147572468966246, 0.031662099063396454, -0.027516191825270653, -0.0431223064661026, 0.004571881610900164, 0.11977313458919525, 0.0007912359433248639, 0.04550827667117119, -0.05085037648677826, -0.004327956587076187, 0.01724174991250038, 0.013000947423279285, -0.0094996253028512, -0.01764819398522377, 0.007021646946668625, 0.012463772669434547, -0.05541299283504486, 0.029507309198379517, 0.01529719028621912, -0.011212269775569439, 0.032077789306640625, 0.00694679981097579, -0.014710105955600739, 0.009214278310537338, 0.02490750327706337, 0.034386590123176575, 0.0812317281961441, -0.03637033328413963, -0.028157999739050865, -0.009366493672132492, 0.013672580942511559, 0.024846114218235016, 0.05694783478975296, 0.006014436483383179, -0.01409489568322897, 0.010454577393829823, -0.031993165612220764, 0.008207307197153568, 0.03890775144100189, 0.004078072030097246, 0.030939698219299316, -0.043529707938432693, -0.022902939468622208, 0.03680611029267311, -0.013980814255774021, -0.03632668778300285, -0.03235483169555664, -0.015265828929841518, -0.05069577693939209, -0.07283103466033936, -0.059457484632730484, 0.045031048357486725, 0.012374830432236195, -0.03951168432831764, -0.004792027175426483, -0.033091962337493896, 0.018206672742962837, 0.05557126924395561, -0.10086409002542496, -0.021120678633451462, 0.02977052703499794, -0.004291322082281113, -0.013696827925741673, 0.006702722050249577, 0.00991829764097929, -0.04085167497396469, -0.01895281672477722, 0.05272771045565605, 0.021032974123954773, 0.007840543054044247, -0.02229626290500164, 0.00003999542605015449, -0.08594255894422531, 0.021537385880947113, 0.011421584524214268, -0.06882090121507645, -0.09116947650909424, 0.05723757669329643, -0.018428368493914604, 0.00626969151198864, 0.07038544863462448, 0.013265563175082207, -0.0178469717502594, -0.0257774218916893, -0.005689518991857767, -0.009911703877151012, 0.0215012114495039, 0.06356292963027954, -0.03104531019926071, 0.10402879863977432, 0.05684025585651398, -0.030272865667939186, -0.031653810292482376, 0.0321815088391304, -0.013145605102181435, 0.005393841303884983, -0.023979218676686287, 0.0002532651415094733, -0.03220181167125702, -0.10552959144115448, -0.0015658839838579297, 0.030593913048505783, -0.034064460545778275, -0.021651729941368103, -0.0034939218312501907, -0.02729378268122673, 0.02694198302924633, -0.027015961706638336, -0.0036225970834493637, 0.005685958545655012, -0.01938985101878643, -0.022803086787462234, -0.06446370482444763, 0.020782604813575745, -0.012337848544120789, 0.005674674641340971, -0.00019736585090868175, -0.06777610629796982, -0.013593623414635658, 0.002834487473592162, 0.04977122321724892, -0.0076125371269881725, 0.007178671192377806, -0.028485078364610672 ]
3,537
Uncovering Gaps in How Humans and LLMs Interpret Subjective Language
https://openreview.net/forum?id=gye2U9uNXx
[ "Erik Jones", "Arjun Patrawala", "Jacob Steinhardt" ]
Spotlight
Humans often rely on subjective natural language to direct language models (LLMs); for example, users might instruct the LLM to write an *enthusiastic* blogpost, while developers might train models to be *helpful* and *harmless* using LLM-based edits. The LLM’s *operational semantics* of such subjective phrases---how it adjusts its behavior when each phrase is included in the prompt---thus dictates how aligned it is with human intent. In this work, we uncover instances of *misalignment* between LLMs' actual operational semantics and what humans expect. Our method, TED (thesaurus error detector), first constructs a thesaurus that captures whether two phrases have similar operational semantics according to the LLM. It then elicits failures by unearthing disagreements between this thesaurus and a human-constructed reference. TED routinely produces surprising instances of misalignment; for example, Mistral 7B Instruct produces more *harassing* outputs when it edits text to be *witty*, and Llama 3 8B Instruct produces *dishonest* articles when instructed to make the articles *enthusiastic*. Our results demonstrate that humans can uncover unexpected LLM behavior by scrutinizing relationships between abstract concepts, without supervising outputs directly.
safety, alignment, constitutional ai, language model failures, misalignment, automated evaluation, automated red-teaming
null
5,672
2503.04113
[ 0.027106856927275658, -0.0028327719774097204, 0.008521058596670628, 0.02842247113585472, 0.0551566556096077, -0.009861922822892666, 0.04695215821266174, 0.04691585525870323, -0.014531200751662254, 0.013620933517813683, -0.04575066640973091, 0.06319938600063324, -0.04322037845849991, -0.022142983973026276, -0.016751650720834732, 0.04855654388666153, 0.02328825742006302, 0.014370680786669254, 0.017055165022611618, -0.026491288095712662, 0.01043966505676508, -0.01307620294392109, -0.010898037813603878, -0.029274245724081993, 0.03857080638408661, 0.018141649663448334, 0.029863867908716202, -0.011936348862946033, -0.04153265058994293, 0.026111073791980743, 0.02900801971554756, 0.0036984526086598635, 0.006898307707160711, -0.007199047598987818, -0.022256705909967422, -0.00556976068764925, -0.03929218649864197, 0.004547550342977047, 0.021071946248412132, 0.0335952453315258, -0.0315522700548172, 0.02263769879937172, -0.009807567112147808, -0.02531401999294758, -0.08284055441617966, 0.015410744585096836, -0.1155281513929367, 0.02713441476225853, -0.003198443679139018, -0.032508909702301025, -0.11223944276571274, 0.03858816623687744, 0.01876082643866539, -0.00838608480989933, -0.002879468724131584, 0.04833481088280678, 0.03768528625369072, -0.09226864576339722, -0.02358713187277317, -0.03913046419620514, -0.025295086205005646, 0.029145874083042145, 0.004825151991099119, -0.014758070930838585, 0.026823068037629128, -0.0009831491624936461, -0.02948375791311264, 0.01221634354442358, -0.050435539335012436, -0.025374049320816994, -0.014558153226971626, 0.002351899864152074, -0.026644617319107056, -0.01026321854442358, -0.004924923647195101, -0.041846729815006256, 0.0222175195813179, 0.05316074937582016, 0.034876201301813126, -0.008311898447573185, -0.023311106488108635, 0.025442158803343773, 0.02011985518038273, 0.048809465020895004, 0.025580834597349167, -0.002200461458414793, -0.002807761775329709, -0.000055370834161294624, -0.05724792182445526, 0.009971680119633675, 0.0021766095887869596, -0.05586065351963043, 0.04527397081255913, 0.04007765278220177, 0.02546541951596737, 0.041624054312705994, 0.0346829853951931, 0.018100913614034653, -0.03652600198984146, 0.010039526037871838, -0.01565088890492916, -0.03644033893942833, 0.03918459638953209, 0.03153358772397041, -0.08386468887329102, -0.035640519112348557, -0.017505178228020668, -0.023408561944961548, 0.003209275659173727, -0.007907694205641747, -0.04471616446971893, -0.0022007888182997704, 0.003038849215954542, 0.00975852645933628, -0.04522261023521423, 0.020029732957482338, 0.010509148240089417, 0.02682376466691494, 0.004931735806167126, 0.011619511991739273, 0.053694941103458405, 0.020129183307290077, 0.018115516752004623, 0.05988984555006027, -0.03793884441256523, -0.0017324609216302633, -0.014153007417917252, 0.04708124324679375, -0.010394447483122349, -0.016069890931248665, -0.015670323744416237, 0.04146241769194603, 0.011580887250602245, 0.01609806902706623, -0.007120699621737003, 0.018558023497462273, 0.05008883774280548, -0.016760023310780525, 0.04425892233848572, 0.044015925377607346, 0.0014371388824656606, 0.0010345692280679941, 0.052779559046030045, -0.040627725422382355, 0.06734126806259155, -0.006830674596130848, 0.008448171429336071, 0.0027330697048455477, -0.04246874898672104, -0.006122921593487263, 0.015697557479143143, -0.0302805844694376, 0.021328281611204147, -0.04786009341478348, 0.04670374095439911, 0.06090998649597168, 0.03001965954899788, 0.006944991182535887, 0.03356800600886345, 0.029158543795347214, -0.010652785189449787, 0.007407741155475378, -0.09611111879348755, -0.01836533658206463, 0.00538791436702013, -0.0768374353647232, -0.016424652189016342, 0.0012298112269490957, -0.0447244793176651, 0.008620848879218102, -0.020129350945353508, -0.026587221771478653, 0.05484776571393013, -0.028134338557720184, -0.058022260665893555, 0.018629351630806923, 0.036568574607372284, 0.03501459211111069, 0.05514589324593544, 0.04668932408094406, -0.073541060090065, 0.014907008036971092, -0.02640315517783165, -0.013088474981486797, 0.053783904761075974, -0.001161932130344212, 0.04319743439555168, -0.027624953538179398, -0.0057927947491407394, 0.02749646082520485, -0.0662967637181282, -0.026779625564813614, 0.00991781335324049, -0.0001794860727386549, 0.08146487176418304, -0.028215553611516953, 0.000013522974768420681, 0.07154082506895065, 0.03458061441779137, 0.06126849725842476, 0.03728833422064781, -0.009583202190697193, 0.041950758546590805, 0.005974083673208952, -0.01667633280158043, 0.01740090921521187, 0.046010177582502365, -0.021494219079613686, -0.03923258185386658, 0.007139519788324833, -0.03779911622405052, 0.013481475412845612, 0.0398438461124897, -0.019061291590332985, 0.03682078421115875, -0.012675801292061806, 0.01700330153107643, -0.011471454054117203, 0.010726701468229294, -0.05949465557932854, 0.02778426930308342, 0.02915284037590027, 0.021992728114128113, -0.0284236129373312, -0.04271698370575905, 0.08060520887374878, 0.0620819628238678, -0.039851412177085876, -0.02017425000667572, 0.020574767142534256, 0.001516130636446178, 0.006236140616238117, 0.013612007722258568, -0.03650505468249321, -0.006203636527061462, -0.005861491430550814, 0.019770093262195587, -0.04955168813467026, 0.04782130569219589, -0.011599416844546795, -0.029690930619835854, 0.05180824548006058, -0.02493583969771862, 0.06777089089155197, -0.020715106278657913, 0.026076747104525566, 0.00808869767934084, -0.016527147963643074, -0.023260893300175667, -0.0001827375526772812, -0.01660303771495819, -0.006079535000026226, 0.0038584067951887846, -0.013833715580403805, 0.005681986454874277, -0.05524827539920807, -0.020969528704881668, -0.013729922473430634, 0.0685330331325531, 0.05118968337774277, 0.009781528264284134, 0.05622292682528496, 0.0019888652022928, -0.041242245584726334, 0.017954373732209206, -0.07260987162590027, -0.033991336822509766, 0.0022626384161412716, -0.0011911630863323808, 0.0055180499330163, 0.01984407566487789, -0.018768994137644768, 0.027902765199542046, -0.013575071468949318, 0.031022343784570694, 0.029325010254979134, 0.04079727083444595, -0.03208725154399872, -0.02306412160396576, -0.007026793900877237, -0.02892303839325905, 0.019393689930438995, -0.029295077547430992, -0.010956446640193462, -0.029166419059038162, -0.05717269331216812, -0.008477751165628433, -0.030122825875878334, -0.001418402185663581, 0.002021700143814087, 0.011195551604032516, -0.011602981016039848, 0.04380972683429718, 0.002459337003529072, 0.05006121098995209, 0.030624153092503548, 0.02702580764889717, -0.017980866134166718, -0.019058743491768837, 0.03810453042387962, -0.03298322856426239, -0.004118079785257578, 0.032051730901002884, 0.02332945168018341, 0.031913645565509796, 0.004493106156587601, 0.019398944452404976, -0.0034416664857417345, -0.2885558307170868, -0.025743752717971802, 0.02679179236292839, -0.04429470747709274, 0.011244270019233227, 0.0013575626071542501, 0.050585418939590454, -0.03603613004088402, -0.02205321006476879, 0.04061393812298775, 0.011870837770402431, 0.04252021759748459, 0.037525396794080734, 0.05587014928460121, 0.029332490637898445, 0.01828565075993538, -0.004578775726258755, -0.04068537428975105, -0.006855478044599295, 0.04759068042039871, -0.019344788044691086, -0.04896382987499237, -0.03083779476583004, 0.04836191609501839, 0.02940461039543152, 0.06358329951763153, -0.04819488897919655, 0.0009235286852344871, -0.038473282009363174, -0.0002928535977844149, 0.0007617389201186597, -0.008103805594146252, -0.020436514168977737, 0.021061912178993225, -0.00603098189458251, -0.0036188915837556124, 0.0379573255777359, -0.021829817444086075, 0.048345357179641724, 0.047484561800956726, -0.0014066669391468167, -0.03659837320446968, -0.005363045260310173, -0.006951256189495325, 0.06848063319921494, 0.00762978894636035, -0.0799035057425499, -0.03688501566648483, -0.014979743398725986, 0.021271809935569763, -0.022991977632045746, -0.024967631325125694, -0.011409933678805828, 0.025606533512473106, 0.008621366694569588, -0.01903250440955162, 0.019361600279808044, -0.03828726336359978, -0.021944258362054825, -0.03904799744486809, -0.011835668236017227, -0.007648739032447338, -0.02510048821568489, -0.012678125873208046, -0.035579174757003784, -0.03262341767549515, -0.0561227984726429, -0.033152833580970764, 0.05801648274064064, 0.06316638737916946, -0.004935638513416052, 0.014363358728587627, -0.015452473424375057, -0.09270526468753815, -0.003139857668429613, -0.004424778278917074, -0.02906040847301483, -0.044224973767995834, -0.0074445526115596294, -0.02024066261947155, -0.038715917617082596, -0.04818157106637955, -0.004833054728806019, 0.03480976074934006, 0.02823689393699169, -0.05093781650066376, 0.02563309110701084, -0.02628682367503643, -0.049774326384067535, -0.04765811562538147, 0.046886980533599854, 0.01908930577337742, -0.04832815006375313, 0.015022879466414452, 0.033014409244060516, 0.04462895914912224, 0.01732679270207882, 0.04758806154131889, 0.04154921695590019, 0.019680330529808998, 0.035393331199884415, -0.08349975943565369, 0.006036592647433281, -0.0030153486877679825, -0.019607486203312874, 0.03079250454902649, -0.06378082931041718, -0.033213190734386444, 0.049741391092538834, -0.03535642474889755, -0.04968598484992981, -0.01034951489418745, 0.0014735390432178974, 0.010771299712359905, -0.045990362763404846, -0.014404382556676865, 0.009655291214585304, 0.018742777407169342, 0.022154392674565315, -0.00646767346188426, -0.018588265404105186, 0.024665284901857376, -0.025797683745622635, 0.011473532766103745, -0.03915581479668617, -0.01862950064241886, -0.02311207540333271, -0.04084497690200806, -0.013807316310703754, 0.00477857980877161, 0.030664632096886635, 0.006330230738967657, 0.03843236342072487, 0.014490042813122272, 0.0406440794467926, -0.004815384745597839, 0.015603192150592804, -0.01953849010169506, 0.0003614293527789414, -0.033712003380060196, 0.019139498472213745, -0.04099782556295395, 0.03441021963953972, 0.05394498258829117, 0.018491094931960106, -0.032585788518190384, 0.0280582495033741, -0.03438058868050575, -0.023715179413557053, 0.03329237923026085, 0.04690733179450035, -0.02211642824113369, 0.024224329739809036, -0.02394699491560459, 0.014829490333795547, -0.006182943936437368, -0.0029561310075223446, 0.007615284528583288, -0.0002021515101660043, -0.046159107238054276, 0.012098539620637894, -0.006996436044573784, -0.004889423958957195, 0.008734235540032387, 0.024100683629512787, 0.003066812874749303, -0.02229924499988556, 0.002787135075777769, 0.029248086735606194, 0.020460879430174828, 0.01781565696001053, -0.02764996327459812, -0.02853103168308735, -0.01570431888103485, -0.043885428458452225, -0.00947722140699625, 0.01899493671953678, -0.04165332764387131, -0.046837106347084045, 0.07078007608652115, 0.001999286701902747, -0.02371155098080635, 0.01894577220082283, -0.0074019827879965305, 0.07829227298498154, 0.020856371149420738, 0.02131395787000656, -0.015257874503731728, -0.029210863634943962, -0.0005564497550949454, -0.020978370681405067, -0.0037716703955084085, -0.03461078926920891, -0.02809772826731205, -0.06919833272695541, -0.03380589187145233, 0.03702112287282944, -0.002517124405130744, 0.003162866923958063, -0.025831470265984535, -0.017978571355342865, 0.011413772590458393, -0.049817271530628204, -0.04139314591884613, 0.05258367955684662, -0.11293873935937881, 0.021853232756257057, -0.008630350232124329, -0.014237675815820694, 0.027698609977960587, -0.06621189415454865, -0.038570765405893326, -0.04856018349528313, -0.046902887523174286, 0.02042365074157715, -0.03362135961651802, -0.03752701357007027, -0.049414798617362976, -0.01577967032790184, 0.005290322471410036, 0.0012894392712041736, -0.023257287219166756, -0.014733107760548592, -0.0019414140842854977, -0.00002174592373194173, -0.005633444990962744, -0.03741142898797989, -0.04638097435235977, 0.022508570924401283, -0.05436313524842262, 0.00963633507490158, -0.03175454959273338, 0.02155953273177147, 0.04373254254460335, -0.04133849963545799, -0.02172212116420269, -0.040255408734083176, 0.0004761231248266995, -0.00043614633614197373, -0.009428825229406357, 0.024749886244535446, -0.034047409892082214, -0.01591089367866516, 0.015427214093506336, 0.019640984013676643, 0.03974207118153572, -0.00012233728193677962, -0.019781053066253662, -0.02623334340751171, 0.029606414958834648, 0.002794456435367465, 0.0014144909800961614, -0.026762867346405983, 0.02031990885734558, 0.07694671303033829, -0.02602813020348549, -0.028432242572307587, -0.051639389246702194, -0.054528672248125076, 0.00685633672401309, 0.014166338369250298, 0.025615831837058067, -0.03508799523115158, 0.05136110261082649, -0.005412548314779997, 0.049695901572704315, 0.011214293539524078, 0.01924935169517994, 0.041234664618968964, -0.03932322934269905, 0.009192422963678837, -0.06984002143144608, -0.015336982905864716, 0.04343728721141815, -0.027543094009160995, -0.007012037094682455, -0.0161097701638937, -0.03043142333626747, 0.055229540914297104, -0.02062646485865116, -0.026671571657061577, 0.008454890921711922, -0.002215077867731452, -0.01650061272084713, 0.04193839430809021, -0.055515289306640625, 0.019187096506357193, -0.0026333173736929893, -0.05220882222056389, -0.008259049616754055, -0.019929740577936172, 0.06382028013467789, 0.0044979313388466835, 0.019321510568261147, -0.013408144004642963, -0.006366427522152662, 0.018714401870965958, 0.057565707713365555, 0.03461601585149765, 0.02789844386279583, -0.015460394322872162, 0.052878785878419876, 0.0495794378221035, -0.0004476633039303124, 0.011209598742425442, -0.01120174303650856, -0.03537536412477493, -0.05799059942364693, 0.0735931321978569, -0.013141156174242496, -0.010824310593307018, -0.04221666231751442, 0.06224903091788292, 0.036646608263254166, -0.027456555515527725, -0.030671676620841026, 0.03479516878724098, -0.03187989816069603, 0.021535329520702362, -0.0033143775071948767, 0.029698040336370468, -0.0012197603937238455, 0.07175396382808685, 0.029759861528873444, 0.06482119858264923, 0.06468640267848969, 0.004055136349052191, -0.012656591832637787, 0.05595565214753151, 0.06622965633869171, 0.06924446672201157, 0.07727116346359253, 0.031060034409165382, 0.08264365047216415, -0.03431566804647446, -0.05514630302786827, -0.0034244495909661055, 0.03010573424398899, -0.0014855299377813935, -0.032750602811574936, 0.006965126376599073, 0.05419468134641647, -0.00999568309634924, 0.04477126523852348, -0.062184687703847885, -0.004700490273535252, 0.031565386801958084, 0.05875365436077118, 0.008269463665783405, 0.04282534867525101, 0.021942827850580215, -0.00012153021089034155, -0.023887507617473602, -0.01975405216217041, 0.017709441483020782, -0.03804062306880951, -0.009147481061518192, 0.010198998264968395, -0.018564598634839058, 0.007850372232496738, -0.05162568390369415, 0.08262480795383453, 0.12853145599365234, -0.014945700764656067, 0.007795744109898806, 0.030169939622282982, 0.010165071114897728, 0.018940230831503868, 0.049363311380147934, 0.0018905512988567352, -0.005045413505285978, -0.0039979866705834866, -0.047557685524225235, -0.016782375052571297, 0.012436239048838615, -0.0047648316249251366, 0.059460628777742386, -0.027612440288066864, -0.004256077576428652, 0.005266938824206591, 0.05905384197831154, -0.04171406850218773, -0.035237498581409454, -0.022274166345596313, -0.012864437885582447, -0.044167015701532364, -0.024254217743873596, 0.056509073823690414, 0.014528203755617142, -0.03725795820355415, 0.020360589027404785, -0.033292777836322784, 0.012115982361137867, 0.0039719450287520885, -0.07321814447641373, 0.02365300990641117, 0.03814082592725754, 0.014763911254703999, -0.023531818762421608, 0.009514751844108105, 0.013337520882487297, -0.01615871675312519, 0.0017394531751051545, 0.022799862548708916, 0.003202530089765787, 0.016299620270729065, -0.024413686245679855, -0.022978931665420532, -0.10027151554822922, -0.016878465190529823, 0.00022004473430570215, -0.003595783142372966, -0.09171051532030106, 0.018311098217964172, -0.015307891182601452, 0.04178547114133835, 0.07329460978507996, 0.039247214794158936, 0.025772975757718086, -0.014298432506620884, -0.018231483176350594, -0.0007913234294392169, 0.03979865089058876, 0.04029727354645729, -0.016673769801855087, 0.06808892637491226, 0.030480677261948586, -0.019126880913972855, -0.0347265787422657, -0.013232627883553505, -0.006252254359424114, -0.0344657301902771, -0.012661921791732311, -0.04900195077061653, -0.01311908196657896, -0.0939447283744812, -0.04475508630275726, 0.04155692085623741, -0.012355697341263294, -0.05148421600461006, 0.0030948377680033445, -0.03772565722465515, -0.038920801132917404, 0.007276161573827267, -0.007542914245277643, -0.008574824780225754, -0.02775156870484352, -0.0247786957770586, -0.06908205151557922, -0.021761026233434677, 0.010542955249547958, -0.019115222617983818, -0.050376392900943756, -0.018902422860264778, -0.014847357757389545, 0.011988546699285507, 0.02240944094955921, -0.007249908987432718, 0.04729926586151123, -0.02445501834154129 ]
3,538
Learning local equivariant representations for quantum operators
https://openreview.net/forum?id=kpq3IIjUD3
[ "Zhanghao Zhouyin", "Zixi Gan", "Shishir Kumar Pandey", "Linfeng Zhang", "Qiangqiang Gu" ]
Spotlight
Predicting quantum operator matrices such as Hamiltonian, overlap, and density matrices in the density functional theory (DFT) framework is crucial for material science. Current methods often focus on individual operators and struggle with efficiency and scalability for large systems. Here we introduce a novel deep learning model, SLEM (strictly localized equivariant message-passing), for predicting multiple quantum operators that achieves state-of-the-art accuracy while dramatically improving computational efficiency. SLEM's key innovation is its strict locality-based design for equivariant representations of quantum tensors while preserving physical symmetries. This enables complex many-body dependency without expanding the effective receptive field, leading to superior data efficiency and transferability. Using an innovative SO(2) convolution and invariant overlap parameterization, SLEM reduces the computational complexity of high-order tensor products and is, therefore, capable of handling systems requiring the $f$ and $g$ orbitals in their basis sets. We demonstrate SLEM's capabilities across diverse 2D and 3D materials, achieving high accuracy even with limited training data. SLEM's design facilitates efficient parallelization, potentially extending DFT simulations to systems with device-level sizes, opening new possibilities for large-scale quantum simulations and high-throughput materials discovery.
Density Functional Theory, Local Graph Neural Network, Equivariant Neural Network
A Strictly Local Equivariant Neural Network for Density Functional Theory Hamiltonian/density matrix/overlap matrix learning, accelerated via invariant parameterization of overlap matrix and SO(2) convolution.
5,661
2407.06053
[ 0.011706782504916191, 0.01316449698060751, -0.02771061658859253, 0.01935083605349064, 0.03845890611410141, -0.016667691990733147, 0.024703269824385643, 0.00046815877431072295, 0.0029228387866169214, -0.03479606285691261, 0.006994088180363178, -0.015753906220197678, -0.07227291911840439, 0.01369621604681015, -0.0014890965539962053, 0.05666051432490349, 0.04052219167351723, 0.0029439821373671293, -0.006630942225456238, 0.02403504028916359, 0.004766297526657581, -0.0040968055836856365, 0.04079828038811684, 0.018341777846217155, -0.004803708288818598, -0.003966002259403467, 0.026287470012903214, -0.0250080693513155, -0.024753037840127945, -0.0019806930795311928, 0.022006578743457794, 0.008125090040266514, -0.018782177940011024, -0.029964981600642204, 0.006801503710448742, 0.023825397714972496, -0.04731893539428711, 0.010650001466274261, 0.005443209316581488, 0.01979135349392891, -0.02735745534300804, -0.009270776994526386, 0.018319683149456978, 0.048746757209300995, -0.07429352402687073, 0.015583436004817486, -0.08515062183141708, 0.041070252656936646, -0.019745580852031708, -0.04266931116580963, -0.07286518067121506, 0.03044619783759117, -0.007663900963962078, -0.015938982367515564, 0.007110904902219772, 0.020030757412314415, 0.03129206970334053, -0.04363022372126579, -0.010533729568123817, -0.044551387429237366, -0.024136940017342567, 0.02578558959066868, 0.016362950205802917, 0.004952091723680496, 0.03917573019862175, 0.009279620833694935, 0.00956388097256422, 0.02866065688431263, -0.0742637887597084, -0.04388842359185219, -0.007274695206433535, 0.00582706555724144, -0.019061554223299026, -0.006597679574042559, 0.018339287489652634, -0.024501284584403038, 0.024282440543174744, 0.01763693057000637, 0.05030224472284317, 0.030128013342618942, -0.0022464091889560223, 0.02065199241042137, 0.020006293430924416, 0.04009142890572548, -0.015492868609726429, 0.007448968943208456, -0.08364816755056381, 0.01521280501037836, -0.053342074155807495, 0.08904784172773361, 0.008905807510018349, 0.002972871297970414, 0.04150889441370964, 0.04747423157095909, 0.034708406776189804, -0.016049141064286232, 0.051992446184158325, 0.008797457441687584, 0.03183648735284805, -0.023310264572501183, -0.015523385256528854, -0.04302361607551575, 0.009367057122290134, -0.034244854003190994, -0.1032738909125328, -0.00194934057071805, -0.0744304358959198, -0.022733930498361588, -0.008968607522547245, -0.011490718461573124, -0.03376242518424988, 0.006102327257394791, -0.0016519647324457765, -0.016920315101742744, -0.07050373405218124, 0.02137363888323307, 0.0058123040944337845, -0.008639320731163025, -0.007291794288903475, 0.015376430936157703, 0.05581197515130043, 0.10759799182415009, -0.0014116405509412289, 0.0600576251745224, 0.03850460797548294, 0.023892609402537346, 0.019030064344406128, 0.04231985658407211, -0.04054474085569382, -0.053140025585889816, 0.04275830090045929, 0.052892908453941345, 0.007991037331521511, 0.03809050843119621, -0.008094996213912964, -0.05506758391857147, 0.003173451405018568, 0.012622208334505558, 0.04040279611945152, -0.008638782426714897, -0.024224678054451942, -0.0398368164896965, 0.057872455567121506, -0.018294043838977814, 0.07258453965187073, -0.013934608548879623, 0.029451772570610046, -0.017166808247566223, 0.006440901663154364, 0.03965012729167938, 0.026874540373682976, -0.023038320243358612, -0.02737870067358017, -0.034920815378427505, 0.01387862116098404, 0.011883964762091637, 0.005860952660441399, 0.03786466270685196, 0.002238370943814516, -0.02115746960043907, 0.00123118469491601, -0.042991336435079575, 0.0069231027737259865, 0.025781264528632164, -0.014532814733684063, -0.02137119136750698, 0.04545965790748596, 0.03267645090818405, -0.027432415634393692, -0.014574161730706692, -0.02249159850180149, -0.04520270973443985, 0.05044306442141533, -0.009701364673674107, -0.018115324899554253, -0.01645372249186039, 0.01810692623257637, 0.00558456452563405, 0.011876610107719898, 0.004138639662414789, -0.08269431442022324, 0.0063879783265292645, 0.025590162724256516, -0.01712615415453911, 0.008719013072550297, 0.017409197986125946, 0.08477670699357986, -0.015098444186151028, -0.013020187616348267, 0.023796088993549347, -0.08143609017133713, 0.012953530065715313, 0.02855590544641018, -0.02503044903278351, 0.07528512924909592, -0.01639801636338234, -0.0304601788520813, 0.017295893281698227, 0.01067198347300291, 0.00403768103569746, 0.012328232638537884, -0.013595554046332836, 0.022290445864200592, 0.00017887854482978582, -0.03711516410112381, -0.006578446365892887, 0.04408269375562668, -0.036325808614492416, -0.00884636864066124, -0.015042443759739399, 0.01997351087629795, -0.03872174024581909, -0.011731375008821487, -0.016516396775841713, -0.012922276742756367, -0.012464546598494053, -0.020686598494648933, 0.005250792950391769, 0.005900553427636623, -0.008501408621668816, 0.05003182217478752, 0.02365179732441902, -0.015065851621329784, -0.011070432141423225, -0.010061768814921379, 0.12145111709833145, 0.059475358575582504, -0.04724961891770363, -0.023638181388378143, 0.05489163473248482, 0.027303488925099373, -0.020328186452388763, 0.010158824734389782, -0.019100185483694077, 0.009786869399249554, -0.01558714359998703, 0.015223915688693523, -0.014925706200301647, 0.08013460785150528, -0.03982875868678093, -0.019205914810299873, 0.05812552943825722, -0.030081817880272865, 0.03757574409246445, 0.0015136695001274347, 0.0008186539635062218, 0.06928558647632599, -0.04189933091402054, -0.03738021105527878, -0.0594535768032074, -0.027373578399419785, 0.0031028399243950844, 0.00022071607236284763, 0.02096482925117016, 0.0400574691593647, -0.06480752676725388, -0.013526427559554577, 0.0238609928637743, 0.06141652911901474, 0.03838463872671127, -0.010895030573010445, 0.02227414958178997, 0.01906117983162403, -0.025846172124147415, -0.053346186876297, -0.09230847656726837, -0.07628647983074188, -0.009199138730764389, 0.034304894506931305, -0.012802061624825, 0.042872942984104156, -0.001354809501208365, -0.020143145695328712, -0.018952371552586555, -0.03350047022104263, 0.01049108523875475, -0.009088841266930103, -0.02010667324066162, -0.018235955387353897, -0.03688947111368179, 0.02878924086689949, 0.08592761307954788, -0.002699869452044368, -0.006268332712352276, -0.01878947764635086, -0.06841424852609634, -0.006511208601295948, -0.05210573226213455, -0.01921750418841839, -0.004530625883489847, 0.04051705077290535, 0.006199265364557505, -0.04160232096910477, 0.016813913360238075, 0.01995253376662731, 0.0726776272058487, 0.05014704540371895, 0.017792850732803345, 0.006007624324411154, 0.02659907564520836, 0.0008711812552064657, 0.031850770115852356, -0.04150161147117615, 0.01959243044257164, -0.009864749386906624, -0.035190217196941376, 0.01810419373214245, -0.0059579103253781796, -0.26434701681137085, -0.026278074830770493, 0.027987096458673477, -0.004976898897439241, 0.04252830520272255, -0.00588246202096343, 0.027847973629832268, -0.024795731529593468, 0.006677062250673771, 0.013491745106875896, -0.012041650712490082, 0.01978655345737934, -0.021495886147022247, 0.02845827303826809, 0.040915537625551224, 0.014868269674479961, 0.02754894085228443, -0.03282124549150467, 0.024682439863681793, 0.022497905418276787, -0.04093101620674133, -0.06788499653339386, -0.021503394469618797, 0.025750694796442986, -0.01171226054430008, 0.03074905462563038, -0.07188162207603455, -0.002342749387025833, -0.026884039863944054, -0.005245128646492958, -0.03480476513504982, -0.012277127243578434, 0.02595270425081253, 0.02453242614865303, 0.03275419399142265, 0.01890537701547146, 0.005470472853630781, -0.035011231899261475, -0.01351605262607336, -0.0021852219942957163, -0.015599933452904224, 0.019803285598754883, -0.04382631182670593, 0.026661930605769157, 0.08065351843833923, 0.022909432649612427, 0.008892342448234558, 0.010389303788542747, -0.01194468792527914, 0.022212408483028412, -0.04095953702926636, -0.05078354477882385, 0.03509591892361641, -0.019878579303622246, -0.023811107501387596, 0.0071001662872731686, -0.060566894710063934, 0.04606572538614273, -0.005196021404117346, 0.010227098129689693, 0.00621757609769702, -0.0618608221411705, -0.037994399666786194, 0.007433687802404165, -0.04969363659620285, -0.042237572371959686, -0.0765039250254631, -0.07847844064235687, 0.056458547711372375, 0.055485423654317856, -0.004740898031741381, 0.0038173922803252935, -0.051713183522224426, -0.08237729221582413, 0.07017147541046143, 0.020809009671211243, -0.016600966453552246, -0.05130089819431305, 0.03340906649827957, 0.03940809518098831, -0.053817570209503174, -0.04077351093292236, -0.004872790537774563, 0.040023379027843475, 0.0305558480322361, -0.016392402350902557, -0.026882192119956017, -0.03981699049472809, -0.06318672001361847, -0.009925947524607182, 0.04359180107712746, 0.00963663775473833, 0.029576173052191734, 0.01027575321495533, 0.05159318819642067, 0.006652983836829662, 0.02585655264556408, 0.02876308374106884, 0.02593531459569931, 0.012375868856906891, 0.04595796763896942, -0.07273156940937042, -0.030578410252928734, -0.04672499746084213, -0.034553397446870804, 0.02563238888978958, -0.04788602143526077, 0.010713493451476097, 0.04804735630750656, 0.03995904698967934, -0.03047121688723564, -0.021859437227249146, -0.009184982627630234, 0.003193183336406946, 0.017916081473231316, -0.016210151836276054, 0.02664104290306568, 0.03993205353617668, 0.01917794719338417, -0.03728726506233215, -0.006311627104878426, 0.0354403480887413, -0.003126729279756546, -0.0033523296006023884, -0.03960271179676056, -0.006488702725619078, -0.010698942467570305, -0.0026346726808696985, -0.004260402638465166, -0.017516208812594414, 0.025884568691253662, 0.05470835790038109, -0.012299398891627789, 0.01785779371857643, 0.08085947483778, -0.015906771644949913, -0.01345064677298069, -0.024341220036149025, 0.004267633892595768, -0.005090863909572363, 0.054968349635601044, -0.03315146639943123, 0.05743962526321411, 0.024901004508137703, 0.020037837326526642, 0.027342984452843666, 0.026177432388067245, 0.007425012532621622, -0.031098123639822006, 0.017866941168904305, 0.036180995404720306, -0.037087541073560715, 0.0022358009591698647, 0.010905602015554905, -0.004135733004659414, 0.004437852185219526, 0.021350618451833725, -0.026339616626501083, 0.017926078289747238, -0.06545599550008774, 0.04996960237622261, 0.052530720829963684, -0.00878510158509016, 0.001148812472820282, -0.007860297337174416, 0.036694981157779694, -0.020249279215931892, 0.036822281777858734, 0.01263462845236063, 0.0011115280212834477, 0.013296056538820267, -0.028803830966353416, -0.024205438792705536, -0.03900830075144768, -0.0436224639415741, 0.03464058041572571, -0.008276202715933323, -0.023946581408381462, -0.020153723657131195, 0.010889384895563126, 0.05977484956383705, 0.0005652791005559266, -0.01117215771228075, 0.029547041282057762, 0.07416601479053497, -0.0025653857737779617, 0.0174980778247118, -0.030159223824739456, -0.003971542697399855, -0.0073942462913692, 0.03643283247947693, 0.00873181689530611, -0.0338471345603466, -0.03223896026611328, -0.029759136959910393, -0.028740791603922844, -0.029337909072637558, 0.043316833674907684, -0.02977285534143448, 0.003043261356651783, 0.017859818413853645, -0.0008377621998079121, -0.06435834616422653, 0.010155333206057549, 0.02775595709681511, -0.061987318098545074, 0.0025719297118484974, 0.03476276248693466, -0.012083092704415321, 0.0020206437911838293, -0.019173212349414825, -0.05203557386994362, -0.031602296978235245, -0.011870358139276505, -0.014264603145420551, -0.008363819681107998, 0.01631614752113819, -0.013852434232831001, -0.02275632508099079, -0.030797064304351807, -0.026386160403490067, 0.017557749524712563, 0.045348867774009705, -0.027047626674175262, -0.005818004719913006, 0.046660374850034714, -0.021794576197862625, 0.038938287645578384, -0.0009930680971592665, -0.0366181805729866, -0.005185235757380724, -0.06178635358810425, 0.030139543116092682, 0.04625130817294121, -0.0033756576012820005, 0.009237688966095448, -0.04990991950035095, 0.004539116285741329, -0.016350196674466133, -0.022677123546600342, 0.00813539419323206, -0.03001924231648445, -0.053936537355184555, 0.023238399997353554, -0.0067407130263745785, 0.016344059258699417, 0.030869251117110252, 0.026575183495879173, -0.009100225754082203, 0.012078670784831047, 0.035175979137420654, -0.03480155020952225, -0.060976024717092514, -0.03390579670667648, 0.06805656850337982, -0.014751252718269825, -0.026532568037509918, -0.08363153785467148, -0.02062908001244068, -0.020098527893424034, -0.052251242101192474, 0.0113285593688488, -0.04730992019176483, 0.042017437517642975, 0.006739899516105652, 0.03940845653414726, 0.011195733211934566, -0.058295730501413345, 0.060623157769441605, -0.02948930114507675, -0.020900506526231766, -0.05419968068599701, -0.011840380728244781, 0.017590751871466637, -0.04791291058063507, -0.0034474029671400785, -0.029285740107297897, -0.0561051182448864, 0.02747863344848156, -0.014916066080331802, -0.07423549890518188, 0.011645762249827385, -0.009370055980980396, -0.02977895736694336, 0.0597202330827713, -0.041852593421936035, -0.030905576422810555, -0.023314982652664185, -0.031458936631679535, -0.004732347093522549, 0.002352106152102351, 0.025462094694375992, -0.006287277676165104, -0.020305152982473373, -0.020167887210845947, 0.03648705780506134, 0.0028395599219948053, 0.07234340906143188, 0.017870603129267693, 0.017361370846629143, -0.028171313926577568, 0.08099386096000671, 0.039476048201322556, 0.008991246111690998, 0.04354334622621536, 0.018491392955183983, -0.023816080763936043, -0.010357691906392574, 0.012847233563661575, -0.00007303346501430497, -0.002099373145028949, -0.07976590096950531, 0.03268914297223091, 0.03369474411010742, -0.07958655804395676, -0.0049756187945604324, 0.03738671541213989, -0.049014102667570114, 0.007233602926135063, -0.0016139085637405515, -0.02250012569129467, -0.010324410162866116, 0.06713797897100449, 0.01006995141506195, 0.04520818963646889, 0.07585283368825912, 0.021591924130916595, -0.011789939366281033, -0.019148971885442734, 0.07380153983831406, 0.07292086631059647, 0.029175668954849243, 0.005246290005743504, 0.06303165853023529, -0.004283634480088949, -0.06995240598917007, 0.0012729872250929475, 0.004551328718662262, -0.027567854151129723, -0.004623311571776867, -0.0021337049547582865, 0.13060134649276733, 0.00030990777304396033, 0.06778153777122498, -0.019735610112547874, -0.005522348452359438, 0.027624845504760742, 0.022543439641594887, -0.018252743408083916, 0.05642840638756752, 0.016210634261369705, 0.022418737411499023, -0.024935252964496613, -0.006187886465340853, -0.04700414091348648, -0.0009568720706738532, 0.04398791491985321, 0.025995634496212006, -0.00380869978107512, 0.030829498544335365, -0.007775945123285055, 0.03986508771777153, 0.07706701010465622, -0.005052231717854738, -0.06949716806411743, -0.0043748533353209496, -0.005514151882380247, -0.008774569258093834, 0.013748922385275364, -0.025069909170269966, 0.005612292792648077, 0.0090718362480402, -0.04298054799437523, 0.047419026494026184, 0.0239256601780653, -0.027799632400274277, 0.01980864629149437, -0.018242763355374336, -0.022599294781684875, 0.004556463100016117, 0.03575274720788002, -0.040209729224443436, -0.05740315839648247, -0.039039868861436844, -0.03148606792092323, -0.045005492866039276, -0.047159552574157715, 0.0422971248626709, -0.010706237517297268, -0.01322468463331461, 0.015370707027614117, -0.020872214809060097, 0.0192990992218256, 0.01822408102452755, -0.06068146228790283, -0.029429074376821518, 0.0554354265332222, 0.032747142016887665, -0.005908466409891844, 0.023738378658890724, 0.04537403583526611, -0.024234868586063385, -0.0011189606739208102, 0.04834819585084915, -0.0034491727128624916, 0.03539464995265007, -0.027570635080337524, -0.009535133838653564, -0.11567924916744232, 0.02480343170464039, 0.027531221508979797, -0.04818692430853844, -0.07702355831861496, 0.02586951106786728, 0.00019750998762901872, 0.014682799577713013, 0.029470235109329224, 0.005028471350669861, 0.02251994051039219, -0.016129817813634872, -0.01909847930073738, 0.005263308063149452, 0.014271384105086327, 0.0680374726653099, -0.023824602365493774, 0.06918368488550186, 0.027167826890945435, 0.004583256784826517, -0.008109347894787788, -0.0031981796491891146, 0.026020227000117302, -0.011597743257880211, -0.0477072075009346, -0.0005479647079482675, -0.04821978136897087, -0.08523322641849518, -0.03667793795466423, -0.006695746444165707, -0.01141632255166769, -0.03097403235733509, -0.02841522917151451, 0.027922501787543297, -0.010552344843745232, -0.01150963082909584, -0.017283640801906586, -0.012533464469015598, -0.03445529192686081, -0.03725435212254524, -0.026237493380904198, 0.030509542673826218, 0.009793499484658241, -0.04472137615084648, 0.0011131330393254757, -0.019093306735157967, -0.01889091171324253, -0.018326351419091225, 0.040464408695697784, 0.03516537696123123, 0.0397275872528553, -0.006042825058102608 ]
3,539
PhyMPGN: Physics-encoded Message Passing Graph Network for spatiotemporal PDE systems
https://openreview.net/forum?id=fU8H4lzkIm
[ "Bocheng Zeng", "Qi Wang", "Mengtao Yan", "Yang Liu", "Ruizhi Chengze", "Yi Zhang", "Hongsheng Liu", "Zidong Wang", "Hao Sun" ]
Spotlight
Solving partial differential equations (PDEs) serves as a cornerstone for modeling complex dynamical systems. Recent progresses have demonstrated grand benefits of data-driven neural-based models for predicting spatiotemporal dynamics (e.g., tremendous speedup gain compared with classical numerical methods). However, most existing neural models rely on rich training data, have limited extrapolation and generalization abilities, and suffer to produce precise or reliable physical prediction under intricate conditions (e.g., irregular mesh or geometry, complex boundary conditions, diverse PDE parameters, etc.). To this end, we propose a new graph learning approach, namely, Physics-encoded Message Passing Graph Network (PhyMPGN), to model spatiotemporal PDE systems on irregular meshes given small training datasets. Specifically, we incorporate a GNN into a numerical integrator to approximate the temporal marching of spatiotemporal dynamics for a given PDE system. Considering that many physical phenomena are governed by diffusion processes, we further design a learnable Laplace block, which encodes the discrete Laplace-Beltrami operator, to aid and guide the GNN learning in a physically feasible solution space. A boundary condition padding strategy is also designed to improve the model convergence and accuracy. Extensive experiments demonstrate that PhyMPGN is capable of accurately predicting various types of spatiotemporal dynamics on coarse unstructured meshes, consistently achieves the state-of-the-art results, and outperforms other baselines with considerable gains.
Physics-encoded; Spatiotemporal PDEs; Graph Network; Deep Learning;
Presented a Physics-encoded Message Passing Graph Network for simulation of spatiotemporal PDE systems.
5,640
2410.01337
[ -0.03633283078670502, -0.010870921425521374, 0.0075849262066185474, 0.05550762265920639, 0.029314324259757996, 0.02177443355321884, 0.002061236882582307, 0.013853966258466244, -0.04773516580462456, -0.07011567056179047, 0.025873927399516106, -0.03447476774454117, -0.0492682158946991, 0.019445879384875298, 0.0319550558924675, 0.06672170758247375, 0.027144018560647964, -0.030748531222343445, 0.007241542916744947, 0.0381191223859787, -0.003862750483676791, -0.049838051199913025, 0.039057787507772446, 0.031011169776320457, 0.016891907900571823, -0.003461083397269249, 0.02939292974770069, 0.012031754478812218, -0.009439698420464993, 0.033724911510944366, -0.0034442164469510317, 0.016760865226387978, -0.002218324923887849, -0.020320262759923935, 0.010354291647672653, 0.03601260483264923, -0.05155820772051811, 0.016936954110860825, -0.013440259732306004, 0.011201620101928711, -0.03600809723138809, 0.005607603117823601, -0.006073375698179007, 0.0027627774979919195, -0.004088188987225294, 0.036065723747015, -0.0759553536772728, 0.05200124904513359, 0.007906864397227764, -0.03119061142206192, -0.11985034495592117, 0.044842250645160675, 0.029870664700865746, 0.006082063540816307, -0.053748782724142075, 0.01568758115172386, 0.03236274793744087, -0.04421022906899452, 0.005609854124486446, -0.05514517053961754, -0.006301151122897863, 0.024146780371665955, 0.004166997503489256, 0.0011410376755520701, 0.013507196679711342, -0.004507160745561123, 0.02248709835112095, 0.05146561563014984, -0.03710278868675232, -0.05604124814271927, -0.008824369870126247, 0.02377723902463913, 0.002664450788870454, 0.0015241722576320171, 0.012952959164977074, -0.06380940973758698, -0.0028514894656836987, 0.012795190326869488, 0.04977840185165405, 0.016468282788991928, -0.008439889177680016, 0.03045804426074028, -0.01301161851733923, 0.05540493130683899, -0.006170749198645353, 0.0032351426780223846, -0.06519804149866104, -0.008238249458372593, -0.05954247713088989, 0.05897597596049309, -0.03652810677886009, -0.05181283876299858, 0.0009798702085390687, 0.027445456013083458, 0.03571535646915436, -0.011654926463961601, 0.008837048895657063, 0.003949353005737066, -0.00298026273958385, -0.018785519525408745, -0.015447848476469517, -0.06419210135936737, 0.03681257739663124, -0.021484382450580597, -0.09755807369947433, -0.05122165381908417, -0.0452224425971508, -0.03553247079253197, -0.00035674654645845294, 0.0075239697471261024, -0.03498673439025879, -0.013018369674682617, 0.010642935521900654, -0.02752860262989998, -0.06490518897771835, 0.04516712203621864, 0.013996102847158909, 0.002769858343526721, -0.0033678191248327494, 0.00446053221821785, 0.04522917792201042, 0.022793112322688103, 0.0067942156456410885, 0.058616310358047485, -0.003947719931602478, 0.03795693442225456, 0.043867792934179306, 0.011670777574181557, -0.05220456048846245, -0.01531987451016903, -0.013935573399066925, 0.05234020948410034, 0.024848852306604385, -0.007999702356755733, 0.028523225337266922, -0.03065449930727482, 0.006604558788239956, 0.036192260682582855, 0.005429267883300781, 0.011625474318861961, 0.0035732826218008995, -0.008103989064693451, 0.0670640841126442, -0.0265961866825819, 0.05648677051067352, -0.027389414608478546, 0.009928436018526554, -0.059111203998327255, -0.01594758965075016, -0.013458075933158398, -0.004557135980576277, -0.0002750676649156958, 0.002049361588433385, -0.05543718487024307, 0.0196184404194355, 0.034208912402391434, 0.04676760360598564, 0.04297015815973282, -0.001811509020626545, -0.018988464027643204, 0.017946206033229828, 0.005498051643371582, -0.016711952164769173, 0.02521825209259987, -0.033302534371614456, -0.035292528569698334, 0.05982924997806549, 0.019589489325881004, -0.028141049668192863, -0.026316439732909203, -0.04736234247684479, -0.047753557562828064, 0.03863097354769707, 0.00294567015953362, 0.0005141273140907288, -0.04596522077918053, 0.05613553896546364, -0.017539098858833313, 0.0005100941052660346, -0.0116768479347229, -0.08010384440422058, 0.023970939218997955, 0.009155089035630226, 0.020656974986195564, 0.012831677682697773, -0.04425809904932976, 0.10474205762147903, -0.03947801515460014, -0.0046005393378436565, 0.014527445659041405, -0.0871572494506836, 0.0000841560322442092, 0.015912994742393494, -0.008868232369422913, 0.05954853817820549, -0.016944821923971176, 0.008669295348227024, -0.0004822721821255982, 0.01608220487833023, 0.0728202536702156, 0.04477660357952118, -0.02653949335217476, 0.04033197835087776, 0.012648704461753368, -0.05913270637392998, -0.02863542176783085, 0.060003358870744705, -0.03885316103696823, -0.05120449140667915, 0.011276843957602978, -0.02172311395406723, -0.024101508781313896, 0.0024322490207850933, -0.022919440641999245, 0.022679047659039497, -0.01860741525888443, -0.007258474826812744, 0.007935402914881706, 0.018652822822332382, -0.0453602597117424, 0.010182495228946209, 0.008686301298439503, -0.021924549713730812, -0.00037134368903934956, -0.020620238035917282, 0.11103688180446625, 0.07495377957820892, -0.027866316959261894, -0.009974967688322067, 0.037823501974344254, 0.03160202130675316, 0.01883016712963581, 0.028600376099348068, 0.007328888401389122, -0.0029008761048316956, -0.005249733105301857, 0.00533188646659255, -0.056111451238393784, 0.03254706412553787, -0.050476621836423874, -0.006181235425174236, 0.06963382661342621, -0.03240935131907463, 0.06920015066862106, -0.011397828347980976, 0.0007436907617375255, 0.050297096371650696, -0.025726929306983948, -0.006529279053211212, -0.002751128515228629, -0.026096638292074203, 0.031651344150304794, 0.03886473923921585, 0.028030168265104294, -0.009656555950641632, -0.06339287012815475, -0.03649696707725525, -0.0005309340194799006, 0.0844445452094078, 0.04144444316625595, 0.0328376367688179, -0.02006012201309204, 0.021320601925253868, -0.022951869294047356, -0.06485839188098907, -0.14341934025287628, -0.03204147517681122, -0.013102208264172077, 0.012288132682442665, 0.015606203116476536, 0.03929956629872322, -0.004136305768042803, 0.004740952048450708, -0.030599389225244522, -0.024111555889248848, 0.0005196433048695326, 0.014535397291183472, -0.02375020831823349, -0.045745205134153366, -0.03219395875930786, 0.03137039393186569, 0.07436791062355042, -0.02957434020936489, -0.03594321012496948, -0.0014510925393551588, -0.04448908939957619, 0.0016833986155688763, 0.001765853725373745, 0.017070090398192406, 0.039044756442308426, 0.0032976516522467136, 0.0026016714982688427, -0.03316669166088104, 0.03287874907255173, 0.04446971416473389, 0.05291798338294029, 0.05357144773006439, -0.029361680150032043, -0.036967456340789795, 0.014724981971085072, -0.00121481588575989, 0.029147131368517876, 0.0023915686178952456, 0.012538915500044823, -0.04586954787373543, -0.019518930464982986, 0.019953729584813118, -0.007572355680167675, -0.25351038575172424, 0.0004946265835314989, 0.02124490775167942, -0.03201361373066902, 0.03802536800503731, 0.024702051654458046, 0.05618073791265488, -0.016467463225126266, -0.04324350133538246, -0.013271711766719818, 0.010521302931010723, 0.018967747688293457, -0.01945880427956581, 0.04596475511789322, 0.06078014895319939, -0.009573232382535934, 0.0057623968459665775, -0.0245255958288908, 0.01988125778734684, 0.001914288615807891, -0.02147533744573593, -0.06513803452253342, -0.030811814591288567, 0.022554170340299606, 0.003912642598152161, 0.0029701855964958668, -0.05477229133248329, -0.01604689098894596, -0.05102347210049629, 0.029300395399332047, -0.013045279309153557, -0.03817792236804962, 0.0013516753679141402, 0.06772153079509735, 0.021707165986299515, 0.016684582456946373, 0.022671794518828392, 0.005029628053307533, 0.03804435580968857, 0.0008936900994740427, -0.013373767025768757, 0.02079734578728676, -0.04389512166380882, 0.008403870277106762, 0.07557041198015213, 0.01432464923709631, -0.016229042783379555, 0.02128056064248085, 0.0022124305833131075, 0.030351825058460236, 0.007969827391207218, -0.05087001621723175, 0.02708256058394909, -0.0246242955327034, -0.002697041956707835, -0.01185181736946106, 0.010962028987705708, -0.018697213381528854, -0.009994502179324627, -0.003432642901316285, 0.0018441816791892052, -0.032881055027246475, -0.02741813287138939, -0.02761819027364254, 0.014376469887793064, -0.029231710359454155, -0.09919679909944534, -0.07395735383033752, 0.041306257247924805, 0.0331362709403038, -0.01606866531074047, -0.017687220126390457, -0.02889334410429001, -0.0958290845155716, 0.009155618958175182, 0.005725563038140535, -0.017039192840456963, -0.020261049270629883, 0.02415507100522518, 0.009506186470389366, -0.046269044280052185, -0.034069329500198364, -0.0035713554825633764, 0.04956381767988205, 0.027302104979753494, 0.020803630352020264, 0.015200238674879074, -0.07029613107442856, -0.015151659958064556, -0.035704951733350754, 0.03732314705848694, 0.00013959799252916127, 0.08059150725603104, -0.031954001635313034, 0.038518257439136505, 0.032655905932188034, 0.004424151033163071, 0.01802794076502323, 0.04395684972405434, -0.030283894389867783, 0.03485209494829178, -0.07829123735427856, -0.018628764897584915, -0.022072656080126762, -0.017386876046657562, 0.0077479504980146885, -0.028503302484750748, 0.0005658657173626125, 0.028873886913061142, 0.011721585877239704, -0.014460630714893341, -0.027912287041544914, 0.027998654171824455, -0.02033296227455139, -0.026384374126791954, -0.0013515735045075417, -0.012837976217269897, 0.030001137405633926, 0.02999829314649105, -0.031327053904533386, -0.024995962157845497, 0.040712978690862656, -0.05122470110654831, 0.02140892669558525, 0.011757801286876202, 0.0001733011013129726, -0.01646922342479229, -0.028910206630825996, 0.013490131124854088, -0.010792668908834457, 0.02669244445860386, 0.06869109719991684, 0.012903260067105293, 0.05041131004691124, 0.040794067084789276, 0.011933373287320137, -0.03373384475708008, -0.02389700524508953, 0.019557787105441093, 0.003273067297413945, 0.024754902347922325, 0.03678087145090103, 0.032973192632198334, -0.02674271911382675, 0.05002254992723465, 0.03181733936071396, 0.0019403824117034674, 0.021553093567490578, 0.013801096007227898, -0.0007477074395865202, 0.0367858000099659, -0.08381058275699615, -0.026976382359862328, -0.048604730516672134, -0.013252805918455124, 0.011083990335464478, 0.0656421110033989, -0.006047127768397331, 0.05109386518597603, -0.03334999457001686, 0.06619872897863388, 0.01775422692298889, -0.043272532522678375, 0.010224764235317707, -0.02168053388595581, 0.04967646673321724, -0.004298836458474398, 0.02775188907980919, -0.006547278258949518, -0.025637125596404076, 0.017190996557474136, -0.010136941447854042, -0.03285527974367142, -0.00901538785547018, -0.017790282145142555, 0.02529214322566986, 0.006125342566519976, -0.016911743208765984, -0.03153616562485695, 0.03023827075958252, 0.010235851630568504, -0.047766294330358505, -0.008997492492198944, 0.05379930138587952, 0.07628348469734192, -0.0004813590203411877, -0.010959426872432232, -0.02982969582080841, -0.05265437066555023, 0.04684716463088989, 0.020506354048848152, 0.027379389852285385, -0.04261952266097069, -0.04465596750378609, -0.006855987478047609, -0.035979025065898895, 0.009002924896776676, 0.041910525411367416, -0.0343339629471302, -0.03134876862168312, 0.010484104044735432, 0.00779023626819253, -0.03175773844122887, 0.04700477048754692, 0.002497130073606968, -0.05486695468425751, -0.002809535013511777, 0.017094068229198456, 0.0059748063795268536, 0.013035941869020462, 0.0035789520479738712, 0.016478776931762695, -0.03807264193892479, 0.01039215736091137, -0.0102377999573946, 0.014070256613194942, -0.012534878216683865, -0.013246224261820316, -0.008601130917668343, 0.03265444189310074, 0.014465410262346268, 0.010871981270611286, 0.0036140531301498413, -0.05661730468273163, -0.010302979499101639, 0.06410299241542816, -0.013961962424218655, -0.019468829035758972, -0.02255689911544323, -0.016193069517612457, 0.023985935375094414, -0.046583764255046844, -0.0009925058111548424, 0.014173350296914577, 0.012279386632144451, -0.0007940027280710638, -0.043756622821092606, 0.01330424565821886, -0.012176064774394035, -0.012327505275607109, -0.003103042021393776, 0.0003141533234156668, -0.05338726192712784, 0.006479545962065458, 0.009074999019503593, 0.04948222264647484, 0.03299711272120476, 0.015507061965763569, -0.00003605700476327911, 0.019164742901921272, 0.04440181702375412, -0.00009558764577377588, -0.08236172050237656, -0.007493576034903526, 0.047017209231853485, 0.010878765024244785, -0.045503146946430206, -0.06637030094861984, -0.009241953492164612, -0.002148708328604698, -0.03621121495962143, 0.0028374360408633947, -0.03010847046971321, 0.04461383819580078, 0.014131049625575542, 0.03528203070163727, 0.045252662152051926, -0.04088370501995087, 0.033716145902872086, -0.039413586258888245, -0.0036099960561841726, -0.0538799874484539, -0.011526055634021759, 0.009680349379777908, -0.003910505678504705, 0.005278999451547861, -0.012423885986208916, -0.024169418960809708, 0.08095812797546387, -0.032019417732954025, -0.05849165469408035, 0.025775277987122536, -0.014959318563342094, -0.02394263632595539, 0.055745501071214676, -0.04375781863927841, -0.0194719135761261, 0.0013391748070716858, -0.046869684010744095, 0.005350140389055014, 0.03767203167080879, 0.007303941063582897, -0.03713351488113403, 0.015310756862163544, -0.009751706384122372, 0.027574023231863976, 0.02359110862016678, 0.04522737115621567, -0.021596377715468407, 0.01757228560745716, -0.05604943260550499, 0.081698939204216, 0.0487293004989624, 0.005341893993318081, -0.002397292060777545, 0.005510631483048201, -0.012772991321980953, -0.0834030881524086, 0.030663885176181793, 0.013743465766310692, -0.025645721703767776, -0.060577861964702606, 0.0476619228720665, 0.021065684035420418, -0.0403914675116539, -0.01756446808576584, 0.030723411589860916, -0.025423675775527954, -0.006340078078210354, -0.0018509014043956995, 0.0068401675671339035, 0.00045356785994954407, 0.07262909412384033, 0.013052769936621189, 0.03993198648095131, 0.04325436055660248, 0.0170141514390707, -0.0006529918173328042, -0.012105251662433147, 0.05912543088197708, 0.06962720304727554, 0.020426388829946518, 0.014867746271193027, 0.07201667129993439, -0.03739842027425766, -0.02528376504778862, 0.008913468569517136, 0.02888277731835842, -0.055370185524225235, -0.038412466645240784, 0.01813497208058834, 0.10351070016622543, 0.0023709270171821117, 0.07421864569187164, -0.03156339377164841, -0.012100448831915855, 0.02675880677998066, 0.03220824897289276, -0.014727340079843998, 0.030960656702518463, 0.019339850172400475, 0.014249106869101524, -0.03516562655568123, -0.02117198333144188, -0.02427123300731182, -0.04013342782855034, 0.02551390789449215, 0.02231587842106819, 0.01819933019578457, 0.01871609315276146, -0.0024698819033801556, 0.018408790230751038, 0.08567782491445541, -0.02512305974960327, -0.051930949091911316, 0.012085970491170883, -0.001329441787675023, -0.01644635945558548, 0.034151963889598846, 0.019672289490699768, -0.014749478548765182, 0.01413014717400074, -0.04328623414039612, 0.04360390454530716, -0.0049080559983849525, -0.019922401756048203, 0.016505572944879532, -0.039031822234392166, -0.026333827525377274, -0.0033229459077119827, -0.005448739044368267, -0.040538955479860306, -0.05758938938379288, -0.0396052785217762, -0.046729572117328644, -0.08287674188613892, -0.03658294677734375, 0.026820247992873192, -0.023327726870775223, -0.01995658129453659, 0.03152298182249069, 0.009273985400795937, 0.008685247041285038, 0.0269312746822834, -0.0468718484044075, -0.03178376704454422, 0.03941534832119942, 0.005947557277977467, 0.029129255563020706, 0.05582756549119949, 0.04408469423651695, -0.03361797705292702, -0.014732210896909237, 0.048855967819690704, -0.010919700376689434, 0.030596693977713585, -0.009877157397568226, 0.012088656425476074, -0.1018393337726593, 0.026984769850969315, 0.007685932796448469, -0.038414742797613144, -0.08004945516586304, 0.047726623713970184, -0.032713890075683594, 0.030870622023940086, 0.047101590782403946, -0.00876505859196186, 0.003512151073664427, -0.06753283739089966, -0.028169507160782814, -0.03818897157907486, -0.005122743081301451, 0.08711932599544525, -0.021372606977820396, 0.03834828361868858, 0.047777533531188965, -0.06084184721112251, 0.016206132248044014, 0.015467952005565166, 0.008368703536689281, 0.000812968413811177, -0.04955875501036644, -0.00840645283460617, -0.02412387914955616, -0.0892559066414833, -0.021712057292461395, 0.024124059826135635, -0.013980678282678127, -0.035246629267930984, 0.01390523836016655, -0.013584015890955925, 0.022429531440138817, -0.010831309482455254, -0.0017353983130306005, -0.028373297303915024, -0.016369888558983803, -0.03173474594950676, -0.07737558335065842, 0.027870120480656624, 0.0045004356652498245, -0.007461974862962961, -0.0096919946372509, -0.04639831557869911, 0.0025309715420007706, -0.012936902232468128, 0.01985832303762436, -0.015746502205729485, 0.018612494692206383, 0.03293732553720474 ]
3,540
Demystifying the Token Dynamics of Deep Selective State Space Models
https://openreview.net/forum?id=qtTIP5Gjc5
[ "Thieu Vo", "Duy-Tung Pham", "Xin T. Tong", "Tan Minh Nguyen" ]
Spotlight
Selective state space models (SSM), such as Mamba, have gained prominence for their effectiveness in modeling sequential data. Despite their outstanding empirical performance, a comprehensive theoretical understanding of deep selective SSM remains elusive, hindering their further development and adoption for applications that need high fidelity. In this paper, we investigate the dynamical properties of tokens in a pre-trained Mamba model. In particular, we derive the dynamical system governing the continuous-time limit of the Mamba model and characterize the asymptotic behavior of its solutions. In the one-dimensional case, we prove that only one of the following two scenarios happens: either all tokens converge to zero, or all tokens diverge to infinity. We provide criteria based on model parameters to determine when each scenario occurs. For the convergent scenario, we empirically verify that this scenario negatively impacts the model's performance. For the divergent scenario, we prove that different tokens will diverge to infinity at different rates, thereby contributing unequally to the updates during model training. Based on these investigations, we propose two refinements for the model: excluding the convergent scenario and reordering tokens based on their importance scores, both aimed at improving practical performance. Our experimental results validate these refinements, offering insights into enhancing Mamba's effectiveness in real-world applications.
Selective state-space model, continuous-time limit, dynamical system, asymptotic behavior, token reordering
We describe the dynamical properties of tokens in a deep selective state-space model, and based on that, we suggest improvements to the model by excluding negatively impactful scenarios and reordering tokens using importance scores.
5,608
2410.03292
[ -0.046683378517627716, -0.03852775692939758, -0.0020205287728458643, 0.04384922236204147, 0.038509003818035126, 0.02929844707250595, 0.019964713603258133, 0.011714361608028412, -0.03833552822470665, -0.02367161400616169, 0.016311630606651306, 0.003703158814460039, -0.07398160547018051, -0.0017182141309604049, 0.020247846841812134, 0.05745589733123779, 0.05426504835486412, -0.018869247287511826, 0.020266925916075706, 0.01055144239217043, -0.00851669441908598, 0.04516129940748215, 0.04818415641784668, 0.024596909061074257, 0.02139100804924965, 0.012577134184539318, 0.008534162305295467, -0.026722220703959465, -0.017677590250968933, -0.018115075305104256, 0.015761472284793854, -0.029041875153779984, -0.010296807624399662, 0.01023039873689413, -0.002111478941515088, 0.01267879456281662, -0.05382205918431282, 0.027107346802949905, 0.012484048493206501, 0.00863085687160492, -0.05851738154888153, 0.005855342373251915, -0.00871632993221283, -0.00425226055085659, -0.025943022221326828, 0.01971226930618286, -0.1279493272304535, 0.018844177946448326, 0.023680811747908592, -0.04452782869338989, -0.11121203005313873, 0.023541145026683807, 0.023761088028550148, 0.019723841920495033, 0.014848796650767326, 0.01718245819211006, 0.022674959152936935, -0.059988487511873245, 0.01654883660376072, -0.06566645205020905, -0.009122340939939022, 0.0023159272968769073, 0.030051767826080322, -0.0025454049464315176, -0.008159351535141468, -0.02046402357518673, 0.019265195354819298, 0.039937056601047516, -0.024711888283491135, -0.021960988640785217, -0.014110613614320755, 0.002600690582767129, -0.0025815805420279503, 0.020696589723229408, 0.002512803301215172, -0.06838897615671158, 0.009405849501490593, 0.03260010480880737, 0.06346525996923447, 0.006050824653357267, -0.013333816081285477, 0.01953219808638096, 0.029795072972774506, 0.042964234948158264, 0.018847165629267693, -0.018768617883324623, -0.03209657222032547, -0.03655898943543434, -0.09321393817663193, 0.04649648442864418, -0.0510808601975441, -0.04749516770243645, 0.008876251056790352, 0.04540792107582092, -0.01685706339776516, -0.003981682006269693, 0.02135845646262169, 0.003969750367105007, 0.0018940502777695656, 0.013945162296295166, -0.020163362845778465, -0.040022075176239014, 0.018525434657931328, -0.006257209461182356, -0.11172698438167572, -0.03196455538272858, -0.02422380819916725, 0.0104134576395154, -0.0027661463245749474, 0.020800819620490074, -0.051743168383836746, -0.015286264941096306, 0.03247327357530594, -0.019990652799606323, -0.07807715982198715, 0.02106139250099659, -0.009819988161325455, 0.03875621408224106, -0.0044739036820828915, -0.003080495400354266, 0.06328599154949188, 0.045691970735788345, -0.0050919996574521065, 0.038907330483198166, -0.015832444652915, -0.001471056486479938, 0.020143134519457817, 0.02183358371257782, -0.042254071682691574, -0.0473499558866024, 0.0034718841779977083, 0.015123453922569752, 0.0016313984524458647, 0.004190664738416672, -0.01054080668836832, 0.01243301760405302, 0.0051608216017484665, 0.03127158060669899, 0.032416023313999176, 0.003970602061599493, 0.009074405767023563, -0.004931469447910786, 0.055170707404613495, -0.002984241582453251, 0.06105430796742439, 0.017095549032092094, -0.0004152891633566469, -0.03136016055941582, -0.04706524312496185, -0.016041813418269157, -0.004092423710972071, -0.005028546322137117, -0.01084863767027855, -0.046872809529304504, 0.0061419373378157616, 0.029858428984880447, 0.005214167758822441, -0.0075010634027421474, 0.018790120258927345, 0.006357009522616863, 0.0260469987988472, -0.015526195988059044, -0.034501440823078156, 0.022165952250361443, 0.00894963275641203, -0.06226237118244171, 0.0696992501616478, 0.03434070944786072, -0.030978400260210037, -0.012255500070750713, -0.05496174842119217, -0.03728659823536873, 0.04356443136930466, 0.0066827028058469296, -0.015475843101739883, -0.0022979259956628084, 0.06036382168531418, 0.00246681971475482, 0.031792059540748596, 0.021477464586496353, -0.0861169695854187, 0.028481027111411095, -0.016541002318263054, 0.01787136308848858, 0.019064148887991905, -0.03244885802268982, 0.08025574684143066, -0.03703593090176582, -0.009545726701617241, -0.020791487768292427, -0.06503666937351227, -0.0002737298491410911, 0.01764923892915249, 0.004735847003757954, 0.0545535683631897, -0.01747439242899418, -0.005608630832284689, 0.026638688519597054, 0.041247159242630005, 0.03865616396069527, 0.0535687580704689, -0.009740335866808891, 0.024551087990403175, -0.0033569680526852608, -0.02451198361814022, 0.0010609051678329706, 0.048552289605140686, -0.0828043669462204, -0.03945048153400421, 0.032173894345760345, -0.020380115136504173, -0.016134893521666527, -0.011125135235488415, -0.028756575658917427, 0.01973770372569561, -0.002378263045102358, 0.004796094726771116, 0.010236826725304127, 0.006267530843615532, -0.04127800092101097, 0.06583131849765778, 0.02083977684378624, -0.02932916209101677, 0.013016371987760067, -0.012554659508168697, 0.10377553850412369, 0.0665515661239624, -0.010170734487473965, -0.00984060950577259, 0.03009619750082493, 0.01798468828201294, -0.01769881695508957, -0.016557425260543823, -0.032988883554935455, 0.017087044194340706, -0.02348475344479084, -0.030806295573711395, -0.017480533570051193, 0.046532757580280304, -0.03265473619103432, 0.01938113011419773, 0.066258005797863, -0.026049919426441193, 0.06448621302843094, -0.01907893642783165, 0.01061815395951271, 0.03865426033735275, -0.0017496615182608366, -0.050758760422468185, -0.013957717455923557, -0.06096731498837471, -0.0188385471701622, 0.025511296465992928, -0.030900511890649796, 0.002029924653470516, -0.04152069240808487, -0.03938296064734459, -0.015062390826642513, 0.06748674064874649, 0.0517086461186409, 0.05154800042510033, 0.020343586802482605, -0.017691168934106827, -0.042670316994190216, -0.026773963123559952, -0.11811672151088715, -0.03710208833217621, -0.0009133951389230788, 0.04759081080555916, 0.013734310865402222, 0.036545529961586, -0.018883101642131805, 0.0368817038834095, -0.03165898099541664, -0.026146817952394485, 0.010177458636462688, 0.009990346617996693, 0.006580831948667765, -0.03497680649161339, -0.0013015951262786984, 0.001332385465502739, 0.07904359698295593, -0.010201148688793182, -0.04358401149511337, -0.011111769825220108, -0.03622924163937569, 0.005094245541840792, -0.03375178948044777, -0.013549084775149822, 0.031072966754436493, 0.042186807841062546, 0.02125244401395321, -0.01623688079416752, 0.01298269722610712, 0.030628986656665802, 0.06275874376296997, 0.03315122053027153, 0.02739110216498375, -0.007648456376045942, 0.02259235829114914, -0.008923698216676712, 0.016669848933815956, -0.0013633118942379951, -0.0003835440438706428, -0.009652892127633095, -0.02795487642288208, 0.014838816598057747, 0.016463298350572586, -0.27989619970321655, -0.012573644518852234, -0.009365123696625233, -0.012054748833179474, 0.027688458561897278, -0.015897370874881744, 0.07015058398246765, 0.005828468594700098, -0.025279102846980095, 0.021463384851813316, 0.0238347128033638, 0.010426323860883713, 0.0015161358751356602, 0.034728094935417175, 0.03873083367943764, 0.002174694323912263, 0.002243570052087307, -0.02387356571853161, 0.0020716111175715923, 0.04081246256828308, -0.018220068886876106, -0.07548091560602188, -0.02686499059200287, 0.06445632874965668, -0.01155984215438366, 0.0383940190076828, -0.0819990485906601, -0.018532786518335342, -0.022368449717760086, 0.011791340075433254, -0.04020799696445465, -0.030179554596543312, 0.00009225586109096184, 0.04469817876815796, 0.003487141104415059, 0.0018552300753071904, 0.013250981457531452, -0.01766848750412464, 0.006911728996783495, 0.01097799465060234, 0.01478708814829588, -0.0014374214224517345, -0.020695403218269348, 0.03976636752486229, 0.049887217581272125, 0.021777870133519173, -0.02181348204612732, 0.009800408966839314, -0.017450375482439995, 0.027281034737825394, 0.012087207287549973, -0.029375046491622925, -0.028639497235417366, -0.006206961814314127, 0.008218038827180862, -0.023694362491369247, -0.025322170928120613, 0.007281842641532421, 0.00776433851569891, 0.021002741530537605, 0.005700821988284588, -0.051496557891368866, 0.004556381609290838, -0.02671501226723194, -0.029007209464907646, -0.04238120838999748, -0.0691261887550354, -0.027505023404955864, 0.03511388599872589, 0.021519208326935768, -0.00713013019412756, 0.00620213383808732, -0.029719278216362, -0.10176734626293182, 0.006803673226386309, -0.016146361827850342, -0.006587856449186802, -0.0176329854875803, 0.014586168341338634, 0.06730567663908005, -0.03148280084133148, -0.024885056540369987, 0.007904063910245895, 0.015330621041357517, 0.024140160530805588, -0.018157340586185455, 0.015353615395724773, 0.010307430289685726, -0.030608484521508217, -0.021004922688007355, 0.03518977016210556, -0.000819423992652446, 0.04541798308491707, -0.02148311212658882, 0.061073869466781616, 0.015823641791939735, 0.0035403212532401085, 0.03699548542499542, 0.04298980161547661, -0.009379631839692593, 0.03474658355116844, -0.07436073571443558, -0.023529309779405594, -0.05074822157621384, -0.024779798462986946, 0.05401422828435898, -0.06704473495483398, -0.02217140607535839, 0.04265937954187393, 0.0038465126417577267, -0.028733540326356888, -0.029963744804263115, 0.002822434762492776, -0.0400870218873024, 0.0047664642333984375, 0.01502419076859951, -0.006587228737771511, 0.00673530250787735, 0.03876453638076782, -0.002148902975022793, -0.05975502356886864, 0.05169660225510597, -0.01977778784930706, 0.01276452373713255, 0.003209206508472562, -0.005000827834010124, -0.01374890562146902, -0.009768468327820301, 0.00223780469968915, -0.036539606750011444, 0.052073732018470764, 0.049906667321920395, 0.00978049449622631, 0.030124183744192123, 0.05316995084285736, 0.01125089917331934, 0.023212408646941185, -0.005192289594560862, 0.020037628710269928, -0.03373827412724495, -0.0048554427921772, -0.006628154776990414, 0.029027245938777924, 0.006526496261358261, 0.024268366396427155, 0.02303505688905716, 0.01530994288623333, 0.019084209576249123, 0.02862226963043213, -0.013291873037815094, 0.061080750077962875, -0.0796096995472908, -0.023450983688235283, -0.055873122066259384, 0.0112512968480587, -0.016410058364272118, 0.03638352081179619, -0.029174810275435448, 0.04229169711470604, -0.08077030628919601, 0.03403976932168007, 0.003923547919839621, -0.019160762429237366, -0.02049103192985058, 0.02351398393511772, 0.064459428191185, -0.04743127152323723, -0.0057464176788926125, 0.05752214789390564, 0.022418810054659843, 0.004027973394840956, -0.044139180332422256, -0.0211147703230381, -0.008722392842173576, -0.010878262110054493, 0.008451690897345543, -0.005232608411461115, -0.01241236086934805, -0.03136203810572624, -0.006414135452359915, -0.006083784159272909, -0.0067245839163661, -0.01747339777648449, 0.02358509972691536, 0.07708925008773804, 0.00005685267024091445, 0.006411505397409201, -0.018520750105381012, -0.029116971418261528, 0.03588476777076721, -0.0020936725195497274, 0.02830197662115097, -0.017648834735155106, -0.0611155703663826, -0.03239579498767853, -0.027840150520205498, -0.02390366420149803, 0.05034848675131798, -0.01722387969493866, 0.00014609900244977325, 0.008951396681368351, 0.02113543264567852, -0.012867814861238003, 0.028251878917217255, 0.040076058357954025, -0.04782576858997345, 0.018514977768063545, 0.038143303245306015, -0.024532096460461617, -0.0025600146036595106, -0.034981098026037216, -0.049360595643520355, -0.05774329975247383, -0.008239040151238441, 0.00701635517179966, 0.014783716760575771, -0.03948899358510971, -0.023762959986925125, 0.013278895989060402, 0.022054288536310196, 0.030233317986130714, 0.03179455175995827, 0.009134480729699135, -0.006742811296135187, -0.008936586789786816, 0.038888655602931976, -0.021232832223176956, 0.017870314419269562, 0.01423037052154541, -0.0034396948758512735, 0.005893010646104813, -0.039207056164741516, 0.02430383302271366, 0.05226624384522438, -0.018592583015561104, -0.00914634671062231, -0.0346158966422081, 0.050325360149145126, -0.007397227920591831, 0.00010240497795166448, -0.012890366837382317, -0.01463235542178154, -0.04223459213972092, 0.013072192668914795, -0.00627551693469286, 0.02765047736465931, 0.03583903610706329, 0.008417460136115551, 0.021362587809562683, 0.00611242838203907, 0.024511825293302536, 0.017749890685081482, -0.06835585832595825, -0.0038762157782912254, 0.060580313205718994, 0.00299312942661345, -0.03231901675462723, -0.08800926804542542, -0.02149638906121254, 0.01528219785541296, -0.013536174781620502, 0.02455192804336548, -0.033243123441934586, 0.039581090211868286, 0.01741255633533001, 0.032206833362579346, 0.032478317618370056, -0.01401774026453495, 0.0647929236292839, -0.025499731302261353, 0.006944803986698389, -0.08151565492153168, -0.02953905425965786, 0.0570470355451107, -0.01861460879445076, 0.02961437590420246, -0.010456264950335026, -0.04236571863293648, 0.004053275566548109, -0.014803801663219929, -0.056142084300518036, 0.04379670321941376, -0.04190618544816971, 0.01663026586174965, 0.0429382361471653, -0.05550650134682655, -0.029724815860390663, -0.03890557214617729, -0.04694012552499771, -0.009186076000332832, -0.004531186074018478, 0.04845917969942093, -0.013479501008987427, 0.021558066830039024, -0.03124367631971836, 0.0083203399553895, 0.03567996621131897, 0.0653286874294281, 0.025083107873797417, 0.04025142639875412, -0.026571689173579216, 0.07577217370271683, 0.015842577442526817, 0.028572728857398033, -0.012142629362642765, 0.0024488884955644608, -0.0353517159819603, -0.056555211544036865, 0.050033580511808395, 0.017854604870080948, -0.010860992595553398, -0.0826035812497139, 0.06333132833242416, 0.019596144556999207, -0.04877812787890434, -0.00041558107477612793, 0.030481737107038498, -0.06894329190254211, -0.02814512886106968, 0.002274235477671027, 0.0010737864067777991, -0.015146326273679733, 0.0642591342329979, 0.026233386248350143, 0.049397245049476624, 0.063927061855793, -0.02013487182557583, -0.021649694070219994, 0.0026012391317635775, 0.08046503365039825, 0.05532368645071983, 0.06874583661556244, 0.0011243418557569385, 0.06784848123788834, -0.03662239760160446, -0.05668577551841736, 0.0443386435508728, 0.008035983890295029, -0.01744227483868599, -0.02933771163225174, 0.003856329247355461, 0.05948055908083916, -0.00729889702051878, 0.0880940854549408, -0.04969639331102371, -0.02412639744579792, 0.05817137658596039, 0.02315722405910492, 0.009989696554839611, 0.035473037511110306, 0.025144433602690697, 0.0004954664618708193, -0.030743103474378586, -0.011960451491177082, -0.014064990915358067, -0.013937694951891899, 0.018647098913788795, 0.01397624146193266, -0.028933590278029442, 0.03619779646396637, 0.03720782324671745, 0.06182555854320526, 0.11836756020784378, -0.04986149072647095, -0.007528644520789385, 0.004713079426437616, -0.012440073303878307, 0.009636816568672657, 0.03664042800664902, -0.006747993640601635, -0.011888641864061356, 0.00957406871020794, -0.019548702985048294, 0.02083319053053856, 0.045816339552402496, -0.036987874656915665, -0.005724519025534391, -0.007114148233085871, -0.03813086077570915, 0.013905547559261322, 0.03307734802365303, -0.03232766315340996, -0.030440427362918854, -0.06442826241254807, -0.051025114953517914, -0.060411859303712845, -0.04462499916553497, 0.03657303750514984, 0.0004960530786775053, -0.009892446920275688, 0.005881851073354483, -0.030227072536945343, 0.006310959346592426, 0.010509294457733631, -0.04526617377996445, -0.016284126788377762, 0.020714689046144485, -0.0146126514300704, -0.014447455294430256, 0.03084755502641201, 0.03982838615775108, -0.02506236732006073, -0.030326571315526962, 0.031244652345776558, 0.03683086857199669, 0.033109378069639206, -0.01830604486167431, -0.014982592314481735, -0.10236889868974686, 0.027019023895263672, 0.021426042541861534, -0.04228243976831436, -0.07436030358076096, 0.026072578504681587, -0.052519410848617554, 0.030542386695742607, 0.06565679609775543, -0.027996687218546867, 0.00566104194149375, -0.04038811847567558, -0.015296664088964462, 0.0009228630224242806, -0.0003209780843462795, 0.043300166726112366, -0.015986250713467598, 0.07893744856119156, 0.05205575004220009, -0.02318972907960415, -0.027490539476275444, 0.03867820277810097, -0.007149976212531328, -0.0071095917373895645, -0.013048212975263596, -0.020453503355383873, -0.03860754147171974, -0.08744027465581894, -0.015324515290558338, 0.04590645059943199, -0.012492245063185692, -0.06771064549684525, 0.0009444522438570857, -0.022468870505690575, -0.004568742588162422, -0.018312077969312668, -0.016361583024263382, -0.015060280449688435, -0.0326341949403286, -0.04588808864355087, -0.08485593646764755, 0.00792261678725481, -0.038361966609954834, 0.010774371214210987, -0.03964903950691223, -0.035646211355924606, 0.021283073350787163, 0.009286570362746716, 0.011476075276732445, -0.0145353889092803, -0.000031348481570603326, -0.013288134709000587 ]
3,541
Let SSMs be ConvNets: State-space Modeling with Optimal Tensor Contractions
https://openreview.net/forum?id=PkpNRmBZ32
[ "Yan Ru Pei" ]
Spotlight
We introduce Centaurus, a class of networks composed of generalized state-space model (SSM) blocks, where the SSM operations can be treated as tensor contractions during training. The optimal order of tensor contractions can then be systematically determined for every SSM block to maximize training efficiency. This allows more flexibility in designing SSM blocks beyond the depthwise-separable configuration commonly implemented. The new design choices will take inspiration from classical convolutional blocks including group convolutions, full convolutions, and bottleneck blocks. We architect the Centaurus network with a mixture of these blocks, to balance between network size and performance, as well as memory and computational efficiency during both training and inference. We show that this heterogeneous network design outperforms its homogeneous counterparts in raw audio processing tasks including keyword spotting, speech denoising, and automatic speech recognition (ASR). For ASR, Centaurus is the first network with competitive performance that can be made fully state-space based, without using any nonlinear recurrence (LSTMs), explicit convolutions (CNNs), or (surrogate) attention mechanism.
state-space models; convolution; tensor networks; audio processing; speech recognition
using deep SSMs like ConvNets to do audio processing
5,569
2501.13230
[ -0.02129945531487465, -0.04097003862261772, -0.024283645674586296, 0.025871947407722473, 0.045503683388233185, 0.017107021063566208, 0.022904934361577034, 0.022830583155155182, -0.02183026820421219, -0.051035962998867035, -0.018699631094932556, -0.004003388341516256, -0.06679022312164307, 0.01593419723212719, -0.01628080941736698, 0.06135515868663788, 0.03970009461045265, 0.0011982094729319215, 0.03682582080364227, 0.020902695134282112, 0.002075294964015484, -0.018875572830438614, 0.042073871940374374, 0.008173505775630474, 0.02455395832657814, 0.005690339021384716, 0.005689884070307016, 0.02479926124215126, -0.027650415897369385, -0.007162692025303841, 0.015551433898508549, -0.015885645523667336, -0.02401983179152012, 0.009650051593780518, 0.012898797169327736, 0.030032962560653687, -0.049433574080467224, -0.010135075077414513, 0.009420212358236313, -0.010235997848212719, -0.030877042561769485, -0.03856588155031204, 0.007599538192152977, -0.01039236318320036, -0.07200133055448532, 0.03015350177884102, -0.11713767796754837, 0.018306095153093338, -0.03328581899404526, -0.061626724898815155, -0.09665139764547348, 0.023017024621367455, -0.005559233017265797, -0.014165018685162067, 0.010877221822738647, 0.02221662551164627, 0.02241862192749977, -0.07193831354379654, 0.011697081848978996, -0.04862057417631149, -0.020053599029779434, 0.007670059334486723, 0.01818470098078251, 0.008920198306441307, -0.0034569629933685064, -0.007866637781262398, 0.020894885063171387, 0.05099187791347504, -0.05602516978979111, -0.05517564341425896, -0.015120078809559345, 0.0325620099902153, -0.0046915109269320965, 0.0423242524266243, 0.023814097046852112, -0.047802869230508804, 0.019325681030750275, -0.024391483515501022, 0.08474735915660858, -0.009449339471757412, -0.005454439204186201, 0.032266855239868164, 0.0161410104483366, 0.028316190466284752, -0.008017981424927711, -0.002570219337940216, -0.02912929654121399, -0.016965221613645554, -0.10081646591424942, 0.04186641052365303, -0.0280682984739542, -0.04241173341870308, 0.019331268966197968, 0.035565659403800964, 0.03584500029683113, -0.01915852166712284, 0.017981931567192078, -0.00593021372333169, 0.021457141265273094, -0.0058064223267138, 0.00437969621270895, -0.04836657643318176, 0.01171858049929142, -0.010224412195384502, -0.12630173563957214, -0.009259926155209541, -0.019281744956970215, -0.00797746516764164, 0.022065619006752968, 0.01631617359817028, -0.017029691487550735, -0.009683375246822834, 0.004615539684891701, -0.0036239770706743, -0.061600491404533386, 0.03343912586569786, 0.02779547870159149, -0.015423101373016834, -0.0037596886977553368, -0.007664927747100592, 0.058893583714962006, 0.04811197891831398, -0.005943387281149626, 0.05932183191180229, -0.00541929854080081, -0.01094573363661766, -0.011415359564125538, 0.011011460795998573, -0.031216925010085106, -0.047482870519161224, -0.017830394208431244, 0.01366783119738102, 0.012278050184249878, 0.014986265450716019, 0.003436949336901307, -0.0097737992182374, 0.006858984474092722, 0.008997420780360699, 0.04424753785133362, 0.006898562889546156, 0.060291871428489685, -0.004703066311776638, 0.027619516476988792, -0.01121668890118599, 0.0942908227443695, 0.002877928549423814, -0.016620174050331116, -0.018633728846907616, -0.017988072708249092, 0.02663753181695938, -0.0001007741957437247, -0.037555936723947525, 0.015375873073935509, -0.04952405393123627, 0.055511899292469025, 0.038007866591215134, 0.03477546572685242, 0.021224182099103928, 0.0017816327745094895, 0.007494697812944651, 0.02503151074051857, -0.023683695122599602, -0.09419852495193481, 0.024233674630522728, -0.0035900648217648268, -0.06721083074808121, 0.022913269698619843, 0.02737598679959774, -0.029301917180418968, -0.000121807970572263, -0.04254644364118576, -0.04139941930770874, 0.03754204511642456, -0.004679364617913961, -0.02775138057768345, -0.017927497625350952, 0.056285470724105835, 0.01947977766394615, 0.02584932930767536, 0.021875180304050446, -0.09470954537391663, 0.04999237507581711, 0.01932331919670105, -0.010935596190392971, 0.024252604693174362, -0.001959382090717554, 0.07617735862731934, -0.022589586675167084, -0.011411706916987896, -0.0036927571054548025, -0.09008181840181351, -0.012877481989562511, -0.017524736002087593, 0.0007509777205996215, 0.04507778584957123, -0.004531733226031065, 0.0019556297920644283, 0.02324644848704338, -0.0008205341291613877, 0.04108002781867981, 0.03733988106250763, -0.01272872556000948, 0.055923473089933395, 0.009208515286445618, -0.014524577185511589, 0.013822629116475582, 0.009610549546778202, -0.05556989833712578, -0.020352447405457497, 0.015285221859812737, 0.008699373342096806, -0.00873173400759697, 0.010780137963593006, -0.009274332784116268, 0.018684567883610725, -0.02281639352440834, 0.006035471800714731, 0.0018872577929869294, 0.015560255385935307, -0.060742542147636414, 0.0869106575846672, 0.026733387261629105, -0.016744237393140793, 0.04525897651910782, -0.05814579874277115, 0.10501985251903534, 0.07182248681783676, -0.0295436792075634, -0.014967720955610275, 0.04285633936524391, -0.0015280131483450532, -0.016231544315814972, 0.0008683078922331333, -0.009209232404828072, 0.01146638859063387, 0.0008101052371785045, 0.0027157883159816265, -0.04297933354973793, 0.05374503880739212, -0.058598633855581284, -0.014531783759593964, 0.07675949484109879, -0.044159214943647385, 0.08602634817361832, -0.011785362847149372, 0.008221769705414772, 0.06027288734912872, -0.0007520763319917023, -0.026445167139172554, -0.03204939886927605, -0.011395425535738468, -0.0026219887658953667, 0.0014834747416898608, -0.019900718703866005, 0.021921848878264427, -0.05882907658815384, -0.016199294477701187, -0.013241546228528023, 0.06145760789513588, 0.04550974816083908, 0.008344169706106186, 0.04404919967055321, -0.013123526237905025, -0.02860727161169052, -0.03184684365987778, -0.1235605999827385, -0.01812490075826645, -0.010185464285314083, 0.0486600436270237, -0.021524809300899506, 0.06120559200644493, 0.0051088109612464905, 0.014835198409855366, -0.012702399864792824, 0.011837068945169449, 0.0061464933678507805, 0.036820635199546814, -0.009264233522117138, -0.021379416808485985, -0.013490606099367142, -0.0007751824450679123, 0.045819178223609924, -0.000004502403044170933, -0.029241234064102173, -0.015449742786586285, -0.03365684673190117, 0.01172169391065836, -0.049303580075502396, -0.013040515594184399, -0.006041062530130148, 0.009497457183897495, 0.03092503361403942, 0.0013296444667503238, 0.005256759934127331, 0.008822382427752018, 0.09641200304031372, 0.049602679908275604, 0.006394543219357729, -0.021174080669879913, 0.023779507726430893, -0.040935151278972626, 0.012372461147606373, 0.008967626839876175, -0.004295556806027889, -0.03723567724227905, -0.039599690586328506, 0.03172342851758003, -0.03107580915093422, -0.28139808773994446, 0.0077909547835588455, 0.003421346889808774, -0.029947921633720398, 0.060629699379205704, -0.01941228285431862, 0.04297913238406181, -0.022776467725634575, -0.03762919083237648, 0.011105211451649666, 0.00839399266988039, 0.04602169245481491, 0.003792878007516265, 0.009852646850049496, 0.06251168251037598, 0.02534748800098896, -0.013104680925607681, -0.03244512155652046, 0.009702424518764019, 0.04479954391717911, 0.028737498447299004, -0.06023059040307999, 0.005385411903262138, 0.020739765837788582, -0.005295306909829378, 0.016973324120044708, -0.09017550200223923, 0.010797340422868729, -0.023335063830018044, -0.002671667141839862, -0.03929326683282852, -0.018965722993016243, 0.014421702362596989, 0.04299560561776161, 0.00822263304144144, 0.0018605260411277413, 0.02369096502661705, 0.006242653355002403, 0.04314138740301132, -0.013106578029692173, 0.012543637305498123, -0.02387681044638157, 0.021620381623506546, 0.0004443841171450913, 0.040468282997608185, 0.03861004486680031, -0.04144072160124779, -0.011718428693711758, -0.04790164902806282, 0.027948448434472084, -0.00526847830042243, -0.016357015818357468, -0.022616947069764137, 0.012095116078853607, -0.004289492033421993, -0.0321049764752388, -0.018937699496746063, 0.00801424216479063, -0.013491098769009113, 0.011986236087977886, 0.024740656837821007, -0.06301791965961456, -0.020525341853499413, -0.07152491807937622, -0.020604735240340233, -0.025602534413337708, -0.03740720450878143, -0.02964690886437893, 0.048511553555727005, 0.03947736322879791, -0.025448549538850784, 0.019204430282115936, -0.0137405376881361, -0.08552175015211105, 0.007045003119856119, -0.005167277529835701, -0.007540717255324125, -0.029246168211102486, -0.006655828561633825, 0.04315771535038948, -0.05671778693795204, -0.05315011367201805, 0.021030716598033905, 0.03022051602602005, 0.013364727608859539, -0.02032516896724701, 0.023603301495313644, -0.007095886394381523, -0.027466004714369774, -0.033487867563962936, 0.03685281425714493, -0.027184301987290382, 0.003089629579335451, -0.0025413709226995707, 0.04299303889274597, 0.046619243919849396, 0.0038311427924782038, 0.05995987355709076, 0.03774319589138031, 0.003349062753841281, 0.02913113310933113, -0.06037933751940727, -0.014043452218174934, -0.04124578833580017, -0.030781472101807594, 0.05424055829644203, -0.06754746288061142, -0.03883387893438339, 0.07061535120010376, 0.012352175079286098, -0.027265623211860657, -0.02597830444574356, 0.02914382889866829, -0.033145371824502945, -0.02051512338221073, -0.005406231619417667, -0.009675967507064342, 0.019111257046461105, 0.017429426312446594, 0.0036603156477212906, -0.01960650086402893, 0.04518241435289383, -0.0037365162279456854, 0.03666611388325691, 0.001181740895844996, -0.016660504043102264, -0.017389334738254547, -0.03439579904079437, -0.006726134568452835, -0.029830239713191986, 0.010263086296617985, 0.05310116335749626, 0.009854787960648537, 0.024669896811246872, 0.06221695616841316, 0.0005631205858662724, 0.010512229055166245, -0.007638214156031609, 0.015314511023461819, -0.008775019086897373, 0.011712372303009033, -0.03520134836435318, 0.02106460928916931, 0.02475709840655327, 0.0073129767552018166, 0.026777349412441254, 0.012362396344542503, 0.018888866528868675, 0.017337825149297714, 0.0251784510910511, 0.03825734183192253, -0.03242233023047447, -0.055267855525016785, -0.03744213655591011, 0.013980614952743053, -0.020372577011585236, 0.01959448866546154, -0.04462902992963791, 0.047831468284130096, -0.08282595127820969, 0.04233156144618988, 0.010499582625925541, 0.0009522957261651754, 0.0036289338022470474, 0.02960542030632496, 0.05374452844262123, -0.014730443246662617, -0.026451457291841507, 0.02710779383778572, 0.017062954604625702, 0.004189607221633196, -0.013781223446130753, -0.02525164745748043, -0.01633971743285656, -0.02490399032831192, 0.02426341362297535, 0.010603416711091995, 0.014161366969347, -0.018381696194410324, 0.030204899609088898, 0.045994967222213745, -0.006917851977050304, -0.002377144293859601, 0.044522859156131744, 0.05694069713354111, 0.022771107032895088, -0.01555109117180109, 0.0020013388711959124, -0.05060175806283951, 0.0666118636727333, -0.005217029247432947, 0.02152893878519535, -0.03755824267864227, -0.041239578276872635, -0.03570268303155899, -0.02403324283659458, -0.004145689774304628, 0.05416934937238693, -0.008063296787440777, -0.025519534945487976, -0.019158005714416504, 0.01901450753211975, -0.03168739005923271, 0.0023120110854506493, 0.032155100256204605, -0.07958688586950302, 0.028129030019044876, 0.019732944667339325, -0.032309867441654205, -0.016856534406542778, -0.03804007172584534, -0.00919251050800085, -0.04145355150103569, -0.042897384613752365, 0.018307477235794067, 0.002265538088977337, -0.025695117190480232, -0.013858039863407612, 0.026765359565615654, -0.023979010060429573, 0.02799443155527115, -0.018201084807515144, -0.00947258248925209, -0.000028164577088318765, -0.006060086190700531, 0.027969984337687492, -0.00685352087020874, 0.016074467450380325, 0.01785760559141636, -0.022838914766907692, 0.023585135117173195, -0.054088860750198364, 0.043561339378356934, 0.055748119950294495, -0.024309469386935234, -0.008768869563937187, -0.024070465937256813, 0.01225336268544197, -0.01840152218937874, -0.0032693620305508375, 0.020949339494109154, -0.003652855521067977, -0.05808345973491669, 0.01319622341543436, 0.01206255704164505, 0.02917296253144741, 0.06253034621477127, 0.02784717082977295, -0.004390908405184746, 0.01978578418493271, 0.02788345329463482, 0.030682943761348724, -0.08292435854673386, -0.007940451614558697, 0.03685222193598747, -0.02299104444682598, -0.019423818215727806, -0.08009167015552521, -0.04930828511714935, -0.0026379425544291735, 0.0014049207093194127, 0.03833349049091339, -0.03995132818818092, 0.055630460381507874, 0.023548301309347153, 0.04442594572901726, 0.016035670414566994, -0.03477715328335762, 0.034224435687065125, -0.022588403895497322, 0.012022997252643108, -0.05104056000709534, -0.03223750740289688, 0.045137710869312286, -0.015443472191691399, 0.0292812492698431, -0.012249771505594254, -0.03195996209979057, 0.027003128081560135, -0.019302422180771828, -0.05016332119703293, 0.021032296121120453, -0.025180242955684662, 0.008767744526267052, 0.01199702825397253, -0.04884989187121391, -0.01011569332331419, -0.016137508675456047, -0.03124021552503109, 0.006637413986027241, 0.016112608835101128, 0.038632530719041824, -0.04034312069416046, 0.00978669710457325, -0.03500859811902046, -0.004460517317056656, 0.02062671259045601, 0.06297613680362701, -0.005945634562522173, 0.03431665897369385, -0.044667355716228485, 0.05699029192328453, 0.04052215442061424, -0.009932098910212517, -0.008187921717762947, -0.004645637236535549, -0.038352202624082565, -0.06655126065015793, 0.06305679678916931, 0.01873001828789711, -0.012930492870509624, -0.07420959323644638, 0.06955287605524063, 0.0210136529058218, -0.030925974249839783, 0.00028876838041469455, 0.037805553525686264, -0.028307603672146797, -0.020927246659994125, -0.004978332668542862, -0.036460988223552704, -0.03176218643784523, 0.049602169543504715, 0.016929127275943756, 0.033619072288274765, 0.0859512984752655, -0.033176735043525696, -0.02926991693675518, 0.011612851172685623, 0.055344726890325546, 0.028961466625332832, 0.04920278489589691, -0.01671581156551838, 0.07745856046676636, -0.05858590826392174, -0.05954369530081749, 0.059969909489154816, 0.046585310250520706, 0.0020614315290004015, -0.041654858738183975, -0.004743590950965881, 0.04743645712733269, 0.005458202213048935, 0.06849377602338791, -0.04234691709280014, -0.003609539708122611, 0.016614826396107674, 0.02046125940978527, -0.002080366248264909, 0.020448733121156693, 0.031496550887823105, 0.006819437723606825, -0.023813491687178612, 0.0014788538683205843, 0.004995168652385473, -0.018991688266396523, 0.013616378419101238, -0.00032273386023007333, -0.005260260310024023, 0.03557632490992546, -0.0101814866065979, 0.02724503166973591, 0.11176332831382751, -0.042847953736782074, -0.05334017053246498, 0.011179107241332531, -0.01207701489329338, 0.006909828167408705, 0.023082103580236435, 0.005067517515271902, -0.04932362586259842, 0.021067805588245392, -0.01671465113759041, 0.020881475880742073, 0.013943211175501347, -0.0007370200473815203, -0.005266635213047266, 0.013722498901188374, -0.016046106815338135, 0.008524578996002674, 0.02238040789961815, -0.05883987247943878, -0.05358127877116203, -0.05900712311267853, -0.07158239185810089, -0.03839857131242752, -0.02182919718325138, 0.020773055031895638, 0.015787968412041664, -0.0013045675586909056, -0.024163778871297836, -0.03687172010540962, 0.013576543889939785, -0.001968205440789461, -0.053763266652822495, 0.014808855950832367, 0.008744911290705204, 0.023616259917616844, -0.009249141439795494, 0.03493712097406387, 0.047637566924095154, -0.027044864371418953, -0.01992020010948181, 0.04885445535182953, 0.041880786418914795, 0.017979467287659645, 0.006522456184029579, 0.0036801891401410103, -0.1083686500787735, 0.03399702534079552, -0.002860757987946272, -0.015034269541501999, -0.09076337516307831, 0.02400556579232216, -0.018326768651604652, 0.038118552416563034, 0.07022049278020859, -0.002447725972160697, 0.021163610741496086, -0.04666619375348091, -0.007221269886940718, 0.025942625477910042, -0.002532729646191001, 0.0307454913854599, -0.012058226391673088, 0.0776124820113182, 0.06098701059818268, -0.009752091020345688, -0.03155558556318283, 0.035238418728113174, 0.010158508084714413, -0.009352488443255424, -0.019543269649147987, -0.035872332751750946, -0.06023118644952774, -0.08218222111463547, -0.05116026848554611, 0.022916056215763092, -0.021498799324035645, -0.04192426800727844, 0.012329371646046638, 0.0009124628850258887, -0.017155930399894714, -0.03776661306619644, 0.004898545797914267, -0.03307971730828285, -0.012409128248691559, -0.048470474779605865, -0.0460146889090538, 0.013894508592784405, -0.00914683472365141, 0.02852923795580864, -0.021113863214850426, -0.025348111987113953, -0.01901319995522499, 0.006702533923089504, 0.033912207931280136, 0.02728665992617607, 0.02892739698290825, 0.00024215869780164212 ]
3,542
MixEval-X: Any-to-any Evaluations from Real-world Data Mixture
https://openreview.net/forum?id=hpCfPEvBsr
[ "Jinjie Ni", "Yifan Song", "Deepanway Ghosal", "Bo Li", "David Junhao Zhang", "Xiang Yue", "Fuzhao Xue", "Yuntian Deng", "Zian Zheng", "Kaichen Zhang", "Mahir Shah", "Kabir Jain", "Yang You", "Michael Shieh" ]
Spotlight
Perceiving and generating diverse modalities are crucial for AI models to effectively learn from and engage with real-world signals, necessitating reliable evaluations for their development. We identify two major issues in current evaluations: (1) inconsistent standards, shaped by different communities with varying protocols and maturity levels; and (2) significant query, grading, and generalization biases. To address these, we introduce MixEval-X, the first any-to-any, real-world benchmark designed to optimize and standardize evaluations across diverse input and output modalities. We propose multi-modal benchmark mixture and adaptation-rectification pipelines to reconstruct real-world task distributions, ensuring evaluations generalize effectively to real-world use cases. Extensive meta-evaluations show our approach effectively aligns benchmark samples with real-world task distributions. Meanwhile, MixEval-X's model rankings correlate strongly with that of crowd-sourced real-world evaluations (up to 0.98) while being much more efficient. We provide comprehensive leaderboards to rerank existing models and organizations and offer insights to enhance understanding of multi-modal evaluations and inform future research.
Evaluation, Multi-modal Evaluation, Benchmark, Multi-modal Benchmark, Any-to-any, MixEval, Real-world, Data Mixture, Artificial General Intelligence, AGI
We propose MixEval-X, the first any-to-any real-world benchmark optimizing benchmark mixtures for a wide range of input-output modalities.
5,532
null
[ -0.010364373214542866, -0.02112133987247944, -0.011262357234954834, 0.03101525455713272, -0.003622698597609997, 0.015426116064190865, 0.016028456389904022, 0.03978283703327179, -0.03507770970463753, -0.041581157594919205, -0.03252740576863289, 0.027095621451735497, -0.06452632695436478, -0.033652059733867645, 0.003949103876948357, 0.04380986467003822, 0.024907605722546577, -0.011342542245984077, 0.0005546195898205042, 0.023326106369495392, 0.026844991371035576, -0.00043223140528425574, -0.010246268473565578, 0.0016331328079104424, 0.00506896385923028, 0.0068199471570551395, 0.022794650867581367, 0.003976984415203333, -0.053370025008916855, -0.0013352062087506056, 0.02683582529425621, 0.012187948450446129, 0.010106552392244339, -0.03969702124595642, -0.020976025611162186, 0.012353166937828064, -0.027214601635932922, -0.0038306175265461206, 0.01165747083723545, 0.01287635788321495, -0.020746689289808273, 0.001067229313775897, 0.020067822188138962, 0.03825313597917557, -0.04732295125722885, 0.008206679485738277, -0.08724857121706009, 0.04591505602002144, 0.0006806575693190098, 0.004215594846755266, -0.09056707471609116, 0.028286542743444443, 0.02608563005924225, -0.022234244272112846, 0.027420055121183395, 0.02758810855448246, 0.03114399127662182, -0.07538377493619919, 0.0024375603534281254, -0.027219029143452644, -0.04988589137792587, 0.05805475637316704, 0.03182169795036316, 0.03326854482293129, 0.02304479107260704, -0.0015524278860539198, 0.022228175774216652, 0.03256926313042641, -0.026125933974981308, -0.024826742708683014, -0.02066069468855858, -0.017167773097753525, -0.002695237984880805, -0.010843547992408276, -0.026916462928056717, -0.05614345893263817, 0.038320064544677734, 0.05283966660499573, 0.03440378978848457, -0.013372298330068588, 0.05494885891675949, -0.010357408784329891, 0.02642027847468853, 0.04625650867819786, 0.03861159458756447, 0.01766146533191204, -0.018551846966147423, -0.025338273495435715, -0.07135975360870361, 0.007500906474888325, -0.013783552683889866, -0.05135154351592064, 0.039289359003305435, 0.051982637494802475, 0.0016802006866782904, -0.0006595727172680199, 0.032490577548742294, -0.008470873348414898, 0.0034285990986973047, 0.0013049101689830422, -0.009547857567667961, -0.007275666110217571, 0.035795632749795914, -0.0031028983648866415, -0.10833602398633957, -0.00791336502879858, -0.03544101491570473, -0.0004445285303518176, -0.0017882889369502664, 0.019109360873699188, -0.019374437630176544, -0.013351712375879288, 0.026175521314144135, -0.002914144191890955, -0.05705839768052101, 0.023376232013106346, -0.007306759245693684, 0.026152240112423897, -0.010031625628471375, 0.010600347071886063, 0.06437227874994278, 0.048401929438114166, -0.007952103391289711, 0.0635291188955307, -0.0009117756271734834, 0.045127760618925095, -0.0010462678037583828, 0.024328619241714478, -0.00449554156512022, -0.030090749263763428, -0.005253590643405914, 0.012816122733056545, -0.0022274877410382032, -0.0029802238568663597, 0.021217582747340202, -0.007735369727015495, 0.03787008300423622, 0.0366949699819088, 0.06426222622394562, 0.005912553519010544, 0.005712477024644613, -0.03447994962334633, 0.06399236619472504, -0.048878300935029984, 0.07250779867172241, 0.030367940664291382, -0.020762665197253227, 0.00636761961504817, -0.018478749319911003, -0.001947777345776558, 0.03126095235347748, 0.022594282403588295, -0.002806686097756028, -0.0785362645983696, 0.04103536531329155, 0.06753958761692047, -0.0017432884778827429, -0.018152866512537003, 0.010916233994066715, 0.008651520125567913, -0.0078189792111516, 0.025671418756246567, -0.06883303821086884, 0.009175742976367474, 0.015872297808527946, -0.050289686769247055, -0.0018521819729357958, 0.03867098689079285, -0.0713513195514679, 0.010471348650753498, -0.06140628829598427, -0.032907359302043915, 0.06898926943540573, -0.018646955490112305, -0.025779565796256065, 0.005112388636916876, 0.10261610895395279, 0.02395881712436676, 0.03851610794663429, 0.02839774824678898, -0.0814533606171608, 0.01161695085465908, -0.02082873322069645, -0.009865171276032925, 0.025933871045708656, 0.008783593773841858, 0.07279183715581894, -0.031308114528656006, 0.02142377942800522, 0.028725851327180862, -0.08444652706384659, -0.04753497987985611, 0.001112325699068606, 0.0013335873372852802, 0.03894157335162163, 0.007025375496596098, -0.01794464699923992, 0.055830877274274826, 0.05033290013670921, 0.02946389466524124, 0.055614423006772995, -0.02110983058810234, 0.04000931978225708, -0.021668432280421257, -0.03859032690525055, -0.00014887223369441926, 0.05505429208278656, -0.0656019076704979, -0.04218572750687599, -0.01015624962747097, -0.012294887565076351, 0.02040703408420086, -0.007885347120463848, 0.008847443386912346, -0.016511600464582443, 0.03463741019368172, 0.021587872877717018, 0.0035869088023900986, 0.014424667693674564, -0.028794046491384506, 0.0815250501036644, 0.02418099157512188, -0.0011569124180823565, -0.0214963611215353, -0.03355169668793678, 0.08455551415681839, 0.0500296913087368, -0.03250059857964516, 0.0020628811325877905, 0.011972881853580475, -0.0060603986494243145, 0.02900976687669754, 0.02521313726902008, -0.004125405102968216, 0.00928539875894785, -0.017025629058480263, -0.001129396609030664, 0.01092127338051796, 0.03857529163360596, -0.0364847406744957, -0.03631361201405525, 0.07523366808891296, -0.00947495736181736, 0.07146706432104111, -0.015202557668089867, 0.014712300151586533, 0.04887351021170616, -0.0028988446574658155, -0.028582824394106865, -0.029902957379817963, -0.0002408892469247803, -0.005656817462295294, 0.01627231575548649, -0.03394341468811035, -0.002795831998810172, -0.04102545604109764, -0.007953939028084278, -0.03821508586406708, 0.04299425333738327, 0.06102394685149193, 0.004546642769128084, 0.030998075380921364, 0.022287659347057343, -0.026194237172603607, 0.03287855535745621, -0.10425842553377151, -0.07006650418043137, -0.018567128106951714, 0.0218197014182806, -0.015994492918252945, 0.04831365495920181, -0.006878075655549765, 0.025893209502100945, -0.017829986289143562, -0.021581392735242844, 0.03804198279976845, -0.0000024398361802013824, 0.0204110499471426, -0.048035573214292526, -0.04003562033176422, -0.024056578055024147, 0.05967911332845688, -0.016872700303792953, -0.02176988124847412, -0.050870008766651154, -0.029107078909873962, 0.014382002875208855, -0.06827738881111145, -0.0124713946133852, 0.03219378739595413, 0.017359916120767593, 0.03316149488091469, -0.0105603551492095, -0.008628672920167446, 0.02660795859992504, 0.06274572759866714, 0.06361612677574158, 0.01198322419077158, -0.05630781501531601, 0.04135589674115181, -0.005117165856063366, 0.001076962216757238, -0.0018993639387190342, -0.015362330712378025, 0.01410799939185381, 0.005339125171303749, -0.014945636503398418, -0.02234865538775921, -0.25338733196258545, -0.026032838970422745, 0.017028510570526123, -0.011651271022856236, 0.026287663727998734, -0.07043270021677017, 0.02668456733226776, -0.01520113367587328, -0.035793136805295944, -0.003954483196139336, 0.02288716845214367, 0.05067070573568344, 0.01701473817229271, 0.05555121973156929, 0.05125443637371063, 0.024129819124937057, 0.02935897745192051, -0.038423750549554825, 0.036434855312108994, 0.04247564822435379, -0.015497291460633278, -0.06987735629081726, -0.025372330099344254, 0.028379837051033974, -0.005228270310908556, 0.028075139969587326, -0.07704370468854904, -0.002221416449174285, -0.030993875116109848, -0.01711239293217659, 0.03244909271597862, -0.01611129567027092, -0.024610821157693863, 0.05999322608113289, 0.0048064677976071835, 0.03524148091673851, 0.0600258894264698, 0.0018386362353339791, 0.030357209965586662, 0.008202114142477512, 0.004745836835354567, -0.018239615485072136, -0.04360281676054001, -0.015352629125118256, 0.07275759428739548, 0.007927535101771355, -0.048518817871809006, -0.010928953066468239, -0.02754809707403183, 0.0003482745960354805, -0.028551099821925163, -0.026375658810138702, -0.02891312539577484, 0.007948994636535645, 0.01330555696040392, -0.036342933773994446, 0.01700829342007637, 0.009518272243440151, 0.0005087127792648971, -0.007525978609919548, 0.012355130165815353, -0.04002614691853523, -0.015017545782029629, -0.032651592046022415, 0.005977854132652283, -0.054172441363334656, -0.06395658105611801, -0.06227439269423485, 0.04594328626990318, 0.019043417647480965, -0.013937423937022686, 0.009167324751615524, 0.0166530329734087, -0.09944610297679901, 0.0019295469392091036, 0.012997135519981384, 0.0005657392321154475, -0.019422125071287155, -0.004437517374753952, 0.04188388213515282, -0.05670291930437088, -0.04444232955574989, -0.009426151402294636, -0.025549612939357758, 0.023632166907191277, -0.02598314918577671, -0.002897132420912385, -0.021871399134397507, -0.035245463252067566, -0.01970222219824791, 0.061494793742895126, -0.023462727665901184, 0.0029191148933023214, 0.01663351245224476, 0.04671333730220795, 0.03155531734228134, 0.02950550802052021, 0.062074851244688034, 0.05124444514513016, 0.026038378477096558, 0.009919204749166965, -0.10177449136972427, 0.01977997086942196, -0.06789903342723846, -0.03417394682765007, 0.02293586917221546, -0.057143233716487885, -0.027589350938796997, 0.03740507364273071, -0.030873585492372513, -0.021946843713521957, -0.03752963989973068, 0.0017005872214213014, -0.016685904935002327, -0.021650373935699463, -0.010316926054656506, -0.005529237911105156, 0.028128083795309067, 0.0342780277132988, -0.023169608786702156, -0.01380299311131239, 0.011557930149137974, -0.012287216261029243, 0.016401099041104317, -0.02532055228948593, -0.042119842022657394, 0.008404935710132122, -0.017680954188108444, 0.006398307625204325, -0.009052892215549946, 0.008494747802615166, 0.06118780001997948, -0.03290071710944176, 0.0162824634462595, 0.02116057462990284, -0.0015131342224776745, 0.013200185261666775, 0.010479383170604706, 0.02610165998339653, -0.019639160484075546, 0.03728416562080383, -0.01735951006412506, 0.05565629154443741, 0.02256661094725132, 0.007202768698334694, 0.001551002380438149, -0.02293182723224163, -0.009812084026634693, -0.02803018130362034, 0.005227117333561182, 0.02346118725836277, -0.05172529071569443, -0.014057029038667679, -0.022880105301737785, 0.01888871379196644, 0.0001681015855865553, 0.023420777171850204, -0.006536643952131271, -0.005046567879617214, -0.0918305441737175, 0.013596790842711926, -0.015370791777968407, -0.017960112541913986, -0.0063472930341959, 0.05336308106780052, 0.033655133098363876, -0.013360219076275826, 0.023992354050278664, -0.027610762044787407, 0.024739088490605354, 0.00781814381480217, -0.0372970849275589, -0.0003556731971912086, -0.048152461647987366, -0.02411625348031521, -0.0004897335893474519, -0.0028569356072694063, 0.014106485061347485, -0.04621002823114395, 0.04326551407575607, 0.01726442761719227, -0.002377572702243924, 0.033061690628528595, -0.01810430735349655, 0.08030325174331665, 0.0060099526308476925, 0.008939924649894238, 0.005621253978461027, -0.005777506623417139, 0.019217638298869133, -0.041254445910453796, 0.023396166041493416, -0.007403297815471888, -0.03271565958857536, -0.061428386718034744, -0.05324834585189819, 0.030996067449450493, -0.009207064285874367, -0.04666149243712425, -0.018448498100042343, -0.0018801597179844975, -0.011906756088137627, -0.04571329802274704, -0.023450013250112534, 0.03949645534157753, -0.09056708961725235, -0.009206493385136127, 0.003703211434185505, -0.03765038773417473, 0.01691458560526371, -0.048123136162757874, -0.0658712163567543, -0.05492394044995308, -0.03252238780260086, -0.001756757963448763, -0.009693177416920662, -0.017552006989717484, -0.006814370863139629, -0.00607246533036232, -0.03357899561524391, 0.022547896951436996, -0.01152887474745512, -0.012726441957056522, -0.011729549616575241, -0.009788955561816692, 0.0423489548265934, -0.03002205118536949, -0.01564331166446209, 0.02109418623149395, -0.023182790726423264, 0.02289416454732418, -0.03221481293439865, -0.007968422956764698, 0.036747679114341736, -0.013179304078221321, 0.009457891806960106, -0.07161661237478256, 0.04896809905767441, 0.004982660990208387, -0.03271276503801346, -0.013231771066784859, -0.01751870848238468, -0.03369322419166565, 0.017666436731815338, 0.0012467426713556051, 0.03691352903842926, -0.012352345511317253, 0.011343339458107948, 0.021084938198328018, -0.006542554125189781, 0.023562844842672348, 0.008390307426452637, -0.055009420961141586, 0.01419493556022644, 0.04212205484509468, -0.04369756951928139, -0.013700665906071663, -0.056952670216560364, -0.05059133097529411, 0.020321452990174294, -0.02973281592130661, 0.04428441449999809, -0.008604930713772774, 0.03765469789505005, 0.020205305889248848, 0.03876354917883873, 0.023715859279036522, -0.04871692508459091, 0.026701409369707108, -0.04983208701014519, 0.024381322786211967, -0.06767408549785614, -0.021857956424355507, 0.06190856546163559, 0.005866635590791702, -0.02479885332286358, -0.017386537045240402, -0.03761988505721092, 0.05979457497596741, -0.020467115566134453, -0.06781137734651566, 0.003897999180480838, -0.037770237773656845, -0.00410735048353672, 0.017651604488492012, -0.029961485415697098, -0.009648350067436695, -0.03934713080525398, -0.03046695701777935, -0.006502982694655657, 0.0015493767568841577, 0.04594968259334564, 0.0076294452883303165, 0.055656757205724716, -0.022996515035629272, -0.005102435126900673, 0.008699997328221798, 0.040513429790735245, -0.0011029678862541914, 0.040749967098236084, -0.02718275412917137, 0.06384803354740143, 0.012804942205548286, 0.013283530250191689, 0.018940385431051254, 0.02455933578312397, -0.039094649255275726, -0.04266979545354843, 0.03068452514708042, 0.0036064658779650927, -0.05421563610434532, -0.07320662587881088, 0.062489595264196396, 0.0245980117470026, -0.04438380151987076, 0.003121054032817483, 0.014329014346003532, -0.07197832316160202, 0.039713628590106964, 0.008911404758691788, 0.009722593240439892, -0.0379086434841156, 0.08404180407524109, 0.015748215839266777, 0.04367206618189812, 0.07764405012130737, 0.018578805029392242, -0.02713797613978386, 0.001917784451507032, 0.07016230374574661, 0.04228083789348602, 0.06040754169225693, -0.022514313459396362, 0.0601092167198658, -0.022346990182995796, -0.05297822505235672, 0.011408806778490543, 0.057491403073072433, -0.010721969418227673, -0.04163936525583267, -0.014063037931919098, 0.05901048704981804, 0.0158231221139431, 0.0663481280207634, -0.05066138878464699, 0.012659703381359577, 0.03764907643198967, 0.006389485206454992, -0.010842637158930302, 0.050427358597517014, 0.02843841351568699, 0.01787242293357849, -0.012484453618526459, -0.023686671629548073, -0.024237031117081642, -0.04428691416978836, 0.014650685712695122, 0.033613380044698715, -0.010449089109897614, 0.014334693551063538, -0.003402772592380643, 0.0390542708337307, 0.11546380817890167, -0.05147533491253853, -0.047929126769304276, 0.020631233230233192, 0.015015222132205963, 0.031163353472948074, 0.007855618372559547, 0.016003267839550972, -0.04629223048686981, 0.01024127658456564, -0.030975408852100372, -0.0027756178751587868, 0.016739867627620697, -0.025440195575356483, 0.0463455393910408, -0.04540318623185158, -0.028258126229047775, 0.011526914313435555, 0.00489447358995676, -0.057723261415958405, -0.03829234838485718, -0.025370655581355095, -0.033086732029914856, -0.04769628867506981, -0.046977344900369644, 0.0074431817047297955, 0.025572415441274643, -0.02865789644420147, -0.012255256995558739, -0.008605592884123325, 0.028209229931235313, 0.07421166449785233, -0.052560217678546906, -0.0007466753013432026, 0.016974909231066704, 0.007297120057046413, -0.03557242825627327, 0.03365481272339821, 0.04977136477828026, -0.009754324331879616, 0.00782364048063755, 0.054419130086898804, 0.015777140855789185, 0.0328374020755291, -0.0043920958414673805, -0.0251918975263834, -0.0706959217786789, 0.01835985668003559, 0.025709178298711777, -0.03585628420114517, -0.09590712934732437, 0.0005961946444585919, -0.04473431780934334, 0.05191543325781822, 0.04551328346133232, 0.030620787292718887, 0.01367431040853262, -0.03260650113224983, -0.011386487632989883, 0.04457855597138405, 0.015756934881210327, 0.03929787874221802, -0.03921610862016678, 0.07783910632133484, 0.040961455553770065, 0.009659862145781517, -0.036529406905174255, 0.05300890654325485, -0.0210574958473444, -0.01873859018087387, 0.0006649886490777135, -0.03702506050467491, -0.04497120529413223, -0.0661858469247818, -0.01564335636794567, 0.038529813289642334, -0.0060978238470852375, -0.029282260686159134, -0.03472181037068367, 0.031668078154325485, -0.02567433752119541, -0.005694315768778324, -0.0367879644036293, 0.0003798639227170497, -0.011322923004627228, -0.022469671443104744, -0.06281343102455139, 0.010117662139236927, -0.028415605425834656, 0.011907324194908142, -0.010920427739620209, -0.03965579345822334, 0.023025548085570335, 0.004231734201312065, 0.05847363919019699, -0.013321244157850742, 0.05651017278432846, -0.005753050092607737 ]
3,543
Knowledge Localization: Mission Not Accomplished? Enter Query Localization!
https://openreview.net/forum?id=tfyHbvFZ0K
[ "Yuheng Chen", "Pengfei Cao", "Yubo Chen", "Kang Liu", "Jun Zhao" ]
Spotlight
Large language models (LLMs) store extensive factual knowledge, but the mechanisms behind how they store and express this knowledge remain unclear. The Knowledge Neuron (KN) thesis is a prominent theory for explaining these mechanisms. This theory is based on the **Knowledge Localization (KL)** assumption, which suggests that a fact can be localized to a few knowledge storage units, namely knowledge neurons. However, this assumption has two limitations: first, it may be too rigid regarding knowledge storage, and second, it neglects the role of the attention module in knowledge expression. In this paper, we first re-examine the KL assumption and demonstrate that its limitations do indeed exist. To address these, we then present two new findings, each targeting one of the limitations: one focusing on knowledge storage and the other on knowledge expression. We summarize these findings as **Query Localization** assumption and argue that the KL assumption can be viewed as a simplification of the QL assumption. Based on QL assumption, we further propose the Consistency-Aware KN modification method, which improves the performance of knowledge modification, further validating our new assumption. We conduct 39 sets of experiments, along with additional visualization experiments, to rigorously confirm our conclusions. Code will be made public soon.
Knowledge Neruon Thesis, Knowledge Localization, Query Localization
We re-evaluate the knowledge localization assumption, demonstrate its limitations, and propose the query localization assumption, proving that the knowledge localization assumption is merely a simplification of the query localization assumption.
5,438
2405.14117
[ -0.013543633744120598, -0.014525569044053555, -0.011618046090006828, 0.05281449109315872, 0.04872855544090271, 0.005000539124011993, 0.04025854170322418, 0.017616260796785355, -0.05134705826640129, 0.015672428533434868, -0.04790818691253662, 0.020056946203112602, -0.030104532837867737, -0.003180022817105055, 0.013628076761960983, 0.05796193331480026, 0.02252875454723835, 0.000477786612464115, 0.03712822124361992, 0.006370174698531628, -0.02073506824672222, 0.007694937288761139, 0.04502934217453003, 0.006286597345024347, 0.05336899682879448, 0.00962953269481659, -0.01931402087211609, -0.015152140520513058, -0.0162928719073534, -0.0038549890741705894, 0.022084170952439308, 0.0031104732770472765, 0.003504567313939333, -0.0017500557005405426, -0.013255251571536064, -0.006937452591955662, -0.020721914246678352, 0.05186336115002632, 0.010074480436742306, -0.0000010000287602451863, -0.04920090734958649, 0.03999720886349678, 0.0020689324010163546, 0.02029391936957836, -0.05796121805906296, -0.026126068085432053, -0.10897552222013474, 0.03932751715183258, 0.020406289026141167, 0.005511790979653597, -0.1123686209321022, 0.04948904365301132, 0.005205749999731779, -0.028942622244358063, -0.02489260397851467, 0.040025744587183, 0.07563483715057373, -0.09484878927469254, -0.0028478882741183043, -0.03333350270986557, -0.009563404135406017, 0.0287509523332119, 0.009288680739700794, 0.01931305229663849, 0.008559409528970718, -0.025873025879263878, -0.013008831068873405, 0.03135134279727936, -0.06475389003753662, -0.04161866754293442, -0.030758431181311607, -0.0015910628717392683, -0.0007493626908399165, 0.007429507095366716, -0.010616382583975792, -0.025214096531271935, 0.015716219320893288, 0.03724329546093941, 0.03748578205704689, -0.003468938637524843, -0.00697711855173111, 0.024809129536151886, 0.008489624597132206, 0.05195555090904236, 0.020578818395733833, -0.0061545828357338905, -0.05199489742517471, -0.05747724324464798, -0.06409360468387604, 0.010792218148708344, -0.02143312804400921, -0.0482819527387619, -0.013276055455207825, 0.030146313831210136, 0.013112383894622326, 0.03157000616192818, 0.05666918307542801, 0.025841839611530304, 0.01018439419567585, -0.007358473725616932, -0.04154965654015541, -0.04212486371397972, 0.0005849241279065609, 0.00738313514739275, -0.09724576771259308, -0.030642446130514145, -0.019099105149507523, -0.017979484051465988, 0.013601908460259438, 0.012490356341004372, -0.047669000923633575, -0.02266833558678627, 0.012657804414629936, -0.017234640195965767, -0.05978918448090553, 0.012645586393773556, 0.007099162321537733, 0.0022456811275333166, -0.0027003204450011253, 0.031940560787916183, 0.020817633718252182, 0.0486895889043808, 0.015760274603962898, 0.07427487522363663, -0.022372867912054062, 0.0033341830130666494, -0.0374986007809639, 0.016338909044861794, -0.030945397913455963, -0.05033034458756447, 0.01813879981637001, 0.018174786120653152, -0.006018379237502813, 0.011181979440152645, -0.006746137980371714, -0.0003013948444277048, 0.03130445256829262, 0.004564082715660334, 0.03356021270155907, -0.003283013589680195, 0.012668615207076073, -0.04407212510704994, 0.03988487645983696, -0.01598605141043663, 0.08839438855648041, -0.010847784578800201, -0.026872405782341957, -0.01533633004873991, -0.020278172567486763, -0.000550052965991199, 0.010694270953536034, -0.0181617122143507, -0.0020621391013264656, -0.04495040699839592, 0.05127595737576485, 0.0885496661067009, -0.009742895141243935, 0.00007122663373593241, 0.038223396986722946, -0.004274000413715839, 0.000990268075838685, 0.009335584938526154, -0.05113722011446953, 0.014849591068923473, -0.0091747110709548, -0.07361623644828796, 0.015401532873511314, 0.01008602138608694, -0.016445156186819077, 0.0009445081814192235, -0.033885225653648376, -0.03633483126759529, 0.07709012925624847, -0.03392041102051735, -0.031385160982608795, 0.004925194196403027, 0.05545610934495926, -0.006557360291481018, 0.022511286661028862, 0.011083072982728481, -0.051972463726997375, 0.018137898296117783, -0.03393469750881195, -0.02731379121541977, 0.005674830172210932, -0.004097416996955872, 0.06198355555534363, -0.04423578083515167, -0.012634459882974625, 0.004951031878590584, -0.07281620055437088, -0.011249407194554806, -0.0011601276928558946, 0.0006675986805930734, 0.09112052619457245, 0.007520156446844339, 0.00581039022654295, 0.05704478919506073, -0.010656406171619892, 0.04427149146795273, 0.06880766153335571, 0.015764407813549042, 0.05399436131119728, -0.003806858090683818, -0.012126101180911064, 0.055883437395095825, 0.0006103396299295127, -0.05831378698348999, -0.02644682303071022, 0.06000588834285736, -0.035298869013786316, 0.003963791765272617, 0.009142407216131687, 0.008190467953681946, -0.0000938844314077869, 0.012886235490441322, -0.009532934054732323, -0.014219557866454124, 0.022505324333906174, -0.034450236707925797, 0.041828274726867676, 0.019933095201849937, 0.0016542100347578526, -0.014765617437660694, -0.010704701766371727, 0.08813729882240295, 0.0402325876057148, -0.02927449904382229, -0.01249085832387209, 0.039683401584625244, 0.020781604573130608, 0.000968360633123666, 0.025730988010764122, -0.02794853039085865, 0.0008975497330538929, -0.02566230297088623, 0.030167430639266968, -0.018852731212973595, 0.009157952852547169, -0.03198520466685295, -0.017407860606908798, 0.06635825335979462, -0.014897528104484081, 0.07318224012851715, 0.012761659920215607, 0.014924108982086182, 0.053715597838163376, -0.021346524357795715, 0.0013740761205554008, -0.017638949677348137, -0.021078627556562424, -0.005430732388049364, -0.006879782769829035, -0.03260517865419388, 0.02235621027648449, -0.041994936764240265, -0.019657976925373077, -0.005626526195555925, 0.08052843064069748, 0.03903087228536606, -0.01437663845717907, 0.028568577021360397, 0.011290596798062325, -0.049173418432474136, 0.006827997043728828, -0.08371876180171967, -0.002258633030578494, -0.02113642729818821, 0.03315817192196846, 0.0135688791051507, 0.02625761367380619, -0.018846724182367325, 0.05534418672323227, -0.022704318165779114, -0.010286705568432808, 0.015995528548955917, 0.002884585876017809, 0.01804625801742077, -0.0271430853754282, -0.011872929520905018, -0.0255566593259573, 0.03822675347328186, -0.02469210885465145, -0.01924641989171505, -0.00925946980714798, -0.03649091348052025, -0.004012771416455507, -0.03572830185294151, -0.03208046779036522, 0.038535188883543015, 0.02265331707894802, -0.019618501886725426, -0.010413709096610546, 0.007475529797375202, 0.043354813009500504, 0.05101228132843971, 0.045637913048267365, -0.0010369374649599195, -0.02879941277205944, 0.03776705637574196, -0.05242248252034187, 0.01988067291676998, -0.0064176879823207855, 0.033798445016145706, 0.013797911815345287, 0.016839396208524704, 0.02163844183087349, 0.01271679438650608, -0.2723458707332611, 0.002740924246609211, -0.00042198513983748853, -0.0279171671718359, 0.02167978323996067, 0.018350403755903244, 0.040142107754945755, -0.02564004622399807, -0.02249174565076828, -0.0035761487670242786, 0.010630995035171509, 0.04224739968776703, -0.01703413762152195, 0.0564543716609478, 0.02357238158583641, 0.03450234234333038, -0.002435244619846344, -0.013147513382136822, -0.0321468859910965, 0.03342636302113533, -0.009357714094221592, -0.06839311867952347, -0.022419441491365433, 0.07870510220527649, 0.007041000295430422, 0.06468313932418823, -0.10546455532312393, 0.004280264489352703, -0.04403408244252205, 0.006543394178152084, -0.004011289682239294, -0.03005105070769787, -0.055464476346969604, 0.04029712453484535, -0.046306077390909195, 0.015844866633415222, 0.03560478240251541, -0.01630563475191593, 0.0486680306494236, 0.010472428053617477, -0.0018084995681419969, 0.0010867684613913298, -0.013546464964747429, 0.018706267699599266, 0.07339072972536087, -0.027172494679689407, -0.09344475716352463, -0.0327179878950119, -0.02870529517531395, 0.034975793212652206, 0.006649643182754517, -0.0487535335123539, -0.017995240166783333, 0.02287987247109413, 0.001081550377421081, -0.06725119799375534, 0.03623403236269951, -0.020581234246492386, 0.0018073178362101316, -0.040706198662519455, 0.03400970250368118, -0.05746025592088699, -0.017725037410855293, -0.05119388923048973, 0.004033743403851986, -0.025790955871343613, -0.06665275990962982, -0.03435412421822548, 0.04671227186918259, 0.02898576855659485, -0.050052545964717865, 0.03714987635612488, -0.020418548956513405, -0.0952262207865715, -0.02483644336462021, -0.012742855586111546, -0.03190702199935913, -0.023910416290163994, 0.009109344333410263, 0.03579255938529968, -0.036430247128009796, -0.03663796931505203, -0.001059356378391385, 0.03841100260615349, 0.019969873130321503, -0.030186736956238747, 0.016685323789715767, -0.05579889938235283, -0.02420222945511341, -0.024574007838964462, 0.030545426532626152, 0.01248494628816843, 0.01324231456965208, 0.000895906297955662, 0.04030044376850128, 0.03440781682729721, 0.025704247877001762, 0.029533375054597855, 0.04159124940633774, 0.0035280596930533648, 0.026557035744190216, -0.07001525163650513, 0.0031654287595301867, -0.010760832577943802, -0.022899817675352097, 0.03174972161650658, -0.056988757103681564, -0.005360759329050779, 0.015800580382347107, 0.01427595503628254, -0.03825272619724274, -0.020361972972750664, -0.030111899599432945, 0.0049120280891656876, -0.009443853981792927, 0.008768267929553986, -0.011653628200292587, 0.027534881606698036, 0.020187560468912125, -0.04650402069091797, -0.0353623628616333, 0.05467037484049797, -0.004461660049855709, 0.025919180363416672, -0.022100552916526794, -0.014199118129909039, 0.0008676138240844011, -0.034550707787275314, 0.022662654519081116, 0.006566213443875313, 0.0319950096309185, 0.0350954644382, -0.013899978250265121, 0.010336514562368393, 0.05354301631450653, -0.03528967127203941, 0.012969525530934334, -0.007474521175026894, -0.00014592143998015672, -0.0041106692515313625, 0.012350054457783699, -0.016443399712443352, 0.04248674213886261, 0.05813722312450409, -0.006808646023273468, -0.01002217922359705, -0.006500911433249712, -0.009334727190434933, 0.0168671403080225, 0.014312689192593098, 0.027355577796697617, -0.04399486258625984, -0.0017471446190029383, -0.02855711244046688, 0.003605201141908765, -0.00779037456959486, 0.034108616411685944, -0.031617265194654465, 0.004008160438388586, -0.036249805241823196, 0.028676705434918404, -0.009486713446676731, 0.01137829851359129, 0.0019017092417925596, 0.02071208506822586, 0.01858149841427803, -0.02037741057574749, 0.014691701158881187, 0.024954447522759438, 0.023179441690444946, -0.01463212538510561, -0.0220772884786129, -0.036422815173864365, -0.026936957612633705, -0.03671516105532646, -0.019146442413330078, -0.0007927428232505918, -0.018545320257544518, -0.016628721728920937, 0.05728010833263397, 0.029324525967240334, -0.004952066577970982, 0.014785689301788807, -0.004637942183762789, 0.07745755463838577, 0.016874779015779495, 0.013447989709675312, -0.004840373527258635, -0.05434982478618622, -0.026081621646881104, -0.03438353165984154, 0.002001372165977955, 0.0021314804907888174, -0.048987410962581635, -0.03916223347187042, -0.03723235800862312, 0.0016436832956969738, 0.017324060201644897, -0.01561727188527584, 0.00935111753642559, -0.032453153282403946, -0.01843123696744442, -0.06758103519678116, 0.013365907594561577, 0.04690822213888168, -0.07130467891693115, 0.02031860128045082, 0.026312032714486122, 0.011888990178704262, 0.022698765620589256, -0.06246054545044899, -0.01741059310734272, -0.06487526744604111, -0.03244413435459137, 0.050642888993024826, -0.03908940404653549, -0.014018603600561619, -0.038654256612062454, -0.013239572755992413, 0.00677615636959672, 0.031077884137630463, -0.018091747537255287, 0.02145233191549778, -0.04585273936390877, 0.02680930867791176, 0.04660128057003021, -0.007374159060418606, -0.010552054271101952, -0.0025164394173771143, -0.04852956533432007, 0.03083772584795952, -0.05411195755004883, 0.042383428663015366, 0.037009455263614655, -0.003992500714957714, 0.0036599563900381327, -0.014233415946364403, 0.04411570355296135, 0.02157769538462162, -0.0000692679823259823, 0.024123361334204674, -0.003423521062359214, 0.003322896081954241, 0.025508400052785873, 0.013429085724055767, 0.0416366346180439, 0.012605520896613598, 0.011537611484527588, 0.00043328216997906566, 0.03468852862715721, 0.02292334847152233, -0.001151030301116407, -0.024314619600772858, 0.012543964199721813, 0.07304131239652634, -0.0359317772090435, -0.052475642412900925, -0.07494695484638214, -0.036469150334596634, 0.006132639944553375, 0.004171033389866352, 0.014338679611682892, -0.031938642263412476, 0.044100407510995865, -0.013198417611420155, 0.044954653829336166, -0.019084760919213295, -0.004613681696355343, 0.03766804188489914, -0.03964829444885254, -0.0007967631099745631, -0.0699794739484787, -0.036249708384275436, 0.05799207463860512, -0.029028810560703278, -0.04882519692182541, 0.00010960057988995686, -0.016123484820127487, 0.031895387917757034, -0.0055436501279473305, -0.056728657335042953, 0.010667303577065468, 0.01296381838619709, -0.00309526058845222, 0.03199734911322594, -0.04724075272679329, -0.030880605801939964, -0.02245500683784485, -0.04324673116207123, -0.02131836861371994, -0.044480085372924805, 0.05561167001724243, 0.015795322135090828, 0.02660941332578659, -0.01861613243818283, 0.0013572254683822393, 0.006723828613758087, 0.0718482956290245, 0.05358240008354187, 0.022326068952679634, -0.016613148152828217, 0.069344162940979, 0.041298478841781616, 0.010682996362447739, -0.001783863641321659, 0.027257800102233887, -0.03958078846335411, -0.043555598706007004, 0.06614100933074951, -0.022838478907942772, 0.015474165789783001, -0.052616968750953674, 0.07168743014335632, 0.026079196482896805, -0.038640785962343216, -0.02898222766816616, 0.002245459007099271, -0.06698880344629288, -0.0010963374515995383, -0.01965777948498726, -0.005641347263008356, -0.01808939129114151, 0.0728030577301979, 0.04263017326593399, 0.026833252981305122, 0.07503695040941238, 0.022733062505722046, -0.007160196080803871, -0.015531596727669239, 0.0694776251912117, 0.05014284327626228, 0.06318868696689606, 0.013672152534127235, 0.07400625944137573, -0.0332297645509243, -0.03353608772158623, 0.00699712336063385, 0.028007525950670242, 0.00553115364164114, -0.026788141578435898, -0.006311851553618908, 0.07049538195133209, 0.0019487731624394655, 0.044978611171245575, -0.060621071606874466, -0.003795510157942772, 0.06835885345935822, 0.03061768226325512, 0.005352960899472237, 0.05354990065097809, 0.022629648447036743, 0.02613750658929348, -0.044307950884103775, -0.02855164185166359, 0.0009561122278682888, -0.02637661062180996, -0.015383783727884293, 0.010930031538009644, -0.014155798591673374, -0.029993006959557533, -0.003066719276830554, 0.053517669439315796, 0.1339442878961563, -0.055687516927719116, -0.0075607383623719215, 0.00017157116963062435, 0.019787617027759552, 0.00513586075976491, 0.08167129009962082, -0.006175868213176727, -0.003896666457876563, -0.01956438086926937, -0.04662507772445679, 0.017172403633594513, -0.003695338498800993, -0.009370949119329453, 0.023628251627087593, -0.05028019845485687, -0.04565054923295975, 0.018504921346902847, 0.0517311692237854, -0.06390196084976196, -0.05523504316806793, -0.01615620031952858, -0.05367368832230568, -0.030743341892957687, -0.019369235262274742, 0.03780415281653404, -0.007310642395168543, -0.027289999648928642, 0.023853199556469917, -0.04442763328552246, 0.011982432566583157, -0.005785786081105471, -0.0481690913438797, 0.030134495347738266, 0.026703063398599625, 0.01736980862915516, -0.011004868894815445, 0.03621276840567589, 0.02766355499625206, -0.04358622059226036, 0.017941854894161224, 0.08153360337018967, 0.016692884266376495, 0.02027563937008381, 0.010350961238145828, -0.036212675273418427, -0.09357458353042603, -0.021583283320069313, -0.01792091503739357, -0.02944859117269516, -0.07642073929309845, 0.00492465402930975, -0.006668490823358297, 0.022168481722474098, 0.051100071519613266, 0.042501889169216156, 0.044003814458847046, -0.009428421966731548, 0.010546834208071232, 0.02166846953332424, 0.011051011271774769, 0.03810775279998779, -0.0170893594622612, 0.06348848342895508, 0.05134870484471321, -0.0095117948949337, -0.06169376149773598, -0.014520084485411644, -0.005799941252917051, -0.018684063106775284, -0.032477766275405884, -0.05712374672293663, -0.013263900764286518, -0.10665331035852432, -0.04661092534661293, 0.011035071685910225, -0.0026704552583396435, -0.020500779151916504, -0.009722224436700344, -0.01043859776109457, -0.03741352632641792, 0.002604492474347353, -0.032447874546051025, 0.015025817789137363, -0.028340239077806473, -0.05255299061536789, -0.03107677958905697, 0.013373131863772869, 0.007126221898943186, -0.013575294055044651, -0.03221127390861511, -0.03488272801041603, 0.009586739353835583, 0.006391179747879505, 0.04857686534523964, 0.02648906409740448, 0.00936867669224739, -0.029840681701898575 ]
3,544
Graph Sparsification via Mixture of Graphs
https://openreview.net/forum?id=7ANDviElAo
[ "Guibin Zhang", "Xiangguo Sun", "Yanwei Yue", "Chonghe Jiang", "Kun Wang", "Tianlong Chen", "Shirui Pan" ]
Spotlight
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have demonstrated superior performance across various graph learning tasks but face significant computational challenges when applied to large-scale graphs. One effective approach to mitigate these challenges is graph sparsification, which involves removing non-essential edges to reduce computational overhead. However, previous graph sparsification methods often rely on a single global sparsity setting and uniform pruning criteria, failing to provide customized sparsification schemes for each node's complex local context. In this paper, we introduce Mixture-of-Graphs (MoG), leveraging the concept of Mixture-of-Experts (MoE), to dynamically select tailored pruning solutions for each node. Specifically, MoG incorporates multiple sparsifier experts, each characterized by unique sparsity levels and pruning criteria, and selects the appropriate experts for each node. Subsequently, MoG performs a mixture of the sparse graphs produced by different experts on the Grassmann manifold to derive an optimal sparse graph. One notable property of MoG is its entirely local nature, as it depends on the specific circumstances of each individual node. Extensive experiments on four large-scale OGB datasets and two superpixel datasets, equipped with five GNN backbones, demonstrate that MoG (I) identifies subgraphs at higher sparsity levels ($8.67\\%\sim 50.85\\%$), with performance equal to or better than the dense graph, (II) achieves $1.47-2.62\times$ speedup in GNN inference with negligible performance drop, and (III) boosts ``top-student'' GNN performance ($1.02\\%\uparrow$ on RevGNN+\textsc{ogbn-proteins} and $1.74\\%\\uparrow$ on DeeperGCN+\textsc{ogbg-ppa}). The source code is available at \url{https://github.com/yanweiyue/MoG}.
Graph Sparsification, Mixture-of-Experts
null
5,422
2405.14260
[ -0.004807719960808754, -0.033940039575099945, 0.012681258842349052, 0.05260691046714783, 0.0262480266392231, 0.037810638546943665, 0.010731411166489124, 0.010889479890465736, -0.03954869881272316, -0.054305464029312134, 0.02960251457989216, -0.00689965533092618, -0.07346393167972565, 0.0019134377362206578, 0.02029998041689396, 0.04499361291527748, 0.03672327101230621, -0.0014903242699801922, -0.0193871408700943, -0.007690682541579008, 0.032707732170820236, -0.036475770175457, 0.013144660741090775, 0.030129913240671158, 0.038347065448760986, -0.015007259324193, 0.012563899159431458, 0.01870454102754593, -0.0024982825852930546, 0.04414471611380577, 0.0203264020383358, 0.020340682938694954, 0.020443465560674667, -0.04349760338664055, 0.03455774486064911, 0.0010073937010020018, -0.056263960897922516, 0.020123369991779327, -0.005842936225235462, 0.030650215223431587, -0.05508207902312279, 0.029137324541807175, -0.006178667768836021, 0.04834927245974541, -0.03787684068083763, 0.025286497548222542, -0.10127733647823334, 0.0195316169410944, -0.0011554975062608719, -0.022510526701807976, -0.09282534569501877, 0.04868962615728378, 0.02921639382839203, -0.006190994754433632, -0.01717858389019966, 0.018044231459498405, 0.058615170419216156, -0.03691982477903366, -0.0021550548262894154, -0.0326416976749897, -0.05735127627849579, 0.018630478531122208, 0.02653047814965248, 0.04461829364299774, -0.03794559836387634, -0.012179232202470303, -0.008842123672366142, 0.06384676694869995, -0.04202759265899658, -0.038995951414108276, 0.030179481953382492, -0.009184109047055244, -0.023669803515076637, 0.050584826618433, 0.015119514428079128, -0.014683942310512066, 0.03846409544348717, 0.01495366357266903, 0.0725175216794014, -0.008516752161085606, 0.024604029953479767, 0.006426879204809666, -0.024384845048189163, 0.022829120978713036, -0.006788450758904219, 0.021197866648435593, -0.05081691965460777, -0.03975648805499077, -0.08840040117502213, 0.037603043019771576, -0.018246643245220184, -0.06543753296136856, 0.01153299119323492, 0.0166228748857975, -0.00046700300299562514, -0.015390809625387192, 0.015240327455103397, -0.011820626445114613, 0.011291476897895336, -0.008963951840996742, -0.006086576730012894, -0.04507191851735115, 0.031328510493040085, 0.0023568139877170324, -0.10509712994098663, -0.03640271723270416, -0.022796383127570152, -0.003907938487827778, -0.014047897420823574, -0.016774583607912064, -0.01151303481310606, 0.007748975418508053, -0.03135900944471359, -0.019696567207574844, -0.07625174522399902, 0.04605826735496521, -0.019744809716939926, -0.008609944954514503, -0.0027148828376084566, -0.005204580724239349, 0.04834935814142227, 0.05879650637507439, 0.0016268535982817411, 0.07427474111318588, -0.0028720188420265913, 0.025627408176660538, 0.008043537847697735, 0.04194072261452675, -0.04304569959640503, -0.015731463208794594, -0.014236644841730595, 0.050289977341890335, 0.006838515400886536, -0.003491524839773774, 0.016846125945448875, -0.03406796604394913, 0.013623327016830444, 0.03209538757801056, 0.03720013052225113, -0.038676667958498, 0.005466793198138475, -0.032307811081409454, 0.028531860560178757, -0.04724498465657234, 0.05539708212018013, -0.03385426849126816, 0.00766590004786849, -0.017329121008515358, -0.024222997948527336, -0.007840456441044807, 0.022015420719981194, -0.019730480387806892, 0.009000329300761223, -0.04777515307068825, -0.009728954173624516, 0.09146370738744736, 0.007819759659469128, 0.041782770305871964, 0.00626092404127121, 0.013268399983644485, 0.0414157435297966, 0.0017810477875173092, -0.024525532498955727, 0.0034876333083957434, -0.036364614963531494, -0.05870594084262848, 0.02112775668501854, 0.048222120851278305, -0.07249391078948975, -0.008858595043420792, -0.021850664168596268, -0.04387292638421059, 0.04549179598689079, -0.045377567410469055, -0.01849396526813507, 0.006059225182980299, 0.059943992644548416, 0.0006943134940229356, 0.055226873606443405, 0.031098591163754463, -0.08610560745000839, 0.03225608170032501, 0.021112868562340736, -0.04253164678812027, -0.023313412442803383, -0.02348160184919834, 0.10176585614681244, -0.02031666226685047, 0.009786750189960003, 0.026288224384188652, -0.0865512415766716, -0.03328990936279297, 0.03864085674285889, -0.029876865446567535, 0.06527135521173477, 0.033739734441041946, -0.014205307699739933, 0.006170700769871473, 0.01535912323743105, 0.014429169707000256, 0.035307832062244415, -0.04824863374233246, 0.08757413923740387, -0.017153868451714516, -0.06943909078836441, 0.010206121951341629, 0.011970724910497665, -0.06587772816419601, -0.04941723868250847, 0.007887134328484535, 0.02578052319586277, -0.017925305292010307, 0.009119010530412197, -0.019426438957452774, 0.025595441460609436, 0.010097752325236797, 0.022407228127121925, -0.004388104658573866, 0.0294966883957386, -0.03505788743495941, 0.05173465609550476, 0.008821732364594936, -0.04127778857946396, 0.010807252489030361, -0.044865384697914124, 0.09058959782123566, 0.07145126163959503, -0.010576439090073109, -0.010240071453154087, -0.01168033853173256, 0.009478968568146229, 0.023977147415280342, 0.0468442440032959, -0.023472165688872337, -0.01119636557996273, -0.044868987053632736, -0.00036874538636766374, -0.007760258857160807, 0.05590706691145897, -0.06267531961202621, 0.003592445980757475, 0.051449310034513474, -0.005288481712341309, 0.034702252596616745, 0.010501968674361706, -0.004530610051006079, 0.018448131158947945, 0.004028009716421366, -0.007598996162414551, -0.03354249522089958, 0.03872282803058624, 0.02381056174635887, 0.0036914749071002007, -0.01129367109388113, 0.010280872695147991, -0.04041345417499542, 0.015851322561502457, -0.018079616129398346, 0.07862968742847443, 0.05595547333359718, 0.035110726952552795, -0.0010071512078866363, 0.011001307517290115, -0.03901870921254158, -0.051659051328897476, -0.10480694472789764, -0.06012142077088356, -0.040133439004421234, 0.039385098963975906, 0.0021027419716119766, 0.05604531988501549, -0.021536292508244514, 0.021772880107164383, -0.010917226783931255, 0.008523101918399334, -0.012471058405935764, 0.01235512737184763, 0.0008388976566493511, -0.04823014885187149, -0.03529788926243782, 0.0017574592493474483, 0.06786427646875381, 0.004721810109913349, -0.006881499197334051, -0.06370211392641068, -0.06481651216745377, 0.03249610587954521, -0.01714731566607952, 0.000536425388418138, 0.01589789055287838, 0.021307606250047684, 0.042552534490823746, -0.041837889701128006, -0.0175874475389719, 0.022538986057043076, 0.0454944409430027, 0.05757512152194977, -0.0003891706874128431, -0.030269449576735497, 0.012036704458296299, 0.01170757133513689, 0.050526104867458344, 0.0035876308102160692, -0.025688154622912407, -0.04190688207745552, 0.00639894837513566, -0.0005715203005820513, 0.006842248607426882, -0.25741273164749146, 0.02417721040546894, -0.000920807127840817, -0.03751801699399948, 0.017217621207237244, -0.06191908195614815, 0.03155190870165825, -0.030736926943063736, -0.05106540396809578, -0.03840554878115654, 0.011048438027501106, 0.02054901234805584, 0.0055831968784332275, 0.03139931336045265, 0.04660600796341896, 0.03538801148533821, 0.0023774956353008747, -0.014938774518668652, 0.023095587268471718, 0.044905148446559906, 0.0035713245160877705, -0.05664612725377083, -0.015688074752688408, 0.03459276258945465, -0.02191215567290783, 0.006921164225786924, -0.1032911166548729, -0.0314791239798069, -0.04350317269563675, -0.0002115065581165254, 0.02397843450307846, -0.01023789867758751, 0.004361256491392851, 0.029688088223338127, 0.009969108738005161, 0.01882730983197689, 0.04286026954650879, -0.024402178823947906, 0.03152402862906456, 0.026921140030026436, 0.017390988767147064, -0.007351126056164503, -0.047617629170417786, 0.012125711888074875, 0.06682223826646805, 0.031568001955747604, -0.036519721150398254, -0.004295642953366041, -0.009494076482951641, 0.04739458113908768, -0.010672193020582199, -0.014083471149206161, -0.01935306191444397, 0.003768663853406906, 0.008791879750788212, -0.01601403020322323, 0.02119184285402298, -0.005770992487668991, -0.013100648298859596, -0.019046181812882423, -0.009948712773621082, -0.05040664225816727, 0.016822611913084984, -0.04317528009414673, -0.022619115188717842, -0.042939815670251846, -0.08639629185199738, -0.08821862190961838, 0.023567793890833855, 0.012681450694799423, -0.02585596591234207, 0.02467554435133934, -0.011522005312144756, -0.07749885320663452, 0.025094864889979362, 0.0013699154369533062, -0.022124934941530228, 0.02840334177017212, -0.010403409600257874, 0.02704641968011856, -0.024547575041651726, -0.030989492312073708, 0.007814580574631691, 0.023252245038747787, 0.04858158528804779, -0.0004972599563188851, 0.012823074124753475, -0.011054298840463161, -0.012121349573135376, -0.02285667136311531, 0.02409871481359005, 0.01176066230982542, 0.03438115864992142, 0.016786914318799973, 0.04158252477645874, 0.03388715907931328, 0.032565318048000336, 0.06708083301782608, 0.042559489607810974, -0.00261228671297431, 0.065394826233387, -0.06134694442152977, -0.016220573335886, -0.02715633437037468, -0.05965648218989372, 0.009855370968580246, -0.04147087782621384, -0.011612382717430592, 0.027053266763687134, -0.018307028338313103, -0.039195507764816284, -0.06654960662126541, 0.018744848668575287, -0.010051391087472439, -0.0066858516074717045, -0.010586844757199287, 0.0014585948083549738, 0.01754685305058956, 0.03203468397259712, 0.004278227686882019, -0.031374070793390274, 0.03522489592432976, -0.011104580014944077, -0.0006779421819373965, -0.003031354397535324, -0.026962779462337494, -0.010958792641758919, -0.03992006182670593, 0.01711740344762802, 0.003543710336089134, 0.024766193702816963, 0.07718930393457413, -0.011393384076654911, -0.018847646191716194, 0.04022318497300148, -0.01575734093785286, -0.027497174218297005, -0.01574988104403019, 0.04094693064689636, 0.015005407854914665, 0.02983187511563301, 0.015539629384875298, 0.05115725100040436, 0.022699443623423576, 0.033193185925483704, 0.010336660780012608, 0.00573926605284214, 0.031035780906677246, -0.004025264177471399, -0.000040922441257862374, -0.017342781648039818, -0.049861498177051544, 0.008816593326628208, -0.04210980236530304, 0.041300732642412186, -0.004591063596308231, 0.0492493100464344, 0.022949136793613434, 0.022497005760669708, -0.041641656309366226, 0.05432426184415817, 0.004798069130629301, -0.012966043315827847, -0.012329848483204842, 0.0019302517175674438, 0.0355168841779232, 0.010409009642899036, 0.010565588250756264, 0.00637764111161232, -0.013940751552581787, 0.03369612619280815, 0.0049351854249835014, -0.01894313469529152, -0.002008723560720682, 0.019065633416175842, 0.019675472751259804, 0.003681958420202136, 0.014245159924030304, -0.025242596864700317, 0.052685290575027466, -0.0015644134255126119, -0.020499246194958687, -0.006287837866693735, 0.013636717572808266, 0.09025350958108902, 0.0492653027176857, -0.03677241504192352, -0.00009338348900200799, -0.025315169245004654, 0.054663076996803284, 0.023410389199852943, 0.02144664153456688, -0.028129808604717255, -0.048116136342287064, 0.001613299478776753, -0.032998938113451004, 0.01955954171717167, 0.024876371026039124, -0.014782787300646305, -0.023010125383734703, -0.0012121160980314016, 0.011373619548976421, -0.05256527289748192, 0.006349886767566204, 0.015655934810638428, -0.0719079002737999, -0.005470198579132557, 0.016667768359184265, -0.0279079582542181, 0.015295817516744137, -0.015252227894961834, -0.03157977759838104, -0.053237952291965485, -0.017296606674790382, 0.02663627825677395, 0.009579976089298725, -0.015179654583334923, 0.0011355978203937411, 0.01345122791826725, -0.0013111690059304237, -0.02275056578218937, 0.010258987545967102, -0.011292905546724796, -0.02770322933793068, 0.01919926516711712, 0.098051056265831, -0.017100365832448006, 0.014750265516340733, -0.03183809667825699, -0.012896325439214706, 0.01614523120224476, -0.008153941482305527, 0.015710914507508278, 0.06776125729084015, 0.008101114071905613, 0.040725380182266235, -0.05189622938632965, 0.024095799773931503, 0.008361533284187317, -0.046141624450683594, 0.021825676783919334, 0.00031662354012951255, -0.05398054048418999, 0.016087742522358894, -0.001062873750925064, 0.030556827783584595, -0.013857287354767323, 0.028482815250754356, 0.011421790346503258, -0.012223031371831894, 0.025422194972634315, 0.020754791796207428, -0.060640815645456314, -0.027101857587695122, 0.06150292605161667, -0.0240850280970335, -0.051059357821941376, -0.06199801340699196, -0.021096589043736458, -0.0015187979442998767, -0.043702661991119385, 0.03024754300713539, 0.01674255169928074, 0.02296242117881775, 0.05138241499662399, 0.03526637703180313, -0.028115825727581978, -0.03599415719509125, -0.009616783820092678, -0.03556658327579498, 0.020377013832330704, -0.0258785393089056, -0.010192939080297947, 0.08776099234819412, -0.03256528079509735, 0.025028999894857407, 0.0019383187172934413, -0.027291998267173767, 0.007016824092715979, -0.01674145832657814, -0.04142747074365616, -0.008285454474389553, -0.016985051333904266, 0.005932546686381102, 0.025886286050081253, -0.04233815521001816, 0.004001143854111433, 0.00868185330182314, -0.052210379391908646, -0.0216335728764534, -0.027613330632448196, 0.03758624568581581, -0.033304277807474136, 0.002140940399840474, -0.01585034839808941, -0.002241189358755946, 0.06382124871015549, 0.06167328357696533, 0.02032524347305298, 0.006983946543186903, -0.04819590598344803, 0.04086759313941002, 0.05674965679645538, -0.0052723269909620285, -0.015491384081542492, 0.02771608717739582, -0.02722511626780033, -0.04133802279829979, 0.047479297965765, 0.00692956754937768, -0.040242750197649, -0.052661288529634476, 0.062148045748472214, 0.00020858882635366172, -0.06440240889787674, -0.05925024300813675, 0.03634878993034363, -0.04133951663970947, 0.038418278098106384, -0.027654312551021576, 0.006426085252314806, 0.013423486612737179, 0.07501515001058578, 0.002389940433204174, 0.012246102094650269, 0.04368087276816368, 0.02328432723879814, -0.005235504824668169, -0.03539000079035759, 0.07494837790727615, 0.056743722409009933, 0.033893734216690063, -0.006226005032658577, 0.07648915797472, -0.029302043840289116, -0.03613675385713577, 0.014301778748631477, 0.014325007796287537, -0.035090167075395584, -0.016728512942790985, 0.0016794275725260377, 0.07732810080051422, -0.00839413981884718, 0.0725255161523819, -0.05881667509675026, -0.005690161604434252, 0.00959822442382574, -0.012184136547148228, -0.011420714668929577, 0.03697984665632248, 0.027381373569369316, 0.023123301565647125, -0.06659968197345734, -0.0016834540292620659, -0.0332312136888504, -0.021271269768476486, 0.004490629304200411, 0.020756511017680168, -0.02592681348323822, 0.001121779321692884, 0.016492599621415138, 0.019971463829278946, 0.09764746576547623, -0.026863563805818558, -0.04541001468896866, 0.016979914158582687, 0.019186314195394516, 0.0005879305535927415, 0.04330497235059738, 0.01679087243974209, -0.044593945145606995, -0.011472991667687893, -0.023915152996778488, 0.013400295749306679, -0.03179420158267021, -0.013895283453166485, 0.0012232880108058453, -0.012620567344129086, -0.04036688432097435, -0.004458925221115351, -0.021058732643723488, -0.018634753301739693, -0.028386209160089493, -0.04819127544760704, -0.05445821210741997, -0.06532847881317139, -0.06212100386619568, 0.011878768913447857, -0.010153714567422867, -0.019669730216264725, -0.00035372411366552114, -0.01673571951687336, -0.007006213068962097, 0.054403286427259445, -0.07177741080522537, 0.014780756086111069, 0.0238224845379591, -0.012231828644871712, -0.014921116642653942, 0.016820615157485008, 0.03911434859037399, -0.01823084056377411, 0.0143033592030406, 0.0497782863676548, 0.036314550787210464, 0.007776868995279074, -0.002334124408662319, 0.004923858214169741, -0.09413502365350723, 0.013129811733961105, -0.012813684530556202, -0.0724266991019249, -0.08133196830749512, 0.01682288385927677, 0.007681151386350393, 0.02905922569334507, 0.0406290739774704, 0.01096891239285469, -0.015760967507958412, -0.06182213872671127, 0.0075402394868433475, -0.006393337622284889, -0.0019645732827484608, 0.051365066319704056, -0.012108317576348782, 0.06429791450500488, 0.03753550350666046, 0.007947049103677273, 0.009525158442556858, 0.020580727607011795, -0.019454555585980415, 0.016622427850961685, -0.021530430763959885, -0.011957043781876564, -0.03568179905414581, -0.09298966079950333, -0.050489626824855804, 0.031021013855934143, -0.004717544186860323, -0.015912916511297226, -0.03371135890483856, -0.02774728089570999, -0.003832457819953561, 0.002874004654586315, -0.006660588551312685, -0.0034181219525635242, -0.02899809367954731, -0.02624993957579136, -0.086038738489151, 0.02342231385409832, 0.00007607160659972578, 0.017199218273162842, -0.05597459897398949, -0.0381663478910923, -0.02511414885520935, 0.016270270571112633, 0.03406152129173279, 0.007137015461921692, 0.03842949867248535, 0.007518125232309103 ]
3,545
Realistic Evaluation of Deep Partial-Label Learning Algorithms
https://openreview.net/forum?id=FtX6oAW7Dd
[ "Wei Wang", "Dong-Dong Wu", "Jindong Wang", "Gang Niu", "Min-Ling Zhang", "Masashi Sugiyama" ]
Spotlight
Partial-label learning (PLL) is a weakly supervised learning problem in which each example is associated with multiple candidate labels and only one is the true label. In recent years, many deep PLL algorithms have been developed to improve model performance. However, we find that some early developed algorithms are often underestimated and can outperform many later algorithms with complicated designs. In this paper, we delve into the empirical perspective of PLL and identify several critical but previously overlooked issues. First, model selection for PLL is non-trivial, but has never been systematically studied. Second, the experimental settings are highly inconsistent, making it difficult to evaluate the effectiveness of the algorithms. Third, there is a lack of real-world image datasets that can be compatible with modern network architectures. Based on these findings, we propose PLENCH, the first Partial-Label learning bENCHmark to systematically compare state-of-the-art deep PLL algorithms. We investigate the model selection problem for PLL for the first time, and propose novel model selection criteria with theoretical guarantees. We also create Partial-Label CIFAR-10 (PLCIFAR10), an image dataset of human-annotated partial labels collected from Amazon Mechanical Turk, to provide a testbed for evaluating the performance of PLL algorithms in more realistic scenarios. Researchers can quickly and conveniently perform a comprehensive and fair evaluation and verify the effectiveness of newly developed algorithms based on PLENCH. We hope that PLENCH will facilitate standardized, fair, and practical evaluation of PLL algorithms in the future.
Partial-label learning, weakly supervised learning, benchmark.
The first partial-label learning benchmark with a new dataset of human-annotated partial labels.
5,419
2502.10184
[ 0.0035478309728205204, -0.044124554842710495, -0.040959808975458145, 0.04184411093592644, 0.02589019201695919, 0.017197053879499435, 0.00276558892801404, 0.002503241179510951, -0.021401001140475273, -0.023062804713845253, -0.0011970567284151912, 0.0104143051430583, -0.06546995043754578, 0.012347470037639141, 0.0018162663327530026, 0.05831349641084671, 0.04630827531218529, -0.009194772690534592, 0.02480432018637657, 0.025376571342349052, -0.007729724049568176, -0.034146394580602646, 0.009792604483664036, 0.004520625341683626, 0.0003930597740691155, -0.012635734863579273, 0.005810206290334463, 0.004575611092150211, -0.01664314791560173, 0.010595778934657574, 0.029072562232613564, -0.016660436987876892, 0.021460479125380516, 0.00023933060583658516, 0.017587892711162567, 0.02285851538181305, -0.04311935603618622, 0.008247200399637222, -0.013866416178643703, -0.003119796747341752, -0.05900970473885536, 0.013962642289698124, -0.02466852031648159, 0.03218691423535347, -0.05395332723855972, 0.009001050144433975, -0.12189199775457382, 0.020908724516630173, 0.004284355789422989, -0.03366164490580559, -0.09792035818099976, 0.03621406853199005, 0.001523977960459888, -0.003531995927914977, 0.010134044103324413, 0.01449884194880724, 0.032419487833976746, -0.08223897218704224, 0.013558121398091316, -0.04091377928853035, -0.025093404576182365, 0.017848337069153786, 0.0344332717359066, 0.013341940008103848, 0.003010587766766548, -0.051455702632665634, -0.001251271809451282, 0.041144583374261856, -0.05202113837003708, -0.04697893187403679, -0.03455965593457222, -0.0004541933594737202, -0.02058407850563526, 0.009439442306756973, 0.020385652780532837, -0.055509380996227264, -0.010341962799429893, 0.012810059823095798, 0.07007284462451935, -0.008741455152630806, 0.0021131413523107767, 0.0471622534096241, 0.01826377399265766, 0.019453633576631546, 0.01585587114095688, 0.03442930802702904, -0.044793501496315, -0.014215697534382343, -0.08455183357000351, 0.030408814549446106, 0.0016386909410357475, -0.040314264595508575, 0.045932989567518234, 0.017335955053567886, 0.021655380725860596, -0.009488430805504322, 0.03175867348909378, 0.001518638338893652, -0.021199731156229973, -0.0339546762406826, -0.030456814914941788, -0.0161362923681736, 0.033209770917892456, 0.01791728287935257, -0.10161671787500381, -0.04169997200369835, -0.02551063895225525, 0.007870897650718689, 0.008503023535013199, 0.017478125169873238, -0.012334681116044521, 0.0062545472756028175, -0.01238271128386259, -0.012106470763683319, -0.06532711535692215, 0.028225526213645935, 0.008644402027130127, 0.031142648309469223, -0.02693590335547924, 0.015293928794562817, 0.03850378096103668, 0.08812929689884186, 0.024387454614043236, 0.05313611403107643, -0.012722156010568142, 0.00638326071202755, 0.004343558568507433, 0.022237582132220268, -0.045470546931028366, -0.02569914236664772, -0.011296270415186882, 0.03243375942111015, -0.001440612250007689, 0.010690552182495594, -0.002004855079576373, -0.007733173202723265, -0.00016210153989959508, 0.0009607605752535164, 0.053307414054870605, -0.021593235433101654, -0.02280644327402115, -0.01457282342016697, 0.04412044584751129, -0.012186925858259201, 0.07608900219202042, -0.023294558748602867, 0.009548251517117023, -0.021528230980038643, -0.05774952843785286, -0.026050029322504997, 0.01879088208079338, -0.019272388890385628, 0.02117117866873741, -0.062098897993564606, 0.0362868458032608, 0.07796619087457657, -0.0010650530457496643, 0.016398465260863304, -0.004397619981318712, -0.017738360911607742, 0.014474427327513695, 0.005974272266030312, -0.04785928130149841, -0.010036527179181576, 0.006106717977672815, -0.0838427022099495, 0.05780987814068794, 0.03136490285396576, -0.03138468787074089, 0.0006280517554841936, -0.039519235491752625, -0.010276800021529198, 0.024930797517299652, -0.012993033975362778, -0.021025309339165688, 0.01611907407641411, 0.04949783906340599, 0.011288244277238846, 0.011635581031441689, 0.026457080617547035, -0.09399048984050751, 0.036569319665431976, -0.005178018938750029, -0.014396974816918373, -0.015822431072592735, -0.03141932561993599, 0.07654977589845657, -0.017416177317500114, -0.013233632780611515, 0.008573455736041069, -0.055015381425619125, 0.00979639682918787, -0.008107351139187813, 0.012596691958606243, 0.04575464129447937, 0.009933766908943653, -0.006819179281592369, 0.03881588578224182, 0.013360696844756603, 0.04414061829447746, 0.040512144565582275, 0.0003301445103716105, 0.016022685915231705, -0.004111278802156448, -0.0736687108874321, 0.006989639718085527, 0.015887131914496422, -0.056788742542266846, -0.036345161497592926, 0.034871648997068405, -0.02789626270532608, -0.006010088603943586, -0.013384896330535412, -0.0003277089854236692, -0.009278389625251293, 0.006064797285944223, -0.011480611748993397, 0.0061451951041817665, 0.023516546934843063, -0.04979600012302399, 0.025051800534129143, 0.05010009557008743, 0.006789475679397583, 0.03124896250665188, -0.03845606744289398, 0.09792026877403259, 0.04850153252482414, -0.0372135266661644, -0.006798947229981422, 0.04309268668293953, 0.04338163509964943, 0.02243955247104168, 0.026260830461978912, -0.019981909543275833, -0.02604695037007332, -0.017280662432312965, -0.023813331499695778, -0.030606471002101898, 0.0567827969789505, -0.04279003292322159, -0.018330829218029976, 0.04566729813814163, -0.01354745589196682, 0.07326905429363251, 0.0003828087938018143, 0.004935650620609522, 0.027580484747886658, -0.02816849574446678, -0.016329849138855934, -0.012371384538710117, -0.021017534658312798, -0.009338639676570892, -0.04714701697230339, -0.016375938430428505, -0.00524523202329874, -0.06325630098581314, 0.001004943624138832, -0.019345441833138466, 0.053612250834703445, 0.055123135447502136, 0.03192848339676857, 0.038817036896944046, 0.003795436816290021, -0.04692487418651581, -0.012312783859670162, -0.12702694535255432, -0.04983291029930115, -0.031484462320804596, 0.07323365658521652, 0.01919972524046898, 0.040341705083847046, -0.015393017791211605, -0.02483532205224037, -0.028455574065446854, -0.03444381058216095, 0.00022251687187235802, 0.03179931640625, 0.015187093988060951, -0.030283281579613686, 0.00011058191012125462, -0.005620863754302263, 0.06237117201089859, 0.027523431926965714, -0.030178507789969444, -0.0334756039083004, -0.03752531483769417, -0.012944824062287807, -0.03666360676288605, 0.005965718533843756, 0.02724858745932579, -0.005811234470456839, 0.05112479254603386, -0.0053710914216935635, 0.019478118047118187, 0.02540379948914051, 0.012764094397425652, 0.056834813207387924, 0.015065104700624943, -0.026975581422448158, 0.0494656078517437, -0.016962291672825813, 0.019080810248851776, 0.00125383329577744, 0.007691348437219858, 0.006595473736524582, 0.01198689453303814, 0.04282592609524727, 0.012653788551688194, -0.28041139245033264, -0.02647792361676693, 0.017741454765200615, -0.031126245856285095, 0.03319520130753517, -0.021598514169454575, 0.023260504007339478, -0.00832280982285738, -0.004855635575950146, 0.022680524736642838, 0.011990869417786598, 0.023847026750445366, 0.01576170325279236, 0.04496223106980324, 0.06806468963623047, 0.024180851876735687, 0.019034385681152344, -0.031550172716379166, 0.03300390765070915, 0.031181028112769127, -0.02370552532374859, -0.060753319412469864, -0.0016617031069472432, 0.07903207838535309, -0.012207787483930588, 0.05749763548374176, -0.047332633286714554, -0.0017142943106591702, -0.02621757611632347, -0.016884656623005867, -0.018244989216327667, -0.03466207534074783, -0.04223275184631348, 0.00810963660478592, 0.0027712590526789427, -0.016526654362678528, 0.019700944423675537, 0.02242473140358925, 0.022543927654623985, 0.02471792697906494, 0.006477736867964268, 0.015492777340114117, -0.002897153375670314, 0.007354846689850092, 0.06282331049442291, 0.021971704438328743, -0.056180261075496674, -0.04345153644680977, -0.03584931790828705, 0.033838141709566116, 0.03416595235466957, -0.015710297971963882, -0.02215445041656494, 0.002638100180774927, 0.005825959611684084, -0.012171251699328423, -0.012839610688388348, 0.0034116781316697598, -0.013635199517011642, -0.01677953451871872, -0.002373108174651861, -0.040717411786317825, -0.025291243568062782, -0.04791141301393509, -0.006603166460990906, -0.0067675416357815266, -0.04203943908214569, -0.08022943139076233, 0.05315788835287094, 0.05903549864888191, -0.021541258320212364, 0.00009338919335277751, -0.04458704590797424, -0.0883142426609993, 0.023664245381951332, -0.01109223160892725, 0.0007550464943051338, 0.016919877380132675, 0.007076582405716181, 0.051778893917798996, -0.009801933541893959, -0.04290151223540306, 0.05111425742506981, 0.015187123790383339, 0.035797737538814545, -0.02177567034959793, 0.013338281773030758, 0.032353125512599945, -0.015262676402926445, -0.03183821961283684, 0.04515049606561661, 0.027272623032331467, 0.008210096508264542, 0.0059826429933309555, 0.020242242142558098, 0.02768840081989765, 0.03928361088037491, 0.0760117694735527, 0.017738915979862213, 0.030986452475190163, 0.013604186475276947, -0.0765923485159874, -0.00842520222067833, -0.03959183394908905, -0.034792590886354446, 0.03465859219431877, -0.06347256153821945, -0.04165343940258026, 0.036214765161275864, -0.01885245367884636, -0.02634195238351822, -0.02593681775033474, 0.027683677151799202, -0.013131573796272278, 0.019862357527017593, -0.022981243208050728, 0.009270614944398403, 0.01903284154832363, 0.04005919769406319, -0.03506855294108391, -0.020914843305945396, 0.05173266679048538, -0.021634427830576897, 0.032547831535339355, 0.0018144106725230813, -0.03279034048318863, 0.010104555636644363, -0.013202779926359653, 0.007572534494102001, -0.0024124891497194767, 0.048847462981939316, 0.05145566910505295, -0.013501310721039772, 0.015507292002439499, 0.036131203174591064, 0.026759270578622818, -0.005874114576727152, -0.005904132500290871, 0.03922191262245178, -0.01480263564735651, 0.000825173978228122, -0.03778406232595444, 0.015338906086981297, 0.025229264050722122, 0.07876114547252655, -0.0034440807066857815, 0.013380762189626694, 0.006082773208618164, -0.010182898491621017, 0.005076004657894373, 0.03371366858482361, -0.059901803731918335, -0.025061851367354393, -0.023408781737089157, 0.0382661409676075, -0.014057178050279617, 0.03661235794425011, -0.0064794747158885, 0.020184148102998734, -0.08050752431154251, 0.03704015910625458, 0.003137108637019992, -0.0014682565815746784, 0.00343963666819036, 0.01951419748365879, 0.0567840151488781, -0.007884292863309383, 0.0008932944620028138, 0.03286544978618622, -0.025027720257639885, 0.005846580024808645, -0.042302556335926056, -0.0013513037702068686, 0.002643026178702712, -0.01929052732884884, 0.006823855917900801, 0.014928283169865608, 0.02239285036921501, -0.036070287227630615, 0.042496953159570694, -0.006774697918444872, -0.015155341476202011, 0.004698664415627718, 0.031267061829566956, 0.09617852419614792, -0.003080677706748247, 0.0023416001349687576, -0.022147437557578087, -0.04950784146785736, 0.06744835525751114, -0.026604704558849335, -0.0038197629619389772, 0.0007523561944253743, -0.03794243931770325, -0.015425177291035652, -0.047079067677259445, -0.01077958382666111, 0.04372258111834526, 0.004052638541907072, -0.026007438078522682, -0.034121524542570114, 0.005242805927991867, -0.020618770271539688, -0.0019688948523253202, 0.02588365040719509, -0.08528424799442291, 0.027172522619366646, 0.05823865905404091, -0.05367682874202728, 0.01386216189712286, -0.03678315505385399, -0.04735032469034195, -0.04293374717235565, -0.04152184724807739, 0.007585117593407631, -0.019468583166599274, -0.03097613900899887, -0.0255119726061821, 0.027590328827500343, -0.014197162352502346, 0.012380590662360191, 0.0021225910168141127, -0.01917625032365322, -0.006268714088946581, 0.0051399762742221355, 0.07728662341833115, -0.05336858704686165, 0.008536913432180882, 0.001623558229766786, -0.008552269078791142, 0.010670057497918606, -0.052210479974746704, 0.04005369171500206, 0.05626121535897255, -0.04306219890713692, -0.007323794532567263, -0.033524349331855774, 0.033348534256219864, -0.015008984133601189, -0.011703218333423138, 0.0032319610472768545, 0.003921932075172663, -0.06292057782411575, 0.0199444480240345, -0.001664855983108282, 0.0475759394466877, 0.014127817936241627, 0.020487386733293533, 0.00013668992323800921, 0.018270403146743774, 0.05139246955513954, 0.003085446311160922, -0.07181114703416824, -0.01430017314851284, 0.06387268006801605, -0.021083291620016098, 0.00811087992042303, -0.05558072775602341, -0.03907401114702225, 0.029894446954131126, -0.016142917796969414, 0.031707633286714554, -0.013295436277985573, 0.048680972307920456, 0.030290810391306877, 0.04621820151805878, 0.0028125790413469076, -0.04634959250688553, 0.01671707257628441, -0.012205670587718487, 0.020087992772459984, -0.03906092792749405, 0.005061013158410788, 0.07431569695472717, -0.0010255881352350116, 0.015386056154966354, -0.028598885983228683, -0.046229928731918335, 0.024533530697226524, -0.01581462100148201, -0.055232446640729904, 0.007642238866537809, -0.012621000409126282, 0.013217940926551819, 0.03189351409673691, -0.058545880019664764, -0.0060124266892671585, -0.0130740562453866, -0.0791253000497818, -0.024004677310585976, 0.018032411113381386, 0.05502123013138771, -0.019249992445111275, -0.015689508989453316, -0.014710130169987679, 0.01605340652167797, 0.00026704289484769106, 0.05778311938047409, -0.021908989176154137, 0.02155492827296257, -0.041160400956869125, 0.06765121966600418, 0.042151451110839844, -0.006976625882089138, -0.015542364679276943, 0.006455090828239918, -0.0019664873834699392, -0.05796923115849495, 0.05334102362394333, -0.003349112346768379, -0.034567076712846756, -0.07856346666812897, 0.05205681174993515, 0.021113961935043335, -0.04669911414384842, -0.03268636390566826, 0.023305369541049004, -0.04471256956458092, 0.011304316110908985, 0.011077589355409145, 0.00808623991906643, -0.021973293274641037, 0.06134675815701485, 0.052511539310216904, 0.038443490862846375, 0.057782165706157684, 0.024964377284049988, -0.018491612747311592, -0.004796438850462437, 0.06772933155298233, 0.07016646862030029, 0.05875686928629875, -0.012383298948407173, 0.07187531888484955, -0.021533532068133354, -0.05957881733775139, 0.03277597948908806, 0.008427755907177925, -0.01180342398583889, -0.04748222604393959, -0.024981459602713585, 0.06876484304666519, 0.016337351873517036, 0.07450511306524277, -0.041256051510572433, 0.006344026420265436, 0.022862672805786133, 0.0025991646107286215, 0.006582646630704403, 0.03231523558497429, 0.011500569991767406, 0.009657499380409718, -0.03593609854578972, 0.007146334275603294, -0.0021662407089024782, -0.015882212668657303, 0.008285578340291977, -0.004932823590934277, -0.046234067529439926, 0.00904298946261406, -0.003943064250051975, 0.03656790032982826, 0.09982578456401825, -0.02178766578435898, -0.05831810086965561, -0.0021191255655139685, -0.004979356657713652, 0.024853335693478584, 0.019363828003406525, 0.036656901240348816, -0.03682851418852806, -0.011927412822842598, -0.02295859344303608, 0.04088357836008072, 0.0026721626054495573, 0.002241716952994466, 0.015204363502562046, -0.021791182458400726, -0.03246176242828369, 0.03388024866580963, 0.023472867906093597, -0.04576119780540466, -0.024541856721043587, -0.036170944571495056, -0.056342147290706635, -0.04259538650512695, -0.0624326728284359, 0.007504845969378948, 0.030690059065818787, -0.024847501888871193, -0.01182278711348772, 0.014768600463867188, 0.02487598918378353, 0.0288835521787405, -0.09178359806537628, 0.009739375673234463, 0.026729509234428406, -0.011331407353281975, -0.022109592333436012, -0.004552982281893492, -0.0017817814368754625, -0.03804135322570801, -0.012320995330810547, 0.0532630980014801, 0.004549000412225723, -0.0017437603091821074, -0.030693909153342247, 0.0005117689142934978, -0.0862669125199318, 0.011633596383035183, -0.010634470731019974, -0.031741127371788025, -0.08215971291065216, 0.04872307553887367, -0.006484590470790863, 0.05904780700802803, 0.052920226007699966, 0.034764066338539124, 0.02765054628252983, -0.03936368599534035, -0.020611325278878212, 0.0025629543233662844, 0.022137023508548737, 0.035038359463214874, -0.009090364910662174, 0.07668007910251617, 0.021683882921934128, 0.015214336104691029, -0.03294742852449417, 0.009009884670376778, -0.02552046813070774, -0.025403177365660667, -0.03420569747686386, -0.06918212026357651, -0.036706458777189255, -0.08774858713150024, -0.04065219312906265, 0.04885434731841087, -0.005402448587119579, -0.05050291121006012, -0.026106806471943855, -0.03368392214179039, -0.023724911734461784, -0.000958819524385035, -0.0026634891983121634, -0.002266951836645603, -0.006930789444595575, -0.027591554448008537, -0.0909433364868164, 0.004128962755203247, -0.022131530568003654, 0.0051874397322535515, -0.02801506780087948, -0.017061082646250725, -0.011370977386832237, 0.01618543639779091, 0.045369215309619904, 0.027999715879559517, 0.024897295981645584, -0.02392774261534214 ]
3,546
BodyGen: Advancing Towards Efficient Embodiment Co-Design
https://openreview.net/forum?id=cTR17xl89h
[ "Haofei Lu", "Zhe Wu", "Junliang Xing", "Jianshu Li", "Ruoyu Li", "Zhe Li", "Yuanchun Shi" ]
Spotlight
Embodiment co-design aims to optimize a robot's morphology and control policy simultaneously. While prior work has demonstrated its potential for generating environment-adaptive robots, this field still faces persistent challenges in optimization efficiency due to the (i) combinatorial nature of morphological search spaces and (ii) intricate dependencies between morphology and control. We prove that the ineffective morphology representation and unbalanced reward signals between the design and control stages are key obstacles to efficiency. To advance towards efficient embodiment co-design, we propose **BodyGen**, which utilizes (1) topology-aware self-attention for both design and control, enabling efficient morphology representation with lightweight model sizes; (2) a temporal credit assignment mechanism that ensures balanced reward signals for optimization. With our findings, BodyGen achieves an average **60.03%** performance improvement against state-of-the-art baselines. We provide codes and more results on the website: https://genesisorigin.github.io.
Reinforcement Learning
This paper introduces BodyGen: a novel framework for efficient embodiment co-design.
5,415
2503.00533
[ 0.0020257700234651566, -0.00885416567325592, -0.0351606085896492, 0.04074155166745186, 0.038773320615291595, 0.03976161405444145, -0.0025812687817960978, -0.014701338484883308, -0.004958829842507839, -0.07076394557952881, -0.02488887682557106, -0.0255130622535944, -0.0458773672580719, -0.013560043647885323, -0.03672691807150841, 0.05058104544878006, 0.0304510910063982, 0.0055995602160692215, -0.0015062447637319565, 0.0329771488904953, -0.01919359527528286, -0.024017661809921265, 0.033820077776908875, 0.01036028191447258, 0.05524710193276405, 0.011211869306862354, 0.01674245297908783, 0.0314735472202301, -0.02522018365561962, 0.0014002970419824123, -0.0036092570517212152, -0.04904288053512573, 0.017254451289772987, -0.04731391370296478, 0.013788259588181973, -0.0330934077501297, -0.054396964609622955, 0.013896429911255836, 0.0009731088648550212, -0.024776756763458252, -0.04825924336910248, 0.01451197825372219, -0.004319081548601389, -0.004409411922097206, -0.041727855801582336, 0.008229875937104225, -0.08848223090171814, 0.03039950132369995, 0.0006843851297162473, -0.0342891551554203, -0.0957920178771019, 0.009765790775418282, -0.004206585697829723, -0.023600256070494652, 0.005377971567213535, 0.02971906214952469, 0.05516354739665985, -0.0740903913974762, -0.04593444988131523, -0.07943186908960342, -0.018083419650793076, 0.030425161123275757, 0.04200848191976547, 0.01749647781252861, 0.0036820927634835243, 0.011117196641862392, 0.0021977785509079695, 0.027280133217573166, -0.03901772201061249, -0.007972524501383305, -0.028639305382966995, -0.01712396740913391, 0.02868654765188694, 0.013089378364384174, 0.005073104985058308, -0.06099920719861984, -0.01261870376765728, 0.02956271544098854, 0.08138296753168106, -0.0038170493207871914, 0.03556971251964569, 0.044039949774742126, 0.017837420105934143, 0.038057394325733185, 0.00474229920655489, 0.03874102234840393, -0.06404206156730652, 0.006878625135868788, -0.04817521199584007, 0.01853301376104355, -0.03569408506155014, -0.056004296988248825, 0.019953278824687004, 0.05608711391687393, 0.0382796972990036, -0.01192881166934967, 0.011376193724572659, 0.02172975055873394, 0.01830402947962284, -0.010148654691874981, -0.015855930745601654, -0.03235570713877678, -0.017098596319556236, -0.029621507972478867, -0.08200610429048538, -0.04553993046283722, -0.025436779484152794, -0.011498559266328812, 0.011564018204808235, 0.013239193707704544, -0.039188042283058167, -0.013629999943077564, 0.006142792291939259, -0.006581293419003487, -0.07668711990118027, 0.07831308990716934, -0.017991557717323303, 0.030034208670258522, -0.009593535214662552, 0.025590024888515472, 0.02525610849261284, 0.04077120125293732, 0.007312961388379335, 0.056420791894197464, -0.0017609577625989914, 0.03515760600566864, 0.034888166934251785, 0.03342088311910629, -0.024257062003016472, -0.0306849405169487, 0.027341505512595177, 0.045096494257450104, 0.008984124287962914, -0.007330289110541344, -0.024580374360084534, -0.01668928563594818, 0.028534725308418274, 0.030617916956543922, 0.03374797850847244, 0.00627640075981617, -0.032924577593803406, -0.05017147213220596, 0.060704365372657776, -0.03428947180509567, 0.09029371291399002, -0.016057666391134262, -0.008707747794687748, -0.013846203684806824, -0.021040448918938637, 0.0025153642054647207, -0.0244111567735672, -0.015690306201577187, -0.017616908997297287, -0.05518666282296181, 0.03848755732178688, 0.06692926585674286, 0.04980843514204025, 0.00732270535081625, 0.0027995347045361996, -0.02227361500263214, 0.010380150750279427, -0.0003909711667802185, -0.059698428958654404, 0.010074048303067684, 0.00627852464094758, -0.04798666387796402, 0.017640555277466774, 0.016830377280712128, -0.013193361461162567, -0.022901048883795738, -0.05058583617210388, -0.04580485075712204, 0.04394806548953056, 0.010222011245787144, -0.011808610521256924, -0.020707381889224052, 0.05265040695667267, -0.04383208602666855, -0.015527872368693352, 0.043790023773908615, -0.07469004392623901, 0.023327473551034927, 0.017961563542485237, -0.01350495032966137, 0.014096296392381191, -0.051528386771678925, 0.10656094551086426, -0.015962986275553703, -0.00109998625703156, 0.016656959429383278, -0.07623598724603653, -0.02096240408718586, 0.030447207391262054, -0.012064932845532894, 0.044092755764722824, -0.018648486584424973, -0.030863778665661812, 0.038343075662851334, 0.012281643226742744, 0.04604412987828255, 0.02237810380756855, -0.03973452001810074, 0.03050454519689083, 0.011489317752420902, -0.00597630999982357, -0.03277578577399254, 0.03292987868189812, -0.039377450942993164, -0.014081152155995369, 0.014367024414241314, 0.00621788902208209, 0.0015901506412774324, -0.005811044480651617, -0.030438357964158058, 0.03260469809174538, -0.007706352975219488, 0.011695130728185177, -0.0020810491405427456, -0.01905057579278946, -0.03772731125354767, 0.06334828585386276, 0.04857749491930008, -0.024814672768115997, 0.0029773961286991835, -0.017661195248365402, 0.09313374757766724, 0.0594058521091938, -0.04036413133144379, -0.013817398808896542, 0.04061025753617287, -0.0011600909056141973, 0.023421691730618477, -0.011407671496272087, -0.0033771302551031113, -0.005768217146396637, 0.007045656908303499, 0.014241529628634453, -0.025759132578969002, 0.061976443976163864, -0.053180232644081116, -0.018946455791592598, 0.08312883228063583, -0.03163330629467964, 0.04054691269993782, 0.010881796479225159, 0.0032290879171341658, 0.07389726489782333, -0.006258178036659956, -0.031078893691301346, 0.000841094006318599, -0.05157088115811348, 0.00036822695983573794, 0.03666537255048752, 0.004152033012360334, -0.006079392042011023, -0.054569173604249954, 0.015112112276256084, -0.04150938242673874, 0.04922459274530411, 0.05002429708838463, 0.022863056510686874, -0.004579437896609306, -0.013695442117750645, 0.0025318816769868135, -0.044876810163259506, -0.10946059972047806, -0.047936707735061646, -0.016881383955478668, 0.02395210973918438, 0.024906614795327187, 0.03812503442168236, -0.002147187478840351, 0.00932982936501503, -0.053878843784332275, -0.01335030235350132, 0.038030367344617844, 0.020262612029910088, -0.01871991716325283, 0.0071174674667418, -0.03608492761850357, -0.018864700570702553, 0.10091705620288849, -0.013441037386655807, -0.019531333819031715, -0.008715001866221428, -0.04875083267688751, 0.014869480393826962, -0.04042130708694458, -0.009734361432492733, 0.023539306595921516, 0.037686437368392944, 0.012585703283548355, -0.0361827127635479, 0.01455692108720541, 0.026811042800545692, 0.05531369149684906, 0.02798982337117195, -0.029108189046382904, -0.01679738610982895, 0.012781142257153988, -0.01806996949017048, 0.023664163425564766, -0.02161620371043682, 0.012033555656671524, -0.013743766583502293, -0.011772988364100456, 0.04017258808016777, -0.0072565204463899136, -0.2540821135044098, -0.04384726285934448, 0.015309671871364117, 0.0001969773438759148, 0.045076146721839905, 0.017752131447196007, 0.05566529557108879, -0.02383413165807724, -0.005981752648949623, -0.0006969257956370711, 0.007532093673944473, 0.024729354307055473, 0.04268144443631172, 0.06498350948095322, 0.05586951598525047, 0.04686244949698448, -0.006124839186668396, -0.009066680446267128, -0.0352652370929718, 0.013283370062708855, -0.03161340951919556, -0.07545898854732513, -0.027673842385411263, 0.01050425786525011, -0.0018400729168206453, 0.004406031221151352, -0.08751916885375977, -0.01751459203660488, -0.039482541382312775, 0.008824148215353489, -0.0024490717332810163, -0.014783809892833233, -0.02805582992732525, 0.006983000319451094, 0.03630760312080383, 0.002846537623554468, 0.045782554894685745, -0.005407289136201143, 0.024570049718022346, 0.008778414689004421, -0.0008862393442541361, -0.01199844479560852, -0.04912162572145462, 0.03505472093820572, 0.06054991856217384, 0.016028737649321556, -0.039807770401239395, -0.0037143193185329437, -0.015594320371747017, 0.02377508208155632, 0.035907082259655, -0.03960762545466423, 0.0026745484210550785, 0.048967860639095306, 0.03724915534257889, -0.01756347343325615, 0.015636686235666275, 0.02133120596408844, -0.006693832576274872, 0.016599243506789207, 0.0028761872090399265, -0.053179070353507996, -0.007672318257391453, -0.06484275311231613, 0.01091099251061678, -0.030041126534342766, -0.05855726823210716, -0.05581512674689293, 0.03251827880740166, 0.03584680333733559, -0.010799314826726913, -0.00712174829095602, -0.010468369349837303, -0.11591757833957672, 0.02324451506137848, -0.0070096575655043125, -0.021530631929636, -0.023660847917199135, 0.0005953267100267112, 0.016447534784674644, -0.016778072342276573, -0.06588146835565567, -0.0023806365206837654, 0.033636484295129776, -0.0016694989753887057, -0.02032218500971794, 0.010825389064848423, -0.07535193115472794, 0.0023149976041167974, 0.0008498752722516656, 0.05087248235940933, 0.0037602127995342016, -0.004228385165333748, -0.01602242700755596, 0.06100159510970116, 0.011498823761940002, 0.061040833592414856, 0.03325561806559563, 0.010554855689406395, 0.008672770112752914, 0.028956936672329903, -0.08905978500843048, -0.029347199946641922, -0.008099601604044437, -0.03345232829451561, -0.0068604545667767525, -0.05401500314474106, 0.001376743079163134, 0.07982435822486877, -0.003399980952963233, -0.009416240267455578, -0.03651585429906845, -0.009249325841665268, -0.03713960945606232, -0.00795659702271223, 0.022937895730137825, -0.012462331913411617, 0.03412335366010666, 0.02347087673842907, 0.0014303053030744195, -0.03373498469591141, 0.05492847412824631, -0.034515395760536194, 0.011315071024000645, 0.006080301012843847, -0.01704208366572857, -0.020635593682527542, -0.025641657412052155, 0.015939749777317047, -0.019969118759036064, 0.03365219756960869, 0.06317200511693954, -0.024441979825496674, 0.019756030291318893, 0.05054014176130295, 0.03184862062335014, -0.016359254717826843, -0.02444574236869812, 0.019106240943074226, -0.04391161724925041, 0.006413677707314491, -0.005229294765740633, 0.015974238514900208, 0.01920134760439396, 0.03268957883119583, 0.0373215451836586, 0.05285103619098663, -0.0012116051511839032, 0.00725993188098073, 0.023946354165673256, 0.04081626608967781, -0.06703998893499374, -0.005539217963814735, -0.05406426638364792, 0.019378578290343285, -0.0671054944396019, 0.012610932812094688, 0.014836618676781654, 0.02992720901966095, -0.052848074585199356, 0.00935131311416626, 0.01112718228250742, 0.006304521579295397, -0.01286442019045353, 0.03429507091641426, 0.06658130139112473, -0.013827604241669178, -0.029507998377084732, -0.009038863703608513, -0.022044995799660683, -0.009949489496648312, -0.022273926064372063, -0.027180049568414688, -0.019587835296988487, -0.03368338569998741, -0.006753149908035994, 0.0021463974844664335, -0.027727652341127396, -0.01881866343319416, 0.02014871872961521, -0.03672034293413162, -0.006933534052222967, 0.037893276661634445, 0.0075604673475027084, 0.09186792373657227, -0.017587151378393173, 0.0011276716832071543, -0.003558678552508354, -0.00465302262455225, -0.015659084543585777, -0.014669442549347878, 0.021377552300691605, -0.0024302045349031687, -0.0459909625351429, -0.03413544222712517, -0.01853589341044426, 0.0027525972109287977, 0.016764963045716286, -0.013147003017365932, -0.018787197768688202, 0.003641607239842415, 0.031096188351511955, -0.03530268743634224, 0.018220704048871994, 0.02038739249110222, -0.055853042751550674, -0.010821331292390823, 0.026012804359197617, -0.01859859749674797, 0.012732715345919132, -0.006204552017152309, -0.029064198955893517, -0.04871145263314247, -0.02359749749302864, -0.008770937100052834, -0.02599896863102913, -0.027260124683380127, -0.025746973231434822, -0.05144975706934929, 0.0032085850834846497, 0.02286357805132866, 0.021881885826587677, -0.014489604160189629, -0.009627703577280045, -0.0026446455158293247, 0.022438690066337585, -0.04071797430515289, -0.028777604922652245, 0.020280249416828156, -0.019801411777734756, 0.008272732608020306, -0.04447019100189209, -0.0020044653210788965, 0.002412162022665143, 0.02210017293691635, -0.028521206229925156, -0.011287244036793709, 0.02552672103047371, 0.029151469469070435, -0.01908002607524395, 0.032321251928806305, 0.01995112933218479, -0.05937892198562622, 0.022138686850667, 0.016265980899333954, 0.0550558902323246, 0.010055660270154476, 0.002210715552791953, 0.002369149588048458, 0.019966697320342064, 0.015352161601185799, 0.016054727137088776, -0.06170981004834175, 0.012843235395848751, 0.026352273300290108, -0.03686857596039772, -0.028021138161420822, -0.0708744004368782, -0.02969462051987648, 0.029487427324056625, 0.0014542073477059603, 0.05927884206175804, -0.03606834635138512, 0.03228720277547836, -0.0010275427484884858, 0.044393207877874374, -0.010539159178733826, -0.03459096699953079, 0.05123133957386017, -0.06197759881615639, -0.007742800749838352, -0.02614145167171955, -0.04119072109460831, 0.05920227989554405, -0.03715892136096954, -0.015676012262701988, -0.008837827481329441, -0.027153145521879196, 0.043703850358724594, -0.046883054077625275, -0.028329111635684967, 0.05872149020433426, -0.015431012958288193, -0.010101435706019402, 0.0376158207654953, -0.04975919425487518, -0.007425289135426283, -0.028991594910621643, -0.02325809746980667, -0.00010981634841300547, 0.023961741477251053, 0.019058601930737495, -0.0012226776452735066, 0.014977941289544106, 0.011915291659533978, 0.01710161380469799, 0.023287059739232063, 0.011949857696890831, -0.011154498904943466, 0.03233075141906738, -0.03294932842254639, 0.07069367915391922, 0.04566266015172005, 0.032910652458667755, -0.0034769056364893913, 0.017308693379163742, -0.005257469601929188, -0.04793524369597435, 0.04481758922338486, 0.009016435593366623, -0.002744524972513318, -0.08154147863388062, 0.059175409376621246, 0.016723118722438812, -0.06641542166471481, -0.014579370617866516, 0.02536727860569954, -0.05087342485785484, -0.018538475036621094, 0.00484542828053236, -0.011944800615310669, -0.0031412430107593536, 0.06822510063648224, 0.026870939880609512, 0.05775469169020653, 0.07163788378238678, 0.006330209784209728, 0.0007910608546808362, -0.03934387490153313, 0.08904804289340973, 0.07109493017196655, 0.036370739340782166, 0.0045263562351465225, 0.08033343404531479, -0.023267142474651337, -0.01433275081217289, 0.04749534651637077, 0.06230723485350609, -0.022241730242967606, -0.007463923189789057, 0.017469916492700577, 0.076738141477108, -0.010496039874851704, 0.0671219527721405, -0.019038816913962364, -0.027846211567521095, 0.017068615183234215, 0.01604458875954151, 0.010210451669991016, 0.041155047714710236, 0.056839991360902786, 0.016701340675354004, -0.05841542035341263, -0.005264729727059603, -0.017909282818436623, -0.03539435565471649, 0.05479995533823967, -0.004919009283185005, -0.0018560367170721292, 0.04370063170790672, -0.015128500759601593, 0.02752770110964775, 0.08814096450805664, -0.04688628017902374, -0.03308405727148056, 0.03017151542007923, -0.00862423051148653, -0.02227841690182686, 0.03997821733355522, 0.024623151868581772, 0.01378760114312172, 0.003206248627975583, -0.03752230107784271, 0.018159572035074234, 0.020052731037139893, 0.020905930548906326, 0.07071100175380707, -0.0445324070751667, -0.045311339199543, -0.021885840222239494, 0.029560573399066925, -0.09122290462255478, -0.022464219480752945, -0.030850941315293312, -0.023885734379291534, -0.0591670460999012, -0.033611420542001724, 0.06280599534511566, 0.01147353183478117, -0.03252437338232994, 0.02217285893857479, 0.010566378012299538, 0.05195125564932823, 0.014744654297828674, -0.06183137744665146, -0.014132893644273281, 0.037735652178525925, -0.009058215655386448, 0.02494654804468155, 0.027236228808760643, 0.03852244094014168, 0.006860922556370497, -0.01027415320277214, 0.020305611193180084, 0.030182279646396637, 0.03646071255207062, -0.025638381019234657, -0.01226245891302824, -0.09533824026584625, -0.005523402243852615, 0.013304845429956913, -0.026607029139995575, -0.06903014332056046, 0.029868202283978462, -0.036296531558036804, 0.04207417741417885, 0.04493516683578491, -0.05352019891142845, 0.005618220195174217, -0.044616349041461945, 0.004456508904695511, 0.010945425368845463, -0.003362456802278757, 0.027738213539123535, -0.03384658694267273, 0.04573947191238403, 0.038561511784791946, -0.01625174842774868, -0.04806321859359741, 0.06106911599636078, -0.0021530711092054844, -0.001169841387309134, -0.033824700862169266, -0.02834727242588997, -0.023594623431563377, -0.09788213670253754, -0.019147051498293877, 0.05904426425695419, -0.005090444348752499, -0.055969443172216415, 0.020010823383927345, 0.0026440636720508337, 0.016022684052586555, 0.015272957272827625, -0.013566290959715843, -0.009679040871560574, -0.04961826652288437, 0.006342989858239889, -0.04612401872873306, -0.01677010767161846, -0.04571708291769028, 0.0393880233168602, -0.03509339317679405, -0.051181234419345856, -0.005028151907026768, -0.0065071177668869495, 0.010158772580325603, -0.0018517266726121306, 0.034233540296554565, 0.020387990400195122 ]
3,547
RAG-SR: Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Neural Symbolic Regression
https://openreview.net/forum?id=NdHka08uWn
[ "Hengzhe Zhang", "Qi Chen", "Bing XUE", "Wolfgang Banzhaf", "Mengjie Zhang" ]
Spotlight
Symbolic regression is a key task in machine learning, aiming to discover mathematical expressions that best describe a dataset. While deep learning has increased interest in using neural networks for symbolic regression, many existing approaches rely on pre-trained models. These models require significant computational resources and struggle with regression tasks involving unseen functions and variables. A pre-training-free paradigm is needed to better integrate with search-based symbolic regression algorithms. To address these limitations, we propose a novel framework for symbolic regression that integrates evolutionary feature construction with a neural network, without the need for pre-training. Our approach adaptively generates symbolic trees that align with the desired semantics in real-time using a language model trained via online supervised learning, providing effective building blocks for feature construction. To mitigate hallucinations from the language model, we design a retrieval-augmented generation mechanism that explicitly leverages searched symbolic expressions. Additionally, we introduce a scale-invariant data augmentation technique that further improves the robustness and generalization of the model. Experimental results demonstrate that our framework achieves state-of-the-art accuracy across 25 regression algorithms and 120 regression tasks.
Symbolic Regression, Genetic Programming, Transformers, Deep Learning
null
5,410
null
[ -0.013153216801583767, -0.02044045180082321, -0.017094671726226807, 0.03247861936688423, 0.04245108738541603, 0.051270898431539536, 0.041564956307411194, -0.030888529494404793, -0.03317579999566078, -0.021202119067311287, -0.042734865099191666, 0.041613295674324036, -0.07718554884195328, 0.01683441549539566, -0.0042684730142354965, 0.05490759015083313, 0.0287858247756958, -0.0010476369643583894, 0.001986113842576742, 0.013333173468708992, -0.0073715136386454105, -0.06690625101327896, 0.005026146303862333, 0.0035336948931217194, 0.02903592400252819, 0.008370683528482914, 0.019849490374326706, -0.023733114823698997, -0.03165287524461746, -0.001051399391144514, 0.03615330904722214, -0.008361016400158405, -0.0022302214056253433, -0.03708566352725029, -0.002321971580386162, 0.03483273461461067, -0.027992282062768936, 0.026981458067893982, 0.0027856738306581974, -0.021326789632439613, -0.04765889421105385, -0.008555886335670948, -0.008022448979318142, 0.00245977402664721, -0.05184555798768997, 0.01575275883078575, -0.10811565071344376, 0.01854262501001358, 0.011997129768133163, -0.00913662277162075, -0.11020070314407349, 0.04893239215016365, 0.015569278039038181, -0.03016912378370762, 0.0005265153595246375, 0.04261716082692146, 0.06681313365697861, -0.07321354001760483, -0.01793251931667328, -0.045786455273628235, -0.035086408257484436, 0.04905226081609726, 0.023124394938349724, -0.016740186139941216, -0.019768165424466133, 0.00005874040652997792, 0.011231468990445137, 0.0135404784232378, -0.06970667093992233, -0.039568375796079636, -0.005597206763923168, 0.009846935048699379, -0.02710062265396118, 0.017600294202566147, 0.0016832853434607387, -0.026495952159166336, -0.0024781404063105583, 0.03994283452630043, 0.06797992438077927, -0.02569926343858242, -0.010914758779108524, 0.038879577070474625, 0.035483065992593765, 0.025574155151844025, 0.038916800171136856, 0.02689065970480442, -0.03669985383749008, -0.029920674860477448, -0.05774470418691635, 0.046580079942941666, -0.0063675991259515285, -0.04547639191150665, 0.012219016440212727, 0.006201758980751038, -0.024492911994457245, 0.02300337515771389, 0.030834702774882317, -0.02113303542137146, 0.0142176803201437, 0.0034802735317498446, -0.02172214910387993, -0.027978776022791862, 0.038245007395744324, -0.017140420153737068, -0.09757659584283829, -0.0073476568795740604, -0.019730037078261375, -0.004265681840479374, 0.00823509693145752, -0.027361657470464706, -0.046256598085165024, 0.015920469537377357, 0.04372623935341835, 0.0000607489600952249, -0.06238869950175285, 0.03141060099005699, -0.01287161186337471, 0.009490763768553734, -0.018199555575847626, 0.027095308527350426, 0.036039575934410095, 0.008139326237142086, -0.019192660227417946, 0.04472239688038826, -0.009747506119310856, 0.04030214250087738, 0.04746222123503685, 0.05105133354663849, -0.037544623017311096, -0.034333549439907074, 0.01303399633616209, 0.04250115901231766, 0.002340054837986827, 0.030027776956558228, -0.012330722063779831, 0.007749904878437519, -0.00827702134847641, -0.00172860745806247, 0.04351527616381645, 0.008121982216835022, 0.0070833731442689896, -0.005331816617399454, 0.026908857747912407, -0.06931130588054657, 0.08279089629650116, -0.017561795189976692, -0.004062769003212452, -0.01188263576477766, -0.02373727597296238, 0.011156083084642887, 0.035343416035175323, 0.0048348139971494675, -0.0036004153080284595, -0.06951534003019333, 0.01307598128914833, 0.07175406813621521, 0.03174807131290436, 0.004429544322192669, 0.014461188577115536, -0.00674948375672102, 0.016178393736481667, -0.005685402546077967, -0.019744856283068657, 0.03198317438364029, -0.04569799080491066, -0.01644848845899105, 0.047506608068943024, 0.028307463973760605, -0.03340056538581848, -0.001450715004466474, -0.03594275563955307, -0.0291848573833704, 0.05649833753705025, -0.00975580420345068, -0.03631825000047684, -0.03981181979179382, 0.03987133130431175, -0.007027386222034693, 0.05245501175522804, 0.01540285348892212, -0.08275269716978073, 0.03885986655950546, -0.01454213634133339, 0.0021747846622020006, 0.022062575444579124, -0.05788569152355194, 0.09222789853811264, -0.02530534379184246, 0.04795107990503311, 0.015837719663977623, -0.07716929912567139, -0.033454302698373795, 0.03133966773748398, 0.00017251363897230476, 0.04996367171406746, 0.025066373869776726, -0.022639214992523193, 0.04428691789507866, -0.004652550909668207, 0.03934543579816818, 0.06318935006856918, -0.010263921692967415, 0.053158704191446304, -0.016522789373993874, -0.028231563046574593, -0.02553749457001686, -0.0033758787903934717, -0.05329579859972, -0.047400590032339096, 0.02401953563094139, -0.020344115793704987, 0.010300460271537304, 0.00201546773314476, -0.02252514287829399, 0.03643731400370598, 0.04720082879066467, -0.035617295652627945, -0.008003158494830132, -0.012148372828960419, -0.04893088340759277, 0.014642476104199886, -0.011614401824772358, -0.0023918473161756992, -0.008068786934018135, -0.024657169356942177, 0.10293418169021606, 0.07745921611785889, -0.025250408798456192, 0.02852841466665268, 0.030668053776025772, 0.003690168494358659, -0.04098661616444588, 0.024824317544698715, -0.016534708440303802, 0.003285746555775404, -0.003626832040026784, 0.009250940755009651, -0.021454257890582085, 0.05703070014715195, -0.040215469896793365, -0.00010221319826086983, 0.0823730081319809, -0.044185820966959, 0.03740136697888374, 0.016843082383275032, 0.018886825069785118, 0.04121415689587593, -0.016505872830748558, -0.02855650521814823, -0.025623155757784843, -0.021823346614837646, 0.01193180587142706, -0.021303784102201462, -0.019678033888339996, 0.006393378134816885, -0.04919493570923805, -0.03834657371044159, -0.018945135176181793, 0.054806917905807495, 0.0633319541811943, 0.009513338096439838, -0.014141222462058067, 0.007770959287881851, -0.022005243226885796, -0.02706572413444519, -0.1126026138663292, -0.04369300603866577, 0.0013547614216804504, 0.052011311054229736, 0.01796814426779747, 0.033798523247241974, -0.008094980381429195, 0.019729366526007652, 0.006486525293439627, -0.04999434947967529, 0.0003772533091250807, 0.033646102994680405, 0.004705908242613077, -0.07864200323820114, -0.0386195108294487, -0.0034101149067282677, 0.039959341287612915, -0.015620735473930836, -0.017969831824302673, -0.0422246940433979, -0.05070493742823601, -0.009441845118999481, -0.015428326092660427, 0.003095372347161174, 0.004537736065685749, -0.009771903045475483, 0.04020612686872482, -0.02506730891764164, 0.02239934727549553, 0.0390116423368454, 0.040748000144958496, 0.05629090219736099, 0.008926060050725937, -0.0053925360552966595, -0.014434589073061943, -0.05206546559929848, 0.003320511896163225, -0.019291633740067482, 0.05605145916342735, 0.007024276535958052, 0.01112015824764967, 0.011520614847540855, -0.007739818189293146, -0.26680389046669006, -0.02654164284467697, -0.007877876050770283, -0.013238133862614632, 0.038223475217819214, -0.00119930284563452, 0.014964855276048183, -0.04347746819257736, -0.03194708004593849, -0.02180478721857071, 0.012078306637704372, 0.012323038652539253, 0.022353725507855415, 0.07297982275485992, 0.043756816536188126, 0.025004057213664055, 0.0308513380587101, -0.03306039795279503, -0.013123762793838978, 0.03803476691246033, 0.018213482573628426, -0.0605405829846859, -0.01964152418076992, 0.06541141122579575, -0.013475760817527771, 0.057735592126846313, -0.06447693705558777, -0.01837967522442341, -0.03100518137216568, -0.0017184041207656264, -0.031843338161706924, -0.017565572634339333, -0.02995888702571392, 0.07855889201164246, 0.00972510315477848, 0.023027215152978897, 0.03798255696892738, -0.01214384101331234, 0.02734680101275444, 0.049010325223207474, 0.0024766467977315187, -0.030050886794924736, -0.04273004084825516, 0.012523732148110867, 0.06241576373577118, -0.00017420000222045928, -0.05195607244968414, -0.024897996336221695, -0.015083570964634418, 0.05302217975258827, -0.059439923614263535, -0.03495131433010101, -0.005298561882227659, 0.011918622069060802, -0.004458559677004814, -0.05980522185564041, 0.005195783916860819, -0.022486891597509384, -0.02614310383796692, 0.0165718924254179, 0.019383016973733902, -0.05595375970005989, 0.004199448972940445, -0.05569837614893913, -0.016282567754387856, -0.008748382329940796, -0.06732048094272614, -0.08287760615348816, 0.03908728063106537, 0.025772862136363983, -0.0028203066904097795, 0.02122790552675724, -0.007023550104349852, -0.10006089508533478, -0.010514585301280022, 0.0005649068625643849, -0.018070459365844727, -0.02419252134859562, 0.0031290960032492876, 0.06315797567367554, -0.01606392301619053, -0.05794534087181091, -0.0018299599178135395, 0.02630806714296341, 0.009743878617882729, 0.0035813874565064907, 0.029758794233202934, -0.044016458094120026, -0.01984301209449768, -0.02237589657306671, 0.02754543349146843, -0.008102769032120705, 0.008867861703038216, 0.003539852099493146, 0.07117970287799835, 0.015086546540260315, 0.01887739636003971, 0.045617591589689255, 0.06642135232686996, 0.0012588109821081161, 0.027921535074710846, -0.08131846785545349, 0.011817334219813347, -0.04244892671704292, -0.04473765194416046, -0.0012675193138420582, -0.042503539472818375, 0.0034843608736991882, 0.031624358147382736, 0.0023130974732339382, -0.027989240363240242, -0.02968447469174862, -0.026005638763308525, 0.005469447001814842, -0.028544658794999123, -0.019416257739067078, 0.025378672406077385, 0.01778029464185238, 0.027544284239411354, -0.0062328120693564415, 0.0025173048488795757, 0.025502340868115425, -0.012455576099455357, -0.002722131786867976, -0.0167979896068573, -0.03058663010597229, 0.019417867064476013, -0.017076630145311356, -0.006228151731193066, 0.004253537859767675, 0.04957842081785202, 0.031425841152668, 0.004806268494576216, 0.044123053550720215, 0.05597918480634689, 0.015524806454777718, -0.010258875787258148, -0.019844908267259598, 0.0524325929582119, 0.0026531449984759092, 0.018786881119012833, 0.01195678859949112, 0.02218259498476982, 0.0436885766685009, 0.02238205075263977, 0.01428396999835968, 0.02478102035820484, -0.00774574326351285, -0.010121895931661129, -0.00044758027070201933, 0.03141253441572189, -0.03331045061349869, 0.016586506739258766, -0.05064627155661583, -0.006173799280077219, 0.00022333447122946382, 0.05796213820576668, -0.024905484169721603, 0.012841702438890934, -0.0653386190533638, 0.05303902179002762, 0.021913832053542137, 0.009082256816327572, 0.01946876384317875, -0.024215878918766975, 0.024539951235055923, -0.0340254008769989, 0.0025598129723221064, 0.026587819680571556, 0.0588708221912384, -0.011187586933374405, -0.012972122058272362, -0.002890133298933506, -0.017332948744297028, -0.05137108638882637, 0.008353350684046745, 0.019103970378637314, -0.002304319990798831, -0.04001779109239578, 0.009326668456196785, 0.0049967351369559765, 0.022125691175460815, -0.016065381467342377, 0.0674995481967926, 0.07994378358125687, 0.024326657876372337, 0.00738568976521492, -0.01537103857845068, -0.05230650305747986, 0.015147586353123188, -0.017563868314027786, -0.011611494235694408, -0.01236742828041315, -0.03726273402571678, -0.047264181077480316, -0.05490761622786522, -0.0007411834667436779, 0.029968339949846268, -0.008771159686148167, -0.011083140969276428, 0.01886087656021118, 0.004380376543849707, -0.02240811288356781, 0.0011777682229876518, 0.005464976187795401, -0.08632050454616547, 0.0065794880501925945, 0.0302868839353323, -0.03132059797644615, 0.023108532652258873, -0.01151491329073906, -0.04355067387223244, -0.047410935163497925, 0.018286684527993202, 0.02268805354833603, -0.00956123135983944, -0.0247478187084198, -0.0033667688257992268, -0.016873259097337723, -0.01362305786460638, 0.03503568843007088, -0.00040418183198198676, 0.02750823087990284, 0.0008366603287868202, -0.0025353769306093454, 0.04066167771816254, -0.03598206490278244, -0.029856080189347267, -0.011395333334803581, -0.008778604678809643, 0.000981114455498755, -0.05089624971151352, 0.030703652650117874, 0.03950604423880577, 0.04100777208805084, -0.012065435759723186, -0.03699808195233345, 0.042759791016578674, -0.01424817182123661, -0.009149829857051373, 0.0003790550399571657, 0.0001662782160565257, -0.04656641185283661, 0.013220992870628834, -0.000026611831344780512, 0.021462049335241318, -0.003994518890976906, 0.014049180783331394, 0.01831245608627796, 0.020196933299303055, 0.0316055566072464, 0.014287196099758148, -0.07148251682519913, -0.017218532040715218, 0.06209927424788475, -0.0003161066269967705, -0.04708701744675636, -0.0818408876657486, -0.015792202204465866, 0.025486255064606667, 0.0007959403446875513, 0.04747888073325157, -0.009439884684979916, 0.06051957979798317, 0.012914041988551617, 0.05641872063279152, -0.00023452364257536829, -0.015590726397931576, 0.07053099572658539, -0.045673951506614685, -0.012454352341592312, -0.056661929935216904, -0.01604187674820423, 0.09348121285438538, -0.001800818950869143, -0.01780064031481743, -0.019035369157791138, -0.03897872939705849, 0.02900637313723564, 0.013279508799314499, -0.056627992540597916, 0.010496899485588074, -0.0081567894667387, 0.009139635600149632, 0.011108999140560627, -0.024864215403795242, -0.010709529742598534, 0.007072697393596172, -0.024280153214931488, -0.005568670574575663, -0.015251693315804005, 0.06540711224079132, -0.045813750475645065, 0.03356891870498657, -0.026038767769932747, 0.022172648459672928, 0.03737841919064522, 0.08319296687841415, -0.005941242445260286, 0.027621274814009666, -0.041791707277297974, 0.052981581538915634, 0.04677564650774002, 0.02006211131811142, -0.00830979272723198, 0.005450658965855837, -0.005928559694439173, -0.0777813121676445, -0.0005020956741645932, -0.03448893129825592, -0.0317714661359787, -0.03535778075456619, 0.06750151515007019, 0.031993985176086426, -0.07210428267717361, -0.007178443018347025, 0.003232921240851283, -0.03341343253850937, 0.005687082186341286, 0.002277958206832409, -0.01779395341873169, -0.02716132067143917, 0.07666690647602081, 0.019211597740650177, 0.026273544877767563, 0.07475118339061737, 0.006900500971823931, -0.004586267285048962, 0.03243130072951317, 0.04742201417684555, 0.043408967554569244, 0.052080512046813965, 0.006814259570091963, 0.05160518363118172, -0.03721875324845314, -0.0599280446767807, 0.045433320105075836, 0.011856282129883766, -0.03063308633863926, -0.03787166252732277, 0.017646940425038338, 0.06430371105670929, -0.01167270913720131, 0.06013492867350578, -0.04256952553987503, 0.0017839526990428567, 0.011382827535271645, -0.012731839902698994, -0.0030988112557679415, 0.035316143184900284, 0.01333320140838623, -0.005841415375471115, -0.046234454959630966, -0.018600517883896828, 0.0013334156246855855, -0.007489311974495649, 0.025073418393731117, 0.009001301601529121, 0.007054323796182871, 0.01083619985729456, -0.03138507157564163, 0.06963218748569489, 0.10873597860336304, -0.05597607046365738, -0.046870943158864975, 0.01809117943048477, 0.06330207735300064, 0.0028079196345061064, 0.04470350965857506, -0.009975391440093517, 0.0009465154143981636, 0.006834192667156458, -0.05412633717060089, 0.02698494680225849, 0.02653748355805874, 0.005002887453883886, 0.02589133381843567, -0.031132545322179794, -0.08251425623893738, -0.0076172975823283195, -0.005024730693548918, -0.0015776562504470348, -0.05837809666991234, -0.03490633890032768, -0.0034965549129992723, -0.06359926611185074, -0.0377129428088665, -0.005585936829447746, 0.009268841706216335, -0.03127725422382355, 0.013373377732932568, -0.022615831345319748, 0.013760796748101711, 0.0309574194252491, -0.040969133377075195, 0.02561149001121521, 0.017580203711986542, 0.008550018072128296, -0.01718880608677864, 0.02521195448935032, 0.026468001306056976, -0.013406501151621342, -0.00565823120996356, 0.038876425474882126, -0.0066370535641908646, 0.011823576875030994, 0.027591295540332794, -0.04838772863149643, -0.08194967359304428, 0.018261326476931572, -0.003335975343361497, -0.04711783677339554, -0.07106760889291763, 0.017268603667616844, -0.033300355076789856, 0.018141740933060646, 0.04971492663025856, -0.0007304619066417217, 0.011715547181665897, -0.023264670744538307, 0.006402322556823492, 0.026302581652998924, 0.029653016477823257, 0.06412513554096222, -0.016868358477950096, 0.06524199992418289, 0.02916138619184494, -0.005412769038230181, -0.04910627007484436, -0.0003936967405024916, -0.017643358558416367, 0.012840671464800835, -0.005227330140769482, -0.004035743419080973, -0.042979687452316284, -0.09851019084453583, -0.040644578635692596, -0.0024664036463946104, -0.02888711541891098, -0.0395527109503746, 0.006189757026731968, 0.0036360379308462143, 0.029413575306534767, -0.0064013684168457985, 0.026702141389250755, 0.005931897554546595, -0.03678147494792938, -0.033611051738262177, -0.0577838271856308, 0.009418152272701263, -0.04937314987182617, 0.024686940014362335, -0.026592446491122246, -0.04629864543676376, -0.0005517820827662945, -0.034046582877635956, 0.02465027943253517, 0.00016642565606161952, 0.031387049704790115, -0.010908706113696098 ]
3,548
Theory on Mixture-of-Experts in Continual Learning
https://openreview.net/forum?id=7XgKAabsPp
[ "Hongbo Li", "Sen Lin", "Lingjie Duan", "Yingbin Liang", "Ness Shroff" ]
Spotlight
Continual learning (CL) has garnered significant attention because of its ability to adapt to new tasks that arrive over time. Catastrophic forgetting (of old tasks) has been identified as a major issue in CL, as the model adapts to new tasks. The Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) model has recently been shown to effectively mitigate catastrophic forgetting in CL, by employing a gating network to sparsify and distribute diverse tasks among multiple experts. However, there is a lack of theoretical analysis of MoE and its impact on the learning performance in CL. This paper provides the first theoretical results to characterize the impact of MoE in CL via the lens of overparameterized linear regression tasks. We establish the benefit of MoE over a single expert by proving that the MoE model can diversify its experts to specialize in different tasks, while its router learns to select the right expert for each task and balance the loads across all experts. Our study further suggests an intriguing fact that the MoE in CL needs to terminate the update of the gating network after sufficient training rounds to attain system convergence, which is not needed in the existing MoE studies that do not consider the continual task arrival. Furthermore, we provide explicit expressions for the expected forgetting and overall generalization error to characterize the benefit of MoE in the learning performance in CL. Interestingly, adding more experts requires additional rounds before convergence, which may not enhance the learning performance. Finally, we conduct experiments on both synthetic and real datasets to extend these insights from linear models to deep neural networks (DNNs), which also shed light on the practical algorithm design for MoE in CL.
continual learning, mixture-of-experts, catastrophic forgetting, generalization error
null
5,392
2406.16437
[ -0.004533205181360245, -0.033612798899412155, -0.01662120223045349, 0.03249532729387283, 0.049142129719257355, 0.009107553400099277, 0.03811883553862572, 0.02526933327317238, -0.043228309601545334, -0.031181981787085533, -0.022278407588601112, 0.04574165865778923, -0.05404172092676163, 0.008770089596509933, -0.015417424961924553, 0.026713447645306587, 0.054101940244436264, -0.01329040713608265, 0.012233154848217964, 0.016463615000247955, -0.009143657982349396, -0.004869888070970774, 0.04199784994125366, 0.006011886987835169, 0.004663614556193352, -0.00920470803976059, 0.000719974865205586, 0.012030070647597313, -0.0035111599136143923, 0.01141089666634798, 0.03956321254372597, -0.0077728466130793095, 0.023818640038371086, -0.038933806121349335, 0.016081932932138443, 0.0147638451308012, -0.019824793562293053, -0.0072199334390461445, 0.012052807956933975, 0.01526764128357172, -0.04886411502957344, 0.01334869209676981, -0.012071065604686737, 0.0063131460919976234, -0.03388816863298416, 0.015304239466786385, -0.1107269898056984, 0.006105448119342327, 0.03825106471776962, -0.05863663926720619, -0.11630269885063171, 0.029889775440096855, 0.02162126451730728, -0.01814538985490799, 0.0062202769331634045, 0.03136127442121506, 0.05361424759030342, -0.05930274724960327, 0.0008885048446245492, -0.0319112129509449, -0.04674118012189865, 0.017765691503882408, -0.014930139295756817, 0.009682836942374706, -0.024402106180787086, -0.020541725680232048, 0.026824751868844032, 0.04341711103916168, -0.03107522614300251, 0.013010106980800629, -0.026122093200683594, -0.02557661384344101, -0.0020780551712960005, 0.015059718862175941, 0.004460906609892845, -0.04642019420862198, 0.02242271415889263, 0.02341906912624836, 0.07124269753694534, -0.02057104930281639, -0.005409950390458107, 0.001990111544728279, 0.003125482238829136, 0.023291626945137978, 0.032201651483774185, 0.019307389855384827, -0.027417099103331566, -0.036163657903671265, -0.09317484498023987, 0.03584294393658638, -0.034419916570186615, -0.04402303695678711, 0.009956493973731995, 0.023357680067420006, -0.003104759380221367, -0.013510708697140217, 0.02170562371611595, 0.004305076785385609, 0.010407195426523685, 0.009862932376563549, -0.017559928819537163, -0.013630776666104794, 0.004211483057588339, 0.006311811972409487, -0.0944499522447586, -0.0050478531047701836, -0.020284144207835197, -0.001802279381081462, -0.012418536469340324, 0.024430664256215096, -0.0660300925374031, -0.00012945178605150431, -0.0004263028677087277, -0.024865105748176575, -0.09026290476322174, 0.019422980025410652, -0.03591331094503403, 0.026654576882719994, -0.011766168288886547, 0.016263579949736595, 0.036834873259067535, 0.045248501002788544, -0.012320457026362419, 0.047758400440216064, -0.016929499804973602, -0.0035706430207937956, 0.00550608616322279, 0.016981275752186775, -0.03587740287184715, -0.028723882511258125, 0.013726807199418545, 0.035767439752817154, -0.006673249416053295, 0.000593101663980633, 0.0002974221424665302, 0.000784867035690695, 0.026449454948306084, 0.04303380474448204, 0.04214402288198471, -0.0013530794531106949, 0.006472919601947069, -0.025733735412359238, 0.05209246277809143, -0.033529821783304214, 0.0632750391960144, -0.020486600697040558, 0.017716171219944954, 0.002437860704958439, -0.030442947521805763, -0.029912671074271202, 0.012237527407705784, -0.004800116643309593, 0.013549485243856907, -0.0828418880701065, 0.016903895884752274, 0.05539220944046974, 0.007550607901066542, 0.03380243107676506, 0.0009926713537424803, 0.03915252909064293, 0.021506337448954582, -0.012887322343885899, -0.045992884784936905, -0.00005036059155827388, 0.004687279462814331, -0.08588322252035141, 0.031827665865421295, 0.08024553209543228, -0.033315032720565796, 0.01273465808480978, -0.030584432184696198, 0.0015622429782524705, 0.04018605127930641, -0.029395712539553642, 0.0021507921628654003, -0.014474737457931042, 0.06462588906288147, -0.01239403709769249, 0.05900798738002777, 0.016554586589336395, -0.0845300629734993, 0.03122037835419178, 0.006425279192626476, 0.00808557029813528, 0.0055557736195623875, -0.016604073345661163, 0.06915996968746185, -0.03031601384282112, 0.012701432220637798, 0.017713958397507668, -0.05689416080713272, -0.029914049431681633, 0.02964293770492077, -0.03460860997438431, 0.09429054707288742, 0.032851692289114, -0.00013638462405651808, 0.03757951036095619, 0.0387662909924984, 0.05078461393713951, 0.06329251080751419, -0.04320123419165611, 0.06328988820314407, 0.007859867997467518, -0.04168660566210747, 0.02243039757013321, 0.02595551311969757, -0.06130199134349823, -0.03217895328998566, 0.026815809309482574, -0.0022116070613265038, -0.002551417564973235, -0.01287577860057354, 0.007401557173579931, 0.020217811688780785, 0.009019418619573116, -0.003563463920727372, -0.034946009516716, 0.014782510697841644, -0.03235194832086563, 0.04543794319033623, 0.01432257890701294, -0.044697605073451996, 0.034006547182798386, -0.04013356566429138, 0.08587285131216049, 0.06697195023298264, -0.05232221260666847, -0.012439839541912079, 0.0036077986005693674, 0.03406291827559471, 0.01570962928235531, 0.043858204036951065, 0.004494942724704742, 0.04586402326822281, -0.023564545437693596, -0.0030605962965637445, -0.025470972061157227, 0.03313836455345154, -0.05290214717388153, -0.029750242829322815, 0.07247189432382584, -0.015788313001394272, 0.053924329578876495, 0.004922389052808285, 0.015798160806298256, 0.0053933169692754745, 0.03876067325472832, -0.010290026664733887, -0.025789136067032814, -0.00034022770705632865, -0.002039632759988308, -0.011212836019694805, -0.018612373620271683, -0.007771379314363003, -0.07080858945846558, -0.03491754084825516, -0.005067000165581703, 0.06283561885356903, 0.05760827660560608, 0.005957965273410082, 0.044115230441093445, 0.0005357233458198607, -0.02832040563225746, -0.020962851122021675, -0.11038453131914139, -0.044191695749759674, -0.0389120951294899, 0.019366072490811348, -0.0035116306971758604, 0.012919069267809391, 0.0010396497091278434, 0.07816597819328308, 0.0051507288590073586, -0.029886920005083084, 0.030864199623465538, 0.02398892305791378, 0.005560241173952818, -0.02503235824406147, -0.03007683902978897, -0.012116121128201485, 0.054742977023124695, -0.007202208507806063, -0.021062152460217476, -0.05280079320073128, -0.04084388166666031, -0.025155682116746902, -0.04322391375899315, -0.023628123104572296, 0.029724281281232834, 0.026718517765402794, 0.017122576013207436, -0.033641375601291656, 0.016740621998906136, 0.028198350220918655, 0.055248867720365524, 0.038782693445682526, 0.009812147356569767, -0.031636711210012436, 0.033408861607313156, -0.01934942603111267, 0.013612106442451477, 0.009042900986969471, 0.005068804137408733, -0.015172953717410564, -0.004183643031865358, 0.02029990404844284, 0.01886894926428795, -0.2578679621219635, -0.01956658996641636, 0.02853229083120823, -0.017192168161273003, 0.03169975057244301, -0.030286598950624466, 0.04331796616315842, -0.03364378213882446, -0.022543469443917274, -0.0049593192525208, 0.04711638018488884, 0.07806828618049622, 0.02686886489391327, 0.042472321540117264, 0.027202870696783066, 0.026731859892606735, 0.002252259524539113, -0.010105025954544544, -0.00736061530187726, 0.044696953147649765, -0.013452148996293545, -0.07776568084955215, -0.04113034904003143, 0.04577481001615524, -0.011944501660764217, 0.014559349045157433, -0.07590233534574509, -0.006617303006350994, -0.020983822643756866, 0.007269817870110273, -0.030358191579580307, -0.018310686573386192, -0.003488765796646476, 0.03461812809109688, 0.0017524994909763336, 0.011861974373459816, 0.06361560523509979, 0.014172269962728024, 0.01742211915552616, 0.0012427481124177575, 0.022058311849832535, -0.02532888948917389, -0.04547493904829025, 0.0064464439637959, 0.05319686979055405, 0.03785182163119316, -0.0714152455329895, -0.01271205022931099, -0.013465647585690022, 0.026729969307780266, -0.00673997588455677, -0.0049953581765294075, -0.03283631056547165, 0.008344416506588459, 0.03474719077348709, -0.011193271726369858, 0.024057241156697273, -0.027960775420069695, -0.0017085885629057884, 0.0009067713981494308, -0.001956160878762603, -0.0364849790930748, -0.02254849672317505, -0.0479690320789814, 0.013765843585133553, -0.04761944338679314, -0.07174940407276154, -0.06517021358013153, 0.04972406104207039, 0.019850393757224083, -0.0436570830643177, 0.012414335273206234, -0.014094318263232708, -0.09809443354606628, 0.025614889338612556, -0.009197201579809189, 0.011119103990495205, 0.012280669063329697, 0.025217078626155853, 0.04200717806816101, -0.037849705666303635, -0.022745219990611076, 0.01900300942361355, -0.011652388609945774, 0.06520101428031921, -0.022895054891705513, 0.02207191102206707, -0.00014684669440612197, -0.016924280673265457, -0.03264175355434418, 0.04760907590389252, 0.03233079984784126, 0.01571016199886799, -0.0062613654881715775, 0.06001577898859978, 0.0560678094625473, 0.0259327981621027, 0.05714006349444389, 0.062369078397750854, -0.018972881138324738, 0.03934844955801964, -0.0814523920416832, -0.004015618469566107, -0.046044040471315384, -0.039321962743997574, 0.003787146881222725, -0.061674151569604874, -0.028057299554347992, 0.04054339975118637, 0.012629295699298382, -0.024001339450478554, -0.04206704720854759, -0.008952092379331589, 0.002765136770904064, -0.03610558807849884, 0.0018388626631349325, -0.01297764666378498, 0.04086440056562424, 0.03215768188238144, -0.005843137390911579, -0.04569709300994873, 0.04227038845419884, -0.0051139164716005325, 0.031474970281124115, 0.023217780515551567, -0.03918164595961571, -0.020285818725824356, -0.015307426452636719, 0.011608785018324852, -0.003274566261097789, 0.002699741628021002, 0.03870275244116783, -0.015199800953269005, 0.017290759831666946, 0.03466410934925079, -0.013342680409550667, -0.009406344965100288, -0.002815987216308713, -0.0020593057852238417, -0.01739857718348503, 0.02516338974237442, 0.015585475601255894, 0.05018976703286171, 0.016452718526124954, 0.031670693308115005, 0.010830244049429893, -0.005124750081449747, -0.013350593857467175, 0.02458820678293705, -0.005632298998534679, 0.02159898355603218, -0.07049304246902466, 0.003481473308056593, -0.020727092400193214, 0.022858278825879097, -0.007039304822683334, 0.027597401291131973, -0.013275476172566414, 0.012931657955050468, -0.05274662375450134, 0.03055596351623535, 0.019290190190076828, -0.008038310334086418, -0.011869201436638832, 0.027179021388292313, 0.05446970835328102, -0.0257098525762558, 0.0225469209253788, 0.004545614123344421, 0.003422813955694437, 0.009641630575060844, -0.03265095502138138, -0.06465616077184677, -0.04072970524430275, 0.026395991444587708, 0.008126266300678253, 0.009312042035162449, -0.0007193086785264313, -0.05267728865146637, 0.025088490918278694, 0.02283392660319805, -0.014504375867545605, -0.024621890857815742, -0.007908895611763, 0.07166416943073273, 0.01829335279762745, 0.008324947208166122, -0.018813611939549446, -0.05484338104724884, 0.009677769616246223, 0.005657453089952469, 0.02573029324412346, -0.028164487332105637, -0.04203387349843979, -0.02458282746374607, -0.031064528971910477, 0.016492731869220734, 0.06677362322807312, -0.036930810660123825, 0.008522371761500835, -0.01824079267680645, -0.0077233631163835526, -0.04953325167298317, -0.010185504332184792, 0.028500352054834366, -0.0826568752527237, 0.019257493317127228, 0.004996040370315313, -0.008205924183130264, 0.01676269620656967, -0.06663771718740463, 0.005006138700991869, -0.03600406274199486, -0.038263991475105286, 0.0023225476033985615, -0.03525517135858536, -0.010396077297627926, 0.002148325787857175, 0.028264589607715607, -0.006192380096763372, 0.0012206524843350053, -0.014969024807214737, -0.014672571793198586, -0.022971542552113533, -0.02744450233876705, 0.06681177020072937, 0.007969989441335201, -0.004476064816117287, 0.004492654465138912, -0.03344453126192093, 0.02357756532728672, -0.0466826893389225, 0.001313382643274963, 0.03789954259991646, -0.02422652766108513, 0.005200546234846115, -0.014469197951257229, 0.06502607464790344, -0.015880081802606583, -0.04826251417398453, -0.013963177800178528, -0.03310838341712952, -0.04686243459582329, -0.014382699504494667, -0.013484898954629898, 0.054112449288368225, -0.017987746745347977, 0.019393248483538628, 0.009976964443922043, 0.02467290312051773, -0.00005276266165310517, 0.03771096467971802, -0.07514268159866333, -0.026669258251786232, 0.06982886046171188, -0.037424203008413315, -0.01961476542055607, -0.06915424764156342, -0.03112383373081684, 0.03220609948039055, -0.03492152690887451, 0.029947277158498764, -0.030062047764658928, 0.018422145396471024, 0.025815973058342934, 0.04880170524120331, -0.020052937790751457, -0.004475943744182587, 0.016997061669826508, -0.10202059149742126, 0.00783077534288168, -0.07598161697387695, -0.024570684880018234, 0.09447000175714493, -0.00761420140042901, 0.022923091426491737, -0.008497040718793869, -0.02780722640454769, 0.03555942326784134, -0.015492923557758331, -0.05722670629620552, -0.03310386463999748, -0.06506912410259247, 0.027838263660669327, 0.025489384308457375, -0.056166183203458786, -0.015046533197164536, -0.013071621768176556, -0.04860265552997589, -0.012901773676276207, -0.0386885441839695, 0.038054902106523514, 0.003526052227243781, 0.03869360312819481, -0.0179196335375309, 0.012942406348884106, 0.004302306566387415, 0.057575076818466187, 0.026839837431907654, 0.039175618439912796, -0.041768159717321396, 0.06557336449623108, 0.021043285727500916, 0.04879140481352806, -0.0002005958231166005, 0.030403025448322296, -0.012151950038969517, -0.047991350293159485, 0.04079471528530121, 0.006260704714804888, -0.01952269859611988, -0.031836993992328644, 0.03614414483308792, 0.024830922484397888, -0.04484253749251366, -0.0777500793337822, 0.03458798676729202, -0.06369737535715103, -0.006988098379224539, 0.00040450110100209713, -0.003949668724089861, -0.017763826996088028, 0.09105834364891052, 0.045690372586250305, 0.03839186951518059, 0.058074451982975006, 0.0343720018863678, -0.04868205264210701, -0.0018558099400252104, 0.06216900795698166, 0.05320729315280914, 0.025135641917586327, 0.004630535375326872, 0.06658156961202621, -0.0284139271825552, -0.053648632019758224, 0.009614151902496815, 0.008816827088594437, -0.0021096421405673027, -0.039168454706668854, 0.024300727993249893, 0.07347788661718369, 0.018120549619197845, 0.08021226525306702, -0.0736800953745842, 0.0045144516043365, 0.05195173621177673, -0.005001462530344725, -0.004374809097498655, 0.043814029544591904, 0.03138789162039757, 0.03903616592288017, -0.02422304078936577, -0.049866098910570145, -0.001769021968357265, -0.030300799757242203, -0.008798117749392986, 0.010551913641393185, 0.0012053957907482982, 0.011505319736897945, 0.025759471580386162, 0.009519007988274097, 0.09976592659950256, -0.04322502389550209, -0.012114145793020725, -0.009985686279833317, -0.02004306949675083, -0.0185882318764925, 0.05080592632293701, 0.030861064791679382, -0.021768653765320778, -0.009238606318831444, -0.02200889401137829, 0.04005541279911995, 0.02339600957930088, -0.0155065031722188, -0.004839552566409111, -0.03629250079393387, -0.023885343223810196, 0.01171664334833622, 0.022981975227594376, -0.017832491546869278, -0.03044489026069641, -0.039773158729076385, -0.05811568722128868, -0.046260375529527664, -0.04514133557677269, 0.05434834212064743, 0.012936243787407875, -0.03077385388314724, 0.00377628649584949, 0.018605995923280716, -0.002289010211825371, 0.05279708281159401, -0.05974750220775604, -0.00838810857385397, 0.03541633486747742, -0.019735418260097504, -0.01342412643134594, 0.04336118698120117, 0.025716762989759445, 0.01053671259433031, -0.003734089434146881, 0.05340223014354706, -0.0066429320722818375, 0.013843164779245853, -0.029581911861896515, -0.016939010471105576, -0.08671785145998001, 0.026063447818160057, 0.013979866169393063, -0.050070103257894516, -0.07428973913192749, 0.01660992205142975, -0.03660736232995987, 0.020314082503318787, 0.03984912484884262, -0.0022893655113875866, 0.017429295927286148, -0.03961683437228203, 0.002471600892022252, -0.021802857518196106, 0.002306201495230198, 0.06808827817440033, -0.0049925073981285095, 0.04640807583928108, 0.04414467513561249, -0.020862523466348648, -0.0116508137434721, 0.02780616097152233, -0.021476028487086296, -0.00905582308769226, -0.00662738224491477, -0.02580847404897213, -0.028878891840577126, -0.09943091124296188, -0.033571597188711166, 0.033010754734277725, 0.005452783312648535, -0.0448865070939064, -0.015888923779129982, 0.014786479994654655, 0.0171939879655838, -0.021300669759511948, -0.024231361225247383, -0.010114017874002457, -0.022948848083615303, -0.021780259907245636, -0.06465371698141098, 0.015994075685739517, -0.013128521852195263, -0.0031740120612084866, -0.014097410254180431, -0.02466735802590847, 0.01222658809274435, -0.028426382690668106, 0.05466412752866745, 0.01305436808615923, 0.015750378370285034, -0.008875577710568905 ]
3,549
Decentralized Sporadic Federated Learning: A Unified Algorithmic Framework with Convergence Guarantees
https://openreview.net/forum?id=cznqgb4DNv
[ "Shahryar Zehtabi", "Dong-Jun Han", "Rohit Parasnis", "Seyyedali Hosseinalipour", "Christopher Brinton" ]
Spotlight
Decentralized federated learning (DFL) captures FL settings where both (i) model updates and (ii) model aggregations are exclusively carried out by the clients without a central server. Existing DFL works have mostly focused on settings where clients conduct a fixed number of local updates between local model exchanges, overlooking heterogeneity and dynamics in communication and computation capabilities. In this work, we propose Decentralized Sporadic Federated Learning ($\texttt{DSpodFL}$), a DFL methodology built on a generalized notion of *sporadicity* in both local gradient and aggregation processes. $\texttt{DSpodFL}$ subsumes many existing decentralized optimization methods under a unified algorithmic framework by modeling the per-iteration (i) occurrence of gradient descent at each client and (ii) exchange of models between client pairs as arbitrary indicator random variables, thus capturing *heterogeneous and time-varying* computation/communication scenarios. We analytically characterize the convergence behavior of $\texttt{DSpodFL}$ for both convex and non-convex models and for both constant and diminishing learning rates, under mild assumptions on the communication graph connectivity, data heterogeneity across clients, and gradient noises. We show how our bounds recover existing results from decentralized gradient descent as special cases. Experiments demonstrate that $\texttt{DSpodFL}$ consistently achieves improved training speeds compared with baselines under various system settings.
Decentralized Federated Learning, Sporadicity, Unified Algorithmic Framework, Convergence Analysis
null
5,391
2402.03448
[ -0.027195602655410767, -0.06288988143205643, -0.009018403477966785, 0.04948633164167404, 0.023978805169463158, 0.013704138807952404, 0.030318161472678185, 0.007176544517278671, -0.02053745463490486, -0.04589136317372322, -0.0030240791384130716, -0.027400419116020203, -0.05593222752213478, -0.002360488288104534, -0.01146218366920948, 0.05845138803124428, 0.05145131051540375, -0.018952971324324608, 0.014147448353469372, 0.03142375499010086, -0.04148054122924805, -0.015795405954122543, -0.009351975284516811, 0.03582938015460968, 0.01777002401649952, -0.0015873314114287496, 0.0365096852183342, 0.01320725865662098, -0.016335122287273407, -0.00722681637853384, 0.0319068618118763, -0.010279785841703415, 0.025700850412249565, -0.024678848683834076, 0.022202417254447937, 0.029073471203446388, -0.002007315866649151, 0.010632137767970562, 0.020172355696558952, 0.027008648961782455, -0.018715597689151764, 0.026430798694491386, 0.03396645188331604, 0.03347654268145561, -0.06254974752664566, 0.0389811210334301, -0.10469124466180801, 0.027462860569357872, 0.03650384768843651, -0.029156023636460304, -0.08472593128681183, -0.006530796643346548, 0.041911639273166656, -0.00546799972653389, 0.018617115914821625, 0.04659966379404068, 0.015388034284114838, -0.08515109121799469, 0.0026225834153592587, -0.023518631234765053, -0.049751345068216324, 0.0005099702975712717, 0.03241397812962532, -0.0031839890871196985, -0.03662006929516792, -0.012379370629787445, 0.023866068571805954, 0.048444509506225586, -0.032651387155056, -0.03156554326415062, -0.0058994716964662075, 0.007220342755317688, -0.005927565973252058, -0.01446321327239275, -0.004039526451379061, -0.03845015540719032, 0.02406962960958481, 0.01986253634095192, 0.06513676047325134, -0.014159065671265125, -0.024959178641438484, 0.030945410951972008, 0.019439037889242172, 0.019517377018928528, -0.028023559600114822, 0.0026606167666614056, -0.03779306262731552, -0.013807487674057484, -0.09487918764352798, 0.0800078883767128, -0.035791441798210144, -0.06204821541905403, 0.01952013000845909, 0.004460134543478489, 0.010135565884411335, -0.010894945822656155, 0.027353918179869652, 0.035036470741033554, 0.04884342476725578, 0.010134395211935043, -0.034563854336738586, -0.010962546803057194, 0.013738200068473816, 0.009270081296563148, -0.09828473627567291, -0.007055408786982298, -0.04754704236984253, -0.03883236274123192, 0.000027150528694619425, -0.005207916256040335, -0.02154357172548771, 0.017291467636823654, 0.020100146532058716, -0.032962094992399216, -0.08375250548124313, 0.03332715108990669, -0.006421750411391258, -0.015521110035479069, -0.02277747541666031, -0.013881891965866089, 0.055666446685791016, 0.05333805829286575, -0.0017542202258482575, 0.06497092545032501, 0.0034245012793689966, 0.011378571391105652, 0.036681339144706726, 0.024990197271108627, -0.03573909029364586, -0.03836913779377937, 0.0063589224591851234, 0.02429310977458954, 0.005930740386247635, 0.006656219717115164, -0.011931788176298141, -0.016259020194411278, -0.04364895075559616, 0.043677106499671936, 0.04746301844716072, -0.007382765877991915, 0.012888646684587002, 0.002435969887301326, 0.03270687907934189, -0.017985476180911064, 0.04707733169198036, -0.0029105599969625473, 0.01867879554629326, -0.032935384660959244, -0.040590982884168625, -0.006323453038930893, 0.0011263005435466766, -0.001591538661159575, -0.0006188677507452667, -0.09211741387844086, 0.012246944010257721, 0.05060524865984917, 0.03504401445388794, 0.011771305464208126, -0.010330249555408955, 0.03587120398879051, 0.0004294202371966094, 0.01519561093300581, -0.020020192489027977, 0.00635668495669961, -0.007937842048704624, -0.06734640896320343, 0.05250471085309982, 0.03447667881846428, -0.009870113804936409, 0.007596466690301895, -0.03317203000187874, -0.03586764261126518, 0.027691585943102837, 0.014789856038987637, 0.018096966668963432, -0.010327324271202087, 0.07379385083913803, 0.0011471881298348308, 0.015059423632919788, 0.041093118488788605, -0.09097018837928772, 0.030028028413653374, 0.041673317551612854, 0.0004617476952262223, -0.024815840646624565, -0.0048898071981966496, 0.08449237793684006, -0.02001320570707321, 0.007047419901937246, 0.020961184054613113, -0.07230725139379501, -0.0049479021690785885, 0.01991635002195835, -0.027035795152187347, 0.06076246127486229, -0.01247467752546072, -0.011222021654248238, -0.0026691174134612083, 0.02758367359638214, 0.025342969223856926, 0.06743654608726501, -0.03751358389854431, 0.017799753695726395, 0.02072274126112461, -0.054108262062072754, 0.04580163210630417, 0.01755439303815365, -0.045624028891325, -0.05775398761034012, 0.020898329094052315, -0.012293379753828049, -0.026152752339839935, 0.0012424758169800043, -0.005024092271924019, 0.016679871827363968, 0.005681111477315426, 0.013750176876783371, 0.015127044171094894, 0.011172902770340443, -0.049345094710588455, 0.028596725314855576, 0.006403285078704357, -0.0281692948192358, 0.0456465482711792, -0.028144847601652145, 0.09481756389141083, 0.09004033356904984, -0.031513605266809464, 0.01673455722630024, 0.04791022464632988, 0.015952114015817642, -0.006269761826843023, -0.010468609631061554, -0.044346779584884644, 0.014440002851188183, -0.0008234899141825736, -0.008567770011723042, -0.04967045783996582, 0.06390848010778427, -0.03351394087076187, -0.020878082141280174, 0.06965288519859314, -0.024946028366684914, 0.06171712279319763, 0.002241348149254918, -0.00756873982027173, 0.010898961685597897, -0.002177735324949026, 0.006044487003237009, -0.02482668124139309, -0.031645238399505615, -0.012256073765456676, -0.009357004426419735, -0.028210151940584183, 0.003661062102764845, -0.05407591536641121, 0.015293091535568237, 0.026392435654997826, 0.0717134103178978, 0.04251067340373993, 0.031537920236587524, 0.009423088282346725, 0.012248019687831402, -0.05060530826449394, -0.031554222106933594, -0.13163581490516663, -0.03274234011769295, 0.021243823692202568, 0.0839289128780365, -0.011431644670665264, 0.04030285030603409, -0.024277331307530403, 0.026750095188617706, -0.002594566438347101, -0.0394708551466465, 0.019573070108890533, 0.03749682381749153, -0.002242228714749217, -0.033350564539432526, -0.027288837358355522, 0.004269647412002087, 0.06340965628623962, 0.017756924033164978, -0.013697232119739056, -0.04705839976668358, -0.02776167541742325, 0.023859402164816856, -0.054229773581027985, -0.006483666133135557, 0.007672123145312071, 0.00010259437840431929, 0.0348026379942894, -0.03830976411700249, 0.003487797686830163, 0.01816294901072979, 0.0740882009267807, 0.02755369246006012, 0.012319575995206833, -0.015964344143867493, 0.02535916492342949, 0.004722105339169502, -0.0029606418684124947, -0.020543765276670456, 0.02120235189795494, -0.03879227116703987, -0.010214429348707199, 0.01266392134130001, 0.0197537150233984, -0.2826056480407715, -0.0040327878668904305, -0.005118091590702534, 0.010106103494763374, 0.02821408584713936, -0.016253948211669922, 0.016977131366729736, -0.02080675959587097, -0.00947132334113121, -0.02128245308995247, 0.00021878728875890374, 0.04133330658078194, -0.007532183546572924, 0.06564896553754807, 0.01984844170510769, 0.018459005281329155, -0.032172221690416336, -0.03930625692009926, 0.0361534059047699, 0.008697678335011005, -0.031324420124292374, -0.07244041562080383, -0.012007535435259342, 0.031234286725521088, -0.00007229730545077473, 0.02652783878147602, -0.05559556558728218, -0.022107819095253944, -0.03550237789750099, -0.003231737995520234, -0.027561800554394722, -0.036337096244096756, -0.004198409151285887, 0.043861836194992065, 0.014817716553807259, 0.02396872080862522, 0.026977987959980965, 0.02605697140097618, 0.028552310541272163, 0.014874918386340141, 0.005001407116651535, 0.012761292979121208, -0.01404014602303505, 0.015235262922942638, 0.09100507944822311, 0.04575425013899803, -0.06124044209718704, -0.02813856303691864, -0.03564944863319397, 0.007090678438544273, 0.006481000687927008, -0.04280654713511467, -0.02620268054306507, -0.007831938564777374, 0.005425425246357918, -0.04119008406996727, -0.019990626722574234, -0.018607845529913902, 0.000538016261998564, 0.02946258708834648, 0.006883128546178341, -0.045904286205768585, -0.0045088487677276134, -0.04185217618942261, -0.0009404839365743101, -0.04494072496891022, -0.09905561804771423, -0.04757904261350632, 0.05855073779821396, 0.021083146333694458, -0.004397086799144745, 0.020979322493076324, -0.01701199822127819, -0.09981285035610199, -0.0023449230939149857, 0.00008388527203351259, 0.012419507838785648, -0.0029962805565446615, 0.0225859172642231, 0.0959930568933487, -0.014659085310995579, -0.03159240633249283, 0.005198972299695015, 0.0015509994700551033, 0.03064577467739582, -0.010773783549666405, 0.0314948670566082, -0.019968699663877487, 0.0031850957311689854, -0.022505994886159897, 0.022753307595849037, 0.010653954930603504, 0.07898194342851639, 0.005908588413149118, 0.061440467834472656, 0.03798273205757141, -0.0048101674765348434, 0.056662026792764664, 0.033529896289110184, 0.027047820389270782, -0.011384423822164536, -0.09249486774206161, -0.0305931456387043, -0.03915955871343613, -0.020666414871811867, 0.040480807423591614, -0.052576467394828796, -0.03348741680383682, 0.07121038436889648, 0.012875490821897984, -0.0057643405161798, -0.055442649871110916, 0.011604866944253445, -0.026949292048811913, -0.0034310841001570225, -0.032176174223423004, -0.004744168370962143, 0.04527219757437706, 0.027689093723893166, -0.010516219772398472, -0.046431995928287506, 0.05380519479513168, 0.009665747173130512, 0.030395539477467537, -0.011082381941378117, 0.014447316527366638, -0.01930359937250614, -0.009398235008120537, 0.011389998719096184, -0.014480814337730408, 0.046670135110616684, 0.036871861666440964, 0.026239337399601936, 0.023348156362771988, 0.04955202713608742, 0.009589546360075474, -0.013050214387476444, -0.008139288984239101, 0.03735543414950371, -0.01905440166592598, 0.051858555525541306, -0.007477317005395889, 0.03540627285838127, 0.014799551106989384, 0.041108984500169754, 0.022485915571451187, -0.008778566494584084, 0.01516797486692667, -0.0015342775732278824, -0.028090614825487137, 0.014716111123561859, -0.0457104928791523, -0.0014794253511354327, -0.01225315686315298, -0.009995869360864162, 0.011735483072698116, 0.03795502707362175, -0.006059660576283932, -0.02244657278060913, -0.06548994034528732, 0.010327716358006, -0.002408810891211033, -0.020857254043221474, -0.009204313158988953, 0.03731510788202286, 0.07338624447584152, -0.03947973623871803, -0.0016837912844493985, 0.0051698531024158, -0.012807951308786869, 0.023975718766450882, -0.03995654731988907, -0.013066127896308899, -0.010593733750283718, 0.0063872672617435455, 0.011230389587581158, 0.029161475598812103, 0.004394015297293663, -0.024301668629050255, 0.024676211178302765, 0.012049238197505474, -0.015738805755972862, -0.019697552546858788, 0.03055841103196144, 0.091362863779068, 0.01913294941186905, 0.011280338279902935, -0.01819906011223793, -0.03564818948507309, 0.056777216494083405, 0.006812634877860546, 0.041071292012929916, -0.013350428082048893, -0.019469132646918297, -0.004116956144571304, -0.03439895808696747, 0.022950071841478348, 0.0217962097376585, -0.02574354037642479, -0.014616004191339016, -0.02980130910873413, -0.001236683689057827, -0.029277421534061432, 0.004080822691321373, 0.026314428076148033, -0.0608338937163353, 0.013022301718592644, 0.022477073594927788, -0.02210533618927002, -0.008619769476354122, -0.034714844077825546, -0.031231002882122993, -0.044561997056007385, -0.005739374551922083, 0.023571178317070007, -0.03794625401496887, -0.029817411676049232, 0.00537022203207016, 0.005014634225517511, -0.007222262676805258, 0.012118530459702015, -0.018819618970155716, -0.03889037296175957, -0.02274436131119728, -0.021207738667726517, 0.061420269310474396, -0.02891893871128559, -0.01771395653486252, -0.016271784901618958, 0.014122324995696545, 0.025356637313961983, -0.06064223498106003, 0.009804846718907356, 0.03352276608347893, -0.017559105530381203, 0.04022061079740524, -0.029911654070019722, 0.04165533557534218, -0.040627848356962204, -0.006486831232905388, -0.0201353020966053, 0.009835591539740562, -0.043845877051353455, -0.04669838398694992, -0.008958742022514343, 0.01271700207144022, 0.022960739210247993, 0.0045743039809167385, 0.01108772587031126, 0.020365817472338676, -0.0022593874018639326, 0.019563503563404083, -0.051691796630620956, 0.002606556285172701, 0.055754370987415314, -0.03119865246117115, -0.0036912732757627964, -0.06846387684345245, 0.006117810495197773, 0.0077912393026053905, -0.05865215137600899, 0.0245624128729105, -0.01840212754905224, 0.04290691390633583, 0.011982961557805538, 0.052721936255693436, 0.051528893411159515, -0.018186375498771667, 0.03470393270254135, -0.031986579298973083, -0.050717078149318695, -0.0731780007481575, -0.004466727841645479, 0.0326613150537014, -0.03247977793216705, 0.04898005351424217, 0.022293105721473694, -0.04448947310447693, -0.002058281097561121, -0.024065980687737465, -0.05990418419241905, 0.004605206660926342, -0.03997669368982315, 0.00687763188034296, 0.014795745722949505, -0.06326927989721298, -0.02523166500031948, -0.014260041527450085, -0.05980357155203819, -0.004938195459544659, 0.023681649938225746, 0.01249158475548029, 0.004026663023978472, 0.00873925443738699, -0.018228644505143166, 0.023426072672009468, 0.017183177173137665, 0.024512065574526787, -0.0008077726233750582, 0.03133499249815941, -0.04361503943800926, 0.0818619504570961, 0.034633293747901917, -0.012170598842203617, 0.018033800646662712, 0.018356073647737503, -0.01528105791658163, -0.04742371290922165, 0.09275320917367935, -0.020858781412243843, -0.050785645842552185, -0.0572097972035408, 0.04242631793022156, 0.03182753548026085, -0.02338636852800846, -0.03702522814273834, 0.003980826120823622, -0.05295775458216667, 0.01820231042802334, 0.023442000150680542, 0.008196420967578888, -0.006718645803630352, 0.06874056160449982, 0.022703340277075768, 0.025239363312721252, 0.060384977608919144, 0.046609729528427124, -0.032320450991392136, 0.01622777059674263, 0.05579237639904022, 0.07958416640758514, 0.00024251779541373253, -0.005665494594722986, 0.07437904179096222, -0.013968663290143013, -0.04986521601676941, -0.010569299571216106, 0.005392389837652445, -0.03517145663499832, -0.03293118253350258, 0.011372633278369904, 0.06677036732435226, -0.003711600322276354, 0.06669556349515915, -0.07081671804189682, 0.00785740278661251, 0.056720152497291565, 0.008076253347098827, 0.017313558608293533, 0.046271827071905136, 0.024125708267092705, 0.03315430507063866, -0.028783362358808517, -0.02534663677215576, 0.002965108258649707, -0.007257928606122732, 0.017594890668988228, 0.0027159887831658125, -0.015814460813999176, 0.04076368734240532, 0.00825339276343584, -0.006439484190195799, 0.054819829761981964, -0.06017685309052467, -0.03963924199342728, 0.0014097337843850255, 0.002438928000628948, -0.015052384696900845, 0.032242532819509506, 0.0265961904078722, -0.026421427726745605, 0.025341469794511795, -0.032951630651950836, 0.032768357545137405, 0.009777214378118515, 0.01556478627026081, 0.009128618985414505, -0.03005347214639187, -0.004564574453979731, 0.02201838605105877, 0.0051365746185183525, -0.0455419197678566, -0.04589393734931946, -0.026811204850673676, -0.055635981261730194, -0.065593421459198, -0.023712264373898506, 0.0204947330057621, 0.007419267203658819, -0.03199669346213341, 0.01718759536743164, -0.03811335191130638, 0.030443798750638962, -0.001979394815862179, -0.045249320566654205, -0.008309982717037201, 0.03270207345485687, 0.0012635075254365802, 0.04056938737630844, 0.007873107679188251, 0.018971877172589302, -0.05927613005042076, -0.010314387269318104, 0.00007808369991835207, -0.01682453602552414, 0.010179713368415833, -0.0038605276495218277, -0.014198817312717438, -0.09103655070066452, 0.026956934481859207, 0.01874806359410286, -0.04241102561354637, -0.08114207535982132, 0.039562154561281204, -0.002873413497582078, 0.003455226542428136, 0.0568905808031559, -0.006565426010638475, -0.01804002746939659, -0.07138324528932571, -0.012004384770989418, -0.0029273107647895813, 0.016819143667817116, 0.0505707785487175, -0.0059749530628323555, 0.05332579463720322, 0.04176337271928787, -0.027737952768802643, -0.06932664662599564, 0.034066092222929, 0.006119732744991779, -0.021991882473230362, -0.05110993981361389, -0.028674766421318054, -0.028884703293442726, -0.08892813324928284, -0.01894206926226616, 0.02174820937216282, -0.017845267429947853, -0.05573103949427605, -0.011145154945552349, -0.011456036940217018, -0.02334127202630043, -0.012260330840945244, -0.008193849585950375, -0.009327070787549019, -0.025249874219298363, -0.022998377680778503, -0.08677707612514496, 0.010667202062904835, -0.008888846263289452, -0.003983944188803434, 0.011009781621396542, -0.06098497286438942, 0.005076065193861723, 0.014995152130723, 0.03750637173652649, 0.02498749829828739, 0.0072481874376535416, 0.006585243623703718 ]
3,550
MAD-TD: Model-Augmented Data stabilizes High Update Ratio RL
https://openreview.net/forum?id=6RtRsg8ZV1
[ "Claas A Voelcker", "Marcel Hussing", "Eric Eaton", "Amir-massoud Farahmand", "Igor Gilitschenski" ]
Spotlight
Building deep reinforcement learning (RL) agents that find a good policy with few samples has proven notoriously challenging. To achieve sample efficiency, recent work has explored updating neural networks with large numbers of gradient steps for every new sample. While such high update-to-data (UTD) ratios have shown strong empirical performance, they also introduce instability to the training process. Previous approaches need to rely on periodic neural network parameter resets to address this instability, but restarting the training process is infeasible in many real-world applications and requires tuning the resetting interval. In this paper, we focus on one of the core difficulties of stable training with limited samples: the inability of learned value functions to generalize to unobserved on-policy actions. We mitigate this issue directly by augmenting the off-policy RL training process with a small amount of data generated from a learned world model. Our method, Model-Augmented Data for TD Learning (MAD-TD) uses small amounts of generated data to stabilize high UTD training and achieve competitive performance on the most challenging tasks in the DeepMind control suite. Our experiments further highlight the importance of employing a good model to generate data, MAD-TD's ability to combat value overestimation, and its practical stability gains for continued learning.
reinforcement learning, model based reinforcement learning, data augmentation, high update ratios
Using model generated data can lead to stable learning with high update ratios in off-policy RL
5,371
null
[ -0.020180387422442436, -0.038691189140081406, -0.050434134900569916, 0.07629095762968063, 0.04227902740240097, 0.011738291941583157, 0.019010022282600403, -0.01767851784825325, -0.05198989063501358, -0.04222024977207184, -0.044980552047491074, 0.013398376293480396, -0.08360961824655533, -0.036670032888650894, 0.014579213224351406, 0.06064419075846672, 0.05735095590353012, -0.03402581810951233, 0.021014852449297905, 0.021286750212311745, -0.023236069828271866, -0.03031941130757332, 0.030297227203845978, 0.003320512128993869, 0.01621658354997635, -0.01402902789413929, 0.007820826955139637, -0.009105993434786797, -0.01899750530719757, -0.006422786507755518, 0.022905029356479645, -0.023927364498376846, 0.010466138832271099, -0.008681935258209705, -0.00025344968889839947, 0.03211945667862892, -0.04841894283890724, -0.007085919845849276, 0.02154756523668766, -0.006470495369285345, -0.03953864797949791, -0.0011297378223389387, -0.016536550596356392, -0.010812320746481419, -0.013615624979138374, 0.02296292781829834, -0.053742919117212296, 0.01633087359368801, 0.011384792625904083, -0.03504667803645134, -0.0953446701169014, 0.03821076452732086, 0.012129572220146656, -0.017759891226887703, -0.002455888083204627, 0.037555206567049026, 0.0387788824737072, -0.08148761838674545, -0.01724274270236492, -0.06638593971729279, -0.009545084089040756, 0.012760822661221027, 0.014434149488806725, -0.0008516231901012361, -0.006199073512107134, 0.005923694930970669, 0.029778366908431053, -0.011161783710122108, -0.03743382543325424, -0.0014271591790020466, -0.035535313189029694, -0.0489952452480793, -0.017902668565511703, 0.0207313634455204, -0.01090033259242773, -0.041622698307037354, 0.012559997849166393, 0.01319453027099371, 0.05645306035876274, -0.0027981780003756285, 0.00004684727537096478, -0.0025933163706213236, 0.027345042675733566, 0.040341779589653015, 0.00431874068453908, 0.00763690983876586, -0.024515563622117043, -0.043641503900289536, -0.0845038965344429, 0.03418772295117378, -0.037258896976709366, -0.035770852118730545, 0.01957174949347973, 0.027007674798369408, -0.010265045799314976, -0.018316470086574554, -0.012285105884075165, 0.015041830949485302, 0.010750345885753632, -0.006982631515711546, 0.013614699244499207, -0.03885860741138458, 0.007934559136629105, -0.009718547575175762, -0.09923804551362991, 0.02092599682509899, -0.02058257907629013, -0.023474417626857758, -0.035645581781864166, 0.017649821937084198, -0.05636324733495712, -0.0005494119832292199, 0.029626039788126945, -0.011139561422169209, -0.0893084928393364, 0.02413359098136425, 0.016767030581831932, 0.060780271887779236, 0.012968741357326508, 0.015296779572963715, 0.057174719870090485, 0.0373629666864872, 0.014549542218446732, 0.07135654985904694, 0.01906169019639492, 0.0023051041644066572, 0.00638787355273962, 0.02266770415008068, 0.0013784028124064207, -0.022330081090331078, 0.02213647961616516, 0.01640874147415161, -0.04244644567370415, -0.015460614114999771, 0.0007553359027951956, -0.007211498916149139, 0.008434046991169453, 0.008388148620724678, 0.045205239206552505, 0.023382510989904404, -0.0033776527270674706, -0.0267132930457592, 0.06195317953824997, -0.0348237082362175, 0.053263042122125626, 0.0022847491782158613, -0.02186655066907406, -0.037507954984903336, -0.044987283647060394, 0.02922692894935608, 0.020156824961304665, -0.0020801264327019453, -0.020695354789495468, -0.035869695246219635, 0.0526764839887619, 0.06106933206319809, 0.005202868953347206, -0.002166496589779854, 0.014607834629714489, 0.050057366490364075, 0.013088034465909004, 0.0030695288442075253, -0.006414475385099649, -0.0265209823846817, 0.017484165728092194, -0.07424228638410568, 0.04793029651045799, 0.02347375452518463, -0.009327232837677002, 0.002136046066880226, -0.05936860293149948, -0.0329846628010273, 0.07461803406476974, 0.002442452823743224, -0.0071864803321659565, 0.027476195245981216, 0.042211469262838364, -0.015046129003167152, 0.01696299947798252, 0.03376695513725281, -0.08690202236175537, 0.05558015778660774, 0.03465224429965019, 0.005111583508551121, 0.0007651011110283434, -0.018487464636564255, 0.07193442434072495, -0.04737185686826706, 0.0342581681907177, 0.029073042795062065, -0.06876634061336517, -0.021544190123677254, 0.020695146173238754, -0.012396484613418579, 0.061897359788417816, -0.007054043933749199, -0.01865229941904545, 0.04753576219081879, 0.04807128757238388, 0.054558299481868744, 0.023434262722730637, -0.04579530283808708, 0.04958067089319229, -0.016589947044849396, 0.01480328943580389, -0.034790389239788055, 0.03960958868265152, -0.04413324594497681, -0.012574400752782822, 0.02791624516248703, -0.03389257565140724, -0.02134779654443264, -0.002864481182768941, 0.012656643986701965, 0.014206894673407078, -0.0033008737955242395, -0.02264343574643135, -0.02041257731616497, 0.009099077433347702, -0.016577795147895813, 0.05356728285551071, 0.00836125947535038, -0.017835265025496483, 0.0003306333674117923, -0.045523375272750854, 0.08550414443016052, 0.0427062101662159, -0.03809216991066933, 0.01232943870127201, 0.01697598397731781, -0.001310344086959958, 0.018813472241163254, 0.0018852906068786979, -0.03361939266324043, 0.021013570949435234, -0.010959049686789513, 0.0015665037790313363, -0.010033899918198586, 0.05297820642590523, -0.03655153512954712, 0.0017030721064656973, 0.07745105028152466, -0.000046739703975617886, 0.09344644099473953, -0.029802875593304634, 0.012364269234240055, 0.047636669129133224, 0.026304833590984344, -0.014621637761592865, -0.048050109297037125, -0.003730453085154295, -0.0021415255032479763, 0.01873347908258438, -0.01014297641813755, 0.003769657341763377, -0.06642443686723709, -0.04138826206326485, -0.05533575639128685, 0.04425477609038353, 0.049313973635435104, -0.02277982421219349, 0.050342924892902374, -0.025335686281323433, -0.05125068873167038, -0.04406723007559776, -0.11707723885774612, -0.01075489167124033, 0.03626098856329918, 0.020235422998666763, 0.0283325407654047, 0.030095558613538742, -0.020699393004179, 0.014064669609069824, -0.025794215500354767, -0.033170025795698166, 0.04891924560070038, 0.043901655822992325, 0.043562110513448715, -0.0540960319340229, -0.0003242102393414825, 0.003494873410090804, 0.07620714604854584, 0.007505127228796482, -0.015279391780495644, -0.03318049758672714, -0.05656762793660164, -0.0201000664383173, -0.04798952490091324, -0.020501617342233658, 0.028330054134130478, 0.010007593780755997, -0.004817332606762648, -0.030846698209643364, 0.025831211358308792, 0.028726937249302864, 0.073903888463974, 0.03260286524891853, 0.01981413923203945, -0.008243815042078495, 0.02398674562573433, 0.004550542216747999, -0.01562191080302, -0.022947827354073524, 0.023519715294241905, 0.020888160914182663, -0.02502557635307312, 0.015219851396977901, 0.013750883750617504, -0.27161312103271484, -0.02759375050663948, 0.009625328704714775, 0.01615801453590393, 0.04710620269179344, -0.025833358988165855, 0.033992644399404526, -0.015966402366757393, -0.02892686240375042, -0.037074245512485504, 0.028039785102009773, 0.0215488001704216, 0.01352071762084961, 0.03211148455739021, 0.04781787469983101, 0.011025991290807724, 0.017228789627552032, -0.042790286242961884, 0.002934176940470934, 0.03678852692246437, -0.020483389496803284, -0.08531267195940018, 0.010676013305783272, 0.05479732155799866, -0.0048157768324017525, 0.01795812137424946, -0.04864095523953438, -0.017268283292651176, -0.03290265053510666, 0.007850156165659428, -0.0021715464536100626, 0.012166919186711311, -0.015721319243311882, 0.022175801917910576, 0.02902848646044731, -0.0029465374536812305, 0.053895436227321625, 0.008690211921930313, 0.03687890246510506, -0.022294091060757637, -0.0004888121620751917, 0.016894251108169556, -0.011627341620624065, 0.03510154038667679, 0.06649122387170792, 0.03732573986053467, -0.06011389195919037, 0.003613928332924843, -0.022608797997236252, 0.03703116253018379, 0.031920913606882095, -0.0009095088462345302, -0.012958928942680359, 0.01649727299809456, 0.009604846127331257, -0.0011376732727512717, 0.01076540071517229, -0.009227048605680466, -0.007019082549959421, 0.04160146787762642, 0.010220889933407307, -0.04656755179166794, -0.00925233494490385, 0.002513397252187133, -0.005483460146933794, -0.06278005987405777, -0.03483498841524124, -0.048945825546979904, 0.03161757439374924, 0.0708424299955368, -0.023884624242782593, -0.005991305690258741, -0.01692276820540428, -0.10676760971546173, 0.027143124490976334, -0.011127425357699394, -0.012231210246682167, -0.040085338056087494, -0.00040397257544100285, 0.05647340789437294, -0.038317594677209854, -0.04640749469399452, 0.006576701998710632, 0.005131841637194157, 0.040491700172424316, -0.03762633726000786, 0.03878812864422798, -0.021169908344745636, 0.0010847451630979776, -0.02808239683508873, 0.05062449350953102, -0.031335800886154175, 0.03314826637506485, -0.02198554202914238, 0.03674229606986046, 0.029468728229403496, 0.0201395433396101, 0.04326910153031349, 0.04171504080295563, 0.005643283482640982, -0.014649048447608948, -0.06838763505220413, 0.02997657097876072, -0.06418021023273468, -0.030986376106739044, -0.02783343940973282, -0.04666637256741524, -0.009038985706865788, 0.007025874685496092, 0.03814184293150902, -0.028128748759627342, -0.06030897796154022, -0.0067926677875220776, -0.018781516700983047, -0.006994029972702265, -0.02150135301053524, -0.004147310741245747, 0.024836743250489235, -0.003919590264558792, -0.030098114162683487, -0.0482877753674984, 0.02793726697564125, -0.006985556334257126, 0.020711297169327736, 0.022397147491574287, -0.019377421587705612, 0.029414333403110504, -0.02551739476621151, 0.00642386032268405, -0.03217633441090584, 0.023511145263910294, 0.045068491250276566, 0.006833027582615614, 0.030521133914589882, 0.014475700445473194, -0.023538609966635704, -0.02073518931865692, 0.011433379724621773, 0.03943097963929176, -0.030812744051218033, 0.002287592738866806, 0.0018859015544876456, 0.03990150988101959, -0.0022023431956768036, 0.0006288837175816298, 0.020600708201527596, 0.014013651758432388, 0.021452881395816803, 0.04911176487803459, -0.013642494566738605, 0.039243921637535095, -0.08097832649946213, -0.0010654234793037176, -0.03688625991344452, 0.03533567488193512, -0.02764805778861046, 0.02899588644504547, -0.015550750307738781, 0.011215154081583023, -0.07752041518688202, -0.007217892911285162, 0.009270166978240013, -0.03453490510582924, 0.010920844972133636, -0.004535389132797718, 0.07226967066526413, -0.030024152249097824, -0.042311131954193115, 0.026136115193367004, 0.0016472298884764314, -0.0014223081525415182, -0.03023623116314411, -0.010815375484526157, -0.028676146641373634, -0.036366019397974014, -0.03268575295805931, 0.04588032141327858, -0.011649339459836483, -0.007760816253721714, 0.012726431712508202, 0.010909127071499825, -0.010686487890779972, -0.016611436381936073, -0.003042658558115363, 0.06744103133678436, -0.00005634854096570052, 0.018299797549843788, 0.0020512614864856005, -0.02463003620505333, 0.009095600806176662, 0.010056743398308754, 0.030053304508328438, -0.041507165879011154, -0.025513960048556328, -0.015603367239236832, -0.0388558991253376, 0.017510900273919106, 0.037246886640787125, -0.013308487832546234, 0.0018462849548086524, -0.00020970989135093987, -0.012694178149104118, -0.03417463228106499, 0.019160408526659012, 0.030517498031258583, -0.08118391036987305, 0.006162028759717941, 0.03660742938518524, 0.0021771639585494995, 0.026600206270813942, -0.05841546133160591, -0.005550775211304426, -0.04856850206851959, -0.022862369194626808, 0.019566792994737625, 0.0025781216099858284, -0.02509945258498192, -0.027359165251255035, -0.021734606474637985, -0.023567771539092064, 0.03712049499154091, -0.02658838778734207, -0.01427891943603754, 0.0015421160496771336, 0.014115344732999802, 0.035936031490564346, 0.012238485738635063, -0.03392345830798149, -0.000301475083688274, 0.017694056034088135, 0.027790047228336334, -0.027257710695266724, 0.007592565845698118, 0.03941698744893074, -0.003209601156413555, -0.012084909714758396, -0.029850006103515625, 0.07705851644277573, -0.023277627304196358, -0.02746536210179329, -0.016569465398788452, -0.014644456095993519, -0.01590871997177601, 0.015380820259451866, -0.02179286628961563, 0.007466204464435577, -0.004823304712772369, 0.00314752827398479, 0.021134741604328156, 0.023512588813900948, 0.04504606872797012, 0.028773672878742218, -0.05618003383278847, 0.02230408787727356, 0.04212285950779915, -0.05100522190332413, 0.0036275996826589108, -0.06165638193488121, -0.023205192759633064, 0.038637399673461914, -0.034041039645671844, 0.02490081638097763, -0.050850000232458115, 0.019527649506926537, 0.007891310378909111, 0.014550699852406979, 0.013983115553855896, -0.06405096501111984, 0.042247969657182693, -0.09702571481466293, 0.02380969747900963, -0.06292302906513214, 0.005883633624762297, 0.05028093606233597, -0.010337748564779758, -0.023724889382719994, 0.03384695202112198, -0.04838988929986954, 0.03005886822938919, -0.025221489369869232, -0.06478210538625717, 0.050332896411418915, -0.025904456153512, -0.010515345260500908, 0.03711014613509178, -0.03296167030930519, -0.013070611283183098, -0.009192054159939289, -0.03230943903326988, 0.018915100023150444, 0.024007167667150497, 0.027501529082655907, 0.007686804514378309, -0.0024701873771846294, -0.03585053235292435, 0.02398899383842945, 0.023115474730730057, 0.015005256980657578, 0.05572895333170891, 0.031954411417245865, -0.034400444477796555, 0.06724423170089722, 0.041491590440273285, 0.04320201277732849, -0.0018907459452748299, 0.005734649021178484, 0.0027702676597982645, -0.05625389516353607, 0.053972240537405014, 0.020100200548768044, 0.002030803356319666, -0.028296800330281258, 0.0462530218064785, 0.03225209563970566, -0.04843210056424141, -0.0018531560199335217, 0.027467355132102966, -0.06918146461248398, 0.004958941601216793, -0.004108059220016003, -0.008614325895905495, -0.006092526018619537, 0.0718020647764206, 0.042644843459129333, 0.06083914637565613, 0.08067730069160461, 0.024669919162988663, -0.02507927082479, -0.0058953529223799706, 0.05835205316543579, 0.08041708171367645, 0.04707659035921097, -0.024041537195444107, 0.06889340281486511, -0.044713083654642105, -0.0525401346385479, 0.0646766796708107, 0.013067534193396568, 0.0022928882390260696, -0.06324847042560577, 0.01396916899830103, 0.08263426274061203, -0.031726300716400146, 0.06355778127908707, -0.026534389704465866, -0.002937368582934141, 0.051067862659692764, -0.026915082708001137, -0.020740751177072525, 0.051734574139118195, -0.001279749907553196, 0.0014284818898886442, -0.008835060521960258, -0.05219089984893799, 0.03118685446679592, -0.042875003069639206, 0.0007323470199480653, 0.008404826745390892, -0.000520404486451298, -0.01830948330461979, 0.01648777537047863, 0.05393999069929123, 0.09245799481868744, -0.05744710937142372, -0.013463028706610203, -0.0028014839626848698, 0.03187304735183716, 0.007187871728092432, 0.028796160593628883, 0.043057046830654144, -0.006160982418805361, 0.032110221683979034, -0.0067919958382844925, -0.000573467172216624, 0.02365962415933609, -0.023637233301997185, 0.036349136382341385, -0.04457782208919525, -0.05247780680656433, 0.04045092314481735, -0.028942329809069633, -0.020243629813194275, -0.05588775500655174, -0.012596157379448414, -0.060131873935461044, -0.04823967441916466, -0.0820409432053566, 0.022820884361863136, -0.025927841663360596, -0.03227244317531586, 0.01103740744292736, -0.030357519164681435, 0.0006820355774834752, 0.008204994723200798, -0.03766753152012825, -0.027640389278531075, 0.02695990540087223, 0.016921985894441605, 0.004247176460921764, 0.05108926445245743, 0.021896418184041977, 0.02471107989549637, -0.019711146131157875, 0.024712057784199715, -0.0019543657545000315, -0.004833477083593607, -0.0030235182493925095, -0.02869877591729164, -0.08534438163042068, -0.0009642086806707084, 0.038678865879774094, -0.020804718136787415, -0.06200304999947548, 0.04023734852671623, -0.06213225796818733, 0.009107193909585476, 0.0713847205042839, -0.0014307033270597458, 0.01859026588499546, -0.020046137273311615, 0.005885825492441654, 0.01883689872920513, 0.015236863866448402, 0.0396784208714962, -0.05152580142021179, 0.059154484421014786, 0.0446256585419178, -0.02316184900701046, -0.055047791451215744, 0.047520313411951065, 0.023653648793697357, -0.017831183969974518, -0.0006230503204278648, -0.030311010777950287, -0.022826509550213814, -0.08276820927858353, -0.012046188116073608, 0.04635531082749367, -0.024712081998586655, -0.03171565756201744, -0.0010036327876150608, -0.0015792791964486241, -0.02887837588787079, -0.014548096805810928, -0.031879451125860214, -0.013020249083638191, -0.050442419946193695, -0.03280090540647507, -0.07579556852579117, 0.02490062080323696, -0.005401288624852896, 0.02257131226360798, -0.03777651861310005, -0.05419979244470596, 0.025493590161204338, -0.016619732603430748, 0.04017522558569908, 0.0058688875287771225, 0.006889867130666971, -0.02419191040098667 ]
3,551
Linear Mode Connectivity in Differentiable Tree Ensembles
https://openreview.net/forum?id=UqYNPyotxL
[ "Ryuichi Kanoh", "Mahito Sugiyama" ]
Spotlight
Linear Mode Connectivity (LMC) refers to the phenomenon that performance remains consistent for linearly interpolated models in the parameter space. For independently optimized model pairs from different random initializations, achieving LMC is considered crucial for understanding the stable success of the non-convex optimization in modern machine learning models and for facilitating practical parameter-based operations such as model merging. While LMC has been achieved for neural networks by considering the permutation invariance of neurons in each hidden layer, its attainment for other models remains an open question. In this paper, we first achieve LMC for soft tree ensembles, which are tree-based differentiable models extensively used in practice. We show the necessity of incorporating two invariances: subtree flip invariance and splitting order invariance, which do not exist in neural networks but are inherent to tree architectures, in addition to permutation invariance of trees. Moreover, we demonstrate that it is even possible to exclude such additional invariances while keeping LMC by designing decision list-based tree architectures, where such invariances do not exist by definition. Our findings indicate the significance of accounting for architecture-specific invariances in achieving LMC.
Linear Mode Connectivity, Soft Tree
Considering additional invariances beyond tree permutation, we achieve linear mode connectivity for tree ensembles.
5,345
2405.14596
[ -0.02578502893447876, 0.007002724800258875, -0.013852491974830627, 0.02881844900548458, 0.049514200538396835, 0.031172309070825577, 0.05126768723130226, 0.0035518452059477568, -0.0350288450717926, -0.02837293967604637, -0.008436976931989193, -0.019854050129652023, -0.07517042756080627, -0.01579567976295948, -0.0054825409315526485, 0.07321824878454208, 0.0267803855240345, -0.01577683538198471, 0.0016944047529250383, 0.03395060822367668, -0.026223760098218918, -0.019144825637340546, 0.02148212492465973, 0.02157486043870449, 0.03862182796001434, -0.026958247646689415, 0.004505560267716646, -0.014490555971860886, -0.01766340434551239, -0.0026113770436495543, 0.03668191283941269, 0.022572899237275124, 0.008314312435686588, -0.00912609975785017, 0.02252487652003765, 0.029735203832387924, -0.04728126525878906, -0.014438462443649769, 0.00851928535848856, -0.00004414280556375161, -0.019753919914364815, -0.0012961199972778559, -0.007833115756511688, 0.013352839276194572, -0.05736706405878067, 0.028430895879864693, -0.11150342971086502, 0.022581398487091064, 0.027878355234861374, -0.012532967142760754, -0.1099885031580925, 0.05419164150953293, -0.031662069261074066, 0.0043183667585253716, 0.02199597656726837, 0.04684288427233696, 0.02695942483842373, -0.055087149143218994, -0.016527516767382622, -0.045842722058296204, -0.0344696119427681, 0.008350091986358166, 0.01763572171330452, -0.011146695353090763, -0.006421506404876709, -0.016532471403479576, 0.017897410318255424, 0.05091962218284607, -0.06214992329478264, -0.03042823262512684, -0.04285664111375809, 0.009783666580915451, 0.008311699144542217, 0.0018869005143642426, -0.015940861776471138, -0.0612499825656414, -0.010052033700048923, -0.007006862200796604, 0.09380656480789185, 0.02056189812719822, 0.021196648478507996, 0.01253094244748354, 0.010606294497847557, 0.04573061689734459, -0.013439745642244816, -0.008037780411541462, -0.034343235194683075, -0.05008365958929062, -0.08889555931091309, 0.0650453120470047, -0.03224711865186691, -0.03864414617419243, 0.03084474615752697, 0.02315778099000454, 0.026958493515849113, -0.018700776621699333, 0.01908697932958603, 0.04050188139081001, 0.011383183300495148, -0.011420986615121365, 0.010544627904891968, -0.03097190149128437, -0.006842150818556547, -0.020172912627458572, -0.11488504707813263, -0.03672989457845688, -0.035857561975717545, -0.01904281973838806, -0.011473104357719421, 0.015037150122225285, -0.08202516287565231, -0.01626872830092907, 0.017654040828347206, -0.009279688820242882, -0.10699734091758728, 0.03373212367296219, -0.011672754772007465, 0.006725703366100788, -0.0021635303273797035, -0.01982373371720314, 0.04820043966174126, 0.07789677381515503, -0.012411405332386494, 0.06382057815790176, -0.010319861583411694, 0.0036984081380069256, 0.010234229266643524, 0.03281443566083908, -0.04005301371216774, -0.02973313070833683, 0.00722362520173192, 0.03283938765525818, -0.02471468597650528, -0.024324627593159676, 0.007330228108912706, -0.02705160342156887, -0.003684218507260084, 0.05747663229703903, 0.011466419324278831, 0.0038953672628849745, -0.0098859379068017, -0.04740418493747711, 0.04501586779952049, -0.013504235073924065, 0.059378352016210556, -0.023970257490873337, -0.02425258234143257, -0.017627429217100143, -0.03907564654946327, -0.008352250792086124, 0.016759471967816353, -0.0034447310026735067, -0.023097779601812363, -0.0883009135723114, 0.034716490656137466, 0.052119940519332886, 0.02042054571211338, 0.04156732186675072, -0.0004827716329600662, -0.002286706818267703, 0.04248885437846184, -0.014975355006754398, 0.001379686058498919, 0.03002120554447174, 0.0006712924223393202, -0.0698540136218071, 0.04749531298875809, 0.015885354951024055, -0.014805089682340622, 0.017717625945806503, -0.040266335010528564, -0.044860050082206726, 0.051920000463724136, 0.002728925319388509, -0.03668694570660591, -0.007755247410386801, 0.05440826714038849, 0.01422780379652977, 0.04343215376138687, 0.017168935388326645, -0.07434318959712982, 0.02792377583682537, -0.025577183812856674, -0.004878590814769268, 0.003412555903196335, -0.01397312618792057, 0.10078684240579605, -0.05167902261018753, 0.005998163018375635, -0.008065581321716309, -0.03573596850037575, -0.0008823765674605966, 0.038478996604681015, -0.015666412189602852, 0.08861079812049866, 0.014611121267080307, 0.006092106457799673, 0.020121676847338676, 0.0174859631806612, 0.030604375526309013, 0.08093138039112091, -0.037897929549217224, 0.02535131201148033, -0.0031072755809873343, -0.02686350792646408, -0.006082168780267239, 0.06306125223636627, -0.03134222701191902, -0.0003613152075558901, 0.005358874797821045, -0.00878729298710823, -0.010848446749150753, 0.0026449807919561863, 0.013525588437914848, 0.040889717638492584, 0.012580681592226028, -0.039557941257953644, 0.00392206571996212, 0.03492659702897072, -0.044846177101135254, 0.021297473460435867, 0.008494699373841286, -0.021654678508639336, 0.01723780296742916, -0.010975459590554237, 0.08144218474626541, 0.09531933814287186, -0.03124723955988884, 0.00902422983199358, 0.021131481975317, 0.0067124273627996445, 0.013697166927158833, 0.013137240894138813, 0.00494571216404438, 0.020198646932840347, -0.01572180539369583, -0.025156889110803604, -0.04733700677752495, 0.06230784207582474, -0.042241305112838745, -0.021129850298166275, 0.07659079134464264, -0.03357072174549103, 0.03325378894805908, -0.01770097017288208, 0.006614879239350557, 0.02800871804356575, -0.02755819261074066, -0.02338997833430767, -0.012749860994517803, -0.02302178367972374, -0.0028941824566572905, 0.028288137167692184, -0.017450325191020966, 0.029218830168247223, -0.05014074593782425, -0.01641193963587284, -0.022682350128889084, 0.07372312992811203, 0.04967402294278145, 0.007992750033736229, 0.03392038121819496, 0.00604621134698391, -0.014594143256545067, -0.029164807870984077, -0.10710133612155914, -0.03643769025802612, 0.000753721222281456, 0.055291786789894104, 0.010447029024362564, 0.043890874832868576, -0.013340228237211704, 0.06237901747226715, -0.002861335873603821, -0.015587874688208103, 0.009394337423145771, 0.004269972909241915, 0.01827266253530979, -0.046507153660058975, -0.035343192517757416, -0.006973753217607737, 0.04379278048872948, 0.01821860857307911, -0.037317726761102676, -0.037965089082717896, -0.03730432316660881, -0.017608363181352615, -0.019980531185865402, 0.025838837027549744, -0.007828108966350555, 0.022873658686876297, 0.002890401752665639, -0.019190626218914986, 0.017613114789128304, 0.016826584935188293, 0.07978986948728561, 0.046388108283281326, 0.026272853836417198, -0.008850992657244205, 0.0058478377759456635, -0.008998009376227856, 0.01680830493569374, 0.015234951861202717, -0.02637932263314724, -0.0269450880587101, 0.014445824548602104, 0.015731966122984886, 0.01467220950871706, -0.28319382667541504, -0.005554446950554848, 0.03597699850797653, -0.037110500037670135, 0.009828060865402222, -0.0018153763376176357, 0.0018636988243088126, -0.04191328585147858, -0.013959781266748905, 0.01476659532636404, 0.00907039362937212, 0.027459001168608665, -0.019297625869512558, 0.03173776715993881, 0.04126579686999321, -0.026964811608195305, -0.007731729187071323, -0.02108139917254448, 0.024426748976111412, 0.04346303269267082, -0.020632309839129448, -0.06273581087589264, -0.01894332841038704, -0.02125495858490467, -0.02756296657025814, 0.024143565446138382, -0.06597103178501129, 0.02691039815545082, -0.03053021803498268, -0.008985447697341442, -0.05534793809056282, -0.024814637377858162, -0.013213551603257656, 0.04512434080243111, -0.0024067440535873175, -0.006168304942548275, 0.010923657566308975, 0.012667221017181873, -0.0013170094462111592, 0.01827317476272583, 0.004715981427580118, -0.0155764389783144, -0.018197262659668922, -0.0013688317267224193, 0.04842296242713928, 0.008626719936728477, -0.04572330042719841, -0.015558098442852497, -0.0030706243123859167, 0.03590599074959755, 0.0061731645837426186, -0.032618045806884766, -0.0003748788731172681, -0.0046983566135168076, -0.01608707383275032, -0.040578506886959076, 0.005070755258202553, -0.010002810508012772, 0.013229808770120144, 0.03328743577003479, 0.006870546843856573, -0.06342393159866333, -0.008601723238825798, -0.03475327044725418, -0.02885867841541767, 0.00574789522215724, -0.07614599168300629, -0.04774513468146324, 0.05256712809205055, 0.033225368708372116, 0.02046738564968109, 0.020165272057056427, -0.046348292380571365, -0.09430839866399765, 0.015416888520121574, 0.015920113772153854, -0.010470118373632431, -0.03078605607151985, -0.005385476164519787, 0.04226350039243698, -0.01826155185699463, -0.03618825599551201, -0.009719322435557842, 0.028459781780838966, 0.0038234542589634657, -0.01789584383368492, -0.00024887494510039687, -0.01845763437449932, -0.00965680181980133, -0.043441157788038254, 0.008776466362178326, 0.014065957628190517, 0.06290192902088165, 0.001972577767446637, 0.02470294199883938, 0.024589363485574722, 0.02803380787372589, 0.02673557959496975, 0.04778865724802017, -0.01509071234613657, 0.026804590597748756, -0.0611443892121315, -0.022549394518136978, -0.00491518247872591, -0.03905383124947548, 0.00995623879134655, -0.06112537533044815, -0.033522311598062515, 0.021769752725958824, 0.04951142147183418, -0.011780870147049427, -0.045909348875284195, 0.013446138240396976, -0.03682180494070053, -0.009110511280596256, -0.017640935257077217, 0.007990892976522446, 0.0438801534473896, 0.02087266556918621, -0.032100167125463486, -0.039884161204099655, 0.03286068141460419, -0.023504558950662613, 0.0029995893128216267, 0.02139199897646904, 0.012317519634962082, -0.020445968955755234, -0.027114247903227806, -0.048280563205480576, -0.001059376634657383, 0.022497765719890594, 0.035594161599874496, 0.051243238151073456, 0.025589101016521454, 0.03334716707468033, -0.0056627108715474606, 0.006704549305140972, 0.018608005717396736, 0.03602876514196396, -0.028833892196416855, 0.027137333527207375, 0.009729091078042984, 0.03150152042508125, 0.035694774240255356, -0.015029283240437508, 0.04197307676076889, 0.006569331511855125, -0.0016378695145249367, -0.005138641223311424, -0.02357563190162182, 0.017503412440419197, -0.04883439466357231, -0.03828129917383194, -0.016010629013180733, -0.004962215665727854, 0.0014847149141132832, 0.040679335594177246, -0.0045570251531898975, 0.006267107091844082, -0.0604354552924633, 0.07724342495203018, 0.025068212300539017, 0.0010449447436258197, -0.019978763535618782, 0.013711230829358101, 0.07472071796655655, -0.044847842305898666, 0.015613362193107605, 0.016345545649528503, 0.0014587374171242118, 0.014137239195406437, -0.03825366497039795, -0.02256818115711212, -0.013917670585215092, -0.026360895484685898, 0.007188421208411455, 0.0019447279628366232, -0.021176720038056374, -0.04483175650238991, 0.03812246397137642, 0.0036586367059499025, -0.012365687638521194, -0.03242391720414162, 0.0011736741289496422, 0.08315640687942505, -0.015553699806332588, -0.01804526336491108, 0.00860285758972168, -0.026060711592435837, 0.05690735951066017, 0.006919390521943569, 0.001886756275780499, -0.039517417550086975, -0.02571578323841095, -0.025829380378127098, -0.014469250105321407, 0.005946019664406776, 0.023607665672898293, -0.0019188204314559698, -0.010261728428304195, -0.030703457072377205, 0.0013696071691811085, -0.02714751474559307, 0.012787877582013607, 0.03687899559736252, -0.07307904958724976, 0.002905735746026039, 0.03293774649500847, -0.04852920025587082, 0.029238514602184296, -0.018424592912197113, -0.04069375619292259, -0.021892176941037178, -0.0064809611067175865, 0.024688728153705597, -0.020722201094031334, -0.028104621917009354, 0.01823374070227146, -0.009587019681930542, 0.002592676319181919, 0.011315315961837769, -0.026140956208109856, 0.013222366571426392, -0.044078558683395386, 0.014013300649821758, 0.07757925987243652, -0.0048903110437095165, 0.012545340694487095, 0.003901084652170539, 0.0003534661664161831, 0.021360276266932487, -0.09758318215608597, 0.006703922990709543, 0.05200029909610748, -0.010686417110264301, 0.004773222841322422, -0.0543513298034668, 0.05350036174058914, -0.015862060710787773, -0.009491638280451298, 0.003114479361101985, 0.030350621789693832, -0.04688125103712082, -0.0028658390510827303, 0.015164378099143505, 0.04574883356690407, 0.03352182358503342, 0.006765487603843212, -0.006800611037760973, -0.01439175009727478, -0.008949230425059795, 0.033584095537662506, -0.03116627410054207, 0.011384973302483559, 0.08150014281272888, -0.012131798081099987, -0.048057109117507935, -0.07762917131185532, -0.01984734646975994, 0.007271900773048401, -0.020633844658732414, 0.03904501721262932, 0.00040177200571633875, 0.04751788079738617, 0.04133287072181702, 0.04545636847615242, -0.02356957644224167, -0.015823455527424812, 0.02699161507189274, -0.07038330286741257, 0.02866084687411785, -0.04425501450896263, -0.021311482414603233, 0.041046541184186935, -0.05303957685828209, -0.0011437709908932447, 0.0009992393897846341, -0.04931996017694473, 0.03007894568145275, -0.015868613496422768, -0.06263472139835358, -0.01741463877260685, -0.03061085380613804, -0.00359361176379025, 0.041431866586208344, -0.02238098718225956, -0.004583458416163921, -0.030114129185676575, -0.023627933114767075, -0.0028401550371199846, -0.00328532001003623, 0.05044175311923027, -0.0030441638082265854, 0.040624964982271194, -0.0036319452337920666, 0.03515764698386192, 0.01920406147837639, 0.08041633665561676, 0.03608432784676552, 0.007338277529925108, -0.05163079500198364, 0.08164569735527039, 0.0469718761742115, 0.024139754474163055, -0.003799098776653409, 0.01367162074893713, 0.0006218092748895288, -0.09679734706878662, 0.03556646779179573, 0.006170562468469143, 0.004373454488813877, -0.06048557907342911, 0.027443431317806244, 0.04506024718284607, -0.04602864012122154, -0.025229066610336304, 0.044752337038517, -0.04271527752280235, 0.039615001529455185, 0.017111148685216904, 0.0210997574031353, -0.012696711346507072, 0.0587407611310482, -0.006055224686861038, 0.035234224051237106, 0.07352093607187271, 0.0046593607403337955, -0.03155029937624931, 0.01086369901895523, 0.07528071850538254, 0.07335226982831955, 0.01851622946560383, 0.031884871423244476, 0.08717865496873856, -0.026552854105830193, -0.05904967337846756, 0.004621683619916439, 0.02346990816295147, -0.01040466595441103, -0.04667268693447113, 0.050672803074121475, 0.0761185735464096, 0.013796193525195122, 0.08400090038776398, -0.04713109880685806, 0.010099058970808983, 0.02243066020309925, 0.002022436587139964, -0.019577400758862495, 0.02195650339126587, 0.025591103360056877, 0.029045026749372482, 0.0001038119153236039, -0.020870391279459, -0.0071159121580421925, -0.0002930912305600941, 0.006064301822334528, 0.0287201888859272, -0.012068587355315685, -0.004273312631994486, 0.019865676760673523, 0.05282709002494812, 0.10141877830028534, -0.03641963005065918, -0.04254559054970741, -0.038955118507146835, 0.043193455785512924, 0.006819562055170536, 0.02177806757390499, 0.012226046063005924, -0.03113635629415512, 0.002195816719904542, -0.03265488147735596, 0.047794364392757416, 0.01154291070997715, 0.008773350156843662, -0.021490393206477165, 0.0033554292749613523, -0.009455034509301186, 0.027914362028241158, 0.03873410448431969, -0.011240527965128422, -0.037450771778821945, -0.02205575816333294, -0.06648258864879608, -0.053747039288282394, -0.05520643666386604, 0.014927230775356293, 0.016972428187727928, -0.02644110471010208, -0.024516703560948372, -0.030530842021107674, 0.024249769747257233, 0.022284897044301033, -0.04342389106750488, 0.00623813271522522, 0.01739189587533474, 0.010037259198725224, 0.01242911722511053, 0.040224019438028336, 0.021973691880702972, -0.016366712749004364, -0.04287392273545265, 0.05319381505250931, 0.008341367356479168, 0.033866457641124725, -0.016929203644394875, -0.010594209656119347, -0.0652260109782219, 0.00892240647226572, 0.024694589897990227, -0.02420334331691265, -0.08712569624185562, 0.03881308063864708, -0.02769988588988781, 0.0018693114398047328, 0.03694812208414078, -0.03577353060245514, 0.009970691055059433, -0.022356871515512466, -0.023589232936501503, -0.011801215820014477, 0.0013059445191174746, 0.03112627938389778, -0.027576135471463203, 0.06094139814376831, 0.03758525848388672, 0.003020662348717451, -0.04162679240107536, 0.03429621830582619, -0.0016123329987749457, 0.0059639038518071175, -0.013834706507623196, -0.04848591983318329, -0.012014186009764671, -0.11098513007164001, -0.0055205123499035835, 0.026721883565187454, 0.017323002219200134, -0.04071763530373573, -0.01899043284356594, -0.012952840887010098, -0.030043145641684532, -0.02822953276336193, -0.0022646442521363497, -0.041511114686727524, -0.029974190518260002, -0.024120895192027092, -0.06754927337169647, 0.013378310948610306, -0.029504070058465004, 0.03447568044066429, -0.044474635273218155, -0.050036992877721786, -0.01780274510383606, -0.005174683872610331, 0.004518680274486542, 0.024602407589554787, 0.018206939101219177, -0.009885593317449093 ]
3,552
Overcoming False Illusions in Real-World Face Restoration with Multi-Modal Guided Diffusion Model
https://openreview.net/forum?id=m9RNBZewW2
[ "Keda TAO", "Jinjin Gu", "Yulun Zhang", "Xiucheng Wang", "Nan Cheng" ]
Spotlight
We introduce a novel Multi-modal Guided Real-World Face Restoration (MGFR) technique designed to improve the quality of facial image restoration from low-quality inputs. Leveraging a blend of attribute text prompts, high-quality reference images, and identity information, MGFR can mitigate the generation of false facial attributes and identities often associated with generative face restoration methods. By incorporating a dual-control adapter and a two-stage training strategy, our method effectively utilizes multi-modal prior information for targeted restoration tasks. We also present the Reface-HQ dataset, comprising over 23,000 high-resolution facial images across 5,000 identities, to address the need for reference face training images. Our approach achieves superior visual quality in restoring facial details under severe degradation and allows for controlled restoration processes, enhancing the accuracy of identity preservation and attribute correction. Including negative quality samples and attribute prompts in the training further refines the model's ability to generate detailed and perceptually accurate images.
Face image restoration, diffusion model
null
5,312
2410.04161
[ -0.0192941315472126, -0.010522374883294106, 0.0065384539775550365, 0.05033661052584648, 0.05668599158525467, 0.03451120853424072, 0.042585067451000214, 0.01161776203662157, -0.023839330300688744, -0.07430177181959152, -0.008745577186346054, 0.0445689931511879, -0.042936526238918304, -0.012540921568870544, -0.023930370807647705, 0.012412930838763714, 0.031011631712317467, 0.004878327250480652, -0.006208007223904133, 0.0709315612912178, -0.01645662449300289, -0.040091339498758316, 0.03553365170955658, 0.0369982086122036, 0.017306193709373474, 0.0010130566079169512, 0.03634556010365486, 0.010075977072119713, -0.014573929831385612, 0.018077529966831207, 0.02108021453022957, -0.010015168227255344, -0.027649464085698128, -0.037356480956077576, 0.014364727772772312, -0.016462378203868866, -0.03363979235291481, 0.015934890136122704, 0.01874621957540512, 0.03480900079011917, -0.05131392553448677, 0.014208969660103321, -0.02214091829955578, -0.000055974291171878576, -0.05424914136528969, -0.017726948484778404, -0.09382721781730652, 0.02730616182088852, 0.029896367341279984, -0.019751550629734993, -0.07522814720869064, 0.019051600247621536, -0.0031966876704245806, 0.0029722044710069895, -0.002129616215825081, 0.03658390790224075, 0.019831763580441475, -0.056975673884153366, -0.03846373409032822, -0.03657916560769081, -0.025453874841332436, 0.0010539022041484714, -0.005918897222727537, -0.00047959116636775434, -0.020730912685394287, -0.012784445658326149, -0.009762883186340332, 0.036758553236722946, -0.030046209692955017, -0.027056163176894188, -0.0027491534128785133, -0.025367524474859238, 0.005158266518265009, -0.02582797221839428, -0.0000893665273906663, -0.02750946395099163, -0.007427444215863943, -0.01946576125919819, 0.0680304765701294, -0.005289439111948013, 0.03863131254911423, 0.0008714302093721926, 0.025610677897930145, 0.014491328969597816, 0.005907296668738127, 0.00419680355116725, 0.0016866963123902678, -0.014379022642970085, -0.028699783608317375, 0.04566815495491028, -0.06497493386268616, -0.04776068776845932, -0.004202699288725853, 0.015667889267206192, 0.04760025069117546, -0.017738455906510353, 0.0066428170539438725, -0.028069250285625458, 0.01395945530384779, 0.015235655941069126, 0.005356606561690569, -0.04035505652427673, -0.017589068040251732, 0.02200297638773918, -0.07620926946401596, 0.008621076121926308, -0.049329228699207306, 0.006099434569478035, -0.021414604038000107, 0.025573991239070892, -0.04901108145713806, 0.008163725957274437, 0.026622619479894638, -0.0110322842374444, -0.12256641685962677, 0.03494570031762123, 0.01015823520720005, -0.014668555930256844, -0.0073990835808217525, 0.013691549189388752, 0.07576753199100494, 0.054696884006261826, -0.0017210185760632157, 0.05808843672275543, -0.002520169597119093, 0.01856413297355175, 0.025027981027960777, 0.04269329085946083, -0.03991754725575447, -0.013995923101902008, -0.007780348416417837, 0.02616950124502182, 0.014017954468727112, -0.006175033748149872, 0.010858317837119102, -0.031043438240885735, 0.016492396593093872, -0.020055970177054405, 0.041490714997053146, -0.0399889312684536, 0.02081010676920414, -0.02656143717467785, 0.003596344031393528, -0.021046331152319908, 0.08517316728830338, -0.02759268693625927, 0.011144903488457203, -0.02776223048567772, -0.016702188178896904, 0.004757300950586796, 0.023340541869401932, -0.001104458118788898, 0.050099439918994904, -0.0609620101749897, 0.007010749541223049, 0.06407883018255234, 0.01780547760426998, -0.016822384670376778, -0.005589010659605265, -0.028477787971496582, 0.04563345015048981, -0.008227868005633354, -0.016971025615930557, 0.01327438373118639, 0.01797555200755596, -0.03656930848956108, -0.004974297247827053, 0.017179522663354874, -0.026227792724967003, -0.012416228652000427, -0.04500414803624153, -0.013940254226326942, 0.01108828466385603, 0.0034327355679124594, -0.01251467876136303, 0.024615447968244553, 0.052066296339035034, 0.029318207874894142, 0.010908150114119053, 0.025463933125138283, -0.08943148702383041, 0.018897561356425285, 0.025305792689323425, -0.007088826969265938, 0.03398619219660759, -0.02958894893527031, 0.07115089148283005, -0.01049083098769188, 0.005143174901604652, 0.05741029232740402, -0.0968213602900505, 0.025000764057040215, 0.04450277239084244, -0.024274269118905067, 0.07527801394462585, 0.07541396468877792, -0.04574699327349663, 0.015483611263334751, 0.04476061090826988, 0.05680233985185623, 0.036346785724163055, -0.07170930504798889, 0.05270737409591675, -0.025020254775881767, -0.026386579498648643, -0.03829542174935341, 0.04095128923654556, -0.03076268546283245, -0.012787916697561741, 0.029824504628777504, -0.025555551052093506, 0.005355823319405317, -0.00904447678476572, 0.012652184814214706, 0.01893344335258007, 0.015085084363818169, -0.033363550901412964, -0.005196969024837017, 0.012143688276410103, -0.041358210146427155, 0.060757827013731, 0.043322909623384476, -0.036583468317985535, 0.009124449454247952, -0.05041825771331787, 0.09081265330314636, 0.06903760880231857, -0.07015222311019897, -0.010918362997472286, -0.000735730747692287, 0.006840862799435854, 0.010407853871583939, 0.026110505685210228, -0.029000049456954002, 0.03377772867679596, -0.0391482338309288, 0.034083642065525055, -0.013464178889989853, 0.07767372578382492, -0.06002538651227951, -0.026809753850102425, 0.06107635423541069, 0.009797321632504463, 0.03729522228240967, 0.017261402681469917, 0.032049842178821564, 0.04077724367380142, 0.023056436330080032, -0.012760771438479424, -0.017943015322089195, 0.004700005054473877, 0.013550849631428719, 0.01281178928911686, -0.03354489803314209, 0.028505893424153328, -0.04965328797698021, 0.017944689840078354, -0.029433520510792732, 0.03555701673030853, 0.07201650738716125, 0.0075467852875590324, 0.02863786183297634, -0.0381871722638607, -0.019217360764741898, -0.06540022790431976, -0.09113799780607224, 0.015997998416423798, -0.009676538407802582, 0.04245627671480179, 0.001210369635373354, 0.04135572537779808, -0.018492238596081734, -0.024626601487398148, -0.022501176223158836, 0.006989107467234135, 0.009388108737766743, 0.04231620579957962, 0.03223006799817085, -0.006926270201802254, 0.04500391334295273, -0.013040179386734962, 0.0917845368385315, -0.019783129915595055, -0.006592833437025547, -0.0560038760304451, -0.030933765694499016, -0.02362985536456108, 0.01658845879137516, -0.021182768046855927, 0.007106191944330931, -0.011849721893668175, 0.019562631845474243, 0.019013114273548126, 0.010430657304823399, 0.01871945895254612, 0.02457769401371479, 0.011595501564443111, 0.035795893520116806, -0.0352463535964489, 0.03142378106713295, 0.022629523649811745, 0.0021206492092460394, 0.006841539870947599, -0.023645032197237015, -0.00809431355446577, 0.016070127487182617, 0.032793015241622925, -0.009877822361886501, -0.26773524284362793, 0.0011927501764148474, 0.03052162192761898, -0.022797739133238792, 0.014609914273023605, -0.052486252039670944, 0.053978536278009415, -0.038667816668748856, -0.05132737755775452, 0.012278405949473381, 0.0017758639296516776, 0.035392601042985916, -0.0013551111333072186, 0.08897247165441513, 0.02424740418791771, 0.01950502023100853, 0.018311263993382454, -0.02689250186085701, 0.0020416313782334328, 0.05049968510866165, -0.004245874471962452, -0.04980184882879257, -0.0531226322054863, 0.029082227498292923, -0.026308393105864525, 0.017703035846352577, -0.047046959400177, -0.02499433606863022, -0.01860900968313217, 0.0028430852107703686, 0.002463800832629204, -0.02473088912665844, 0.00400380278006196, 0.06361003965139389, 0.008346451446413994, -0.02589980699121952, 0.035695381462574005, -0.004522837698459625, 0.023042690008878708, -0.05046616867184639, -0.006004421040415764, 0.0028721163980662823, -0.021360017359256744, 0.03902382403612137, 0.06627237796783447, 0.009344806894659996, -0.04881823807954788, 0.014625690877437592, -0.017112864181399345, 0.03706000745296478, 0.008132449351251125, -0.014833739958703518, -0.031230013817548752, 0.007217679638415575, -0.012045258656144142, 0.009386049583554268, 0.018894635140895844, 0.00232296553440392, -0.030876493081450462, 0.0002342983934795484, -0.031003326177597046, -0.031595245003700256, -0.020748497918248177, -0.0159128550440073, 0.003529419656842947, -0.05392293259501457, -0.0850311890244484, -0.08425945788621902, 0.06142023950815201, 0.021385904401540756, -0.029945891350507736, 0.010202676989138126, -0.016760356724262238, -0.10683880746364594, 0.036060500890016556, 0.0010705216554924846, -0.047184549272060394, -0.01572033204138279, -0.03799975663423538, 0.012571240775287151, -0.002689403248950839, -0.042161356657743454, 0.014695145189762115, 0.011605659499764442, 0.0020927083678543568, 0.014460683800280094, 0.05130448937416077, -0.003364205826073885, 0.0037398640997707844, -0.030924633145332336, 0.0923447385430336, -0.009857086464762688, -0.0016923502553254366, -0.00023048203729558736, 0.031087007373571396, 0.04611190780997276, 0.03383985906839371, 0.04724632948637009, 0.03656426817178726, 0.0003295412752777338, 0.016671549528837204, -0.07751723378896713, -0.018075373023748398, -0.04227081686258316, -0.041078001260757446, 0.01738862320780754, -0.05274951085448265, -0.03425253555178642, 0.055035848170518875, 0.003429053584113717, -0.03526536002755165, 0.039816781878471375, 0.030481355264782906, 0.008561726659536362, -0.01400995347648859, -0.01929020695388317, 0.0005956928944215178, 0.00511963153257966, 0.05717577040195465, 0.0030814444180577993, 0.02047569677233696, 0.023691223934292793, -0.03658371791243553, 0.00960512738674879, -0.01391304936259985, -0.025898342952132225, -0.007981198839843273, 0.0027939341962337494, -0.006415701936930418, -0.00041147079900838435, 0.06119348481297493, 0.03110593743622303, 0.024052534252405167, 0.029112359508872032, 0.07521560788154602, 0.015968479216098785, -0.01663803867995739, -0.015010271221399307, 0.06621485948562622, -0.014192531816661358, 0.08236970752477646, -0.011324562132358551, 0.030777668580412865, 0.0251346193253994, 0.047460611909627914, -0.021384472027420998, -0.008895333856344223, 0.016381163150072098, -0.013532249256968498, 0.00857282429933548, 0.02266048640012741, -0.04496176540851593, -0.07622915506362915, -0.0004347258945927024, -0.02217891812324524, -0.0015291445888578892, 0.016876695677638054, -0.030505450442433357, 0.036835748702287674, -0.06338226795196533, 0.045838095247745514, 0.038128986954689026, -0.02248264290392399, 0.0019046657253056765, -0.010740888305008411, 0.01706348918378353, 0.03144174441695213, -0.02258085273206234, 0.020140627399086952, 0.021426768973469734, 0.027416208758950233, -0.010095587000250816, -0.03964493051171303, -0.05020060017704964, 0.007926031947135925, 0.028472812846302986, 0.01889878138899803, -0.05044868588447571, -0.033812399953603745, 0.05848665162920952, -0.005718281026929617, -0.05815570428967476, 0.015542641282081604, 0.006554716732352972, 0.04680544510483742, -0.0026197852566838264, -0.016950156539678574, -0.04235939309000969, -0.02500665746629238, -0.003557290183380246, -0.01500154659152031, 0.011909815482795238, -0.037429917603731155, -0.03657158091664314, -0.04584694653749466, -0.061212148517370224, -0.021028926596045494, 0.03864177316427231, 0.004925965331494808, 0.017587503418326378, -0.0318702831864357, 0.01703706942498684, -0.024311667308211327, -0.0016745111206546426, 0.012953287921845913, -0.058794524520635605, 0.004497359041124582, 0.03467775881290436, -0.06385450065135956, 0.029775790870189667, -0.004787227138876915, -0.02165338769555092, -0.06647159159183502, -0.022511836141347885, -0.00581367826089263, -0.053549375385046005, -0.021758684888482094, -0.024362903088331223, 0.002075339201837778, 0.02038942091166973, 0.005200394429266453, -0.004961223807185888, -0.031263552606105804, -0.00100554502569139, -0.01312803290784359, 0.024646155536174774, 0.000898393802344799, 0.00389791838824749, 0.014063788577914238, -0.01972152478992939, 0.013028611429035664, -0.03064100444316864, -0.0021378817036747932, 0.04754330590367317, 0.015032351948320866, 0.003037754911929369, -0.031148582696914673, 0.030311882495880127, 0.007630861829966307, 0.002236216329038143, 0.012410340830683708, 0.0010274602100253105, -0.03486169874668121, -0.0009360303520224988, 0.002901124069467187, 0.015684934332966805, -0.027343235909938812, -0.0012664421228691936, -0.008116994053125381, 0.047861963510513306, -0.011032750830054283, -0.00516450684517622, -0.02599668875336647, 0.02437225915491581, 0.02180762030184269, -0.04228243604302406, -0.010224263183772564, -0.06585158407688141, -0.026438994333148003, 0.035150106996297836, 0.022712647914886475, 0.034781455993652344, -0.016533339396119118, -0.008950606919825077, 0.050801899284124374, 0.00532539514824748, -0.03857121244072914, 0.0030942445155233145, 0.037946444004774094, -0.04014608636498451, 0.032704222947359085, -0.04956592991948128, 0.020358826965093613, 0.04969661682844162, -0.037030138075351715, 0.001995624043047428, -0.023184053599834442, -0.013548126444220543, 0.023155231028795242, -0.036487411707639694, -0.05925067514181137, -0.015218398533761501, -0.02584679052233696, -0.028431886807084084, 0.0089543666690588, -0.03418398275971413, 0.006642636843025684, -0.038614027202129364, -0.06211894378066063, -0.0009654564200900495, 0.016616646200418472, 0.040756240487098694, -0.03457505255937576, 0.03329578414559364, -0.0317048579454422, 0.026705734431743622, -0.005275014787912369, 0.08554086834192276, -0.025987889617681503, 0.027785852551460266, 0.009344752877950668, 0.0823657214641571, 0.012665784917771816, 0.012999073602259159, 0.058660127222537994, 0.026131747290492058, 0.00796099379658699, -0.05142880603671074, 0.03899744153022766, 0.028171757236123085, -0.015267448499798775, -0.07148106396198273, 0.03878004476428032, 0.03084883652627468, -0.0506562702357769, -0.03450006991624832, 0.02864539623260498, -0.03055090270936489, 0.017644943669438362, -0.02078571729362011, 0.01897655986249447, 0.021614402532577515, 0.04736674204468727, -0.029249196872115135, 0.039820004254579544, 0.053902529180049896, 0.016049783676862717, 0.02075825072824955, -0.005505384411662817, 0.057326868176460266, 0.07357260584831238, 0.03024549037218094, -0.0002685065264813602, 0.07432761788368225, 0.015253691002726555, -0.04898161441087723, 0.029194679111242294, 0.029928788542747498, -0.02065705694258213, -0.053485315293073654, 0.0016395528800785542, 0.10052504390478134, -0.004583009984344244, 0.06776446104049683, -0.026243126019835472, 0.013437710702419281, -0.012368159368634224, 0.013145661912858486, 0.006986318621784449, -0.018436482176184654, 0.032874222844839096, -0.027661602944135666, -0.02405649982392788, 0.01265628356486559, -0.008779428899288177, -0.02926192618906498, 0.023270729929208755, 0.017518136650323868, -0.028501994907855988, 0.04355858638882637, -0.0006706722197122872, -0.0038515343330800533, 0.08180148899555206, -0.038437824696302414, -0.05394892767071724, 0.011393996886909008, -0.024221451953053474, 0.018811771646142006, 0.038953542709350586, 0.03726305812597275, -0.02865142561495304, 0.0007410745020024478, -0.013464653864502907, 0.010862342081964016, 0.02729659155011177, 0.013661127537488937, -0.002918036188930273, -0.06937823444604874, -0.027995998039841652, 0.04409129172563553, -0.026986291632056236, -0.05935915932059288, -0.044791027903556824, -0.05401831492781639, -0.059012722223997116, -0.04387422278523445, -0.032338544726371765, 0.022572986781597137, -0.012764837592840195, -0.0503479465842247, -0.019467711448669434, -0.002009390387684107, -0.002440126845613122, 0.05298242345452309, -0.07585929334163666, -0.044346269220113754, 0.06205178424715996, -0.035273730754852295, -0.03259522095322609, 0.009706140495836735, 0.013058691285550594, 0.0008433257462456822, -0.00964997336268425, 0.038591425865888596, -0.025395557284355164, 0.03382605314254761, -0.032297320663928986, -0.02060573548078537, -0.10043369978666306, -0.001530294306576252, 0.025277674198150635, -0.02246914803981781, -0.07404715567827225, 0.020974989980459213, -0.03773438557982445, 0.052755504846572876, 0.03295288607478142, 0.0032526629511266947, 0.00012611756392288953, -0.04188723489642143, 0.011674673296511173, -0.023292938247323036, 0.01044598687440157, 0.07909435778856277, -0.018265986815094948, 0.0939340591430664, 0.0325777567923069, -0.000922280945815146, -0.04267101734876633, 0.060333289206027985, 0.005394237581640482, 0.005780594423413277, -0.03756381943821907, -0.011584761552512646, -0.051808979362249374, -0.0945425033569336, -0.016342539340257645, 0.0028560273349285126, -0.008931982330977917, -0.022717799991369247, -0.0030293678864836693, -0.029832130298018456, 0.005298474337905645, 0.0005569913191720843, -0.017721258103847504, -0.020226063206791878, -0.04701714217662811, -0.045201729983091354, -0.06339287757873535, 0.0017808241536840796, 0.01759505830705166, 0.014918085187673569, 0.022493576630949974, -0.05004596337676048, -0.0012491777306422591, 0.012241252698004246, 0.025294199585914612, -0.015767540782690048, 0.006959161721169949, -0.018720675259828568 ]
3,553
DEEM: Diffusion models serve as the eyes of large language models for image perception
https://openreview.net/forum?id=qtWjSboqfe
[ "Run Luo", "Yunshui Li", "Longze Chen", "Wanwei He", "Ting-En Lin", "Ziqiang Liu", "Lei Zhang", "Zikai Song", "Hamid Rokny", "Xiaobo Xia", "Tongliang Liu", "Binyuan Hui", "Min Yang" ]
Spotlight
The development of large language models (LLMs) has significantly advanced the emergence of large multimodal models (LMMs). While LMMs have achieved tremendous success by promoting the synergy between multimodal comprehension and creation, they often face challenges when confronted with out-of-distribution data, such as which can hardly distinguish orientation, quantity, color, structure, etc. This is primarily due to their reliance on image encoders trained to encode images into task-relevant features, which may lead them to disregard irrelevant details. Delving into the modeling capabilities of diffusion models for images naturally prompts the question: Can diffusion models serve as the eyes of large language models for image perception? In this paper, we propose DEEM, a simple but effective approach that utilizes the generative feedback of diffusion models to align the semantic distributions of the image encoder. This addresses the drawbacks of previous methods that solely relied on image encoders like CLIP-ViT, thereby enhancing the model's resilience against out-of-distribution samples and reducing visual hallucinations. Importantly, this is achieved without requiring additional training modules and with fewer training parameters. We extensively evaluated DEEM on both our newly constructed RobustVQA benchmark and other well-known benchmarks, POPE and MMVP, for visual hallucination and perception. In particular, DEEM improves LMM's visual perception performance to a large extent (e.g., 4\% ↑ on RobustVQA, 6.5\% ↑ on MMVP and 12.8 \% ↑ on POPE ). Compared to the state-of-the-art interleaved content generation models, DEEM exhibits enhanced robustness and a superior capacity to alleviate model hallucinations while utilizing fewer trainable parameters, less pre-training data (10\%), and a smaller base model size. Extensive experiments demonstrate that DEEM enhances the performance of LMMs on various downstream tasks without inferior performance in the long term, including visual question answering, image captioning, and text-conditioned image synthesis.
MLLM; Diffusion Model;
Diffusion Model Can help MLLM see better
5,298
2405.15232
[ 0.011581250466406345, 0.005588340573012829, 0.01654021069407463, 0.029414957389235497, 0.03492536023259163, 0.02779429778456688, 0.027964990586042404, 0.025437450036406517, -0.019684845581650734, -0.0369030125439167, -0.03355361521244049, 0.014805153012275696, -0.058206282556056976, 0.014797212556004524, 0.012654326856136322, 0.06292985379695892, 0.0388110987842083, 0.001274274429306388, -0.02226926013827324, 0.0471847839653492, -0.01000635139644146, -0.024407165125012398, 0.02081669308245182, 0.007878935895860195, 0.02704559452831745, -0.02095632255077362, 0.021943921223282814, 0.017094485461711884, -0.0275717843323946, -0.01680907793343067, 0.02845795452594757, -0.03769076243042946, 0.011299071833491325, -0.017494795843958855, 0.017604157328605652, 0.006401538848876953, -0.0404527522623539, 0.012017679400742054, 0.03661869466304779, 0.007780448533594608, -0.05796697363257408, 0.015732087194919586, 0.004357622005045414, -0.01899283193051815, -0.07239869236946106, -0.02480027824640274, -0.09937477856874466, 0.0501774437725544, 0.006998754106462002, -0.02660144306719303, -0.07922257483005524, 0.011346770450472832, 0.011340944096446037, -0.0027582980692386627, -0.00030457848333753645, 0.0346306748688221, 0.015456036664545536, -0.0680631697177887, -0.015613426454365253, -0.06056588888168335, -0.002344774082303047, 0.01151513122022152, 0.005062148440629244, 0.005549429450184107, -0.021118758246302605, -0.019601933658123016, -0.020251909270882607, 0.061718545854091644, -0.0619797445833683, -0.04444023221731186, 0.007443093229085207, -0.016613345593214035, -0.03223605081439018, -0.010068187490105629, -0.04375239834189415, -0.04473929479718208, 0.025113767012953758, 0.013465359807014465, 0.05394638702273369, -0.0545329824090004, -0.006003540009260178, 0.023973146453499794, 0.006260997615754604, 0.03930500149726868, -0.015630004927515984, 0.007451585493981838, 0.0016641108086332679, -0.013702239841222763, -0.06237334385514259, 0.03922821581363678, -0.029327496886253357, -0.05592019483447075, -0.011079070158302784, 0.03591877594590187, 0.019462332129478455, 0.015752479434013367, 0.026193436235189438, -0.0030204385984688997, 0.01588861085474491, 0.001417126040905714, -0.009492158889770508, -0.0583026148378849, 0.019797245040535927, 0.00844038836658001, -0.0814928412437439, 0.010845060460269451, -0.020127922296524048, -0.018686259165406227, -0.02716038003563881, 0.042656607925891876, -0.03824779763817787, 0.0008558504050597548, 0.013011269271373749, -0.013469014316797256, -0.08711528033018112, 0.02411615662276745, 0.02272019162774086, 0.002265982097014785, -0.008371317759156227, 0.013079266063869, 0.05294391140341759, 0.03671456500887871, -0.035748064517974854, 0.06594514846801758, -0.011629891581833363, 0.010337024927139282, 0.007948372513055801, 0.02536182478070259, -0.0220964252948761, -0.004618800710886717, 0.035376958549022675, 0.03133007884025574, 0.015740739181637764, -0.010830472223460674, 0.012811416760087013, -0.0162447988986969, 0.03321077302098274, 0.008484335616230965, 0.03804894536733627, -0.034743551164865494, 0.02096252329647541, -0.0058197202160954475, 0.0280996635556221, -0.021203940734267235, 0.07205948978662491, -0.01731155626475811, 0.008056092076003551, 0.007939441129565239, -0.03309554234147072, -0.0042907255701720715, 0.04045415669679642, 0.010679636150598526, 0.04397882521152496, -0.06503315269947052, 0.02485668659210205, 0.07006800919771194, 0.007743986789137125, 0.02093604765832424, 0.037561140954494476, 0.0006654394092038274, 0.011709379963576794, -0.016627226024866104, -0.0025827805511653423, -0.008844688534736633, -0.03162677213549614, -0.03832075744867325, 0.012854725122451782, 0.009226170368492603, -0.030517857521772385, 0.011806133203208447, -0.03121250309050083, -0.023109719157218933, 0.023387515917420387, -0.009534123353660107, -0.011550282128155231, 0.014880889095366001, 0.04503745585680008, 0.046466365456581116, 0.04007041081786156, 0.024373160675168037, -0.08800482004880905, 0.006568256765604019, 0.00026458720094524324, -0.03646625950932503, 0.048356834799051285, -0.054504189640283585, 0.09040458500385284, -0.0033873131033033133, -0.01584695465862751, 0.010796021670103073, -0.07149238884449005, 0.006289595738053322, 0.02282307669520378, -0.0035637591499835253, 0.06340091675519943, 0.012869884259998798, -0.011549493297934532, 0.030684245750308037, 0.08352870494127274, 0.05421621724963188, 0.0568305179476738, -0.015591109171509743, 0.05436860769987106, -0.011910274624824524, -0.0277845561504364, 0.001271498971618712, 0.05386771634221077, -0.029077548533678055, -0.06354523450136185, -0.001142747700214386, -0.0045134276151657104, -0.048514705151319504, 0.00328326178714633, 0.034039221704006195, 0.03889407217502594, 0.018483182415366173, 0.002189505845308304, 0.002528838347643614, 0.0003769047325477004, -0.05603369325399399, 0.03946777060627937, 0.03461809828877449, -0.045382335782051086, -0.019821342080831528, -0.04357891529798508, 0.08778665959835052, 0.06683889776468277, -0.053423989564180374, -0.01687394455075264, 0.020017098635435104, 0.019183533266186714, 0.0031439471058547497, 0.031049303710460663, -0.01098835002630949, 0.00615009805187583, -0.03133933246135712, 0.031942594796419144, -0.02284989133477211, 0.08016224950551987, -0.05399703606963158, -0.007431922014802694, 0.03838152810931206, 0.004057096783071756, 0.02539571188390255, -0.002430957043543458, 0.009561664424836636, 0.04639740288257599, -0.024898456409573555, -0.0034843548201024532, -0.01779286190867424, -0.01143664214760065, 0.02720547653734684, -0.003730730153620243, -0.05996733158826828, 0.028108039870858192, -0.033830028027296066, -0.0076724025420844555, -0.015401400625705719, 0.06183804199099541, 0.05336456373333931, -0.0032064777333289385, 0.07342838495969772, -0.01720188558101654, -0.01597721129655838, -0.03169101104140282, -0.09135497361421585, -0.03671304136514664, -0.002912635449320078, 0.021592892706394196, -0.0043568797409534454, 0.06890099495649338, 0.0028860692400485277, 0.0013754840474575758, -0.04085950553417206, -0.0007164404378272593, 0.01747945323586464, 0.03484269604086876, 0.010797169059515, -0.02890472114086151, -0.018848557025194168, -0.0012961685424670577, 0.07583273947238922, 0.019009457901120186, 0.0073827230371534824, -0.024605780839920044, -0.020362742245197296, -0.008263815194368362, -0.01269096601754427, -0.000795238243881613, 0.014010987244546413, 0.011437681503593922, 0.011239634826779366, 0.016716718673706055, 0.0058069690130651, 0.005309027619659901, 0.024353627115488052, 0.039866961538791656, -0.021177425980567932, -0.04200826585292816, 0.028020264580845833, 0.010386158712208271, 0.026879074051976204, 0.016198905184864998, 0.02493545226752758, -0.04213498532772064, 0.016147781163454056, 0.034174155443906784, -0.0005031234468333423, -0.2901550233364105, -0.008167047053575516, 0.014374302700161934, -0.014772294089198112, 0.02221161313354969, -0.041783448308706284, 0.026350028812885284, -0.051837507635354996, -0.04183434322476387, 0.016103144735097885, -0.004919793922454119, 0.02355564944446087, -0.04086829721927643, 0.051987625658512115, 0.04728839173913002, 0.0434163436293602, -0.0008725007646717131, -0.023564377799630165, 0.022352974861860275, 0.07288648933172226, 0.0022453758865594864, -0.05452209338545799, -0.043740008026361465, 0.07633398473262787, -0.031307876110076904, 0.05456363037228584, -0.09234476834535599, 0.002537051448598504, -0.009847493842244148, -0.002414755756035447, -0.008748910389840603, -0.02801637537777424, 0.008774145506322384, 0.04898335784673691, 0.011431891471147537, 0.009625738486647606, 0.051426973193883896, -0.03407055884599686, 0.01784343831241131, -0.015578358434140682, 0.015076425857841969, -0.026876144111156464, -0.036467988044023514, 0.01891244575381279, 0.04901811107993126, 0.019389020279049873, -0.0660981610417366, -0.022839397192001343, -0.006543874740600586, 0.027679581195116043, -0.01330169290304184, -0.025935424491763115, -0.028061699122190475, 0.009355119429528713, -0.005616227630525827, -0.01195697020739317, 0.007013087626546621, -0.02000603824853897, -0.0016871819971129298, 0.0002187074424000457, -0.0042563495226204395, -0.03522998467087746, -0.030239170417189598, -0.03573688864707947, 0.006675197742879391, -0.0257588941603899, -0.06404446810483932, -0.038496922701597214, 0.044342514127492905, 0.0032101969700306654, -0.02471647411584854, -0.002343713538721204, -0.024356698617339134, -0.10097718983888626, 0.017088966444134712, 0.030225902795791626, -0.008133405819535255, -0.04154687002301216, -0.033891864120960236, 0.026437317952513695, -0.0018691775621846318, -0.046616081148386, 0.025019094347953796, -0.0033977667335420847, 0.008637656457722187, -0.031562887132167816, 0.009850931353867054, -0.03688434138894081, -0.0065754251554608345, -0.04439908638596535, 0.04830066114664078, -0.006009980570524931, 0.02493569254875183, -0.004692351445555687, 0.04873089864850044, 0.04457857459783554, 0.033567529171705246, 0.06063379719853401, 0.023339038714766502, 0.004690265748649836, 0.02791641466319561, -0.07620397955179214, -0.02230551466345787, -0.023944191634655, -0.035240352153778076, 0.02784508839249611, -0.04690876603126526, -0.021345922723412514, 0.0342051163315773, -0.030402518808841705, -0.05757137015461922, -0.012319634668529034, 0.004024700727313757, 0.0272548645734787, -0.001999589614570141, -0.02358981966972351, 0.004867538344115019, 0.026043202728033066, 0.036643147468566895, -0.016078971326351166, 0.002326744608581066, 0.01871643215417862, -0.038806043565273285, 0.01383837591856718, 0.017155969515442848, 0.016031669452786446, -0.03473043069243431, -0.03941056877374649, -0.036921124905347824, 0.02335595339536667, 0.03249303624033928, 0.016258079558610916, 0.022631561383605003, 0.01654978096485138, 0.0750790536403656, -0.04047279804944992, -0.016576889902353287, -0.007004851009696722, 0.04350586608052254, -0.03697213903069496, 0.03438039869070053, -0.02099725417792797, 0.052933886647224426, 0.06352783739566803, 0.018162302672863007, 0.00017922509869094938, 0.007216298021376133, 0.0007183412672020495, -0.025744536891579628, -0.0224541537463665, 0.03030485101044178, -0.05789671838283539, -0.043423689901828766, -0.02096373774111271, -0.010456804186105728, -0.012192156165838242, -0.016773905605077744, -0.026593592017889023, 0.022897202521562576, -0.0764194056391716, 0.06936125457286835, 0.015041313134133816, -0.04834230989217758, 0.01678922213613987, -0.006671638693660498, 0.036253415048122406, 0.01654559187591076, 0.015266815200448036, 0.016310924664139748, 0.001069049583747983, 0.031121136620640755, -0.02609264850616455, -0.05561963841319084, -0.024973856285214424, -0.0012772567570209503, 0.024701552465558052, -0.010052474215626717, -0.011651704087853432, -0.04861021041870117, 0.0663657933473587, 0.028349008411169052, -0.0362064391374588, 0.018225673586130142, 0.005751876626163721, 0.07296567410230637, 0.006414393428713083, -0.016388045623898506, -0.0014322015922516584, -0.06037873774766922, 0.036859285086393356, -0.030688820406794548, 0.02026180736720562, -0.06725971400737762, -0.03673255071043968, -0.0464472658932209, -0.049834463745355606, -0.007182752247899771, 0.007474927697330713, -0.010887181386351585, -0.009275672025978565, -0.0016981610096991062, 0.027622386813163757, -0.02911783754825592, -0.005996735766530037, 0.005858980119228363, -0.07318383455276489, 0.013428504578769207, 0.06195462495088577, -0.05076432228088379, 0.00936696957796812, -0.01757419854402542, -0.01121427584439516, -0.06673629581928253, -0.04084343835711479, 0.01261057984083891, -0.01305594015866518, -0.011673511005938053, -0.051999419927597046, 0.022653555497527122, -0.002706995466724038, 0.0029500278178602457, -0.005883553996682167, -0.026232939213514328, 0.019317926838994026, 0.0017261229222640395, 0.01772722788155079, -0.014219878241419792, -0.009953310713171959, -0.0044241310097277164, -0.018077287822961807, 0.018036847934126854, -0.021089812740683556, 0.00125810073222965, 0.05771654471755028, -0.014616426080465317, -0.012123484164476395, -0.01969640888273716, 0.03461906313896179, 0.027145102620124817, 0.01481449231505394, 0.023240188136696815, 0.024835072457790375, -0.02294701710343361, 0.026959991082549095, 0.02595851570367813, 0.05544203892350197, -0.004817353095859289, -0.00045740281348116696, 0.025826258584856987, 0.030747070908546448, -0.0002477930102031678, 0.012584219686686993, -0.0236596018075943, -0.019433654844760895, 0.04386262595653534, -0.023473896086215973, -0.019393034279346466, -0.05982411652803421, -0.056057967245578766, 0.019479071721434593, 0.0036700828932225704, 0.03482142835855484, -0.039630819112062454, 0.036462388932704926, 0.03469471633434296, 0.010986357927322388, -0.00488388491794467, -0.010800673626363277, 0.03876258432865143, -0.03450615331530571, 0.01412829291075468, -0.06059827283024788, -0.024944081902503967, 0.07439173758029938, -0.02799471653997898, 0.015168321318924427, -0.024654632434248924, -0.057676829397678375, 0.05870485305786133, -0.04243128001689911, -0.04442473500967026, 0.0013956764014437795, -0.0341201014816761, -0.01378058921545744, 0.02006387896835804, -0.036854520440101624, 0.018470648676156998, -0.025067903101444244, -0.0336679145693779, -0.0034604312386363745, 0.0025578911881893873, 0.03157524764537811, -0.01846555434167385, 0.03379450738430023, -0.033336758613586426, 0.018166935071349144, 0.021830927580595016, 0.05839971452951431, 0.01616031490266323, -0.0006039165891706944, 0.02922540344297886, 0.0758315846323967, 0.04122278839349747, 0.007603270001709461, 0.02322343923151493, 0.020629629492759705, -0.02297624573111534, -0.06609289348125458, 0.0408683679997921, -0.001042393152602017, -0.007839005440473557, -0.07112935930490494, 0.04319817200303078, 0.03385087475180626, -0.03494718670845032, 0.006774483248591423, 0.0557127445936203, -0.016460444778203964, 0.03291889652609825, -0.023922288790345192, 0.0037042624317109585, 0.014752719551324844, 0.05585446208715439, 0.006472528912127018, 0.0576896108686924, 0.06739185750484467, -0.0024639018811285496, 0.0015488096978515387, 0.016810448840260506, 0.05191079154610634, 0.07255260646343231, 0.057629842311143875, 0.010797991417348385, 0.09393961727619171, -0.023958103731274605, -0.03534300625324249, 0.00891550350934267, 0.036593664437532425, -0.02659428119659424, -0.06568815559148788, 0.004272618796676397, 0.10800264775753021, -0.0067239971831440926, 0.037640515714883804, -0.05599584802985191, 0.007168418262153864, 0.004923587664961815, 0.016874931752681732, -0.010935253463685513, 0.010697291232645512, 0.05295943096280098, -0.017876969650387764, -0.025618361309170723, 0.007137949112802744, -0.003964531701058149, -0.027323370799422264, 0.007801700849086046, -0.0060065439902246, 0.0030710832215845585, 0.041697580367326736, -0.03020358830690384, 0.04283253848552704, 0.10521979629993439, -0.012545110657811165, -0.027438245713710785, -0.01638265699148178, -0.03063671663403511, 0.019736463204026222, 0.06449100375175476, -0.013415792025625706, -0.013973293825984001, 0.012928323820233345, -0.05398540943861008, 0.005411580670624971, 0.04256181791424751, -0.007610107772052288, 0.008003461174666882, -0.05067218467593193, -0.043243493884801865, 0.02428789995610714, 0.01754198968410492, -0.0720507949590683, -0.04838220030069351, -0.028591735288500786, -0.05087287351489067, -0.054383814334869385, -0.03399142622947693, 0.03308923542499542, -0.0006263962714001536, -0.03887273743748665, -0.03856544941663742, -0.01962808147072792, 0.00040904845809563994, 0.01209043338894844, -0.06510783731937408, -0.00402190862223506, 0.05577903613448143, -0.010932310484349728, -0.0681908130645752, 0.020055631175637245, 0.0075523401610553265, -0.03219038248062134, -0.00649780360981822, 0.020375488325953484, 0.013714655302464962, 0.0018653770675882697, -0.006836364045739174, 0.010673141106963158, -0.09095222502946854, 0.014644334092736244, 0.014611532911658287, -0.03538345918059349, -0.08422718197107315, -0.0020716250874102116, -0.01255073118954897, 0.04410024359822273, 0.05571671575307846, 0.018791254609823227, 0.022419022396206856, -0.03459813818335533, -0.008834803476929665, -0.00919259898364544, 0.0063650705851614475, 0.07917758822441101, -0.009469155222177505, 0.08386114239692688, 0.03937429189682007, -0.006009307224303484, -0.04336142539978027, 0.020367266610264778, -0.017156172543764114, -0.000947104359511286, -0.007131045684218407, -0.04962436482310295, -0.03687445819377899, -0.09451563656330109, -0.03021594136953354, 0.03506183251738548, -0.03826992213726044, -0.032358959317207336, 0.00664996774867177, -0.029085125774145126, -0.02385353110730648, -0.020696569234132767, -0.014580377377569675, -0.03587987646460533, 0.0025744300801306963, -0.022410236299037933, -0.05360233411192894, 0.03455055132508278, 0.004509390331804752, -0.009661450982093811, -0.03864886611700058, -0.03743789717555046, -0.0027398241218179464, 0.014664393849670887, 0.032123591750860214, 0.001168134156614542, 0.05216563865542412, -0.03600329905748367 ]
3,554
Stabilizing Reinforcement Learning in Differentiable Multiphysics Simulation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=DRiLWb8bJg
[ "Eliot Xing", "Vernon Luk", "Jean Oh" ]
Spotlight
Recent advances in GPU-based parallel simulation have enabled practitioners to collect large amounts of data and train complex control policies using deep reinforcement learning (RL), on commodity GPUs. However, such successes for RL in robotics have been limited to tasks sufficiently simulated by fast rigid-body dynamics. Simulation techniques for soft bodies are comparatively several orders of magnitude slower, thereby limiting the use of RL due to sample complexity requirements. To address this challenge, this paper presents both a novel RL algorithm and a simulation platform to enable scaling RL on tasks involving rigid bodies and deformables. We introduce Soft Analytic Policy Optimization (SAPO), a maximum entropy first-order model-based actor-critic RL algorithm, which uses first-order analytic gradients from differentiable simulation to train a stochastic actor to maximize expected return and entropy. Alongside our approach, we develop Rewarped, a parallel differentiable multiphysics simulation platform that supports simulating various materials beyond rigid bodies. We re-implement challenging manipulation and locomotion tasks in Rewarped, and show that SAPO outperforms baselines over a range of tasks that involve interaction between rigid bodies, articulations, and deformables. Additional details at https://rewarped.github.io/.
reinforcement learning, differentiable simulation
null
5,094
2412.12089
[ -0.031229989603161812, -0.018134603276848793, 0.00017886592831928283, 0.041997525840997696, 0.04470977932214737, 0.04119252786040306, 0.010337889194488525, 0.0035359503235667944, -0.0641384869813919, -0.04539972171187401, -0.005976701620966196, 0.004687052685767412, -0.06465976685285568, 0.005569629371166229, 0.02793976664543152, 0.05589430034160614, 0.020996641367673874, -0.04000159725546837, -0.019478095695376396, 0.02636067382991314, -0.015759676694869995, 0.002076443051919341, 0.020825985819101334, 0.024489201605319977, 0.04297449439764023, -0.003190284129232168, 0.009498795494437218, 0.03859441354870796, -0.003954962827265263, -0.011180955916643143, -0.0024838545359671116, -0.002539738779887557, -0.0016561857191845775, -0.030041111633181572, 0.0009317669318988919, 0.012082124128937721, -0.04955661669373512, 0.013903477229177952, 0.0004748812352772802, -0.0024480002466589212, -0.00646764924749732, 0.029577992856502533, -0.03639497235417366, -0.017821967601776123, -0.004036709666252136, 0.017240600660443306, -0.057658858597278595, 0.03239665925502777, 0.015116347000002861, -0.028651980683207512, -0.09483534097671509, 0.020150190219283104, 0.03517157584428787, -0.02566598914563656, -0.023093797266483307, 0.011606087908148766, 0.01732090674340725, -0.06844677776098251, -0.003941680770367384, -0.08180965483188629, 0.002650112146511674, 0.03423929959535599, 0.009621787816286087, -0.003967343829572201, -0.005095086060464382, -0.0015920134028419852, 0.025626735761761665, 0.010475811548531055, -0.01574130356311798, -0.013106905855238438, -0.04041878134012222, -0.014196847565472126, 0.02408493682742119, 0.01857100799679756, 0.0065245795994997025, -0.06652913987636566, 0.01661042682826519, 0.02712961472570896, 0.061454758048057556, 0.01650586538016796, 0.03735360875725746, 0.014076389372348785, 0.009138799272477627, 0.05567150190472603, 0.005915704183280468, 0.019205346703529358, -0.030665799975395203, 0.006451771594583988, -0.06674998998641968, 0.0385441780090332, -0.04384071007370949, -0.039495278149843216, 0.008738426491618156, 0.04123682528734207, 0.017926475033164024, 0.011671862564980984, 0.0040954649448394775, 0.015656691044569016, -0.02041020616889, -0.017996197566390038, -0.022862335667014122, -0.043862782418727875, -0.016677426174283028, -0.012892416678369045, -0.08960466086864471, -0.017835600301623344, -0.010793786495923996, -0.005982248578220606, -0.028238996863365173, 0.021769551560282707, -0.0384400300681591, -0.001926963566802442, 0.00948534905910492, -0.058452874422073364, -0.09323190897703171, 0.019233915954828262, 0.03406437486410141, 0.046151936054229736, -0.0016983050154522061, 0.017705976963043213, 0.04985794425010681, 0.04774622246623039, 0.0058111343532800674, 0.05717306211590767, 0.005399844143539667, 0.015855038538575172, -0.000455286237411201, 0.016427526250481606, -0.02288568578660488, -0.059686653316020966, 0.04024553298950195, 0.04773111641407013, -0.024762652814388275, -0.004141975659877062, -0.004620472900569439, 0.003074183827266097, 0.018311256542801857, 0.045424509793519974, 0.03638279065489769, 0.02147478237748146, -0.020489804446697235, -0.04454419016838074, 0.0892956331372261, -0.04910261929035187, 0.04620598629117012, -0.03512340039014816, 0.012373218312859535, -0.03541103005409241, -0.07572511583566666, 0.009231251664459705, -0.010469446890056133, 0.006771616172045469, -0.015513638034462929, -0.0529492050409317, 0.03993911296129227, 0.023616159334778786, 0.03435767441987991, 0.016846200451254845, 0.014534433372318745, 0.005134811624884605, 0.004606848582625389, -0.009764356538653374, -0.026089342311024666, -0.004664182662963867, 0.012580097652971745, -0.04964451119303703, 0.04661116003990173, 0.02186049520969391, -0.011139766313135624, 0.00481882318854332, -0.04348735511302948, 0.01877293363213539, 0.019341178238391876, 0.022129423916339874, -0.018619036301970482, -0.0016930283745750785, 0.05067112296819687, -0.027056479826569557, 0.04935381934046745, 0.01992391049861908, -0.05825863406062126, 0.014052893035113811, -0.014294557273387909, 0.01353683602064848, 0.000017025759007083252, -0.040530625730752945, 0.1009642630815506, -0.02448400855064392, -0.008888320066034794, 0.009597965516149998, -0.08499101549386978, 0.0032490419689565897, 0.020458564162254333, -0.011944777332246304, 0.05629976466298103, 0.002445064252242446, -0.023655835539102554, 0.016948530450463295, 0.010370578616857529, 0.06254186481237411, 0.021332353353500366, -0.031508296728134155, 0.014611159451305866, 0.0035837639588862658, -0.00996177177876234, -0.04941074922680855, 0.05591514706611633, -0.02695835754275322, -0.013605504296720028, 0.007527217268943787, -0.03737008199095726, -0.010032128542661667, -0.0015483764000236988, -0.0115548986941576, 0.03352581337094307, 0.002823048271238804, -0.014836241491138935, 0.026554876938462257, 0.018409203737974167, -0.02701028436422348, 0.03124741092324257, -0.01101630087941885, -0.0039637587033212185, -0.020899642258882523, -0.036891672760248184, 0.0976468175649643, 0.07012475281953812, -0.03591174632310867, -0.018702678382396698, -0.0032086160499602556, -0.0047852639108896255, -0.0033976698759943247, 0.011343790218234062, -0.025642676278948784, -0.026882601901888847, -0.009317120537161827, 0.014763111248612404, -0.014115782454609871, 0.040439803153276443, -0.04402579367160797, -0.05974406376481056, 0.07164016366004944, 0.011889422312378883, 0.07923398911952972, -0.0011793895391747355, 0.030859781429171562, 0.06116124987602234, 0.0021118412259966135, -0.02253495343029499, -0.016586696729063988, -0.07431869953870773, 0.019309014081954956, 0.03256892040371895, 0.02590680494904518, -0.00239704386331141, -0.060004822909832, -0.031758081167936325, -0.011467103846371174, 0.06884821504354477, 0.046208929270505905, 0.022529130801558495, 0.004055635537952185, 0.0015564741333946586, -0.01672588475048542, -0.03735451027750969, -0.11905663460493088, -0.026638099923729897, 0.00820276327431202, 0.02058793604373932, 0.03619031608104706, 0.04284794256091118, -0.028590718284249306, 0.04757178574800491, -0.029322663322091103, -0.03456907346844673, 0.0021799025125801563, 0.011753776110708714, 0.027500657364726067, -0.028154795989394188, -0.042365968227386475, 0.02764788456261158, 0.08276547491550446, -0.007392324507236481, -0.024138035252690315, 0.0037634954787790775, -0.03648298233747482, -0.009660962037742138, -0.022214097902178764, 0.014803504571318626, -0.00418231263756752, -0.0024802780244499445, 0.002346535213291645, -0.03475591540336609, 0.019878825172781944, 0.007601541001349688, 0.08989919722080231, 0.04732346907258034, 0.02559254691004753, -0.00750346016138792, 0.009697402827441692, -0.02784176543354988, -0.007523988373577595, -0.026093417778611183, 0.0413585789501667, 0.002676380565389991, -0.019876766949892044, 0.010528194718062878, 0.008503036573529243, -0.2626913785934448, -0.0361054427921772, 0.017797721549868584, 0.008060157299041748, 0.06379063427448273, 0.02869735099375248, 0.03437652438879013, -0.02907462604343891, -0.023330019786953926, 0.009508954361081123, 0.033940210938453674, 0.024989472702145576, 0.02017175406217575, 0.06768254190683365, 0.08513259142637253, 0.013663184829056263, 0.013475444167852402, -0.017260372638702393, -0.010322270914912224, 0.024595776572823524, -0.033896926790475845, -0.0721023827791214, -0.020111147314310074, -0.0244051031768322, 0.009164445102214813, 0.017549529671669006, -0.08310552686452866, -0.016254547983407974, -0.04391665384173393, -0.022805599495768547, -0.03089846484363079, -0.011092598550021648, -0.03538405895233154, 0.03745760768651962, 0.027942698448896408, -0.004659550730139017, 0.034175027161836624, -0.0048695397563278675, 0.05337065830826759, 0.004760246258229017, -0.029153617098927498, -0.010583500377833843, -0.057552289217710495, 0.04598851501941681, 0.07478388398885727, 0.014690238051116467, -0.042992424219846725, -0.010166737250983715, -0.020337264984846115, 0.03204311057925224, 0.033189963549375534, -0.02574528567492962, -0.006269157864153385, 0.017833558842539787, 0.022680146619677544, -0.005688719917088747, 0.0006431268411688507, 0.010692819021642208, -0.007986797019839287, 0.00017062643019016832, -0.013182401657104492, -0.045811254531145096, -0.028603633865714073, -0.0023674259427934885, 0.008456001058220863, -0.0435737706720829, -0.05460978299379349, -0.04950876906514168, 0.0303813386708498, 0.032792169600725174, -0.012651626951992512, -0.039683111011981964, -0.03919389471411705, -0.11000636219978333, 0.014959226362407207, -0.013616159558296204, 0.001779482001438737, -0.06440924853086472, 0.014801355078816414, 0.02866806462407112, -0.040308017283678055, -0.046180661767721176, -0.017053335905075073, 0.004413666669279337, 0.021740656346082687, -0.0074476394802331924, 0.05054814741015434, -0.05831532925367355, -0.004994634538888931, -0.030124258249998093, 0.030490363016724586, 0.014919627457857132, 0.032446783035993576, -0.046258632093667984, 0.05803706869482994, -0.000848955474793911, 0.009825950488448143, 0.003777442965656519, 0.028466617688536644, -0.013006671331822872, 0.00345785915851593, -0.10528493672609329, -0.014509393833577633, -0.06341367214918137, 0.0071766069158911705, -0.005719427485018969, -0.027313198894262314, -0.026248758658766747, 0.04152265936136246, 0.050682686269283295, 0.00045729646808467805, -0.051788654178380966, 0.05262243375182152, -0.01423113327473402, -0.014307571575045586, 0.00030842379783280194, -0.005071407649666071, 0.045905906707048416, 0.015643024817109108, -0.02398562803864479, -0.05057810992002487, 0.05272379890084267, -0.037915393710136414, -0.01246242318302393, -0.003681236645206809, 0.007666072808206081, 0.010114765726029873, -0.02609003521502018, 0.009644987992942333, -0.017843542620539665, 0.0039464556612074375, 0.04458688199520111, -0.006721419282257557, 0.030282096937298775, 0.011362200602889061, 0.03035140223801136, -0.017643773928284645, -0.006126515567302704, 0.04795023053884506, -0.024390775710344315, -0.0022612465545535088, -0.033150747418403625, 0.04234977439045906, -0.0049560521729290485, 0.01598110795021057, 0.05368901789188385, 0.022040994837880135, 0.026674548164010048, 0.030103877186775208, 0.005446812137961388, 0.05370810627937317, -0.07326401770114899, -0.015343355014920235, -0.036009155213832855, 0.0161655992269516, -0.0440850704908371, 0.04861190542578697, -0.0075829653069376945, 0.013084699399769306, -0.05593647435307503, 0.028162268921732903, 0.044985391199588776, -0.06770489364862442, 0.01681433618068695, 0.016647182404994965, 0.058294616639614105, -0.03857738897204399, -0.02428867295384407, 0.009213732555508614, -0.020164918154478073, 0.002307058311998844, -0.04866533726453781, -0.017808087170124054, -0.028152991086244583, -0.03415330871939659, -0.01828768104314804, 0.013829418458044529, -0.059877797961235046, -0.01866769604384899, 0.00422928761690855, 0.008887295611202717, -0.021578723564743996, -0.01762358658015728, -0.02941427007317543, 0.06669244170188904, -0.030744075775146484, 0.0058760931715369225, -0.010089550167322159, 0.0018990065436810255, 0.04243442788720131, 0.015313473530113697, 0.026921935379505157, -0.023296678438782692, -0.014644159935414791, -0.01750321500003338, -0.03053680993616581, 0.028307585045695305, 0.033232372254133224, -0.029787300154566765, 0.0006241205846890807, 0.003943326883018017, 0.014710826799273491, -0.032660603523254395, 0.021487748250365257, 0.014910862781107426, -0.06225775182247162, -0.02705882117152214, 0.03565884381532669, 0.03333471342921257, 0.019923511892557144, -0.05090610682964325, -0.023079583421349525, -0.05214599147439003, 0.0014808435225859284, -0.0021638472098857164, -0.0036002842243760824, -0.016630608588457108, -0.032200220972299576, -0.03028583526611328, 0.007247611414641142, 0.02389819361269474, -0.014257444068789482, -0.005565802566707134, -0.046583373099565506, 0.01885131001472473, 0.05191439762711525, -0.023609492927789688, -0.02529381774365902, 0.026619762182235718, 0.03589949756860733, 0.026932159438729286, -0.04936164990067482, 0.002945337677374482, 0.015740592032670975, 0.010181382298469543, 0.02985451929271221, -0.03764783963561058, 0.0475863479077816, -0.017339585348963737, -0.04721928387880325, -0.009844452142715454, 0.015506778843700886, -0.023173315450549126, -0.0077253482304513454, -0.009714975021779537, 0.01176309771835804, 0.008086485788226128, 0.003086330369114876, 0.019667748361825943, -0.0008430352318100631, 0.02788064442574978, -0.013552761636674404, -0.04381091892719269, 0.00819061417132616, 0.05920828878879547, -0.012715945951640606, -0.0013894363073632121, -0.06865639239549637, -0.013442693278193474, 0.01877548173069954, -0.022190656512975693, 0.023364802822470665, -0.06345608830451965, 0.032747380435466766, -0.004284221678972244, 0.03413967788219452, 0.049520865082740784, -0.06444687396287918, 0.03962012380361557, -0.08608130365610123, 0.013804054819047451, -0.04957559332251549, 0.00021103410108480603, 0.04846545681357384, -0.02948640286922455, 0.004527790937572718, 0.020397435873746872, -0.034314095973968506, 0.06708328425884247, -0.024044441059231758, -0.06406902521848679, 0.05198436975479126, -0.026967428624629974, -0.03030310943722725, 0.04789290204644203, -0.042919356375932693, -0.02053884044289589, -0.0071166702546179295, -0.010968964546918869, 0.024957580491900444, 0.012590138241648674, 0.022099919617176056, -0.004378535784780979, -0.006898225750774145, -0.03455360233783722, 0.033110156655311584, 0.012723731808364391, 0.02201126329600811, 0.01625026762485504, 0.02106022834777832, -0.06419266760349274, 0.08982887864112854, 0.03142557293176651, 0.04638836532831192, 0.013648207299411297, -0.006118976045399904, -0.0018937478307634592, -0.016550032421946526, 0.048936374485492706, -0.0008366953115910292, -0.01042930781841278, -0.049293261021375656, -0.00014390726573765278, 0.005277175921946764, -0.0489775687456131, 0.00008522552525391802, 0.035289980471134186, -0.06478338688611984, -0.025781992822885513, 0.0026592386420816183, 0.01043170690536499, 0.022122148424386978, 0.07164084911346436, -0.0007359139272011817, 0.05044475942850113, 0.07659528404474258, 0.03739479184150696, -0.012794523499906063, -0.03130059689283371, 0.08629254251718521, 0.054253291338682175, 0.038724470883607864, -0.013060813769698143, 0.06242959573864937, -0.046374864876270294, -0.03885788097977638, 0.07577232271432877, 0.032601021230220795, -0.027633408084511757, -0.04059625789523125, 0.005910999607294798, 0.07623553276062012, 0.006149258464574814, 0.07186568528413773, -0.041448164731264114, -0.030840566381812096, 0.06638989597558975, 0.004036379046738148, -0.01571839116513729, 0.03653834015130997, 0.028848154470324516, 0.01107688620686531, -0.0036048151087015867, -0.034881532192230225, -0.0008610148215666413, -0.04047045484185219, 0.03463244438171387, -0.015185452997684479, -0.030166003853082657, 0.010937092825770378, 0.0219237320125103, 0.039785318076610565, 0.12397564947605133, -0.047931771725416183, -0.00348681746982038, -0.0009905305923894048, -0.007572914939373732, -0.009684475138783455, -0.012371441349387169, 0.01924300007522106, -0.008761533536016941, 0.04366090148687363, -0.06198158860206604, 0.027676977217197418, 0.05483385920524597, 0.013117373920977116, 0.04808405786752701, -0.0219394713640213, -0.015581266954541206, 0.03028344176709652, 0.01632506772875786, -0.02168046310544014, -0.055825911462306976, -0.027278007939457893, -0.01558274868875742, -0.05196576192975044, -0.033040713518857956, 0.027516020461916924, -0.0009393743239343166, -0.04306361451745033, 0.023973843082785606, -0.013008147478103638, 0.038149144500494, 0.013200970366597176, -0.04495371878147125, -0.026511793956160545, 0.027165943756699562, -0.0048448736779391766, 0.011744045652449131, 0.05140126496553421, 0.033276237547397614, 0.007681255228817463, -0.02833368256688118, 0.014773731119930744, -0.004443086683750153, 0.015341782942414284, -0.01022266037762165, -0.014396879822015762, -0.09073618799448013, -0.000827719341032207, 0.026179546490311623, -0.033283885568380356, -0.07423755526542664, 0.02209429256618023, -0.06278582662343979, -0.00918238889425993, 0.07574688643217087, -0.006271413993090391, 0.023040158674120903, -0.016090134158730507, -0.05436353757977486, 0.011093988083302975, 0.0069393739104270935, 0.054856009781360626, -0.035555679351091385, 0.03688150271773338, 0.0447099469602108, -0.03976747393608093, -0.03371122106909752, 0.04824739694595337, 0.023126618936657906, -0.007749190088361502, -0.014244899153709412, -0.017006242647767067, -0.013587349094450474, -0.10549475252628326, -0.016542067751288414, 0.0663103461265564, 0.013736803084611893, -0.04103028029203415, 0.011484730988740921, 0.004324736539274454, 0.018343525007367134, -0.023305295035243034, -0.004533420782536268, -0.033747393637895584, -0.04843683913350105, -0.018148478120565414, -0.049323052167892456, 0.035487525165081024, -0.01991836354136467, 0.02324831485748291, -0.007309156470000744, -0.05014972388744354, 0.007126192562282085, 0.004627023357897997, 0.009507440030574799, 0.006401591934263706, 0.009046437218785286, -0.01856907084584236 ]
3,555
Credal Wrapper of Model Averaging for Uncertainty Estimation in Classification
https://openreview.net/forum?id=cv2iMNWCsh
[ "Kaizheng Wang", "Fabio Cuzzolin", "Keivan Shariatmadar", "David Moens", "Hans Hallez" ]
Spotlight
This paper presents an innovative approach, called credal wrapper, to formulating a credal set representation of model averaging for Bayesian neural networks (BNNs) and deep ensembles (DEs), capable of improving uncertainty estimation in classification tasks. Given a finite collection of single predictive distributions derived from BNNs or DEs, the proposed credal wrapper approach extracts an upper and a lower probability bound per class, acknowledging the epistemic uncertainty due to the availability of a limited amount of distributions. Such probability intervals over classes can be mapped on a convex set of probabilities (a credal set) from which, in turn, a unique prediction can be obtained using a transformation called intersection probability transformation. In this article, we conduct extensive experiments on several out-of-distribution (OOD) detection benchmarks, encompassing various dataset pairs (CIFAR10/100 vs SVHN/Tiny-ImageNet, CIFAR10 vs CIFAR10-C, CIFAR100 vs CIFAR100-C and ImageNet vs ImageNet-O) and using different network architectures (such as VGG16, ResNet-18/50, EfficientNet B2, and ViT Base). Compared to the BNN and DE baselines, the proposed credal wrapper method exhibits superior performance in uncertainty estimation and achieves a lower expected calibration error on corrupted data.
Uncertainty Estimation, Model Averaging, Credal Stes, Probability Intervals, Out-of-Distribution Detection
null
5,087
null
[ 0.000394212402170524, 0.03398647531867027, -0.03964083269238472, 0.05699453130364418, 0.02142472192645073, 0.02743183635175228, 0.023558245971798897, -0.023297835141420364, -0.04281354323029518, -0.05408449098467827, -0.04062403738498688, 0.005510698538273573, -0.06582308560609818, -0.01327805407345295, 0.023853598162531853, 0.05873020738363266, 0.04162617400288582, -0.012256618589162827, -0.007978939451277256, 0.03924176096916199, -0.015172057785093784, -0.07492366433143616, -0.01247239951044321, 0.01730099879205227, 0.0271123256534338, -0.026413440704345703, 0.06104382872581482, 0.00479336641728878, -0.017931293696165085, -0.025691891089081764, 0.03885539248585701, 0.006958879064768553, -0.014123182743787766, -0.04507815092802048, 0.0030848653987050056, 0.025429559871554375, -0.0421261265873909, -0.023089395835995674, -0.0016038314206525683, 0.0321054682135582, -0.036481183022260666, -0.011821207590401173, 0.00865801889449358, 0.012785116210579872, -0.0241314098238945, -0.0030691013671457767, -0.04546887055039406, 0.022174067795276642, 0.021299973130226135, -0.036145757883787155, -0.0879349410533905, 0.0019012817647308111, -0.019462132826447487, -0.021217545494437218, 0.0021465877071022987, 0.03305887430906296, 0.03396206349134445, -0.10585733503103256, -0.004341064020991325, -0.054233353585004807, -0.008663391694426537, 0.016938570886850357, 0.02329140342772007, -0.0009633875451982021, 0.01264934428036213, 0.004360391292721033, 0.007008727639913559, 0.038064923137426376, -0.008196774870157242, -0.02450343780219555, -0.009498223662376404, -0.016611455008387566, 0.011535821482539177, -0.0011364759411662817, -0.023683670908212662, -0.05810686945915222, 0.03945213556289673, 0.01153262984007597, 0.055217038840055466, -0.04475301504135132, 0.04363774135708809, -0.03283348307013512, 0.0177263543009758, 0.027400419116020203, 0.03657158464193344, 0.0006846013711765409, -0.03665042668581009, -0.05082450062036514, -0.08262160420417786, 0.03727862238883972, 0.019335690885782242, -0.03446430712938309, 0.021353356540203094, 0.017303375527262688, -0.009541265666484833, -0.0061433929949998856, 0.03238622099161148, -0.015885673463344574, 0.03320402279496193, -0.026076890528202057, -0.00225019920617342, -0.05040457472205162, 0.026316799223423004, -0.0039821648970246315, -0.08756647258996964, -0.05964414030313492, -0.01704077608883381, -0.03808775171637535, -0.028501780703663826, 0.03412088006734848, -0.020083444193005562, 0.02715541608631611, 0.0272053312510252, -0.003688469296321273, -0.07482434809207916, 0.01877414621412754, 0.0014873690670356154, 0.013466124422848225, -0.0008533468353562057, -0.014030078426003456, 0.06502638012170792, 0.09263606369495392, -0.009748612530529499, 0.05652158334851265, -0.006126271560788155, 0.0235699862241745, -0.02305392362177372, 0.025954142212867737, -0.01593482866883278, -0.03443854674696922, -0.01492827944457531, 0.02595309168100357, -0.0046051242388784885, 0.01597563736140728, -0.003268674947321415, -0.039241231977939606, -0.0067611210979521275, -0.0021195414010435343, 0.057489290833473206, 0.007406079210340977, -0.0034465049393475056, -0.05191614106297493, 0.05128918215632439, 0.012038977816700935, 0.07113873958587646, 0.023017434403300285, 0.004845581483095884, 0.005712477024644613, -0.03294855356216431, 0.016303252428770065, 0.0009853021474555135, -0.01104400958865881, 0.0005986243486404419, -0.06648058444261551, 0.010056992061436176, 0.029256615787744522, -0.009858733043074608, 0.01749495603144169, 0.025014903396368027, -0.0004035396850667894, 0.002949340036138892, -0.03325926512479782, -0.04601696506142616, 0.01829882711172104, 0.014870164915919304, -0.10355507582426071, 0.07587055116891861, 0.034594714641571045, -0.023656347766518593, 0.01433013565838337, -0.045105669647455215, -0.07843527942895889, 0.044924814254045486, -0.014693309552967548, -0.00841849111020565, -0.010710409842431545, 0.05203364044427872, 0.01028100773692131, 0.0525222048163414, 0.0030894451774656773, -0.0963427945971489, 0.03774511069059372, 0.01243421621620655, 0.0037181058432906866, 0.001124274916946888, -0.017759505659341812, 0.07409042119979858, -0.022463660687208176, 0.027020305395126343, 0.04746319726109505, -0.07912439852952957, -0.007872717455029488, 0.0082230931147933, -0.013883122242987156, 0.052207354456186295, 0.01605796627700329, -0.010481663979589939, 0.02753252349793911, 0.02251867577433586, 0.0037756257224828005, 0.046388112008571625, -0.01816345565021038, 0.014019719325006008, 0.004500364884734154, -0.03542599081993103, 0.01566353254020214, 0.029893657192587852, -0.012365165166556835, -0.0341305285692215, -0.0018591840052977204, -0.013278523460030556, 0.0017351398710161448, -0.0010167587315663695, -0.02570522390305996, 0.012885885313153267, 0.011252925731241703, 0.029265863820910454, -0.006057688966393471, 0.03309015557169914, -0.035076405853033066, 0.030749475583434105, 0.016303908079862595, -0.00838683545589447, 0.0016932400176301599, -0.02463565580546856, 0.08212430030107498, 0.07007306814193726, -0.024127785116434097, 0.011718721129000187, -0.011961123906075954, 0.01978241465985775, 0.0065792701207101345, 0.014070998877286911, 0.005274845287203789, 0.00029853760497644544, -0.0009764465503394604, -0.02271820791065693, -0.04337654635310173, 0.05622135475277901, -0.030385946854948997, -0.00948128942400217, 0.07363668829202652, -0.029322071000933647, 0.07719425112009048, 0.021081792190670967, 0.009777857922017574, 0.03583608195185661, -0.0037721171975135803, -0.04274251312017441, -0.026854567229747772, 0.008374965749680996, 0.00556296156719327, -0.01754937320947647, -0.01821674406528473, -0.012006658129394054, -0.05003919079899788, 0.013528943993151188, 0.030310077592730522, 0.07664310187101364, 0.042009416967630386, 0.038198161870241165, 0.022343657910823822, 0.023571163415908813, -0.010621936060488224, -0.012448168359696865, -0.13369527459144592, -0.04150252416729927, -0.013522794470191002, 0.033062972128391266, 0.0085531584918499, 0.03808506578207016, 0.012968258000910282, 0.011277941055595875, -0.011984582990407944, -0.0037582970689982176, 0.00539768161252141, 0.02503037266433239, 0.07596971839666367, -0.02413683757185936, 0.006069106049835682, -0.019702613353729248, 0.07324835658073425, -0.00031930836848914623, -0.020580744370818138, 0.008658794686198235, -0.020136363804340363, 0.0006539251771755517, -0.04503488913178444, -0.021591011434793472, -0.0014224498299881816, 0.03801516816020012, 0.033181268721818924, 0.016508521512150764, 0.02701622247695923, 0.04348546639084816, 0.02588985301554203, 0.06844987720251083, -0.018237896263599396, -0.025798941031098366, 0.01105126179754734, -0.04344872757792473, 0.047718729823827744, -0.011788169853389263, -0.0017085104482248425, 0.030344158411026, 0.020444579422473907, 0.018128596246242523, 0.026152169331908226, -0.29440784454345703, -0.029714498668909073, 0.05580860376358032, -0.004702871665358543, 0.05420630797743797, -0.05029527470469475, 0.027893994003534317, -0.01911131665110588, -0.009482466615736485, 0.023137999698519707, 0.029086468741297722, 0.004247777629643679, 0.0034584698732942343, 0.06372139602899551, 0.06132366508245468, 0.01641518622636795, 0.019339067861437798, -0.014450917020440102, 0.03896017372608185, 0.0004949910216964781, -0.013683595694601536, -0.06778691709041595, -0.0011641948949545622, 0.017972370609641075, -0.02022906392812729, 0.03279103338718414, -0.052408747375011444, 0.006231797393411398, -0.0445847250521183, -0.01666015014052391, 0.028308656066656113, -0.020151913166046143, -0.02226724475622177, 0.0211959108710289, -0.01438076701015234, -0.014583347365260124, 0.007130551151931286, -0.008152211084961891, 0.023239566013216972, 0.010244578123092651, 0.011462543159723282, -0.0037415886763483286, 0.005221427883952856, -0.005396624561399221, 0.09138155728578568, -0.003923471551388502, -0.028965819627046585, 0.01915944553911686, -0.05353669822216034, 0.013981951400637627, 0.013090303167700768, -0.022126244381070137, 0.003956926986575127, 0.008923222310841084, 0.004578887484967709, -0.026596426963806152, -0.0165801290422678, -0.023101268336176872, -0.017735997214913368, 0.010795298963785172, 0.011499105952680111, -0.06002133712172508, -0.03118579275906086, -0.05176452919840813, -0.03134757652878761, -0.041569553315639496, -0.05677862465381622, -0.09451544284820557, 0.01763588935136795, 0.03284647688269615, -0.007243939209729433, 0.02485910803079605, -0.020547905936837196, -0.08049540966749191, 0.03458172827959061, -0.04620855301618576, 0.00573116447776556, -0.016033928841352463, 0.01189889945089817, 0.025544915348291397, -0.024253327399492264, -0.06361930072307587, 0.03142211213707924, -0.004822933580726385, 0.01540293451398611, 0.0039962162263691425, 0.013816528022289276, -0.032152678817510605, -0.014403893612325191, -0.037742532789707184, 0.04731079190969467, 0.013692702166736126, 0.021633299067616463, 0.017960192635655403, 0.01639505848288536, 0.08967821300029755, -0.0025985033717006445, 0.04711245745420456, 0.016545196995139122, 0.014113043434917927, 0.014653194695711136, -0.08527838438749313, -0.024224737659096718, -0.06422340869903564, -0.09066131711006165, 0.003602013224735856, -0.002505530370399356, -0.02376065030694008, 0.02807832695543766, -0.011258281767368317, 0.021190382540225983, -0.06905865669250488, 0.014103386551141739, -0.015773268416523933, -0.03357941284775734, 0.0023372904397547245, -0.019356075674295425, 0.030943546444177628, 0.014106991700828075, -0.015751061961054802, -0.008239270187914371, 0.04196685180068016, -0.03412723168730736, -0.03151773288846016, 0.005673917941749096, -0.04066264256834984, 0.02179710566997528, 0.021223776042461395, -0.0014164643362164497, -0.02737567201256752, -0.020783331245183945, 0.03303292393684387, 0.0022865389473736286, 0.015381790697574615, 0.03681301325559616, 0.016017364338040352, -0.007454622071236372, 0.012763384729623795, 0.04501185938715935, -0.015458560548722744, 0.009830256924033165, -0.008326473645865917, 0.04764905199408531, 0.02785322070121765, 0.04249715805053711, 0.007531120907515287, 0.022275099530816078, -0.010951889678835869, 0.011707566678524017, -0.013803551904857159, 0.0011588467750698328, -0.008637710474431515, -0.025785215198993683, 0.01244545727968216, -0.010439146310091019, -0.016902312636375427, 0.06751903891563416, -0.007504686247557402, -0.00459563871845603, -0.07153350859880447, 0.04781869053840637, 0.022659705951809883, -0.0180390365421772, -0.0025783029850572348, -0.006136626470834017, 0.06440050154924393, -0.03288719430565834, -0.05654752999544144, 0.03084281086921692, 0.032478734850883484, -0.013104833662509918, -0.026645777747035027, -0.020976828411221504, 0.013912376947700977, -0.0702371746301651, 0.006070572417229414, 0.009086164645850658, -0.0022157561033964157, -0.05948065593838692, 0.02177446335554123, 0.012022741138935089, -0.015617689117789268, -0.00012328459706623107, 0.021693293005228043, 0.058367613703012466, 0.019608624279499054, -0.028984712436795235, 0.00002189361293858383, -0.011867808178067207, 0.04227495938539505, -0.028688155114650726, 0.025974707677960396, -0.003004708793014288, -0.012909646145999432, -0.017659034579992294, -0.05839115008711815, 0.00912674143910408, 0.029242556542158127, 0.004532362800091505, -0.013850840739905834, -0.016575515270233154, -0.006556803826242685, -0.05816882848739624, -0.03621848300099373, 0.006701588165014982, -0.07930602133274078, 0.0290088914334774, 0.045509036630392075, -0.03301715850830078, -0.00027268414851278067, -0.05776696652173996, -0.032762523740530014, -0.03612729534506798, -0.024640969932079315, -0.004320213105529547, 0.015465646050870419, -0.02788412943482399, 0.0064460220746695995, -0.012658908031880856, -0.0352359414100647, 0.01661612093448639, -0.03633078187704086, -0.0000729399616830051, 0.028137821704149246, 0.002834502374753356, 0.052022047340869904, -0.015249405056238174, 0.03632741421461105, -0.021414870396256447, 0.00018044647003989667, 0.023977741599082947, -0.03111208975315094, -0.0061746621504426, 0.011363254860043526, -0.02065042033791542, 0.036642786115407944, -0.0409361906349659, 0.03738754242658615, -0.015668530017137527, 0.00646336330100894, -0.022966239601373672, -0.020121442154049873, 0.014288833364844322, 0.010515800677239895, 0.003139753360301256, -0.0018066384363919497, 0.034184593707323074, 0.02253425493836403, 0.01577693782746792, -0.004355727694928646, 0.008195732720196247, -0.0035643104929476976, -0.08940723538398743, 0.02806883491575718, 0.07292389124631882, -0.020783379673957825, -0.024033494293689728, -0.07092179358005524, -0.03776570409536362, 0.03126315400004387, -0.001732701319269836, 0.011747118085622787, -0.006351253017783165, 0.03636452928185463, 0.011950536631047726, 0.04174346104264259, -0.006190584972500801, -0.030673805624246597, 0.0002727090904954821, -0.0349511057138443, 0.03634745255112648, -0.025251928716897964, -0.0392610989511013, 0.08315559476613998, -0.058462049812078476, 0.013388806022703648, 0.001443429384380579, -0.03937038034200668, 0.018287813290953636, -0.05608867481350899, -0.04797522723674774, 0.014443979598581791, -0.043594155460596085, 0.006165545433759689, 0.003612215630710125, -0.032047685235738754, -0.02231903187930584, -0.035176049917936325, -0.04708234965801239, 0.004356760997325182, 0.029838846996426582, 0.05914966017007828, -0.023292461410164833, 0.0299465823918581, -0.026395194232463837, 0.04635104909539223, 0.02761753648519516, 0.07745355367660522, 0.03357682004570961, 0.021968072280287743, -0.06038237363100052, 0.0776226669549942, 0.028822317719459534, 0.0004095745098311454, 0.020723136141896248, 0.02044154331088066, -0.005167079623788595, -0.03990616649389267, 0.034884389489889145, 0.024516765028238297, -0.04700446128845215, -0.04285386949777603, 0.0500044971704483, 0.005342619493603706, -0.04384929686784744, -0.012171080335974693, 0.012348699383437634, -0.05993970111012459, 0.020692987367510796, -0.007375719025731087, -0.002692365786060691, 0.013024646788835526, 0.04373076930642128, 0.026601677760481834, 0.013872847892343998, 0.08462533354759216, -0.028222138062119484, -0.014886360615491867, 0.007205810863524675, 0.0695657730102539, 0.052078332751989365, 0.030554786324501038, -0.007130474783480167, 0.040727660059928894, -0.04445116966962814, -0.0425102561712265, 0.02261495031416416, 0.004801583010703325, 0.008172258734703064, -0.035616710782051086, 0.028682274743914604, 0.05642853304743767, 0.03358735144138336, 0.052658528089523315, -0.058904070407152176, 0.01787019893527031, 0.03065621852874756, 0.020221950486302376, -0.029325880110263824, -0.0031717652454972267, -0.008859495632350445, -0.01354827731847763, -0.008073720149695873, -0.024929258972406387, -0.0015904000028967857, -0.007358259987086058, 0.004527661483734846, -0.0012969974195584655, 0.008902516216039658, 0.005497084930539131, 0.008993207477033138, 0.0642593577504158, 0.08232646435499191, -0.02920958399772644, -0.05722702294588089, -0.0010218654060736299, 0.026881929486989975, 0.007626069709658623, 0.034716904163360596, 0.051602184772491455, -0.012422272004187107, 0.002984806429594755, -0.012718296609818935, 0.056726668030023575, 0.019230250269174576, 0.002798470901325345, -0.007824334315955639, -0.008158661425113678, -0.0592271126806736, 0.016487613320350647, -0.02470998279750347, -0.06737352907657623, -0.03978504613041878, -0.0067979576997458935, -0.007334069348871708, -0.06187385693192482, -0.057500556111335754, 0.04237879812717438, 0.00618528900668025, -0.025687675923109055, -0.00196616118773818, 0.011528227478265762, 0.033295631408691406, 0.0630553737282753, -0.023884514346718788, 0.029012000188231468, 0.04018118977546692, 0.01117419172078371, -0.0005187474889680743, 0.02257661148905754, 0.008087513968348503, 0.0035259402357041836, -0.037787746638059616, 0.05369693040847778, 0.004931447561830282, 0.004026595503091812, 0.0016850137617439032, -0.0008008770528249443, -0.0717354416847229, -0.011554975993931293, 0.059721726924180984, -0.06862874329090118, -0.08655820041894913, 0.0746927484869957, -0.008663550950586796, 0.012683434411883354, 0.07485518604516983, -0.0001521802187198773, -0.016588222235441208, -0.03059094212949276, -0.03494586423039436, -0.020344795659184456, 0.018794013187289238, 0.007532346528023481, 0.000002282132072650711, 0.05768686160445213, 0.05645718798041344, -0.0009558440651744604, -0.03411673754453659, 0.01895776391029358, 0.006456725765019655, 0.00009192533616442233, -0.02289353683590889, -0.010793918743729591, -0.03158771991729736, -0.11767629534006119, -0.012435510754585266, 0.01819581538438797, -0.04679599776864052, -0.03142959624528885, 0.007841130718588829, 0.011753986589610577, 0.000016078620319603942, 0.004155965521931648, -0.01712287776172161, -0.017060264945030212, -0.041753072291612625, -0.02229362539947033, -0.07033919543027878, 0.03072224371135235, -0.010108002461493015, 0.024938425049185753, -0.017503058537840843, -0.07478233426809311, -0.02870308794081211, -0.02300768345594406, 0.03533060848712921, 0.01889164187014103, 0.010708369314670563, -0.03211222589015961 ]
3,556
Discovering Temporally Compositional Neural Manifolds with Switching Infinite GPFA
https://openreview.net/forum?id=2iCIHgE8KG
[ "Changmin Yu", "Maneesh Sahani", "Máté Lengyel" ]
Spotlight
Gaussian Process Factor Analysis (GPFA) is a powerful latent variable model for extracting low-dimensional manifolds underlying population neural activities. However, one limitation of standard GPFA models is that the number of latent factors needs to be pre-specified or selected through heuristic-based processes, and that all factors contribute at all times. We propose the infinite GPFA model, a fully Bayesian non-parametric extension of the classical GPFA by incorporating an Indian Buffet Process (IBP) prior over the factor loading process, such that it is possible to infer a potentially infinite set of latent factors, and the identity of those factors that contribute to neural firings in a compositional manner at \textit{each} time point. Learning and inference in the infinite GPFA model is performed through variational expectation-maximisation, and we additionally propose scalable extensions based on sparse variational Gaussian Process methods. We empirically demonstrate that the infinite GPFA model correctly infers dynamically changing activations of latent factors on a synthetic dataset. By fitting the infinite GPFA model to population activities of hippocampal place cells during spatial tasks with alternating random foraging and spatial memory phases, we identify novel non-trivial and behaviourally meaningful dynamics in the neural encoding process.
Computational neuroscience, neural data analysis, Bayesian nonparametrics, latent variable modelling;
We propose a fully Bayesian nonparametric extension of GPFA that enables discovery of temporally compositional neural manifolds underlying high-dimensional population neuronal activities.
5,086
null
[ -0.0053077139891684055, -0.001120863831602037, 0.013899161480367184, 0.00463495310395956, 0.012526819482445717, 0.04698813334107399, 0.03683999925851822, 0.04573877155780792, -0.04531370848417282, -0.04222594201564789, 0.004189212340861559, -0.017487380653619766, -0.06520723551511765, 0.017992056906223297, 0.011208714917302132, 0.03735261783003807, 0.041564032435417175, -0.04100705683231354, -0.009184179827570915, 0.009815757162868977, -0.008712761104106903, 0.024858098477125168, 0.00859512947499752, 0.011030553840100765, 0.029112134128808975, 0.012870505452156067, 0.03814573585987091, -0.010657683946192265, 0.01351770106703043, 0.0013231231132522225, 0.0044022779911756516, 0.01794731430709362, 0.0008159090066328645, -0.022358402609825134, 0.017165789380669594, -0.026017416268587112, -0.04106844961643219, 0.0016822924371808767, 0.001963309943675995, 0.027016185224056244, -0.05237387493252754, -0.011281921528279781, -0.019402990117669106, 0.013833845034241676, -0.049959696829319, 0.016300160437822342, -0.10050222277641296, 0.03319690003991127, 0.017565159127116203, -0.0394412986934185, -0.09072967618703842, 0.021392954513430595, 0.02398975007236004, -0.0029832792934030294, 0.0033984817564487457, 0.017921412363648415, 0.030826859176158905, -0.06055941805243492, -0.005810978356748819, -0.03801633417606354, -0.041876211762428284, -0.001295851543545723, 0.02216697484254837, -0.0000893445685505867, -0.018661469221115112, 0.01662316359579563, 0.019613878801465034, 0.06050536036491394, -0.019011443480849266, -0.011115708388388157, -0.017720868811011314, 0.001305500860325992, 0.0073420824483036995, 0.026453698053956032, -0.01457868330180645, -0.03695607930421829, 0.031634390354156494, 0.023463556542992592, 0.07565119862556458, 0.0037771190982311964, 0.016644956544041634, 0.021269990131258965, 0.021204423159360886, 0.035079266875982285, -0.004305005539208651, 0.005302648991346359, -0.020672911778092384, -0.033662162721157074, -0.07420504838228226, 0.02907533384859562, -0.03277013823390007, -0.042450856417417526, -0.017704732716083527, 0.028954291716217995, 0.01145975012332201, -0.016892654821276665, 0.04458918422460556, -0.002031745621934533, -0.004921149928122759, 0.018639633432030678, -0.034310076385736465, -0.015219573862850666, -0.024561462923884392, -0.0018839570693671703, -0.09532137215137482, -0.032582368701696396, -0.02590257301926613, -0.029949085786938667, -0.017289672046899796, 0.01674358919262886, -0.02872578054666519, 0.010562346316874027, 0.025842534378170967, -0.013400509022176266, -0.07456326484680176, 0.010613016784191132, -0.000815790263004601, 0.0232631117105484, 0.0003888107312377542, -0.00587191479280591, 0.06851133704185486, 0.03342745080590248, -0.0020479734521359205, 0.05966801568865776, -0.01548800989985466, 0.008806813508272171, 0.02700744941830635, 0.015868443995714188, -0.03392030671238899, -0.039279621094465256, 0.028875090181827545, 0.037014905363321304, 0.012829519808292389, 0.0018932698294520378, -0.007882880046963692, -0.03446397930383682, -0.005790067370980978, 0.040739573538303375, 0.03976476937532425, -0.0020924631971865892, 0.022082438692450523, -0.043447889387607574, 0.021130211651325226, -0.03824199363589287, 0.05192013457417488, -0.023574426770210266, -0.025515053421258926, -0.024146122857928276, -0.05188819020986557, -0.026578160002827644, -0.008058475330471992, -0.007971717976033688, 0.009290284477174282, -0.09245232492685318, 0.012362947687506676, 0.05215894803404808, 0.013004790991544724, 0.022447125986218452, 0.014459501020610332, -0.012883542105555534, 0.03033379651606083, 0.009661721996963024, -0.03473389148712158, 0.05145833641290665, -0.008329736068844795, -0.06314373761415482, 0.02859841100871563, 0.01609831675887108, -0.05683383345603943, 0.0009643675875850022, -0.036749135702848434, -0.049171268939971924, 0.04145783931016922, 0.006560453213751316, -0.03071681223809719, -0.03722104802727699, 0.05887056514620781, -0.005797895602881908, 0.03070429526269436, 0.004094012547284365, -0.08578626066446304, 0.010570816695690155, 0.008562233299016953, 0.006819421425461769, 0.022081153467297554, -0.03336840867996216, 0.07321078330278397, -0.05122959613800049, -0.0010805929778143764, 0.0297633558511734, -0.044539280235767365, 0.008192997425794601, 0.010055173188447952, 0.0015542625915259123, 0.0833899974822998, 0.017765456810593605, -0.048417601734399796, 0.03352397680282593, 0.07130533456802368, 0.054935701191425323, 0.03670220822095871, -0.06250734627246857, 0.021565867587924004, -0.015155415050685406, -0.024460840970277786, -0.023228464648127556, 0.061977360397577286, -0.04218631237745285, -0.022684741765260696, 0.035848554223775864, -0.009662117809057236, 0.0031306673772633076, 0.0017940780380740762, 0.0032821649219840765, 0.022167999297380447, 0.01787034422159195, 0.022226743400096893, 0.02796744741499424, 0.002615240402519703, -0.05440553277730942, 0.010707591660320759, -0.0007518603815697134, -0.019130311906337738, -0.007149366661906242, -0.019627267494797707, 0.11124250292778015, 0.07369298487901688, -0.039186861366033554, 0.012949422001838684, 0.0356447659432888, 0.023658499121665955, 0.00699677225202322, 0.018119290471076965, -0.015880683436989784, 0.02864680252969265, 0.009688690304756165, 0.02271890640258789, -0.04063121974468231, 0.061009228229522705, -0.06209916993975639, -0.014623892493546009, 0.04508272930979729, -0.015573377721011639, 0.05910519137978554, -0.024779461324214935, 0.004879783373326063, 0.0450342521071434, -0.003336513414978981, -0.03602872043848038, -0.03600850701332092, -0.0420558787882328, 0.0024269139394164085, -0.006425553001463413, -0.01489848829805851, 0.010526794008910656, -0.06075992435216904, -0.017863545566797256, -0.03163260221481323, 0.06439164280891418, 0.05306068807840347, 0.004532592836767435, 0.018749799579381943, 0.009349402040243149, -0.03551319241523743, -0.029041461646556854, -0.1205323189496994, -0.02817862667143345, -0.0206922460347414, 0.0422993041574955, 0.012138988822698593, 0.012152398005127907, -0.011341774836182594, 0.028888601809740067, -0.009261569939553738, -0.015885034576058388, -0.009907702915370464, 0.007842987775802612, -0.008930609561502934, -0.018991198390722275, -0.0309560876339674, 0.0316353403031826, 0.058189522475004196, -0.020992355421185493, -0.007557158824056387, -0.011885878629982471, -0.050621915608644485, -0.016049783676862717, 0.01615794561803341, 0.017649130895733833, 0.006320231128484011, 0.007043702527880669, 0.005798476282507181, -0.026425762102007866, 0.013913873583078384, 0.014496913179755211, 0.0836753100156784, 0.04175526648759842, -0.0015922869788482785, -0.02723286673426628, 0.03212878480553627, 0.01677273027598858, 0.051142025738954544, 0.018778270110487938, 0.010278953239321709, 0.002330724149942398, -0.011231005191802979, -0.00938540231436491, -0.02399406023323536, -0.2638634741306305, -0.015240793116390705, 0.011345228180289268, -0.009249463677406311, 0.02458142302930355, 0.02017616480588913, 0.05093817412853241, -0.03636212646961212, 0.0029705821070820093, 0.013795765116810799, -0.014532727189362049, 0.025136534124612808, -0.004336431156843901, 0.09373244643211365, 0.03243476152420044, -0.009981581941246986, -0.015263947658240795, -0.009263705462217331, 0.012516501359641552, 0.025467097759246826, -0.030448393896222115, -0.05176801607012749, -0.01808948814868927, 0.023144138976931572, -0.01730980910360813, 0.039966169744729996, -0.060956768691539764, -0.02062596008181572, -0.03861916810274124, -0.0006000465946272016, -0.03210889548063278, -0.04920065030455589, 0.023796720430254936, 0.06645309180021286, 0.006038542836904526, -0.0002650272799655795, -0.007433370221406221, -0.018030500039458275, 0.022057536989450455, 0.01630205661058426, 0.009105325676500797, -0.0007274231174960732, -0.001945994095876813, 0.014843328855931759, 0.07683484256267548, -0.003661021590232849, -0.04079386964440346, -0.011430438607931137, -0.01682071015238762, 0.021741021424531937, -0.012718050740659237, 0.00010791938984766603, -0.022140027955174446, -0.009828001260757446, -0.004257252439856529, -0.009052078239619732, -0.004004319664090872, -0.012780524790287018, 0.002139775548130274, -0.00904459785670042, 0.0121517488732934, -0.03665202483534813, -0.00876068975776434, -0.052070312201976776, -0.014695452526211739, -0.02288820594549179, -0.07472178339958191, -0.06625233590602875, 0.06302117556333542, 0.04503445327281952, -0.019192958250641823, 0.0008927438757382333, -0.026332026347517967, -0.09792906045913696, 0.02913198433816433, 0.01493080984801054, -0.023917583748698235, 0.0035361533518880606, -0.00503090675920248, 0.04003939777612686, -0.029812900349497795, -0.03417007252573967, -0.00864558108150959, 0.009949525818228722, 0.034525878727436066, 0.0007061486248858273, -0.012208259664475918, -0.013223393820226192, -0.0368080772459507, -0.043235696852207184, 0.04574134945869446, 0.012613451108336449, 0.060466498136520386, -0.016941267997026443, 0.03214271739125252, 0.050812408328056335, 0.02920360118150711, 0.06792765110731125, 0.041946832090616226, -0.01033465750515461, 0.07074207067489624, -0.07414417713880539, -0.03746310621500015, -0.02191014029085636, -0.020839009433984756, 0.03550823777914047, -0.07487815618515015, -0.02940705046057701, 0.05095670744776726, 0.014630206860601902, -0.014143683016300201, -0.001682781265117228, -0.017547236755490303, -0.014649391174316406, 0.008046938106417656, -0.03466496989130974, 0.00449034757912159, 0.056853998452425, 0.026506057009100914, -0.011129355989396572, -0.027617506682872772, 0.004837021231651306, -0.054451871663331985, 0.02629963308572769, 0.013252239674329758, -0.0007858739700168371, -0.009592048823833466, -0.056133389472961426, 0.02408076450228691, 0.023053407669067383, 0.043059613555669785, 0.03629382699728012, 0.014026295393705368, 0.025476962327957153, 0.04813193157315254, -0.018284212797880173, 0.0034504292998462915, 0.007589721120893955, 0.03788447380065918, -0.031496044248342514, 0.049461979418992996, 0.002480674535036087, 0.04122093692421913, 0.010266169905662537, 0.010927127674221992, 0.009976893663406372, 0.00616668863222003, 0.005241947714239359, 0.005716734565794468, -0.026495330035686493, 0.05111195519566536, -0.04834293946623802, -0.056382112205028534, -0.014833180233836174, -0.023254329338669777, -0.0068177212961018085, 0.027893630787730217, -0.016058744862675667, 0.003390401368960738, -0.06633781641721725, 0.03588571399450302, 0.00214973883703351, -0.04801192879676819, 0.0014580925926566124, 0.006675786338746548, 0.07192129641771317, -0.007036254741251469, 0.03071466274559498, 0.04265904054045677, -0.0017943145940080285, 0.03199240565299988, 0.002718308474868536, 0.006579338572919369, -0.03256009891629219, -0.010728737339377403, -0.00647767074406147, -0.0025297794491052628, -0.01921672374010086, -0.059581056237220764, 0.05074664205312729, 0.02490127459168434, -0.027042174711823463, 0.005427285563200712, -0.01390077080577612, 0.06682518869638443, 0.019946377724409103, 0.009597237221896648, -0.0027260391507297754, -0.028748096898198128, 0.038992203772068024, -0.025577520951628685, -0.0019268831238150597, -0.03793683275580406, -0.053652942180633545, -0.022910740226507187, -0.042175497859716415, -0.00014942568668629974, 0.03517603501677513, 0.0012101461179554462, -0.048420947045087814, 0.0018890677019953728, -0.0040065934881567955, -0.04249824583530426, 0.008133497089147568, 0.07900825142860413, -0.05933205783367157, 0.008638366125524044, 0.029747163876891136, -0.010347646661102772, 0.021312104538083076, -0.02116524614393711, -0.030738312751054764, -0.05539888143539429, -0.05589922145009041, 0.014997304417192936, 0.005888506304472685, -0.013997314497828484, -0.04537922516465187, -0.0040293410420417786, -0.0006949002272449434, 0.0058881849981844425, 0.024058837443590164, -0.016824275255203247, -0.04105651006102562, 0.01821003295481205, 0.043188802897930145, -0.02473600022494793, 0.004989723674952984, 0.020068615674972534, 0.0008990023634396493, 0.01026748027652502, -0.03205811604857445, -0.011670980602502823, 0.04979744553565979, -0.019100191071629524, -0.036078210920095444, -0.02708277478814125, 0.0353536382317543, 0.01226093526929617, 0.008785560727119446, 0.010548839345574379, 0.0004920435603708029, -0.028251653537154198, -0.014430893585085869, -0.019371939823031425, 0.039121389389038086, 0.011545187793672085, 0.03723915293812752, 0.020038267597556114, 0.01932644471526146, -0.005098206922411919, 0.00352358422242105, -0.05384638532996178, -0.02088601142168045, 0.044612787663936615, -0.007862233556807041, -0.010765096172690392, -0.07196950167417526, -0.005873761605471373, 0.021148808300495148, 0.01414387859404087, 0.00008723262726562098, -0.047508273273706436, 0.04094020277261734, 0.0365559421479702, 0.02150590531527996, 0.01401454396545887, -0.002505610464140773, 0.05090548098087311, -0.06586077064275742, 0.015167392790317535, -0.04951908439397812, -0.03614058718085289, 0.03728596866130829, -0.04242267832159996, -0.011665087193250656, 0.008120331913232803, -0.053362954407930374, 0.06451122462749481, -0.041833728551864624, -0.048068445175886154, 0.028363065794110298, -0.03294465318322182, -0.009355553425848484, 0.020670045167207718, -0.0711611658334732, -0.0075093419291079044, -0.04804002121090889, -0.04127754643559456, 0.019613763317465782, 0.05504715070128441, 0.03839952498674393, -0.005162729416042566, 0.034035179764032364, 0.00474643474444747, 0.029285095632076263, 0.04056323319673538, 0.10016343742609024, 0.01587827131152153, 0.035454172641038895, -0.03847179189324379, 0.0740867555141449, 0.032322969287633896, 0.03594755753874779, 0.0002184045733883977, 0.0009307699510827661, -0.01483991276472807, -0.065140500664711, 0.015063585713505745, -0.0041380091570317745, -0.013871167786419392, -0.0680229514837265, 0.042882051318883896, 0.013630170375108719, -0.05408221855759621, -0.02473432943224907, 0.02951638214290142, -0.06142277643084526, -0.0034114932641386986, 0.02858865261077881, 0.009089435450732708, -0.014396176673471928, 0.06100765988230705, 0.02203253284096718, 0.05852716416120529, 0.06530847400426865, 0.033489566296339035, -0.013238547369837761, 0.013033784925937653, 0.07200497388839722, 0.06099090352654457, -0.013460103422403336, 0.017560673877596855, 0.07887301594018936, -0.003359769470989704, -0.054372165352106094, 0.051573801785707474, -0.0021045245230197906, -0.02859058976173401, -0.049249593168497086, 0.03860395774245262, 0.08887122571468353, 0.020521817728877068, 0.08936578035354614, -0.0333271324634552, 0.00747394235804677, 0.05641654133796692, 0.02235741913318634, -0.009009109809994698, 0.005737733095884323, 0.0646185353398323, 0.023954354226589203, -0.004937696270644665, -0.039773885160684586, -0.047763511538505554, -0.039861299097537994, 0.01787639781832695, 0.0327020101249218, -0.015575230121612549, 0.03279098495841026, -0.0009304131381213665, 0.030285662040114403, 0.09963691234588623, 0.00846425537019968, -0.014853817410767078, -0.013954102993011475, 0.01709546335041523, 0.03276615962386131, 0.04216531291604042, -0.01880921609699726, 0.01314837671816349, -0.006475245580077171, -0.039796438068151474, 0.030149180442094803, 0.005308183841407299, 0.006792909931391478, -0.0032591726630926132, -0.056842610239982605, 0.01570974662899971, -0.008429903537034988, 0.01912844553589821, -0.0309415515512228, -0.05302825942635536, -0.012258829548954964, -0.0480506531894207, -0.0679754912853241, -0.03484372794628143, 0.03135077282786369, -0.03304499015212059, -0.04824768006801605, -0.014922263100743294, -0.009689784608781338, 0.011465014889836311, 0.005303764715790749, -0.06530378013849258, -0.02684018760919571, 0.0708475336432457, -0.011463507078588009, 0.00766739621758461, 0.006243500392884016, 0.0495888814330101, 0.0006676573539152741, -0.02309512533247471, 0.022419698536396027, -0.008556770160794258, 0.01156968716531992, -0.031082361936569214, -0.019647158682346344, -0.11138296127319336, 0.05083470046520233, 0.007877771742641926, -0.03246128559112549, -0.08987724035978317, 0.021535011008381844, -0.009005030617117882, 0.01642589643597603, 0.053359538316726685, -0.027045341208577156, 0.002979754004627466, -0.06861566007137299, -0.011683967895805836, -0.002474480075761676, -0.03345954790711403, 0.07328560948371887, -0.029511818662285805, 0.05867645889520645, 0.053439948707818985, -0.003062518546357751, -0.03841396048665047, 0.04669633507728577, -0.022198587656021118, 0.006818816997110844, -0.03204923868179321, -0.06236186996102333, -0.026159396395087242, -0.11203759908676147, -0.01103143859654665, 0.01591714285314083, -0.01237836480140686, -0.029161857441067696, 0.004427902400493622, -0.029353655874729156, 0.008819245733320713, -0.030565951019525528, -0.004144150298088789, -0.016394926235079765, -0.01101519912481308, -0.03949318826198578, -0.06913572549819946, -0.003201851388439536, -0.013666048645973206, 0.0005291968118399382, -0.04387689381837845, -0.0255796667188406, -0.04872811958193779, -0.002436015522107482, 0.02756848931312561, -0.0014603865565732121, 0.0018432247452437878, 0.00944723840802908 ]
3,557
Presto! Distilling Steps and Layers for Accelerating Music Generation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Gj5JTAwdoy
[ "Zachary Novack", "Ge Zhu", "Jonah Casebeer", "Julian McAuley", "Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick", "Nicholas J. Bryan" ]
Spotlight
Despite advances in diffusion-based text-to-music (TTM) methods, efficient, high-quality generation remains a challenge. We introduce Presto!, an approach to inference acceleration for score-based diffusion transformers via reducing both sampling steps and cost per step. To reduce steps, we develop a new score-based distribution matching distillation (DMD) method for the EDM-family of diffusion models, the first GAN-based distillation method for TTM. To reduce the cost per step, we develop a simple, but powerful improvement to a recent layer distillation method that improves learning via better preserving hidden state variance. Finally, we combine our step and layer distillation methods together for a dual-faceted approach. We evaluate our step and layer distillation methods independently and show each yield best-in-class performance. Our combined distillation method can generate high-quality outputs with improved diversity, accelerating our base model by 10-18x (230/435ms latency for 32 second mono/stereo 44.1kHz, 15x faster than the comparable SOTA model) — the fastest TTM to our knowledge.
music generation, diffusion distillation, diffusion, diffusion acceleration, text-to-music generation, layer dropping
null
4,966
2410.05167
[ -0.01951269805431366, -0.032084301114082336, 0.009254823438823223, 0.06475640088319778, 0.054550014436244965, -0.007451651152223349, 0.03217955306172371, 0.0028782656881958246, -0.002327058929949999, -0.03517625480890274, -0.011952067725360394, 0.0011793174780905247, -0.0442487969994545, 0.0064651551656425, 0.0035836421884596348, 0.06027977913618088, 0.052585940808057785, -0.04801814630627632, 0.008371332660317421, 0.004024284891784191, 0.0012743279803544283, -0.026650408282876015, 0.0307927206158638, 0.028741316869854927, -0.008614996448159218, -0.019846204668283463, 0.006393606774508953, -0.009688152000308037, -0.039873894304037094, 0.0039452784694731236, 0.044364601373672485, 0.01274648867547512, 0.020886948332190514, -0.039643317461013794, 0.01957870088517666, 0.009464627131819725, -0.05387022718787193, 0.00028060685144737363, 0.008883185684680939, 0.0017361046047881246, -0.027434810996055603, -0.005102215334773064, 0.007107499986886978, -0.003049927530810237, -0.052342791110277176, 0.000028634654881898314, -0.08242779225111008, 0.05073397979140282, -0.02809249609708786, -0.040759358555078506, -0.08873923867940903, 0.014803715981543064, -0.01834448054432869, -0.008105908520519733, 0.02580779790878296, -0.010268458165228367, 0.018553147092461586, -0.03804432228207588, -0.0020762435160577297, -0.043945424258708954, -0.010511753149330616, 0.00375783140771091, -0.0014193570241332054, -0.028487425297498703, 0.009961605072021484, -0.044612400233745575, -0.008914903737604618, 0.05353207141160965, -0.05597585067152977, -0.058535393327474594, 0.01658005826175213, 0.029326077550649643, -0.004545251838862896, 0.005387919023633003, -0.004666276276111603, -0.03398849070072174, 0.05018160492181778, 0.008450901135802269, 0.06193732097744942, 0.02551412582397461, 0.025834333151578903, -0.00046856704284437, 0.02946186624467373, 0.0479300357401371, -0.0277875829488039, 0.004271449521183968, -0.017686324194073677, 0.026712829247117043, -0.0715760663151741, 0.018899759277701378, -0.037248533219099045, -0.047463417053222656, 0.028933025896549225, 0.022924894466996193, 0.03286905959248543, -0.008672548457980156, 0.038262028247117996, 0.013998890295624733, 0.020930012688040733, 0.007901487872004509, -0.004906460642814636, -0.0383889302611351, 0.020047973841428757, -0.0031725468579679728, -0.09814151376485825, -0.00739528052508831, -0.011373690329492092, -0.005532607436180115, 0.022229691967368126, -0.005672468338161707, -0.0007380445022135973, 0.001076245796866715, 0.015272965654730797, 0.002504102885723114, -0.06228072941303253, 0.019245877861976624, 0.00786669086664915, 0.009338215924799442, -0.0031630038283765316, -0.0036381185054779053, 0.0755261778831482, 0.04485974833369255, 0.003690167795866728, 0.05911000072956085, -0.021634887903928757, 0.04270957037806511, 0.04324701800942421, 0.040978431701660156, 0.009816505946218967, -0.010908924974501133, -0.015423141419887543, 0.03678259998559952, 0.03444301337003708, 0.007725399453192949, -0.014378822408616543, -0.021877538412809372, 0.006214867811650038, 0.03735753148794174, 0.06350935250520706, 0.0001613203639863059, 0.0213366337120533, -0.003955924417823553, 0.03168850019574165, -0.04646161198616028, 0.03001660853624344, -0.024096008390188217, -0.029228217899799347, -0.009537728503346443, -0.03635227680206299, 0.01886608824133873, 0.035343945026397705, 0.02895173989236355, -0.006746532395482063, -0.06345780938863754, 0.00046650550211779773, 0.042185161262750626, 0.015566091984510422, 0.006214890629053116, -0.020935608074069023, 0.02132618986070156, 0.014600050635635853, 0.027706434950232506, -0.02255645953118801, -0.021361542865633965, -0.0110579589381814, -0.03968934714794159, 0.024611053988337517, 0.045591942965984344, -0.03229182958602905, -0.03757635876536369, -0.028446512296795845, -0.02975221909582615, 0.0390407033264637, 0.0070734708569943905, -0.01827307790517807, -0.009023571386933327, 0.044259704649448395, 0.02138865925371647, 0.028181621804833412, 0.0476735457777977, -0.08993209898471832, 0.0357186384499073, 0.01870969869196415, -0.04376700520515442, -0.01009098719805479, -0.0076211923733353615, 0.07409512251615524, -0.011819357052445412, 0.008874498307704926, 0.032516609877347946, -0.09542254358530045, -0.03320290893316269, 0.03714841231703758, 0.004134913440793753, 0.05946040153503418, 0.019045252352952957, 0.0048241098411381245, 0.0050279684364795685, 0.061976950615644455, 0.03690328449010849, 0.07878958433866501, 0.002216718625277281, 0.03985569253563881, -0.036018915474414825, -0.016677532345056534, -0.005584965460002422, 0.022510770708322525, -0.09015586227178574, -0.041147008538246155, -0.02320380136370659, -0.01973065361380577, -0.04554087668657303, 0.020541300997138023, -0.005578565411269665, -0.0012575013097375631, -0.006506960839033127, -0.016153201460838318, 0.01810084655880928, 0.021003013476729393, -0.04641256481409073, 0.05592486634850502, 0.02817322313785553, -0.01275430154055357, 0.021673953160643578, -0.04015060141682625, 0.0926656723022461, 0.059668924659490585, -0.024743488058447838, 0.00014102367276791483, 0.002071595750749111, 0.003379961708560586, -0.016768788918852806, 0.01553696021437645, -0.02143690548837185, 0.018036404624581337, -0.01106151845306158, -0.013878311961889267, -0.020126765593886375, 0.04815000668168068, -0.05602116137742996, -0.027077725157141685, 0.05185798555612564, -0.047639671713113785, 0.08479534089565277, 0.014595511369407177, 0.023926597088575363, 0.023110616952180862, -0.02537369728088379, 0.006838959641754627, -0.030109593644738197, 0.0007251097122207284, 0.0019511955324560404, -0.002794987987726927, -0.022031350061297417, 0.01980050653219223, -0.03363844379782677, -0.01767711713910103, -0.005608347710222006, 0.017830224707722664, 0.01480956096202135, -0.015650594606995583, 0.03870675712823868, 0.06362666934728622, -0.05468810722231865, -0.024877551943063736, -0.11992645263671875, -0.06381970643997192, -0.0019155701156705618, 0.04485895112156868, -0.01697797328233719, 0.05880918353796005, 0.020790407434105873, 0.02301066368818283, -0.02308117039501667, -0.046490978449583054, 0.030150383710861206, 0.014927352778613567, 0.0011563239386305213, -0.021635230630636215, -0.04932249337434769, 0.0025017440784722567, 0.07734907418489456, -0.03615625575184822, -0.02796901948750019, -0.07058980315923691, -0.032643068581819534, 0.00667742732912302, -0.031713392585515976, 0.016226327046751976, 0.025191547349095345, 0.014128307811915874, 0.018895188346505165, -0.016695410013198853, 0.029695188626646996, 0.05100145936012268, 0.06382127851247787, 0.04558328166604042, -0.008496175520122051, -0.043760620057582855, 0.03662843257188797, -0.01911287195980549, 0.0054549272172153, 0.02651202119886875, 0.026398830115795135, -0.019509119912981987, -0.03777668625116348, 0.013612545095384121, 0.01095299981534481, -0.2818455696105957, -0.0012944135814905167, -0.03826506435871124, -0.021404793485999107, 0.05310199782252312, -0.05317217856645584, 0.020045539364218712, -0.027787890285253525, -0.006435307674109936, 0.02123134769499302, -0.027248723432421684, 0.07679688185453415, -0.00581825478002429, 0.023090224713087082, 0.033238962292671204, 0.012283300049602985, -0.027283985167741776, -0.030897231772542, -0.012918035499751568, 0.02965490333735943, 0.008545796386897564, -0.07705177366733551, -0.008979014120995998, 0.04182492941617966, -0.005431773141026497, 0.023606792092323303, -0.07177357375621796, 0.012586197815835476, -0.013117964379489422, 0.013238601386547089, 0.0030940494034439325, -0.047065578401088715, -0.0012988871894776821, 0.012996160425245762, -0.005793419200927019, 0.008160670287907124, 0.016624053940176964, 0.02585878223180771, 0.039686139672994614, 0.00623037526383996, 0.022889889776706696, -0.022140512242913246, 0.0010604376439005136, 0.020187944173812866, 0.04892662912607193, 0.028787603601813316, -0.04618650674819946, -0.010548042133450508, 0.006229503080248833, 0.06224771961569786, 0.008794255554676056, -0.03934086859226227, -0.03572003170847893, -0.010352893732488155, 0.013735893182456493, -0.04362243041396141, 0.02415052428841591, -0.014124317094683647, 0.008007659576833248, 0.04042753577232361, 0.007566764019429684, -0.04889862611889839, -0.023120636120438576, -0.015151518397033215, -0.01572621613740921, -0.022764509543776512, -0.05352439731359482, -0.038494136184453964, 0.03598526492714882, 0.03408871591091156, -0.012000557966530323, 0.009308898821473122, 0.0008229188970290124, -0.09297607839107513, -0.011707036755979061, 0.020128538832068443, -0.003978168126195669, -0.020667584612965584, -0.005436172243207693, 0.06236119568347931, -0.05378875136375427, -0.02809530682861805, -0.005569201894104481, -0.016193578019738197, 0.011761529371142387, -0.0014462751569226384, -0.023758843541145325, -0.029040591791272163, -0.030144499614834785, -0.03268997743725777, 0.06409816443920135, -0.018278954550623894, 0.01900521293282509, -0.019422497600317, 0.04888129606842995, 0.04053803160786629, 0.004328002687543631, 0.06053650379180908, 0.004822988528758287, -0.002929108450189233, 0.03649052605032921, -0.08719398081302643, -0.0532444603741169, -0.03341025859117508, 0.01338935736566782, -0.01232687197625637, -0.06512951105833054, -0.046405963599681854, 0.03628584370017052, -0.017971454188227654, -0.02472878433763981, -0.018013641238212585, 0.003432451980188489, -0.02081729657948017, -0.007493898272514343, -0.030359918251633644, 0.016756393015384674, 0.02961641736328602, 0.023310746997594833, -0.019202370196580887, 0.006102125160396099, 0.04184145852923393, -0.005769739393144846, 0.011525032110512257, -0.006781646981835365, 0.012764890678226948, 0.0022015338763594627, -0.016010237857699394, 0.010292435064911842, -0.02864687889814377, 0.013816268183290958, 0.029233397915959358, -0.01047268696129322, 0.01487900223582983, 0.03655659034848213, -0.031559426337480545, -0.010258646681904793, -0.021625611931085587, 0.040477652102708817, -0.008137756027281284, 0.0021687401458621025, -0.05001820623874664, 0.033462200313806534, 0.0011352490400895476, 0.06054225191473961, 0.02180028147995472, 0.016244880855083466, -0.0002303464279975742, -0.016954174265265465, -0.037689097225666046, 0.0451706126332283, -0.032183315604925156, -0.009893146343529224, -0.049886561930179596, 0.05503415688872337, -0.03374306857585907, 0.008023048751056194, -0.026410361751914024, 0.03897598013281822, -0.060728929936885834, 0.057750508189201355, 0.005763484165072441, -0.013336990028619766, -0.013468625023961067, 0.019158056005835533, 0.0378122478723526, -0.01294959057122469, -0.007593683432787657, 0.00571255199611187, -0.001912105712108314, 0.03670841082930565, -0.010738053359091282, -0.017021818086504936, -0.019489865750074387, 0.0020210840739309788, 0.02075202949345112, 0.023564757779240608, 0.005104216746985912, -0.04617246612906456, 0.07780468463897705, 0.02783302031457424, -0.02279548905789852, -0.0016338363057002425, 0.005443851463496685, 0.08838356286287308, 0.0069799879565835, 0.011418051086366177, -0.0024256764445453882, -0.03622666746377945, 0.026847073808312416, -0.07154484838247299, 0.0024233944714069366, -0.034154120832681656, -0.0809820219874382, -0.009878769516944885, -0.0553855337202549, -0.010922067798674107, 0.06260142475366592, -0.022685609757900238, -0.004828294739127159, -0.02156618982553482, -0.024196315556764603, -0.01679810881614685, -0.028202317655086517, 0.04344172030687332, -0.08542414754629135, 0.017190881073474884, 0.028456103056669235, -0.042586181312799454, -0.014669554308056831, 0.04094269499182701, -0.054775040596723557, -0.0753110721707344, -0.029446139931678772, -0.009264904074370861, -0.030985385179519653, -0.009490691125392914, -0.027009548619389534, 0.015475551597774029, 0.0016733064549043775, 0.02234622649848461, 0.018209582194685936, -0.011912776157259941, 0.02191356010735035, -0.0036912059877067804, -0.001534322276711464, -0.05142822489142418, 0.021047748625278473, -0.02446644939482212, -0.029892412945628166, 0.01902293786406517, -0.045437607914209366, 0.014877763576805592, 0.05657077580690384, -0.0020858680363744497, 0.013709479942917824, -0.08007951825857162, 0.035026855766773224, 0.010294790379703045, 0.02945980243384838, 0.013930495828390121, -0.005346587393432856, -0.02264365181326866, 0.017758211120963097, 0.008923832327127457, 0.002075805561617017, 0.04264203831553459, 0.008278420194983482, 0.00023966743901837617, 0.035476285964250565, 0.05606268346309662, 0.035077497363090515, -0.07418012619018555, 0.0044020963832736015, 0.049733273684978485, -0.0854915976524353, -0.019478144124150276, -0.04630151018500328, -0.05550672113895416, 0.05097164586186409, -0.007894030772149563, 0.03836103528738022, -0.010430080816149712, 0.007899089716374874, 0.02891380898654461, 0.01869817078113556, 0.03180184215307236, -0.0034546346869319677, 0.005181558895856142, -0.03728047385811806, 0.005473509430885315, -0.064649298787117, -0.01975053735077381, 0.0715206190943718, -0.044961072504520416, 0.017174256965517998, 0.0004416588635649532, -0.031765177845954895, 0.03285056725144386, -0.03900689631700516, -0.04989810660481453, 0.011274071410298347, -0.027343248948454857, -0.012137076817452908, 0.01618023030459881, -0.05361524596810341, -0.0063766734674572945, -0.02071596123278141, -0.02855665422976017, -0.008517015725374222, 0.010747955180704594, 0.048044897615909576, 0.03091905266046524, 0.03289882466197014, -0.02355368249118328, -0.0028634120244532824, 0.04771885648369789, 0.052184317260980606, 0.004281962290406227, 0.032439276576042175, -0.008459286764264107, 0.05204305797815323, 0.05137145519256592, 0.014196337200701237, 0.014100158587098122, -0.005728438496589661, -0.010964102111756802, -0.07283524423837662, 0.04977966099977493, -0.013401906937360764, 0.00954782497137785, -0.07105406373739243, 0.04151218757033348, 0.04011911898851395, -0.044407911598682404, -0.0409170538187027, 0.0631232038140297, -0.0273419301956892, -0.0035673805978149176, -0.016948113217949867, 0.0004555277118925005, -0.009316151030361652, 0.052787136286497116, 0.013275563716888428, 0.0710320994257927, 0.048165977001190186, 0.006570497527718544, -0.016145629808306694, 0.000710853433702141, 0.07218526303768158, 0.04304445534944534, 0.07998864352703094, -0.017965970560908318, 0.05535070225596428, -0.02945299819111824, -0.048477333039045334, 0.011136474087834358, 0.03231135010719299, -0.005568999797105789, -0.04065500944852829, 0.013367891311645508, 0.08575695008039474, -0.014224045909941196, 0.06731604784727097, -0.02942408062517643, -0.004383663646876812, -0.007861415855586529, -0.006326999049633741, -0.05259457603096962, 0.011086517944931984, 0.00009475263505009934, 0.029884401708841324, -0.03737223520874977, -0.013209660537540913, 0.007344934158027172, -0.010180425830185413, 0.0240658987313509, 0.02299973927438259, -0.027638578787446022, 0.035358693450689316, -0.016506582498550415, 0.03412141650915146, 0.10649196803569794, -0.05877915397286415, -0.03123701550066471, 0.0034836637787520885, 0.028933202847838402, -0.0047709462232887745, 0.025796066969633102, 0.016766879707574844, -0.024581605568528175, -0.004447188228368759, -0.05607232451438904, 0.011763526126742363, 0.03940410166978836, -0.009368127211928368, 0.03216428682208061, -0.009651771746575832, 0.03260539472103119, 0.02008328214287758, -0.007330493535846472, -0.029453609138727188, -0.07860171794891357, -0.020392511039972305, -0.05059944465756416, -0.05981258302927017, -0.0468137264251709, 0.05755273997783661, -0.00880849827080965, -0.029492873698472977, -0.01961439475417137, -0.04262864589691162, 0.023076599463820457, 0.015934966504573822, -0.06835183501243591, -0.023865515366196632, 0.03362113609910011, -0.00264159357175231, -0.053545039147138596, 0.034889526665210724, 0.05164443328976631, 0.002696421928703785, -0.012082599103450775, 0.029623225331306458, 0.024056939408183098, 0.023861831054091454, -0.03514312207698822, 0.03346731513738632, -0.059057049453258514, 0.037014540284872055, 0.039427466690540314, -0.021033212542533875, -0.07469102740287781, 0.011758443899452686, -0.017395732924342155, 0.027772702276706696, 0.06119620054960251, -0.019498491659760475, 0.0014517412055283785, -0.04822777211666107, -0.028037836775183678, 0.012148423120379448, 0.002881403546780348, 0.05136798322200775, -0.027063366025686264, 0.0830330029129982, 0.03612079843878746, -0.014312039129436016, -0.023435933515429497, 0.05989133194088936, 0.008855342864990234, 0.01139341201633215, -0.019681520760059357, -0.02366933599114418, -0.03601626679301262, -0.07538817822933197, -0.03678762540221214, 0.025781754404306412, -0.02041027322411537, -0.0340312235057354, 0.017366504296660423, -0.026386985555291176, 0.027041543275117874, -0.008676275610923767, -0.033508751541376114, -0.03232254832983017, -0.027091987431049347, -0.00575632881373167, -0.07148754596710205, 0.0028186659328639507, 0.007671147119253874, 0.0039632441475987434, 0.020702963694930077, -0.015982219949364662, 0.0179770328104496, -0.04315353184938431, 0.037204865366220474, 0.008237292058765888, 0.008894607424736023, -0.041271865367889404 ]
3,558
Grounding Video Models to Actions through Goal Conditioned Exploration
https://openreview.net/forum?id=G6dMvRuhFr
[ "Yunhao Luo", "Yilun Du" ]
Spotlight
Large video models, pretrained on massive quantities of amount of Internet video, provide a rich source of physical knowledge about the dynamics and motions of objects and tasks. However, video models are not grounded in the embodiment of an agent, and do not describe how to actuate the world to reach the visual states depicted in a video. To tackle this problem, current methods use a separate vision-based inverse dynamic model trained on embodiment-specific data to map image states to actions. Gathering data to train such a model is often expensive and challenging, and this model is limited to visual settings similar to the ones in which data is available. In this paper, we investigate how to directly ground video models to continuous actions through self-exploration in the embodied environment -- using generated video states as visual goals for exploration. We propose a framework that uses trajectory level action generation in combination with video guidance to enable an agent to solve complex tasks without any external supervision, e.g., rewards, action labels, or segmentation masks. We validate the proposed approach on 8 tasks in Libero, 6 tasks in MetaWorld, 4 tasks in Calvin, and 12 tasks in iThor Visual Navigation. We show how our approach is on par with or even surpasses multiple behavior cloning baselines trained on expert demonstrations while without requiring any action annotations.
Embodied AI, Decision Making, Robotics, Video Model
We illustrate how we can ground video models to actions without using actions labels through goal conditioned exploration.
4,940
2411.07223
[ 0.02215087041258812, -0.005213234107941389, -0.022296782582998276, 0.03336673974990845, 0.028722960501909256, 0.00042791644227690995, 0.03944920375943184, 0.011182574555277824, -0.03852323442697525, -0.032059237360954285, -0.034331437200307846, -0.009842642582952976, -0.05818776413798332, -0.025643086060881615, -0.016187578439712524, 0.032096873968839645, 0.007665606215596199, -0.003463654313236475, 0.007632619701325893, 0.0033431369811296463, -0.0516526997089386, -0.010625637136399746, 0.04375153407454491, 0.0317734032869339, 0.03091127797961235, 0.0033931643702089787, 0.033696550875902176, 0.034900132566690445, -0.038592346012592316, -0.027901507914066315, 0.000028222961191204377, -0.03732941672205925, 0.032965656369924545, -0.04116253927350044, 0.009524407796561718, -0.008117574267089367, -0.0351264625787735, 0.010755076073110104, 0.005746187176555395, -0.023345738649368286, -0.05009235069155693, 0.017392495647072792, -0.02206823043525219, -0.025498755276203156, -0.03138728812336922, 0.02929995395243168, -0.06320905685424805, 0.017621833831071854, 0.04591553285717964, -0.03798707574605942, -0.07459366321563721, 0.07303648442029953, 0.011733156628906727, 0.005961572285741568, 0.003032754175364971, 0.022993093356490135, 0.040347080677747726, -0.09404857456684113, 0.007151367608457804, -0.04556475579738617, -0.01212226040661335, 0.027160942554473877, 0.022520292550325394, 0.027173196896910667, 0.013038798235356808, -0.019236646592617035, 0.012853249907493591, 0.0585172101855278, -0.018664350733160973, -0.016170963644981384, -0.022462904453277588, -0.03212134912610054, -0.023718280717730522, 0.014412215910851955, 0.030748017132282257, -0.02951042354106903, 0.03881928697228432, 0.036271870136260986, 0.03849274665117264, -0.02549988403916359, 0.03197387233376503, 0.043193966150283813, 0.015809010714292526, 0.03206269070506096, 0.021662386134266853, 0.03557991608977318, -0.01303779985755682, -0.01292093750089407, -0.07316502928733826, 0.01980637200176716, -0.013621856458485126, -0.04664270579814911, -0.02062867395579815, 0.052827466279268265, 0.025764362886548042, -0.0033992237877100706, -0.006483593489974737, -0.012602447532117367, 0.035637691617012024, -0.00860815029591322, -0.009959552437067032, -0.0273545254021883, -0.0032114218920469284, 0.0028886969666928053, -0.08054972440004349, -0.036306627094745636, 0.012097557075321674, -0.03334040939807892, -0.006478196941316128, 0.021300282329320908, -0.08672045916318893, -0.014296967536211014, 0.00914810225367546, -0.021600278094410896, -0.038276348263025284, 0.03288619592785835, 0.01604628749191761, 0.04437663406133652, -0.02223055809736252, 0.03665037453174591, 0.06516823172569275, 0.030954085290431976, -0.002810458652675152, 0.05079488083720207, -0.019313493743538857, 0.01093730702996254, -0.00006584014045074582, 0.013950146734714508, -0.03855597600340843, -0.03462711721658707, 0.03990405797958374, 0.028287025168538094, -0.005430101882666349, -0.007286413572728634, 0.0026860248763114214, -0.017697496339678764, 0.04740611091256142, -0.015322166495025158, 0.003499967511743307, -0.00775957852602005, -0.004157481715083122, -0.019252734258770943, 0.10349700599908829, -0.04790712893009186, 0.08714040368795395, -0.013380816206336021, -0.0006474640686064959, -0.003079573158174753, -0.0509444884955883, 0.008324029855430126, -0.0005481831030920148, -0.02317875809967518, 0.011729300953447819, -0.06289923936128616, 0.0077535053715109825, 0.06656622141599655, 0.04415946453809738, 0.020386653020977974, 0.010844673961400986, -0.010403161868453026, 0.016517601907253265, -0.006714525166898966, -0.026607152074575424, -0.005805274471640587, 0.010646642185747623, -0.05991131439805031, 0.029353395104408264, -0.0114072784781456, -0.024901388213038445, -0.002714526141062379, -0.029510166496038437, -0.007990694604814053, 0.012416849844157696, 0.0036278909537941217, -0.03991684690117836, 0.020432505756616592, 0.04152655228972435, -0.015192770399153233, 0.025667354464530945, 0.02876373752951622, -0.08140488713979721, 0.008149216882884502, -0.019686922430992126, -0.034936584532260895, 0.012929406948387623, -0.06009528785943985, 0.0671110525727272, -0.016352904960513115, -0.03236795589327812, 0.04342317581176758, -0.050667498260736465, -0.01295904815196991, 0.03541380912065506, -0.0217363890260458, 0.047400977462530136, -0.012443054467439651, -0.01795773394405842, 0.02000129409134388, 0.03974912688136101, 0.059812549501657486, -0.001315626665018499, -0.04262128472328186, 0.06127370148897171, 0.01870572194457054, 0.0021543987095355988, 0.011746465228497982, 0.02754342555999756, -0.017156610265374184, -0.01946740597486496, 0.029812011867761612, 0.015482394956052303, 0.009279654361307621, 0.029602808877825737, 0.0038799026515334845, 0.0177681352943182, 0.01309903059154749, -0.03501354530453682, 0.024712130427360535, 0.028348855674266815, -0.027317386120557785, 0.006697295233607292, 0.017088567838072777, -0.0329560860991478, -0.009552565403282642, -0.04070768132805824, 0.06983369588851929, 0.03712456673383713, -0.04377222806215286, -0.004488952923566103, 0.013901305384933949, -0.02409287728369236, 0.040620844811201096, -0.006267951801419258, -0.028522295877337456, 0.02894827537238598, -0.03907725587487221, 0.047573257237672806, -0.03352455049753189, 0.032533857971429825, -0.03898453712463379, -0.012178830802440643, 0.07067596912384033, -0.010294896550476551, 0.051171015948057175, -0.02863309532403946, -0.00021253630984574556, 0.09585510194301605, 0.026198673993349075, -0.022567570209503174, 0.007460488472133875, -0.02748713828623295, -0.0017612017691135406, 0.01501078624278307, -0.015136842615902424, -0.004543809685856104, -0.04495776444673538, 0.008704557083547115, -0.047157205641269684, 0.059994038194417953, 0.05013616383075714, 0.046591512858867645, 0.03130558133125305, -0.012889998033642769, 0.012456192634999752, -0.024962270632386208, -0.10719628632068634, -0.03574984893202782, -0.02177681401371956, 0.007361707743257284, 0.02813834324479103, 0.04189922660589218, -0.009674661792814732, 0.06126328557729721, -0.035216957330703735, -0.01251965668052435, 0.032398246228694916, 0.026339642703533173, 0.026308026164770126, -0.01235584169626236, -0.0021585975773632526, -0.01735302247107029, 0.06313560903072357, 0.00831399392336607, -0.003217963967472315, -0.0009219890926033258, -0.02955189161002636, -0.027709193527698517, -0.0070518129505217075, -0.013667173683643341, -0.002592373639345169, 0.04789160564541817, 0.007756332866847515, -0.011768248863518238, 0.03191685304045677, 0.02739408239722252, 0.07730698585510254, 0.03200944513082504, -0.007931352593004704, -0.024079345166683197, 0.013392745517194271, -0.024024294689297676, 0.017109641805291176, -0.007447052281349897, -0.006115937605500221, -0.011188577860593796, 0.008256173692643642, 0.03227483108639717, 0.007699855603277683, -0.2607343792915344, -0.03948985040187836, 0.01436860952526331, 0.017663273960351944, 0.02822858840227127, -0.027107546105980873, 0.055523522198200226, -0.04584945738315582, -0.044129565358161926, 0.03863091021776199, 0.008324448019266129, 0.023390527814626694, -0.010100794024765491, 0.0699816420674324, 0.059207744896411896, 0.0320720449090004, 0.009741688147187233, -0.0007165331626310945, -0.02477163076400757, 0.03744841739535332, -0.03402002900838852, -0.06438606232404709, -0.04753493145108223, 0.04609258472919464, -0.02231457084417343, 0.03270994499325752, -0.10148373246192932, -0.013884570449590683, -0.005599378142505884, -0.005907975137233734, -0.012345384806394577, -0.02375127002596855, -0.04731154441833496, 0.018887365236878395, 0.009916955605149269, -0.007130051497370005, 0.05341228470206261, -0.01654515229165554, 0.04116051271557808, -0.005931601859629154, -0.009163781069219112, -0.012010274454951286, -0.04716130346059799, 0.03865388035774231, 0.0592842735350132, -0.012697878293693066, -0.03611857071518898, -0.02518666535615921, -0.01263491716235876, 0.027942178770899773, 0.03459854796528816, -0.00663008401170373, 0.01325994823127985, 0.00007836157601559535, 0.023546529933810234, -0.049654655158519745, 0.0508994422852993, -0.009279662743210793, -0.007530740927904844, 0.004285910632461309, -0.003541723359376192, -0.03780244663357735, -0.04677499085664749, -0.025209583342075348, 0.023738466203212738, -0.04070018231868744, -0.02802443876862526, -0.051630545407533646, 0.033042456954717636, 0.006265074480324984, -0.015280062332749367, -0.004405145533382893, -0.016758594661951065, -0.1137777715921402, 0.007489943876862526, 0.018439115956425667, 0.0035103182308375835, -0.057838618755340576, 0.013690655119717121, 0.030706163495779037, -0.028008002787828445, -0.015336860902607441, 0.021927889436483383, 0.02558416873216629, 0.038982294499874115, -0.009286195039749146, 0.032945118844509125, -0.06340242922306061, 0.005281943827867508, -0.03263666480779648, 0.042949333786964417, 0.007178806699812412, 0.012775654904544353, 0.0210909191519022, 0.02588232047855854, 0.016618086025118828, 0.030464909970760345, 0.0072827693074941635, 0.036259252578020096, -0.014107848517596722, 0.015237520448863506, -0.08784010261297226, 0.01910378225147724, -0.041104722768068314, -0.022990532219409943, 0.016221320256590843, -0.05416854843497276, -0.0017236112616956234, 0.0426674410700798, 0.011532178148627281, -0.021402603015303612, -0.02905437722802162, -0.00791193451732397, 0.015528632327914238, -0.0206516832113266, 0.007400996051728725, 0.001486678491346538, 0.03394807130098343, 0.03778304532170296, -0.006265238858759403, -0.03996259719133377, 0.031784769147634506, -0.027141684666275978, 0.04885021224617958, 0.003256462048739195, -0.010148284956812859, 0.01330885011702776, 0.002815686631947756, -0.006979249883443117, 0.015063975937664509, 0.038845889270305634, 0.03398897871375084, -0.021480409428477287, 0.054639507085084915, 0.05823107436299324, -0.01520717516541481, 0.010648366995155811, 0.002822326961904764, 0.031096527352929115, -0.06247905641794205, -0.028235871344804764, -0.0019814837723970413, 0.03523829206824303, 0.053950220346450806, 0.025317974388599396, 0.02067839540541172, 0.052093472331762314, 0.011202539317309856, 0.0017369715496897697, 0.01966412179172039, 0.09110735356807709, -0.06371964514255524, -0.0021988251246511936, -0.02633882686495781, 0.02691974677145481, -0.052461348474025726, -0.022168636322021484, -0.05489034205675125, 0.05081624910235405, -0.06009676679968834, 0.045145392417907715, -0.007661172654479742, -0.01374080777168274, -0.008408790454268456, 0.01742563769221306, 0.03848930448293686, 0.002352745970711112, -0.035766083747148514, 0.021099664270877838, 0.008980241604149342, 0.012208082713186741, -0.073715940117836, -0.019396701827645302, -0.036087602376937866, -0.014777432195842266, 0.0015118846204131842, -0.016446782276034355, -0.02920507825911045, -0.0444667786359787, 0.03181133791804314, 0.011639938689768314, -0.047693267464637756, 0.020555229857563972, -0.052160970866680145, 0.05971281975507736, -0.027254851534962654, 0.007794911507517099, 0.0026395858731120825, -0.03780939429998398, 0.0015251267468556762, 0.002459221985191107, 0.03922397270798683, -0.00398291926831007, -0.06555838882923126, -0.04069975018501282, -0.01083485409617424, 0.013862350024282932, 0.008419213816523552, -0.004746624268591404, 0.004938714671880007, -0.01686747744679451, 0.0017931598704308271, -0.03833915293216705, 0.014775232411921024, 0.048013363033533096, -0.05207541957497597, -0.002099518897011876, 0.0671783983707428, -0.01062421128153801, 0.012350090779364109, -0.07819243520498276, -0.03071412816643715, -0.052657317370176315, -0.07000230252742767, -0.029609685763716698, -0.010939154773950577, 0.010404453612864017, -0.06846366822719574, -0.022081609815359116, 0.014819554053246975, -0.0006207327242009342, 0.014628397300839424, -0.03352050483226776, -0.007059191353619099, -0.008404859341681004, 0.001516285934485495, -0.014926414005458355, -0.015949012711644173, 0.04241262003779411, -0.036188073456287384, 0.008956169709563255, -0.026468127965927124, 0.022342948243021965, 0.034576743841171265, 0.003312924178317189, -0.009684625081717968, -0.04141371697187424, 0.07105457037687302, 0.014296101406216621, -0.012112095952033997, 0.007506925147026777, 0.02382015809416771, -0.015934808179736137, 0.012492458336055279, 0.03700685128569603, 0.025509530678391457, 0.028407547622919083, -0.004065473563969135, 0.027396945282816887, 0.009387865662574768, 0.026454897597432137, 0.005397486500442028, -0.028808647766709328, -0.002278886502608657, 0.047827694565057755, -0.059090908616781235, -0.016922136768698692, -0.04229434207081795, -0.03213238716125488, 0.019978614524006844, 0.008329284377396107, 0.0022590712178498507, -0.046346936374902725, 0.009224810637533665, -0.007945031858980656, 0.026142770424485207, 0.03823697566986084, -0.0155997509136796, 0.034615568816661835, -0.06044972315430641, 0.02501051314175129, -0.04399794712662697, -0.020557951182127, 0.083280548453331, -0.04033356532454491, -0.008175380527973175, 0.009570309892296791, -0.041125182062387466, 0.04755285009741783, -0.03454923629760742, -0.05966254696249962, 0.056425366550683975, -0.023478364571928978, -0.0004115537740290165, 0.03230232372879982, -0.024917379021644592, -0.0023237192071974277, -0.031026851385831833, -0.04100057855248451, 0.0015899884747341275, -0.029952522367239, 0.04414743185043335, -0.0031499206088483334, -0.006110707763582468, -0.015125410631299019, 0.029904497787356377, 0.03724217042326927, 0.019145632162690163, 0.04543640464544296, 0.022751817479729652, -0.02132852002978325, 0.06315884739160538, 0.02068960852921009, 0.005350303836166859, 0.011402232572436333, -0.018316226080060005, -0.01089366152882576, -0.036578211933374405, 0.04040655493736267, 0.019965767860412598, -0.041779451072216034, -0.09347351640462875, 0.051913682371377945, 0.033034682273864746, -0.03828649967908859, 0.01908770762383938, 0.03946808725595474, -0.07543554157018661, -0.028830446302890778, 0.017556916922330856, 0.00030314712785184383, 0.01521550863981247, 0.061321921646595, 0.005467298440635204, 0.06767592579126358, 0.041910309344530106, 0.028261415660381317, -0.028386607766151428, -0.022763747721910477, 0.06767020374536514, 0.058828361332416534, 0.04547204077243805, 0.01587929204106331, 0.08335425704717636, -0.04302365332841873, -0.03135152533650398, 0.04255722090601921, 0.028570549562573433, -0.015607411973178387, -0.04721939563751221, -0.0039050173945724964, 0.06555365771055222, 0.012773402035236359, 0.03757341951131821, -0.06467345356941223, -0.055448874831199646, 0.08415910601615906, -0.007981535978615284, -0.02099147066473961, -0.006819004658609629, 0.05670071765780449, 0.01583518087863922, -0.00039183415356092155, -0.015507916919887066, -0.004436129238456488, -0.03820399194955826, 0.02291625738143921, 0.041062839329242706, -0.016991904005408287, 0.02067936398088932, -0.008424103260040283, 0.026411065831780434, 0.10694879293441772, -0.054427191615104675, 0.00910094752907753, -0.007665568497031927, -0.020866846665740013, -0.004798895679414272, 0.05205651745200157, -0.018383368849754333, -0.0044439746998250484, 0.021101070567965508, -0.04559217020869255, 0.03133165091276169, 0.0601266585290432, -0.020558027550578117, 0.02600371465086937, -0.050620246678590775, -0.030784692615270615, 0.013789525255560875, 0.035255998373031616, -0.03624391555786133, -0.054889269173145294, -0.04396377131342888, -0.03196440637111664, -0.06765104085206985, -0.04616864398121834, 0.0362398661673069, -0.026171844452619553, -0.07394488900899887, -0.02405070886015892, -0.03638356924057007, 0.015064709819853306, 0.011858559213578701, -0.06602045893669128, -0.005231423303484917, 0.02728281542658806, -0.0012873284285888076, 0.02878347411751747, 0.02279474027454853, 0.019077841192483902, -0.003541757119819522, -0.020909683778882027, 0.014402439817786217, 0.024887848645448685, 0.004275357350707054, -0.0585077665746212, -0.018176814541220665, -0.09553518146276474, 0.024324269965291023, 0.013363323174417019, -0.014524172060191631, -0.060349952429533005, -0.013469076715409756, -0.04105047509074211, 0.04225100576877594, 0.09530945122241974, -0.022032009437680244, 0.008803489618003368, -0.05435306951403618, -0.005223894026130438, -0.019987238571047783, -0.02716604806482792, 0.0690130814909935, -0.04216986522078514, 0.05327604338526726, 0.027909647673368454, -0.015271330252289772, -0.0460045225918293, 0.03348206728696823, 0.020031031221151352, 0.01619900017976761, -0.0033546853810548782, -0.019199848175048828, 0.010065599344670773, -0.11097098141908646, -0.038777872920036316, 0.06898819655179977, 0.029248200356960297, -0.03862348943948746, -0.012010283768177032, -0.005947243422269821, -0.008016105741262436, -0.03722357004880905, -0.030698692426085472, -0.017880108207464218, -0.021197713911533356, -0.03856430947780609, -0.041007332503795624, 0.0012536903377622366, -0.045815035700798035, 0.002432111417874694, -0.0235288068652153, -0.03727409616112709, -0.012127825990319252, 0.00047498225467279553, 0.01261657290160656, 0.007661906071007252, 0.03272329643368721, -0.03059338964521885 ]
3,559
RESuM: A Rare Event Surrogate Model for Physics Detector Design
https://openreview.net/forum?id=lqTILjL6lP
[ "Ann-Kathrin Schuetz", "A.W.P. Poon", "Aobo Li" ]
Spotlight
The experimental discovery of neutrinoless double-beta decay (NLDBD) would answer one of the most important questions in physics: Why is there more matter than antimatter in our universe? To maximize the chances of discovery, NLDBD experiments must optimize their detector designs to minimize the probability of background events contaminating the detector. Given that this probability is inherently low, design optimization either requires extremely costly simulations to generate sufficient background counts or contending with significant variance. In this work, we formalize this dilemma as a Rare Event Design (RED) problem: identifying optimal design parameters when the design metric to be minimized is inherently small. We then designed the Rare Event Surrogate Model (RESuM) for physics detector design optimization under RED conditions. RESuM uses a pre-trained Conditional Neural Process (CNP) model to incorporate additional prior knowledge into a Multi-Fidelity Gaussian Process model. We applied RESuM to optimize neutron shielding designs for the LEGEND NLDBD experiment, identifying an optimal design that reduces the neutron background by $(66.5 \pm 3.5)$% while using only 3.3% of the computational resources compared to traditional methods. Given the prevalence of RED problems in other fields of physical sciences, especially in rare-event searches, the RESuM algorithm has broad potential for accelerating simulation-intensive applications.
surrogate model, simulation, rare event search, AI4Sci, AI for physics, conditional neural process, Bayesian methods, emulator, Multi-Fidelity Gaussian Process
We developed a Rare Event Surrogate Model (RESuM) powered by Conditional Neural Process to optimize particle physics detector design under high-variance design metrics.
4,920
null
[ -0.015307322144508362, -0.005720249842852354, -0.03689240291714668, 0.02485976181924343, 0.03813565894961357, 0.007904764264822006, 0.009661688469350338, -0.023983189836144447, -0.055014073848724365, -0.03381688520312309, -0.008737606927752495, 0.012212701141834259, -0.009438036940991879, 0.009571707807481289, -0.008648530580103397, 0.04851580411195755, 0.06314124166965485, -0.016719330102205276, 0.022075414657592773, 0.0499570332467556, 0.008431164547801018, -0.025279853492975235, 0.023474927991628647, 0.03673756867647171, 0.02658884786069393, 0.017539631575345993, 0.03717872500419617, -0.02568928338587284, -0.0352805070579052, 0.003424663795158267, 0.030692707747220993, -0.019316472113132477, -0.0028345203027129173, -0.017088336870074272, 0.014986518770456314, 0.014192032627761364, -0.03934686258435249, 0.007536991965025663, -0.00035359960747882724, 0.020314257591962814, -0.06265831738710403, -0.007554624229669571, -0.016016332432627678, -0.009254448115825653, -0.04102369397878647, 0.02875184640288353, -0.03598929941654205, 0.015590265393257141, -0.004941631108522415, -0.024893267080187798, -0.08664526045322418, 0.01761859469115734, 0.01987476833164692, 0.022181950509548187, -0.011245029978454113, -0.017531877383589745, 0.07322988659143448, -0.022313380613923073, -0.005699037574231625, -0.06110309809446335, -0.001936153625138104, -0.00020068211597390473, -0.0011711003025993705, 0.011160983704030514, 0.004248165525496006, -0.018750622868537903, 0.015456858091056347, 0.034328170120716095, -0.030222151428461075, -0.010441052727401257, -0.021933799609541893, 0.006820206996053457, 0.0014118353137746453, 0.0005964513402432203, 0.023472264409065247, -0.017170527949929237, 0.03646805137395859, 0.020551772788167, 0.028842657804489136, -0.0017290348187088966, 0.016539204865694046, -0.016854384914040565, 0.028097864240407944, 0.024930361658334732, 0.0074522001668810844, 0.008904196321964264, -0.04223693534731865, 0.002511200960725546, -0.06526456773281097, 0.047899279743433, -0.01801840215921402, -0.05134935677051544, 0.036124248057603836, 0.05209872126579285, 0.03759292513132095, 0.04313601553440094, 0.04499798268079758, 0.011185073293745518, 0.008031439036130905, 0.01988941617310047, -0.009341246448457241, -0.04717221111059189, 0.027939489111304283, 0.016911154612898827, -0.0908423364162445, -0.030665893107652664, -0.039909087121486664, -0.047449223697185516, -0.019581956788897514, 0.005714246537536383, -0.03396911546587944, 0.0036339510697871447, -0.014184397645294666, -0.004025723319500685, -0.11559385806322098, 0.040155112743377686, 0.012210618704557419, 0.002960213692858815, 0.010559309273958206, 0.00176822894718498, 0.0811607837677002, 0.06630203872919083, 0.008253693580627441, 0.05340596288442612, 0.005283872596919537, -0.014089813455939293, 0.014075322076678276, 0.034898050129413605, -0.045069899410009384, -0.005660024005919695, 0.01094434317201376, 0.07211019843816757, 0.014689553529024124, -0.015637319535017014, 0.005550922825932503, -0.006527869496494532, 0.018899763002991676, -0.001672051497735083, 0.009709564968943596, 0.024030448868870735, 0.012289635837078094, -0.01600911095738411, 0.055208656936883926, -0.060260117053985596, 0.07662253081798553, -0.003013520035892725, -0.00872762966901064, -0.03515003249049187, -0.03265969455242157, 0.04267405718564987, 0.013926899060606956, -0.011714640073478222, 0.01123724039644003, -0.057917520403862, 0.006795609835535288, 0.04083250090479851, -0.009668582119047642, 0.008060289546847343, -0.014059501700103283, -0.01896735094487667, 0.02534416876733303, -0.008681966923177242, 0.005067406687885523, 0.04721986502408981, -0.013529476709663868, -0.0026096967048943043, 0.06269966810941696, 0.02700919285416603, -0.036301061511039734, -0.006995746400207281, -0.040410250425338745, -0.041229259222745895, 0.052207041531801224, -0.02569716051220894, 0.0014606438344344497, 0.01678931713104248, 0.04441119357943535, 0.013339357450604439, 0.012751874513924122, 0.012142779305577278, -0.09725701808929443, 0.019002823159098625, 0.007546708919107914, 0.016613636165857315, -0.0025400298181921244, 0.0011093514040112495, 0.09100332111120224, -0.03216726332902908, -0.016164623200893402, 0.025729456916451454, -0.08268921077251434, -0.006679689045995474, 0.014974655583500862, -0.027995890006422997, 0.05738748610019684, -0.008129328489303589, -0.022076157853007317, 0.07976309210062027, 0.0012797159142792225, 0.038455888628959656, 0.003439336083829403, -0.01255322527140379, 0.020969903096556664, -0.02179679460823536, -0.04170307517051697, -0.019853217527270317, 0.0825282633304596, -0.026993390172719955, 0.00643909489735961, 0.0017049384769052267, 0.003238149918615818, -0.01576821506023407, 0.003925445955246687, -0.011380264535546303, 0.02354056015610695, -0.0293633583933115, -0.019909992814064026, -0.011997940950095654, 0.01398883480578661, -0.025009064003825188, 0.03530295565724373, 0.019219335168600082, -0.010737039148807526, -0.028418809175491333, -0.04261480271816254, 0.12317654490470886, 0.08928458392620087, -0.042158905416727066, -0.022512538358569145, 0.05308092013001442, 0.047513172030448914, 0.01714853197336197, -0.0015741161769255996, 0.003882029326632619, 0.017142675817012787, -0.011573434807360172, 0.008022191002964973, -0.015410644002258778, 0.07395433634519577, -0.053116634488105774, -0.0010787415085360408, 0.07504236698150635, -0.029393348842859268, 0.08114217966794968, -0.03126955404877663, 0.007437877357006073, 0.0619158111512661, -0.008193365298211575, -0.036953140050172806, -0.021783165633678436, -0.04492630809545517, 0.019207244738936424, 0.049938514828681946, 0.021684907376766205, 0.058781061321496964, -0.05420085787773132, -0.015465697273612022, 0.004805190954357386, 0.057162053883075714, 0.05689382553100586, 0.007266107946634293, -0.01670292392373085, 0.004946458153426647, -0.040438827127218246, -0.02573920600116253, -0.1099897176027298, -0.032930631190538406, 0.008435970172286034, 0.02235906571149826, 0.006732247304171324, 0.0019831713289022446, 0.0000195744723896496, 0.02071247436106205, -0.02233448252081871, -0.02200952358543873, -0.013482741080224514, 0.04678494855761528, 0.05165999010205269, -0.025040114298462868, -0.015468946658074856, -0.004243741277605295, 0.06296564638614655, -0.042251698672771454, -0.026569552719593048, -0.030022822320461273, -0.025061573833227158, -0.022764598950743675, -0.0472477525472641, -0.017896415665745735, 0.014884492382407188, -0.0032872320152819157, 0.015140590257942677, -0.01603664644062519, 0.020853634923696518, 0.060465697199106216, 0.07130535691976547, 0.023692848160862923, -0.004665393382310867, -0.011487864889204502, 0.048883240669965744, 0.007965531200170517, 0.004732281900942326, -0.02652810327708721, 0.03536786884069443, -0.01134113222360611, -0.01577402465045452, 0.04415895789861679, 0.02165943942964077, -0.2862474024295807, -0.01042269729077816, 0.03748345002532005, -0.027590429410338402, 0.003428711788728833, 0.017592214047908783, 0.03572431579232216, -0.012513287365436554, -0.048702139407396317, -0.018686309456825256, -0.0017961144912987947, -0.008853603154420853, 0.019785411655902863, 0.04998449981212616, 0.06094340980052948, 0.013875403441488743, 0.05018940567970276, -0.023341456428170204, -0.012908061034977436, 0.003956910222768784, 0.01265533547848463, -0.03862052783370018, 0.0020536098163574934, 0.00010417008161311969, -0.018597427755594254, 0.011714348569512367, -0.0713290348649025, 0.025987137109041214, -0.04108899086713791, 0.007532014511525631, 0.05120290443301201, -0.029081042855978012, -0.025807075202465057, -0.008923434652388096, 0.010002071969211102, -0.016442498192191124, 0.01587916724383831, -0.05224953219294548, 0.03662833943963051, 0.031632911413908005, 0.02320394665002823, -0.00572644267231226, -0.03044411912560463, 0.02426966279745102, 0.054131828248500824, 0.015749461948871613, -0.031395286321640015, -0.012601178139448166, 0.002188816200941801, 0.02729063667356968, -0.0069820755161345005, -0.01865430921316147, -0.02324279583990574, -0.020983943715691566, -0.005581884644925594, -0.007931496016681194, -0.04039252549409866, 0.029862722381949425, -0.011888517998158932, -0.025593865662813187, -0.008471691980957985, -0.0036724654491990805, -0.002026093890890479, -0.010300690308213234, -0.03586650639772415, -0.04281627759337425, -0.06453993916511536, -0.04907795041799545, 0.06410183757543564, 0.039761487394571304, -0.026053693145513535, -0.021321116015315056, -0.034437716007232666, -0.08766982704401016, 0.017768165096640587, 0.01754658669233322, -0.024527350440621376, -0.03542861342430115, -0.009740998037159443, 0.05319209024310112, -0.04083272069692612, -0.03735702857375145, 0.0011514477664604783, 0.03907037153840065, 0.013759367167949677, 0.0019745584577322006, -0.013297325931489468, -0.04056397080421448, -0.014281777665019035, -0.030953412875533104, 0.03419645503163338, -0.013893594034016132, -0.00995566789060831, -0.04723324626684189, 0.06647510826587677, 0.02953694947063923, 0.04048573970794678, 0.025386745110154152, 0.042982105165719986, 0.012663302011787891, 0.03184414282441139, -0.06294409930706024, 0.0003796789678744972, -0.07595668733119965, -0.015180055983364582, -0.004326075781136751, -0.021968793123960495, 0.017559045925736427, 0.005309193395078182, -0.006468834355473518, -0.01611737720668316, 0.00821963232010603, 0.0003376532986294478, -0.02314634434878826, 0.031537577509880066, -0.006415790878236294, 0.013716249726712704, 0.047691699117422104, -0.00043760964763350785, -0.01362391747534275, -0.044635429978370667, 0.002414420945569873, -0.05010930448770523, -0.0336061492562294, -0.013063238933682442, -0.02533947117626667, -0.025379715487360954, -0.0071383011527359486, -0.01481772493571043, -0.0272081196308136, 0.014941765926778316, 0.06761939078569412, 0.002214419189840555, 0.01486663892865181, 0.06580234318971634, 0.013088062405586243, -0.03356659784913063, -0.005302737466990948, 0.044001322239637375, -0.010305795818567276, 0.014293014071881771, -0.027366751804947853, 0.033782076090574265, 0.01896457001566887, 0.03735220059752464, 0.04432589188218117, 0.01817493326961994, 0.025756804272532463, 0.020280903205275536, -0.029383910819888115, 0.028163528069853783, -0.06250860542058945, -0.013154590502381325, -0.03564241901040077, -0.016581540927290916, 0.0008441431564278901, 0.04847230762243271, -0.014260012656450272, 0.03720990568399429, -0.1016889214515686, 0.029642991721630096, 0.02227250672876835, -0.025206001475453377, 0.0001244664890691638, -0.0047780778259038925, 0.08391407877206802, -0.023243959993124008, 0.0022584719117730856, 0.05556713044643402, -0.02546931430697441, -0.02591421827673912, -0.04249406233429909, -0.02007332444190979, -0.005631609354168177, -0.03367067873477936, 0.038881685584783554, 0.016797995194792747, -0.046563953161239624, -0.020241087302565575, 0.015203728340566158, -0.00232505239546299, 0.018686210736632347, -0.03138161450624466, -0.01081936340779066, 0.04859528690576553, -0.02717592939734459, -0.008510002866387367, -0.01961795799434185, -0.02439245395362377, 0.005784748122096062, 0.02076246403157711, -0.01770741492509842, 0.0015581556363031268, 0.002546270377933979, -0.024924984201788902, -0.07538513839244843, -0.024585889652371407, 0.037803635001182556, -0.0005100868293084204, -0.018878689035773277, 0.03488323464989662, -0.010714860633015633, -0.039055630564689636, -0.003492022631689906, 0.0017949538305401802, -0.057162169367074966, 0.04423139989376068, 0.0406360924243927, 0.0014859193470329046, 0.028120022267103195, -0.033823225647211075, -0.04198923707008362, -0.048472389578819275, 0.024109546095132828, 0.002586514223366976, 0.012169080786406994, -0.05673227459192276, 0.0018020110437646508, 0.016091519966721535, -0.0012323958799242973, -0.00867837481200695, -0.008764690719544888, 0.02063777856528759, -0.010888557881116867, 0.01883351057767868, 0.0364549458026886, -0.007696419954299927, -0.025476111099123955, 0.022174932062625885, -0.01610945351421833, 0.023367898538708687, -0.05208202823996544, -0.0006213217857293785, 0.01002558320760727, -0.007202768232673407, 0.032871540635824203, -0.0457632951438427, 0.0007164786220528185, -0.0401548333466053, 0.0026630351785570383, -0.008281365036964417, -0.011498628184199333, -0.03307264298200607, 0.04710760712623596, -0.023871099576354027, 0.0289600882679224, 0.02959982119500637, 0.03136555477976799, -0.011554758064448833, 0.015346473082900047, -0.009996624663472176, -0.018873190507292747, -0.06991691887378693, -0.021898919716477394, 0.07095606625080109, -0.0060287825763225555, -0.018581176176667213, -0.07137002795934677, -0.025797458365559578, -0.011083107441663742, -0.019942935556173325, 0.016765635460615158, -0.02257169969379902, 0.06439842283725739, -0.01488860510289669, 0.03415588662028313, -0.0016047980170696974, -0.05511736497282982, 0.04778672382235527, -0.06260541826486588, 0.03551080822944641, -0.05274106189608574, 0.01653684303164482, 0.047524843364953995, -0.03745648264884949, 0.04516679421067238, -0.012427113018929958, -0.02585485763847828, 0.015430503524839878, -0.038537055253982544, -0.025696851313114166, 0.024666164070367813, -0.00018089385412167758, 0.00917997770011425, 0.05779173597693443, -0.05509655550122261, -0.04132087901234627, -0.0033522620797157288, -0.024938810616731644, 0.0219261571764946, -0.002024650340899825, 0.030739570036530495, -0.016581298783421516, -0.007323670666664839, -0.023626262322068214, -0.021649029105901718, 0.022831963375210762, 0.051652610301971436, 0.015614720061421394, 0.0011280743638053536, -0.05466923490166664, 0.05412440747022629, 0.039371613413095474, -0.013892827555537224, 0.015929995104670525, -0.0321028046309948, 0.016353698447346687, -0.021563321352005005, 0.011231544427573681, 0.0001359927555313334, 0.003983950242400169, -0.06487046927213669, 0.03789713606238365, 0.016744207590818405, -0.07846453040838242, 0.0000035093319183943095, 0.02848636731505394, -0.0317142978310585, 0.005277346819639206, -0.021228671073913574, 0.004296114668250084, 0.03679409995675087, 0.061703745275735855, -0.007187865674495697, 0.009753606282174587, 0.06713706254959106, -0.0012536471476778388, 0.015298384241759777, -0.008846688084304333, 0.07415055483579636, 0.08600908517837524, 0.0379607118666172, 0.049004897475242615, 0.08029238134622574, -0.077518992125988, -0.06964755058288574, -0.0031412045937031507, -0.01869797147810459, -0.0403466634452343, -0.018429256975650787, -0.021323464810848236, 0.0770048126578331, -0.025473671033978462, 0.05779985338449478, 0.0012147522065788507, 0.018754400312900543, 0.0427846759557724, 0.01737079583108425, 0.025434602051973343, 0.034517209976911545, 0.011527174152433872, -0.015058716759085655, -0.0009166969102807343, -0.0416221097111702, -0.006317181047052145, -0.028065547347068787, 0.02894323319196701, -0.00709955720230937, -0.01608770713210106, -0.033786941319704056, 0.009356498718261719, 0.0638073980808258, 0.09654119610786438, 0.013147862628102303, -0.031054675579071045, 0.005901004187762737, -0.016923872753977776, 0.0028505781665444374, 0.00850247498601675, -0.008754434064030647, 0.010065790265798569, -0.03126941993832588, -0.03523195907473564, 0.03441368043422699, 0.00816430151462555, -0.02366994507610798, 0.0354175828397274, -0.01076455321162939, -0.0198025181889534, 0.01266811415553093, -0.001197554636746645, -0.029477596282958984, -0.060796283185482025, -0.06520118564367294, -0.004447861108928919, -0.0370967797935009, 0.00856967642903328, 0.005700734443962574, -0.006535071413964033, 0.025254450738430023, 0.026925282552838326, 0.0016569058643653989, 0.01041058823466301, 0.018244560807943344, -0.07310778647661209, -0.03890734910964966, 0.09528718143701553, -0.05389617383480072, 0.01530330628156662, 0.06850489228963852, 0.042675867676734924, -0.006107505410909653, -0.012561407871544361, 0.038907185196876526, 0.010501581244170666, 0.034286465495824814, -0.0033045050222426653, -0.02344531938433647, -0.10360617935657501, 0.007098430301994085, 0.014151102863252163, -0.027272598817944527, -0.08402173966169357, 0.027123039588332176, -0.036813683807849884, -0.008682837709784508, 0.05443171411752701, -0.009927093051373959, 0.013535135425627232, -0.003407309530302882, -0.036573026329278946, -0.03429674729704857, 0.03815365955233574, 0.05200038477778435, -0.04921795427799225, 0.05587269365787506, 0.01506043504923582, -0.06018111854791641, -0.031062370166182518, 0.0027054334059357643, -0.010050900280475616, -0.051942817866802216, -0.013788260519504547, -0.00631319684907794, -0.0716564729809761, -0.10548435151576996, -0.022604942321777344, 0.01866030879318714, -0.0034812898375093937, -0.03700133413076401, 0.011190423741936684, 0.011231383308768272, 0.023333918303251266, -0.010712753981351852, 0.004938668571412563, -0.021308820694684982, -0.025571921840310097, -0.07260995358228683, -0.051321789622306824, 0.021123964339494705, 0.006580417975783348, 0.0054125702008605, -0.0141424760222435, -0.013546943664550781, -0.017455164343118668, -0.06347908824682236, 0.05683238431811333, 0.04366006702184677, 0.007731531746685505, -0.0158705934882164 ]
3,560
Bi-Factorial Preference Optimization: Balancing Safety-Helpfulness in Language Models
https://openreview.net/forum?id=GjM61KRiTG
[ "Wenxuan Zhang", "Philip Torr", "Mohamed Elhoseiny", "Adel Bibi" ]
Spotlight
Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) on human preferences, typically through reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF), has proven successful in enhancing their capabilities. However, ensuring the safety of LLMs during fine-tuning remains a critical concern, and mitigating the potential conflicts in safety and helpfulness is costly in RLHF. To address this issue, we propose a supervised learning framework called Bi-Factorial Preference Optimization (BFPO), which re-parameterizes a joint RLHF objective of both safety and helpfulness into a single supervised learning objective. In the supervised optimization, a labeling function is used to capture global preferences ranking to balance both safety and helpfulness. To evaluate BFPO, we develop a benchmark including comprehensive discriminative and generative tasks for helpfulness and harmlessness. The results indicate that our method significantly outperforms existing approaches in both safety and helpfulness. Moreover, BFPO eliminates the need for human prompting and annotation in LLM fine-tuning while achieving the same level of safety as methods that heavily rely on human labor, with less than 10\% of the computational resources. The training recipes and models will be released.
Large Language Models, RLHF, Safety
We introduce a theoretically framework to re-parameterize the multi-objective RLHF into supervised optimization and empirically show the effectiveness in improving both the helpfulness and harmlessness in LLM.
4,919
2408.15313
[ -0.012899799272418022, -0.0006350435432977974, 0.023025816306471825, 0.00602108845487237, 0.030877970159053802, 0.037991996854543686, 0.01345838699489832, 0.0043469443917274475, -0.0031312627252191305, -0.01175406388938427, -0.02574802003800869, 0.05868057161569595, -0.07503611594438553, -0.009227453731000423, -0.015476090833544731, 0.046172741800546646, 0.0255440641194582, 0.011033372022211552, 0.01157375518232584, 0.009410306811332703, 0.02901887707412243, -0.01783449575304985, 0.018562663346529007, 0.008910494856536388, 0.03962336480617523, 0.03616541251540184, 0.03545312210917473, 0.01347286906093359, -0.011129714548587799, -0.02897913195192814, 0.04622851312160492, -0.0066283950582146645, 0.008329948410391808, -0.0037287320010364056, -0.017713844776153564, -0.018520986661314964, -0.03268582746386528, 0.0039520347490906715, 0.007895617745816708, 0.03485582023859024, -0.04468050226569176, 0.00790618546307087, -0.006485384423285723, -0.010287418030202389, -0.05716525390744209, 0.015451244078576565, -0.10108964145183563, 0.0321614071726799, 0.01274713221937418, -0.09384746104478836, -0.14381657540798187, 0.0559563934803009, 0.016336925327777863, -0.009443693794310093, 0.016471272334456444, 0.04870985820889473, 0.04944491386413574, -0.08436863869428635, 0.009189163334667683, -0.046118080615997314, -0.04702470079064369, 0.05409238114953041, 0.028664764016866684, 0.016896765679121017, -0.012523021548986435, 0.0015074450056999922, -0.028896300122141838, 0.026530306786298752, -0.05227457359433174, -0.027294181287288666, -0.04315796494483948, 0.00343506783246994, -0.007471067830920219, 0.020234564319252968, 0.008914423175156116, -0.05373051390051842, 0.00981654692441225, 0.047512393444776535, 0.02351217158138752, 0.001819600467570126, 0.0025682998821139336, 0.028241842985153198, 0.016092149540781975, 0.021021807566285133, 0.015034102834761143, -0.000032703519536880776, -0.026253048330545425, -0.024010803550481796, -0.08134415000677109, 0.014542898163199425, 0.0008978776168078184, -0.04760434478521347, -0.0033821749966591597, 0.013146238401532173, 0.013887222856283188, 0.011563755571842194, 0.017361197620630264, 0.02110554277896881, -0.020719120278954506, 0.008641541004180908, -0.02251107431948185, -0.02600369229912758, 0.025466954335570335, -0.020296471193432808, -0.12288909405469894, -0.03707602247595787, -0.01087415125221014, 0.00401267921552062, 0.023075513541698456, 0.003116813488304615, -0.019791074097156525, -0.011596795171499252, 0.02002669870853424, 0.010581753216683865, -0.06700947880744934, 0.022106943652033806, -0.02894071489572525, 0.04770117625594139, 0.010559453628957272, -0.009540141560137272, 0.041069451719522476, 0.027221212163567543, 0.009168941527605057, 0.08349205553531647, -0.014197633601725101, 0.0238039530813694, 0.016325917094945908, 0.047412578016519547, -0.025664744898676872, -0.052771423012018204, -0.0014448307920247316, 0.06052546203136444, -0.014905089512467384, 0.002869869116693735, -0.02222287282347679, 0.026107357814908028, 0.01376516092568636, 0.020461056381464005, 0.04184198006987572, 0.017655925825238228, -0.000558111525606364, -0.0012996428413316607, 0.08483158051967621, -0.02660645917057991, 0.0769120529294014, -0.010453583672642708, -0.01880451664328575, -0.016306228935718536, -0.037357039749622345, 0.0011487712617963552, 0.021851956844329834, -0.007077591028064489, -0.014573837630450726, -0.05519740656018257, 0.03316357359290123, 0.056991297751665115, 0.043557215481996536, -0.008415041491389275, 0.00014518228999804705, 0.010911206714808941, -0.007029115222394466, 0.01912485994398594, -0.04996400326490402, -0.015258672647178173, -0.015622138045728207, -0.06697793304920197, 0.025848448276519775, 0.021837575361132622, -0.030122848227620125, 0.020958920940756798, -0.030240952968597412, 0.00018499302677810192, 0.04952937364578247, -0.02207494154572487, -0.0193759948015213, -0.007749883458018303, 0.06667353957891464, -0.019115988165140152, 0.06319373100996017, 0.044603828340768814, -0.08104530721902847, 0.030022311955690384, 0.011176184751093388, 0.026380110532045364, 0.0025683187413960695, -0.02130165323615074, 0.07443981617689133, -0.011881250888109207, 0.01874886266887188, 0.03449813649058342, -0.06220173463225365, -0.024427251890301704, 0.027335721999406815, -0.025952551513910294, 0.0687040314078331, 0.003146079368889332, 0.004225223790854216, 0.057615626603364944, 0.05705408751964569, 0.0639030858874321, 0.05016016960144043, -0.029892053455114365, 0.014308948069810867, -0.006941458210349083, -0.04870861396193504, 0.011369685642421246, 0.047889623790979385, -0.03329840302467346, -0.03308456018567085, 0.019267652183771133, -0.03968936949968338, 0.02747208997607231, 0.012681907042860985, -0.0015667411498725414, 0.012640113942325115, 0.005625023040920496, -0.024154050275683403, 0.023325983434915543, -0.005693806800991297, -0.05681554228067398, 0.039468467235565186, 0.019847575575113297, -0.0031686071306467056, 0.009079291485249996, -0.04872305691242218, 0.0856192409992218, 0.05922098457813263, -0.023288674652576447, -0.007237530779093504, 0.0471043586730957, -0.008934898301959038, 0.0131199536845088, 0.022515056654810905, -0.01203386764973402, 0.011023510247468948, -0.004048904404044151, -0.022547248750925064, -0.019539326429367065, 0.07537087053060532, -0.035993579775094986, -0.013757170177996159, 0.0584438294172287, -0.04214675724506378, 0.051785554736852646, -0.020149117335677147, 0.021993715316057205, 0.02857755497097969, 0.014960456639528275, -0.013739857822656631, -0.017807668074965477, -0.04916969686746597, 0.009416263550519943, 0.006379691883921623, -0.009535695426166058, 0.027729349210858345, -0.05057447403669357, 0.006296585313975811, -0.0077228969894349575, 0.06152993440628052, 0.05861470848321915, 0.02468160353600979, 0.01355358399450779, -0.025821300223469734, -0.03465340659022331, 0.03301328793168068, -0.0983109176158905, -0.02872985601425171, -0.011793948709964752, 0.02157101221382618, 0.023853689432144165, 0.01481509767472744, -0.0037162965163588524, 0.025191523134708405, -0.03534907475113869, 0.0028966290410608053, 0.02559240721166134, 0.033639635890722275, 0.015823068097233772, -0.05079013854265213, -0.02659500762820244, 0.01837773621082306, 0.056101493537425995, -0.029490051791071892, -0.02854427881538868, -0.021610723808407784, -0.043974556028842926, -0.00036166710196994245, -0.05741996690630913, -0.0029245764017105103, 0.0013629411114379764, 0.009981108829379082, 0.0021652905270457268, -0.0007196937222033739, -0.0014861448435112834, 0.02289525792002678, 0.004219715017825365, 0.05848483368754387, 0.038518745452165604, -0.02483277954161167, 0.05410498380661011, 0.0008446029387414455, 0.02563057653605938, -0.009701164439320564, 0.01718115620315075, 0.002043541520833969, 0.008763669058680534, 0.014833720400929451, 0.002309738425537944, -0.27576613426208496, -0.03774091973900795, -0.0012504647020250559, -0.007364159915596247, 0.009893244132399559, 0.003611455438658595, 0.042868632823228836, -0.038028206676244736, -0.0236098300665617, 0.005395852494984865, 0.02749204821884632, 0.016281098127365112, 0.02226637303829193, 0.057591214776039124, 0.05750950425863266, 0.05542664974927902, -0.03620486706495285, -0.03271748125553131, -0.011175536550581455, 0.01177225448191166, -0.005724397022277117, -0.08604732155799866, -0.021144649013876915, 0.01902916468679905, 0.009960769675672054, 0.06922515481710434, -0.08589410036802292, 0.0022697122767567635, -0.03504132479429245, -0.03646530210971832, 0.0011200628941878676, -0.004741350654512644, -0.00542405666783452, 0.012152890674769878, 0.050426747649908066, 0.0133671835064888, 0.032049696892499924, -0.022941172122955322, 0.049775660037994385, 0.04523540660738945, -0.007587940897792578, -0.04001513496041298, -0.025823116302490234, -0.007936626672744751, 0.05627311393618584, 0.0075561716221272945, -0.07276923209428787, -0.014619795605540276, -0.015299828723073006, 0.044787656515836716, 0.005793520715087652, -0.018745258450508118, -0.02582615613937378, 0.026379777118563652, 0.023312052711844444, 0.029812514781951904, 0.015547244809567928, -0.027106191962957382, -0.007856674492359161, -0.032623711973428726, -0.009005047380924225, -0.022045306861400604, -0.023506613448262215, -0.01090660784393549, -0.020247843116521835, -0.016186509281396866, -0.0429861955344677, -0.025056863203644753, 0.03320576995611191, 0.040256939828395844, -0.02064455673098564, 0.007874186150729656, 0.0217676293104887, -0.09395373612642288, -0.007258121389895678, -0.017935441806912422, -0.013921501114964485, -0.022797036916017532, -0.007518184836953878, 0.043548908084630966, -0.05428016930818558, -0.05041801556944847, 0.0064578489400446415, 0.021537242457270622, 0.044057298451662064, -0.032160330563783646, 0.05575195327401161, -0.0270070843398571, -0.018527831882238388, -0.05816638842225075, 0.03699248656630516, 0.001947614480741322, 0.008540749549865723, -0.01189531572163105, 0.047255370765924454, 0.03686809539794922, 0.02433238923549652, 0.047952938824892044, 0.03472839295864105, 0.012538976036012173, 0.014877401292324066, -0.076791912317276, -0.02368146926164627, -0.05475978925824165, -0.03244173154234886, 0.04333101585507393, -0.08093634992837906, -0.015255378559231758, 0.029361331835389137, -0.015381740406155586, -0.0372428297996521, -0.002739503514021635, 0.016281265765428543, -0.0007744025788269937, -0.018799440935254097, -0.012800653465092182, -0.004812098573893309, 0.03167172148823738, 0.03854014351963997, 0.011070174165070057, -0.03764226660132408, 0.027478398755192757, -0.038683436810970306, 0.008577198721468449, -0.031511060893535614, -0.017161427065730095, -0.009180895984172821, -0.04155657812952995, 0.0029892888851463795, -0.006861961912363768, 0.03043729066848755, 0.02012764848768711, -0.014051524922251701, 0.033122215420007706, 0.038404472172260284, -0.0258824210613966, -0.009663831442594528, -0.003755053272470832, 0.02540012076497078, -0.03469477966427803, 0.020395556464791298, -0.010407309047877789, 0.021738549694418907, -0.001920660026371479, 0.02943565882742405, 0.01744670420885086, 0.014428735710680485, 0.007016553543508053, 0.008838244713842869, 0.01269385777413845, 0.041788250207901, -0.050408873707056046, -0.038175955414772034, -0.04320642724633217, 0.010339993052184582, 0.00397592643275857, 0.02646254561841488, -0.008816591463983059, 0.011716031469404697, -0.08289842307567596, 0.02703253924846649, -0.011370893567800522, -0.014851565472781658, 0.020173264667391777, 0.04882087558507919, 0.02223922312259674, -0.0369938425719738, 0.01498432457447052, 0.00013733237574342638, 0.015683099627494812, 0.024637335911393166, -0.007541254162788391, -0.031645048409700394, -0.01763475313782692, -0.02910471335053444, -0.002728794002905488, 0.008556853048503399, -0.02790566347539425, -0.024141058325767517, 0.055814098566770554, 0.003162482287734747, -0.03010150045156479, 0.017413176596164703, -0.015534531325101852, 0.08296474814414978, 0.010793477296829224, 0.005806814879179001, -0.011092881672084332, -0.016651034355163574, 0.021301671862602234, -0.027485236525535583, 0.013255618512630463, -0.024367840960621834, -0.018744008615612984, -0.01465793140232563, -0.05598986893892288, 0.008552641607820988, -0.003547626780346036, -0.021103596314787865, -0.004854183178395033, -0.026564186438918114, 0.012668466195464134, -0.056600458920001984, -0.02716859243810177, 0.030430907383561134, -0.08228316903114319, 0.004308121744543314, 0.028924735262989998, 0.0008522964781150222, 0.04327946901321411, -0.05197104811668396, -0.04770013317465782, -0.0511467307806015, -0.04650427773594856, 0.022916661575436592, -0.031357210129499435, -0.05056602507829666, -0.01082172617316246, -0.00842017401009798, 0.007609334774315357, -0.00558215519413352, -0.017748333513736725, -0.00038941335515119135, -0.03884866088628769, 0.01060204952955246, 0.0543881393969059, -0.051600221544504166, -0.029767511412501335, 0.022972408682107925, -0.035499829798936844, 0.03790108859539032, -0.03979896381497383, 0.03312983363866806, 0.03648238256573677, -0.010787416249513626, 0.01922345720231533, -0.0631134957075119, 0.05620015785098076, -0.0061528789810836315, -0.03146657720208168, -0.0005690949037671089, -0.0002307631220901385, -0.02498123236000538, -0.01954391598701477, -0.03586659952998161, 0.02251850813627243, 0.012187753804028034, 0.01872766949236393, 0.008425723761320114, 0.009558000601828098, -0.02866842783987522, 0.011684915982186794, -0.04782785475254059, 0.0021784889977425337, 0.053172655403614044, 0.03129655122756958, -0.03460667282342911, -0.06095046550035477, -0.02946591190993786, 0.010938900522887707, -0.01660352200269699, 0.058977700769901276, -0.024088900536298752, 0.0400255061686039, 0.017414843663573265, 0.04411720111966133, 0.008169358596205711, -0.02592739835381508, 0.021678820252418518, -0.060251325368881226, 0.005941706243902445, -0.07031872868537903, 0.008828355930745602, 0.057637639343738556, -0.047817811369895935, 0.013570842333137989, -0.028682665899395943, -0.05860794335603714, 0.048564258962869644, -0.011819613166153431, -0.041264500468969345, 0.0024994101841002703, -0.025974290445446968, -0.01703435741364956, 0.04976766183972359, -0.06744785606861115, -0.03108547441661358, -0.014204570092260838, -0.044940412044525146, 0.009052284993231297, 0.018224792554974556, 0.05452992022037506, -0.02413129061460495, 0.01818653754889965, -0.0364144928753376, 0.0011486363364383578, 0.005631530657410622, 0.061566971242427826, -0.00373482471331954, 0.027829783037304878, -0.01621408388018608, 0.042988818138837814, 0.022685520350933075, 0.04491746798157692, -0.005840579513460398, 0.025686044245958328, -0.00006537275476148352, -0.043013714253902435, 0.04923315346240997, -0.013988330960273743, -0.009382625110447407, -0.05133042111992836, 0.057975370436906815, 0.040282584726810455, -0.04212312027812004, -0.00017954688519239426, 0.03137417510151863, -0.0326094813644886, -0.03570425137877464, 0.008628033101558685, 0.021845107898116112, 0.0037717123050242662, 0.09305933117866516, 0.02710654027760029, 0.04564419388771057, 0.08414407074451447, -0.0091039277613163, -0.00916869007050991, 0.002167611150071025, 0.07531766593456268, 0.041509732604026794, 0.07520414143800735, 0.0011681884061545134, 0.057934388518333435, -0.043895360082387924, -0.06675441563129425, 0.018596528097987175, 0.03744851052761078, -0.0469394288957119, -0.028988786041736603, -0.0018066775519400835, 0.060998380184173584, -0.019724510610103607, 0.05618001148104668, -0.025036979466676712, 0.0027846000157296658, 0.020788338035345078, 0.015123413875699043, 0.007342403754591942, 0.05539495125412941, 0.029664508998394012, 0.03232193738222122, -0.027896875515580177, -0.017070800065994263, -0.0011915587820112705, -0.011736661195755005, -0.0004929964779876173, -0.020926419645547867, -0.024257389828562737, 0.010794262401759624, 0.0043232557363808155, 0.035085760056972504, 0.11108999699354172, -0.037808701395988464, -0.012869191356003284, 0.050417982041835785, -0.01748059317469597, 0.012962688691914082, 0.026328828185796738, -0.00395337026566267, -0.02225400321185589, -0.0011315123410895467, -0.025537332519888878, -0.0027478495612740517, 0.017399709671735764, 0.004618111066520214, 0.03980237618088722, -0.032713405787944794, 0.004914237651973963, 0.03021056205034256, 0.014461777172982693, -0.054767731577157974, -0.057674746960401535, -0.03467632457613945, -0.0601428858935833, -0.03890528157353401, -0.044358205050230026, -0.002134626964107156, -0.0028956695459783077, -0.014190741814672947, 0.047270290553569794, -0.00485867727547884, 0.0019146865233778954, 0.021984199061989784, -0.0824519693851471, -0.007776916492730379, 0.05157763883471489, -0.006176382303237915, -0.0027202588971704245, 0.03309144824743271, 0.020529603585600853, -0.02495020627975464, -0.01628059148788452, 0.024058591574430466, 0.012613145634531975, 0.010369556024670601, -0.011067873798310757, -0.003616528818383813, -0.09972760081291199, -0.005115406587719917, 0.018990587443113327, -0.008073939010500908, -0.09142929315567017, 0.012019420973956585, -0.016211804002523422, 0.041511256247758865, 0.08542440831661224, 0.031017886474728584, -0.002477819100022316, -0.05984104052186012, 0.004642868414521217, 0.0023871478624641895, 0.015718959271907806, 0.062084224075078964, -0.040470268577337265, 0.047008343040943146, 0.01592451147735119, -0.046741828322410583, -0.05202502757310867, 0.03929366171360016, -0.026843663305044174, -0.03889426589012146, -0.01773410104215145, -0.021218545734882355, -0.015396584756672382, -0.09902162849903107, -0.018734430894255638, 0.008077404461801052, -0.02025461010634899, -0.0314675010740757, -0.013159663416445255, -0.014627560041844845, -0.00223289686255157, 0.013143566437065601, -0.03732201084494591, -0.029381489381194115, -0.007170267403125763, -0.02487288787961006, -0.07636605203151703, 0.016560953110456467, -0.029268180951476097, -0.0010103719541803002, -0.032907839864492416, -0.02131698839366436, 0.0129345478489995, -0.005031288135796785, 0.04404958710074425, 0.006826625671237707, 0.01626141369342804, -0.0001620798429939896 ]
3,561
Enhancing the Scalability and Applicability of Kohn-Sham Hamiltonians for Molecular Systems
https://openreview.net/forum?id=twEvvkQqPS
[ "Yunyang Li", "Zaishuo Xia", "Lin Huang", "Xinran Wei", "Samuel Harshe", "Han Yang", "Erpai Luo", "Zun Wang", "Jia Zhang", "Chang Liu", "Bin Shao", "Mark Gerstein" ]
Spotlight
Density Functional Theory (DFT) is a pivotal method within quantum chemistry and materials science, with its core involving the construction and solution of the Kohn-Sham Hamiltonian. Despite its importance, the application of DFT is frequently limited by the substantial computational resources required to construct the Kohn-Sham Hamiltonian. In response to these limitations, current research has employed deep-learning models to efficiently predict molecular and solid Hamiltonians, with roto-translational symmetries encoded in their neural networks. However, the scalability of prior models may be problematic when applied to large molecules, resulting in non-physical predictions of ground-state properties. In this study, we generate a substantially larger training set (PubChemQH) than used previously and use it to create a scalable model for DFT calculations with physical accuracy. For our model, we introduce a loss function derived from physical principles, which we call Wavefunction Alignment Loss (WALoss). WALoss involves performing a basis change on the predicted Hamiltonian to align it with the observed one; thus, the resulting differences can serve as a surrogate for orbital energy differences, allowing models to make better predictions for molecular orbitals and total energies than previously possible. WALoss also substantially accelerates self-consistent-field (SCF) DFT calculations. Here, we show it achieves a reduction in total energy prediction error by a factor of 1347 and an SCF calculation speed-up by a factor of 18\%. These substantial improvements set new benchmarks for achieving accurate and applicable predictions in larger molecular systems.
AI for Science, Quantum Chemistry, EGNN
We present a new framework to enhance the scalability and applicability of Kohn-Shan Hamiltonian.
4,886
2502.19227
[ -0.014147807843983173, 0.013901722617447376, -0.029955580830574036, 0.05871487036347389, 0.041112642735242844, -0.002239742549136281, 0.030497178435325623, 0.005147081334143877, 0.008982578292489052, -0.05810268968343735, 0.03362806886434555, 0.00931310374289751, -0.059764280915260315, 0.014084262773394585, 0.034525204449892044, 0.05050228536128998, 0.0565483383834362, 0.009152591228485107, 0.0028408635407686234, -0.029382910579442978, 0.00021717867639381438, -0.011641442775726318, 0.007184773683547974, 0.022002490237355232, 0.021762624382972717, 0.005372221581637859, 0.004154233727604151, 0.005880123935639858, -0.012659193947911263, 0.005115308333188295, 0.04013707861304283, 0.0139877088367939, 0.006470493506640196, -0.03497517853975296, 0.00868520513176918, 0.03361691161990166, -0.03427328169345856, -0.004302406683564186, 0.006709780544042587, 0.02413409948348999, -0.040914591401815414, 0.018213985487818718, 0.04019979014992714, 0.0623655691742897, -0.042729612439870834, 0.013833549804985523, -0.07563430070877075, 0.06510354578495026, -0.03487900644540787, -0.04083793982863426, -0.07155130803585052, 0.04114454239606857, 0.0020301383920013905, -0.03799774497747421, -0.021586062386631966, 0.0319562666118145, -0.005090340506285429, -0.00657845102250576, -0.032934799790382385, -0.04063739255070686, -0.017522666603326797, 0.015941346064209938, -0.01376066729426384, -0.00778333842754364, 0.018817277625203133, -0.040028586983680725, 0.030014680698513985, 0.043553028255701065, -0.07723230123519897, 0.008786218240857124, 0.017282309010624886, 0.011606954969465733, -0.005350571591407061, -0.03233109042048454, -0.0016013343119993806, -0.016573145985603333, 0.04411416873335838, 0.01146070659160614, 0.057322658598423004, 0.05402608960866928, 0.007318504620343447, 0.04162418097257614, 0.004192608408629894, 0.012044454924762249, -0.014698944054543972, 0.009071312844753265, -0.05971960723400116, 0.0347064808011055, -0.065072201192379, 0.04598258435726166, -0.005724179558455944, -0.008181450888514519, 0.021545767784118652, 0.0357968844473362, 0.04723067954182625, -0.021544545888900757, 0.029195386916399002, 0.0018317995127290487, 0.015142838470637798, -0.00589088024571538, -0.008611856959760189, -0.035147927701473236, 0.00999821349978447, -0.029205914586782455, -0.06955394148826599, -0.007846149615943432, -0.06527493894100189, -0.019732069224119186, -0.009645393118262291, 0.005073057487607002, -0.044149335473775864, 0.031327858567237854, -0.00016666993906255811, -0.005747475661337376, -0.06382054090499878, 0.026920028030872345, -0.0020816284231841564, 0.024467458948493004, -0.008874481543898582, -0.001175092882476747, 0.051589008420705795, 0.09246888011693954, -0.02047715149819851, 0.06146477162837982, 0.01802319660782814, -0.0036579349543899298, 0.039436567574739456, 0.014532861299812794, -0.03841627761721611, -0.031306710094213486, 0.05571343004703522, 0.04661337286233902, 0.022447548806667328, 0.0018917903071269393, -0.013053862378001213, -0.031061111018061638, 0.010666578076779842, 0.020005274564027786, 0.045534953474998474, -0.000238120075664483, -0.005335684400051832, -0.051330167800188065, 0.05851929262280464, -0.012673669494688511, 0.05227375775575638, -0.01230626180768013, 0.021678907796740532, -0.049591004848480225, -0.004247215576469898, 0.01599516160786152, -0.013515525497496128, -0.012484164908528328, -0.015491307713091373, -0.04894606024026871, 0.04298407584428787, 0.03212332725524902, 0.046575166285037994, 0.016220247372984886, 0.02501065470278263, -0.0172636229544878, -0.007971546612679958, -0.03630029782652855, 0.0011078399838879704, -0.005167068913578987, 0.011767026036977768, -0.05243062600493431, -0.0003051873354706913, 0.07045994699001312, -0.01650114916265011, 0.01657441072165966, -0.014475665986537933, -0.04955599829554558, 0.058775097131729126, -0.011428759433329105, 0.006113739218562841, -0.002086399355903268, 0.02562417834997177, -0.0039698099717497826, 0.013277636840939522, 0.0220150426030159, -0.07816163450479507, 0.018634304404258728, 0.03447998687624931, -0.014536458998918533, -0.006441527511924505, 0.027405304834246635, 0.09308180212974548, -0.00040740828262642026, -0.007429656572639942, 0.024230580776929855, -0.08239252120256424, -0.018551837652921677, 0.054673079401254654, -0.008647967129945755, 0.07827413082122803, -0.01945212110877037, -0.01696578413248062, 0.005930508486926556, -0.0024347170256078243, 0.014637086540460587, 0.020345553755760193, 0.008030720055103302, 0.05843236297369003, -0.02209341712296009, -0.04927919805049896, -0.021215267479419708, 0.057525634765625, -0.06804061681032181, -0.022557565942406654, -0.0090357456356287, 0.01557502243667841, -0.04651792347431183, 0.00592400785535574, 0.003139471635222435, 0.010347706265747547, -0.008450503461062908, 0.015280032530426979, 0.0013551961164921522, -0.0052498215809464455, 0.019381796941161156, 0.02237495593726635, 0.027655882760882378, -0.007325383834540844, -0.014317357912659645, -0.02158414013683796, 0.1169263944029808, 0.09872836619615555, -0.042236581444740295, -0.026752743870019913, 0.028531739488244057, 0.023677505552768707, -0.021670904010534286, 0.019426915794610977, -0.021306078881025314, 0.015991609543561935, -0.07031816989183426, 0.027186939492821693, -0.004342669155448675, 0.057692185044288635, -0.06046009808778763, -0.005143544636666775, 0.06536684930324554, -0.009878170676529408, 0.06080906093120575, -0.015349150635302067, -0.005798874422907829, 0.06526801735162735, -0.04284948483109474, -0.03648434206843376, -0.004436656832695007, -0.02584214322268963, 0.017591118812561035, -0.01756332255899906, 0.0039147064089775085, 0.06172291561961174, -0.08561775088310242, -0.0010542876552790403, 0.015861891210079193, 0.05415930971503258, 0.024502893909811974, 0.0012056045234203339, 0.04527215659618378, -0.002865985967218876, -0.038369420915842056, -0.03615861386060715, -0.1165090873837471, -0.03674588352441788, -0.003168306779116392, 0.014728272333741188, -0.011576964519917965, 0.03893653303384781, 0.012560545466840267, -0.013921728357672691, -0.04124123230576515, -0.04684068262577057, -0.0021446174941956997, -0.025530852377414703, -0.008288216777145863, -0.025474194437265396, -0.04259864240884781, 0.010505523532629013, 0.10338461399078369, -0.0028001258615404367, -0.05344441905617714, -0.02442309260368347, -0.07209187746047974, 0.00300536397844553, -0.012562545016407967, 0.00457131490111351, -0.005291782319545746, 0.0008602666785009205, -0.01611056737601757, -0.017128795385360718, 0.020709408447146416, 0.02840488962829113, 0.040092434734106064, 0.06130608916282654, 0.01717897318303585, -0.01991243287920952, 0.0345037505030632, 0.02561301179230213, -0.008699774742126465, -0.03456748276948929, 0.02042534574866295, -0.015065093524754047, -0.0037069590762257576, 0.0169098898768425, 0.022457865998148918, -0.26784011721611023, -0.010775391012430191, 0.009221469983458519, -0.007438191212713718, 0.045451413840055466, -0.0018336920766159892, -0.003802546299993992, -0.023769397288560867, -0.03743946924805641, -0.004961458034813404, -0.0049133882857859135, 0.0324694998562336, -0.005026618950068951, 0.04747328162193298, 0.05267307534813881, 0.029073240235447884, 0.019109293818473816, -0.016771385446190834, -0.028708938509225845, 0.01673683151602745, -0.025329215452075005, -0.06306932866573334, -0.013769506476819515, 0.008710058405995369, 0.0035507604479789734, 0.023476654663681984, -0.08537270873785019, -0.003261025995016098, -0.046952247619628906, -0.023163631558418274, -0.05791689082980156, -0.011054598726332188, 0.020934805274009705, 0.03997677564620972, 0.05056434124708176, 0.0202164463698864, -0.001456765690818429, -0.030179519206285477, -0.006708545610308647, 0.011204843409359455, -0.048548243939876556, 0.0026702333707362413, -0.054112549871206284, 0.021986378356814384, 0.08729363232851028, 0.04867975041270256, 0.0005555252428166568, 0.039152175188064575, -0.033443428575992584, 0.033250752836465836, -0.03870883956551552, -0.03038291074335575, -0.010769780725240707, -0.03963718190789223, -0.05392932519316673, -0.0027501180302351713, -0.03457971289753914, 0.026430495083332062, -0.014081651344895363, 0.00921018049120903, 0.0055093723349273205, -0.029092159122228622, 0.0033906851895153522, -0.010768355801701546, -0.043703462928533554, -0.03597741201519966, -0.06855142116546631, -0.042120739817619324, 0.05181742459535599, 0.030815916135907173, -0.017568713054060936, 0.02065473049879074, -0.04488324001431465, -0.09598322212696075, 0.018612772226333618, -0.0005136207910254598, -0.019607452675700188, -0.04989413172006607, 0.0002661755424924195, 0.026113338768482208, -0.034000884741544724, -0.021390274167060852, 0.029981639236211777, 0.022312702611088753, 0.018461361527442932, -0.021364698186516762, -0.04864255338907242, -0.0059249382466077805, -0.024081310257315636, -0.008644293062388897, 0.045653700828552246, -0.021403243765234947, 0.030593672767281532, -0.0235272366553545, 0.046439338475465775, -0.018348820507526398, 0.02956060692667961, 0.024689726531505585, 0.010997489094734192, 0.03194020688533783, 0.02620660327374935, -0.03809865936636925, 0.002619928913190961, -0.05452845245599747, -0.042252615094184875, 0.024966714903712273, -0.05177660658955574, -0.002520671347156167, 0.0310312919318676, 0.029138419777154922, -0.03232241049408913, -0.007227789144963026, 0.020295290276408195, -0.007545359432697296, -0.005651136394590139, -0.016190048307180405, 0.00190399878192693, 0.03156140446662903, 0.01070422399789095, -0.017053663730621338, -0.016984520480036736, 0.04442473500967026, -0.013796460814774036, -0.04236424341797829, -0.035298097878694534, 0.005928786471486092, -0.02896840125322342, -0.01568281091749668, -0.007966367527842522, 0.009325913153588772, -0.012459308840334415, 0.05913742259144783, -0.0035447159316390753, 0.024605445563793182, 0.03870222344994545, 0.014305317774415016, -0.03706140071153641, -0.03683391213417053, 0.03591575473546982, -0.03726043179631233, 0.024906916543841362, -0.03062428906559944, 0.0459124930202961, 0.016979338601231575, 0.0230841264128685, 0.050743184983730316, 0.031201040372252464, 0.05086898431181908, 0.007512966636568308, 0.03896176442503929, 0.012498399242758751, -0.06863141804933548, -0.012153059244155884, -0.010398008860647678, -0.02605137974023819, -0.0036628583911806345, 0.017965596169233322, -0.006060909014195204, 0.05990328639745712, -0.04999488964676857, 0.034041743725538254, 0.010369258932769299, -0.015086661092936993, -0.006773634348064661, -0.007497463840991259, 0.049849897623062134, -0.050659578293561935, 0.027622593566775322, -0.024655118584632874, 0.0012344676069915295, 0.014861062169075012, -0.04327942430973053, -0.055382221937179565, -0.03313639387488365, -0.02850293554365635, 0.026005111634731293, 0.019604090601205826, -0.0064191813580691814, -0.03798435628414154, -0.005397332366555929, 0.008091767318546772, -0.016649112105369568, -0.004235859960317612, -0.00473689055070281, 0.05799112096428871, -0.015303341671824455, -0.016579441726207733, -0.04106496647000313, 0.004692684393376112, 0.014964614994823933, 0.002379175741225481, 0.01258615218102932, -0.020430918782949448, -0.01595780812203884, -0.030400078743696213, -0.0518970713019371, -0.0015951641835272312, 0.05824194476008415, -0.029694635421037674, 0.03823194280266762, 0.00660206051543355, 0.007548371329903603, -0.07418106496334076, 0.0228736512362957, 0.02378210611641407, -0.0674414411187172, 0.0017444683471694589, 0.05001431331038475, 0.049126334488391876, -0.0110520850867033, -0.024583641439676285, -0.0512637123465538, -0.05695296451449394, -0.006039551924914122, -0.0009720295784063637, 0.024150125682353973, 0.04916956275701523, -0.025417188182473183, 0.001213842537254095, -0.014501281082630157, -0.00925200991332531, 0.03438233211636543, 0.01724184863269329, -0.016888706013560295, 0.022650280967354774, 0.056901343166828156, -0.03187476098537445, 0.04896235093474388, 0.008460638113319874, -0.029355186969041824, 0.001712282421067357, -0.05551404878497124, 0.0030464318115264177, 0.02339158020913601, -0.0012649522395804524, 0.02612869068980217, -0.032006315886974335, 0.03278608247637749, -0.00936864223331213, 0.0004670933703891933, -0.004501511808484793, 0.012884113937616348, -0.009681868366897106, -0.01454467885196209, -0.026836402714252472, -0.0121562285348773, 0.009238967671990395, 0.02134675718843937, -0.012549690902233124, 0.014864734373986721, 0.03574802726507187, -0.015189285390079021, -0.059588368982076645, -0.009370269253849983, 0.07282450795173645, 0.0026122224517166615, -0.05935801938176155, -0.06685186177492142, -0.04290182143449783, -0.006143261678516865, -0.02425447106361389, 0.024333123117685318, -0.03986652195453644, 0.03186335787177086, 0.027249086648225784, 0.026737840846180916, -0.000541499350219965, -0.08516596257686615, 0.06369098275899887, -0.06357062608003616, -0.00003587797618820332, -0.07448316365480423, 0.0014055537758395076, 0.0366724468767643, 0.0036631114780902863, 0.010783812031149864, 0.0016060826601460576, -0.030353425070643425, 0.04413639381527901, -0.010934882797300816, -0.04071944206953049, 0.04387925565242767, 0.013602320104837418, -0.017338482663035393, 0.0326463058590889, -0.053114041686058044, -0.03340158611536026, -0.038331519812345505, -0.025376928970217705, -0.029358062893152237, 0.028329046443104744, 0.04277929663658142, -0.0274732057005167, -0.0013706558384001255, -0.039580781012773514, 0.014877323992550373, -0.0017096492229029536, 0.056105971336364746, -0.0021442866418510675, 0.03661813959479332, -0.03198852390050888, 0.0985485166311264, 0.06747239083051682, 0.00037593970773741603, 0.020820699632167816, 0.026537945494055748, 0.003525337902829051, -0.034503523260354996, 0.03722549229860306, 0.027862971648573875, 0.0015858145197853446, -0.057296060025691986, 0.007219940423965454, 0.0008978857076726854, -0.08170807361602783, 0.01226100604981184, 0.03946487978100777, -0.02355862595140934, 0.00947597622871399, 0.016951126977801323, 0.006586960982531309, -0.014435917139053345, 0.0778866857290268, -0.002979096956551075, 0.06550214439630508, 0.09077014029026031, 0.02555658668279648, -0.03567662090063095, -0.024566683918237686, 0.0521739237010479, 0.07463483512401581, 0.009171555750072002, -0.007959970273077488, 0.03232263773679733, -0.02251794934272766, -0.043607503175735474, -0.012202637270092964, -0.010227430611848831, -0.05048637464642525, -0.0001843438221840188, 0.01917981542646885, 0.10051017254590988, 0.002404293743893504, 0.05951102823019028, -0.028271324932575226, 0.026887213811278343, -0.018993927165865898, -0.01091616228222847, -0.010901268571615219, 0.042553141713142395, -0.00038366924854926765, 0.021394293755292892, -0.01336489338427782, -0.015509270131587982, -0.023913230746984482, -0.013826892711222172, 0.02310102805495262, -0.010704112239181995, 0.001069658319465816, 0.00048601668095216155, -0.0034292677883058786, 0.0457502081990242, 0.08893025666475296, -0.01483175065368414, -0.021126020699739456, 0.0019796269480139017, 0.004673610907047987, -0.004283999092876911, 0.036506425589323044, -0.013468779623508453, 0.014093613252043724, 0.00010245881276205182, -0.03696843609213829, 0.023872653022408485, 0.012299678288400173, -0.02639995887875557, 0.025839846581220627, -0.015942836180329323, -0.026376772671937943, 0.002169825369492173, 0.02253350429236889, -0.05355345830321312, -0.07440995424985886, -0.02311905100941658, -0.034759942442178726, -0.07120897620916367, -0.0768035501241684, 0.015259074978530407, -0.03315718472003937, -0.04562515765428543, 0.02564070373773575, -0.0017610889626666903, 0.018341129645705223, 0.03402535989880562, -0.05114517733454704, -0.036505430936813354, 0.0719350278377533, 0.01603490673005581, -0.046257320791482925, 0.04831226170063019, 0.06753323972225189, -0.02403002418577671, -0.023701945319771767, 0.05847322195768356, -0.005806444212794304, 0.04140068590641022, -0.016886932775378227, 0.02056037075817585, -0.09433996677398682, 0.00005731502460548654, -0.0012858485570177436, -0.02823602966964245, -0.0624258928000927, 0.000753471627831459, -0.009137754328548908, 0.016418419778347015, 0.03456389531493187, 0.024603556841611862, 0.0030598570592701435, -0.032499849796295166, -0.002389375353232026, 0.01985969953238964, -0.0012531365500763059, 0.07212362438440323, -0.06316403299570084, 0.052331022918224335, 0.025461001321673393, -0.01934679225087166, -0.023945949971675873, 0.004203143063932657, 0.011221258901059628, -0.012054214254021645, -0.04197756201028824, 0.018027519807219505, -0.053890328854322433, -0.0837676078081131, -0.021561570465564728, 0.022679289802908897, -0.015181285329163074, -0.022065818309783936, -0.01192934438586235, 0.022210365161299706, -0.003750713774934411, -0.0038861646316945553, -0.01583724655210972, -0.0029284670017659664, -0.043310459703207016, -0.05161994695663452, -0.04836782440543175, 0.01396010909229517, 0.022707123309373856, -0.021244624629616737, -0.03172481805086136, -0.03896027058362961, 0.0017456565983593464, -0.0158216655254364, 0.03923835977911949, 0.03430398553609848, 0.02955448068678379, -0.016132179647684097 ]
3,562
Dense Video Object Captioning from Disjoint Supervision
https://openreview.net/forum?id=auZZ2gN0ZN
[ "Xingyi Zhou", "Anurag Arnab", "Chen Sun", "Cordelia Schmid" ]
Spotlight
We propose a new task and model for dense video object captioning -- detecting, tracking and captioning trajectories of objects in a video. This task unifies spatial and temporal localization in video, whilst also requiring fine-grained visual understanding that is best described by natural language. We propose a unified model, and demonstrate how our end-to-end approach is more accurate and temporally coherent than a multi-stage pipeline combining state-of-the-art detection, tracking, and captioning models. Moreover, we propose a training strategy based on a mixture of disjoint tasks, which allows us to leverage diverse, large-scale datasets which supervise different parts of our model. Although each pretraining task only provides weak supervision, they are complementary and, when combined, result in noteworthy zero-shot ability and serve as strong initialization for additional finetuning to further improve accuracy. We carefully design new metrics capturing all components of our task, and show how we can repurpose existing video grounding datasets (e.g. VidSTG and VLN) for our new task. We show that our model improves upon a number of strong baselines for this new task. Furthermore, we can apply our model to the task of spatial grounding, outperforming prior state-of-the-art on VidSTG and VLN, without explicitly training for it. Our code is available at https://github.com/google-research/scenic.
object captioning, video, tracking
null
4,872
2306.11729
[ 0.039892420172691345, -0.02394692413508892, 0.00264012161642313, 0.04820467159152031, 0.020407596603035927, -0.010962146334350109, 0.026794863864779472, 0.016331715509295464, -0.018734315410256386, -0.01989556849002838, -0.05113079398870468, 0.003643018426373601, -0.06947106122970581, 0.012242724187672138, 0.01322527602314949, 0.04729890078306198, 0.04435274377465248, 0.0005913685308769345, 0.010478104464709759, 0.0161952655762434, -0.014825672842562199, -0.03520544618368149, 0.021095043048262596, -0.011844675987958908, 0.018600206822156906, 0.001671252422966063, -0.0032191418576985598, 0.024139776825904846, -0.0659470185637474, -0.022588303312659264, 0.017085591331124306, -0.021836940199136734, -0.008477122522890568, -0.010161230340600014, 0.041609637439250946, -0.04043897986412048, -0.0307986531406641, 0.010042057372629642, 0.03184998780488968, 0.019240379333496094, -0.02752823755145073, -0.017828213050961494, -0.003680971683934331, -0.02498539909720421, -0.07322201132774353, -0.003993126563727856, -0.0902898833155632, 0.018459904938936234, 0.028789309784770012, -0.05609973892569542, -0.07767023146152496, 0.041877031326293945, 0.03146819397807121, 0.021630246192216873, -0.012443180195987225, 0.010499568656086922, 0.05774462968111038, -0.11282582581043243, 0.006295256316661835, -0.05153799057006836, -0.003574965288862586, 0.02953905239701271, 0.016192618757486343, 0.02484584040939808, 0.023063119500875473, -0.037899721413850784, -0.008516213856637478, 0.05372191220521927, -0.023912319913506508, -0.061342187225818634, 0.011095207184553146, -0.011638865806162357, -0.008168177679181099, 0.02212502434849739, 0.013514917343854904, -0.00990893505513668, 0.011939456686377525, -0.011858378536999226, 0.07136112451553345, -0.03647258132696152, 0.01328094769269228, 0.02614261955022812, 0.011908814311027527, 0.03654417768120766, 0.04364096373319626, 0.04465626925230026, -0.03592148423194885, -0.03737184405326843, -0.06758743524551392, 0.0165927242487669, -0.023699495941400528, -0.0062219854444265366, 0.009446348994970322, 0.02359163947403431, 0.018945196643471718, 0.001608742866665125, 0.010754162445664406, 0.0036775381304323673, 0.01385929249227047, -0.006516577675938606, -0.035750698298215866, -0.02139206789433956, 0.05803176015615463, 0.012306221760809422, -0.09672814607620239, -0.051106974482536316, -0.01977083459496498, 0.016140086576342583, 0.010904152877628803, 0.001326188095845282, -0.02299731783568859, 0.0006423492450267076, 0.010021003894507885, 0.005938197486102581, -0.04482926428318024, 0.004897526931017637, 0.0035339398309588432, 0.003955961670726538, -0.035643257200717926, 0.002371065318584442, 0.0368899330496788, 0.03379833698272705, 0.02295118384063244, 0.06001612916588783, -0.011540441773831844, 0.0120084835216403, -0.03375646844506264, 0.014973185956478119, -0.043392907828092575, -0.01495906338095665, 0.009378168731927872, 0.03328265622258186, 0.006087685469537973, 0.01288408599793911, 0.0050741578452289104, 0.0098178181797266, 0.025625022128224373, -0.035973191261291504, 0.024031976237893105, -0.010899796150624752, -0.0009367959573864937, -0.005129396449774504, 0.043279293924570084, -0.012009424157440662, 0.08426832407712936, -0.017225690186023712, -0.016220245510339737, -0.020110413432121277, -0.011527936905622482, 0.009856543503701687, 0.02874007262289524, -0.05089069902896881, 0.03866970166563988, -0.08530591428279877, 0.022278521209955215, 0.08826307207345963, 0.009598586708307266, 0.047101303935050964, 0.012468540109694004, -0.0022788785863667727, 0.014004073105752468, 0.016410578042268753, -0.07510188966989517, 0.01251003984361887, -0.022162506356835365, -0.09536216408014297, 0.014462083578109741, 0.00340220145881176, -0.0381951667368412, 0.00812098290771246, -0.028928866609930992, -0.028026612475514412, 0.03821296617388725, -0.005094329360872507, -0.033020686358213425, -0.006330218631774187, 0.05932807922363281, 0.02437504753470421, 0.0377364456653595, 0.04779231175780296, -0.08866008371114731, 0.0382232740521431, 0.021852664649486542, -0.04738643765449524, 0.032279256731271744, 0.0037094675935804844, 0.0640190839767456, -0.025654660537838936, -0.04803209751844406, 0.009845742024481297, -0.03986306115984917, -0.03102860227227211, -0.0022970319259911776, -0.03826834633946419, 0.02997973933815956, 0.005173449870198965, 0.004389057867228985, 0.018987003713846207, 0.03784956783056259, 0.047522690147161484, 0.03949262201786041, -0.012919070199131966, 0.06549721211194992, -0.00490102032199502, -0.029086865484714508, 0.016155296936631203, 0.022268416360020638, -0.011514801532030106, -0.022198248654603958, 0.01683485321700573, -0.0046015349216759205, -0.0019771892111748457, 0.02199532277882099, 0.03626101091504097, 0.01512385904788971, 0.045389801263809204, 0.008916238322854042, 0.0014119629049673676, 0.03230692446231842, -0.04171711578965187, 0.04365566372871399, 0.011296280659735203, -0.029452836140990257, 0.0018038572743535042, -0.07055912166833878, 0.0914873480796814, 0.03140812739729881, -0.004260334651917219, -0.004087832290679216, 0.006730341352522373, 0.0027662012726068497, 0.024323299527168274, -0.0032406041864305735, -0.04475495219230652, -0.021909121423959732, -0.008846708573400974, 0.04480239748954773, -0.041910406202077866, 0.020527394488453865, -0.05106588825583458, 0.013137777335941792, 0.06040135398507118, 0.0034861178137362003, 0.02802412584424019, -0.01363852433860302, -0.004417992662638426, 0.07737407088279724, 0.012486028485000134, -0.017798347398638725, -0.006675019394606352, -0.008032189682126045, -0.007467202842235565, -0.021382948383688927, -0.007044109981507063, 0.006363287102431059, -0.036560602486133575, -0.0413086861371994, -0.04172462970018387, 0.06856434047222137, 0.05605525150895119, 0.0503535196185112, 0.05723657086491585, -0.02019207552075386, -0.031817927956581116, -0.04840964451432228, -0.08936750143766403, -0.041112154722213745, -0.00587577885016799, 0.029039200395345688, 0.00826038047671318, 0.03861679881811142, 0.018172957003116608, 0.03651177138090134, -0.037285178899765015, 0.011500879190862179, 0.00745055079460144, 0.04944273829460144, 0.05035078898072243, 0.00457511842250824, 0.00016120096552185714, -0.010330275632441044, 0.04068398103117943, 0.009837408550083637, 0.01077956985682249, -0.032798461616039276, -0.03930721804499626, -0.020842919126152992, -0.026397155597805977, -0.015885822474956512, -0.036547426134347916, 0.026664558798074722, 0.01620797999203205, -0.019085673615336418, 0.003359475638717413, 0.02281181886792183, 0.0776933953166008, 0.06110546365380287, -0.013635246083140373, -0.016981860622763634, 0.03650873154401779, -0.013289039954543114, 0.023768717423081398, 0.006910078227519989, 0.012302388437092304, -0.023020125925540924, 0.015181795693933964, 0.03273557499051094, -0.005626448895782232, -0.26512664556503296, -0.007117030210793018, 0.025543462485074997, 0.01301927212625742, 0.042938072234392166, -0.051709022372961044, 0.0445641465485096, -0.06128785386681557, -0.04352062940597534, 0.012615742161870003, 0.0008556040120311081, 0.03310680016875267, 0.01760011911392212, 0.032937996089458466, 0.06520573049783707, 0.04741809517145157, 0.01952490210533142, -0.030097348615527153, 0.007094474043697119, 0.05803068354725838, -0.0222953911870718, -0.06277184933423996, -0.003947507590055466, 0.04748981073498726, -0.025600843131542206, 0.044070713222026825, -0.07892348617315292, -0.019231265410780907, -0.006024430971592665, -0.03507765009999275, 0.0075536263175308704, -0.02035975083708763, -0.03737057372927666, 0.030938856303691864, -0.014902379363775253, 0.03545069321990013, 0.0692727267742157, -0.012596039101481438, 0.024047836661338806, -0.027891652658581734, 0.009549552574753761, -0.0046422360464930534, -0.015892477706074715, 0.009051076136529446, 0.0879184901714325, -0.007818003185093403, -0.05804549530148506, -0.0491529256105423, -0.03349686786532402, 0.00002275953556818422, 0.011874892748892307, 0.009218712337315083, -0.03390168398618698, -0.00800777692347765, 0.02107393369078636, -0.035735972225666046, 0.011579002253711224, -0.006769695319235325, 0.0019780045840889215, -0.006145515013486147, -0.00197456288151443, -0.04519634321331978, -0.021759839728474617, -0.02493695728480816, -0.003330039791762829, -0.02136499062180519, -0.037965018302202225, -0.032375309616327286, 0.020990338176488876, 0.033293239772319794, -0.03070126101374626, 0.0351296029984951, -0.01087638083845377, -0.09801474213600159, 0.020793640986084938, -0.005501735955476761, 0.00535734836012125, -0.03920748457312584, 0.02315877564251423, 0.050719521939754486, -0.022917626425623894, -0.06213495135307312, 0.04733811318874359, 0.028806036338210106, 0.04736068844795227, -0.03311082348227501, 0.04106646776199341, -0.04516575485467911, 0.011546122841536999, -0.05801749229431152, 0.049681179225444794, -0.0364261157810688, -0.000055043328757165, 0.020780500024557114, 0.01998342201113701, 0.07119551301002502, 0.026573488488793373, 0.026444947347044945, 0.03328508138656616, -0.005361851770430803, 0.020284242928028107, -0.06566719710826874, 0.0007115171756595373, -0.03793913871049881, -0.009594695642590523, 0.0009347752784378827, -0.04444419965147972, 0.0021074919495731592, 0.026508241891860962, -0.0021296399645507336, -0.05906790494918823, 0.0017354817828163505, 0.01314118504524231, -0.004372454714030027, -0.0049908156506717205, 0.0032049762085080147, -0.026864366605877876, 0.018566634505987167, 0.03250391036272049, -0.04728194698691368, -0.03557664901018143, 0.023249270394444466, -0.01955178938806057, 0.03403849899768829, -0.03156209737062454, -0.026936907321214676, 0.005224969703704119, -0.01545171719044447, -0.005083752330392599, -0.003483240492641926, 0.022795094177126884, 0.06129416823387146, 0.00859071034938097, 0.020560050383210182, 0.047866497188806534, -0.03116721846163273, 0.006905173417180777, -0.021687673404812813, 0.060850173234939575, -0.0019351851660758257, 0.0014716709265485406, -0.034747928380966187, -0.003453778801485896, 0.06274113804101944, 0.02756238356232643, 0.004535284824669361, 0.02006840705871582, 0.02592848613858223, -0.01479694340378046, 0.007059226278215647, 0.021405000239610672, -0.041087985038757324, -0.033965639770030975, -0.00626634294167161, 0.017108842730522156, -0.01074859406799078, 0.009587522596120834, 0.002248005010187626, 0.03293329104781151, -0.030231477692723274, 0.048227161169052124, 0.024528374895453453, -0.014470528811216354, -0.003320785705000162, 0.051728781312704086, 0.0042884680442512035, 0.031186336651444435, -0.02645699679851532, 0.02406381443142891, -0.0011632915120571852, -0.004376951139420271, -0.006117747165262699, -0.03563320264220238, -0.01838638447225094, -0.01376271154731512, -0.026279153302311897, 0.013778125867247581, 0.022857515141367912, -0.04745292291045189, 0.05980420857667923, 0.028116891160607338, 0.004541427828371525, 0.041130658239126205, -0.024603333324193954, 0.05235009640455246, 0.03653983399271965, -0.022746369242668152, -0.028462886810302734, -0.02642671950161457, 0.05424948036670685, -0.016146712005138397, 0.014119517989456654, -0.026608573272824287, -0.024463023990392685, -0.027467135339975357, -0.0420299656689167, -0.00739657087251544, 0.03680664300918579, -0.03304191306233406, 0.015282083302736282, -0.036232396960258484, 0.03793942183256149, -0.06932677328586578, 0.013346916995942593, 0.01759636402130127, -0.056852567940950394, 0.021417906507849693, 0.05767809599637985, -0.03151461482048035, -0.0009541484178043902, -0.03913983330130577, -0.06319738179445267, -0.0543411448597908, -0.07851073145866394, -0.002712792716920376, -0.0173291377723217, 0.00741309579461813, -0.04730644449591637, 0.034352466464042664, -0.028492121025919914, 0.04537205025553703, 0.03129167854785919, -0.02706439420580864, 0.0008376079495064914, 0.009371038526296616, 0.023259853944182396, -0.03904319927096367, -0.0006172167486511171, 0.030641550198197365, -0.00183948187623173, -0.0020375982858240604, -0.016580676659941673, 0.005151290912181139, 0.0727703869342804, -0.050776977092027664, -0.009731622412800789, -0.052431728690862656, 0.02150285802781582, -0.00393318198621273, 0.004424850456416607, 0.05015415698289871, 0.023954464122653008, 0.007244891952723265, 0.03760383278131485, -0.0038460218347609043, 0.012553955428302288, 0.02546539343893528, 0.01578168012201786, 0.024760663509368896, 0.018994541838765144, 0.031292401254177094, -0.0033347916323691607, -0.045386265963315964, -0.013866467401385307, 0.03619259595870972, -0.04908217862248421, 0.010973270051181316, -0.08096319437026978, -0.04499835520982742, 0.023516515269875526, -0.007331377826631069, 0.026266658678650856, -0.03425921872258186, 0.026942601427435875, 0.022135229781270027, 0.03416593745350838, 0.017422953620553017, -0.009269341826438904, 0.024679528549313545, -0.045123741030693054, 0.011345664039254189, -0.04973200336098671, -0.053766924887895584, 0.07603450119495392, 0.012923662550747395, -0.002157520968466997, -0.023590678349137306, -0.022403806447982788, 0.04515467584133148, -0.018154775723814964, -0.06511783599853516, 0.026429682970046997, -0.05361352860927582, 0.02756619267165661, -0.03269961103796959, -0.04339483752846718, -0.006185873411595821, -0.0069001964293420315, -0.038176994770765305, 0.005514575634151697, -0.04233386740088463, 0.040154829621315, -0.0018039887072518468, -0.021340901032090187, -0.019051866605877876, -0.00452446611598134, 0.05227278172969818, 0.04542873799800873, 0.03082994744181633, 0.0026829501148313284, -0.0194729994982481, 0.04478708654642105, 0.00394852552562952, -0.06379137188196182, -0.02189416065812111, 0.005784373730421066, 0.016117967665195465, -0.05201468989253044, 0.08795391023159027, 0.005654764827340841, -0.018164684996008873, -0.07892336696386337, 0.05105642229318619, 0.022571507841348648, -0.03784655034542084, -0.0154804065823555, 0.0604364238679409, -0.04708915203809738, -0.014646078459918499, -0.00020082484115846455, 0.01082602608948946, -0.022812923416495323, 0.05889349803328514, 0.018925249576568604, 0.023531664162874222, 0.04671477526426315, 0.008748892694711685, 0.00418626656755805, -0.002822295529767871, 0.044297922402620316, 0.026101207360625267, 0.03722085803747177, -0.02740943431854248, 0.07395728677511215, -0.04943250119686127, -0.021533453837037086, 0.040492571890354156, -0.009871447458863258, -0.0021714982576668262, -0.04057411104440689, 0.0030366629362106323, 0.09622608870267868, -0.0020059109665453434, 0.05035949870944023, -0.05056343972682953, -0.04796634986996651, 0.050142183899879456, -0.027280576527118683, 0.008652910590171814, 0.02058180421590805, 0.05029822140932083, -0.007330790627747774, -0.0018771316390484571, -0.020184412598609924, 0.008690663613379002, -0.026944125071167946, 0.026987915858626366, -0.0075808558613061905, -0.013471276499330997, -0.021461885422468185, -0.01947788894176483, 0.02890554629266262, 0.11618251353502274, -0.000982373021543026, -0.040590789169073105, -0.011992022395133972, 0.012559537775814533, 0.004490259103477001, 0.05181160569190979, -0.010036301799118519, -0.04031609371304512, 0.019165383651852608, -0.0841241106390953, 0.023238420486450195, 0.02799508161842823, -0.020772721618413925, 0.025163846090435982, -0.005521549843251705, -0.021629558876156807, 0.005149885080754757, 0.005837377160787582, -0.023170165717601776, -0.034845318645238876, -0.03797202557325363, -0.05135105550289154, -0.047495875507593155, -0.06902330368757248, 0.042005740106105804, 0.032312966883182526, -0.03349069133400917, -0.03899413347244263, -0.04238259792327881, 0.039465613663196564, 0.011428073048591614, -0.0706135630607605, 0.017982371151447296, 0.0639026015996933, 0.01429734006524086, -0.028191842138767242, 0.032757315784692764, 0.008312885649502277, -0.020177192986011505, -0.016443507745862007, 0.02665822021663189, 0.05124937370419502, 0.0009920628508552909, -0.013903426006436348, -0.04195118322968483, -0.09537908434867859, -0.005377516616135836, 0.025911904871463776, -0.030132519081234932, -0.08282223343849182, 0.002843964844942093, -0.0129790548235178, 0.06200132891535759, 0.06154024973511696, -0.006772758439183235, 0.025891082361340523, -0.034721970558166504, -0.017422927543520927, -0.03356734663248062, 0.00871471781283617, 0.06663498282432556, -0.013773906975984573, 0.07164273411035538, 0.02456684038043022, -0.0033175002317875624, -0.03176916018128395, 0.016597643494606018, -0.006186292506754398, 0.02232278883457184, 0.005370624363422394, -0.05213804543018341, -0.03788881003856659, -0.10945110023021698, -0.05997559428215027, 0.03828209266066551, -0.02043805830180645, -0.02646392025053501, -0.027849985286593437, 0.003404727904126048, -0.013546728529036045, -0.001826489926315844, -0.003035662928596139, -0.010260420851409435, -0.02285141311585903, -0.03451640531420708, -0.03947763890028, 0.004934350959956646, -0.028955694288015366, -0.03389657288789749, -0.03451857343316078, -0.03150589019060135, -0.028173144906759262, -0.012815653346478939, 0.02751380205154419, 0.026166141033172607, 0.004998425021767616, -0.009075071662664413 ]
3,563
SplatFormer: Point Transformer for Robust 3D Gaussian Splatting
https://openreview.net/forum?id=9NfHbWKqMF
[ "Yutong Chen", "Marko Mihajlovic", "Xiyi Chen", "Yiming Wang", "Sergey Prokudin", "Siyu Tang" ]
Spotlight
3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS) has recently transformed photorealistic reconstruction, achieving high visual fidelity and real-time performance. However, rendering quality significantly deteriorates when test views deviate from the camera angles used during training, posing a major challenge for applications in immersive free-viewpoint rendering and navigation. In this work, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of 3DGS and related novel view synthesis methods under out-of-distribution (OOD) test camera scenarios. By creating diverse test cases with synthetic and real-world datasets, we demonstrate that most existing methods, including those incorporating various regularization techniques and data-driven priors, struggle to generalize effectively to OOD views. To address this limitation, we introduce SplatFormer, the first point transformer model specifically designed to operate on Gaussian splats. SplatFormer takes as input an initial 3DGS set optimized under limited training views and refines it in a single forward pass, effectively removing potential artifacts in OOD test views. To our knowledge, this is the first successful application of point transformers directly on 3DGS sets, surpassing the limitations of previous multi-scene training methods, which could handle only a restricted number of input views during inference. Our model significantly improves rendering quality under extreme novel views, achieving state-of-the-art performance in these challenging scenarios and outperforming various 3DGS regularization techniques, multi-scene models tailored for sparse view synthesis, and diffusion-based frameworks. The project url is https://sergeyprokudin.github.io/splatformer.
Novel View Synthesis, Gaussian Splatting, Point cloud modeling
A feed-forward transformer that refines 3DGS for out-of-distribution novel view synthesis
4,834
2411.06390
[ 0.00742175942286849, -0.020280594006180763, 0.04193899407982826, 0.029857419431209564, 0.009801388718187809, 0.012304369360208511, 0.005499741993844509, 0.0057716090232133865, -0.041343189775943756, -0.04224051907658577, -0.010418727062642574, -0.026063067838549614, -0.06207342818379402, 0.013906043022871017, -0.013420228846371174, 0.05367908254265785, -0.022117098793387413, -0.011153146624565125, -0.015839366242289543, 0.05320761725306511, -0.0028071862179785967, -0.06028807908296585, 0.03464731201529503, 0.01020112819969654, 0.009790880605578423, -0.001031090272590518, 0.032640572637319565, 0.06760548055171967, -0.030839726328849792, -0.009959173388779163, 0.01768590323626995, -0.00006492468673968688, 0.0026695923879742622, -0.08490604907274246, -0.005977177992463112, -0.01651017926633358, -0.06312717497348785, 0.009276101365685463, 0.000020287840015953407, -0.015857679769396782, -0.029867492616176605, 0.02670704573392868, -0.023497577756643295, -0.02004442736506462, -0.03336206078529358, 0.007910377345979214, -0.05563275143504143, 0.03958924114704132, -0.024134570732712746, -0.028874581679701805, -0.07612229138612747, 0.028332984074950218, -0.006759402342140675, 0.004600442945957184, -0.006629830226302147, 0.039034515619277954, 0.05071336776018143, -0.05259276181459427, -0.010787799954414368, -0.05863615497946739, -0.04052412882447243, -0.022221196442842484, 0.008184878155589104, 0.005574455019086599, 0.009646530263125896, 0.0017588743939995766, -0.013342024758458138, 0.043589431792497635, 0.00599166052415967, -0.039720162749290466, 0.007299987133592367, -0.0304690171033144, 0.02509847655892372, 0.008056708611547947, -0.0010089585557579994, -0.027727991342544556, 0.0013804887421429157, 0.024403778836131096, 0.08621397614479065, -0.013300721533596516, 0.06353416293859482, -0.04505830630660057, 0.014671418815851212, 0.02799113467335701, -0.007287493906915188, 0.003822303144261241, 0.010858556255698204, -0.01494112703949213, -0.05260283127427101, 0.05408399924635887, -0.0011309441179037094, -0.048388272523880005, 0.01765354909002781, 0.03152184560894966, 0.04472603648900986, 0.03206528350710869, 0.0020963505376130342, 0.01318003237247467, 0.02677711471915245, -0.014263688586652279, 0.02655094861984253, -0.006913688965141773, 0.006693563424050808, 0.011324523948132992, -0.1065208688378334, -0.033657949417829514, -0.008336382918059826, -0.024146059527993202, -0.007239188998937607, 0.01903732307255268, -0.05791902914643288, -0.008126386441290379, 0.00864380318671465, -0.0129523491486907, -0.09115571528673172, 0.03423287719488144, 0.022562632337212563, 0.01691139116883278, 0.006757623516023159, 0.008203069679439068, 0.07353544980287552, 0.02635491080582142, -0.01789402775466442, 0.06168932095170021, -0.002772037871181965, 0.02230881340801716, 0.027677353471517563, 0.023707928135991096, -0.057402946054935455, -0.03854309022426605, 0.02160891331732273, -0.0023436842020601034, -0.030650803819298744, 0.0183404553681612, 0.026683583855628967, -0.06761801987886429, -0.0072222487069666386, -0.0041380333714187145, -0.0008631770615465939, -0.020073464140295982, 0.007085684686899185, -0.001521055935882032, 0.04219212010502815, -0.023601066321134567, 0.06580963730812073, -0.03366205468773842, 0.004640006460249424, -0.014491626992821693, -0.0435396172106266, 0.045096542686223984, 0.024030698463320732, -0.0065942504443228245, 0.015570160001516342, -0.07596604526042938, 0.038777582347393036, 0.049152206629514694, 0.04556886851787567, 0.021021105349063873, -0.00478880200535059, -0.007301414385437965, 0.0035593409556895494, 0.00896507315337658, -0.024490179494023323, 0.018054284155368805, -0.017547816038131714, -0.012274048291146755, 0.015963617712259293, -0.013416833244264126, -0.018512964248657227, -0.034426916390657425, -0.030391722917556763, -0.02306392602622509, 0.03860292211174965, 0.023263942450284958, 0.0127329733222723, -0.04042494669556618, 0.04843172803521156, -0.0017408716958016157, -0.00627181539312005, 0.03602595627307892, -0.0834994912147522, -0.02218061499297619, 0.009904063306748867, -0.034397874027490616, -0.006061260122805834, -0.033945925533771515, 0.07688967883586884, -0.005086857359856367, -0.04683161899447441, 0.026423241943120956, -0.10423555225133896, -0.03805790841579437, -0.000004348356924310792, -0.0008198580471798778, 0.05882364884018898, 0.003910338506102562, -0.029382146894931793, -0.0030861597042530775, 0.05134246498346329, 0.033878106623888016, 0.03323415666818619, -0.016040509566664696, 0.05166042968630791, 0.016181301325559616, -0.019854363054037094, -0.03601976856589317, 0.0318855345249176, -0.02024882845580578, -0.04131552204489708, -0.003868812695145607, 0.029009496793150902, -0.02380470372736454, 0.024733824655413628, 0.010969821363687515, 0.010702937841415405, 0.0016328952042385936, -0.023762758821249008, 0.009979610331356525, 0.013350394554436207, -0.04083159193396568, 0.0031095794402062893, 0.028182610869407654, -0.026059113442897797, -0.00728848110884428, -0.02136959694325924, 0.07877220213413239, 0.05967911705374718, -0.025052282959222794, -0.01741807721555233, -0.047535065561532974, -0.0239085853099823, 0.022533012554049492, 0.03039064072072506, -0.05230860784649849, 0.004587792791426182, -0.04171370342373848, 0.046365898102521896, -0.05132630094885826, 0.05408095940947533, -0.05091404169797897, -0.04326486960053444, 0.04768743738532066, 0.018331633880734444, 0.04665077105164528, 0.049414072185754776, 0.023380037397146225, 0.05437089875340462, -0.017016036435961723, -0.004616598132997751, -0.02838161773979664, 0.0034681865945458412, 0.012858542613685131, -0.0016196384094655514, -0.014737281017005444, -0.03345601260662079, -0.010302389040589333, -0.015532846562564373, -0.05212000012397766, 0.06650654971599579, 0.03992176055908203, 0.02262149192392826, 0.001701677800156176, 0.027563150972127914, -0.02819223515689373, -0.05675693228840828, -0.1070714071393013, -0.042734451591968536, -0.027314895763993263, -0.003598502604290843, 0.027064822614192963, 0.05114502087235451, 0.007969687692821026, -0.0014028724981471896, -0.047120172530412674, -0.013142549432814121, 0.0027244228404015303, -0.0088888518512249, 0.01606438308954239, -0.014129195362329483, -0.029935769736766815, 0.005318862851709127, 0.06719538569450378, -0.020538659766316414, 0.005413541570305824, -0.05379195883870125, -0.028406640514731407, -0.00003161992572131567, 0.0017562259454280138, -0.014603386633098125, -0.015229511074721813, 0.02468266896903515, 0.016793860122561455, -0.03701353818178177, 0.0147273950278759, 0.067156121134758, 0.09040958434343338, 0.038202472031116486, -0.03674609959125519, -0.03835958614945412, 0.011148432269692421, -0.033761166036129, 0.002116595860570669, 0.01415509358048439, -0.021440276876091957, -0.03813846409320831, -0.014121705666184425, 0.02682076208293438, -0.02258172072470188, -0.27752724289894104, -0.011302643455564976, -0.0013930097920820117, -0.03181006386876106, 0.020665667951107025, -0.009557776153087616, 0.04647618159651756, -0.039846271276474, -0.030733633786439896, 0.043487515300512314, -0.002702749567106366, 0.05031323432922363, 0.012466343119740486, 0.06344332545995712, 0.05072847381234169, 0.020610077306628227, 0.016568390652537346, -0.0010975445620715618, 0.019849205389618874, 0.04343933239579201, -0.0374026745557785, -0.08359777927398682, -0.01519467867910862, 0.02154490537941456, -0.03434447571635246, 0.02719533070921898, -0.05169644579291344, -0.01408308558166027, -0.02658086083829403, 0.007014711387455463, 0.01954071968793869, -0.04675867781043053, -0.018093857914209366, 0.033228080719709396, -0.006878012325614691, -0.0022625448182225227, 0.055767085403203964, 0.006956708617508411, 0.026065342128276825, 0.0062711238861083984, 0.03951036185026169, 0.0022937492467463017, -0.03863244131207466, 0.033951371908187866, 0.08668499439954758, -0.047512754797935486, -0.03523359075188637, 0.03197048231959343, -0.01737191528081894, 0.040888696908950806, 0.03998355194926262, -0.028542373329401016, -0.000410242413636297, 0.021139658987522125, -0.048607245087623596, -0.048737358301877975, 0.06424549967050552, -0.002282549859955907, -0.0262006763368845, -0.00705354567617178, -0.03490808606147766, -0.025558102875947952, -0.057751063257455826, 0.011891651898622513, -0.014099117368459702, -0.05793316289782524, -0.03554578870534897, -0.08253137767314911, 0.006714357063174248, 0.0030892931390553713, 0.003627081634476781, 0.007192549761384726, -0.03248727321624756, -0.10632248967885971, 0.040461353957653046, 0.031206106767058372, -0.025807350873947144, -0.03719797730445862, -0.007956917397677898, 0.02319622039794922, -0.05856016278266907, -0.07798971235752106, 0.052335482090711594, 0.03073892369866371, 0.02287558652460575, -0.01867443323135376, -0.00883407425135374, -0.025381574407219887, 0.007558245677500963, -0.018943602219223976, 0.06543771177530289, -0.005930612329393625, 0.05585517734289169, 0.018361395224928856, 0.03490389138460159, 0.04584772139787674, 0.043767377734184265, 0.03950270637869835, 0.028215300291776657, 0.0009461208828724921, 0.026070611551404, -0.06789477914571762, -0.018135257065296173, -0.003524492960423231, -0.03083096817135811, 0.02043747715651989, -0.019925257191061974, -0.0051980637945234776, 0.04602237045764923, -0.002613716758787632, 0.013178052380681038, -0.011561335064470768, 0.033917371183633804, 0.023658590391278267, 0.012602515518665314, -0.005140126682817936, 0.04057425260543823, 0.0257720910012722, 0.041025158017873764, -0.024115459993481636, -0.027308622375130653, 0.007605846039950848, -0.015919199213385582, 0.006767170038074255, -0.014911486767232418, -0.013881758786737919, -0.016115037724375725, 0.014192949049174786, -0.005025392863899469, 0.014267452992498875, 0.05138283595442772, 0.062048833817243576, 0.006497519556432962, 0.0028000876773148775, 0.06552436202764511, 0.0011586551554501057, -0.01730130985379219, -0.028002798557281494, 0.044502273201942444, 0.012999371625483036, -0.0034756450913846493, 0.009187228046357632, 0.0041272323578596115, 0.01682513765990734, 0.029773563146591187, -0.009845691733062267, 0.05684946849942207, 0.03229774907231331, -0.008325238712131977, 0.020141586661338806, 0.02131689339876175, -0.06487317383289337, -0.0075437333434820175, -0.01913214661180973, -0.0005476248916238546, -0.025872739031910896, 0.025787118822336197, -0.02763955481350422, 0.017190733924508095, -0.04701947048306465, 0.058154135942459106, 0.05660988762974739, -0.036081090569496155, -0.010632301680743694, 0.01183750107884407, 0.019998682662844658, 0.002868254669010639, 0.018003933131694794, 0.002257912652567029, -0.009519669227302074, 0.015357387252151966, -0.03601713478565216, -0.0368523895740509, -0.05042226240038872, 0.0012589304242283106, 0.025009937584400177, -0.0006323251873254776, 0.010077400133013725, -0.017241600900888443, 0.02416815795004368, 0.033651016652584076, 0.008107857778668404, 0.013726849108934402, -0.0037406962364912033, 0.0508938692510128, 0.004418436903506517, -0.019680101424455643, 0.0033968191128224134, -0.005178845953196287, 0.02794307842850685, 0.02006671577692032, 0.04303302988409996, -0.037732817232608795, 0.0025096049066632986, -0.048113737255334854, -0.029010238125920296, -0.03319675475358963, 0.010367912240326405, -0.031007716432213783, -0.038299065083265305, 0.0035852957516908646, 0.009423049166798592, -0.03882273659110069, -0.030023008584976196, 0.023520734161138535, -0.06174622103571892, 0.02396146021783352, 0.05656920000910759, -0.03257869929075241, 0.040560901165008545, -0.019734187051653862, -0.01626230962574482, -0.048546094447374344, -0.020722974091768265, 0.012083154171705246, 0.006215893663465977, 0.0040600840002298355, -0.028118498623371124, 0.004254825878888369, -0.014518339186906815, -0.003402676898986101, -0.002997645875439048, -0.017438648268580437, -0.014020321890711784, -0.008369754068553448, 0.05808167904615402, -0.04034349322319031, 0.001797821489162743, 0.004254195839166641, -0.039680782705545425, 0.02475164830684662, -0.03523195534944534, 0.017753032967448235, 0.0714486837387085, 0.04017861559987068, 0.027915604412555695, -0.0651225820183754, 0.050849780440330505, 0.014646644704043865, -0.01052901241928339, 0.014990459196269512, -0.004282297566533089, 0.008216721937060356, 0.048658885061740875, 0.044635288417339325, 0.01059624645859003, 0.007109018508344889, 0.015678273513913155, -0.014271720312535763, 0.027931135147809982, 0.022885775193572044, 0.032629042863845825, -0.04414879158139229, -0.0031508489046245813, 0.0557737834751606, -0.07096399366855621, -0.004316252656280994, -0.05567663535475731, -0.059329237788915634, 0.014933756552636623, -0.022365912795066833, 0.0382688082754612, -0.032515931874513626, -0.01323738694190979, 0.04393190145492554, 0.0029844953678548336, -0.006178706884384155, -0.009950242936611176, 0.03087940253317356, -0.06169556826353073, 0.016120295971632004, -0.0237099751830101, 0.023798085749149323, 0.045588262379169464, -0.042746588587760925, -0.008416608907282352, -0.002023026579990983, -0.020903801545500755, 0.022488698363304138, -0.0458252839744091, -0.061901502311229706, 0.037345968186855316, -0.052941907197237015, -0.039972491562366486, 0.023761846125125885, -0.010775712318718433, 0.019389715045690536, -0.007325511891394854, -0.04540235921740532, 0.006294206250458956, -0.009092562831938267, 0.021931929513812065, -0.02749135158956051, 0.011154338717460632, -0.030078139156103134, 0.024662131443619728, 0.05437355488538742, 0.043595120310783386, -0.009736922569572926, 0.039367467164993286, -0.014873645268380642, 0.0702163428068161, 0.06923103332519531, -0.02640816755592823, 0.033139873296022415, -0.012737899087369442, 0.00400514667853713, -0.06074615567922592, 0.06585446745157242, 0.02862504869699478, -0.04714541137218475, -0.08731576055288315, 0.030469229444861412, 0.017760902643203735, -0.04799638316035271, -0.0189443901181221, 0.04326798766851425, -0.04161571338772774, 0.01087907887995243, -0.04577398672699928, -0.008224107325077057, 0.009361736476421356, 0.04795555770397186, -0.027868162840604782, 0.02973764017224312, 0.008867613039910793, 0.04519401490688324, -0.02079710364341736, -0.03152645379304886, 0.04241635277867317, 0.0852082371711731, 0.029464781284332275, 0.007836933247745037, 0.05028802901506424, -0.03553557023406029, -0.021231338381767273, -0.0025296867825090885, 0.003696220926940441, -0.0009791518095880747, -0.046522315591573715, -0.020662667229771614, 0.08926904946565628, 0.045996684581041336, 0.06087876111268997, -0.05434194207191467, -0.0034009041264653206, 0.03485002741217613, -0.0019842409528791904, -0.016230659559369087, 0.03915301710367203, 0.07609889656305313, 0.02991386689245701, -0.008874338120222092, 0.010696450248360634, -0.02413032203912735, -0.052336614578962326, 0.032954614609479904, -0.005220460239797831, -0.020754951983690262, 0.019967153668403625, -0.02180294319987297, -0.010757705196738243, 0.06664218008518219, -0.0446334183216095, -0.02530209720134735, -0.003145037917420268, 0.02307870052754879, 0.0039879861287772655, 0.06485068053007126, 0.04396858066320419, -0.03238976001739502, -0.010939610190689564, -0.04139523208141327, 0.042221058160066605, 0.03204268962144852, -0.023112140595912933, 0.036862101405858994, -0.018586577847599983, 0.0067337993532419205, 0.009408168494701385, 0.003463566768914461, -0.03392176702618599, -0.061982061713933945, -0.03554961085319519, -0.06125442311167717, -0.03422403335571289, -0.0399433895945549, 0.01660219021141529, -0.007146552670747042, -0.08909463882446289, -0.038916703313589096, -0.03433406725525856, -0.0011964557925239205, 0.019990453496575356, -0.060901522636413574, -0.0013710492057725787, 0.04087672010064125, 0.0008433685288764536, -0.0032862224616110325, 0.047728583216667175, 0.03394077345728874, 0.0076339649967849255, 0.01318332552909851, -0.00909481942653656, 0.005375629756599665, 0.03302380070090294, -0.013439462520182133, 0.008351568132638931, -0.10449793189764023, 0.0010604094713926315, 0.050590600818395615, -0.03349977359175682, -0.07866571843624115, 0.0021493241656571627, -0.03140128776431084, 0.026497188955545425, 0.0534815676510334, -0.00841730646789074, 0.02093644067645073, -0.061736512929201126, -0.004062448628246784, -0.036839574575424194, 0.009784488938748837, 0.05334518849849701, -0.025388559326529503, 0.02857603318989277, 0.04851611703634262, -0.02129187434911728, 0.01102758850902319, 0.03812658041715622, 0.011814206838607788, 0.05076270177960396, -0.0358499176800251, -0.037228018045425415, -0.04197096824645996, -0.09596709161996841, -0.014223702251911163, 0.03963075205683708, 0.015374401584267616, -0.029043061658740044, -0.030176667496562004, -0.0044031511060893536, 0.013499323278665543, -0.028513580560684204, 0.02127355895936489, 0.0008751034620217979, -0.05760229378938675, -0.003566850908100605, -0.05761498957872391, 0.025744237005710602, -0.013129048980772495, 0.05664290487766266, 0.01371300220489502, -0.02656581439077854, 0.002728002844378352, 0.009888776578009129, -0.003144921502098441, 0.0020188770722597837, 0.049493882805109024, 0.02081209421157837 ]
3,564
DeLLMa: Decision Making Under Uncertainty with Large Language Models
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Acvo2RGSCy
[ "Ollie Liu", "Deqing Fu", "Dani Yogatama", "Willie Neiswanger" ]
Spotlight
The potential of large language models (LLMs) as decision support tools is increasingly being explored in fields such as business, engineering, and medicine, which often face challenging tasks of *decision-making under uncertainty*. In this paper, we show that directly prompting LLMs on these types of decision-making problems can yield poor results, especially as the problem complexity increases. To aid in these tasks, we propose DeLLMa (Decision-making Large Language Model assistant), a framework designed to enhance decision-making accuracy in uncertain environments. DeLLMa involves a multi-step reasoning procedure that integrates recent best practices in scaling *inference-time reasoning*, drawing upon principles from decision theory and utility theory, to provide an accurate and human-auditable decision-making process. We validate our procedure on multiple realistic decision-making environments, demonstrating that DeLLMa can consistently enhance the decision-making performance of leading language models, and achieve up to a 40% increase in accuracy over competing methods. Additionally, we show how performance improves when scaling compute at test time, and carry out human evaluations to benchmark components of DeLLMa.
large language models, decision theory, decision making under uncertainty
We introduce an inference-time reasoning procedure for reliable decision making under uncertainty with LLMs, drawing upon principles from classical decision theory.
4,817
2402.02392
[ -0.03332066535949707, 0.002235321095213294, -0.023816386237740517, 0.037339791655540466, 0.05543278157711029, 0.04397876188158989, 0.009277399629354477, 0.01728234998881817, -0.03130566328763962, -0.020509254187345505, -0.026330675929784775, 0.060715269297361374, -0.058251168578863144, 0.0020309421233832836, 0.017076678574085236, 0.059823840856552124, 0.028793441131711006, -0.0075816260650753975, 0.030034584924578667, -0.005622158758342266, -0.007355178706347942, -0.011548783630132675, 0.03083280846476555, 0.026289889588952065, 0.03143494203686714, 0.03561419993638992, 0.06186911091208458, 0.026330864056944847, -0.033343371003866196, -0.026282109320163727, 0.0546555370092392, -0.016038352623581886, 0.0116812065243721, 0.005194372031837702, -0.000314755568979308, 0.020591454580426216, -0.03074592724442482, 0.005757445469498634, 0.002441347809508443, 0.040629733353853226, -0.05363642796874046, 0.039918817579746246, -0.00026324240025132895, 0.004391136113554239, -0.0662456825375557, 0.013219043612480164, -0.08234242349863052, 0.04541853070259094, 0.03212069720029831, -0.017028624191880226, -0.11855728179216385, 0.0168781541287899, 0.0059126620180904865, 0.00562342070043087, -0.012727094814181328, 0.04032500088214874, 0.05430793762207031, -0.10654333978891373, 0.020616741850972176, -0.04845168814063072, -0.01577604189515114, -0.005514137912541628, 0.009907386265695095, 0.00474283192306757, -0.0031368588097393513, -0.03102707676589489, -0.0029936719220131636, 0.02273397333920002, -0.06638563424348831, -0.017340460792183876, -0.04292551428079605, -0.017106568440794945, -0.008181329816579819, 0.007931199856102467, -0.005926833022385836, -0.056986723095178604, 0.02567158080637455, 0.046833720058202744, 0.014369092881679535, -0.0021094942931085825, -0.028776850551366806, 0.002226154087111354, 0.03072712942957878, 0.028213461861014366, 0.03621143475174904, 0.009730707854032516, -0.007778804749250412, -0.03515276312828064, -0.09928671270608902, 0.03005261719226837, 0.0075871325097978115, -0.07645086199045181, 0.004987957421690226, 0.04195550084114075, 0.02066289819777012, 0.019931117072701454, 0.019283315166831017, 0.008738034404814243, -0.04268712177872658, 0.002914351411163807, -0.017937002703547478, -0.03592388704419136, 0.005129124503582716, 0.008369071409106255, -0.11665116995573044, -0.03222496807575226, -0.0018005482852458954, -0.00007496334001189098, -0.011086626909673214, 0.02134210243821144, -0.014131505973637104, -0.001642223447561264, 0.027997376397252083, -0.015637118369340897, -0.0698029026389122, 0.046680789440870285, 0.013361035846173763, 0.02431419864296913, -0.00202628830447793, 0.011969535611569881, 0.08459249883890152, 0.04063265770673752, 0.0045686825178563595, 0.05806376039981842, -0.04358861595392227, -0.00411213468760252, 0.03706100210547447, 0.01970834657549858, -0.025920068845152855, -0.05220739170908928, 0.006616195663809776, 0.020032353699207306, -0.0038422783836722374, -0.007661271840333939, -0.018613358959555626, -0.0005676872096955776, 0.025674503296613693, 0.04139889404177666, 0.05442063882946968, 0.00033853872446343303, 0.0024497895501554012, -0.02618042379617691, 0.050306286662817, -0.016599144786596298, 0.034812889993190765, 0.02407064661383629, 0.01795835979282856, -0.004365534987300634, -0.03692203015089035, -0.01445809006690979, 0.005141051951795816, -0.005625527817755938, 0.001889325794763863, -0.05198872834444046, 0.05110922083258629, 0.043999120593070984, 0.01302303932607174, -0.021463632583618164, 0.00827022735029459, 0.03561414033174515, -0.004299697000533342, -0.014261244796216488, -0.06540149450302124, -0.008955501951277256, -0.023344814777374268, -0.07266473770141602, 0.06905491650104523, -0.0041104466654360294, -0.05836218595504761, 0.012280365452170372, -0.012439788319170475, -0.033774483948946, 0.05626458674669266, -0.024091089144349098, 0.017744723707437515, -0.0010825367644429207, 0.05906039848923683, -0.01383228413760662, 0.041473448276519775, 0.038195811212062836, -0.07150211185216904, 0.03023100644350052, 0.0019989986903965473, -0.01583966612815857, 0.009002042934298515, 0.00950354989618063, 0.07023664563894272, -0.04172633960843086, 0.0231164563447237, 0.03209763765335083, -0.08930565416812897, -0.04421230033040047, 0.028968095779418945, 0.02770235203206539, 0.044038254767656326, -0.023837316781282425, -0.009080896154046059, 0.05536282807588577, 0.050689369440078735, 0.05063029006123543, 0.05762042850255966, -0.004693985916674137, 0.014986668713390827, 0.025300493463873863, -0.02273610606789589, -0.004082483239471912, 0.030441226437687874, -0.04917656257748604, -0.04676312953233719, 0.035773228853940964, -0.014328806661069393, -0.023366766050457954, 0.01606377772986889, 0.01431895699352026, 0.03188466280698776, -0.01594475284218788, -0.00899266917258501, -0.009156357496976852, 0.017044609412550926, -0.042541470378637314, 0.05290134623646736, 0.01824888214468956, -0.007956393994390965, 0.002562249545007944, 0.00008475273352814838, 0.07458184659481049, 0.07017064839601517, -0.003993404563516378, -0.02337094210088253, 0.020577343180775642, -0.020663678646087646, -0.001018516137264669, 0.0277376901358366, -0.03634875640273094, 0.029292849823832512, -0.010660604573786259, 0.004903124179691076, -0.02754945121705532, 0.05048427730798721, -0.019326619803905487, -0.02599869668483734, 0.04884961619973183, -0.013770591467618942, 0.07219182699918747, 0.0000820901695988141, 0.012698163278400898, 0.028234286233782768, -0.009844113141298294, -0.0021195700392127037, -0.04315059259533882, -0.02063070423901081, 0.011927693150937557, 0.01700352318584919, 0.0004561816167552024, -0.03579450026154518, -0.05370208993554115, -0.002228029305115342, 0.01662522740662098, 0.08125289529561996, 0.034563105553388596, 0.018258143216371536, 0.020962871611118317, 0.014233669266104698, -0.04212382435798645, 0.022099841386079788, -0.10811278223991394, -0.048331938683986664, 0.0030134576372802258, 0.021086445078253746, 0.018852926790714264, 0.02241053618490696, -0.029943251982331276, 0.04289267584681511, -0.010399717837572098, -0.03139428421854973, -0.021292243152856827, 0.02023635245859623, 0.016985775902867317, -0.06459563225507736, 0.004444556310772896, 0.004667444620281458, 0.028572695329785347, -0.000967515108641237, -0.038015857338905334, -0.011521147564053535, -0.009321204386651516, 0.007058255840092897, -0.05871322378516197, 0.00247607147321105, 0.02419942058622837, 0.033488210290670395, 0.01064006146043539, -0.04661118984222412, 0.022005314007401466, 0.026646113023161888, 0.03715531527996063, 0.03342072293162346, -0.001849923050031066, -0.0140549186617136, 0.039664044976234436, -0.019878774881362915, 0.03396070376038551, -0.0053178719244897366, 0.03999476134777069, -0.019319118931889534, -0.010363923385739326, -0.01623535342514515, 0.005514488089829683, -0.2694331109523773, -0.027408601716160774, -0.0035969207528978586, -0.03495774790644646, 0.038945481181144714, -0.010080776177346706, 0.05347319692373276, -0.012385050766170025, -0.008319718763232231, 0.0025779216084629297, 0.008974287658929825, 0.029774557799100876, -0.02841366082429886, 0.04301891475915909, 0.057554785162210464, 0.043206553906202316, -0.01282589416950941, -0.04331686347723007, -0.002134478185325861, -0.0037492115516215563, -0.012510860338807106, -0.052376504987478256, -0.014635673724114895, 0.05179814621806145, -0.0038579339161515236, 0.06266097724437714, -0.07914476841688156, -0.004338035359978676, -0.04255402833223343, 0.0016461537452414632, -0.00735609233379364, -0.021205708384513855, -0.04189980775117874, 0.02236185595393181, 0.006229627877473831, 0.03918222337961197, 0.061158686876297, -0.0028150964062660933, 0.015657851472496986, 0.003354414366185665, 0.04131825640797615, -0.023654397577047348, -0.05320335552096367, -0.01939348131418228, 0.05142413452267647, 0.013429936021566391, -0.06336864084005356, -0.045499108731746674, -0.015458877198398113, 0.040636226534843445, -0.004492029547691345, -0.017961930483579636, -0.013337960466742516, -0.008712377399206161, 0.02773325890302658, 0.0026444890536367893, -0.005786961875855923, -0.026641754433512688, -0.028837718069553375, 0.007458907086402178, 0.018860548734664917, -0.023690659552812576, -0.03609733656048775, -0.05227457731962204, -0.03254997357726097, -0.023940959945321083, -0.03987323120236397, -0.055477023124694824, 0.03727360814809799, 0.03925182297825813, -0.027727622538805008, 0.012805107049643993, -0.0038277863059192896, -0.09174534678459167, -0.014076907187700272, -0.03764546662569046, 0.0002162026212317869, -0.027503877878189087, -0.00443228567019105, 0.025320427492260933, -0.04060608893632889, -0.03696678206324577, -0.01865459978580475, -0.011541806161403656, 0.025481773540377617, -0.03142717853188515, -0.012915563769638538, -0.007338861469179392, -0.016068466007709503, -0.012642946094274521, 0.01867629960179329, 0.03992711752653122, -0.004390748683363199, 0.0018153919372707605, 0.08051058650016785, 0.036196496337652206, 0.007910591550171375, 0.05862174555659294, 0.04207662492990494, -0.024719804525375366, 0.01729774847626686, -0.1149473786354065, -0.013806591741740704, -0.045049212872982025, -0.060034189373254776, 0.024796871468424797, -0.06517142057418823, -0.04360062628984451, 0.037586718797683716, -0.01723787561058998, -0.008035244420170784, -0.03750607371330261, 0.0013941011857241392, -0.0250360406935215, -0.028649987652897835, -0.02707700803875923, -0.007215780671685934, 0.0504726804792881, 0.04603569954633713, -0.007838430814445019, -0.052283283323049545, 0.027186032384634018, -0.008602822199463844, -0.008214594796299934, -0.022405700758099556, 0.009185190312564373, 0.013593372888863087, 0.0003489273367449641, -0.006550189107656479, -0.0136967608705163, 0.010156339034438133, 0.01027066633105278, 0.00877629965543747, 0.01945638284087181, 0.03953356295824051, -0.016677452251315117, -0.0008565016323700547, -0.007455792278051376, 0.02046709507703781, -0.017219234257936478, -0.017932428047060966, -0.024852266535162926, 0.02585623785853386, 0.0006249456782825291, 0.039948973804712296, 0.011189580895006657, 0.005033520050346851, 0.05295219644904137, 0.028149180114269257, 0.018094023689627647, 0.010051396675407887, -0.049566905945539474, 0.011444510892033577, -0.01757913827896118, 0.006106165237724781, -0.004665568005293608, 0.05846504867076874, -0.02312280610203743, 0.005911761894822121, -0.1036389172077179, 0.017673062160611153, 0.006005721632391214, -0.008927722461521626, 0.002510329708456993, 0.013735239394009113, 0.07702144235372543, -0.052189167588949203, -0.0011497761588543653, 0.013324815779924393, 0.03759589046239853, 0.017330849543213844, -0.047237467020750046, -0.022836271673440933, 0.013269894756376743, -0.018821492791175842, 0.03786817193031311, 0.02101455256342888, 0.008536586537957191, -0.029331034049391747, 0.029330169782042503, 0.004829063080251217, -0.03627115860581398, -0.029426880180835724, -0.000036881516280118376, 0.04990199953317642, 0.018168684095144272, 0.023294078186154366, -0.01841779239475727, -0.05555421859025955, 0.01301943976432085, -0.025348059833049774, 0.014691030606627464, 0.00980248861014843, -0.04706842452287674, -0.04238351061940193, -0.057305071502923965, 0.023299597203731537, -0.022343726828694344, -0.0021439907141029835, -0.036670491099357605, 0.019732898101210594, -0.008827710524201393, -0.06379897147417068, -0.022017722949385643, 0.024937091395258904, -0.08308722078800201, -0.0010144907282665372, 0.025588691234588623, 0.03336302936077118, 0.035838037729263306, -0.06312547624111176, -0.014990754425525665, -0.03657115623354912, -0.022826213389635086, 0.03927723690867424, -0.0039029070176184177, -0.03558652848005295, -0.011462087742984295, -0.0013241837732493877, -0.011309499852359295, 0.01003261934965849, -0.03627169132232666, 0.003106846706941724, -0.006953262258321047, -0.007981483824551105, 0.055251020938158035, -0.03154730796813965, -0.02593143843114376, -0.002185292774811387, -0.019711365923285484, 0.010660325177013874, -0.054884813725948334, -0.004096050281077623, 0.03291454166173935, 0.025572650134563446, 0.009691792540252209, -0.04234188795089722, 0.009898476302623749, 0.0057710506953299046, 0.0020755319856107235, -0.022570041939616203, -0.007687319535762072, -0.013225547969341278, -0.006041922140866518, -0.014155575074255466, 0.04639115184545517, 0.02615322172641754, 0.0034313362557440996, 0.007923736236989498, 0.015754662454128265, -0.008784795179963112, 0.020140275359153748, -0.025899402797222137, 0.0039094178937375546, 0.0615299753844738, 0.024025967344641685, -0.00782827939838171, -0.05344599857926369, -0.03550613671541214, -0.003451460972428322, -0.037473514676094055, 0.03682961314916611, -0.04348793253302574, 0.058908335864543915, 0.017953254282474518, 0.03781725466251373, 0.009940299205482006, -0.023861022666096687, 0.0422358475625515, -0.08622085303068161, 0.013600054197013378, -0.06480918824672699, -0.017405765131115913, 0.022407319396734238, -0.033859431743621826, 0.01683502271771431, 0.017558177933096886, -0.06305630505084991, 0.03380550444126129, 0.003988293930888176, -0.036532554775476456, 0.04229173809289932, -0.027769532054662704, 0.006023164372891188, 0.056561294943094254, -0.040689680725336075, -0.04167058318853378, 0.01465247105807066, -0.023572850972414017, 0.003228194545954466, 0.02416185289621353, 0.03997713327407837, -0.011732188984751701, 0.030776022002100945, -0.05876198038458824, 0.0014511949848383665, 0.0434345044195652, 0.054690439254045486, 0.0183259304612875, 0.029306408017873764, -0.03678491339087486, 0.06351219117641449, 0.041692689061164856, 0.035184796899557114, 0.005154071841388941, 0.0028584785759449005, -0.05552376061677933, -0.061352238059043884, 0.03791479021310806, 0.004534351639449596, 0.00021386082516983151, -0.05485283583402634, 0.08647723495960236, 0.03329958766698837, -0.025834059342741966, -0.010447759181261063, -0.005737295839935541, -0.056463573127985, 0.019454512745141983, 0.0016593871405348182, 0.017488081008195877, -0.0007024515070952475, 0.05631937459111214, 0.018734289333224297, 0.0628594160079956, 0.07344375550746918, -0.0003252810856793076, -0.010828920640051365, 0.022759729996323586, 0.05969676002860069, 0.029867306351661682, 0.045770417898893356, 0.0229708943516016, 0.05329011753201485, -0.051114972680807114, -0.045413870364427567, 0.027550384402275085, 0.012267641723155975, -0.009714391082525253, -0.04491674527525902, 0.026659606024622917, 0.05242767930030823, 0.027140263468027115, 0.051250699907541275, -0.027955636382102966, -0.012247997336089611, 0.05956844985485077, 0.016076484695076942, 0.012519428506493568, 0.05281141400337219, 0.023086320608854294, 0.024192795157432556, -0.03551197052001953, -0.012621056288480759, 0.02260054089128971, -0.023616893216967583, 0.0019965122919529676, 0.0029675441328436136, -0.0193540770560503, -0.00033705649548210204, -0.016712704673409462, 0.0907093733549118, 0.12948395311832428, -0.002600075677037239, -0.019414234906435013, 0.014973980374634266, 0.018305497244000435, -0.003496206598356366, 0.0399845652282238, 0.026564188301563263, 0.014354975894093513, 0.02006179466843605, -0.022971082478761673, 0.029878204688429832, 0.03664126619696617, -0.012740193866193295, 0.02354259602725506, -0.03140043467283249, -0.021649880334734917, 0.012401962652802467, 0.008066541515290737, -0.0770483985543251, -0.04528689756989479, -0.00730521697551012, -0.04748377576470375, -0.02925291284918785, -0.04203008487820625, 0.05848170444369316, 0.0004932371084578335, -0.027235595509409904, 0.022735489532351494, -0.022892767563462257, -0.013670261949300766, -0.014350336976349354, -0.04703643545508385, 0.011405722238123417, 0.05259879678487778, 0.0038784299977123737, -0.009714895859360695, 0.05652223154902458, -0.00042633520206436515, -0.03089330345392227, -0.014563062228262424, 0.01828109286725521, 0.007277452386915684, 0.019314533099532127, -0.010362903587520123, -0.0015941039891913533, -0.07528805732727051, -0.008466513827443123, 0.029681436717510223, -0.050918374210596085, -0.07382375001907349, 0.0695079043507576, -0.0337466336786747, 0.022535037249326706, 0.07406171411275864, 0.019488275051116943, 0.022977245971560478, -0.011237050406634808, -0.02658354677259922, 0.010210162959992886, -0.004106544423848391, 0.012568850070238113, -0.028229134157299995, 0.03967374935746193, 0.04134266823530197, -0.028349047526717186, -0.06000034138560295, 0.03417288511991501, -0.01066261250525713, -0.008575269021093845, -0.0075700231827795506, -0.010211442597210407, -0.0239267461001873, -0.09019044041633606, -0.0160673800855875, 0.008445275016129017, -0.025062959641218185, -0.05060139670968056, 0.011295905336737633, 0.005508290138095617, -0.013014053925871849, 0.009793093428015709, -0.03245558217167854, -0.040591709315776825, -0.05140800029039383, -0.048334162682294846, -0.08088508993387222, 0.025721512734889984, -0.04277876764535904, -0.020949678495526314, -0.00797666423022747, -0.0663861408829689, -0.006722054909914732, 0.001762957195751369, 0.014336523599922657, -0.021942049264907837, 0.0073236278258264065, -0.031288497149944305 ]
3,565
OmniRe: Omni Urban Scene Reconstruction
https://openreview.net/forum?id=11xgiMEI5o
[ "Ziyu Chen", "Jiawei Yang", "Jiahui Huang", "Riccardo de Lutio", "Janick Martinez Esturo", "Boris Ivanovic", "Or Litany", "Zan Gojcic", "Sanja Fidler", "Marco Pavone", "Li Song", "Yue Wang" ]
Spotlight
We introduce OmniRe, a comprehensive system for efficiently creating high-fidelity digital twins of dynamic real-world scenes from on-device logs. Recent methods using neural fields or Gaussian Splatting primarily focus on vehicles, hindering a holistic framework for all dynamic foregrounds demanded by downstream applications, e.g., the simulation of human behavior. OmniRe extends beyond vehicle modeling to enable accurate, full-length reconstruction of diverse dynamic objects in urban scenes. Our approach builds scene graphs on 3DGS and constructs multiple Gaussian representations in canonical spaces that model various dynamic actors, including vehicles, pedestrians, cyclists, and others. OmniRe allows holistically reconstructing any dynamic object in the scene, enabling advanced simulations (~60 Hz) that include human-participated scenarios, such as pedestrian behavior simulation and human-vehicle interaction. This comprehensive simulation capability is unmatched by existing methods. Extensive evaluations on the Waymo dataset show that our approach outperforms prior state-of-the-art methods quantitatively and qualitatively by a large margin. We further extend our results to 5 additional popular driving datasets to demonstrate its generalizability on common urban scenes. Code and results are available at [omnire](https://ziyc.github.io/omnire/).
Gaussians Splatting, Neural Rendering, Dynamic Scene Reconstruction, Autonomous Driving
null
4,816
2408.16760
[ 0.009009521454572678, -0.019750207662582397, 0.029124977067112923, 0.046029675751924515, 0.03652813658118248, 0.022712964564561844, 0.022316785529255867, 0.02553086169064045, -0.04144161567091942, -0.07630310952663422, -0.02151431329548359, -0.023367872461676598, -0.06480845808982849, -0.028515102341771126, 0.009352401830255985, 0.022993024438619614, 0.01818750984966755, -0.005853687878698111, -0.008635057136416435, 0.035789139568805695, 0.005484405905008316, -0.019455788657069206, -0.009267319925129414, 0.004810626152902842, 0.017185399308800697, 0.005996753927320242, 0.009367930702865124, 0.04271308705210686, -0.038242507725954056, 0.02621479704976082, -0.008355694822967052, 0.014310512691736221, 0.005442838184535503, -0.09135697782039642, 0.0042010946199297905, -0.0016625466523692012, -0.05257579684257507, -0.011687477119266987, -0.01530025340616703, 0.019847536459565163, -0.058457762002944946, 0.02051292359828949, -0.001922022202052176, -0.03828579559922218, -0.05845590680837631, 0.007113107945770025, -0.06325717270374298, 0.04191973805427551, -0.009261093102395535, -0.026989882811903954, -0.050744008272886276, 0.0004916454199701548, 0.014554140157997608, 0.0013594754273071885, -0.003388208569958806, 0.044073622673749924, 0.05701352655887604, -0.10543187707662582, 0.00893301423639059, -0.04175369814038277, -0.015326330438256264, 0.039290063083171844, 0.044397737830877304, 0.01055696327239275, 0.009833404794335365, 0.005258641205728054, 0.008835593238472939, 0.06031721085309982, 0.0033195591531693935, -0.014908076263964176, 0.00352281890809536, 0.015093648806214333, -0.014287594705820084, 0.004187257494777441, -0.014844218268990517, -0.057376693934202194, 0.02463734708726406, 0.0007687148754484951, 0.0663408637046814, 0.0020832617301493883, 0.03592034801840782, -0.02237744815647602, 0.013591768220067024, 0.05543716624379158, -0.006257306784391403, 0.025017332285642624, -0.013985706493258476, -0.022094760090112686, -0.09966174513101578, 0.06552804261445999, -0.03321020305156708, -0.058053623884916306, 0.011714502237737179, 0.04605896398425102, 0.02194792777299881, 0.037800513207912445, 0.0013147176941856742, 0.026282882317900658, -0.008468762040138245, -0.0014967225724831223, -0.006298609543591738, -0.010471576824784279, 0.005078209564089775, 0.03933708369731903, -0.08921309560537338, -0.0084614846855402, -0.007332914974540472, 0.0034830502700060606, -0.011018585413694382, 0.01999647729098797, -0.024590788409113884, -0.017104968428611755, 0.024009263142943382, -0.022392455488443375, -0.06472630053758621, 0.0028798708226531744, 0.028989583253860474, 0.019113969057798386, 0.0019064826192334294, 0.013874158263206482, 0.07559891790151596, 0.0523318313062191, -0.006224042735993862, 0.06808072328567505, -0.028209544718265533, 0.012692024931311607, 0.00022377802815753967, 0.018047405406832695, -0.026832103729248047, -0.0012870273785665631, -0.005141166038811207, 0.04300544410943985, -0.046590231359004974, -0.00421568239107728, -0.004579032771289349, -0.03552459180355072, 0.004941638559103012, 0.026888664811849594, 0.04058283194899559, -0.01351234596222639, 0.017517123371362686, -0.03929244354367256, 0.06538619846105576, -0.026338912546634674, 0.10317223519086838, -0.04345497861504555, 0.0219854936003685, -0.01709047146141529, -0.04675651341676712, -0.0051529123447835445, -0.009806787595152855, 0.013374035246670246, -0.005898541770875454, -0.10184558480978012, 0.06650767475366592, 0.05081954225897789, 0.03242253512144089, 0.03559679910540581, -0.018882662057876587, -0.0011731283739209175, -0.005457764491438866, -0.010601251386106014, -0.03095029667019844, 0.00325948023237288, -0.02158437855541706, -0.0510396882891655, 0.02395392581820488, 0.007707853335887194, 0.0037228104192763567, -0.03737275302410126, -0.04888119176030159, -0.039290912449359894, 0.027792910113930702, 0.002276951912790537, -0.014632056467235088, -0.0035577183589339256, 0.05963947996497154, -0.011544648557901382, -0.02123907394707203, 0.03102230839431286, -0.09150819480419159, 0.003991563338786364, 0.01624353788793087, -0.0154751967638731, 0.0017657228745520115, -0.035799119621515274, 0.08285617083311081, -0.022542906925082207, -0.02956821396946907, -0.017009787261486053, -0.06762375682592392, -0.026607627049088478, 0.02617824636399746, -0.038353268057107925, 0.03739707171916962, 0.0054860301315784454, -0.000293848046567291, 0.00979406014084816, 0.04515999183058739, 0.03575625643134117, 0.022356275469064713, -0.035112425684928894, 0.07415225356817245, -0.004562332760542631, -0.007817365229129791, -0.028484294191002846, 0.045380789786577225, -0.04996155574917793, -0.043511420488357544, -0.021639155223965645, 0.007740408647805452, -0.021636366844177246, 0.016177894547581673, -0.0010937812039628625, 0.022025903686881065, 0.016339804977178574, -0.015503094531595707, 0.019489923492074013, -0.000647365755867213, -0.029503600671887398, 0.010882304981350899, 0.02006024494767189, -0.040844958275556564, -0.03760714828968048, -0.029802821576595306, 0.08069080859422684, 0.07622179388999939, -0.07331730425357819, 0.0015615866286680102, -0.023468485102057457, -0.011781452223658562, 0.0336809903383255, -0.00962913315743208, -0.02603345550596714, -0.015146887861192226, -0.011038598604500294, 0.06433995068073273, -0.019974665716290474, 0.05647719278931618, -0.03025834821164608, -0.042881473898887634, 0.04119295999407768, 0.010089061222970486, 0.044928375631570816, 0.036474183201789856, -0.0167617779225111, 0.05275702849030495, -0.039059117436409, -0.006643732078373432, -0.018264418467879295, 0.02103588916361332, -0.012648601084947586, 0.026348618790507317, -0.008298953995108604, -0.00626370171085, -0.07485995441675186, 0.023006685078144073, -0.013042818754911423, 0.08394486457109451, 0.020039478316903114, 0.051725178956985474, 0.017308223992586136, 0.0006626307149417698, -0.026180604472756386, -0.024599464610219002, -0.10353970527648926, -0.036132149398326874, -0.03821750730276108, -0.001398940454237163, 0.043384432792663574, 0.024103838950395584, 0.018326779827475548, 0.015481362119317055, -0.002615815494209528, 0.018312787637114525, -0.011391006410121918, 0.002008791547268629, 0.0204051211476326, -0.01187804527580738, -0.029740137979388237, -0.009398645721375942, 0.047634873539209366, -0.002781911753118038, 0.002313110511749983, -0.030526315793395042, -0.03693610057234764, 0.018380386754870415, 0.005220431834459305, -0.03264428675174713, -0.018058544024825096, 0.04425153508782387, 0.00421815225854516, 0.015004529617726803, 0.005776410456746817, 0.034466393291950226, 0.062319573014974594, 0.021635450422763824, -0.03780419006943703, -0.04612249508500099, 0.0298268124461174, -0.017849860712885857, 0.0008828143472783267, 0.020914293825626373, -0.015803640708327293, -0.0202755406498909, 0.008916839025914669, -0.011546870693564415, -0.01651754416525364, -0.2816365361213684, -0.00921675842255354, 0.015728745609521866, -0.014854611828923225, 0.027992451563477516, -0.0376826673746109, 0.01736680045723915, -0.017992516979575157, -0.011090084910392761, 0.04089607670903206, 0.013519072905182838, 0.012867341749370098, -0.011254223063588142, 0.04110437631607056, 0.0525285042822361, 0.019882967695593834, 0.015971895307302475, 0.0030314375180751085, 0.005858991295099258, 0.039712220430374146, -0.0501440092921257, -0.08786886930465698, -0.009623214602470398, 0.010940827429294586, -0.027173692360520363, 0.017297111451625824, -0.06355835497379303, -0.040550436824560165, -0.02251209318637848, 0.000969804881606251, 0.023082109168171883, -0.05706184357404709, -0.010487017221748829, 0.03435566648840904, -0.013598810881376266, 0.017192132771015167, 0.05788414180278778, 0.014804041013121605, 0.044879596680402756, -0.05045156925916672, -0.023889809846878052, -0.020526671782135963, -0.02553395926952362, -0.01715235784649849, 0.08406703174114227, 0.003193796379491687, -0.044421348720788956, 0.017241213470697403, -0.016878122463822365, 0.019781921058893204, 0.002615674864500761, -0.01685795933008194, -0.008863971568644047, 0.01839987002313137, -0.0042078206315636635, -0.06010317802429199, 0.03769470378756523, 0.026871351525187492, 0.002498969668522477, -0.026740526780486107, 0.03505926951766014, -0.00693858927115798, -0.054683830589056015, 0.008739891462028027, 0.01670685037970543, -0.052444688975811005, -0.03998060151934624, -0.05539941415190697, 0.023131076246500015, 0.030264582484960556, -0.02554609254002571, -0.019657298922538757, -0.015028764493763447, -0.09549262374639511, 0.03258304297924042, 0.02864961512386799, -0.02609720453619957, -0.04025207459926605, -0.018684938549995422, 0.02328740805387497, -0.04879118129611015, -0.034646060317754745, 0.03422059863805771, -0.020634202286601067, 0.013581772334873676, 0.015649251639842987, -0.006146141793578863, -0.040422163903713226, -0.007200418505817652, -0.03353746980428696, 0.06137892231345177, -0.006480025127530098, 0.03838242217898369, 0.012543861754238605, 0.04222005233168602, 0.05517260357737541, 0.05895696580410004, 0.04947652295231819, 0.0077439709566533566, -0.005203536245971918, 0.021700488403439522, -0.05456675961613655, -0.030449116602540016, -0.008518454618752003, -0.02692386321723461, 0.05302871763706207, -0.029862383380532265, -0.012838322669267654, 0.05526130646467209, 0.0285737793892622, -0.005910792388021946, -0.00010292933438904583, 0.03269520401954651, 0.017887815833091736, 0.004813223145902157, -0.016233114525675774, 0.03271147608757019, 0.021412981674075127, 0.05105016380548477, -0.009882636368274689, -0.057145144790410995, 0.018494516611099243, -0.03370789438486099, 0.03983824700117111, -0.005284512881189585, -0.005258082877844572, -0.013614300638437271, 0.00016666513693053275, 0.0040441551245749, -0.008020791225135326, 0.026431886479258537, 0.055997610092163086, -0.019933609291911125, 0.06610237807035446, 0.03711698576807976, 0.012076250277459621, -0.030243011191487312, -0.011406540870666504, 0.04687504097819328, 0.025873592123389244, 0.021683409810066223, -0.02392956055700779, 0.022000843659043312, 0.02958081290125847, 0.02924252115190029, 0.0043002041056752205, 0.008388787508010864, 0.016062002629041672, -0.03302887827157974, -0.009841270744800568, 0.03249184042215347, -0.05935926362872124, -0.040481094270944595, -0.04382873699069023, 0.008718075230717659, -0.03173646330833435, 0.02384408935904503, -0.020311549305915833, 0.031090451404452324, -0.06814226508140564, 0.061561860144138336, 0.014212066307663918, -0.01827855221927166, -0.029149135574698448, -0.0006002213922329247, 0.04488660767674446, 0.039541929960250854, -0.0625683143734932, -0.019984759390354156, 0.0025793793611228466, -0.01874098926782608, -0.04153634235262871, -0.036410391330718994, -0.05815458670258522, -0.004826097283512354, 0.0420047827064991, 0.0001708242780296132, -0.0275726355612278, -0.031215623021125793, 0.03734176978468895, 0.004685171414166689, 0.035304974764585495, 0.0010286744218319654, -0.0010513869347050786, 0.09439649432897568, 0.001922285882756114, -0.01317688263952732, -0.018055876716971397, 0.023777281865477562, 0.03193571791052818, 0.0321180485188961, 0.06000695750117302, -0.07080070674419403, -0.012122927233576775, -0.016183843836188316, -0.019623177126049995, 0.00938420556485653, 0.0040542068891227245, -0.02225251868367195, -0.02859293296933174, -0.014104226604104042, 0.01924816146492958, -0.024288294836878777, -0.007342949043959379, 0.025510361418128014, -0.05298342928290367, 0.027210569009184837, 0.02898908033967018, -0.020112989470362663, 0.008369450457394123, -0.020634125918149948, -0.009089859202504158, -0.039022404700517654, -0.04756564646959305, -0.04155700281262398, 0.020838692784309387, -0.013396760448813438, -0.032144490629434586, -0.04594993591308594, -0.03154493495821953, 0.007241921499371529, 0.016539402306079865, -0.016502266749739647, -0.014416245743632317, 0.0006356682279147208, 0.047539178282022476, -0.01574898511171341, -0.018498074263334274, -0.003939698915928602, -0.009265626780688763, 0.008940903469920158, -0.021444588899612427, -0.0025678337551653385, 0.04701923951506615, 0.02207641489803791, -0.011769527569413185, -0.023902148008346558, 0.006951955147087574, 0.0013299804413691163, 0.015472200699150562, -0.019061779603362083, 0.0105974730104208, -0.03523029014468193, 0.0131604028865695, 0.06311489641666412, 0.022676637396216393, 0.00014069843746256083, 0.028354942798614502, -0.0000482670875499025, 0.003565815044566989, 0.003718041116371751, -0.0032708789221942425, -0.024626966565847397, -0.024006571620702744, 0.03276391327381134, -0.04854458197951317, -0.018015112727880478, -0.055928848683834076, -0.005218562204390764, -0.004325092304497957, -0.026113543659448624, 0.0017704686615616083, -0.017310846596956253, 0.028448227792978287, 0.00895007699728012, 0.04090024530887604, 0.03433448448777199, -0.056253690272569656, 0.025020189583301544, -0.0613999105989933, 0.027292294427752495, -0.039888057857751846, -0.009412432089447975, 0.061703912913799286, -0.009386652149260044, 0.01965141110122204, 0.03575434535741806, -0.01005146186798811, 0.04853232949972153, -0.06409211456775665, -0.026608072221279144, 0.020130129531025887, -0.03435751795768738, -0.021611230447888374, 0.012343564070761204, -0.01223737932741642, 0.002792580984532833, -0.02048722468316555, -0.029455356299877167, 0.0018505197949707508, -0.0287456251680851, 0.005216394085437059, -0.017717629671096802, 0.04481417313218117, 0.0017100914847105742, 0.010913405567407608, 0.04331623762845993, 0.029426952823996544, 0.0028896413277834654, 0.027916140854358673, -0.028290048241615295, 0.07318032532930374, 0.028344353660941124, -0.024342022836208344, 0.03249109536409378, -0.00003064955672016367, -0.007146608084440231, -0.0533384270966053, 0.07239428162574768, 0.01339658722281456, -0.03481496125459671, -0.07904361933469772, 0.04936720430850983, 0.04637233167886734, -0.04428974539041519, 0.020276935771107674, 0.02071235701441765, -0.047998663038015366, 0.018508078530430794, -0.009698071517050266, 0.006937538739293814, 0.04510757327079773, 0.05515940859913826, -0.03259987384080887, 0.03895553946495056, 0.04351107031106949, 0.04674762859940529, -0.013627217151224613, -0.015245429240167141, 0.05686509981751442, 0.06847240030765533, 0.04923643544316292, -0.0022989448625594378, 0.09198170155286789, -0.03004436381161213, -0.026077738031744957, 0.008574903942644596, 0.07283967733383179, -0.025344185531139374, -0.058337192982435226, -0.02224746346473694, 0.08484005928039551, 0.04685407504439354, 0.0377105176448822, -0.05911228060722351, -0.0028081180062144995, 0.05460872873663902, 0.0035185639280825853, -0.024582501500844955, 0.04420911520719528, 0.03135805204510689, 0.0004292969242669642, -0.00677539361640811, -0.002558589680120349, -0.005648051854223013, -0.03776078298687935, 0.04099204018712044, 0.027145998552441597, 0.013995199464261532, 0.03459135442972183, -0.033796198666095734, 0.022672340273857117, 0.10942588746547699, -0.014103593304753304, -0.04523654282093048, -0.011068454943597317, 0.009990330785512924, 0.011710917577147484, 0.0269947350025177, 0.020920824259519577, -0.01259157620370388, 0.01740298606455326, -0.05837325006723404, 0.0006361705018207431, 0.023585982620716095, -0.010327284224331379, 0.029077233746647835, -0.03336907923221588, -0.019017325714230537, -0.03174062818288803, -0.012253430671989918, -0.02608812227845192, -0.01232225727289915, -0.041684169322252274, -0.010718313045799732, -0.03041750006377697, -0.047319259494543076, 0.02064504288136959, -0.015570152550935745, -0.07903841882944107, -0.0006820275448262691, -0.04488079622387886, -0.006772411987185478, 0.034714166074991226, -0.05521475896239281, -0.038002725690603256, 0.022533925250172615, -0.020286327227950096, -0.009036589413881302, 0.03707396239042282, 0.050212495028972626, -0.02364162728190422, -0.0029057946521788836, 0.011857646517455578, 0.032702747732400894, 0.034189119935035706, -0.00827842764556408, -0.03806385397911072, -0.10766160488128662, -0.0013868749374523759, 0.018140720203518867, -0.050765156745910645, -0.08612626791000366, 0.007781888823956251, -0.046141091734170914, 0.036732740700244904, 0.05483487248420715, -0.0243794284760952, 0.043124571442604065, -0.0470561720430851, -0.023053690791130066, -0.0068846880458295345, 0.015075935050845146, 0.02961738035082817, -0.034824199974536896, 0.0476776584982872, 0.04258941859006882, -0.020663991570472717, 0.05470144376158714, 0.03921634703874588, 0.028169868513941765, -0.013297660276293755, -0.03172903507947922, -0.043415617197752, -0.0439574234187603, -0.07460808753967285, -0.006082805804908276, 0.0569106824696064, 0.04048760607838631, -0.041678544133901596, -0.006280991248786449, 0.009396681562066078, -0.036131151020526886, -0.021652409806847572, -0.025714125484228134, 0.001432877848856151, -0.04762418940663338, 0.003145991824567318, -0.06368716061115265, 0.014825413934886456, -0.019090892747044563, 0.02085537649691105, -0.034270819276571274, -0.0026385211385786533, 0.019507672637701035, 0.019708305597305298, 0.03879687562584877, -0.020367030054330826, 0.06971696019172668, -0.009844427928328514 ]
3,566
ZAPBench: A Benchmark for Whole-Brain Activity Prediction in Zebrafish
https://openreview.net/forum?id=oCHsDpyawq
[ "Jan-Matthis Lueckmann", "Alexander Immer", "Alex Bo-Yuan Chen", "Peter H. Li", "Mariela D Petkova", "Nirmala A Iyer", "Luuk Willem Hesselink", "Aparna Dev", "Gudrun Ihrke", "Woohyun Park", "Alyson Petruncio", "Aubrey Weigel", "Wyatt Korff", "Florian Engert", "Jeff Lichtman", "Misha Ahrens", "Michal Januszewski", "Viren Jain" ]
Spotlight
Data-driven benchmarks have led to significant progress in key scientific modeling domains including weather and structural biology. Here, we introduce the Zebrafish Activity Prediction Benchmark (ZAPBench) to measure progress on the problem of predicting cellular-resolution neural activity throughout an entire vertebrate brain. The benchmark is based on a novel dataset containing 4d light-sheet microscopy recordings of over 70,000 neurons in a larval zebrafish brain, along with motion stabilized and voxel-level cell segmentations of these data that facilitate development of a variety of forecasting methods. Initial results from a selection of time series and volumetric video modeling approaches achieve better performance than naive baseline methods, but also show room for further improvement. The specific brain used in the activity recording is also undergoing synaptic-level anatomical mapping, which will enable future integration of detailed structural information into forecasting methods.
neuroscience, zebrafish, forecasting, benchmark, timeseries, lightsheet microscopy, calcium imaging
ZAPBench evaluates how well different models can predict the activity of over 70,000 neurons in a novel larval zebrafish dataset.
4,784
2503.02618
[ -0.002177901566028595, -0.006855892948806286, -0.03324202075600624, 0.022130154073238373, 0.07192724198102951, -0.003498984966427088, 0.040194880217313766, 0.004409047309309244, -0.037693701684474945, -0.038158729672431946, 0.016980476677417755, -0.029843885451555252, -0.05522779002785683, -0.00008035490463953465, -0.037148457020521164, 0.05868047475814819, 0.05085914954543114, -0.017330575734376907, 0.04929134249687195, 0.012578163295984268, -0.020365450531244278, -0.03277086466550827, 0.018115203827619553, 0.04128214716911316, 0.02819632552564144, -0.019520817324519157, 0.029794780537486076, -0.00959909800440073, -0.022133033722639084, -0.000963989004958421, 0.029520519077777863, 0.009353392757475376, -0.017321113497018814, -0.030489439144730568, 0.021045735105872154, 0.047288622707128525, -0.03836777061223984, 0.004298788495361805, -0.021386398002505302, 0.005613035522401333, -0.06759494543075562, 0.041807737201452255, -0.018831651657819748, -0.006906331051141024, -0.036682311445474625, 0.041447751224040985, -0.07929553091526031, 0.03374995291233063, 0.0422232560813427, -0.013950220309197903, -0.07948439568281174, 0.030263615772128105, 0.032295748591423035, -0.013843993656337261, -0.024952275678515434, 0.022617140784859657, 0.010763797909021378, -0.07978735864162445, -0.025373829528689384, -0.04443250223994255, 0.02001502364873886, -0.005559201817959547, -0.00959845446050167, 0.01064574159681797, 0.009138371795415878, -0.04977085068821907, 0.03297143429517746, 0.038374513387680054, -0.035201456397771835, -0.01785481907427311, -0.008498684503138065, 0.004124411381781101, -0.012245037592947483, 0.000051279086619615555, 0.009315777570009232, -0.05232560262084007, -0.006690171081572771, 0.038671333342790604, 0.0891258642077446, 0.00843525305390358, 0.0400669239461422, 0.0033471351489424706, 0.04330039024353027, 0.0324428528547287, -0.029545297846198082, 0.02072838693857193, -0.020131537690758705, -0.05725017562508583, -0.07224927097558975, 0.04548024386167526, -0.009003032930195332, -0.012314525432884693, 0.027971668168902397, 0.050764795392751694, 0.01151337195187807, 0.014787697233259678, 0.01398293487727642, 0.00539169367402792, -0.0024362497497349977, 0.031466320157051086, -0.017840217798948288, -0.03049727901816368, 0.021367112174630165, -0.009440946392714977, -0.11624674499034882, -0.049290407449007034, -0.02210974507033825, -0.052131861448287964, -0.024717560037970543, 0.017119282856583595, -0.017543183639645576, 0.0018881033174693584, 0.031600091606378555, -0.001135897939093411, -0.06259859353303909, 0.07303497940301895, 0.0028056649025529623, 0.009401747025549412, 0.002528608776628971, -0.005603897385299206, 0.042298831045627594, 0.07272065430879593, 0.004531113896518946, 0.04844577610492706, -0.025929396972060204, 0.024373238906264305, 0.020264191552996635, -0.004337204620242119, -0.0097147012129426, -0.051951732486486435, 0.019368236884474754, 0.05142863839864731, 0.0146842822432518, -0.02219623140990734, -0.01048671267926693, 0.018961938098073006, 0.02377057820558548, -0.03463377431035042, 0.03139758110046387, 0.045600686222314835, 0.027195371687412262, -0.04896954819560051, 0.021478034555912018, -0.0376543290913105, 0.05084136500954628, -0.012246480211615562, 0.002937023527920246, 0.011920593678951263, -0.047061674296855927, -0.005828207358717918, -0.016089407727122307, 0.03059195913374424, -0.03497777879238129, -0.06446286290884018, 0.02188846655189991, 0.018654553219676018, 0.027544643729925156, -0.012849334627389908, -0.0032049294095486403, -0.010269631631672382, 0.006675161886960268, -0.02139430306851864, -0.02389155700802803, -0.006693071685731411, -0.02148049883544445, -0.022755702957510948, 0.046142056584358215, 0.01868002861738205, -0.049304667860269547, 0.012654039077460766, -0.050230611115694046, -0.03680757060647011, 0.06559920310974121, 0.029050346463918686, -0.0034830537624657154, 0.012465732172131538, 0.05069485679268837, -0.03649965301156044, 0.011397289112210274, 0.009789038449525833, -0.0827186331152916, 0.03682577237486839, 0.013585888780653477, 0.03474486619234085, 0.006308358162641525, 0.003809727029874921, 0.07954331487417221, -0.025129802525043488, -0.006575264502316713, 0.028629207983613014, -0.06192893534898758, -0.038579054176807404, 0.07167454808950424, 0.029359053820371628, 0.07401059567928314, 0.0031298319809138775, 0.013039732351899147, 0.020444955676794052, 0.007422377821058035, 0.03446527197957039, 0.01208030991256237, -0.03553919121623039, 0.03226393088698387, -0.014280200004577637, -0.06331875920295715, -0.01744784042239189, 0.029565678909420967, -0.06580351293087006, -0.04602554440498352, -0.02169451303780079, -0.021830687299370766, -0.017997941002249718, 0.022945793345570564, 0.006852711085230112, 0.030151527374982834, -0.003288585226982832, 0.007343682926148176, 0.0020117314998060465, -0.009071598760783672, -0.04345691204071045, -0.0004512774175964296, -0.013266588561236858, -0.04209665209054947, -0.0028281323611736298, 0.017981428653001785, 0.0958528220653534, 0.06724891066551208, -0.049379173666238785, 0.000923365296330303, 0.014273351989686489, 0.006561005022376776, -0.0054809278808534145, -0.031183157116174698, 0.008460471406579018, 0.003416789462789893, -0.023132184520363808, 0.01252389419823885, -0.017618028447031975, 0.05158472806215286, -0.035322755575180054, 0.020812131464481354, 0.046336978673934937, -0.009704716503620148, 0.04055450111627579, 0.029972227290272713, 0.007962898351252079, 0.05219573527574539, -0.028890026733279228, -0.056276172399520874, -0.030336109921336174, -0.017445530742406845, 0.009227992035448551, -0.006341711618006229, 0.009376676753163338, -0.003626675345003605, -0.07555504888296127, -0.012410735711455345, -0.01229398138821125, 0.0607757568359375, 0.028295040130615234, 0.03217093646526337, 0.031137503683567047, -0.004150467924773693, -0.02865404263138771, 0.013247777707874775, -0.13102026283740997, -0.023609662428498268, -0.033262353390455246, 0.04575982689857483, 0.008293290622532368, 0.06206517294049263, -0.008134717121720314, 0.03708186373114586, -0.016960350796580315, -0.018448181450366974, 0.027430737391114235, 0.031191373243927956, -0.0061882962472736835, -0.00675756623968482, -0.009673845954239368, 0.008955310098826885, 0.07600100338459015, 0.00819865521043539, -0.011308674700558186, -0.009921533055603504, -0.07879999279975891, 0.005589501466602087, -0.015838058665394783, 0.002717110328376293, -0.0048117442056536674, 0.026926111429929733, -0.009565767832100391, 0.004717693198472261, 0.018918508663773537, 0.012354027479887009, 0.06857488304376602, 0.02924007549881935, -0.006382661405950785, -0.061723411083221436, 0.004082520958036184, -0.01819271594285965, 0.0020292033441364765, -0.012003601528704166, -0.007822375744581223, 0.00454265670850873, 0.00737385218963027, 0.0022144324611872435, -0.027145830914378166, -0.27326688170433044, -0.0030107649508863688, 0.011543604545295238, 0.00953954178839922, 0.027519719675183296, -0.00976630300283432, 0.01765098236501217, -0.015660246834158897, -0.025626491755247116, 0.007129746023565531, -0.027206020429730415, 0.03840620815753937, -0.011062602512538433, 0.052744559943675995, 0.052964989095926285, -0.018738077953457832, 0.02340095303952694, -0.02015167474746704, -0.008413730189204216, 0.010637140832841396, 0.006008719094097614, -0.0691084936261177, -0.023108940571546555, 0.026327233761548996, 0.017023811116814613, 0.037861745804548264, -0.045499663800001144, -0.005582995247095823, -0.04812455549836159, -0.014961169101297855, -0.004451876971870661, -0.04830409213900566, -0.022373151034116745, 0.012473244220018387, 0.0342085063457489, 0.015257971361279488, 0.013383157551288605, 0.02572755515575409, 0.020594876259565353, -0.024775858968496323, 0.0009699107613414526, -0.003329430241137743, -0.05719907954335213, -0.007643844000995159, 0.04631073400378227, 0.047658614814281464, -0.015222165733575821, 0.0010077483020722866, -0.00021551881218329072, 0.02807934582233429, -0.046616893261671066, -0.011367862112820148, -0.031052730977535248, 0.01985696144402027, -0.03424852713942528, -0.049736153334379196, 0.00898010190576315, 0.019537433981895447, -0.0031033079139888287, -0.018751269206404686, 0.0006207178812474012, -0.060438670217990875, -0.04976586252450943, -0.04898693412542343, -0.021024055778980255, -0.04314924404025078, -0.046829961240291595, -0.06277785450220108, 0.06044099107384682, 0.03127555921673775, 0.022192206233739853, -0.016010403633117676, -0.03657031059265137, -0.0995531901717186, -0.006687887944281101, 0.003676889929920435, -0.016067638993263245, -0.01984744891524315, 0.0005812824238091707, 0.04182552173733711, -0.020331934094429016, -0.04796653613448143, 0.01850597746670246, 0.03434121608734131, 0.004911534488201141, -0.060497965663671494, -0.02907910943031311, -0.00998582225292921, 0.006498188246041536, -0.02208448201417923, 0.036335647106170654, -0.025365889072418213, 0.010712739080190659, -0.02879136987030506, 0.03922407329082489, 0.010526701807975769, 0.02044469118118286, 0.068346306681633, 0.018624110147356987, 0.0013009813847020268, 0.04704781621694565, -0.05830710381269455, -0.007973053492605686, -0.04845710098743439, -0.009905817918479443, 0.010503762401640415, -0.022873084992170334, -0.016460580751299858, 0.05302052944898605, 0.011982389725744724, -0.00042499921983107924, -0.01910601742565632, 0.03698340430855751, -0.025123612955212593, 0.029329629614949226, -0.03421562910079956, 0.03196093440055847, 0.049968354403972626, 0.018882574513554573, -0.013781043700873852, -0.056911442428827286, 0.016242265701293945, -0.037054337561130524, -0.01133766584098339, 0.018898267298936844, 0.00500907190144062, 0.022897886112332344, -0.010696984827518463, -0.027327267453074455, 0.01701134257018566, 0.020414605736732483, 0.053483717143535614, -0.01799166016280651, 0.021091587841510773, 0.027843695133924484, 0.014654657803475857, -0.007644779048860073, -0.0508631207048893, 0.03566581755876541, -0.03985637426376343, 0.010618974454700947, -0.0014367589028552175, 0.056076958775520325, 0.003720022737979889, 0.027490243315696716, 0.042564671486616135, 0.01513651479035616, 0.011337618343532085, 0.0000043811755858769175, 0.014905824325978756, 0.025595786049962044, -0.05225002020597458, -0.05193363130092621, -0.013642722740769386, 0.02469884231686592, -0.02584422007203102, 0.03140098229050636, -0.016302013769745827, 0.05974135175347328, -0.07395140081644058, 0.015342638827860355, -0.01184764038771391, -0.020407352596521378, -0.032013922929763794, 0.021806038916110992, 0.08342216908931732, -0.002670491812750697, 0.011861479841172695, 0.03727862611413002, -0.02779492735862732, 0.010489651001989841, -0.042640652507543564, -0.007432860322296619, 0.002426369348540902, -0.037372127175331116, 0.026975270360708237, 0.0006134576979093254, -0.023645706474781036, -0.04295261949300766, 0.028886666521430016, 0.004470848944038153, -0.042200781404972076, -0.012366984970867634, -0.0011532155331224203, 0.07612898200750351, 0.045521534979343414, 0.01567971147596836, -0.012270432896912098, -0.00943494401872158, 0.02787465788424015, -0.0004985130508430302, 0.02122417651116848, -0.008356320671737194, -0.026030877605080605, -0.05422788858413696, -0.04688024893403053, 0.046119846403598785, 0.028554007411003113, -0.020552178844809532, -0.0605001337826252, -0.01664811745285988, -0.013360055163502693, -0.010611461475491524, 0.0196613147854805, 0.0624459870159626, -0.07636798918247223, -0.0053842272609472275, 0.06447899341583252, 0.022571003064513206, 0.017364468425512314, -0.03797948732972145, -0.018450593575835228, -0.030090317130088806, 0.013729440979659557, 0.005323929712176323, 0.021200019866228104, 0.009039110504090786, -0.0440884530544281, -0.011031841859221458, -0.0016086155083030462, -0.0025810771621763706, 0.022204535081982613, -0.026343083009123802, -0.06647130846977234, -0.007687215227633715, 0.024939268827438354, -0.023241713643074036, -0.006311315111815929, 0.017237655818462372, -0.02614850364625454, 0.023930365219712257, -0.04649832472205162, -0.02393847145140171, 0.05040954425930977, -0.002905390691012144, 0.022161593660712242, -0.028333386406302452, 0.03888161852955818, 0.04045477882027626, 0.03451402112841606, -0.02350284531712532, 0.034546561539173126, -0.032628513872623444, 0.011077395640313625, 0.00491680670529604, 0.010972554795444012, 0.014895080588757992, 0.046174295246601105, 0.018576456233859062, 0.006408145185559988, 0.017258545383810997, 0.022754326462745667, -0.006708770524710417, 0.0038981724064797163, 0.04743824899196625, 0.007009380962699652, -0.03985507786273956, -0.05694255977869034, -0.019942166283726692, 0.004166613798588514, -0.01881680265069008, 0.04360673576593399, -0.007454430218786001, 0.07368548959493637, 0.014451163820922375, 0.013560273684561253, -0.010998944751918316, -0.031620707362890244, 0.04389238357543945, -0.03412603959441185, 0.054179251194000244, -0.04011649265885353, -0.020303787663578987, 0.05853075906634331, -0.042471714317798615, 0.007749109994620085, 0.019364269450306892, -0.017593996599316597, 0.047829583287239075, -0.04105423763394356, -0.035892222076654434, 0.0443454384803772, -0.01500716246664524, -0.02906702272593975, 0.008156711235642433, -0.04452004283666611, 0.0034743521828204393, -0.05437347665429115, -0.01608862355351448, -0.009261268191039562, 0.03951263427734375, 0.022862592712044716, -0.014622812159359455, 0.016848918050527573, -0.00691901845857501, 0.043596334755420685, 0.06257864087820053, 0.04647330567240715, 0.006214331369847059, 0.009607192128896713, -0.048106104135513306, 0.07977163046598434, 0.029344409704208374, 0.004055075813084841, -0.010102652944624424, 0.027064526453614235, -0.009937804192304611, -0.0317346453666687, -0.0003007006016559899, 0.026190349832177162, -0.0047035180032253265, -0.0801474079489708, 0.05723898112773895, 0.03676633909344673, -0.05091232433915138, -0.0018438161350786686, 0.0146408686414361, -0.048150695860385895, 0.01855785958468914, 0.003579241456463933, -0.015756839886307716, -0.018142642453312874, 0.039937157183885574, 0.03515908122062683, 0.02008548378944397, 0.05518363043665886, 0.02012474462389946, -0.0066989208571612835, 0.04722943529486656, 0.10876956582069397, 0.05774916708469391, 0.010073862038552761, 0.0009725987329147756, 0.08549260348081589, -0.020901577547192574, -0.04124252498149872, 0.03527683764696121, 0.000520015659276396, -0.047466833144426346, 0.001501409919001162, 0.06974996626377106, 0.0934339314699173, 0.04243823513388634, 0.05980418995022774, -0.04963603615760803, 0.0002576104016043246, 0.030444741249084473, 0.03256605938076973, -0.0011773357400670648, 0.024131808429956436, 0.020079001784324646, 0.032675862312316895, -0.015091437846422195, -0.014894258230924606, -0.016723711043596268, -0.042912423610687256, 0.01760023832321167, 0.02840987965464592, -0.03365550562739372, 0.004200509283691645, -0.017731335014104843, 0.054729778319597244, 0.05940953269600868, -0.00523696793243289, -0.021047214046120644, 0.00989720318466425, -0.009965920820832253, 0.012395224533975124, 0.04641810432076454, 0.010456823743879795, 0.008898911997675896, -0.015393387526273727, 0.007068447768688202, 0.003583678975701332, 0.009670875035226345, -0.01585213653743267, 0.013675001449882984, -0.07337506860494614, -0.055089566856622696, 0.01663755625486374, 0.010128908790647984, -0.05164356157183647, -0.0499417781829834, -0.018973257392644882, -0.027180403470993042, -0.08909560739994049, -0.02690201811492443, 0.00911867804825306, -0.014913046732544899, -0.06782492250204086, -0.021052809432148933, -0.029430802911520004, 0.024039320647716522, 0.010991849936544895, -0.04631676524877548, -0.043062541633844376, 0.04950520396232605, -0.01704961247742176, -0.0164432805031538, 0.019610518589615822, 0.022576838731765747, -0.019180838018655777, -0.04479487985372543, 0.0305984765291214, -0.0020924299024045467, 0.012689893133938313, -0.04740029200911522, -0.023564722388982773, -0.09755248576402664, 0.025839829817414284, 0.034298110753297806, -0.010841086506843567, -0.07535913586616516, 0.019864173606038094, 0.006611760705709457, 0.02913498505949974, 0.06713159382343292, -0.014663364738225937, 0.019455427303910255, -0.043092019855976105, -0.013546999543905258, -0.04276461526751518, -0.00940873846411705, 0.04154381901025772, -0.04599548876285553, 0.07866861671209335, 0.05307333543896675, -0.02194586582481861, -0.0288813728839159, 0.01893228478729725, -0.019602077081799507, 0.003472274634987116, -0.03791370242834091, -0.01895001158118248, -0.07028745859861374, -0.1300947070121765, 0.02492961660027504, 0.03598268702626228, -0.013949483633041382, -0.051682423800230026, 0.0063768308609724045, 0.02735883742570877, 0.018635008484125137, -0.01786268688738346, -0.0037132445722818375, -0.023244017735123634, -0.023011719807982445, -0.03680236265063286, -0.09198110550642014, -0.003933265805244446, -0.022962046787142754, 0.03975103422999382, -0.030908558517694473, -0.027685241773724556, 0.018152674660086632, 0.001898042275570333, 0.017272964119911194, -0.006468190811574459, 0.005285781808197498, -0.020714398473501205 ]
3,567
Lumina-T2X: Scalable Flow-based Large Diffusion Transformer for Flexible Resolution Generation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=EbWf36quzd
[ "Peng Gao", "Le Zhuo", "Dongyang Liu", "Ruoyi Du", "Xu Luo", "Longtian Qiu", "Yuhang Zhang", "Rongjie Huang", "Shijie Geng", "Renrui Zhang", "Junlin Xie", "Wenqi Shao", "Zhengkai Jiang", "Tianshuo Yang", "Weicai Ye", "Tong He", "Jingwen He", "Junjun He", "Yu Qiao", "Hongsheng Li" ]
Spotlight
Sora unveils the potential of scaling Diffusion Transformer (DiT) for generating photorealistic images and videos at arbitrary resolutions, aspect ratios, and durations, yet it still lacks sufficient implementation details. In this paper, we introduce the Lumina-T2X family -- a series of Flow-based Large Diffusion Transformers (Flag-DiT) equipped with zero-initialized attention, as a simple and scalable generative framework that can be adapted to various modalities, e.g., transforming noise into images, videos, multi-view 3D objects, or audio clips conditioned on text instructions. By tokenizing the latent spatial-temporal space and incorporating learnable placeholders such as |[nextline]| and |[nextframe]| tokens, Lumina-T2X seamlessly unifies the representations of different modalities across various spatial-temporal resolutions. Advanced techniques like RoPE, KQ-Norm, and flow matching enhance the stability, flexibility, and scalability of Flag-DiT, enabling models of Lumina-T2X to scale up to 7 billion parameters and extend the context window to 128K tokens. This is particularly beneficial for creating ultra-high-definition images with our Lumina-T2I model and long 720p videos with our Lumina-T2V model. Remarkably, Lumina-T2I, powered by a 5-billion-parameter Flag-DiT, requires only 35% of the training computational costs of a 600-million-parameter naive DiT (PixArt-alpha), indicating that increasing the number of parameters significantly accelerates convergence of generative models without compromising visual quality. Our further comprehensive analysis underscores Lumina-T2X's preliminary capability in resolution extrapolation, high-resolution editing, generating consistent 3D views, and synthesizing videos with seamless transitions. All code and checkpoints of Lumina-T2X are released at https://github.com/Alpha-VLLM/Lumina-T2X to further foster creativity, transparency, and diversity in the generative AI community.
Generative Models, Text-to-Image Generation, Diffusion Models, Flow Matching
We propose Lumina-T2X, leveraging Flow-based Large Diffusion Transformer to transform noise into various resolution images with various advanced applications..
4,783
null
[ 0.011821170337498188, -0.05779382213950157, 0.0018867633771151304, 0.02017947845160961, 0.03168997913599014, 0.05143061652779579, 0.0054268003441393375, -0.013027425855398178, -0.0021132330875843763, -0.03149895742535591, 0.021432535722851753, -0.03984636440873146, -0.020252959802746773, 0.014767673797905445, -0.01794816367328167, 0.06314718723297119, 0.01897503435611725, -0.0028855514246970415, 0.01264241710305214, 0.051709383726119995, -0.007623462472110987, -0.020411230623722076, 0.03724465146660805, 0.01741144061088562, 0.004388067871332169, -0.029806163161993027, 0.007081412710249424, 0.007375756278634071, -0.031162139028310776, 0.0040179891511797905, 0.043624717742204666, -0.00769523810595274, 0.005100602749735117, -0.012249439023435116, 0.028587287291884422, -0.008027104660868645, -0.04132131487131119, 0.004330090247094631, 0.017179889604449272, -0.03286956250667572, -0.013188560493290424, -0.001612095977179706, 0.011459804140031338, 0.006282823625952005, -0.0383729487657547, -0.004079385660588741, -0.13231024146080017, 0.050219252705574036, -0.022046905010938644, -0.011009203270077705, -0.08025572448968887, 0.003291292581707239, -0.020676733925938606, 0.028672082349658012, 0.0007949656574055552, 0.02405041828751564, 0.01728522777557373, -0.05637696012854576, -0.005823139101266861, -0.043901871889829636, -0.0019386360654607415, -0.01405337918549776, 0.017646687105298042, -0.00862929504364729, 0.000519758032169193, -0.028874650597572327, -0.007313731126487255, 0.04347281530499458, -0.04243919253349304, -0.06684331595897675, 0.014287259429693222, 0.024330155923962593, -0.012710800394415855, 0.005730172153562307, -0.02801118791103363, -0.031066427007317543, -0.005966901313513517, 0.01979779824614525, 0.05483313277363777, -0.0015728548169136047, 0.053894005715847015, 0.01652035117149353, 0.003422520821914077, 0.05968363955616951, 0.015188830904662609, 0.030923085287213326, -0.012631573714315891, -0.006534867454320192, -0.0505196675658226, 0.0034242430701851845, -0.029536643996834755, -0.05518043041229248, 0.011052560992538929, 0.044770412147045135, 0.03884586691856384, -0.0028552385047078133, 0.020172135904431343, 0.02575942501425743, 0.01786712370812893, -0.013490860350430012, -0.013813551515340805, -0.04224725067615509, 0.010147874243557453, -0.01005613524466753, -0.06395694613456726, -0.016677893698215485, -0.040368277579545975, -0.0257989764213562, 0.01533801481127739, 0.030159806832671165, -0.026457665488123894, 0.00032848090631887317, 0.028013283386826515, -0.016860293224453926, -0.09639162570238113, 0.028548525646328926, 0.025788564234972, 0.005942055489867926, -0.013585071079432964, 0.0011035342467948794, 0.08815758675336838, 0.05753173306584358, -0.004636585246771574, 0.07036980241537094, 0.01142526138573885, 0.026756824925541878, 0.017477957531809807, 0.01591111533343792, -0.022133875638246536, 0.00412375433370471, 0.026720469817519188, 0.034701623022556305, -0.007764984387904406, -0.014253037981688976, 0.005212129559367895, -0.02466578222811222, 0.0019480891060084105, -0.002472253981977701, 0.06619596481323242, -0.04907503351569176, 0.031534209847450256, -0.016751892864704132, 0.03917591646313667, -0.03437171131372452, 0.06715702265501022, -0.020091990008950233, -0.014904371462762356, -0.010359562933444977, -0.0407789871096611, 0.014821182936429977, 0.02748452126979828, -0.0017280391184613109, 0.04255281761288643, -0.05012930929660797, 0.0037006251513957977, 0.05786785110831261, 0.0245373398065567, -0.013160585425794125, -0.0163724422454834, 0.006992442067712545, 0.029151014983654022, -0.01783853769302368, -0.007814829237759113, -0.004441129043698311, -0.025138800963759422, -0.02098805271089077, 0.027842476963996887, -0.005617846269160509, -0.048062801361083984, -0.04174761101603508, -0.03148933872580528, -0.048259928822517395, 0.023877345025539398, 0.02171741984784603, -0.012645388953387737, 0.005427907221019268, 0.03049238584935665, 0.023934978991746902, 0.022753622382879257, 0.02416062541306019, -0.0973956286907196, 0.020151307806372643, 0.010814016684889793, -0.0017496069194748998, 0.021808937191963196, -0.021580887958407402, 0.07318656146526337, -0.024766333401203156, -0.007993169128894806, 0.011378373019397259, -0.07584474980831146, -0.014480166137218475, 0.016715964302420616, -0.004290946759283543, 0.03924267366528511, 0.01258886605501175, -0.028794459998607635, 0.005078931339085102, 0.05969502776861191, 0.050474051386117935, 0.005110701080411673, -0.03936449810862541, 0.07869651913642883, -0.034272175282239914, -0.032840169966220856, -0.021016361191868782, 0.06405463069677353, -0.02678055688738823, -0.025409717112779617, 0.001337110297754407, 0.0024397263769060373, -0.01725924015045166, 0.017758071422576904, 0.007169362157583237, 0.023135406896471977, 0.004266322590410709, -0.02408434823155403, 0.03204769641160965, 0.008371684700250626, -0.04402247443795204, 0.05784713104367256, 0.03039286844432354, -0.03999241068959236, 0.020013833418488503, -0.03971631079912186, 0.09408242255449295, 0.053897541016340256, -0.06268294155597687, -0.028992893174290657, 0.03560159355401993, -0.0402100533246994, 0.0042725964449346066, -0.0011237493017688394, -0.03694688156247139, 0.007521097082644701, -0.04889388754963875, 0.030602537095546722, -0.01465699914842844, 0.037126269191503525, -0.08084934204816818, 0.0038018536288291216, 0.03907421976327896, -0.015578248538076878, 0.06540773808956146, -0.010114976204931736, 0.0004347822687122971, 0.053930800408124924, -0.00545693002641201, -0.018853656947612762, 0.00533220125362277, 0.002367585664615035, 0.02258189581334591, 0.008504224941134453, -0.05406918004155159, 0.04305359721183777, -0.06081642210483551, -0.014593468979001045, -0.007426202762871981, 0.04993085190653801, 0.04365185275673866, -0.005602171644568443, 0.018743429332971573, -0.001777864876203239, -0.03772195056080818, -0.026898756623268127, -0.1238294243812561, -0.03001534380018711, -0.018862372264266014, 0.04407632723450661, -0.004824363626539707, 0.06119416654109955, 0.006581515539437532, -0.0015913924435153604, -0.05288631469011307, -0.0031070264521986246, -0.010481834411621094, 0.005244400352239609, 0.016154298558831215, -0.0024934776592999697, -0.023143112659454346, 0.032944485545158386, 0.07344923168420792, 0.0004404808860272169, -0.001452900585718453, -0.037869248539209366, -0.02173781581223011, 0.009973018430173397, -0.03194713592529297, -0.007173024583607912, -0.001851809211075306, 0.025878194719552994, 0.026807252317667007, -0.015418858267366886, -0.013522802852094173, 0.017877647653222084, 0.05899731069803238, 0.029320884495973587, -0.008952058851718903, -0.0321267694234848, 0.023599013686180115, -0.019461078569293022, -0.0007986039272509515, 0.02407986856997013, 0.03504612669348717, -0.03499448299407959, -0.00820955727249384, 0.058957960456609726, -0.025331970304250717, -0.26066356897354126, -0.01020547654479742, 0.007947252131998539, -0.0087920306250453, 0.02548152394592762, -0.022165268659591675, 0.0016538240015506744, -0.03344260901212692, -0.020355185493826866, 0.012279367074370384, -0.023651162162423134, 0.03826155886054039, -0.04232902079820633, 0.03719707578420639, 0.030437909066677094, 0.019582120701670647, 0.011046661995351315, -0.021471144631505013, 0.02219063974916935, 0.02643798291683197, -0.03738738223910332, -0.04738258942961693, -0.0243741013109684, 0.02092120610177517, -0.029749304056167603, -0.0007814275450073183, -0.09157108515501022, -0.011559260077774525, 0.0005631802487187088, -0.022633323445916176, -0.01575731672346592, -0.02865411341190338, 0.00233094347640872, 0.05432482436299324, -0.009563149884343147, -0.006362195126712322, 0.045802436769008636, -0.024588357657194138, 0.029945239424705505, -0.03208957985043526, 0.026420388370752335, 0.0035681286826729774, -0.008947864174842834, 0.005310850217938423, 0.06177893653512001, -0.030690981075167656, -0.050928931683301926, 0.02299606055021286, 0.00003512641342240386, 0.04721517488360405, 0.0035301554016768932, -0.0068110148422420025, -0.04442362114787102, -0.03556337207555771, -0.0027227899990975857, -0.02319287694990635, -0.010639926418662071, -0.016350453719496727, 0.01125324610620737, 0.03159140422940254, -0.027395032346248627, -0.03891998529434204, -0.01679929904639721, -0.022614553570747375, -0.0242181196808815, -0.01748262532055378, -0.057843565940856934, -0.05134831741452217, 0.016063595190644264, 0.05842302739620209, -0.015028619207441807, 0.011890146881341934, -0.007246031891554594, -0.09853211790323257, -0.012155963107943535, -0.001409892924129963, -0.006962676532566547, -0.001753331278450787, -0.04760724678635597, 0.037159062922000885, -0.030918758362531662, -0.04416581243276596, 0.023888353258371353, -0.00008394058386329561, -0.001904129865579307, -0.015766706317663193, 0.026187121868133545, -0.040487468242645264, 0.020771021023392677, -0.016398929059505463, 0.0544188916683197, 0.007462456356734037, 0.02414826489984989, -0.02657848224043846, 0.06487203389406204, 0.022231008857488632, 0.07013501226902008, 0.055910639464855194, 0.01834902912378311, -0.004759259521961212, 0.055380888283252716, -0.054416023194789886, -0.02700648456811905, -0.037928398698568344, -0.040507685393095016, 0.048288360238075256, -0.024660823866724968, -0.007225025445222855, 0.03216575086116791, 0.015742359682917595, -0.043387748301029205, -0.01618947833776474, -0.0017293429700657725, -0.016170458868145943, 0.020046669989824295, -0.028092775493860245, 0.0075126695446670055, 0.034378908574581146, 0.06749571114778519, -0.004854866769164801, -0.010764718055725098, 0.03070257604122162, -0.03145745024085045, -0.011447523720562458, 0.00695197144523263, 0.016898375004529953, -0.04809616133570671, 0.0022848632652312517, 0.00843274686485529, 0.007885501720011234, 0.032758284360170364, 0.01750519685447216, 0.018663616850972176, 0.0442918986082077, 0.05562577396631241, -0.04686374217271805, -0.020087003707885742, -0.006208533421158791, 0.026851758360862732, -0.021570760756731033, 0.012345599010586739, 0.004732589237391949, 0.05149246007204056, -0.0158531554043293, 0.04668015241622925, 0.008896002545952797, 0.017568623647093773, 0.04380457103252411, -0.019981391727924347, 0.016495319083333015, 0.041521333158016205, -0.09094302356243134, -0.08503454923629761, -0.03925229609012604, 0.01087264996021986, -0.02078375779092312, 0.0039559099823236465, -0.022846471518278122, 0.02460191585123539, -0.07976362854242325, 0.048790451139211655, 0.029646430164575577, -0.0177344661206007, -0.01031044963747263, 0.03182298690080643, 0.0013976511545479298, 0.02401130273938179, -0.0006529006641358137, -0.012016932480037212, -0.010394975543022156, -0.000869914423674345, -0.01184097770601511, -0.050121013075113297, -0.035703081637620926, -0.02170342393219471, 0.04728787764906883, -0.020233064889907837, 0.0022707919124513865, -0.029152126982808113, 0.0927380621433258, 0.015541857108473778, -0.004101583734154701, 0.01124820951372385, -0.001778285251930356, 0.07914791256189346, 0.014368277043104172, -0.0111768189817667, -0.02800627239048481, -0.041494566947221756, 0.041991088539361954, -0.0310228131711483, 0.037512291222810745, -0.06035241857171059, -0.0440460629761219, -0.03554249554872513, -0.061227623373270035, 0.012950727716088295, 0.037301212549209595, -0.0022040423937141895, 0.004908266942948103, -0.002215886488556862, -0.02351546660065651, -0.037058275192976, -0.00570270698517561, -0.002601633546873927, -0.06862325966358185, 0.02338501065969467, 0.0496707521378994, -0.042942363768815994, 0.01490610372275114, 0.02134672738611698, -0.037634316831827164, -0.05524548143148422, -0.03535623103380203, -0.0012697686906903982, -0.008957365527749062, -0.024671047925949097, -0.062060751020908356, 0.03063936159014702, -0.014024496078491211, 0.022825373336672783, 0.01938924565911293, -0.0017931237816810608, 0.018341870978474617, -0.011164671741425991, 0.027940480038523674, -0.05933304876089096, 0.008543593809008598, -0.002547379583120346, -0.02348913438618183, 0.030457325279712677, -0.05405620485544205, 0.018910327926278114, 0.06635616719722748, 0.015299266204237938, 0.035178665071725845, -0.05683558061718941, 0.009915056638419628, 0.02088232710957527, -0.01329100877046585, 0.027222327888011932, 0.008921705186367035, -0.025503531098365784, 0.048270951956510544, 0.005916930735111237, 0.048361580818891525, -0.029943406581878662, 0.011987186968326569, -0.0016894378932192922, 0.022506151348352432, 0.02012684941291809, 0.01713191531598568, -0.04601173475384712, -0.019799116998910904, 0.08958829194307327, -0.0756266638636589, 0.014300656504929066, -0.06053779274225235, -0.08218219131231308, 0.021929971873760223, -0.006023795809596777, 0.027084721252322197, -0.006936702877283096, -0.017016936093568802, 0.04715508222579956, 0.010489060543477535, -0.000957314798142761, -0.02052682638168335, 0.04192422330379486, -0.03004150278866291, 0.022824643179774284, -0.05648507922887802, -0.01258701179176569, 0.013988888822495937, -0.04878730699419975, 0.0028211039025336504, -0.0009407397010363638, -0.03959019109606743, 0.01828164979815483, -0.03874054551124573, -0.050224579870700836, 0.054208412766456604, -0.013620770536363125, 0.004443909972906113, 0.017821306362748146, -0.028039313852787018, 0.026559188961982727, -0.010672458447515965, -0.040907908231019974, 0.018782248720526695, -0.00489850714802742, 0.023981209844350815, -0.00027897130348719656, -0.004771978594362736, -0.02540714293718338, -0.00019395712297409773, 0.031397972255945206, 0.04711883142590523, -0.010886701755225658, 0.02468765899538994, 0.004488995764404535, 0.08449593186378479, 0.049837276339530945, -0.007558858022093773, 0.03913852944970131, 0.019207555800676346, -0.009440360590815544, -0.042415864765644073, 0.04482616111636162, -0.0038062387611716986, -0.0020335300359874964, -0.0792405903339386, 0.0469970628619194, 0.041053950786590576, -0.07173803448677063, 0.015109540894627571, 0.03085755556821823, -0.02105541154742241, -0.0004974399344064295, -0.039662107825279236, 0.0205942764878273, 0.018509944900870323, 0.05772032216191292, -0.0368071049451828, 0.03190675750374794, 0.05935356393456459, 0.012033534236252308, -0.004945829510688782, -0.025826502591371536, 0.06529340147972107, 0.04803917929530144, 0.04470667988061905, -0.037069275975227356, 0.06268838793039322, -0.05241233855485916, -0.04256012663245201, 0.07347646355628967, 0.022270340472459793, -0.019793903455138206, -0.07255151122808456, 0.03227486088871956, 0.12108037620782852, -0.010373760014772415, 0.03593544289469719, -0.060447514057159424, 0.0018270255532115698, 0.005327371880412102, 0.0010854463325813413, 0.0070421393029391766, 0.013775695115327835, 0.04004635661840439, -0.0007629189640283585, -0.018991149961948395, 0.018725818023085594, 0.005927791353315115, -0.038883596658706665, 0.019200708717107773, 0.0013353911926969886, 0.008935154415667057, 0.019675932824611664, -0.0010217741364613175, 0.024459796026349068, 0.09206203371286392, -0.035306159406900406, -0.044892001897096634, -0.0184493325650692, 0.011682739481329918, 0.005131027661263943, 0.01660028286278248, -0.02366236224770546, -0.011820237152278423, 0.013652466237545013, -0.06652971357107162, 0.036690276116132736, 0.023497598245739937, 0.006912529934197664, 0.03864508867263794, -0.010965236462652683, -0.0008988814661279321, 0.029706867411732674, -0.0057686613872647285, -0.05537332594394684, -0.03122861683368683, -0.03047778457403183, -0.05040278285741806, -0.056277792900800705, -0.009928983636200428, -0.0006604120135307312, 0.02408994361758232, -0.04097936302423477, -0.053537726402282715, -0.020744629204273224, 0.006423845421522856, 0.027405599132180214, -0.06751520186662674, -0.00930473580956459, 0.06662830710411072, -0.02791728265583515, -0.06891530752182007, 0.03215361014008522, 0.03848239406943321, 0.005064827390015125, 0.009782145731151104, 0.022143667563796043, 0.04476616159081459, 0.014428742229938507, -0.006033118814229965, 0.0030972387176007032, -0.08545128256082535, 0.0022962274961173534, 0.04487524554133415, -0.020083682611584663, -0.08179111033678055, 0.03773021697998047, -0.017135920003056526, 0.04361563175916672, 0.03872070834040642, 0.0030169279780238867, 0.013869029469788074, -0.031453218311071396, -0.011491567827761173, 0.00959346629679203, -0.006939931772649288, 0.058974869549274445, -0.03181929886341095, 0.07937036454677582, 0.05026458948850632, 0.013401628471910954, 0.006327752955257893, 0.0573497973382473, -0.04513499140739441, 0.029986359179019928, 0.0004607962036971003, -0.014764511957764626, -0.052819766104221344, -0.12178216129541397, -0.04608706757426262, 0.016613878309726715, -0.02502426877617836, -0.04759499058127403, 0.0031823902390897274, 0.00017425358237233013, 0.012582317925989628, -0.028269603848457336, 0.011086630634963512, -0.02158329077064991, -0.0287950336933136, -0.04449452459812164, -0.03176426514983177, -0.005187493748962879, 0.0006653920863755047, 0.030467161908745766, 0.030917443335056305, -0.025891849771142006, -0.015695882961153984, -0.008230192586779594, 0.051276907324790955, 0.0004086503176949918, 0.049608517438173294, -0.008068067021667957 ]
3,568
A Periodic Bayesian Flow for Material Generation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Lz0XW99tE0
[ "Hanlin Wu", "Yuxuan Song", "Jingjing Gong", "Ziyao Cao", "Yawen Ouyang", "Jianbing Zhang", "Hao Zhou", "Wei-Ying Ma", "Jingjing Liu" ]
Spotlight
Generative modeling of crystal data distribution is an important yet challenging task due to the unique periodic physical symmetry of crystals. Diffusion-based methods have shown early promise in modeling crystal distribution. More recently, Bayesian Flow Networks were introduced to aggregate noisy latent variables, resulting in a variance-reduced parameter space that has been shown to be advantageous for modeling Euclidean data distributions with structural constraints (Song, et al.,2023). Inspired by this, we seek to unlock its potential for modeling variables located in non-Euclidean manifolds e.g. those within crystal structures, by overcoming challenging theoretical issues. We introduce CrysBFN, a novel crystal generation method by proposing a periodic Bayesian flow, which essentially differs from the original Gaussian-based BFN by exhibiting non-monotonic entropy dynamics. To successfully realize the concept of periodic Bayesian flow, CrysBFN integrates a new entropy conditioning mechanism and empirically demonstrates its significance compared to time-conditioning. Extensive experiments over both crystal ab initio generation and crystal structure prediction tasks demonstrate the superiority of CrysBFN, which consistently achieves new state-of-the-art on all benchmarks. Surprisingly, we found that CrysBFN enjoys a significant improvement in sampling efficiency, e.g., 200x speedup (10 v.s. 2000 steps network forwards) compared with previous Diffusion-based methods on MP-20 dataset.
Crystal Generation, Bayesian Flow Networks, Crystal Structure Prediction
We propose a periodic Bayesian flow with a novel mechanism to generate material under entropy guidance, achieving consistent better performance and significant higher sampling efficiency.
4,764
2502.02016
[ 0.00423740828409791, 0.010348992422223091, -0.007331445347517729, 0.05017891898751259, 0.020891385152935982, -0.013616135343909264, 0.02662406675517559, -0.02758537046611309, -0.013011467643082142, -0.05266217887401581, -0.0027469440829008818, -0.012502572499215603, -0.03459905460476875, 0.02805974707007408, 0.016401946544647217, 0.04119258001446724, 0.04963240772485733, 0.00018774032650981098, 0.060685280710458755, 0.03331243619322777, -0.01819266937673092, -0.002048477763310075, 0.04966217279434204, 0.021783996373414993, 0.03476666659116745, 0.005248041823506355, 0.028964215889573097, -0.016695449128746986, 0.009667228907346725, -0.004640167113393545, 0.008592810481786728, -0.02093077264726162, -0.005800463259220123, -0.045804597437381744, 0.010669806972146034, 0.009063336066901684, -0.043805040419101715, 0.008666395209729671, -0.017531879246234894, 0.01047942042350769, -0.025882180780172348, 0.023332832381129265, 0.006818491965532303, 0.017040343955159187, -0.006855628918856382, 0.03072364442050457, -0.09445474296808243, 0.061995841562747955, -0.015287326648831367, -0.031579308211803436, -0.09189950674772263, 0.029464054852724075, 0.026715587824583054, -0.006968043278902769, 0.01480674184858799, 0.008231360465288162, 0.013791010715067387, -0.03397898003458977, -0.021198222413659096, -0.04619908705353737, -0.0038375849835574627, -0.005722659640014172, 0.006542219314724207, 0.008026638999581337, -0.0005627350765280426, -0.00805750023573637, 0.007306575309485197, 0.05015961825847626, -0.034812599420547485, -0.004386873450130224, -0.044137585908174515, 0.006397266406565905, 0.018997611477971077, -0.01897605136036873, -0.015495030209422112, -0.028777513653039932, 0.022755594924092293, 0.024441907182335854, 0.07051020115613937, 0.019795065745711327, 0.029710477218031883, 0.017589371651411057, 0.020069537684321404, 0.03810837119817734, 0.0011722797062247992, 0.002044142922386527, -0.06308404356241226, 0.010484931990504265, -0.059072040021419525, 0.06929232180118561, -0.017410166561603546, -0.050996337085962296, 0.031512320041656494, 0.03889240324497223, 0.04090511053800583, -0.06310642510652542, 0.049811411648988724, -0.00798431783914566, 0.019264638423919678, 0.022511852905154228, -0.022381477057933807, -0.03968122601509094, -0.002717425813898444, -0.00043800019193440676, -0.06827099621295929, -0.026031646877527237, -0.05974504351615906, -0.023006856441497803, -0.06216281279921532, -0.015377718023955822, 0.007699096109718084, 0.006183453369885683, 0.01045540813356638, 0.000662212900351733, -0.08328772336244583, 0.027764692902565002, -0.0032090332824736834, 0.004146547522395849, -0.004423763137310743, 0.003408578922972083, 0.0845286101102829, 0.03172409534454346, -0.024844244122505188, 0.03755318745970726, 0.009746789932250977, 0.008623581379652023, 0.02882993221282959, 0.0501813106238842, -0.03485105559229851, -0.034923456609249115, 0.002902588341385126, 0.04659495875239372, 0.011600257828831673, -0.01912054978311062, 0.011118312366306782, -0.0593641996383667, -0.00598505511879921, 0.02485567517578602, 0.040375713258981705, -0.0005783821106888354, 0.009888538159430027, 0.0006989235989749432, 0.04538756236433983, -0.01855110004544258, 0.06655202805995941, -0.0035226198378950357, -0.02102252095937729, -0.02320573478937149, -0.03524176776409149, 0.01053652260452509, 0.023606160655617714, -0.014788961037993431, 0.01214654091745615, -0.03481433168053627, -0.0029668831266462803, 0.011569635011255741, 0.016917014494538307, 0.01936350390315056, -0.000529651646502316, -0.04979359731078148, 0.005672093015164137, 0.012209364213049412, -0.015564994886517525, 0.039098743349313736, -0.0019830609671771526, -0.04687775298953056, 0.05193185806274414, 0.08110462129116058, -0.07560184597969055, -0.016594650223851204, -0.022419875487685204, -0.010545260272920132, 0.01576521061360836, 0.02109653130173683, -0.012472061440348625, -0.012650959193706512, 0.03711998462677002, 0.003038509516045451, 0.019239168614149094, -0.0004133685433771461, -0.08195332437753677, 0.024680430069565773, 0.022265490144491196, -0.017644884064793587, 0.011000832542777061, -0.013790775090456009, 0.09505714476108551, -0.026178907603025436, 0.007941075600683689, 0.04523420333862305, -0.09322355687618256, -0.0023382320068776608, 0.0355793833732605, -0.0004899357445538044, 0.058335479348897934, -0.011091950349509716, -0.0228464026004076, 0.059514015913009644, 0.025587474927306175, 0.026324106380343437, 0.020040323957800865, 0.01718498393893242, 0.025461886078119278, -0.06518837809562683, -0.053371213376522064, -0.05314246192574501, 0.08631814271211624, -0.057250458747148514, -0.02481909468770027, 0.043279629200696945, 0.004113234579563141, -0.016688359901309013, 0.007965316995978355, -0.025836393237113953, 0.015255842357873917, -0.02178690955042839, -0.008281439542770386, 0.02047489397227764, -0.005086487624794245, -0.0199752077460289, 0.015225119888782501, 0.014545435085892677, -0.03616907075047493, 0.008752626366913319, -0.02396966889500618, 0.1113382875919342, 0.09185495227575302, -0.05423387885093689, 0.005507288500666618, 0.022556155920028687, 0.042534422129392624, -0.014048517681658268, 0.03345659002661705, 0.0009576482698321342, 0.025040045380592346, -0.019922947511076927, -0.013009579852223396, -0.005235934630036354, 0.041794370859861374, -0.06015855073928833, 0.010372094810009003, 0.047151971608400345, -0.03402721509337425, 0.05188432335853577, 0.023453371599316597, 0.014434210024774075, 0.07824242115020752, -0.021114131435751915, -0.052524060010910034, 0.022601017728447914, -0.04154011607170105, 0.006004406604915857, 0.012002650648355484, 0.022246208041906357, 0.0036828501615673304, -0.0868285521864891, -0.011860263533890247, 0.034401554614305496, 0.045412059873342514, 0.08026625216007233, 0.026659175753593445, -0.029062965884804726, 0.006199967581778765, -0.0320441909134388, -0.05601954460144043, -0.13919496536254883, -0.02490299567580223, -0.024903375655412674, 0.03570978343486786, 0.026213042438030243, 0.033050306141376495, 0.004985388834029436, -0.006252146791666746, 0.002140187192708254, -0.016228320077061653, -0.0028639542870223522, 0.009702399373054504, 0.009471048600971699, -0.030310586094856262, -0.04082054644823074, 0.000375278847059235, 0.08491452038288116, 0.004074107389897108, -0.015789693221449852, -0.0264752134680748, -0.03352618217468262, 0.0012672845041379333, 0.015784477815032005, 0.010897057130932808, 0.02329264208674431, -0.008343249559402466, -0.025698857381939888, -0.01068804319947958, 0.008247976191341877, 0.023396257311105728, 0.05599410831928253, 0.04054789990186691, 0.006213983986526728, -0.042230892926454544, 0.02115362137556076, 0.011185090988874435, 0.007201888598501682, -0.027875352650880814, 0.008424053899943829, -0.01731245219707489, -0.0012939164880663157, 0.0018698599888011813, -0.004016861319541931, -0.2459055781364441, 0.016495799645781517, 0.025599339976906776, -0.028450584039092064, 0.03215987607836723, 0.00950806774199009, 0.010435870848596096, -0.021198241040110588, -0.03371971473097801, 0.013793449848890305, -0.01866183616220951, 0.05029231309890747, 0.004690719768404961, 0.06714318692684174, 0.05982369929552078, 0.02283719927072525, 0.01841961219906807, -0.01665256917476654, 0.021558675915002823, 0.01068714540451765, -0.016854863613843918, -0.03292527422308922, -0.03900916874408722, -0.00239690113812685, -0.009103566408157349, -0.00124594965018332, -0.05361325293779373, -0.02283228002488613, -0.04079532250761986, 0.006079344544559717, -0.05036935955286026, -0.026933975517749786, 0.04479393735527992, 0.023446401581168175, 0.019906768575310707, 0.00421194126829505, 0.01660129427909851, -0.008002337999641895, 0.017828121781349182, -0.00579390162602067, 0.016951851546764374, 0.003189103677868843, -0.03670671209692955, 0.03042285516858101, 0.07565774768590927, -0.006130166817456484, -0.02883075922727585, 0.01223396323621273, -0.05742547661066055, 0.03256212919950485, -0.015445015393197536, -0.014387519098818302, 0.02022930234670639, -0.02824525162577629, -0.012870603241026402, 0.009019622579216957, -0.01031293161213398, 0.033066246658563614, 0.0058225300163030624, -0.003623911878094077, -0.021666239947080612, -0.021709727123379707, -0.006095038261264563, -0.012680908665060997, -0.008865069597959518, -0.05255052074790001, -0.08045526593923569, -0.0569721981883049, 0.029805459082126617, 0.057644933462142944, 0.007836518809199333, -0.003666518023237586, -0.031551867723464966, -0.10090319067239761, 0.04146876931190491, 0.0079469820484519, 0.007625378668308258, -0.019532503560185432, 0.015231478027999401, 0.011868766508996487, -0.04164151847362518, -0.0295678973197937, 0.013286976143717766, 0.04075255244970322, 0.02073890157043934, -0.0072829388082027435, 0.024792779237031937, -0.02286549098789692, -0.03803093731403351, -0.023019462823867798, 0.034729860723018646, 0.025937817990779877, 0.06097465008497238, 0.002754002111032605, 0.033123936504125595, 0.01905330829322338, 0.006161941681057215, 0.011991020292043686, 0.032394882291555405, -0.011172334663569927, 0.05965990945696831, -0.09132089465856552, -0.04789554327726364, -0.04857149347662926, -0.04860227555036545, 0.0277455672621727, -0.050807420164346695, -0.016130750998854637, 0.02309541404247284, 0.01919427514076233, -0.02999819815158844, -0.0036674379371106625, 0.009801510721445084, 0.011378559283912182, 0.015427151694893837, -0.01662563532590866, 0.0007098031928762794, 0.020749641582369804, 0.01344324741512537, -0.0269253421574831, -0.0702773705124855, 0.03589186072349548, -0.027684500440955162, -0.0001589134189998731, -0.005419479217380285, -0.02423843927681446, -0.01945132203400135, -0.009384121745824814, 0.028745919466018677, -0.004707655869424343, -0.006922288332134485, 0.02624577470123768, 0.010719086974859238, 0.020505007356405258, 0.028530411422252655, 0.0008538259426131845, -0.05011473596096039, -0.02877073921263218, 0.013114980421960354, -0.05017468333244324, 0.041438449174165726, -0.0035492151509970427, 0.030433177947998047, 0.006154096685349941, 0.07309665530920029, 0.05810194090008736, 0.019961398094892502, 0.05639660358428955, 0.020017845556139946, -0.019085798412561417, 0.008501099422574043, -0.05603022128343582, -0.02245756797492504, -0.005012964829802513, -0.026380881667137146, 0.0008802155498415232, 0.02948661707341671, 0.011957273818552494, 0.02085339091718197, -0.07482747733592987, 0.05228426307439804, 0.042148441076278687, -0.020071880891919136, -0.009110425598919392, -0.02983332984149456, 0.0755399614572525, -0.009510823525488377, 0.015211914665997028, 0.0032245817128568888, -0.0007130940211936831, 0.0024370625615119934, -0.02347700111567974, -0.030023343861103058, -0.01161816157400608, -0.03155401349067688, 0.03924153372645378, -0.00040379847632721066, -0.0548882931470871, -0.03214435651898384, 0.019555075094103813, 0.019770007580518723, -0.022769546136260033, -0.0037905722856521606, 0.017033686861395836, 0.06003611534833908, 0.012331632897257805, -0.020875465124845505, -0.01606934331357479, -0.02906082756817341, 0.033996809273958206, 0.0234024990350008, -0.001576591981574893, -0.022242290899157524, -0.028047235682606697, -0.01894797384738922, -0.043795354664325714, 0.03677964583039284, 0.03788332641124725, -0.01838439702987671, 0.006402540020644665, -0.004808978643268347, -0.012958668172359467, -0.054414860904216766, -0.00076557497959584, 0.03583994507789612, -0.05122716724872589, 0.008159332908689976, 0.041023675352334976, 0.002063049701973796, -0.0048536742106080055, -0.01682521589100361, -0.0009494757978245616, -0.06294872611761093, 0.004570826422423124, -0.017965156584978104, 0.024531325325369835, -0.018096644431352615, -0.01293118204921484, 0.017991110682487488, -0.0031238901428878307, -0.013836627826094627, 0.005955297965556383, 0.029271062463521957, -0.041866235435009, -0.0013456507585942745, 0.052106305956840515, -0.022267203778028488, 0.0024737233761698008, 0.0018417404498904943, -0.01489442028105259, 0.03842766582965851, -0.06638344377279282, -0.021866003051400185, 0.03869987279176712, 0.00273718754760921, 0.018883612006902695, -0.033509571105241776, 0.03580344840884209, 0.020930498838424683, -0.003751256735995412, -0.03636215627193451, -0.025896765291690826, -0.026892434805631638, -0.0017396514303982258, -0.027269111946225166, 0.005766399670392275, 0.00967142079025507, 0.026775268837809563, 0.003916033543646336, 0.05000190809369087, -0.0188614372164011, -0.02921624295413494, -0.029611103236675262, -0.025357810780405998, 0.04958957061171532, -0.005802921950817108, -0.016152016818523407, -0.09721389412879944, -0.00658139493316412, 0.005149902775883675, -0.042241133749485016, 0.016411155462265015, -0.03875670209527016, 0.030573951080441475, 0.009313216432929039, 0.03556756302714348, 0.01653725653886795, -0.050078775733709335, 0.0450386106967926, -0.043004922568798065, -0.0004788816731888801, -0.05213034525513649, -0.015175500884652138, 0.04010588303208351, -0.023891141638159752, 0.013347022235393524, -0.018799560144543648, -0.025361845269799232, 0.020893581211566925, -0.037521351128816605, -0.0742649957537651, 0.023725735023617744, -0.019284211099147797, 0.003819817677140236, 0.05427280813455582, -0.043296463787555695, -0.042255599051713943, -0.02662057802081108, -0.04872281104326248, 0.007867942564189434, 0.040628254413604736, 0.033449068665504456, -0.028401890769600868, 0.008229756727814674, -0.016285734251141548, 0.006953052710741758, 0.03357984498143196, 0.0676804780960083, 0.016518989577889442, 0.04072946682572365, -0.03603338822722435, 0.09048105776309967, 0.06345608085393906, 0.03260201960802078, 0.04596779868006706, 0.0028133585583418608, -0.021575095131993294, -0.031606610864400864, 0.026493286713957787, 0.035315703600645065, -0.018624478951096535, -0.06459543853998184, 0.03285456448793411, 0.0024693275336176157, -0.09052302688360214, -0.030621865764260292, 0.0612589530646801, -0.04093923792243004, -0.011826588772237301, 0.01361113041639328, 0.0033237787429243326, -0.023179225623607635, 0.0464320033788681, -0.006208688952028751, 0.02461695857346058, 0.07434294372797012, -0.002802852774038911, -0.0005759773193858564, -0.03633929789066315, 0.06763731688261032, 0.05351801589131355, 0.008696998469531536, 0.007476204540580511, 0.06067916750907898, -0.023276695981621742, -0.05187951773405075, -0.03139540180563927, 0.02428942359983921, -0.03460048511624336, -0.019759928807616234, 0.030883612111210823, 0.10055054724216461, -0.0026012039743363857, 0.05148080363869667, -0.030711637809872627, 0.004617846570909023, -0.0034085006918758154, 0.014107168652117252, -0.0013193831546232104, 0.032583605498075485, 0.013877039775252342, 0.009500175714492798, -0.032441042363643646, -0.04972611740231514, -0.049869604408741, -0.026457998901605606, 0.013823269866406918, 0.028600871562957764, -0.018002307042479515, 0.015272966586053371, -0.01577584445476532, -0.0010444207582622766, 0.08672427386045456, -0.02619793824851513, -0.06507609039545059, -0.0029304942581802607, -0.021275775507092476, 0.0036365410778671503, -0.008319420740008354, 0.007193854544311762, 0.03237040340900421, 0.017676394432783127, -0.028081176802515984, 0.0020702120382338762, 0.013218467123806477, -0.006438423879444599, 0.02429860271513462, -0.018983758985996246, -0.029654299840331078, 0.003694067941978574, -0.0015582123305648565, -0.03140911087393761, -0.08069304376840591, -0.02616661787033081, -0.06819392740726471, -0.084127277135849, -0.01610378734767437, 0.07825372368097305, -0.030434245243668556, -0.03208961710333824, 0.022295502945780754, 0.014845374040305614, 0.0007069601560942829, 0.03355085104703903, -0.07602255046367645, -0.04638420045375824, 0.09352296590805054, 0.016488350927829742, 0.010626005008816719, 0.021410929039120674, 0.028132162988185883, -0.026686206459999084, -0.004590935539454222, 0.05472007393836975, 0.0030875506345182657, 0.04122849181294441, 0.0010655736550688744, 0.019357189536094666, -0.0981689989566803, 0.03423573076725006, 0.016371900215744972, -0.058122288435697556, -0.08116499334573746, 0.026997124776244164, -0.03422357514500618, 0.002287068171426654, 0.061403825879096985, 0.013842275366187096, -0.0013976991176605225, -0.07553640007972717, 0.00900598056614399, -0.01499820128083229, 0.007546153385192156, 0.08406682312488556, -0.045008011162281036, 0.0695061981678009, 0.025132348760962486, -0.04095358029007912, -0.0356195829808712, 0.0033998137805610895, 0.0069760046899318695, -0.007874121889472008, -0.009822587482631207, 0.0006195768364705145, -0.0645405724644661, -0.10552653670310974, -0.0385543629527092, 0.02503242716193199, -0.017966117709875107, -0.02060788869857788, 0.02752106823027134, 0.013932930305600166, 0.021597201004624367, -0.022728443145751953, 0.015280460938811302, 0.0030386836733669043, -0.02987639605998993, -0.039898209273815155, -0.055814530700445175, 0.03164488822221756, 0.019483329728245735, 0.006834434811025858, -0.038134388625621796, -0.06192740052938461, 0.005028529092669487, -0.03644286468625069, 0.0211363285779953, 0.02159825712442398, 0.015209122560918331, 0.0017379692289978266 ]
3,569
DiffPuter: Empowering Diffusion Models for Missing Data Imputation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=3fl1SENSYO
[ "Hengrui Zhang", "Liancheng Fang", "Qitian Wu", "Philip S. Yu" ]
Spotlight
Generative models play an important role in missing data imputation in that they aim to learn the joint distribution of full data. However, applying advanced deep generative models (such as Diffusion models) to missing data imputation is challenging due to 1) the inherent incompleteness of the training data and 2) the difficulty in performing conditional inference from unconditional generative models. To deal with these challenges, this paper introduces DiffPuter, a tailored diffusion model combined with the Expectation-Maximization (EM) algorithm for missing data imputation. DiffPuter iteratively trains a diffusion model to learn the joint distribution of missing and observed data and performs an accurate conditional sampling to update the missing values using a tailored reversed sampling strategy. Our theoretical analysis shows that DiffPuter's training step corresponds to the maximum likelihood estimation of data density (M-step), and its sampling step represents the Expected A Posteriori estimation of missing values (E-step). Extensive experiments across ten diverse datasets and comparisons with 17 different imputation methods demonstrate DiffPuter's superior performance. Notably, DiffPuter achieves an average improvement of 8.10\% in MAE and 5.64\% in RMSE compared to the most competitive existing method.
Diffusion models, missing data imputation
This paper combines EM algorithm and a Diffusion model for missing data imputation
4,746
null
[ 0.002305234083905816, -0.04005987197160721, -0.05333773046731949, 0.07522118836641312, 0.06419187784194946, 0.04517526924610138, 0.025185702368617058, -0.014847679063677788, -0.012064109556376934, -0.06414749473333359, 0.02082434669137001, -0.009189924225211143, -0.04737181216478348, 0.023665277287364006, -0.02216757833957672, 0.0595845989882946, 0.057869184762239456, -0.02440734952688217, -0.0077766845934093, 0.054820239543914795, -0.022394664585590363, -0.05592667683959007, 0.028645960614085197, 0.008856617845594883, 0.0050001852214336395, 0.005031420849263668, 0.04190126061439514, -0.033108901232481, -0.028724409639835358, -0.005094080697745085, 0.024387110024690628, -0.003317861584946513, 0.03792077302932739, -0.03884138539433479, 0.007358291652053595, -0.005941550247371197, -0.0466952882707119, 0.0133617939427495, -0.008121391758322716, 0.024340873584151268, -0.03213588148355484, 0.00359298731200397, -0.03139325603842735, 0.04650945961475372, -0.05031849443912506, -0.004303150810301304, -0.09153416007757187, 0.011197595857083797, -0.016330625861883163, -0.010033334605395794, -0.10495074093341827, 0.0213068388402462, 0.031072821468114853, -0.012322979979217052, -0.008889565244317055, 0.004594967234879732, 0.05533597990870476, -0.09162639081478119, -0.014541233889758587, -0.04301827773451805, -0.01990978792309761, 0.007022548466920853, 0.018209777772426605, -0.005396016873419285, 0.002962476573884487, -0.07835862040519714, 0.015209862031042576, 0.05739978700876236, -0.01148191373795271, -0.06137726083397865, -0.02573874592781067, 0.004535176325589418, -0.003005450591444969, -0.030033862218260765, 0.0012674913741648197, -0.027543896809220314, 0.017598213627934456, 0.01705843396484852, 0.1059173122048378, -0.012076855637133121, -0.00003503026891849004, -0.023660337552428246, 0.024755749851465225, 0.02676680125296116, -0.010884741321206093, 0.013049027882516384, -0.05198229104280472, -0.028518399223685265, -0.051463719457387924, 0.029163941740989685, -0.026621870696544647, -0.0311641413718462, 0.02048403210937977, 0.0031312620267271996, 0.020540723577141762, 0.03649939224123955, 0.04830556362867355, -0.03349804878234863, 0.023834025487303734, -0.0030361381359398365, -0.014568542130291462, -0.03370388224720955, 0.0029827295802533627, 0.033959392458200455, -0.0942986011505127, -0.028264911845326424, -0.038536399602890015, -0.03831523656845093, 0.0006558768218383193, -0.00013452302664518356, -0.01245168223977089, 0.0164396483451128, -0.012116385623812675, -0.006645461078733206, -0.08461672812700272, 0.05089845880866051, 0.017493177205324173, 0.013469632714986801, 0.014823549427092075, -0.005658465903252363, 0.05560353770852089, 0.06800021231174469, 0.041867710649967194, 0.06284761428833008, -0.03713740408420563, 0.06278257817029953, 0.06161661818623543, 0.014689275063574314, -0.01905563287436962, 0.007859654724597931, -0.013566559180617332, 0.04364436864852905, 0.013714352622628212, 0.005728243850171566, 0.004467451479285955, -0.02022862806916237, 0.004252998158335686, 0.0016776309348642826, 0.07767059653997421, -0.04638967290520668, -0.00019947187684010714, 0.0034457019064575434, 0.023495780304074287, -0.022953014820814133, 0.024861376732587814, -0.014307129196822643, -0.020169241353869438, -0.016179485246539116, -0.03329581394791603, 0.00846964679658413, 0.02600436843931675, 0.02010699361562729, 0.05933161452412605, -0.028893273323774338, -0.01987326703965664, 0.03494320437312126, -0.04163224250078201, -0.0008998915436677635, -0.02134176529943943, 0.005297303665429354, 0.024100180715322495, -0.00507791293784976, -0.033706944435834885, 0.0027858249377459288, -0.02750067599117756, -0.033653512597084045, 0.04792962968349457, 0.009979214519262314, -0.05470913648605347, -0.036060042679309845, -0.029963186010718346, -0.020590536296367645, 0.057531993836164474, 0.010236077010631561, 0.015951337292790413, -0.012694536708295345, 0.011406724341213703, 0.02667727880179882, 0.02923867292702198, 0.05562083423137665, -0.08737940341234207, 0.03138871490955353, 0.007887103594839573, -0.009196758270263672, -0.007766148075461388, 0.016064312309026718, 0.08140096068382263, -0.00037086184602230787, 0.008868117816746235, 0.04532761499285698, -0.0861576646566391, -0.03871505707502365, 0.04251670464873314, -0.0098592983558774, 0.047084175050258636, 0.00021097747958265245, -0.009303832426667213, 0.002634737640619278, 0.010360180400311947, 0.04234634339809418, 0.04883648082613945, -0.03870018199086189, 0.037473414093256, -0.018749073147773743, -0.03252233937382698, -0.0005897384835407138, 0.044373344630002975, -0.011103524826467037, -0.038375407457351685, 0.0324515774846077, -0.027370603755116463, 0.0047842576168477535, 0.004171750042587519, -0.02193557657301426, 0.04294801130890846, 0.04459561035037041, -0.015095316804945469, -0.026489978656172752, -0.009557986631989479, -0.036740582436323166, 0.02877413108944893, 0.041850000619888306, -0.007465633563697338, 0.016230400651693344, -0.0182441808283329, 0.08511170744895935, 0.08575143665075302, -0.03644825145602226, 0.0006056030979380012, 0.03876210376620293, -0.0061255283653736115, 0.015826908871531487, 0.03337687626481056, -0.008973833173513412, 0.024477997794747353, -0.017996447160840034, -0.004257667809724808, -0.035871971398591995, 0.07455771416425705, -0.05116375908255577, -0.0016582482494413853, 0.052445847541093826, -0.007364320568740368, 0.076948381960392, 0.027768876403570175, 0.007803930435329676, 0.03524502366781235, -0.002887788927182555, -0.04095263034105301, -0.02878396585583687, -0.003494924632832408, 0.024993332102894783, 0.016428541392087936, -0.011589135974645615, 0.023766467347741127, -0.05262750759720802, 0.016637103632092476, -0.011564761400222778, 0.07838023453950882, 0.05408751592040062, 0.009102599695324898, -0.008128099143505096, -0.006968464702367783, -0.05196739360690117, -0.0000957268857746385, -0.12317944318056107, -0.050366248935461044, -0.03098888136446476, 0.050430770963430405, -0.025623897090554237, 0.038787055760622025, -0.010050523094832897, -0.01656263880431652, -0.035592954605817795, 0.0104476073756814, 0.008884538896381855, 0.004141706973314285, 0.021858753636479378, -0.044318344444036484, -0.014231269247829914, 0.002220236463472247, 0.09030254185199738, -0.027802495285868645, -0.0021402647253125906, -0.018162138760089874, -0.03638345003128052, -0.0254523903131485, -0.003849796950817108, -0.005148362368345261, 0.02299349755048752, -0.0037743179127573967, 0.01959880255162716, -0.029456816613674164, -0.02747906930744648, 0.06811509281396866, 0.02140735648572445, 0.03656628355383873, 0.0060813212767243385, -0.032578837126493454, 0.025647882372140884, 0.00462349085137248, 0.024316975846886635, 0.0163288414478302, 0.017447464168071747, -0.02043933980166912, -0.021171575412154198, 0.05725087970495224, -0.04118821397423744, -0.25853028893470764, 0.033525288105010986, 0.014381914399564266, -0.021486856043338776, 0.053012385964393616, -0.029403451830148697, 0.043898046016693115, -0.002114124596118927, -0.019845951348543167, 0.018746517598628998, -0.00944164115935564, 0.041522204875946045, -0.006363024469465017, 0.057467978447675705, 0.050133444368839264, 0.035638902336359024, 0.010758430697023869, -0.03161792829632759, 0.03556118533015251, 0.026354392990469933, 0.007357809692621231, -0.046260278671979904, -0.026525776833295822, 0.04157223552465439, -0.003947574179619551, 0.03199031576514244, -0.061501286923885345, 0.002897026250138879, -0.04846739023923874, -0.02378196455538273, -0.003152829362079501, -0.023967275395989418, -0.02802423946559429, 0.03606854006648064, -0.013396776281297207, 0.008151487447321415, 0.023154886439442635, 0.0483141764998436, 0.024002473801374435, 0.009175347164273262, 0.021909311413764954, 0.0003083346819039434, -0.0062084984965622425, 0.004276088438928127, 0.044451601803302765, 0.009774146601557732, -0.04476471617817879, -0.0019403838086873293, 0.00601404020562768, 0.04271373152732849, 0.00008061013068072498, -0.015162590891122818, -0.02538403682410717, 0.005342625547200441, 0.005564621649682522, -0.003040933283045888, -0.03773488104343414, 0.009351956658065319, 0.004846849944442511, 0.0218485277146101, 0.016020774841308594, -0.019717497751116753, -0.015617696568369865, -0.0437222495675087, -0.032781943678855896, -0.06001553684473038, -0.0868903398513794, -0.06326959282159805, 0.048820264637470245, 0.031213248148560524, -0.026853639632463455, -0.011891149915754795, 0.005649718455970287, -0.09567362815141678, 0.02760576829314232, -0.005019316449761391, -0.012574373744428158, -0.011852209456264973, -0.012841811403632164, 0.012143060564994812, -0.027109211310744286, -0.0529300719499588, 0.0034291092306375504, 0.011669151484966278, 0.021504713222384453, -0.014104344882071018, 0.0027463536243885756, -0.033464960753917694, -0.02049466222524643, -0.055659741163253784, 0.03368150442838669, -0.0076531278900802135, 0.03033406287431717, -0.004045586567372084, 0.017802763730287552, 0.07481959462165833, 0.04187185317277908, 0.0887022390961647, 0.009717555716633797, 0.001119617954827845, 0.030473891645669937, -0.09272143244743347, -0.04722897335886955, -0.09072298556566238, -0.005206199362874031, 0.011902514845132828, -0.06198694929480553, -0.027397243306040764, 0.0366658940911293, -0.031046798452734947, -0.011653117835521698, -0.03729745373129845, -0.004647009074687958, -0.021368663758039474, 0.00016964868700597435, -0.00643462548032403, 0.013885954394936562, 0.04654230177402496, 0.04030913859605789, -0.008127130568027496, 0.004336298909038305, 0.016722720116376877, -0.0693921446800232, 0.002501084702089429, 0.013542930595576763, -0.03208879753947258, -0.010772493667900562, 0.010354114696383476, 0.022960808128118515, -0.014516889117658138, 0.04913835600018501, 0.04211259260773659, -0.01473807543516159, 0.010231009684503078, 0.03599735349416733, -0.009358263574540615, -0.011733705177903175, -0.005155839957296848, 0.026941990479826927, -0.029357785359025, 0.01233399473130703, -0.03522590547800064, 0.045861683785915375, -0.010096529498696327, 0.06189427524805069, 0.012248499318957329, 0.003666994860395789, 0.021910151466727257, -0.0008906791335903108, -0.02981295809149742, 0.03375658765435219, -0.0509028285741806, 0.012884153053164482, -0.04032503440976143, -0.04070986062288284, -0.014053543098270893, 0.027483392506837845, -0.030248574912548065, -0.0007252892246469855, -0.0810382291674614, 0.03354303166270256, 0.011315563693642616, -0.024418357759714127, 0.00794101133942604, -0.013819375075399876, 0.060739170759916306, 0.010187321342527866, 0.00649293465539813, 0.027525627985596657, 0.025067299604415894, 0.027537601068615913, -0.03585037961602211, -0.02667674422264099, -0.00343000958673656, 0.012406372465193272, 0.025693586096167564, 0.025024980306625366, 0.013585265725851059, -0.04362387955188751, 0.026603400707244873, -0.0018797180382534862, -0.03626934811472893, -0.013591128401458263, 0.02663377858698368, 0.08448466658592224, 0.0076803225092589855, 0.024703748524188995, 0.007904875092208385, -0.035508062690496445, 0.03334791958332062, -0.047518640756607056, -0.013128399848937988, -0.03246795013546944, -0.05269909277558327, -0.017032615840435028, -0.054438699036836624, -0.030018776655197144, 0.04947531595826149, -0.02108929306268692, 0.001255498267710209, -0.03359435126185417, -0.009482406079769135, -0.010373085737228394, 0.0026587722823023796, 0.015166694298386574, -0.08009030669927597, -0.01144037488847971, 0.013882008381187916, -0.06030651554465294, 0.02527422271668911, -0.03197919577360153, -0.03631674870848656, -0.06531699746847153, 0.01875067874789238, -0.0014372484292834997, -0.012764533050358295, -0.0008442322141490877, -0.0281561017036438, 0.03730730712413788, -0.008205663412809372, -0.0032600327394902706, -0.0032871311996132135, -0.0009403495932929218, -0.002484853845089674, -0.012616394087672234, -0.0050324443727731705, -0.04289029538631439, -0.030361663550138474, 0.0019471598789095879, 0.0026372605934739113, -0.012678265571594238, -0.04133914038538933, 0.006509268190711737, 0.06510598212480545, 0.0037670976016670465, -0.009274806827306747, 0.014279192313551903, 0.040747977793216705, -0.00019378232536837459, -0.02129530720412731, -0.01607852801680565, -0.028656190261244774, -0.052787117660045624, -0.019258050248026848, 0.04188530892133713, 0.0005528574110940099, -0.0038652957882732153, -0.021098794415593147, 0.01936391182243824, 0.03903547674417496, 0.010701742023229599, 0.004378265235573053, -0.05838411673903465, -0.007442900445312262, 0.04181243106722832, -0.020297199487686157, -0.03055158257484436, -0.06884684413671494, -0.018214207142591476, 0.01715177297592163, 0.016828807070851326, 0.01038910262286663, -0.007915121503174305, 0.037313312292099, 0.031976260244846344, -0.0007421694463118911, -0.009962133131921291, -0.021544165909290314, 0.02654607594013214, -0.030744152143597603, 0.00545268040150404, -0.05309514328837395, -0.039402738213539124, 0.09046709537506104, -0.05956205353140831, 0.0014421911910176277, 0.017316805198788643, 0.02244540862739086, 0.03895336389541626, -0.04646638408303261, -0.0580059178173542, 0.017299238592386246, 0.002613265533000231, 0.0011751367710530758, 0.020761141553521156, -0.005650452338159084, -0.01278354600071907, -0.0058079976588487625, -0.028384458273649216, 0.009324148297309875, 0.030818047001957893, 0.03614294156432152, -0.027508044615387917, 0.0028990856371819973, -0.0015165176009759307, 0.013522016815841198, 0.0010163510451093316, 0.06789518892765045, -0.0074851918034255505, 0.032338257879018784, -0.006319099105894566, 0.08177389949560165, 0.031023239716887474, 0.020155202597379684, 0.015372906811535358, -0.0027666648384183645, 0.006317073479294777, -0.04449263587594032, -0.0028324953746050596, 0.03533570095896721, -0.005317556671798229, -0.06609959900379181, 0.06605705618858337, 0.03684728965163231, -0.0629071369767189, -0.030845684930682182, 0.01169582549482584, -0.02679063379764557, 0.03159331530332565, -0.01931479014456272, 0.00755050964653492, 0.019065748900175095, 0.06454965472221375, 0.005252206698060036, 0.039179727435112, 0.06431081146001816, 0.04125787317752838, 0.01832406595349312, 0.01806665025651455, 0.07554210722446442, 0.07084798067808151, 0.04182136058807373, 0.02237984724342823, 0.08385606110095978, -0.016671888530254364, -0.03703032433986664, -0.003542511723935604, 0.014090733602643013, -0.010522102005779743, -0.026142654940485954, 0.0406242273747921, 0.10145844519138336, -0.004573724698275328, 0.06765812635421753, -0.02982795052230358, 0.01587148942053318, 0.021941030398011208, 0.038771700114011765, -0.0053617702797055244, -0.0006245910772122443, 0.027575567364692688, -0.016265690326690674, -0.031141862273216248, 0.001386508927680552, -0.006998613476753235, -0.0443507581949234, 0.02441658265888691, 0.012633105739951134, 0.014835458248853683, 0.0241641104221344, -0.009005870670080185, -0.010344956070184708, 0.056525819003582, -0.037688929587602615, -0.010528512299060822, -0.028714915737509727, 0.02332065999507904, -0.008300792425870895, 0.04500211030244827, 0.015590991824865341, 0.012851662933826447, -0.01690019480884075, -0.022787239402532578, 0.027227647602558136, 0.050868913531303406, -0.00018528955115471035, 0.011361771263182163, -0.06634653359651566, -0.000942534941714257, 0.029819602146744728, -0.02187255024909973, -0.0596344955265522, -0.06231722980737686, -0.005026514176279306, -0.019882436841726303, -0.059640493243932724, -0.015695014968514442, 0.05319295823574066, 0.00809086300432682, -0.03476458042860031, 0.015193178318440914, -0.020221037790179253, -0.011407384648919106, 0.020196225494146347, -0.07672051340341568, -0.04368647187948227, 0.05282166972756386, -0.021338099613785744, -0.0267728753387928, 0.029037028551101685, -0.007634831126779318, 0.006250122562050819, -0.025782380253076553, 0.02875441685318947, 0.0007797632133588195, 0.023029319941997528, -0.04091237112879753, -0.019140813499689102, -0.07674140483140945, 0.03568020835518837, 0.03684331849217415, -0.0390501543879509, -0.0951584130525589, 0.04331007972359657, -0.017164917662739754, 0.042361266911029816, 0.03799517825245857, 0.024372348561882973, -0.0029910423327237368, -0.043161921203136444, -0.029378468170762062, -0.0291602723300457, 0.005290621425956488, 0.04364553093910217, -0.035297129303216934, 0.07252534478902817, 0.055585332214832306, 0.0016494322335347533, -0.05283790081739426, 0.03598281368613243, -0.02249993197619915, -0.01943042501807213, -0.02017148584127426, -0.009713396430015564, -0.034122467041015625, -0.08006827533245087, -0.018841344863176346, 0.001142897643148899, -0.04496944695711136, -0.048163771629333496, 0.005543444771319628, -0.02544509619474411, 0.019820958375930786, 0.013041731901466846, -0.039276693016290665, 0.004182633012533188, -0.0429692342877388, -0.0011055292561650276, -0.06036511808633804, 0.010086736641824245, -0.020340008661150932, 0.001919928239658475, -0.03069939836859703, -0.03765163943171501, 0.01237932313233614, -0.024276182055473328, 0.023028161376714706, -0.0015683835372328758, 0.02020850032567978, -0.0405968613922596 ]
3,570
Towards Marginal Fairness Sliced Wasserstein Barycenter
https://openreview.net/forum?id=NQqJPPCesd
[ "Khai Nguyen", "Hai Nguyen", "Nhat Ho" ]
Spotlight
The Sliced Wasserstein barycenter (SWB) is a widely acknowledged method for efficiently generalizing the averaging operation within probability measure spaces. However, achieving marginal fairness SWB, ensuring approximately equal distances from the barycenter to marginals, remains unexplored. The uniform weighted SWB is not necessarily the optimal choice to obtain the desired marginal fairness barycenter due to the heterogeneous structure of marginals and the non-optimality of the optimization. As the first attempt to tackle the problem, we define the marginal fairness sliced Wasserstein barycenter (MFSWB) as a constrained SWB problem. Due to the computational disadvantages of the formal definition, we propose two hyperparameter-free and computationally tractable surrogate MFSWB problems that implicitly minimize the distances to marginals and encourage marginal fairness at the same time. To further improve the efficiency, we perform slicing distribution selection and obtain the third surrogate definition by introducing a new slicing distribution that focuses more on marginally unfair projecting directions. We discuss the relationship of the three proposed problems and their relationship to sliced multi-marginal Wasserstein distance. Finally, we conduct experiments on finding 3D point-clouds averaging, color harmonization, and training of sliced Wasserstein autoencoder with class-fairness representation to show the favorable performance of the proposed surrogate MFSWB problems.
Sliced Wasserstein Barycenter, Optimal Transport, Sliced Wasserstein, Averaging Measures.
We discuss the notion of marginal fairness sliced Wasserstein barycenter which is a special case of sliced Wasserstein barycenter where the distances to marginals are approximately equal.
4,722
2405.07482
[ -0.0026019492652267218, -0.04860943555831909, 0.025361627340316772, 0.025498447939753532, -0.00043110272963531315, 0.03396937996149063, 0.02379370480775833, 0.009584848769009113, -0.028851890936493874, -0.06218016520142555, -0.01881793886423111, -0.01970154047012329, -0.047280553728342056, -0.019225917756557465, 0.045181550085544586, 0.07152348011732101, 0.037222567945718765, 0.002285995753481984, -0.022679172456264496, 0.025649266317486763, -0.0023003544192761183, -0.011786685325205326, 0.017872819676995277, 0.009395779110491276, 0.036461640149354935, 0.002319042105227709, 0.04006483405828476, 0.03455866873264313, -0.023062091320753098, -0.020687608048319817, 0.026453064754605293, 0.03411554917693138, 0.006085619330406189, -0.026523718610405922, -0.007368393242359161, -0.005133968777954578, -0.06206389516592026, 0.02836085483431816, 0.011166597716510296, 0.0023265411145985126, -0.009113606996834278, -0.014634791761636734, -0.0011894361814484, 0.009386242367327213, -0.041939862072467804, -0.0034519112668931484, -0.0909314751625061, 0.020133012905716896, -0.001012675347737968, -0.022181715816259384, -0.06016657128930092, 0.02004663087427616, 0.015058891847729683, 0.018255703151226044, 0.007190099451690912, 0.027669070288538933, -0.0009667236590757966, -0.07530828565359116, 0.006012364756315947, -0.07365170866250992, -0.0409451387822628, -0.0011573170777410269, 0.025846121832728386, 0.014582225121557713, -0.0041163708083331585, 0.0008187683997675776, 0.02475193701684475, 0.05888190492987633, -0.018703600391745567, -0.03508969768881798, -0.0041957879438996315, -0.036399517208337784, 0.016453608870506287, 0.02876807004213333, -0.0037200029473751783, -0.060070984065532684, -0.004006739240139723, 0.03025771491229534, 0.05708775669336319, -0.04011747986078262, 0.00793454796075821, -0.010374934412539005, 0.013599731028079987, 0.04563990235328674, 0.008787360042333603, -0.010556857101619244, -0.04294934496283531, -0.016473310068249702, -0.08666722476482391, 0.04512990266084671, -0.040670543909072876, -0.034209318459033966, 0.029677847400307655, 0.03800536319613457, -0.0006575927836820483, -0.010127009823918343, 0.04873728007078171, 0.02954780124127865, 0.04396127536892891, -0.03493141010403633, -0.026945630088448524, -0.0369894877076149, 0.03196205571293831, 0.021148154512047768, -0.09473328292369843, -0.0036267368122935295, -0.0027616096194833517, -0.014508233405649662, -0.016832901164889336, 0.03375539183616638, -0.04979316145181656, 0.0008206788916140795, 0.011067507788538933, -0.012067905627191067, -0.062092334032058716, 0.024794721975922585, 0.009790735319256783, 0.006614942103624344, -0.015252139419317245, -0.01933186873793602, 0.07109200209379196, 0.02909577079117298, -0.003429910633713007, 0.07694194465875626, 0.011464867740869522, -0.01822330802679062, 0.024592669680714607, 0.04755805432796478, -0.0031332760117948055, -0.03604743257164955, 0.017930664122104645, 0.0417715348303318, -0.000044691878429148346, -0.002458673669025302, -0.021362429484725, -0.001870949985459447, -0.004495866596698761, -0.007104105781763792, 0.004094038624316454, -0.03500956669449806, -0.007801142521202564, -0.03224341571331024, 0.06259120255708694, -0.010905833914875984, 0.07100345194339752, -0.04467933624982834, 0.011898782104253769, -0.030990730971097946, -0.01922544650733471, 0.023653866723179817, -0.008160958997905254, -0.03944391384720802, 0.021295037120580673, -0.05260854959487915, 0.013384882360696793, 0.019815463572740555, 0.019516559317708015, 0.0041042715311050415, 0.003356406930834055, 0.011609074659645557, 0.025474606081843376, 0.010703775100409985, -0.06800045073032379, 0.004404402803629637, -0.0038784623611718416, -0.04768230393528938, 0.06356393545866013, 0.025929635390639305, -0.0507064014673233, -0.004325604997575283, -0.044176533818244934, -0.01971970498561859, 0.0631294921040535, 0.005136188585311174, -0.033065639436244965, -0.013796837069094181, 0.08042190223932266, 0.04981549456715584, 0.03981013223528862, 0.008709288202226162, -0.09171244502067566, 0.01772621087729931, 0.045617178082466125, 0.02419576607644558, 0.028368599712848663, -0.02395744062960148, 0.07651615142822266, -0.03106304071843624, 0.0009405269520357251, 0.028019921854138374, -0.08939030766487122, -0.005710283759981394, 0.010699876584112644, -0.040121644735336304, 0.06251069903373718, 0.020983582362532616, -0.0048377239145338535, -0.0033456224482506514, -0.011041628196835518, 0.01563710719347, 0.0365772619843483, -0.025942813605070114, 0.008025718852877617, -0.010207219049334526, -0.09236276894807816, -0.01102656964212656, 0.03883516788482666, -0.05228562653064728, -0.048563431948423386, 0.03783722221851349, -0.006898768246173859, -0.020673014223575592, -0.024457110092043877, 0.004617557395249605, 0.00036039133556187153, 0.007894899696111679, 0.0016793693648651242, -0.005053699482232332, 0.02895212732255459, -0.05959933623671532, 0.05296986922621727, 0.01560831256210804, 0.01607191376388073, -0.0007290134089998901, -0.004744088277220726, 0.09166182577610016, 0.07996324449777603, -0.016952520236372948, 0.0038151638582348824, 0.028765615075826645, 0.023658141493797302, 0.01888226345181465, -0.001870106440037489, -0.014480618759989738, 0.014667863957583904, -0.02732497826218605, 0.005176015663892031, -0.053169019520282745, 0.08973916620016098, -0.028427308425307274, -0.0015160954790189862, 0.05249212682247162, 0.011040793731808662, 0.040716223418712616, -0.009756452403962612, 0.011523325927555561, 0.033446457237005234, -0.00703119533136487, 0.004868399817496538, -0.02425052411854267, -0.03579476848244667, 0.011962523683905602, -0.0031487129162997007, -0.04114631190896034, -0.014692402444779873, -0.027019301429390907, 0.01363691221922636, -0.0005878211231902242, 0.056069452315568924, 0.06528794020414352, 0.07531806081533432, -0.008881738409399986, -0.002708268817514181, -0.02479165606200695, -0.03979206830263138, -0.11455085873603821, -0.07390563189983368, -0.008322414942085743, 0.07872679829597473, 0.043320432305336, 0.026020392775535583, -0.000029377415557974018, -0.003620385890826583, -0.03226620331406593, 0.00783631857484579, 0.00820914376527071, 0.026456980034708977, -0.01045189332216978, -0.03812345117330551, 0.0003692199243232608, 0.017695005983114243, 0.049824897199869156, -0.015133216045796871, -0.0024872617796063423, 0.00681478762999177, -0.04065430909395218, 0.0005155584076419473, -0.05187949538230896, 0.0014040436362847686, 0.014648141339421272, -0.024787208065390587, 0.03163722902536392, 0.005457920487970114, -0.0047379592433571815, 0.07379595935344696, 0.040228527039289474, 0.04067769646644592, -0.022873811423778534, -0.014175484888255596, 0.016348233446478844, -0.0307457372546196, 0.04349702596664429, 0.013964727520942688, -0.010323009453713894, -0.008465367369353771, -0.021214280277490616, 0.011829959228634834, -0.008698790334165096, -0.28726065158843994, -0.006456594914197922, -0.005473091267049313, -0.016733132302761078, 0.005283048842102289, -0.03330522030591965, 0.025399481877684593, -0.02755028009414673, -0.008617518469691277, 0.0046474323607981205, 0.01299042347818613, 0.02722267620265484, 0.02712652087211609, 0.03432692959904671, 0.05963863432407379, 0.044470615684986115, -0.014725346118211746, -0.018826430663466454, 0.036630719900131226, 0.008760388009250164, -0.021987106651067734, -0.0978357121348381, -0.022379016503691673, 0.01311936043202877, 0.004838063381612301, 0.04101382568478584, -0.06246002018451691, 0.02115474082529545, -0.03161868453025818, -0.039868857711553574, 0.00542041240260005, -0.02367125079035759, -0.003049595048651099, 0.021840255707502365, 0.011022522114217281, -0.0021657543256878853, 0.011352098546922207, -0.028615674003958702, 0.025478554889559746, 0.012514190748333931, 0.004445925820618868, -0.01638232357800007, -0.026758242398500443, -0.0017944173887372017, 0.07309059798717499, 0.011150076985359192, -0.0019604519475251436, -0.01220045518130064, -0.01904085837304592, 0.021821020171046257, 0.024441007524728775, -0.0488973967730999, -0.006838731002062559, 0.01715877093374729, -0.022337794303894043, -0.051880523562431335, 0.011587842367589474, 0.001210056128911674, -0.013158882036805153, 0.028794685378670692, -0.008369569666683674, -0.04032082483172417, 0.00022434166749008, -0.02158440835773945, -0.012639320455491543, -0.035596802830696106, -0.06818389147520065, -0.08205809444189072, 0.023337779566645622, 0.04286838322877884, 0.0043460652232170105, 0.04382942244410515, -0.022922717034816742, -0.0869612842798233, 0.07245603948831558, 0.012694869190454483, -0.013446726836264133, 0.0031762034632265568, -0.00350772007368505, 0.0661996603012085, 0.030486252158880234, -0.057120662182569504, 0.044122856110334396, 0.011642171069979668, 0.008386823348701, 0.00806452427059412, 0.029555687680840492, -0.020740952342748642, -0.003342089941725135, -0.03549641743302345, 0.032310497015714645, 0.015526005066931248, 0.030633095651865005, 0.00034811528166756034, 0.04309816658496857, 0.06172885745763779, -0.012941090390086174, 0.02866104245185852, 0.025476912036538124, 0.018546685576438904, 0.03838281333446503, -0.08984126895666122, -0.02896002121269703, -0.04066125303506851, -0.029422353953123093, 0.055185992270708084, -0.04653550311923027, -0.024865208193659782, 0.042068228125572205, -0.008893678896129131, -0.023560255765914917, -0.017665209248661995, -0.004913756623864174, -0.01692011207342148, 0.01894020289182663, 0.00030084216268733144, -0.007188021205365658, 0.005025119986385107, 0.013202506117522717, -0.016400199383497238, -0.040346041321754456, 0.03406652808189392, -0.018609963357448578, 0.0042746770195662975, -0.03547677397727966, -0.004120932891964912, -0.009109092876315117, -0.006914529018104076, 0.008080245926976204, 0.015640567988157272, 0.0632089301943779, 0.0630078911781311, 0.004012688063085079, 0.02686361037194729, 0.057756803929805756, 0.020342428237199783, -0.021622203290462494, 0.0030332037713378668, 0.07142391055822372, -0.0009535057470202446, 0.029480209574103355, -0.013705559074878693, 0.0036627990193665028, 0.022770775482058525, 0.02560599520802498, 0.008603694848716259, 0.01573062501847744, -0.01277470588684082, -0.01861659437417984, -0.003622297430410981, -0.010575134307146072, -0.04773541912436485, -0.004465653095394373, -0.015015434473752975, -0.013257576152682304, 0.0014039777452126145, 0.01527089811861515, 0.00452475156635046, 0.019712407141923904, -0.09427449107170105, 0.059552308171987534, 0.027310561388731003, -0.020047593861818314, -0.01825607195496559, 0.015659745782613754, 0.0493335984647274, -0.005495667923241854, -0.027314063161611557, 0.02509908564388752, 0.027329271659255028, 0.007227668073028326, -0.03937356546521187, -0.00569959357380867, -0.009460208006203175, -0.03483979403972626, 0.007721623871475458, -0.00489590410143137, -0.007458689156919718, -0.07461392879486084, 0.017517585307359695, -0.006168368272483349, -0.00013481013593263924, 0.007813476957380772, 0.011133412830531597, 0.061292823404073715, 0.008146417327225208, -0.04183320701122284, 0.014612233266234398, -0.009469852782785892, 0.054595012217760086, -0.004704595077782869, 0.022811543196439743, -0.046748340129852295, -0.006685222033411264, -0.03137782961130142, -0.030055448412895203, -0.005498624872416258, -0.0006702492828480899, -0.03662148490548134, -0.0528731569647789, -0.005898638628423214, 0.07063931971788406, 0.006477853283286095, -0.033962417393922806, 0.02254369854927063, -0.06246011704206467, 0.03413418307900429, 0.04763353615999222, -0.04620688036084175, -0.006675466895103455, -0.03082393668591976, -0.03224077448248863, -0.04060798138380051, -0.004681140184402466, 0.015712037682533264, -0.009907212108373642, -0.004222487099468708, 0.007558699697256088, -0.007071777246892452, 0.00650937482714653, -0.0035623961593955755, -0.029967518523335457, 0.010120894759893417, 0.008853817358613014, 0.015399893745779991, 0.07539007067680359, -0.023150602355599403, -0.017139635980129242, 0.008866477757692337, -0.014523107558488846, 0.0031800074502825737, -0.07087717950344086, 0.01248203869909048, 0.06928609311580658, 0.002810713602229953, 0.008371845819056034, -0.08500037342309952, 0.0015689911087974906, -0.04746140167117119, -0.010261700488626957, 0.022517835721373558, 0.03899183124303818, -0.025465961545705795, 0.006890909280627966, 0.020149899646639824, -0.016765041276812553, 0.022517360746860504, 0.0013197817606851459, 0.0021736728958785534, 0.012460649013519287, -0.042489852756261826, -0.0131990946829319, -0.04236707463860512, -0.00894708652049303, 0.04276503995060921, -0.014003418385982513, -0.018648900091648102, -0.0700463131070137, -0.03448271006345749, 0.026857102289795876, -0.04291705787181854, 0.05199683457612991, -0.011072156019508839, 0.05972403287887573, 0.0008667160291224718, 0.024233747273683548, 0.030271712690591812, -0.02229868620634079, -0.0011533272918313742, -0.049954310059547424, 0.008630327880382538, -0.03166424483060837, -0.017131639644503593, 0.05669572204351425, -0.04136042669415474, 0.04061763361096382, 0.0013062742073088884, -0.031504981219768524, 0.030105266720056534, -0.06422392278909683, -0.07039177417755127, -0.006766407284885645, -0.023452404886484146, -0.013449450023472309, 0.019062116742134094, -0.039232287555933, 0.02115696109831333, -0.015367924235761166, -0.04266919195652008, 0.011213959194719791, 0.02004932425916195, 0.04086689651012421, -0.022381680086255074, 0.020903324708342552, -0.022785533219575882, -0.020464375615119934, 0.0488693043589592, 0.05674652010202408, -0.01345392782241106, 0.010843763127923012, -0.035909879952669144, 0.03856945037841797, 0.03190254420042038, -0.009830264374613762, 0.034406110644340515, 0.03473624214529991, 0.01015533972531557, -0.04544999450445175, 0.057762596756219864, 0.021063756197690964, -0.027048159390687943, -0.08025410771369934, 0.06630666553974152, -0.00669724540784955, -0.05628582090139389, -0.02609223872423172, 0.022510120645165443, -0.022213678807020187, 0.01086844690144062, -0.003134373342618346, 0.0035999726969748735, 0.005253687500953674, 0.08019863069057465, -0.022945011034607887, 0.0001775517303030938, 0.0690636932849884, -0.007695832289755344, 0.0011055992217734456, -0.0310871209949255, 0.10016848891973495, 0.08909216523170471, 0.0721118152141571, -0.025907373055815697, 0.06191226467490196, -0.04419901967048645, -0.035134706646203995, 0.004280347842723131, 0.0022161530796438456, -0.011618335731327534, -0.05740819871425629, -0.010814380832016468, 0.05863827466964722, 0.010489864274859428, 0.07360591739416122, -0.05061907321214676, 0.021345017477869987, 0.020435018464922905, -0.007657747715711594, -0.01665164902806282, 0.02028730884194374, 0.029459770768880844, -0.004336704034358263, -0.012299035675823689, -0.007900066673755646, 0.018830956891179085, 0.017252663150429726, 0.002108808374032378, -0.008967585861682892, -0.034167926758527756, 0.021182172000408173, -0.01613088883459568, -0.01810835301876068, 0.0812554880976677, -0.02735445462167263, -0.0767613872885704, 0.011714731343090534, 0.023223500698804855, 0.01929342746734619, 0.03907662630081177, 0.03928268328309059, -0.033285390585660934, -0.0036265875678509474, -0.07436976581811905, 0.046294327825307846, 0.018204377964138985, 0.041956666857004166, 0.018229249864816666, -0.013570883311331272, 0.024420538917183876, 0.005806821398437023, 0.016084466129541397, -0.08061334490776062, -0.02945975586771965, -0.038235362619161606, -0.039794281125068665, -0.03727512061595917, -0.04726509004831314, 0.001219199039041996, -0.007089689839631319, -0.020604155957698822, -0.00999167189002037, -0.04814688116312027, 0.03359399735927582, 0.016281815245747566, -0.05801594257354736, -0.029932262375950813, 0.03554617986083031, 0.011762927286326885, 0.01899886503815651, 0.02072264812886715, 0.03136931732296944, -0.019949786365032196, -0.029753824695944786, -0.0019919653423130512, 0.022445248439908028, 0.03358881548047066, 0.017440104857087135, 0.0015413014916703105, -0.08304069191217422, 0.028182365000247955, 0.005000843666493893, -0.023686232045292854, -0.09143198281526566, 0.02673211507499218, -0.004282536916434765, 0.02261602319777012, 0.06477302312850952, 0.01268888171762228, 0.02215086854994297, -0.055557556450366974, -0.023511551320552826, -0.05956230312585831, 0.004965582396835089, 0.015521284192800522, -0.01654510572552681, 0.07294853031635284, 0.012815695255994797, -0.0024766279384493828, -0.025666363537311554, 0.0453961081802845, -0.008852148428559303, 0.005627227947115898, -0.04596127197146416, -0.015138622373342514, -0.030933909118175507, -0.09024910628795624, -0.005834430456161499, 0.03295644372701645, -0.017067894339561462, -0.014065856114029884, -0.00035846553510054946, -0.010855473577976227, -0.009690125472843647, -0.04039953649044037, 0.014189298264682293, 0.005634097382426262, -0.04286644980311394, -0.023030705749988556, -0.06958138942718506, 0.04424974322319031, -0.038948770612478256, 0.009943713434040546, -0.03443165868520737, -0.03758573532104492, -0.02191099524497986, 0.004271348938345909, 0.018979590386152267, 0.04288820922374725, 0.017811493948101997, -0.0022171353921294212 ]
3,571
Continuous Exposure Learning for Low-light Image Enhancement using Neural ODEs
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Mn2qgIcIPS
[ "Donggoo Jung", "Daehyun Kim", "Tae Hyun Kim" ]
Spotlight
Low-light image enhancement poses a significant challenge due to the limited information captured by image sensors in low-light environments. Despite recent improvements in deep learning models, the lack of paired training datasets remains a significant obstacle. Therefore, unsupervised methods have emerged as a promising solution. In this work, we focus on the strength of curve-adjustment-based approaches to tackle unsupervised methods. The majority of existing unsupervised curve-adjustment approaches iteratively estimate higher order curve parameters to enhance the exposure of images while efficiently preserving the details of the images. However, the convergence of the enhancement procedure cannot be guaranteed, leading to sensitivity to the number of iterations and limited performance. To address this problem, we consider the iterative curve-adjustment update process as a dynamic system and formulate it as a Neural Ordinary Differential Equations (NODE) for the first time, and this allows us to learn a continuous dynamics of the latent image. The strategy of utilizing NODE to leverage continuous dynamics in iterative methods enhances unsupervised learning and aids in achieving better convergence compared to discrete-space approaches. Consequently, we achieve state-of-the-art performance in unsupervised low-light image enhancement across various benchmark datasets.
NeuralODE, Low-light Enhancement
This is a low-light image enhancement method using NeuralODE.
4,698
null
[ 0.027727875858545303, -0.030332179740071297, -0.014422263950109482, 0.03654919192194939, 0.04269769415259361, 0.042351845651865005, 0.01733536832034588, 0.008029675111174583, -0.014730256982147694, -0.03917962685227394, -0.004721407778561115, 0.004667460452765226, -0.06363498419523239, 0.011940968222916126, 0.022715477272868156, 0.03198837861418724, 0.0724688395857811, -0.00456981873139739, -0.02062622644007206, 0.07471147179603577, 0.006464557722210884, -0.023254025727510452, 0.029034696519374847, -0.007681142073124647, -0.00857806671410799, -0.03614431992173195, 0.00847778469324112, 0.005780975800007582, -0.03768202289938927, 0.025714604184031487, 0.015260892920196056, 0.019417960196733475, -0.013324790634214878, -0.07168987393379211, 0.03542659804224968, 0.019194621592760086, -0.045964810997247696, -0.009695230983197689, 0.0027066858019679785, 0.006549438461661339, -0.05667546018958092, -0.03824850544333458, -0.03933150693774223, -0.010540462099015713, -0.0417565256357193, -0.006550199817866087, -0.07965270429849625, 0.032534267753362656, 0.01775466278195381, 0.003527749329805374, -0.07031742483377457, 0.004639080259948969, 0.02238098718225956, 0.007758521940559149, 0.02303512580692768, 0.0493599958717823, 0.018564708530902863, -0.026545463129878044, -0.012806846760213375, -0.0727766677737236, -0.014514965936541557, -0.003957419190555811, -0.008758666925132275, 0.00857281219214201, -0.009304937906563282, 0.012265235185623169, 0.03289499133825302, 0.05253785103559494, -0.02653511054813862, -0.026203056797385216, 0.025728806853294373, -0.013279792852699757, -0.018084021285176277, 0.0018288634018972516, -0.0000856058977660723, -0.0503724031150341, -0.012402243912220001, -0.039372824132442474, 0.07545261085033417, 0.0014514087233692408, 0.048892512917518616, -0.006626610178500414, 0.022704387083649635, 0.05675783008337021, 0.014300286769866943, 0.0006792314816266298, -0.0028761951252818108, -0.008548257872462273, -0.042442720383405685, 0.018091917037963867, -0.02737991139292717, -0.053578250110149384, 0.06095881387591362, 0.0453767292201519, 0.038398563861846924, -0.023337680846452713, 0.011917215771973133, 0.008587411604821682, 0.008287142962217331, -0.00009638557094149292, 0.008678460493683815, -0.013340424746274948, -0.003922715317457914, -0.011886009015142918, -0.07271704822778702, -0.02975243143737316, -0.012060857377946377, -0.04754567891359329, -0.009701209142804146, 0.0007151686004363, -0.04225630685687065, -0.009200293570756912, 0.037312962114810944, 0.000060046349972253665, -0.09965167939662933, 0.009440192021429539, 0.01396131981164217, 0.0006154707516543567, 0.002734681824222207, -0.021513506770133972, 0.052426982671022415, 0.04428573325276375, 0.0332627072930336, 0.061358045786619186, 0.021168362349271774, 0.04289846122264862, 0.032373130321502686, 0.019601916894316673, -0.02566569671034813, -0.0010129378642886877, -0.0007804908091202378, 0.006545649841427803, -0.015915684401988983, -0.004850142635405064, 0.01657186448574066, -0.02198854833841324, 0.035310469567775726, -0.0074085211381316185, 0.027709156274795532, 0.0012556673027575016, 0.008682272396981716, -0.03398545831441879, 0.06875362992286682, -0.04569656401872635, 0.05347449332475662, -0.04160657525062561, 0.014671813696622849, -0.04782076179981232, -0.04768253490328789, -0.010573365725576878, 0.02639441378414631, -0.0306907556951046, -0.030629543587565422, -0.10459939390420914, 0.01606367900967598, 0.04078815504908562, 0.030666591599583626, 0.020382437855005264, -0.016868019476532936, 0.015519280917942524, 0.03265109658241272, -0.024666011333465576, -0.005934556480497122, 0.015729181468486786, -0.010763537138700485, -0.05818585678935051, 0.06504129618406296, 0.026847196742892265, 0.0003411324287299067, -0.030200060456991196, -0.04819057509303093, -0.023317759856581688, 0.013343037106096745, -0.02612893469631672, -0.015068157576024532, 0.015647415071725845, 0.06024208664894104, 0.0003046983038075268, -0.0017048688605427742, 0.030770808458328247, -0.08142862468957901, 0.003907754551619291, 0.016130488365888596, 0.009592542424798012, -0.0019287810428068042, -0.0713648721575737, 0.07607338577508926, -0.045014042407274246, -0.014578060247004032, 0.0038977244403213263, -0.08159992843866348, -0.0032296977005898952, 0.018851010128855705, -0.021494505926966667, 0.04440491273999214, -0.00382635579444468, -0.005028922576457262, -0.016816508024930954, 0.011719383299350739, 0.06394848227500916, 0.04582805559039116, -0.07103611528873444, 0.05962403491139412, -0.01719665341079235, -0.05173022300004959, -0.012317744083702564, 0.05904169753193855, -0.035277824848890305, 0.011925606057047844, 0.006303016562014818, -0.03267287835478783, 0.0013291210634633899, -0.0035668290220201015, 0.010385151952505112, 0.01618991792201996, -0.005586436949670315, -0.03701534867286682, 0.02579606883227825, 0.0009600532939657569, -0.04831811413168907, 0.022785363718867302, 0.04256588965654373, -0.006066519767045975, 0.022972941398620605, -0.013041941449046135, 0.12673865258693695, 0.09504073113203049, -0.06398215889930725, -0.017639359459280968, -0.01391449011862278, 0.0331149585545063, 0.004685134161263704, 0.017813287675380707, -0.01802486553788185, -0.0011604276951402426, 0.00008381262159673497, 0.020478708669543266, -0.01480991579592228, 0.08824854344129562, -0.048507556319236755, 0.01999952830374241, 0.08007439970970154, -0.03233131021261215, 0.04536876082420349, -0.018032386898994446, -0.004930374678224325, 0.04580880329012871, -0.01605553738772869, -0.04136842489242554, -0.009220588952302933, -0.012667248025536537, 0.033742137253284454, -0.006382802035659552, -0.016784582287073135, 0.027346670627593994, -0.03533553704619408, -0.059070758521556854, -0.032239947468042374, 0.07584705203771591, 0.04964883252978325, 0.038241852074861526, 0.03144422546029091, -0.005093734245747328, -0.027430564165115356, -0.038473453372716904, -0.09867000579833984, -0.039900947362184525, -0.00810304470360279, 0.053307678550481796, -0.004110666457563639, 0.01334268320351839, 0.022611169144511223, 0.013939308002591133, -0.019762875512242317, -0.004887439776211977, 0.005429696291685104, 0.04271581023931503, 0.029936466366052628, -0.013612264767289162, -0.00835162028670311, 0.022544333711266518, 0.05210155248641968, 0.017252344638109207, -0.02469189278781414, -0.00819147564470768, -0.04508398473262787, -0.002638476202264428, 0.008753550238907337, -0.014942077919840813, -0.01332294475287199, -0.005033746361732483, 0.0326676070690155, -0.015749279409646988, 0.034206558018922806, 0.0025468231178820133, 0.05391562730073929, 0.04334918409585953, -0.020070698112249374, -0.043001167476177216, 0.039814069867134094, -0.01643769070506096, 0.0063198767602443695, 0.009679769165813923, 0.004452612716704607, -0.044755011796951294, 0.016738830134272575, 0.025131186470389366, -0.001816821750253439, -0.2464248389005661, -0.018592655658721924, 0.018498655408620834, 0.005422155372798443, 0.03797571361064911, -0.028188137337565422, 0.034244779497385025, -0.024975525215268135, -0.02739502117037773, 0.015684660524129868, 0.018453767523169518, 0.024069664999842644, -0.0009518438600935042, 0.06297796964645386, 0.04436499997973442, 0.018514689058065414, 0.021784057840704918, -0.005739235784858465, -0.0063134231604635715, 0.02612653374671936, -0.054828792810440063, -0.06795980036258698, 0.010783910751342773, 0.052814893424510956, -0.027056263759732246, 0.02502933330833912, -0.04309960454702377, -0.019656149670481682, -0.037701915949583054, -0.029618656262755394, -0.01605517975986004, -0.04501064866781235, 0.007053568493574858, 0.051744312047958374, 0.00216952757909894, 0.0022274984512478113, 0.05159591883420944, -0.0174106378108263, 0.03469977527856827, 0.024412235245108604, -0.01676628738641739, 0.006163070909678936, -0.013264431618154049, 0.04938487708568573, 0.064772829413414, -0.0195295512676239, -0.06928950548171997, 0.015477443113923073, -0.02687709964811802, 0.04249100759625435, 0.028900137171149254, -0.013455984182655811, -0.03693144768476486, 0.005427015013992786, -0.024200521409511566, -0.06530826538801193, -0.010658449493348598, -0.00856438186019659, 0.00922467838972807, -0.0036098777782171965, -0.03997541964054108, -0.04928289353847504, -0.035712894052267075, -0.012922579422593117, 0.023531263694167137, -0.006973422132432461, -0.05654565244913101, -0.07387675344944, 0.00559017900377512, 0.0511850044131279, 0.011924199759960175, -0.002223955001682043, -0.013101176358759403, -0.09481441974639893, 0.04006810113787651, -0.00030718123889528215, 0.007426666561514139, -0.05825250595808029, -0.01851990818977356, 0.04175836220383644, -0.013249124400317669, -0.03504267707467079, 0.03554724156856537, 0.014616914093494415, 0.011435347609221935, -0.03914131224155426, 0.01843860372900963, -0.05237540602684021, 0.010028264485299587, -0.037945229560136795, 0.06855656951665878, 0.0031988809350878, 0.03007785975933075, -0.013882801868021488, 0.01916203834116459, 0.025589648634195328, 0.05894556641578674, 0.04246217757463455, -0.008097766898572445, -0.020339038223028183, 0.035116128623485565, -0.0681493952870369, -0.020962556824088097, -0.04561302810907364, -0.04161721095442772, 0.016397953033447266, -0.015293030068278313, -0.00601405231282115, 0.03469383344054222, -0.004611784126609564, -0.013234208337962627, -0.03178573399782181, 0.003972665872424841, -0.015049395151436329, 0.0027885569725185633, -0.026165684685111046, 0.008609394542872906, 0.0022336163092404604, 0.06333979219198227, -0.017145400866866112, -0.04127516224980354, 0.04153174161911011, -0.029105162248015404, 0.024533603340387344, 0.0028258920647203922, -0.00021143622871022671, -0.021700752899050713, -0.010044507682323456, -0.028910338878631592, 0.018059255555272102, 0.028384147211909294, 0.06298098713159561, 0.013615362346172333, 0.054843902587890625, 0.04486425593495369, -0.000028441574613680132, 0.0012615633895620704, -0.002156386384740472, 0.02273528277873993, 0.004099761135876179, 0.022616522386670113, 0.04648091271519661, 0.052898768335580826, 0.006982498336583376, 0.033900849521160126, 0.024218402802944183, 0.027658933773636818, -0.01514872070401907, -0.011781296692788601, -0.00716969883069396, 0.024321122094988823, -0.04847949743270874, -0.07799646258354187, -0.03769852966070175, -0.0021546066273003817, -0.027690615504980087, 0.007569937966763973, -0.02574126422405243, -0.004193779546767473, -0.04763109236955643, 0.03320697322487831, 0.03457792475819588, -0.03842941299080849, -0.00039860891411080956, 0.017432481050491333, 0.0127417529001832, 0.03162691369652748, -0.029143212363123894, 0.01650887541472912, 0.010795963928103447, -0.008359886705875397, -0.023532584309577942, -0.024566903710365295, -0.07840493321418762, -0.018197394907474518, 0.014988885261118412, -0.015174049884080887, -0.00934544950723648, -0.07213935256004333, 0.024001002311706543, 0.01118953712284565, -0.0022396263666450977, 0.013780687935650349, 0.0025924083311110735, 0.0934465229511261, -0.004596011713147163, -0.04148280620574951, -0.04097704961895943, -0.011654471047222614, 0.05583294481039047, -0.0014446181012317538, 0.01426899153739214, -0.047647733241319656, -0.03565585985779762, -0.004135351162403822, -0.04101994261145592, -0.00728191202506423, 0.055489081889390945, 0.0009312704205513, -0.02707493305206299, -0.014119765721261501, 0.02289298176765442, -0.023899750784039497, 0.008942585438489914, 0.019392160698771477, -0.060027044266462326, 0.04615913704037666, 0.0771048292517662, -0.056587040424346924, 0.014382471330463886, -0.014783162623643875, -0.05488213151693344, -0.05815639719367027, -0.06554698944091797, -0.02182287536561489, 0.0007033493602648377, -0.027121147140860558, -0.021914027631282806, 0.013887960463762283, -0.031723424792289734, 0.04394248127937317, 0.02259393036365509, -0.03855288773775101, -0.02070343866944313, 0.016908472403883934, 0.03159233555197716, -0.04135672375559807, 0.016286106780171394, 0.003759911051020026, 0.0005106095923110843, -0.004748877603560686, -0.030231213197112083, 0.03062027134001255, 0.03147261217236519, -0.011049920693039894, 0.03964828699827194, -0.06795759499073029, 0.02941153571009636, -0.019997725263237953, 0.00013552888412959874, -0.02203572727739811, -0.01180266123265028, -0.047552336007356644, -0.004794668406248093, 0.032632071524858475, 0.042358893901109695, -0.020188048481941223, -0.007850270718336105, 0.005079871043562889, 0.03560393303632736, 0.026429908350110054, 0.008492420427501202, -0.03860902413725853, -0.017899470403790474, 0.05228329449892044, -0.01837380789220333, 0.017154501751065254, -0.06820565462112427, -0.0187519621104002, 0.03256431594491005, -0.013215409591794014, 0.016311239451169968, -0.017107611522078514, 0.019886434078216553, 0.04422140121459961, 0.027843324467539787, -0.010097232647240162, -0.023960746824741364, 0.03244145214557648, -0.047970857471227646, 0.036093682050704956, -0.04067716747522354, -0.021235864609479904, 0.04506894201040268, -0.04704016074538231, 0.03271956741809845, 0.027452079579234123, -0.014235381036996841, 0.045242443680763245, -0.05952302739024162, -0.03421556204557419, 0.004235020373016596, -0.041150324046611786, 0.024245496839284897, 0.026313992217183113, -0.0441766157746315, 0.015511766076087952, -0.03926698490977287, -0.04449845477938652, 0.00566601799800992, 0.002778016496449709, 0.008978272788226604, 0.0017053333576768637, 0.02446548268198967, -0.017734525725245476, 0.03645390272140503, 0.03436855226755142, 0.04279991611838341, -0.0040861451998353004, 0.020881421864032745, -0.03353595361113548, 0.08137308806180954, 0.04241545498371124, 0.003009306499734521, 0.0022954274900257587, 0.019923314452171326, 0.0057761892676353455, -0.04082408919930458, 0.02690974250435829, 0.0025196156930178404, -0.02454880066215992, -0.05567760020494461, 0.010404990054666996, 0.012659386731684208, -0.03659281134605408, -0.005410101264715195, 0.04959116876125336, -0.05055642127990723, 0.004927410278469324, 0.0007263691513799131, -0.012861284427344799, 0.03926657885313034, 0.059999559074640274, 0.0006048766081221402, 0.022625574842095375, 0.03386486694216728, 0.05286101996898651, 0.011833746917545795, 0.004319644533097744, 0.07881679385900497, 0.08005822449922562, 0.01984892226755619, -0.009293519891798496, 0.08040165901184082, -0.037788715213537216, -0.0254233218729496, 0.04001760855317116, -0.018283763900399208, -0.04356309771537781, -0.09694205224514008, 0.02552136965095997, 0.10695651918649673, 0.06541202962398529, 0.04923836886882782, -0.051688309758901596, -0.013713983818888664, 0.018022295087575912, -0.009342958219349384, -0.012273686937987804, 0.026085518300533295, 0.03307940810918808, -0.018868302926421165, -0.006013080477714539, -0.011310606263577938, -0.021417172625660896, -0.03377116844058037, 0.013246352784335613, 0.014117850922048092, -0.007109192665666342, -0.014155345037579536, 0.027556030079722404, 0.03474671393632889, 0.07962887734174728, -0.029932888224720955, -0.03289029747247696, 0.024018198251724243, 0.010128487832844257, 0.025898849591612816, 0.06762775033712387, 0.012422359548509121, -0.004994372837245464, 0.009889407083392143, -0.020204927772283554, 0.0036938206758350134, 0.030858881771564484, -0.00874335877597332, 0.02035847306251526, -0.02814580500125885, -0.021445084363222122, 0.026969164609909058, -0.011067686602473259, -0.06429325044155121, -0.0359322763979435, -0.029952945187687874, -0.061810243874788284, -0.037855759263038635, -0.0646812841296196, 0.010667748749256134, -0.003150240983814001, -0.03913532570004463, -0.008841167204082012, -0.012273525819182396, 0.0011727266246452928, 0.03323467820882797, -0.05736487731337547, 0.035971250385046005, 0.051292434334754944, -0.02378659136593342, -0.024276215583086014, 0.026913423091173172, 0.03068963997066021, -0.015071619302034378, -0.022221479564905167, 0.0070592546835541725, -0.010235358960926533, 0.04821132495999336, -0.03564492613077164, -0.006978154648095369, -0.08517894148826599, 0.030450625345110893, 0.04164014384150505, -0.04146673157811165, -0.0701771154999733, 0.0687718391418457, -0.03332766890525818, 0.05221955105662346, 0.052562810480594635, -0.008045726455748081, 0.008245701901614666, -0.058736275881528854, -0.021904317662119865, -0.036993835121393204, 0.0032402141951024532, 0.04632040485739708, 0.005521092563867569, 0.055788442492485046, 0.04531930014491081, 0.021659111604094505, 0.004735459573566914, 0.026877857744693756, -0.03981650993227959, 0.01473667286336422, -0.00965272169560194, -0.008633350022137165, -0.04404100775718689, -0.10877640545368195, -0.014120799489319324, 0.02689477428793907, -0.0037531449925154448, -0.05016369745135307, -0.021921144798398018, 0.005060799885541201, 0.011175817809998989, -0.004551984835416079, 0.02862473390996456, 0.0016552603337913752, -0.06510932743549347, -0.04176948964595795, -0.04726492613554001, -0.020309433341026306, -0.022537175565958023, 0.011771601624786854, 0.004087638109922409, -0.050069890916347504, -0.04413587972521782, -0.03045533411204815, 0.03134353831410408, 0.0017517582746222615, 0.007071345113217831, -0.011964927427470684 ]
3,572
Learning to Solve Differential Equation Constrained Optimization Problems
https://openreview.net/forum?id=VeMC6Bn0ZB
[ "Vincenzo Di Vito Francesco", "Mostafa Mohammadian", "Kyri Baker", "Ferdinando Fioretto" ]
Spotlight
Differential equations (DE) constrained optimization plays a critical role in numerous scientific and engineering fields, including energy systems, aerospace engineering, ecology, and finance, where optimal configurations or control strategies must be determined for systems governed by ordinary or stochastic differential equations. Despite its significance, the computational challenges associated with these problems have limited their practical use. To address these limitations, this paper introduces a learning-based approach to DE-constrained optimization that combines techniques from proxy optimization \citep{kotary2021end} and neural differential equations \citep{chen2019neural}. The proposed approach uses a dual-network architecture, with one approximating the control strategies, focusing on steady-state constraints, and another solving the associated DEs. This combination enables the approximation of optimal strategies while accounting for dynamic constraints in near real-time. Experiments across problems in energy optimization and finance modeling show that this method provides full compliance with dynamic constraints and it produces results up to 25 times more precise than other methods which do not explicitly model the system's dynamic equations.
Learning-based optimization proxy, differential equations constrained optimization, neural differential equations, system dynamics
null
4,668
2410.01786
[ -0.039674874395132065, 0.0034057709854096174, -0.02195623703300953, 0.057579606771469116, 0.06266272813081741, 0.02662365511059761, 0.005947839468717575, -0.004059363156557083, -0.02471810206770897, -0.031579095870256424, 0.013544140383601189, 0.032186418771743774, -0.046296581625938416, 0.008871306665241718, 0.010557440109550953, 0.048290133476257324, 0.005594473332166672, -0.01068187691271305, -0.007025204598903656, 0.034593261778354645, 0.008859718218445778, -0.04625760018825531, 0.040688373148441315, 0.036754392087459564, 0.010650267824530602, 0.01803058758378029, 0.01167241856455803, 0.0014597331173717976, -0.012097902595996857, 0.01651611551642418, 0.01694944128394127, 0.029443852603435516, 0.0009323945851065218, -0.020600616931915283, -0.02704247459769249, 0.023455681279301643, -0.005705160554498434, -0.018206719309091568, -0.020366720855236053, 0.006724350154399872, -0.06131508946418762, 0.0008667079964652658, -0.02042989619076252, 0.013973776251077652, -0.057291917502880096, 0.019170254468917847, -0.05624280497431755, -0.011695997789502144, -0.0025621510576456785, -0.06496970355510712, -0.11450565606355667, 0.02455630712211132, 0.03594809025526047, -0.02167513594031334, -0.03068637102842331, 0.041249390691518784, 0.016940709203481674, -0.055101051926612854, -0.03139814734458923, -0.07956495881080627, 0.01709182746708393, 0.04426564648747444, -0.003799483412876725, -0.0019290329655632377, 0.012428270652890205, 0.0017067462904378772, 0.016097748652100563, 0.031670987606048584, -0.05828488618135452, 0.0014342895010486245, -0.03819095715880394, -0.0025596923660486937, 0.021945128217339516, 0.01605234108865261, -0.0016040434129536152, -0.028840458020567894, 0.02112732268869877, 0.00033920127316378057, 0.052684035152196884, 0.04144994542002678, 0.020210305228829384, 0.02850399538874626, 0.020165394991636276, 0.001487554283812642, 0.00835095252841711, -0.003999514039605856, -0.04850030317902565, -0.007171595469117165, -0.0557771697640419, 0.06178785488009453, -0.035091158002614975, -0.060599491000175476, -0.0012068217620253563, 0.06108180806040764, 0.03434302657842636, 0.009389631450176239, 0.04591469466686249, 0.007853765040636063, 0.013390924781560898, 0.015994250774383545, 0.008651484735310078, -0.0394706055521965, 0.00504002021625638, -0.010366308502852917, -0.0802675262093544, -0.050882913172245026, -0.026631571352481842, -0.00852346234023571, -0.001796271069906652, -0.018144313246011734, -0.03111771121621132, 0.007726556621491909, -0.003827685723081231, -0.038478802889585495, -0.07436811923980713, 0.04204052314162254, 0.0014674888225272298, 0.024738764390349388, 0.007722345180809498, -0.0007869421388022602, 0.036095842719078064, 0.0325191468000412, -0.007532124873250723, 0.05208510532975197, 0.01705915480852127, 0.028344618156552315, 0.051806945353746414, 0.01976567693054676, -0.04587316885590553, -0.05060867965221405, 0.009934633038938046, 0.03894574195146561, 0.0021537605207413435, -0.025033770129084587, -0.012571115046739578, -0.02710234373807907, 0.016978206112980843, 0.035863831639289856, 0.01610277034342289, 0.041153840720653534, -0.03306404873728752, -0.03900335356593132, 0.042531516402959824, -0.028374576941132545, 0.03751346468925476, -0.009374801069498062, 0.05759682506322861, -0.0437973253428936, -0.020671270787715912, 0.01126530859619379, 0.008065298199653625, -0.014194939285516739, -0.032998375594615936, -0.05817428603768349, 0.016491685062646866, 0.04932298883795738, 0.015126749873161316, 0.02531088888645172, -0.02700173854827881, 0.014127565547823906, 0.030026141554117203, -0.004368573892861605, 0.004056709352880716, 0.014124508015811443, 0.0031642010435462, -0.07309107482433319, 0.07824892550706863, 0.051758404821157455, -0.031666383147239685, -0.04567854478955269, -0.027953539043664932, -0.02755589410662651, 0.04546026512980461, -0.012855582870543003, 0.020425895228981972, -0.0024607456289231777, 0.04188713803887367, -0.024387840181589127, 0.054992806166410446, 0.004830377642065287, -0.08514589071273804, 0.037488218396902084, 0.062358055263757706, -0.022096332162618637, 0.018320001661777496, -0.024757282808423042, 0.0769079327583313, -0.02799108438193798, 0.03257818892598152, 0.03827084228396416, -0.0722067579627037, -0.035211093723773956, 0.03341037407517433, -0.031136902049183846, 0.03249318152666092, -0.00030541972955688834, -0.01790955662727356, 0.0436733104288578, -0.002267084550112486, 0.06155424937605858, 0.05481565743684769, -0.05840076133608818, 0.0521572083234787, -0.003372705075889826, -0.01477853674441576, -0.03391215577721596, 0.049682144075632095, -0.04309014603495598, 0.009628789499402046, 0.01734766736626625, -0.03750351443886757, -0.0322122797369957, 0.0018067543860524893, -0.005856064148247242, 0.03803131356835365, -0.01672697812318802, -0.053189367055892944, 0.03717202693223953, 0.028548484668135643, -0.017719389870762825, 0.050949182361364365, 0.047426458448171616, -0.022105680778622627, 0.04238530248403549, -0.04782407730817795, 0.09986668080091476, 0.0892971009016037, -0.0375259630382061, -0.007584202568978071, 0.021073900163173676, 0.02903253212571144, 0.017965493723750114, 0.02229677140712738, -0.03466946259140968, 0.02514304220676422, 0.026257140561938286, -0.043016787618398666, -0.021939964964985847, 0.10052980482578278, -0.04681341350078583, 0.012771764770150185, 0.08345047384500504, -0.07709850370883942, 0.064573734998703, -0.015728769823908806, 0.01485868263989687, 0.05829107388854027, 0.010637512430548668, -0.05250236392021179, -0.027903718873858452, -0.03450687974691391, 0.018966248258948326, 0.01102545764297247, 0.014703773893415928, 0.03104027360677719, -0.06914947181940079, -0.03875066712498665, 0.004075751174241304, 0.06318393349647522, 0.04280766472220421, 0.008095244877040386, 0.018311507999897003, 0.02534598857164383, -0.0007282041478902102, -0.029333285987377167, -0.11484810709953308, -0.0507938452064991, -0.017681702971458435, 0.034543346613645554, 0.011320826597511768, 0.041050639003515244, -0.029800839722156525, 0.04825805872678757, -0.014964725822210312, -0.0390036441385746, -0.007644811179488897, 0.013688493520021439, 0.012334344908595085, -0.03427591547369957, -0.030498875305056572, 0.028314080089330673, 0.08514291048049927, -0.0005483297863975167, -0.034510113298892975, -0.02276488207280636, -0.043569013476371765, -0.01586865447461605, -0.010842890478670597, 0.0012098602019250393, 0.006477663293480873, -0.006494008004665375, -0.02830633521080017, -0.06296814233064651, 0.05080833286046982, 0.009884290397167206, 0.02769211120903492, 0.04420049116015434, 0.0367659293115139, 0.0108308345079422, 0.006194090470671654, -0.0031065542716532946, 0.009346771985292435, -0.028120508417487144, 0.02349061705172062, -0.012655201368033886, 0.013511311262845993, 0.027434958145022392, 0.003278869204223156, -0.2552993893623352, -0.04075305536389351, 0.009425108321011066, 0.011578903533518314, 0.05369877442717552, -0.006450554821640253, 0.04679333418607712, -0.04044951871037483, -0.0177162978798151, -0.003968923352658749, -0.002024661283940077, 0.016077935695648193, 0.0011258360464125872, 0.05807116627693176, 0.03076646290719509, 0.020856264978647232, 0.027787432074546814, -0.04134279116988182, -0.03272952884435654, 0.009900448843836784, -0.03929436579346657, -0.07078579813241959, -0.03700444847345352, 0.027735119685530663, 0.00911374669522047, 0.01760544441640377, -0.06053982675075531, -0.03088279813528061, -0.05085058882832527, -0.001769629423506558, -0.046585291624069214, -0.010647007264196873, -0.029701465740799904, 0.04576410353183746, 0.02107696793973446, 0.020857593044638634, 0.021609878167510033, -0.002437931951135397, 0.033604156225919724, 0.0429442934691906, -0.011406626552343369, -0.021721728146076202, -0.02710261009633541, -0.02069821022450924, 0.021635254845023155, 0.04139317572116852, -0.029215950518846512, -0.013391202315688133, 0.019837936386466026, 0.052480801939964294, 0.02432030253112316, -0.016886811703443527, 0.023999322205781937, -0.014679670333862305, 0.036050453782081604, -0.012166940607130527, 0.010082950815558434, -0.033518970012664795, 0.01905008777976036, 0.03363938629627228, 0.02352369949221611, -0.02265212871134281, -0.02626177854835987, -0.021048594266176224, -0.00921823363751173, -0.033802323043346405, -0.06468252092599869, -0.08545880764722824, 0.03272731602191925, 0.044578369706869125, 0.016837267205119133, -0.0031858538277447224, -0.020489659160375595, -0.10217129439115524, 0.028084194287657738, -0.02617470733821392, 0.01877307891845703, -0.027637002989649773, 0.016562610864639282, 0.024996861815452576, -0.019981037825345993, -0.023053638637065887, 0.008942963555455208, 0.021202068775892258, 0.0034363053273409605, -0.021187318488955498, 0.006549352779984474, -0.026136275380849838, 0.01432811003178358, -0.02264983579516411, 0.013690963387489319, -0.027300886809825897, 0.07044879347085953, -0.028304506093263626, 0.06621025502681732, 0.04550318047404289, 0.018149495124816895, 0.01167251355946064, 0.04289667680859566, -0.029961442574858665, 0.009422538802027702, -0.045523300766944885, -0.010588369332253933, -0.05106378346681595, 0.00454357685521245, 0.008119184523820877, -0.056510694324970245, -0.004656557459384203, 0.03315870836377144, -0.001256978721357882, 0.0014390283031389117, -0.04762530326843262, -0.022391729056835175, -0.029722323641180992, -0.05387638509273529, -0.015530825592577457, -0.01127853523939848, 0.05128999426960945, 0.028371555730700493, -0.012371592223644257, -0.03656618669629097, 0.07884139567613602, 0.003914480097591877, -0.0021803127601742744, -0.02316982112824917, 0.0032737220171839, -0.00044777648872695863, -0.02440156228840351, 0.006776480004191399, -0.015111320652067661, 0.04493482783436775, 0.04769982397556305, 0.01856253482401371, 0.04196091741323471, 0.02498582936823368, 0.01017745304852724, -0.017636476084589958, -0.02477523870766163, 0.051401033997535706, 0.02523731254041195, 0.0003277593641541898, 0.028367849066853523, 0.03752735257148743, -0.019424036145210266, 0.07118279486894608, 0.05477346107363701, 0.01378871314227581, 0.008151267655193806, 0.004917479585856199, -0.0075607444159686565, 0.011841507628560066, -0.014724146574735641, 0.0009755149367265403, -0.04611038416624069, 0.01923912577331066, -0.01996195875108242, 0.0604887381196022, -0.018200485035777092, 0.03469707816839218, -0.04935995861887932, 0.05539185553789139, 0.016382096335291862, -0.023347867652773857, 0.01878880150616169, -0.012460577301681042, 0.08892073482275009, -0.009165724739432335, -0.015009776689112186, -0.004516878630965948, -0.020332040265202522, 0.04541310295462608, -0.010191736742854118, -0.07573477923870087, -0.01628694497048855, -0.007944331504404545, -0.03505077585577965, 0.030063563957810402, -0.04756942018866539, -0.023432685062289238, 0.00951120164245367, -0.00040225687553174794, -0.03700065240263939, -0.031323350965976715, 0.01519958209246397, 0.04389429837465286, -0.011657699011266232, -0.006443960126489401, -0.0017580949934199452, -0.024541091173887253, 0.01774839125573635, -0.0034160406794399023, 0.004227056168019772, -0.03545524924993515, -0.04347112402319908, 0.02472136728465557, -0.047024667263031006, 0.0007194901118054986, 0.04066431522369385, -0.018331700935959816, 0.034236129373311996, -0.025535928085446358, -0.01777065545320511, -0.041909653693437576, 0.020098015666007996, 0.006132764741778374, -0.06998841464519501, 0.00945326592773199, 0.029301973059773445, 0.02008160389959812, 0.010944209061563015, -0.013722793199121952, -0.05349612981081009, -0.08393454551696777, 0.0041877394542098045, 0.020327692851424217, -0.017883392050862312, -0.01887674815952778, -0.012119682505726814, 0.0054938700050115585, 0.016454951837658882, 0.033503226935863495, 0.022450637072324753, -0.024371154606342316, -0.04533929377794266, -0.023675041273236275, 0.03919592872262001, -0.0406019352376461, -0.00454098591580987, -0.010447973385453224, 0.010066251270473003, -0.002808015327900648, -0.013474728912115097, -0.01238337904214859, 0.029827188700437546, 0.028969191014766693, 0.023818576708436012, -0.05119338259100914, 0.03605065122246742, -0.0586543008685112, -0.03419477120041847, -0.01107786688953638, -0.0070058791898190975, -0.030109265819191933, -0.025683004409074783, -0.018224617466330528, 0.05040293186903, 0.02288302220404148, -0.010921193286776543, -0.011893097311258316, 0.0001855995215009898, 0.013987538404762745, 0.0009491718374192715, -0.07495612651109695, 0.023845568299293518, 0.04237541928887367, 0.0002035787474596873, -0.03287385031580925, -0.06813687831163406, 0.010650639422237873, 0.022457413375377655, -0.03581527993083, 0.03260554000735283, -0.04927396774291992, 0.041250079870224, 0.01959439553320408, 0.04583592712879181, 0.0017075545620173216, -0.02257566899061203, 0.056587956845760345, -0.05853154882788658, -0.020737672224640846, -0.05136291682720184, -0.004254133440554142, 0.06612087041139603, -0.0034576815087348223, 0.030160600319504738, 0.02207070216536522, -0.00801217183470726, 0.04885518178343773, -0.039794377982616425, -0.07411566376686096, -0.008969307877123356, -0.031794223934412, -0.010411424562335014, 0.020408913493156433, -0.019938012585043907, -0.028853638097643852, 0.012986079789698124, -0.0497266948223114, -0.02082751877605915, 0.023738127201795578, -0.0025954123120754957, -0.0014391227159649134, -0.029384756460785866, -0.028698716312646866, 0.014732780866324902, 0.04508417844772339, 0.028668487444519997, 0.0032292010728269815, -0.017175251618027687, -0.06587051600217819, 0.0502273328602314, 0.01736331917345524, 0.038731396198272705, -0.005876279901713133, 0.013098611496388912, 0.007176980376243591, -0.02644033543765545, 0.02789635956287384, -0.004130430053919554, 0.018598610535264015, -0.04624238610267639, 0.009466901421546936, 0.018710345029830933, -0.018276721239089966, -0.017330704256892204, -0.014552267268300056, -0.042934924364089966, -0.009035096503794193, 0.03006167896091938, 0.019472716376185417, 0.020782316103577614, 0.07024187594652176, -0.023748992010951042, 0.03554564714431763, 0.05799492448568344, 0.021951749920845032, 0.006451994180679321, 0.005152195692062378, 0.06793355196714401, 0.04544439539313316, 0.033901289105415344, -0.0031535278540104628, 0.07253704220056534, -0.032509662210941315, -0.04806744307279587, 0.002718542004004121, -0.006340698804706335, -0.02318429760634899, -0.045425690710544586, -0.013921347446739674, 0.08108767122030258, 0.05371297150850296, 0.06330379843711853, -0.03679633140563965, 0.018492761999368668, 0.011792771518230438, 0.02838784269988537, -0.028825461864471436, 0.010945235379040241, -0.031493525952100754, 0.021151024848222733, -0.011058795265853405, -0.04581630229949951, -0.01762216165661812, -0.01934686489403248, 0.025078166276216507, 0.004352644085884094, 0.01663685217499733, -0.006454758811742067, 0.032622162252664566, 0.01225399412214756, 0.08174291253089905, -0.08196772634983063, -0.010089213028550148, -0.004633749835193157, 0.02803390473127365, -0.02114066854119301, 0.03159564733505249, 0.029511820524930954, -0.02305235154926777, -0.022114085033535957, -0.04680104926228523, 0.03237149864435196, 0.015689939260482788, 0.0005676720174960792, 0.006108551751822233, -0.04486069828271866, 0.03501032665371895, 0.0158284492790699, 0.01061010267585516, -0.011015738360583782, -0.08364174515008926, -0.013266311958432198, -0.04062271863222122, -0.050693340599536896, -0.05371326580643654, 0.050367482006549835, 0.021487964317202568, -0.037011709064245224, 0.014321385882794857, -0.007563823368400335, -0.0015942471800372005, 0.01750657707452774, -0.05465337261557579, -0.0010515744797885418, 0.03804410248994827, -0.009610103443264961, 0.023266823962330818, 0.025683369487524033, 0.036024775356054306, -0.00851401686668396, -0.023955287411808968, 0.044792983680963516, 0.009165397845208645, 0.008945651352405548, -0.026342973113059998, 0.008540485985577106, -0.07135210186243057, -0.019599786028265953, 0.028776656836271286, -0.065754733979702, -0.0694834366440773, 0.06843715906143188, -0.027147850021719933, 0.045136354863643646, 0.03156707063317299, -0.04825460910797119, 0.03358535096049309, -0.02726171165704727, -0.026783600449562073, -0.0039038038812577724, 0.009018942713737488, 0.012651439756155014, -0.019957035779953003, 0.06265073269605637, 0.03478766605257988, -0.017485102638602257, -0.032515496015548706, 0.03560107946395874, -0.0007535666809417307, 0.010749474167823792, -0.04941534996032715, 0.00943746604025364, -0.04229971393942833, -0.09017510712146759, -0.05159039795398712, 0.028898751363158226, -0.04222423955798149, -0.04834597930312157, 0.003140608547255397, 0.031952809542417526, 0.01892343908548355, 0.014665398746728897, -0.04081670194864273, -0.04064532741904259, -0.03244783729314804, -0.028147689998149872, -0.03143462911248207, 0.03644930571317673, 0.04315439239144325, -0.0074942284263670444, -0.055405907332897186, -0.043151695281267166, -0.04493672028183937, -0.04460383206605911, 0.028712306171655655, 0.011904320679605007, 0.011429556645452976, 0.00019979107310064137 ]
3,573
Fast Uncovering of Protein Sequence Diversity from Structure
https://openreview.net/forum?id=1iuaxjssVp
[ "luca alessandro silva", "Barthelemy Meynard-Piganeau", "Carlo Lucibello", "Christoph Feinauer" ]
Spotlight
We present InvMSAFold, an inverse folding method for generating protein sequences optimized for diversity and speed. For a given structure, InvMSAFold generates the parameters of a pairwise probability distribution over the space of sequences, capturing the amino acid covariances observed in Multiple Sequence Alignments (MSA) of homologous proteins. This allows for the efficient generation of highly diverse protein sequences while preserving structural and functional integrity. We demonstrate that this increased diversity in sampled sequences translates into greater variability in biochemical properties, highlighting the exciting potential of our method for applications such as protein design. The orders of magnitude improvement in sampling speed compared to existing methods unlocks new possibilities for high-throughput in virtual screening.
Protein design, inverse folding, generative modelling, transfer learning
null
4,663
null
[ -0.017976578325033188, -0.03114769421517849, -0.014109211973845959, 0.021625587716698647, 0.0341162271797657, 0.0040433150716125965, 0.03672908991575241, 0.004855782259255648, -0.00561479153111577, -0.04768473654985428, 0.022848650813102722, 0.0056226528249681, -0.06263375282287598, 0.009260322898626328, 0.015380316413939, 0.06334789842367172, 0.01117470022290945, -0.0032556182704865932, 0.030165348201990128, 0.02649235911667347, -0.046242646872997284, -0.014736613258719444, 0.04651891440153122, 0.021377794444561005, 0.03142682462930679, 0.015568897128105164, -0.015669282525777817, -0.002666295738890767, -0.051117561757564545, -0.02427048049867153, 0.012902394868433475, -0.03116128034889698, 0.029355047270655632, -0.0363292470574379, 0.019406534731388092, -0.034062132239341736, -0.06601595878601074, 0.0316111259162426, -0.003576708724722266, 0.012494780123233795, -0.01718883030116558, -0.01793782413005829, -0.00851255189627409, 0.017241591587662697, -0.03796732425689697, 0.0303465835750103, -0.055103931576013565, 0.043409205973148346, -0.02769140899181366, -0.004971126560121775, -0.057185202836990356, 0.03986681252717972, 0.010468197986483574, -0.023355448618531227, 0.012951829470694065, 0.028808820992708206, 0.03691130504012108, -0.03531818836927414, -0.012577163055539131, -0.06788401305675507, -0.0504789762198925, -0.03656617924571037, 0.016447147354483604, 0.04798115789890289, 0.01932208053767681, 0.0070666358806192875, -0.003346338402479887, 0.02988732047379017, -0.04118140786886215, -0.01185633521527052, -0.03995034843683243, -0.02710113674402237, 0.0022869480308145285, -0.00918319821357727, 0.04671786352992058, -0.04254116490483284, 0.001778345089405775, 0.030164428055286407, 0.07155998796224594, 0.006750736851245165, -0.008881359361112118, 0.017377719283103943, -0.00532926619052887, 0.04142189770936966, -0.002164227655157447, -0.003765443107113242, -0.07129416614770889, 0.004747878294438124, -0.06108839437365532, 0.06521706283092499, -0.018818270415067673, -0.05584593489766121, 0.05899649113416672, 0.02528643049299717, 0.07023267447948456, -0.02185884676873684, 0.014109576120972633, 0.02704913727939129, -0.009628393687307835, 0.01951589062809944, -0.05007974058389664, -0.030034441500902176, -0.009413107298314571, -0.028404267504811287, -0.10783781856298447, -0.03919929265975952, -0.04169140011072159, -0.00043363997247070074, 0.005391627550125122, 0.01651984453201294, -0.05468875542283058, 0.0001359307352686301, -0.005120484158396721, 0.013715555891394615, -0.08944596350193024, 0.062019430100917816, 0.026248052716255188, 0.015189710073173046, -0.02571818046271801, -0.026338189840316772, 0.04037486016750336, 0.08136879652738571, 0.010446707718074322, 0.08741824328899384, 0.022710181772708893, 0.00736313546076417, -0.0325438492000103, 0.03332732617855072, -0.03749097138643265, -0.02772892452776432, 0.0012328890152275562, 0.049510013312101364, -0.0011710632825270295, 0.0033773668110370636, -0.015421085990965366, -0.011255553923547268, -0.011941817589104176, 0.009080614894628525, 0.047960396856069565, -0.02467213198542595, -0.004872491117566824, -0.006739554926753044, 0.021206794306635857, -0.03888186812400818, 0.03550935536623001, -0.00520342355594039, -0.037967365235090256, -0.03242427110671997, -0.02949456311762333, 0.01380758173763752, 0.01962827332317829, -0.02245895005762577, -0.0075179822742938995, -0.0380493625998497, 0.026746047660708427, 0.11339182406663895, 0.0257194172590971, 0.019947689026594162, 0.03043069876730442, 0.0073755583725869656, 0.010077614337205887, 0.0182639192789793, -0.055593185126781464, 0.0177749115973711, 0.014345605857670307, -0.01191333495080471, 0.04602781683206558, 0.09183433651924133, -0.055978402495384216, 0.007173735648393631, -0.04013466089963913, -0.045191213488578796, 0.05102896690368652, -0.017828118056058884, -0.024503830820322037, -0.024895990267395973, 0.06854704767465591, 0.01550331711769104, 0.03952295705676079, 0.01055384986102581, -0.07566598057746887, 0.014102112501859665, 0.0022027280647307634, 0.0010632334742695093, -0.008775207214057446, -0.02440355345606804, 0.09688539057970047, 0.027282079681754112, 0.0019256442319601774, 0.01635489985346794, -0.06759943068027496, -0.06181930750608444, 0.02602890133857727, 0.001452363096177578, 0.07128551602363586, -0.014740313403308392, -0.0006743217818439007, 0.022085165604948997, -0.016467763110995293, 0.021636197343468666, -0.0135949132964015, 0.011294840835034847, 0.01482365746051073, -0.05228709429502487, -0.06309369951486588, -0.004837505519390106, 0.042006295174360275, -0.06610456109046936, -0.01513094361871481, -0.031225068494677544, 0.013554787263274193, -0.010675826109945774, -0.0034301583655178547, 0.007217708509415388, 0.045116666704416275, 0.01066355686634779, 0.0029483912512660027, -0.03466220572590828, 0.0003035878180526197, -0.06270372122526169, 0.03651035577058792, 0.01611420512199402, 0.02300758846104145, -0.014972847886383533, -0.03597201034426689, 0.11444034427404404, 0.05937502905726433, -0.05070050060749054, 0.031137697398662567, 0.049941886216402054, 0.029179751873016357, -0.018855014815926552, 0.020144125446677208, -0.0490986630320549, 0.014575042761862278, -0.011073515750467777, 0.019210467115044594, 0.005077173467725515, 0.07806579768657684, -0.05752209946513176, -0.005941078532487154, 0.05424201488494873, -0.04934297129511833, 0.029367057606577873, 0.0003428598865866661, -0.008280081674456596, 0.015071893110871315, -0.010446850210428238, -0.0636020079255104, -0.010065775364637375, 0.006364499684423208, 0.015742454677820206, 0.02142336592078209, -0.009970510378479958, -0.0005921118427067995, -0.05149684473872185, 0.009504668414592743, -0.022507723420858383, 0.06546477973461151, 0.06344763934612274, 0.006593194790184498, 0.018478170037269592, 0.02478339709341526, -0.007897445932030678, -0.02674953266978264, -0.09828581660985947, -0.028095316141843796, 0.006169273983687162, 0.04340064525604248, 0.044677734375, 0.06538887321949005, 0.032167863100767136, -0.04066002368927002, -0.002637050813063979, -0.026180719956755638, -0.05404678359627724, 0.022155627608299255, 0.0026363208889961243, -0.0680154338479042, -0.008307605050504208, 0.027003450319170952, 0.07107213139533997, -0.014771980233490467, -0.05165752023458481, -0.06189166009426117, -0.016171421855688095, -0.02091471664607525, -0.04002487286925316, -0.020541058853268623, 0.02927265502512455, 0.03015517070889473, 0.04190542548894882, -0.036826685070991516, -0.006898538209497929, 0.03370301425457001, 0.02363470382988453, 0.020427420735359192, 0.07249916344881058, -0.0024369421880692244, 0.016386879608035088, 0.038926780223846436, -0.013004996813833714, -0.03397096320986748, -0.017031770199537277, -0.013106029480695724, -0.007433036342263222, 0.03698214888572693, -0.03669752553105354, -0.2563033699989319, -0.038024064153432846, 0.002574092708528042, 0.00042241442133672535, 0.06767141073942184, -0.03793485462665558, 0.03646678477525711, -0.015354752540588379, -0.024630865082144737, 0.008909845724701881, 0.003144060494378209, 0.04511740803718567, -0.0063203503377735615, 0.010128323920071125, 0.032439377158880234, 0.037567026913166046, -0.01238618977367878, 0.00033008988248184323, 0.05520178750157356, 0.01341521181166172, -0.01221910584717989, -0.09126859158277512, 0.002218145178630948, 0.006080637685954571, -0.023318249732255936, 0.011210458353161812, -0.09008777141571045, 0.02262330800294876, -0.03355209156870842, 0.003640107112005353, -0.02734427899122238, -0.015938369557261467, -0.008123403415083885, -0.0034846453927457333, 0.007830746471881866, -0.016358954831957817, -0.009148280136287212, -0.013066014274954796, 0.015030675567686558, 0.046135786920785904, 0.01451806165277958, -0.036747366189956665, -0.03708428516983986, -0.00610559806227684, 0.05654476583003998, 0.03696337342262268, -0.0063103195279836655, -0.019324345514178276, -0.00744630815461278, 0.05160347744822502, -0.007750758435577154, -0.06318719685077667, -0.004550560377538204, 0.05265005677938461, 0.001993100857362151, -0.005188666749745607, 0.015937944874167442, 0.019497234374284744, -0.021625176072120667, 0.007663067430257797, 0.002052167896181345, -0.07149513810873032, -0.015267767943441868, -0.04566989466547966, -0.03095734491944313, -0.03666866570711136, -0.048205338418483734, -0.02632388472557068, 0.04370668902993202, 0.0413210429251194, -0.015657976269721985, 0.014191624708473682, -0.027647048234939575, -0.0880025252699852, 0.04700823873281479, 0.008075879886746407, -0.03322932496666908, -0.018815305083990097, -0.0011906278086826205, 0.022906862199306488, -0.021267307922244072, -0.0007549724541604519, -0.0018504475010558963, 0.03331249952316284, 0.032391760498285294, -0.048740386962890625, -0.014829241670668125, -0.030610021203756332, -0.014865254051983356, -0.04682670161128044, 0.015294492244720459, -0.005501639097929001, 0.04203356057405472, -0.011036081239581108, 0.04001569002866745, 0.01664607785642147, 0.004090368747711182, 0.06255987286567688, 0.04105040431022644, 0.011699282564222813, 0.06739779561758041, -0.09766864031553268, 0.0027327858842909336, -0.049618106335401535, -0.011971698142588139, -0.01321371179074049, -0.04938114434480667, -0.037217091768980026, 0.04341611638665199, 0.02062954567372799, -0.04915883019566536, -0.04840714484453201, -0.013577355071902275, -0.022874126210808754, 0.013654221780598164, -0.0363769456744194, 0.016525577753782272, 0.04064527899026871, -0.007572314701974392, -0.027057290077209473, -0.026539810001850128, 0.040873944759368896, -0.017874740064144135, -0.00022570039436686784, -0.0030605026986449957, -0.013664972968399525, -0.0011163778835907578, 0.019574157893657684, 0.017815325409173965, -0.01075291819870472, 0.06552843749523163, 0.04816282540559769, -0.0005287047242745757, 0.0047274320386350155, 0.05317705497145653, 0.030283596366643906, -0.021023929119110107, -0.018024910241365433, -0.034127917140722275, -0.02336324378848076, 0.02789277583360672, -0.03460657596588135, 0.01420755684375763, 0.040075358003377914, 0.045379720628261566, 0.0342659056186676, 0.05579427257180214, 0.04783378913998604, -0.00960763543844223, 0.020425163209438324, -0.036587148904800415, -0.034700121730566025, 0.0021790352184325457, -0.03800935298204422, -0.0201127789914608, -0.01288451999425888, 0.04498136788606644, 0.02802306041121483, 0.017537187784910202, -0.0819634348154068, 0.01937638781964779, -0.0018714603502303362, -0.021898319944739342, 0.021330546587705612, 0.000437131937360391, 0.040867868810892105, -0.009255459532141685, -0.008179319091141224, 0.006943434942513704, 0.007857504300773144, 0.010813151486217976, -0.004617759957909584, -0.04764668643474579, -0.013049406930804253, -0.08630701899528503, 0.010540930554270744, -0.014701695181429386, 0.027357639744877815, -0.04088741913437843, 0.015807846561074257, 0.023542318493127823, -0.013633123598992825, 0.027743088081479073, 0.007930637337267399, 0.06989476829767227, -0.010388338938355446, -0.0215549785643816, -0.06681972742080688, 0.004981833044439554, 0.01759542152285576, -0.026874471455812454, 0.002491563092917204, 0.022902049124240875, -0.0164139736443758, -0.024565543979406357, -0.03263649716973305, 0.012008472345769405, 0.02335437946021557, -0.018963180482387543, -0.04152911528944969, 0.01275293156504631, 0.029970087110996246, -0.03280332684516907, -0.026865245774388313, 0.0492536760866642, -0.04063092917203903, 0.009893421083688736, 0.002800646238029003, 0.021777521818876266, 0.01339768711477518, -0.012867024168372154, -0.049535010010004044, 0.021291175857186317, 0.020494453608989716, -0.006798736751079559, 0.02096058428287506, 0.035835620015859604, 0.018061840906739235, 0.015545297414064407, -0.007888483814895153, -0.019275357946753502, 0.005166804417967796, 0.0007659870898351073, -0.035905588418245316, -0.01554687600582838, 0.05847911909222603, -0.002434025751426816, 0.010063985362648964, 0.03242412209510803, -0.029591839760541916, 0.05641844868659973, -0.05921260640025139, 0.04101519286632538, 0.037618961185216904, -0.003560051554813981, 0.011142184026539326, -0.028988458216190338, 0.023500042036175728, 0.00842760968953371, -0.01253353152424097, 0.001899596070870757, -0.014333946630358696, -0.03169798105955124, 0.006427693646401167, -0.01951819472014904, 0.008231233805418015, 0.01708493009209633, -0.0014181716833263636, -0.007316581904888153, 0.054755304008722305, -0.0014805702958256006, 0.004642671439796686, -0.02771325223147869, 0.0013037589378654957, 0.05750459432601929, -0.020301062613725662, -0.04160323366522789, -0.08264486491680145, -0.024671275168657303, 0.006117353681474924, -0.015998737886548042, 0.0022948712576180696, -0.027746165171265602, 0.044378142803907394, 0.03136248514056206, 0.00801797304302454, -0.0025666444562375546, -0.035602178424596786, 0.05394802242517471, -0.013565188273787498, -0.008601308800280094, -0.05934282764792442, 0.018847327679395676, 0.08226975053548813, -0.035048745572566986, 0.03868502750992775, -0.02073070779442787, 0.00017578651022631675, 0.027352269738912582, -0.03499479219317436, -0.06421475112438202, 0.012471470050513744, -0.006105408072471619, -0.007953771390020847, 0.02686188742518425, -0.03834310919046402, -0.017280979081988335, -0.002791366074234247, -0.028712542727589607, -0.010033410042524338, 0.02327117882668972, 0.034878216683864594, -0.04541986435651779, -0.014169938862323761, -0.034164223819971085, 0.022107310593128204, 0.02588992565870285, 0.0482679046690464, 0.0056616151705384254, 0.01972208544611931, -0.02361859567463398, 0.11252299696207047, 0.08092420548200607, 0.02215498499572277, -0.009084564633667469, -0.008900735527276993, -0.016269706189632416, -0.005492399446666241, -0.010671952739357948, 0.016549857333302498, -0.017339156940579414, -0.06642311811447144, 0.07126796990633011, 0.023909181356430054, -0.034466423094272614, 0.008554172702133656, 0.011930355802178383, -0.042625389993190765, 0.0416666716337204, 0.0003856109397020191, 0.017238307744264603, 0.003985255490988493, 0.05502434819936752, 0.0013709537452086806, 0.0037963755894452333, 0.060953348875045776, -0.011385688558220863, 0.017604583874344826, -0.017021536827087402, 0.07113411277532578, 0.0327361598610878, 0.020892078056931496, -0.019508058205246925, 0.05328575521707535, -0.015267563983798027, -0.03609028086066246, -0.014511310495436192, 0.011752440594136715, -0.019329020753502846, -0.012710511684417725, 0.06246761605143547, 0.06541530787944794, 0.012437955476343632, 0.03843384236097336, 0.008077074773609638, 0.006116450298577547, 0.01960110478103161, 0.008871965110301971, 0.0065347799099981785, 0.04605376347899437, 0.021694859489798546, 0.004797197878360748, -0.026566945016384125, -0.012872322462499142, -0.03475314751267433, 0.01052137278020382, 0.01764254830777645, -0.025364503264427185, -0.028889773413538933, 0.021031895652413368, -0.05139270797371864, -0.001750486670061946, 0.0945344865322113, 0.032841965556144714, -0.03947693854570389, 0.005487161222845316, 0.014629173092544079, 0.01535067893564701, 0.028206124901771545, -0.022097760811448097, 0.016756191849708557, -0.022654421627521515, -0.0370701439678669, -0.005202581640332937, 0.012528673745691776, 0.030270202085375786, -0.00474745687097311, -0.016549566760659218, -0.006557745859026909, 0.014931036159396172, -0.01568690687417984, -0.04666418209671974, -0.0431068018078804, -0.04275413602590561, -0.05776013061404228, -0.06407725811004639, -0.05963873863220215, 0.0352054089307785, -0.041978441178798676, -0.04350003972649574, 0.008341866545379162, -0.023683084174990654, 0.028239363804459572, 0.014962561428546906, -0.06563397496938705, -0.03434222936630249, 0.06196673959493637, 0.0018003236036747694, -0.0033739875070750713, 0.03659318387508392, 0.030234064906835556, -0.02962132729589939, -0.02117226831614971, 0.03618865832686424, 0.031674809753894806, 0.036102548241615295, 0.009754070080816746, 0.01457748282700777, -0.09895164519548416, 0.03631443530321121, 0.03259541094303131, -0.023751214146614075, -0.07574595510959625, -0.02966572716832161, -0.020133934915065765, 0.009380887262523174, 0.04734216257929802, -0.0015326283173635602, -0.017157090827822685, -0.043644726276397705, -0.009877774864435196, 0.014284216798841953, -0.02787528932094574, 0.07009072601795197, -0.0637313574552536, 0.060776252299547195, 0.0008154027163982391, 0.016239993274211884, -0.06788280606269836, 0.021937720477581024, -0.0005297806346789002, 0.021850280463695526, 0.0034028913360089064, -0.022121496498584747, -0.06066729500889778, -0.07500770688056946, 0.013818470761179924, 0.030736073851585388, -0.04033276066184044, -0.02470986545085907, 0.01857082173228264, 0.015504670329391956, -0.017168434336781502, -0.021796416491270065, -0.027881156653165817, -0.030694345012307167, -0.020274706184864044, -0.05501813441514969, -0.05463678017258644, -0.009192625060677528, -0.01460120640695095, 0.0003140352782793343, -0.02528395503759384, -0.029396938160061836, 0.008760889060795307, 0.019282730296254158, 0.02085738442838192, 0.031055860221385956, 0.02580358274281025, 0.03733162209391594 ]
3,574
Boosting Ray Search Procedure of Hard-label Attacks with Transfer-based Priors
https://openreview.net/forum?id=tIBAOcAvn4
[ "Chen Ma", "Xinjie Xu", "Shuyu Cheng", "Qi Xuan" ]
Spotlight
One of the most practical and challenging types of black-box adversarial attacks is the hard-label attack, where only top-1 predicted labels are available. One effective approach is to search for the optimal ray direction from the benign image that minimizes the $\ell_p$ norm distance to the adversarial region. The unique advantage of this approach is that it transforms the hard-label attack into a continuous optimization problem. The objective function value is the ray's radius and can be obtained through a binary search with high query cost. Existing methods use a "sign trick" in gradient estimation to reduce queries. In this paper, we theoretically analyze the quality of this gradient estimation, proposing a novel prior-guided approach to improve ray search efficiency, based on theoretical and experimental analysis. Specifically, we utilize the transfer-based priors from surrogate models, and our gradient estimators appropriately integrate them by approximating the projection of the true gradient onto the subspace spanned by these priors and some random directions, in a query-efficient way. We theoretically derive the expected cosine similarity between the obtained gradient estimators and the true gradient, and demonstrate the improvement brought by using priors. Extensive experiments on the ImageNet and CIFAR-10 datasets show that our approach significantly outperforms 11 state-of-the-art methods in terms of query efficiency.
adversarial attack, hard-label attack, decision-based attack, black-box attack, gradient estimation, surrogate model, transfer-based priors
We propose a novel prior-guided hard-label attack approach by using subspace projection approximation.
4,515
null
[ -0.020824028179049492, -0.012722063809633255, 0.003704124828800559, 0.04829934239387512, 0.026284627616405487, 0.008217860013246536, 0.025362875312566757, -0.012443033047020435, -0.001918311812914908, -0.037944816052913666, -0.030769875273108482, 0.012546766549348831, -0.0388801135122776, 0.0009283866384066641, -0.019584327936172485, 0.08107362687587738, 0.02331068366765976, -0.010493768379092216, 0.009346290491521358, 0.03562254086136818, -0.01126848068088293, -0.0177515409886837, 0.03283724561333656, 0.014171474613249302, 0.04003056883811951, -0.012562808580696583, 0.0003833143273368478, 0.025360452011227608, -0.03542822599411011, -0.0005886827711947262, 0.05240738391876221, -0.025304999202489853, 0.02462374046444893, -0.05539531260728836, 0.01913001574575901, 0.04963522404432297, -0.030666247010231018, 0.01626468077301979, 0.013186015188694, 0.03104633279144764, -0.0505196712911129, -0.01141139306128025, -0.015545706264674664, 0.028957918286323547, -0.06807539612054825, 0.004889822099357843, -0.09685420244932175, 0.025916283950209618, 0.0037768064066767693, -0.020086895674467087, -0.0650768131017685, 0.023145386949181557, -0.004824299365282059, -0.016815973445773125, 0.03940276801586151, 0.03237520530819893, 0.03311038389801979, -0.05479746311903, -0.0010681075509637594, -0.06270197033882141, -0.029827047139406204, 0.02072402462363243, 0.028348242864012718, 0.018907712772488594, -0.013875823467969894, -0.014781906269490719, 0.03193013370037079, 0.05597887188196182, -0.050273969769477844, -0.05260203778743744, -0.017795367166399956, -0.003547717584297061, 0.015617690049111843, 0.0007875473238527775, -0.012149075977504253, -0.01961534470319748, 0.008282091468572617, -0.027387017384171486, 0.0450817234814167, -0.03371896594762802, 0.04883340373635292, 0.0014198016142472625, 0.020927635952830315, 0.02131391316652298, -0.00934803206473589, 0.02270433120429516, -0.029834328219294548, 0.006785227917134762, -0.07811012119054794, 0.04143717139959335, -0.011848106980323792, -0.0298890583217144, 0.04032688960433006, 0.02124718949198723, 0.012488463893532753, 0.0021299601066857576, 0.02801724150776863, 0.01259148120880127, 0.009889748878777027, -0.0010585365816950798, -0.016316810622811317, -0.0339369997382164, 0.008345343172550201, 0.006825530901551247, -0.1065780520439148, 0.005668940953910351, -0.010093952529132366, -0.011535254307091236, -0.032365720719099045, 0.01846473477780819, -0.04658545181155205, 0.03197130933403969, -0.012242340482771397, -0.02522604539990425, -0.09857171028852463, 0.01776648685336113, -0.005569498986005783, 0.01833157241344452, 0.002276770072057843, 0.009617544710636139, 0.05198601260781288, 0.06646451354026794, 0.00795784778892994, 0.06184963136911392, 0.03058173693716526, -0.018483897671103477, 0.015606445260345936, 0.03564342483878136, -0.03956611454486847, -0.023602385073900223, -0.015362616628408432, 0.03374643996357918, 0.03012605383992195, 0.0319310761988163, 0.020350009202957153, -0.019244873896241188, -0.027118876576423645, 0.034634895622730255, 0.02003180794417858, -0.022596295922994614, 0.018240531906485558, -0.056170620024204254, 0.024355581030249596, -0.035279225558042526, 0.06890631467103958, -0.023427730426192284, -0.009994822554290295, -0.01897582970559597, -0.04381224140524864, 0.017992591485381126, 0.01337351929396391, -0.0349590927362442, 0.04296984151005745, -0.09123058617115021, -0.016817523166537285, 0.05442778766155243, 0.021812837570905685, 0.016725564375519753, -0.008468536660075188, -0.02545350417494774, 0.015136727131903172, -0.02091587893664837, -0.035055555403232574, 0.0422116257250309, -0.013548312708735466, -0.049986667931079865, 0.04397302865982056, 0.04733186960220337, -0.0336868092417717, 0.03096458502113819, -0.03426006808876991, -0.02677912265062332, 0.039817098528146744, -0.004460889380425215, -0.028138795867562294, 0.02974422089755535, 0.0794905498623848, 0.005150697194039822, 0.05015068128705025, 0.002369662979617715, -0.09169664978981018, 0.03353530541062355, 0.023892009630799294, 0.01417576801031828, -0.0169533584266901, -0.018775394186377525, 0.0753413662314415, -0.024416491389274597, 0.028936175629496574, 0.04669491574168205, -0.08457159250974655, 0.016202155500650406, 0.004165026359260082, -0.02426833100616932, 0.0631827861070633, 0.024724861606955528, 0.005944203119724989, 0.016858896240592003, 0.010457086376845837, 0.031139997765421867, 0.04526672139763832, -0.011223976500332355, 0.04039983078837395, -0.018041018396615982, -0.068508580327034, 0.001848494983278215, 0.03456219285726547, -0.05987383797764778, -0.02353484183549881, 0.034442268311977386, -0.012059860862791538, -0.007721191272139549, -0.03400854393839836, 0.018157262355089188, 0.021789323538541794, -0.0010837774025276303, -0.01392598170787096, 0.012606455013155937, 0.020308982580900192, -0.0765429139137268, 0.0394316166639328, 0.03445856645703316, 0.0018150919349864125, 0.046502966433763504, -0.0012448631459847093, 0.1041506826877594, 0.05618918314576149, -0.020761849358677864, 0.016272900626063347, -0.011876859702169895, 0.046088188886642456, -0.0019473007414489985, 0.0257639829069376, -0.005324656143784523, 0.0045799980871379375, -0.012845720164477825, 0.010526242665946484, -0.010136649012565613, 0.059548184275627136, -0.05421043932437897, -0.01298514474183321, 0.07718227058649063, -0.003511862363666296, 0.061559636145830154, -0.006747513543814421, -0.011744299903512001, 0.05390745401382446, -0.0077456263825297356, -0.006803569383919239, -0.010776862502098083, -0.025072617456316948, -0.003924292512238026, -0.004990150686353445, -0.02112351544201374, 0.03228607401251793, -0.044145286083221436, 0.014354354701936245, -0.024077000096440315, 0.07060512155294418, 0.0709013119339943, 0.0021591405384242535, 0.029205696657299995, 0.0007051131688058376, -0.019935710355639458, -0.030886199325323105, -0.10663997381925583, -0.04252254590392113, -0.026404717937111855, 0.06019779294729233, 0.005251301918178797, 0.04546606168150902, -0.0007846764638088644, -0.009409353137016296, -0.031407564878463745, -0.030695393681526184, 0.023698706179857254, 0.009217229671776295, 0.0606413297355175, -0.04238799586892128, 0.004957183729857206, -0.0002533714286983013, 0.0645381286740303, 0.00685620354488492, -0.01384424977004528, -0.03350536525249481, -0.05688294768333435, -0.03754723444581032, -0.06289758533239365, -0.03038419783115387, 0.03379262611269951, -0.011777987703680992, 0.04593285918235779, -0.0061311060562729836, 0.05841036140918732, 0.02961595728993416, 0.042735323309898376, 0.0417000874876976, -0.0015539429150521755, -0.025368064641952515, 0.012439883314073086, 0.004142192658036947, 0.022950025275349617, -0.028387079015374184, -0.013358140364289284, -0.017192747443914413, -0.008106471039354801, 0.030964355915784836, 0.003950934391468763, -0.28091347217559814, 0.003990331664681435, 0.014029859565198421, 0.010343116708099842, 0.028238432481884956, -0.024755245074629784, 0.014690633863210678, -0.04585302248597145, -0.030925210565328598, 0.009340567514300346, 0.010048188269138336, 0.0029294262640178204, 0.03444098308682442, 0.021410726010799408, 0.04555916413664818, 0.026629185304045677, 0.004583130590617657, -0.01808289624750614, 0.03125772997736931, 0.030420951545238495, -0.009829281829297543, -0.05749182030558586, 0.0035610594786703587, 0.038041289895772934, -0.0077122231014072895, 0.03859163820743561, -0.04846629500389099, -0.01343314815312624, -0.01010759174823761, -0.01667887531220913, -0.009894667193293571, -0.013187034986913204, -0.016517242416739464, 0.03309771791100502, 0.0023510355968028307, -0.010967209003865719, 0.028808411210775375, -0.018477972596883774, -0.005227657034993172, 0.005570617970079184, 0.024730052798986435, 0.019754061475396156, 0.01654001511633396, 0.025431744754314423, 0.07244987040758133, -0.017933333292603493, -0.027122747153043747, -0.012231015600264072, -0.009688123129308224, 0.040995240211486816, -0.0005947637837380171, -0.05523056536912918, -0.03217218071222305, 0.035792842507362366, -0.013718011789023876, -0.030096272006630898, 0.006356738042086363, -0.016001654788851738, 0.009170097298920155, 0.021926483139395714, 0.005112646613270044, -0.05761253461241722, -0.016886712983250618, -0.023908548057079315, 0.02115566097199917, -0.027826102450489998, -0.05176851525902748, -0.06913769990205765, 0.04846367985010147, 0.032148804515600204, -0.012419120408594608, 0.021627407521009445, -0.020409060642123222, -0.09040303528308868, 0.024468038231134415, 0.022649690508842468, -0.019575703889131546, 0.0015287318965420127, 0.022312277927994728, 0.04869160056114197, -0.03925175964832306, -0.08012185990810394, 0.023353783413767815, 0.018133560195565224, 0.02234656549990177, -0.05133749544620514, 0.015347770415246487, -0.0014825471444055438, -0.00796712376177311, -0.01380875613540411, 0.04592376574873924, 0.002026032656431198, 0.02497275546193123, -0.019605223089456558, 0.04330240562558174, 0.030752770602703094, 0.05991926044225693, 0.023027798160910606, 0.06133989617228508, 0.03559253737330437, -0.010140041820704937, -0.05266236141324043, -0.02021827921271324, -0.06821827590465546, -0.030810106545686722, 0.0023637963458895683, -0.03303016349673271, -0.009766285307705402, 0.04068237543106079, -0.05258379131555557, -0.022262990474700928, -0.03565838932991028, 0.011391040869057178, -0.024447396397590637, 0.0014729073736816645, 0.0015997160226106644, 0.013724897056818008, 0.02939336560666561, 0.017376407980918884, -0.054231107234954834, -0.023378022015094757, 0.05329126492142677, -0.00575927272439003, 0.014567318372428417, -0.025387197732925415, -0.00858965516090393, 0.003090600948780775, -0.01727120205760002, -0.017312705516815186, -0.007281786296516657, 0.026507919654250145, 0.0367245115339756, 0.023952048271894455, -0.000580373452976346, 0.07061700522899628, 0.01716264709830284, 0.01972944289445877, -0.01906103454530239, 0.014804303646087646, -0.01878565363585949, 0.031921178102493286, -0.012676361948251724, 0.0518525093793869, 0.05820227786898613, 0.020164066925644875, 0.019444920122623444, 0.010346351191401482, -0.011259309947490692, 0.006441149860620499, -0.005902381148189306, 0.01297793909907341, -0.028568008914589882, -0.003981026355177164, -0.025454513728618622, 0.029866283759474754, 0.019469955936074257, 0.03894698619842529, -0.04766516014933586, 0.0050911144353449345, -0.06559382379055023, 0.05241664871573448, 0.024982163682579994, -0.02232949249446392, -0.002249765209853649, 0.03798374533653259, 0.04799848049879074, -0.018031885847449303, -0.03461489453911781, -0.002812035847455263, -0.009421460330486298, -0.007258566562086344, -0.02767728455364704, -0.045746903866529465, -0.01738019660115242, -0.02672419883310795, 0.013808002695441246, -0.0019065813394263387, 0.019939878955483437, -0.03352203220129013, 0.011250747367739677, 0.02706538885831833, -0.006957692094147205, -0.011449413374066353, 0.011777606792747974, 0.06989558041095734, -0.027472004294395447, -0.02049555443227291, -0.02915821596980095, -0.04339013621211052, 0.06642849743366241, -0.026757266372442245, 0.0026470087468624115, -0.007301573175936937, -0.015490790829062462, -0.002520002657547593, -0.0507400743663311, -0.0359375886619091, 0.03284059092402458, -0.00038419905467890203, -0.012883479706943035, 0.0054159038700163364, 0.022662976756691933, -0.017789028584957123, 0.027198543772101402, 0.008469591848552227, -0.07303269952535629, 0.04723067581653595, 0.06166749447584152, -0.05392904952168465, 0.010826478712260723, -0.028771283105015755, -0.044909700751304626, -0.08328206837177277, 0.00606816541403532, 0.01680007018148899, -0.0028296217788010836, -0.055452171713113785, -0.002957433694973588, 0.018139123916625977, -0.02723689191043377, 0.027364205569028854, 0.015691382810473442, 0.013605230487883091, 0.006768530234694481, 0.0076128458604216576, 0.05870071426033974, -0.012218168005347252, 0.0024441254790872335, 0.004424104001373053, -0.03715214878320694, 0.004305698908865452, -0.040808990597724915, 0.029499191790819168, 0.03857824578881264, -0.024299660697579384, 0.01875670813024044, -0.04719070345163345, 0.03094153292477131, -0.043674785643815994, -0.014390368945896626, -0.007360735442489386, 0.005421762820333242, -0.031104395166039467, 0.03947172313928604, 0.017539674416184425, 0.02961152419447899, 0.01781284250319004, 0.013936522416770458, -0.014334063045680523, 0.016574697569012642, 0.01733332872390747, 0.03621000424027443, -0.08095008879899979, -0.020098334178328514, 0.06343566626310349, -0.06520487368106842, -0.026558537036180496, -0.06133849918842316, -0.029983628541231155, 0.03485221043229103, -0.03949319198727608, 0.019882407039403915, -0.029588287696242332, 0.02450387179851532, 0.011199845001101494, 0.01941106468439102, -0.006421394646167755, -0.01175921130925417, 0.027783779427409172, -0.027635876089334488, -0.016167424619197845, -0.06462053954601288, 0.011470798403024673, 0.06448110193014145, -0.0339934416115284, 0.030801011249423027, -0.005752289667725563, -0.036716997623443604, -0.006878457963466644, -0.019579870626330376, -0.06328976154327393, 0.005084546748548746, -0.023073818534612656, -0.01915481686592102, 0.011682610027492046, -0.050088055431842804, -0.016310377046465874, 0.002305376809090376, -0.035128142684698105, -0.005647693295031786, 0.0013060624478384852, 0.057207558304071426, -0.008536099456250668, -0.028698274865746498, -0.02142549306154251, 0.0006626971298828721, 0.01816672272980213, 0.06148228794336319, 0.012328342534601688, 0.00360193126834929, -0.028399258852005005, 0.05282283201813698, 0.039203841239213943, -0.020748045295476913, 0.0002595784026198089, 0.027858814224600792, -0.023667098954319954, -0.04393093287944794, 0.06818921864032745, -0.015111766755580902, -0.023537160828709602, -0.06445042043924332, 0.03852059319615364, 0.02130851522088051, -0.042778585106134415, -0.044605035334825516, 0.04313203692436218, -0.05201122537255287, -0.008927383460104465, -0.03444956988096237, -0.04711426421999931, -0.002452969318255782, 0.06117696687579155, 0.02862073853611946, -0.004309624899178743, 0.04474309831857681, 0.011484459042549133, -0.0286080464720726, -0.026845676824450493, 0.06346962600946426, 0.0866386666893959, 0.049946464598178864, -0.02256670966744423, 0.082467220723629, -0.035231564193964005, -0.05385971814393997, 0.022492408752441406, -0.03109639696776867, -0.014977548271417618, -0.04732759669423103, -0.022902902215719223, 0.10144077241420746, 0.0040838154964149, 0.06223456189036369, -0.0647406354546547, 0.004823746625334024, 0.03654332086443901, -0.00823161005973816, -0.018762070685625076, 0.032933250069618225, 0.028262728825211525, 0.01483470480889082, -0.02574777789413929, -0.041828591376543045, 0.01879298686981201, -0.015246889553964138, 0.014095582999289036, -0.002786626573652029, -0.04901352524757385, -0.020257607102394104, -0.016415605321526527, -0.008331776596605778, 0.08904264122247696, -0.03780120238661766, -0.05031413212418556, 0.0034976829774677753, 0.01181729231029749, 0.019764715805649757, 0.05086764693260193, 0.009277775883674622, -0.017731640487909317, -0.012164602056145668, -0.03812956437468529, 0.005365991499274969, 0.010149125941097736, 0.002763852709904313, 0.039050228893756866, -0.02287120185792446, -0.0376313216984272, 0.010935720056295395, 0.0056416126899421215, -0.017217477783560753, -0.0697166696190834, -0.0378112718462944, -0.06722234189510345, -0.06216011941432953, -0.08286579698324203, 0.01703423261642456, 0.011766575276851654, -0.035561125725507736, 0.0012078378349542618, -0.009698416106402874, 0.015258828178048134, 0.03882825747132301, -0.052064768970012665, 0.039485227316617966, 0.032114870846271515, 0.008785993792116642, 0.027777783572673798, 0.02375847101211548, 0.03177357837557793, -0.05278589203953743, -0.0202923770993948, 0.027661047875881195, 0.00190056674182415, 0.03171897679567337, -0.012917791493237019, 0.002161293523386121, -0.09557939320802689, 0.0019894300494343042, 0.014820830896496773, -0.0367913618683815, -0.07832513004541397, 0.005565041676163673, -0.036797139793634415, 0.01722213625907898, 0.07149069756269455, -0.0003132779092993587, 0.02801043912768364, -0.03934852406382561, 0.004172538872808218, 0.00815789494663477, -0.012219992466270924, 0.036485299468040466, -0.0010804622434079647, 0.05016978085041046, 0.04237314686179161, 0.0021674614399671555, -0.0293620266020298, -0.0016704262234270573, -0.021915175020694733, 0.02392139472067356, -0.04888621345162392, -0.050979308784008026, -0.03760772570967674, -0.11512687057256699, -0.01230691373348236, 0.02817603573203087, 0.004497087560594082, -0.029481371864676476, -0.019695358350872993, 0.015568266622722149, 0.03152997046709061, -0.010697406716644764, -0.004108447581529617, -0.0296633243560791, -0.02206076681613922, -0.03418274223804474, -0.04836146906018257, 0.06218210607767105, -0.01684066466987133, 0.0238746777176857, 0.003953416366130114, -0.0435371957719326, -0.02200332283973694, -0.0034053397830575705, 0.05504710227251053, 0.03629842400550842, 0.01273428276181221, -0.02118680067360401 ]
3,575
3DIS: Depth-Driven Decoupled Image Synthesis for Universal Multi-Instance Generation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=MagmwodCAB
[ "dewei Zhou", "Ji Xie", "Zongxin Yang", "Yi Yang" ]
Spotlight
The increasing demand for controllable outputs in text-to-image generation has spurred advancements in multi-instance generation (MIG), allowing users to define both instance layouts and attributes. However, unlike image-conditional generation methods such as ControlNet, MIG techniques have not been widely adopted in state-of-the-art models like SD2 and SDXL, primarily due to the challenge of building robust renderers that simultaneously handle instance positioning and attribute rendering. In this paper, we introduce Depth-Driven Decoupled Image Synthesis (3DIS), a novel framework that decouples the MIG process into two stages: (i) generating a coarse scene depth map for accurate instance positioning and scene composition, and (ii) rendering fine-grained attributes using pre-trained ControlNet on any foundational model, without additional training. Our 3DIS framework integrates a custom adapter into LDM3D for precise depth-based layouts and employs a finetuning-free method for enhanced instance-level attribute rendering. Extensive experiments on COCO-Position and COCO-MIG benchmarks demonstrate that 3DIS significantly outperforms existing methods in both layout precision and attribute rendering. Notably, 3DIS offers seamless compatibility with diverse foundational models, providing a robust, adaptable solution for advanced multi-instance generation. The code is available at: https://github.com/limuloo/3DIS.
Image Generation; Diffusion Models
null
4,481
null
[ -0.00433297548443079, 0.014271055348217487, 0.003963483031839132, 0.03632683306932449, 0.03795772045850754, 0.05195244401693344, 0.013307628221809864, 0.011314066126942635, -0.003812223905697465, -0.0592549666762352, -0.012705196626484394, -0.013251119293272495, -0.056060150265693665, 0.049352724105119705, 0.011129815131425858, 0.025874478742480278, -0.0003998510946985334, -0.020414847880601883, -0.019554503262043, 0.054754626005887985, -0.02312769554555416, -0.03888094797730446, 0.0010610504541546106, -0.0012413538061082363, 0.0013127316487953067, -0.002984608057886362, 0.01888647861778736, 0.039244912564754486, -0.01895180530846119, -0.03137970715761185, 0.002373346360400319, -0.016862759366631508, 0.0014021738898009062, -0.0755142793059349, 0.0002138350682798773, -0.035107750445604324, -0.06903422623872757, -0.005385847762227058, -0.012525594793260098, 0.0116351917386055, -0.028573838993906975, 0.010640318505465984, 0.03833135589957237, -0.01726209558546543, -0.020134931430220604, 0.0000031693114124209387, -0.0825662910938263, 0.02258170023560524, 0.011943680234253407, 0.01043663825839758, -0.08527204394340515, 0.013005800545215607, -0.0062182750552892685, 0.008793043904006481, 0.009245107881724834, 0.03153698518872261, 0.027715252712368965, -0.053611014038324356, -0.0070273070596158504, -0.05757587403059006, -0.003666217904537916, -0.009708460420370102, 0.02057267352938652, 0.027627956122159958, 0.016519570723176003, -0.04469232261180878, -0.013659135438501835, 0.04345952346920967, -0.038561053574085236, -0.04333078861236572, -0.014846532605588436, -0.003977412357926369, 0.008075226098299026, 0.028234632685780525, 0.00309817586094141, -0.04411890357732773, -0.008827663958072662, -0.0018183919601142406, 0.0805613175034523, -0.0026143009308725595, 0.040255747735500336, 0.0025642337277531624, 0.014610650017857552, 0.026796994730830193, -0.02102886512875557, 0.0052329981699585915, 0.000959161901846528, -0.010776061564683914, -0.04658818617463112, 0.029811199754476547, -0.0196151752024889, -0.04331391677260399, 0.02946758270263672, 0.051051169633865356, 0.017457371577620506, 0.006485245190560818, -0.008510395884513855, 0.02594505436718464, 0.01924801617860794, 0.0470016710460186, 0.013762510381639004, -0.03321974724531174, -0.007935924455523491, 0.016004463657736778, -0.08073209971189499, -0.019488753750920296, -0.050352733582258224, -0.0171681996434927, 0.0026180692948400974, 0.015132022090256214, -0.037718623876571655, -0.02804648131132126, 0.03309820219874382, -0.01840982399880886, -0.07373618334531784, 0.0220192801207304, 0.003547257510945201, 0.016201704740524292, -0.022947559133172035, 0.01619090512394905, 0.0667194128036499, 0.03230578452348709, -0.0056147342547774315, 0.07017984241247177, 0.01211228035390377, 0.0007931793224997818, 0.02687329426407814, 0.032516054809093475, -0.03752322494983673, -0.019848685711622238, 0.023593299090862274, 0.013199117965996265, -0.0009954264387488365, -0.04160454869270325, 0.0069506000727415085, -0.03628150373697281, 0.016611173748970032, 0.013024349696934223, 0.02763720229268074, 0.0020091088954359293, -0.01406837347894907, -0.025419941172003746, 0.052193108946084976, -0.02379295788705349, 0.07185725122690201, -0.0119983721524477, 0.01380331814289093, -0.024560455232858658, -0.03406956419348717, 0.05296320095658302, 0.0332677848637104, 0.012684471905231476, -0.004071428440511227, -0.0611879788339138, 0.022356463596224785, 0.08208715915679932, 0.05514685809612274, 0.020813262090086937, 0.025028876960277557, 0.009581169113516808, 0.0016265626763924956, 0.0018913004314526916, -0.03485524654388428, -0.009607098996639252, -0.009488042443990707, -0.011917924508452415, -0.00290972413495183, 0.022122029215097427, -0.01375523116439581, -0.04280612990260124, -0.039221182465553284, -0.04298127070069313, 0.011792309582233429, 0.009342551231384277, -0.020801609382033348, -0.021330321207642555, 0.07339832186698914, -0.0036749253049492836, 0.026715323328971863, 0.0037923287600278854, -0.0793478786945343, -0.017892153933644295, 0.00743648549541831, -0.01482795923948288, -0.010574527084827423, -0.04482373967766762, 0.06520099937915802, 0.01575659215450287, 0.007733481004834175, 0.03731092810630798, -0.09761287271976471, -0.009371284395456314, 0.02320338599383831, -0.03868505358695984, 0.05747557431459427, 0.0080797728151083, -0.04962371662259102, 0.03576325997710228, 0.038040436804294586, 0.028342319652438164, 0.04388152435421944, -0.021574003621935844, 0.05368774011731148, -0.001928413286805153, -0.030999507755041122, -0.047681987285614014, 0.03658577799797058, -0.025610869750380516, -0.029240764677524567, -0.0011106490856036544, 0.0013589805457741022, -0.020334508270025253, 0.03162667900323868, -0.003583979094401002, 0.025350051000714302, 0.016247659921646118, -0.02045402303338051, -0.0030554188415408134, 0.018025152385234833, -0.048933643847703934, 0.05041646957397461, 0.029630806297063828, -0.023932667449116707, -0.010966718196868896, -0.035107407718896866, 0.09366873651742935, 0.05766826868057251, -0.06754704564809799, -0.002929443260654807, -0.017130408436059952, -0.02335127256810665, 0.04429197311401367, 0.0052993446588516235, -0.0460335798561573, -0.033006057143211365, -0.041028544306755066, 0.0408882200717926, 0.015424316748976707, 0.05145452171564102, -0.033726632595062256, -0.0029352433048188686, 0.028100717812776566, -0.021749792620539665, 0.03831108286976814, 0.03544943407177925, 0.016271905973553658, 0.031318776309490204, -0.009535878896713257, -0.04046826809644699, -0.04440655931830406, 0.008682104758918285, 0.013118456117808819, 0.005512921139597893, -0.018485933542251587, -0.019666975364089012, -0.048354119062423706, -0.007277027703821659, -0.03133422136306763, 0.03487841412425041, 0.06080450490117073, 0.011824795044958591, 0.010166327469050884, 0.021021950989961624, -0.0038115959614515305, -0.024388035759329796, -0.08726140111684799, -0.03817044571042061, -0.011212295852601528, 0.045402638614177704, -0.01865515299141407, 0.06791422516107559, 0.019606593996286392, -0.009871996007859707, -0.028966024518013, -0.004847537726163864, 0.014038344845175743, 0.0047257994301617146, 0.005302893929183483, -0.029190771281719208, -0.02395605854690075, 0.00788046047091484, 0.07070401310920715, -0.016359247267246246, 0.005297878757119179, -0.042763616889715195, -0.013820238411426544, 0.0019489377737045288, -0.04881688579916954, -0.02502751536667347, -0.014418120495975018, 0.016030075028538704, 0.016802363097667694, -0.03285248950123787, 0.028614485636353493, 0.0716843381524086, 0.06852192431688309, 0.03343500196933746, -0.029891585931181908, -0.05393581837415695, 0.017564348876476288, -0.006317128427326679, 0.01546255312860012, -0.0014061537804082036, -0.02536638081073761, -0.03644007071852684, 0.008554873988032341, 0.03869818523526192, -0.0023880137596279383, -0.2968311607837677, -0.04660940170288086, -0.018044983968138695, -0.027167756110429764, 0.02356809750199318, -0.027513796463608742, 0.03276222199201584, -0.0464441254734993, -0.014642741531133652, 0.031065035611391068, 0.011139052920043468, 0.021300654858350754, -0.004164150450378656, 0.06243199482560158, 0.04829414188861847, 0.06483596563339233, 0.0013859713217243552, -0.012663142755627632, 0.00562946405261755, 0.046098463237285614, -0.04626026377081871, -0.04872894659638405, -0.0390867181122303, 0.009704000316560268, -0.01957602985203266, 0.01638108305633068, -0.05567178130149841, -0.017179857939481735, -0.011645489372313023, -0.02838207222521305, 0.002068975940346718, -0.034281808882951736, -0.004559690598398447, 0.01855807565152645, 0.004058877471834421, -0.001907661440782249, 0.04893476516008377, -0.003157178172841668, 0.017945026978850365, -0.04224712401628494, 0.029781464487314224, -0.04602033272385597, -0.015852157026529312, 0.01434342097491026, 0.08590921014547348, -0.02632744610309601, -0.046764034777879715, -0.010772272013127804, -0.05056899040937424, 0.05094160512089729, 0.009214007295668125, -0.03180459886789322, -0.0028431403916329145, 0.04255048185586929, -0.007019366603344679, -0.02813476324081421, 0.019797062501311302, 0.010011781938374043, -0.016488520428538322, 0.016319092363119125, -0.021286740899086, -0.03124801255762577, -0.07824406027793884, 0.007309353910386562, 0.020461035892367363, -0.03373019024729729, -0.08034944534301758, -0.08518332242965698, -0.021949419751763344, 0.028983863070607185, 0.011098151095211506, 0.013151146471500397, -0.0006481041782535613, -0.10010012239217758, 0.020715398713946342, -0.005200991872698069, -0.011418276466429234, -0.045144472271203995, -0.020372658967971802, 0.049133121967315674, -0.026773573830723763, -0.053957559168338776, 0.011397648602724075, 0.0014675403945147991, 0.014607022516429424, 0.0008812734740786254, 0.02754385955631733, -0.03542414307594299, -0.00365379243157804, -0.0028376560658216476, 0.07570931315422058, 0.016656696796417236, 0.03895643353462219, -0.02040688693523407, 0.0682818666100502, 0.014306183904409409, 0.06764253973960876, 0.025376519188284874, 0.04628271982073784, -0.014112104661762714, 0.03905721753835678, -0.06296075135469437, -0.013600585982203484, 0.005276286043226719, -0.020219024270772934, 0.0011553033255040646, -0.01989099010825157, -0.030147235840559006, 0.022436557337641716, 0.024566173553466797, -0.025995688512921333, -0.033038850873708725, -0.0007862976053729653, -0.021047644317150116, -0.004621283616870642, 0.0027146036736667156, 0.011442316696047783, 0.05249599739909172, 0.04361198842525482, -0.007545608561486006, -0.027030186727643013, 0.03670071065425873, -0.019933711737394333, 0.004352161660790443, 0.011395965702831745, 0.012666846625506878, -0.01635538786649704, -0.00112196896225214, 0.013800124637782574, -0.03222610801458359, 0.0355217270553112, 0.01783677190542221, 0.013202267698943615, 0.024823106825351715, 0.05229204520583153, -0.010916512459516525, -0.01455238088965416, -0.0160512737929821, 0.04078737646341324, -0.008991655893623829, 0.02109052985906601, 0.00460870610550046, 0.023581188172101974, -0.001343095675110817, 0.03825603052973747, 0.012683515436947346, 0.030607381835579872, 0.009261537343263626, 0.015162517316639423, -0.03019326739013195, 0.02351946197450161, -0.06569339334964752, -0.021966299042105675, -0.03184453397989273, -0.03107433393597603, -0.039327945560216904, -0.010770536959171295, -0.03521479293704033, 0.022790804505348206, -0.06884501129388809, 0.07948105782270432, 0.006341628730297089, -0.02613925375044346, -0.017292501404881477, 0.030064525082707405, 0.055820100009441376, 0.03711862117052078, -0.0009521290776319802, -0.008461748249828815, -0.011704851873219013, 0.013628129847347736, -0.011981155723333359, -0.022056451067328453, -0.016220813617110252, -0.0272735133767128, 0.06755821406841278, -0.012509874999523163, -0.003832444781437516, -0.004253345541656017, 0.05234038084745407, 0.000051018199883401394, -0.01590322144329548, 0.053548336029052734, -0.01457170955836773, 0.05937691032886505, 0.007185820955783129, -0.033303193747997284, 0.015954872593283653, 0.007077489513903856, 0.04599379748106003, -0.008105323649942875, 0.012248111888766289, -0.04912398010492325, -0.011776612140238285, -0.050642888993024826, -0.029420990496873856, 0.011636927723884583, 0.007186554372310638, -0.017941372469067574, -0.01248273253440857, -0.025748351588845253, 0.007266123779118061, -0.04873368889093399, -0.024956010282039642, 0.03379373997449875, -0.07394814491271973, 0.015011650510132313, 0.043903056532144547, 0.008841848000884056, 0.04126087948679924, -0.014431378804147243, -0.005748141091316938, -0.06120748072862625, -0.05136322230100632, 0.00789281353354454, 0.002084739739075303, -0.017237216234207153, -0.02730770967900753, -0.006469932850450277, -0.011962228454649448, 0.022817151620984077, 0.0019272012868896127, -0.016683092340826988, -0.026230541989207268, -0.007148844189941883, 0.036603521555662155, -0.04650358110666275, -0.024392850697040558, -0.0000036136832477495773, -0.013043520972132683, 0.044387705624103546, -0.022571973502635956, -0.0038230372592806816, 0.03179522976279259, 0.013303184881806374, 0.03282877430319786, -0.021813997998833656, 0.05667765066027641, 0.01640160195529461, -0.009220952168107033, 0.003515911754220724, 0.0032086181454360485, -0.03471395745873451, 0.018554164096713066, 0.037579625844955444, 0.017355265095829964, -0.03394212946295738, -0.010053638368844986, -0.017491646111011505, 0.039042580872774124, -0.01585577242076397, -0.008894333615899086, -0.042151425033807755, -0.03659682348370552, 0.05904673784971237, -0.0531463623046875, 0.00631221616640687, -0.05428912490606308, -0.05904151499271393, 0.010513839311897755, -0.028590518981218338, 0.0710650235414505, -0.0011544087901711464, 0.016721267253160477, 0.042635656893253326, 0.02948589064180851, 0.0245790034532547, -0.038624100387096405, 0.03463633731007576, -0.042617715895175934, 0.017616668716073036, -0.062170617282390594, 0.004047206602990627, 0.05600437521934509, -0.01735439896583557, -0.03909922018647194, 0.0003332523920107633, -0.0010274156229570508, 0.035195961594581604, -0.02936517260968685, -0.07326698303222656, 0.009110629558563232, -0.056231506168842316, -0.006164558231830597, 0.018963664770126343, -0.006813294254243374, -0.015808211639523506, -0.026614297181367874, -0.031853511929512024, 0.010949264280498028, 0.00998636707663536, 0.00977911427617073, 0.01623355783522129, 0.011701805517077446, -0.02762622758746147, -0.013908213004469872, 0.04153652861714363, 0.04645372927188873, 0.01398492231965065, 0.043469835072755814, 0.006370832212269306, 0.08998310565948486, 0.037664368748664856, 0.006118721794337034, 0.04491910710930824, -0.03077114000916481, -0.0007447637035511434, -0.0456700399518013, 0.05110899358987808, 0.07166972756385803, -0.030862882733345032, -0.06847819685935974, 0.04183344915509224, 0.016614599153399467, -0.05018367990851402, -0.018628660589456558, 0.0543353296816349, -0.061496552079916, 0.037696100771427155, -0.030936721712350845, 0.004952509421855211, 0.01630312390625477, 0.0534052699804306, -0.036100417375564575, 0.030607419088482857, 0.06181247532367706, -0.004350544419139624, 0.0034523052163422108, -0.03698113560676575, 0.056468065828084946, 0.07389091700315475, 0.026061585173010826, -0.028369678184390068, 0.07009176909923553, -0.02409098483622074, -0.07290191203355789, 0.010229128412902355, 0.03927529975771904, 0.010864605195820332, -0.06703192740678787, 0.018243856728076935, 0.09760434180498123, 0.010671351104974747, 0.05789461359381676, -0.01954561099410057, -0.015532098710536957, 0.00015709680155850947, 0.024380510672926903, -0.012119709514081478, 0.031794384121894836, 0.05878874287009239, 0.02027517929673195, -0.005243727006018162, 0.01617085561156273, -0.010968613438308239, -0.015397411771118641, 0.017696568742394447, -0.00479477271437645, 0.003862062469124794, 0.05010799691081047, 0.0005399967194534838, 0.040769413113594055, 0.08837094902992249, -0.029666442424058914, -0.06988086551427841, 0.0012539041927084327, -0.008313925936818123, 0.03963245451450348, 0.03475332260131836, 0.004778801929205656, -0.03583776578307152, 0.026519326493144035, -0.04783757030963898, -0.020659422501921654, 0.02158440835773945, -0.026195915415883064, 0.01623084768652916, -0.028117381036281586, -0.026609519496560097, 0.016690952703356743, 0.009305919520556927, -0.05452476069331169, -0.05561261251568794, -0.04709985852241516, -0.06149813160300255, -0.05326712504029274, 0.011671379208564758, 0.03156186640262604, -0.00024149840464815497, -0.027245616540312767, -0.05340639501810074, -0.021131161600351334, 0.02812020666897297, 0.05325237661600113, -0.04371215030550957, 0.010100172832608223, 0.03608795627951622, -0.004413334187120199, -0.003272119676694274, 0.05920377001166344, 0.012069069780409336, -0.009059271775186062, -0.003987730480730534, -0.007009914610534906, 0.04104100912809372, 0.022497160360217094, -0.00991505291312933, -0.007417019922286272, -0.12016401439905167, -0.00479866424575448, 0.016790397465229034, 0.0005860446835868061, -0.0755053460597992, 0.0029188820626586676, -0.01135463360697031, 0.015133878216147423, 0.07778207957744598, 0.013756614178419113, 0.023660583421587944, 0.0052160583436489105, 0.009003700688481331, -0.03595944494009018, 0.020648006349802017, 0.06747148931026459, -0.020701061934232712, 0.08986846357584, 0.03637779504060745, -0.02016078308224678, -0.004615511745214462, 0.050490155816078186, -0.009455329738557339, 0.012243966571986675, -0.01852637343108654, 0.00048171894741244614, -0.051916949450969696, -0.11258603632450104, -0.017251374199986458, 0.010858612135052681, 0.016873762011528015, -0.037052981555461884, -0.006462726276367903, -0.020823705941438675, -0.03131229802966118, -0.03128436580300331, -0.0018045388860628009, 0.007505914196372032, -0.054304491728544235, -0.04415968060493469, -0.062494970858097076, 0.0032753259874880314, -0.008006315678358078, 0.035137198865413666, 0.0025974875316023827, -0.02363516576588154, -0.011132646352052689, 0.013777789659798145, 0.032370809465646744, -0.010137403383851051, 0.07797887921333313, -0.00021094217663630843 ]
3,576
Strong Model Collapse
https://openreview.net/forum?id=et5l9qPUhm
[ "Elvis Dohmatob", "Yunzhen Feng", "Arjun Subramonian", "Julia Kempe" ]
Spotlight
Within the scaling laws paradigm, which underpins the training of large neural networks like ChatGPT and Llama, we consider a supervised regression setting and establish a strong form of the model collapse phenomenon, a critical performance degradation due to synthetic data in the training corpus. Our results show that even the smallest fraction of synthetic data (e.g., as little as 1 per 1000) can still lead to model collapse: larger and larger training sets do not enhance performance. We further investigate whether increasing model size, an approach aligned with current trends in training large language models, exacerbates or mitigates model collapse. In a simplified regime where neural networks are approximated via random projections of tunable size, we both theoretically and empirically show that larger models can amplify model collapse. Interestingly, our theory also indicates that, beyond the interpolation threshold (which can be extremely high for very large datasets), larger models may mitigate the collapse, although they do not entirely prevent it. Our theoretical findings are empirically verified through experiments on language models and neural networks for images.
Model Collapse, Regression, High dimensional asymptotics, Synthetic Data, Scaling Laws
We provide an exact characterization of model collapse for mixing original and AI-generated data in the regression setting; even a small (but constant) fraction of synthetic data is detrimental asymptotically. We also study the impact of model size.
4,448
2410.04840
[ -0.029426807537674904, -0.02508070319890976, -0.002062887419015169, 0.04186759889125824, 0.037999264895915985, 0.024655556306242943, 0.023519165813922882, 0.006180251017212868, -0.048928193747997284, -0.01696372963488102, -0.005070083308964968, 0.021904585883021355, -0.07481405884027481, 0.026002896949648857, -0.0044866944663226604, 0.05614466220140457, 0.03749917447566986, -0.019408049061894417, 0.017301218584179878, 0.049559611827135086, -0.00823766365647316, -0.02458135411143303, 0.006313876248896122, 0.02191242389380932, 0.022879328578710556, -0.027657225728034973, -0.003049435093998909, -0.004070519004017115, -0.01596718095242977, -0.005782832391560078, 0.04806986823678017, -0.003738017985597253, 0.012128747999668121, -0.020533086732029915, 0.03759479895234108, 0.012717986479401588, -0.05113432556390762, 0.011323272250592709, -0.0114511176943779, 0.027456704527139664, -0.044954072684049606, 0.023911399766802788, -0.024464845657348633, 0.012493719346821308, -0.0672028511762619, -0.01242739800363779, -0.10163088142871857, 0.040475621819496155, 0.02956361137330532, -0.038958124816417694, -0.12882192432880402, 0.04651685804128647, 0.002275411505252123, -0.010610193014144897, 0.014513772912323475, 0.03059522807598114, 0.04732644930481911, -0.08308909088373184, -0.01080556120723486, -0.05167706683278084, -0.03157877177000046, 0.03797992318868637, 0.009967934340238571, -0.010057926177978516, -0.009076173417270184, -0.023985419422388077, 0.013445121236145496, 0.0409516915678978, -0.07371173799037933, -0.04644643887877464, -0.025641052052378654, 0.020990410819649696, -0.01910584419965744, -0.006559412460774183, -0.014050721190869808, -0.03886152058839798, 0.01407795399427414, 0.025840111076831818, 0.07991384714841843, -0.00057843083050102, -0.004074492491781712, 0.0019293436780571938, 0.03350021317601204, 0.03958487510681152, 0.009571332484483719, -0.0006866283365525305, -0.03604530543088913, -0.03670515492558479, -0.08875042200088501, 0.0401637926697731, -0.015473934821784496, -0.03755464777350426, -0.01419101096689701, 0.027413610368967056, -0.023635225370526314, 0.038466762751340866, 0.006047103088349104, 0.018045740202069283, -0.009061542339622974, 0.01011362299323082, -0.033057715743780136, -0.04376405104994774, 0.017959320917725563, 0.016552332788705826, -0.11826134473085403, -0.018265392631292343, -0.00894865207374096, 0.003325125202536583, 0.016770988702774048, -0.021188225597143173, -0.04911122843623161, -0.005878945346921682, -0.0025601305533200502, -0.023961178958415985, -0.09132200479507446, 0.009941025637090206, -0.004344932734966278, 0.020763127133250237, -0.004751563537865877, -0.003968796227127314, 0.021158818155527115, 0.022240063175559044, 0.013041132129728794, 0.07269023358821869, -0.029356295242905617, 0.020590461790561676, 0.018274366855621338, 0.030669450759887695, -0.040503062307834625, -0.022744951769709587, 0.007695057429373264, 0.028903041034936905, -0.001232132432051003, 0.009279627352952957, 0.0268113873898983, -0.009762933477759361, 0.014870354905724525, 0.015072925016283989, 0.009183826856315136, -0.02236984483897686, 0.029419677332043648, -0.006737944204360247, 0.06313129514455795, -0.006977175362408161, 0.07371025532484055, 0.007712854538112879, -0.015676327049732208, -0.03582790493965149, -0.04548784717917442, -0.019801810383796692, 0.021057436242699623, 0.00020790915004909039, -0.02891700342297554, -0.05110334977507591, 0.05447559058666229, 0.05777871981263161, -0.010697517544031143, 0.0037123628426343203, 0.012733419425785542, 0.014613093808293343, 0.027213741093873978, -0.0126950703561306, -0.002907265443354845, 0.009530627168715, 0.01229922566562891, -0.03972826525568962, 0.03024311363697052, 0.021536311134696007, -0.03286720812320709, 0.03614328056573868, -0.04000554606318474, -0.026494288817048073, 0.08161097019910812, -0.012075178325176239, -0.033896882086992264, -0.01535071525722742, 0.06731502711772919, 0.016793042421340942, 0.025314979255199432, 0.03951920568943024, -0.0812113955616951, 0.01993400603532791, 0.027700792998075485, 0.007645904086530209, -0.018186932429671288, -0.038307640701532364, 0.10795144736766815, -0.03604135662317276, 0.015470271930098534, 0.015028904192149639, -0.0782572403550148, -0.0053278543055057526, 0.023960646241903305, -0.015716010704636574, 0.07709349691867828, -0.004323635715991259, -0.02362574078142643, 0.03162708505988121, 0.05527874454855919, 0.040171731263399124, 0.051296815276145935, -0.01107926294207573, 0.05393070727586746, -0.016767118126153946, -0.04321414977312088, -0.006914621684700251, 0.02252304181456566, -0.06023861840367317, -0.061191707849502563, 0.03397621586918831, -0.041214484721422195, -0.029085293412208557, 0.014997421763837337, -0.012122714892029762, 0.03505798801779747, 0.013100449927151203, -0.007936007343232632, -0.007883705198764801, 0.008981424383819103, -0.034983132034540176, 0.022019093856215477, 0.0015652936417609453, -0.016982248052954674, 0.0001863590005086735, -0.016360070556402206, 0.0919698104262352, 0.06525343656539917, 0.0015216985484585166, -0.004359525628387928, -0.010607588104903698, 0.014269880950450897, -0.005587324965745211, 0.022331852465867996, 0.0032038444187492132, 0.02214675024151802, -0.026508260518312454, -0.009644421748816967, -0.02469608001410961, 0.04396262392401695, -0.04528677836060524, -0.006281379610300064, 0.06381090730428696, -0.007823417894542217, 0.05903495475649834, -0.019510244950652122, 0.020720573142170906, 0.0657547190785408, -0.03526756167411804, -0.03831344097852707, -0.03299535810947418, -0.003383937757462263, -0.001062612165696919, 0.004358978010714054, 0.002564634196460247, 0.010977761819958687, -0.04007892310619354, -0.044410135596990585, -0.028491981327533722, 0.0726458802819252, 0.05030161142349243, 0.020408030599355698, 0.006954618263989687, -0.01691308617591858, -0.022303108125925064, -0.008315195329487324, -0.11770812422037125, -0.019220875576138496, -0.02692120149731636, 0.0639006495475769, 0.008513697423040867, 0.044050611555576324, 0.00270853447727859, 0.018530717119574547, -0.031528688967227936, -0.008007213473320007, 0.00025297803222201765, 0.028074510395526886, 0.015486868098378181, -0.053340762853622437, -0.011510559357702732, 0.005606365855783224, 0.08633874356746674, -0.0002574037353042513, -0.05038031190633774, -0.052408792078495026, -0.03355162590742111, -0.012407817877829075, -0.044980209320783615, -0.000023560589397675358, -0.005141043569892645, 0.014681201428174973, 0.018379706889390945, -0.007956736721098423, 0.01466932613402605, 0.028273876756429672, 0.060828763991594315, 0.04969654232263565, 0.0026203757151961327, -0.010965983383357525, 0.0458863228559494, -0.03112395852804184, 0.01603413186967373, -0.028888056054711342, 0.033405937254428864, -0.017975613474845886, 0.008129565045237541, 0.023126140236854553, 0.026157839223742485, -0.2684119641780853, 0.00873078964650631, 0.03367424011230469, -0.02863704040646553, 0.01912270113825798, -0.0224732868373394, 0.04778973385691643, -0.030998703092336655, -0.033579371869564056, -0.005106130614876747, 0.005826843436807394, 0.027234647423028946, -0.01643342152237892, 0.057151567190885544, 0.01996471919119358, 0.03698049113154411, 0.029174156486988068, -0.011699280701577663, 0.012706930749118328, 0.04665525630116463, -0.006889270152896643, -0.04744841158390045, -0.008732178248465061, 0.07192152738571167, -0.022785669192671776, 0.05938059836626053, -0.07246971130371094, -0.0210260022431612, -0.04072216525673866, 0.001988777657970786, 0.012375004589557648, -0.031908322125673294, -0.01811969093978405, 0.07244189083576202, -0.006955306511372328, 0.04352698102593422, 0.03611188009381294, 0.008869129233062267, 0.01741400547325611, 0.017634179443120956, 0.008985687047243118, -0.017838090658187866, -0.01182573102414608, 0.0046411058865487576, 0.08361721783876419, -0.006682551931589842, -0.021129511296749115, 0.013945252634584904, -0.030719496309757233, 0.017403870820999146, -0.008140030317008495, -0.04169232398271561, -0.00910912174731493, 0.002721235854551196, 0.03426847234368324, 0.012126009911298752, -0.014638029038906097, -0.013784375041723251, -0.014673453755676746, 0.02359655499458313, 0.0073391590267419815, -0.05842018872499466, -0.01668202504515648, -0.036934707313776016, -0.011439187452197075, -0.02278919517993927, -0.07363908737897873, -0.05677541717886925, 0.02721419557929039, 0.04074789956212044, -0.02831175923347473, 0.026844527572393417, -0.0036273538134992123, -0.08669496327638626, 0.013182288967072964, -0.0007677762187086046, -0.009977948851883411, -0.00939930323511362, -0.010963238775730133, 0.05691032484173775, -0.04767962172627449, -0.03215828537940979, 0.00929212011396885, -0.021518023684620857, 0.023073317483067513, -0.012085250578820705, 0.004967107903212309, -0.008898571133613586, -0.020437253639101982, -0.030728254467248917, 0.036382656544446945, 0.007575191091746092, 0.038070064038038254, 0.01130696851760149, 0.053845178335905075, 0.030062619596719742, 0.02181420475244522, 0.06197115778923035, 0.019768621772527695, 0.01707369089126587, 0.020646901801228523, -0.06937886774539948, -0.0056985002011060715, -0.05171798914670944, -0.03654755651950836, 0.04189632833003998, -0.05761438608169556, -0.02811896614730358, 0.014996923506259918, -0.0016014983411878347, -0.022265443578362465, -0.036679819226264954, -0.023710941895842552, -0.01149406936019659, -0.043322715908288956, -0.010473789647221565, -0.000570968259125948, 0.03803910315036774, 0.033502303063869476, -0.03239504247903824, -0.02097165770828724, 0.06645675748586655, -0.021357975900173187, 0.010718460194766521, -0.0073881628923118114, -0.013555819168686867, 0.030467195436358452, -0.0034027632791548967, -0.02957139164209366, -0.018785905092954636, -0.01965867541730404, 0.03611863777041435, 0.015509439632296562, 0.01628284342586994, 0.06582793593406677, 0.03323032334446907, 0.007250236347317696, -0.03147367388010025, 0.028958246111869812, -0.005135491956025362, 0.004663859494030476, 0.011489453725516796, 0.023368071764707565, 0.0009879671270027757, -0.002120949560776353, 0.016201801598072052, 0.04269785434007645, 0.0015827511670067906, 0.023924926295876503, 0.007316608913242817, 0.026369616389274597, -0.06120867282152176, -0.013052432797849178, -0.01573166437447071, -0.006279332097619772, -0.001945397350937128, 0.014158157631754875, 0.005474884528666735, 0.010844900272786617, -0.07381235063076019, 0.04651438072323799, 0.0084068076685071, -0.04747696965932846, -0.0047355955466628075, 0.0012681464431807399, 0.04853184148669243, -0.031361714005470276, 0.0059206816367805, 0.036752548068761826, -0.003965021576732397, 0.003730123396962881, -0.005095707718282938, -0.025408832356333733, -0.012886124663054943, 0.010286596603691578, 0.018450502306222916, 0.0014205507468432188, 0.009759576059877872, -0.009473076090216637, 0.03941512107849121, 0.03558184579014778, -0.01799405924975872, -0.006141771096736193, -0.0026956982910633087, 0.057946886867284775, 0.03988944739103317, -0.0033373774494975805, 0.04090041667222977, -0.053693823516368866, 0.046925775706768036, -0.020901616662740707, -0.010294820182025433, -0.009394858032464981, -0.01105600968003273, -0.03547699749469757, -0.016123900189995766, 0.013676169328391552, 0.02024080976843834, -0.0010582522954791784, 0.028545865789055824, 0.012231726199388504, 0.0007185132126323879, -0.05785170942544937, -0.01449552457779646, 0.007153496146202087, -0.09378641098737717, -0.0014649517834186554, 0.021519696339964867, -0.0035980897955596447, 0.04555603489279747, -0.021307146176695824, -0.005172723904252052, -0.07945982366800308, -0.007059119176119566, 0.04762531444430351, -0.03930211439728737, -0.012896118685603142, -0.0016905987868085504, 0.026807671412825584, -0.030266007408499718, 0.02377253584563732, -0.020992230623960495, -0.0028400940354913473, -0.03630254790186882, 0.008205359801650047, 0.050867121666669846, -0.022543253377079964, 0.024676019325852394, 0.010739860124886036, -0.05060310661792755, 0.03894434869289398, -0.05259750783443451, -0.007913205772638321, 0.05613800138235092, -0.004443475976586342, -0.0003779628314077854, -0.011163844726979733, 0.04862098768353462, -0.015377577394247055, -0.005222476087510586, 0.001100278226658702, 0.014253783039748669, -0.02684052288532257, 0.029461948201060295, -0.012617194093763828, 0.05465889722108841, 0.0020029470324516296, 0.0077420431189239025, 0.002632347634062171, -0.005266000982373953, 0.03109523467719555, 0.027623722329735756, -0.09165892004966736, -0.004308575764298439, 0.0735313668847084, -0.03025415912270546, -0.02449493296444416, -0.08247727900743484, -0.018467731773853302, 0.011877194978296757, -0.011967366561293602, 0.029643870890140533, -0.04083826020359993, 0.027652466669678688, 0.023055030032992363, 0.0431811548769474, 0.009332344867289066, -0.026706639677286148, 0.05590830743312836, -0.057175084948539734, -0.018462859094142914, -0.046115342527627945, -0.05123176425695419, 0.04741085693240166, -0.006767114158719778, 0.012362625449895859, 0.0004212087078485638, -0.027381736785173416, 0.015134226530790329, -0.015685947611927986, -0.05235123634338379, 0.027252908796072006, -0.020548781380057335, -0.01569129154086113, 0.014978392980992794, -0.04271519184112549, -0.0110469413921237, -0.03790147230029106, -0.05812781676650047, -0.005595840513706207, 0.002833931241184473, 0.05372922122478485, -0.02044273354113102, 0.009766520000994205, -0.01758473925292492, 0.005917166825383902, 0.03054174780845642, 0.060865528881549835, 0.060530632734298706, 0.014148165471851826, -0.01905812695622444, 0.058959271758794785, 0.021400801837444305, 0.008126785978674889, -0.020174114033579826, -0.010146097280085087, -0.011341620236635208, -0.08138205111026764, 0.05643803998827934, 0.011534527875483036, -0.011187447234988213, -0.031160609796643257, 0.05072325840592384, 0.05152544751763344, -0.051713403314352036, -0.0039708251133561134, 0.021652044728398323, -0.05464799329638481, 0.009957844391465187, -0.014464988373219967, -0.0014772848226130009, -0.008148782886564732, 0.06575018167495728, 0.007034871261566877, 0.03211779147386551, 0.05971163511276245, -0.0022901450283825397, -0.021014651283621788, -0.01595381088554859, 0.05178256332874298, 0.04769524559378624, 0.05288591980934143, 0.012514304369688034, 0.048956479877233505, -0.03405715897679329, -0.06348420679569244, 0.01169306505471468, 0.01623828150331974, -0.00655906880274415, -0.06645286083221436, 0.01805572770535946, 0.06864906847476959, -0.023729270324110985, 0.0812874510884285, -0.0418103002011776, 0.01180734857916832, 0.00969872996211052, -0.009346628561615944, -0.020790111273527145, 0.03818579390645027, 0.03982117772102356, -0.004675428848713636, -0.013672370463609695, -0.03656497597694397, 0.01794796995818615, -0.018222471699118614, 0.011473587714135647, 0.014514151960611343, -0.004121004603803158, -0.0053109461441636086, -0.0069986553862690926, 0.08906029164791107, 0.10139043629169464, -0.033925872296094894, -0.01588749885559082, 0.019024156033992767, 0.019671976566314697, 0.0067491838708519936, 0.04179047793149948, 0.003372537437826395, -0.04485534876585007, 0.02138368971645832, -0.028139978647232056, -0.0005043612327426672, 0.006651785224676132, -0.01575537957251072, -0.005490915384143591, -0.015937231481075287, -0.044986795634031296, 0.00900545995682478, 0.016128376126289368, -0.05473540723323822, -0.0427209809422493, -0.03397504985332489, -0.05600334703922272, -0.05324714630842209, -0.03897501900792122, 0.012538844719529152, -0.01981218345463276, -0.02073545940220356, 0.003218855243176222, -0.05778377875685692, -0.007527816109359264, 0.053408220410346985, -0.052167441695928574, -0.0015434017404913902, 0.05152799189090729, -0.002767010359093547, -0.016873963177204132, 0.048440802842378616, 0.03354053944349289, 0.0017012403113767505, -0.027457840740680695, 0.05617060139775276, 0.026351137086749077, 0.022628875449299812, 0.014199658297002316, 0.0011226637288928032, -0.11076747626066208, -0.017204588279128075, 0.002456109505146742, -0.062104351818561554, -0.07776952534914017, 0.044164158403873444, -0.02283969148993492, 0.018109209835529327, 0.05645880848169327, 0.016921382397413254, 0.023519234731793404, -0.036319028586149216, -0.0036920090205967426, -0.03029143624007702, 0.0246127936989069, 0.031971462070941925, 0.003548199078068137, 0.04174500331282616, 0.04795698821544647, -0.014953592792153358, -0.0524081289768219, 0.02160576730966568, -0.022980734705924988, 0.013305115513503551, -0.019985077902674675, -0.01817791722714901, -0.01655476726591587, -0.0916009470820427, -0.009138044901192188, 0.0245526023209095, -0.012201236560940742, -0.027357984334230423, -0.030659625306725502, -0.02177019603550434, -0.0033384899143129587, -0.02185136266052723, -0.017822371795773506, -0.016871599480509758, -0.0496794655919075, -0.03632684797048569, -0.07608462870121002, 0.01915307715535164, -0.01843547448515892, 0.01180545799434185, -0.042200587689876556, -0.05170885846018791, -0.0009438871056772768, -0.006047261878848076, 0.058817408978939056, -0.02645559422671795, 0.02643931284546852, -0.005073653068393469 ]
3,577
DRoP: Distributionally Robust Data Pruning
https://openreview.net/forum?id=fxv0FfmDAg
[ "Artem M Vysogorets", "Kartik Ahuja", "Julia Kempe" ]
Spotlight
In the era of exceptionally data-hungry models, careful selection of the training data is essential to mitigate the extensive costs of deep learning. Data pruning offers a solution by removing redundant or uninformative samples from the dataset, which yields faster convergence and improved neural scaling laws. However, little is known about its impact on classification bias of the trained models. We conduct the first systematic study of this effect and reveal that existing data pruning algorithms can produce highly biased classifiers. We present theoretical analysis of the classification risk in a mixture of Gaussians to argue that choosing appropriate class pruning ratios, coupled with random pruning within classes has potential to improve worst-class performance. We thus propose DRoP, a distributionally robust approach to pruning and empirically demonstrate its performance on standard computer vision benchmarks. In sharp contrast to existing algorithms, our proposed method continues improving distributional robustness at a tolerable drop of average performance as we prune more from the datasets.
Data Pruning, Classification Bias, Robustness
We find that existing data pruning algorithms exacerbate classification bias and propose a simple robustness-aware random pruning protocol to address this deficiency.
4,435
2404.05579
[ 0.007208031136542559, -0.01538738515228033, -0.018391219899058342, 0.04904305189847946, 0.030978064984083176, 0.04500577971339226, 0.0004411041736602783, -0.016546957194805145, -0.012200605124235153, -0.04750290885567665, -0.02369023859500885, -0.012186598964035511, -0.07505015283823013, 0.012353053316473961, 0.003382307244464755, 0.049856796860694885, 0.02263464406132698, -0.01511235348880291, -0.0055591813288629055, 0.048010002821683884, 0.014105172827839851, -0.061559807509183884, 0.01718946546316147, 0.03544824570417404, 0.019067659974098206, -0.030190488323569298, 0.028750767931342125, 0.02062307856976986, -0.004839600529521704, 0.018820248544216156, 0.04812796041369438, 0.0108436718583107, 0.009543453343212605, -0.03609755262732506, 0.02718951925635338, 0.02550455741584301, -0.03793717548251152, 0.00750162685289979, 0.0024447974283248186, 0.04556815326213837, -0.020773189142346382, -0.0049245343543589115, -0.026850378140807152, -0.001975828781723976, -0.06758351624011993, 0.011708131991326809, -0.10631626844406128, 0.03648928925395012, 0.006035779602825642, -0.016471009701490402, -0.10430416464805603, 0.050355251878499985, 0.0024715850595384836, -0.02286369726061821, -0.008364061824977398, 0.039794206619262695, 0.048833657056093216, -0.07935710996389389, -0.004049007780849934, -0.07216522842645645, -0.03702746331691742, -0.002448313869535923, 0.027984773740172386, 0.0019092302536591887, -0.011537715792655945, -0.031916458159685135, 0.02796510048210621, 0.06620646268129349, -0.04252886027097702, -0.054734356701374054, -0.006695178337395191, -0.0028707643505185843, -0.01503663044422865, 0.014024457894265652, -0.01045615691691637, -0.05135506018996239, 0.013105045072734356, 0.014996538870036602, 0.09650114178657532, -0.0007807461079210043, 0.017588254064321518, -0.01600208319723606, 0.01758686453104019, 0.06812535226345062, 0.008708097971975803, -0.004406175576150417, -0.04217791184782982, -0.05351213738322258, -0.052068162709474564, 0.03153044357895851, -0.008544902317225933, -0.016156556084752083, 0.041853923350572586, 0.034306902438402176, 0.015799637883901596, 0.026126084849238396, 0.008743531070649624, -0.022337837144732475, 0.009869853034615517, -0.0005402280949056149, -0.01131595391780138, -0.05173387750983238, 0.037734709680080414, 0.01767459698021412, -0.09534241259098053, -0.0008045819704420865, -0.0047291056253015995, -0.007080589886754751, -0.00955266784876585, 0.0120230782777071, -0.014909024350345135, 0.013157300651073456, 0.0106451865285635, 0.00010941601067315787, -0.10819297283887863, 0.004573429469019175, -0.001914649037644267, -0.002072131261229515, 0.0054872711189091206, -0.030120834708213806, 0.06031288951635361, 0.03959579020738602, 0.011478502303361893, 0.06546740233898163, -0.01706131361424923, 0.0008612123201601207, 0.03346087783575058, 0.03330286964774132, -0.00009922621393343434, -0.03621555119752884, 0.018153246492147446, 0.02099423296749592, 0.0031687880400568247, 0.004397388081997633, -0.009728513658046722, -0.004467057064175606, -0.012082112953066826, 0.05494414269924164, 0.031864721328020096, -0.024109475314617157, 0.0034913732670247555, -0.011559183709323406, 0.026723945513367653, -0.03717046603560448, 0.05402841418981552, -0.009940816089510918, 0.021343212574720383, -0.015746142715215683, -0.0133504718542099, -0.022272871807217598, 0.007342551834881306, 0.01817934960126877, -0.020034780725836754, -0.0872214138507843, 0.0013967429986223578, 0.04236221686005592, -0.030880194157361984, 0.035406310111284256, 0.0070617967285215855, 0.013301365077495575, 0.0005175192491151392, -0.012729478999972343, -0.035452116280794144, -0.0020530892070382833, -0.0028715014923363924, -0.05544488504528999, 0.06042609363794327, 0.014030372723937035, -0.05035442113876343, 0.010635515674948692, -0.03707686811685562, -0.032524727284908295, 0.06867522746324539, -0.0038544507697224617, -0.016410762444138527, 0.020893771201372147, 0.06181773543357849, 0.006094461306929588, 0.01083608902990818, 0.03640715777873993, -0.09245722740888596, 0.03871236741542816, 0.009565317071974277, -0.005894176196306944, -0.027405787259340286, -0.02160712331533432, 0.08588863164186478, -0.023128721863031387, 0.056725483387708664, 0.023058656603097916, -0.0876317173242569, -0.016414672136306763, -0.002558126114308834, -0.0009974446147680283, 0.06922407448291779, 0.04011113941669464, -0.013060387223958969, -0.001828579930588603, 0.023682966828346252, 0.03460998833179474, 0.06916783004999161, -0.056459907442331314, 0.02907782606780529, -0.026102101430296898, -0.056339964270591736, -0.0056904894299805164, -0.008335055783390999, -0.042768966406583786, -0.022112825885415077, 0.020707981660962105, -0.020977091044187546, -0.018247157335281372, -0.009736047126352787, 0.0035097221843898296, 0.051015157252550125, -0.008941931650042534, -0.03300205618143082, 0.005584011785686016, 0.011250237934291363, -0.055735018104314804, 0.05298571288585663, 0.014862687326967716, -0.018030870705842972, 0.004334008786827326, 0.009860800579190254, 0.08930475264787674, 0.06034814938902855, 0.01243454497307539, 0.051125191152095795, -0.005729345139116049, 0.006379372905939817, 0.0015295566990971565, 0.004811657592654228, -0.030106427147984505, 0.004365693312138319, -0.018097596243023872, -0.0004448181134648621, -0.0553816482424736, 0.06787879019975662, -0.03084278292953968, -0.005974066909402609, 0.07554292678833008, 0.01214421447366476, 0.04807690158486366, 0.023446451872587204, 0.0065153976902365685, 0.05688540264964104, -0.014583028852939606, 0.008548074401915073, -0.05369799584150314, -0.015073169954121113, 0.02203267440199852, -0.013927290216088295, -0.05062215030193329, 0.0004830617399420589, -0.014798176474869251, -0.0028349843341857195, 0.0025980877690017223, 0.07665003836154938, 0.05868005380034447, -0.0038445349782705307, 0.0013638518285006285, -0.01610337197780609, -0.01630874164402485, -0.011195200495421886, -0.1259959191083908, -0.039341434836387634, 0.01689363829791546, 0.06151413172483444, 0.01098829135298729, 0.050345636904239655, 0.0005833851173520088, 0.027226854115724564, -0.01376170665025711, -0.015957148745656013, -0.01453131902962923, 0.02497796155512333, 0.048045601695775986, -0.03215724974870682, -0.014490900561213493, 0.0008238750160671771, 0.055603861808776855, -0.017129769548773766, 0.0045770928263664246, -0.04573307931423187, -0.042010292410850525, 0.028165841475129128, -0.0014353609876707196, -0.02653246931731701, 0.02008764073252678, 0.04398791119456291, 0.03527515381574631, -0.024546610191464424, -0.004343557637184858, 0.06027831882238388, 0.09131259471178055, 0.04634507745504379, -0.00474154856055975, -0.015901852399110794, 0.03056786023080349, -0.02411559224128723, 0.05040053278207779, -0.011873087845742702, 0.02518114633858204, -0.0242308396846056, -0.032284241169691086, 0.028719577938318253, 0.003048055339604616, -0.268632173538208, -0.004659691359847784, 0.035261981189250946, 0.02244143933057785, -0.001964789582416415, -0.05379756912589073, 0.008881100453436375, -0.012416365556418896, -0.005438508465886116, 0.00059040094492957, 0.0054186126217246056, 0.011468772776424885, 0.023345068097114563, 0.06333086639642715, 0.051611967384815216, 0.046645306050777435, 0.03350798040628433, -0.009203015826642513, 0.01933564618229866, 0.03722415491938591, -0.01629520393908024, -0.08329661935567856, -0.020571457222104073, 0.027827663347125053, -0.019518930464982986, 0.05505531653761864, -0.030393794178962708, -0.0012068763608112931, -0.030340608209371567, -0.01857239566743374, -0.005281816702336073, -0.01596425287425518, 0.005119713954627514, 0.04353182762861252, 0.031776878982782364, -0.0034125945530831814, 0.039012230932712555, 0.018778596073389053, 0.029627829790115356, 0.055596526712179184, 0.027727626264095306, -0.0035757594741880894, -0.0019282865105196834, 0.011482375673949718, 0.07443204522132874, 0.020434653386473656, -0.035649511963129044, -0.005130942910909653, -0.014312411658465862, 0.011521606706082821, 0.002309876959770918, -0.049213070422410965, -0.019818689674139023, 0.0021988353691995144, -0.00515309302136302, -0.002375009236857295, -0.0190108772367239, 0.013050433248281479, -0.01711111329495907, 0.04165158420801163, 0.022840997204184532, -0.048765916377305984, 0.02821073681116104, -0.0576898455619812, -0.020206838846206665, -0.034562140703201294, -0.05457427725195885, -0.05912911519408226, 0.05389232188463211, 0.010657072067260742, -0.016314834356307983, 0.009121472015976906, 0.004951734561473131, -0.09003429114818573, 0.05346927046775818, 0.008500296622514725, -0.004717645701020956, -0.00884948205202818, -0.002327363006770611, 0.05860904976725578, -0.020586300641298294, -0.06779415160417557, 0.024689780548214912, 0.004135431256145239, -0.008077219128608704, -0.030803220346570015, 0.008020291104912758, -0.013272099196910858, 0.014921925961971283, -0.01870197057723999, 0.030699001625180244, 0.007908538915216923, 0.02240389585494995, 0.0053894734010100365, 0.045998189598321915, 0.05970160663127899, 0.035787392407655716, 0.06418491899967194, 0.011189962737262249, 0.03952345252037048, -0.005901982542127371, -0.07498542964458466, -0.04817894473671913, -0.061426520347595215, -0.0282612107694149, 0.03450009226799011, -0.026906592771410942, 0.014479012228548527, 0.024642502889037132, -0.036487139761447906, 0.008056745864450932, -0.052988480776548386, -0.007307915948331356, -0.03064660355448723, 0.005415907129645348, -0.023058801889419556, 0.00027438794495537877, 0.0133478669449687, 0.020364176481962204, -0.05597057566046715, -0.014398780651390553, 0.03418635576963425, -0.010864609852433205, -0.0008638344006612897, -0.001942570204846561, -0.019090261310338974, 0.013012358918786049, -0.004507757723331451, -0.01786736398935318, -0.04785381630063057, 0.032563209533691406, 0.03865320235490799, -0.01731276884675026, 0.014050176367163658, 0.03183605149388313, 0.010456905700266361, -0.017535388469696045, -0.007880434393882751, 0.042381394654512405, -0.008786424994468689, 0.018222441896796227, 0.008854680694639683, 0.01568274199962616, 0.045214779675006866, 0.025635259225964546, -0.0026136457454413176, -0.013567334972321987, -0.008646653033792973, -0.009124291129410267, -0.02936536818742752, -0.026561086997389793, -0.04646049067378044, 0.0037510362453758717, -0.022894075140357018, -0.02250329777598381, 0.003476920537650585, 0.03258433938026428, -0.0221488606184721, -0.0237008985131979, -0.055026523768901825, 0.046554695814847946, 0.039861928671598434, -0.03475964441895485, -0.02569333277642727, -0.0034254826605319977, 0.026494095101952553, -0.003168281866237521, -0.032650042325258255, 0.019687538966536522, -0.0002792355080600828, -0.0020531744230538607, 0.006174938753247261, -0.029453588649630547, -0.03298238664865494, -0.008132937364280224, -0.01963634230196476, 0.018836170434951782, 0.0036667538806796074, -0.057669274508953094, 0.05352624133229256, 0.005237167235463858, -0.008880602195858955, -0.02479800581932068, 0.0076258196495473385, 0.06902230530977249, 0.017803892493247986, -0.029116744175553322, 0.004710848443210125, -0.041750259697437286, 0.04323043301701546, -0.031757328659296036, 0.023636387661099434, -0.0034778073895722628, -0.023874931037425995, -0.023257317021489143, -0.02310527302324772, 0.012471131049096584, 0.011980842798948288, -0.024236109107732773, -0.0049805836752057076, -0.0048887156881392, 0.024878233671188354, -0.0379210039973259, -0.030618509277701378, 0.0017566406168043613, -0.08226229250431061, 0.02704028971493244, 0.06965212523937225, -0.05291229113936424, 0.02524242363870144, -0.026977745816111565, -0.032980840653181076, -0.05446380376815796, -0.022898197174072266, 0.023482993245124817, -0.028171531856060028, -0.008993648923933506, 0.008655083365738392, 0.006745453458279371, -0.036153972148895264, -0.016240982338786125, -0.024490222334861755, 0.017639974132180214, 0.0272661242634058, 0.02187693677842617, 0.07201746106147766, -0.022368336096405983, -0.0019048481481149793, -0.005725636146962643, -0.007435831241309643, -0.012211046181619167, -0.04285987839102745, 0.012692746706306934, 0.039651330560445786, -0.0077246129512786865, 0.01333407312631607, -0.04575815051794052, 0.025592058897018433, -0.04091271013021469, -0.02189449965953827, -0.006156104616820812, 0.017418842762708664, -0.02743222936987877, -0.0044660987332463264, 0.008260730654001236, 0.017463644966483116, 0.0013499876949936152, -0.0009175006416626275, 0.023718243464827538, 0.010624502785503864, 0.0520712286233902, 0.027555100619792938, -0.06801638752222061, -0.008682843297719955, 0.06243937835097313, -0.03623982518911362, -0.02598489820957184, -0.10956364870071411, -0.013242878019809723, 0.029068728908896446, -0.016677675768733025, 0.013796452432870865, -0.0038147594314068556, 0.02355806529521942, 0.013650457374751568, 0.04778389632701874, -0.017868150025606155, -0.007159773726016283, 0.007304799742996693, -0.06526918709278107, -0.022400809451937675, -0.04049491882324219, -0.03788246586918831, 0.0626748725771904, -0.047318197786808014, 0.036690227687358856, 0.012084144167602062, -0.0477943941950798, 0.03335320204496384, -0.03286048397421837, -0.07451533526182175, 0.010229596868157387, -0.017980920150876045, -0.01192533876746893, -0.00928068533539772, -0.010907837189733982, 0.008778736926615238, -0.0034584233071655035, -0.03729230910539627, 0.0010930841090157628, 0.015223145484924316, 0.05864042788743973, -0.013297819532454014, 0.009212575852870941, -0.04630284011363983, 0.020896021276712418, 0.02008715830743313, 0.05323057994246483, -0.006653838325291872, 0.023280171677470207, -0.03588547930121422, 0.044334881007671356, 0.03040989302098751, -0.018164174631237984, 0.000821154797449708, 0.008748659864068031, 0.022441623732447624, -0.03906827047467232, 0.04632367566227913, -0.024862827733159065, -0.009966657496988773, -0.055223364382982254, 0.06562963873147964, 0.034894347190856934, -0.08260136842727661, -0.038034841418266296, 0.0514984130859375, -0.030432868748903275, 0.023137643933296204, -0.033264823257923126, -0.0348871685564518, -0.009486919268965721, 0.06821297854185104, -0.019270315766334534, 0.03870781511068344, 0.06291612982749939, -0.001698308507911861, -0.0026792087592184544, 0.01696598157286644, 0.04172014072537422, 0.0844767615199089, 0.06904970109462738, -0.023403193801641464, 0.05164665728807449, -0.007510530296713114, -0.044934261590242386, 0.013528261333703995, 0.0048707048408687115, -0.0012267088750377297, -0.042018670588731766, 0.025646144524216652, 0.07878793030977249, 0.010789354331791401, 0.0630543977022171, -0.04654533416032791, -0.007471475750207901, 0.01055640634149313, 0.0003397151012904942, 0.006947971880435944, 0.03695501387119293, 0.01503773219883442, -0.0019540516659617424, -0.006696230266243219, 0.004989154636859894, 0.042690251022577286, -0.014645233750343323, -0.014174829237163067, 0.002373893279582262, -0.025534648448228836, 0.0011401219526305795, -0.004597296938300133, 0.052657708525657654, 0.09122075140476227, -0.03071337565779686, -0.03830542415380478, -0.015452682040631771, 0.05239609628915787, 0.010965798981487751, 0.0450826995074749, 0.012331068515777588, -0.054646704345941544, 0.026135366410017014, -0.04615093767642975, -0.00940069742500782, 0.001658536377362907, 0.015151916071772575, 0.004886924754828215, -0.024283388629555702, -0.04887939617037773, 0.011793579906225204, 0.01953698880970478, -0.015422658063471317, -0.03198390081524849, -0.02212401106953621, 0.00716460170224309, -0.05551476776599884, -0.07082732766866684, 0.022944333031773567, 0.004736112896353006, -0.0022885596845299006, -0.002565547591075301, -0.03639993816614151, 0.015055719763040543, 0.06117018684744835, -0.05021245777606964, 0.004449512809514999, 0.017851315438747406, 0.008600045926868916, -0.016125310212373734, 0.014182615093886852, 0.019141538068652153, -0.012781286612153053, -0.04818976670503616, 0.03569210320711136, -0.003906297497451305, 0.0012176993768662214, 0.007353536318987608, -0.01252831518650055, -0.09929159283638, 0.0002480356488376856, 0.007366255857050419, -0.06217319518327713, -0.09158202260732651, 0.05013107508420944, -0.01859583891928196, 0.0333276204764843, 0.05615749582648277, -0.00039454735815525055, -0.010849288664758205, -0.06509769707918167, -0.019997306168079376, -0.03312595561146736, 0.005876774899661541, 0.05244120955467224, 0.004941464401781559, 0.03889502212405205, 0.03858203440904617, -0.023180069401860237, -0.03721471503376961, 0.028060728684067726, -0.01142403855919838, 0.010865545831620693, -0.037304021418094635, -0.010670368559658527, -0.019487667828798294, -0.09097958356142044, -0.01566096395254135, 0.03189361095428467, -0.029452141374349594, -0.03349735587835312, -0.01388479582965374, -0.033767007291316986, -0.006453944370150566, -0.05680977180600166, -0.010390784591436386, -0.009960243478417397, -0.05587080493569374, -0.02268100716173649, -0.07765266299247742, 0.054349131882190704, -0.0175605658441782, 0.036510396748781204, -0.03374934569001198, -0.056259144097566605, -0.010583940893411636, -0.009849929250776768, 0.019275406375527382, 0.04252876713871956, -0.0004760721349157393, -0.005887562874704599 ]
3,578
Co3Gesture: Towards Coherent Concurrent Co-speech 3D Gesture Generation with Interactive Diffusion
https://openreview.net/forum?id=VaowElpVzd
[ "Xingqun Qi", "Yatian Wang", "Hengyuan Zhang", "Jiahao Pan", "Wei Xue", "Shanghang Zhang", "Wenhan Luo", "Qifeng Liu", "Yike Guo" ]
Spotlight
Generating gestures from human speech has gained tremendous progress in animating virtual avatars. While the existing methods enable synthesizing gestures cooperated by people self-talking, they overlook the practicality of concurrent gesture modeling with two-person interactive conversations. Moreover, the lack of high-quality datasets with concurrent co-speech gestures also limits handling this issue. To fulfill this goal, we first construct a large-scale concurrent co-speech gesture dataset that contains more than 7M frames for diverse two-person interactive posture sequences, dubbed $\textbf{GES-Inter}$. Moreover, we propose Co$^{\mathbf{3}}$Gesture, a novel framework that enables concurrent coherent co-speech gesture synthesis including two-person interactive movements. Our framework is built upon two cooperative generation branches conditioned on decomposed speaker audio. Specifically, to enhance the coordination of human postures w.r.t corresponding speaker audios while interacting with the conversational partner, we present a Temporal-Interaction Module ($\textbf{TIM}$). TIM can effectively model the temporal association representation between two speakers' gesture sequences as interaction guidance and fuse it into the concurrent gesture generation. Then, we devise a mutual attention mechanism to further boost learning dependencies of interacted concurrent motions, thereby enabling us to generate vivid and coherent gestures. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our method outperforms the state-of-the-art models on our newly collected GES-Inter dataset.
3D co-speech gesture generation, human motion modeling
We introduce the new task of concurrent co-speech gesture generation cooperating with one newly collected large-scale dataset named GES-Inter.
4,425
null
[ -0.010826150886714458, -0.002391996094956994, 0.000964270846452564, 0.017145143821835518, 0.011375338770449162, 0.045934513211250305, 0.04445111006498337, 0.028283195570111275, -0.021149691194295883, -0.030330536887049675, -0.014211278408765793, -0.01550882589071989, -0.06239521503448486, 0.0015013525262475014, -0.013993335887789726, 0.033759407699108124, -0.008662018924951553, -0.011403258889913559, 0.005291611887514591, 0.017809774726629257, -0.01900402456521988, -0.0012664827518165112, 0.06509922444820404, -0.008075771853327751, 0.022065142169594765, 0.0024265781976282597, 0.017898129299283028, 0.046703703701496124, -0.03272060304880142, -0.029612477868795395, 0.00021254111197777092, -0.0044290474615991116, 0.028190169483423233, -0.06263885647058487, 0.02682727761566639, -0.010409034788608551, -0.04142431542277336, 0.0497179739177227, 0.010774928145110607, -0.013251867145299911, -0.028331441804766655, -0.007158929016441107, 0.012044914998114109, -0.012112856842577457, -0.02895866148173809, 0.0020374369341880083, -0.09022476524114609, 0.051180656999349594, 0.002143010962754488, -0.04626784846186638, -0.1185121163725853, 0.001827659667469561, 0.011850228533148766, -0.007367309182882309, 0.021703820675611496, 0.017287811264395714, 0.04227738827466965, -0.08862651884555817, 0.01076282374560833, -0.06610894203186035, -0.01250557042658329, 0.03346753865480423, 0.021115288138389587, -0.040933236479759216, -0.006792551372200251, -0.024269534274935722, 0.0032361706253141165, 0.03669307380914688, -0.02445593662559986, -0.042606811970472336, 0.00018003970035351813, 0.02528969943523407, -0.011780132539570332, 0.033421583473682404, 0.0028293596114963293, -0.04411324858665466, 0.026665128767490387, 0.035651858896017075, 0.06245185807347298, -0.05439173802733421, 0.030703961849212646, -0.019195344299077988, 0.026386091485619545, 0.05893281474709511, -0.01755816675722599, 0.010729561559855938, -0.013088718056678772, 0.02443601004779339, -0.07344406843185425, 0.014230485074222088, -0.035842448472976685, -0.04563872143626213, 0.008961516432464123, 0.03995883837342262, 0.015863412991166115, 0.0283370241522789, 0.017018411308526993, 0.016300559043884277, 0.022374533116817474, 0.006467459723353386, -0.017423275858163834, -0.027297493070364, -0.03486861661076546, 0.03193759545683861, -0.079181008040905, -0.017421288415789604, -0.0223857369273901, -0.0005016415379941463, 0.021390818059444427, 0.01072897668927908, -0.06450191140174866, -0.03108670376241207, 0.041663896292448044, -0.0034343653824180365, -0.07957618683576584, 0.07394357025623322, 0.0076039498671889305, 0.021300919353961945, -0.020976029336452484, 0.005364872515201569, 0.07736239582300186, 0.057229746133089066, -0.022549016401171684, 0.05203266441822052, -0.005920406896620989, 0.02453627437353134, 0.0005523199797607958, 0.007070805877447128, -0.026340113952755928, -0.02471292018890381, 0.014443515799939632, 0.03859320655465126, 0.009774652309715748, -0.0003737166989594698, 0.011811560951173306, -0.012831995263695717, 0.01600240357220173, 0.013749752193689346, 0.04868612065911293, 0.01137202512472868, 0.012637470848858356, -0.002170091262087226, 0.057362500578165054, -0.02326325699687004, 0.0694744810461998, -0.007012852467596531, -0.04457478225231171, -0.007861058227717876, -0.02137385681271553, 0.014330236241221428, -0.030761253088712692, -0.05286799743771553, 0.031201867386698723, -0.06869050115346909, 0.02110288292169571, 0.053251516073942184, 0.0740879476070404, 0.013575810939073563, 0.04748397693037987, -0.006886952091008425, 0.022483861073851585, -0.005276993382722139, -0.06112092733383179, -0.009716241620481014, -0.017105702310800552, -0.04197891056537628, -0.015261159278452396, 0.019812775775790215, -0.03542138263583183, -0.014100243337452412, -0.048786308616399765, 0.003644519718363881, 0.010689442045986652, 0.0017029764130711555, 0.010430493392050266, -0.025291509926319122, 0.03755350783467293, 0.002116878516972065, 0.032770488411188126, 0.023929838091135025, -0.08659208565950394, 0.037104856222867966, 0.001468978589400649, -0.018161071464419365, 0.019856659695506096, -0.020029786974191666, 0.08124573528766632, -0.020583564415574074, -0.03620954230427742, 0.006533681880682707, -0.07073347270488739, -0.02601635456085205, 0.04202785715460777, 0.005263091064989567, 0.030910007655620575, 0.005345579236745834, -0.025415459647774696, 0.01349336002022028, 0.06048811972141266, 0.037608757615089417, 0.017715904861688614, -0.014390683732926846, 0.0888347178697586, 0.06620445102453232, -0.015709349885582924, -0.02641194872558117, 0.024789439514279366, -0.0391092374920845, -0.04603634029626846, 0.04333779588341713, -0.010305199772119522, -0.0013629565946757793, 0.026413453742861748, -0.016655398532748222, 0.04066094011068344, 0.007182886358350515, -0.009803895838558674, -0.000990965054370463, -0.03749729320406914, -0.021532809361815453, 0.031726010143756866, 0.043867532163858414, -0.033072516322135925, 0.007202929817140102, -0.017689943313598633, 0.09595870226621628, 0.05755864828824997, -0.01894266903400421, 0.004657917656004429, -0.0034263641573488712, 0.0051772273145616055, 0.017848124727606773, -0.0005007288418710232, -0.03883517161011696, 0.04476189985871315, -0.026303738355636597, 0.05702321231365204, -0.03254885599017143, 0.01881495490670204, -0.03232002630829811, -0.015394508838653564, 0.05491993948817253, -0.0412123017013073, 0.060813650488853455, -0.012040376663208008, 0.025311043485999107, 0.0423412024974823, -0.0012117846636101604, -0.013686719350516796, -0.0042112055234611034, -0.0023358881007879972, 0.0049643986858427525, 0.0067470017820596695, -0.014761860482394695, -0.02521798014640808, -0.026280608028173447, 0.015187152661383152, -0.07328567653894424, 0.04724057763814926, 0.03072403557598591, 0.08977769315242767, 0.010134871117770672, 0.008460965007543564, -0.015602059662342072, -0.05538660287857056, -0.10814299434423447, -0.05644942820072174, -0.024253586307168007, 0.015843193978071213, 0.011129539459943771, 0.04983151704072952, 0.001494981232099235, 0.024244321510195732, -0.04079965502023697, -0.012432169169187546, 0.01372676994651556, 0.0006616802420467138, -0.00945031177252531, -0.031824998557567596, -0.05729673430323601, -0.02157064527273178, 0.06653912365436554, -0.029610013589262962, -0.010057462379336357, -0.013113068416714668, -0.031767167150974274, -0.016597868874669075, 0.00040959290345199406, -0.007810039911419153, 0.01973515748977661, 0.008947844617068768, 0.009786165319383144, -0.013086333870887756, 0.005060915369540453, 0.040344856679439545, 0.047239676117897034, 0.03721599653363228, 0.004156236536800861, -0.053650207817554474, 0.02649880386888981, -0.01959225721657276, 0.005132968071848154, 0.05197557434439659, -0.02022283896803856, -0.029008008539676666, -0.036577366292476654, 0.03723352774977684, -0.03568464145064354, -0.26753997802734375, -0.03156855329871178, 0.020243078470230103, -0.03594484552741051, 0.0239216648042202, 0.017025507986545563, 0.08822068572044373, -0.0638609454035759, -0.03640542924404144, 0.04592713713645935, -0.003665838623419404, 0.047402724623680115, 0.0018041325965896249, 0.03188567981123924, 0.0353827178478241, 0.04863477125763893, -0.053610991686582565, -0.037178073078393936, -0.0021848706528544426, 0.03473260626196861, -0.019273221492767334, -0.05095630884170532, -0.02414705418050289, 0.0119321309030056, 0.000943144375924021, -0.005980620160698891, -0.06258080899715424, -0.008651530370116234, -0.02253754250705242, 0.00586534570902586, 0.025447240099310875, -0.010104597546160221, -0.018826786428689957, 0.05609624460339546, 0.011790180578827858, -0.008398930542171001, 0.0726252943277359, 0.023957442492246628, 0.0462748147547245, -0.034470487385988235, 0.025991830974817276, -0.025360990315675735, -0.00627396535128355, 0.003258944721892476, 0.06961338967084885, -0.012687234207987785, -0.028615262359380722, 0.01164352148771286, -0.03614610433578491, 0.034857723861932755, 0.00610700249671936, -0.04440399259328842, -0.01191741693764925, 0.003668474964797497, 0.004668355919420719, -0.016599159687757492, 0.012663429602980614, 0.005626774858683348, 0.0015621029306203127, 0.032146159559488297, -0.038825783878564835, -0.03110583871603012, -0.039573222398757935, -0.05858459323644638, -0.005060517694801092, -0.04387793317437172, -0.07986918836832047, -0.04401605203747749, 0.05388982966542244, 0.04106701537966728, -0.0011657449649646878, -0.014588036574423313, -0.022266993299126625, -0.10252944380044937, -0.005613172426819801, -0.005370913073420525, -0.005705906078219414, -0.03385242447257042, 0.0022082312498241663, 0.04783278703689575, -0.029368586838245392, -0.04555307328701019, 0.012358731590211391, 0.008489358238875866, 0.04613211378455162, 0.02649850584566593, 0.012906333431601524, -0.04310256615281105, 0.0002494195941835642, -0.019785111770033836, 0.04035061597824097, 0.004897148348391056, -0.003421904519200325, 0.008633280172944069, 0.029225468635559082, 0.02680494636297226, 0.045717258006334305, 0.06484616547822952, 0.030630331486463547, 0.007198081351816654, 0.045521657913923264, -0.07910504937171936, -0.025245342403650284, -0.01802278868854046, 0.0007284673629328609, 0.02039385586977005, -0.05404457822442055, -0.02244766615331173, 0.04568285495042801, 0.0036976204719394445, -0.02369687333703041, -0.004491940140724182, 0.00648779422044754, -0.009299241937696934, 0.002385549945756793, -0.008755304850637913, -0.017107101157307625, 0.048979952931404114, 0.03289663791656494, 0.0016558566130697727, -0.0027643050998449326, 0.0418933741748333, -0.03219052404165268, 0.02048458158969879, -0.01905490830540657, 0.018762929365038872, -0.0590374693274498, -0.025489553809165955, -0.03947365656495094, -0.011140024289488792, 0.020522065460681915, 0.0034466718789190054, -0.004940507467836142, 0.01085561141371727, 0.06043824180960655, -0.022948408499360085, -0.04935301095247269, -0.025889934971928596, 0.01026949007064104, -0.05102206766605377, 0.02742641791701317, -0.020342428237199783, 0.010326527059078217, 0.032481707632541656, 0.008536124601960182, -0.001934747793711722, 0.030164310708642006, -0.015148560516536236, 0.0047482154332101345, -0.0012829202460125089, 0.08805003762245178, -0.038731396198272705, -0.046790480613708496, -0.012726063840091228, -0.006465213838964701, -0.0069411820732057095, -0.004612128250300884, 0.013226913288235664, 0.018158484250307083, -0.03723035380244255, 0.05895330756902695, 0.03332194685935974, 0.000331245333654806, -0.03232434019446373, 0.02599475532770157, 0.022094234824180603, -0.01307656429708004, -0.0018291844753548503, -0.002381471451371908, 0.0013491840800270438, 0.021319109946489334, -0.013391603715717793, -0.026759713888168335, -0.0054682656191289425, -0.01203316729515791, 0.0380186066031456, -0.009888294152915478, -0.0173358041793108, -0.018343646079301834, 0.03204336017370224, 0.03728588670492172, -0.007135012652724981, 0.014289713464677334, 0.003994442988187075, 0.04996407777070999, 0.0011739975307136774, 0.0024759643711149693, -0.026872171089053154, -0.014293156564235687, 0.02187865413725376, -0.012269355356693268, 0.03546886146068573, -0.008293972350656986, -0.06980948895215988, -0.023128287866711617, -0.0298635121434927, 0.00859109591692686, 0.013760576024651527, -0.023732692003250122, -0.020034605637192726, 0.008743726648390293, 0.019887203350663185, -0.0164487287402153, -0.010696042329072952, 0.057319194078445435, -0.060162175446748734, 0.011904292739927769, 0.014335356652736664, -0.03887863829731941, -0.004442483652383089, -0.027489228174090385, -0.03004489094018936, -0.035460032522678375, -0.06080806255340576, -0.0321069061756134, -0.01872788742184639, -0.008754141628742218, -0.07951685786247253, -0.01743701472878456, 0.0033833503257483244, 0.004771423060446978, -0.01307613868266344, -0.010591715574264526, -0.008006625808775425, -0.022420737892389297, 0.029630407691001892, -0.01656389608979225, 0.01079793181270361, 0.010589640587568283, -0.04470236226916313, 0.02008717507123947, -0.033344022929668427, 0.006221756339073181, 0.04040287435054779, -0.006844118237495422, -0.02161676250398159, -0.051165834069252014, 0.011178693734109402, 0.023760095238685608, 0.006957358215004206, 0.027020158246159554, 0.006401857361197472, -0.03474889695644379, -0.011954735033214092, 0.028566675260663033, 0.05055651068687439, -0.009308296255767345, -0.009480494074523449, -0.02818296290934086, 0.042238038033246994, -0.007484543137252331, 0.023291142657399178, -0.06804364174604416, -0.007534310687333345, 0.015072785317897797, -0.055299099534749985, -0.028432024642825127, -0.04041231423616409, -0.05678399279713631, -0.005695690866559744, -0.009424388408660889, 0.01859150268137455, -0.02374441921710968, 0.001272849622182548, 0.02576112560927868, 0.030680479481816292, 0.02506222575902939, -0.0060294927097857, 0.05416451394557953, -0.04046819731593132, -0.009180129505693913, -0.057020530104637146, -0.0029899547807872295, 0.033657148480415344, -0.032889578491449356, -0.011281345039606094, 0.0253467857837677, -0.009746541269123554, 0.058814261108636856, -0.03174484148621559, -0.026715952903032303, 0.009650235064327717, -0.05205539986491203, -0.011586123146116734, 0.012088948860764503, -0.03366824612021446, -0.00029175798408687115, -0.0340949147939682, -0.042815759778022766, -0.03185296058654785, 0.006731947883963585, 0.03914070501923561, -0.003964106552302837, 0.06547816842794418, -0.017749659717082977, -0.03334663063287735, 0.035592492669820786, 0.03712600842118263, -0.014474929310381413, 0.025797396898269653, -0.012025202624499798, 0.08372487872838974, 0.036645714193582535, 0.022357923910021782, -0.017603719606995583, -0.0093653853982687, -0.005259842611849308, -0.049284469336271286, 0.05742952600121498, 0.025622818619012833, -0.008019492030143738, -0.05562062934041023, 0.04677615314722061, 0.03919772058725357, -0.02065642550587654, -0.005938943941146135, 0.04651303589344025, -0.030864108353853226, 0.012503516860306263, -0.03051142953336239, -0.02013312093913555, -0.031207531690597534, 0.07737340033054352, -0.005053416360169649, 0.04003134369850159, 0.0366348996758461, 0.023833824321627617, 0.0012573488056659698, -0.04286675900220871, 0.058253031224012375, 0.043450817465782166, 0.049709584563970566, 0.041128672659397125, 0.06939884275197983, -0.03374522179365158, -0.03638480231165886, 0.034549154341220856, 0.08973417431116104, -0.02299252152442932, -0.0325164832174778, 0.0032166556920856237, 0.077299103140831, -0.026844996958971024, 0.06952586024999619, -0.016848355531692505, -0.053675826638936996, -0.003595564980059862, 0.03106791339814663, -0.005964377894997597, 0.0011187688214704394, 0.0597153902053833, 0.053226541727781296, -0.03236044570803642, -0.022549238055944443, 0.020716968923807144, -0.018268853425979614, 0.049367569386959076, 0.03060099296271801, 0.000824133341666311, 0.06343025714159012, 0.0038805624935775995, 0.04994130879640579, 0.09797929972410202, -0.053213879466056824, -0.036295633763074875, 0.019747594371438026, 0.00264419405721128, 0.00444960268214345, 0.05438756197690964, 0.024564648047089577, -0.0008772516157478094, 0.002341817133128643, -0.06838832795619965, 0.005845487583428621, 0.005947045516222715, -0.0081712631508708, 0.0229046493768692, -0.030316820368170738, -0.015889545902609825, 0.022572971880435944, -0.017556218430399895, -0.07696819305419922, -0.04016951099038124, -0.019668463617563248, -0.05126392841339111, -0.04579349607229233, -0.012317782267928123, 0.07081370055675507, -0.013377008959650993, -0.05307637155056, 0.01014943327754736, -0.023062502965331078, 0.044808097183704376, -0.00629329401999712, -0.07640546560287476, -0.029677344486117363, 0.048127710819244385, -0.000820370449218899, 0.02049115300178528, 0.023773279041051865, 0.038555316627025604, -0.009134935215115547, 0.00037606991827487946, -0.022752908989787102, 0.05764078348875046, 0.05123008042573929, -0.0028508813120424747, -0.024790165945887566, -0.11735938489437103, 0.01624443754553795, -0.018758123740553856, 0.007389615755528212, -0.07851099222898483, -0.003951048478484154, -0.02247169427573681, 0.046691689640283585, 0.04857053607702255, 0.004023144021630287, -0.00528355548158288, -0.05741690844297409, -0.010092494077980518, 0.013165976852178574, 0.02364996448159218, 0.04922599717974663, -0.013654210604727268, 0.06356444954872131, 0.042558543384075165, -0.015850190073251724, -0.007737524341791868, 0.06041352078318596, -0.016375577077269554, 0.0031771922949701548, -0.007214318960905075, -0.03950149565935135, -0.04510702192783356, -0.08630938827991486, -0.06155775859951973, 0.0495791994035244, 0.02730855531990528, -0.019393324851989746, 0.01370856910943985, 0.0066953604109585285, 0.010338358581066132, -0.002017734805122018, -0.019938642159104347, -0.033280275762081146, -0.04596564546227455, -0.021563725546002388, -0.04854731261730194, -0.008159072138369083, -0.049519263207912445, -0.024293098598718643, 0.008856967091560364, -0.021917549893260002, -0.007322118151932955, -0.014951788820326328, 0.0137483524158597, 0.006753443740308285, 0.03688238933682442, -0.0032427108380943537 ]
3,579
Following the Human Thread in Social Navigation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=M8OGl34Pmg
[ "Luca Scofano", "Alessio Sampieri", "Tommaso Campari", "Valentino Sacco", "Indro Spinelli", "Lamberto Ballan", "Fabio Galasso" ]
Spotlight
The success of collaboration between humans and robots in shared environments relies on the robot's real-time adaptation to human motion. Specifically, in Social Navigation, the agent should be close enough to assist but ready to back up to let the human move freely, avoiding collisions. Human trajectories emerge as crucial cues in Social Navigation, but they are partially observable from the robot's egocentric view and computationally complex to process. We present the first Social Dynamics Adaptation model (SDA) based on the robot's state-action history to infer the social dynamics. We propose a two-stage Reinforcement Learning framework: the first learns to encode the human trajectories into social dynamics and learns a motion policy conditioned on this encoded information, the current status, and the previous action. Here, the trajectories are fully visible, i.e., assumed as privileged information. In the second stage, the trained policy operates without direct access to trajectories. Instead, the model infers the social dynamics solely from the history of previous actions and statuses in real-time. Tested on the novel Habitat 3.0 platform, SDA sets a novel state-of-the-art (SotA) performance in finding and following humans. The code can be found at https://github.com/L-Scofano/SDA.
Embodied AI, Social Navigation, Human Trajectories
null
4,339
2404.11327
[ -0.008512862958014011, -0.013087362982332706, 0.003664751071482897, 0.018013514578342438, 0.03419135883450508, 0.0017000128282234073, 0.037375401705503464, 0.041420914232730865, -0.05134183540940285, -0.05917558819055557, -0.04039156809449196, -0.018177716061472893, -0.06604840606451035, -0.03134945407509804, 0.013939659111201763, 0.02742360346019268, 0.025130432099103928, 0.00023606003378517926, -0.0036942774895578623, -0.022059602662920952, -0.028507782146334648, 0.02251451648771763, 0.026340028271079063, 0.010301790200173855, 0.02382699027657509, 0.013709760271012783, 0.038650162518024445, 0.013822171837091446, -0.025756284594535828, 0.004909641575068235, 0.004859997890889645, -0.026548979803919792, 0.005510179325938225, -0.01926906406879425, -0.01023377850651741, -0.03282472491264343, -0.05203564465045929, 0.008889821358025074, -0.011146482080221176, 0.02125796675682068, -0.03487687185406685, 0.022521568462252617, -0.03487774729728699, -0.02886900305747986, -0.0037132897414267063, 0.024797415360808372, -0.09172282367944717, 0.04850650578737259, 0.04410705715417862, -0.042220067232847214, -0.09268587082624435, 0.02906416729092598, 0.05324886739253998, 0.005572016350924969, 0.016386015340685844, 0.006471049971878529, 0.0448605902493, -0.08473322540521622, -0.02590085379779339, -0.06871611624956131, 0.016624510288238525, 0.04687507823109627, 0.02361699752509594, 0.015297433361411095, -0.0001333956461166963, -0.012182843871414661, 0.05319591984152794, 0.0447595976293087, 0.0024358725640922785, -0.004129153676331043, -0.021247422322630882, 0.009325619786977768, 0.001318799564614892, 0.040035806596279144, 0.00023287400836125016, -0.05343955010175705, 0.027385514229536057, 0.023626364767551422, 0.06256521493196487, -0.005866914056241512, 0.010093003511428833, 0.03286704421043396, -0.01689719595015049, 0.04521513730287552, 0.026381900534033775, 0.0339379757642746, -0.027295414358377457, -0.014654629863798618, -0.05839976295828819, 0.026355016976594925, -0.07509182393550873, -0.05362420901656151, -0.017808767035603523, 0.05749501660466194, 0.02970115840435028, 0.005182651802897453, 0.017031824216246605, 0.02486303448677063, 0.015194515697658062, -0.013087124563753605, -0.04633016884326935, 0.001079419394955039, 0.00844088476151228, 0.011952669359743595, -0.08559136092662811, -0.03479612246155739, 0.00862302165478468, 0.006904877256602049, -0.03448689356446266, 0.00459421519190073, -0.05327066406607628, -0.012474008835852146, 0.02880016155540943, -0.016639254987239838, -0.06404831260442734, 0.041172005236148834, 0.00993337482213974, 0.04571826756000519, -0.005868758540600538, 0.017207171767950058, 0.05700761452317238, 0.03315092623233795, -0.025280965492129326, 0.04911405220627785, -0.038852035999298096, 0.02494119107723236, -0.009505083784461021, -0.021878020837903023, -0.037940070033073425, -0.019220292568206787, 0.010412600822746754, 0.05180750787258148, 0.01223695371299982, 0.017246467992663383, -0.02470829337835312, -0.020156990736722946, 0.02587008848786354, 0.036211106926202774, -0.0020873278845101595, 0.012264997698366642, -0.0028743238653987646, 0.0073220147751271725, 0.0863913893699646, -0.02837563119828701, 0.09718482196331024, -0.023296808823943138, 0.011813227087259293, -0.0434134416282177, -0.052124183624982834, -0.0019440078176558018, -0.017749560996890068, -0.04041638970375061, 0.001933180377818644, -0.08054228872060776, 0.015299986116588116, 0.03612456098198891, 0.022258134558796883, -0.009287124499678612, 0.00955136213451624, 0.009464637376368046, 0.002441281918436289, 0.014770056121051311, -0.02162882313132286, -0.004410828463733196, 0.020884813740849495, -0.08854037523269653, 0.022064974531531334, 0.028475763276219368, -0.010432178154587746, -0.020134927704930305, -0.022656669840216637, -0.00919998250901699, 0.01690215989947319, -0.018925093114376068, -0.028065036982297897, 0.018635418266057968, 0.058087170124053955, -0.02128964103758335, 0.004134884104132652, 0.026117008179426193, -0.08016569167375565, 0.03329075127840042, 0.00872271228581667, -0.02782735601067543, 0.012486530467867851, -0.020435482263565063, 0.06718353182077408, -0.017142945900559425, -0.03278911113739014, -0.021807638928294182, -0.07409682124853134, -0.015377748757600784, 0.014075211249291897, 0.010810079984366894, 0.05699683353304863, -0.019795438274741173, -0.009310002438724041, 0.020663360133767128, 0.03170682117342949, 0.0751364678144455, 0.004172876942902803, -0.023344632238149643, 0.07155678421258926, 0.023072391748428345, -0.04223909229040146, 0.0009715480846352875, 0.06568099558353424, -0.03211210295557976, -0.03710734099149704, 0.03232579305768013, -0.02714122086763382, 0.010715262964367867, -0.00020828293054364622, 0.006920622196048498, 0.05348283424973488, 0.012035911902785301, -0.0045050764456391335, 0.011634859256446362, 0.02318406291306019, -0.03743663802742958, 0.005563683342188597, 0.00008282545604743063, -0.01904517225921154, -0.0038170788902789354, -0.01370176114141941, 0.08184652030467987, 0.07444453239440918, -0.029349038377404213, -0.023738110437989235, 0.01027433481067419, 0.010858668014407158, 0.007675719913095236, 0.0042222342453897, 0.007275800686329603, 0.011896283365786076, -0.04317101463675499, 0.050274837762117386, -0.03650883957743645, 0.019539082422852516, -0.020870082080364227, -0.011045334860682487, 0.07757937163114548, -0.01734316349029541, 0.05715404078364372, -0.006681003142148256, 0.00546650867909193, 0.08576574921607971, -0.009497602470219135, -0.014552651904523373, 0.05016573891043663, -0.04021942988038063, -0.01594424620270729, 0.05765269324183464, 0.0030321564991027117, -0.013003257103264332, -0.0641133114695549, 0.009012915194034576, -0.052490949630737305, 0.05548850819468498, 0.029309391975402832, 0.05361079052090645, 0.014783975668251514, -0.025365415960550308, -0.030986865982413292, -0.02543330378830433, -0.11107182502746582, -0.059960462152957916, 0.002212892286479473, 0.0030552642419934273, 0.06728362292051315, 0.015596921555697918, -0.046809811145067215, 0.05719095095992088, -0.059445951133966446, -0.0074518704786896706, 0.03620826080441475, 0.03577527031302452, 0.015451778657734394, 0.001926169847138226, 0.008673343807458878, 0.0013718014815822244, 0.05751048028469086, -0.017872653901576996, -0.018674597144126892, 0.0018029550556093454, -0.05870020017027855, -0.006016145460307598, 0.00510905496776104, -0.006320245563983917, 0.041840795427560806, 0.023966923356056213, -0.005858310963958502, -0.013769191689789295, -0.00381415244191885, 0.015309611335396767, 0.0825059562921524, 0.04532473906874657, -0.019459689036011696, -0.038163624703884125, -0.01789393089711666, -0.02348426543176174, 0.010191195644438267, 0.007161398883908987, 0.03263866528868675, 0.03275139257311821, -0.02374054677784443, 0.010972801595926285, 0.0017825793474912643, -0.26719897985458374, -0.01919464021921158, 0.02652229182422161, 0.009589143097400665, 0.029857007786631584, 0.017866501584649086, 0.06600344926118851, -0.014373940415680408, -0.022422295063734055, 0.024971185252070427, 0.007464004680514336, 0.05615254119038582, 0.024856174364686012, 0.02910727448761463, 0.023665763437747955, 0.012314419262111187, -0.04029308259487152, -0.027896059677004814, -0.011170622892677784, 0.02862977236509323, -0.03782307356595993, -0.0705181136727333, -0.03419606387615204, 0.04393161088228226, -0.012429007329046726, 0.019794508814811707, -0.0643913671374321, -0.043811917304992676, -0.008816326037049294, -0.005472531542181969, -0.02275206707417965, 0.006771640852093697, -0.040129873901605606, 0.013079343363642693, 0.00785270519554615, 0.007629876025021076, 0.009123867377638817, 0.004379508085548878, 0.034469570964574814, 0.005830809473991394, -0.008657367900013924, 0.02237567864358425, -0.050167761743068695, 0.03285590559244156, 0.08045434206724167, 0.025014545768499374, -0.056291162967681885, 0.003676618216559291, 0.014817182905972004, 0.02886224538087845, 0.004860064946115017, -0.027458922937512398, 0.007665293291211128, 0.00005221470564720221, 0.004479929804801941, -0.01937004178762436, 0.003353871637955308, -0.020328829064965248, -0.018931405618786812, 0.011636444367468357, -0.010252384468913078, -0.022394074127078056, -0.024840665981173515, -0.06114691123366356, 0.003559328382834792, -0.029035469517111778, -0.05966995656490326, -0.03607682138681412, 0.009756471961736679, 0.017371559515595436, -0.02176480181515217, 0.021172190085053444, -0.03804991766810417, -0.11630694568157196, 0.02033626288175583, 0.004757350776344538, -0.033340081572532654, -0.020249610766768456, 0.011714075691998005, 0.048224061727523804, -0.007719777058809996, -0.03145343065261841, -0.008680076338350773, 0.021859250962734222, 0.009593666531145573, -0.015128789469599724, 0.034636884927749634, -0.049151089042425156, -0.02485884167253971, -0.01727406494319439, 0.030857272446155548, 0.006239170208573341, -0.0026246653869748116, -0.02218659222126007, 0.047855183482170105, 0.04381430894136429, 0.012299969792366028, 0.006422881036996841, 0.041895512491464615, 0.0058350530453026295, 0.0497828908264637, -0.07904630899429321, 0.004586733877658844, -0.028068654239177704, 0.0051049902103841305, 0.04067615792155266, -0.032679010182619095, -0.02614876814186573, 0.03892171010375023, 0.01764463260769844, 0.015442562289536, -0.05595195293426514, 0.00556576531380415, -0.006741415709257126, -0.024496544152498245, -0.013463371433317661, -0.007089667953550816, 0.006427360698580742, 0.04377894848585129, 0.011122813448309898, -0.05957557633519173, 0.034047361463308334, -0.03353969007730484, 0.03882142901420593, -0.022082453593611717, -0.013069572858512402, -0.024903424084186554, -0.025952115654945374, 0.05072013661265373, -0.02335583232343197, 0.052037306129932404, 0.06923987716436386, 0.003847487038001418, 0.01722700148820877, 0.042718175798654556, -0.006443335209041834, -0.018464595079421997, 0.006147150415927172, 0.027389654889702797, -0.039617326110601425, -0.02283811941742897, -0.018671918660402298, 0.032727696001529694, 0.022740064188838005, -0.027132123708724976, 0.013038074597716331, 0.016444815322756767, 0.014780282974243164, 0.03120073303580284, -0.016146959736943245, 0.0637429878115654, -0.041522830724716187, -0.007305908482521772, -0.013248646631836891, 0.03480972722172737, -0.052710071206092834, 0.029888242483139038, -0.009596429765224457, 0.01599258743226528, -0.0537688173353672, 0.021184351295232773, -0.018935371190309525, -0.009172934107482433, 0.018352337181568146, 0.00053969252621755, 0.04757910594344139, -0.022251026704907417, -0.026631155982613564, -0.003862070618197322, -0.021564247086644173, 0.0076028513722121716, -0.011923807673156261, -0.028208475559949875, -0.037507232278585434, -0.01774200238287449, -0.016175732016563416, -0.000317098485538736, -0.039457499980926514, -0.056809455156326294, -0.004393273498862982, -0.010387374088168144, 0.02116583287715912, 0.004559745080769062, -0.0053522041998803616, 0.05970670282840729, -0.014354896731674671, 0.010575329884886742, -0.012732821516692638, -0.011868317611515522, 0.0016468963585793972, 0.008195055648684502, 0.04285517707467079, -0.04113801196217537, -0.049967966973781586, -0.01577160321176052, -0.030241182073950768, 0.02231578342616558, -0.0005560644785873592, -0.01643591746687889, 0.01214707363396883, -0.013489414937794209, 0.03754568099975586, -0.017896469682455063, 0.014121951535344124, 0.03654604032635689, -0.057922765612602234, 0.00803305022418499, 0.04228605329990387, -0.0025362714659422636, 0.01061836164444685, -0.050408609211444855, -0.0551736056804657, -0.04769217595458031, -0.04380149021744728, -0.023747164756059647, -0.023814599961042404, -0.036673035472631454, -0.06757757812738419, -0.037430595606565475, 0.03660419583320618, 0.0346471406519413, 0.0008989979978650808, -0.010220727883279324, -0.007471559569239616, -0.012506039813160896, 0.057513121515512466, -0.016782430931925774, -0.018115825951099396, 0.02841423638164997, -0.037925995886325836, 0.009278714656829834, -0.013554933480918407, 0.011741796508431435, 0.006508090067654848, -0.04109277203679085, 0.004877289291471243, -0.07487062364816666, -0.008588080294430256, 0.005348004400730133, 0.003512865398079157, -0.007527751382440329, 0.014276831410825253, -0.027746664360165596, -0.012650788761675358, 0.038013264536857605, 0.03299439698457718, -0.004216245375573635, 0.015572821721434593, 0.006594066973775625, 0.001036093570291996, 0.038543082773685455, -0.01785171590745449, -0.033095769584178925, 0.003171083750203252, 0.037356164306402206, -0.006668409798294306, -0.03366129845380783, -0.05848054960370064, 0.0027009269688278437, 0.0003708548319991678, -0.02513214386999607, 0.029671594500541687, -0.0802583396434784, 0.02338952012360096, 0.01173907145857811, 0.023213544860482216, 0.03315444663167, -0.011833586730062962, 0.047550298273563385, -0.07128781825304031, 0.00962011981755495, -0.05457371100783348, 0.0028045768849551678, 0.053876835852861404, -0.027307363227009773, 0.017990365624427795, 0.03615865483880043, 0.028346221894025803, 0.034726567566394806, -0.04028647765517235, -0.034856438636779785, 0.04034421592950821, -0.02532785013318062, 0.007582749705761671, 0.026284493505954742, -0.03659502789378166, -0.00907174963504076, -0.028835784643888474, -0.043098095804452896, 0.016040872782468796, 0.0024091864470392466, 0.022200852632522583, -0.008985254913568497, 0.0506906621158123, -0.022203080356121063, 0.008829138241708279, -0.0038669246714562178, 0.03212245553731918, -0.004252150189131498, 0.045021530240774155, -0.04215623438358307, 0.07669992744922638, 0.03593771159648895, 0.017415296286344528, 0.013183988630771637, 0.008142775855958462, -0.026035651564598083, -0.025242434814572334, 0.06913486868143082, 0.03025243990123272, -0.048959046602249146, -0.06732520461082458, 0.066870778799057, 0.03172535076737404, -0.07217711955308914, 0.026299193501472473, 0.028467552736401558, -0.06197081878781319, -0.0012292718747630715, 0.002348905662074685, -0.004249665420502424, 0.01812850497663021, 0.05700670927762985, 0.015241296961903572, 0.07424415647983551, 0.0257254708558321, 0.04868227243423462, 0.013552576303482056, -0.034896984696388245, 0.053966399282217026, 0.06856866925954819, 0.04488365352153778, -0.008811584673821926, 0.07708023488521576, -0.036292191594839096, -0.014857977628707886, 0.04297837242484093, 0.0035572012420743704, -0.02446741797029972, -0.020381255075335503, 0.019639689475297928, 0.035931434482336044, -0.008700292557477951, 0.0697227492928505, -0.039613813161849976, -0.031026436015963554, 0.03674463555216789, 0.012958530336618423, -0.005601488519459963, 0.025634780526161194, 0.032186027616262436, 0.04826163500547409, -0.022518182173371315, -0.04208351671695709, 0.004905875772237778, -0.021322187036275864, 0.052127331495285034, 0.008613922633230686, -0.011357342824339867, 0.0035613910295069218, 0.02573711797595024, 0.03269769623875618, 0.11821836233139038, -0.028971493244171143, 0.0005107496399432421, -0.026780296117067337, -0.029596377164125443, -0.013197055086493492, 0.03499067574739456, 0.010865558870136738, 0.016893424093723297, 0.0480085127055645, -0.046845804899930954, 0.021702583879232407, 0.04308154061436653, -0.012915150262415409, 0.016747070476412773, -0.02991022914648056, -0.01582951657474041, -0.022593481466174126, 0.007387527264654636, -0.03591389209032059, -0.03977379947900772, -0.021232152357697487, -0.04971008002758026, -0.06834186613559723, -0.0523349829018116, 0.03378073498606682, -0.003955361433327198, -0.047253839671611786, -0.0019793000537902117, -0.05392380431294441, 0.0213305726647377, -0.01035419199615717, -0.07496177405118942, 0.007215158548206091, 0.027672406286001205, 0.009985323995351791, 0.029705112800002098, 0.03159690275788307, 0.04485076293349266, 0.011378291063010693, -0.0019017568556591868, -0.010661936365067959, 0.027919188141822815, 0.04591299220919609, -0.03424859791994095, -0.05051786080002785, -0.10141461342573166, 0.016206229105591774, 0.029275016859173775, -0.009146290831267834, -0.07683084160089493, 0.009948602877557278, -0.06465913355350494, 0.07715573161840439, 0.07390520721673965, 0.003490616800263524, 0.014664912596344948, -0.0450584851205349, -0.020124148577451706, 0.025470729917287827, -0.0079645412042737, 0.0333414301276207, -0.04023808613419533, 0.04313071817159653, 0.04073745012283325, -0.03990604355931282, -0.03113233670592308, 0.02666173130273819, 0.02272043190896511, -0.02929775044322014, 0.021189184859395027, -0.06354306638240814, -0.011998687870800495, -0.10334627330303192, -0.037944644689559937, 0.06767010688781738, 0.05356282368302345, -0.05491108074784279, -0.014839410781860352, 0.0030000549741089344, 0.020276125520467758, 0.00001529124529042747, -0.026768503710627556, -0.01298140361905098, -0.04014188051223755, -0.02720353938639164, -0.051440708339214325, 0.008536959066987038, -0.03837425634264946, -0.003841488854959607, -0.025146685540676117, -0.013284503482282162, 0.01114983856678009, -0.04647437110543251, -0.008121183142066002, 0.00982654932886362, -0.0043830256909132, 0.009250525385141373 ]
3,580
Don't flatten, tokenize! Unlocking the key to SoftMoE's efficacy in deep RL
https://openreview.net/forum?id=8oCrlOaYcc
[ "Ghada Sokar", "Johan Samir Obando Ceron", "Aaron Courville", "Hugo Larochelle", "Pablo Samuel Castro" ]
Spotlight
The use of deep neural networks in reinforcement learning (RL) often suffers from performance degradation as model size increases. While soft mixtures of experts (SoftMoEs) have recently shown promise in mitigating this issue for online RL, the reasons behind their effectiveness remain largely unknown. In this work we provide an in-depth analysis identifying the key factors driving this performance gain. We discover the surprising result that tokenizing the encoder output, rather than the use of multiple experts, is what is behind the efficacy of SoftMoEs. Indeed, we demonstrate that even with an appropriately scaled single expert, we are able to maintain the performance gains, largely thanks to tokenization.
Reinforcement learning, Deep reinforcement learning, Mixture of experts
We demonstrate that one of the main reasons for the efficacy when using mixtures of experts comes from the choice of tokenization, and we demonstrate that even with a single expert, tokenization is enough to yield the previously observed benefits.
4,327
null
[ -0.0375053770840168, -0.05328424274921417, 0.001436639460735023, 0.04324628412723541, 0.04131472855806351, 0.02625948004424572, 0.018571656197309494, 0.01178932934999466, -0.04850131273269653, -0.02415248565375805, -0.03912380710244179, 0.033349886536598206, -0.06681141257286072, -0.017886564135551453, -0.0036492878571152687, 0.07904434204101562, 0.01234703790396452, -0.016752177849411964, -0.012281958013772964, 0.01294585783034563, 0.009978842921555042, 0.010686053894460201, 0.019739413633942604, 0.00012792795314453542, 0.043484702706336975, -0.035389237105846405, -0.008132660761475563, 0.005858530756086111, -0.023170536383986473, -0.02931925654411316, 0.03743563964962959, -0.006127965170890093, 0.021516166627407074, -0.02403910644352436, 0.012335298582911491, 0.0028289544861763716, -0.05282791703939438, 0.03873606026172638, 0.010805081576108932, 0.0064674075692892075, -0.057924360036849976, 0.01744483970105648, -0.015129443258047104, -0.01158049888908863, -0.011823832057416439, -0.000011537077625689562, -0.09140589833259583, 0.0055129192769527435, 0.01317792758345604, -0.032452862709760666, -0.1091342344880104, 0.03923758864402771, 0.02101830393075943, -0.019281964749097824, 0.01594489812850952, 0.011571790091693401, 0.028061198070645332, -0.09017226099967957, -0.01081535778939724, -0.0891001969575882, -0.011674041859805584, 0.04571080207824707, 0.017783785238862038, -0.02555135451257229, -0.005663926713168621, 0.005750701297074556, -0.007196358405053616, 0.029153939336538315, -0.039883192628622055, -0.028506189584732056, -0.0038430229760706425, -0.026186905801296234, -0.01690107397735119, 0.03662913292646408, -0.0127674276009202, -0.05253084748983383, 0.007876133546233177, 0.046815041452646255, 0.06973347067832947, -0.017780618742108345, 0.00942161213606596, 0.021999163553118706, 0.029930679127573967, 0.04394766315817833, 0.03268791362643242, 0.014959005638957024, -0.0020132320933043957, -0.00411467719823122, -0.06346665322780609, 0.03308861702680588, -0.03342416509985924, -0.05140369012951851, 0.026448287069797516, 0.030009010806679726, -0.018531223759055138, 0.038663677871227264, 0.01771298423409462, 0.04541986435651779, -0.004372868221253157, 0.009103146381676197, -0.019537458196282387, -0.027410181239247322, 0.024878889322280884, -0.016901815310120583, -0.09914813190698624, -0.017201660200953484, -0.004695968236774206, -0.0011194621911272407, -0.012510357424616814, 0.017205314710736275, -0.05414566397666931, -0.02423728257417679, 0.003729608841240406, -0.019024832174181938, -0.07325010746717453, 0.020784921944141388, 0.009353010915219784, 0.050937358289957047, 0.0014211987145245075, 0.005479741375893354, 0.05426132306456566, 0.0671025738120079, 0.021327750757336617, 0.06314437091350555, -0.012651837430894375, 0.01625858061015606, -0.012604642659425735, 0.026983480900526047, -0.017761506140232086, -0.04878152534365654, 0.04654451087117195, 0.046673014760017395, -0.0345396064221859, 0.01760747842490673, 0.00223229406401515, 0.004012320190668106, 0.03745989128947258, 0.026240339502692223, 0.04277093708515167, -0.019882623106241226, -0.02588861994445324, -0.024490544572472572, 0.0672135204076767, -0.02531570754945278, 0.0779615044593811, -0.034961991012096405, 0.012433263473212719, -0.016527900472283363, -0.0394582524895668, -0.0008763683144934475, 0.0049346028827130795, -0.01685597188770771, -0.001889979699626565, -0.04750531166791916, 0.042789656668901443, 0.0483231358230114, 0.03029395267367363, 0.028421321883797646, 0.007975567132234573, 0.05062401294708252, 0.007127551827579737, -0.015406467951834202, -0.022902807220816612, 0.007574877701699734, -0.001622701995074749, -0.0662425309419632, 0.046064045280218124, 0.026203513145446777, -0.019812610000371933, 0.01728403940796852, -0.041948433965444565, -0.020861035212874413, 0.04985762760043144, -0.009542765095829964, -0.01806226745247841, -0.01476836297661066, 0.057831067591905594, 0.019732823595404625, 0.02905546873807907, 0.03770194575190544, -0.07621710002422333, 0.042894039303064346, -0.02578619495034218, 0.0027653691358864307, 0.006581178400665522, -0.043864842504262924, 0.08921907842159271, -0.028416333720088005, 0.0044447616674005985, 0.04124864190816879, -0.07321447134017944, -0.01958865486085415, 0.01153525523841381, -0.015267772600054741, 0.07016164064407349, -0.00710480147972703, -0.04571577534079552, 0.041692424565553665, 0.028745604678988457, 0.039076969027519226, 0.03654929995536804, -0.012605638243258, 0.033532969653606415, -0.0074693746864795685, -0.030709197744727135, 0.01642494648694992, 0.035997770726680756, -0.031177939847111702, -0.011755099520087242, 0.018412213772535324, -0.01541865710169077, -0.01165382843464613, -0.027137069031596184, -0.004710454028099775, 0.012411878444254398, 0.016638565808534622, 0.0315222293138504, -0.013681815005838871, 0.039538104087114334, -0.030444223433732986, 0.04672131687402725, -0.005755316931754351, -0.029309455305337906, -0.0007243375875987113, -0.04020468518137932, 0.0848865807056427, 0.06855519115924835, -0.03728095442056656, -0.020186539739370346, 0.014617475681006908, -0.02970900386571884, 0.005706605035811663, 0.022320598363876343, -0.018513355404138565, 0.006215824745595455, -0.028338445350527763, -0.028624966740608215, -0.05416516959667206, 0.05188418924808502, -0.04177743196487427, -0.019200842827558517, 0.06604202836751938, -0.003786833491176367, 0.05431273207068443, 0.0033517719712108374, 0.06383577734231949, 0.026765674352645874, -0.019526690244674683, -0.01506856270134449, -0.016554370522499084, -0.01884300448000431, -0.00748457433655858, 0.009128122590482235, -0.015203112736344337, 0.026218954473733902, -0.035740867257118225, -0.03240370377898216, -0.04377884045243263, 0.06837471574544907, 0.04591716453433037, 0.006124276202172041, 0.05531919375061989, -0.037921469658613205, -0.02257877215743065, -0.01358589343726635, -0.10469981282949448, -0.022078193724155426, -0.01439567282795906, 0.03239380940794945, 0.00022453060955740511, 0.023679854348301888, -0.016696898266673088, 0.03648550808429718, -0.02689632959663868, -0.0007731439545750618, 0.025129953399300575, 0.04003478214144707, 0.008265218697488308, -0.014583361335098743, -0.0401216596364975, -0.018984157592058182, 0.06448967754840851, 0.01394331268966198, -0.022305650636553764, -0.021667003631591797, -0.03522874042391777, 0.017871275544166565, -0.026239054277539253, -0.01948360539972782, 0.026855895295739174, 0.023999817669391632, 0.018862614408135414, -0.03616085648536682, 0.04030703008174896, 0.02347535826265812, 0.07971592247486115, 0.050594232976436615, 0.03077644854784012, -0.010312369093298912, 0.042270369827747345, -0.014102338813245296, 0.03929518535733223, -0.011924602091312408, -0.006959076970815659, 0.004975973628461361, -0.004316117148846388, 0.029850462451577187, 0.03236302360892296, -0.28322434425354004, -0.02097107470035553, 0.006988285109400749, -0.0017012209864333272, 0.03191308677196503, -0.03694811835885048, 0.03549014404416084, -0.010029546916484833, -0.022713596001267433, -0.0023309828247874975, 0.01496848464012146, 0.015338199213147163, 0.02317177876830101, -0.015323796309530735, 0.04040401056408882, 0.025529779493808746, 0.00411135982722044, -0.0074026137590408325, -0.00643259147182107, 0.0488625131547451, -0.03801066428422928, -0.07355308532714844, -0.017593247815966606, 0.052831001579761505, -0.006232346408069134, 0.05710123851895332, -0.04448931664228439, -0.015304564498364925, -0.02943539060652256, -0.039901841431856155, -0.010028173215687275, 0.0089801587164402, -0.005489425268024206, 0.013778317719697952, 0.0006630578427575529, -0.013400361873209476, 0.02726132795214653, -0.02242712862789631, 0.02616339735686779, 0.013959015719592571, 0.002254835097119212, -0.026541514322161674, -0.04024989902973175, 0.010490929707884789, 0.06255282461643219, 0.008338194340467453, -0.05983707308769226, -0.005668401252478361, -0.015270987525582314, 0.029901443049311638, 0.01723535545170307, -0.045724883675575256, -0.009163026697933674, 0.007885121740400791, 0.010395468212664127, -0.002145219361409545, -0.011505044996738434, -0.015884144231677055, -0.0003047727223020047, 0.015809491276741028, 0.01600974053144455, -0.04939610883593559, -0.028669603168964386, -0.03202204778790474, -0.013924329541623592, -0.03960675001144409, -0.047068554908037186, -0.056312814354896545, 0.06829415261745453, 0.02157994918525219, -0.02112840674817562, 0.008505879901349545, -0.01606595702469349, -0.1007140502333641, 0.020141638815402985, 0.007574266288429499, -0.008317816071212292, -0.027950983494520187, 0.012306498363614082, 0.07103496044874191, -0.043772194534540176, -0.04352888837456703, 0.0159838255494833, -0.03079579770565033, -0.0010677763493731618, -0.007621898781508207, 0.01956787519156933, 0.00023261744354385883, -0.009961597621440887, -0.02229892462491989, 0.059623535722494125, 0.013171551749110222, -0.014153477735817432, -0.013671506196260452, 0.07112003862857819, 0.0200192853808403, 0.016253337264060974, 0.029006730765104294, 0.0317564383149147, 0.004713835194706917, 0.012767859734594822, -0.09605136513710022, 0.002304934663698077, -0.06324318051338196, -0.052160367369651794, 0.020014142617583275, -0.04697946459054947, -0.02600807696580887, 0.04114330932497978, 0.006479767616838217, 0.00047087232815101743, -0.05405811965465546, 0.01324878353625536, -0.0009761626715771854, -0.01751536689698696, -0.012153398245573044, -0.00969963613897562, 0.041323862969875336, 0.04071035608649254, -0.014691543765366077, -0.041835639625787735, 0.03627106174826622, -0.015782970935106277, 0.015355334617197514, -0.016146764159202576, -0.024439360946416855, 0.005145042669028044, -0.005553392227739096, 0.003858916461467743, -0.008007343858480453, 0.027353152632713318, 0.05617138743400574, -0.01829214207828045, 0.00722499517723918, 0.04210794344544411, -0.019747797399759293, -0.01930822990834713, -0.00912861991673708, 0.00880087073892355, -0.0118632223457098, 0.0014291151892393827, -0.005850784946233034, 0.040180105715990067, 0.020522067323327065, 0.006092223338782787, 0.025414789095520973, -0.005490604322403669, 0.016686122864484787, 0.021852126345038414, 0.00747304642572999, 0.025899313390254974, -0.05443088710308075, 0.0030640442855656147, -0.025056514889001846, 0.0693204328417778, -0.03207044303417206, 0.021332168951630592, -0.012878118082880974, 0.007382772862911224, -0.06665273010730743, 0.03198656812310219, 0.023329604417085648, -0.059800274670124054, 0.011312718503177166, 0.036407168954610825, 0.053853701800107956, -0.04259061440825462, -0.006089739501476288, 0.008691764436662197, -0.019230011850595474, 0.00840049423277378, -0.051657550036907196, -0.03812839835882187, -0.026016848161816597, -0.010493021458387375, -0.011934134177863598, 0.0035312045365571976, -0.021275104954838753, -0.02760990709066391, 0.013884620741009712, 0.02514909766614437, -0.002444962738081813, -0.0028527560643851757, -0.02552873082458973, 0.06631540507078171, 0.007002010941505432, 0.01287627499550581, -0.0048156240954995155, -0.035359013825654984, 0.023493433371186256, -0.0213032066822052, 0.04023762419819832, -0.04097931087017059, -0.012506010010838509, -0.051729124039411545, -0.02684084139764309, 0.0047903843224048615, 0.047500625252723694, -0.028233561664819717, 0.0026137586683034897, -0.018568066880106926, 0.009941132739186287, -0.018168259412050247, -0.014458662830293179, 0.02521560713648796, -0.09200888127088547, 0.028691133484244347, 0.025291096419095993, -0.030038639903068542, 0.024020489305257797, -0.032414667308330536, -0.01371845044195652, -0.05529560148715973, -0.02309473790228367, 0.01710888184607029, -0.0322597473859787, -0.03487028926610947, -0.038165636360645294, -0.009258121252059937, -0.0020975263323634863, 0.005045898258686066, -0.03325508162379265, -0.03158596530556679, -0.014423114247620106, -0.011149207130074501, 0.034394945949316025, -0.05498543381690979, -0.020743083208799362, 0.02809910662472248, 0.015895316377282143, 0.027593491598963737, -0.03538336604833603, 0.03929688781499863, 0.057127710431814194, -0.016699757426977158, 0.031280700117349625, -0.03816042095422745, 0.03856395557522774, -0.0296833124011755, -0.04886670410633087, 0.0151246702298522, -0.0006382890278473496, -0.05707808583974838, 0.02816486358642578, -0.028224937617778778, 0.0256089735776186, 0.00017714120622258633, 0.009144335985183716, 0.001423774054273963, -0.009059162810444832, 0.05473875626921654, 0.0163028035312891, -0.05976079776883125, -0.004342603962868452, 0.08716726303100586, -0.028549058362841606, -0.029445674270391464, -0.059686049818992615, -0.02179405651986599, 0.032189056277275085, -0.019149476662278175, 0.03602886199951172, -0.030201781541109085, 0.01777125708758831, 0.014140889048576355, 0.04265158250927925, 0.0031759648118168116, -0.02564517967402935, 0.035396210849285126, -0.06894396990537643, 0.014344255439937115, -0.08190254867076874, -0.026622802019119263, 0.07999370247125626, -0.03108585998415947, 0.019609959796071053, 0.025253072381019592, -0.04593290016055107, 0.028050895780324936, -0.020011350512504578, -0.061235856264829636, 0.027184894308447838, -0.029374152421951294, -0.002610424067825079, 0.05471538007259369, -0.06897411495447159, -0.029402222484350204, -0.016922101378440857, -0.059429120272397995, -0.013844870962202549, -0.01557376328855753, 0.049895063042640686, -0.006880173459649086, 0.005593255162239075, -0.021933818235993385, 0.028047161176800728, 0.03509999066591263, 0.047124046832323074, 0.05134228616952896, 0.005956913810223341, -0.03608940169215202, 0.047901593148708344, 0.031198786571621895, 0.026067323982715607, -0.007135647814720869, 0.009392469190061092, -0.013192194513976574, -0.040204789489507675, 0.06150241941213608, -0.009418428875505924, -0.009961027652025223, -0.04168440029025078, 0.04767528921365738, 0.018472110852599144, -0.05144842341542244, -0.03224966302514076, 0.016785748302936554, -0.06382932513952255, -0.0052971919067204, 0.01170836016535759, 0.014111863449215889, 0.014858326874673367, 0.06541375815868378, 0.039726871997117996, 0.03461907058954239, 0.05974836274981499, 0.01691128872334957, -0.03665713965892792, 0.053138744086027145, 0.06166800484061241, 0.049947772175073624, 0.06978154182434082, -0.0027046913746744394, 0.07006113231182098, -0.043149981647729874, -0.07934969663619995, 0.06705041974782944, 0.01702887751162052, -0.00530203664675355, -0.030491504818201065, 0.003206827212125063, 0.05323087424039841, 0.010016955435276031, 0.08190981298685074, -0.07107936590909958, -0.019207622855901718, 0.04237475246191025, 0.02086525969207287, -0.033068712800741196, 0.0226175207644701, 0.04676214978098869, -0.010537433438003063, -0.0278633963316679, -0.03170263394713402, 0.007502267602831125, -0.03540230169892311, 0.016504116356372833, 0.011982621625065804, -0.005929268430918455, -0.0032731937244534492, 0.013398240320384502, 0.07050062716007233, 0.11963247507810593, -0.04071614518761635, -0.016063515096902847, 0.015968549996614456, -0.0031850114464759827, 0.013005510903894901, 0.015577509999275208, 0.018805554136633873, -0.03808823972940445, 0.017998790368437767, -0.00957542285323143, 0.01409345306456089, 0.04015938565135002, -0.01585901714861393, 0.032564252614974976, -0.03490057960152626, -0.02977939136326313, 0.006523816380649805, 0.0046451338566839695, 0.006044400855898857, -0.038020748645067215, -0.029209492728114128, -0.05503176525235176, -0.046038512140512466, -0.04446407034993172, 0.019744805991649628, 0.005196697078645229, -0.04724251106381416, -0.002839435823261738, -0.027842141687870026, 0.00812650565057993, 0.018712954595685005, -0.05624775215983391, 0.022634513676166534, 0.02636113204061985, -0.01650773547589779, -0.01303228922188282, 0.036299511790275574, 0.04500679299235344, 0.009856045246124268, 0.0001833932037698105, 0.029055600985884666, 0.02660008892416954, 0.01264377124607563, -0.017566286027431488, -0.05066104233264923, -0.08451037108898163, -0.00865123514086008, 0.011284560896456242, -0.034093502908945084, -0.07386130839586258, 0.03893177583813667, -0.040417153388261795, 0.028931807726621628, 0.08388584852218628, -0.0004636308003682643, 0.0293296966701746, -0.016910523176193237, -0.02187662571668625, 0.02374299243092537, -0.00274085090495646, 0.019009213894605637, -0.015808003023266792, 0.06365358829498291, 0.03487290441989899, -0.009137882851064205, -0.012938515283167362, 0.036116067320108414, -0.01433484349399805, -0.009378942660987377, -0.02197275683283806, -0.007440842222422361, -0.012569747865200043, -0.11518882215023041, -0.036891620606184006, 0.04255029931664467, -0.017849151045084, -0.06718437373638153, 0.003457119455561042, -0.026333041489124298, -0.007622045930474997, 0.003339015645906329, -0.015308862552046776, -0.022747904062271118, -0.006553207524120808, 0.009807473979890347, -0.06809742748737335, 0.019962646067142487, -0.019456611946225166, 0.014537026174366474, -0.01807376742362976, -0.01953102834522724, 0.014399923384189606, 0.024437541142106056, 0.017965054139494896, -0.005879137199372053, 0.010167781263589859, -0.012153890915215015 ]
3,581
Boltzmann-Aligned Inverse Folding Model as a Predictor of Mutational Effects on Protein-Protein Interactions
https://openreview.net/forum?id=lzdFImKK8w
[ "Xiaoran Jiao", "Weian Mao", "Wengong Jin", "Peiyuan Yang", "Hao Chen", "Chunhua Shen" ]
Spotlight
Predicting the change in binding free energy ($\Delta \Delta G$) is crucial for understanding and modulating protein-protein interactions, which are critical in drug design. Due to the scarcity of experimental $\Delta\Delta G$ data, existing methods focus on pre-training, while neglecting the importance of alignment. In this work, we propose Boltzmann Alignment technique to transfer knowledge from pre-trained inverse folding models to prediction of $\Delta\Delta G$. We begin by analyzing the thermodynamic definition of $\Delta\Delta G$ and introducing the Boltzmann distribution to connect energy to the protein conformational distribution. However, the protein conformational distribution is intractable. Therefore, we employ Bayes’ theorem to circumvent direct estimation and instead utilize the log-likelihood provided by protein inverse folding models for the estimation of $\Delta\Delta G$. Compared to previous methods based on inverse folding, our method explicitly accounts for the unbound state of the protein complex in the $\Delta \Delta G$ thermodynamic cycle, introducing a physical inductive bias and achieving supervised and unsupervised state-of-the-art (SoTA) performance. Experimental results on SKEMPI v2 indicate that our method achieves Spearman coefficients of 0.3201 (unsupervised) and 0.5134 (supervised) on SKEMPI v2, significantly surpassing the previously reported %SoTA values SoTA results of 0.2632 and 0.4324, respectively. Furthermore, we demonstrate the capability of our method in binding energy prediction, protein-protein docking, and antibody optimization tasks. Code is available at [https://github.com/aim-uofa/BA-DDG](https://github.com/aim-uofa/BA-DDG)
Mutational Effects; Protein-Protein Interactions
null
4,282
2410.09543
[ -0.018092449754476547, -0.01622162200510502, -0.015939243137836456, 0.007526555564254522, 0.038066718727350235, 0.0019509178819134831, 0.037878844887018204, -0.0028180305380374193, 0.03461796045303345, -0.05493348464369774, 0.03138417750597, 0.01430764701217413, -0.09599889069795609, 0.016238825395703316, 0.039864834398031235, 0.059742458164691925, 0.0232477318495512, 0.0033747339621186256, 0.024410957470536232, 0.009650152176618576, -0.009028570726513863, 0.00048550887731835246, -0.013671716675162315, 0.03093419224023819, 0.037764858454465866, -0.00345040881074965, 0.0327540822327137, -0.025738678872585297, -0.022081702947616577, -0.007034209556877613, 0.023235419765114784, 0.001680260058492422, 0.016177760437130928, -0.033946774899959564, 0.027122147381305695, 0.03492957353591919, -0.07167921215295792, 0.019114017486572266, -0.0031795953400433064, 0.005205078050494194, -0.045896921306848526, -0.012926080264151096, -0.023905036970973015, 0.02760218270123005, -0.04734361171722412, 0.014942540787160397, -0.059631362557411194, 0.07004432380199432, -0.006764706689864397, -0.06104179471731186, -0.04471270740032196, 0.04584493115544319, -0.004835418425500393, -0.01329938042908907, 0.009847734123468399, 0.042059481143951416, 0.02502431906759739, -0.034721437841653824, 0.0010352486278861761, -0.059400346130132675, -0.0016662945272400975, -0.011922918260097504, 0.0016569099389016628, 0.012169476598501205, 0.02497798763215542, -0.0017800690839067101, 0.009244360029697418, 0.014753909781575203, -0.04532816261053085, -0.010244165547192097, -0.047177646309137344, -0.015631012618541718, 0.006142904981970787, -0.003494675038382411, 0.04956650361418724, -0.024755103513598442, 0.004024537280201912, 0.020955156534910202, 0.07443667203187943, 0.01333753950893879, 0.007591236848384142, -0.022207945585250854, 0.0036698172334581614, 0.04080750048160553, 0.004407959058880806, -0.015669772401452065, -0.05997810512781143, -0.014565040357410908, -0.08269882947206497, 0.07149448990821838, -0.01181006245315075, -0.03271413967013359, 0.05128972604870796, 0.04107624664902687, 0.035544414073228836, 0.011404389515519142, 0.024567175656557083, 0.02154369279742241, -0.02173275128006935, -0.0071444702334702015, -0.04244302585721016, -0.044223036617040634, -0.02440100908279419, -0.009413947351276875, -0.09204009920358658, -0.045674532651901245, -0.04016740620136261, -0.04193989932537079, -0.009282204322516918, 0.009035023860633373, -0.03872695937752724, -0.009156223386526108, -0.02380184456706047, 0.008819918148219585, -0.10384058207273483, 0.050698522478342056, -0.012072327546775341, -0.008217591792345047, -0.03480157628655434, -0.009666124358773232, 0.036200977861881256, 0.0905342772603035, -0.018184613436460495, 0.06395317614078522, 0.03663068264722824, 0.015336265787482262, 0.000887504022102803, 0.01771346852183342, -0.05527937412261963, -0.028606677427887917, 0.013651024550199509, 0.0449199415743351, 0.022835178300738335, -0.008615778759121895, -0.02545723132789135, 0.0019630577880889177, 0.0006114741554483771, 0.016538985073566437, 0.04175858572125435, -0.009738932363688946, -0.013173840008676052, -0.00945036206394434, 0.0404326356947422, 0.011068403720855713, 0.040990252047777176, 0.0014773030998185277, -0.021358812227845192, -0.009257040917873383, -0.0172844547778368, 0.04066665470600128, 0.03298851102590561, -0.02057364210486412, 0.0009084150660783052, -0.04196224734187126, 0.03665906935930252, 0.0776292160153389, -0.0009133617277257144, 0.006386332679539919, 0.05025056004524231, -0.0033284726087003946, 0.022699695080518723, 0.0030094992835074663, -0.01812565140426159, 0.008786365389823914, 0.014762801118195057, -0.009267324581742287, 0.049007076770067215, 0.05655563250184059, -0.04041418060660362, -0.006515433546155691, -0.02141864039003849, -0.03694150224328041, 0.043353836983442307, 0.014739301055669785, -0.0036461767740547657, -0.0027865858282893896, 0.06062768027186394, -0.008851940743625164, 0.02952943928539753, 0.005604317877441645, -0.07953466475009918, 0.012805686332285404, 0.019387846812605858, -0.0029413176234811544, 0.010771338827908039, 0.003775207092985511, 0.10769610106945038, 0.01584572158753872, 0.006358785089105368, 0.04636570066213608, -0.07278113812208176, -0.017129162326455116, 0.03502555936574936, 0.011336463503539562, 0.07132069766521454, -0.05507431551814079, -0.004483967088162899, 0.059409379959106445, 0.0009778481908142567, 0.022605208680033684, -0.01789107359945774, 0.0027349567972123623, 0.037356290966272354, -0.0190122090280056, -0.06518480181694031, -0.01972232200205326, 0.045451920479536057, -0.047382548451423645, -0.017934508621692657, 0.03457390144467354, 0.017192499712109566, -0.016572145745158195, -0.006274213083088398, 0.005196368787437677, 0.01767379231750965, -0.016979148611426353, -0.010012717917561531, -0.015742456540465355, -0.013507574796676636, -0.01506324578076601, 0.0002869690943043679, 0.02656090259552002, 0.0038236528635025024, -0.012846278958022594, -0.010914284735918045, 0.12625253200531006, 0.07019196450710297, -0.022985920310020447, 0.014000719413161278, 0.027062781155109406, 0.0346987247467041, -0.048306453973054886, 0.04451373219490051, 0.008386043831706047, -0.00007535131589975208, -0.0555170513689518, 0.024523194879293442, -0.015858393162488937, 0.05227690562605858, -0.08269789814949036, 0.008882208727300167, 0.07277040183544159, -0.06121307983994484, 0.033294133841991425, -0.002863912843167782, -0.01001238264143467, 0.049994200468063354, -0.02463032677769661, -0.06902818381786346, 0.004704372491687536, -0.032909732311964035, 0.026115024462342262, -0.006673803087323904, -0.0224638469517231, 0.025728590786457062, -0.05851796269416809, -0.009984651580452919, 0.005212847609072924, 0.06995675712823868, 0.026542136445641518, 0.012308843433856964, -0.013794826343655586, -0.0024937638081610203, -0.018818341195583344, -0.02289358340203762, -0.10345673561096191, -0.06647267937660217, 0.013310103677213192, 0.0008031799225136638, 0.03677717596292496, 0.023968100547790527, 0.002224049298092723, -0.01651870273053646, -0.012120152823626995, -0.03654470294713974, -0.03592480346560478, 0.012147960253059864, 0.015261085703969002, -0.044811543077230453, -0.011695358902215958, 0.03784564509987831, 0.04220572113990784, -0.0162191279232502, -0.05937259644269943, -0.019298316910862923, -0.04982529953122139, -0.022955268621444702, -0.028928695246577263, -0.01929519511759281, 0.013456080108880997, 0.02556506171822548, 0.024975799024105072, -0.02894057147204876, -0.010857895016670227, 0.043421726673841476, 0.009205634705722332, 0.01936725154519081, 0.06444750726222992, -0.01438086200505495, 0.05384249612689018, 0.02243713289499283, -0.001588725484907627, -0.015239119529724121, 0.031014006584882736, -0.006155845243483782, -0.011413929052650928, 0.054204635322093964, 0.01063603162765503, -0.27659910917282104, 0.007563063874840736, 0.014746243134140968, 0.005175456870347261, 0.05451858788728714, -0.018594112247228622, 0.042730070650577545, -0.013552463613450527, -0.0211151372641325, -0.002996453084051609, -0.0029571326449513435, 0.0317813865840435, 0.007929915562272072, 0.014476480893790722, 0.022764625027775764, 0.018838347867131233, 0.009467095136642456, -0.0029784648213535547, 0.04698224738240242, 0.0006441993173211813, -0.01909267157316208, -0.07075879722833633, -0.03692162036895752, 0.01089569367468357, -0.0008241389878094196, 0.018579009920358658, -0.08426602184772491, 0.004820681642740965, -0.01821158267557621, -0.0184603501111269, -0.052834998816251755, 0.011679349467158318, -0.024383271113038063, 0.0013688072795048356, 0.047866251319646835, -0.005617934744805098, 0.00010972875315928832, -0.01334967091679573, 0.011665822938084602, 0.038940317928791046, 0.039399247616529465, -0.005039626266807318, -0.03096805512905121, 0.005112602841109037, 0.0671638697385788, 0.030902836471796036, -0.028974246233701706, -0.00011059925600420684, -0.04393715783953667, 0.049598466604948044, -0.00681016081944108, -0.06591233611106873, -0.007438125088810921, 0.014989200048148632, 0.00447231438010931, 0.012455516494810581, 0.00360492174513638, 0.019516868516802788, -0.032082390040159225, 0.003170871175825596, -0.021919086575508118, -0.05163278803229332, -0.005664140451699495, -0.04213832691311836, -0.020244665443897247, -0.015798570588231087, -0.06811438500881195, -0.07333510369062424, 0.03107661008834839, 0.08496388792991638, -0.05626799166202545, -0.0013801122549921274, -0.03793351724743843, -0.09385041892528534, 0.010677437297999859, -0.017974961549043655, -0.01565452292561531, -0.013280465267598629, -0.0018409376498311758, 0.012291455641388893, -0.04528947174549103, 0.005109639838337898, 0.0239834263920784, 0.06803601235151291, 0.009731050580739975, -0.029128532856702805, -0.017716774716973305, -0.02730441465973854, -0.02132592909038067, -0.028319429606199265, -0.02145371213555336, -0.003465153742581606, 0.03151622414588928, -0.031837236136198044, 0.019127674400806427, -0.007341218180954456, 0.0009519409504719079, 0.04828329756855965, 0.028305847197771072, 0.02358759008347988, 0.034944869577884674, -0.07136417180299759, -0.022782089188694954, -0.05151832103729248, -0.032203689217567444, 0.019787881523370743, -0.05198570340871811, -0.02683749981224537, 0.031724829226732254, -0.0015541162574663758, -0.0440683513879776, -0.041461508721113205, 0.009160172194242477, -0.005119995679706335, 0.02536156214773655, -0.006993590854108334, -0.004294899292290211, 0.057179126888513565, 0.0006294574704952538, -0.020650865510106087, -0.02432768978178501, 0.029498079791665077, -0.03776545822620392, -0.010985824279487133, 0.0016026668017730117, 0.004752612207084894, 0.01182700414210558, -0.013283148407936096, 0.002286541275680065, 0.0014380986103788018, 0.039389386773109436, 0.04203960672020912, -0.002669682027772069, 0.020085472613573074, 0.05394267290830612, 0.05207570269703865, -0.026545817032456398, 0.0072968206368386745, -0.0029951378237456083, -0.05326170474290848, 0.015719758346676826, -0.03290094435214996, 0.016769269481301308, -0.01705857366323471, 0.041201166808605194, 0.03953632712364197, 0.044703539460897446, 0.02606942504644394, -0.011021802201867104, 0.0008729231194593012, 0.002165404614061117, 0.012908944860100746, -0.0005776514299213886, -0.038487620651721954, -0.001570018008351326, 0.0068967388942837715, 0.07925014942884445, 0.01798861101269722, 0.037657443434000015, -0.08600978553295135, 0.025562191382050514, -0.02181742526590824, -0.026020262390375137, 0.026850681751966476, 0.0006213014712557197, 0.02956867404282093, -0.014187884517014027, -0.006163065787404776, 0.02060503512620926, 0.016844280064105988, -0.004154026508331299, -0.017999794334173203, -0.04016711562871933, 0.012566253542900085, -0.05463492497801781, 0.00028472935082390904, 0.01766478642821312, -0.014793720096349716, -0.015318230725824833, 0.01097005046904087, 0.021252084523439407, -0.009486211463809013, -0.0055502112954854965, 0.008931025862693787, 0.0794784426689148, -0.001380967441946268, -0.046849608421325684, -0.01564079336822033, -0.0007822354673407972, -0.004268838558346033, 0.00795589666813612, -0.004472209606319666, -0.011738254688680172, -0.0323566272854805, -0.0009879530407488346, -0.056444209069013596, 0.006879530381411314, 0.03312422335147858, -0.04289808124303818, -0.015042916871607304, 0.0026809137780219316, 0.04073091223835945, -0.05711103603243828, 0.007354033179581165, 0.021499449387192726, -0.041337307542562485, -0.001514063565991819, 0.041451722383499146, 0.009605772793293, 0.017024150118231773, -0.0343119278550148, -0.07355563342571259, -0.047447316348552704, 0.024574270471930504, 0.03493292257189751, 0.020693346858024597, 0.0293340552598238, -0.006219055037945509, 0.020640676841139793, 0.03017253801226616, 0.025894224643707275, 0.01737211085855961, 0.014491935260593891, -0.030556892976164818, 0.014198383316397667, 0.038793209940195084, 0.014762811362743378, 0.04102513939142227, -0.007483530789613724, -0.05458443984389305, 0.030238380655646324, -0.05931762605905533, 0.02306159771978855, 0.025225825607776642, -0.010779257863759995, -0.009329916909337044, -0.041319072246551514, 0.03463363274931908, 0.014401940628886223, -0.039097465574741364, 0.0014309185789898038, -0.0025789421051740646, -0.017695171758532524, 0.00736953504383564, -0.014120183885097504, -0.0008420934900641441, -0.00619561318308115, 0.009320375509560108, -0.025076422840356827, 0.03291044756770134, 0.0040821353904902935, -0.020508771762251854, -0.03581910952925682, 0.0017574916128069162, 0.04945402592420578, -0.011707218363881111, -0.078209787607193, -0.06589239090681076, -0.04847482964396477, 0.004421694204211235, -0.0034734916407614946, 0.031892187893390656, -0.048771001398563385, 0.04357639700174332, 0.01664571277797222, 0.015044981613755226, 0.0004415981820784509, -0.028233259916305542, 0.05497182160615921, -0.026855725795030594, -0.02203010767698288, -0.056051384657621384, -0.0022352938540279865, 0.05197124928236008, -0.028114067390561104, 0.0350046306848526, -0.015795337036252022, -0.01465347595512867, 0.020606733858585358, -0.04204084351658821, -0.04692020267248154, 0.04310782253742218, 0.013624551706016064, 0.007322677876800299, 0.03243812173604965, -0.026985550299286842, -0.02490556240081787, -0.012135589495301247, -0.03527515381574631, -0.010379048064351082, 0.012835838831961155, 0.056032128632068634, -0.0599314346909523, -0.0338771678507328, -0.0590851791203022, 0.02936549298465252, 0.01804928295314312, 0.036393649876117706, 0.037933144718408585, 0.003977678716182709, -0.02559489756822586, 0.0989224761724472, 0.08448569476604462, 0.04049273952841759, -0.006996620912104845, 0.012521770782768726, -0.015092041343450546, -0.024206355214118958, -0.0019541026558727026, 0.021709434688091278, 0.007747098803520203, -0.0528421513736248, 0.06289634853601456, 0.005724182352423668, -0.0491819866001606, 0.015936551615595818, 0.029962673783302307, -0.018877433612942696, -0.0161786787211895, 0.007000857964158058, 0.0013243205612525344, 0.012312701903283596, 0.040199149399995804, 0.0020738241728395224, 0.04325265437364578, 0.042673543095588684, 0.00985371321439743, 0.028613274917006493, -0.02297963760793209, 0.09863169491291046, 0.05176616460084915, 0.00657961331307888, 0.02805367298424244, 0.06535399705171585, -0.019852882251143456, -0.0554095059633255, -0.011639091186225414, 0.03902624174952507, -0.03608065843582153, -0.035685453563928604, 0.02400972694158554, 0.05624720826745033, -0.009446769021451473, 0.05256194621324539, -0.015144610777497292, -0.017560601234436035, 0.008464997634291649, -0.009993771091103554, 0.011864160187542439, 0.017341116443276405, 0.019795488566160202, 0.0027585511561483145, -0.04561489820480347, -0.010392528958618641, -0.0027321495581418276, -0.0002877131337299943, 0.02363208867609501, -0.028277697041630745, -0.025743205100297928, 0.003710574936121702, -0.04185132682323456, 0.03109356015920639, 0.09681155532598495, 0.014788207598030567, -0.03968723863363266, 0.000022723617803421803, 0.021046604961156845, -0.01916208490729332, 0.034661151468753815, -0.013837628997862339, -0.0004257326072547585, -0.011797665618360043, -0.05059671029448509, 0.00022843730403110385, 0.009247071109712124, -0.010783238336443901, 0.013642976060509682, -0.01888330467045307, -0.026454176753759384, 0.037588972598314285, 0.016838520765304565, -0.06399405747652054, -0.05840650200843811, -0.023407908156514168, -0.043748050928115845, -0.05287133529782295, -0.07227184623479843, 0.014593887142837048, -0.025400778278708458, -0.022708753123879433, 0.05132431164383888, -0.042150843888521194, 0.020046468824148178, 0.02198520302772522, -0.06399807333946228, -0.03755881264805794, 0.07162511348724365, -0.01247820071876049, -0.002037931000813842, 0.045480258762836456, 0.024248186498880386, 0.001714072423055768, -0.017115313559770584, 0.04881419241428375, 0.048832863569259644, 0.025727443397045135, -0.005499623715877533, 0.03508422151207924, -0.10364904999732971, 0.026589347049593925, 0.038147974759340286, -0.05684168264269829, -0.08395330607891083, 0.037699341773986816, -0.0012259545037522912, 0.03391185775399208, 0.05277981981635094, 0.007219940423965454, -0.031169410794973373, -0.03554598242044449, 0.005177744198590517, 0.007136525586247444, -0.020835913717746735, 0.0498301163315773, -0.052063263952732086, 0.0677909329533577, 0.0011162945302203298, -0.02926868572831154, -0.06176997721195221, 0.00030110805528238416, 0.03700445592403412, 0.008767756633460522, -0.018881401047110558, -0.02526116743683815, -0.06353769451379776, -0.0751437097787857, -0.02823527529835701, 0.062365468591451645, -0.027120616286993027, -0.017813818529248238, 0.0013509284472092986, 0.043062303215265274, 0.03919314593076706, -0.014547253027558327, -0.005537626799196005, -0.04286422207951546, -0.046825945377349854, -0.051852934062480927, -0.05613137409090996, 0.006946765352040529, -0.04180429130792618, -0.015534582547843456, -0.023377995938062668, -0.04244772344827652, 0.033497344702482224, -0.005487627349793911, 0.027633627876639366, 0.006756887771189213, 0.013654537498950958, 0.029937854036688805 ]
3,582
Improving Unsupervised Constituency Parsing via Maximizing Semantic Information
https://openreview.net/forum?id=qyU5s4fzLg
[ "Junjie Chen", "Xiangheng He", "Yusuke Miyao", "Danushka Bollegala" ]
Spotlight
Unsupervised constituency parsers organize phrases within a sentence into a tree-shaped syntactic constituent structure that reflects the organization of sentence semantics. However, the traditional objective of maximizing sentence log-likelihood (LL) does not explicitly account for the close relationship between the constituent structure and the semantics, resulting in a weak correlation between LL values and parsing accuracy. In this paper, we introduce a novel objective that trains parsers by maximizing SemInfo, the semantic information encoded in constituent structures. We introduce a bag-of-substrings model to represent the semantics and estimate the SemInfo value using the probability-weighted information metric. We apply the SemInfo maximization objective to training Probabilistic Context-Free Grammar (PCFG) parsers and develop a Tree Conditional Random Field (TreeCRF)-based model to facilitate the training. Experiments show that SemInfo correlates more strongly with parsing accuracy than LL, establishing SemInfo as a better unsupervised parsing objective. As a result, our algorithm significantly improves parsing accuracy by an average of 7.85 sentence-F1 scores across five PCFG variants and in four languages, achieving state-of-the-art level results in three of the four languages.
unsupervised constituency parsing, information theory, semantic information
null
4,272
2410.02558
[ -0.013855126686394215, -0.026545779779553413, -0.011020352132618427, 0.03602597117424011, 0.03476004675030708, 0.009182842448353767, 0.03250256925821304, 0.009423675015568733, -0.002098899567499757, 0.0009938180446624756, -0.03041199967265129, 0.028598681092262268, -0.06545664370059967, -0.0069248792715370655, 0.014594413340091705, 0.05227500572800636, 0.017299721017479897, -0.016519395634531975, 0.023698925971984863, -0.012493343092501163, -0.00912956427782774, 0.007148326374590397, 0.024630092084407806, 0.014391445554792881, 0.08153076469898224, 0.05254311487078667, 0.03132697939872742, -0.014383941888809204, -0.004460412077605724, 0.01277220994234085, 0.032547760754823685, -0.006937968544661999, -0.011708436533808708, -0.009290226735174656, -0.0004796549037564546, -0.00480668107047677, -0.023017508909106255, 0.0071142083033919334, 0.02179567515850067, 0.008928491733968258, -0.053783517330884933, 0.009019286371767521, -0.01614762656390667, 0.0024296476040035486, -0.06002723053097725, -0.027729874476790428, -0.09120868891477585, 0.013943564146757126, -0.0053094797767698765, -0.038097552955150604, -0.11226043105125427, 0.025323275476694107, 0.008059274405241013, -0.02146303839981556, 0.0031894466374069452, 0.06040876358747482, 0.045818526297807693, -0.07496921718120575, -0.013070805929601192, -0.02472773753106594, -0.03530255705118179, 0.010838456451892853, 0.006015912629663944, 0.002134469337761402, 0.010631982237100601, -0.02641582302749157, -0.05928276479244232, 0.023943141102790833, -0.03848179429769516, -0.061094388365745544, 0.0030155929271131754, 0.010772635228931904, -0.02257327176630497, 0.034934643656015396, 0.04757276549935341, -0.031892240047454834, 0.010902130976319313, 0.03530760109424591, 0.04813406243920326, 0.01663016714155674, -0.012334704399108887, 0.024330902844667435, 0.015205382369458675, 0.030041346326470375, 0.014151927083730698, 0.006911033298820257, -0.05369466170668602, -0.028850266709923744, -0.0611114427447319, 0.0379694439470768, 0.012608790770173073, -0.04949318617582321, 0.012403854168951511, 0.00910141970962286, 0.00017398453201167285, 0.021059725433588028, 0.04310307651758194, 0.03693336993455887, 0.00653837388381362, -0.013941608369350433, -0.04063912481069565, -0.015240125358104706, 0.075332872569561, 0.006793627981096506, -0.10275992751121521, -0.03282976523041725, -0.0545935295522213, -0.011532551608979702, 0.025646083056926727, -0.020450374111533165, -0.00038630925700999796, -0.017631320282816887, 0.03929984197020531, 0.007758330553770065, -0.055559489876031876, 0.027364300563931465, -0.0019198376685380936, 0.01525858137756586, 0.007378182839602232, 0.010092007927596569, 0.03207085654139519, 0.04930032417178154, 0.029253920540213585, 0.08211926370859146, -0.003393764840438962, 0.030098337680101395, 0.0023270021192729473, 0.05255725607275963, -0.046769626438617706, -0.03812960907816887, -0.011130820959806442, 0.04446417838335037, 0.005893804598599672, 0.041219308972358704, -0.03141983970999718, 0.0037850968074053526, -0.005103163421154022, 0.014750796370208263, 0.08341346681118011, -0.01570151560008526, -0.00520581379532814, -0.025673719123005867, 0.04518403112888336, -0.011652493849396706, 0.05582070350646973, -0.03648911789059639, -0.024565700441598892, -0.013163088820874691, -0.034087907522916794, 0.01613485813140869, 0.03237753361463547, -0.04249982163310051, 0.04881393164396286, -0.06586543470621109, 0.029246458783745766, 0.07708179205656052, 0.024020906537771225, -0.01612682454288006, 0.019773786887526512, 0.020866520702838898, 0.017582552507519722, 0.01712857186794281, -0.054521311074495316, 0.01697448268532753, -0.01609177701175213, -0.07903508841991425, 0.04700608178973198, 0.034806814044713974, -0.05162976682186127, 0.03161945939064026, -0.008382015861570835, -0.049331482499837875, 0.07158280909061432, -0.05810561031103134, -0.04642566666007042, -0.01790856570005417, 0.051007747650146484, -0.01125413179397583, 0.03910014405846596, 0.02085750736296177, -0.08087672293186188, 0.022395212203264236, -0.017595341429114342, -0.0084179462864995, 0.020170141011476517, 0.0047833118587732315, 0.063804030418396, -0.003363704774528742, 0.0035819057375192642, 0.011750026606023312, -0.05450715497136116, -0.0339391753077507, 0.009776204824447632, -0.026976946741342545, 0.059075210243463516, -0.012759319506585598, 0.018697645515203476, 0.04904312640428543, -0.0014234166592359543, 0.04035467654466629, 0.02152039110660553, 0.010546676814556122, 0.04278462007641792, 0.006350586656481028, -0.04605184122920036, 0.008070963434875011, 0.028480689972639084, -0.038809485733509064, -0.03141951933503151, 0.01617373712360859, -0.025584017857909203, 0.0296523105353117, 0.016919299960136414, -0.029178228229284286, -0.008893328718841076, 0.009252185001969337, -0.009121344424784184, -0.03320441022515297, 0.01737944222986698, -0.04008619487285614, 0.037871506065130234, 0.017201676964759827, -0.03189016506075859, -0.006021495442837477, -0.03256865590810776, 0.09424283355474472, 0.06874082237482071, -0.009813842363655567, 0.009499382227659225, 0.03741830214858055, 0.018916578963398933, -0.006938510108739138, 0.02660655416548252, -0.026003263890743256, -0.004868640564382076, -0.009583769366145134, -0.021027226001024246, -0.048329249024391174, 0.05372365191578865, -0.02437152899801731, 0.016866549849510193, 0.04832276329398155, -0.043289098888635635, 0.022963954135775566, 0.01214609481394291, 0.0007263827719725668, 0.046308837831020355, -0.033712420612573624, 0.0016952072037383914, -0.032006047666072845, -0.016694193705916405, -0.005802238825708628, -0.007719389628618956, -0.021304842084646225, 0.02918022684752941, -0.02289639413356781, -0.01862429454922676, -0.01399307046085596, 0.07363609224557877, 0.049721792340278625, 0.037535659968853, 0.0005477481172420084, -0.009654643945395947, -0.0481293760240078, 0.0014197734417393804, -0.09863006323575974, 0.011144894175231457, -0.045541465282440186, 0.020178839564323425, 0.03527199476957321, 0.015103600919246674, -0.009613579139113426, 0.03456725925207138, -0.0036235505249351263, 0.011318819597363472, 0.007361544296145439, 0.03848645091056824, 0.00543260807171464, -0.05198129266500473, -0.02145651914179325, -0.02653471753001213, 0.014003777876496315, -0.04531613364815712, -0.022832008078694344, -0.05133594945073128, -0.038175322115421295, -0.0026910079177469015, -0.03063376620411873, 0.0013578446814790368, 0.034533824771642685, 0.010289696976542473, 0.013243597000837326, -0.008808114565908909, -0.01976155862212181, 0.07381104677915573, 0.013455552980303764, 0.056435901671648026, 0.015380068682134151, -0.016579747200012207, 0.020400527864694595, -0.018620258197188377, 0.015056447125971317, -0.0064856987446546555, 0.04793664067983627, 0.004115100484341383, -0.005713936407119036, -0.008150158450007439, 0.0062100933864712715, -0.26411527395248413, -0.01683921180665493, -0.026991721242666245, -0.0311705581843853, 0.030181363224983215, -0.03017476201057434, 0.02196657471358776, -0.05012992024421692, -0.019838007166981697, 0.018211036920547485, 0.0012174947187304497, 0.009058009833097458, 0.026488948613405228, 0.04509151726961136, 0.046160321682691574, 0.022375836968421936, -0.0023126211017370224, -0.008099474012851715, 0.009271107614040375, 0.03563959151506424, 0.02338249608874321, -0.05902818590402603, -0.000351232971297577, 0.05254953354597092, -0.0005315320449881256, 0.0701424852013588, -0.08106188476085663, -0.014928912743926048, -0.04137701168656349, -0.012985769659280777, -0.0010612442856654525, -0.006092495750635862, 0.00583410682156682, -0.006604648660868406, -0.019343562424182892, -0.0081410463899374, 0.022498127073049545, 0.026569128036499023, 0.024174625054001808, 0.03661113232374191, -0.0011491604382172227, -0.03482777252793312, -0.009353101253509521, 0.0005541818682104349, 0.05241093412041664, -0.009613164700567722, -0.0627063438296318, -0.03411286696791649, -0.01410195603966713, 0.03607727214694023, -0.017251919955015182, -0.03549281135201454, -0.021499453112483025, 0.008786799386143684, 0.03045005351305008, -0.03732600063085556, 0.05572928488254547, -0.03057950548827648, -0.03593521937727928, -0.024451415985822678, 0.023031065240502357, -0.04757010191679001, -0.0024291707668453455, -0.04318772256374359, -0.022342033684253693, -0.01668201945722103, -0.0631164163351059, -0.033256519585847855, 0.0272094514220953, 0.05342128872871399, -0.025569822639226913, 0.03548380360007286, 0.008854375220835209, -0.07000146806240082, -0.011368788778781891, -0.0021869968622922897, -0.02085511013865471, -0.025943659245967865, -0.004695536568760872, 0.0449838750064373, -0.05755004659295082, -0.03824875131249428, -0.0020098804961889982, 0.02941681258380413, 0.04593292251229286, -0.023125499486923218, 0.0032259703148156404, -0.03883422166109085, -0.034195080399513245, -0.06068246066570282, 0.046939823776483536, -0.01664160005748272, 0.009682404808700085, 0.03038686513900757, 0.03467688709497452, 0.06667584925889969, -0.006045091897249222, 0.05699535086750984, 0.046912796795368195, -0.006217012647539377, 0.034495577216148376, -0.0493614599108696, -0.016615182161331177, -0.018916048109531403, -0.04456690326333046, 0.028872203081846237, -0.07350921630859375, -0.012981626205146313, 0.013852536678314209, -0.011686916463077068, -0.03848244622349739, -0.029906537383794785, 0.008546455763280392, -0.009077447466552258, 0.0029474396724253893, 0.013652171939611435, 0.0017164205200970173, 0.009846149012446404, 0.024003110826015472, -0.0054631661623716354, -0.02546836994588375, 0.015964576974511147, -0.03989947587251663, -0.014755523763597012, -0.022117268294095993, -0.048551663756370544, 0.013223609887063503, -0.0334949865937233, -0.0318743959069252, -0.0124775730073452, 0.02344590239226818, 0.03314225375652313, -0.00232153688557446, 0.005347852129489183, 0.06923853605985641, -0.0031770924106240273, -0.007017959840595722, -0.02368185855448246, 0.018117621541023254, -0.019786309450864792, -0.002075757598504424, -0.013481887057423592, 0.0376959890127182, 0.05720188096165657, 0.045479223132133484, -0.0037651199381798506, -0.002671182621270418, 0.0044225603342056274, 0.0009505497291684151, 0.009354155510663986, 0.03516721352934837, -0.032969292253255844, -0.02224068157374859, -0.05074978992342949, -0.0075624482706189156, -0.012418176978826523, 0.03606762737035751, 0.00043341252603568137, 0.02039424702525139, -0.06816743314266205, 0.03345850855112076, -0.03177865594625473, 0.015726853162050247, -0.03456496819853783, 0.04385768622159958, 0.016614357009530067, -0.012465993873775005, 0.03157476335763931, 0.027223054319620132, 0.02092624083161354, 0.014608017168939114, 0.0023050056770443916, -0.03202756494283676, 0.026486588642001152, -0.03180260583758354, -0.02169412188231945, 0.01871536299586296, 0.017243847250938416, -0.041726477444171906, 0.06496517360210419, -0.007036295253783464, -0.009928703308105469, -0.004152410198003054, 0.015505221672356129, 0.09576746076345444, 0.05257546901702881, -0.0022446310613304377, -0.019781693816184998, -0.04828169196844101, 0.04095163568854332, -0.008669881150126457, -0.01631915755569935, -0.011357196606695652, -0.038892876356840134, -0.028690043836832047, -0.04740418866276741, -0.009437047876417637, 0.020820971578359604, -0.03203781694173813, 0.004602631088346243, -0.03982359170913696, -0.014863856136798859, -0.055824995040893555, -0.03379552438855171, 0.04038533568382263, -0.07119947671890259, 0.010729159228503704, 0.017909962683916092, 0.0074972128495574, 0.023912817239761353, -0.02045517973601818, -0.04378320276737213, -0.044632650911808014, -0.044047761708498, 0.013178173452615738, -0.011109254322946072, -0.02073427103459835, -0.020616300404071808, -0.034283485263586044, -0.026549512520432472, 0.02713179960846901, -0.012138708494603634, -0.005803513806313276, -0.03559897840023041, 0.0266339760273695, 0.07798286527395248, -0.008907172828912735, -0.06413917243480682, 0.012281154282391071, -0.04668304696679115, 0.004358591046184301, -0.03969539329409599, 0.04569292441010475, 0.05289949104189873, -0.0034593623131513596, 0.003531543305143714, -0.06072401627898216, 0.02249576896429062, 0.02657320536673069, 0.008066531270742416, 0.028701046481728554, -0.008996955119073391, -0.018556810915470123, 0.027330458164215088, -0.048789504915475845, 0.0349094457924366, 0.04087841138243675, -0.024969400838017464, -0.003680180525407195, 0.042607538402080536, 0.03008652850985527, 0.026905646547675133, -0.06006854027509689, 0.008742128498852253, 0.051907386630773544, 0.0075429282151162624, -0.07958079874515533, -0.06613407284021378, -0.03399256616830826, 0.038276854902505875, 0.003470958909019828, 0.011351408436894417, -0.02851804345846176, 0.08017983287572861, 0.01846095360815525, 0.05505825951695442, -0.03467502072453499, -0.013248493894934654, 0.03182046115398407, -0.01889018714427948, -0.0002822369569912553, -0.06188078597187996, -0.02220340259373188, 0.10987763851881027, -0.02329511009156704, -0.0061698006466031075, -0.024644358083605766, -0.018296221271157265, 0.007191353943198919, 0.0033458396792411804, -0.06909891217947006, 0.014168329536914825, 0.016757583245635033, 0.00021793463383801281, -0.0010189436143264174, -0.058514028787612915, -0.02338746190071106, 0.00609842361882329, -0.026772884652018547, -0.013145485892891884, -0.012242023833096027, 0.08115661144256592, -0.031462643295526505, 0.002028954913839698, -0.032848648726940155, 0.003710058517754078, 0.01794378273189068, 0.09330601990222931, 0.023924391716718674, 0.025912722572684288, -0.05435515195131302, 0.050039369612932205, 0.03011825866997242, -0.00898832455277443, -0.05088084191083908, -0.016309143975377083, -0.0014993301592767239, -0.08626967668533325, 0.047714732587337494, 0.007824508473277092, 0.03483933210372925, -0.059322457760572433, 0.07373146712779999, 0.02455073967576027, -0.02728043496608734, -0.03545287251472473, 0.015365430153906345, -0.03158537670969963, -0.0039654443971812725, -0.017837824299931526, 0.02926228940486908, -0.026648366823792458, 0.07135015726089478, 0.04445703700184822, 0.014523789286613464, 0.07298219203948975, 0.0123064573854208, 0.011378797702491283, 0.001540963537991047, 0.052609022706747055, 0.03932551294565201, 0.04728464037179947, -0.0022859149612486362, 0.05759291723370552, -0.0499151274561882, -0.05914415419101715, 0.018096836283802986, 0.006374824792146683, 0.01927759125828743, -0.03566208481788635, 0.01860201545059681, 0.08051493763923645, -0.014775746501982212, 0.07389973849058151, -0.025247149169445038, -0.014743615873157978, 0.04191423952579498, 0.011111733503639698, 0.03959798812866211, 0.05602826178073883, 0.024433383718132973, 0.005165774840861559, 0.0006027371855452657, 0.0015962091274559498, -0.002109409077093005, -0.02141704224050045, -0.01164148561656475, -0.01069154404103756, -0.02817569673061371, 0.02510574832558632, -0.00021270215802360326, 0.07137835770845413, 0.07697691023349762, -0.017169445753097534, -0.04352850839495659, 0.02150728739798069, 0.009673533029854298, 0.03239348903298378, 0.07209351658821106, -0.0006702297832816839, -0.03713814914226532, -0.005979574751108885, -0.044816505163908005, -0.017551342025399208, -0.018049748614430428, -0.02367762289941311, 0.041057344526052475, -0.018506307154893875, -0.016399528831243515, 0.010735922493040562, 0.004861750639975071, -0.05647454038262367, -0.05949605256319046, -0.0063576363027095795, -0.03610512241721153, -0.0430641770362854, -0.058108650147914886, 0.00264177517965436, 0.02445678412914276, 0.010285724885761738, -0.0051244888454675674, -0.040774155408144, 0.00009028248314280063, 0.010039681568741798, -0.059670332819223404, 0.020160526037216187, 0.041497211903333664, 0.005903452169150114, -0.02409704215824604, 0.040030501782894135, -0.0013321536825969815, -0.028642304241657257, 0.006554031744599342, 0.06331673264503479, 0.02482861466705799, 0.017969969660043716, 0.006201577372848988, -0.014016998931765556, -0.08384236693382263, 0.022065311670303345, 0.01837869919836521, -0.014212705194950104, -0.08000576496124268, 0.010934889316558838, 0.0035297644790261984, 0.04463966190814972, 0.045854486525058746, 0.004270102828741074, 0.012058185413479805, -0.012190754525363445, -0.01781250350177288, 0.012623544782400131, 0.00025133354938589036, 0.06587476283311844, -0.016544083133339882, 0.07462584972381592, 0.03753862529993057, 0.017431357875466347, -0.05424744263291359, 0.015138120390474796, -0.013194200582802296, -0.035892829298973083, -0.018588056787848473, -0.03743762895464897, -0.02469824254512787, -0.09969833493232727, -0.04649968072772026, 0.03016403317451477, -0.014263827353715897, -0.02533021569252014, -0.01611226424574852, -0.02895914763212204, -0.02902575396001339, 0.019519563764333725, 0.006575231906026602, 0.009701849892735481, -0.0021446081809699535, -0.024320710450410843, -0.068275086581707, -0.020580120384693146, -0.03206643462181091, -0.006954299286007881, -0.03506835550069809, -0.014830471947789192, -0.03206910938024521, 0.018663616850972176, 0.05170963704586029, 0.019879795610904694, 0.011878556571900845, -0.036586880683898926 ]
3,583
Student-Informed Teacher Training
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Dzh0hQPpuf
[ "Nico Messikommer", "Jiaxu Xing", "Elie Aljalbout", "Davide Scaramuzza" ]
Spotlight
Imitation learning with a privileged teacher has proven effective for learning complex control behaviors from high-dimensional inputs, such as images. In this framework, a teacher is trained with privileged task information, while a student tries to predict the actions of the teacher with more limited observations, e.g., in a robot navigation task, the teacher might have access to distances to nearby obstacles, while the student only receives visual observations of the scene. However, privileged imitation learning faces a key challenge: the student might be unable to imitate the teacher's behavior due to partial observability. This problem arises because the teacher is trained without considering if the student is capable of imitating the learned behavior. To address this teacher-student asymmetry, we propose a framework for joint training of the teacher and student policies, encouraging the teacher to learn behaviors that can be imitated by the student despite the latters' limited access to information and its partial observability. Based on the performance bound in imitation learning, we add (i) the approximated action difference between teacher and student as a penalty term to the reward function of the teacher, and (ii) a supervised teacher-student alignment step. We motivate our method with a maze navigation task and demonstrate its effectiveness on complex vision-based quadrotor flight and manipulation tasks.
Reinforcement Learning, Imitation Learning, Robotics
To address the teacher-student asymmetry in imitation learning, we propose a joint learning framework for both teacher and student, adapting the teacher to the capabilities of the student during training to enhance alignment.
4,246
2412.09149
[ -0.015785738825798035, -0.037936147302389145, -0.01367899589240551, 0.05399871617555618, 0.0462203249335289, 0.003083072369918227, 0.035893216729164124, 0.006574269384145737, -0.03281041979789734, -0.024969659745693207, -0.04694939777255058, -0.0025019964668899775, -0.05770464241504669, -0.016013704240322113, -0.03534670174121857, 0.05497590824961662, 0.013783137314021587, -0.028104424476623535, -0.010795613750815392, 0.03198876231908798, -0.03820279985666275, -0.028672100976109505, 0.03878453001379967, 0.005786035675555468, 0.01854904554784298, 0.02119068056344986, 0.013953841291368008, 0.023735903203487396, -0.013694273307919502, -0.02251824177801609, 0.010905854403972626, -0.026548802852630615, 0.030656810849905014, -0.01976914331316948, 0.007002023048698902, 0.015282031148672104, -0.02798689901828766, -0.001188255031593144, 0.007064429111778736, -0.009755468927323818, -0.019637973979115486, 0.00819062814116478, -0.01833256520330906, -0.022351307794451714, -0.04543467238545418, 0.009750657714903355, -0.09205645322799683, 0.04203084111213684, 0.043137259781360626, -0.02266700379550457, -0.10257650166749954, 0.05302192643284798, 0.03627470135688782, -0.023735325783491135, -0.0018210671842098236, 0.034950897097587585, 0.05349531024694443, -0.07948565483093262, 0.008436247706413269, -0.0775931254029274, -0.004030718933790922, 0.041546352207660675, 0.012514293193817139, 0.005379009060561657, 0.010341458022594452, 0.014055411331355572, 0.02288581058382988, 0.026943176984786987, -0.03393586352467537, -0.03685150295495987, -0.04625421389937401, -0.03262612968683243, 0.0007325144833885133, 0.02870059758424759, 0.020495811477303505, -0.049073476344347, 0.03679988160729408, 0.0239697378128767, 0.054424773901700974, -0.028740927577018738, 0.009948267601430416, 0.030858946964144707, -0.01409171149134636, 0.027687031775712967, 0.02391938678920269, 0.002774309366941452, -0.04139163717627525, -0.011073706671595573, -0.06951548904180527, 0.045452963560819626, -0.02877315878868103, -0.03812120482325554, -0.005664448719471693, 0.03436454012989998, 0.015532509423792362, 0.00012079517910024151, 0.0352676585316658, -0.006669629365205765, 0.02338627725839615, -0.02456585131585598, -0.014957774430513382, -0.037657614797353745, 0.007121262140572071, 0.00469459081068635, -0.08788345754146576, -0.025954876095056534, -0.017648959532380104, -0.01686878688633442, -0.05024246871471405, 0.04596048220992088, -0.08555056154727936, 0.016326740384101868, 0.016670187935233116, -0.03787194564938545, -0.0734652429819107, 0.044245511293411255, -0.01103144884109497, 0.06918884068727493, -0.018196526914834976, 0.015892324969172478, 0.02896595001220703, 0.0305185504257679, -0.011633175425231457, 0.052119180560112, 0.028686080127954483, 0.03880337253212929, -0.0013565565459430218, 0.03773077204823494, -0.05119730159640312, -0.027057738974690437, 0.05327378213405609, 0.022197017446160316, 0.024337299168109894, 0.01461346261203289, -0.011994443833827972, -0.01571003906428814, 0.031392112374305725, -0.0020365004893392324, 0.006320253945887089, 0.01900426670908928, 0.007627543061971664, 0.0072062755934894085, 0.07140563428401947, -0.03748819977045059, 0.06710248440504074, -0.0225368719547987, 0.023963067680597305, -0.002334797056391835, -0.054715149104595184, 0.0039116740226745605, -0.00203334866091609, -0.044914159923791885, 0.0038067952264100313, -0.06952370703220367, 0.0149845564737916, 0.022939573973417282, 0.018268637359142303, 0.022621897980570793, 0.00793600082397461, -0.001585661550052464, 0.007817096076905727, 0.017298918217420578, -0.03089427947998047, -0.039234012365341187, 0.004710276145488024, -0.04908259958028793, 0.031732574105262756, 0.0196579247713089, -0.026779603213071823, 0.0015747523866593838, -0.044362135231494904, -0.016060788184404373, 0.04891900345683098, -0.022013559937477112, -0.03563835099339485, -0.007166791241616011, 0.023249436169862747, -0.03274575248360634, 0.08047057688236237, 0.007296113297343254, -0.0639764815568924, 0.028241610154509544, -0.012629290111362934, -0.017533067613840103, -0.015332616865634918, -0.05149490013718605, 0.046113815158605576, -0.02278764359652996, -0.022853555157780647, 0.009574230760335922, -0.07363226264715195, -0.0034995204769074917, 0.033960651606321335, -0.020783280953764915, 0.05625380203127861, 0.01950974017381668, -0.0008621177403256297, 0.011210535652935505, 0.024158578366041183, 0.08226525783538818, 0.012489152140915394, -0.026752853766083717, 0.05351386219263077, 0.01116575300693512, 0.004334063269197941, -0.013575236313045025, 0.02205287665128708, -0.05344243347644806, -0.03389612212777138, 0.034702904522418976, -0.029163479804992676, 0.006682810839265585, 0.018320905044674873, 0.012680464424192905, 0.02387416921555996, 0.004153606481850147, -0.05547219514846802, 0.0050695533864200115, 0.034053537994623184, -0.010498814284801483, -0.0033495735842734575, 0.012791845016181469, -0.02537018060684204, 0.016218125820159912, -0.039236851036548615, 0.09506408125162125, 0.06519754976034164, -0.02723563462495804, -0.020075632259249687, 0.03808020055294037, -0.014602545648813248, -0.02594674751162529, -0.0054774838499724865, -0.000584426277782768, 0.02977442741394043, -0.02125001884996891, 0.00698597077280283, -0.03175526112318039, 0.0695982575416565, -0.0730120912194252, -0.020353099331259727, 0.0793357565999031, -0.0031754341907799244, 0.07358170300722122, 0.021720189601182938, 0.00199501751922071, 0.04922587051987648, 0.03958723321557045, -0.0017656827112659812, 0.0002495093212928623, -0.05018021538853645, 0.00036305372486822307, 0.01100645400583744, -0.023882059380412102, -0.008720100857317448, -0.04658407345414162, -0.009522687643766403, -0.041056081652641296, 0.07709667086601257, 0.05152396112680435, 0.011047556065022945, 0.06272677332162857, 0.012712055817246437, 0.0012844358570873737, -0.017081305384635925, -0.10943026095628738, -0.011640185490250587, -0.008625690825283527, 0.023037893697619438, 0.048921551555395126, 0.01807483844459057, -0.013538646511733532, 0.0551799051463604, -0.019112277776002884, -0.06175748631358147, 0.033039845526218414, 0.02493874542415142, 0.01001281663775444, -0.02579527720808983, -0.0323895663022995, 0.006865635514259338, 0.07934573292732239, 0.01744566485285759, -0.003673179540783167, -0.015909545123577118, -0.044881124049425125, -0.014943964779376984, -0.04798358678817749, -0.0372890830039978, 0.0162067674100399, 0.013155234977602959, 0.025285599753260612, -0.016994474455714226, 0.0053867436945438385, 0.01827583648264408, 0.05379607155919075, 0.012568521313369274, -0.011379798874258995, 0.0008314292645081878, -0.006071493029594421, -0.029992803931236267, 0.03216521814465523, -0.03022441640496254, 0.029890010133385658, -0.009494972415268421, 0.017590807750821114, 0.0296209454536438, 0.03417438641190529, -0.2438635230064392, -0.03450567647814751, 0.013102533295750618, 0.009586653672158718, 0.047455545514822006, -0.02652537077665329, 0.06629618257284164, -0.0358513668179512, -0.059214890003204346, 0.032989609986543655, 0.04013705253601074, 0.0434703528881073, 0.020033301785588264, 0.09049572795629501, 0.01080919336527586, 0.007394141051918268, 0.0032060875091701746, -0.03628430515527725, -0.0034735621884465218, 0.031682927161455154, -0.03336621820926666, -0.08093421906232834, -0.05862794816493988, 0.0501103512942791, 0.003519554855301976, 0.05525067076086998, -0.08333389461040497, -0.05133769288659096, -0.0390898697078228, -0.010675588622689247, -0.023139413446187973, -0.008804061450064182, -0.03983456268906593, 0.02406974509358406, 0.002593917539343238, 0.028435345739126205, 0.03896186873316765, -0.01071343757212162, 0.035071853548288345, 0.019097665324807167, -0.009302789345383644, -0.02555260807275772, -0.04982028156518936, 0.041709356009960175, 0.04819275066256523, 0.016851838678121567, -0.03800366446375847, -0.02976190857589245, -0.01608683168888092, 0.027331212535500526, 0.02757582813501358, -0.03889886662364006, 0.01971011608839035, -0.0067145549692213535, -0.0014197154669091105, -0.013455681502819061, 0.02505498193204403, 0.006655244622379541, -0.02681117318570614, 0.016768377274274826, 0.010081042535603046, -0.04557877406477928, -0.031020469963550568, -0.05453258007764816, -0.003707343013957143, -0.05329543352127075, -0.03694114834070206, -0.07528671622276306, 0.024921322241425514, 0.035175975412130356, -0.024763934314250946, -0.023729031905531883, -0.055144526064395905, -0.12127339094877243, 0.02079017646610737, 0.008406351320445538, -0.008590719662606716, -0.05220838263630867, 0.01670694537460804, 0.04053877294063568, -0.03394850343465805, -0.036789651960134506, 0.004525326192378998, 0.036463648080825806, 0.007239823695272207, -0.0245093684643507, 0.02888425998389721, -0.04000813886523247, 0.021207788959145546, -0.03021751344203949, 0.05721230432391167, 0.013882748782634735, 0.022730443626642227, -0.009828341193497181, 0.06782256811857224, 0.05232328176498413, 0.04526854306459427, 0.05543424189090729, 0.026444973424077034, -0.002040815306827426, -0.0005621458403766155, -0.0890657901763916, 0.001740110688842833, 0.01042261440306902, -0.012407238595187664, 0.009505480527877808, -0.05577052757143974, 0.00990272220224142, 0.036988239735364914, 0.03398770093917847, -0.009939564391970634, -0.024694398045539856, 0.007690716534852982, 0.021324969828128815, -0.012315778993070126, 0.007768666837364435, 0.013973033055663109, 0.03947385773062706, 0.014301087707281113, 0.006101714447140694, -0.05023381859064102, 0.0401349700987339, -0.030165955424308777, 0.04679381102323532, -0.011615928262472153, -0.017766395583748817, 0.043299127370119095, -0.018258651718497276, 0.02349000796675682, -0.013171420432627201, 0.048316799104213715, 0.028651932254433632, -0.0009144966606982052, 0.036511555314064026, 0.047983188182115555, 0.012819863855838776, -0.017988646402955055, -0.011840018443763256, 0.010215165093541145, -0.04183574393391609, 0.002878282917663455, 0.009369895793497562, 0.01394549012184143, 0.013576241210103035, 0.02518594078719616, 0.006815827451646328, 0.028608649969100952, 0.023234279826283455, 0.009525969624519348, -0.02270708791911602, 0.08215880393981934, -0.05545807629823685, -0.017316069453954697, -0.047898828983306885, 0.015193931758403778, -0.04471563920378685, -0.0051243240013718605, -0.017140457406640053, 0.023541435599327087, -0.026635462418198586, 0.046467576175928116, 0.020781654864549637, -0.015093169175088406, -0.02583847939968109, 0.02812054753303528, 0.045390840619802475, -0.03611360117793083, 0.0006257949862629175, -0.0028572476003319025, -0.010117631405591965, 0.037512920796871185, -0.0640948936343193, -0.028609946370124817, -0.02250686287879944, -0.015485726296901703, -0.04129897058010101, -0.0008412916213274002, -0.04793484881520271, -0.049965932965278625, 0.0027708811685442924, 0.007771966978907585, -0.018679693341255188, 0.0006074877455830574, -0.01771179586648941, 0.05962660163640976, -0.020648371428251266, 0.014849841594696045, -0.03986044228076935, -0.029077259823679924, 0.02149471826851368, -0.0206445325165987, 0.02674698643386364, -0.045312222093343735, 0.0019999719224870205, -0.02258557826280594, -0.04350210353732109, -0.007357827387750149, 0.01396660041064024, 0.010180912911891937, 0.006747908890247345, -0.03972967714071274, 0.010400042869150639, -0.027623435482382774, 0.014484359882771969, 0.011892332695424557, -0.04635051265358925, 0.009481312707066536, 0.0448743999004364, -0.0064534698612987995, 0.01751265674829483, -0.08855471760034561, -0.016308212652802467, -0.011859566904604435, -0.018406348302960396, -0.0036365885753184557, -0.03188294917345047, -0.031198551878333092, -0.03227194771170616, -0.027520550414919853, 0.0023053078912198544, 0.04184258356690407, -0.003846630919724703, -0.026638640090823174, -0.02417241781949997, 0.010211418382823467, 0.029880037531256676, -0.025595704093575478, -0.025573696941137314, 0.030443232506513596, -0.012974786572158337, 0.021844593808054924, -0.018207019194960594, 0.025175204500555992, 0.03055408038198948, -0.011232334189116955, -0.0066137113608419895, -0.03910402953624725, 0.06024496629834175, -0.0007656540255993605, -0.018747007474303246, 0.04252001270651817, 0.029156595468521118, -0.05713258311152458, 0.021114321425557137, 0.018015077337622643, 0.05094349384307861, 0.009831517934799194, -0.018878096714615822, 0.04908841475844383, 0.005536294542253017, 0.03633885085582733, 0.005906791891902685, -0.05073487386107445, 0.02397993393242359, 0.06350837647914886, -0.015161787159740925, -0.015603967942297459, -0.04356798902153969, -0.0031794430688023567, 0.046877678483724594, -0.002441751305013895, 0.04753539338707924, -0.03548574075102806, 0.005461334716528654, -0.010849595069885254, 0.028118129819631577, 0.011651544831693172, -0.03178417682647705, 0.04163749888539314, -0.0710599422454834, 0.02281775139272213, -0.04702738672494888, 0.009901896119117737, 0.04832952469587326, -0.04252229630947113, -0.006510007660835981, 0.01784253492951393, -0.009418354369699955, 0.043228697031736374, -0.027722803875803947, -0.06947574764490128, 0.04137112572789192, -0.027187000960111618, -0.0383598729968071, -0.0010579635854810476, -0.028967415913939476, 0.0005733055295422673, -0.02131436951458454, -0.04578118771314621, 0.027220143005251884, -0.006703784689307213, 0.05502879619598389, 0.0005341263022273779, 0.005086868070065975, -0.033834103494882584, 0.021944504231214523, 0.0033490718342363834, 0.031255584210157394, 0.025294845923781395, 0.024440176784992218, -0.03388061374425888, 0.04775103181600571, 0.034027740359306335, 0.023682745173573494, 0.0033897755201905966, 0.019251126796007156, -0.00012399116531014442, -0.028289567679166794, 0.04424463212490082, -0.016422364860773087, -0.04456197842955589, -0.06865217536687851, 0.03849329799413681, 0.006577650085091591, -0.03379790112376213, 0.0011672488180920482, 0.0335526317358017, -0.05590582266449928, -0.02718423679471016, 0.009097399190068245, -0.0013421368785202503, 0.0019313738448545337, 0.05506478250026703, 0.003412514226511121, 0.028213292360305786, 0.0466422513127327, 0.029939088970422745, -0.026584917679429054, -0.019132796674966812, 0.054319754242897034, 0.04868219792842865, 0.06566338241100311, 0.003812654409557581, 0.0778302252292633, -0.047068893909454346, -0.048929017037153244, 0.03494955599308014, 0.0073533873073756695, 0.02144511044025421, -0.010538864880800247, 0.03502406179904938, 0.06832561641931534, -0.0017458890797570348, 0.03484291955828667, -0.05056587606668472, -0.01780700869858265, 0.06342126429080963, 0.01913386769592762, -0.020142143592238426, 0.00508887367323041, 0.025497213006019592, 0.017026150599122047, -0.02812589891254902, -0.03509647771716118, -0.016360890120267868, -0.0318608433008194, 0.03723815828561783, -0.010397028177976608, -0.03196015581488609, 0.022691326215863228, 0.003811185248196125, 0.02499564178287983, 0.08851452171802521, -0.0700611025094986, -0.01983066461980343, 0.010386476293206215, 0.01017248909920454, 0.03191984072327614, 0.052682261914014816, 0.020167505368590355, -0.00036033146898262203, 0.018601281568408012, -0.04202840477228165, 0.044396933168172836, 0.036449089646339417, 0.005888498853892088, 0.017135215923190117, -0.020030274987220764, -0.01315312460064888, 0.015762198716402054, 0.0351342037320137, -0.019513504579663277, -0.04702303558588028, -0.030952978879213333, -0.03540847823023796, -0.021564582362771034, -0.02329867146909237, 0.04062663018703461, 0.00208520726300776, -0.05184085667133331, -0.01137136947363615, -0.03232014179229736, 0.048086121678352356, 0.028459521010518074, -0.0686163604259491, -0.020714599639177322, 0.013315651565790176, -0.005163916386663914, 0.03066140227019787, 0.020167173817753792, 0.04169471561908722, 0.027073506265878677, -0.02555941604077816, 0.0008359019411727786, -0.013472815044224262, -0.007904833182692528, -0.031865302473306656, -0.04894537851214409, -0.11962354183197021, -0.01398374978452921, 0.02799839898943901, -0.015506578609347343, -0.05204721540212631, -0.019712163135409355, -0.031421251595020294, 0.052084434777498245, 0.08806075900793076, -0.03657463565468788, 0.007189540658146143, -0.0019662880804389715, -0.026379957795143127, 0.00852496549487114, -0.00465808529406786, 0.06941726058721542, -0.04501284658908844, 0.06066526472568512, 0.038146957755088806, -0.023164236918091774, -0.026545148342847824, 0.028438223525881767, -0.004027363378554583, -0.005951773840934038, -0.019423212856054306, -0.04120055213570595, 0.0008946814341470599, -0.12833018600940704, -0.03164457902312279, 0.05343502387404442, 0.022124342620372772, -0.050453368574380875, -0.022987408563494682, -0.0036449674516916275, 0.041596755385398865, -0.02216454967856407, 0.004470727872103453, -0.022395534440875053, -0.033931829035282135, -0.028186751529574394, -0.03274853900074959, -0.0076271588914096355, -0.06289807707071304, 0.016862541437149048, -0.04627052694559097, -0.03312871605157852, -0.019361278042197227, -0.02058822475373745, 0.009487902745604515, 0.04986601695418358, 0.01692485436797142, 0.010032610036432743 ]
3,584
OS-ATLAS: Foundation Action Model for Generalist GUI Agents
https://openreview.net/forum?id=n9PDaFNi8t
[ "Zhiyong Wu", "Zhenyu Wu", "Fangzhi Xu", "Yian Wang", "Qiushi Sun", "Chengyou Jia", "Kanzhi Cheng", "Zichen Ding", "Liheng Chen", "Paul Pu Liang", "Yu Qiao" ]
Spotlight
Existing efforts in building GUI agents heavily rely on the availability of robust commercial Vision-Language Models (VLMs) such as GPT-4o and GeminiProVision. Practitioners are often reluctant to use open-source VLMs due to their significant performance lag compared to their closed-source counterparts, particularly in GUI grounding and Out-Of-Distribution (OOD) scenarios. To facilitate future research in this area, we developed OS-Atlas—a foundational GUI action model that excels at GUI grounding and OOD agentic tasks through innovations in both data and modeling. We have invested significant engineering effort in developing an open-source toolkit for synthesizing GUI grounding data across multiple platforms, including Windows, Linux, MacOS, Android, and the web. Leveraging this toolkit, we are releasing the largest open-source cross-platform GUI grounding corpus to date, which contains over 13 million GUI elements. This dataset, combined with innovations in model training, provides a solid foundation for OS-Atlas to understand GUI screenshots and generalize to unseen interfaces. Through extensive evaluation across six benchmarks spanning three different platforms (mobile, desktop, and web), OS-Atlas demonstrates significant performance improvements over previous state-of-the-art models. Our evaluation also uncovers valuable insights into continuously improving and scaling the agentic capabilities of open-source VLMs.
GUI agent, language agent, GUI grounding, executable language grounding
Through innovations in both data and modeling, we are releasing the first foundational action model specifically designed for GUI agents.
4,239
null
[ -0.02349444292485714, -0.036441437900066376, 0.010197531431913376, 0.012891309335827827, 0.04693087190389633, 0.009827458299696445, 0.010598602704703808, 0.04433151334524155, -0.03126530349254608, -0.05133388191461563, -0.03250508010387421, 0.023358628153800964, -0.09920439124107361, -0.003793512238189578, 0.00941893644630909, 0.056703612208366394, 0.03362777456641197, -0.012235763482749462, -0.0025958421174436808, -0.0037562428042292595, -0.014641507528722286, -0.016501886770129204, 0.010350838303565979, 0.015461412258446217, -0.005315633025020361, 0.01608152687549591, 0.04183277115225792, 0.025716710835695267, -0.022135145962238312, -0.027254650369286537, 0.010654517449438572, -0.014584636315703392, 0.022628573700785637, -0.046019989997148514, -0.025428377091884613, -0.00641496479511261, -0.040313322097063065, 0.00011657549475785345, -0.00507326377555728, -0.009897992946207523, -0.025654733180999756, 0.05094097554683685, 0.01827087625861168, 0.008584718219935894, -0.016657957807183266, 0.016991809010505676, -0.07634341716766357, 0.020756162703037262, 0.020784521475434303, -0.022345956414937973, -0.09684938937425613, 0.02561115100979805, -0.052291788160800934, -0.012942871078848839, 0.013868889771401882, 0.045693397521972656, 0.02297046221792698, -0.08582693338394165, -0.020017890259623528, -0.01828543283045292, -0.03133023902773857, -0.009626462124288082, 0.038550954312086105, 0.03180483728647232, 0.012639076448976994, -0.016509028151631355, -0.02123718336224556, 0.03997816517949104, -0.0274425707757473, -0.0038115784991532564, -0.013381333090364933, 0.013135590590536594, -0.0312332920730114, -0.03251161053776741, 0.025875074788928032, -0.032733842730522156, 0.05496527999639511, 0.020849233493208885, 0.06952463090419769, -0.02977607771754265, 0.01730259321630001, 0.03165562078356743, -0.005440438631922007, 0.034537676721811295, 0.03398115932941437, 0.00576619990170002, -0.02249751053750515, -0.023142609745264053, -0.08269335329532623, 0.051347363740205765, 0.03256283327937126, -0.056602198630571365, -0.015265507623553276, 0.03173403814435005, 0.023085322231054306, 0.042954493314027786, -0.011544594541192055, 0.015155932866036892, 0.013603134080767632, -0.005927865393459797, -0.01544143632054329, 0.002016528509557247, 0.0029124566353857517, 0.019728058949112892, -0.08444954454898834, -0.04041497781872749, -0.008747740648686886, -0.021527361124753952, 0.0005280798650346696, 0.029925746843218803, -0.06496879458427429, 0.012008548714220524, -0.011271227151155472, -0.01634310744702816, -0.06808847934007645, 0.0505327470600605, 0.004561235196888447, 0.001954734092578292, 0.01564006134867668, 0.003416251391172409, 0.07718877494335175, 0.09996769577264786, -0.041084710508584976, 0.06533896923065186, 0.00198168121278286, 0.007492912467569113, -0.014942836947739124, 0.021024243906140327, -0.02849113941192627, -0.021812286227941513, 0.030085107311606407, 0.043121714144945145, 0.002492271363735199, -0.026658808812499046, 0.002980364952236414, 0.01692315936088562, 0.03893614187836647, 0.018689049407839775, 0.035270314663648605, -0.013325504958629608, -0.002238827757537365, -0.041889090090990067, 0.050508689135313034, -0.021256813779473305, 0.0648651197552681, -0.004808716010302305, 0.014833993278443813, -0.017153792083263397, -0.057435449212789536, 0.005201505031436682, -0.008193190209567547, -0.015217803418636322, -0.007173988036811352, -0.05107225105166435, 0.04216434806585312, 0.061631593853235245, 0.0424354262650013, -0.007143932394683361, 0.02915196307003498, -0.030984055250883102, 0.008735736832022667, 0.002106406958773732, -0.044832583516836166, -0.014756901189684868, 0.0007583178230561316, -0.03518176078796387, 0.006091381423175335, -0.004393062088638544, 0.030030619353055954, -0.010610988363623619, -0.026798222213983536, -0.08902028203010559, 0.008272306993603706, -0.005886964499950409, -0.01001485250890255, -0.0017127720639109612, 0.08509679138660431, 0.004746263846755028, 0.022555246949195862, 0.01611698977649212, -0.07884732633829117, -0.00017521351401228458, 0.0075610242784023285, -0.030353303998708725, 0.020879395306110382, -0.029095890000462532, 0.05942070856690407, -0.024044685065746307, -0.03881695494055748, 0.0014147990150377154, -0.07476336508989334, -0.02758612483739853, 0.04551263526082039, 0.014455724507570267, 0.05103855952620506, 0.010376659221947193, -0.05228927731513977, 0.049863364547491074, 0.03060254082083702, 0.03652184456586838, 0.0346221998333931, -0.006973948795348406, 0.04804398491978645, -0.00004298034400562756, -0.025919396430253983, 0.00003142959758406505, 0.05348880961537361, -0.045003727078437805, -0.023698363453149796, 0.015420597046613693, -0.021180370822548866, 0.010363909415900707, 0.05341824144124985, -0.0009289077133871615, 0.054490115493535995, 0.04364684969186783, 0.02029687725007534, -0.030619891360402107, 0.011879166588187218, -0.04295138642191887, 0.003884654026478529, -0.011555501259863377, -0.024441849440336227, -0.015120938420295715, -0.038076482713222504, 0.06882113218307495, 0.052702397108078, -0.06415321677923203, -0.015528320334851742, -0.005164343863725662, -0.024436822161078453, 0.013098372146487236, 0.013539774343371391, -0.0609222836792469, 0.010222440585494041, -0.06593798100948334, 0.02280806005001068, -0.033080749213695526, 0.019124044105410576, -0.04573240876197815, -0.005365604534745216, 0.05897469073534012, -0.015222368761897087, 0.07183157652616501, 0.022457746788859367, 0.000854714133311063, 0.03851250559091568, -0.037668853998184204, -0.009445447474718094, -0.02111896313726902, -0.017934372648596764, 0.00573338195681572, 0.018424225971102715, -0.05956057086586952, -0.023397350683808327, -0.05610809475183487, 0.02173500508069992, -0.04125453531742096, 0.04556303843855858, 0.052946243435144424, 0.022394539788365364, 0.016689231619238853, -0.000014876415662001818, 0.008612491190433502, 0.01850331574678421, -0.10409586876630783, -0.020146267488598824, 0.013482704758644104, 0.022411996498703957, 0.027271384373307228, -0.0021663345396518707, -0.012242181226611137, 0.023302562534809113, -0.04582897573709488, 0.011244215071201324, -0.009129001758992672, 0.00497059803456068, 0.04948624595999718, -0.0444665402173996, -0.032870952039957047, 0.020910345017910004, 0.061503149569034576, 0.018238306045532227, 0.003426981158554554, -0.0019827978685498238, -0.01443573646247387, 0.03710542991757393, -0.057882122695446014, -0.011381692253053188, 0.010615364648401737, 0.03718474134802818, 0.014723135158419609, -0.00952593982219696, 0.019378265365958214, 0.028043175116181374, 0.06652075052261353, 0.011037230491638184, -0.007916995324194431, -0.06640692055225372, 0.021009817719459534, -0.02927469089627266, -0.012753779999911785, -0.006459008902311325, -0.007348825689405203, -0.008791252039372921, 0.017281178385019302, -0.008486665785312653, 0.012952887453138828, -0.2855212092399597, -0.020959217101335526, 0.009526601061224937, -0.0076176756992936134, 0.0044437893666327, -0.01538574043661356, 0.05031002312898636, -0.019214462488889694, -0.03153131529688835, 0.019237127155065536, 0.01576993241906166, 0.005454630125313997, 0.014430110342800617, 0.06947266310453415, 0.050608813762664795, 0.08561650663614273, 0.0002876441285479814, -0.02247372455894947, 0.0031006867066025734, 0.014617111533880234, -0.03425183147192001, -0.07575546205043793, -0.023398354649543762, 0.019093411043286324, -0.02027129754424095, 0.0565323680639267, -0.08688939362764359, -0.011402337811887264, -0.006444516591727734, 0.0024539949372410774, 0.007183780428022146, -0.03306339681148529, -0.053353890776634216, 0.04887871444225311, -0.004500993527472019, -0.034455254673957825, 0.014531311579048634, 0.010670405812561512, 0.039028361439704895, -0.017934225499629974, 0.024410419166088104, 0.007787324488162994, -0.07034624367952347, 0.029442420229315758, 0.06860895454883575, -0.019798414781689644, -0.06798532605171204, -0.03313351795077324, -0.02649543061852455, 0.05837208405137062, 0.005736587569117546, -0.020107194781303406, -0.044939927756786346, -0.025714850053191185, 0.004449689760804176, -0.018257586285471916, -0.006215751636773348, 0.02642192132771015, 0.007992561906576157, 0.02006830833852291, -0.017588691785931587, -0.03043256886303425, -0.03770815581083298, -0.041019655764102936, -0.014199351891875267, -0.00814118143171072, -0.05401016026735306, -0.08873161673545837, 0.03979158401489258, -0.0014805536484345794, -0.0019063211511820555, 0.026641996577382088, -0.001165944617241621, -0.0988851860165596, -0.02435448206961155, 0.03365420550107956, -0.03271802142262459, -0.06153500825166702, 0.02417645789682865, 0.018826374784111977, -0.036518145352602005, -0.03287531062960625, 0.011393386870622635, -0.022685742005705833, 0.019864274188876152, -0.028752783313393593, -0.014608149416744709, -0.04578742757439613, -0.007449474185705185, -0.01276460476219654, 0.04377532750368118, -0.024757660925388336, 0.0007748825591988862, 0.043583840131759644, 0.06627733260393143, 0.0032619440462440252, 0.04421517625451088, 0.0210355743765831, 0.010200944729149342, 0.01435990259051323, 0.0337514728307724, -0.07699072360992432, 0.0029240697622299194, -0.045327767729759216, -0.040352292358875275, 0.04828662425279617, -0.030704643577337265, -0.026839427649974823, 0.04713495075702667, 0.023696990683674812, 0.01133781112730503, -0.03077595867216587, 0.0222306028008461, -0.010078612715005875, -0.024830585345625877, -0.000027841038900078274, 0.013393503613770008, 0.04065482318401337, 0.03084203600883484, 0.0026369185652583838, -0.0219737458974123, 0.023265497758984566, -0.043842047452926636, 0.03106759674847126, -0.016053028404712677, 0.020158180966973305, -0.007116350345313549, 0.011968381702899933, 0.012262196280062199, -0.01554254349321127, -0.00033982121385633945, 0.036220572888851166, 0.005140629131346941, 0.026551201939582825, 0.030323825776576996, 0.0015071367379277945, -0.0035426996182650328, -0.01075794082134962, 0.0062432195991277695, -0.026433445513248444, -0.00012262123345863074, 0.0008383406675420702, 0.06385787576436996, 0.03426974266767502, -0.0014520788099616766, -0.022944945842027664, 0.045298729091882706, 0.019055306911468506, 0.02739151380956173, 0.03349096328020096, 0.04325123131275177, -0.05145439878106117, -0.0017536156810820103, -0.024273384362459183, -0.03367820009589195, -0.03995853662490845, 0.019378187134861946, -0.03454797342419624, 0.042722880840301514, -0.05603064224123955, 0.0334894172847271, -0.01854666881263256, -0.03148452565073967, 0.007543014362454414, 0.02041783556342125, 0.0411468967795372, -0.009495922364294529, -0.011360363103449345, 0.005006600171327591, 0.011148477904498577, 0.0003867405466735363, -0.03261171281337738, 0.012617559172213078, -0.019332975149154663, -0.03998621925711632, 0.016009997576475143, -0.012424739077687263, -0.0008162456215359271, 0.008114725351333618, 0.06933662295341492, -0.017192292958498, -0.03552975878119469, -0.006186829414218664, -0.07056289911270142, 0.06619474291801453, -0.015071477741003036, -0.004756346344947815, 0.014680495485663414, -0.007618846837431192, 0.011114154942333698, 0.030770570039749146, 0.06652455776929855, -0.015017586760222912, -0.008692638017237186, -0.05679211765527725, -0.07063113898038864, 0.01728038303554058, 0.01253023836761713, -0.014361964538693428, -0.021033478900790215, -0.02435440570116043, 0.017527475953102112, -0.07138781994581223, 0.011952399276196957, 0.037968579679727554, -0.05677139014005661, 0.02918987348675728, 0.020549586042761803, 0.007700905669480562, 0.027398085221648216, -0.07800854742527008, -0.03281319513916969, -0.03560640290379524, -0.03054836392402649, -0.00857026781886816, -0.0339837446808815, 0.00951200071722269, -0.05138145387172699, -0.018690912052989006, -0.02011197805404663, -0.03130430728197098, 0.015443007461726665, -0.03343162313103676, 0.013479674234986305, -0.013834455981850624, 0.054271578788757324, -0.008757367730140686, -0.017731983214616776, 0.010858978144824505, -0.03836377337574959, 0.03809371963143349, -0.03095235489308834, 0.020804116502404213, 0.03608002886176109, -0.010793957859277725, 0.03663097321987152, -0.03833116590976715, 0.027460256591439247, 0.015164931304752827, -0.018175659701228142, -0.00848178006708622, 0.02211921103298664, -0.031179673969745636, 0.013207011856138706, 0.019724395126104355, 0.019108209758996964, 0.013890340924263, -0.025435959920287132, 0.01449329499155283, -0.00802041869610548, 0.028921473771333694, -0.004223878029733896, -0.041641198098659515, -0.0028016006108373404, 0.05317915976047516, -0.06699282675981522, -0.040761932730674744, -0.026216300204396248, -0.0689263641834259, 0.011422746814787388, 0.019094450399279594, 0.0153048662468791, -0.04863371327519417, 0.017069511115550995, 0.032211024314165115, 0.044206809252500534, 0.023060280829668045, -0.03562307357788086, 0.06411286443471909, -0.045559968799352646, 0.03204146772623062, -0.06258916109800339, -0.017088744789361954, 0.050261713564395905, -0.03423183783888817, -0.044089674949645996, 0.008180427365005016, -0.026378197595477104, 0.0379142127931118, -0.01635400950908661, -0.05933284014463425, 0.03428756073117256, 0.008768043480813503, -0.005193782038986683, 0.002384613733738661, -0.019127676263451576, 0.0227877926081419, -0.011420020833611488, -0.030843239277601242, 0.022841801866889, 0.0373324453830719, 0.05594931170344353, -0.012737404555082321, 0.03098691813647747, -0.017126277089118958, -0.00821618176996708, 0.030097050592303276, 0.03790397197008133, 0.017230937257409096, 0.05765903741121292, -0.017764048650860786, 0.08873997628688812, 0.049950528889894485, 0.024495290592312813, 0.030382562428712845, -0.0088517339900136, -0.002995822811499238, -0.031979650259017944, 0.028579028323292732, 0.034464865922927856, -0.033416397869586945, -0.06791232526302338, 0.03847969323396683, 0.018803156912326813, -0.052630018442869186, 0.012472708709537983, 0.005285487975925207, -0.0773414671421051, 0.02141657844185829, -0.005113484337925911, 0.02038457617163658, 0.04716545715928078, 0.03568124398589134, 0.015180431306362152, 0.06689886748790741, 0.07261279970407486, 0.007278771605342627, 0.002689566696062684, 0.026316901668906212, 0.07208272069692612, 0.05222576856613159, 0.024738313630223274, 0.019824370741844177, 0.08137357234954834, -0.040960557758808136, -0.055933140218257904, 0.007261644117534161, 0.018191607668995857, -0.02340613678097725, -0.01643439382314682, 0.03163909167051315, 0.08542455732822418, -0.004595066886395216, 0.007813624106347561, -0.03434647619724274, -0.02445860393345356, 0.05479481443762779, 0.013301851227879524, -0.00702395336702466, -0.007859136909246445, 0.045467060059309006, 0.004909633658826351, -0.023348957300186157, -0.00863565132021904, -0.006364906206727028, -0.06278396397829056, -0.01933407224714756, 0.013851488940417767, 0.02548294886946678, 0.002991302637383342, -0.01287982426583767, 0.03757930546998978, 0.1173478439450264, -0.019644720479846, -0.007238347083330154, 0.0031623251270502806, 0.001757277874276042, 0.017253337427973747, 0.027199849486351013, -0.006945106666535139, -0.025888865813612938, 0.004727618768811226, -0.011174400337040424, 0.021870387718081474, 0.04788308963179588, 0.000149576022522524, 0.03211814910173416, -0.03626979887485504, -0.030221452936530113, -0.01740512251853943, 0.01299493107944727, -0.06301335990428925, -0.027354611083865166, -0.03585740551352501, -0.02133306674659252, -0.023841947317123413, -0.02463560551404953, 0.02021986059844494, 0.03483534976840019, -0.05175917223095894, -0.018266849219799042, -0.02506577968597412, 0.027371445670723915, -0.0074950456619262695, -0.04187653213739395, 0.004251343198120594, 0.029226403683423996, 0.01697552390396595, -0.008298722095787525, 0.04155423492193222, 0.06372786313295364, -0.026380015537142754, 0.008074067533016205, 0.0005753384903073311, 0.03335439786314964, -0.002992853056639433, -0.005441561806946993, -0.00531805120408535, -0.12120426446199417, 0.002361141610890627, 0.015024086460471153, 0.000001324954268966394, -0.07572352886199951, 0.015165450051426888, -0.02654571831226349, 0.0625593364238739, 0.07009774446487427, 0.030055023729801178, 0.01573597826063633, 0.00421635527163744, 0.005370780359953642, -0.01268813107162714, -0.004709070548415184, 0.055222027003765106, -0.03903279826045036, 0.04166540130972862, 0.022141942754387856, -0.024990225210785866, -0.029379213228821754, 0.07345663011074066, 0.03483801335096359, 0.006215658970177174, -0.02875288762152195, -0.044161953032016754, -0.005446987692266703, -0.06572923064231873, 0.006541887763887644, 0.022761952131986618, 0.010104642249643803, -0.03193870931863785, -0.023954452946782112, -0.013613731600344181, -0.02264668606221676, -0.01936088316142559, -0.02635117992758751, -0.0536121167242527, -0.027156462892889977, -0.04577222466468811, -0.05367927625775337, 0.020287642255425453, -0.01528765819966793, -0.008237254805862904, -0.022220978513360023, -0.010589107871055603, -0.03278360143303871, 0.031074659898877144, 0.04188802093267441, 0.008401522412896156, 0.021020561456680298, -0.028401924297213554 ]
3,585
Sample then Identify: A General Framework for Risk Control and Assessment in Multimodal Large Language Models
https://openreview.net/forum?id=9WYMDgxDac
[ "Qingni Wang", "Tiantian Geng", "Zhiyuan Wang", "Teng Wang", "Bo Fu", "Feng Zheng" ]
Spotlight
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) exhibit promising advancements across various tasks, yet they still encounter significant trustworthiness issues. Prior studies apply Split Conformal Prediction (SCP) in language modeling to construct prediction sets with statistical guarantees. However, these methods typically rely on internal model logits or are restricted to multiple-choice settings, which hampers their generalizability and adaptability in dynamic, open-ended environments. In this paper, we introduce *TRON*, a **t**wo-step framework for **r**isk c**o**ntrol and assessme**n**t, applicable to any MLLM that supports sampling in both open-ended and closed-ended scenarios. *TRON* comprises two main components: (1) a novel conformal score to **sample** response sets of minimum size, and (2) a nonconformity score to **identify** high-quality responses based on self-consistency theory, controlling the error rates by two specific risk levels. Furthermore, we investigate semantic redundancy in prediction sets within open-ended contexts for the first time, leading to a promising evaluation metric for MLLMs based on average set size. Our comprehensive experiments across four Video Question-Answering (VideoQA) datasets utilizing eight MLLMs show that *TRON* achieves desired error rates bounded by two user-specified risk levels. Additionally, deduplicated prediction sets maintain adaptiveness while being more efficient and stable for risk assessment under different risk levels.
generative models, calibration/uncertainty, inference methods
We propose a general framework for risk control and assessment, which creates rigorous prediction sets with statistical guarantees calibrated by two user-specified risk levels, applicable to any MLLMs supporting sampling in open-ended settings.
4,201
2410.08174
[ 0.025894317775964737, -0.017250776290893555, -0.007292991038411856, 0.04564304277300835, 0.042738281190395355, 0.005342723801732063, 0.025225240737199783, 0.020522190257906914, -0.027348356321454048, -0.007321879733353853, -0.0164114348590374, 0.02824597992002964, -0.07812830060720444, -0.00785470474511385, -0.007654906250536442, 0.03336469084024429, 0.039504677057266235, -0.01721017062664032, 0.009892457164824009, 0.017248883843421936, -0.020083552226424217, -0.06146402657032013, 0.03840738534927368, 0.008214826695621014, 0.03314661234617233, -0.0048878127709031105, 0.02965676039457321, -0.0024189078249037266, -0.029047569260001183, 0.00854028481990099, 0.044588252902030945, -0.01072196289896965, 0.005868430715054274, -0.03063121996819973, 0.019708579406142235, 0.021956710144877434, -0.03869890049099922, 0.029654547572135925, 0.012689868919551373, 0.024548139423131943, -0.03185223788022995, 0.0024828955065459013, -0.02390734851360321, -0.010017957538366318, -0.06185726821422577, -0.0015827754978090525, -0.04576472193002701, 0.015328476205468178, 0.0362892784178257, -0.033118996769189835, -0.08648373931646347, 0.05066589266061783, -0.023975374177098274, -0.031955551356077194, 0.01004865299910307, 0.021291447803378105, 0.044989511370658875, -0.1084030419588089, 0.001863814890384674, -0.03912912681698799, -0.04411668702960014, -0.011988837271928787, 0.024251649156212807, -0.000002691115469133365, -0.01583879441022873, -0.005957945715636015, -0.018672719597816467, 0.036911673843860626, -0.0614178366959095, -0.03339932858943939, -0.005142384208738804, 0.016679760068655014, -0.007379569578915834, -0.02607288397848606, 0.018649833276867867, -0.0474214106798172, 0.013481412082910538, 0.016329476609826088, 0.02905980683863163, 0.006215304601937532, 0.004502969328314066, 0.027123382315039635, 0.03183526545763016, 0.03174669295549393, 0.016691574826836586, 0.000015795021681697108, 0.00255856616422534, -0.04320259392261505, -0.06011461839079857, 0.012571847066283226, 0.022106504067778587, -0.05588291957974434, 0.011313351802527905, 0.016259893774986267, -0.000778185436502099, 0.008976833894848824, 0.012473511509597301, 0.0062271468341350555, -0.04162567853927612, -0.027974238619208336, -0.029411768540740013, -0.018755845725536346, 0.014606126584112644, 0.005754726938903332, -0.13175027072429657, -0.028891626745462418, -0.009349965490400791, 0.0022971942089498043, -0.005795695353299379, 0.011002402752637863, -0.030631449073553085, -0.009116643108427525, 0.004452911205589771, -0.03532392531633377, -0.06955080479383469, 0.02442317269742489, 0.00100024847779423, 0.04379367083311081, -0.0013781085144728422, 0.014103048481047153, 0.04696797579526901, 0.022454237565398216, -0.004916112869977951, 0.07208177447319031, -0.020324595272541046, 0.015680696815252304, 0.0011898628436028957, 0.02828332968056202, -0.01979839615523815, -0.03829987719655037, 0.013155166059732437, 0.03804674744606018, 0.011750908568501472, 0.009317496791481972, 0.008260812610387802, 0.021009206771850586, 0.021920058876276016, -0.01007760688662529, 0.0710182636976242, -0.001989873358979821, 0.015315674245357513, -0.014257868751883507, 0.036298125982284546, -0.005894124042242765, 0.09177414327859879, 0.007148509845137596, -0.04623311012983322, -0.008427196182310581, -0.0613211914896965, 0.028547007590532303, 0.024407140910625458, -0.014615041203796864, 0.0020661524031311274, -0.059598781168460846, 0.020485492423176765, 0.05458897352218628, 0.03221229463815689, 0.022559424862265587, 0.010657859034836292, 0.003561153309419751, 0.013016477227210999, 0.012496065348386765, -0.056942541152238846, 0.009206989780068398, -0.0020050269085913897, -0.07746864855289459, 0.022661058232188225, 0.019673656672239304, -0.051255326718091965, 0.02283930592238903, -0.05696442723274231, -0.045559801161289215, 0.04123281314969063, -0.03004266694188118, -0.014279489405453205, -0.012659949250519276, 0.05874324217438698, 0.036207541823387146, 0.03518778458237648, 0.01423434168100357, -0.07126351445913315, 0.019369397312402725, 0.013949592597782612, -0.027027254924178123, 0.019934577867388725, -0.007482868619263172, 0.08068302273750305, -0.006227381993085146, -0.02841346338391304, 0.021932542324066162, -0.0561884343624115, -0.016244839876890182, 0.018853262066841125, 0.004215423483401537, 0.06097894534468651, -0.016354428604245186, 0.020213400945067406, 0.06712370365858078, 0.04101983830332756, 0.030879369005560875, 0.06117239221930504, -0.011882527731359005, 0.0419340580701828, -0.009330282919108868, -0.025668028742074966, 0.004309260752052069, 0.03161444514989853, -0.053913820534944534, -0.04827019199728966, 0.03517021983861923, -0.014590196311473846, 0.0400196798145771, -0.00034126199898310006, 0.013133392669260502, 0.014856016263365746, 0.015129301697015762, 0.011021449230611324, 0.007605744060128927, 0.006861715577542782, -0.053403422236442566, 0.04543284326791763, 0.001092787366360426, -0.03353504091501236, -0.02364904247224331, -0.011383269913494587, 0.11085964739322662, 0.05440882220864296, -0.010984235443174839, -0.04083400219678879, 0.03860873728990555, 0.002043267013505101, -0.0007955242763273418, 0.025082815438508987, -0.01569739170372486, -0.007119583897292614, -0.019106199964880943, -0.011783107183873653, -0.022408202290534973, 0.049121465533971786, -0.03367694467306137, -0.020536303520202637, 0.08502460271120071, -0.015691835433244705, 0.05087209865450859, -0.010898583568632603, 0.009405791759490967, 0.02096824161708355, -0.01977134495973587, -0.007378503680229187, -0.005378315690904856, -0.009873156435787678, 0.002348964801058173, -0.024295276030898094, -0.05384214594960213, -0.0051708403043448925, -0.023013075813651085, -0.01246738899499178, -0.011295615695416927, 0.0714758038520813, 0.0510338731110096, 0.04048212990164757, 0.04861163720488548, 0.011898472905158997, -0.05656910687685013, -0.01856335438787937, -0.10665852576494217, -0.04924451559782028, -0.02713019773364067, 0.03971531242132187, 0.02122916467487812, 0.040290139615535736, 0.0023232176899909973, 0.010819071903824806, -0.008377495221793652, 0.018438130617141724, 0.02421608194708824, 0.034148599952459335, 0.03608069196343422, -0.04886366054415703, 0.0153591837733984, 0.007648566272109747, 0.05575559288263321, -0.017154144123196602, -0.050089526921510696, -0.03741947561502457, -0.011415135115385056, -0.0035335503052920103, -0.04386008903384209, 0.018190402537584305, -0.011815380305051804, -0.014484303072094917, 0.012356076389551163, 0.0005194250261411071, 0.004911592695862055, 0.02831232361495495, 0.024749573320150375, 0.047755345702171326, 0.027243956923484802, -0.02377220243215561, 0.04751007258892059, -0.028744524344801903, 0.010629422962665558, -0.00214129826053977, 0.006670971866697073, -0.017344143241643906, -0.008216711692512035, 0.017532555386424065, -0.010608366690576077, -0.2871042788028717, -0.045918673276901245, 0.013858768157660961, -0.0022467037197202444, 0.0230682622641325, -0.022158076986670494, 0.047635518014431, -0.025749461725354195, -0.026200732216238976, 0.019968193024396896, 0.028306616470217705, 0.056596338748931885, 0.02329348213970661, 0.052823346108198166, 0.07971902191638947, 0.01699790544807911, -0.005473223980516195, -0.021356772631406784, 0.021154649555683136, 0.050325989723205566, 0.001528416178189218, -0.04004208743572235, -0.03621120750904083, 0.06285227090120316, -0.020559264346957207, 0.08077401667833328, -0.0897374078631401, 0.00850498117506504, -0.015109941363334656, 0.008814974687993526, 0.014290239661931992, -0.037313662469387054, -0.012012405321002007, 0.04647015035152435, 0.016560129821300507, 0.03487306833267212, 0.061355311423540115, 0.027110088616609573, 0.026615798473358154, -0.0225553996860981, -0.01685280352830887, -0.03252928704023361, -0.028234297409653664, -0.0058077056892216206, 0.07852523028850555, -0.0006504547200165689, -0.04537507891654968, -0.01026301272213459, 0.014294108375906944, 0.039962153881788254, -0.014512942172586918, -0.016108982264995575, -0.031054263934493065, 0.028111783787608147, -0.009273684583604336, -0.01439710147678852, 0.024088872596621513, -0.023125436156988144, -0.011041449382901192, 0.01420788187533617, 0.013877579011023045, -0.02336052805185318, -0.002443154575303197, -0.04754449054598808, -0.016348574310541153, -0.029609233140945435, -0.07254064828157425, -0.05111857131123543, 0.015788353979587555, 0.014812146313488483, -0.013664886355400085, 0.019583890214562416, -0.0042725782841444016, -0.09946898370981216, 0.0007795862620696425, -0.00016292586224153638, -0.004512791521847248, -0.012014200910925865, 0.013548184186220169, 0.04355126991868019, -0.04525956138968468, -0.04384796693921089, 0.029812313616275787, -0.00004767288191942498, 0.02890387736260891, -0.0351993702352047, 0.007000459358096123, -0.024295831099152565, -0.016643505543470383, -0.08010351657867432, 0.03908092901110649, 0.004622488748282194, 0.010623784735798836, 0.008572940714657307, 0.04745190590620041, 0.03698393702507019, 0.0165226049721241, 0.05614401772618294, 0.04131663590669632, 0.01743372529745102, 0.01609859988093376, -0.09495939314365387, -0.017946170642971992, -0.06953191757202148, -0.025543533265590668, 0.016167493537068367, -0.055736739188432693, -0.02100355736911297, -0.0006750168395228684, -0.03561198711395264, -0.01831640489399433, 0.011407707817852497, 0.013697323389351368, 0.01755790039896965, -0.025725485756993294, -0.009267739951610565, -0.007844645529985428, 0.017644912004470825, 0.03876272588968277, -0.02271917834877968, -0.018121104687452316, 0.02863742969930172, -0.02101404219865799, 0.001313006621785462, 0.016497734934091568, -0.05166884884238243, 0.0014182680752128363, -0.009749824181199074, -0.03693646565079689, -0.004111276939511299, 0.005493958480656147, 0.03796383738517761, 0.016093455255031586, 0.009908488020300865, 0.05452438071370125, 0.009005994535982609, -0.016790304332971573, 0.005105755291879177, 0.030842136591672897, -0.012653865851461887, -0.015924865379929543, -0.01299881748855114, 0.03664286062121391, 0.05006249248981476, 0.01974572241306305, -0.010696937330067158, -0.003761543892323971, -0.0151952700689435, -0.02312864176928997, 0.015790797770023346, 0.03443576395511627, -0.032246846705675125, 0.003512598341330886, -0.008943937718868256, 0.012909935787320137, 0.004391940776258707, 0.005094240885227919, -0.0024052970111370087, 0.0369771346449852, -0.06611619144678116, 0.045259203761816025, 0.012478266842663288, -0.008578470908105373, 0.017725704237818718, 0.015231967903673649, 0.009172936901450157, -0.01895224116742611, 0.016612643375992775, 0.013476632535457611, 0.01942048780620098, 0.034896545112133026, -0.027187155559659004, -0.01709161512553692, 0.014630716294050217, -0.027817804366350174, 0.006262793205678463, 0.005916414316743612, -0.009961345233023167, -0.03964163735508919, 0.058659572154283524, 0.004718199372291565, -0.047287195920944214, -0.010394290089607239, 0.007706271018832922, 0.1013731136918068, 0.013494502753019333, -0.00812239944934845, -0.002126191509887576, -0.036275241523981094, 0.009092471562325954, -0.029005782678723335, 0.012244763784110546, -0.028049450367689133, -0.017239762470126152, -0.045463282614946365, -0.046161629259586334, 0.015496347099542618, 0.004435153212398291, 0.019803572446107864, -0.01581038162112236, 0.015404567122459412, -0.010476200841367245, -0.0301678366959095, -0.04578705132007599, 0.0379861481487751, -0.08851520717144012, -0.014300643466413021, 0.01490581315010786, -0.032026875764131546, 0.04217490553855896, -0.0378057062625885, -0.06556427478790283, -0.03724849224090576, -0.01924545131623745, 0.01126408763229847, -0.05209975689649582, -0.04877528175711632, -0.024279063567519188, 0.009857640601694584, -0.011691426858305931, 0.01992211677134037, -0.026526831090450287, 0.012907019816339016, -0.00973462127149105, 0.018870791420340538, 0.05573141202330589, -0.06189240515232086, 0.0000051127231017744634, 0.04108000174164772, -0.021682389080524445, 0.023735158145427704, -0.050699833780527115, 0.03178387135267258, 0.04430669546127319, -0.007934537716209888, -0.020450185984373093, -0.05879921466112137, 0.048377782106399536, 0.02138441428542137, -0.01128419116139412, 0.01466209627687931, 0.03773344308137894, -0.025313064455986023, 0.019884737208485603, -0.008880188688635826, 0.035019420087337494, 0.04419529065489769, 0.011433233506977558, 0.035258322954177856, 0.014949179254472256, 0.034120962023735046, 0.023082861676812172, -0.06407191604375839, -0.009546566754579544, 0.060154691338539124, -0.001837072428315878, -0.03596418350934982, -0.062114913016557693, -0.04685981944203377, 0.042063143104314804, 0.01022933330386877, 0.01846211776137352, -0.03729208931326866, 0.034102607518434525, 0.020789509639143944, 0.05537239834666252, 0.02334556356072426, -0.014515284448862076, 0.005620751529932022, -0.057784803211688995, 0.00952734425663948, -0.091873899102211, -0.004025996662676334, 0.06731870770454407, -0.035051729530096054, -0.00024460122222080827, -0.01599580980837345, -0.057511571794748306, 0.036183468997478485, -0.00039165353518910706, -0.0455695204436779, 0.0027656578458845615, -0.007869815453886986, -0.014536099508404732, 0.034200675785541534, -0.035994015634059906, 0.0018730321899056435, 0.002281871624290943, -0.05136501416563988, -0.014633430168032646, -0.0022780566941946745, 0.07215631753206253, -0.036907318979501724, 0.016540728509426117, -0.045429348945617676, 0.025923654437065125, 0.01172297541052103, 0.050190068781375885, 0.016196466982364655, 0.020637908950448036, -0.004132173024117947, 0.04558243602514267, 0.012251628562808037, -0.00950629636645317, 0.008910946547985077, -0.026939984411001205, -0.028085902333259583, -0.05263252928853035, 0.08850149065256119, 0.02838067337870598, -0.03457758203148842, -0.05549636855721474, 0.07721797376871109, 0.05013326182961464, -0.048330001533031464, -0.027704931795597076, 0.028129443526268005, -0.05426099896430969, -0.0031521469354629517, -0.006685870699584484, 0.022537924349308014, -0.039212267845869064, 0.0668451339006424, 0.04244452342391014, 0.06383005529642105, 0.07925214618444443, -0.015822848305106163, -0.02520013600587845, 0.020155921578407288, 0.07293256372213364, 0.07209433615207672, 0.07684630900621414, -0.020709585398435593, 0.0753709077835083, -0.06933264434337616, -0.05063651502132416, 0.0031912752892822027, 0.015924127772450447, -0.027269667014479637, -0.022481827065348625, 0.00444338982924819, 0.05539126694202423, 0.003360183909535408, 0.06407362222671509, -0.04047980159521103, -0.00954071432352066, 0.03842100873589516, 0.015039225108921528, -0.021840207278728485, 0.016622178256511688, 0.031266216188669205, 0.0059300693683326244, -0.0036882483400404453, -0.01823747158050537, 0.04439180716872215, -0.01229502446949482, -0.004631315357983112, -0.006720120552927256, -0.018643172457814217, 0.01335785910487175, -0.02463281713426113, 0.061535391956567764, 0.10868295282125473, -0.03135501965880394, -0.0316767580807209, -0.006825249642133713, 0.009972925297915936, 0.009326414205133915, 0.05370594933629036, 0.009811907075345516, -0.036271415650844574, -0.009859060868620872, -0.04286959022283554, -0.02266416698694229, 0.011087269522249699, -0.0353788360953331, 0.0010273960651829839, -0.022013990208506584, -0.027461644262075424, 0.029329350218176842, 0.001081455615349114, -0.04044017568230629, -0.03582098335027695, -0.02061532996594906, -0.053898755460977554, -0.06336580216884613, -0.04258942976593971, 0.022993072867393494, 0.014213514514267445, -0.007056278642266989, 0.007126630283892155, -0.02595681883394718, 0.025697464123368263, 0.016160987317562103, -0.061229124665260315, 0.00011489354801597074, 0.02904125303030014, -0.032087184488773346, -0.01670963317155838, 0.030434543266892433, 0.036782365292310715, 0.02574394829571247, -0.024545075371861458, 0.02854202874004841, 0.01489289477467537, 0.01836562529206276, -0.011529572308063507, 0.015777716413140297, -0.08570531010627747, -0.016403915360569954, -0.0013385119382292032, -0.0054639047011733055, -0.07418613135814667, 0.020219724625349045, -0.015018651261925697, 0.044516727328300476, 0.05540497228503227, 0.006919113919138908, 0.015913261100649834, -0.041752930730581284, -0.013710776343941689, -0.0031025102362036705, 0.014636465348303318, 0.023391801863908768, -0.0426664762198925, 0.04303886368870735, 0.026512162759900093, -0.048608068376779556, -0.0435074046254158, 0.023814411833882332, 0.00917264074087143, 0.0032203744631260633, -0.011338470503687859, -0.02405344694852829, -0.03470958024263382, -0.10029898583889008, -0.004561365116387606, 0.01891550049185753, -0.0040167407132685184, 0.007849454879760742, -0.011692316271364689, -0.04338573291897774, -0.020494908094406128, -0.0003560007316991687, -0.00822411384433508, -0.019833514466881752, -0.020189762115478516, -0.056511253118515015, -0.07346586138010025, 0.018485097214579582, -0.040318526327610016, -0.0012333334889262915, -0.02207333594560623, -0.04486878216266632, -0.025255588814616203, -0.00753340357914567, 0.03907739371061325, 0.011694811284542084, 0.01993793621659279, -0.04933406412601471 ]
3,586
Exploring the Camera Bias of Person Re-identification
https://openreview.net/forum?id=SgymXhOEA5
[ "Myungseo Song", "Jin-Woo Park", "Jong-Seok Lee" ]
Spotlight
We empirically investigate the camera bias of person re-identification (ReID) models. Previously, camera-aware methods have been proposed to address this issue, but they are largely confined to training domains of the models. We measure the camera bias of ReID models on unseen domains and reveal that camera bias becomes more pronounced under data distribution shifts. As a debiasing method for unseen domain data, we revisit feature normalization on embedding vectors. While the normalization has been used as a straightforward solution, its underlying causes and broader applicability remain unexplored. We analyze why this simple method is effective at reducing bias and show that it can be applied to detailed bias factors such as low-level image properties and body angle. Furthermore, we validate its generalizability across various models and benchmarks, highlighting its potential as a simple yet effective test-time postprocessing method for ReID. In addition, we explore the inherent risk of camera bias in unsupervised learning of ReID models. The unsupervised models remain highly biased towards camera labels even for seen domain data, indicating substantial room for improvement. Based on observations of the negative impact of camera-biased pseudo labels on training, we suggest simple training strategies to mitigate the bias. By applying these strategies to existing unsupervised learning algorithms, we show that significant performance improvements can be achieved with minor modifications.
Person re-identification, Camera bias, Debiasing, Unsupervised learning
We investigate the camera bias problem of ReID models, including debiasing effects of feature normalization and risk of camera bias in unsupervised learning.
4,178
2502.10195
[ 0.018725154921412468, -0.05472756177186966, 0.0011767513351514935, 0.05261535197496414, 0.039128366857767105, -0.002268067793920636, 0.04179440811276436, -0.007689501624554396, -0.018954690545797348, -0.04293825849890709, -0.01818377897143364, -0.0025114775635302067, -0.09801755100488663, -0.0229610875248909, -0.02199549414217472, 0.046964265406131744, 0.023337092250585556, 0.009417089633643627, 0.011028666980564594, 0.05114242434501648, 0.0036622672341763973, -0.034540243446826935, 0.0184430330991745, 0.005212499760091305, 0.012987465597689152, -0.004457204136997461, 0.03453768789768219, 0.011210008524358273, -0.042058054357767105, 0.011625166051089764, 0.03436654433608055, -0.022846048697829247, 0.008058123290538788, -0.010712090879678726, 0.010778026655316353, 0.013320335187017918, -0.05322261527180672, 0.018806204199790955, 0.007051312364637852, 0.011141008697450161, -0.04548804834485054, -0.004327032249420881, -0.026958908885717392, -0.01712506264448166, -0.07242201268672943, -0.02197429910302162, -0.12252964824438095, 0.026762014254927635, 0.01914755068719387, -0.026538049802184105, -0.06143341213464737, 0.05651676654815674, -0.01645069010555744, 0.022802574560046196, 0.032121628522872925, 0.03725115582346916, 0.034669458866119385, -0.08098845928907394, -0.03708986937999725, -0.042224787175655365, -0.004339385777711868, 0.030678732320666313, 0.030956273898482323, 0.0013119799550622702, 0.00902455486357212, -0.017035657539963722, 0.02114063873887062, 0.02860831469297409, -0.013743151910603046, -0.030165305361151695, -0.016672877594828606, -0.009849721565842628, -0.007690907455980778, 0.026396561414003372, -0.013453585095703602, -0.025492921471595764, 0.0031908529344946146, -0.01736276224255562, 0.10509908199310303, -0.03626052290201187, 0.029649119824171066, -0.011043816804885864, 0.0007182955741882324, 0.028132271021604538, 0.0427568294107914, 0.011072179302573204, -0.011510021053254604, -0.041076842695474625, -0.02985086478292942, 0.03977629914879799, -0.052410710602998734, -0.07176338881254196, 0.04498082399368286, 0.050342436879873276, -0.005225787404924631, -0.016232134774327278, -0.00030288976267911494, -0.029616042971611023, 0.011380132287740707, -0.010765726678073406, -0.009332629851996899, -0.03944546356797218, 0.007632997818291187, 0.007475268095731735, -0.09587506204843521, -0.026440251618623734, -0.007315968628972769, 0.0339643694460392, -0.0273144394159317, 0.02252458781003952, -0.03300425037741661, 0.0103516336530447, -0.007241636980324984, -0.02870110049843788, -0.07409580796957016, 0.009144672192633152, -0.015804409980773926, 0.022030768916010857, -0.011634177528321743, 0.037182509899139404, 0.03741157054901123, 0.05425793305039406, 0.00905190035700798, 0.05873969569802284, 0.03625968098640442, 0.024549098685383797, 0.018324026837944984, 0.031232133507728577, -0.06926503032445908, -0.0006223621312528849, 0.013814735226333141, 0.020149031654000282, -0.014323835261166096, 0.005343384109437466, 0.002114891307428479, -0.02370486967265606, -0.021176932379603386, -0.019314436241984367, 0.035033293068408966, -0.00404829578474164, 0.038213517516851425, 0.00342753017321229, 0.04015134274959564, -0.016596075147390366, 0.06262443959712982, -0.043830566108226776, 0.023579604923725128, 0.003949043340981007, -0.021230224519968033, 0.012193872593343258, 0.010388522408902645, -0.04468639940023422, 0.02726868912577629, -0.10301671922206879, 0.019628316164016724, 0.05148322507739067, 0.019632067531347275, 0.0138546759262681, -0.023112954571843147, 0.006611143238842487, 0.019450873136520386, -0.036122094839811325, -0.010346597991883755, 0.019961191341280937, -0.010338908061385155, -0.045195069164037704, 0.04372077062726021, 0.022584140300750732, 0.011288393288850784, 0.00468621077015996, -0.029513852670788765, -0.03264598548412323, 0.03940526768565178, 0.004416644107550383, -0.013856885023415089, 0.03669622913002968, 0.039337191730737686, 0.011275792494416237, -0.004146830178797245, 0.023323146626353264, -0.08426879346370697, 0.032786183059215546, -0.014959714375436306, -0.0048301671631634235, 0.0226015355437994, -0.017033571377396584, 0.06798091530799866, -0.021622702479362488, -0.011254679411649704, 0.011098245158791542, -0.06985431164503098, 0.017786459997296333, 0.04262674227356911, -0.02261205203831196, 0.04337509348988533, 0.03732447698712349, 0.017297055572271347, 0.03135605528950691, 0.0018807145534083247, 0.03274071589112282, 0.04285038635134697, -0.05206093192100525, 0.034909069538116455, 0.014247624203562737, -0.01279935147613287, 0.002838526153936982, 0.02446732483804226, -0.036002982407808304, -0.033893413841724396, 0.03993908315896988, -0.006457951385527849, 0.03344862535595894, -0.008351525291800499, 0.03552374988794327, -0.0017313461285084486, 0.020793812349438667, -0.009360836818814278, 0.016589704900979996, 0.017959803342819214, -0.0498172827064991, 0.04359675198793411, 0.0455339252948761, -0.016763245686888695, 0.008077849633991718, -0.02797168307006359, 0.10051164031028748, 0.06403691321611404, -0.0549294650554657, -0.014776024036109447, 0.026190422475337982, 0.014529094099998474, 0.02924446202814579, 0.02457531727850437, 0.0007811055984348059, -0.030509036034345627, -0.016414722427725792, 0.024501901119947433, -0.03276538848876953, 0.0788293182849884, -0.034524738788604736, 0.023284224793314934, 0.07777148485183716, -0.02032712660729885, 0.030411142855882645, -0.027792474254965782, -0.004578371997922659, 0.03926043584942818, 0.013448514975607395, -0.019837794825434685, -0.01276023406535387, -0.0021777276415377855, 0.01109720952808857, 0.005692108068615198, -0.040392957627773285, 0.036106426268815994, -0.04725088179111481, 0.018980341032147408, -0.050750114023685455, 0.04762306064367294, 0.06672295928001404, 0.03298487141728401, 0.028061987832188606, -0.05289367958903313, -0.007318350952118635, -0.040714241564273834, -0.0775747299194336, -0.045681167393922806, -0.017989862710237503, 0.019729873165488243, 0.018717434257268906, 0.06078898906707764, 0.004745624493807554, 0.01996011473238468, -0.012306589633226395, 0.01437689084559679, 0.02231954038143158, 0.044174905866384506, 0.021403629332780838, -0.0073462072759866714, 0.03178415074944496, -0.022383950650691986, 0.08552353829145432, -0.00788195338100195, -0.010348557494580746, -0.05047084763646126, -0.0536176860332489, -0.0437871553003788, -0.025351671501994133, -0.02843645215034485, 0.014828934334218502, 0.011483612470328808, 0.03614214062690735, 0.028831377625465393, 0.001674894941970706, 0.009088399820029736, 0.04065537080168724, 0.03393949940800667, -0.009935133159160614, -0.02626687102019787, 0.03833002969622612, -0.019075384363532066, 0.05955195799469948, 0.0481623038649559, -0.011694851331412792, 0.000581332016736269, -0.026463443413376808, 0.05297752469778061, -0.00440748268738389, -0.2666003704071045, 0.02124376967549324, 0.02791040576994419, -0.004246027674525976, 0.033220041543245316, -0.050042666494846344, 0.04291863739490509, -0.04062074050307274, -0.02812620811164379, 0.06006671115756035, 0.019620953127741814, 0.006547783501446247, 0.004973698407411575, 0.029822146520018578, 0.03705502673983574, 0.03387743979692459, 0.02391769178211689, 0.016670694574713707, -0.007777834311127663, 0.053581077605485916, -0.051458004862070084, -0.061655398458242416, -0.03390444442629814, 0.03730340301990509, -0.04498880356550217, 0.03860324248671532, -0.0474880114197731, -0.031161649152636528, -0.017216110602021217, -0.014721842482686043, 0.010012815706431866, -0.020815324038267136, 0.006760596297681332, 0.03384323790669441, 0.024506086483597755, -0.020751219242811203, 0.023611795157194138, -0.014684123918414116, -0.012191683053970337, -0.014775237068533897, -0.015293181873857975, -0.0240706168115139, -0.0025546534452587366, 0.035840317606925964, 0.07087167352437973, 0.019588107243180275, -0.03940283879637718, -0.005784273613244295, -0.023292001336812973, 0.01726004295051098, -0.000821286637801677, -0.011347204446792603, -0.037853751331567764, 0.02020561695098877, -0.0533173605799675, -0.042579617351293564, 0.024188369512557983, -0.001435943995602429, -0.025294706225395203, -0.008866178803145885, 0.009799120016396046, -0.029110515490174294, 0.008521012030541897, -0.011638153344392776, -0.008976200595498085, -0.043158456683158875, -0.04829118773341179, -0.07196249067783356, 0.030402159318327904, 0.02539033256471157, -0.05186412110924721, 0.021831069141626358, -0.020804282277822495, -0.10030427575111389, 0.020027417689561844, -0.015978435054421425, -0.0016456081066280603, -0.01161295548081398, -0.014282908290624619, 0.03548610955476761, -0.018857838585972786, -0.01380747277289629, 0.041494663804769516, 0.003746454603970051, 0.008383255451917648, -0.036858972162008286, 0.020478200167417526, -0.027684340253472328, 0.01405354868620634, -0.013256286270916462, 0.06298835575580597, -0.007915952242910862, 0.03609989583492279, 0.02301464043557644, 0.022066907957196236, 0.038966529071331024, 0.03815621882677078, 0.03421339765191078, 0.0689239427447319, 0.003182017244398594, 0.014871155843138695, -0.05494619905948639, -0.029652046039700508, -0.0578201524913311, -0.03136814385652542, 0.028359219431877136, -0.025532204657793045, -0.005615564528852701, 0.037654854357242584, -0.03062804788351059, -0.03731219470500946, 0.010072728618979454, -0.018984006717801094, -0.011522366665303707, -0.006411422044038773, -0.029137201607227325, 0.01570064015686512, -0.007365101482719183, 0.06044334918260574, -0.029240472242236137, -0.005617077928036451, 0.05457829684019089, -0.0237694401293993, 0.060327768325805664, -0.04133554920554161, -0.014225470833480358, -0.02877647615969181, -0.025856340304017067, -0.02136850357055664, -0.0001965523697435856, 0.03953726589679718, 0.02617758698761463, -0.010415628552436829, 0.04114317148923874, 0.0792437270283699, 0.026118416339159012, 0.026932407170534134, -0.029024913907051086, 0.017392300069332123, -0.03653633967041969, 0.015700967982411385, -0.00467339064925909, 0.006330640520900488, 0.05235717073082924, 0.04738066345453262, 0.00753207691013813, 0.02287057228386402, 0.019790174439549446, -0.03722619265317917, -0.01822856441140175, 0.03724057599902153, -0.06216956675052643, -0.05728431046009064, -0.019287114962935448, 0.016855306923389435, -0.019158482551574707, 0.03174124285578728, -0.007056329865008593, -0.005097051616758108, -0.05279410257935524, 0.056434422731399536, 0.022692326456308365, 0.009314313530921936, 0.010326780378818512, 0.014532774686813354, 0.03034309297800064, 0.014839624054729939, -0.0670485720038414, 0.010417417623102665, 0.028441153466701508, -0.03307119011878967, -0.03430406376719475, -0.016281098127365112, -0.03984871134161949, 0.005196682643145323, 0.0011020235251635313, 0.009116055443882942, -0.0016498067416250706, -0.05527989938855171, 0.024094074964523315, -0.020724810659885406, 0.008861151523888111, -0.0002668005181476474, 0.014669776894152164, 0.07953982055187225, 0.020531289279460907, -0.03530985116958618, -0.04922487586736679, -0.021242305636405945, 0.05493882670998573, 0.010144428350031376, 0.0031735647935420275, -0.03444591909646988, -0.03694666922092438, -0.027782509103417397, -0.017461027950048447, -0.013082308694720268, -0.007843846455216408, -0.013070916756987572, 0.008446724154055119, -0.034296173602342606, 0.03972524777054787, 0.002289487048983574, 0.006796534173190594, -0.014318453148007393, -0.06551159173250198, 0.024791451171040535, 0.031165139749646187, -0.0743737667798996, 0.02484300546348095, -0.013420174829661846, -0.044332701712846756, -0.06787876784801483, -0.04273010417819023, 0.004147917497903109, -0.01017044484615326, -0.02600082941353321, -0.025028962641954422, -0.003938307054340839, -0.0023912121541798115, 0.024960700422525406, 0.014096410945057869, -0.005398860666900873, 0.027663281187415123, 0.013931336812675, 0.0511058084666729, -0.006670846603810787, -0.019250724464654922, 0.016289975494146347, -0.01846972666680813, -0.0031203264370560646, -0.03764992207288742, 0.030766325071454048, 0.05955909565091133, -0.040395982563495636, -0.008411763235926628, -0.0318431630730629, 0.030118389055132866, -0.006961279083043337, -0.012499449774622917, 0.007059094030410051, -0.003528823144733906, -0.008976021781563759, 0.033774834126234055, 0.018459245562553406, 0.029486803337931633, 0.0017692350083962083, -0.01041950099170208, -0.003193336073309183, 0.02112957462668419, -0.00020532058260869235, 0.009562226012349129, -0.041558265686035156, -0.0027693447191268206, 0.02159937657415867, -0.02119021862745285, 0.008180606178939342, -0.0808226615190506, -0.02933504246175289, 0.02301263064146042, -0.006891318596899509, 0.023008452728390694, 0.01543064322322607, 0.018305432051420212, 0.007042147219181061, 0.013478557579219341, -0.03576284274458885, 0.010900944471359253, 0.05350133776664734, -0.03743188455700874, -0.05018186196684837, -0.015492682345211506, 0.007877646014094353, 0.08560429513454437, -0.012810791842639446, 0.043345171958208084, -0.026240982115268707, -0.016990438103675842, 0.015756109729409218, -0.008800679817795753, -0.06227966770529747, -0.02991112507879734, -0.02442670427262783, -0.0016821532044559717, 0.005293851252645254, -0.02356831729412079, 0.044291917234659195, -0.011020704172551632, -0.04937230795621872, -0.03626638650894165, 0.005083838012069464, 0.03526943549513817, -0.024647576734423637, 0.010298293083906174, -0.0013616862706840038, 0.008175582624971867, -0.001884615165181458, 0.06052348390221596, -0.025925777852535248, 0.02359757013618946, -0.013254578225314617, 0.0459190234541893, 0.0224172230809927, -0.015973208472132683, -0.005056462250649929, 0.03655624017119408, -0.011051444336771965, -0.08852043002843857, 0.08257310092449188, -0.002183305798098445, -0.052919235080480576, -0.05149579793214798, 0.03622893616557121, 0.035723693668842316, -0.057767149060964584, -0.05163921043276787, 0.04815676063299179, -0.03662661463022232, 0.00010207266313955188, -0.012272585183382034, -0.04357399046421051, -0.029788581654429436, 0.04974807798862457, 0.010474301874637604, 0.03931990638375282, 0.038549236953258514, 0.01069885864853859, 0.034712400287389755, -0.02376795932650566, 0.05561894550919533, 0.07421267777681351, 0.07659182697534561, 0.004630581475794315, 0.07718560844659805, -0.006697537377476692, -0.03988875821232796, 0.04885841906070709, -0.011736365035176277, -0.017309462651610374, -0.03296129032969475, -0.02958151511847973, 0.08590339124202728, 0.01035758014768362, 0.06419726461172104, -0.054879531264305115, -0.005240017548203468, 0.04822998493909836, -0.020011713728308678, 0.0076473308727145195, 0.02312498725950718, 0.015567101538181305, -0.007713505998253822, -0.08307436853647232, 0.01350647583603859, 0.007730384822934866, -0.01988288201391697, 0.03364457190036774, -0.011571391485631466, -0.03332800790667534, 0.01715799979865551, -0.03557257726788521, 0.02069459855556488, 0.0921066552400589, -0.04207802563905716, -0.0740969255566597, -0.0052470676600933075, -0.004483811091631651, 0.02247026562690735, 0.05515778437256813, 0.020000139251351357, -0.03632255643606186, 0.035176072269678116, -0.068062923848629, 0.020911674946546555, 0.06123651564121246, -0.04569514840841293, 0.017703836783766747, -0.04108939692378044, -0.03323930874466896, 0.01601186953485012, 0.02551070787012577, -0.017996149137616158, -0.011712308041751385, -0.049162883311510086, -0.05289722606539726, -0.043414607644081116, -0.034238044172525406, 0.02872355468571186, 0.02030313014984131, -0.026009416207671165, 0.0013091953005641699, -0.011610534973442554, 0.03405420854687691, 0.03776279091835022, -0.08237811923027039, 0.02249941974878311, 0.02210088260471821, 0.005518761463463306, 0.00923921074718237, 0.04339490085840225, -0.0023855280596762896, -0.020085658878087997, -0.03436059504747391, 0.03265375271439552, -0.0036468137986958027, 0.03217364847660065, -0.016657182946801186, -0.06011667475104332, -0.09841669350862503, -0.025065787136554718, 0.027227802202105522, -0.07111699134111404, -0.06467776000499725, 0.04372778162360191, -0.015452033840119839, 0.060999397188425064, 0.060730334371328354, -0.000332979136146605, 0.00225860089994967, -0.03471923619508743, -0.015708226710557938, -0.04650318995118141, 0.032145097851753235, 0.03193240612745285, -0.011561674065887928, 0.06153469160199165, -0.007377264089882374, -0.017392093315720558, -0.037453584372997284, 0.019652169197797775, -0.02560495212674141, -0.004717526491731405, -0.029373975470662117, -0.024350130930542946, -0.029660774394869804, -0.09253774583339691, -0.012961856089532375, 0.02582208625972271, 0.007213000673800707, -0.023514147847890854, 0.00798467081040144, 0.019942205399274826, -0.024802597239613533, -0.0054517993703484535, 0.019635740667581558, 0.014453332871198654, -0.06109723821282387, -0.02265119180083275, -0.0561760738492012, -0.031106874346733093, -0.036100197583436966, 0.014644376002252102, -0.010201177559792995, -0.07358871400356293, -0.017713194712996483, -0.00960242934525013, 0.03983228653669357, -0.018331626430153847, 0.042119767516851425, -0.009664928540587425 ]
3,587
Preference Optimization for Reasoning with Pseudo Feedback
https://openreview.net/forum?id=jkUp3lybXf
[ "Fangkai Jiao", "Geyang Guo", "Xingxing Zhang", "Nancy F. Chen", "Shafiq Joty", "Furu Wei" ]
Spotlight
Preference optimization techniques, such as Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), are frequently employed to enhance the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) in domains like mathematical reasoning and coding, typically following supervised fine-tuning. These methods rely on high-quality labels for reasoning tasks to generate preference pairs; however, the availability of reasoning datasets with human-verified labels is limited. In this study, we introduce a novel approach to generate pseudo feedback for reasoning tasks by framing the labeling of solutions to reason problems as an evaluation against associated \emph{test cases}. We explore two forms of pseudo feedback based on test cases: one generated by frontier LLMs and the other by extending self-consistency to multi-test-case. We conduct experiments on both mathematical reasoning and coding tasks using pseudo feedback for preference optimization, and observe improvements across both tasks. Specifically, using Mathstral-7B as our base model, we improve MATH results from 58.3 to 68.6, surpassing both NuminaMath-72B and GPT-4-Turbo-1106-preview. In GSM8K and College Math, our scores increase from 85.6 to 90.3 and from 34.3 to 42.3, respectively. Building on Deepseek-coder-7B-v1.5, we achieve a score of 24.3 on LiveCodeBench (from 21.1), surpassing Claude-3-Haiku.
Large Language Model, Code Generation, Natural Language Reasoning, Reinforcement Learning
We develop a framework to continuously improve LLMs for reasoning and code generation through self-consistency-based pseudo feedback.
4,129
2411.16345
[ -0.009486605413258076, -0.005830379202961922, 0.0027464665472507477, 0.061980634927749634, 0.04461585730314255, 0.046772997826337814, 0.00999885331839323, 0.010913084261119366, -0.01588311232626438, -0.014955415390431881, -0.018964529037475586, 0.043229665607213974, -0.05633582919836044, -0.003002226585522294, -0.0000982877318165265, 0.055747177451848984, 0.02965245395898819, 0.0035669489298015833, 0.016895418986678123, 0.01153579168021679, 0.025065895169973373, -0.037444889545440674, 0.0008534213411621749, 0.0008692504488863051, 0.025587351992726326, 0.03465849161148071, 0.03731757402420044, 0.01892264559864998, -0.017772819846868515, -0.03058410808444023, 0.033027563244104385, 0.018704811111092567, 0.0249928068369627, 0.010818997398018837, -0.036780040711164474, 0.0024881167337298393, -0.04025877267122269, 0.030072014778852463, 0.012395733036100864, 0.036448944360017776, -0.04844140261411667, 0.02285069040954113, 0.0018622514326125383, -0.0042882091365754604, -0.05266251415014267, 0.02014850080013275, -0.08415880054235458, 0.009908009320497513, -0.026352660730481148, -0.04551805183291435, -0.10162625461816788, 0.04501339793205261, 0.0013852360425516963, -0.03200202062726021, -0.014606572687625885, 0.05019409954547882, 0.06586865335702896, -0.08958879858255386, 0.013903729617595673, -0.04155636206269264, -0.05203069746494293, 0.030409933999180794, 0.012375175952911377, 0.006388474255800247, 0.0026178385596722364, -0.027816524729132652, -0.019383616745471954, 0.03313779458403587, -0.052288416773080826, -0.022134030237793922, -0.03668636083602905, -0.0011820559157058597, 0.010548951104283333, -0.017204565927386284, -0.002038140781223774, -0.0390651635825634, 0.030354728922247887, 0.04085717722773552, 0.01810772530734539, -0.0061749960295856, -0.012130122631788254, 0.047383807599544525, 0.03541194647550583, 0.03418680280447006, 0.04231908172369003, 0.002536081476137042, -0.00807216577231884, -0.02549869380891323, -0.07588737457990646, 0.024711081758141518, 0.017385950312018394, -0.04742685705423355, 0.030881918966770172, 0.04319695383310318, 0.05168762430548668, 0.00017626200860831887, 0.02885402739048004, 0.01447821594774723, 0.0015433485386893153, 0.000058654135500546545, -0.02229415625333786, -0.0603863000869751, 0.06455106288194656, -0.018677303567528725, -0.09938148409128189, -0.024284904822707176, 0.0009556182194501162, -0.012725664302706718, -0.012716587632894516, 0.038031645119190216, -0.04822288826107979, 0.0005230173119343817, 0.04533017799258232, -0.005993558559566736, -0.08389036357402802, 0.009800479747354984, -0.007429139222949743, 0.03720763698220253, -0.029860524460673332, 0.03507419675588608, 0.030445696786046028, 0.0267124455422163, 0.021647371351718903, 0.07679923623800278, -0.012176022864878178, 0.01993589848279953, 0.018809737637639046, 0.04525991901755333, -0.03817988932132721, -0.04683440178632736, 0.0008857574430294335, 0.039765890687704086, -0.016749756410717964, 0.004574149381369352, -0.02935650572180748, 0.012226460501551628, 0.003667205572128296, -0.021609755232930183, 0.037186432629823685, 0.013692883774638176, -0.01620185375213623, -0.012242273427546024, 0.07673284411430359, -0.02302231639623642, 0.04768054187297821, -0.004762093536555767, 0.010619291104376316, -0.00023098589736036956, -0.026759883388876915, -0.0012591273989528418, -0.009770247153937817, -0.01634777896106243, -0.024832218885421753, -0.0730932429432869, 0.018039599061012268, 0.05278272181749344, 0.028451813384890556, 0.011852558702230453, 0.002212236635386944, 0.00677477428689599, 0.00437463354319334, 0.0043587530963122845, -0.03684101998806, -0.0001774099509930238, -0.008520495146512985, -0.05445808544754982, 0.04462866857647896, 0.018596207723021507, -0.05780502408742905, 0.0289560966193676, -0.0435289591550827, -0.028834063559770584, 0.07950347661972046, -0.020642627030611038, -0.021450264379382133, 0.0057648248039186, 0.08071812242269516, -0.008275852538645267, 0.0619228295981884, 0.01932440884411335, -0.06308613717556, 0.0037132930010557175, -0.017307190224528313, -0.0019725149031728506, -0.009406120516359806, -0.023076897487044334, 0.09190057963132858, -0.019046247005462646, 0.02148534543812275, 0.03308752924203873, -0.07568599283695221, -0.01854645274579525, 0.05195799469947815, 0.012752671726047993, 0.0659695640206337, 0.0024245488457381725, -0.00518942903727293, 0.06303895264863968, 0.028247680515050888, 0.0717439204454422, 0.06181227043271065, -0.016132576391100883, 0.05699320137500763, 0.009077453054487705, -0.02312009409070015, 0.02046331763267517, 0.047536954283714294, -0.04912293329834938, -0.0335661843419075, 0.0320635586977005, -0.04158272594213486, -0.004135360475629568, 0.02036265656352043, -0.01200423389673233, -0.011678985320031643, -0.014988461509346962, -0.003392483340576291, -0.014974222518503666, 0.028356751427054405, -0.05447942391037941, 0.03378169611096382, 0.01983840949833393, 0.01244890596717596, 0.01433571707457304, -0.030968153849244118, 0.09083442389965057, 0.0711948350071907, -0.036513201892375946, 0.008505296893417835, 0.03671320527791977, -0.009682741947472095, 0.02952444925904274, 0.015296010300517082, -0.03169059753417969, 0.017174120992422104, -0.030101781710982323, -0.013086823746562004, -0.019996989518404007, 0.07181867957115173, -0.04134873300790787, 0.0021918804850429296, 0.0781703069806099, -0.043500080704689026, 0.06549390405416489, -0.028500700369477272, 0.012392343953251839, 0.016536036506295204, 0.03102833218872547, -0.02030075713992119, -0.014122105203568935, -0.03177617862820625, 0.008876793086528778, 0.015260489657521248, -0.015736224129796028, -0.001129187410697341, -0.04987981542944908, 0.007955143228173256, -0.015571699477732182, 0.05532414838671684, 0.04298439249396324, -0.004428134765475988, 0.011153850704431534, 0.03190796449780464, -0.06401509791612625, 0.023412121459841728, -0.08839450031518936, -0.047311972826719284, 0.017770424485206604, 0.022047994658350945, -0.0020868980791419744, 0.01292625442147255, -0.0048113614320755005, 0.03170099854469299, -0.03310355544090271, -0.060377396643161774, 0.015344291925430298, 0.010387055575847626, 0.007483851630240679, -0.0590578094124794, -0.02608007937669754, 0.01969495415687561, 0.06578309088945389, -0.059763651341199875, -0.031252115964889526, -0.032029859721660614, -0.04501400142908096, 0.0036625810898840427, -0.06221172958612442, 0.005294610746204853, 0.04238314554095268, 0.02160647325217724, 0.022084267809987068, -0.05129970237612724, 0.020991923287510872, 0.07573293894529343, -0.00018799274403136224, 0.06466406583786011, 0.0007649565814062953, -0.010095166973769665, 0.03528346121311188, -0.012112410739064217, 0.03248026221990585, -0.004170619882643223, 0.0668485015630722, -0.019504453986883163, 0.005016536917537451, 0.02488236501812935, 0.009985874406993389, -0.2482137382030487, -0.017088955268263817, -0.010953821241855621, -0.009882165119051933, 0.03295436501502991, -0.012662908993661404, 0.054983463138341904, -0.04589023068547249, -0.04393486678600311, 0.00493281427770853, 0.023179983720183372, 0.006892863195389509, -0.019266434013843536, 0.07034964859485626, 0.054679982364177704, 0.03805483505129814, 0.0003427471383474767, -0.01622144505381584, -0.0049189175479114056, 0.0022427102085202932, 0.010679395869374275, -0.08509700745344162, 0.01358748134225607, 0.035725612193346024, 0.02290496602654457, 0.06000704690814018, -0.0988236740231514, 0.003848916618153453, -0.04329623281955719, -0.03006109781563282, -0.035817380994558334, -0.03715478256344795, -0.0400211364030838, 0.022400924935936928, 0.03785056248307228, 0.01529085636138916, 0.05001802742481232, -0.03280598670244217, 0.04137247055768967, 0.06445075571537018, 0.003082410665228963, -0.012677442282438278, -0.0047866529785096645, -0.003970364108681679, 0.04544699192047119, 0.01438688300549984, -0.06491613388061523, -0.026743141934275627, -0.015174170024693012, 0.04233638569712639, 0.02677907422184944, -0.0031426269561052322, -0.03014860488474369, 0.011538972146809101, 0.0010212999768555164, -0.021964294835925102, 0.014372747391462326, -0.022172216325998306, -0.026477010920643806, -0.01628786511719227, 0.020808516070246696, -0.02052142843604088, -0.015135137364268303, -0.017989564687013626, -0.023156384006142616, -0.042541515082120895, -0.05515364930033684, -0.021098118275403976, 0.051867932081222534, 0.045004915446043015, -0.0065032364800572395, -0.006740964949131012, 0.020696837455034256, -0.09172865748405457, -0.02230146899819374, -0.011762171983718872, 0.004252372309565544, -0.011093867011368275, 0.017412930727005005, 0.045722320675849915, -0.05308346822857857, -0.03113936446607113, 0.00311236921697855, 0.015128830447793007, 0.021115627139806747, -0.0137382997199893, -0.005262407474219799, -0.045104604214429855, -0.01548922248184681, -0.03000716120004654, 0.03892765939235687, -0.018365146592259407, 0.013738094829022884, 0.007246452383697033, 0.05836815387010574, 0.03820353373885155, 0.05429461970925331, 0.019836509600281715, 0.03812181577086449, 0.015985799953341484, -0.0013670068001374602, -0.07727166265249252, -0.0019487186800688505, -0.0369240865111351, -0.02750464156270027, -0.003319601295515895, -0.06249632686376572, 0.006807412952184677, 0.02563878707587719, -0.01392932515591383, -0.05537242442369461, -0.01131510641425848, 0.004913655575364828, -0.0070776063948869705, -0.03498663380742073, -0.0013056985335424542, 0.013456474989652634, 0.03269454091787338, 0.009220581501722336, -0.029855990782380104, -0.038798123598098755, 0.0322544239461422, -0.03767364099621773, 0.001244705985300243, -0.02844364382326603, 0.02645178884267807, -0.027142973616719246, -0.03689310699701309, -0.012476443313062191, -0.003114010440185666, 0.013371976092457771, 0.03394535556435585, -0.007940900512039661, 0.027028722688555717, 0.050690945237874985, -0.009197869338095188, 0.0028680714312940836, -0.011434182524681091, 0.023306533694267273, -0.01916411519050598, 0.0011174011742696166, -0.010664393194019794, 0.034939300268888474, 0.019542379304766655, 0.036839134991168976, -0.012514605186879635, 0.015615803189575672, -0.0024790577590465546, 0.0027453775983303785, 0.00290668080560863, 0.05856040120124817, -0.09390982240438461, 0.006646483205258846, -0.045856427401304245, 0.01028592698276043, -0.010115615092217922, 0.01453615352511406, -0.007674709428101778, -0.004131055902689695, -0.053979627788066864, 0.0224558524787426, -0.007434724830091, -0.005244174972176552, -0.004601262975484133, 0.04073803871870041, 0.051655031740665436, -0.027251722291111946, 0.019700437784194946, -0.0022724594455212355, -0.005928166676312685, 0.03613023832440376, -0.008777901530265808, -0.022743871435523033, -0.016502486541867256, -0.014559350907802582, 0.00213981163688004, 0.042666662484407425, -0.01867721974849701, -0.0530688539147377, 0.018361452966928482, -0.02263442799448967, -0.05904967337846756, -0.00928379688411951, 0.004258894361555576, 0.07994408905506134, 0.010650123469531536, 0.019559582695364952, -0.0084748025983572, -0.01972799375653267, 0.008609824813902378, -0.03956489637494087, -0.012517184019088745, 0.009029155597090721, -0.01663322187960148, -0.07161754369735718, -0.054062750190496445, -0.014314712025225163, 0.014346295967698097, -0.007754921447485685, -0.00912992749363184, -0.03885547071695328, 0.0163388904184103, -0.048716504126787186, -0.038517750799655914, 0.05037128925323486, -0.0597572885453701, -0.0028486009687185287, 0.009829350747168064, 0.030573967844247818, -0.001370942685753107, -0.051196351647377014, -0.07106033712625504, -0.04972560703754425, -0.025324193760752678, 0.0007364805787801743, -0.03726525232195854, -0.013999533839523792, -0.0015226391842588782, -0.038451503962278366, -0.029528360813856125, 0.020677171647548676, -0.00999387539923191, 0.0012312554754316807, -0.04105990007519722, -0.013086874969303608, 0.05516701936721802, -0.02932986058294773, -0.0434131845831871, 0.0034362440928816795, -0.03886912018060684, 0.04199589416384697, -0.038496315479278564, 0.015347235836088657, 0.04947296530008316, 0.0122681288048625, 0.006255586631596088, -0.04435229301452637, 0.060596030205488205, -0.01920383609831333, -0.019650422036647797, -0.006871320307254791, -0.02208227850496769, -0.015384146943688393, -0.0146767757833004, -0.02823830209672451, 0.059533439576625824, 0.027875207364559174, -0.012241650372743607, 0.009021450765430927, 0.0327238067984581, 0.004513869993388653, 0.03829110413789749, -0.05948973447084427, 0.011161680333316326, 0.054353371262550354, 0.008924445137381554, -0.012706930749118328, -0.056395020335912704, -0.04602034389972687, 0.01224710512906313, -0.035182442516088486, 0.03780563175678253, -0.009281063452363014, 0.06397639960050583, -0.008022688329219818, 0.032795101404190063, 0.04978019371628761, -0.024495992809534073, 0.02100885473191738, -0.06294631212949753, -0.01844550296664238, -0.05942394956946373, 0.036985378712415695, 0.04952439293265343, -0.009341529570519924, 0.00964271742850542, -0.005470946431159973, -0.04846779629588127, 0.06807209551334381, -0.02066873386502266, -0.03197813779115677, -0.01174941286444664, -0.010596737265586853, -0.031200554221868515, 0.04799260199069977, -0.051175933331251144, -0.025337688624858856, 0.011849557980895042, -0.050223808735609055, 0.022166544571518898, 0.0009040378499776125, 0.03758624196052551, 0.010533817112445831, 0.006837307941168547, -0.019603261724114418, 0.022855030372738838, 0.023189164698123932, 0.04990050941705704, 0.023781388998031616, 0.0001717001141514629, -0.02423909492790699, 0.05505235865712166, 0.05589244142174721, 0.05381869524717331, -0.016654077917337418, 0.023187050595879555, -0.030261879786849022, -0.06030770763754845, 0.04647416993975639, 0.014797266572713852, -0.030736418440937996, -0.058627743273973465, 0.04467882961034775, 0.02307094633579254, -0.014451253227889538, -0.018589049577713013, 0.02596229873597622, -0.040984898805618286, -0.025702444836497307, -0.0001554028276586905, -0.017536748200654984, 0.00984569638967514, 0.09282370656728745, 0.03390700742602348, 0.019922351464629173, 0.0738898292183876, 0.00920149777084589, -0.024597911164164543, -0.019354797899723053, 0.057144250720739365, 0.053924258798360825, 0.04825178161263466, 0.004165283869951963, 0.05553198605775833, -0.03558879718184471, -0.0215313583612442, 0.020781200379133224, 0.00269393902271986, -0.021588696166872978, -0.026953112334012985, 0.013123695738613605, 0.05489683896303177, -0.021758954972028732, 0.05485489219427109, -0.03439417481422424, 0.003076080232858658, 0.03690977394580841, 0.023608578369021416, -0.007373660337179899, 0.08732613176107407, 0.0018852184293791652, 0.02279549278318882, -0.03844287246465683, -0.0028148547280579805, -0.0013883081264793873, -0.014767338521778584, -0.021015718579292297, -0.03182043135166168, -0.019351448863744736, 0.021747862920165062, 0.007316657342016697, 0.030470335856080055, 0.07876625657081604, -0.07385260611772537, -0.034606076776981354, 0.04168775677680969, 0.003462487366050482, 0.033421460539102554, 0.02433241344988346, -0.004113934002816677, -0.016913915053009987, -0.00028908668900839984, -0.028939900919795036, -0.01058746688067913, 0.013059237971901894, -0.0004964183899573982, 0.02371298149228096, -0.015999343246221542, -0.004057100508362055, 0.040655266493558884, -0.0004268109623808414, -0.08677128702402115, -0.0570586621761322, -0.011434061452746391, -0.04220586270093918, -0.0661519467830658, -0.04055994376540184, -0.009961564093828201, -0.03898284584283829, -0.014571044594049454, 0.0028810405638068914, -0.04228821024298668, 0.006126574240624905, 0.004520426969975233, -0.055543456226587296, -0.02028663083910942, 0.024461260065436363, 0.019987059757113457, -0.0016121573280543089, 0.01701088808476925, 0.01200444158166647, -0.03009146824479103, 0.012009810656309128, 0.001476595876738429, 0.0029710931703448296, -0.014696033671498299, -0.0026265159249305725, -0.006088279653340578, -0.07774434238672256, -0.02598806470632553, 0.004585817456245422, -0.006719052325934172, -0.06795167177915573, 0.016563059762120247, -0.031891193240880966, 0.03264518454670906, 0.09782594442367554, 0.01874440908432007, 0.02597583830356598, -0.01983577013015747, 0.014097749255597591, 0.019913166761398315, 0.019777392968535423, 0.06209547445178032, -0.031151190400123596, 0.055303800851106644, 0.021308233961462975, -0.05744249001145363, -0.060987766832113266, 0.03011925332248211, -0.002382292877882719, -0.029573477804660797, -0.01380165945738554, -0.027868803590536118, -0.041001345962285995, -0.09636924415826797, -0.016250818967819214, 0.014454174786806107, -0.03806498646736145, -0.04879050329327583, -0.01088031753897667, -0.00384046183899045, -0.015668164938688278, 0.04045550152659416, -0.039846062660217285, 0.028450816869735718, -0.023743925616145134, -0.02608855813741684, -0.04143615439534187, -0.0010083786910399795, -0.007067883387207985, 0.013340627774596214, -0.017862839624285698, -0.017574584111571312, -0.012599593959748745, 0.004174776840955019, 0.04915323108434677, 0.021706683561205864, 0.029503358528017998, -0.02394345961511135 ]
3,588
Regularization by Texts for Latent Diffusion Inverse Solvers
https://openreview.net/forum?id=TtUh0TOlGX
[ "Jeongsol Kim", "Geon Yeong Park", "Hyungjin Chung", "Jong Chul Ye" ]
Spotlight
The recent development of diffusion models has led to significant progress in solving inverse problems by leveraging these models as powerful generative priors. However, challenges persist due to the ill-posed nature of such problems, often arising from ambiguities in measurements or intrinsic system symmetries. To address this, we introduce a novel latent diffusion inverse solver, regularization by text (TReg), inspired by the human ability to resolve visual ambiguities through perceptual biases. TReg integrates textual descriptions of preconceptions about the solution during reverse diffusion sampling, dynamically reinforcing these descriptions through null-text optimization, which we refer to as adaptive negation. Our comprehensive experimental results demonstrate that TReg effectively mitigates ambiguity in inverse problems, improving both accuracy and efficiency.
Inverse problem, Text regularization, Diffusion model
We propose text regularization for inverse problem solving.
4,127
2311.15658
[ 0.0031146074179559946, -0.025437159463763237, -0.0005555131938308477, 0.07163077592849731, 0.06603219360113144, 0.016069933772087097, 0.025394467636942863, -0.00043124702642671764, -0.029441824182868004, -0.06158829852938652, -0.001259446144104004, 0.03961898386478424, -0.018274934962391853, -0.011853068135678768, -0.018310140818357468, 0.051766347140073776, 0.025925366207957268, -0.017453007400035858, -0.020748134702444077, 0.057620249688625336, 0.030650001019239426, -0.03419135883450508, 0.04571935161948204, 0.008649035356938839, 0.05940208584070206, 0.004497814457863569, 0.024006983265280724, -0.00949579756706953, -0.024463362991809845, 0.013095572590827942, 0.013484333641827106, 0.012695975601673126, -0.01675979048013687, -0.05164094269275665, -0.0007167553994804621, 0.020162271335721016, -0.0674535408616066, 0.022140156477689743, -0.006747991777956486, 0.0057827471755445, -0.04819260537624359, -0.003523715306073427, -0.046376898884773254, 0.028762487694621086, -0.0431070551276207, 0.012134858407080173, -0.10630372911691666, 0.00937173143029213, -0.030657200142741203, -0.02059786580502987, -0.10142214596271515, 0.04426008090376854, -0.009263970889151096, -0.015439899638295174, -0.010651851072907448, 0.05012592300772667, 0.03837541118264198, -0.06947047263383865, -0.01897013559937477, -0.039189938455820084, -0.034668292850255966, 0.017489690333604813, -0.022443033754825592, -0.0025373471435159445, -0.009237983264029026, -0.011324664577841759, 0.010721966624259949, 0.026280894875526428, -0.044753219932317734, -0.03438934311270714, -0.01087184902280569, 0.020246421918272972, 0.01429031789302826, -0.0021068791393190622, -0.005213768221437931, -0.01770414225757122, 0.013476870954036713, 0.02565871924161911, 0.05300906300544739, -0.009573371149599552, 0.008922566659748554, -0.00008989584603114054, 0.013455291278660297, 0.027334142476320267, 0.009550081565976143, -0.014752772636711597, -0.028652070090174675, 0.004284474067389965, -0.05833865702152252, 0.04452015087008476, -0.02511308342218399, -0.08894743025302887, 0.008015233092010021, 0.03547283262014389, 0.053470078855752945, -0.01266593299806118, 0.05361376330256462, 0.029329203069210052, 0.01570390723645687, 0.024545840919017792, -0.025287145748734474, -0.03655894845724106, 0.013136644847691059, 0.00022462494962383062, -0.09909001737833023, -0.011380083858966827, -0.058293700218200684, 0.004335284698754549, -0.02987842634320259, -0.010930619202554226, -0.023652711883187294, -0.018613897264003754, -0.012984280474483967, -0.021293316036462784, -0.08623785525560379, 0.03326650336384773, 0.03899608552455902, 0.018839353695511818, 0.011730979196727276, -0.017190707847476006, 0.05242947116494179, 0.06130873039364815, 0.01371639221906662, 0.07725944370031357, 0.016325930133461952, 0.045216552913188934, 0.04869835078716278, 0.03378668054938316, -0.07104083895683289, -0.02945454977452755, -0.013330112211406231, 0.04230315610766411, 0.024175487458705902, 0.009077309630811214, 0.007012401707470417, -0.04355165734887123, 0.02110234834253788, 0.0010678124381229281, 0.053570058196783066, -0.022646047174930573, -0.006593924015760422, -0.03063836507499218, 0.023900547996163368, -0.009396820329129696, 0.05179331451654434, -0.05605195462703705, -0.0008267983794212341, -0.01575993001461029, -0.04184859246015549, 0.03836223483085632, -0.00478265481069684, -0.04748052731156349, 0.03502817079424858, -0.06007370352745056, 0.008307509124279022, 0.05525314062833786, 0.001965555362403393, 0.02069941908121109, -0.02564396522939205, 0.003250190056860447, 0.04961179196834564, 0.006675690412521362, -0.006607142277061939, 0.011286900378763676, -0.019737690687179565, -0.05107636749744415, 0.03378303349018097, 0.011152489110827446, -0.025678277015686035, -0.03489292040467262, -0.04055638611316681, -0.047249987721443176, 0.05012607201933861, 0.004505109041929245, -0.019761858507990837, -0.0011641134042292833, 0.022184837609529495, 0.009020496159791946, 0.026057317852973938, 0.019482966512441635, -0.09510830789804459, 0.038836125284433365, 0.008205683901906013, 0.0051088412292301655, 0.02692246437072754, -0.030319785699248314, 0.07211767882108688, -0.03639679402112961, 0.006984401494264603, 0.017562109977006912, -0.08790166676044464, -0.003289234358817339, 0.03979383409023285, -0.007489247713238001, 0.05230528861284256, 0.023421404883265495, 0.00700350059196353, 0.043009161949157715, 0.023322025313973427, 0.036066457629203796, 0.03431425988674164, -0.07048849016427994, 0.05121690034866333, -0.017696049064397812, -0.002411997877061367, 0.0004880724009126425, 0.0622091069817543, -0.041885584592819214, -0.01714215613901615, 0.030598092824220657, 0.0017344801453873515, -0.004241476766765118, 0.0009766649454832077, 0.005909277126193047, 0.010332760401070118, 0.0023688029032200575, -0.021140730008482933, 0.002290769014507532, 0.012643350288271904, -0.04454115405678749, 0.036486659198999405, 0.03501707687973976, -0.004302012734115124, 0.004063393454998732, -0.035370513796806335, 0.08804767578840256, 0.06821519136428833, -0.05505788326263428, 0.014176787808537483, 0.03341197967529297, 0.005953113082796335, 0.01030748337507248, 0.047215912491083145, -0.029685737565159798, 0.015371808782219887, -0.025491058826446533, 0.020284529775381088, -0.03786272928118706, 0.07813037186861038, -0.048609934747219086, -0.008613301441073418, 0.04715355485677719, -0.038421742618083954, 0.0678592324256897, -0.015411227941513062, 0.01699003204703331, 0.045239318162202835, -0.013286805711686611, -0.03245280683040619, -0.0533292181789875, 0.013062581419944763, 0.018872668966650963, 0.0003927903308067471, -0.02352258376777172, 0.028972527012228966, -0.03610645979642868, -0.030773943290114403, -0.02092074230313301, 0.06959791481494904, 0.051353421062231064, 0.0027380341198295355, 0.03464522957801819, 0.006871935911476612, -0.04284306988120079, -0.02135474607348442, -0.12100999802350998, -0.011788125149905682, 0.001014240551739931, 0.016070395708084106, -0.002363440580666065, 0.07434163242578506, -0.05033014714717865, 0.0009212597506120801, -0.014492561109364033, 0.011412856169044971, -0.03274533897638321, 0.018917927518486977, -0.0019333796808496118, -0.0295199453830719, -0.022094551473855972, 0.02231936901807785, 0.07982353866100311, -0.02496512234210968, -0.011618323624134064, -0.02974996156990528, -0.054530903697013855, -0.0060998545959591866, 0.024544566869735718, -0.003211198840290308, 0.038060590624809265, 0.03931652009487152, 0.01781301572918892, -0.017999466508626938, 0.015580881386995316, -0.002915916731581092, 0.050644710659980774, 0.021982664242386818, 0.004516028333455324, -0.005859063006937504, 0.03195314481854439, -0.00012838002294301987, 0.007246355060487986, -0.005245501175522804, 0.04479710012674332, -0.021276624873280525, -0.005111853592097759, 0.031821079552173615, 0.0008976788376457989, -0.26945048570632935, 0.02832086570560932, 0.022325702011585236, -0.033343974500894547, 0.028685878962278366, -0.012068882584571838, 0.033639151602983475, -0.053987838327884674, -0.019055921584367752, 0.020533258095383644, 0.006474857684224844, 0.048948731273412704, -0.0011416299967095256, 0.043481264263391495, 0.04151155427098274, 0.0013001181650906801, 0.013069947250187397, -0.019969744607806206, 0.02014007233083248, 0.05038602650165558, -0.013367308303713799, -0.0709935799241066, -0.029582703486084938, 0.025938035920262337, -0.022448426112532616, 0.017839305102825165, -0.0492100715637207, 0.0012003647862002254, -0.028139401227235794, 0.01810128055512905, -0.006953816395252943, -0.04249219968914986, 0.023399289697408676, 0.07513073831796646, -0.035332854837179184, 0.019409624859690666, 0.036185912787914276, -0.021558592095971107, 0.030949624255299568, 0.04635569080710411, -0.019052913412451744, 0.02403121255338192, -0.026205459609627724, -0.010323154740035534, 0.04304933547973633, -0.015992512926459312, -0.029392672702670097, -0.014323940500617027, 0.02707497403025627, 0.02516869828104973, -0.0007102829986251891, -0.018686167895793915, -0.014281293377280235, 0.01282622292637825, 0.007111503276973963, -0.01658383570611477, -0.0025888916570693254, -0.04086242988705635, 0.005099339410662651, 0.011889563873410225, 0.0036207425873726606, -0.03760209679603577, -0.010566461831331253, -0.02618277072906494, 0.013849202543497086, -0.050835806876420975, -0.0723813846707344, -0.0671389251947403, 0.03738269582390785, 0.032619208097457886, -0.0379304364323616, 0.03157728537917137, -0.032671958208084106, -0.08717848360538483, 0.031043697148561478, 0.013582520186901093, -0.0175800584256649, -0.033314138650894165, 0.0008290507248602808, -0.009984162636101246, -0.050486039370298386, -0.03772040829062462, -0.017947688698768616, 0.03433363512158394, 0.004504764452576637, -0.0018661468056961894, 0.008048724383115768, -0.03305025398731232, -0.011058157309889793, -0.04640667885541916, 0.05201370269060135, -0.000021830437617609277, 0.0005265626241452992, 0.0187736377120018, 0.04322545975446701, 0.020201602950692177, 0.02360823005437851, 0.05883932113647461, 0.059845101088285446, -0.0007931094733066857, 0.028192631900310516, -0.06426525115966797, -0.02207259088754654, -0.02745891362428665, -0.0319925881922245, 0.021098129451274872, -0.0593869648873806, -0.00827376265078783, 0.03931982442736626, -0.011345879174768925, -0.046607278287410736, 0.026712577790021896, -0.0029299138113856316, -0.0010160679230466485, 0.00975755788385868, -0.014977781102061272, -0.0033291878644376993, 0.02292446233332157, 0.044053785502910614, -0.041416507214307785, 0.010315687395632267, 0.02298111654818058, -0.03645104542374611, 0.009226369671523571, 0.003059323178604245, -0.009164697490632534, -0.00837739184498787, -0.013277124613523483, 0.004100921098142862, -0.004465869627892971, 0.06409889459609985, 0.028888989239931107, 0.04326242208480835, 0.04492427781224251, 0.06217769905924797, -0.024228539317846298, -0.021758731454610825, -0.003485325491055846, 0.007226590067148209, -0.016508260741829872, 0.029370339587330818, -0.01909446157515049, 0.00848561991006136, 0.014595079235732555, 0.046400513499975204, -0.0016957186162471771, -0.01413697935640812, 0.01414355356246233, -0.039506688714027405, -0.024959104135632515, 0.012923234142363071, -0.032174911350011826, -0.040249984711408615, -0.022942442446947098, 0.025616195052862167, -0.004835785832256079, 0.040642719715833664, -0.008458269760012627, 0.04719637334346771, -0.06565503776073456, 0.04058900848031044, 0.06513848900794983, -0.030375713482499123, 0.0013104118406772614, -0.01957150176167488, 0.01971818506717682, -0.03360815346240997, -0.01617640070617199, 0.0007988451397977769, -0.008020523004233837, 0.04340599477291107, -0.020277325063943863, -0.05308281630277634, -0.011085052974522114, -0.010570770129561424, -0.004850694909691811, 0.0009415433160029352, -0.04080527275800705, -0.0453566238284111, 0.0585014671087265, 0.04455239325761795, -0.019621793180704117, -0.010279053822159767, 0.015118861570954323, 0.10325253754854202, -0.004167728126049042, -0.005873003043234348, -0.009956893511116505, -0.035232312977313995, 0.02433726377785206, -0.01675679162144661, -0.023410942405462265, -0.07662556320428848, -0.05786283314228058, -0.027118423953652382, -0.060769494622945786, -0.01082064863294363, 0.035763029009103775, -0.009261641651391983, 0.007450780365616083, -0.015821751207113266, 0.00499706482514739, -0.043773751705884933, -0.007766967173665762, 0.015997031703591347, -0.08307020366191864, 0.010293062776327133, 0.00328241684474051, -0.030432969331741333, 0.023920813575387, -0.007449623662978411, -0.04270590841770172, -0.06211840733885765, 0.02092416025698185, 0.008155307732522488, -0.038854245096445084, -0.0256760586053133, -0.015938421711325645, 0.014768640510737896, 0.004824085161089897, 0.005027937237173319, 0.0001221517741214484, 0.013910304754972458, -0.024084266275167465, -0.005052265245467424, 0.06831832230091095, -0.020224271342158318, -0.019755028188228607, -0.010254589840769768, -0.006644423585385084, -0.007441360969096422, -0.022690095007419586, 0.03260289877653122, 0.06867682933807373, 0.004634734708815813, -0.005690392106771469, -0.042763128876686096, 0.010871021077036858, -0.02481161244213581, -0.021022384986281395, -0.0058242566883563995, -0.038842130452394485, -0.03728172183036804, 0.006618418265134096, 0.00729378592222929, 0.05080341175198555, -0.012746559455990791, -0.011974225752055645, 0.006338058039546013, 0.033460039645433426, 0.044494401663541794, 0.020368441939353943, -0.08471526950597763, -0.000034896376746473834, 0.05557966232299805, -0.006042653229087591, -0.022722408175468445, -0.08613365143537521, -0.016172397881746292, 0.009470896795392036, -0.008950455114245415, 0.00214948202483356, -0.026317760348320007, 0.022362269461154938, 0.02533327043056488, 0.00788981094956398, 0.0004931017756462097, 0.0076048290356993675, 0.04090588539838791, -0.040784936398267746, -0.02984096296131611, -0.053425755351781845, -0.004982024431228638, 0.055585090070962906, -0.06477127224206924, -0.004737015813589096, -0.00515973474830389, -0.000019557428458938375, 0.039372529834508896, -0.03628871589899063, -0.06879191100597382, 0.0034679872915148735, -0.011538981460034847, -0.021643590182065964, 0.03533697500824928, -0.028416544198989868, 0.0000426358419645112, 0.0057538836263120174, -0.05709996819496155, -0.032193973660469055, 0.024943731725215912, 0.02627427689731121, -0.04086541384458542, -0.02539134956896305, 0.007616179529577494, 0.007059468887746334, 0.019044728949666023, 0.07872484624385834, 0.04316495358943939, 0.029389742761850357, -0.04150194302201271, 0.06458345055580139, 0.06020316481590271, 0.008412234485149384, 0.02942127175629139, 0.01180585753172636, -0.010690570808947086, -0.07256292551755905, 0.02622321806848049, 0.0017681439640000463, 0.0007463513175025582, -0.05577584356069565, 0.026792626827955246, 0.050207916647195816, -0.01997619867324829, -0.04759977385401726, 0.03173219412565231, -0.01045829989016056, 0.030972225591540337, -0.019717834889888763, 0.004575165919959545, 0.03295087814331055, 0.06745480746030807, -0.014599771238863468, 0.024545475840568542, 0.04373057559132576, 0.02937379851937294, 0.010481352917850018, -0.004738139919936657, 0.05433213710784912, 0.055137068033218384, 0.053547583520412445, 0.02118079550564289, 0.0688428059220314, -0.0345408134162426, -0.04604897275567055, 0.04305205121636391, 0.025028696283698082, -0.01106831431388855, -0.057038433849811554, -0.02029990218579769, 0.11381982266902924, -0.0048242961056530476, 0.04425889626145363, -0.045928385108709335, 0.014227564446628094, 0.027952399104833603, 0.024568188935518265, -0.0035776859149336815, 0.016997292637825012, 0.013304159976541996, -0.01607379876077175, -0.024010634049773216, -0.00499281520023942, -0.01778099127113819, -0.0304391011595726, 0.04758083075284958, 0.02246762439608574, -0.015899211168289185, 0.009352236054837704, -0.004032250493764877, -0.0029496995266526937, 0.09219521284103394, -0.0384749174118042, -0.03182630240917206, 0.016296524554491043, 0.018375596031546593, -0.0005817581550218165, 0.04125070199370384, 0.0019713316578418016, -0.02462783083319664, -0.02304394170641899, -0.02517707273364067, 0.03342988342046738, 0.022160282358527184, 0.015651360154151917, 0.02877776324748993, -0.017957745119929314, -0.0012078392319381237, 0.03505472466349602, 0.006797293666750193, -0.012756312265992165, -0.0588306300342083, -0.02704688161611557, -0.03209828585386276, -0.05866960436105728, -0.028172021731734276, 0.05063442513346672, 0.03546135500073433, -0.03673974424600601, 0.02387278340756893, -0.05019347369670868, 0.022219941020011902, 0.02015995793044567, -0.0842457190155983, -0.0016685571754351258, 0.061857886612415314, -0.014915741980075836, -0.043641623109579086, 0.02720126137137413, 0.004104690160602331, 0.01168147660791874, -0.008610532619059086, 0.051781266927719116, -0.007450147997587919, 0.016471993178129196, -0.027432631701231003, -0.013289359398186207, -0.08067943900823593, -0.010051625780761242, 0.03360944986343384, -0.05192632973194122, -0.08280704915523529, 0.048619549721479416, -0.03158143535256386, 0.02537275291979313, 0.03499496728181839, -0.009803280234336853, 0.007202859502285719, -0.017234347760677338, -0.029600413516163826, -0.00008672383410157636, 0.012622111476957798, 0.031281713396310806, -0.023412730544805527, 0.0713639035820961, 0.04566996544599533, -0.017269549891352654, -0.021454893052577972, 0.030075574293732643, -0.0027723864186555147, 0.02235732041299343, -0.03915178403258324, 0.019900957122445107, -0.03655216842889786, -0.10744811594486237, -0.04047732800245285, -0.0021138351876288652, -0.036997709423303604, -0.02202051319181919, 0.029843389987945557, -0.030522193759679794, 0.008132854476571083, 0.030110685154795647, -0.029878444969654083, -0.029288802295923233, -0.02913985401391983, -0.025644276291131973, -0.037141576409339905, -0.005451512988656759, 0.025645287707448006, -0.017795970663428307, -0.029634496197104454, -0.05069933086633682, -0.01672755740582943, 0.002823979128152132, 0.061449144035577774, 0.0004144148842897266, 0.02286706492304802, -0.011505083180963993 ]
3,589
Multi-modal Agent Tuning: Building a VLM-Driven Agent for Efficient Tool Usage
https://openreview.net/forum?id=0bmGL4q7vJ
[ "Zhi Gao", "Bofei Zhang", "Pengxiang Li", "Xiaojian Ma", "Tao Yuan", "Yue Fan", "Yuwei Wu", "Yunde Jia", "Song-Chun Zhu", "Qing Li" ]
Spotlight
The advancement of large language models (LLMs) prompts the development of multi-modal agents, which are used as a controller to call external tools, providing a feasible way to solve practical tasks. In this paper, we propose a multi-modal agent tuning method that automatically generates multi-modal tool-usage data and tunes a vision-language model (VLM) as the controller for powerful tool-usage reasoning. To preserve the data quality, we prompt the GPT-4o mini model to generate queries, files, and trajectories, followed by query-file and trajectory verifiers. Based on the data synthesis pipeline, we collect the MM-Traj dataset that contains 20K tasks with trajectories of tool usage. Then, we develop the T3-Agent via Trajectory Tuning on VLMs for Tool usage using MM-Traj. Evaluations on the GTA and GAIA benchmarks show that the T3-Agent consistently achieves improvements on two popular VLMs: MiniCPM-V-8.5B and Qwen2-VL-7B, which outperforms untrained VLMs by 20%, showing the effectiveness of the proposed data synthesis pipeline, leading to high-quality data for tool-usage capabilities.
Multimodal Agents, Vision-language Model, Tool usage
null
4,107
2412.15606
[ -0.004435418639332056, -0.028288468718528748, 0.027666883543133736, 0.041599974036216736, 0.035750612616539, 0.01243753544986248, 0.032484058290719986, 0.02146807685494423, -0.02624753676354885, -0.03034987859427929, -0.03383500128984451, 0.06887681037187576, -0.08265882730484009, 0.003164909780025482, 0.01280889380723238, 0.048071492463350296, 0.019839398562908173, -0.0035231669899076223, 0.017764737829566002, 0.002955214586108923, -0.007052219472825527, -0.01989666558802128, 0.06756646186113358, 0.010853473097085953, 0.03360207751393318, 0.013392987661063671, 0.02035885863006115, 0.02066611871123314, -0.039480485022068024, -0.004252451006323099, 0.011182575486600399, -0.03822857514023781, 0.02408158965408802, -0.021525664255023003, -0.006223658099770546, -0.01428200863301754, -0.05567869544029236, 0.01813366636633873, -0.0052688224241137505, 0.013661885634064674, -0.03574936091899872, 0.04341529682278633, -0.002737561007961631, -0.008538649417459965, -0.017445430159568787, 0.0040176683105528355, -0.08385691046714783, 0.03676942363381386, 0.044117119163274765, -0.04896847531199455, -0.1034032553434372, 0.016205204650759697, -0.009814872406423092, 0.008198904804885387, 0.007490128744393587, 0.013090728782117367, 0.05686158314347267, -0.10303106904029846, -0.014197338372468948, -0.04117880389094353, -0.04156503081321716, 0.004748922307044268, 0.051446445286273956, -0.00032372568966820836, -0.00925865862518549, -0.0018562619807198644, 0.010724161751568317, 0.03411536291241646, -0.03261629492044449, -0.027883075177669525, -0.01022468600422144, -0.006929566152393818, -0.019702240824699402, -0.006395413540303707, -0.0010846717050299048, -0.038468122482299805, 0.028993064537644386, 0.019042009487748146, 0.03518650308251381, 0.004641409497708082, -0.023436395451426506, 0.019825825467705727, 0.006993981543928385, 0.035533104091882706, 0.01266258955001831, 0.0063849566504359245, -0.03129707649350166, -0.014487584121525288, -0.059430401772260666, 0.02196257747709751, 0.0031717796809971333, -0.06176121160387993, -0.0004586752620525658, 0.03331994637846947, 0.028732579201459885, 0.03433411940932274, 0.019697027280926704, 0.01059593167155981, 0.00486028054729104, 0.015149193815886974, -0.011594267562031746, -0.01611536741256714, 0.01256293710321188, 0.012461433187127113, -0.10461407154798508, -0.02683035284280777, -0.0418226383626461, -0.014802126213908195, -0.005896080285310745, 0.003313635475933552, -0.03783343732357025, -0.029177475720643997, 0.01500116940587759, -0.01798412576317787, -0.0807778611779213, 0.05442241579294205, 0.0125195924192667, 0.03078330121934414, 0.02514156512916088, 0.029343729838728905, 0.08960425108671188, 0.0633847713470459, -0.0017404373502358794, 0.062364161014556885, -0.05831445753574371, 0.0006163023645058274, 0.03709041699767113, 0.012208297848701477, -0.015543949790298939, -0.03441036865115166, 0.05259081348776817, 0.03399743139743805, 0.011226441711187363, -0.005777634680271149, -0.011072168126702309, 0.004507430363446474, 0.02249167673289776, 0.02058320678770542, 0.04746688902378082, -0.021859513595700264, 0.013212713412940502, -0.012348574586212635, 0.04490143805742264, -0.036988433450460434, 0.08335814625024796, 0.01929490640759468, -0.029333245009183884, -0.04750632122159004, -0.06646493077278137, -0.021261224523186684, 0.014320103451609612, 0.02149992622435093, 0.0021925196051597595, -0.0622258260846138, 0.021496856585144997, 0.06867017596960068, 0.02158666029572487, 0.011030646041035652, 0.02286405861377716, 0.000671189627610147, 0.010610287077724934, 0.005204984452575445, -0.016897784546017647, 0.025936955586075783, -0.01810377649962902, -0.026485836133360863, 0.016095826402306557, 0.01755911484360695, -0.0006941446918062866, 0.010989490896463394, -0.05467460677027702, -0.02719402313232422, 0.025240963324904442, -0.003565565450116992, -0.021002277731895447, -0.0075655230320990086, 0.06212601438164711, -0.023058682680130005, 0.019820069894194603, 0.019840070977807045, -0.07862722128629684, 0.026374854147434235, -0.007843774743378162, -0.011403653770685196, 0.027753690257668495, -0.0022703632712364197, 0.08649598807096481, -0.02465309202671051, -0.02901342883706093, 0.00034470297396183014, -0.07569775730371475, -0.021336855366826057, 0.05508485436439514, 0.007061096373945475, 0.04963368922472, -0.006294270046055317, -0.016941986978054047, 0.041244134306907654, 0.04225931689143181, 0.07974258065223694, 0.040694255381822586, -0.019144808873534203, 0.03742015361785889, -0.02361304871737957, -0.006989256478846073, -0.012216083705425262, 0.03491507098078728, -0.038815323263406754, -0.04461689293384552, 0.060511939227581024, -0.03393072262406349, 0.012800480239093304, 0.007050849962979555, -0.009229226037859917, 0.04846438765525818, -0.00492418697103858, -0.02865440770983696, -0.011247561313211918, -0.033184975385665894, -0.03747905418276787, 0.0329277366399765, 0.03292550891637802, -0.060711897909641266, -0.005835681222379208, -0.04725750908255577, 0.08680856227874756, 0.06370681524276733, -0.04324231669306755, -0.01634846441447735, 0.014818070456385612, 0.03166965767741203, 0.02234947495162487, 0.022385239601135254, -0.049554336816072464, 0.00940354261547327, -0.04927632957696915, 0.009962676092982292, -0.010930386371910572, 0.01712917722761631, -0.05067478492856026, -0.010618996806442738, 0.04057500511407852, -0.006847949232906103, 0.06315676867961884, 0.015271053649485111, 0.023819752037525177, 0.042516451328992844, -0.0022099290508776903, -0.003762796288356185, -0.009174162521958351, -0.014998848550021648, 0.005427650175988674, 0.006481105461716652, -0.018734687939286232, -0.02635975368320942, -0.05491546913981438, 0.003933403640985489, -0.0189005509018898, 0.05634045973420143, 0.06802426278591156, 0.028793485835194588, 0.028377873823046684, 0.01685228757560253, -0.026091882959008217, 0.012796777300536633, -0.11525527387857437, -0.03971974924206734, -0.014460436068475246, 0.025192100554704666, 0.022565286606550217, 0.0252483319491148, -0.005220687948167324, 0.029059328138828278, -0.025419073179364204, 0.0022994987666606903, 0.02599846012890339, 0.014536199159920216, 0.026120662689208984, -0.01955878548324108, -0.036261919885873795, 0.0008795459871180356, 0.05881653353571892, -0.01987914741039276, -0.00008822006202535704, -0.044398244470357895, -0.019953284412622452, -0.0026511342730373144, -0.053777582943439484, -0.0030392573680728674, -0.0070962258614599705, 0.003382651833817363, -0.010234935209155083, -0.01639476977288723, 0.024296609684824944, 0.013628611341118813, 0.042072467505931854, 0.023208580911159515, -0.0012180868070572615, -0.04063837602734566, 0.012520295567810535, -0.019737649708986282, 0.015742378309369087, 0.003546189982444048, -0.00812947005033493, -0.013506469316780567, -0.012825624085962772, -0.015950974076986313, 0.008346009068191051, -0.2945241928100586, -0.032922301441431046, -0.009124689735472202, -0.008001659065485, 0.028897393494844437, 0.02016613259911537, 0.07494956254959106, -0.03456021845340729, -0.011478661559522152, -0.01540305558592081, 0.03265591710805893, 0.03157174587249756, 0.01920246332883835, 0.05925149843096733, 0.06176876649260521, 0.05570041388273239, -0.026441950350999832, -0.04054347425699234, 0.03413357213139534, 0.014272828586399555, -0.015665072947740555, -0.06693368405103683, -0.01972222700715065, 0.019680358469486237, 0.010601027868688107, 0.04870083928108215, -0.08262608200311661, -0.029015658423304558, -0.006559186615049839, -0.019702695310115814, -0.012918164022266865, -0.018450532108545303, -0.052515190094709396, 0.023641545325517654, 0.014388073235750198, -0.01833929680287838, 0.06551279872655869, -0.0028033670969307423, 0.08152181655168533, -0.009687615558505058, 0.006969125475734472, 0.0052451686933636665, -0.0437624566257, 0.014326300472021103, 0.06440147012472153, 0.034169793128967285, -0.08529302477836609, 0.01017959788441658, 0.014212592504918575, 0.036209963262081146, 0.00067881029099226, -0.02935979701578617, -0.015501375310122967, 0.019280172884464264, 0.03200281783938408, -0.031569138169288635, 0.023996228352189064, -0.009310304187238216, -0.00578125286847353, 0.010076592676341534, -0.003199621569365263, -0.0362076498568058, -0.02709590084850788, -0.030963541939854622, -0.023263927549123764, -0.004074347671121359, -0.05398388206958771, -0.07715658843517303, 0.02946031093597412, 0.012108974158763885, -0.014516400173306465, -0.014379613101482391, -0.00896106194704771, -0.1030542179942131, 0.016011886298656464, 0.014186330139636993, -0.0009633906302042305, -0.019745100289583206, 0.002106400905176997, 0.051302630454301834, -0.035890139639377594, -0.04990305006504059, -0.008281777612864971, -0.008132596500217915, 0.03811652213335037, -0.028825387358665466, 0.008335421793162823, -0.059847086668014526, -0.017335930839180946, -0.029146650806069374, 0.04120033606886864, -0.025083180516958237, 0.016345977783203125, 0.02239641733467579, 0.05656905844807625, 0.003727250499650836, 0.03180854022502899, 0.042901258915662766, 0.020113922655582428, 0.024836711585521698, 0.03228248283267021, -0.08373669534921646, 0.000955846393480897, -0.006367566995322704, -0.022548019886016846, 0.024334706366062164, -0.03906787559390068, -0.02124372124671936, 0.0365532785654068, 0.029785849153995514, 0.012892644852399826, -0.00426556495949626, 0.022124797105789185, 0.004632195923477411, -0.006908989977091551, 0.011663015931844711, 0.008474485017359257, 0.02310515008866787, 0.05613362044095993, -0.03137625381350517, -0.05789368972182274, 0.008514630608260632, -0.04313630238175392, 0.018315060064196587, -0.0058191935531795025, 0.003624064614996314, -0.020522601902484894, 0.0006494623376056552, 0.007493640761822462, 0.0069426377303898335, -0.0017849201103672385, 0.031455148011446, -0.002108838176354766, 0.009296931326389313, 0.04203053191304207, -0.022156139835715294, -0.018061010167002678, -0.012974397279322147, 0.03774864599108696, -0.00754248071461916, -0.019240697845816612, -0.01234412007033825, 0.029956437647342682, 0.03836910426616669, 0.03341422230005264, 0.009131480008363724, 0.03346031904220581, 0.007202938199043274, 0.02445109561085701, 0.0026600786950439215, 0.06134900450706482, -0.046353813260793686, 0.005006012972444296, -0.03801340237259865, 0.012926552444696426, -0.060562994331121445, 0.03160209208726883, -0.034071214497089386, 0.02393738180398941, -0.03874468058347702, 0.030818723142147064, -0.008345901034772396, -0.017079681158065796, 0.012360408902168274, 0.004103814251720905, 0.03987133502960205, -0.010739466175436974, -0.0037116780877113342, -0.0008218287257477641, -0.0017464184202253819, 0.012687107548117638, -0.028370626270771027, -0.028463657945394516, -0.019101416692137718, -0.015941308811306953, -0.00818690937012434, -0.011829093098640442, -0.009034814313054085, -0.03741195425391197, 0.04742395505309105, 0.0013216292718425393, -0.015332081355154514, -0.030303673818707466, -0.02122502587735653, 0.07194186747074127, -0.013883416540920734, 0.02168305218219757, -0.0017936357762664557, -0.00041839483310468495, 0.005219714716076851, 0.004042157903313637, 0.08674294501543045, -0.027763403952121735, -0.04687391594052315, -0.04289374127984047, -0.06141063943505287, 0.03464658558368683, 0.03546968847513199, -0.004693374037742615, -0.007288394961506128, 0.01321058627218008, 0.00719007384032011, -0.050649721175432205, -0.01237296499311924, 0.025225531309843063, -0.06463267654180527, -0.008209509775042534, 0.03238672390580177, -0.008615324273705482, 0.022633910179138184, -0.045974984765052795, -0.03438746556639671, -0.030576296150684357, 0.015511472709476948, -0.01537343766540289, -0.046915438026189804, -0.01574382185935974, -0.02198040671646595, 0.0055302223190665245, -0.002895571291446686, -0.00807739794254303, 0.010662469081580639, -0.013376587070524693, -0.005558001808822155, -0.018805140629410744, 0.045033153146505356, -0.03741912916302681, -0.014244536869227886, -0.002501983195543289, -0.012679177336394787, 0.03634526580572128, -0.054434701800346375, 0.01124510820955038, 0.04234236106276512, 0.003226526314392686, 0.024648619815707207, -0.06131810322403908, 0.03258424997329712, 0.004181930795311928, -0.039312634617090225, -0.008020581677556038, 0.010669625364243984, -0.03331518918275833, -0.01114634145051241, 0.010516887530684471, 0.04428316652774811, -0.021145202219486237, -0.009313615970313549, -0.0010164529085159302, 0.006101528182625771, -0.003241522703319788, 0.020291006192564964, -0.03800687566399574, 0.003552864072844386, 0.048581842333078384, -0.05511409789323807, -0.010295961983501911, -0.03718947991728783, -0.04778454452753067, 0.0000086630179794156, -0.0005797836929559708, 0.01872018724679947, -0.05480758845806122, 0.04050791263580322, 0.01198712270706892, 0.03882806748151779, 0.009491928853094578, -0.03225967660546303, 0.03437036648392677, -0.07309500873088837, 0.04261916130781174, -0.08236418664455414, -0.01874331757426262, 0.0540948361158371, -0.024578705430030823, -0.030059408396482468, 0.0136609161272645, -0.03769802674651146, 0.04490666091442108, -0.018235523253679276, -0.060409802943468094, 0.018888989463448524, -0.009637194685637951, -0.027018830180168152, 0.02791064977645874, -0.05011650174856186, -0.011207424104213715, -0.015443723648786545, -0.021869828924536705, 0.021728970110416412, -0.00017028108413796872, 0.048743344843387604, -0.035063497722148895, 0.04909330606460571, -0.06441336125135422, -0.002684926148504019, 0.03198942169547081, 0.03752797096967697, -0.012509739026427269, 0.0414838008582592, 0.0025496655143797398, 0.07263806462287903, 0.04721716791391373, 0.001963966991752386, 0.020529834553599358, -0.012991100549697876, -0.010272260755300522, -0.008799412287771702, 0.06535761803388596, 0.014019699767231941, -0.03628527745604515, -0.06423109769821167, 0.07118429243564606, 0.04495411366224289, -0.04699193313717842, -0.02313273213803768, 0.04700741916894913, -0.0470145046710968, -0.01838717795908451, -0.0259854756295681, 0.02461382932960987, 0.02236170321702957, 0.06244772672653198, -0.0037620053626596928, 0.05367878079414368, 0.06441232562065125, 0.02209770679473877, -0.012205498293042183, 0.007890891283750534, 0.04063759744167328, 0.06447344273328781, 0.05649571865797043, 0.005688195116817951, 0.07374563068151474, -0.04245816543698311, -0.03757455199956894, 0.028767354786396027, 0.046733368188142776, -0.03099505417048931, -0.013417139649391174, 0.022693749517202377, 0.08283583074808121, -0.01066727563738823, 0.0688629075884819, -0.03394290804862976, -0.03170182555913925, 0.0492958128452301, -0.008353319019079208, 0.006316910497844219, 0.03249865025281906, 0.04503755271434784, 0.03256238251924515, -0.028458232060074806, 0.005411879625171423, 0.003295465838164091, -0.05921093374490738, -0.004751197528094053, 0.007236468140035868, -0.01964135468006134, 0.008996982127428055, -0.023831747472286224, 0.049517981708049774, 0.1283133625984192, -0.04872104898095131, -0.010310123674571514, 0.009780358523130417, 0.0016462133498862386, -0.0013384170597419143, 0.039580199867486954, -0.015838857740163803, -0.000867782044224441, 0.04164521023631096, -0.054978303611278534, 0.01746039092540741, 0.020298855379223824, -0.011239685118198395, 0.025748012587428093, -0.04544752091169357, -0.017846694216132164, -0.007819075137376785, 0.013365710154175758, -0.03141403570771217, -0.04126512631773949, -0.047483425587415695, -0.04641342535614967, -0.04549067094922066, -0.02276213839650154, 0.018300345167517662, 0.007583015598356724, -0.03604652360081673, 0.012623502872884274, -0.014221741817891598, -0.010512827895581722, 0.002507413737475872, -0.08376173675060272, 0.011307514272630215, 0.02793191187083721, -0.012861517257988453, -0.008821194060146809, 0.03480777144432068, 0.038737133145332336, 0.0166248120367527, -0.00677560456097126, -0.007057933136820793, 0.02141651324927807, 0.01879037730395794, -0.014613913372159004, 0.0018440121784806252, -0.10301128029823303, 0.009198905900120735, -0.00015984968922566622, -0.021270927041769028, -0.0954635813832283, -0.007647608872503042, -0.022266486659646034, 0.042337026447057724, 0.07673794031143188, -0.00027630620752461255, 0.04041023179888725, -0.02123350463807583, 0.0022586039267480373, 0.007351709995418787, -0.003299446776509285, 0.03807850182056427, -0.03310246393084526, 0.05114398151636124, 0.007295405026525259, -0.04193795099854469, -0.03975424915552139, 0.048894792795181274, 0.014969764277338982, -0.020000888034701347, -0.02510008215904236, -0.0529569648206234, -0.018695365637540817, -0.09564028680324554, -0.02640043944120407, 0.040014609694480896, 0.01986972987651825, -0.009350684471428394, -0.014383465051651001, -0.018799766898155212, -0.03266995772719383, -0.020580949261784554, -0.02991965413093567, -0.024656113237142563, -0.030464088544249535, -0.0477241650223732, -0.0721677839756012, 0.03203132376074791, -0.017887545749545097, -0.01782187819480896, -0.029952676966786385, -0.03470471128821373, 0.001971862744539976, -0.024387584999203682, 0.026845058426260948, 0.010623898357152939, 0.048240236937999725, -0.001221147133037448 ]
3,590
Monitoring Latent World States in Language Models with Propositional Probes
https://openreview.net/forum?id=0yvZm2AjUr
[ "Jiahai Feng", "Stuart Russell", "Jacob Steinhardt" ]
Spotlight
Language models (LMs) are susceptible to bias, sycophancy, backdoors, and other tendencies that lead to unfaithful responses to the input context. Interpreting internal states of LMs could help monitor and correct unfaithful behavior. We hypothesize that LMs faithfully represent their input contexts in a latent world model, and we seek to extract these latent world states as logical propositions. For example, given the input context ``Greg is a nurse. Laura is a physicist.'', we aim to decode the propositions WorksAs(Greg, nurse) and WorksAs(Laura, physicist) from the model's internal activations. To do so we introduce _propositional probes_, which compositionally extract lexical concepts from token activations and bind them into propositions. Key to this is identifying a _binding subspace_ in which bound tokens have high similarity (Greg $\leftrightarrow$ nurse) but unbound ones do not (Greg $\not\leftrightarrow$ physicist). Despite only being trained on linguistically simple English templates, we find that propositional probes generalize to inputs written as short stories and translated to Spanish. Moreover, in three settings where LMs respond unfaithfully to the input context---prompt injections, backdoor attacks, and gender bias--- the decoded propositions remain faithful. This suggests that LMs often encode a faithful world model but decode it unfaithfully, which motivates the search for better interpretability tools for monitoring LMs.
Interpretability, Language models, AI Safety
We develop propositional probes, which extract logical propositions describing a language model's internal world state
4,104
2406.19501
[ -0.026642652228474617, -0.007864447310566902, -0.0318555124104023, 0.043744951486587524, 0.041885364800691605, 0.028433332219719887, 0.03155149146914482, 0.02287142537534237, -0.013459913432598114, 0.004328147973865271, -0.034926638007164, 0.027104277163743973, -0.038661081343889236, -0.004658762365579605, -0.0021854655351489782, 0.046720314770936966, 0.02380940690636635, -0.009527224116027355, 0.02462606690824032, -0.012829435989260674, 0.014452089555561543, 0.0009683867683634162, 0.04227840527892113, 0.004883051849901676, 0.03693545237183571, 0.021887673065066338, 0.032207001000642776, -0.010257725603878498, -0.030861129984259605, -0.0011910725152119994, 0.018013183027505875, 0.008911661803722382, 0.005818839650601149, 0.004893028177320957, -0.009389031678438187, 0.014655529521405697, -0.039479464292526245, 0.05098535865545273, 0.006666266359388828, 0.018427133560180664, -0.05550298094749451, 0.014555486850440502, -0.002124438062310219, -0.004435444716364145, -0.06906655430793762, -0.007026286795735359, -0.12712931632995605, 0.04618457332253456, 0.019203804433345795, -0.025820303708314896, -0.10866168141365051, 0.05020001903176308, 0.02466880902647972, 0.001623545540496707, 0.01513195876032114, 0.02829197235405445, 0.05464906990528107, -0.10399244725704193, 0.004628159571439028, -0.04269854724407196, -0.06423097103834152, 0.010937347076833248, 0.0010944162495434284, -0.0012735138880088925, 0.008658095262944698, -0.006855877581983805, 0.011954237706959248, 0.03202108293771744, -0.04687567427754402, -0.023128435015678406, -0.030512457713484764, 0.009702783077955246, -0.02099892497062683, 0.005179641768336296, 0.032883960753679276, -0.026988057419657707, 0.02320180833339691, 0.04030856490135193, 0.03449495509266853, -0.004212595522403717, -0.01536669209599495, 0.036008432507514954, 0.03693939745426178, 0.04486849531531334, 0.026650747284293175, -0.02774566225707531, -0.026166245341300964, -0.022847356274724007, -0.06803250312805176, 0.02177167497575283, -0.00285576400347054, -0.05578231066465378, 0.008143381215631962, 0.02335403487086296, 0.014608724974095821, 0.020416850224137306, 0.03625229373574257, 0.021546555683016777, -0.003749223193153739, -0.005564595572650433, -0.043220505118370056, -0.03183215111494064, 0.013038378208875656, 0.014204424805939198, -0.10068393498659134, -0.03586426004767418, -0.017576374113559723, -0.018222806975245476, -0.028063125908374786, 0.011180690489709377, -0.03396649658679962, -0.015480534173548222, 0.030569300055503845, -0.01445593498647213, -0.065088652074337, 0.04834195598959923, 0.011318155564367771, 0.02343268133699894, -0.0014466751599684358, 0.03319655731320381, 0.04839552193880081, 0.021757807582616806, 0.02286871336400509, 0.06233685091137886, -0.01908627524971962, -0.007234563585370779, -0.01611177809536457, 0.035174574702978134, -0.018360737711191177, -0.05066586285829544, 0.015530024655163288, 0.05451861396431923, 0.01852981373667717, 0.012795032002031803, 0.014387249946594238, -0.00289363507181406, 0.017590314149856567, 0.00831738580018282, 0.043930016458034515, 0.034129273146390915, 0.02231203205883503, 0.005312067922204733, 0.056884944438934326, -0.0059770154766738415, 0.07211509346961975, 0.0019068099791184068, -0.02967618592083454, -0.007944218814373016, -0.03862488642334938, 0.007276476360857487, 0.014635662548244, -0.013764148578047752, 0.005583440884947777, -0.04166286811232567, 0.03749917447566986, 0.053282883018255234, 0.01860041357576847, 0.027917873114347458, -0.005528051406145096, 0.0013340041041374207, 0.015154443681240082, 0.009018201380968094, -0.06136665865778923, 0.01047507580369711, 0.031051406636834145, -0.06567831337451935, 0.027206607162952423, -0.016653787344694138, -0.04223988205194473, 0.016090039163827896, -0.02090292237699032, -0.02848867140710354, 0.05889131873846054, -0.05106627941131592, -0.03562808781862259, 0.0010248525068163872, 0.05868663266301155, 0.005358704831451178, 0.04418838396668434, 0.03660881891846657, -0.07255733013153076, 0.010852927342057228, -0.030496781691908836, -0.00030769468867219985, 0.0259200818836689, -0.023534702137112617, 0.04397306963801384, -0.03813827037811279, -0.012873941101133823, 0.011802966706454754, -0.07361100614070892, -0.006757606286555529, 0.036590736359357834, 0.012247420847415924, 0.07615544646978378, -0.029132260009646416, 0.004495534114539623, 0.07204416394233704, 0.026134885847568512, 0.04327341914176941, 0.054623767733573914, -0.010899649932980537, 0.025562290102243423, 0.016594044864177704, -0.008849416859447956, 0.006099766120314598, 0.04164749011397362, -0.05085962638258934, -0.04447464272379875, 0.04560435935854912, -0.029404543340206146, -0.006393949501216412, 0.03912581130862236, -0.02609380893409252, 0.007983298972249031, -0.007185586728155613, -0.019862137734889984, 0.012030314654111862, 0.020969141274690628, -0.03129247575998306, 0.058510083705186844, 0.0007181441178545356, -0.004924878012388945, -0.041745252907276154, -0.03302989900112152, 0.10793076455593109, 0.0707460567355156, -0.032162368297576904, -0.017544370144605637, 0.029278552159667015, 0.00665265042334795, 0.005767263006418943, 0.02467438392341137, -0.02632485330104828, 0.026294371113181114, -0.0010685689048841596, 0.003008142812177539, -0.050041601061820984, 0.05334977060556412, -0.04130260646343231, -0.007629843428730965, 0.07987212389707565, -0.03725363686680794, 0.06486261636018753, -0.035497210919857025, 0.03405454382300377, 0.04295487329363823, -0.02338077872991562, -0.03890825808048248, -0.00869763270020485, -0.03982064872980118, -0.00920204445719719, -0.002529544522985816, -0.023082682862877846, 0.004039482679218054, -0.03233294561505318, -0.03470466658473015, -0.01633111573755741, 0.08309339731931686, 0.048859093338251114, 0.006170781794935465, 0.021183745935559273, -0.016539042815566063, -0.04711439460515976, 0.013276426121592522, -0.0941840186715126, -0.017602350562810898, -0.005959039553999901, 0.0021186203230172396, -0.015739401802420616, 0.022973008453845978, -0.018915889784693718, 0.015129993669688702, 0.0009362450800836086, 0.017745014280080795, 0.010514818131923676, 0.024964120239019394, -0.0035132099874317646, -0.029322639107704163, 0.001053141662850976, -0.009403334930539131, 0.050672296434640884, -0.016136955469846725, -0.020841684192419052, -0.011879712343215942, -0.07967890053987503, -0.012869622558355331, -0.04663803055882454, 0.001117156120017171, 0.016643552109599113, 0.01776265539228916, -0.02109706588089466, -0.011149877682328224, 0.003981906455010176, 0.04264834150671959, 0.051146574318408966, 0.03983677551150322, 0.02096252515912056, -0.010211719200015068, 0.02802937850356102, -0.027217498049139977, 0.026433438062667847, 0.004884898662567139, 0.033813778311014175, -0.009997318498790264, -0.009353459812700748, 0.03122738003730774, -0.009157650172710419, -0.293384313583374, -0.006802970077842474, 0.00512169161811471, -0.04877648130059242, 0.017240848392248154, 0.0152628468349576, 0.06170882657170296, -0.036749400198459625, -0.03430132195353508, 0.003317367285490036, 0.01579361781477928, 0.009978686459362507, 0.015561970882117748, 0.04239274933934212, 0.04023256152868271, -0.0001247360632987693, -0.00721399812027812, -0.033750977367162704, 0.011471683159470558, 0.03559939190745354, -0.006534676533192396, -0.03958665952086449, -0.025109881535172462, 0.05932106450200081, 0.031001802533864975, 0.054024308919906616, -0.07681208103895187, 0.004163082223385572, -0.03281843289732933, 0.0076806312426924706, -0.035286661237478256, -0.01899649202823639, -0.013978475704789162, 0.00781373679637909, -0.013639668002724648, -0.0035028059501200914, 0.0341169647872448, -0.0003704143164213747, 0.016844050958752632, 0.02978168986737728, -0.0005179319996386766, -0.011493189260363579, -0.008397409692406654, 0.011251701042056084, 0.057328563183546066, 0.0037841207813471556, -0.05823420733213425, -0.03100196085870266, -0.008947017602622509, 0.01633993163704872, -0.015871137380599976, -0.025668352842330933, -0.012270433828234673, -0.02476712130010128, 0.000673866830766201, -0.007778069470077753, 0.0010087420232594013, -0.0390157476067543, -0.05204036459326744, -0.0334673635661602, 0.022658605128526688, -0.027007071301341057, -0.004907046444714069, -0.04182470589876175, -0.028321700170636177, -0.03561558946967125, -0.0678257867693901, -0.049482185393571854, 0.0525442473590374, 0.034805815666913986, -0.03209828957915306, 0.011813458055257797, -0.010151981376111507, -0.0998411700129509, -0.001273179310373962, 0.0027638371102511883, -0.0363185778260231, -0.06571990251541138, 0.029422711580991745, 0.016645075753331184, -0.05617975816130638, 0.00521537521854043, -0.017144493758678436, 0.013838568702340126, 0.027327237650752068, -0.02536027319729328, 0.028435442596673965, -0.04288028925657272, -0.06511545926332474, -0.021093061193823814, 0.033449821174144745, 0.00020473773474805057, -0.0061196875758469105, 0.008195205591619015, 0.03815404325723648, 0.043422143906354904, 0.038769617676734924, 0.03824084624648094, 0.03079194575548172, 0.0044763823971152306, 0.01621314510703087, -0.07696454972028732, 0.008535802364349365, -0.026933064684271812, -0.030607309192419052, 0.03593950346112251, -0.06020386144518852, -0.031501587480306625, 0.012458810582756996, -0.016269315034151077, -0.045923858880996704, -0.01832389272749424, -0.0007896482129581273, 0.005978879518806934, 0.0047889407724142075, -0.0027039332780987024, 0.006670401897281408, 0.03063335083425045, 0.0364118367433548, -0.04220309481024742, -0.04441959783434868, 0.020609581843018532, -0.03049132227897644, 0.02649812400341034, -0.018575206398963928, -0.0253004003316164, -0.011818686500191689, -0.031112821772694588, -0.012675303034484386, 0.010283187963068485, 0.034181009978055954, 0.02538513019680977, 0.015015034936368465, 0.0164814330637455, 0.07461061328649521, 0.008876158855855465, 0.007450804114341736, 0.002709698863327503, 0.015786616131663322, 0.003904201090335846, -0.002073063747957349, -0.023346057161688805, 0.034327711910009384, 0.03477463871240616, 0.0395374558866024, -0.016574351117014885, 0.023406226187944412, -0.004511322360485792, -0.0062424056231975555, -0.007935762405395508, 0.07888959348201752, -0.05522127076983452, 0.008510463871061802, -0.023163441568613052, 0.0006336694932542741, -0.014113680459558964, 0.009106909856200218, -0.0007862933562137187, 0.014734504744410515, -0.07867838442325592, 0.04081231728196144, -0.013679095543920994, 0.007670674938708544, 0.006266454700380564, 0.03788672760128975, 0.04109377786517143, -0.029539620503783226, 0.032901421189308167, 0.02661297656595707, 0.023220080882310867, -0.001281792763620615, -0.03876997157931328, -0.006797106470912695, 0.015354316681623459, -0.04474451765418053, -0.01114672888070345, -0.011714878492057323, -0.017057549208402634, -0.054463841021060944, 0.01291265245527029, 0.023239513859152794, -0.009002238512039185, 0.020806290209293365, 0.006827639415860176, 0.08012744784355164, 0.008257635869085789, 0.019018467515707016, -0.0051110051572322845, -0.03704438731074333, 0.035130392760038376, -0.006590004079043865, 0.01857726089656353, -0.0158854927867651, -0.02139231376349926, -0.05955586954951286, -0.059793323278427124, -0.021962951868772507, 0.009591162204742432, -0.003352972213178873, -0.023944512009620667, -0.02489585429430008, 0.006207258906215429, -0.059209659695625305, -0.015577273443341255, 0.045394107699394226, -0.058996669948101044, 0.0006391061469912529, 0.012086356990039349, 0.0030216623563319445, 0.02475571073591709, -0.03818010538816452, -0.040631912648677826, -0.05888466164469719, -0.03187856450676918, 0.035297244787216187, -0.021260404959321022, -0.037961434572935104, -0.03426676616072655, -0.017358699813485146, 0.01625349000096321, 0.02567802183330059, -0.005219436716288328, 0.011596412397921085, -0.0018043556483462453, 0.02114453725516796, 0.013317589648067951, -0.03452704846858978, -0.021459702402353287, 0.04752296581864357, -0.04395541921257973, 0.023427685722708702, -0.027385633438825607, 0.048292092978954315, 0.03357315808534622, -0.01441803015768528, -0.002119227312505245, -0.03801639750599861, 0.026099417358636856, -0.01059655100107193, 0.015106608159840107, 0.020451297983527184, -0.020782969892024994, -0.03766416758298874, -0.00017867860151454806, -0.01170425582677126, 0.04195839911699295, 0.017918776720762253, 0.003717664163559675, 0.004064313601702452, 0.017380205914378166, -0.0009089034283533692, 0.01626959815621376, -0.023384256288409233, -0.02567116916179657, 0.053176283836364746, -0.005531694740056992, -0.03708406537771225, -0.06494538486003876, -0.03687719628214836, -0.024488722905516624, -0.00039737956831231713, 0.01021829154342413, -0.045720428228378296, 0.0610879585146904, -0.004151194356381893, 0.025798115879297256, 0.012553559616208076, 0.004777403082698584, 0.03592447191476822, -0.0573669895529747, 0.004922302905470133, -0.07150476425886154, -0.00968657061457634, 0.051405008882284164, -0.041228871792554855, 0.0019457896705716848, -0.008385049179196358, -0.037381432950496674, 0.031187769025564194, -0.030912481248378754, -0.054088469594717026, 0.03569943085312843, 0.005549710243940353, -0.0039558797143399715, 0.053084954619407654, -0.07155218720436096, -0.012795329093933105, -0.02402215637266636, -0.038992661982774734, -0.024629874154925346, 0.009239645674824715, 0.05465969815850258, -0.012481332756578922, -0.013577884994447231, -0.003356288420036435, 0.027495916932821274, 0.02056577242910862, 0.06679350882768631, 0.04021869972348213, 0.019707631319761276, -0.04237550124526024, 0.03518712520599365, 0.044298335909843445, 0.0105448542162776, -0.015541885048151016, -0.001816349453292787, -0.03538595885038376, -0.08474457263946533, 0.04007352516055107, -0.000949267705436796, -0.002290381584316492, -0.04244768247008324, 0.07097078859806061, 0.03096177987754345, -0.04040614888072014, -0.004157067742198706, 0.03977467492222786, -0.04183642566204071, -0.02052491530776024, 0.014399691484868526, 0.017995409667491913, -0.017678506672382355, 0.08971341699361801, 0.026115044951438904, 0.06241905689239502, 0.06533622741699219, 0.011807767674326897, 0.007950907573103905, 0.00703046889975667, 0.08134367316961288, 0.05935205891728401, 0.06473235040903091, 0.03745200112462044, 0.06785701215267181, -0.06559935957193375, -0.04577597603201866, 0.005682117305696011, 0.023100998252630234, -0.013344325125217438, -0.012374024838209152, -0.0032213616650551558, 0.08024253696203232, -0.009221966378390789, 0.08044929802417755, -0.032313860952854156, 0.0027921730652451515, 0.055342480540275574, 0.0363507904112339, 0.006628045812249184, 0.05554168298840523, 0.03171239793300629, 0.0029916686471551657, -0.023364773020148277, -0.023871906101703644, 0.0032714679837226868, -0.05954493582248688, -0.0038928973954170942, 0.016504129394888878, -0.026600582525134087, 0.005243320949375629, -0.02104640193283558, 0.05139460787177086, 0.12342358380556107, -0.008557272143661976, -0.019977260380983353, 0.030590858310461044, -0.011443492956459522, 0.03459513932466507, 0.06403473764657974, -0.012696485035121441, 0.004493494518101215, -0.012686883099377155, -0.048358313739299774, 0.026414640247821808, 0.0017161518335342407, -0.042700886726379395, 0.016800157725811005, -0.018174484372138977, -0.040223415940999985, -0.0005839858204126358, 0.0424780435860157, -0.030203448608517647, -0.07038885354995728, -0.02489304356276989, -0.03656749427318573, -0.029019566252827644, -0.050657931715250015, 0.02931051328778267, 0.0013852774864062667, -0.021338870748877525, 0.0225665420293808, -0.03206683695316315, -0.00493342662230134, -0.024807807058095932, -0.04970959946513176, 0.007641398813575506, 0.05362469330430031, 0.01796148531138897, -0.01707005873322487, 0.03435509279370308, 0.034919459372758865, -0.03027602657675743, -0.00815120805054903, 0.02776574157178402, 0.009983483701944351, 0.01325545646250248, -0.031724974513053894, -0.00558736827224493, -0.09397169202566147, -0.012789761647582054, 0.01340565551072359, -0.03192242980003357, -0.08250317722558975, 0.010830462910234928, -0.026519909501075745, 0.039281703531742096, 0.07005302608013153, 0.04585423320531845, 0.02790488675236702, 0.00837733969092369, -0.02745744027197361, 0.0006782587734051049, 0.02153751626610756, 0.05581585690379143, -0.01671210117638111, 0.0717436820268631, 0.0517539381980896, -0.029088204726576805, -0.056653086096048355, 0.006599972955882549, -0.0031604969408363104, -0.03582306578755379, -0.016114437952637672, -0.023465169593691826, -0.011086019687354565, -0.0942668467760086, -0.023450955748558044, 0.02809878997504711, -0.012944694608449936, -0.05299847945570946, 0.001999844331294298, -0.015185152180492878, -0.012526018545031548, 0.006750942673534155, -0.03175360709428787, -0.011704260483384132, -0.024944836273789406, -0.04726818576455116, -0.04224706441164017, -0.004196245223283768, -0.03925091028213501, -0.0028723538853228092, -0.04648531973361969, -0.047386810183525085, -0.014626885764300823, 0.013993054628372192, 0.045585747808218, 0.0005677566514350474, 0.0209504421800375, -0.025563614442944527 ]
3,591
TAID: Temporally Adaptive Interpolated Distillation for Efficient Knowledge Transfer in Language Models
https://openreview.net/forum?id=cqsw28DuMW
[ "Makoto Shing", "Kou Misaki", "Han Bao", "Sho Yokoi", "Takuya Akiba" ]
Spotlight
Causal language models have demonstrated remarkable capabilities, but their size poses significant challenges for deployment in resource-constrained environments. Knowledge distillation, a widely-used technique for transferring knowledge from a large teacher model to a small student model, presents a promising approach for model compression. A significant remaining issue lies in the major differences between teacher and student models, namely the substantial capacity gap, mode averaging, and mode collapse, which pose barriers during distillation. To address these issues, we introduce $\textit{Temporally Adaptive Interpolated Distillation (TAID)}$, a novel knowledge distillation approach that dynamically interpolates student and teacher distributions through an adaptive intermediate distribution, gradually shifting from the student's initial distribution towards the teacher's distribution. We provide a theoretical analysis demonstrating TAID's ability to prevent mode collapse and empirically show its effectiveness in addressing the capacity gap while balancing mode averaging and mode collapse. Our comprehensive experiments demonstrate TAID's superior performance across various model sizes and architectures in both instruction tuning and pre-training scenarios. Furthermore, we showcase TAID's practical impact by developing two state-of-the-art compact foundation models: $\texttt{TAID-LLM-1.5B}$ for language tasks and $\texttt{TAID-VLM-2B}$ for vision-language tasks. These results demonstrate TAID's effectiveness in creating high-performing and efficient models, advancing the development of more accessible AI technologies.
Lanauge Models, Knowledge Distillation
We propose TAID, a novel knowledge distillation method for language models that uses a time-dependent intermediate distribution to dynamically bridge student-teacher gaps, addressing common challenges in distilling large language models.
4,087
2501.16937
[ 0.006976475473493338, -0.010466775856912136, -0.020017072558403015, 0.06093427538871765, 0.04583205655217171, 0.007620589341968298, 0.046838756650686264, 0.0076730214059352875, -0.013932636938989162, -0.000040137176256394014, -0.013964690268039703, 0.011621862649917603, -0.04340582713484764, 0.01728578470647335, 0.013071567751467228, 0.054148439317941666, 0.04844605177640915, -0.04003855958580971, 0.024868661537766457, 0.038109295070171356, -0.024690963327884674, -0.04980142414569855, 0.03995446860790253, 0.013176565058529377, -0.002439189236611128, 0.01422115508466959, -0.005453929305076599, -0.0019903695210814476, -0.0328664667904377, -0.010934192687273026, 0.04042185842990875, 0.013043220154941082, 0.0310684684664011, -0.02549399621784687, 0.006668900605291128, 0.0013428826350718737, -0.04922371357679367, 0.0352652370929718, 0.01380359660834074, 0.018743105232715607, -0.025141580030322075, 0.00863724946975708, 0.015219559893012047, -0.0012155236909165978, -0.03284910321235657, 0.007317221257835627, -0.1129331886768341, 0.05041661486029625, 0.007138747721910477, -0.021945662796497345, -0.1327252984046936, 0.011511392891407013, 0.008864852599799633, -0.030761709436774254, 0.013458164408802986, 0.04837260767817497, 0.03862077742815018, -0.09358099848031998, 0.009919102303683758, -0.03692613169550896, -0.03548680245876312, 0.010898666456341743, 0.02006619982421398, 0.0032456086482852697, -0.0020425692200660706, -0.034811120480298996, -0.023329531773924828, 0.023612046614289284, -0.0473548024892807, -0.04992085322737694, -0.014788453467190266, 0.009238884784281254, -0.013328052125871181, -0.016356127336621284, 0.0012206007959321141, -0.029359646141529083, 0.02792680449783802, 0.02478264644742012, 0.07659022510051727, -0.011149189434945583, -0.010861745104193687, 0.0036651750560849905, 0.030911199748516083, 0.03835073485970497, 0.004906732123345137, -0.008384022861719131, -0.033733878284692764, -0.03147488832473755, -0.06685344129800797, 0.022374412044882774, -0.03956594690680504, -0.030455153435468674, 0.006888153497129679, 0.008221058174967766, 0.005946152377873659, 0.00856854859739542, 0.031276218593120575, 0.011146360076963902, 0.02177928015589714, 0.0061776889488101006, 0.0035546424333006144, -0.037517253309488297, 0.02486361935734749, 0.027079086750745773, -0.10264009982347488, 0.0006544240168295801, -0.025072474032640457, -0.026487598195672035, 0.01905248686671257, 0.0021105194464325905, -0.0033112955279648304, -0.009505737572908401, 0.009899619966745377, -0.03410246968269348, -0.08938231319189072, 0.03099812939763069, 0.006847596261650324, 0.042930714786052704, -0.00655946834012866, -0.004042329266667366, 0.04764269292354584, 0.04271030053496361, 0.013012074865400791, 0.06698848307132721, 0.01339397206902504, 0.003292179200798273, -0.014098539017140865, 0.027683256193995476, -0.030808309093117714, -0.015780817717313766, 0.010023391805589199, 0.02080039493739605, 0.01367600355297327, -0.020643871277570724, 0.008401398546993732, 0.013632924295961857, 0.01830766163766384, 0.012348494492471218, 0.05082907900214195, -0.020588843151926994, -0.02733222395181656, -0.010554914362728596, 0.05328105762600899, -0.03823927789926529, 0.041388608515262604, 0.010070662945508957, -0.01067843846976757, 0.005762456450611353, -0.020005833357572556, 0.0146442586556077, 0.011529150418937206, 0.0026985821314156055, 0.004751254804432392, -0.06354154646396637, 0.027874480932950974, 0.06464310735464096, -0.0151240024715662, -0.007516036741435528, 0.010168801993131638, 0.020645692944526672, -0.0003946546639781445, -0.003032761625945568, -0.034304022789001465, -0.03307560831308365, 0.02275698259472847, -0.06659746915102005, 0.02475736103951931, 0.0308693777769804, -0.017064698040485382, -0.009384127333760262, -0.041217729449272156, -0.009787722490727901, 0.07181679457426071, -0.039574429392814636, -0.008992454037070274, 0.004304031375795603, 0.03545472025871277, 0.0018726305570453405, 0.040545810014009476, 0.00983636174350977, -0.08612658828496933, 0.04219945892691612, 0.013091523200273514, -0.0019644282292574644, -0.02274254336953163, -0.015145083889365196, 0.09589073061943054, -0.06287653744220734, 0.01146339438855648, 0.035685475915670395, -0.09005045145750046, -0.027620773762464523, 0.043286506086587906, -0.003724395064637065, 0.0643288865685463, 0.02278820239007473, -0.0015451227081939578, 0.02584821917116642, 0.018562395125627518, 0.03293668106198311, 0.061671990901231766, -0.002273151185363531, 0.06326423585414886, -0.011205251328647137, -0.019368775188922882, 0.005006084218621254, 0.028693804517388344, -0.05684959143400192, -0.05978694558143616, 0.016595615074038506, -0.022977225482463837, -0.031549930572509766, 0.016274739056825638, -0.0023403118830174208, 0.0028001656755805016, 0.0019186269491910934, -0.007790995761752129, -0.018640782684087753, 0.025030922144651413, -0.05162171274423599, 0.022374402731657028, 0.007961510680615902, -0.03331799805164337, 0.002231983467936516, -0.03208037465810776, 0.09030269086360931, 0.05987416207790375, 0.0020723463967442513, 0.02002018876373768, 0.027482377365231514, 0.0048531717620790005, -0.006760499905794859, 0.021207692101597786, -0.034373871982097626, 0.052883632481098175, -0.01888742297887802, -0.005695104133337736, -0.018295738846063614, 0.03630223870277405, -0.03712917119264603, -0.008586589246988297, 0.05845217779278755, -0.017560143023729324, 0.0709516704082489, 0.018806124106049538, 0.020158182829618454, 0.04086095467209816, -0.00746941426768899, 0.0012630404671654105, -0.04711940512061119, 0.010214067064225674, 0.0045461347326636314, -0.00292657851241529, -0.03233852982521057, -0.021748941391706467, -0.04209856688976288, -0.022359760478138924, -0.023071877658367157, 0.04665118455886841, 0.04827344790101051, -0.029492471367120743, 0.011446488089859486, 0.011817248538136482, -0.042846016585826874, -0.006709568668156862, -0.11686738580465317, -0.024117209017276764, -0.016614310443401337, 0.03148926794528961, -0.004090473987162113, 0.03096025250852108, 0.002976238029077649, 0.03574422374367714, -0.026175806298851967, -0.044319506734609604, 0.020480697974562645, 0.023682471364736557, 0.01974610611796379, -0.0528990663588047, -0.030490543693304062, -0.014324279502034187, 0.0649571493268013, -0.0367143489420414, -0.013122577220201492, -0.03964764624834061, -0.04022543504834175, -0.015509253367781639, -0.07578962296247482, -0.0027020343113690615, 0.017876340076327324, 0.04249771684408188, -0.000999219948425889, -0.04492570459842682, 0.009918480180203915, 0.06328492611646652, 0.046480417251586914, 0.038835372775793076, 0.0005210178205743432, -0.019298743456602097, 0.027067510411143303, -0.013219588436186314, 0.0274432972073555, -0.018056347966194153, 0.07683694362640381, -0.02083873748779297, 0.010224870406091213, 0.0225262138992548, 0.011550664901733398, -0.2850024104118347, 0.010689198039472103, 0.012179942801594734, -0.030411995947360992, 0.048755742609500885, -0.02078966423869133, 0.05972879379987717, -0.03574502840638161, -0.029221484437584877, 0.027342237532138824, 0.009434053674340248, 0.03466116264462471, 0.012029796838760376, 0.0617767870426178, 0.046060480177402496, 0.04121653363108635, -0.034663308411836624, -0.03039577603340149, 0.025522129610180855, 0.05116323009133339, 0.006098609417676926, -0.04702797904610634, -0.009374896995723248, 0.06130179762840271, 0.005734231323003769, 0.02007097564637661, -0.09846560657024384, 0.010021321475505829, -0.020436443388462067, -0.003869706531986594, 0.002181275514885783, -0.02150590531527996, -0.005361675750464201, 0.04650450125336647, -0.015190603211522102, 0.020011309534311295, 0.0449487566947937, 0.03524259105324745, 0.04424503073096275, 0.00048785103717818856, -0.0030274703167378902, -0.02809363417327404, 0.008433574810624123, 0.007106421049684286, 0.06668216735124588, 0.02887200005352497, -0.04601261019706726, -0.024274729192256927, -0.018254095688462257, 0.051059313118457794, -0.022448217496275902, -0.02911754511296749, -0.01400092151015997, 0.002065169857814908, 0.013831435702741146, -0.009252330288290977, 0.028678173199295998, -0.017326701432466507, 0.008792325854301453, 0.010150480084121227, -0.01321020070463419, -0.04294367879629135, 0.0012864016462117434, -0.0468158982694149, 0.013105399906635284, -0.043570928275585175, -0.06724537909030914, -0.035968560725450516, 0.027698451653122902, 0.029549000784754753, -0.05193067342042923, 0.0281610656529665, 0.0063507393933832645, -0.08984605967998505, -0.004556463565677404, 0.0036552813835442066, 0.007084357552230358, -0.045083463191986084, 0.006659480277448893, 0.054577019065618515, -0.051714688539505005, -0.0165084395557642, -0.008519252762198448, 0.014208581298589706, 0.049243394285440445, -0.015501568093895912, 0.01121373102068901, -0.059033360332250595, -0.0022440773900598288, -0.03322591260075569, 0.040454406291246414, 0.008549338206648827, 0.0069610606878995895, 0.020895039662718773, 0.05862290784716606, 0.05166682228446007, 0.039014507085084915, 0.0763053297996521, 0.0366063229739666, -0.018303319811820984, 0.025261186063289642, -0.08016817271709442, -0.023058827966451645, -0.04612905904650688, -0.02189089171588421, 0.033561527729034424, -0.05446417257189751, -0.043532226234674454, 0.019546393305063248, -0.0037998610641807318, -0.04958922043442726, -0.03087671473622322, -0.02776784636080265, -0.004447269253432751, -0.021935561671853065, 0.0081064747646451, 0.006937914062291384, 0.027471449226140976, 0.01207225676625967, -0.022657372057437897, -0.017929062247276306, 0.04851479455828667, -0.017792409285902977, 0.00022756264661438763, 0.01141740195453167, -0.042610179632902145, -0.000279419356957078, -0.00878879800438881, 0.0052424827590584755, -0.027211971580982208, 0.005233002360910177, 0.031246306374669075, 0.0042182765901088715, 0.012788350693881512, 0.037817101925611496, -0.00364392576739192, -0.012960875406861305, -0.009943297132849693, 0.020691178739070892, -0.022790418937802315, -0.00959446094930172, -0.016658639535307884, 0.04144497215747833, -0.007878625765442848, 0.021167058497667313, 0.012802339158952236, 0.0017411430599167943, -0.012629243545234203, 0.007477214559912682, 0.001874683191999793, 0.028753703460097313, -0.04229060932993889, -0.013876713812351227, -0.04385272040963173, 0.00039220519829541445, -0.02329426445066929, 0.02518775314092636, -0.01589248888194561, 0.02868700586259365, -0.04345468804240227, 0.04853406921029091, 0.029138321056962013, -0.014108652248978615, -0.002615981735289097, 0.03140079975128174, 0.04746227711439133, -0.042978376150131226, 0.0002195844572270289, 0.015279057435691357, -0.0059480369091033936, 0.0024441001005470753, -0.0234040766954422, -0.0586269311606884, -0.003803916508331895, -0.02029990777373314, 0.020565969869494438, 0.0029125367291271687, -0.01211562566459179, -0.037435565143823624, 0.0360998660326004, 0.03330312669277191, -0.02132624015212059, -0.014674022793769836, 0.0053450195118784904, 0.08690944314002991, 0.011463994160294533, -0.0035739431623369455, 0.00543230539187789, -0.05245404690504074, 0.03291691467165947, -0.008433302864432335, -0.0017357509350404143, -0.01515255868434906, -0.03266201168298721, -0.03168383240699768, -0.043065447360277176, 0.01161195058375597, 0.02791621908545494, 0.000766111770644784, 0.03207856044173241, -0.004759002011269331, -0.019697872921824455, -0.023927712813019753, -0.026639804244041443, 0.01785639300942421, -0.07254254072904587, 0.01909158192574978, 0.037610989063978195, -0.0046593123115599155, 0.021284256130456924, -0.0011009166482836008, -0.04945053160190582, -0.058334678411483765, 0.00025442076730541885, 0.007846910506486893, -0.033957045525312424, -0.010406587272882462, -0.018944431096315384, 0.012403623200953007, -0.026335692033171654, 0.04724657163023949, -0.007962708361446857, 0.027348646894097328, -0.018656419590115547, -0.014799999073147774, 0.027646556496620178, -0.039425868541002274, 0.022284310311079025, -0.015399029478430748, -0.03774472326040268, 0.020942823961377144, -0.036541782319545746, 0.029094984754920006, 0.05461766943335533, -0.014065027236938477, 0.004447219893336296, -0.03916531801223755, 0.055675555020570755, -0.0029353944119066, -0.029743364080786705, -0.008629901334643364, -0.007340461481362581, -0.022814512252807617, 0.007743432652205229, -0.007963757961988449, 0.016370661556720734, -0.006992307025939226, -0.015058872289955616, 0.008267011493444443, 0.004762429744005203, 0.03068161942064762, 0.015070630237460136, -0.05299342796206474, 0.0038425736129283905, 0.07371836155653, -0.07119705528020859, -0.050288133323192596, -0.07190466672182083, -0.06144353747367859, 0.0175249632447958, -0.02053789421916008, 0.02393648400902748, -0.01850440725684166, 0.028872791677713394, 0.013678415678441525, 0.028472544625401497, 0.018744343891739845, -0.027958804741501808, 0.03380976989865303, -0.04071249067783356, -0.00619294261559844, -0.0774192065000534, -0.013788893818855286, 0.06325890123844147, -0.027469977736473083, -0.022928601130843163, 0.015012458898127079, -0.05047633871436119, 0.022585289552807808, -0.015694882720708847, -0.03855528309941292, 0.03534826636314392, -0.031644415110349655, 0.007434512488543987, 0.0014860084047541022, -0.046242546290159225, -0.007947561331093311, -0.04116792231798172, -0.037474580109119415, 0.0027557280845940113, 0.010106965899467468, 0.04616633802652359, 0.005754262674599886, 0.01239000167697668, -0.04617037996649742, -0.018673617392778397, 0.01830465905368328, 0.046926021575927734, 0.012909258715808392, 0.04430590569972992, -0.02449347823858261, 0.0820036232471466, 0.038806743919849396, 0.023069191724061966, 0.008354941383004189, -0.014858130365610123, -0.013916423544287682, -0.08063115179538727, 0.05440535768866539, -0.008540287613868713, -0.005336147733032703, -0.037385132163763046, 0.06515859812498093, 0.04467380791902542, -0.04368140175938606, -0.026251420378684998, 0.05449463427066803, -0.03185436129570007, -0.017179735004901886, -0.009913966059684753, 0.02172350510954857, -0.026678621768951416, 0.06533195078372955, 0.016399910673499107, 0.043510690331459045, 0.06665384024381638, 0.017529292032122612, -0.03127991035580635, -0.0286366268992424, 0.07052560895681381, 0.05170666053891182, 0.0633828416466713, 0.015463266521692276, 0.07752898335456848, -0.04286558926105499, -0.02230176515877247, 0.031198300421237946, 0.0626087337732315, -0.02624082937836647, -0.035829681903123856, 0.03891591355204582, 0.09543325752019882, -0.03489433601498604, 0.06991212069988251, -0.07502933591604233, -0.016283560544252396, 0.021411199122667313, 0.018599724397063255, -0.01176803931593895, 0.031253695487976074, 0.014602161943912506, 0.0006876318366266787, -0.004318380728363991, -0.05183548480272293, 0.016920629888772964, -0.034059956669807434, 0.008290715515613556, -0.0061153843998909, -0.01153885293751955, 0.001956687308847904, -0.009803754277527332, 0.0332685261964798, 0.1003810465335846, -0.06085282936692238, -0.021327834576368332, 0.01889166049659252, 0.029401792213320732, -0.023707272484898567, 0.058743916451931, 0.017302600666880608, -0.002812127349898219, -0.007648017723113298, -0.054291363805532455, -0.004754670895636082, 0.016912616789340973, 0.001124010537751019, 0.03659163787961006, -0.02324678562581539, -0.007258163765072823, 0.025069469586014748, -0.008044273592531681, -0.07883942872285843, -0.07142853736877441, -0.050304487347602844, -0.0444515235722065, -0.0443013571202755, -0.027909671887755394, 0.04272473230957985, 0.006796571891754866, -0.0329529270529747, -0.005762565415352583, -0.034947142004966736, 0.02966739982366562, 0.024580566212534904, -0.07881448417901993, 0.006584975868463516, 0.03590897098183632, -0.009521868079900742, -0.036600466817617416, 0.04649370536208153, 0.030462121590971947, -0.005795449484139681, -0.004839426837861538, 0.008597726933658123, 0.029363181442022324, 0.018724797293543816, 0.009165165945887566, -0.00896792858839035, -0.0925208181142807, -0.002039894461631775, 0.025492453947663307, -0.037839800119400024, -0.07118356972932816, 0.018665742129087448, -0.02668536826968193, 0.02718275971710682, 0.059675414115190506, 0.013742647133767605, 0.03590509295463562, -0.02471551112830639, -0.01580858789384365, 0.025612544268369675, 0.032192837446928024, 0.04544983431696892, -0.03561771288514137, 0.08214259147644043, 0.052544962614774704, -0.01375180296599865, -0.04176712781190872, 0.03079332411289215, -0.0015567659866064787, -0.00428583100438118, -0.016548270359635353, 0.0003202881198376417, -0.029278019443154335, -0.07570819556713104, -0.014872967265546322, 0.020362140610814095, -0.020714323967695236, -0.042112722992897034, 0.009095954708755016, -0.010195385664701462, 0.0012802378041669726, -0.010867281816899776, -0.027155188843607903, -0.012188980355858803, -0.042609307914972305, -0.027532154694199562, -0.05769041180610657, 0.007981750182807446, -0.015455057844519615, -0.017719347029924393, -0.05416599288582802, -0.03062611259520054, 0.00913336593657732, 0.0024033545050770044, 0.05518006160855293, -0.001318039488978684, 0.021522998809814453, 0.00803255196660757 ]
3,592
Learning Transformer-based World Models with Contrastive Predictive Coding
https://openreview.net/forum?id=YK9G4Htdew
[ "Maxime Burchi", "Radu Timofte" ]
Spotlight
The DreamerV3 algorithm recently obtained remarkable performance across diverse environment domains by learning an accurate world model based on Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs). Following the success of model-based reinforcement learning algorithms and the rapid adoption of the Transformer architecture for its superior training efficiency and favorable scaling properties, recent works such as STORM have proposed replacing RNN-based world models with Transformer-based world models using masked self-attention. However, despite the improved training efficiency of these methods, their impact on performance remains limited compared to the Dreamer algorithm, struggling to learn competitive Transformer-based world models. In this work, we show that the next state prediction objective adopted in previous approaches is insufficient to fully exploit the representation capabilities of Transformers. We propose to extend world model predictions to longer time horizons by introducing TWISTER (Transformer-based World model wIth contraSTivE Representations), a world model using action-conditioned Contrastive Predictive Coding to learn high-level temporal feature representations and improve the agent performance. TWISTER achieves a human-normalized mean score of 162% on the Atari 100k benchmark, setting a new record among state-of-the-art methods that do not employ look-ahead search. We release our code at https://github.com/burchim/TWISTER.
model-based reinforcement learning, transformer network, contrastive predictive coding
We introduce TWISTER, a Transformer model-based reinforcement learning algorithm using action-conditioned Contrastive Predictive Coding to learn high-level feature representations and improve the agent performance.
3,995
2503.04416
[ -0.004079652018845081, -0.037218254059553146, -0.01943775825202465, 0.03957180306315422, 0.018024826422333717, 0.02873673103749752, 0.023962758481502533, 0.017300289124250412, -0.027789227664470673, -0.016520000994205475, -0.02258290722966194, -0.011426779441535473, -0.06467824429273605, 0.009161233901977539, 0.0017692422261461616, 0.051985446363687515, 0.009466970339417458, 0.0030810926109552383, -0.010009554214775562, 0.017771050333976746, -0.002770600840449333, -0.044990114867687225, 0.031384896486997604, -0.0007236436358653009, 0.04014298692345619, -0.0037392834201455116, 0.02581373229622841, 0.014787670224905014, -0.017685730010271072, -0.007282734382897615, 0.010557777248322964, -0.006872737780213356, 0.016300229355692863, -0.014430115930736065, 0.0047783819027245045, -0.010499821975827217, -0.07266865670681, 0.0071555860340595245, 0.02220829576253891, -0.0006987808737903833, -0.03433927148580551, -0.013788120821118355, 0.0016145926201716065, -0.0017344137886539102, -0.013501385226845741, -0.0019101542420685291, -0.08036626130342484, 0.02697019837796688, 0.01826784387230873, -0.060271792113780975, -0.08394278585910797, 0.05894279107451439, 0.01626306027173996, -0.007399006746709347, 0.013901966623961926, 0.029260097071528435, 0.07177449017763138, -0.06712377071380615, -0.008195273578166962, -0.04121021926403046, -0.009767256677150726, 0.00984883401542902, 0.029368147253990173, 0.015260538086295128, -0.015224292874336243, -0.01761326566338539, 0.015864478424191475, 0.04277362301945686, -0.010683124884963036, -0.035985637456178665, -0.034409236162900925, 0.019565261900424957, -0.00043213777826167643, 0.03343269228935242, 0.008322717621922493, -0.04889173433184624, 0.009562674909830093, 0.02182571403682232, 0.06435355544090271, -0.00927732978016138, 0.0024998183362185955, 0.04240066558122635, 0.03864118829369545, 0.025772511959075928, 0.0232720747590065, -0.0023299825843423605, 0.0026131689082831144, -0.031930241733789444, -0.0967249646782875, 0.007069129962474108, -0.029343076050281525, -0.02926870435476303, 0.0038983270060271025, 0.053196556866168976, 0.020626721903681755, 0.008677107281982899, 0.011528048664331436, 0.0020248969085514545, -0.005726142320781946, -0.02127547189593315, -0.021609747782349586, -0.026953741908073425, 0.024316219612956047, -0.005966302938759327, -0.09374011307954788, -0.015643825754523277, 0.03739999234676361, -0.0303758904337883, 0.024741465225815773, 0.03411510959267616, -0.08308342099189758, -0.001320713316090405, 0.03930465504527092, -0.033195026218891144, -0.06390263140201569, 0.01572967693209648, 0.0216295775026083, 0.05130774527788162, -0.021903300657868385, 0.013117914088070393, 0.05314808338880539, 0.01756785437464714, -0.010970073752105236, 0.08053690940141678, -0.008623496629297733, 0.008541140705347061, -0.009735397063195705, 0.01736237108707428, -0.029650956392288208, -0.04570068046450615, 0.05379626527428627, 0.02224220335483551, -0.021207598969340324, 0.039928533136844635, -0.01476426050066948, -0.004836279433220625, -0.0038855464663356543, 0.005686076823621988, 0.04775664582848549, 0.006771600339561701, -0.018161647021770477, -0.009073176421225071, 0.0809929296374321, -0.0074305408634245396, 0.07992725074291229, -0.019886741414666176, -0.02212592214345932, -0.010944015346467495, -0.03971535339951515, 0.010431643575429916, -0.0050793178379535675, -0.0027321656234562397, -0.03410950303077698, -0.06381701678037643, 0.04984506592154503, 0.05917349457740784, 0.025531712919473648, 0.03398711606860161, 0.012785392813384533, 0.004325082991272211, 0.001490012276917696, 0.02127332054078579, -0.03629451245069504, -0.008586100302636623, 0.004127865191549063, -0.0652725026011467, 0.022363802418112755, 0.0021903021261096, -0.015948161482810974, -0.025163229554891586, -0.036708660423755646, -0.028697170317173004, 0.04175611585378647, -0.005569620057940483, -0.023990899324417114, -0.051665354520082474, 0.07352375984191895, 0.017862781882286072, 0.032930996268987656, 0.03484707325696945, -0.06847213208675385, 0.022264642640948296, 0.006382854655385017, -0.03485416620969772, 0.019936678931117058, -0.05050282180309296, 0.06301950663328171, 0.00880005955696106, 0.0034769074991345406, 0.04170649126172066, -0.06622497737407684, -0.02376607619225979, 0.015523876994848251, -0.007218343671411276, 0.04733848199248314, 0.008355357684195042, -0.02804407849907875, 0.03946460038423538, 0.017343956977128983, 0.06551986187696457, 0.05492762103676796, -0.03630093112587929, 0.0625661313533783, 0.003674713894724846, -0.043882157653570175, -0.015443587675690651, 0.04949141666293144, -0.058517709374427795, -0.0357622392475605, 0.0017275726422667503, -0.0028017740696668625, -0.006801250856369734, 0.01698176935315132, 0.003820169949904084, 0.019883152097463608, 0.019705383107066154, 0.012551180087029934, 0.020694853737950325, 0.05050753802061081, -0.017557287588715553, 0.04317539185285568, -0.023023078218102455, -0.03884826600551605, -0.012532195076346397, 0.005022991448640823, 0.09767701476812363, 0.03299422934651375, -0.04258408397436142, -0.030376726761460304, -0.0022476338781416416, -0.01647263951599598, 0.02253091149032116, 0.023335129022598267, -0.04127149656414986, 0.021971797570586205, -0.04182940721511841, -0.0050497534684836864, -0.04475432261824608, 0.01993054337799549, -0.01824665255844593, -0.008719978854060173, 0.07285306602716446, -0.043771035969257355, 0.03416972607374191, 0.006465801503509283, 0.04858017340302467, 0.042978230863809586, -0.02108478918671608, -0.01901880092918873, 0.0010386614594608545, -0.017734266817569733, -0.00028105106321163476, 0.0299775842577219, -0.011724571697413921, 0.010654902085661888, -0.0297243595123291, -0.047850947827100754, -0.02461334317922592, 0.0734955221414566, 0.04543863236904144, 0.020716840401291847, 0.047268111258745193, -0.040880102664232254, -0.024064049124717712, -0.027799729257822037, -0.10941129177808762, -0.04156661778688431, -0.020915506407618523, 0.016563914716243744, -0.0008072492200881243, 0.03642982989549637, 0.012463566847145557, 0.05649537220597267, -0.060764286667108536, -0.011523387394845486, 0.017426783218979836, 0.02930155210196972, 0.02578096278011799, -0.011095547117292881, -0.010656614787876606, 0.0103736761957407, 0.041868239641189575, 0.012548072263598442, -0.011770874261856079, -0.002877851016819477, -0.05559748783707619, 0.014241216704249382, -0.013566887006163597, -0.014508374966681004, 0.011184162460267544, 0.033263303339481354, 0.01719100959599018, -0.023818280547857285, 0.02128499560058117, 0.04968094453215599, 0.09162001311779022, 0.06654820591211319, -0.008120485581457615, -0.030567998066544533, 0.014310821890830994, -0.03464827686548233, 0.022460466250777245, -0.004303265362977982, 0.006380471866577864, -0.0028548419941216707, 0.009243791922926903, 0.0287130419164896, 0.0022222776897251606, -0.26250985264778137, -0.052052974700927734, -0.00880480371415615, -0.028910323977470398, 0.051879070699214935, -0.01568763516843319, 0.06834296882152557, -0.029414864256978035, -0.006839157547801733, 0.026859411969780922, -0.01338854432106018, 0.006167258135974407, -0.0104796988889575, 0.03966744989156723, 0.030796580016613007, 0.02470247447490692, -0.00452039809897542, 0.01004115305840969, 0.003855363233014941, 0.036889951676130295, -0.028660405427217484, -0.08121012896299362, -0.08861932903528214, 0.05968783423304558, 0.011240782216191292, 0.06638257205486298, -0.06393315643072128, -0.025139132514595985, -0.011181535199284554, -0.014748699963092804, -0.01319247018545866, -0.004457388073205948, -0.0011371435830369592, 0.05293372645974159, 0.021026479080319405, -0.00670945318415761, 0.03218087926506996, 0.020463043823838234, 0.0460016205906868, 0.006308224052190781, -0.026663964614272118, -0.04118192195892334, -0.03226129338145256, 0.040357641875743866, 0.06651470065116882, 0.006016587372869253, -0.04017363861203194, -0.014137737452983856, -0.028396641835570335, 0.0367964431643486, 0.025050146505236626, -0.04734082892537117, -0.00572449853643775, 0.01956990547478199, 0.028823912143707275, -0.016554364934563637, -0.001110284123569727, -0.025307195261120796, -0.03322353586554527, 0.01716766320168972, -0.010876868851482868, -0.04435684159398079, -0.013944177888333797, -0.03847577050328255, 0.0004957555211149156, -0.04685300588607788, -0.02424156852066517, -0.06055831164121628, 0.025853708386421204, 0.027154991403222084, -0.025388188660144806, -0.004808427765965462, -0.037867650389671326, -0.10262937098741531, 0.02175232023000717, 0.011067465879023075, 0.0005883608246222138, -0.010098692029714584, 0.008905651047825813, 0.02800356224179268, -0.03838828206062317, -0.07413230091333389, -0.0014696161961182952, -0.009712698869407177, -0.010893432423472404, 0.006000533699989319, 0.03155774995684624, -0.04649534821510315, -0.023316578939557076, -0.022094912827014923, 0.041319455951452255, -0.006817786954343319, 0.027811478823423386, -0.027040012180805206, 0.03982515260577202, 0.05814368650317192, 0.027740882709622383, 0.020199161022901535, 0.005327888764441013, 0.011366810649633408, 0.006542823743075132, -0.07341935485601425, 0.0051402379758656025, -0.03802155330777168, -0.01322265900671482, 0.044716157019138336, -0.024044165387749672, -0.022263959050178528, 0.05499196797609329, 0.04716638848185539, 0.0005364781827665865, -0.05109250545501709, 0.019483154639601707, 0.01254838053137064, -0.029884086921811104, -0.01818566955626011, 0.012861480936408043, 0.04032282903790474, 0.02560395561158657, -0.017210837453603745, -0.02829422987997532, 0.036697324365377426, -0.023630280047655106, 0.034167129546403885, 0.010587777011096478, -0.017037659883499146, -0.014354154467582703, 0.005477153230458498, 0.0002862568071577698, -0.0020535315852612257, 0.02734687365591526, 0.032666824758052826, -0.014899172820150852, 0.016736499965190887, 0.07760656625032425, -0.00039667109376750886, 0.006721610203385353, -0.021874766796827316, 0.050456371158361435, -0.018255149945616722, -0.010548916645348072, -0.02287951111793518, 0.046343885362148285, 0.0037238234654068947, 0.01565823145210743, -0.006696419790387154, 0.03946332633495331, 0.013031487353146076, 0.01722179539501667, -0.025499312207102776, 0.05229876562952995, -0.04459281265735626, 0.0055651175789535046, -0.04566044732928276, -0.0018934281542897224, -0.02512790635228157, 0.03049340285360813, -0.03661518916487694, 0.011642337776720524, -0.06710785627365112, 0.0784582570195198, 0.015602901577949524, 0.00001733420322125312, -0.002038127975538373, 0.07005425542593002, 0.032883040606975555, 0.017169833183288574, -0.007155742030590773, 0.022563114762306213, 0.0031281323172152042, 0.0012862224830314517, -0.040373824536800385, -0.035142067819833755, 0.01450614258646965, -0.016569556668400764, -0.009844256564974785, 0.008554887026548386, -0.015991300344467163, -0.035867806524038315, 0.02201773039996624, -0.01084022969007492, -0.0003820809070020914, 0.0016246597515419126, -0.0006176605820655823, 0.06480291485786438, 0.013151239603757858, 0.021154478192329407, 0.02770019695162773, -0.02825910411775112, 0.023014482110738754, -0.014956697821617126, 0.013654755428433418, -0.027824172750115395, -0.05178570747375488, -0.027871927246451378, -0.05040448158979416, 0.002822528826072812, 0.021973926573991776, -0.031254690140485764, -0.014798465184867382, -0.0409662090241909, 0.020774153992533684, -0.03913210704922676, -0.05026029050350189, 0.0394451878964901, -0.07489485293626785, -0.02692222408950329, -0.006807086989283562, -0.0032728291116654873, 0.018165670335292816, -0.007058928720653057, -0.01543375477194786, -0.047301847487688065, -0.04851851984858513, -0.01999194361269474, -0.03358856588602066, -0.0254561398178339, -0.030419107526540756, 0.012320797890424728, -0.0018387304153293371, 0.03941396623849869, -0.002817679662257433, -0.007935231551527977, -0.01662871055305004, -0.015361146070063114, 0.04212570562958717, -0.031038854271173477, -0.00063814886379987, -0.026967188343405724, -0.022588202729821205, 0.007223942317068577, -0.033764928579330444, 0.019859371706843376, 0.04597948119044304, -0.015857577323913574, 0.0015460981521755457, -0.03746649995446205, 0.06229603663086891, -0.009093660861253738, -0.01160604227334261, 0.019129274412989616, -0.013473056256771088, -0.03524818643927574, 0.03636389225721359, 0.03344077616930008, 0.032187383621931076, 0.00976900476962328, 0.01693948544561863, 0.02376478724181652, 0.0087661137804389, 0.02282804064452648, -0.012031028047204018, -0.06130244582891464, -0.0074409740045666695, 0.05321421101689339, -0.03967904672026634, -0.029720328748226166, -0.0631907731294632, -0.05589570105075836, 0.028114886954426765, -0.011612026952207088, 0.02652561105787754, -0.05210471153259277, 0.04245684668421745, 0.025338217616081238, 0.03932256996631622, -0.004836600739508867, -0.010214626789093018, 0.015166206285357475, -0.07169488817453384, 0.028160881251096725, -0.03300650417804718, -0.017059821635484695, 0.07722856104373932, -0.011577896773815155, -0.01013958640396595, 0.0009525068453513086, -0.052175309509038925, 0.06553380936384201, -0.01987357623875141, -0.055318914353847504, 0.053204912692308426, -0.026237163692712784, -0.007081189658492804, 0.02169177308678627, -0.023445654660463333, -0.015339888632297516, -0.026013199239969254, -0.045856885612010956, -0.02103356085717678, -0.012866249307990074, 0.03842201456427574, -0.022273892536759377, 0.007224653381854296, -0.03004484623670578, -0.004604256246238947, 0.0340447761118412, 0.032196834683418274, 0.013672170229256153, 0.004024452995508909, -0.018572069704532623, 0.06476105749607086, 0.025677550584077835, -0.004242649767547846, 0.0006368097383528948, 0.012523394078016281, -0.024817122146487236, -0.022802721709012985, 0.044563986361026764, 0.020323961973190308, -0.036062899976968765, -0.05471796542406082, 0.0381484180688858, 0.014376869425177574, -0.03356242924928665, 0.045446570962667465, 0.02084900252521038, -0.09176163375377655, -0.03648236766457558, 0.0010597524233162403, -0.02313716523349285, -0.012192018330097198, 0.054091133177280426, 0.05822627991437912, 0.06432422995567322, 0.057539600878953934, -0.004075865261256695, -0.03594948351383209, -0.026828542351722717, 0.0812569335103035, 0.057690445333719254, 0.042031217366456985, -0.04172488674521446, 0.05922475457191467, -0.06067734211683273, -0.03780224174261093, 0.047238919883966446, 0.047160714864730835, 0.002673681126907468, -0.0683535784482956, 0.009802127256989479, 0.0671599879860878, 0.02647656947374344, 0.06691911071538925, -0.027648285031318665, -0.02298280969262123, 0.05406133085489273, 0.003330154111608863, -0.01881778985261917, 0.052663639187812805, 0.04370095208287239, 0.014801586046814919, -0.005894646979868412, -0.028893835842609406, 0.0004869314725510776, -0.023630864918231964, 0.042991772294044495, 0.018375087529420853, -0.006242870353162289, 0.005699736997485161, 0.013382118195295334, 0.06160861626267433, 0.1085611954331398, -0.03403300791978836, -0.005050298757851124, -0.0331292524933815, 0.00785790290683508, 0.015644775703549385, 0.026015663519501686, -0.00940101221203804, -0.01239706203341484, -0.01319955289363861, -0.05932433158159256, 0.03929496929049492, 0.03534650802612305, 0.002415878465399146, 0.0073199039325118065, -0.05454988405108452, -0.04086298123002052, -0.026086343452334404, 0.026090743020176888, -0.04036327451467514, -0.046453725546598434, -0.038042597472667694, -0.038054682314395905, -0.07742258161306381, -0.05585489422082901, -0.006377681624144316, 0.017337344586849213, -0.05394728481769562, -0.022314133122563362, -0.02727719210088253, -0.014562086202204227, 0.00903445202857256, -0.06866948306560516, 0.007699612062424421, 0.025483964011073112, -0.0017108108149841428, -0.00838970672339201, 0.0429973341524601, 0.060185402631759644, -0.015624656341969967, -0.031412623822689056, 0.02594144083559513, 0.017679013311862946, -0.009124279022216797, -0.011393212713301182, -0.0047201719135046005, -0.10259618610143661, 0.018230149522423744, 0.044119417667388916, -0.05873226746916771, -0.0720575600862503, 0.05033908411860466, -0.036650095134973526, 0.05113361403346062, 0.06970468908548355, 0.0007304592290893197, 0.03469886630773544, -0.026632076129317284, -0.00929353293031454, -0.004135036375373602, -0.026001092046499252, 0.050091397017240524, -0.018818452954292297, 0.053160615265369415, 0.04300939664244652, -0.022350547835230827, -0.031090479344129562, 0.011723190546035767, 0.01586582139134407, -0.0401746965944767, 0.0036749173887073994, -0.03277641162276268, -0.031326066702604294, -0.09115267544984818, -0.01717749796807766, 0.0440431609749794, 0.0258451160043478, -0.03856194391846657, -0.012436360120773315, -0.011567419394850731, 0.0075896549969911575, -0.00020289639360271394, -0.03601040691137314, -0.030095474794507027, -0.006995484232902527, -0.006174623034894466, -0.04656600579619408, 0.02187192626297474, -0.04988260567188263, 0.042470235377550125, -0.04331750050187111, -0.028176818042993546, 0.037931423634290695, -0.039757296442985535, 0.025998571887612343, -0.0004412509733811021, 0.021852733567357063, -0.027266493067145348 ]
3,593
Multimodality Helps Few-shot 3D Point Cloud Semantic Segmentation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=jXvwJ51vcK
[ "Zhaochong An", "Guolei Sun", "Yun Liu", "Runjia Li", "Min Wu", "Ming-Ming Cheng", "Ender Konukoglu", "Serge Belongie" ]
Spotlight
Few-shot 3D point cloud segmentation (FS-PCS) aims at generalizing models to segment novel categories with minimal annotated support samples. While existing FS-PCS methods have shown promise, they primarily focus on unimodal point cloud inputs, overlooking the potential benefits of leveraging multimodal information. In this paper, we address this gap by introducing a multimodal FS-PCS setup, utilizing textual labels and the potentially available 2D image modality. Under this easy-to-achieve setup, we present the MultiModal Few-Shot SegNet (MM-FSS), a model effectively harnessing complementary information from multiple modalities. MM-FSS employs a shared backbone with two heads to extract intermodal and unimodal visual features, and a pretrained text encoder to generate text embeddings. To fully exploit the multimodal information, we propose a Multimodal Correlation Fusion (MCF) module to generate multimodal correlations, and a Multimodal Semantic Fusion (MSF) module to refine the correlations using text-aware semantic guidance. Additionally, we propose a simple yet effective Test-time Adaptive Cross-modal Calibration (TACC) technique to mitigate training bias, further improving generalization. Experimental results on S3DIS and ScanNet datasets demonstrate significant performance improvements achieved by our method. The efficacy of our approach indicates the benefits of leveraging commonly-ignored free modalities for FS-PCS, providing valuable insights for future research. The code is available at github.com/ZhaochongAn/Multimodality-3D-Few-Shot.
3D segmentation, 3D point cloud, few-shot segmentation, multimodality, few-shot point cloud semantic segmentation
null
3,954
2410.22489
[ 0.021916620433330536, -0.030616318807005882, 0.022672506049275398, 0.07247750461101532, 0.03286968171596527, 0.048333533108234406, 0.019940616562962532, 0.047872286289930344, -0.03755431994795799, -0.04743186756968498, -0.054243139922618866, -0.005210511852055788, -0.0520133413374424, -0.005602165590971708, 0.0229019932448864, 0.04766078665852547, -0.007856066338717937, -0.04017650708556175, -0.004979295656085014, 0.07268330454826355, -0.0396411269903183, -0.007757625076919794, 0.04267849400639534, -0.008937072940170765, 0.024533404037356377, -0.022253412753343582, 0.029638132080435753, 0.045214541256427765, -0.046305183321237564, -0.028772301971912384, -0.0066972412168979645, 0.004260598216205835, -0.015372049063444138, -0.06853549182415009, 0.0438474677503109, -0.029313167557120323, -0.056741055101156235, 0.03911557421088219, 0.01476760022342205, 0.0038125168066471815, -0.029817208647727966, 0.004935469012707472, 0.04121113941073418, -0.037212759256362915, -0.023175371810793877, 0.011892816051840782, -0.09736577421426773, 0.03131701797246933, 0.014764162711799145, -0.012646596878767014, -0.04686515033245087, 0.017518706619739532, -0.016601329669356346, 0.010808982886373997, -0.018856113776564598, 0.03645198792219162, -0.020193113014101982, -0.06612052023410797, -0.04011885076761246, -0.05949074402451515, -0.022150155156850815, 0.013796753250062466, 0.0028054865542799234, 0.019378166645765305, 0.006461793556809425, -0.03939710929989815, -0.022865833714604378, 0.03787491098046303, -0.018228471279144287, -0.0444006510078907, 0.04810050129890442, -0.012110469862818718, 0.016745401546359062, 0.017028283327817917, -0.022427957504987717, -0.031551655381917953, 0.02070092223584652, -0.012131833471357822, 0.05685225501656532, -0.028967970982193947, 0.0033736536279320717, 0.018537651747465134, 0.028643395751714706, 0.04110676050186157, -0.023837653920054436, 0.015045026317238808, 0.01618032343685627, -0.024502573534846306, -0.05643188953399658, 0.033340804278850555, -0.003055885434150696, -0.06547439843416214, 0.035032499581575394, 0.04949592053890228, 0.05346835032105446, 0.010794421657919884, 0.02048664540052414, 0.00025115435710176826, 0.01536637730896473, -0.006345625035464764, -0.0034423042088747025, -0.0020686062052845955, 0.026045212522149086, 0.025921322405338287, -0.0668419748544693, -0.017605114728212357, -0.018413206562399864, -0.010390738025307655, -0.027283547446131706, 0.015570036135613918, -0.061650704592466354, -0.04449588432908058, 0.025402341037988663, 0.004021446220576763, -0.07003064453601837, 0.013011259026825428, -0.010389545932412148, 0.024561891332268715, -0.029164496809244156, -0.017261888831853867, 0.050835978239774704, 0.05870477110147476, 0.0006320993998087943, 0.06211921572685242, -0.009192928671836853, 0.006470421329140663, 0.005977939814329147, 0.04412034526467323, -0.040559131652116776, -0.02327846921980381, 0.005859639495611191, 0.023534724488854408, -0.014854812994599342, -0.008586511015892029, 0.01848895102739334, -0.04170592874288559, 0.014989189803600311, -0.022671764716506004, 0.04538837820291519, -0.01774929091334343, 0.0254113357514143, -0.03294502943754196, 0.03628235310316086, -0.01018902100622654, 0.06526753306388855, -0.03080255351960659, -0.011278588324785233, -0.018957465887069702, -0.044427290558815, 0.0230860598385334, 0.010576264001429081, -0.05239040404558182, 0.023534681648015976, -0.06228625401854515, 0.014747648499906063, 0.07509764283895493, 0.04413462057709694, 0.0030458325054496527, 0.023555172607302666, 0.002510911552235484, 0.018995456397533417, -0.009390605613589287, -0.01562805287539959, 0.04142902418971062, -0.009551513008773327, -0.06486931443214417, 0.043977729976177216, 0.02010377123951912, -0.032677218317985535, 0.022000743076205254, -0.05140390619635582, -0.07440333813428879, 0.022956356406211853, -0.020018262788653374, -0.011125745251774788, 0.027085062116384506, 0.0542287603020668, 0.01022318471223116, 0.015956006944179535, 0.03207904472947121, -0.07291143387556076, 0.008208871819078922, 0.014514217153191566, -0.04830024391412735, 0.026771800592541695, -0.04322239011526108, 0.07373657822608948, -0.021637916564941406, -0.03597649559378624, 0.0058477045968174934, -0.050609417259693146, -0.016872581094503403, 0.01865292526781559, -0.00907537154853344, 0.06806537508964539, 0.04079729691147804, -0.03490563482046127, 0.019300583750009537, 0.03840567544102669, 0.028901932761073112, 0.03516008332371712, 0.006678630597889423, 0.06034756451845169, 0.01402009092271328, -0.041395824402570724, -0.02627149224281311, 0.03490738570690155, -0.010767624713480473, -0.048946816474199295, 0.03983915597200394, -0.019373098388314247, -0.003356096800416708, 0.014839672483503819, 0.034152448177337646, 0.031743232160806656, 0.009475483559072018, 0.00782795250415802, -0.008822653442621231, 0.002912420779466629, -0.06527052819728851, 0.04263187572360039, 0.02963460236787796, -0.039860811084508896, 0.009686130098998547, -0.04024878144264221, 0.09509578347206116, 0.07945951074361801, -0.052138857543468475, -0.023920709267258644, -0.01314550917595625, -0.02066013216972351, 0.02726198546588421, 0.009203263558447361, -0.048297859728336334, -0.00507412338629365, -0.04077963903546333, 0.07116740196943283, 0.0046934084966778755, 0.012581677176058292, -0.046467557549476624, -0.05735469236969948, 0.035758066922426224, 0.0021113224793225527, 0.011030751280486584, 0.02024434693157673, -0.0069610076025128365, 0.055969901382923126, 0.007168898358941078, 0.004791491199284792, -0.026521148160099983, 0.013810180127620697, 0.014502817764878273, -0.031201861798763275, -0.038309626281261444, -0.007372599095106125, -0.04369013011455536, 0.02410152740776539, -0.039922457188367844, 0.06714452803134918, 0.044132791459560394, -0.008193476125597954, 0.03082401491701603, -0.01242780964821577, -0.010442457161843777, -0.05010484531521797, -0.07047101110219955, -0.033029962331056595, -0.028241204097867012, 0.04518846422433853, 0.010940653271973133, 0.07845115661621094, 0.010570865124464035, 0.02579587697982788, -0.015196971595287323, 0.04410048946738243, -0.011997993104159832, 0.022121764719486237, 0.008372403681278229, -0.0092264199629426, 0.0032495439518243074, -0.006266409531235695, 0.08013676106929779, -0.0007921236101537943, -0.010509596206247807, -0.04867972433567047, 0.0016473571304231882, 0.015486015938222408, -0.0399119034409523, -0.007597294170409441, -0.0077024782076478004, -0.0005907960585318506, -0.009080423973500729, 0.007329129613935947, 0.001630024635232985, 0.03018508292734623, 0.03847123309969902, 0.012291458435356617, -0.016234299167990685, -0.059586673974990845, 0.025766467675566673, -0.03383181244134903, 0.03411826491355896, 0.015817303210496902, -0.01784176006913185, -0.014893211424350739, -0.01207287423312664, 0.009438593871891499, -0.010586109012365341, -0.2736920118331909, -0.030422180891036987, 0.0003901833260897547, 0.002519880421459675, 0.014528537169098854, -0.017734603956341743, 0.02621251717209816, -0.04362412542104721, -0.030142785981297493, 0.0018049495993182063, 0.029268870130181313, 0.03152160719037056, 0.0025325061287730932, 0.04010497033596039, 0.05805322527885437, 0.03214249759912491, -0.00780854094773531, -0.023799989372491837, 0.014165116474032402, 0.06706865131855011, -0.03626828268170357, -0.06688037514686584, -0.024314232170581818, 0.04603724554181099, -0.04278178513050079, 0.02197524718940258, -0.06391678005456924, -0.0023725975770503283, -0.003953682258725166, -0.05192346125841141, 0.026684844866394997, -0.02851272001862526, 0.011249031871557236, 0.028130248188972473, -0.007956128567457199, 0.006554456893354654, 0.057105112820863724, -0.0028430595993995667, -0.009075970388948917, -0.021848928183317184, -0.00807803962379694, 0.015753252431750298, -0.041222378611564636, 0.0357791930437088, 0.07031897455453873, -0.03752081096172333, -0.03629622608423233, 0.00022970404825173318, 0.0009571346454322338, 0.033760879188776016, 0.037198182195425034, -0.05462218075990677, -0.024401232600212097, 0.023664414882659912, -0.02120979130268097, -0.059749774634838104, 0.04816703870892525, 0.0186921413987875, -0.0462663359940052, -0.013129081577062607, -0.04093087092041969, -0.027898553758859634, -0.02596820332109928, -0.015846673399209976, 0.021228548139333725, -0.03413485735654831, -0.10550881922245026, -0.06113480404019356, 0.028375573456287384, 0.044168680906295776, -0.0010026239324361086, 0.010970884002745152, -0.012729938142001629, -0.10145770013332367, 0.041298191994428635, 0.021485090255737305, -0.03049079328775406, -0.071746326982975, -0.005678224377334118, 0.05936885625123978, -0.031635504215955734, -0.03211991861462593, 0.02292187139391899, 0.009901005774736404, 0.034387752413749695, -0.03325216844677925, 0.04250046983361244, -0.015775041654706, -0.004632687661796808, -0.042512472718954086, 0.06183056905865669, -0.00920873787254095, 0.043633099645376205, 0.014815396629273891, 0.011826553381979465, 0.005168276373296976, 0.03348102793097496, 0.02882709726691246, 0.028709525242447853, 0.004638004116714001, 0.030342092737555504, -0.047233663499355316, -0.0162208154797554, -0.013473821803927422, -0.05652229115366936, -0.005550983361899853, -0.03575833886861801, -0.03789591044187546, 0.029776977375149727, 0.0006999007309786975, -0.03164804354310036, 0.03128634765744209, 0.009204558096826077, 0.014365491457283497, 0.004423774313181639, -0.006458138581365347, 0.0029485858976840973, -0.022340236231684685, 0.05466228350996971, -0.02002124860882759, 0.003026260994374752, 0.021648751571774483, -0.014932245016098022, 0.00013429437240120023, -0.030328257009387016, -0.031063469126820564, -0.05260694399476051, -0.0028581994120031595, -0.04794444143772125, 0.010564974509179592, 0.04604253172874451, 0.03215297684073448, 0.001404673676006496, 0.007404417730867863, 0.07307664304971695, -0.00621418422088027, 0.006241351831704378, -0.013199369423091412, 0.04463933780789375, -0.026325589045882225, 0.03266463428735733, -0.026801127940416336, 0.03080204874277115, 0.07415242493152618, 0.017849551513791084, -0.020883765071630478, -0.027809036895632744, 0.029932061210274696, -0.031621865928173065, -0.01117090042680502, -0.015175625681877136, -0.052186280488967896, -0.04996717721223831, 0.0048555186949670315, -0.00157632096670568, -0.007369170896708965, -0.018053192645311356, -0.0011850472074002028, 0.012372724711894989, -0.05852017179131508, 0.03073357790708542, 0.04252435266971588, -0.004675652366131544, -0.012742671184241772, 0.018033262342214584, 0.022056715562939644, 0.011383073404431343, 0.008641872555017471, 0.01132830698043108, -0.0025633485056459904, 0.039612263441085815, -0.0780554711818695, -0.03572618588805199, -0.02044679783284664, -0.008266999386250973, 0.011395193636417389, -0.04434744641184807, -0.008539254777133465, -0.04224918410181999, 0.036956820636987686, -0.006037930026650429, -0.000579429033678025, 0.0362347774207592, -0.03657703846693039, 0.07049766927957535, -0.002872826298698783, -0.011428721249103546, -0.03697437047958374, -0.002748433267697692, 0.0436682365834713, -0.026911405846476555, 0.05030125379562378, -0.05389988049864769, 0.0023666536435484886, -0.026906665414571762, -0.0353129506111145, -0.022458892315626144, 0.0038773270789533854, 0.0008998211123980582, -0.0037742024287581444, -0.03979773074388504, 0.04329436272382736, -0.004928187932819128, -0.01225617527961731, 0.03574686869978905, -0.061816342175006866, 0.0246110949665308, 0.0449184775352478, -0.01588894985616207, -0.001498128636740148, -0.03745930641889572, -0.030753806233406067, -0.05265512689948082, -0.03845473378896713, 0.004367695190012455, -0.005103439558297396, -0.009095416404306889, -0.05557077378034592, -0.019483128562569618, -0.017842305824160576, 0.0018721717642620206, -0.02863643690943718, -0.03467073664069176, -0.04950632527470589, 0.009838871657848358, 0.03553646802902222, -0.004458610434085131, -0.015301709063351154, 0.004029394593089819, -0.021201051771640778, 0.0028913808055222034, -0.041171200573444366, 0.022343803197145462, 0.04405386373400688, 0.022610269486904144, 0.03997129574418068, -0.04032023251056671, 0.03368523716926575, 0.0026261762250214815, 0.016575397923588753, 0.012865275144577026, 0.02169346623122692, -0.006189321167767048, 0.0419091172516346, 0.006186447571963072, 0.03225846216082573, 0.01716509275138378, -0.02374270372092724, -0.03317556530237198, 0.029990294948220253, -0.015299289487302303, -0.010059508495032787, -0.037307120859622955, -0.0013530426658689976, 0.04002530500292778, -0.0074176606722176075, -0.005904639605432749, -0.010643738321959972, -0.021291911602020264, 0.014616101048886776, -0.024103309959173203, 0.023235786706209183, -0.03542720526456833, 0.0317499041557312, 0.032828908413648605, 0.030948081985116005, -0.01612032949924469, -0.028958961367607117, 0.024451998993754387, -0.04710650444030762, -0.007414588239043951, -0.06451298296451569, 0.012205562554299831, 0.04443203657865524, -0.04150265455245972, -0.0254946481436491, 0.03429710865020752, -0.0052855359390378, 0.031839948147535324, -0.025330910459160805, -0.04506399482488632, 0.02166719175875187, -0.023664511740207672, -0.005363221745938063, 0.020482137799263, -0.009547575376927853, 0.016587380319833755, -0.003808373585343361, -0.03736661747097969, 0.0017749466933310032, 0.032129522413015366, 0.019191652536392212, -0.032412219792604446, 0.011706138029694557, -0.007995134219527245, 0.006486600264906883, 0.008600890636444092, 0.04358227550983429, -0.010741694830358028, 0.05482109263539314, -0.015620646998286247, 0.06072402000427246, 0.045019377022981644, -0.02597920037806034, 0.011013044975697994, -0.02044290490448475, -0.005696140695363283, -0.04400009289383888, 0.06742891669273376, 0.025394584983587265, -0.05075468122959137, -0.07790575921535492, 0.04379699379205704, 0.039056405425071716, -0.036067597568035126, -0.03978736698627472, 0.03470665588974953, -0.05050145089626312, 0.027828039601445198, -0.023447444662451744, -0.01728166826069355, 0.039303433150053024, 0.06199229508638382, 0.008210258558392525, 0.029289955273270607, 0.06867074966430664, -0.003944906406104565, -0.001942452508956194, 0.020804576575756073, 0.053187571465969086, 0.06572923809289932, 0.04758184775710106, 0.0009301135432906449, 0.06524262577295303, -0.01986282505095005, -0.030687827616930008, 0.03352492302656174, 0.005959451664239168, 0.011305449530482292, -0.03222310543060303, -0.015298297628760338, 0.10842473804950714, 0.03134171664714813, 0.07606128603219986, -0.01540557760745287, -0.01117660477757454, 0.017146864905953407, 0.03232651203870773, 0.02186020277440548, 0.03706182911992073, 0.07597559690475464, 0.017773818224668503, -0.02729668654501438, -0.004668298177421093, -0.03366304934024811, -0.03159580007195473, 0.02424953505396843, -0.00036971166264265776, -0.022812768816947937, 0.05277993157505989, -0.020384637638926506, 0.04661503806710243, 0.08396473526954651, 0.009341497905552387, -0.05059989169239998, 0.010395222343504429, -0.01331708300858736, 0.03114539384841919, 0.07850218564271927, 0.013812682591378689, 0.009461233392357826, 0.056593284010887146, -0.034357700496912, 0.016337992623448372, 0.028118962422013283, -0.018900692462921143, 0.018686862662434578, -0.02761629968881607, -0.04554133862257004, 0.021932702511548996, -0.007548896595835686, -0.051595043390989304, -0.03323769196867943, -0.0389917716383934, -0.044760845601558685, -0.06402726471424103, 0.0054527949541807175, 0.041867103427648544, 0.01671692542731762, -0.02373025193810463, -0.01853214204311371, -0.029022561386227608, 0.0355454757809639, 0.013981723226606846, -0.08173735439777374, 0.006509819999337196, 0.05089602246880531, -0.008775218389928341, -0.0252859964966774, 0.05316910892724991, 0.018374374136328697, -0.008122365921735764, -0.0033178585581481457, 0.014832117594778538, -0.010309106670320034, 0.044563956558704376, 0.007426508702337742, -0.0171207245439291, -0.0852445662021637, 0.009491362608969212, -0.027794143185019493, 0.05017004534602165, -0.06652140617370605, -0.011649216525256634, -0.014496262185275555, 0.02332645282149315, 0.056180015206336975, 0.024961024522781372, 0.07301309704780579, -0.03495360165834427, -0.022933518514037132, -0.04651257395744324, 0.012207971885800362, 0.0546707957983017, -0.0220645759254694, 0.05864793062210083, 0.022773699834942818, 0.017350884154438972, -0.02223384566605091, 0.003561899531632662, 0.01743149198591709, 0.03880298137664795, -0.02429298497736454, -0.06113345921039581, -0.04687739908695221, -0.11077761650085449, -0.03330526128411293, 0.02130216918885708, 0.020033327862620354, -0.04406184330582619, -0.015000535175204277, -0.0253379475325346, -0.05668068677186966, -0.019540857523679733, 0.009181390516459942, -0.003142767818644643, -0.030108582228422165, -0.04814744368195534, -0.0930841714143753, 0.006220338866114616, -0.004750538617372513, 0.006568666081875563, -0.016847476363182068, -0.03807215020060539, -0.009548496454954147, 0.036379359662532806, 0.014064362272620201, 0.020672829821705818, 0.035695746541023254, -0.0021544229239225388 ]
3,594
MMAU: A Massive Multi-Task Audio Understanding and Reasoning Benchmark
https://openreview.net/forum?id=TeVAZXr3yv
[ "S Sakshi", "Utkarsh Tyagi", "Sonal Kumar", "Ashish Seth", "Ramaneswaran Selvakumar", "Oriol Nieto", "Ramani Duraiswami", "Sreyan Ghosh", "Dinesh Manocha" ]
Spotlight
The ability to comprehend audio—which includes speech, non-speech sounds, and music—is crucial for AI agents to interact effectively with the world. We present MMAU, a novel benchmark designed to evaluate multimodal audio understanding models on tasks requiring expert-level knowledge and complex reasoning. MMAU comprises 10k carefully curated audio clips paired with human-annotated natural language questions and answers spanning speech, environmental sounds, and music. It includes information extraction and reasoning questions, requiring models to demonstrate 27 distinct skills across unique and challenging tasks. Unlike existing benchmarks, MMAU emphasizes advanced perception and reasoning with domain-specific knowledge, challenging models to tackle tasks akin to those faced by experts. We assess 18 open-source and proprietary (Large) Audio-Language Models, demonstrating the significant challenges posed by MMAU. Notably, even the most advanced Gemini 2.0 Flash achieves only 59.93% accuracy, and the state-of-the-art open-source Qwen2-Audio achieves only 52.50%, highlighting considerable room for improvement. We believe MMAU will drive the audio and multimodal research community to develop more advanced audio understanding models capable of solving complex audio tasks.
Benchmark, Audio Language Models, Complex Reasoning
We introduce MMAU, a comprehensive benchmark evaluating multimodal audio understanding across speech, sound, and music, challenging models with 27 distinct skills requiring advanced perception, reasoning, and domain-specific knowledge.
3,927
2410.19168
[ 0.011316879652440548, 0.0019284902373328805, 0.009940405376255512, 0.05185704305768013, 0.016273735091090202, 0.02545955963432789, 0.051962729543447495, 0.004287828225642443, -0.029812395572662354, -0.036946240812540054, -0.00892674271017313, 0.07457785308361053, -0.06798209995031357, -0.02079782634973526, -0.0014018276706337929, 0.04278838261961937, 0.015994083136320114, -0.02296922355890274, 0.01492395717650652, 0.003628093982115388, 0.00942319631576538, -0.0013768303906545043, 0.037906937301158905, 0.021775638684630394, 0.021163104102015495, 0.01969785988330841, 0.03968541696667671, 0.02705562673509121, -0.053455155342817307, 0.031583067029714584, 0.04269982501864433, -0.0200765710324049, -0.001989186741411686, -0.03866806998848915, 0.001090218429453671, 0.015012686140835285, -0.027562495321035385, 0.03527488186955452, 0.025980737060308456, 0.023952703922986984, -0.03830965980887413, 0.02089042216539383, 0.023668643087148666, 0.009693371132016182, -0.07346558570861816, 0.007904181256890297, -0.0954737737774849, 0.04280393570661545, 0.020474862307310104, -0.01774291880428791, -0.09074895828962326, 0.0063855210319161415, -0.02084910124540329, -0.014881947077810764, 0.017782356590032578, 0.03221389278769493, 0.03481157496571541, -0.09867189824581146, 0.0014082028064876795, -0.03198821470141411, -0.01556119043380022, 0.004373742733150721, -0.0063519529066979885, -0.010626311413943768, 0.0060729216784238815, -0.02317790314555168, 0.02393234893679619, 0.034576065838336945, -0.04317595437169075, -0.01946345530450344, 0.0020306629594415426, -0.006593361031264067, -0.030970189720392227, 0.0016159816877916455, -0.02615196444094181, -0.054381489753723145, 0.05906575173139572, 0.013139152899384499, 0.04367051646113396, -0.006061412859708071, -0.021018730476498604, 0.013132098130881786, 0.0042219762690365314, 0.034460943192243576, -0.008784462697803974, -0.013616085983812809, -0.009290147572755814, 0.0009251579758711159, -0.11329309642314911, 0.048136815428733826, -0.012282137759029865, -0.069972924888134, 0.009681694209575653, 0.03744133934378624, 0.022748369723558426, 0.05981649458408356, 0.01185522973537445, 0.012229632586240768, -0.003604042110964656, 0.032610323280096054, 0.005581425037235022, -0.025258146226406097, 0.017414096742868423, 0.0259638000279665, -0.10080046951770782, 0.004665125161409378, -0.013693028129637241, -0.010488815605640411, -0.0011640891898423433, 0.015253228135406971, 0.012836077250540257, -0.011312396265566349, 0.03675880283117294, -0.02159264124929905, -0.06547030806541443, 0.03721274435520172, 0.0035377051681280136, 0.0022656070068478584, 0.005202918313443661, 0.05530991405248642, 0.07621355354785919, 0.07197807729244232, 0.006279125809669495, 0.04726119339466095, -0.01948864944279194, -0.019409000873565674, 0.007373235188424587, 0.00795416533946991, 0.019520210102200508, -0.011797908693552017, 0.012635385617613792, 0.01696530543267727, 0.02207329496741295, 0.002059027785435319, 0.012788031250238419, 0.009654896333813667, 0.05509644374251366, -0.0012116323923692107, 0.036021485924720764, 0.017930585891008377, 0.01753178983926773, -0.022320959717035294, 0.041739147156476974, -0.027860773727297783, 0.08433499932289124, -0.00291752559132874, -0.05254171043634415, -0.003224083688110113, -0.00463036447763443, -0.029355531558394432, 0.008953940123319626, 0.010144872590899467, 0.01452531386166811, -0.06222418695688248, 0.026168236508965492, 0.053065672516822815, 0.02920609898865223, -0.03291363641619682, 0.035186074674129486, -0.0013486958341673017, 0.003100710455328226, 0.014199875295162201, -0.08568935841321945, 0.014788540080189705, -0.0060371351428329945, -0.05380605161190033, -0.026089241728186607, 0.03189937397837639, -0.07163688540458679, -0.006816504523158073, -0.049864139407873154, -0.048818979412317276, 0.04966987669467926, -0.008428799919784069, -0.04861552640795708, -0.005297248717397451, 0.07356710731983185, 0.017493700608611107, 0.04037126526236534, 0.027660546824336052, -0.07376164942979813, 0.029104793444275856, -0.015604634769260883, 0.009022090584039688, 0.017712457105517387, 0.013716735877096653, 0.06112571433186531, -0.042381640523672104, 0.011793040670454502, 0.024744806811213493, -0.06439994275569916, -0.04844628646969795, 0.035050950944423676, 0.0261668860912323, 0.05895938351750374, 0.010680261068046093, -0.0158047117292881, 0.06087527424097061, 0.02361602708697319, 0.07291456311941147, 0.06496143341064453, -0.005530730355530977, 0.05317051336169243, -0.012477170675992966, -0.029774848371744156, 0.003040899755433202, 0.02505549043416977, -0.08168777078390121, -0.04198198765516281, 0.002671855967491865, -0.031042510643601418, -0.016147995367646217, 0.011954978108406067, 0.01617700234055519, 0.0019082026556134224, 0.010837510228157043, -0.012598094530403614, -0.013977926224470139, -0.014098340645432472, -0.06217186525464058, 0.04273029789328575, 0.011464433744549751, -0.005273432470858097, -0.0036254061851650476, -0.06644034385681152, 0.059239134192466736, 0.05059586092829704, -0.04675741493701935, -0.03083820641040802, 0.02847517468035221, 0.015276587568223476, 0.012381788343191147, -0.011865807697176933, -0.027780158445239067, 0.02134755812585354, -0.01982310228049755, 0.0029952675104141235, -0.012200758792459965, 0.02786440961062908, -0.011434958316385746, -0.04954924061894417, 0.04424678906798363, -0.017099516466259956, 0.055809471756219864, 0.009186322800815105, 0.005368741694837809, 0.038469910621643066, 0.005675138905644417, 0.02021384984254837, -0.030147802084684372, 0.012675744481384754, -0.00716009084135294, 0.005008524749428034, 0.00593063747510314, 0.014463464729487896, -0.055974118411540985, -0.005608664825558662, -0.03599425405263901, 0.05069609358906746, 0.024981673806905746, 0.022025901824235916, 0.050547610968351364, 0.003230608766898513, -0.032726675271987915, 0.0012974203564226627, -0.1202588677406311, -0.020374180749058723, -0.01310892403125763, 0.009522838518023491, -0.005370496306568384, 0.04452655836939812, 0.01560921873897314, 0.047056909650564194, -0.015509078279137611, -0.015037065371870995, 0.01907741092145443, 0.030981222167611122, -0.011269264854490757, -0.014727108180522919, -0.017687618732452393, 0.01107074599713087, 0.056618403643369675, -0.041851986199617386, 0.0018668193370103836, -0.007825545035302639, -0.01088047306984663, -0.004290255252271891, -0.034740157425403595, 0.015381461009383202, 0.03885355591773987, 0.003926392178982496, -0.007852692157030106, -0.031256821006536484, 0.020828919485211372, 0.0336945541203022, 0.01802043616771698, 0.05233858525753021, -0.02206166833639145, -0.03720394894480705, 0.02811935916543007, -0.01287822611629963, 0.006798468064516783, -0.0029117604717612267, -0.01520040538161993, -0.007265360094606876, -0.016656871885061264, -0.0036292660515755415, -0.010960068553686142, -0.2620859742164612, -0.020763520151376724, 0.004407445900142193, -0.026382723823189735, 0.05903298780322075, -0.05335424095392227, 0.053429313004016876, -0.05137548968195915, -0.023867979645729065, -0.029572490602731705, 0.04572281241416931, 0.043647732585668564, 0.01422363705933094, 0.04857110232114792, 0.03322743996977806, -0.008634897880256176, -0.03650995343923569, -0.0357167012989521, 0.007901236414909363, 0.029155755415558815, 0.002365097403526306, -0.0583517886698246, -0.014513570815324783, 0.03880367800593376, -0.005413133185356855, 0.011907707899808884, -0.09260957688093185, -0.013964643701910973, -0.007274888921529055, -0.030949221923947334, 0.01990625448524952, -0.004192967899143696, -0.010596910491585732, 0.04695728421211243, 0.027883335947990417, 0.03598686307668686, 0.07021594792604446, -0.0014375984901562333, 0.04463585466146469, -0.02410835586488247, 0.02523515559732914, -0.03111167810857296, 0.008492873050272465, 0.0024429536424577236, 0.048944465816020966, -0.008075091987848282, -0.04180237650871277, -0.02365589141845703, -0.025253066793084145, 0.039400842040777206, -0.03496605157852173, -0.022518934682011604, -0.05210983380675316, -0.015582412481307983, -0.0019032434793189168, -0.030704738572239876, 0.03398049622774124, 0.01184080820530653, -0.008291532285511494, -0.02410307712852955, 0.0034519231412559748, -0.029404131695628166, -0.02802232652902603, -0.004225117154419422, -0.00010932369332294911, -0.03989186882972717, -0.04688597470521927, -0.0380934476852417, 0.05950470641255379, 0.036095403134822845, -0.01923498697578907, -0.0020163252484053373, -0.02515084482729435, -0.09228742122650146, -0.02080521732568741, 0.014626329764723778, -0.021375808864831924, -0.008343067020177841, -0.006608078256249428, 0.04443366453051567, -0.05439871549606323, -0.03647146746516228, -0.008702646009624004, 0.010288583114743233, -0.01131371222436428, -0.01764734834432602, 0.009542097337543964, -0.01384423766285181, 0.011474469676613808, -0.008566629141569138, 0.02504619210958481, -0.019572164863348007, -0.012645266018807888, -0.013760880567133427, 0.05477346107363701, 0.020466076210141182, 0.013243100605905056, 0.07630310952663422, 0.02334658056497574, 0.038816023617982864, -0.004402617923915386, -0.09734980016946793, -0.0017378521151840687, -0.03244893625378609, -0.036698732525110245, -0.007917333394289017, -0.03598019853234291, -0.04247665777802467, 0.06433283537626266, 0.0018933297833427787, -0.03305288776755333, -0.04539461061358452, 0.02901892364025116, -0.0035698246210813522, -0.01265527680516243, -0.024432305246591568, 0.026881495490670204, 0.04187338054180145, 0.018610669299960136, 0.005235846620053053, -0.00044555755448527634, 0.011301709339022636, -0.03187528997659683, 0.029740747064352036, -0.013453518971800804, -0.012245972640812397, -0.012348185293376446, -0.023904772475361824, -0.009000900201499462, -0.028493370860815048, 0.0018638380570337176, 0.026370229199528694, -0.01906350627541542, 0.010759406723082066, 0.06162680685520172, -0.05068112537264824, -0.010766752064228058, -0.01323021575808525, 0.048398036509752274, -0.02254144288599491, 0.030784670263528824, -0.047442156821489334, 0.0304638110101223, 0.03574967384338379, 0.030127180740237236, 0.009668956510722637, 0.007559847552329302, -0.020194940268993378, -0.027096468955278397, -0.024002311751246452, 0.05205107107758522, -0.05497796833515167, -0.042575012892484665, -0.043154165148735046, 0.03531036153435707, 0.0016636442160233855, 0.0048559363931417465, 0.00045484540169127285, -0.017676448449492455, -0.07695676386356354, 0.04531636834144592, 0.008444759994745255, -0.017369700595736504, -0.010200909338891506, 0.03094540722668171, 0.05712046101689339, 0.013966226018965244, -0.001498707104474306, 0.019715163856744766, 0.009591251611709595, 0.0036086044274270535, -0.054210398346185684, -0.013007511384785175, -0.03764807805418968, -0.017777664586901665, 0.01956617459654808, 0.02025795727968216, -0.0115223228931427, -0.0277250986546278, 0.059143275022506714, 0.007852520793676376, -0.04289105534553528, 0.010404473170638084, -0.013310380280017853, 0.07364263385534286, 0.016206800937652588, 0.004461930599063635, -0.004050330724567175, -0.04148557037115097, -0.004416777286678553, -0.03625348210334778, 0.0063849519938230515, -0.0354715995490551, -0.0723198652267456, -0.05188320204615593, -0.054840411990880966, 0.04067867994308472, -0.008355862461030483, -0.039397191256284714, -0.016843270510435104, 0.013311970047652721, 0.0010977712227031589, -0.043225787580013275, -0.018654221668839455, 0.023999538272619247, -0.07888822257518768, -0.02357299253344536, 0.026788998395204544, -0.020422445610165596, 0.007894347421824932, -0.047847431153059006, -0.044149935245513916, -0.03317307308316231, -0.019516978412866592, -0.0010245023295283318, -0.04263725131750107, -0.027251973748207092, -0.004897064529359341, 0.004231257364153862, -0.015995044261217117, 0.012516209855675697, -0.004234209656715393, -0.016420478001236916, -0.008085773326456547, -0.0015509939985349774, 0.014778882265090942, 0.008825239725410938, 0.0033652419224381447, -0.027869295328855515, -0.04679759964346886, 0.030972499400377274, -0.015188992023468018, 0.024283401668071747, 0.05016082525253296, 0.002550580305978656, -0.015441764146089554, -0.05137050524353981, 0.0005196725833229721, 0.038822345435619354, -0.015749430283904076, 0.03051389753818512, 0.00259001855738461, -0.02093678154051304, 0.03029738739132881, 0.00043316720984876156, 0.057935457676649094, 0.031006138771772385, -0.00033737020567059517, 0.01730269007384777, 0.03202100098133087, 0.007491552736610174, 0.012716677039861679, -0.03263639286160469, -0.004006978124380112, 0.05347306281328201, -0.042020898312330246, 0.008060197345912457, -0.027124112471938133, -0.062237270176410675, 0.03524764999747276, -0.02985317073762417, 0.03737165406346321, -0.014230228029191494, 0.026880064979195595, -0.0033328537829220295, 0.006062901578843594, 0.007008252199739218, -0.0270684901624918, 0.049801964312791824, -0.04131833091378212, 0.048685040324926376, -0.0679173469543457, -0.011929123662412167, 0.06641802191734314, -0.01903059333562851, -0.0274326354265213, 0.0038467280101031065, -0.05730564892292023, 0.05392317846417427, 0.006547636352479458, -0.016635410487651825, 0.020002640783786774, -0.058978404849767685, -0.02033163420855999, 0.014816302806138992, -0.017199667170643806, 0.027713745832443237, -0.01447610929608345, 0.0002903524145949632, 0.004202663898468018, -0.018382281064987183, 0.04933130368590355, 0.008402476087212563, 0.07576200366020203, -0.015334866009652615, 0.00017167079204227775, 0.018583238124847412, 0.03722848743200302, 0.028039786964654922, 0.013376178219914436, -0.007164716254919767, 0.07129751890897751, 0.02910061739385128, 0.0353485606610775, 0.02582637220621109, -0.018322627991437912, -0.030831122770905495, -0.05639157444238663, 0.05700260400772095, -0.006047333125025034, -0.031886130571365356, -0.0578339658677578, 0.08413473516702652, 0.028235159814357758, -0.023265570402145386, 0.0013544564135372639, 0.028783565387129784, -0.06700985878705978, 0.005651431158185005, 0.0019055759767070413, -0.009003320708870888, -0.031875304877758026, 0.037558767944574356, 0.035442888736724854, 0.07845502346754074, 0.06672381609678268, 0.01982145756483078, -0.0361398421227932, 0.02059086225926876, 0.0548236146569252, 0.02838481403887272, 0.06434439867734909, -0.002374993870034814, 0.05894153192639351, -0.06709598749876022, -0.04187365248799324, 0.048759330064058304, 0.0692979171872139, -0.013409458100795746, -0.03693626448512077, 0.014008799567818642, 0.06492172181606293, -0.0010336375562474132, 0.04767807945609093, -0.051251597702503204, -0.015125058591365814, 0.04480018466711044, 0.0009193249279633164, 0.009730066172778606, 0.05351374298334122, 0.025443879887461662, 0.019929813221096992, -0.007938051596283913, -0.04243019223213196, -0.006269077304750681, -0.01156250387430191, 0.004023465793579817, 0.01409409660845995, -0.014761540107429028, 0.05293576046824455, -0.025157902389764786, 0.045768752694129944, 0.11935792863368988, -0.030941324308514595, -0.006319996900856495, 0.029310278594493866, -0.0016549366991966963, 0.02089538238942623, 0.04279917851090431, 0.006105891428887844, -0.01968979835510254, 0.001187365036457777, -0.04886367917060852, 0.014866873621940613, 0.034758228808641434, 0.008662953972816467, 0.01263496559113264, -0.07180322706699371, -0.020752158015966415, 0.027947377413511276, 0.008039784617722034, -0.019229581579566002, -0.04201885312795639, -0.04244065657258034, -0.027091410011053085, -0.03208351507782936, -0.04263174161314964, 0.03729499876499176, 0.01718861609697342, -0.05393216386437416, 0.009152751415967941, -0.027761152014136314, -0.00026681480812840164, 0.024193627759814262, -0.07118979096412659, -0.02387026883661747, 0.031219448894262314, 0.0033097148407250643, -0.034543029963970184, 0.05110451951622963, 0.02406870201230049, 0.00003640568320406601, -0.011813875287771225, 0.04122862592339516, 0.0015880361897870898, 0.012048020958900452, -0.011784608475863934, -0.036761753261089325, -0.08083789050579071, -0.002419501543045044, 0.009709503501653671, -0.017292626202106476, -0.08104640245437622, 0.007859928533434868, -0.03096090629696846, 0.04324953258037567, 0.04993389546871185, 0.015456722117960453, 0.04120203107595444, -0.021466989070177078, -0.029047342017292976, -0.004359415732324123, -0.027126740664243698, 0.04358936473727226, -0.020658379420638084, 0.09046761691570282, 0.027339687570929527, -0.016566861420869827, -0.04163408279418945, 0.054865509271621704, -0.006235420238226652, -0.012003309093415737, 0.0005053814966231585, -0.04775407537817955, -0.03205186501145363, -0.09930465370416641, -0.024662058800458908, 0.044827964156866074, -0.009618861600756645, -0.05351054295897484, 0.038821469992399216, -0.04519188404083252, -0.038261380046606064, -0.016220178455114365, -0.03707408159971237, -0.02581825666129589, -0.00770793529227376, -0.03168219327926636, -0.07953943312168121, 0.03461455553770065, -0.0287479255348444, -0.04223009571433067, -0.014995540492236614, -0.020714767277240753, -0.013936926610767841, 0.006770386826246977, 0.049543917179107666, 0.03488706424832344, 0.01786222495138645, -0.050206732004880905 ]
3,595
Higher-Order Graphon Neural Networks: Approximation and Cut Distance
https://openreview.net/forum?id=SjufxrSOYd
[ "Daniel Herbst", "Stefanie Jegelka" ]
Spotlight
Graph limit models, like *graphons* for limits of dense graphs, have recently been used to study size transferability of graph neural networks (GNNs). While most literature focuses on message passing GNNs (MPNNs), in this work we attend to the more powerful *higher-order* GNNs. First, we extend the $k$-WL test for graphons (Böker, 2023) to the graphon-signal space and introduce *signal-weighted homomorphism densities* as a key tool. As an exemplary focus, we generalize *Invariant Graph Networks* (IGNs) to graphons, proposing *Invariant Graphon Networks* (IWNs) defined via a subset of the IGN basis corresponding to bounded linear operators. Even with this restricted basis, we show that IWNs of order $k$ are at least as powerful as the $k$-WL test, and we establish universal approximation results for graphon-signals in $L^p$ distances. This significantly extends the prior work of Cai & Wang (2022), showing that IWNs—a subset of their *IGN-small*—retain effectively the same expressivity as the full IGN basis in the limit. In contrast to their approach, our blueprint of IWNs also aligns better with the geometry of graphon space, for example facilitating comparability to MPNNs. We highlight that, while typical higher-order GNNs are discontinuous w.r.t.\ cut distance—which causes their lack of convergence and is inherently tied to the definition of $k$-WL—their transferability remains comparable to MPNNs.
Graph neural networks, invariant graph networks, universal approximation, graph limits, graphons, transferability, homomorphism densities, machine learning theory.
We extend higher-order GNNs to the graphon space and investigate their continuity, expressivity, and transferability.
3,892
2503.14338
[ -0.04616660252213478, -0.018524914979934692, 0.01612442173063755, 0.04375876858830452, 0.014430951327085495, 0.023572634905576706, 0.014464152976870537, 0.014837706461548805, -0.006960997357964516, -0.05401863157749176, 0.02519471012055874, -0.0011415001936256886, -0.07351275533437729, -0.0001611077896086499, 0.04056870937347412, 0.06734038889408112, 0.03934543952345848, 0.004138530232012272, -0.0010626032017171383, 0.009290945716202259, 0.010780527256429195, -0.02911563217639923, 0.026353580877184868, 0.031048890203237534, 0.025202831253409386, 0.012088855728507042, 0.02855239436030388, -0.020248085260391235, -0.014994342811405659, 0.014814568683505058, 0.050528183579444885, 0.014176075346767902, 0.0073957862332463264, -0.06007774546742439, 0.03286522254347801, 0.001202543848194182, -0.02596983313560486, -0.004577043931931257, 0.009463743306696415, 0.02421175129711628, -0.0545518659055233, -0.005033840890973806, -0.010165243409574032, 0.023983420804142952, -0.06821589916944504, 0.02362818643450737, -0.08693066239356995, 0.024325929582118988, 0.0014836117625236511, -0.024387387558817863, -0.11830161511898041, 0.03605949133634567, 0.01252372283488512, 0.014130037277936935, 0.007679011672735214, 0.02286175824701786, 0.0203996691852808, -0.03214770555496216, -0.0011814659228548408, -0.05421796813607216, -0.01943465694785118, 0.025377366691827774, 0.033813510090112686, 0.02434616908431053, -0.022296147421002388, -0.0026656542904675007, 0.018527815118432045, 0.05245358124375343, -0.06129938364028931, -0.03903307020664215, -0.006269567180424929, 0.002937117125838995, 0.00736192287877202, 0.03561263158917427, 0.012426781468093395, -0.038950201123952866, 0.013713949359953403, -0.005389282945543528, 0.08377126604318619, 0.026953229680657387, 0.003795814933255315, 0.051358651369810104, 0.019180668517947197, 0.025290781632065773, -0.01669440045952797, 0.0032495891209691763, -0.03767475485801697, -0.030720505863428116, -0.06443338096141815, 0.04238959774374962, -0.07289906591176987, -0.04420525208115578, 0.029327036812901497, 0.0030976084526628256, 0.003994334023445845, -0.012872876599431038, 0.022019922733306885, 0.011043873615562916, 0.032792992889881134, -0.008910119533538818, -0.013942289166152477, -0.04699966683983803, 0.009506328962743282, -0.003621339797973633, -0.09796338528394699, -0.06311652809381485, -0.026808002963662148, -0.02672421932220459, 0.013199015520513058, -0.015901675447821617, -0.05271674320101738, 0.006064943969249725, 0.01785053126513958, -0.00732986768707633, -0.08727312833070755, 0.011795279569923878, 0.0003885698679368943, 0.02043537050485611, -0.012940964661538601, 0.015581682324409485, 0.03558513894677162, 0.05149875953793526, -0.0036978726275265217, 0.07722535729408264, -0.012306859716773033, 0.0003045654739253223, 0.018338432535529137, 0.03201945498585701, -0.03378060460090637, -0.045582737773656845, 0.010051814839243889, 0.05979647487401962, 0.01641417294740677, 0.02064943127334118, 0.016253633424639702, -0.06516812741756439, -0.020807137712836266, 0.01429175864905119, 0.004408609122037888, 0.003917313646525145, 0.029030557721853256, -0.018228240311145782, 0.057504527270793915, -0.028347602114081383, 0.08223775774240494, -0.04735959321260452, -0.01662381924688816, -0.04689513146877289, -0.011946682818233967, -0.02151171676814556, -0.006178510375320911, -0.007691989652812481, -0.013111705891788006, -0.03775687515735626, 0.005103367380797863, 0.031187649816274643, 0.026050372049212456, 0.06077878922224045, -0.022624840959906578, -0.008141370490193367, 0.03507512807846069, -0.019034171476960182, -0.0007660830160602927, 0.026039835065603256, -0.024230798706412315, -0.05112156271934509, 0.007362942211329937, 0.06390074640512466, -0.03938828408718109, -0.0038569134194403887, -0.00995250791311264, -0.0402073934674263, 0.04895135015249252, -0.0013471560087054968, -0.020364727824926376, -0.017658768221735954, 0.061459723860025406, 0.00374911492690444, 0.03071688860654831, 0.02917695976793766, -0.08318863064050674, 0.04045700654387474, 0.023852337151765823, 0.01633896306157112, -0.033066097646951675, -0.012505928054451942, 0.08096086978912354, -0.02547566220164299, 0.008651659823954105, 0.015739981085062027, -0.055060453712940216, 0.007023594807833433, 0.011851691640913486, -0.039785392582416534, 0.09173683077096939, 0.0109060388058424, -0.0070055690594017506, 0.01259539183229208, 0.019153492525219917, 0.02583150379359722, 0.055265653878450394, -0.024259425699710846, 0.04495905339717865, -0.009735648520290852, -0.052212007343769073, 0.009189369156956673, 0.016579443588852882, -0.04895109310746193, -0.03895799443125725, 0.0165900569409132, 0.01024362538009882, -0.024775030091404915, 0.018760813400149345, -0.00037763366708531976, 0.02737073041498661, -0.007074048742651939, -0.01703925058245659, -0.00410261657088995, 0.049078598618507385, -0.03678451478481293, 0.04486998915672302, 0.018877476453781128, -0.034325528889894485, 0.014487330801784992, -0.03617096692323685, 0.10738766938447952, 0.08417674899101257, -0.025803131982684135, -0.021487802267074585, 0.021573903039097786, 0.01119922287762165, 0.01597178913652897, -0.0014413809403777122, -0.013005886226892471, 0.0019859301391988993, -0.034945469349622726, 0.0008662162581458688, -0.05366512015461922, 0.05970748886466026, -0.04243699461221695, -0.0105125205591321, 0.07518744468688965, -0.022001149132847786, 0.05419667065143585, 0.006389165297150612, 0.018520133569836617, 0.044032491743564606, -0.025379199534654617, 0.0019826486241072416, 0.013631860725581646, -0.015855439007282257, -0.004403519909828901, 0.02974788472056389, -0.008992962539196014, 0.009299569763243198, -0.03484942764043808, 0.008725094608962536, 0.005836935248225927, 0.07933291792869568, 0.05803433805704117, 0.049143947660923004, -0.02690029889345169, -0.0163081344217062, -0.013477428816258907, -0.05115363374352455, -0.11781839281320572, -0.054231055080890656, -0.01863485760986805, 0.062150198966264725, 0.009267750196158886, 0.05178036168217659, -0.003705296665430069, 0.021216822788119316, -0.008226297795772552, -0.02155466377735138, 0.004465414676815271, -0.004310439806431532, 0.020166030153632164, -0.07292816042900085, -0.029507622122764587, 0.0008615421247668564, 0.08974302560091019, -0.02298116497695446, -0.01206967793405056, -0.022203611209988594, -0.04998564347624779, -0.028849320486187935, -0.03704723343253136, 0.0017454014159739017, 0.004210709594190121, -0.0001951495505636558, -0.0018463871674612164, -0.009439484216272831, 0.009279226884245872, 0.04360543563961983, 0.025866124778985977, 0.05778663232922554, -0.01675616204738617, -0.012595226988196373, -0.0012627928517758846, -0.018695557489991188, 0.0428520105779171, -0.006256606429815292, 0.008475073613226414, -0.025044791400432587, 0.006645310204476118, 0.018788810819387436, -0.0014849946601316333, -0.27795708179473877, 0.020961744710803032, 0.01744435355067253, -0.02174893207848072, 0.015923932194709778, -0.019552288576960564, 0.03305872529745102, -0.01944248378276825, -0.031047217547893524, 0.015805602073669434, -0.017954055219888687, 0.012648476287722588, -0.007544389460235834, 0.03941766172647476, 0.029330438002943993, 0.01280913595110178, -0.005557996686547995, -0.005856057163327932, 0.03055049292743206, 0.03700427711009979, -0.03839169442653656, -0.07239030301570892, -0.0237744003534317, 0.01405633520334959, -0.010002381168305874, 0.006235705688595772, -0.09012867510318756, -0.01003600936383009, -0.03897807002067566, -0.0003280322125647217, -0.029952382668852806, -0.0016452553682029247, 0.0005269211251288652, 0.05506794899702072, 0.0039474088698625565, -0.013049343600869179, 0.01595359481871128, -0.03246089443564415, -0.013815722428262234, 0.00020597096590790898, 0.005958016496151686, 0.007815084420144558, -0.006518320646136999, 0.030561957508325577, 0.0846676304936409, 0.007837929762899876, -0.040122680366039276, 0.03222343698143959, 0.0006623092340305448, 0.029297495260834694, -0.029862919822335243, -0.049527108669281006, 0.009039956144988537, -0.014020436443388462, 0.0035192715004086494, -0.02207300253212452, -0.013266523368656635, 0.008074432611465454, -0.029959946870803833, 0.01535626407712698, -0.002509075915440917, -0.040408674627542496, 0.003269264940172434, -0.020256346091628075, -0.044899553060531616, -0.030674125999212265, -0.08271446824073792, -0.06092458590865135, 0.03281796723604202, -0.013430554419755936, 0.015294253826141357, 0.026812579482793808, -0.02544804848730564, -0.08850590139627457, 0.007853109389543533, 0.001956575084477663, -0.025407055392861366, 0.013006172142922878, 0.029356293380260468, 0.0662245824933052, -0.03633597493171692, -0.03906762972474098, -0.01723937876522541, 0.04495399817824364, -0.008176482282578945, 0.023833276703953743, 0.008092282339930534, -0.022288881242275238, -0.027080800384283066, -0.03749396651983261, 0.021957028657197952, -0.010552373714745045, 0.053559280931949615, -0.019220661371946335, 0.05934908986091614, -0.0014636507257819176, 0.05783182010054588, 0.03985689580440521, 0.04058646038174629, 0.012306181713938713, 0.02783515863120556, -0.06087927147746086, -0.023758308961987495, -0.021378852427005768, -0.023600636050105095, 0.0474180206656456, -0.03834470734000206, 0.0012117016594856977, 0.037274621427059174, 0.003443709574639797, -0.030127840116620064, -0.05265580490231514, 0.00528092822059989, -0.02479207143187523, -0.03947965055704117, -0.02175309881567955, -0.018481848761439323, 0.025083957239985466, -0.0026778187602758408, -0.0337412990629673, -0.03354144096374512, 0.05688273534178734, -0.04749035835266113, 0.007362562697380781, -0.002316776430234313, 0.003471777541562915, -0.02553858421742916, -0.039918456226587296, -0.010607446543872356, -0.0008429010049439967, 0.014558617025613785, 0.061129987239837646, 0.020038381218910217, 0.027916718274354935, 0.06178965047001839, 0.014716139994561672, -0.012319509871304035, -0.010165086947381496, 0.051324471831321716, -0.009915568865835667, 0.015726173296570778, 0.035486530512571335, 0.04067084565758705, 0.0002047792513621971, 0.014601476490497589, 0.02369377389550209, 0.013270490802824497, -0.013332371599972248, -0.008672133088111877, 0.0016984370304271579, 0.027782995253801346, -0.05031874030828476, -0.005838902201503515, -0.01651098020374775, 0.0204685777425766, 0.0031643621623516083, 0.05188092216849327, 0.01877911575138569, 0.02346033602952957, -0.06340246647596359, 0.0702928900718689, 0.005457018036395311, -0.029083453118801117, -0.00563056068494916, 0.004147097002714872, 0.05129455775022507, -0.024366218596696854, 0.008421488106250763, 0.014841179363429546, -0.01893574744462967, 0.021121099591255188, 0.018879981711506844, -0.0436432883143425, 0.01672496646642685, -0.005987315438687801, 0.03584577515721321, 0.0059648845344781876, -0.0049855709075927734, -0.012348521500825882, 0.022821670398116112, 0.00919115636497736, -0.019500700756907463, -0.009773260913789272, 0.0276133231818676, 0.07706573605537415, 0.008426009677350521, 0.008699665777385235, -0.0020054630003869534, -0.011630984023213387, 0.04807569459080696, 0.0009505249909125268, 0.03686204552650452, -0.04723995923995972, -0.028853612020611763, -0.02219426818192005, -0.022208476439118385, 0.0292610265314579, 0.016116958111524582, -0.014310725033283234, -0.0208002720028162, 0.0007354601402767003, 0.004023819230496883, -0.05224854499101639, 0.012614757753908634, 0.041562650352716446, -0.06708908826112747, 0.013755560852587223, 0.03389514610171318, 0.0032044013496488333, 0.006380140315741301, -0.025756701827049255, -0.0256696455180645, -0.05306130647659302, -0.006267520599067211, 0.02528315596282482, 0.019634727388620377, -0.017310310155153275, 0.0034353872761130333, 0.007481491658836603, -0.021616816520690918, 0.0008490080945193768, 0.0009120444301515818, 0.026867881417274475, -0.027803625911474228, 0.013872559182345867, 0.08607877045869827, -0.00342502910643816, 0.022791430354118347, -0.018158141523599625, -0.03370128571987152, 0.013473020866513252, -0.037559546530246735, 0.005502437707036734, 0.040267590433359146, 0.012460780330002308, 0.003241811180487275, -0.07007317245006561, 0.035190287977457047, -0.04356164112687111, -0.03151193633675575, 0.005022747442126274, -0.004305396229028702, -0.042590729892253876, 0.0011762898648157716, -0.0003368378966115415, 0.03727274760603905, 0.011936497874557972, 0.003329602302983403, -0.0048346505500376225, -0.0069770608097314835, -0.004693272057920694, -0.008628733456134796, -0.053027138113975525, -0.0028977112378925085, 0.07115773856639862, -0.021749477833509445, -0.03226893022656441, -0.05707535520195961, -0.019830575212836266, 0.03315538540482521, -0.0566498264670372, 0.02304876036942005, -0.02626749686896801, 0.03640393167734146, 0.02108677662909031, 0.03314562886953354, 0.007173219695687294, -0.018726039677858353, 0.02328839711844921, -0.04095393046736717, 0.015759821981191635, -0.06557052582502365, -0.02803157828748226, 0.024148624390363693, -0.029574822634458542, 0.009365588426589966, 0.001951643731445074, 0.008733424358069897, 0.014614773914217949, -0.029755862429738045, -0.05004870891571045, 0.008397625759243965, -0.021534400060772896, -0.012111738324165344, 0.03747635334730148, -0.03731132671236992, -0.019533148035407066, -0.02204788848757744, -0.05968756601214409, 0.0005971756181679666, 0.002457738621160388, 0.022786209359765053, -0.0075121717527508736, 0.0013899133773520589, -0.014791416935622692, -0.0007666786550544202, 0.0526193305850029, 0.07601655274629593, 0.02336183190345764, 0.043597254902124405, -0.040569815784692764, 0.046964745968580246, 0.05575820803642273, 0.015866078436374664, 0.014418655075132847, 0.046997688710689545, -0.032278575003147125, -0.06128722429275513, 0.07354346662759781, 0.011737173423171043, -0.033309727907180786, -0.06675662845373154, 0.05219690129160881, -0.0032115858048200607, -0.052596110850572586, -0.016681190580129623, 0.032918401062488556, -0.04995628446340561, 0.008148864842951298, -0.007777881808578968, -0.0021096121054142714, -0.011274095624685287, 0.06298688799142838, -0.01358251366764307, 0.00554956030100584, 0.07329816371202469, -0.008862512186169624, -0.002229740610346198, -0.039544105529785156, 0.06748224794864655, 0.06132569536566734, 0.046118251979351044, -0.024703439325094223, 0.06363902240991592, -0.03053283877670765, -0.05323527008295059, -0.020175784826278687, 0.015297597274184227, -0.011523268185555935, -0.014995119534432888, 0.01832888461649418, 0.09147541224956512, -0.025278251618146896, 0.09529361873865128, -0.04897404462099075, 0.012050213292241096, 0.009045293554663658, 0.004971913527697325, 0.0021130621898919344, 0.051947157829999924, 0.023859504610300064, 0.020887361839413643, -0.028463365510106087, -0.007169492542743683, -0.020074009895324707, -0.02585127018392086, 0.03475193679332733, 0.010975055396556854, -0.0038667581975460052, 0.014832457527518272, 0.03156125545501709, 0.044409073889255524, 0.10350093245506287, -0.04265379533171654, -0.051615603268146515, 0.0036903375294059515, 0.012470007874071598, 0.020037176087498665, 0.01606399193406105, 0.02431381121277809, -0.036398254334926605, 0.015790842473506927, -0.029688160866498947, 0.022556081414222717, -0.020588034763932228, -0.010576711967587471, -0.008429070003330708, 0.0007672635256312788, -0.04018724337220192, -0.001409249845892191, 0.02612701803445816, -0.006598432548344135, -0.048222269862890244, -0.01363358087837696, -0.06290198117494583, -0.050039682537317276, -0.04908132180571556, 0.030096763744950294, -0.030337007716298103, -0.043215736746788025, 0.012002193368971348, -0.017081035301089287, -0.005037314258515835, 0.03862212970852852, -0.06582784652709961, -0.004590116906911135, 0.03094630315899849, 0.017516419291496277, 0.004412105772644281, 0.03714429959654808, 0.04450664669275284, -0.023301955312490463, -0.018028782680630684, 0.05991343408823013, 0.02229270152747631, 0.03192921355366707, 0.017256779596209526, 0.009210179559886456, -0.11922591924667358, -0.0069578574039042, -0.016501534730196, -0.0630670040845871, -0.08182596415281296, 0.029324432834982872, -0.015525930561125278, 0.001856930204667151, 0.05634317547082901, 0.01752926968038082, 0.004030726384371519, -0.05827784165740013, 0.00972980447113514, -0.003324992023408413, -0.018115470185875893, 0.06447532773017883, -0.013928312808275223, 0.06018621474504471, 0.04000267758965492, -0.03668951988220215, -0.007808902766555548, 0.018910910934209824, -0.004555404186248779, 0.031169814988970757, -0.050555966794490814, -0.0319981724023819, -0.008560053072869778, -0.10546205937862396, -0.010168989188969135, 0.010509503073990345, 0.014897014945745468, -0.036978960037231445, -0.016427231952548027, -0.02223466895520687, -0.014349113218486309, 0.011704931035637856, -0.04377502202987671, -0.016860809177160263, -0.02836134284734726, -0.03491233289241791, -0.08300784230232239, 0.016269603744149208, -0.0015675820177420974, -0.0033761803060770035, -0.03696705773472786, -0.05735965073108673, -0.05176905170083046, -0.02948320470750332, 0.023862658068537712, 0.007553427014499903, 0.02924063801765442, 0.012109344825148582 ]
3,596
Towards General-Purpose Model-Free Reinforcement Learning
https://openreview.net/forum?id=R1hIXdST22
[ "Scott Fujimoto", "Pierluca D'Oro", "Amy Zhang", "Yuandong Tian", "Michael Rabbat" ]
Spotlight
Reinforcement learning (RL) promises a framework for near-universal problem-solving. In practice however, RL algorithms are often tailored to specific benchmarks, relying on carefully tuned hyperparameters and algorithmic choices. Recently, powerful model-based RL methods have shown impressive general results across benchmarks but come at the cost of increased complexity and slow run times, limiting their broader applicability. In this paper, we attempt to find a unifying model-free deep RL algorithm that can address a diverse class of domains and problem settings. To achieve this, we leverage model-based representations that approximately linearize the value function, taking advantage of the denser task objectives used by model-based RL while avoiding the costs associated with planning or simulated trajectories. We evaluate our algorithm, MR.Q, on a variety of common RL benchmarks with a single set of hyperparameters and show a competitive performance against domain-specific and general baselines, providing a concrete step towards building general-purpose model-free deep RL algorithms.
Deep reinforcement learning, model-free, general-purpose
We introduce a model-free RL algorithm with a strong performance on a variety of popular benchmarks.
3,889
2501.16142
[ -0.027179960161447525, -0.01819242350757122, 0.015427827835083008, 0.03989607095718384, 0.03984253108501434, 0.014205673709511757, 0.014645908959209919, 0.001908756559714675, -0.03336429223418236, -0.02337615005671978, -0.0305367149412632, 0.03030504658818245, -0.09949009865522385, -0.006582051049917936, 0.025560298934578896, 0.07563858479261398, 0.002618307713419199, -0.0027025786694139242, -0.014174634590744972, -0.0010748732602223754, -0.01049506850540638, 0.014759659767150879, 0.02950596809387207, 0.028946753591299057, 0.029377005994319916, -0.0024128914810717106, 0.05189608782529831, 0.03450055792927742, -0.011960453353822231, -0.012304260395467281, 0.03903903439640999, -0.009329850785434246, 0.015020887367427349, -0.035032134503126144, 0.0022969397250562906, -0.009172420017421246, -0.02773885615170002, -0.0041754539124667645, 0.018275052309036255, -0.018393373116850853, -0.03419012948870659, 0.02206537500023842, -0.033400651067495346, 0.015449797734618187, -0.015898432582616806, 0.016868827864527702, -0.08746388554573059, 0.016360322013497353, 0.04050176590681076, -0.05694611370563507, -0.08995463699102402, 0.04221693053841591, 0.028581339865922928, -0.03879961743950844, -0.025714518502354622, 0.037361182272434235, 0.024325575679540634, -0.0954400822520256, -0.01409266795963049, -0.07856833934783936, -0.013673094101250172, 0.03219912573695183, 0.0205057505518198, 0.009812097065150738, -0.003676318097859621, 0.016529610380530357, 0.030492939054965973, 0.04144898056983948, -0.04214857891201973, -0.0027772309258580208, -0.03502551093697548, -0.03937132656574249, -0.0022162904497236013, 0.01749393343925476, -0.015340900979936123, -0.04434899613261223, 0.03429614007472992, 0.031619586050510406, 0.05818147957324982, -0.0006201149080879986, 0.022190069779753685, 0.028472494333982468, 0.003674539038911462, 0.0263285543769598, 0.02060534432530403, 0.017522355541586876, -0.04089431092143059, -0.04240051656961441, -0.08828850090503693, 0.04058177024126053, -0.02420441247522831, -0.046758342534303665, -0.00866861641407013, 0.04946508631110191, -0.012553720735013485, -0.005409482400864363, 0.0070178089663386345, 0.0265988577157259, -0.001234432915225625, -0.010622617788612843, -0.02591678500175476, -0.02129269205033779, 0.03153621777892113, -0.029434166848659515, -0.09226325154304504, -0.03424912691116333, -0.0010767431231215596, -0.017768895253539085, -0.01194339245557785, 0.01356035191565752, -0.07012409716844559, -0.02067870832979679, 0.021776344627141953, -0.04351602494716644, -0.0674809142947197, 0.024440212175250053, 0.00005895703725400381, 0.04683399572968483, 0.0015406992752104998, 0.021206969395279884, 0.02722853422164917, 0.0037030724342912436, -0.018205229192972183, 0.05117276310920715, 0.016024865210056305, 0.012306243181228638, 0.01640406623482704, 0.026169903576374054, -0.021289052441716194, -0.06328371912240982, 0.03320169448852539, 0.018780430778861046, -0.009492503479123116, 0.001655049156397581, -0.024230629205703735, -0.026523306965827942, 0.013927830383181572, 0.006934736389666796, -0.00014980205742176622, 0.010704796761274338, -0.017441097646951675, -0.01254927646368742, 0.11132302135229111, -0.032186850905418396, 0.08602762967348099, -0.016558853909373283, 0.0017578615806996822, -0.004757835064083338, -0.04196983575820923, -0.006525276694446802, 0.0030379025265574455, 0.02443614788353443, -0.03738654777407646, -0.06592420488595963, 0.05230490490794182, 0.056813646107912064, 0.001751704839989543, 0.012582461349666119, 0.007048660423606634, 0.007403348106890917, 0.01761237531900406, -0.004866308532655239, -0.05830151215195656, -0.01365434005856514, 0.023548994213342667, -0.07543207705020905, 0.06617013365030289, 0.030843794345855713, -0.020947735756635666, -0.03564410284161568, -0.027442002668976784, -0.03910784050822258, 0.03496359661221504, 0.011726299300789833, -0.023323914036154747, 0.003895343281328678, 0.06540347635746002, -0.010771194472908974, 0.038365330547094345, -0.01530113723129034, -0.08732769638299942, 0.003141752677038312, 0.015430052764713764, -0.020648404955863953, 0.0028529574628919363, -0.044033706188201904, 0.07326427847146988, -0.00961690116673708, 0.01838027499616146, 0.008672477677464485, -0.07270907610654831, -0.012171412818133831, 0.01974240131676197, -0.0070230974815785885, 0.06540865451097488, 0.03669910505414009, -0.03929555043578148, 0.05296897888183594, 0.015247601084411144, 0.058824192732572556, 0.056563038378953934, -0.010898775421082973, 0.03693082183599472, 0.006866698153316975, -0.020224586129188538, -0.025435471907258034, 0.027789302170276642, -0.05631546303629875, -0.018606355413794518, 0.0043564955703914165, -0.01908002607524395, 0.0007346778875216842, -0.0034608780406415462, -0.013973853550851345, 0.005895867943763733, 0.014240661635994911, 0.008260988630354404, 0.003321412717923522, 0.02264406904578209, -0.06074490398168564, 0.020009750500321388, -0.004756750073283911, -0.04006781056523323, -0.015677545219659805, -0.02779730036854744, 0.09080490469932556, 0.06069585308432579, -0.03561101108789444, -0.019209330901503563, 0.01818925514817238, 0.00457353051751852, 0.025495056062936783, 0.025170674547553062, -0.03839074820280075, 0.03391428664326668, -0.006558994762599468, -0.0014366403920575976, -0.017873596400022507, 0.021312899887561798, -0.02313576079905033, -0.011521751992404461, 0.07907943427562714, 0.00991168525069952, 0.07652150094509125, -0.0025349250063300133, 0.006033544894307852, 0.01748676598072052, 0.006931315176188946, -0.014768936671316624, -0.04087565466761589, -0.07181094586849213, -0.002950273687019944, 0.021893994882702827, 0.017848631367087364, 0.011447916738688946, -0.055834170430898666, -0.021857086569070816, -0.024854319170117378, 0.0515010729432106, 0.05461641773581505, 0.008460359647870064, 0.03845199942588806, -0.020910728722810745, -0.009229465387761593, -0.01710311509668827, -0.10319206863641739, -0.03805514797568321, 0.012223715893924236, 0.04583914950489998, 0.037367936223745346, -0.0017610377399250865, -0.009554329328238964, 0.04437384009361267, 0.00031869550002738833, -0.05745431035757065, 0.0002260007313452661, 0.03638479486107826, 0.0255779717117548, -0.03875693306326866, -0.025988470762968063, 0.02679712325334549, 0.06061756610870361, -0.016367945820093155, -0.015115085989236832, -0.01953250728547573, -0.011527543887495995, 0.009319834411144257, -0.029737399891018867, -0.021027039736509323, 0.009314369410276413, 0.02530526928603649, 0.027934763580560684, -0.03649912029504776, 0.02957829087972641, 0.03295989707112312, 0.07081189006567001, 0.046196211129426956, 0.023073580116033554, 0.010973315685987473, 0.017389072105288506, -0.026877406984567642, 0.0012692945310845971, -0.027493715286254883, 0.004273473285138607, 0.02159968763589859, 0.009290957823395729, 0.012351782992482185, 0.02504970319569111, -0.2505835294723511, -0.03698405995965004, -0.003700624220073223, 0.015645449981093407, 0.030793949961662292, 0.00352098629809916, 0.04230958968400955, -0.021178973838686943, -0.014196421019732952, 0.02384244278073311, 0.02664591372013092, 0.003675539279356599, 0.009204495698213577, 0.07143308967351913, 0.059322647750377655, 0.027126051485538483, 0.026005955412983894, -0.0069985827431082726, 0.0024937002453953028, 0.028793204575777054, -0.015252215787768364, -0.08249258249998093, -0.011012590490281582, 0.023001112043857574, -0.006241652183234692, 0.07630464434623718, -0.07028178870677948, -0.005064401775598526, -0.022417334839701653, -0.013477383181452751, -0.023597247898578644, -0.023336272686719894, -0.045750442892313004, 0.024717627093195915, 0.023154817521572113, 0.022539107128977776, 0.025255367159843445, -0.0008914375212043524, 0.04302668571472168, 0.033750906586647034, -0.02290964499115944, -0.01123000681400299, -0.02543182112276554, 0.029858767986297607, 0.0677807405591011, 0.015388988889753819, -0.053686436265707016, -0.02202630043029785, -0.018041133880615234, 0.027113592252135277, 0.00010065620153909549, -0.008091685362160206, 0.017399437725543976, 0.019831962883472443, 0.026783520355820656, -0.023613668978214264, 0.0005895424983464181, -0.02538912370800972, 0.0006674168398603797, 0.009572717361152172, 0.022958846762776375, -0.0424669124186039, -0.03699628636240959, -0.030119771137833595, -0.013278160244226456, -0.03591672331094742, -0.055727049708366394, -0.05731688067317009, 0.015265144407749176, 0.055510830134153366, -0.00461636483669281, -0.010786514729261398, -0.026716189458966255, -0.08513029664754868, 0.009573216550052166, 0.012773393653333187, -0.0012396253878250718, -0.04180105775594711, 0.016549766063690186, 0.05016428604722023, -0.04482043907046318, -0.07799456268548965, -0.022726114839315414, 0.011207954958081245, 0.03583219274878502, -0.02296811155974865, 0.01914510317146778, -0.05418018996715546, -0.03047732450067997, -0.036970946937799454, 0.020846212282776833, 0.014642920345067978, 0.05062367394566536, -0.01864634081721306, 0.06563499569892883, 0.035976652055978775, 0.03803255036473274, 0.029691500589251518, 0.02913711592555046, -0.00815415009856224, -0.014756251126527786, -0.08619818091392517, 0.012275596149265766, -0.025634320452809334, -0.03997069597244263, 0.021444061771035194, -0.06399549543857574, -0.03958564251661301, 0.03712735325098038, 0.011643840000033379, -0.008835534565150738, -0.04865441471338272, -0.00480255763977766, -0.0070833503268659115, -0.027173642069101334, -0.00628462852910161, 0.007968871854245663, 0.027417950332164764, 0.04092951491475105, -0.0034217212814837694, -0.06403879821300507, 0.04242024943232536, -0.029389875009655952, 0.03750722110271454, -0.010403752326965332, -0.02165963500738144, 0.0388866625726223, 0.0024192535784095526, 0.01583046466112137, -0.020858734846115112, 0.021864524111151695, 0.06120676174759865, -0.02721870131790638, 0.01093701459467411, 0.058347463607788086, -0.007380204740911722, 0.012696538120508194, -0.0028925761580467224, 0.027429575100541115, -0.009089944884181023, 0.02614360675215721, -0.008334636688232422, 0.027324972674250603, 0.018161721527576447, -0.010667361319065094, 0.03637770190834999, 0.024166252464056015, 0.013575089164078236, 0.009783366695046425, 0.007148127071559429, 0.030467038974165916, -0.05701657012104988, 0.007862419821321964, -0.044835545122623444, 0.052247196435928345, -0.01935356855392456, 0.03841889649629593, -0.053110163658857346, 0.008745557628571987, -0.06862925738096237, 0.01848882995545864, -0.010420751757919788, -0.041744038462638855, -0.004626374691724777, 0.028106743469834328, 0.07637041807174683, -0.018971998244524002, -0.019348738715052605, 0.006799475289881229, -0.005453731399029493, 0.014117598533630371, -0.04719463735818863, -0.013408406637609005, -0.010530645959079266, -0.03651545196771622, -0.01948261819779873, 0.016788683831691742, -0.0352897122502327, -0.013642515987157822, 0.030048971995711327, 0.01764867827296257, -0.04812376946210861, 0.003420264692977071, -0.010385601781308651, 0.05336439982056618, -0.01923481747508049, 0.01631709560751915, 0.02396972104907036, -0.03747812286019325, 0.023359183222055435, 0.014279644936323166, 0.028751308098435402, -0.02500850334763527, -0.04217710718512535, -0.03148507699370384, -0.016584662720561028, 0.00271145929582417, 0.025450732558965683, -0.006534757558256388, 0.01777867041528225, -0.006467674858868122, -0.007818654179573059, -0.020688572898507118, -0.0005137533880770206, 0.04804803803563118, -0.0740264505147934, -0.0013821541797369719, 0.05163939669728279, 0.0020709349773824215, 0.07032182067632675, -0.07746457308530807, -0.06233799085021019, -0.04251115024089813, -0.028574496507644653, -0.006977187003940344, -0.0031890019308775663, -0.002087055006995797, 0.00010137542267329991, -0.021419189870357513, 0.016554737463593483, 0.017562076449394226, -0.0070565263740718365, -0.0076885526068508625, -0.03932688385248184, 0.0024310476146638393, 0.05471382290124893, -0.03709079697728157, -0.033781662583351135, 0.010779934003949165, -0.0008606099872849882, 0.032761458307504654, -0.037695836275815964, 0.0013393424451351166, 0.030787615105509758, -0.00014999358973000199, 0.013160066679120064, -0.052963417023420334, 0.07322859764099121, -0.021589258685708046, -0.035287436097860336, -0.011619429104030132, 0.01819811575114727, -0.03714020922780037, -0.006756280083209276, 0.00641202786937356, 0.012331780046224594, 0.03308377414941788, 0.021014532074332237, 0.03365156799554825, -0.015492154285311699, 0.01687738113105297, -0.0006825246964581311, -0.04378622770309448, 0.0038035043980926275, 0.07290887832641602, -0.015251592732965946, -0.0029548245947808027, -0.04216405376791954, 0.0014666932402178645, 0.025746436789631844, -0.03573214262723923, 0.024292102083563805, -0.054083798080682755, 0.04114512726664543, 0.029954468831419945, 0.04844227433204651, 0.021468544378876686, -0.02593059651553631, 0.06450177729129791, -0.054803695529699326, 0.01096491888165474, -0.06976673752069473, -0.022076064720749855, 0.06812525540590286, -0.027951685711741447, 0.018773509189486504, 0.01110311970114708, -0.023537397384643555, 0.02900071255862713, -0.011915977112948895, -0.06257924437522888, 0.03674681484699249, -0.023691600188612938, -0.02528025023639202, 0.04326579347252846, -0.04396314546465874, -0.037291284650564194, -0.002608403330668807, -0.04064648598432541, 0.008464166894555092, 0.030470071360468864, 0.03136615455150604, -0.016366608440876007, 0.01242571510374546, -0.030022308230400085, 0.01607470028102398, -0.00003979599932790734, 0.04409240931272507, 0.029423609375953674, 0.03612014651298523, -0.03320140391588211, 0.0639207512140274, 0.01619606651365757, 0.03781920671463013, -0.00272549781948328, 0.016216589137911797, -0.011095079593360424, -0.034578513354063034, 0.050758082419633865, -0.008818167261779308, -0.002273295074701309, -0.056899718940258026, 0.05754275247454643, 0.016457997262477875, -0.048699215054512024, -0.006012354511767626, 0.009737861342728138, -0.07758500427007675, -0.0006612415891140699, 0.018819577991962433, -0.007690614089369774, 0.028346536681056023, 0.07621350139379501, 0.03699802979826927, 0.05597088485956192, 0.08355414122343063, 0.04319712147116661, -0.017562296241521835, 0.007496751844882965, 0.05888587608933449, 0.053780972957611084, 0.031069548800587654, -0.042587023228406906, 0.05096954479813576, -0.043433692306280136, -0.04828966408967972, 0.04462415352463722, 0.011646517552435398, -0.025974391028285027, -0.04918419197201729, 0.03041621670126915, 0.04327601194381714, -0.004536706954240799, 0.04398444667458534, -0.051918622106313705, -0.03660163655877113, 0.07784909754991531, 0.0031528554391115904, -0.009499847888946533, 0.04730826988816261, 0.03580396994948387, 0.0231857281178236, -0.0010809554951265454, -0.0480850413441658, -0.008852623403072357, -0.003737931838259101, 0.005967640317976475, 0.02515134960412979, -0.02842801809310913, -0.008412427268922329, 0.03312094137072563, 0.03598123788833618, 0.12615948915481567, -0.05329558253288269, -0.013162062503397465, -0.01364332064986229, -0.005794233176857233, 0.015368585474789143, 0.002118336036801338, 0.0024427990429103374, -0.04392480477690697, 0.013013939373195171, -0.025707831606268883, 0.018815839663147926, 0.03500097617506981, 0.004096591379493475, 0.018557604402303696, -0.037061143666505814, -0.037483908236026764, 0.007818522863090038, 0.021203547716140747, -0.03525634855031967, -0.045517340302467346, -0.053181249648332596, -0.04879121109843254, -0.049184758216142654, -0.06541112065315247, -0.004098621197044849, 0.009900405071675777, -0.03812936320900917, 0.007328590843826532, -0.03606017306447029, 0.001607595942914486, 0.01885155588388443, -0.03608730807900429, -0.014937218278646469, 0.03272201120853424, -0.009308664128184319, 0.011151955462992191, 0.030602706596255302, 0.030222244560718536, 0.012939009815454483, -0.02197905257344246, 0.004002484027296305, -0.01345317903906107, 0.002182006137445569, -0.014996367506682873, -0.02947711944580078, -0.09083318710327148, -0.01001063734292984, 0.026900537312030792, -0.015081163495779037, -0.08736614137887955, 0.02003568597137928, -0.04640330746769905, 0.04084671288728714, 0.08294454962015152, 0.017066633328795433, 0.01928999461233616, -0.014997572638094425, -0.013941018842160702, 0.013300346210598946, -0.006114640738815069, 0.030736038461327553, -0.039871275424957275, 0.04661142826080322, 0.05975906923413277, -0.026083780452609062, -0.05924917012453079, 0.05430223047733307, 0.02000180445611477, -0.03030826523900032, -0.008629455231130123, -0.040514279156923294, -0.01619318313896656, -0.09237798303365707, -0.009638040326535702, 0.053252000361680984, 0.012367167510092258, -0.0249326154589653, -0.005467939656227827, -0.014277136884629726, 0.01633087359368801, -0.004079763311892748, -0.07248901575803757, -0.019258303567767143, -0.016961777582764626, -0.03587314859032631, -0.06793306767940521, 0.028717752546072006, -0.036293644458055496, 0.001965428004041314, -0.0395154133439064, -0.029469389468431473, 0.0012974627315998077, -0.00671354541555047, 0.01772085763514042, -0.013359501026570797, 0.006533687002956867, -0.004551723599433899 ]
3,597
Multi-Field Adaptive Retrieval
https://openreview.net/forum?id=3PDklqqqfN
[ "Millicent Li", "Tongfei Chen", "Benjamin Van Durme", "Patrick Xia" ]
Spotlight
Document retrieval for tasks such as search and retrieval-augmented generation typically involves datasets that are _unstructured_: free-form text without explicit internal structure in each document. However, documents can have some structure, containing fields such as an article title, a message body, or an HTML header. To address this gap, we introduce Multi-Field Adaptive Retrieval (mFAR), a flexible framework that accommodates any number and any type of document indices on _semi-structured_ data. Our framework consists of two main steps: (1) the decomposition of an existing document into fields, each indexed independently through dense and lexical methods, and (2) learning a model which adaptively predicts the importance of a field by conditioning on the document query, allowing on-the-fly weighting of the most likely field(s). We find that our approach allows for the optimized use of dense versus lexical representations across field types, significantly improves in document ranking over a number of existing retrievers, and achieves state-of-the-art performance for multi-field structured data.
information retrieval, hybrid retrievers, semi-structured data
We introduce a framework for retrieval over structured documents that adaptively accommodates multiple scorers.
3,882
2410.20056
[ -0.01946217752993107, -0.030630389228463173, 0.007783209905028343, 0.024731237441301346, 0.05039994791150093, -0.009841532446444035, -0.024255210533738136, 0.016225775703787804, -0.017172900959849358, -0.029288798570632935, -0.026695627719163895, 0.03529804199934006, -0.06111425906419754, 0.006724526174366474, 0.011415502987802029, 0.0635765790939331, 0.015605798922479153, -0.007208561059087515, 0.022635089233517647, -0.01962166465818882, 0.004045965615659952, -0.012124576605856419, 0.029313815757632256, 0.008292067795991898, 0.05544133484363556, 0.0013855017023161054, 0.01218995451927185, 0.034136608242988586, -0.0354454405605793, 0.01647927425801754, 0.021741826087236404, -0.0198617335408926, 0.016550593078136444, -0.011560365557670593, 0.00500761391595006, -0.04691629111766815, -0.03591974452137947, 0.005957792047411203, 0.029289890080690384, -0.0014712006086483598, -0.03496583551168442, 0.018399935215711594, -0.011041740886867046, 0.004770399536937475, -0.05082862079143524, 0.013896624557673931, -0.09168283641338348, 0.023690320551395416, -0.004230565391480923, -0.006985677406191826, -0.09264115244150162, 0.026807069778442383, -0.003407507436349988, -0.01777385175228119, -0.005352429114282131, 0.0578545406460762, 0.022546062245965004, -0.05309738591313362, 0.014520303346216679, -0.0056193796917796135, -0.036791615188121796, 0.016804326325654984, 0.02132139354944229, 0.03997113183140755, -0.008253046311438084, -0.053251780569553375, -0.046175532042980194, 0.042128365486860275, -0.0580870620906353, -0.01843922771513462, 0.010153203271329403, 0.009941096417605877, 0.0005131197394803166, 0.002961815567687154, 0.01043061912059784, 0.0008913430501706898, 0.017663976177573204, 0.0212375707924366, 0.042314156889915466, 0.03864062577486038, -0.016016611829400063, 0.02322680503129959, 0.012065940536558628, 0.03796590492129326, 0.01965457573533058, 0.008499473333358765, -0.06505688279867172, 0.005408455617725849, -0.027338551357388496, 0.033480700105428696, -0.011748773977160454, -0.04846625402569771, 0.009878113865852356, 0.01730532757937908, 0.01749107614159584, -0.03288597986102104, 0.027933893725275993, -0.01585027389228344, 0.006181247066706419, -0.0044773537665605545, -0.024264683946967125, -0.024089161306619644, 0.049603238701820374, 0.0035498924553394318, -0.09851900488138199, 0.009649940766394138, 0.0010832898551598191, 0.002590300515294075, 0.027049869298934937, 0.005829065106809139, -0.03158503770828247, -0.006042870692908764, 0.005373074673116207, -0.01853182353079319, -0.08840532600879669, 0.007468800526112318, 0.01773896813392639, 0.05060361698269844, 0.008333404548466206, 0.021264638751745224, 0.00260394555516541, 0.033612921833992004, 0.00048647678340785205, 0.05588715150952339, -0.02211286686360836, -0.012918318621814251, 0.019028114154934883, 0.04102371260523796, -0.060950785875320435, -0.03583335503935814, -0.023939812555909157, 0.04283745959401131, -0.009251953102648258, 0.05219920352101326, -0.02202185057103634, 0.0034475838765501976, -0.01037006825208664, 0.004464287776499987, 0.07092922180891037, -0.0036145730409771204, 0.002072619739919901, -0.06267879158258438, -0.019549034535884857, -0.015759270638227463, 0.07095035165548325, -0.009945026598870754, -0.012457210570573807, -0.018039032816886902, -0.00864807516336441, -0.028868718072772026, 0.02161218784749508, -0.027105893939733505, 0.020135220140218735, -0.04968200996518135, -0.011910912580788136, 0.07904398441314697, 0.013734344393014908, 0.021089991554617882, -0.010871350765228271, 0.011763615533709526, 0.014347084797918797, 0.004753073211759329, -0.062086496502161026, 0.03050946816802025, -0.04207286611199379, -0.05921361595392227, 0.017300421372056007, 0.06309011578559875, 0.0022190141025930643, 0.01720743626356125, -0.0458461157977581, -0.04863906651735306, 0.032859086990356445, -0.016936013475060463, -0.011670230887830257, -0.008029225282371044, 0.08476760238409042, 0.015652036294341087, 0.03958982601761818, 0.005708754062652588, -0.07257728278636932, 0.021952025592327118, -0.018550215288996696, -0.006817547604441643, 0.01337552908807993, -0.0011550795752555132, 0.11116781830787659, 0.03247954696416855, -0.005755139980465174, 0.0025026046205312014, -0.10075319558382034, -0.04842979088425636, 0.00026348192477598786, -0.023832790553569794, 0.039615172892808914, -0.010123753920197487, 0.015020796097815037, 0.0612398125231266, 0.041160546243190765, 0.052269335836172104, 0.06241510063409805, 0.01249540876597166, 0.03264614939689636, -0.04163500666618347, -0.06443554162979126, -0.02398078143596649, 0.047541361302137375, -0.07579553872346878, -0.017615217715501785, 0.04514186829328537, -0.0033771616872400045, 0.03525133803486824, 0.005946476943790913, -0.0012226291000843048, -0.030477339401841164, 0.039219778031110764, 0.01016783993691206, 0.004370981361716986, -0.003955957945436239, -0.07853062450885773, 0.06544577330350876, 0.025610575452446938, -0.013922013342380524, 0.030666807666420937, -0.04881397634744644, 0.10076184570789337, 0.06465683877468109, -0.029840318486094475, -0.013476250693202019, -0.0008845502161420882, 0.029514649882912636, -0.002893915167078376, 0.05062934011220932, -0.05929664522409439, -0.017281055450439453, -0.0037821747828274965, -0.015121877193450928, -0.01305646076798439, 0.059999994933605194, -0.03943232446908951, -0.029169851914048195, 0.04171101003885269, -0.0321163535118103, 0.043868668377399445, 0.015247213654220104, 0.004332291893661022, 0.006788908038288355, -0.0290113165974617, 0.008961147628724575, -0.04771820083260536, 0.006174340378493071, -0.014136306941509247, -0.04123261570930481, -0.02805020660161972, 0.01680486649274826, -0.03786994516849518, -0.0026473933830857277, 0.013141576200723648, 0.08236105740070343, 0.03562290593981743, 0.030485741794109344, 0.02742549031972885, 0.012565165758132935, -0.027330676093697548, -0.026306914165616035, -0.09352975338697433, -0.013405848294496536, -0.033614739775657654, 0.024322103708982468, 0.020430492237210274, 0.044055476784706116, 0.03369518369436264, 0.003900734707713127, 0.028881248086690903, -0.011806884780526161, -0.02515576034784317, 0.08458888530731201, -0.00044860990601591766, -0.04952382668852806, -0.04481139034032822, -0.00018586203805170953, 0.04543060064315796, 0.01261176448315382, -0.08655209839344025, -0.01760217361152172, -0.04625710844993591, -0.00109213893301785, -0.033983033150434494, -0.007732096128165722, -0.0026846930850297213, -0.026860319077968597, 0.04087017849087715, -0.00944199413061142, 0.0034844852052628994, 0.06428651511669159, 0.03403468057513237, 0.029198933392763138, 0.012410001829266548, -0.020815646275877953, 0.01343456655740738, -0.050799477845430374, -0.008789341896772385, 0.022851193323731422, 0.005440329667180777, 0.0007902661454863846, -0.005214969161897898, -0.032194558531045914, -0.0029441295191645622, -0.24613416194915771, -0.001180437859147787, 0.0028228163719177246, -0.011240520514547825, 0.011302565224468708, -0.013362054713070393, 0.016756366938352585, -0.031184295192360878, -0.001480119302868843, -0.030796051025390625, 0.005215386860072613, 0.03830423578619957, 0.025336211547255516, 0.0542377270758152, 0.033292632550001144, 0.07210909575223923, 0.014208592474460602, -0.01707235351204872, -0.016993701457977295, 0.028868217021226883, -0.0027619702741503716, -0.0593213215470314, -0.03409536927938461, 0.004243891686201096, 0.012099728919565678, 0.027596114203333855, -0.08709827065467834, 0.004902504850178957, -0.030099280178546906, -0.0075681377202272415, 0.008897688239812851, -0.028789248317480087, -0.005992772523313761, 0.05018395930528641, 0.007741954643279314, 0.03736908733844757, 0.1043015569448471, 0.0233890600502491, 0.00482920790091157, -0.013390539214015007, -0.006002885289490223, -0.028170950710773468, -0.048783812671899796, -0.01901852712035179, 0.08353501558303833, -0.000475711451144889, -0.0428958460688591, -0.012675616890192032, -0.004062571097165346, 0.025684935972094536, -0.03461773321032524, -0.04326191917061806, -0.026326293125748634, 0.01008941512554884, 0.028803855180740356, -0.06158478930592537, 0.025198448449373245, -0.03370162472128868, -0.018945515155792236, -0.011951889842748642, 0.026743773370981216, -0.06309909373521805, 0.006376206874847412, -0.050144925713539124, -0.012756681069731712, -0.03890547901391983, -0.08176430314779282, -0.045607954263687134, 0.05865088105201721, 0.005239298567175865, -0.01853695511817932, 0.07053854316473007, 0.005922822281718254, -0.10304399579763412, 0.004237381741404533, -0.029396111145615578, -0.0056159463711082935, -0.009700924158096313, -0.03304411470890045, 0.06162956729531288, -0.017987148836255074, -0.05511869117617607, -0.029270822182297707, 0.008501718752086163, 0.021092265844345093, -0.03313382714986801, 0.013718274421989918, -0.02983572706580162, -0.01973607763648033, -0.033066242933273315, 0.051774848252534866, -0.0304317157715559, 0.0499202162027359, 0.013800341635942459, 0.03890983387827873, 0.026251018047332764, 0.012289981357753277, 0.027236877009272575, 0.06797387450933456, 0.02893577702343464, 0.030114613473415375, -0.06881526857614517, 0.010659853927791119, -0.015862535685300827, -0.0012483219616115093, 0.02478523924946785, -0.04809347167611122, -0.0021363256964832544, 0.06070069596171379, -0.017851784825325012, -0.0195644311606884, -0.001029963605105877, -0.013294169679284096, -0.011213239282369614, -0.005376931745558977, -0.023050939664244652, 0.016846803948283195, 0.02531169354915619, 0.036660369485616684, -0.00481859827414155, -0.03104294277727604, 0.03789130970835686, -0.005594752263277769, -0.009746290743350983, -0.046602167189121246, -0.03723754361271858, 0.016308540478348732, -0.019892971962690353, 0.004362868145108223, -0.04496030509471893, 0.04331601783633232, -0.0011123630683869123, -0.027928221970796585, 0.0033536169212311506, 0.04563603922724724, -0.01967119798064232, -0.010585878044366837, -0.004859461449086666, 0.044322919100522995, -0.035863883793354034, 0.003039666684344411, -0.03075536899268627, 0.04015486687421799, 0.042095862329006195, 0.04681232199072838, 0.013597189448773861, -0.018330754712224007, 0.0537722073495388, 0.0025903861969709396, 0.009737531654536724, -0.028829047456383705, -0.020509380847215652, -0.04256182163953781, -0.03392054885625839, -0.024771548807621002, -0.00783615279942751, 0.03737034648656845, 0.0015202537178993225, 0.0036180175375193357, -0.06334967911243439, 0.04716900363564491, -0.004626380279660225, 0.012510889209806919, -0.015764307230710983, 0.01755785197019577, 0.0322963148355484, -0.02253013104200363, 0.03811703994870186, 0.0002456163929309696, 0.030095014721155167, 0.023201733827590942, -0.02657342329621315, -0.01671699620783329, -0.02303159050643444, -0.0594845786690712, 0.021078649908304214, 0.027942411601543427, 0.020846029743552208, -0.012841025367379189, 0.060794949531555176, -0.005283602513372898, -0.025128470733761787, -0.014685011468827724, 0.03532063215970993, 0.0722542330622673, 0.008401528932154179, 0.037269894033670425, -0.023661687970161438, -0.026381321251392365, 0.021173642948269844, -0.006499708164483309, 0.0025618651416152716, -0.018932988867163658, -0.031442124396562576, 0.009372206404805183, -0.07330216467380524, 0.010367601178586483, -0.002403732156381011, -0.02190339006483555, 0.002039364306256175, -0.033593278378248215, 0.03023381158709526, -0.05526404455304146, -0.03781352937221527, -0.025344161316752434, -0.07066882401704788, 0.02019348368048668, -0.01865285634994507, -0.026572832837700844, 0.01906060241162777, -0.009817234240472317, -0.03257881477475166, -0.04218023642897606, 0.010079520754516125, 0.026165707036852837, -0.007921939715743065, -0.008669918403029442, -0.003255866700783372, 0.0060795065946877, -0.03009003959596157, 0.06146092712879181, -0.0012908308999612927, -0.011081777513027191, -0.005898700561374426, 0.0024967906065285206, 0.056953102350234985, 0.007880199700593948, -0.026544038206338882, -0.01639392040669918, -0.010614852420985699, 0.03480227291584015, -0.026668930426239967, 0.03205498680472374, 0.05343494936823845, 0.003827840555459261, -0.009311825968325138, -0.06342988461256027, 0.004497891757637262, -0.004547897260636091, 0.012745462357997894, 0.009650388732552528, -0.04711708799004555, -0.008484318852424622, 0.0055449348874390125, -0.000528492673765868, 0.020056404173374176, 0.0017216225387528539, 0.005406081210821867, -0.010289499536156654, 0.04473476856946945, -0.014649747870862484, 0.025992348790168762, -0.043973226100206375, 0.002672398928552866, 0.03265386074781418, 0.02033201791346073, -0.017645329236984253, -0.07446657866239548, -0.029332950711250305, 0.03437210991978645, 0.02526482567191124, 0.01361900381743908, -0.052775345742702484, 0.06118126958608627, 0.04565395042300224, 0.031556785106658936, -0.003908915910869837, -0.021386614069342613, 0.05692434683442116, -0.04227351024746895, -0.0166300218552351, -0.042036887258291245, -0.03522254899144173, 0.08459898829460144, 0.007021209225058556, 0.0551484078168869, -0.006177560426294804, -0.04413403570652008, 0.012360859662294388, -0.008096353150904179, -0.08482098579406738, -0.02050897665321827, -0.011762872338294983, 0.012030787765979767, 0.034511107951402664, -0.028004782274365425, -0.013081885874271393, -0.01024957001209259, -0.05303772911429405, -0.014665166847407818, -0.0037442161701619625, 0.062223732471466064, -0.06058574840426445, -0.005732371471822262, -0.013593059964478016, -0.03774435818195343, 0.00929486658424139, 0.092664435505867, -0.029154857620596886, 0.04886656627058983, -0.053537268191576004, 0.04423706233501434, 0.04570118337869644, -0.03849509358406067, 0.051596593111753464, -0.007722566369920969, -0.00841775443404913, -0.03900214284658432, 0.053726959973573685, 0.021504856646060944, -0.02915632352232933, -0.052732087671756744, 0.07327596843242645, 0.03598153591156006, -0.04756125807762146, -0.026551490649580956, -0.0033582677133381367, -0.031087124720215797, 0.019633637741208076, -0.01738082431256771, 0.04124397784471512, -0.022306524217128754, 0.05516756325960159, 0.010321815498173237, 0.02074160985648632, 0.08709501475095749, -0.010779484175145626, -0.025813372805714607, -0.01037397887557745, 0.04718688130378723, 0.06820524483919144, 0.05182601138949394, -0.04615103453397751, 0.0489472895860672, -0.019718118011951447, -0.05638756975531578, -0.0014312652638182044, 0.016492299735546112, 0.012723187915980816, -0.006693792063742876, 0.012679181061685085, 0.06816801428794861, 0.012444773688912392, 0.08449722826480865, -0.023868896067142487, -0.0027825685683637857, 0.03627334162592888, -0.00824327114969492, 0.045424990355968475, 0.028744740411639214, 0.026743434369564056, -0.010783211328089237, -0.01970277912914753, -0.03294413164258003, 0.017177272588014603, 0.007877393625676632, -0.0007936322363093495, 0.0015540807507932186, -0.010373751632869244, 0.020835524424910545, -0.02778380922973156, 0.08362216502428055, 0.09575821459293365, -0.009967293590307236, -0.028790658339858055, 0.012906597927212715, 0.011371852830052376, -0.001741904066875577, 0.03135702759027481, 0.024064140394330025, -0.022795407101511955, -0.001542285201139748, -0.07020148634910583, -0.01771799847483635, 0.02359832264482975, -0.011443153955042362, 0.016681179404258728, -0.019045289605855942, -0.04451785236597061, 0.027855757623910904, 0.004565890412777662, -0.0416514053940773, -0.04907165467739105, -0.04640815407037735, -0.006282500922679901, -0.033100325614213943, -0.022228272631764412, 0.05447553098201752, 0.03634420037269592, -0.008593711070716381, -0.005161650013178587, -0.07078651338815689, 0.019818760454654694, 0.032866865396499634, -0.04656999185681343, 0.008916770108044147, 0.024313168600201607, 0.023364244028925896, -0.007354626897722483, 0.051933951675891876, 0.024790972471237183, -0.04643312096595764, 0.004582018591463566, 0.04408816620707512, -0.000849935517180711, 0.04315139725804329, 0.020184919238090515, -0.03782733157277107, -0.09280290454626083, 0.01555691473186016, 0.02494535595178604, -0.03501386195421219, -0.07351653277873993, 0.03444508835673332, -0.025608915835618973, 0.020619692280888557, 0.025362713262438774, 0.020986026152968407, -0.008105199784040451, -0.023952318355441093, 0.01267603226006031, -0.009128345176577568, 0.0072681354358792305, 0.04845837131142616, -0.00887078046798706, 0.058032967150211334, 0.026913966983556747, 0.01709568127989769, -0.01022761408239603, 0.011962099000811577, -0.0003009230422321707, -0.015695491805672646, -0.04924793913960457, -0.02755398489534855, -0.06871037930250168, -0.07609021663665771, -0.031682152301073074, 0.012791051529347897, -0.02401045709848404, -0.040815021842718124, -0.0025252499617636204, 0.023734040558338165, -0.020950162783265114, -0.009852816350758076, -0.012513780035078526, 0.010095844976603985, -0.02755936235189438, -0.022150283679366112, -0.08218207210302353, 0.007925115525722504, -0.011885719373822212, -0.0018568213563412428, -0.004633702337741852, -0.04244637489318848, 0.018498575314879417, -0.049668360501527786, 0.006189743056893349, -0.00372446421533823, 0.009552724659442902, -0.006153155583888292 ]
3,598
Scaling FP8 training to trillion-token LLMs
https://openreview.net/forum?id=E1EHO0imOb
[ "Maxim Fishman", "Brian Chmiel", "Ron Banner", "Daniel Soudry" ]
Spotlight
We train, for the first time, large language models using FP8 precision on datasets up to 2 trillion tokens --- a 20-fold increase over previous limits. Through these extended training runs, we uncover critical instabilities in FP8 training that were not observable in earlier works with shorter durations. We trace these instabilities to outlier amplification by the SwiGLU activation function. Interestingly, we show, both analytically and empirically, that this amplification happens only over prolonged training periods, and link it to a SwiGLU weight alignment process. To address this newly identified issue, we introduce Smooth-SwiGLU, a novel modification that ensures stable FP8 training without altering function behavior. We also demonstrate, for the first time, FP8 quantization of both Adam optimizer moments. Combining these innovations, we successfully train a 7B parameter model using FP8 precision on 256 Intel Gaudi2 accelerators, achieving on-par results with the BF16 baseline while delivering up to a $\sim$ 34 % throughput improvement. A reference implementation is supplied in https://github.com/Anonymous1252022/Megatron-DeepSpeed
quantization, fp8, llms, training, acceleration, compression
Training LLMs up to 2 trillion tokens, for the first time in FP8 precision
3,789
2409.12517
[ -0.03161908686161041, -0.05569535121321678, 0.0047347890213131905, 0.04014228656888008, 0.026550477370619774, 0.04530679062008858, 0.019364716485142708, 0.02222079411149025, -0.03035496361553669, 0.0016002827323973179, -0.0021498233545571566, 0.02052300237119198, -0.07202108949422836, -0.011713719926774502, -0.01937081478536129, 0.0387008972465992, 0.02950463257730007, -0.017491549253463745, 0.03540561720728874, 0.04441875219345093, 0.00959084089845419, -0.0018861782737076283, 0.025653241202235222, 0.005662162322551012, 0.01583058014512062, 0.004438287112861872, 0.008693933486938477, -0.01680518500506878, -0.04720301181077957, 0.006570436991751194, 0.030560383573174477, -0.011828853748738766, 0.016453716903924942, -0.03233635798096657, 0.01029982976615429, 0.016559280455112457, -0.06692259013652802, 0.025802744552493095, 0.012772861868143082, 0.03569325432181358, -0.04364004358649254, -0.017740095034241676, -0.02021619863808155, 0.0076520368456840515, -0.07797499746084213, 0.030858593061566353, -0.13480882346630096, 0.024813873693346977, 0.008235184475779533, -0.03339749202132225, -0.11932659149169922, 0.023671166971325874, -0.006556750275194645, -0.017364418134093285, 0.016195109114050865, 0.021275512874126434, 0.01432373933494091, -0.10384512692689896, 0.004367311019450426, -0.040944766253232956, -0.017281854525208473, 0.0026276696007698774, 0.009585727006196976, 0.00043688234291039407, 0.0041320133022964, -0.023571353405714035, -0.00035980503889732063, 0.03117123246192932, -0.08555904030799866, -0.047305453568696976, -0.012358860112726688, 0.02427309937775135, -0.02905121073126793, 0.01845289021730423, 0.019100435078144073, -0.06662517786026001, -0.00916098803281784, 0.04725056141614914, 0.06677030771970749, 0.005786729510873556, 0.0066838315688073635, 0.008993957191705704, 0.03996001183986664, 0.054848674684762955, 0.006506088189780712, 0.019722001627087593, -0.02880183793604374, -0.03738965466618538, -0.07818664610385895, 0.03230505436658859, 0.003966208081692457, -0.05473927780985832, 0.00780654139816761, 0.02229362167418003, 0.014495732262730598, 0.008679263293743134, -0.004190517123788595, 0.012057383544743061, -0.02298242598772049, 0.012124269269406796, -0.031012291088700294, -0.03731502965092659, 0.008938183076679707, 0.018624505028128624, -0.09752572327852249, 0.006961084436625242, -0.03198995068669319, -0.0033796157222241163, 0.027426769956946373, 0.0026621948927640915, -0.027580708265304565, -0.0068318406119942665, 0.0164081621915102, -0.017128203064203262, -0.09111355990171432, 0.01908949203789234, 0.0007976217311806977, 0.018336288630962372, -0.007335977628827095, -0.011674920096993446, 0.06057048588991165, 0.07100243121385574, 0.03884032741189003, 0.06875073909759521, -0.027478931471705437, 0.029743213206529617, 0.038358911871910095, 0.03585688769817352, -0.03195931389927864, -0.027921754866838455, -0.012424116022884846, 0.0352705679833889, -0.010158554650843143, 0.009429092518985271, 0.011730586178600788, 0.012018973007798195, 0.003205100540071726, 0.011826693080365658, 0.06176406890153885, -0.018097233027219772, 0.020181337371468544, -0.011341487057507038, 0.04363277554512024, -0.026627419516444206, 0.06032586842775345, -0.007309809327125549, -0.039111439138650894, -0.03656218573451042, -0.06483913213014603, -0.008876758627593517, 0.0014981162967160344, -0.0011459931265562773, -0.003182768588885665, -0.06682364642620087, 0.0410657562315464, 0.05771487206220627, 0.0047804564237594604, -0.00842782948166132, 0.0005944197182543576, 0.04392008110880852, -0.004503751639276743, -0.003203412052243948, -0.05016867443919182, 0.01488459948450327, -0.01808510534465313, -0.022034117951989174, 0.045977313071489334, 0.005627546925097704, -0.06309103220701218, 0.023702695965766907, -0.047686077654361725, -0.02604200318455696, 0.06898621469736099, -0.0034037588629871607, -0.012952758930623531, -0.025931086391210556, 0.07404651492834091, -0.004674230236560106, 0.02288711816072464, 0.052652258425951004, -0.08876346051692963, 0.018289832398295403, 0.040196001529693604, 0.02528470568358898, -0.00552736409008503, -0.025214264169335365, 0.07173376530408859, -0.025171535089612007, -0.004324350971728563, 0.019411882385611534, -0.06898082047700882, -0.016274772584438324, 0.0032325549982488155, -0.0025741669815033674, 0.07434248924255371, 0.006681834813207388, 0.029740191996097565, 0.011747987009584904, 0.04328974708914757, 0.04472162947058678, 0.048741910606622696, -0.04474151134490967, 0.04680229350924492, 0.0069906641729176044, -0.03968815878033638, 0.008803518489003181, 0.02187720313668251, -0.04063621535897255, -0.032754868268966675, -0.008761794306337833, -0.01278646569699049, 0.004918205551803112, 0.004658984486013651, -0.005342518910765648, 0.006323625799268484, -0.01704568602144718, -0.018191445618867874, -0.011019484139978886, 0.0019299965351819992, -0.04666688293218613, 0.027468781918287277, 0.01929880678653717, 0.006316392682492733, -0.007230096030980349, -0.03417396545410156, 0.09100694954395294, 0.058081019669771194, -0.04727984592318535, -0.021137215197086334, 0.008777933195233345, 0.014631691388785839, -0.022716226056218147, -0.008728592656552792, -0.027268854901194572, 0.012759828940033913, -0.022582069039344788, -0.0010058314073830843, -0.027296945452690125, 0.04300941526889801, -0.05770197883248329, 0.011350041255354881, 0.05993230268359184, -0.011827505193650723, 0.06504634022712708, 0.0006011455552652478, 0.018572945147752762, 0.04370959475636482, -0.03552429750561714, -0.012149276211857796, -0.04021341726183891, -0.014676225371658802, 0.004621433559805155, -0.00781365018337965, -0.020259736105799675, -0.006764787714928389, -0.022664103657007217, -0.007212301716208458, -0.01010699849575758, 0.06252801418304443, 0.04777579754590988, 0.0035773739218711853, 0.007883558981120586, -0.00005946063174633309, -0.039459310472011566, 0.010859574191272259, -0.11211757361888885, -0.007585678715258837, -0.01611020602285862, 0.05511025711894035, -0.005176396109163761, 0.043951865285634995, 0.010839018039405346, 0.005781368352472782, -0.031482864171266556, -0.004260589834302664, -0.002816624939441681, 0.056065648794174194, -0.016747258603572845, -0.04982734099030495, -0.018313655629754066, -0.015419736504554749, 0.05326187610626221, -0.0280882827937603, -0.011557739228010178, -0.04566590115427971, -0.049814190715551376, -0.004744650796055794, -0.06882188469171524, -0.004342551343142986, 0.02008127234876156, 0.02330055832862854, 0.04602484777569771, -0.024723026901483536, 0.023441141471266747, 0.05173385888338089, 0.056039098650217056, 0.04304581135511398, 0.009942504577338696, -0.030297135934233665, 0.037058889865875244, -0.010224795900285244, 0.03163734823465347, -0.022312283515930176, 0.02412470243871212, -0.03389464691281319, -0.02024075947701931, 0.016064520925283432, -0.030631957575678825, -0.26369428634643555, 0.008651130832731724, -0.017223717644810677, -0.022569531574845314, 0.044067107141017914, -0.01063575316220522, 0.03130554407835007, -0.013835283927619457, -0.02983730100095272, -0.005456550978124142, 0.00696549704298377, 0.030892886221408844, 0.009997625835239887, 0.028869451954960823, 0.04057982191443443, 0.03517582640051842, 0.006620530039072037, -0.03419916704297066, 0.02466253563761711, 0.05652504786849022, 0.006284212227910757, -0.08869167417287827, 0.009081979282200336, 0.06637020409107208, -0.010965057648718357, 0.049393653869628906, -0.09520313143730164, -0.012126225046813488, -0.028529975563287735, -0.016346167773008347, -0.02848662994801998, -0.006306528113782406, -0.0007781581371091306, 0.033816784620285034, -0.016806403174996376, 0.001668520038947463, 0.02736268937587738, -0.012093666940927505, 0.039149072021245956, 0.01010975707322359, 0.04484919086098671, -0.023168178275227547, -0.006603228859603405, 0.0037720645777881145, 0.08274288475513458, 0.014778602868318558, -0.05866522341966629, -0.002985074883326888, -0.018158001825213432, 0.040364883840084076, -0.017315929755568504, -0.024371540173888206, -0.029909512028098106, 0.011723888106644154, 0.00323370099067688, -0.006490778643637896, 0.008409349247813225, 0.0030991414096206427, -0.01265847310423851, 0.011999551206827164, -0.002475593239068985, -0.04108990728855133, -0.020855210721492767, -0.035572052001953125, -0.027207717299461365, -0.049978092312812805, -0.05106319114565849, -0.038983773440122604, 0.03520742431282997, 0.029884018003940582, -0.023996423929929733, 0.04684185981750488, 0.007240544073283672, -0.0840337723493576, -0.019367793574929237, -0.015774402767419815, -0.025531277060508728, 0.020316386595368385, -0.011042000725865364, 0.07287412136793137, -0.03843250498175621, -0.04802899435162544, 0.0012473727110773325, -0.0009961629984900355, 0.042645953595638275, -0.02781888283789158, 0.0031510870903730392, -0.020893938839435577, 0.007954390719532967, -0.024613292887806892, 0.03554777801036835, -0.0017075963551178575, -0.001145463320426643, -0.01907176524400711, 0.06240314990282059, -0.004209296312183142, 0.043307527899742126, 0.07701806724071503, 0.03125940263271332, 0.025427257642149925, 0.02103721722960472, -0.0673125833272934, -0.02895735204219818, -0.05623738840222359, -0.03812278434634209, 0.033143941313028336, -0.04804900661110878, -0.031908709555864334, 0.03367161378264427, 0.015121913515031338, -0.029680844396352768, -0.06752235442399979, 0.015782730653882027, -0.03575306013226509, -0.025556864216923714, 0.001926393830217421, 0.009029364213347435, 0.03455758094787598, 0.019579125568270683, -0.015930527821183205, -0.029758531600236893, 0.03775898367166519, -0.020043451339006424, -0.006675845943391323, 0.01654767617583275, -0.005848068278282881, 0.009994764812290668, -0.015500671230256557, 0.006110999267548323, -0.009932802990078926, 0.01734161004424095, 0.03428742289543152, -0.010374839417636395, 0.0024015509989112616, 0.042302701622247696, 0.00037150015123188496, 0.027053486555814743, -0.013008162379264832, 0.02814396284520626, 0.003928873222321272, 0.009985911659896374, 0.002157412702217698, 0.03571460396051407, 0.022037873044610023, 0.015123475342988968, 0.03816908970475197, 0.020008957013487816, 0.0021292392630130053, -0.009263288229703903, 0.0052392734214663506, 0.06010286137461662, -0.05157160758972168, -0.021436383947730064, -0.033813539892435074, 0.012149072252213955, 0.015733342617750168, 0.029629718512296677, -0.005127318203449249, 0.01537744514644146, -0.06618154793977737, 0.049654070287942886, 0.003255763091146946, -0.027917025610804558, 0.013658911921083927, 0.028616001829504967, 0.018559565767645836, -0.021590862423181534, 0.01699567772448063, 0.01408158428966999, 0.003547538071870804, -0.011192691512405872, -0.013813330791890621, -0.04477183520793915, -0.00028213014593347907, 0.008999449200928211, 0.019859395921230316, -0.003633331973105669, 0.001106324139982462, 0.0013122326927259564, 0.03870731219649315, 0.006920699495822191, -0.022330865263938904, 0.01032011117786169, 0.0049748714081943035, 0.09941980242729187, 0.0026939893141388893, -0.009830310009419918, 0.0000388524895242881, -0.030651835724711418, 0.027651585638523102, -0.019904781132936478, -0.011253615841269493, 0.004138030577450991, -0.013948779553174973, -0.025349900126457214, -0.026976970955729485, 0.023448171094059944, 0.024654749780893326, 0.01032279897481203, -0.023333115503191948, -0.013262050226330757, 0.015451333485543728, -0.06321847438812256, 0.007465702015906572, 0.038731373846530914, -0.08457092940807343, -0.0012387183960527182, 0.004751759581267834, -0.011235945858061314, 0.027853095903992653, -0.01703733764588833, -0.0457584373652935, -0.06642898172140121, 0.007203748915344477, 0.03483004868030548, -0.009472434408962727, -0.01821041852235794, 0.004911400843411684, 0.0043102349154651165, -0.028080696240067482, 0.012068000622093678, -0.017829326912760735, 0.0011169516947120428, -0.008627721108496189, 0.00908363051712513, 0.046005137264728546, -0.02740877866744995, 0.01526109129190445, 0.0066527738235890865, -0.05580459535121918, 0.03478340804576874, -0.05480742081999779, 0.040486592799425125, 0.03877350687980652, -0.011647181585431099, 0.013838140293955803, -0.07838082313537598, 0.03674224391579628, -0.013081164099276066, -0.004828663542866707, 0.0033633795101195574, -0.008651075884699821, -0.025188637897372246, 0.029577821493148804, -0.024924082681536674, 0.03314218670129776, 0.00903829000890255, 0.01845341920852661, -0.013066322542726994, 0.002599109895527363, 0.0009203550289385021, 0.048206087201833725, -0.04974401369690895, -0.012025614269077778, 0.06976546347141266, -0.05719009041786194, -0.010362655855715275, -0.06475100666284561, -0.049993131309747696, -0.0144285187125206, -0.02840285189449787, 0.03437164053320885, -0.05779455974698067, 0.05113445222377777, 0.022631634026765823, 0.047375839203596115, 0.00626788754016161, -0.0294126458466053, 0.04167203977704048, -0.01618816889822483, -0.004948718007653952, -0.07324782013893127, -0.04237096384167671, 0.06198928877711296, -0.04461652413010597, 0.007871798239648342, 0.007672751322388649, -0.03644273430109024, 0.020354097709059715, -0.013798657804727554, -0.03536486625671387, 0.033384084701538086, -0.027981838211417198, -0.0032329540699720383, 0.03518535569310188, -0.03434319049119949, -0.005929951556026936, -0.00930243730545044, -0.042344044893980026, 0.012438693083822727, 0.018306219950318336, 0.0649302527308464, -0.017810700461268425, 0.001304787932895124, -0.04560075327754021, -0.013542156666517258, 0.028162823989987373, 0.026007063686847687, 0.012302720919251442, 0.04093196988105774, -0.019818032160401344, 0.058675941079854965, 0.03284886106848717, -0.016758866608142853, 0.009345249272882938, 0.0062504783272743225, -0.0176832377910614, -0.07946313917636871, 0.048972856253385544, -0.016534779220819473, -0.0349830687046051, -0.04100308567285538, 0.08225981891155243, 0.03508225828409195, -0.03625301644206047, -0.040992215275764465, 0.01729014702141285, -0.031664397567510605, -0.01767660863697529, -0.009778706356883049, -0.008228849619626999, -0.030719419941306114, 0.08468025922775269, 0.022345133125782013, 0.028991399332880974, 0.07895965874195099, 0.011532005853950977, -0.007068997249007225, -0.02714194729924202, 0.0658678337931633, 0.0510784275829792, 0.05943965166807175, -0.010880070738494396, 0.054329100996255875, -0.04862736910581589, -0.05619705468416214, 0.023695696145296097, 0.019963130354881287, -0.03149569779634476, -0.02582378312945366, 0.02834954299032688, 0.09861763566732407, -0.01311030238866806, 0.07859014719724655, -0.043992720544338226, -0.015487993136048317, 0.03421171382069588, -0.0028372430242598057, 0.013818686828017235, 0.07535196095705032, 0.012795224785804749, 0.006898324936628342, -0.007111547514796257, -0.04950279742479324, 0.021752795204520226, -0.0071924179792404175, 0.01677151769399643, 0.016639064997434616, -0.006586112082004547, 0.01832021214067936, -0.002189505146816373, 0.04400136321783066, 0.11591816693544388, -0.03512392193078995, -0.02511025220155716, 0.013306206092238426, 0.0017969701439142227, 0.04449639469385147, 0.04748726636171341, -0.01233618427067995, -0.020009325817227364, 0.021158818155527115, -0.027823027223348618, -0.011390957050025463, 0.008337571285665035, -0.002340728184208274, 0.03095460869371891, -0.011885491199791431, -0.03022611141204834, 0.006648082751780748, 0.0029466871637851, -0.04591178148984909, -0.05130370706319809, -0.028625743463635445, -0.04702312499284744, -0.026436246931552887, -0.05964740365743637, -0.007803158834576607, 0.006027163006365299, -0.03122955746948719, -0.008241224102675915, -0.042267806828022, 0.01060690637677908, 0.028008973225951195, -0.05252450332045555, 0.0053522321395576, 0.042768437415361404, -0.011858188547194004, -0.026111967861652374, 0.041863009333610535, 0.034026842564344406, -0.0019679730758070946, -0.016539135947823524, 0.02792777679860592, 0.02689332701265812, 0.0063971951603889465, 0.028435027226805687, -0.013917900621891022, -0.12096639722585678, 0.03297841548919678, 0.022658508270978928, -0.02813838981091976, -0.08300847560167313, 0.03436049818992615, -0.028430793434381485, 0.03014088049530983, 0.06168215721845627, 0.03188936039805412, 0.0157337486743927, -0.022885460406541824, -0.02372651733458042, -0.018956972286105156, 0.0002661880280356854, 0.049604155123233795, -0.0052340407855808735, 0.05937281996011734, 0.03728117793798447, -0.0018014318775385618, -0.034590866416692734, 0.01649942435324192, -0.02358192205429077, 0.0048983716405928135, 0.003981877584010363, -0.05637848377227783, -0.019018834456801414, -0.09532066434621811, 0.01227483805269003, 0.006880370434373617, -0.009529583156108856, -0.046578288078308105, 0.02593328058719635, -0.008398480713367462, -0.018000217154622078, -0.01938115432858467, 0.011880209669470787, -0.022035254165530205, -0.01101455744355917, -0.04635937884449959, -0.06977386772632599, 0.026405896991491318, -0.014289232902228832, 0.009832141920924187, -0.011171326041221619, -0.03597651422023773, 0.003352387109771371, 0.019173765555024147, 0.05355869606137276, 0.01958504132926464, 0.006651914678514004, -0.0069574834778904915 ]
3,599
Topograph: An Efficient Graph-Based Framework for Strictly Topology Preserving Image Segmentation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Q0zmmNNePz
[ "Laurin Lux", "Alexander H Berger", "Alexander Weers", "Nico Stucki", "Daniel Rueckert", "Ulrich Bauer", "Johannes C. Paetzold" ]
Spotlight
Topological correctness plays a critical role in many image segmentation tasks, yet most networks are trained using pixel-wise loss functions, such as Dice, neglecting topological accuracy. Existing topology-aware methods often lack robust topological guarantees, are limited to specific use cases, or impose high computational costs. In this work, we propose a novel, graph-based framework for topologically accurate image segmentation that is both computationally efficient and generally applicable. Our method constructs a component graph that fully encodes the topological information of both the prediction and ground truth, allowing us to efficiently identify topologically critical regions and aggregate a loss based on local neighborhood information. Furthermore, we introduce a strict topological metric capturing the homotopy equivalence between the union and intersection of prediction-label pairs. We formally prove the topological guarantees of our approach and empirically validate its effectiveness on binary and multi-class datasets, demonstrating state-of-the-art performance with up to fivefold faster loss computation compared to persistent homology methods.
Image Segmentation, Topology, Graph
A novel metric and loss function based on component graphs for topology preserving image segmentation.
3,773
2411.03228
[ -0.004520967602729797, -0.019014554098248482, 0.009149542078375816, 0.03830062225461006, 0.0004496299661695957, 0.03181803971529007, 0.016565760597586632, 0.02124881185591221, -0.03944741562008858, -0.0668342337012291, -0.035781074315309525, -0.019799841567873955, -0.06649009883403778, 0.008201776072382927, 0.03534785285592079, 0.03639741986989975, 0.027630219236016273, -0.01997877098619938, 0.010676171630620956, 0.04869804158806801, -0.03146127983927727, -0.02806313894689083, -0.013911692425608635, 0.02068459428846836, 0.03407854959368706, -0.013316326774656773, 0.007699257228523493, 0.03299097344279289, -0.02638830803334713, 0.012110990472137928, 0.02364017628133297, -0.01693912222981453, 0.026795176789164543, -0.060443513095378876, 0.03308729827404022, -0.022298874333500862, -0.0335782915353775, 0.026002567261457443, -0.010024997405707836, -0.006536790169775486, -0.05885537713766098, 0.016871919855475426, 0.04808297008275986, 0.021822122856974602, -0.05144329369068146, -0.0006475454429164529, -0.10468626022338867, 0.028888599947094917, 0.0007342394674196839, -0.01122944988310337, -0.04883883520960808, 0.04411843419075012, 0.0009471921948716044, 0.025967558845877647, -0.034526191651821136, 0.030464909970760345, 0.04589731991291046, -0.042436882853507996, -0.00885168556123972, -0.047990452498197556, -0.005760029889643192, 0.038047682493925095, 0.016035281121730804, 0.005128080490976572, -0.02702547051012516, -0.000014156513316265773, 0.0007041388307698071, 0.057416047900915146, -0.03496972844004631, -0.039226751774549484, 0.0070646293461322784, 0.00042308878619223833, 0.012788871303200722, 0.041253283619880676, 0.010652692057192326, -0.0318455807864666, -0.0527074933052063, -0.020438794046640396, 0.06986010819673538, -0.028847195208072662, 0.012969830073416233, 0.0578840970993042, -0.009785955771803856, 0.010563977994024754, 0.004611271899193525, 0.02667076885700226, -0.01939058117568493, -0.035098034888505936, -0.09209346771240234, 0.029119092971086502, -0.04822158440947533, -0.02884122170507908, 0.019078092649579048, 0.01343228667974472, 0.01140539813786745, -0.03781947121024132, 0.01641015149652958, 0.005345443729311228, 0.025588219985365868, -0.04848547652363777, -0.01705300435423851, 0.004180587362498045, 0.009747561998665333, 0.008332320488989353, -0.0818876102566719, -0.0450894720852375, -0.021079566329717636, 0.0031806982588022947, -0.01898745447397232, 0.017484502866864204, -0.02376495860517025, -0.023012302815914154, 0.009954473003745079, -0.029531408101320267, -0.06311853229999542, 0.03586198017001152, 0.007693855091929436, 0.007573382463306189, -0.022342121228575706, 0.021029271185398102, 0.02443116344511509, 0.053318317979574203, -0.005831155925989151, 0.09129505604505539, -0.00044350724783726037, -0.0001523870014352724, -0.007593738380819559, 0.025797482579946518, -0.06988079845905304, -0.03300213813781738, -0.0004287224146537483, 0.06169776991009712, -0.013958708383142948, -0.011727829463779926, 0.02673341892659664, -0.036274369806051254, 0.033394020050764084, -0.011552436277270317, -0.004393032751977444, -0.02866547368466854, 0.014782039448618889, -0.041615746915340424, 0.03713810443878174, -0.03133178874850273, 0.059171050786972046, -0.04473763704299927, -0.010745049454271793, -0.017890747636556625, -0.03342156484723091, 0.010254592634737492, -0.01013142429292202, -0.0037520062178373337, 0.00047746748896315694, -0.049172766506671906, 0.004165951628237963, 0.0629485622048378, 0.017271259799599648, 0.04144491255283356, -0.02349529229104519, -0.00854270439594984, 0.024277443066239357, 0.006915976293385029, 0.007956914603710175, 0.04141703620553017, -0.02077752910554409, -0.07160468399524689, 0.04471363127231598, 0.04427330940961838, -0.02866296097636223, 0.014883221127092838, -0.021780144423246384, -0.08543307334184647, 0.03837181627750397, -0.0023201722651720047, -0.000929101079236716, 0.0045612892135977745, 0.07407709211111069, -0.02121325023472309, 0.0064864447340369225, 0.029272397980093956, -0.09160489588975906, 0.026757070794701576, 0.014462684281170368, -0.01859799213707447, 0.003401504596695304, -0.026723647490143776, 0.07048365473747253, -0.023228151723742485, 0.0004790418315678835, -0.005106266587972641, -0.04479015991091728, -0.024721652269363403, 0.029220258817076683, -0.00043647384154610336, 0.05020110681653023, 0.03583136200904846, -0.010490131564438343, -0.007155921775847673, 0.029028913006186485, 0.03767598792910576, 0.02338513545691967, -0.03812141716480255, 0.04964267835021019, -0.023589203134179115, -0.044083159416913986, -0.010840590111911297, 0.0021778361406177282, -0.05588538944721222, -0.0517534464597702, 0.001312402542680502, -0.002159134717658162, -0.005447082687169313, 0.018365364521741867, 0.012357677333056927, 0.02671843022108078, 0.008501691743731499, -0.007763656321913004, 0.0041524977423250675, 0.041008755564689636, -0.06993157416582108, 0.022046076133847237, 0.026080869138240814, -0.0318380631506443, -0.004728524945676327, -0.018839817494153976, 0.09920409321784973, 0.08270112425088882, -0.03759314492344856, 0.010054866783320904, 0.014257973060011864, -0.026492496952414513, 0.024723321199417114, -0.008765680715441704, -0.041345156729221344, -0.015037531964480877, -0.025193138048052788, 0.034522347152233124, -0.04292580857872963, 0.06311000883579254, -0.05163503438234329, -0.014591085724532604, 0.029881801456212997, 0.0260203555226326, 0.04175139218568802, 0.04152830317616463, 0.005148409400135279, 0.08116095513105392, -0.004364431370049715, -0.025888387113809586, 0.0035460302606225014, -0.03228335827589035, -0.005943354219198227, -0.002615658799186349, -0.007142936810851097, -0.010192567482590675, -0.04832468926906586, 0.04724203050136566, 0.001150334719568491, 0.05965931713581085, 0.07137570530176163, 0.030133498832583427, 0.0015763581031933427, -0.03226136788725853, -0.03125489503145218, -0.04635407030582428, -0.10516617447137833, -0.04189884662628174, -0.025049427524209023, 0.07988086342811584, -0.020866133272647858, 0.050160154700279236, -0.015119682066142559, 0.041443485766649246, -0.01889338344335556, -0.03250080719590187, -0.006015881430357695, 0.025309186428785324, 0.030772769823670387, -0.04008762910962105, -0.0013161993119865656, 0.023767506703734398, 0.07198192924261093, 0.011796433478593826, -0.004716732073575258, -0.011276312172412872, -0.04783619940280914, 0.027516277506947517, -0.030128415673971176, -0.008500411175191402, 0.01724664494395256, 0.03929895907640457, 0.03283356875181198, -0.014254438690841198, 0.0021618553437292576, 0.003232521004974842, 0.04816623404622078, 0.06598495692014694, -0.00925483088940382, -0.0288443211466074, -0.022359905764460564, 0.006493012420833111, 0.05096457898616791, -0.007758558262139559, -0.013886451721191406, 0.010530805215239525, 0.005229444243013859, 0.031120168045163155, 0.0026189323980361223, -0.2595617175102234, 0.006769304629415274, -0.00008708795940037817, -0.015761978924274445, 0.04405637085437775, -0.022104037925601006, 0.02707080729305744, -0.011574739590287209, -0.04577162116765976, -0.0002775322354864329, -0.0011839893413707614, 0.012129222974181175, -0.002377595752477646, 0.03908270597457886, 0.07599297165870667, 0.04364800080657005, 0.030328767374157906, 0.007188504561781883, 0.03449666500091553, 0.052741117775440216, -0.05789707973599434, -0.06530766189098358, -0.013184908777475357, 0.028939757496118546, -0.03392806276679039, 0.03497059643268585, -0.08064033091068268, -0.024330148473381996, -0.04280326887965202, -0.032172273844480515, 0.010227557271718979, -0.03315170854330063, -0.007559997495263815, 0.026499291881918907, -0.008129535242915154, 0.02265111170709133, 0.020543545484542847, -0.007101132068783045, -0.016246886923909187, -0.030492814257740974, 0.003957511857151985, 0.05138933286070824, -0.03910696506500244, 0.0243521761149168, 0.044302891939878464, -0.01807241328060627, -0.025411199778318405, -0.03757903724908829, 0.006294265855103731, 0.03173461928963661, 0.013079036958515644, -0.010582839138805866, 0.0027225175872445107, 0.0009826425230130553, -0.00807622354477644, -0.021610936149954796, -0.0024059126153588295, 0.021797895431518555, -0.04725255072116852, 0.003572453511878848, -0.01881188154220581, -0.06339535862207413, 0.0016632789047434926, -0.035455282777547836, 0.014536953531205654, -0.04681086912751198, -0.08773890882730484, -0.034227315336465836, 0.013391039334237576, 0.043407589197158813, 0.02526276744902134, 0.04579375684261322, -0.02966206893324852, -0.09402406960725784, 0.006601664237678051, 0.026756618171930313, -0.007674023043364286, -0.033131394535303116, -0.007708913646638393, 0.02153724990785122, -0.046909648925065994, -0.02515576221048832, 0.03347368910908699, 0.033867575228214264, -0.01873193494975567, -0.01748558133840561, 0.0073082176968455315, -0.028094472363591194, -0.013658205047249794, -0.021471746265888214, 0.04370012879371643, 0.02388322912156582, 0.0249636210501194, -0.01483136136084795, 0.026605602353811264, 0.04424125701189041, 0.054673682898283005, 0.04452531039714813, 0.02832905575633049, -0.01952728070318699, 0.03914432227611542, -0.07412581890821457, -0.014024351723492146, -0.0081162229180336, -0.047517646104097366, 0.026417257264256477, -0.04588944464921951, -0.0100735267624259, 0.05508150905370712, 0.00604337640106678, -0.039648186415433884, -0.008341269567608833, 0.05334793031215668, -0.020837297663092613, 0.007072778418660164, -0.012949631549417973, 0.007102766539901495, -0.007777626626193523, 0.04550211876630783, -0.03918756917119026, -0.013314381241798401, 0.05057816952466965, -0.011137919500470161, 0.0262234415858984, 0.0116050960496068, -0.004931686446070671, -0.02879440039396286, -0.01826493628323078, 0.03164522722363472, 0.02314760722219944, 0.0548611581325531, 0.09578365832567215, 0.003654305124655366, 0.036922886967659, 0.08009237796068192, -0.006714392453432083, -0.01586744748055935, -0.03384717181324959, 0.04908444732427597, -0.016643323004245758, 0.034289173781871796, 0.015647197142243385, 0.04793790355324745, 0.03403002396225929, 0.03967268392443657, -0.004065951332449913, -0.02895197458565235, 0.007129240315407515, 0.007924842648208141, 0.010638033039867878, -0.017136216163635254, -0.056595247238874435, -0.006273351609706879, -0.04282057285308838, 0.03172864392399788, -0.005087359808385372, 0.01959596946835518, -0.010819138959050179, 0.00909052137285471, -0.05416250228881836, 0.05738186836242676, 0.047018375247716904, -0.006371637340635061, -0.014609698206186295, -0.005334474146366119, 0.07001431286334991, 0.01142209768295288, -0.0574180968105793, -0.01081573124974966, -0.017246361821889877, 0.025226015597581863, -0.03143377974629402, 0.0066200848668813705, -0.01981128752231598, -0.00909485574811697, 0.006196631584316492, 0.003888319944962859, 0.0117117278277874, -0.03401586413383484, 0.025331299751996994, -0.012593615800142288, 0.00845106691122055, 0.025751307606697083, 0.004322088323533535, 0.07676047831773758, -0.0001672411017352715, -0.025317339226603508, -0.023929143324494362, -0.025333484634757042, 0.08858149498701096, -0.001176833757199347, 0.020750008523464203, -0.0629354864358902, 0.00035774277057498693, -0.022887708619236946, -0.03855012357234955, 0.012874377891421318, -0.011869656853377819, -0.02561718225479126, -0.02699781395494938, -0.025682924315333366, 0.01987011916935444, -0.0028748547192662954, 0.027320781722664833, 0.05472434312105179, -0.04247891902923584, 0.0029311738908290863, 0.06248640641570091, -0.009775004349648952, 0.009895173832774162, -0.007628076709806919, -0.006954638287425041, -0.04296812787652016, -0.04492221027612686, 0.030473237857222557, -0.01156158372759819, -0.021483495831489563, -0.04666856303811073, 0.0006515848799608648, -0.013953614048659801, -0.016107359901070595, 0.023839911445975304, 0.005325742997229099, -0.027258967980742455, 0.038929492235183716, 0.08740514516830444, -0.018025806173682213, -0.020313898101449013, 0.027855128049850464, -0.018561776727437973, -0.00960479024797678, -0.01051013357937336, 0.00976571161299944, 0.03547310829162598, -0.011996676214039326, 0.02208641543984413, -0.048407405614852905, 0.03287755697965622, -0.0013016131706535816, 0.005450945347547531, 0.017277853563427925, 0.03444860130548477, -0.029897665604948997, 0.007589505985379219, 0.016039056703448296, 0.02164456807076931, 0.044656816869974136, 0.008056863211095333, 0.023494768887758255, 0.013728414662182331, 0.0145944869145751, -0.0061749923042953014, -0.03302483633160591, -0.029225092381238937, 0.03142646700143814, -0.02373337931931019, -0.03294111415743828, -0.07546428591012955, -0.0304944459348917, 0.027323033660650253, -0.03228306770324707, 0.010244417004287243, 0.0075848777778446674, 0.017702285200357437, 0.0030182315967977047, 0.03937879949808121, -0.02274204045534134, -0.03553694859147072, 0.03135959059000015, -0.05587806552648544, 0.025741582736372948, -0.029781805351376534, -0.01514115184545517, 0.029262296855449677, -0.05924835801124573, 0.0072287688963115215, 0.0054769148118793964, -0.02506333962082863, -0.0062873950228095055, -0.03746827691793442, -0.07383352518081665, 0.006720687262713909, -0.004324331413954496, -0.0013733922969549894, 0.008819246664643288, -0.016757851466536522, 0.0012487589847296476, -0.016413794830441475, -0.049433376640081406, 0.0018199526239186525, 0.02874154783785343, 0.002719973213970661, 0.003969108685851097, -0.001328116632066667, -0.0034508612006902695, 0.0320688933134079, 0.022262709215283394, 0.076509490609169, 0.021294627338647842, 0.008782397024333477, -0.05803290754556656, 0.06705359369516373, 0.02117309533059597, -0.00568599347025156, 0.004999644588679075, 0.020820295438170433, -0.01013987883925438, -0.04690916836261749, 0.021940818056464195, 0.006712731905281544, -0.026301641017198563, -0.09330984205007553, 0.06280723959207535, 0.012921958230435848, -0.047198519110679626, -0.012347858399152756, 0.032425668090581894, -0.03507315367460251, 0.02174708992242813, -0.017826130613684654, -0.010894215665757656, 0.004275284241884947, 0.05402270704507828, -0.00710295932367444, 0.016705095767974854, 0.06717509776353836, -0.0220384169369936, 0.00391393294557929, -0.02299559861421585, 0.08177671581506729, 0.07140885293483734, 0.020380113273859024, -0.01733858697116375, 0.0692693367600441, -0.045127153396606445, -0.019836515188217163, 0.021234039217233658, 0.015642991289496422, -0.03402133658528328, -0.03843381628394127, -0.0010037471074610949, 0.08833634853363037, -0.003980759996920824, 0.08501341193914413, -0.07469843327999115, 0.008767824620008469, 0.03581083565950394, 0.012873834930360317, -0.007000613026320934, 0.04444485530257225, 0.027834104374051094, 0.019211383536458015, -0.030595632269978523, 0.02666577883064747, 0.005296272691339254, -0.014154670760035515, 0.03828413784503937, -0.006193835753947496, -0.013304379768669605, 0.0249989852309227, 0.0002182485186494887, 0.014393066056072712, 0.09797406941652298, -0.030383478850126266, -0.07895954698324203, 0.00018682026711758226, 0.006281625013798475, 0.012176109477877617, 0.053474873304367065, 0.03230750188231468, 0.011698663234710693, 0.029728427529335022, -0.015119929797947407, 0.03434741497039795, 0.008638638071715832, -0.014593423344194889, 0.0016349743818864226, -0.019652873277664185, -0.054982297122478485, -0.014395209960639477, 0.01780415140092373, -0.04349350184202194, -0.040043652057647705, -0.039606042206287384, -0.06363014876842499, -0.06143037974834442, -0.05683375149965286, 0.006710839923471212, -0.00024726404808461666, -0.02028670907020569, -0.0015884515596553683, -0.0052199470810592175, 0.010479037649929523, 0.03359515964984894, -0.06390542536973953, 0.007076431531459093, 0.0535753108561039, -0.011650335043668747, 0.007652555592358112, 0.03252269700169563, 0.02327909879386425, -0.0632043331861496, -0.017326101660728455, 0.015104957856237888, 0.022030116990208626, 0.020402848720550537, -0.014512377791106701, -0.0360291562974453, -0.10847994685173035, 0.026303421705961227, 0.0029961811378598213, -0.044481534510850906, -0.07337790727615356, 0.0305575393140316, -0.011494657956063747, 0.017961641773581505, 0.050728294998407364, -0.012317225337028503, 0.020110437646508217, -0.05965908244252205, -0.0009380192495882511, -0.055034611374139786, -0.021043552085757256, 0.05538468807935715, -0.029793957248330116, 0.03580046072602272, 0.018730685114860535, 0.008680845610797405, 0.008694390766322613, 0.04861938953399658, 0.022442160174250603, 0.03266545757651329, -0.030894022434949875, -0.034200046211481094, -0.02292795293033123, -0.12372265756130219, -0.02669668383896351, 0.02826712094247341, 0.01944551058113575, -0.05112485960125923, -0.019284119829535484, 0.004466776270419359, -0.03981148824095726, 0.0002387392451055348, -0.012038685381412506, 0.0011504393769428134, -0.02159728854894638, -0.04929351806640625, -0.09267931431531906, -0.020844044163823128, -0.025034509599208832, 0.02778569981455803, -0.011664479970932007, -0.04100894182920456, -0.016244783997535706, 0.0021266464609652758, 0.03764869272708893, -0.004336503800004721, 0.028539644554257393, 0.0001967042189789936 ]